;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;
“They’re OK if They’re
Our S.O.B’s”
United States Involvement in the
1954 Guatemalan Coup d’état
Robert Franklin
History 383
ɨF6OJUFE4UBUFT$PME8BSIJTUPSZJTTISPVEFEJO
TFDSFDZBOEXIFOSFWFBMFEJUJTBQQSPBDIFEXJUIGFFMJOHTPG
TIBNFBOHFSBOEGSVTUSBUJPOBUFWFOUTQFSQFUVBUFECZUIF64
HPWFSONFOUBOEGPSFJHOJOUFSFTUT1FFSJOHJOUPSFDFOUMZPQFOFE
$FOUSBM*OUFMMJHFODF"HFODZEPDVNFOUTBOEUIFNFNPJSTPG
UIPTFQSPNJOFOUJOEJWJEVBMTJOUIF5SVNBOBOE&JTFOIPXFS
"ENJOJTUSBUJPOTDBTUTOFXMJHIUPOUIF64SPMFJOTIBQJOH
UIFFNFSHJOHHPWFSONFOUTPGVOEFSEFWFMPQFEOBUJPOTJO-BUJO
"NFSJDB0GUIFTFUIF(VBUFNBMBO$PVQEÏUBUCFBST
BOPCWJPVT64TJHOBUVSFCPUIJOUIFQBSUJDVMBSGPSNPGUIF
DPVQTJNJMBSUBDUJDTXFSFVTFEJO*SBOJO
BOEUIFDPMPTTBM
NJTVOEFSTUBOEJOHTJOXIJDIUIF$PVQTVDDFFEFEɨF64
NJTKVEHFEUIFTPDJBMJTUSFGPSNTBOEDPNNVOJTUQSFTFODFJO
(VBUFNBMBTOFXSFWPMVUJPOBSZHPWFSONFOUBTUIFXPSLPG
JOUFSOBUJPOBMDPNNVOJTNMPPLJOHUPFTUBCMJTIB-BUJO"NFSJDBO
,SFNMJOUIBUXPVMEEFTUBCJMJ[FUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTFDPOPNJDBOE
QPMJUJDBMJOUFSFTUTJO-BUJO"NFSJDBɨF64GFMUUIJTWJFXHBWF
UIFNUIFKVTUJëDBUJPOUPJOTUJHBUFUIF$PVQEÏUBUUIBU
EVFUPBDSVDJBMMBDLPGNJMJUBSZTVQQPSUGPSUIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZ
HPWFSONFOUSFQMBDFEUIF+BDPCP"SCFO[BENJOJTUSBUJPOXJUI
UIF64TVQQPSUFE$BTUJMMP"SNBTɨJTJOUFSWFOUJPOCZUIF
64JOPWFSUISPXJOHBEFNPDSBUJDBMMZFMFDUFEHPWFSONFOUSBO
DPVOUFSUPJUTQSPEFNPDSBDZSIFUPSJDCVUëUQFSGFDUMZJOUIF
MJOFPG$PME8BSGPSFJHOQPMJDZUIBUTPVHIUUPQSPUFDUBUBOZ
DPTU64IFHFNPOZJOUIF8FTUFSOIFNJTQIFSF
'SPNJOEFQFOEFODFUPUIFFTUBCMJTINFOUPGB
EFNPDSBUJDBMMZFMFDUFEHPWFSONFOUJO(VBUFNBMB
QSPHSFTTFEUISPVHIBTFSJFTPGEJDUBUPST*OBMJCFSBM
HPWFSONFOUVOEFS1SFTJEFOU+VTUP3VëOP#BSSJPTUPPLQPXFS
NBSLJOHBUSBOTJUJPOGSPNBMBSHFMZJOUFSOBMBOEBUSPQIJFE
FDPOPNZUPOBTDFOUJOEVTUSJBMJ[BUJPOBOEGPSFJHOJOWFTUNFOU1
#BSSJPTFTUBCMJTIFEGSFFEPNPGSFMJHJPOPO.BSDIJO
BOBUUFNQUUPXFBLFOUIFDPOUSPMPGUIF$BUIPMJD$IVSDIXIJMF
TJNVMUBOFPVTMZFODPVSBHJOHJNNJHSBUJPOGSPNiQSPUFTUBOUBOE
NPEFSODPVOUSJFTwTVDIBTUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTBOE(FSNBOZ2
#BSSJPTIPQFEUIBUBOJOìVYPG1SPUFTUBOUNJTTJPOBSJFTXPVME
CSJOHUIFWBMVFTBOEBQQFUJUFTPGUIFJSDBQJUBMJTUTPDJFUJFT
XJUIUIFNUP(VBUFNBMBBOEBDUBTBTVCUMFJOìVFODFPOUIF
(VBUFNBMBOQFPQMF
1SPXFTUFSOSFGPSNTCZUIFiMJCFSBMTwIBEUIFFêFDUPG
DIBOHJOHMBOEPXOFSTIJQCVUOPUJOBXBZUIBUCFOFëUFEUIF
NBKPSJUZPGUIFQPQVMBUJPO3ɨFTZTUFNPGVOFRVBMEJTUSJCVUJPO
PGMBOEXBTBNBKPSDBVTFPGUIFSFWPMVUJPOBOEUIFJTTVF
PGMBOESFGPSNJTDSVDJBMUPVOEFSTUBOEJOHUIFFWFOUTMFBEJOHVQ
UPUIF$PVQ*OUIFMBUFOJOFUFFOUIBOEFBSMZUXFOUJFUI
centuries, CaudillosFMJUFMBOEPXOFST
BOEUIFHPWFSONFOU
JODSFBTJOHMZTPMEMBOEUPGPSFJHOCVTJOFTTJOUFSFTUTJOUIFCBOBOB
BOEDPêFFFYQPSUNBSLFUTɨFTFDPNQBOJFTPêFSFEMPXXBHFT
BOESFMJFEPOBTZTUFNPGGPSDFEMBCPSUPTUBêUIFFWFSHSPXJOH
LatifundiasPSMBSHFTDBMFFYQPSUGBSNT4ɨFQPXFSPGFYQPSU
BHSJDVMUVSFJO(VBUFNBMBDBOOPUCFPWFSTUBUFE‰BUUIFUJNFPG
UIFSFWPMVUJPOCBOBOBTBOEDPêFFHSPXOGPSFYQPSUNBEF
VQPGBHSJDVMUVSBMQSPEVDUJPO5#BOBOBTXFSFUIFNBKPSJUZ
PGDSPQTHSPXOPOUIFTFLatifundiasBOESFRVJSFQFSJPEJD
SPUBUJPOPOEJêFSFOUQMPUTPGMBOEUPGBMMPXNBLJOHMBSHF
TDBMFPXOFSTIJQPGQSJNFBHSJDVMUVSBMMBOEOFDFTTBSZCZFYQPSU
DPNQBOJFT&UIOJD.BZBO*OEJBOTPGUFOPXOFEWFSZTNBMM
QMPUTPGBHSJDVMUVSBMMZQPPSMBOEPSMinifundias6%VFUPUIF
TIPSUBHFPGMBOEBWBJMBCMFGPSQFSTPOBMDVMUJWBUJPOMinifundias
XFSFIFBWJMZQMBOUFEPOXJUIOPSPPNUPGBMMPXDSFBUJOHQPPS
TPJMDPOEJUJPOTBOEBOFWFSJODSFBTJOHSFMJBODFPOUIFQPPS
XBHFTQSPWJEFEGSPNBHSJDVMUVSBMMBCPS
ɨF6OJUFE'SVJU$PNQBOZPS6'$0XBTUIFNBJO
FYQPSUFSPGCBOBOBTJO(VBUFNBMBBOEUIFTPVSDFPGTFSJPVT
SFTFOUNFOUGSPNUIFQPQVMBUJPOBOEMBUFS"SFWBMPBOE"SCFO[
HPWFSONFOUT'SPNJUTGPSNBUJPOJO6'$0LOPXO
in Guatemala as el pulpoUIFPDUPQVT
XPSLFEUPTFDVSFB
WFSZQSPëUBCMFBOENPOPQPMJTUJDCVTJOFTTFOWJSPONFOUJO
(VBUFNBMB6'$0XBTUIFMBSHFTUQSJWBUFMBOEPXOFSJO
(VBUFNBMBXJUIKVTUPWFSUISFFNJMMJPOBDSFTCSJOHJOHJUT
UPUBMQSPQFSUZUPNPSFUIBOUIFDPNCJOFEIPMEJOHTPGIBMGPG
(VBUFNBMBTMBOEPXOJOHQPQVMBUJPO76'$0HBSOFSFEBO
FYDMVTJWFDPOUSBDUUPUSBOTQPSUUIFDPVOUSZTNBJMUPUIF6OJUFE
4UBUFTPXOFEPVUPGNJMFTPGSBJMSPBEUSBDLBOEUIF
TIJQQJOHDPNQBOZUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM3BJMXBZTPG$FOUSBM
3
7JSHJOJB(BSSBSE#VSOFUUi1SPUFTUBOUJTN*O3VSBM(VBUFNBMB
wLatin American Research ReviewOP
7
#VSOFUUi1SPUFTUBOUJTN*O3VSBM(VBUFNBMBw
Ibid
+PTÏ."ZCBSEF4PUPDependency and Intervention: The Case of
Guatemala in 1954#PVMEFS8FTUWJFX1SFTT*OD
3JDIBSE)*NNFSNBOThe CIA in Guatemala: The Foreign Policy of
Intervention"VTUJO6OJWFSTJUZPG5FYBT1SFTT
"ZCBSEF4PUPDependency and Intervention, Immerman, The CIA In Guatemala
)0)0/67PMVNF
"NFSJDBPS*3$"
CVJMUBOENBJOUBJOFEUIFUFMFHSBQITZTUFN
BOEPXOFEUIFXIBSWFTBUCPUIPG(VBUFNBMBTQPSUTJOUIF
1BDJëDBOE$BSJCCFBO8$POUSPMPGUIFSBJMSPBEDPNQBOZ
NFBOUUIBU6'$0iBSCJUSBSJMZJODSFBTF<E>UIFDPTUTPGBMMJUT
DPNQFUJUPSTCZSBJTJOHUSBOTQPSUBUJPOSBUFTwXIJMFLFFQJOHUIFJS
own rates low*OPOFPGUIFMBSHFTUBCVTFTPGJUTJOìVFODFPO
(VBUFNBMBOQPMJUJDT6'$0JOFYUSBDUFEGSPN1SFTJEFOU
+PSHF6CJDPBDPOUSBDUUIBUTUJQVMBUFEBOJOFUZOJOFZFBSMFBTF
POJUTMBOEIPMEJOHTGSFFEPNGSPNBMNPTUBMMUBYFTJNQPSU
EVUJFTSFHVMBUJPOBOEUIFBCJMJUZUPTFWFSFMZVOEFSWBMVFJUT
QSPQFSUZUBYIPMEJOHTBOJTTVFUIBUXPVMEDBVTFQSPCMFNT
EVSJOHUIF"SCFO[BENJOJTUSBUJPO
ɨFUFOUBDMFTPGel pulpo
SFBDIFEEFFQJOUPUIFGBCSJDPG(VBUFNBMBUIFNPOPQPMJTUJD
DPOUSPMPGUIFFDPOPNZDPNCJOFEXJUIUIFJSIFBWZQPMJUJDBM
JOìVFODFCSFEBOBOUJ6CJDPBOEBOUJGPSFJHOJOWFTUNFOU
TFOUJNFOUUIBUDVMNJOBUFEJOUIF3FWPMVUJPOPG
ɨF3FWPMVUJPOPGFOEFEBQFSJPEPG(VBUFNBMBO
IJTUPSZëMMFEXJUIBTVDDFTTJPOPGEJDUBUPSTBOETUSPOHNFOɨF
MBTUPGUIFTF+PSHF6CJDPQSFTJEFOUGSPN
TUBSUFE
IJTSFJHOXJUIUIFTVQQPSUPGUIFCaudillos and the military,
CVUUIJSUFFOZFBSTPGNBTTJWFDPODFTTJPOTUPGPSFJHODPNQBOJFT
NBJOMZ6'$0
JNQSJTPONFOUPGQPMJUJDBMPQQPOFOUTBOEB
HFOFSBMOFHMFDUPGTPDJBMJOFRVBMJUZDPNCJOFEJOBHSPVOETXFMM
PGPQQPTJUJPO3FTFOUNFOUXBTNPTUQSPGPVOEJOUIFFNFSHJOH
NJEEMFDMBTTPG(VBUFNBMBOTPDJFUZMPDBUFEQSJNBSJMZJOVSCBO
BSFBTMJLF(VBUFNBMB$JUZɨFTFCMVFBOEXIJUFDPMMBSXPSLFST
CFDBNFQPMJUJDBMMZSBEJDBMJ[FEEVSJOHUIF(SFBU%FQSFTTJPO
BOEXFSFJOìVFODFECZ8PSME8BS**SIFUPSJDMJLFUIBUJOUIF
"UMBOUJD$IBSUFSXJUIJUTDBMMGPSGSFFEPNBEWBODFNFOUPG
TPDJBMXFMGBSFBOETFMGEFUFSNJOBUJPO100O0DUPCFS
BDPMMBUJPOPGTUVEFOUTJOUFMMFDUVBMTBOEZPVOHPïDFSTMFECZ
.BKPS'SBODJTDP"SBOB+PSHF5PSJFMMPBOE$BQUBJO+BDPCP
"SCFO[BUUBDLFEUIF/BUJPOBM1BMBDFBOEGPSDFEUIF6CJDP
HPWFSONFOUUPTUFQEPXO
ɨF6OJUFE4UBUFTJOJUJBMSFBDUJPOUPUIF0DUPCFS
3FWPMVUJPOXBTJOJUJBMMZPOFPGTVQQPSU4FDUBSZPG4UBUF
$PSEFMM)VMMTUBUFEJOUIBUiUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTIBTOP
JOUFOUJPOPGJOUFSGFSJOHJO(VBUFNBMBOJOUFSOBMBêBJSTw11
ɨFSFWPMVUJPOBSZHPWFSONFOUXFOUPOUPIPMEiUIFëSTU
GSFFFMFDUJPOJO(VBUFNBMBTIJTUPSZwPO%FDFNCFS
12ɨBUUIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZBENJOJTUSBUJPOIFMEFMFDUJPOT
XBTQSPNJTJOHQSFWJPVTBENJOJTUSBUJPOTIBEPGUFOSFOFHFE
POTVDIQSPNJTFT
BOEFWFONPSFPQFOXBTUIFGBDUUIBU
OPOFPGUIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZMFBEFSTTPVHIUPïDFUIFëSTU
UFSN(VBUFNBMBOTPWFSXIFMNJOHMZFMFDUFE+VBO+PTF
10
11
12
1BVM+%PTBMDoing Business With The Dictators: A Political History
of United Fruit in Guatemala, 1899-19448JMJNJOHUPO4DIPMBSMZ
3FTPVSDFT*OD
*NNFSNBOɨF$*" In Guatemala
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
Ibid
Ibid
30 - HOHONU Volume 8 2010
"SFWBMP#FSNFKBOJOUFMMFDUVBMXIPIBEOPUJFTUPQSFWJPVT
BENJOJTUSBUJPOT13"SFWBMPXBTBDPOUSBEJDUPSZQFSTPOUPUIF
5SVNBOBENJOJTUSBUJPOBTUBVODIEFNPDSBUBOEEFGFOEFSPG
DBQJUBMJTNIFOFWFSUIFMFTTCFMJFWFEJOi4QJSJUVBM4PDJBMJTNw
PSUIFJEFBUIBUBiIBSNPOJPVTTPDJFUZDPVMECFBDIJFWFE
UISPVHIQTZDIPMPHJDBMMJCFSBUJPOSBUIFSUIBOBSFEJTUSJCVUJPO
PGXFBMUIw14 15"SFWBMPTQBUIUPNPEFSOJ[BUJPOBOEFRVBMJUZ
XBTUISPVHIFEVDBUJPOBOEMBCPSSFGPSNGPSUIF.BZBO
NBKPSJUZUIFSFCZIPQJOHUPESBXUIJTHSPVQJOUPHPWFSONFOU
QBSUJDJQBUJPOBOETUSFOHUIFOJOHBOEXJEFOJOHUIFTVQQPSUPG
UIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZDPBMJUJPOXIJMFTBQQJOHJOìVFODFGSPNUIF
Caudillos
ɨFOFX(VBUFNBMBO$POTUJUVUJPOWFSZNVDISFTFNCMFE
UIBUPGUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTCVUUPFODPVSBHFNPSFWBSJFUZJO
FMFDUJPOTJUCBOOFEGPSFJHOPSJOUFSOBUJPOBMQPMJUJDBMQBSUJFT
TVDIBT4PWJFU$PNNVOJTN16 Arevalo included Guatemalan
DPNNVOJTUTJOIJTHPWFSONFOUCFHSVEHJOHMZUIFPSHBOJ[BUJPOBM
BOEQPMJUJDBMFYQFSJFODFXBTTPNFUIJOHUIFOFXHPWFSONFOU
OFFEFE17 Arevalo feared too much communist control in
IJTHPWFSONFOUBTJUDPVMECFMJOLFEUPUIF4PWJFU6OJPO
BOEVTFEBHBJOTUIJNCZIJTFOFNJFT#VUDPSSFDUJOHZFBSTPG
VOEFSEFWFMPQNFOUBOEFDPOPNJDFYQMPJUBUJPOCSPVHIUPOCZ
6OJUFE4UBUFTCVTJOFTTJOUFSFTUTGPSDFEIJNUPVTFUIFQFPQMFBU
IJTEJTQPTBMSFBMJ[JOHUIF64BTBEJSFDUUISFBUNPSFQSFTTJOH
UIBODPNNVOJTN184VQQPSUJWFBUëSTUUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTTPPO
CFDBNFDSJUJDBMPGUIF"SFWBMPBENJOJTUSBUJPOɨFFYJTUFODF
PGDPNNVOJTUTBMPOHXJUIMFHJTMBUJPOUPQSPUFDUBHSJDVMUVSBM
XPSLFSTPO-BUJGVOEJBTXIJDIIVSU6'$0JOUFSFTUT
BOE
"SFWBMPTFOUSBODFJOUPUIFBOUJ64$BSJCCFBO-FHJPOESFX
IBSTIDSJUJDJTNBOEJSFGSPNUIF5SVNBOBENJOJTUSBUJPO
"SFWBMPXBTOPUQPQVMBSXJUIUIFCaudillos, many of
XIPNXBOUFEUPPVTUIJNGSPNQPXFSPGUFOBDDVTJOHIJNPG
GFSNFOUJOHDMBTTXBSGBSF5XFOUZëWFDPVQTXFSFBUUFNQUFE
EVSJOHIJTTJYZFBSTJOQPXFS‰OPOFXFSFTVDDFTTGVMBOEJO
/PWFNCFSPG+BDPCP"SCFO[XBTFMFDUFEQSFTJEFOU20
"SCFO[GBDFETUJêDPNQFUJUJPOJOUIFFMFDUJPOGSPNIJTQBSUOFS
JOUIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZDPVQ.BKPS'SBODJTDP"SBOBVOUJMIF
XBTDPOWFOJFOUMZFMJNJOBUFEJO+VMZ21"SCFO[TPPO
13
14
15
16
17
18
20
21
Ibid
4UFQIFO.4USFFUFSManaging The Counterrevolution: The United
States and Guatemala, 1954-1961,"UIFOT0IJP6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUFSGPS
*OUFSOBUJPOBM4UVEJFT
1TZDIPMPHJDBMMJCFSBUJPOFOUBJMFEUIBUiFBDIDJUJ[FOIBTBSFTQPOTJCJMJUZUP
(VBUFNBMBBOEUIBUUIFHPWFSONFOUIBEBSFTQPOTJCJMJUZUPFBDIDJUJ[FOw
'SPN4USFFUFSManaging The Counterrevolution
Immerman, CIA in Guatemala
3POBME.4DIOFJEFSCommunism In Guatemala, 1944-1954 /FX:PSL
'SFEFSJDL"1SBFHFS*OD,
Ibid
ɨF$BSJCCFBO-FHJPOXBTBOPSHBOJ[BUJPODPNQSJTFEPGSBEJDBM
EFNPDSBUTMPPLJOHUPPVTUEJDUBUPSTPGUFO64TVQQPSUFE
GSPN-BUJO
"NFSJDBOHPWFSONFOUTJOIPQFTPGDSFBUJOHBVOJUFE-BUJO"NFSJDBUP
SJWBM64JOìVFODFJOUIFIFNJTQIFSF
Immerman, CIA in Guatemala
ɨFSFWPMVUJPOBSZHPWFSONFOUIBTCFFOMJOLFEUP"SBOBTBTTBTTJOBUJPO
CVUJUTSPMFJTTVTQFDU"SBOBXBTSFQPSUFEMZPOIJTXBZUPVODPWFSBTUBTI
GBDFEFWFOCJHHFSUISFBUTUPIJTHPWFSONFOUBTIFUSJFEUPTUFFS
(VBUFNBMBOQPMJDZUPPOFPGTFMGTVïDJFODZBOEGSFFEPNPG
GPSFJHOJOUFSWFOUJPOVOGBWPSBCMFUPCPUIGPSFJHOCVTJOFTTFTBOE
6OJUFE4UBUFTDPOUSPMJO(VBUFNBMB
)PQJOHUPFOEUIFiEFWFMPQNFOUPGVOEFSEFWFMPQNFOUw
UIBUSFTVMUFEGSPN(VBUFNBMBTQSJNBSZGPDVTPOFYQPSU
BHSJDVMUVSFEVFUPUIFTUSBOHMFIPMEPGGPSFJHOCVTJOFTTJOUFSFTUT
"SCFO[TFUBCPVUBUUFNQUJOHUPNPEFSOJ[F(VBUFNBMBBOEUBLF
the revolution farther than Arevalo22*OIJTJOBVHVSBMBEESFTT
IFFYQSFTTFEIJTEFTJSFUPiDPOWFSU(VBUFNBMBGSPNBDPVOUSZ
CPVOECZBQSFEPNJOBOUMZGFVEBMFDPOPNZJOUPBNPEFSO
DBQJUBMJTUPOFw235PEPUIJT"SCFO[XBOUFEUPJODSFBTFUIFSPMF
PGHPWFSONFOUJOUIFMJWFTPGDJUJ[FOT‰GVOEJOHFEVDBUJPOBM
IFBMUIBOETPDJBMQSPHSBNTXIJMFFOTVSJOHBTNPPUIUSBOTJUJPO
UIBUXPVMELFFQUIFNBTTFTCFIJOEIJTBENJOJTUSBUJPO
ɨFHSFBUFTUPGBMMUIFTFQSPHSBNTBOEUIFGVMëMMNFOUPGIJT
DBNQBJHOQSPNJTFXBT%FDSFFJO%FDSFF
XIJDIPOF64TDIPMBSIBTDPNQBSFEUPUIF)PNFTUFBE"DU
XBTJOìVFODFECZUIF6OJUFE/BUJPOT(FOFSBM"TTFNCMZ
3FTPMVUJPOXIJDIiTBODUJPOFEUIFVTFPGBHSBSJBOSFGPSNT
BTBOBQQSPQSJBUFNFUIPEGPSVOEFSEFWFMPQFEDPVOUSJFTUP
SFTUSVDUVSFUIFBHSJDVMUVSBMTFDUPSPGUIFFDPOPNZw24 25%FDSFF
IBEUXPHPBMT
UPEFTUSPZUIFlatifundo-minifundio
TZTUFNDPOëTDBUJOHVOVTFEFYQPSUBHSJDVMUVSBMMBOETBOE
SFEJTUSJCVUJOHJUUPGBSNFSTXIPDPVMEHSPXTUBQMFGPPET‰
EFDSFBTJOH(VBUFNBMBOSFMJBODFPOJNQPSUTBOE
SFGPDVTJOH
UIFOFXMZVOGFUUFSFEFYQPSUBHSJDVMUVSFXPSLFSTJOUPBO
JOEVTUSJBMMBCPSXPSLGPSDF26ɨFQSPNJTFPGMBOESFBDIFE
BDSPTTDMBTTBOEFUIOJDMJOFTUPESBXTVQQPSUGSPNUIF.BZB
XIJMFGVSUIFSBMJFOBUJOHUIFCaudillos, who claimed that
22
23
24
25
26
PGXFBQPOTIJEEFOCZUIF$BSJCCFBOMFHJPOGPSVTFCZ"SCFO[UPBSN
IJTTVQQPSUFST)JTMJNPVTJOFXBTTUPQQFEBOEiTPNFNFOKVNQFE
PVUGSPNVOEFSBCSJEHFSJEEMJOHUIFMJNPVTJOFXJUITVCNBDIJOFHVO
ëSF"SBOBEJFEJOTUBOUMZw*NNFSNBOThe CIA in Guatemala
ɨFESJWFSPGUIFMJNPVTJOF-JFVUFOBOU$IJDP1BMBDJPTTVSWJWFEBOE
DMBJNTUPIBWFTFFO"SCFO[TQFSTPOBMDIBVêFVSBOE-JFVUFOBOU"MGPOTP
.BSUJOF[&TUFWF[XIPMBUFSPDDVQJFETFWFSBMJOìVFOUJBMQPTJUJPOTJO
UIF"SCFO[BENJOJTUSBUJPO
BNPOHUIFNFOMJOLJOHUIFBTTBTTJOBUJPO
UP"SCFO[1BMBDJPTTTVSWJWBMUPHJWFUIFTFëSTUIBOEBDDPVOUTIPXFWFS
ESBXTTVTQJDJPOBOERVFTUJPOJOHPGUIFBTTBTTJOBUJPOBTUIFXPSLPG
DPVOUFSSFWPMVUJPOBSJFTMPPLJOHUPJODJUFBOUJ"SCFO[TFOUJNFOUɨF
"SCFO[HPWFSONFOUEJEOPUJOWFTUJHBUFUIFLJMMJOHBOETFWFSBMEBZTMBUFS
ëHIUJOHCSPLFPVUCFUXFFO"SBOBTVQQPSUTBOEUIFHPWFSONFOUɨF
"SCFO[HPWFSONFOUXPOUIBOLTUPBSBJTFENJMJUJBNBEFVQPGXPSLFST
BOETUVEFOUTɨF$*"UPPLUIJTPQQPSUVOJUZEVSJOHUIFëHIUJOHUP
BUUFNQUBDPVQUXP64QJMPUTXFSFBSSFTUFEBMPOHXJUIUIFDPVQMFBEFS
$BSMPT$BTUJMMP"SNBT"SNBTXBTTVCTFRVFOUMZFYJMFEGSPN(VBUFNBMB
BOEXPVMEOPUSFUVSOVOUJMBTUIFMFBEFSPGUIBUTVDDFTTGVMDPVQ
'SPN*NNFSNBOThe CIA in Guatemala
"ZCBSEF4PUPDependency and Intervention: The Case of Guatemala in
1954
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
4USFFUFSManaging the Counterrevolution: The United States and
Guatemala, 1954-1961
"ZCBSEF4PUPDependency and Intervention: The Case of Guatemala in
1954,
%FDSFFPOMZUBSHFUFElatifundiosPGPWFSBDSFTUIJTXBTNFBOUUP
TJOHMFPVUGPSFJHOFYQPSUBHSJDVMUVSFDPNQBOJFTTVDIBT6'$0'SPN
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
DPNNVOJTUTXFSFSVOOJOHUIF"SCFO[HPWFSONFOU
ɨF6OJUFE'SVJU$PNQBOZXBTUIFWFSZTZNCPM
PGi:BOLFFJNQFSJBMJTNwBDPNCJOBUJPOPGCSJCFSZBOE
JOUJNJEBUJPOVTFEUPHBJOHPWFSONFOUDPODFTTJPOTBOE
SBDJTUFYQMPJUBUJWFUSFBUNFOUPGUIFOBUJWFQPQVMBUJPOUIBU
UIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZHPWFSONFOUXBTUSZJOHUPFYDJTFGSPN
(VBUFNBMB27#FDBVTFPG6'$0TBTTPDJBUJPOXJUIUIF6CJDP
SFHJNFJUXBTUIFNBKPSUBSHFUPG%FDSFFɨFCJMMQSPWJEFE
DPNQFOTBUJPOGPSMBOETFJ[FECZUIFHPWFSONFOUBDDPSEJOH
UPUIFQSPQFSUZUBYWBMVFQBJEɨF"SCFO[HPWFSONFOU
BQQSPQSJBUFENPSFUIBOBDSFTPG6'$0MBOEBOE
XIFOUIFHPWFSONFOUPêFSFENJMMJPOUIFBNPVOUPO
UIFMBTUUBYSFUVSO
6'$0JOTJTUFEUIFMBOEXBTXPSUI
NJMMJPO28ɨF(VBUFNBMBOHPWFSONFOUSFGVTFEUPQBZBOE
6'$0UPPLJUTDMBJNUPUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTHPWFSONFOUJO
&DPOPNJDBOEQPMJUJDBMDPOOFDUJPOTCFUXFFO6'$0
BOEUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTHPWFSONFOUJOUIFCFHJOOJOHPGUIF
DPMEXBSBSFUIFTVCKFDUPGNVDIBYFHSJOEJOHCZTDIPMBST
IPXFWFSJUXBTBOVOFWFOSFMBUJPOTIJQJOGBWPSPGUIF6OJUFE
4UBUFTHPWFSONFOU%FTQJUFEFFQQFSTPOBMDPOOFDUJPOTBOE
TIBSFEJEFPMPHJDBMBïOJUJFT64HPWFSONFOUPïDJBMTSFBMJ[FE
UIBU6'$0TDPSSVQUSFMBUJPOTIJQTXJUI-BUJO"NFSJDBO
EJDUBUPSTBOEDPOUSJCVUJPOUPUIFVOEFSEFWFMPQNFOUJOUIF
SFHJPOXFSFEJSFDUMZBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIF64HPWFSONFOUBOE
i:BOLFFJNQFSJBMJTNw30 31ɨF+VTUJDF%FQBSUNFOUEVSJOH
UIF&JTFOIPXFS"ENJOJTUSBUJPOXBTQVSTVJOHBOBOUJUSVTU
TVJUBHBJOTU6'$0XIJDIXBTTVTQFOEFEJOEVSJOHUIF
$PVQEÏUBUCVUMBUFSUIBUZFBSSFTVMUFEJOBDPOWJDUJPOBHBJOTU
6'$0'SPNUIFFOEPGUIFTUISPVHIUIFFBSMZT
6'$0FOHBHFEJOBWJHPSPVTQSFTTDBNQBJHOBHBJOTUUIF
"SCFO[HPWFSONFOUJOBOBUUFNQUUPXJOTVQQPSUGPSUJNFMZ
64JOUFSWFOUJPOJOUIFXBLFPGMBOEBQQSPQSJBUJPOTVOEFS
%FHSFF32ɨFDBNQBJHOPSJHJOBMMZGPDVTFEPOUIFEBNBHF
27
28
30
31
32
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
6'$0IBEEFMFCSFBUMZVOEFSWBMVFEUIFQSPQFSUZUBYWBMVFPGUIFMBOE
VOEFSUIFBHSFFNFOUSFBDIFEXJUI+PSHF6CJDPJO4FFQH
4FF*NNFSNBOThe CIA in GuatemalaQHBOE4DIOFJEFS
Communism in GuatemalaQHɨFDPOOFDUJPOTCFUXFFOUIF6OJUFE
4UBUFTBOE6'$0SFBDIQBTUDPJODJEFODFBOEUIFTFMJOLTDPVMECFVTFEUP
FYQMBJOUIFBDDFQUBODFPG6'$0DPOUSPMPG(VBUFNBMBBOEUIFEFMBZJO
XIJDI6'$0XBTQSPTFDVUFEGPSJUTBOUJUSVTUTVJUJO
&JTFOIPXFS4FDSFUBSZPG4UBUF+PIO'PTUFS%VMMFTQSFWJPVTMZXPSLFE
GPS4VMMJWBOBOE$SPNXFMMBMFHBMëSNUIBUSFQSFTFOUFE6'$0JO
OFHPUJBUJPOTXJUI6CJDPJO"MMFO%VMMFT%JSFDUPSPGUIF$*"
EVSJOHUIF$PVQXBTBMTPBQBSUOFSJO4VMMJWBOBOE$SPNXFMMBOEPXOFE
BiTUSPOHJOUFSFTUwJO*3$"+PIO$BCPUBTTJTUBOUTFDSFUBSZPGTUBUFGPS
JOUFS"NFSJDBOBêBJSTJOBOEGPSNFSBNCBTTBEPSUP(VBUFNBMB
IFMEBMBSHFBNPVOUPGTUPDLJO6'$0"OO8IJUNBOUIFQSFTJEFOUT
QFSTPOBMTFDSFUBSZXBTUIFFYXJGFPGB6'$0EJSFDUPSXIPXBTUIFOWJDF
QSFTJEFOUGPSQVCMJDSFMBUJPOT(FOFSBM3PCFSU$VUMFSëSTUTQFDJBMBTTJTUBOU
UPUIFQSFTJEFOUGPSOBUJPOBMTFDVSJUZBêBJSTBOEIFBEPGUIF1#46$$&44
QMBOOJOHCPBSEIBECFFOCPBSEDIBJSNBOPG6'$0BOEJUTUSBOTGFS
CBOL0ME$PMPOZ5SVTU/VNFSPVTPUIFSPïDJBMTJOUIF5SVNBOBOE
&JTFOIPXFSBENJOJTUSBUJPOTIBEDPOOFDUJPOTUP6'$0*$3"0ME
$PMPOZ5SVTUBOE4VMMJWBOBOE$SPNXFMM'SPNThe CIA in Guatemala,
The CIA in Guatemala
Ibid
HOHONU Volume 8 2010 - 31
UPUIFDPNQBOZCVUëOEJOHMJUUMFTZNQBUIZGSPNUIF5SVNBO
BENJOJTUSBUJPOUIFDPNQBOZEFDJEFEUPMJOLUIFEBNBHFJU
TVTUBJOFEUPJUT(VBUFNBMBOPQFSBUJPOTCZUIF"SFWBMPBOE
"SCFO[BENJOJTUSBUJPOTUPUIFHSPXJOH64BOUJDPNNVOJTU
DPMEXBSFUIPTɨJTXBTTPTVDDFTTGVMUIBUCZUIFNew York
TimesEFDMBSFEUIBUUIFiJNNFEJBUFBJNTPGUIF<(VBUFNBMBO>
HPWFSONFOUBOE$PNNVOJTUTBSFJOEJTUJOHVJTIBCMFw33-JLFB
CBSPNFUFS64QPMJDZNBLFSTHBVHFEUIFSFMBUJWFTUBCJMJUZPG
-BUJO"NFSJDBOHPWFSONFOUTBOEUIFJSXJMMJOHOFTTUPDPMMVEF
XJUI64GPSFJHOQPMJDZJOUFSFTUTCBTFEPOUIFSFMBUJPOTIJQ
CFUXFFOGPSFJHOJOWFTUNFOUDPNQBOJFTBOEUIF-BUJO"NFSJDBO
HPWFSONFOUT$PNQBOJFTMJLF6'$0EJEOPUXBOU64
QBUFSOBMJTNPGUIFJSJOUFSFTUT‰UIFJSBJNXBTUPNBLFNPOFZGPS
TIBSFIPMEFST#VUJOCPUI6'$0BOEUIF64XBOUFEUIF
SFNPWBMPGUIF"SCFO[HPWFSONFOUBOEUIFSFUVSOPGGBWPSBCMF
FDPOPNJDBOEGPSFJHOQPMJDZDPOEJUJPOT
ɨF5SVNBOBOE&JTFOIPXFSBENJOJTUSBUJPOTQFSDFJWFE
(VBUFNBMBOSFGPSNBDUJPOTMJLF%FDSFFOPUBTBHSJDVMUVSF
SFGPSNDSFBUFEUPVOEPUIFVOFRVBMEJTUSJCVUJPOPGMBOE
CVUBTTZNQUPNTPGBOJOUFSOBUJPOBMDPNNVOJTUUBLFPWFSJO
(VBUFNBMBOQPMJUJDT64QPMJDZNBLFSTVTFEUIFFYJTUFODFPG
SFHJTUFSFE(VBUFNBMBODPNNVOJTUTJOUPDMBJN
XJEFTQSFBEDPNNVOJTUJOëMUSBUJPOPGUIF"SCFO[HPWFSONFOU34
$PNNVOJTUTMJLF+PTF.BOVFM'PSUVOZ"SBOBUIF4FDSFUBSZ
(FOFSBMPGUIF/BUJPOBM"HSBSJBO%FQBSUNFOUPDDVQJFE
LFZSPMFTJOUIFHPWFSONFOUBOEPGUFOFOKPZFEUIFQFSTPOBM
TVQQPSUPG"SCFO[XIPTFXJGFXBTBDPNNVOJTU)PXFWFS
UIJTXBTBOPSHBOJDGPSNPGDPNNVOJTNUIBUXBTTFQBSBUFGSPN
UIF4PWJFUWFSTJPO(VBUFNBMBODPNNVOJTUTGPMMPXJOHUIF
UFBDIJOHTPG,BSM.BSYCFMJFWFEUIBUUIFJSDPVOUSZOFFEFEUP
EFWFMPQDBQJUBMJTNCFGPSFJUDPVMESFBDITPDJBMJTN35ɨF$PME
8BSTDIPMBS3POBME.4DIOFJEFSBENJUUFEJOUIBUUIF
i$PNNVOJTUTTFFNFEQSFGFSBCMFUPUIFFUFSOBMMZRVBSSFMMJOH
UIPSPVHIMZPQQPSUVOJTUJDBOEPGUFODPSSVQUMFBEFSTPGUIFPUIFS
SFWPMVUJPOBSZQBSUJFTw36$PNNVOJTUTVQQPSUFEQSPHSBNTTVDI
BTTUBUFGVOEFEDPNQVMTPSZFEVDBUJPOXPSLFSTPSHBOJ[BUJPO
BOEBHSJDVMUVSFSFGPSNDPOOFDUFEXJUINBOZTFHNFOUTPG
(VBUFNBMBOTPDJFUZ"SCFO[SFMJFEPOUIFDPNNVOJTUTUPCFB
DPSFNFNCFSPGIJTHPWFSONFOUBMDPBMJUJPOBSFMJBODFUIBU64
MFBEFSTWJFXFEBTQSPNPUJOHJOUFSOBUJPOBMDPNNVOJTN
ɨFSFGPSNTPGUIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZHPWFSONFOUUISFBUFOFE
UIFHPBMPG6OJUFE4UBUFTGPSFJHOQPMJDZUIBU(VBUFNBMBSFNBJOT
iBQMBDFGPSDBQJUBMJOWFTUNFOUw37%FDSFFSFQSFTFOUFEB
iSBEJDBMNFBTVSFBHBJOTUB6OJUFE4UBUFTCVTJOFTTwBOEUIVT
33
34
35
36
37
Ibid
4DIOFJEFSCommunism in Guatemala, 1944-1954
4UFQIFO.4USFFUFSi*OUFSQSFUJOHUIF64*OUFSWFOUJPOJO
(VBUFNBMB3FBMJTU3FWJTJPOJTUBOE1PTUSFWJTJPOJTU1FSTQFDUJWFTwThe
History TeacherOP
4DIOFJEFSCommunism in Guatemala, 1944-1954
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
32 - HOHONU Volume 8 2010
(VBUFNBMBXBTiEPNJOBUFECZ$PNNVOJTUTwɨJTCSPBE
HFOFSBMJ[BUJPOPGDPNNVOJTNDSFBUFEDBUFHPSJFTMJLFUIBU
PGiDSZQUP$PNNVOJTNwPSUIPTFXIPEJEOPUJEFOUJGZBT
DPNNVOJTUTCVUBMMJFEPSTZNQBUIJ[FEXJUIUIFDPNNVOJTU
DBVTFXIJDI64QPMJDZNBLFSTCFMJFWFEXFSFNPSFEBOHFSPVT
CFDBVTFUIFZXFSFIBSEUPJOEFOUJGZBOEDPVMECFBOZXIFSF40 41
5PSFQMBDFUIF"SCFO[HPWFSONFOUXJUIPVUQSPWPLJOHBEPNFTUJD
PSJOUFSOBUJPOBMPVUDSZUIF64OFFEFEUPMJOLUIFSFDFOUFWFOUT
JO(VBUFNBMBUPUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTJEFPMPHJDBMFOFNZUIF4PWJFU
6OJPO3JDIBSE*NNFSNBOPVUMJOFTIPXUIJTXBTBDDPNQMJTIFE
ɨFJEFOUJëDBUJPOPGUIF4PWJFU6OJPOBTUIFNBTUFSNJOE
CFIJOEUIF(VBUFNBMBODPOTQJSBDZQSFTFOUFENVDIMFTTPGB
QSPCMFN*OUIFCJQPMBSXPSMEPGUIFDPMEXBS6OJUFE4UBUFT
MFBEFSTVTFEi$PNNVOJTUwBOEi4PWJFUwJOUFSDIBOHFBCMZ
*OUIFXPSETPGUIF&JHIUZUIJSE$POHSFTT4FOBUF'PSFJHO
3FMBUJPOT$PNNJUUFFDIBJSNBO"MFYBOEFS8JMFZiɨFSFJT
OPDPNNVOJTNCVUUIF$PNNVOJTNXIJDIUBLFTJUPSEFST
GSPNUIFEFTQPUTPGUIF,SFNMJOJO.PTDPX*UJTBOBCTPMVUF
NZUIUPCFMJFWFUIBUUIFSFJTTVDIBUIJOHBTIPNFHSPXO
$PNNVOJTNBTPDBMMFEOBUJWFPSMPDBMDPNNVOJTNw42
)BWJOHMJOLFEUIFFWFOUTUSBOTQJSJOHJO(VBUFNBMBUPUIF
JOSPBETPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMDPNNVOJTNWJBUIF4PWJFU6OJPO
UIF5SVNBOBENJOJTUSBUJPOJOEFDJEFEPOUBLJOHHSFBUFS
JOWPMWFNFOUUPSFJOTUBUF6OJUFE4UBUFTIFHFNPOZJOUIFSFHJPO
"GSBJEUIBUTVQQPSUUPUIFFOFNJFTPG"SFWBMPBOE"SCFO[XPVME
CFTFFOBT:BOLFFJNQFSJBMJTNUIF5SVNBOBENJOJTUSBUJPO
EFDJEFEUPiXJUIIPMEGBWPSTGSPNUIF(VBUFNBMBO(PWFSONFOUw
XIJDIBNPVOUFEUPUIFTVTQFOTJPOPGNJMJUBSZBOEFDPOPNJDBJE
JO43*OUIF64EFOJFE(VBUFNBMB.VUVBM4FDVSJUZ
"JEXIJMFHJWJOHHFOFSPVTBNPVOUTUPJUTIPTUJMFOFJHICPST44
ɨFOFXMZFMFDUFE&JTFOIPXFSBENJOJTUSBUJPOEFDJEFEJO
FBSMZUPHFUSJEPG"SCFO[BOETUBSUFEQMBOOJOHB$PVQ
EÏUBU&JTFOIPXFSBENJOJTUSBUJPOPïDJBMTBOEUIF$*"QSJ[FE
TFDSFDZBOEDPWFSUUBDUJDTɨFZOFFEFEUPQSPWJEFBOJOWBTJPO
GPSDFXIJDIXPVMEFOHBHFUIF"SCFO[HPWFSONFOUJOXIBU
MPPLFEMJLFBDJWJMXBSXIJMFVTJOH64JOUFSOBUJPOBMQPXFSUP
DPOEFNO"SCFO[GPSCFJOHB4PWJFUQVQQFUBOEEFMBZJOHBOZ
6OJUFE/BUJPOTPS0SHBOJ[BUJPOPG"NFSJDBO4UBUFTBDUJPOJO
38
40
41
42
43
44
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
Ibid
4DIOFJEFSCommunism in Guatemala, 1944-1954
ɨF64BNCBTTBEPSUP(VBUFNBMBGSPN3JDIBSE1BUUFSTPO
SFDPNNFOEFEBSBUIFSOBDPHEPDIFTNFUIPEGPSJEFOUJGZJOHBDPNNVOJTU
UIFiEVDLUFTUwi4VQQPTFZPVTFFBCJSEXBMLJOHBSPVOEJOBGBSNZBSE
ɨJTCJSEXFBSTOPMBCFMUIBUTBZTiEVDLw#VUUIFCJSEDFSUBJOMZMPPLTMJLF
BEVDL"MTPIFHPFTUPUIFQPOEBOEZPVOPUJDFUIBUIFTXJNTMJLFB
EVDLɨFOIFPQFOTIJTCFBLBOERVBDLTMJLFBEVDL8FMMCZUIJTUJNF
ZPVIBWFQSPCBCMZSFBDIFEUIFDPODMVTJPOUIBUUIFCJSEJTBEVDLXIFUIFS
IFTXFBSJOHBMBCFMPSOPUw'SPN*NNFSNBOThe CIA in Guatemala,
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
Ibid
"OESFX+4DIMFXJU[i*NQFSJBM*ODPNQFUFODFBOE(VBUFNBMBO
.JMJUBSJTNwInternational Journal of Politics, Culture and
SocietyOP
(VBUFNBMBVOUJMUIFTFDSFU$PVQEÏUBUSBOJUTDPVSTF%VSJOH
UIJTUJNFUIF$*"SFDSVJUFE$BSMPT&OSJRVF$BTUJMMP"SNBTB
(VBUFNBMBOFYJMFXIPIBEQSFWJPVTMZUSJFEUPPWFSUISPXUIF
HPWFSONFOUJOBOEXBTMJWJOHJO)POEVSBTUSZJOHUPCVJME
BDPVOUFSSFWPMVUJPOBSZGPSDF45"SNBTXBTFWFSZUIJOHUIF64
HPWFSONFOUXBTIPQJOHGPSJOB-BUJO"NFSJDBOBMMZBNJMJUBSZ
NBOXIPXBTBOUJDPNNVOJTUIFMEMJCFSBMFDPOPNJDJEFBT
BOEXBTQSP$BUIPMJD46-BUFSJO&JTFOIPXFSBQQPJOUFE
+PIO1FVSJGPZBNCBTTBEPSUP(VBUFNBMB"TiBNBOPGBDUJPOw
1FVSJGPZXPVMETFSWFBTBWJUBMMJOLCFUXFFOUIF4UBUF%FQBSUNFOU
BOEUIF$*"JO(VBUFNBMBBOEBTBEFNPDSBUIFXPVMETFSWF
BTBOFêFDUJWFQBUTZJODBTFUIFDPVQGBJMFE47 48ɨF4UBUF
%FQBSUNFOUTNPTUWJUSJPMJDBUUBDLTBHBJOTU(VBUFNBMBDBNFBU
UIFUFOUI*OUFS"NFSJDBO$POGFSFODFIFMEJO$BSBDBT7FOF[VFMB
GSPN.BSDIUP4FDSFUBSZPG4UBUF+PIO'PTUFS%VMMFT
FTUBCMJTIFEUIFDIJFGJOUFSFTUPGUIF64BUUIFDPOGFSFODFBT
iTFDVS<JOH>BTUSPOHBOUJ$PNNVOJTUSFTPMVUJPOXIJDIXPVME
SFDPHOJ[F$PNNVOJTNBTBOJOUFSOBUJPOBMDPOTQJSBDZJOTUFBE
PGSFHBSEJOHJUNFSFMZBTBOJOEJHFOPVTNPWFNFOUw At the
DPOGFSFODF%VMMFTQSPQPTFEUIBUi$PNNVOJTUEPNJOBUJPO
PSDPOUSPMPGBOZDPVOUSZXPVMEKVTUJGZABQQSPQSJBUFBDUJPO
JOBDDPSEBODFXJUIFYJTUJOHUSFBUJFTw‰HJWJOHUIF64BMFHBM
CBDLHSPVOEGPSJOUFSWFOUJPO50ɨF6OJUFE4UBUFTCVJMUPOJUT
SFBTPOJOHUIBUBMMDPNNVOJTNTBSFJOUFSOBUJPOBMDPNNVOJTNJO
EJTHVJTFJUTFYJTUFODFJO-BUJO"NFSJDBJTOPUWPMVOUBSZCVUNVTU
PSJHJOBUFJOUIF4PWJFU6OJPO%VMMFTTQSPQPTJUJPOLOPXOBTUIF
$BSBDBT3FTPMVUJPOQBTTFEXJUIPOMZ(VBUFNBMBWPUJOHBHBJOTU51
#ZUZJOHUIF$BSBDBT3FTPMVUJPOXJUIPUIFSFYJTUJOHIFNJTQIFSJD
EFGFOTFUSFBUJFTUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTIBEEJQMPNBUJDDBSUFCMBODIFUP
NPWFBHBJOTU(VBUFNBMB
#ZNJE"SCFO[LOFXUIBUBOJOWBTJPOMFECZ$BTUJMMP
"SNBTXBTPOMZBNBUUFSPGUJNF*OBOBUUFNQUUPSFNPWFUIF
SFBTPOGPS6OJUFE4UBUFTJOUFSWFOUJPOIFQSPQPTFEBSCJUSBUJPO
CFUXFFO(VBUFNBMBBOE6OJUFE'SVJUJOFBSMZ52 When
UIJTGBJMFE"SCFO[UPPLESBTUJDBDUJPOUPTFDVSFNJMJUBSZBJE
GPS(VBUFNBMBSJTLJOHUIFJSFPGUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTBOEIJT
PXONJMJUBSZ"SCFO[UVSOFEUPUIF4PWJFUTGPSBTTJTUBODF‰
SFJOGPSDJOHUIF64DMBJNTPG4PWJFUJOUFSWFOUJPOJO(VBUFNBMB
$[FDIPTMPWBLJBBHSFFEUPTFOEUXPUIPVTBOEUPOTPG88**
TVSQMVTTNBMMBSNTBCPBSEB4XFEJTIGSFJHIUFSUIFAlfhem53
ɨFAlfhem NBEFQPSUJO(VBUFNBMBCVUUIFNJMJUBSZGFBSGVM
PG"SCFO[BSNJOHIJTDJWJMJBOTVQQPSUFSTTFJ[FEUIFTIJQNFOU
JOQPSUɨF$*"TQPUUFEUIFTIJQNFOUJO1PMBOEJOGPSNJOH
45
46
47
48
50
51
52
53
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
4USFFUFSManaging the Counterrevolution
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala, Ibid
Ibid
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
"ZCBSEF4PUPDependency and Intervention: The Case of Guatemala in
1954
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
Ibid
1SFTJEFOU&JTFOIPXFSXIPEFDJEFEUPJOWPLFUIF$BSBDBT
BHSFFNFOUUPBSSBOHFBNFFUJOHPGUIF0"4XIJMFTJNVMUBOFPVTMZ
TUFQQJOHVQQMBOOJOHGPSUIF$PVQEÏUBU54
$BTUJMMP"SNBTBOENFSDFOBSJFTDSPTTFEUIF)POEVSBO
(VBUFNBMBOCPSEFSJOUIFFBSMZIPVSTPG+VOFCBDLFE
VQCZ6OJUFE4UBUFTQMBOFTBDPWFSUSBEJPTUBUJPOQMBZJOHBOUJ
"SCFO[QSPQBHBOEBBOEGVMMTVQQPSUPGUIF$BUIPMJD$IVSDI55
*OJUBMMZ"SNBTNPWFEPOMZTJYNJMFTJOUP(VBUFNBMBDBMMFE
GPS"SCFO[TVODPOEJUJPOBMTVSSFOEFSBOEUIFONPWFEOP
GVSUIFS56"SNBTTQMBOFTDPOUJOVFEUPNBLFCPNCJOHSVOTPO
UIFDBQJUBM(VBUFNBMB$JUZDBVTJOHQBOJDBOEGFBSBNPOHUIF
QPQVMBDFBOEUIFNJMJUBSZUIFMBUUFSLOPXJOHUIBU"SNBTXBT
CFJOHTVQQMJFECZUIF6OJUFE4UBUFT57"SCFO[EFDJEFEUPVTF
EJQMPNBUJDDIBOOFMTUPSFTPMWFUIFTJUVBUJPOBTIFXBTIFTJUBOUUP
BUUBDLBO64CBDLFEGPSDF0O+VOF(VBUFNBMBO'PSFJHO
.JOJTUFS(VJMMFSNP5PSJFMMPDBCMFEUIF6/BTLJOHGPSUIF
4FDVSJUZ$PVODJMUPTFOEBOPCTFSWBUJPOUFBNUP(VBUFNBMB58
ɨF64EPNJOBUFE4FDVSJUZ$PVODJMWPUFEUPUIF4PWJFU
6OJPODBTUJOHUIFOBZWPUF
JOGBWPSPGSFUVSOJOH(VBUFNBMBT
DPNQMBJOUTUPUIF*OUFS"NFSJDBO1FBDF$PNNJUUFFBOBSNPG
UIF0SHBOJ[BUJPOPG"NFSJDBO4UBUFTXIPTFNFNCFSTiHFOFSBMMZ
TIBSF64WJFXT<BOE>BHSFBUFSEFHSFFPGDPOUSPMFYJTUTw
"SCFO[UIFODBMMFEGPSUIFNJMJUBSZUPSFMFBTFBSNTUPIJTDJWJMJBO
TVQQPSUFSTCVUUIFNJMJUBSZSFGVTFEBOE"SCFO[CMPDLFEJOUIF
JOUFSOBUJPOBMTZTUFNCZUIF64BOEQSFTTVSFECZIJTNJMJUBSZ
PïDFSTSFTJHOFEIJTQSFTJEFODZPO+VOF4UFQIFO.
4USFFUFSPêFSTBOBOBMZTJTPGUIFQJWPUBMSPMFUIFNJMJUBSZQMBZFEJO
UIFTVDDFTTPGUIFDPVQ
)BEUIFIJHIDPNNBOEDIPTFOUPëHIUTFSJPVTMZUIFZDPVME
IBWFFBTJMZDSVTIFE$BTUJMMP"SNBTTSBHUBHCBOE.PTU
NJMJUBSZPïDFSTDIPTFUPBCBOEPO"SCFO[IPXFWFSCFDBVTF
UIFZIBEHSPXOXFBSZPGUIFFUIOJDDPOìJDUUSJHHFSFECZ
54
55
56
57
58
ɨFEJTDPWFSZPGUIFTIJQNFOUSFBETMJLFBQBHFGSPNBTQZOPWFMi1PTJOH
BTBCJSEXBUDIFSUIFBHFODZTPQFSBUJWFJO4UFUUJO<1PMBOE>TQJFEXIBU
IFCFMJFWFEUPCFBSNT)FUIFOXSPUFBTFFNJOHMZJOOPDVPVTMFUUFSUPB
1BSJTJBOBVUPNPCJMFQBSUTDPODFSO)FNFUJDVMPVTMZQBTUFEBNJDSPëMN
EPUPWFSPOFQFSJPEɨFBHFOUJO1BSJTUSBOTMBUFEUIFNJDSPëMNNFTTBHF
JOUPDPEFBOEJNNFEJBUFMZUSBOTNJUUFEJUCZTIPSUXBWFUP8BTIJOHUPO
ɨFNFTTBHFSFBEMJLFUIFUXFOUZTFDPOEQSBZFSPG%BWJEJOUIF#PPLPG
1TBMNTi.Z(PENZ(PEXIZIBTUUIPVGPSTBLFONF w%FDPEFEUIJT
NFBOUUIBUNJMJUBSZTVQQMJFTXFSFPOCPBSEUIFTIJQw'SPN*NNFSNBO
The CIA in GuatemalaQH
ɨFUISFFBJSDSBGUHJWFOUP"SNBTXFSFMPTUBGUFSUIFëSTUEBZBOE
VQPOIFBSJOHUIFOFXT&JTFOIPXFSEFDJEFEUPTFOENPSFUIFOFYUEBZ
/FFEJOHUPHFUUIFQMBOFTDPWFSUMZUP$BTUJMMP"SNBTUIF$*"XPSLJOH
XJUIUIF&JTFOIPXFSBENJOJTUSBUJPOVTFEUIFTFSWJDFTPG8JMMJBN1BXMFZ
B-BUJO"NFSJDBOCVTJOFTTNBODVSSFOUMZXPSLJOHGPSUIF&JTFOIPXFS
BENJOJTUSBUJPO1BXMFZSFQPSUFEMZIBOEFEBCSJFGDBTFëMMFEXJUI
UPUIF/JDBSBHVBOBNCBTTBEPS(VJMMFSNP4FWJMMB4BDBTBXIP
QVSDIBTFEUIFQMBOFTGSPNUIF1FOUBHPOBOEUIFOìFXUIFNUP1BOBNB
XIFSFUIFZXFSFUVSOFEPWFSUP"SNBT'SPN.BY)PMMBOEi1SJWBUF
4PVSDFTPG64'PSFJHO1PMJDZ8JMMJBN1BXMFZBOEUIF$PVQE²UBU
JO(VBUFNBMBwJournal of Cold War Studies 7OP
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
.BY)PMMBOEi1SJWBUF4PVSDFTPG64'PSFJHO1PMJDZ8JMMJBN1BXMFZ
BOEUIF$PVQE²UBUJO(VBUFNBMBwJournal of Cold War Studies 7
OP
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
Ibid
HOHONU Volume 8 2010 - 33
UIFMBOESFGPSNBOECFDBVTFUIFZGFBSFEUIBUUIXBSUJOH
1#46$$&44XPVMEPOMZJOWJUFBNVDIMBSHFS64NJMJUBSZ
JOUFSWFOUJPOɨFUSBOTJUJPOCFUXFFO"SCFO[BOE$BTUJMMP
"SNBTSFQSFTFOUFEJOSFBMJUZNJMJUBSZDPVQOPUBNBTTCBTFE
SFWPMVUJPOBHBJOTUDPNNVOJTN60
ɨF(VBUFNBMBONJMJUBSZSPMFJOUIFDPVQXBTMPTUUPUIF
QMBOOFSTPG1#46$$&44XIPBTDSJCF"SNBTTTVDDFTTUP64
TVQQPSUBOEQMBOOJOHɨJTTIPSUTJHIUFEOFTTDBNFCBDLUPIBVOU
1SFTJEFOU+PIO',FOOFEZTBENJOJTUSBUJPOBTUIF#BZPG1JHT
JOWBTJPOXBTCBTFEPOUIFGBVMUZ$*"MPHJDPWFSTUBUJOHUIFSPMFPG
UIF64JOUIF$PVQEÏUBU
0O+VMZ$BTUJMMP"SNBTXBTFMFDUFEQSFTJEFOUCZUIF
NJMJUBSZKVOUBQMBDFEJOQPXFSBGUFS"SCFO[TSFTJHOBUJPO61 Armas
JNNFEJBUFMZTFUPVUUPSFWFSTFUIFQPMJDJFTPGUIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZ
HPWFSONFOU)FCBOOFEUIFDPNNVOJTUQBSUZBSSFTUFEBOZPOF
IFEFFNFEBDPNNVOJTUSFWFSTFEUIFMBOETFJ[VSFTVOEFS%FDSFF
BOESFQFBMFEUIFDPOTUJUVUJPOPG62 It was clear that
"SNBTXJTIFEUPCFKVTUBOPUIFSEJDUBUPSJO(VBUFNBMBTMPOH
IJTUPSZPGSFQSFTTJWFQPMJUJDT5PUIF64UIFDPVQSFQSFTFOUFE
BiGPSFJHOQPMJDZQBOBDFBwBXBZUPDPNCBUXIBUUIFZWJFXFEBT
JOUFSOBUJPOBMDPNNVOJTNCVUXIBUXBTSFBMMZBEFNPDSBUJDBMMZ
FMFDUFEHPWFSONFOUMPPLJOHUPSFWFSTFUIFMPOHIJTUPSZPG
VOEFSEFWFMPQNFOUJO(VBUFNBMB63ɨJTUZQFPGGPSFJHO
QPMJDZXPVMEJOUIFFOEEPUIF64HSFBUIBSNBTFNFSHJOH
HPWFSONFOUTJO-BUJO"NFSJDBXPVMESFNFNCFSIPXUIF64
USFBUFE(VBUFNBMBGSPN
*OB(VBUFNBMBO&NCBTTZPïDJBMXBTPWFSIFBSE
TBZJOHUPUIF644UBUF%FQBSUNFOUUIBUiUIPVHIJUXBTB
EJïDVMUUIJOHGPSB(VBUFNBMBOUPBENJUOPHPWFSONFOUDPVME
TVSWJWFJO(VBUFNBMBVOMFTTJUXBTBDDFQUBCMFUPUIF6OJUFE
4UBUFT(PWFSONFOUw64'SPNJOEFQFOEFODFJOUISPVHIUIF
EFNPDSBUJDSFWPMVUJPOPG(VBUFNBMBOQPMJUJDTTBXUIFSJTF
BOEGBMMPGBTFSJFTPGEJDUBUPSTNPTUPGXIPNPQFOFEUIFDPVOUSZ
VQUPFYQMPJUBUJWF64CVTJOFTTJOUFSFTUTɨFSFWPMVUJPOPG
MPPLFEUPSFWFSTFUIJTiEFWFMPQNFOUPGVOEFSEFWFMPQNFOUw
CZJOTUJUVUJOHBTFSJFTPGTPDJBMBOEBHSBSJBOSFGPSNTUIBUXPVME
FNQPXFSCPUIUIFNJEEMFDMBTTBOEFUIOJD.BZBO*OEJBOTXIJMF
ESBXJOHUIFJSTVQQPSUUPUIFTUSVHHMJOHHPWFSONFOU65ɨFTF
SFGPSNTëSTUCSPVHIUUIF(VBUFNBMBOHPWFSONFOUJOUPDPOìJDU
XJUIUIF6OJUFE'SVJU$PNQBOZBQPXFSGVM64CVTJOFTT
JOUFSFTUXJUIDPOOFDUJPOTUPNFNCFSTJOUIF64HPWFSONFOU
4FFJOHUIFTFSFGPSNTBTBUISFBUUPJUTFDPOPNJDBOEQPMJUJDBM
IFHFNPOZJO-BUJO"NFSJDBUIF6OJUFE4UBUFTOPUFEUIFQSFTFODF
60
61
62
63
64
65
4USFFUFSi*OUFSQSFUJOHUIF64*OUFSWFOUJPOJO(VBUFNBMB3FBMJTU
3FWJTJPOJTUBOE1PTUSFWJTJPOJTU1FSTQFDUJWFTw
Immerman, The CIA in Guatemala
Ibid
)PMMBOEi1SJWBUF4PVSDFTPG64'PSFJHO1PMJDZ8JMMJBN1BXMFZBOEUIF
$PVQE²UBUJO(VBUFNBMBw
4DIMFXJU[i*NQFSJBM*ODPNQFUFODFBOE(VBUFNBMBO.JMJUBSJTN
w
"ZCBSEF4PUPDependency and Intervention: The Case of Guatemala in
1954,
34 - HOHONU Volume 8 2010
PGDPNNVOJTUTJOUIF(VBUFNBMBOHPWFSONFOUBOEDPOEFNOFE
UIFNXJUI$PME8BSSIFUPSJDUIBUMJOLFE(VBUFNBMBUPUIF4PWJFU
6OJPO%FDSFFFOBDUFECZUIF+BDPCP"SCFO[HPWFSONFOU
XBTUIFMBSHFTUPGUIFTFBHSBSJBOSFGPSNBOECSPVHIUUIF64
JOUPJODSFBTFEDPOìJDUXJUI(VBUFNBMB$VUUJOHPêBMMBJEBOE
MPPLJOHUPDVSUBJOXIBUJUTBXBTBCFBDIIFBEPGJOUFSOBUJPOBM
DPNNVOJTNUIF64HPWFSONFOUTUBSUFEUPUBLFMFHBMBOE
DPWFSUBDUJPOBHBJOTU(VBUFNBMB0O+VOFUIF64
HPWFSONFOUTVQQPSUFEBDPVQEÏUBUMFECZ$BTUJMMP"SNBTUIBU
XBTVMUJNBUFMZTVDDFTTGVMJOSFQMBDJOHUIF"SCFO[HPWFSONFOU
EVFUPBMBDLPGNJMJUBSZTVQQPSUUPëHIUUIFJOWBTJPOɨF
JOTUBMMBUJPOPG$BTUJMMP"SNBTQSPWJEFETFDVSJUZGPS64
IFHFNPOZJO-BUJO"NFSJDBBUUIFDPTUPGTFMGEFUFSNJOBUJPO
GPSUIF(VBUFNBMBOQFPQMFBOEJSSFQBSBCMFEBNBHFUPUIF64
SFQVUBUJPOJO-BUJO"NFSJDB
Bibliography
"ZCBSEF4PUP+PTÏ.Dependency and Intervention: The Case of
Guatemala in 1954.#PVMEFS8FTUWJFX1SFTT
#VSOFUU7JSHJOJB(BSSBSEi1SPUFTUBOUJTNJO3VSBM(VBUFNBMBw
Latin American Research Review.7PM/P
%PTBM1BVM+Doing Business With The Dictators: A Political
History of United Fruit In Guatemala, 1899-1944.
8JMNJOHUPO4DIPMBSMZ3FTPVSDFT*OD
)PMMBOE.BYi8JMMJBN1BXMFZBOEUIF$PVQ%ÏUBUJO
(VBUFNBMBwJournal of Cold War Studies. 7PM/P
*NNFSNBO3JDIBSE)The CIA in Guatemala"VTUJO
6OJWFSTJUZPG5FYBT1SFTT
4DIMFXJU["OESFX+i*NQFSJBM*ODPNQFUFODFBOE(VBUFNBMBO
.JMJUBSJTNw
International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society7PM/P
4DIOFJEFS3POBME.Communism in
Guatemala, 1944-1954. /FX:PSL'SFEFSJDL"1SBFHFS
*OD1VCMJTIFST
4PEFSMVOE8BMUFS$i"O"OBMZTJTPGUIF(VBUFNBMBO*OTVSHFODZ
BOE$PVQ%ÏUBUBT5FDIOJRVFTPG*OEJSFDU"HHSFTTJPOw
International Studies Quarterly7PM/P
4USFFUFS4UFQIFO.Managing the Counterrevolution: The United
States and Guatemala, 1954-1961."UIFOT0IJP6OJWFSTJUZ
$FOUFSGPS*OUFSOBUJPOBM4UVEJFT
i*OUFSQSFUJOH
UIF64*OUFSWFOUJPOJO(VBUFNBMB3FBMJTU
3FWJTJPOJTUBOE1PTU3FWJTJPOJTU1FSTQFDUJWFTwThe History
Teacher.7PM/P