Pollution haven hypothesis and Environmental impacts
of foreign direct investment: The Case of Industrial
Emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) in Chinese provinces
Jie He
To cite this version:
Jie He. Pollution haven hypothesis and Environmental impacts of foreign direct investment:
The Case of Industrial Emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) in Chinese provinces. 2005.06. 2011.
<halshs-00564699>
HAL Id: halshs-00564699
https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00564699
Submitted on 9 Feb 2011
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
Document de travail de la série
Etudes et Documents
Ec 2005.06
Pollution haven hypothesis and Environmental impacts of foreign direct
investment: The Case of Industrial Emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO2)
in Chinese provinces
Jie HE
CERDI
Université d’Auvergne
65 Boulevard de F. Mitterrand
63000 Clermont-Ferrand
France
Tel: 00.33.4.73.17.74.23
Fax: 00.33.4.73.17.74.28
Email: [email protected]
(Feb 9th 2005)
38 p.
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
!
$ %&
$
)
'( %
"#
"
"*
'( %
+,
'( %
-"
-&&,
$
".
$
/
0
$
"1
"
/
"
2
'( %
$
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
!
" # $%
&'
#
3
+&&-
4
"
5
6
'
"1
(7
"1
(7
3%--84
%--9
:9"
:
6
6'
'
38-
;
6' 4
:--
"
38<
6' 4
%:
6'
"3''. %--84
+&<=
+
5
.
+&&9"
!
"(7
3%--84
$
!
$
3
>
"
+
4
$
%:
"1
!
+&=-$"1
+&&-$
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
%?9
7
!
0
1
$
37014
@
+
"
*
A'
$
A
1
!
$
"#
3'( %4
%&
+&&8 %--+
"#
"#
;BB
3+&&=4
'
#
3+&&C4
.
!
!
B
.
"
;
3;BB4
"
#
"
"'
9
"#
"#
'
'
C"
+
"
:"
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
$' (
)
!
B
$
"#
/
$
%
"
#
$
/
/
$
$
9
"
.
"
$
"
"
*
*
3+&&<4
5
<-,"D
$
%
#
;
3%---4 '
'
3+&&%4 F
* 3%--+4 G
".
3+&=: +&== +&=&4 ;
3+&&% +&&C4 .
3+&&C4 E
E
3%--%4
F
6"
'"#
E
F
B
3+&&+4
3%--+4 F
3%--94 "B
"#
"B
;
3%--94
>
9
#
E
HI $
G
" #
3+&&+4 B
*
B
B
D
"
E
3%--%4
6'
"
3%--%4
.
B
7
%%
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
"3
+&=+
+&<& ;
4#
(7
"3J
/
+&=< >
$
"+&&:4'
K
0
30
G
L
F
+&&&4"#
+&&:)
/
$
"3J
$/
+&&:4
$
"
#
"(
/
$
3
/
+&&%4"(
$
M
"3B
*
+&&<4;
"
">
N
M
N
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
8
"
;
)
"1
37
>
+&&<)
"
4
"#
$
!
3
B
F
+&&<4)
"
"B
"
#
"#
3
4
3
3
!
4
4
;
3+&&:4
"(
3
4
8
7
!
4
3
"1
>
3+&&<4
"
HI $
D
B
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
"(
"
3F
%--+)
3#
%--%
%--%)
%--84
F
F
*
%--8
3#
P
F
%--94
O
E
%--84"'
$
"(
/
$
$
"(
$
"
#
3+&&8 +&&<4
1
"3%--+4
"
#
"#
"
"
;
$
F
E
!
"*
3%---4
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
!
*'
"
#$
#
%:
"
%
'( %
:
%--+"
9-
"#
; 0
"*
; 0
'( %
"#
'( %
!
;
"
1
'( %
>
5
'
5
'( %
3
%
Q
'( %
"
4
9
'( %
"7
6!
"(
:#
+&&-
"
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
#
"
3
+'
9
4
,
(
-
'( %
"
1
3+&&=4"
">
M
N
"
'( %
: !
"
3+4
3%4
394
384
3:4
Ω
τ
!
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
"
#
"
#
"
#
!
!
#
!
!!" # $
%"
!
!
'
& !!
%
# (&
"
Ω
*&
!
>
.
&
!# &
&
%"
#
&
&
!
& !!
! #!
)
)
# 0"
%"
τ
0
&& *
*&
&
&
#
&
$+
& !!
#
&
%
+ # & !!
)
#
!
+
$
#
!
,
)!
.
τ
%"
# !
+
)"
+
!%
& !!
Ω
# %
&
& !!
&
Ω
&
)/
& +
!)
$+
#
+
! #!
"
#
)
<
#
!
"
3+&=94
!
3%4"
!
"#
!
3%4
!
3C4"
$
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
!
δ" '
2
F
>F
E
>E
7
>7
"1
3+&=94
$
$
$
"#
3C4
!
!
3%4
1
!
"
3%4
$
"#
%
!
"
!
2
"
$
"#
394"#
M
τ
N
"
"*
&'
τ()
"#
&'
"()"
"
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
#
!
384
!
"1
!
"3F
R +&&8)'
'
+&&:4*
"
5
$
"#
$
#
7+
3T 4"0
)
T
S-";
*)"#
!
!
"
7!
3:4
#
"
3+&&:4
1
"3%--+4
!
$
"'
τ
F
"*
τ
$
+
"1
/
+
$
T
"
+
S-"
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
8
"#
!
"
"(
"
3
8
4
#
"#
"#
"
+,
-
-
.
-
-
-
.
.
1
/,
-
0,
2,
-
-
-
3,
3U4
34
3U4
-
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
#
5
"*
2
1
#
2
!
!
"
"*
!
"#
"(
".
!
3+V4 3:V4
3<4
3E 4
9
2
34
3
8
4
"
#
$
"#
"#
"#
5
"
U
( #
$ && ' ( "" #
%( # %
$#%&
3<4
"" #
( #
#+ ./ "" #
#+%
# , # )( * +
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
0
( #
1 , 2
(% 2" (,%
0
# , 2
3
#+%
( # ( )/&%
%& 1 , 2
0
*
( #
(% 2" (,%
( " (# ,
"" #
:
"#
"#
$
"#
!
"#
"
3
:
4
.'
4
#
$
+&&8 %--+
"
$
"#
!
"
'
$ %:
$
"#
+&&%
+&&8 %--+
"
$
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
"
+5
!
#
'( %
#
!
"
'( %
"#
3#'04
"1
+&&"'
'( %
"#
M
N
";
$
'( %
"#
'( %
C
"
"*
4
4
4
"
; 0
+9
6
+9
<=
+&&+"
6
<
>
#
B"E"
+9
3
5
'( %
6)
C
"#
!
#"B"'
2
3%---4
'(%
7
'
"
T
+&=& %--%4
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
3E?F4
1
"3%--+4
"3%--94
#
3+&&8 +&&:4
3%--84
"
!
"6
3E?F4
"
3%---4
>
3%--94
$
M
N3
%---4
"#
+9
"
+9
&=,
; 0
"
1
/
$
$
37
+&&<)E
F
+&&&)'
*
%--+
$
M#
7
7
F
>
%---
"#
Q
3#7Q 4N
!
=
E
5
F
"6
M
=-,
N3
"
4">
+&&&4"1
+&&-$
3%--%4
"
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
#7Q
"*
3%--%4
!
"
"
!
=-,
"
"#
'( %
$
"
#
!
+&&$
$
!
"1
!
3:V4
"
/ 5
7!
#
#
"#
+&&"0
"#
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
$
"
#
+
"1
"
3
#
+
4
# 5
.
"#
"(
"(
".
;BB
.
1
>
.
3+&=%4
!
3+&&=4
1
.
!
"
3+&&+4"#
"1
1
3+&&+4" #
!
8
79 79
:
6 5 5
"ε
"*
5 5
:
:
8
:
;
79
79
"#
3+&=%4
.
:
6 5
5
.
1
.
3+&&+4
:
"#
5
.
3+&&=4
1
>
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
".
:
./
1
:
1
.
>
3+&=%4 .
.
3+&&+4
:
%
9
8
W
+
"
1
.
$
.
.
3+&&=4
"M#
;BB
1
.
"
N 3.
%--94
!
"#
:
./
+
.0
./
.
8
.0
/
.0
+
.
.2
8
#
/
.
+
"
"1
# ' 5 54
!
"*
;
5
4
B
B
3;BB4
">
;BB
.
"F
'
#
.
;BB
.
3+&&C4
P
3+&CC4
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
!
;BB
"
#
"
#
'
3+&&C4
"
;BB
"
!
"
3
#
#
%
4
%
"#
"B
"#
>
3+&<=4
J
!
"1
!
!
"#
;BB
#
#
!
"
%
'(%
;
"#
"
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
'(
&
"
!
#
"#
-"
C&9
3E 4
";
%
-"
%9+
; 0
-"
%9+×-"
C&9X-"
+C,
+,
"
+,
-"
98:,$
"(
; 0
$
+,
; 0
-"
:-:,"#
"3+&&:4
-"
C9:"#
"#
+"
:,
#
"#
"1
"#
&
+- δ?3
+Uδ4X-"
-8&
δX-"
-:"
"
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
">
$
"(
+,
-"
+9+,
$
#
#
"
%
$
"*
3+"
-%<4
$
3-"
+<C4"#
7E
$
3> %--94
+&&-
*
*
3+&&C4
$
*
.
3%---4"1
"(
"#
N
"#
M
N
$
"*
"#
"#
"#
++
"
"
.
2
3 4( &
M
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
"#
!
"
"'
'( %
!
"#
!
"*
$
"#
3Y-"
-+%4
!
$
3
C
/
"
4
C
'( %
"#
'( %
-"
-&&,"#
"
/'
+,$
$
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
'( %
"*
?
2
!
"
#
1
*
$ %&
3%--+4
$
'( %
"
'( %
"
"
+,
'( %
-"
-&&,
$
"
.
$
/
N
"1
'( %
/
$
"
0
1
7
1
#"
">
+=2 C< =%"
* "." "
&+3842=<< &-="
+&=%"
B"
'"#
"J
%--+"
#
;
#
7
A1
7
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
1
B" (".
+&&:"1
F
D
7
7
B
"
J
7
C=2 %& :+"
1
B"
'" ".
+&&+"'
#
'
2 B
7
1
7
7!
"
7
'
:=2 %<< %&<"
.
0" B"P
+&CC"0
'
#
'
7
B
2
#
P
; "7
982 :=: C+%"
.
.">"+&&:"7
1
0
"*
' F "* '
7
9-8 "
.
#"J" +&=:".
F
6
'
27
7
6
#
(
'
"J
.
7
'
93+42+8 %%"
.
#"
J"+&=="#
7
.
F
6
'
";
+&3942%% 88"
.
)#"
J" +&=&"'
.
' 6
6
'
2 7
7
'
"
'
7
J
::3842+--8 +-+="
.
1" %--9"1
0
7
2B
7
1
"
-:?-9 7
.
"
.
" '" ".
+&&="
B
0
B
"J
7
"=<2++: +89"
.
B"+&&C" 0
1
A7
;
"B
6
1
"
# 0
27
" 2 (7
37
4
"J"T
"; +&&&"'(%
7
#
2
(7
0 2 (7
%99 %:<"
" F"
T"L
+&&:"#
$ 0 +&<= 7
"*
%93842C&+ <-9"
T"
'"
%--%"
I
$
R
2F H
$
I
"7
&%2 +9+ +C8"3
4
E T 0"F %--8"'
7
27
0
"
7
+:2 %: 88"
B"
1"%--8"#
E
2
"
7
7
8=3+42<+ =+"
"B"
1"
"J" "7
%--9"
Y
2
"J
7
7
B
8C39429C9 9=9"
."
B"'"#
+&&8"P
'
#
7
"# Q
J
7
+-&3942<:: <=<"
." B"'"#
+&&<"1 '
B
#
B
7
P.7 *
P ":=&=
B1"
." "
B"
'"#
%--9"#
7
2#
7
"0
6
0
0
(
9-8 "
'"
."F
P"B
+&&<"
B
7
0
"*
0
P "+&-& *
.
*
"
'"B"> ! "*
"L
+&&C"*
0
2
7
0
*
P "+C9- *
.
*
"
'
"*
+&&<"
7
2 7
"0
*
0
P "+<-8 *
.
*
"
'" 1"B
'"
"*
+&&:"7
21
7
1
0
*
0
P "+88= *
.
*
"
'" ."F
P"B
>"*
%---"
7
0
0
*
0
P "%%=: *
.
*
"
'">"*
"*
+&&<"'
'
20
0
0 7 *
.
*
"
J"B"+&&="#
#
F
7
2
"
0";"37
4#
;
0
7
8 "
:: C9"
7" " +&<&"1
'
7
;
2 # 6"
'"
+&<-$".
*
"
'"
"
B"
0 %---"1 !
2
"7
7
9839428-& 8%"
7
;"
'"
1"
7" >
%--9" B
;
0
AB
0
>
>
"J
7
<-3+42+ %9"
;"+&=9"(
"J
7
+%3+ %42:& <9"
;"J"
1"F
"
F"B
%--9".
7
0
6"
'"
2#
7
"J
0
7
=<2 +8-< +89-"
J" "1";
J"'
+&&%"*
1
B
A7
.
0
F
6
'
"J
'
9%38428-9 +="
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
;
T
;
I
;
*
;
* ">"%--- 7
1
7
3D
D4 0
>
"P
"
JB
J" B
+&&:
P
' 2
5
! !
$
I
I
+&&:3842 C& +-%"3
4
;"
1"E
+&&+"7
1P
1
#
1
P.7
0
P "9&+8
B1"
;"B"
1"."E
+&&9"7
P
1
#
1
"
0"37
4# 6"'"YB
#
1
B #0
B1"
;
;" +&&:"0
2*
A 2;
*
37
4# 7
'
6
0 "
>
J"+&<="'
#
7
"7
8C2 +%:+ +%<+"
>
"
>" ;"
."
+&=+"7
0
;
" >"
B"0
0" "
0
1"
D"
E
37
"
47
6"
'" 7
"
*
":: <:"
> J"3%--94"7
$
'(% 7
2
"'
*
0
7
6
I $
1
"
>
B"E"
#"B"'
%---"
7
7
2
# 5
.
>
7
"7
7
C2 C9 =9"
>
>" "7"."F
"*
+&&%"# #
0
2;
0
#
#
0
"1
7
=%3%428<= 8=+"
J
1"."'" "0
0"P"0
"P"'
+&&:"7
6"
'"B
2*
7
# 6'AJ
7
F
GGG 2 +9% +C9"
J
"
1"
1"
F"(
+&&C"7
0
B
2 10
;
B
"
.
;
*
"
E
* " 1"F
+&&&"7
6"'"
"
P7.
P "<9C&
B1"
E
*"
1"F
+&&&"0
1
6"
'"'
"
P.7 "*
0
"<9C&
B1"
E
* " 1"F
%--+"0
1
6"
'"'
"#
7
'
FGGG D 3842C&+ <-9"
F
"
"O E
%--8"1
#
#
#
2 #
"*
9%3:42 =%& =:-"
F
>"J"+&=="0
'
# *
0
"
6
0
%<% "
F
"
"E
%---"
/
$
5
"
0
%&2 :& <&"
F
1" +&&%"7
B
$
2 7
B
"P T
6
"
F
1" +&&C"7
B
$F
2 7
B
"J
0
7
"C%2 : %&"
F G"G"F
"0
%--+"
0
'
B
'
"7
'
%:2 9-: 9%+"
F
J"
1"
"
T"
%---"# 7
7
"J
7
7
B
8-2 + %-"
F G"
"*
%--9"
#
0
A7
"
0
9%2 &8: &:9"
F
" +&&8" # 7
2 # 7
7
;
#
F
"J
7
7
B
%<2 +C9 +=8"
F
"7" ." "*
>">
+&&%"7
7
B
#
2 +&C-+&==" 2 0"F
37
4
#
7
P "+:& *
.
*
"
B
B"
"*
+&&<" '
0
>
A
*
7
+&C: +&&: 2
0
(7
7
3+&&&4"#
P
"
B
F"
0"'
+&&%"# 7
0
2>
#
1
"E
1
0
::% "
(7
%--8"#
"J %--8"(7
0 "
0
B"
7"
"
F
+&&:" #
1 P
7
"J
7
0
&2 &< ++="
"F"+&&%"
2
/
.
$
"P T
6
F
C<2 +%+-+%:8"
;" "
7"#
+&&<"'
;
21
;
7!
1
"*
%:3+-42+C-& +C%:"
6
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
'
#"B"
"'
+&&8"7
Q
2
E
1 0
7
AJ
7
7
B
%<2 +8< +C%"
'
#
B"
"'
+&&:"P
;
J
1
6
0
"J
7
7
B
%&2 +C% +C="
'701 3'
7
0
1
0 4 +&&= %--%"
7
'
T
"
. 5 "
'701 3'
7
0
1
0 4 +&=C +&&<"
7
T
"
'
0
>
. 5 "
'
0
1
#
+&&C"
F
B
" 2 F"B
0"'
37
4 #
7
0
< E
1
0
"
'
."
E"
' J"* %--+"0
>
2
'
0
B A
P.7 *
0
P "
=8C:
B1"
''. 3' '
.
0 4+&=8 %--8"
'
T
'
0
. 5 "
''. 3'
'
.
0 4 +&=C +&&<"
7
'
T
"
'
0
>
. 5 "
#
7" "%--%"
7
#
#
27
>
E
;
"*
9-3:42=<9 ==&"
1
* #("J
#
" F" "
T"P %--8"B
1
7
+:2 C<9YC&9"
D
7"
#"
0"P 5
%--%"7
2 7
!
"
7
7
8-3%42+:< +<&"
*
>"%---"0
0
1
0
"0
*
0
P "%99< *
.
*
"
*
>"
"*
+&&C"0
0
21 7
1
F
'
"
0
*
0
P "+C88 *
.
*
"
*
J"%--%"7
(
2
7
" 2 0
7
%+
2
6
6
P
J "
*
" B
1
+&&%"
F
2#
6"'"
J
7
993+ %42:< <C"
*
" %--%"
.
A
1 0
"*
.
*
"
*
J"
B"%--%"7
1
'
0
"B # 0
<8- "
*
.
%---";
2P
"(
6
0
+:- "
* T" +&&&"0
7
$
7
" # #
"37
4 7
7
0
;
1
0
7
7
0
9:+ "
G
1"
1" L
+&&&"7
0
2# 0
>
"J
7
7
B
9<2 +C: +=%"
G
T"
" "E
%--%" F 7
1
A7
7
%%2 + %%"
L
F" +&&<" '
B AP
'
;
7
"
(7
37
4
;
7
' 2 (7
7
0
(7 "
L
F" +&&&">
'
2 6
7
1
7
" 2 0
(7
7
3+&&&4 #
P
"
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
&'
1
#
1
"
1
'(%
; 0 +-& T
Ω
'
τ
1
'
T
1
!
+&&"
9C<"
99- +C"
=&+ +<C-"
-:<
%9%
<9"
&--
C="
+--
%9%
%8"
=--
:"
8%=
+8"
9C=
88"
%8=
%9%
-"
-C-
-"
-8-
-"
-++
-"
%8<
%9%
98"
8-9
C:"
%C<
%-9
-"
-+&
-"
+:+
-"
99<
-"
:&C
%-9
-"
+++
-"
-98
-"
-:&
-"
%:+
%-9
-"
-8+
-"
+9-
-"
%:8
-"
<-:
%-9
-"
-&C
-"
<-9
-"
=8&
="
-<<
%-9
-"
98%
-"
9<:
-"
---
8"
:&9
%"
&<- 9:9"
---
-"
-8- 8=-"
---
%
+&&-
%
0
3
3+4
3%4#
2 !'
%
"
1
' 2 '
+&&-
'
!
'
%9% :--"
:&&
+-&
+-& T
"
'
+---
'(%
1
'
%
"
%9% +%&"
---
+%9"
--- +9"
+-- <:8"
---
%9% 989"
888
%:-"
8%=
+&"
C-9 +--%"
---
%9% 9:&"
%%-
8%:"
-==
C"
-=8 %<--"
+&C
%9%
-"
-9%
-"
-8:
-"
-98
-"
%<:
%-9
-"
-8C
-"
-8%
-"
-9-
-"
+<C
%-9
-"
-9%
-"
-C%
-"
9--
-"
-=C
%-9
-"
-+%
-"
-%C
-"
-&&
-"
+=&
%
#
)
=
3+&&8 %--+4
"
3
+&&-4
"B
* 3+&&&4"
394
"
"
'
T
"
5
384
; 0
"
"
"*
%---
<9,
%---
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
$'
;BB
%&
=
-
(
1
-"
9<8VVV
3-"
---4
F
-"
+<&
3-"
+<:4
-"
-%+
3-"
<C+4
F
+"
C+=VVV
3-"
---4
-"
+:9VVV
3-"
---4
F
-"
+&8VVV
3-"
---4
F
)4'4&$555
"4'44&%
-"
++&VVV
3-"
--+4
F
+"
-%<VVV
3-"
---4
4'$+$5
"4'46*%
4'*47555
"4'44&%
)4'&&.555
"4'44&%
-"
-%+
3-"
%:-4
-"
+9:VVV
3-"
---4
4'*+.555
"4'444%
-"
C&8VVV
3-"
--%4
-"
+<+VVV
3-"
---4
-"
-8&
3-"
%<C4
>
3
>
3
1
+-"
8+
3-"
-9=4
:"
<+
3-"
%%%4
-"
:<%VVV
3-"
---4
4
4
3<8
J
3'
4'&*&555
"4'444%
-"
-<%
3-"
%:%4
+%"
:3-"
-:%4
<"
+C
3-"
9-<4
-"
8+=+VVV
3-"
---4
-"
+%:VV
3-"
-++4
-"
C8%
3-"
%::4
+9"
++
3-"
-++4
+8"
93-"
--C4
-"
88:VVV
3-"
---4
="
8=
3-"
-<:4
-"
&=
3-"
&+94
-"
+%<V
3-"
-C%4
++"
=+
3-"
-+&4
9"
:9
3-"
8<94
-"
:%%VVV
3-"
---4
-"
<+=
4
%"
-8×+-+<
3
%"1
+"VVV
&&, VV
&:,
V
&-,"
!
;BB
!
*
"
9"#
!
>
!
"
8"1
*
3%--%4 0%=% %=9"
#%
<8
:"#
!
2 =
<8<
(( (
X9 8 W #)X+ % W P"*
Y-"
:
"
J
;BB
+%8"
&9X-"
<+=×+<8
+C-"
&<
C"
<"
%
"B
'
%+-3
+"
---"
J
";
4
%
"
'( %
"
!
$
20
03
20
01
19
99
19
97
19
95
19
93
19
91
19
89
19
87
19
85
19
79
-1
98
3
!"#
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
<
<
<
<
5 <
5 <
5 <
5 <
5
#(
,-&#.
"$%
'
'
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
)
(#
(#
(#
(#
5
5
5
& &
6
%
&
% &
78#
"$%
&#..
'
#()
"$%
9
:,
;
* )
%++
6
(%
"$%
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
SHANGAI
16291.2
× 9?87$9=5
$9==,>
×
>?@ AAA
E:F C> F:D
B C: AAA
NINGXIA
29.9789
9?87$9= @
C;
:
EF
BEIJING
TIANJIN
HEBEI
SHANDONG
GUIZHOU SHAANXI
LIAONING
GUANGXI
GUANGDON
JIANGSU
Sichuan+
GANSU ZHEJIANG
FUJIAN
GUANGDON
XINJIANG
JILIN
HUBEI
HEILONGJ
HEBEI
XINJIANG
INNER
MO
ANHUI
SHANXI
JIANGXI
HUNAN
QINGHAI
HENAN
GUANGXI
NINGXIA
SHAANXI
Sichuan+
YUNNAN
GANSU
1709.91
GUIZHOU
BEIJING
HUNAN
HENANHUBEI
YUNNAN JILIN
JIANGXI
HEILONGJ
ANHUI
QINGHAI
hainan
FUJIAN
hainan
2.42249
1.40695
85.4767
fdi_gdp
1.40695
NINGXIA
C:
E:F
:
SO2PC-FDIK/GDP
×$9==,@
;' =,>
SHANXI
85.4767
fdi_gdp
FDIK/GDP-GDPPC
29.9789
@?D AAA
F:D
SHANGAI
JIANGSU
LIAONING
SHANDONG
:
INNER MO
TIANJIN
ZHEJIANG
× 9?87$9=@
;' =,>5
SHANXI
D: A
hainan
85.4767
F:D
×A +)
@
:@
: CC AA
9?8>5
B CC AAA
GUANGDON
E:F
;
F:D
FUJIAN
TIANJIN
INNER MO
TIANJIN
SHANGAI
SHANGAI
HEBEI
GUIZHOU
SHAANXI
GUANGXI
Sichuan+
GANSU
SHANDONG
JIANGSU
LIAONING
BEIJING
JIANGSU
ZHEJIANG
GUANGDON
XINJIANG
HUNAN
HENAN HUBEI
JILIN
YUNNAN
JIANGXI
HEILONGJ
ANHUI
QINGHAI
BEIJING
GUANGXI
SHANDONG
FUJIAN
1709.91
HUBEI
SHAANXI
HUNAN
HEBEI
JIANGXI
HENAN
SHANXI
ANHUI
MO
NINGXIAINNER GUIZHOU
YUNNAN GANSU
XINJIANG
1.40695
gdppc
16291.2
.014059
SO2PC-GDPPC
(
*'
ZHEJIANG
Sichuan+
hainan
2.42249
LIAONING
JILIN
HEILONGJ
QINGHAI
envregso2
.15409
FDIK-Env Regulation
8(
8
#$
"$44&%
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
+
/0
τ
! #!
1
9?
)
2
)
# "
/"
30
?
/
!
'
&
2
#(4
'
Ω
2
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
8 #
%
4
4
4
"
7
↑
.
↑
↑
&
↑
'
GH
↓
9
&
;&!
!+
↓
6
↑
0
1
#(↑ 5
7
↓
'
∆
/2
'
∆
!"
>
@
$#%&
9(
"" #
#$
@
# , 2
"" #
@
# , 2
'
"" #
#(
:
'
#+ ./
"" #
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
%
4
4
4
"
7
%
↑ +%3%×
×+9+95 + %%5
.
↑
&
↑
↑
×
&
↓5
9
;&!
!+
< . !
'
×
<>
<
%
6
↑
×
<>
↓ +:+;×++ 5 +++:5
<
0
1
7
#(↑ 5
%
↓ 4+ 9×+9 ;5 ++<+5
'
'
↑+ :5
, &
& !!
/2
↑ +:+;×+ : 5 ++3+5
!"
>
::J @
1 ,
$#%&
<#
'
B
!
#(
. !
B J
'
5
C J5
#+ ./
;J >
# ,
:
DDJ
%&
#I
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06
!'
(
"&79*%
3+&=94
>
2
>"
"
+
6
2
'
2
*
9 9∈
K
" "
2
×
×
#
$
"
"
C