Workplace bullies

CARM workplace violence report
CARM
TM
Workplace Violence Training
Issue 2
Workplace
bullies
How bullies affect your people and your business
If you have been the target or have witnessed incidents of workplace bullying,
you are not alone. Indeed, experts says the number of incidents of workplace
bullying have been on the increase for the past six years and estimate that 15 to
20 per cent of the workforce has been subject to workplace bullying.
More cases are coming to light as public awareness of the problem grows, though
anecdotal evidence suggests many, many more cases go unreported.
“People who are targets [of bullying] often lose their sense of self-esteem and with
the constant criticism about their work they can come to believe they are at fault,”
says Fraser Duff, Managing Director of workplace violence specialists, Passmore
Duff International.
Fear of losing a job can add to the feeling of helplessness and despair, leaving the
target feeling trapped in a distressing situation.
The reaction – or lack of it – from colleagues can worsen matters.
“To be frank, it is not unusual for colleagues to be pleased that someone other
than himself or herself is copping the brunt of a bully’s abuse,” says Duff, who prefers the term target to epithet of victim.
“People are not victims in these situations,” he says. “They are targets of wholly inappropriate behavior that needs to be dealt with swiftly and effectively.”
Doing so, however, is not without its difficulties: harassment or assault is readily
identified and, therefore, can be dealt with by policies and laws; bullying can be far
more insidious, using psychological tactics, such as verbal abuse, humiliation and
unfair work demands, rather than physical attacks.
In any event, bullying affects both individuals and businesses, though tracking the
repercussions for the latter is complex.
One figure often quoted is from a 2001 study by an employment agency, Drake
Personnel, which claims bullying costs Australian employers $12 million a year.
The argument goes along the lines that bullying takes its toll in absenteeism, less
creativity and higher employee turnover. Targets can also retaliate – not only with
lawsuits but also with acts of violence or vandalism.
Another school of thought, however, points out that bullying patterns do not appear
to undercut productivity at all. As a New York Times (22/6/04) article on the subject
notes: “Workers may loathe a bullying boss and hate going to work each morning,
but they still perform. Researchers find little relationship between people’s attitudes
toward their jobs and their productivity, as measured by output and even the quality
of their work. Even in the most hostile work environment, conscientious people
keep doing the work they are paid for.”
The fall off in unpaid extras, such as being polite to customers or helpful to coworkers, and, indirectly, in performance is much smaller than expected, the Times’
article concludes from research conducted by Dr Bennett Tepper, an organizational
psychologist at the University of North Carolina. Dr Tepper’s study in April of 173
randomly selected employees, showed in situations where bosses were abusive,
some employees did nothing or little extra, while others did a lot, covering for less
helpful peers.
“This is not what we expected,” Dr Tepper told the Times. “And we speculate that
one reason people keep doing extra in these abusive situations is to advance themselves at the expense of others. It makes them look good and others look much
worse.”
The affect on individuals, nonetheless, should be enough to get companies to act.
1
Tackling the Bully
Workplace bullies can find themselves the targets of people not
willing to tolerate their behavior.
Take, for example, nurses in one
North American hospital who
came up with “code pink” as their
way of dealing with a bullying
physician.
Tired of his foul temper (and
language) and unable to get any
help from hospital administrators,
they figured out a system
whereby when he fired off any
nurse with time to spare would
stand in a circle and silently
watch him. Faced with the prospect of witnesses, he would shut
down.
Not all workplaces, however, are
as mutually supportive, and targets are often left to their own
devices.
Any incidents of bullying should
be investigated in the same way
as any other workplace complaint. By the same token, companies should have anti-bullying
policies in place.
The first question to ask is anyone really being bullied?
A personality clash or someone’s
nose out of joint following a
reprimand at work can lead some
people to claim they are being
bullied. Potentially it could be a
case of someone simply trying to
get even with a boss.
Rather than a one-off event,
bullying tends to be a continuous
behavior pattern aimed at causing someone else harm,
If someone does become a target
of bullying behavior, they may
think it is temporary and will pass.
It rarely does (unless another
target comes on the radar). As
time goes by, the target may try
to adjust to the situation by trial
and error only to find good intentions making things worse.
CARM workplace violence report
Issue 2
“There may be a lack of neatly packaged financial arguments for dealing with the
problem, but natural decency suggests that if an employee is suffering disturbed
sleep, brooding, anxiety and depression, or a myriad of other symptoms, because of
treatment by someone at work, something should be done,” says Duff.
The Symptoms of Bullying
Among the “myriad of symptoms” medical specialists highlight the sense of helplessness felt by the target, which can lead to other symptoms such as gastroenteritis
and heart trouble. One leading psychologist in the UK, Dr Noreen Tehrani, who has
counseled victims of the troubles in Northern Ireland, goes as far as comparing the
experience of bullied workers to that of soldiers suffering battle stress.
“ The symptoms displayed by people who have been in conflict situations and workplaces where bullying happens are strikingly similar,” Dr Tehrani told the BBC in
August. “Both groups suffer nightmares, are jumpy and seem fuelled by too much
adrenaline. In addition, they show greater susceptibility to illnesses, heart disease
and alcoholism.”
Dr Tehrani found in a study of 165 professionals in the caring sector, such as
nurses and social workers, that 36% of the men and 42% of the women reported
having experienced bullying. Further, overall, one in five people exhibited the main
symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), the three signs of which are
hyper arousal, a feeling of constant anxiety and over-vigilance; avoidance of anything to do with the traumatizing event; and re-experiencing, in which subjects suffer
flashbacks or obsessive thoughts concerning the trauma.
In addition to caring sectors, bullying can be found in many other professions, such
as education and policing, as well in the media and entertainment industries.
“Many of these environments require workers to be omni-competent and to have
total faith in their own abilities, and can, therefore, attract people with bullying natures,” says Duff.
Do not think for a moment that bullying is restricted to ranting males, either. Sure,
about 80 per cent of targets are women, according to Gary Namie, director of the
Workplace Bullying & Trauma Institute, in the US. But, he says, 58 per cent of all
bullies are women and they target women 87 per cent of the time. Men account for
42 per cent of workplace bullies, who pick on women 71 per cent of the time.
“Most [bullies] are soccer moms and deacons and parents of the month. They slip
into the role at work,” Namie says. “They are threatened by the competence and
independence of the person they target.”
In most cases, workplace bullies are likely to be supervisors and managers lacking
interpersonal skills needed to deal with co-workers, especially in high-pressure environments. It may even be a form of covering up their lack of skills to do the job in
the first place.
“Under pressure, some managers feel they have to adopt a more autocratic style of
management. As the pressure increases, autocratic behavior can rapidly descend
into bullying,” says Duff.
The fact of the matter is many workplaces unwittingly encourage bullying by piling
pressure on for results and by regarding complainants as whiners and troublemakers.
“There is a world of difference, however, between tough management and bullying,”
says Duff. “High or exacting standards and goals are not the problem – it is how
they are achieved. Bullying involves singling out individuals and making demands of
them or exposing them to behavior that others are not expected to tolerate.”
In the absence of action by others and lack of policies and systems to deal with
such behavior, those individuals are very much alone.
Except as a growing statistic.
2
What to do if targeted by a
bully
Being bullied or harassed at work
is a debilitating and distressing
experience and younger people,
unaware of the nuances of the
workplace, can be particularly at
risk.. When someone is being
bullied, they should:-
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Recognise they are being
bullied
Realize it is not their fault
Tell the bully their behavior is
unacceptable
Inform a senior manager or
human resources
Contact their union rep, if
there is one
Record a formal grievance
Keep a record of what happens. This record may become what courts refer to as
contemporaneous notes that
can be used in evidence.
Keep copies of any letters,
memos, notes, or emails
Build a support network,
including friends and family
Consult a doctor if bullying
causes stress
Training may also help by assisting the person to:-
•
Deal with aggression & conflict resolution
•
Improve communication skills
•
Manage stress; and
•
Build self confidence and self
esteem.
Whatever the person does they
should ensure they do not suffer
in silence , remain confident in
their own abilities and avoid
being alone with the bully.
CARM workplace violence report
Issue 2
Spotting bully types and tactics
Be in no doubt: bullies are often weak individuals, usually incompetent in their
jobs, very immature, and inadequate at forming human relations. And, they can
be categorized, albeit the ability to adopt any tactic at any time to accomplish
their goal can make them harder to spot.
One of the most readily identified is the stereotypical bully, Bravemouth who controls through fear and intimidation. Bravemouths cast themselves as heroes by making lots of noise and ensuring everyone hears. By publicly putting workers down,
they look as if they are in charge. Being emotionally stunted, impulsive and explosive, all add up to the very real possibility of spilling over to physical violence. With a
desperate need to instill sense of dread, hence the overbearing attitude, they are
self-centered, insensitive to needs of others, and terrified themselves about being
detected as imposter, so expect angry outbursts, tantrums and intimidating gestures: finger pointing, slamming things down, throwing objects, crowding your personal space. You will also face lots of job threats or dark promises of change, such
as demotion or transfer.
The Mr. (or Ms.) Freeze can be far more subtle and difficult to detect. Unlike the
villain in the Batman movie, who freezes people in position, this bully freezes people
out, refusing to offer praise, never listening to staff and ignoring suggestions. They
will withhold resources (time, materials, finances, information, supplies, support,
goals) or anything else necessary for you to succeed.
Meanwhile Catty Critic uses barbs of humor to lacerate a target’s self-esteem in a
death of a thousand verbal cuts. This is the nitpicking, complaining, perfectionist,
who masks personal insecurity with bravado. Generally admired by senior management for “getting results” they privately aim to destroy confidence and create selfdoubt. Beware if you are good at your job, he or she will use put-downs, insults,
belittling comments, and name-calling to draw attention to your “incompetence”.
They often use aggressive eye contact, glaring at you, demanding eye contact when
they speak and deliberately avoiding eye contact when you speak. Any contribution
you make will be met with negativity – anticipate anything from sighs, or frowns, to
peering over top of eyeglasses or a sour face – and when things go wrong expect
to get the blame, even if lies are needed to back up such claims. Don’t expect criticism to stop at your work: your personal life, appearance, family, friends, religious
beliefs and sexual orientation are all fair targets to the Catty Critic.
The Designating Dervish is more intent in rushing around looking busy and unfairly
allocating work as a way of over-burdening those he or she wants to push around.
Expect unreasonable work demands with impossible deadlines along with a barrage of memos, e-mails, messages and paperwork all needing replies.
The Petty Tyrant aims much lower. The American Heritage® Dictionary defines
petty as: “1. Of small importance; trivial: a petty grievance. 2. Marked by narrowness
of mind, ideas, or views. 3. Marked by meanness or lack of generosity, especially in
trifling matters. 4. Secondary in importance or rank; subordinate.” They may be all
these things, but they prefer Milton’s view: “Like a petty god I walked about, admired of all.” In fact they are perhaps the dullest form of bully employing the full
wrath of correct procedure to crush staff, particularly over minor mistakes. Absolute
control freaks – at times admitting they are – they need to establish themselves as
superior to you so they can order you around or to control your circumstances. Approval for the most minor of matters must be solicited from them. They are not beyond tricks (remember, we are talking petty) such as setting the clock ahead of
time, so you are late, but never allowed to go home until the same clock says so.
3
Defining a global
phenomenon…..
The Workplace Bullying &
Trauma Institute, in the US, defines workplace bullying or psychological violence at work as:
“The repeated, healthendangering mistreatment of a
person (the target) by a cruel
perpetrator (the bully) is best
understood through the bully's
behaviors – acts of commission
(hostile verbal, nonverbal communication and interfering actions)
and omission (the withholding of
resources – time, information,
training, support, equipment –
that guarantee failure) – which
are all driven by the bully's need
to control the target.”
An amendment to Quebec's
Labor Standards Act brought into
effect in June, 2004, defines
psychological harassment as:
"any vexatious behavior in the
form of repeated and hostile or
unwanted conduct, verbal comments, actions or gestures that
affect an employee's dignity or
psychological or physical integrity
and that results in a harmful work
environment for the employee."
The favored definition of bullying
amongst psychologists is persistent devaluing demeaning or
harassing of someone at work.
The International Labor Organization (ILO) definition of workplace
violence includes bullying: "any
incident in which a person is
abused, threatened or assaulted
in circumstances relating to their
work. These behaviors would
originate from customers, coworkers at any level of the organization. This definition would
include all forms or harassment,
bullying, intimidation, physical
threats/assaults, robbery and
other intrusive behaviors."
CARM workplace violence report
Issue 2
You, of course, are not important enough to be part of the communication loop; no
mail, no e-mail, no place on memo distribution, no calls returned. New rules appear
on a whim, which you have to adhere to, unlike the Petty Tyrant who is way above
such things.
Then there is the more common Smiling Assassin: the so-called friend who is really
an enemy; or the changeling whose main weapons are inconsistency and unpredictability; or the reporter, quick to point out your enemies and uses rumor and the
threat of rumors to undermine colleagues. Smiling Assassins adopt a passiveaggressive, indirect, dishonest style of dealing with people and issues. Think, Jekyll
and Hyde: one minute pretending to be supportive while in the next breath (behind
you back) sabotaging you. Friendship to these people is no more than a means of
lowering resistance and gathering information. Behind that smile lurks naked aggression, ready to assassinate your reputation with co-workers and bosses. Confidentiality? No such thing: private information is currency to sabotage your career.
Less common, but by far the most dangerous, is the Corporate Psychopath who will
use any or all of the above tactics to get where they want – to the top. Here’s Dr
Paul Babiak’s description from ABC’s Background Briefing (18/7/04): “Insincere,
arrogant, untrustworthy, manipulative, insensitive to the thoughts and feelings of
others, remorseless, shallow, meaning the person seems not to have feelings, is
incapable of experiencing or understanding the feelings of others. Tends to blame
others for things that go wrong, has low frustration tolerance and is therefore impatient with things. Erratic, unreliable, unfocused, and is selfish, parasitic, they take
advantage of the goodwill of people they work with as well as the company itself.”
This may not sound like the kind of person you would want around, but you would
only know if you were their target. They are generally busy doing many things at
once, but never finishing any of them. Not that anyone notices: the pace is fast and
furious and they look like the perfect employee. Look for them especially in organizations, from corporations to churches. “It’s easier for them to hide because the
kinds of things they say and do seem to be what the organizations want: someone
who has charm and charisma, someone who can command respect, who is larger
than life, and the psychopath is very prone to fill those shoes,” says Dr Babiak.
“They really do have charm and charisma. And we can sometimes mistake that for
leadership, especially if we believe their stories…and they are great storytellers. They
can tell a good story and they can be very entertaining and they can weave a lot of
facts, which really are disjointed, but they can bring it together into a powerful story,
almost looking to us like a vision.”
Publisher
The CARM™ Workplace Violence
Report is published by Passmore
Duff International Pty Ltd, specialists in the provision of high
quality workplace violence training services.
For more information please visit
our website at
www.carmtraining.com
Disclaimer
The CARM™ Workplace Violence
Report is intended as general
information only and is not a
substitute for specific advice
which takes account of your
particular needs and circumstances. Such specific advice
should always be obtained prior
to making any decision or taking
any action with respect to the
subject matter of a CARM™
Workplace Violence Report.
Passmore Duff International Pty
Ltd expressly disclaims liability for
any act or omission which occurs
as a direct or indirect result of
reliance upon the information
contained in the CARM™ Workplace Violence Report
.
No matter which type of bully operates in your workplace, as Edmund Burk reminds
us: “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.”
CA RM Workplace Violence Training
TM
North America
Asia Pacific
44 Thirty Sixth Street Toronto, Ontario
M8W3K9, Canada.
Unit 2, 152 Sailors Bay Road, Northbridge,
NSW, Australia.
Tel: + 416-259-0430
PO Box 718, Northbridge NSW 1560 Aust
Email: [email protected]
Tel: +61 (2) 9967-1555
Email: [email protected]
4
CARM
Workplace Violence Training
TM