The Hives of Others: Bees Wage War across Species - Scientific American
21/01/2015 07:14
ADVERTISEMENT
OIL
SELECTIVE
SPILL
KITS
Spill Kits for oils for spills of all sizes
Subscription Center
Sign In | Register
0
Subscribe to All Access »
Subscribe to Print »
Give a Gift »
Search ScientificAmerican.com
View the Latest Issue »
Subscribe
News & Features
Topics
Blogs
Videos & Podcasts
More Science » Scientific American Volume 312, Issue 2 » Advances
Education
::
Citizen Science
Email ::
Print
SA Magazine
SA Mind
Books
SA en español
More from Scientific American
The Hives of Others: Bees
Wage War across Species
Australian stingless bees stage strikingly rare interspecies battles
See Inside
Jan 20, 2015 | By Jason G. Goldman
Jane Goodall discovered 40 years ago that
chimpanzees wage war. Until then, she
thought they were “rather nicer” than
humans. But her shocking observation of
ADVERTISEMENT
animal warfare was not the first. It was the
second. By then scientists had known for at
least 80 years that we were not the only
species to kill others of our own kind. Some
insects do it, too.
Thomas Fuchs
The Australian stingless bee Tetragonula
carbonaria is notorious for inciting war,
usually to usurp the hive of another. Instead of wasting time building their own hives,
they just steal one and redecorate. The fights between stingless bee colonies are epic in
scale, according to John Paul Cunningham of Queensland University of Technology in
Australia, with “swarms from the attacking and defending hives colliding midair and
fighting bees falling to the ground locked in a death grip from which neither
combatant survives.”
While studying such skirmishes, Cunningham and his colleagues were surprised to
find that the stingless bees were being attacked not only by other colonies of their own
species but also by colonies of a different species entirely, Tetragonula hockingsi. This
insight marks the first known description of interspecies warfare in bees—the only
other instance of this type of conflict observed throughout the animal kingdom occurs
among some ant species.
The stingless bees' aggression against others was so remarkable that the researchers
monitored approximately 260 colonies of T. carbonaria in Queensland over five years
to make sure they were not wrong. Because the bees are hard to distinguish by sight,
Cunningham's team identified instances of usurpation of one species by the other by
Latest News
Most Read
Tropical Forests Pay Price For Gold Rush
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-hives-of-others-bees-wage-war-across-species/
Page 1 of 4
The Hives of Others: Bees Wage War across Species - Scientific American
21/01/2015 07:14
assessing the structure of the hives each year when they were opened for honey
extraction. The hives of T. carbonaria are made up of well-organized cells built in a
spiral pattern. Those of T. hockingsi contain cells that look haphazardly arranged. If a
hive known to hold T. carbonaria had the structure of a T. hockingsi hive the
following year, then that was the site of a successful seizure of territory. The
researchers recorded evidence of 46 such interspecies usurpations, with victors
coming from either species in equal proportion. The findings were detailed last
December in the American Naturalist.
Attempts to Predict Terrorist Attacks Hit
Limits
Life Extension May Add Just Bad Time
Solar Plane's Route for Around-the-World
Flight Revealed
Secrets of Neandertal Cognition Revealed
Cunningham also observed the daily activities of a T. carbonaria hive over a single
winter, witnessing three major battles and collecting the dead for later genetic
analyses. By the end of the winter, the hive had been successfully commandeered by T.
hockingsi, with the invaders dragging out all remaining occupants, including larvae,
and installing a new queen.
What induces thousands of bees to go into battle and risk death? One clue comes from
the genetic analysis of the dead conducted by University of Queensland researcher
James Hereward. He found that the new queen was most likely the daughter of the
attacking hive's own queen—brought to her new home to continue the ruling species'
lineage. When the reproductive capacity of the royal class is at stake, the potential
benefits to either colony may outweigh the risks of massive casualties.
Follow Us: 

See what we're tweeting about
Scientific American Contributors
philipyam With @mcatsandoval
@ShirleyCNJ @MonetteRivera
@SovyProducer at Jeepney: @aajanewyork
@sajahq Fil-Am press club mixer
http://t.co/Y9iyX7lRUt
1 hour ago · reply · retweet · favorite
sciam New satellite may help determine
what global warming will do to Earth's
fertility. http://t.co/RCRF2bBzO2 #science
http://t.co/aA6g38cpGG
2 hours ago · reply · retweet · favorite
The trigger for a war is uncertain, Cunningham says, “especially because beekeepers
can have many hives of both species living harmoniously in close proximity.” As
Christoph Grüter of the University of Lausanne in Switzerland, who was not involved
in the work, points out, this study highlights how much is still unknown about insect
warfare and how it evolved. “The entire colony of the attacked species is wiped out,
marynmck RT @darwinsbulldog:
@David_Dobbs @eruptionsblog
@marynmck Just to share, my little project
on Tesspring right now, just a few days left:
ht…
2 hours ago · reply · retweet · favorite
and a substantial number of attackers die as well,” he explains. “It's very unusual to
have these kinds of costs among both attackers and defenders.”
More »
Solve Innovation Challenges
Long live the queen.
This article was originally published with the title "Cry “Havoc” and Let Slip the Bees of War."
Target Identification Mechanism for Bispecific
Antibodies
Deadline: Feb 06 2015
Reward: Varies
Bispecific antibodies (BsAbs) can offer advantages
over conventional monoclonal antibodies (mAbs)
because they have the potential to mod
Buy Digital Issue
Sign In
DARPA Forecasting Chikungunya Challenge
Deadline: Feb 01 2015
Reward: See Details
Subscribe
Share this Article:








Comments
Oldest - Newest
You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-hives-of-others-bees-wage-war-across-species/
DARPA(Defense Advanced Research Projects
Agency) seeks methods to accurately forecast
the spread of
More Challenges »
Powered By:
ADVERTISEMENT
Page 2 of 4
The Hives of Others: Bees Wage War across Species - Scientific American
21/01/2015 07:14
Latest from SA Blog Network
Energy in the 2015 State of the Union
Plugged In | 15 hours ago
What Rabbits and Martian Rovers Taught Me
About Scale
Frontiers for Young Minds | 15 hours ago
Visualizing a global oil price crash in three
charts
Plugged In | 16 hours ago
Dawn Approaches Ceres
Life, Unbounded | 16 hours ago
Time To Teach: Supporting Technology for
Science Education in Special Education
Classrooms
The Urban Scientist | 17 hours ago
News From Our Partners
Fukushima Worker Dies after Falling into
Water Storage Tank
Attempts to Predict Terrorist Attacks Hit
Limits
Solar Plane's Route for Around-the-World
Flight Revealed
Satellite Treats Earth as Terrarium
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Oil Selective Spill Kits
Spill Kits for oils for
spills of all sizes
Science Jobs of the Week
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-hives-of-others-bees-wage-war-across-species/
Page 3 of 4
The Hives of Others: Bees Wage War across Species - Scientific American
21/01/2015 07:14
Research Fellow (Atmospheric Chemistry)
Earth Observatory of Singapore (EOS)
Research Scientist II, Pharmacology
Vertex Pharmaceuticals
Research Scientist, PI
Suzhou Institute of Systems Medicine, Chinese Academy
of Medical Sciences
More jobs from Naturejobs.com »
Scientific American is a trademark of Scientific American, Inc., used with permission
© 2015 Scientific American, a Division of Nature America, Inc.
YES! Send me a free issue of Scientific
All Rights Reserved.
American with no obligation to continue
the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed
for the one-year subscription.
Subscribe Now
Advertise
About Scientific American
Give a Gift
Special Ad Sections
Press Room
Renew Your Print Subscription
SA Custom Media and
Partnerships
Site Map
Print Subscriber Customer
Service
Science Jobs
Partner Network
International Editions
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Use of Cookies
Buy Back Issues
FAQs
Contact Us
Travel
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-hives-of-others-bees-wage-war-across-species/
Page 4 of 4