Woods Are for Warblers

land
314
ALLEN'S HUMMINGBIRD • AMERICAN AVOCET • AMERICAN BITTERN • AMERICAN BLACK DUCK • AMERICAN DIPPER • AMERICAN
GOLDEN-PLOVER • AMERICAN KESTREL • AMERICAN OYSTERCATCHER • AMERICAN PIPIT • AMERICAN REDSTART • AMERICAN THREE-TOED
WOODS ARE FOR WARBLERS
CHRIS BOYER
A growing global trade in wood pellets threatens biodiversity and a key carbon sink.
By T. Edward Nickens
314
United States
Dem. Rep. of Congo
L
ALLEN'S HUMMINGBIRD • AMERICAN AVOCET • AMERICAN BITTERN • AMERICAN BLACK DUCK • AMERICAN DIPPER • AMERI-
SB
Brazil
A Longish Headline Can Go to Explain the Land Infographic
S
Malaysia
CP
PO
FBB34D
Argentina
Indonesia
PO
PW
Australiaof wood pellet timber comes from
An eighty word intro was ordered up for this space. In addition, much sourcing
the South’s bottomland hardwood forests, brooding groves of cypress, tupelo gum, sweetgum, oaks and poplars.
While these are typically second- and third-growth forests, mature hardwood bottoms are soaring woodlands that
often cloak river corridors and swamp borders with dark, Gothic forests that serve as critical habitats for birds such
Tree Plantations
Cattle Pasture
Soy Bean
Logging
Slashing, Burning
Palm Oil
Agriculture (General)
Pulpwood
as cerulean and prothonotary warblers. Even in upland forests, conservationists worry that the soaring demand for.
S
A
CP
S
L
TP
SB
PO
A
PW
Total Forest vs. Total Forest Lost
Per country per year, 2001-2011
Russia
Brazil
Canada
United States
Dem. Rep. of Congo
China
Indonesia
Australia
Argentina
Malaysia
4%
6.3%
5.6%
8.6%
2.6%
3.3%
8.8%
11.6%
14.7%
15%
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Total Forest
Forest lost
Measured in Million Hectares
Net greenhouse gas emissions
Much of the timber used to make pellets is sourced from southern bottomland hardwood forests. These woodlands serve as critical habitats for
many species of wildlife, including Cerulean and Prothonotary warblers and more than two dozen other threatened bird species.
58 Audubon
September-October 2014
power Europe, conservationists say, is
an accounting formula: According to
E.U. policy, wood pellets are considered
a carbon-neutral fuel source, based on
the principle that regenerating forests
will eventually recapture the carbon
released when the trees were cut. But
a growing chorus of scientists and
conservationists points to new research
showing that harvesting, transporting,
and burning trees for large-scale energy
production actually produces a “carbon
debt” that isn’t repaid for 35 to 50
years—an eon in the rapidly shrinking
timeline of climate change. Europe’s
policies were put into place “before
scientists came to the conclusion that
not all biomass is created equal,” explains Ginny Kreitler, a senior adviser
on energy and the environment for
National Audubon. Derb Carter, director of the Southern Environmental
Law Center’s Chapel Hill, N.C., office,
puts it more bluntly. “Europe equates
woody biomass with solar panels and
wind turbines,” he says. “The entire accounting policy is flawed and, frankly,
dangerous.”
21.7%
20%
10%
China (125%)
Russia (2%)
Malaysia (16%)
Argentina (19%)
Brazil (32%)
Canada (9%)
Indonesia (29%)
Australia (4%)
Dem. Rep. of Congo (1%)
United States (5%)
0%
-10%
-20%
-25.3%
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
Percentage Change 2001-2011
PITCH
what’s happening. And during the past
five years, such an unlikely scenario has
spawned an entirely new industry. Conservationists are concerned that this latest
rush to purportedly green energy is not
only a carbon emissions boondoggle but a
potential train wreck for wildlife and some
of the most diverse forests remaining in
North America.
The volume of pellets being shipped
overseas is exploding. Exports from
North America to Europe doubled in
two years, to 4.7 million tons in 2013.
Southern forests accounted for nearly
two-thirds of that volume. At the new
Enviva Biomass pellet plant in northeastern North Carolina, a transfer truck
is filled with wood pellets about every
28 minutes, each one bound for Europe.
That continent’s appetite for
wood pellets is fueled by the European Union’s 2020 climate and energy
package, which set binding goals for
reducing greenhouse gases, increasing energy produced by renewable
resources, and improving overall energy
efficiency. The basis of the flawed logic
leading to U.S. wood being burned to
THIS PAGE: MATT EICH. PRECEDING PAGES: CHRIS BOYER
I
t looks like a rabbit pellet,
speckled quail-egg brown, a cylinder perhaps an inch long, thick as a
No. 2 pencil, with a shiny coat that
brings to mind a sausage casing.
There are no fillers, no binders, no
added chemicals. Wood pellets are allnatural, made of nothing but wood.
A single pellet is light as a feather,
but a transfer truck filled with them
will push 27 tons, and these days, trucks
are being filled at a rate never before
known. Millions of tons of wood pellets
are being produced in plants across the
U.S. South and hauled to coastal ports.
From there they are shipped to power
plants in Europe to fuel a massive conversion of energy facilities from burning
coal to burning wood.
It seems to defy common sense that
trees from forests in North Carolina,
South Carolina, Virginia, Georgia, and
other southern states could be cut, trucked
to a mill, pulverized and pelletized,
shipped to a seaport, sailed across the
Atlantic Ocean, and delivered to a power
plant in the Netherlands, all in the name
of reducing global warming. Yet that’s
Per country per year, 2001-2011
Measured in Metric Tons of CO2 equivalent
Audubon 59
September-October 2014
314
ALLEN'S HUMMINGBIRD • AMERICAN AVOCET • AMERICAN BITTERN • AMERICAN BLACK DUCK • AMERICAN DIPPER • AMERILAND c ont i n u e d f r om page 6 0
M
to Europe to speak with legislators and
industry officials. “But that is only up to a
point, and we don’t know where that point
is for an industry that has shown up very
quickly and on a very large scale. Before
we say, ‘Hey, the door is wide open,’ we
need to know in real time how it impacts
the landscape.”
W
hile logging has been
a common practice in the
South’s bottomland forests
for generations, these
woodlands still retain a
wild quality. Buttressed tree
trunks rise to a dense canopy festooned
with trumpet creeper and resurrection
fern. Trellised with streams and rivers, the
forests are best accessed with a paddle, so
early one morning Smalling and I slipped
canoes into North Carolina’s Gardner
Creek, a serpentine ribbon of water that
winds through private forests adjacent
to the Roanoke River National Wildlife
Refuge. We paddled three miles into the
swamp, skies grumbling with thunder,
then drifted quietly. I pulled out my
smartphone and started the clock. Within
two minutes Smalling had called out 16
species of singing birds. A Yellow-billed
Cuckoo clattered overhead. Eastern Wood
Peewees whistled back and forth across
the creek. We heard Yellow-throated
Warblers and Acadian Flycatchers.
For some of these birds, these habitats
hold substantial portions of their overall populations. Some 14 percent of the
world’s Yellow-throated Warblers breed in
eastern North Carolina bottomland forests,
as do an estimated 11 percent of all Acadian Flycatchers. As primordial fish called
a bowfin gulped air around our boats, a pair
of Prothonotary Warblers hawked over
the canoes like dragonflies dipped in gold.
Another pair hopped from tree branch to
tree branch, at times mere inches from the
water and only 20 feet away. One in five of
all Prothonotary Warblers rely on bottomland forests in eastern North Carolina.
Coupled with their irreplaceable function as a carbon sink, this ecological richness makes the possibility of losing such
forests a frightening prospect. That’s what
most concerns Smalling. “If the carbon
accounting doesn’t change and this industry
goes full-tilt boogie,” he says, “where are we
going to be 5 or 10 years from now?” n
Wood pellets are made from timber that is dried, ground, and compressed with a combination
of heat and pressure. A uniform size and low moisture content make them easy to transport.
forests more bird-friendly. “We’re forging
partnerships with landowners, loggers, scientists, and even hunting clubs that lease
large swaths of bottomlands,” says Curtis
Smalling, director of land bird conservation for Audubon North Carolina. “We
understand that healthy timber markets
can have an upside for conservation, and
there are lots of ways to work together.”
F
ive years ago there wasn’t a
single wood pellet plant in North
Carolina. Today there are three,
and a typical plant might produce
a half-million tons of wood pellets
per year. According to the Southern Environmental Law Center, more
than a half-dozen new pellet plants have
been proposed for North Carolina and
Virginia alone, with other plants planned
for Louisiana, Mississippi, Georgia, and
South Carolina.
I visited the Enviva plant in Ahoskie,
North Carolina, on a hot day made hotter
by the massive drying units that bake
moisture out of wood fiber. Built on an
old sawmill site, the $100 million facility
shipped its first load of pellets in April
2013. It now runs 24/7. The plant looks
like a gigantic hamster funhouse, a labyrinth of massive tubes and conveyors that
ferry treetops, sawdust, and whole trees up
to 26 inches in diameter through grinders,
dryers, and presses. Much of the plant’s
39 acres is covered in soaring stacks of tree
trunks 30 feet high—tens of thousands of
them. But all those stacks of logs are not
as unequivocal as they might seem.
The value of the wood shipped to a
pellet plant typically represents between
10 percent and 30 percent of the timber
tract’s total value. At a harvest site in
southeastern Virginia, I watched as a log
loader picked up whole felled trees with a
giant grappling bucket. For most trees, the
lower 30 feet were sawed off and placed
into one pile, earmarked for a lumber mill.
Treetops up to 40 feet long were sorted
for Enviva. It’s a process called “merchandising.” Timber from a single clear-cut
might go to a half-dozen different mills
and plants, of which a wood pellet plant is
only the newest buyer.
While the budding threat looms,
there’s a fair argument to be made that
the wood pellet industry gives landowners another market to consider when
calculating a harvest and could prompt
the cutting of marginal tracts. Enviva
maintains that by supporting the market
for byproducts of timber harvests, it provides a financial incentive to keep forests
forested, and that its procurement policies require suppliers to reforest timbered
tracts, either through planting or by
allowing natural regeneration to occur.
Still, those scenarios would fall under
the 30- to 50-year carbon debt window
that worries some conservationists. And
even scientists who give tentative points
to the wood pellet industry’s sustainability
measures are concerned about the potential scale of the new industry. “Right now
the ability of our forests to supply these
materials is largely a positive story,” says
Dennis Hazel, a member of North Carolina State University’s Biomass Ecosystem
Sustainability Team who recently traveled
MATT EICH
uch of the timber used
to make pellets comes from
the South’s bottomland
hardwood forests—brooding groves of cypress, tupelo
gums, sweetgums, oaks, and
poplars. Sixty percent of the 30 million
acres of hardwood bottoms once found in
the Southeast have already been destroyed
to make way for agricultural land and
timber tracts. The woodlands that remain
cloak river corridors and swamp borders
with dark, Gothic forests that serve as
critical habitats for such birds as Cerulean
and Prothonotary warblers and 28 other
species of conservation concern, 14 of them
listed in Audubon’s newly released report
on climate change. Conservationists also
worry that in upland forests, the skyrocketing demand for pellets could accelerate the
conversion of natural forests to shortrotation pine timber, which would be a
devastating blow to local biodiversity.
This issue is not limited to the pinelands and river bottoms of Dixie. On a
global scale, forests that serve as invaluable
carbon “sinks”—lands that absorb more
carbon than they emit—are under siege. In
Indonesia a massive swath of rainforest and
peatlands holds 57 billion tons of carbon
in one of the planet’s largest sinks. But the
country lost 15 million acres, or 16 percent,
of its forest cover between 2002 and 2012,
largely due to rampant conversion to palm
oil plantations. In the dry tropical forests
and savannas of South America’s Gran
Chaco region, deforestation rates exceed
those of even the Amazon.
As debate rages over the environmental benefits of replacing dirty coal with
wood, there is at least one silver lining to
the new scrutiny of the infant industry:
While the 2020 guidelines are in place
for the European Union, the 2030 plans
and targets are not. “This is the right time
for incorporating a more scientifically
rigorous approach to carbon accounting of
wood pellets,” says Kreitler.
It’s also the right time to recognize the
value of standing forests, such as the 5,548
acres of Audubon’s 17,000-acre Francis
Beidler Forest in South Carolina that were
recently protected as carbon offsets in
California’s cap-and-trade program. And
in late June, 91 leading scientists signed
a letter urging the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency to distinguish between
different biomass sources as it drafts new
carbon emission rules. If nothing else, the
new inquiry provides an emerging forum
for examining ways to make working
Contributing editor T. Edward Nickens last
wrote about Costa Rica’s Osa Peninsula (“It’s
a Jungle in There,” May-June 2014).
cont in ued on page 00
60 Audubon
September-October 2014
Audubon 61
September-October 2014