Similarity and contrast relations and inductive rules Alistair Knott

!"#$%'&()+*,(& -/.10325476)018:9<; =!4>4
?A@!BDC7E<FGHBIBJ@!E)KML>C7NKOGPE/QR7SR7CUT%LWV<FRXENYTR
ZAE!K\[R>T]SKON^_G7`,abKOEc!@!TYdHV
f =gih 6!87012>=; 2j6!2:k=ml n8Un; kn
78 n.164701=; 2
op7qsr
tPu]tHvw
xy5z7r3qs{7vw1rp7y]|}xy5~tPuWw3qsr3y5zw3vuW3qsyzUr xYuWz
vqsz>3v5wuW3v{|qs3p7qsz,uWz, >o(Msqsv~AyX{UvyWP{7qsr3xy57w3r1v
jv|qs!xy5z7r3qs{7vwM|(yw1vu]1qy5z7rY! 5Ht7w3y53yW
M >t7qsxYu]ss r1qszPuWsv{ ¡xyzUz7vx1q¢5vrsqsv£]¤¦¥§,u]zU{:¨\§§Y©
u]zU{«ª¬®/tUw3y1yM >t7qsxYuWs r1q5zPu]ssv{ xyz7z7vx
3qs¢5vrsqsv¯°7±²3±£]¥u]z7{¯°7³s¤s±©)´µz1p7vµ¶u]xv y]qsr17xp
w3vuW3qsyzUrr1p7yU{ vjvYu]r1 ·1y:¸H|qs1p7qszuWzuWxxyUzX
sqsv >o¹ rYAº y]|(v¢5vwY3p7v jvYu]xpjv»>p7q qsxvw3uWqszjq{¼
qsyr1 XzUxwuWxqsvrYj½Uywqsz7r1u]zUxv1p7vª¬/w3vu]1qsyz
qszIµ>oiqsr,UzXUr3PuWqzJpPu¢>qsz7¾u'~7s3qsz>7xsvYu]w
r13w3Ux
3Uw3vHwuW3p7vw 3pHu]z1p7vM >t7qsxYu]z>7xv7rMMruW3vssqs3vr13w3Ux
3Uw3vj\¿uWz7zDu]z7{Jop7y~At7r3y5z(ÀYÁÂ5Â©: 5H·qsr
7z>7r1Pu]µqz/1pPu]qs3ruWr3r1yXxquW3v{Ãxyz7zUvx3qs¢5vrxYuWz·u]t¼
tPuWw3vz>3s ¢>qsyu]1v r13w3Ux37wu]xyz7r13wu]qsz>3ry] >o>sqsz75
qsz7_3p7vr1tPu]z/qsz:|pUqxp/3pUv IuWt7tPvu]w3yjr13w17x3Uwu]ss qszPu]xxvr3r1q svr3tPuWz7rYHu]rqsz1p7v
\y5sy]|qsz7
1v»>YÄ
3À© ÅpHu¢vM|(y w3y53p7vw3rY_Æ5yp7zjqsr,u¡r137{Uvz>YÇ°7±
È £3É§5²¥,³Ê°U³s¥¨\§5²Ë]
º vsqsvr
|u]3vwÌtHysyHÍuWz7{
p7vAt7u >r,1p7v{7w17~r¡Îqss(qru]Ïp7qspjr3xp7y>y5¶
ºµqr
~¡u]qszqsz>3vw1vr3Ïqrµ{7wuW~uU Ð±£W¤Ñ¥§A¥+¨OÒ>Ó³±¥
°U³s¥¨\§5²Ë] 7p7vÏ{7y>vr3z¹ sqsvµq~Uxp
´µ7w¡r375vr13qsyzÃ\ywAqszX1vwu]1qzU:xy5~tPuWw3qsr3y5zDw3vu%
3qsy5z7r,|qs1p7qsz:u~AyX{UvyW {7qsr3xy57w3r1vw3vuW3qsyzUr,{7vw3qs¢vr
\w1y~$u<~v1p7y>{Ôy]{7v+¸Pz7qsz7}w3vuW3qsyzUrjqzÕ1vw3~Arjy]
t7w1vr37tUtPy5r3v{D{Uv\vYuWr3q svw17svrY'op7qsr,~Av3p7y>{j|qss v
yU3sqsz7v{<\y5wxu]7ru]Ö]qsz>\vw3vz>3quWw3vuW3qsyz7r,uWz7{}3p7vz
u]{Hu]t71v{¡3yxy5~tPuWwu]1qs¢vw3vuW3qsyzUrY
× f =l n87n;µkn·87n.364703=;µ2j6!; Ø"Ø nÍÙYn6!2>03Ú .1n
87Û .1n2
>v¢5vwuW7w3vr3vYuWw3xp7vw1rpPu¢5v7r1v{,{Uv\vYuWr3q svw17svr!qszw3vu%
3qsy5z{Uv¸Pz7qs3qsy5z7rYÅMzJ\´µ¢vw1r31vvvzÀÁÁ5Ü©u]zU{:\Ý
w1y1v
vju]MsÀYÁ5ÁÜ©{7v+\vYu]r1q svjw37svr:uWw3v:Ur3v{Þ\yww1vt7w1v
r3vzX1qsz7¡3p7vª¬®ªHßPY\¬®Iw1vu]1qy5zÅMz/à
z7y53ÀÁÁáUÇ
à
z7y1)uWz7{,¿¡vssqsr3p5ÀYÁ5Áá©1p7v ,uWw3v7r1v{~Ayw3v!|qs{7vs >
qsz3p7vµ{7v¸PzUq1qsyz7r(y])u
|pUysv(¶u]~Aqs yWxYu]7ru]u]z7{¡u]wâ
U~vz>uW3qs¢vÏxyp7vw3vz7xvw1vu]1qy5z7rYjv,|qss v5qsz yU3sqsz7qsz7r3y5~v
u]r3tHvx1r
y])1p7qsru]31vw u]xxy7z>
ÅMz¾à
z7y53¹ ruWxxyUzXÏy]xyp7vw3vz7xvw1vu]1qy5z7rYu]s!w3v
u]1qy5z7r
|qs3pjuxu]7ru](yw
qsz>\vw1vz>3qu]xy~tHyzUvz>ÌtUw3v
e
r17t7tHyr3v
u{Uv\vYuWr3q sv w17sv)½Uyw(qsz7r3u]z7xv>xyzUr3qs{7vw(3p7v
\y5sy]|qsz7
xYuWr3vÄ
Oã© Æ5yp7z¡|u]r1qw1v{Ur3yp7v|(vz>3y v{
DpHu]qsz>\y5w3~¡u]3qsy5z¾{7y>vr1p7v¡xypUvw3vzUxv¾w1vu]1qy5z:r1qW
zPuWsv{ ¥§xy5z>3w3q U3v3y
1p7v3v»>ä¡ÅMqsrqs~t7uW7r3q sv
1yÌr175vr3(3pHu]qs!qsz>\yw1~r!3pUvp7vYu]w1vw(y]u
z7v|/w3Uvµy]
qsz>\vw3vz7xvÇHqzA¶uWxqsr3vv~rz7vxvr3ru]w3 _3pHu]3pUvp7vYuWw3vw
uWw1vYu]{U ,pPu¢5v3p7vµz7vxvr3ruWw3 Aw37sv 1y~uWv(r3vzUr3v
y]3p7v
1v»>Yå v31vwu]zPuWs Xr1qsrqsr3pPuW,1p7vpUvYu]w1vwqsr vqzU
1ys{j3pPuW3p7qsrw37svAy]Ìqsz>Ovw3vzUxvj¥Ò>ææ±±Ó]¥qsz:1p7v¡r3qsM
PuW3qsyzj{Uvr3xw1q v{Djv¡xYu]z/r17~~¡u]w3qsr1v,1p7qsrq{UvYu t7w1ytHyr1qzU1pPu]uw1vu]1qy5z¾yWç1p7v\y5w3~éèçê¥+§JëDt7w1v
r17t7tHyr3vr,u{7v+\vYu]r1q sv,w17sv,1pPu]µpPu]rìiuWr tPuWw3
y]qs1r
sv\â¶pHu]z7{Ar3qs{7vHu]z7{¡íÔy5z¡q1rw3qsp>
op7vvz7vwuWµ\wuW~v|(yw1_\ywAt7w3vr17t7tHyr1v{}w37svrAqsr
5q¢5vzDqsz}½qs57w3vDÀ5î½Uyw'3p7vjt7w1vr3vzX|(vjqszX1vw3tUw3v
1p7v
xyz7zUvx3qs¢5v,ïu]r1p7v
{7v\vYuWr3q svqs~tUqsxYuW3qsy]zAð·qsz
å r3pUvw,u]zU{ñ¿¡y5w3w1vYu]mÀYÁÁUÀY©¹ rµsyqsxyWxy5~~y5z7r3vz7r3v
vz>u]qss~vz>YHòµy3v(3pHu]|(v(pPu¢vu r31wuWx3v{u|u Ow3y~
op7vw1vu]3qsy5zpUys{7r vM|(vvz_M|yAt7w3y5tPyW
r3qs3qsy5z7rY>óÔuWz7{Aô#
ÅMtUw3vr17t7tHyr3vrÌ1p7v
v»>qsr33vz7xvyW)u{7v+\vYu
r3q sv
w37sv
y]!3p7võ\yw1~iöi÷ìÃïùø
½ qs7w1v#À5Ä½7wu]~Av|y5w3Ï\ywú!w1vr37tUtPy5r3v{:û7svr
1p7vr1qs~t7svxy5w3w1vr3tHyz7{Uvz7xv vM|vvzw1vu]3qsy5z#uWz7{,w17sv
uWr3r3U~v{,u y]¢5vÄ1p7v~uWt7t7qsz7 vM|(vvzAüìDuWz7{ø/qsr
{7v3vw1~qsz7v{ 3p7vµ¢u]s7vryWM|yõ\7w31p7vw(tPu]wu]~Av3vw1rY
uWrv»>t7uWqzUv{¡qz>vx3qsyzUr ã7sÀÌuWz7{ã7ýã7
¬ ß Jß X ß P¬®H
þ®ÿ
´µz7vy]1p7vtPuWwu]~Av3vw3r |(vz7vv{j1yr1tPvxq¦\ xy5z7xvw1z7r
|p7v3p7vwÏ3p7v{7v\vu]r3q svw37svr37xxvv{7ry5w
qrµ{7v\vu]3v{
ÅMz !»7u]~At7svã73p7vmw37svr17xxvv{7rY7uWr|(vpPu¢vmr3vvzÇ U
1p7vw3v¡u]w1vu]sr3yr1qs~qsu]w xu]r3vr,|p7vw3vu«{7v\vYuWr3q svw17sv
r1p7y7s{ v,uWzPu]s >r3v{u]r vqsz7{7v+\vYu]1v{(½7y5wqzUr3uWz7xvÄ
© Æ5yp7z¡|u]r1qw1v{ 7p7v
r3u v{u|u]5v
jvxYu]z<xYuW
1p7qsrw1vu]1qy5z·u:ª¬®ªHßP\¬®ý© ÅO#|(v
1w3vYuWÌ1p7vr3Uxxvr1rywµ¶u]qss7w1v,yW3p7vtUw3vr17t7tHyr3v{Iw17sv
u]r uÏtPuWwu]~Av3vw1y vr3tHvxq¦¸Pv{7|(v
xYu]z¡7r1vÌ1p7v
ruW~v
\wu]~v|y5w31y,w1vt7w3vr3vz> y53pAv»7u]~tUvrYop7v tPuWwuW~
v1vwxYuWz v(xYuWsv{ P¬®HÇ]opUvw1vsv¢u]z>!¢u]s7vr!u]w1v
qs¢5vzqsz½q57w3vãU
H¬H
H¬ ß üqrµqs{7vz>3qsxYuW)1yü \Ç1p7vt7w1v
r3Ut7tPy5r3v{'w37sv
r37xxvv{7r
ß > ß ü}qsrqsz7xy5z7r3qsr31vz>|qs1pü OÇ>3p7v
t7w1vr37tUtPy5r3v{_w37svµ¶uWqsr
Æ :|u]r'~u]{Uv ûqxpPuWw3{}ú!u]v5 Yâop7qsr
3w y>y>xp|u]r(u]sr3y~¡u]{7v ,qsxpPuWw3{ú!u]5vÎ(7
|pUvw3vYuWrÆ |u]r~¡u]{7vqsz}ÀYÁ5ÂÜ7!1p7qsr w3y>y>xp
|u]r~¡u]{7vqszjÀYÁ5Á U
op7qsrxy5~tPuWw3v3u]zU{>¶xyz>3wu]r3tPu]13vw1zqsrxy5~~Ayzqsz{7v
r1xw3qst71q¢5v¡3v»>3rDjvAr3vv~1y¾pHu¢v¡p7vw1v¾u¾ª¬®ªHßP
\¬jw1vu]1qy5zjr3qs5zPu]ssv{ ÒX¨s©H|p7y5r3vru]1vsqs1vqsr u
xy5~t7sv»r1tPu]zxy5~t7w1qr1qsz7 u Hw3vuW3qsyz]uWz7{
|p7y5r3vµzXUxsv7r qsruxy~tUv»,r1tPu]zAxy~At7w3qsr3qsz7u,ª¬®
¾w1vu]1qy5zÄr1vv½qs57w3v Hop7v >7vr33qsy5zqsrY7|p> OÜ©
<>
@-
A
!
½ qs57w3vã7Ä!opUv H¬H:tPu]wu]~v3vw
op7v P¬5HtPuWwu]~Av3vw~u]tUrPüDy5z>3y u(z7v|j¢uWw3q¦
u v!ü ÅMz !»7u]~tUvrÍãuWz7{ 7ü r1p7yU{ vqs{7vz>3q¦¸Pv{
|qs3pJ3p7v¡xy5z7xs7r3qsy5zIø"yWÌ1p7v¡t7w3vr17t7tHyr1v{Dw3Uv51y
qs¢5v3p7vµw3qsp>qsz>3vw1t7w3vu]1qsyz!åDxu]r3vµ|p7vw1vÌü Pz7vv{7r
u{7q vw3vz> qsz7{UqzU,qsrqs¢5vzqsz¡3p7v
z7v»Xµr3vx3qsyz
5>ß7
P>ß7
þ®ÿþ
op7v¸PzHu]!tPu]wu]~Av3vw
|(v,|qss!xyzUr3qs{7vw
qsr
xYu]ssv{ ]X
ß7:¬ >>\¬®!op7qsr!\vYuW37w1vÌqsr~Ay1q¢uW3v{
v»7uW~t7svr(r37xpu]r1p7v
\y5sy]|qsz7HÄ
>© Æ5yp7z¡|u]r3qsw1v{ 73p7vw3v|u]r|(yw13y{7yH
svYu]w1s Ì|(v{7y
z7y5|u]z>!3y
ru 1pPu]!1p7qsr)v»¼uW~t7svtUw3v
r3Ut7tPy5r3vruw17sv,u]ssy]|qsz7qsz>\vw1vz7xvOw3y~"Æ5yp7z vqsz7
3qsw1v{,1y
3p7vw1v vqzUÌzUyÌ|(yw1
3y
{7yPÅM!qsr)tUw3v\vwu v1y
vz>¢>qsru]5v#uw37sv|qs3p_M|yAxyz7{Uq1qsyz7r
qszqs3r
sv\â¶pPuWz7{
r3qs{7v5ru Xqsz7µ3pPuW!qÑÆy5p7zqr!1qw1v{£ÊUÓ3p7vw3v qsr!z7y
|(yw3
3y{UyPp7v!|qs]5y3y v{jv!xYu]z1p7vz,uWr3r1yXxquW3v1p7vü
¢u]s7v|qs1p3pUv r3vxyz7{¡t7w1v~qsr1v>wuW3p7vw(3pHu]z|qs1p3pUv
xy5z7xs7r3qsy5z!op7v
tPu]wu]~Av3vw({7v1vw3~Aqsz7qsz73pUv qzU{7qsz7
\y5wü qsrqs¢vzAqsz«½qsUw3v 7
]>ß7I¬ >>\¬
5XßU ü <ì
H>ß7 ü <ø
?
>
= >
.-
1
"
B
CONCESSION
#
SIMILARITY
CONTRAST
$
J0 was made
by Richard
Page.
&%
(*)
'
+,
.-
0/
1
2
0/
3
4
)
4
½qs7w1v UÄop7v ]XßU ¬ ¾>>\¬®¾tPuWwuW~
v1vw
!»7u]~At7sv qsr1p7vzu]zPuWs Xr1v{uWrß > ß H¬
H >ß7H
|p7qsv !»7uW~t7sv _qsru]zHu]s >r3v{Du]r
ß > ß P¬5H P5>ß7P>vv,à
z7y53PÀÁÁáUÇ
à
z7y1#uWz7{I¿«vsqsr1p ÀÁÁá5©µ\y5w#u'~y5w3v{7vu]qssv{:tUw3v
r3vzXu]1qy5z:yWç1p7qsr\wu]~Av|y5w3uWy5z7¡|qs3pj{7v¸Hz7qs3qsyz7r
y]!r3v¢5vwuW!~yw1v qsz7{7vtPvzU{7vz> tPuWwuW~v1vw3r
f =gih 6!87012>=; 2j6!; Ø"n hnkH4764703=;µ2
Dp> ~qsp>|(v u]r1r37~Av1pPu](3pUvw3vµqr(u
{7v\vu]r3q svw17sv
7z7{Uvw3s >qsz7,w1vu]1qy5z7r(y]) 5HñuWz7{ª¬®ä
å zÏqzUq1qu]]t7qsvxvmy]7v¢>qs{7vz7xvxy~vrH\w3y5~·xy5z>3v»>3r!r17xp
u]r
1p7v\yssy]|qsz7P>qsz|pUqxpjuAr3qs~qsu]w1qM vM|(vvzjM|(y
y vx3r¡qszDy5z7vw3vr3tHvx¾uWt7tPu]w1vz>3s /qs¢vrw3qsr3v_3y/u]z
v»>tHvxuW3qsyz'y])r1qs~qsu]w3qs1qvr)qsz¡y1p7vww1vr3tHvx1rY
5
$
0/
61
(
3
7
(
8)
0:
9
<;
.-
This brooch was But whereas this brooch
also made by
J0 was made was made
Richard Page.
in 1985,
in 1990.
½ qs57w3v PÄå zHu]s >r3qsry]!3p7v1v»>qsz »¼uW~t7sv Ü
{7y|(v!pPu¢v(uª¬ªHßPO¬w3vuW3qsyz vM|(vvz3p7vr1vM|(y
xy5~t7sv»¡r1tPu]z7rä}åµxxyw1{7qsz7¡3y1p7vu]zHu]s >r3qsr yWûª¬®
ªHßP\¬Jw3vu]1qsyz7rqszj>vx1qsyz:ã7sÀ53p7vw1vu]1qy5z¾~Ur3
t7w1vr3Ut7tPy5r3vA3p7vv»>qsr31vz7xvAy] uA{7v\vYuWr3q svw37sv|p7qsxp
qsr vqsz7{7vOvYu]1v{u](3p7qsrtHyqsz>YDpPu](xy57s{3pUvÌw17sv
vqszj3pUqrÏxYu]r1vYä"jv|(y7s{_z7y|u]z>3y'r37t7tHyr1vu
w17sv 3pHu](qÑ)uWzy vxqsr(~u]{Uv ú!uWv>qsqsr(qs5vs ,1y
v ~¡u]{7v(qszÀYÁÁ 7! uW3p7vw|(v zUvv{u
w3Uvµ3pPuWr1uW3vr
1pPu](q¦)M|(y,y vx1rÌu]w1v
r3qs~qsu]w!qszr1y~vµw3vr1tPvxYH3pUv uWw3vu]sr3yr3qs~AquWw)qsz¡y1p7vww1vr3tHvx1rY
f =gihµ6)8U032>=; 2j6!;µØ"03; ØµÛ kH470 (nD87Û .1n2
jvt7w1ytHyr1v 3pHu]ur1q~AqsuWw3qsM w1vu]1qy5zr1p7y7s{ v w1vt>
w1vr3vz>1v{:u]rµ3w3qs5vw1qzUr3Uxpjuw17svµjvr375vr1
3pPuW
r1q~AqsuWw3qsM sqsv!y1p7vw!w3vuW3qsyzUrYt7w3vr37t7tHyr1vru{7vOvYu]r1qÑ
svw17svÇ 7(3pPuW1p7v w17sv qsz >7vr13qsyzAqrµ³Ê7ÓÒ>æ¨\³ Y±(qsz
\y5w3~_!ÅMz w3qsvP|(vr175vr3µ3pPuWÌur1qs~qsu]w3qsM w3vuW3qsyz
vM|(vvzjM|(yt7w3y5tPy5r3qs3qsy5z7r v1p7y75p>ÌyWûuWrtHvw3~Aqâ
1qzUu]zqsz7{7Ux3qs¢vw3UvÏ3y¸Hw3v|pUqsv,uxyz>1wu]r1
w3vu
1qy5z vA3p7y57p>y]ÌuWrt7w3v¢vz>3qsz7ju]zJqsz7{77x1qs¢vw17sv
\w1y~Õ¸Hw3qsz7P
ÅMz¾>vx1qsyz HÀ
|(vy573sqsz7vu~AvxpPu]z7qsr1~Õ\ywµqsz7{77x
1q¢5v,w17svrYu]z7{jqsz¾>vx3qsyz Hýã|(v\wuW~vuA{7v¸Pz7qs1qy5z
\y5wxy~AtPu]w1qsr3yz¡w1vu]3qsy5z7r
|q1pw3vr3tHvx1y3pUqr
~Avxp>
uWz7qsr3~¾
ÿ
jv_|qs
w1vt7w3vr3vz>jqsz7{77x3qs¢vjw17svrñuWr¡ytHvwuW3qsz7·uW
u'~vuMsv¢vmyzIu_{Uv\vYuWr3q sv¸Pw1r3â¶y5w3{7vwAsyqsx uWr3v{
y5zxy5~~y5z7r3vz7r3vvz>u]qss~vz>Y®jv vz>¢>qsru]5v
qzU{77x1q¢5v
w17svr#uWt7t7s >qsz7¾u]r
w3UvrY(|p7yr1v¡xyz>
xs7r1qsyz7ruWw3v
{7v\vYuWr3q svw17svrYÇµ|p7vz·uWz
qsz7{7Ux3qs¢vw3UvÏ¸Pw1vrYqsÌw1vr3U1rqsz¾1p7vu]{U{7qs3qsyzy5wu]¦
1vwuW3qsyzy]{7v\vu]r3q sv(w37svrm|q1p7qsz,1p7v(¸Pw1r3MMyw1{7vw(r3 >rM
1v~¾
C1
D
.-
<;
E>
<;
HG
F
IB
J
(1
K
81
LNM
O P
7\
@QRS M
Z X .O[ @
S
[
O
TUWV,XY+ PI V
½7y5w 1p7v,~Ay~Avz>Y>|(v{7y¡z7yµ|çuWz> r3y¡{7vr3xw1q v3pUv
|(yw3>qsz75rÌyW3pUqr
r1vxyzU{>¶y5w3{7vw,r1 Xr13v~ qszju]z> ¡{7vuWqs¶Ç
yUwxy5z7xvw1z,p7vw3v(qrw3vYuWs 7r13yxyz7r1q{Uvw!|p7v3pUvw!qz¼
{77x3qs¢vµw37svr(~qsp>!pPu¢5v uw1ysvqszv»>t7u]qsz7qsz7
xvw3uWqsz
r31w37x37wu](t7w3y5tPvw13qsvry]xy~AtPu]w1qsr3yzUrYòµv¢vw33pUvsvr3r
|(v|qst7w3y5tPy5r3vuAw37{Uq~Avz>uWw3 ~AyX{UvyWç~Avu%¶sv¢5v
w3UvrY
op7v/¸Pw1r3â¶y5w3{7vwÃr3 >r31v~ |(v·tUw3ytHyr1v·qsrJq{Uvz>3qsxYu]
3y¡xy5~~Ayz7r1vz7r3v
vz>u]qss~vz>YUv»>xvt73pHu]
vYu]xp'¸Pw3r1M
yw1{7vwµ{7v\vYuWr3q svw17svÌqsr uWr3r3y>xquW3v{_|qs3pu

w3vt7w3vr1vz>3v{ ñu«tPu]qswy] ¢u]s7vr Y|p7vw3v qr3pUv
z>7~ vwy]3qs~Avr3pUvw37sv pHu]r vvz¡3w1qsvw3v{¡u]z7{ µqsr
3pUvzXU~ vw
yWç1q~Avr qs
pPuWrr37xxvv{7v{¡åiw3UvyzU vxy~AvrtPuWw3y]3p7vAr3v7r1v{:qsz_¸Pw1r3MMyw1{7vw{7v\vu]r3q¦
sv
w3vYuWr3y5z7qsz7q¦)qs3r¢uWUvrOyw u]z7{ vYu]xp¡w3vYuWxp¾u
xvw1uWqz¡1p7w3vr1p7ys{mº y]|(v¢vwY7w17svr |qs1p¢u]s7vr vsy]|
3pUv,1p7w3vr1p7ys{_xYu]z'r33qss v7r3v{ju]rµ3p7vt7w1vxyzU{7qs3qsyz7r
\y5w{7qsr3xy57w3r1vw3vuW3qsyz7r
jv
3p7vz_{7v¸Hz7vur1vxyzU{>¶y5w3{7vw{7v\vu]r3q svxyz7z7vx
3qs¢5v 3y~Ay>{7vqsz7{U7x3qs¢5vw37svr
å z_qsz7{77x1qs¢vw17sv
pPuWr3p7v5vz7vwu]®\yw1~iqs¢vz vsy]|Ä
\á5©
ì ì >©÷¡ì ©\÷ ©
|p7vw1v v¢u]sPu]1vr1y,y5z7vyw(~y5w3vm¸Pw3r1MMyw3{Uvw{7v\vu]r3q¦
svw17svrY!DpUvz,uw17svqsr3w3qs5vw1v{]1p7v )uWz7{ (¢uWUvr
y]vu]xpyW3p7vµw3qsp>MMpPuWz7{r3qs{7vµw37svr uWw3v qsz7xw3v~Avz>3v{
jv,|qss vA7r3qsz7 Ur3M|y¡qsz7{77x3qs¢vw17svrY!|p7qsxp
u]w1vqs¢vz,qsz½qs57w3vÜ7!7sv ru >r!3pHu]5q¢5vzM|y
y
vx3r qsz¡xu]r1r µ|p7qsxpu]w3v y53pì7|(v
xYu]z'qzUxw3v~Avz>
3pUvr31w3vz753pjyW 1p7vw17sv3pPuWÌuWr3r3vw33rÏ3pPuW y vx3r
qsz
xu]r1r ,uWw3vM XtUqxu]ss ìû7sv,Âru Xr
1pPu]
q¦M|(yy
vx3r¡pPu¢v¡y5z7vt7w1ytHvw3M ·ì qszDxy5~~Ayz!|(vr3pUy7s{
qsz7xw1v~vz>
3pUv,r13w3vz71pjy]çuW!w17svr
3pPuWõuWsy]|<7r1y
qsz>\vwt7w3y5tPvw33qsvrmy]Py5z7vy vx!y5z3p7v uWr3qsr!y]P>z7y]|qsz7
t7w1ytHvw31qvr y]1p7v
y3pUvwY
ÿþ
º y]|Õ~Aq5p>|v¡u]zPuW >r1v£W¤Ñ¥§u]rÏt7w3vr17t7tHyr1qzUñuWzjqz¼
{77x3qs¢vw17svYä<op7v¸Pw1r31p7qsz7|(vz7vv{jqsruAz7v|ÕtPu%
wuW~v1vw!\y5wr3tHvxq¦\ >qsz7|pHu]r1yw3my]w3Uvqsr vqsz7tUw3v
r3Ut7tPy5r3v{ÇP1p7qsrqsr5q¢5vz¡qsz½qs7w1võáU
5ßjH 7ß
] ¬ ß7 ÅMz3p7vµt7w3vr37t7tHyr1v{w17svXï qsr
qszX1vw3tUw3v1v{¾u]r
ð
ªH ß ÅMz3p7vµt7w3vr37t7tHyr1v{w17svXï qsr
qszX1vw3tUw3v1v{¾u]r <
;
IS #]^
ca
!_+`ba
Z_
da
(_`a
!e
f hgjig[k
i
k
7lll enm
m
a
!_
;
;
po
"q
<;
q
;
<;
r RVXY+ PI V
K
.-
.u
+s
\#
R
3
t
C
.u
3
Ue
½ qs57w3vá7Ä µv¸Hz7qs3qsyzAy])1p7v ß_H 7ß¡\vu]3Uw3v
jvxYuWz3p7vzj{7v¸Pz7v¡£]¤¦¥§#uWr r1q5zPu]ssqsz7u H¬ ß
P¬®H >ß7u]z7{ ªH ßw3vuW3qsyz v
M|(vvz1p7v
t7w3y5tPy5r3qs3qsyzUrq(sqsz7>rY!º vw3vqsr u]zAv»7u]~At7svÄ
\Á5© Î(w3y>y>xpÎÌÀ(qsr!yw3zHu]3v51Y1©Î(w3y>y>xpÎçãûqruWr1y
y5w3zPuW3v
v
R
3
I
3
.u
3
åµxxyw1{7qsz71yy7wm~y>{7vM]y5z7vy]1p7vv vx3rµy]3p7qsrw1v
u]1qsyz qsr3y
xYu]Ur3v(3p7v(qsz7{77x1qs¢vw17sv 1y¸Pw1v]|p7qsxpqsz
17w3zpHu]r 1p7vv vxÏy]qsz7xw3vu]r3qsz7A3p7vÏr33w1vz753p_y]3p7v
5vz7vwu]sqsru]1qsyz/3pPuW w3y>y>xp7vr¡y]1p7vxu]r1r¡3yj|p7qsxp
Î
À,uWz7{Îã vsyz7¡u]w3vM >t7qsxYu]ss yw1zPu]1v
op7qsr r1vv~Ar
ut7u]7r1q vv vx!tPu]w13qsx7u]w1s qszjuA{7vr3xw3qst73qs¢5vxyz>
1v»>|p7vw3vuw3vu]{7vwÖ]p7vu]w3vwÌqsr vqsz7qsz>\y5w3~v{u yU
y vx1r qszuWzUz>¶u]~Aqsqsu]w!{7y5~u]qsz
ò y]|<xyz7r1qs{7vwuxyz>1wu]r1 w1vu]3qsy5z7yW 1p7v>qsz7{r1qW
zPuWsv{ ¯°7±²3±£]¥´µzy57w~Ay>{7vM1p7qsrw3vuW3qsyz
|(y7s{
vß > ß P¬5H >ß7IuWz7{j ª
ßºµvw3vqsr uWzv»¼uW~t7svyW r17xpuw3vu]1qsyzÄ
1À © Î(w3y>y>xpjÎÌÀqsr
yw1zPu]1v|pUvw3vYuWrÎ(w3y>y>xpjÎãAqsr
r1qs~t7sv
åµxxyw1{7qsz7_3y_3p7v¡~y>{7v¶3pUvv Ívxy] 1p7qsrw3vuW3qsyz
qsrr1q~At7s 3y'vu¢v1p7v ¡uWz7{ ¢u]s7vr,yW 3p7vAvz7vwM
uWqsru]3qsy5z3pHu] Ñu]s w3y>y>xp7vryW3p7vw3vsv¢uWz>ÌxuWr3ru]w1v
y5w3zPuW3v¹57z7xpPuWz7v{!op7qsrqsrz7y(tPuWw33qsxUuWw3s ru]3qsrâ¶u]x
1yw3 ÇH|(v~qsp>(|çuWz>3y~¡u]5v qs pPu¢5v,u~y5w3v
r3qs5z7q¦
qsxYuWzX
v vx!tPvw3pPuWt7r qsz7xw3vYuWr3qsz7¡yz7s 1p7v ¢u]s7v
3p7vw1v ¾w1v{77xqzU ©Ç 7,uWrÌ1p7qsz7ru]w3vx7w3w1vz>3s \y5w3~7uW3v{xpPu]zUvrA3yj3pUvr31w3vz753p7rAy]
¸Pw1r3MMyw1{7vw
w17svr u]w1vÌy5z7s tPy5r3r1q vÏ|p7vzu]z¡qsz7{77x3qs¢vµw37sv ²1±¥
>ß7I¬ >>\¬
ªH ß
[%
6o
[%
[%
<;
w
.u
3
3 -
+>
x%
y_
8a
z
[%
a
{_`a
U|
0/
}T~ .u
3
+,
jvjpPu¢5v:r1vvzi1pPu]_3p7v P¬®H"tPuWwu]~Av3vw¾u]t>
tHvYu]w1r3yÃ{7y/7r3vO7,|(yw1DOyw¡ ªH ß}w3vu]1qsyz7r
jvr1p7y7s{jz7y]|Õxy5z7r3qs{7vw,|p7v3p7vw1p7v ]>ß7Ô¬
>>\¬jtHu]wuW~v1vwqsr t7w1y>{77x1q¢5vOyw ª
ß_w3vuW3qsyzUrYop7y5r3v|(vpPu¢vr3vvz:r1y¡¶u]w
pPu¢5v#uWs
vvz 5>ß7P¡DpHu]~Aq5p> u]zj ªH ß H
5XßUw3vuW3qsyz_syXy5sqsvYä}>Uxp:uAw1vu]3qsy5z¾|(y7s{
pPu¢5v1y
p7ys{ vM|(vvzAM|y
t7w1ytHyr1q1qsyz7ry5z7v vqzUõuWz
qsz7{7qs¢>qs{7PuW)tUw3ytHyr1qs3qsyzuWz7{:1p7v¡y1p7vw vqsz7ju'vz>
vwu]sqsruW3qsyz\y5w|pUqxpA3p7vµqzU{7qs¢Xqs{7Hu]Ht7w3y5tPy5r3qs3qsyztUw3y]
¢>qs{7v{qsz7{7Ux3qs¢vµr37tUtPy5w3Y´µz7vµtPy5r3r1q qsqsM qrm3pPuW1p7qsr
xuWr3ryWÍw1vu]3qsy5z7ru]w3v1p7yr1v |p7qsxpxYu]z vr3qszHu]ssv{ 1p7vxyzUz7vx1q¢5v³Ê7Ó±±Ó yzUr3qs{7vw(3p7vû\yssy]|qsz7v»7u]~
t7svÄ
1ÀÀY© opUqr v|(vqsrvu ywuW3vJÅMz7{7vv{(~y5r3åµw3M
µvxy v|(vsr u]w3vÏvu ywuW3v
ÅOÕ|v u]r3r17~v 3pPuW"3p7v t7w1ytHyr1q1qsyz È §]¥¨ ²¨
Ï±æ§<É±¯±¤¦¥Ô£²1± ±¤£ §²3£5¨\±<u]vrÔu]r<q1r}r3v~¡u]z>3qsx
¢uWUvîu ¸Hw3r3â¶y5w3{7vw {7v+\vYu]r1q sv"w37sv yW1p7v"Oyw3~
H
]©_ð
© 1p7vz}qsr1vv~Ar
1pPu]|(vxYuWzD{7vr1xw3q vj3p7vw1vu]1qy5z/r3qszPuWsv{ <³Ê
Ó5±±Ó uWr P¬ ß H¬H> ªH ßu]zU{ P5>
ß7H

.u
3
Z
0/
.u
3 -
.u
3
3
s) -
2
;
;
v

EA
fw _+i

g[i@a
qS
@ikSiYaj

y
.u 3
I)
.-
&
#~@C8 ~¡S¢p¢p¡S~~£@¢p~£USIS ~£¤
S¥d£¦~¦d£¡~§~~££¨#¢pS+£ ~©¡[ªS~ R~£ ~~«
¬ ¡j~®@~¯£¨CªS~@S£¡S£¡+¦ ~¦+¥7°&±<²S³³²$¦¡+p¡S£
¨[®S#£¡U<dUª@~~ S´£¨d§¡S§<¡S~¦p@ ~ ~¡@+£.¡[#°µ±<²@³³²p¦~¤
ªS~S£~¶£¨.~ªS@¦«
ì
5©
f pg
o

H
H

_+i
· gjq

gjq
f pg
ì ©
÷
ì ©

g ·

H ©ðDì ©
= f7 _i
e
·

ì
\Â5©
©÷¡ì ©
÷
©÷¡ì ©
_+i
g · gjq

=f
e
·

?
gjq
íÕí ©ðDí ©

· ?

½qs7w1võÜUÄ!o|y~Avu%¶sv¢5vHqzU{77x1q¢5v
w37svr
4787Û kH47Ûµ876!.,k=;µ2>n Û n; kn2j=Ù
30 ; ØµÛ kH470 (n·87Ûµ.3n2
jv|qssPz7y]|/xy5z7r3qs{7vw|p7v3pUvw3p7vµt7w3y5tPy5r3v{uWxxyUzX
y]Hxy~AtPu]w1qr1yzw1vu]1qy5z7rxu]zp7vst,Urqsz,u]xxy7z>3qsz7µ\y5w
r3y5~vµy])1p7vqsw UzXUr3PuWr33w17x17wuW)xpPuWwuWx3vw1qsr33qsxr
®ÿ
½qsw3r31s XHxy5z7r3qs{7vwu]XuWqsz !»7u]~At7svõÜUo!yw1vxYuWtÄ|pPuW
|(vpPu¢vp7vw1vqsrutHu]qsw
y]xy~AtPu]w1qr1yzw1vu]1qy5z7rY!u]t¼
tPuWw3vz>3s sqsz75v{ ¾u¡ª¬®ªHßPY\¬®:w3vuW3qsyzu]z7{_3pUv
{7q x7sM /qsr1yIv»XtUuWqszD|p> I1p7v:ª¬ªHßHY\¬ w3vu%
3qsy5z:u]t7t7sqsvr¾jvAxYu]z vqsz:1yñuWxxyUzXÏ\y5w,1p7qsr,v
\vx zUy3qsz73pHu](3p7v
qsz7qs3qu]Hr3qs~AquWw3qsM w3vu]1qsyz v
M|(vvz/3p7v¸Pw3r1,M|(y_r3vz>3vz7xvrAxYu]7r1vrUv¡Â¡3y'¸Pw1v
u]rÏ|vsuWr,Uv Uop7vAv Ívx,yWûû7svÂ¸Pw3qsz7qsr1y
u]{U{PÖ]qsz7xw1v~vzX
1p7vr13w3vz71p:y] u¡|p7y5svr3vy](¸Pw3r1M
yw1{7vww17svru]ssy]|qsz7qsz>\vw1vz7xv(\w1y~}Æ 7¹ r!tPy5r3r3vr3r3qsy5zy]
uAqs¢vzt7w3y5tPvw3M _3y1p7v w1yXy>xp¹ r
tPy5r3r1vr3r1qy5zjy]1pPu]
t7w1ytHvw3M _\u]zU{¢>qsxv
¢vw3ru5©´µz7vyW)1p7vr3vÏw37svr uWsy]|r
u]zqsz>\vw1vz7xv(Ow3y~ 3p7v{Hu]3v(y]~uWz>>¶u]x37w1vy]Py5z7vy
vx)1y
3pPuWy]H3p7vy53p7vwopUvxy5z>3wuWr3w1vu]1qy5zqsz3pUv
r3vxyz7{¡r1vz>3vz7xvÌtUw3y]¢>qs{7vr(qz¼\yw1~u]1qsyz1pPu]v»XtUqsxqs1 r3u]1vr1pPu]m3p7qsrqsz>\vw3vz7xv qsrz7y5tPvw3~qs13v{>u]zU{,~7r1
w3vr37s(qz1p7v zUv|s 3u]{U{7v{w3Uv vqzU{7v\vu]3v{q¦Íxyz>
r3qsr13vz7x qsr1y vÌtUw3vr1vw3¢5v{ÅO!|vµxYu]zAuWv3pUqr(3y v
uxu]r3v|pUvw3vû7sv,Âqsr {Uv\vYuW3v{|p7qsxpr3vv~r
t7u]¼
r3q sv(1p7vz<|v¡xYuWzDxyzUr3qs{7vwA3p7v_p7qsp>Msv¢vw3vu]1qsyz
r3qs5zPu]ssv{ YÒ>¨3y vß > ß P¬5H P>
ß7u]zU{¾ ªH ßH3pUvw3v _r3 r37~AqzUqµ|qs3p7qsz
u_¢vw3 /vzUvwuWõuWxxy57z>y]1p7vxy5zX1v»>3r¡|p7vw1v3pUqr
xy5z7z7vx1qs¢vqsr u]tUt7sqxu sv
®ÿþ
½qszPu]ss XÏ|v/xYuWzÕxyz7r1qs{7vwj|p7v1p7vwJ3p7v·uWxxy57z>jy]
xy5~tPuWw3qsr3y5z7r¾u]r_t7w1vr37tUtPy5r3qsz7Ôqsz7{U7x3qs¢5v:w3Uvrjt7w3yW
¢>qs{7vr:u]z> <|çu }yWv»>t7u]qsz7qsz7D1p7v/¢>qy5u]3qsy5z·yW«u]{¼
uWxvz7x }|pUqxp<3p7vJr3qs~qsu]w1qsM :w3vuW3qsyz<r3qs5zPu]ssv{ £]¤¦¥§u]t7tHvYu]w1r 1ytPvw1~qsY(´µ7wr375vr13qsyz'p7vw3vÏqr1pPu]
r3qsz7xvÌ1p7v
w37svrtUw3vr17t7tHyr3v{ xy~AtPu]w1qr1yzw1vu]3qsy5z7r
u]w1v¾yW,u:{Uq vw1vz>r1yw1Ow3y~ 3pUyr3v_t7w1vr37tUtPy5r3v{ xYuW7ruWÖWqsz>\vw1vz>3qu]
w3vuW3qsyzUrYqs¡qsrtHyr3r1q sv¾1pPu]¡3pUv
3pUvyw1v~Mt7w3y]¢>qsz7r1 >r33v~r(|p7qsxp¡r1vYu]w1xpA\y5w1p7v
qsz>\vwâ
vz7xvr
3pPuWxYu]z vÌ{Uwu|zA\w3y5~i3pUvqsz7xy~Aqsz7
¶uWx3rqsz
uµ{7qsr3xy57w3r1v u]w1vÓ³ ±²3±Ê7¨5\y5w)1p7v(M|y
>qsz7{7r!y]w37svrÅM
¸
Rº
¹
HG
» ¼
M8½
Oj0OxXYW @"@ V,XY+V
&¾
Zo
[%
;
>
A
.u
;
»
¿
8
3
p©T"ÀX XYQ
µ%
Á
)
.-
sq r Uz7xyz>1w3y]¢vw3r3quW)1pPu]
1p7vw3vr1p7yU{ ±
~Av3pUyX{Ur\y5w
xy5z7r31wuWqzUqzU1p7vr3vu]w3xp \yw
qsz>\vw1vz7xvr3y vA{7wu|z
\y5w y53p_M XtHvryWçw17svÇ!qszñuWz> uWw3vr1 >r33v~éyWMu]x1r
uWz7{}w37svrj1p7vw1vIqsr¾uWzÔv»>t7sy5r3qsyz}yWtPy5r3r3q svJqz¼\vwM
vzUxvr3y~¡u]v5#½Uyw
xYuW7ruWÖ]qsz>\vw1vz>3qu]mw3vu]1qsyz7r|(v
xy57s{,tHyr137uW3v 1pPu]m3p7vµr3vYuWw3xp\y5wqsz>\vw1vz7xvrqrmxyz>
r13wuWqsz7v{ ¾1p7vxy~tHyr1qs3qsyzPuW!r33w17x17w3v¡y]3pUv{7qsrM
xy57w3r1v!u]z7{_3p>7rqsz H7vz7xv{ '3p7vz>7xsv7râ¶ru]3vsqs3v
r13w3Ux37w1v¡y] qs3rw3vuW3qsyz7rÇu]z7{j1pPu]qsqsr,1p7qsr|p7qsxp
svYuW{7r,1y¾1p7v¡xw3qs1vw3qsyz/yWõu]{ u]xvz7x vqsz7_vz>\y5w3xv{
½Uyw¡xy5~tPuWw3qsr3y5z·w1vu]3qsy5z7rYÏyz}3pUv:y1p7vw_pPu]zU{|(v
xy57s{qs~uWqsz7v {Uq vw1vz>Ìxw3qs3vw1qu\y5w xy5z7r31wu]qsz7qsz7A3p7v
r1vYu]w1xpAr3tPuWxvÇ5\y5wqsz7r3u]z7xv>|vxy7s{r3Uvr3(3pPuW3p7v
r1vYu]w1xp'{7y>vr z7y5uWvr13w3Ux37wu]!t7w1y~qsz7vz7xv
qszX1yu]x
xy57z>Y 7!qr!r1q~At7s sqs~qs3v{Ì1y
3p7vt7w1v¢>qsy7r tUw3ytHy]
r1q1qsyz7rop7vw3v
qsrz7yr3tHu]xv
p7vw1v
3yv»>t7syw3vµ3p7qsr(tPy5r3r1qÑ
qssqsM qszuWzX {UvuWqMÇ>p7y]|(v¢5vwY>qsr3vv~ru]zAqz>1vw3vr13qsz7
y5z7v
3yxyz7r1qs{7vwY
/nHÙYn87n;µkn2
òÕå r1p7vw,uWz7{j¿ ¿¡y5w3w1vYu]ÀYÁ5Á7À5 y~A~yzUr3vz7r1vvz>
u]qss~vzXÄå~y>{PuW)1p7vy5w3 :yW z7yzU~yzUy3y5z7qsx,w1vYu
r3yzUqzUPÅMzDè²3§æ±±Ó5³Ê W¥§ ¡¨s°7± X¨s° Ê7¨\±²Ê7£5¨\³§Ê7£W¤
X§5³Ê7¨ §5Ê ±²3±Ê7æ±¾§5Ê ²Ö³ æ³£]¤ ÊU¨\±¤¤³ ±Ê7æ±Y> >{>
z7v >>å 7r13wuWsquU
ÎÕÝ
w3y53vò vz7v!u]zU{:¿>3v{UvÀÁÁÜU ¿uUw©â>qzU
xyz7xvr3r1qy5z7rqsz !z75qsr1p:u]z7{:Ý
vw3~uWz
ÅMz:è²1§Yæ±±Ó
³Ê W¥#§ ¨s°7± (³ ¨° ûÒX²1§ 7±£Ê A§² W¥3°7§ §5Ê £5¨\Ò>²1£]¤
£5Ê Ò>£ ± ±Ê7±Y²1£Ö³§ÊU vq{Uvz71p7v
ò v1p7vw1uWz7{7r
åÕà
z7y1u]z7{ ¿¡vssqsr3pÀÁÁ5á7å \vYuW37w1v u]r1v{:u]x
xy7z>yWÌ3pUvw1vu]1qy5z7rr3qs5zPu]ssv{ jr1vz>3vz7xvñuWz7{
xu]7r1vxyzUz7vx1q¢5vrY £5Ê 5ÒX£ ±j£5Ê7Ó 7±±æ°7 5Á7Oã
©ÄsÀ ÀYÂ 7
åJàÌzUy3ÀYÁ5ÁáU £Ö£ Ï²³ ±YÊ _±¨°U§YÓ5§]¤s§ 5Ë §² _§
¨\³ £Ö³Ê A£ H±Y¨(§ §°7±²3±Ê7æ± û±¤s£Ö³§Ê>¥ú!p U3p7v
r3qsrY µvtPuWw33~Avz> yWå w13q¦¸Pxqu]!ÅMz>3vsqsvz7xv zUq¢5vwM
r3qsM yW !{7qsz 7w1p

¿uWz7z:u]z7{/_å opUy~tUr3yzÀYÁÂ5Â7ûp7v3y5w3qsxYuW
r33w17x17w3v1p7vy5w3 Äå3p7vy5w3 jyW 3v»>yw1XuWz7q Yu]1qy5z
P± 5¨\7ÂU ©Äýã ¼ã5Â7À
®vyz7y>y5w ´µ¢vw3r31vv5vz ÀÁÁÜU
u]7ru] uWz7{
xyz>3wu]r13qs¢v xy5z7z7vx3qs¢vr o!vxp7zUqxu] vtHyw1
ÀsÀ5 opUv åµò Å3´µò yz7r1yw31qs7~¾
oq Uw3XÖWò q ~Avvz
*A
Â
;
µ%
Ã
Ä
2
<Å
Ê
IË
SÆ
~Æ
s
ÇbÈ
|
É
dÉ
&Å
ÍÌ
s
<Å
Æ
Õ
<Å
!Î
Æ

(Ï
[Ð
Å 7Ö
ÒÑ
~Ó
xÐ
Ô
Ì
2
Õ
@1Ø
R
J
<Å
Å
*×Ð
U
Ø
E
<Å
I×

~ÆIË
J
Ù
jÅ #Æ
"Ú
#Ù

v
.v
Û
,
2
ÝÜ
Þ [ß
1bØ
2
Ì
àv
;
"vCÌ
2
2
Ì

Download Report

Similarity and contrast relations and inductive rules Alistair Knott

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz