Title: Equity Research Headline: Identifying High Yield Opportunities – 2011 Outlook The NBF Daily Bulletin Industry Comment Equity Research National Bank’s 2016 Dividend All-Stars Industry Ratings: See Appendix 1 (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) National Bank analysts collectively cover 350+ TSX-listed equities, of which roughly half offer investors income in the form of dividends or distributions. To help navigate this universe we assemble a portfolio that contains 33 of NBF’s favorite yield ideas, the basket spanning a variety of industries, sizes and liquidity, but sharing three investment criteria: 1. Dividend/distribution yield approximately 4% or greater; 2. Extremely low risk of the current payout proving unsustainable; and 3. Positive analyst bias regarding the prospects for share/unit price. Takeaways Trevor Johnson Leon Aghazarian Greg Colman Cameron Doerksen Patrick Kenny Shubha Khan Matt Kornack Endri Leno Rupert Merer Brian Milne Kyle Preston Peter Routledge Adam Shine NBF’s 2015 Dividend All-Stars portfolio introduced January 26, 2015 returned income of 6.0% and realized an average price return of -17.7% over the last twelve months, this -11.7% total return ahead of the S&P/TSX Composite’s -15.0% for the same period (2.9% income and -17.9% price return for the index). Despite recent weakness the average annual total return of NBF’s Dividend All-Stars over its four year history is 6% compared to 2% from the S&P/TSX. Sixteen of the 31 names highlighted as 2015 All-Stars (52%) outpaced the market, compared to 38% in 2014 (16/42), 71% in 2013 (27/38) and 85% in 2012 (28/33). Ten All-Stars increased dividends in 2015 (AltaGas, Bank of Montreal, CIBC, Exchange Income, First National, Gibson, Innergex, Inter Pipeline, National Bank and Premium Brands) while there were two cuts (Canadian Energy Services and Crescent Point). To date there have been 55 dividend/distribution increases versus four cuts from this portfolio. The average yield of an All-Star is elevated at 6.4%, but payout is easily funded for each, with most equities having the capacity to grow dividends/distributions over time. For investors seeking stable, predictable, elevated income and exposure to high quality companies, the following basket reflects NBF’s favourite ideas for 2016. NBF DIVIDEND ALL-STARS 2016 PORTFOLIO Share/Unit Dividend / Yield Analyst Equity Ticker Price Distribution Ag Growth International AFN-T $28.64 $2.40 Colman 8.4% American Hotels HOT.UN-T $10.11 US$0.65 Johnson 8.9% Bank of Montreal BMO-T $74.57 $3.36 4.5% Routledge Boralex BLX-T $15.03 $0.52 Merer 3.5% Chorus Aviation CHR.B-T $5.32 $0.48 9.0% Doerksen Cominar CUF.UN-T $14.57 $1.47 10.1% Kornack Crombie CRR.UN-T $13.23 $0.89 Kornack 6.7% Enbridge ENB-T $46.45 $2.12 Kenny 4.6% Enbridge Income Fund ENF-T $28.87 $1.87 Kenny 6.5% Exchange Income Corp EIF-T $23.43 $1.92 Johnson 8.2% First Capital Realty FCR-T $18.74 $0.86 Kornack 4.6% First National Financial FN-T $20.90 $1.55 Khan 7.4% High Arctic Energy Services HWO-T $3.16 $0.20 Colman 6.3% Innergex Renewable Energy INE-T $11.40 $0.62 Merer 5.4% Inter Pipeline IPL-T $22.60 $1.56 Kenny 6.9% Manitoba Telecom Services MBT-T $29.52 $1.30 Shine 4.4% MCAN Mortgage Corp MKP-T $12.14 $1.16 Khan 9.6% Milestone Apartments MST.UN-T $14.99 US$0.55 Kornack 5.4% Morneau Shepell MSI-T $14.65 $0.78 Johnson 5.3% Northland Power NPI-T $19.31 $1.08 Merer 5.6% Pembina Pipeline PPL-T $31.71 $1.83 Kenny 5.8% Pure Multi-Family RUF.U-V US$4.65 US$0.38 Johnson 8.2% Savaria Corp SIS-T $5.10 $0.20 3.9% Aghazarian Slate Retail SRT.UN-T $14.27 US$0.78 Leno 7.9% Student Transportation STB-T $4.91 $0.44 Colman 9.0% Sun Life Financial SLF-T $39.53 $1.56 3.9% Routledge Toronto Dominion TD-T $52.75 $2.04 3.9% Routledge TransAlta Renewables RNW-T $9.83 $0.88 Merer 9.0% Transcontinental TCL.A-T $18.13 $0.68 Shine 3.8% Vermillion Energy VET-T $37.72 $2.58 Preston 6.8% Whitecap Resources WCP-T $7.62 $0.45 Milne 5.9% WPT Industrial WIR-T US$9.10 US$0.76 Johnson 8.4% WSP Global WSP-T $40.13 $1.50 3.7% Aghazarian Average 6.4% Source: NBF, Reuters; Priced January 28th close Page 2 2015 Recap & 2016 Outlook The primary objective of the NBF Dividend All-Star portfolio is to provide elevated income to investors through high quality, diversified companies that our analysts view favourably. The 2016 portfolio’s average 6.4% yield is relatively high and compelling in the context of investment alternatives, but more importantly it is underpinned by stable and growing cash flows, healthy balance sheets and encouraging operating outlooks that provide confidence that the respective management teams will be increasing payout to investors over time, not decreasing. So far this is overwhelmingly the case, with ten All-Stars increasing dividends in 2015 (AltaGas, Bank of Montreal, CIBC, Exchange Income, First National, Gibson, Innergex, Inter Pipeline, National Bank and Premium Brands), building upon the eight that increased payout in 2014, 12 in 2013 and 15 in 2012. A total of 45 All-Stars have increased dividends/distributions since inception (52% of equities included), versus just four cuts, and given the collectively low forward payout ratios our analysts project we believe the 2016 basket is well-positioned to continue increasing capital returned to investors. Despite the negative returns the Dividend All-Stars still outperformed, posting a total return of -11.7% (6.0% income & -17.7% price) versus the S&P/TSX Composite’s -15% (2.9% income & -17.9% price) for the same twelve month period. H1/15 PERIOD RETURN* Equity Ticker % Price Period + = Yield Change Ag Growth International AltaGas American Hotels ARC Resources Bank of Montreal Boralex Cardinal Energy Crescent Point Crombie REIT First National Financial Gibson Energy Inergex Renewable Energy Inter Pipeline KP Tissue Milestone Apartments Morneau Shepell Mullen Group Premium Brands Pure Multi-Family Superior Plus Vermilion Energy Whitecap Resources WSP Global AFN ALA HOT.UN ARX BMO BLX CJ CPG CRR.UN FN GEI INE IPL KPT MST.UN MSI MTL PBH RUF.U SPB VET WCP WSP -14.5% -16.2% -5.0% -16.9% -7.9% 2.5% -10.3% -39.4% -8.5% -21.2% -23.9% -10.7% -21.0% -23.0% 3.8% -7.1% -8.2% 35.1% 9.9% -7.4% -24.5% -12.5% 17.6% 2.3% 2.1% 4.2% 2.7% 2.0% 2.0% 3.2% 4.5% 3.3% 3.4% 2.6% 2.6% 2.2% 2.1% 2.5% 2.3% 2.9% 2.9% 4.1% 3.0% 2.3% 3.2% 2.1% -12.2% -14.1% -0.8% -14.2% -5.8% 4.5% -7.1% -34.9% -5.2% -17.8% -21.3% -8.1% -18.7% -21.0% 6.4% -4.8% -5.3% 38.0% 14.0% -4.4% -22.2% -9.3% 19.7% Dropped Mid-Year Chemtrade Logistics Enercare MCAN Mortgage CHE.UN ECI MKP -10.5% -9.1% -22.9% 2.8% 2.7% 4.1% -7.7% -6.4% -18.8% Added Mid-Year Cdn Energy Services CIBC Dream Global REIT Exchange Income Corp National Bank CEU CM DRG.UN EIF NBF -9.7% + -5.4% + All-Stars Average S&P/TSX Composite 2.9% 1.5% = = H2/15 PERIOD RETURN** 2015 PERIOD RETURN*** Total % Price Period + = Return Change Yield Total % Price Period + = Return Change Yield Total Return -32.9% -12.9% 3.8% -7.9% 1.8% 10.4% -46.7% -27.9% 9.5% 17.5% -24.7% 2.7% -18.2% -24.7% 15.7% -6.2% -22.5% 22.6% -2.1% -6.9% -16.7% -27.8% -6.6% -6.8% -3.9% -35.5% -15.6% -0.7% -11.1% -0.4% 8.4% -50.3% -31.8% 5.9% 13.2% -28.2% -0.2% -21.1% -27.4% 13.2% -8.7% -25.7% 20.5% -5.8% -10.2% -19.7% -31.5% -8.4% 2.6% 2.7% 4.4% 3.2% 2.3% 1.9% 3.6% 3.9% 3.6% 4.3% 3.4% 2.9% 2.9% 2.7% 2.5% 2.4% 3.2% 2.1% 3.7% 3.3% 3.1% 3.7% 1.8% -44.1% -4.4% -14.5% 8.8% -15.9% 2.5% 2.5% 4.3% 4.4% 2.4% -12.2% + -13.3% + 3.1% 1.8% = = -44.9% -29.2% -5.6% -26.1% -8.3% 11.2% -55.4% -58.7% -3.1% -10.8% -45.3% -10.9% -37.6% -44.1% 17.6% -15.1% -31.8% 62.8% 3.5% -16.9% -39.4% -40.0% 7.8% 4.5% 4.4% 8.5% 5.3% 4.1% 4.0% 6.4% 6.8% 6.6% 6.7% 5.2% 5.2% 4.5% 4.1% 5.1% 4.5% 5.8% 5.7% 8.2% 6.1% 4.7% 6.5% 4.2% -40.3% -24.8% 2.8% -20.8% -4.1% 15.2% -48.9% -51.9% 3.5% -4.1% -40.1% -5.7% -33.1% -40.0% 22.6% -10.6% -26.0% 68.5% 11.7% -10.8% -34.8% -33.6% 12.0% -10.5% -9.1% -22.9% 2.8% 2.7% 4.1% -7.7% -6.4% -18.8% -41.5% -1.9% -10.2% 13.2% -13.5% -44.1% -4.4% -14.5% 8.8% -15.9% 2.5% 2.5% 4.3% 4.4% 2.4% -41.5% -1.9% -10.2% 13.2% -13.5% -9.1% -11.5% -17.7% + -17.9% + 6.0% 2.9% = = -11.7% -15.0% Source: NBF, company reports * From basket introduction January 26,2015 to July 26, 2015 ** From July 27, 2015 to January 26, 2016 *** From January 26, 2015 to January 27, 2015 Despite recent weakness the average annual total return of NBF’s Dividend All-Stars over its four year history is 6%, compared to 2% from the S&P/TSX. LEGACY NBF DIVIDEND ALL-STARS PERFORMANCE S&P/TSX Period Period Yield + Price Return = Total Return Total Return 2012 6.0% 6.8% 12.8% 3.1% 2013 5.9% 12.5% 18.4% 9.3% 2014 5.8% -1.3% 4.5% 10.6% 2015 6.0% -17.7% -11.7% -15.0% Average 5.9% 0.1% 6.0% 2.0% Source: NBF, Thomson Page 3 In recent years dividend equities have generally led the broader market, and there continues to be enthusiasm amongst investors for income. Our continued positive bias and confidence in the Dividend All-Stars product stems from: 1) Canada’s interest rate environment remains favorable, with little evidence to suggest a near-term rise in rates; 2) muted enthusiasm for Canada’s resource sector is helping contribute to favorable funds flow into diversified income equities; 3) balance sheet health for the group is collectively strong; and 4) low payout ratios support our outlook for continued dividend growth, which is one of the primary determinants of share/unit price appreciation. Our performance has been negatively impacted by overexposure to Canada’s resource sector in recent years, as a disproportionate amount of NBF’s coverage list is tied to energy. One meaningful change to this year’s basket is a rebalancing to a far lower weighting towards equities tied to the resource sector given its continued uncertainty, the 2016 portfolio breakdown outlined below. 2016 DIVIDEND ALL-STARS BY SECTOR Real Estate American Hotels Cominar Crombie First Capital Realty Milestone Apartments Pure Multi-Family Slate Retail WPT Industrial Financials Bank of Montreal First National Financial MCAN Mortgage Corp Sun Life Financial Toronto Dominion Power Boralex Innergex Renewable Northland Power TransAlta Renewables Diversified Morneau Shepell Savaria Corp Transcontinental Energy Vermillion Energy Whitecap Resources Energy Services High Arctic Infrastructure WSP Global Source: NBF Pipelines/Utilities Transportation Enbridge Chorus Aviation Enbridge Income Fund Exchange Income Inter Pipeline Student Transportation Pembina Pipeline Industrial Ag Growth International Media & Telecom Manitoba Telecom Page 4 Table of Contents Ag Growth International AFN-T American Hotels HOT.UN-T Bank of Montreal BMO-T Boralex BLX-T Chorus Aviation CHR.B-T Cominar CUF.UN-T Crombie CRR.UN-T Enbridge ENB-T Enbridge Income Fund ENF-T Exchange Income Corp EIF-T First Capital Realty FCR-T First National Financial FN-T High Arctic Energy Services HWO-T Innergex Renewable Energy INE-T Inter Pipeline IPL-T Manitoba Telecom Services MBT-T MCAN Mortgage Corp MKP-T Milestone Apartments MST.UN-T Morneau Shepell MSI-T Northland Power NPI-T Pembina Pipeline PPL-T Pure Multi-Family RUF.U-V Savaria Corp SIS-T Slate Retail SRT.UN-T Student Transportation STB-T Sun Life Financial SLF-T Toronto Dominion TD-T TransAlta Renewables RNW-T Transcontinental TCL.A-T Vermillion Energy VET-T Whitecap Resources WCP-T WPT Industrial WIR-T WSP Global WSP-T All pricing as at January 26, 2015 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 Page 5 Title: Ag Growth International Inc. - AFN (T) $53.17 Price: $53.17 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: $57.00 Headline: Domestic Grain Storage & Handling Leader with Emerging Department Theme Piece Machinery Ag Growth International Inc. $29.32 AFN (T) Sector Perform Stock Rating: $37.00 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: 34% 2016E 4.9x 3.2x 4.0x 5.0x Valuation 2014 2015E 2016E P/E 93.1x -282.8x 9.9x EV/EBITDA 6.5x 10.7x 8.7x Target EV/EBITDA 7.8x 12.3x 10.0x All amounts in Cdn$ unless otherwise noted. Dividend looks compelling with a 66% payout ratio. AFN pays a $2.40/year dividend, or ~$34 mln annually, well covered by our estimated ~$52 mln in capital available after interest ($18 mln), taxes ($6 mln) and maintenance capital ($13 mln). Sector Perform, $37.00 target. Our target is driven by a 10.0x 2016 EV/EBITDA, above the historical average of 8.7x, but below peak multiples of 10.6x. While we believe longer-term investors, who subscribe to the notion that transient weather events have again distracted investors from AFN fundamentals, may be interested in the normally premium-priced AFN at any time now, those with a trading mindset or who believe further turbulence is ahead in the upcoming quarters may hang on for an entry point closer to our trough share price estimation 1: year end debt net of cash vs. TTM EBITDA Industry Rating: Overweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Greg Colman - (416) 869-6775 [email protected] Andrew Jacklin, CFA - (416) 869-7571 [email protected] Michael Storry-Robertson – (416) 507-8007 [email protected] Westley Macdonald-Nixon - (416) 507-9568 [email protected] Stock Performance (Source: Thomson One) 500,000 $58.00 450,000 $54.00 400,000 $50.00 350,000 $46.00 300,000 $42.00 250,000 200,000 $38.00 150,000 $34.00 100,000 $30.00 50,000 $26.00 0 Jan-15 Company Profile: Ag Growth International Inc. (Ag Growth), headquartered in Winnipeg, MB, is a leading manufacturer of grain handling equipment, including grain augers, belt conveyors, aeration equipment and storage bins. Ag Growth has operations in Alberta, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Indiana, South Dakota and Finland, and distributes equipment across approximately 1,400 dealers in North America. Source: ThomsonONE, NBF Volume Price Dec-15 2015E 1.7x 6.8x Nov-15 2014 Debt/EBITDA 1 Interest Coverage Oct-15 Balance Sheet Sep-15 2016E $ 572.4 $ 88.7 $ 3.80 $ 2.40 $ 2.91 Leverage to trend down. AFN exited Q3/15 with a 1.9x debt/TTM EBITDA ratio, safely below the 3.25x covenant limit which excludes convertible debt from the calculation. We model leverage increasing to 2.3x in Q1/16 but ultimately move downwards to 1.8x exiting 2016 as stabilizing debt and modest EBITDA growth work to maintain leverage at acceptable levels. Aug-15 2015E $ 448.6 $ 70.5 $ 3.19 $ 2.40 $ (0.12) Jul-15 2014 $ 400.1 $ 78.2 $ 4.38 $ 2.40 $ 0.23 Memories of 2012? Attractive entry point draws close. In the wake of the 2012 “once-in-a-century” drought, AFN shares traded off heavily, eventually finding a bottom in November 2012 at $27.84. We estimate that where AFN is trading today, based on EV/EBITDA and dividend yield, implies shares are within ~5%-10% (~$26-$28) of a valuation implied bottom. Jun-15 Revenue (mln) EBITDA (mln) CFPS DPS EPS May-15 52-w eek High-Low $57.72 - $27.94 253,120 Average Weekly Volume Net Tangible Book Value per Share $4.51 HIGHLIGHTS Apr-15 14.3 $420.6 $323.4 $744.0 8.2% Mar-15 Shares Outstanding (mln) Market Capitalization (mln) Net Debt/(Cash) (mln) Enterprise Value (mln) Dividend Yield Estimates Domestic Grain Storage & Handling Leader with Emerging International Platform Feb-15 Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Page 6 Title: American Hotel Income Properties - HOT.UN (T) Cdn$10.05 Price: Cdn$10.05 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$12.50 Headline: Compelling Mix of Yield & Growth Department Theme Piece Real Estate American Hotel Income Properties Cdn$10.05 HOT.UN (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$12.50 Target: NBF Dividend All-Star Compelling Mix of Yield & Growth Below Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 33.4% HIGHLIGHTS Stock Data: Cash Yield 9.0% Implied Price Return 24.4% 52-w eek High-Low $11.43-$9.04 Bloomberg/Reuters: HOT-U CN / HOT.UN-T Forecasts: FYE Dec. 31 2014a Occupancy 81.4% 2015e 77.3% 2016e 77.2% $70.27 $78.43 $79.58 Revenue (US$mln) $93.1 $146.7 $183.0 EBITDA (US$mln) $24.4 $41.8 $51.1 FFO/unit (US$) $0.91 $0.94 $1.11 ADR (US$) AFFO/unit (US$) $0.83 $0.81 $0.95 Distribution/unit C$0.90 C$0.90 US$0.65 99% 83% 60% AFFO Payout Ratio 108% 96% 69% EV/EBITDA 19.3x 12.7x 10.7x P/FFO 11.0x 10.1x 8.7x P/AFFO 12.1x 10.3x 8.8x FFO Payout Ratio Financial Data: Units Outstanding (mln) Market Capitalization (mln) Cash (US$ mln) Total Debt (US$ mln) Net Debt to GBV NAV per unit 34.8 $349.8 $17.8 50% ~$12.50 Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: AHIP is a portfolio of 45 rail hotels and ~3,700 rooms, located in 22 U.S. States largely under the “Oak Tree Inn” banner. The properties are strategically located at or near rail hubs, and are almost entirely occupied by four railroads (Union Pacific, BNSF, CSX, CP) at minimum guaranteed levels. AHIP also has 35 non-rail, branded hotels totalling ~3,300 rooms across 11 U.S. states. Trevor Johnson, CFA, MBA - (416) 869-8511 [email protected] Associates: Endri Leno - (416) 869-8047 [email protected] Kyle Stanley - (416) 507-8108 [email protected] Alex Bauer - (416) 869-7535 [email protected] $292.8 Largest U.S. railway lodging operator HOT owns and operates a portfolio of 80 hotels totaling ~7,000 guestrooms, of which 45 Oak Tree Inn Hotels (3,718 guest rooms) and 31 Penny’s Dinner restaurants cater to four of the seven Class I rail operators whose employees have union mandated downtime between shifts. The average four-year remaining contract term on these hotels, encompassing ~77% of the rail portfolio guestrooms, guarantees occupancy and generates better revenue visibility than traditional hotels. Despite weakness in oil and gas related markets, HOT’s geographic diversification across 22 states should minimize any material operational impacts. Defensive portfolio attributable to diversified hotel mix 2015 saw the addition of 12 hotels to HOT’s non-rail hotel portfolio, which now consists of 35 branded hotels (Hilton, Marriott, InterContinental, etc.) totaling 3,330 guestrooms located in close proximity to transportation hubs in secondary and tertiary markets in the U.S. We believe that favourable U.S. lodging fundamentals attributable to the ongoing U.S. economic recovery and minimal new hotel supply which are forecasted to drive low to mid-single digit growth in occupancy, ADR and RevPAR through 2016 should provide a near-term tailwind for the branded hotel portfolio. Underleveraged relative to TSX hotel peers At ~50% debt to GBV HOT’s capital structure is relatively conservative with the bulk of its debt under long-term, favourable fixed rate terms that translate to cash flow visibility. Yield protected by conservative balance sheet and payout AHIP’s 9.0% cash yield is well cushioned by a 69% 2016e AFFO payout ratio and favorable operating backdrop. We use an ~11x P/AFFO to derive our $12.50 target price, reiterating an Outperform rating. Stock Performance (Source: Thompson) Page 7 Title: Great-West Lifeco Inc. - GWO (T) Cdn$22.00 Price: Cdn$22.00 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$27.00 Headline: High Dividend Yield Supported by Stable Operating Model Department Theme Piece Banking Bank of Montreal Cdn$71.69 BMO (T) Sector Perform Stock Rating: Cdn$82.00 Target: Below Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return HIGHLIGHTS 52-w eek Low -High 64.01 - 83.81 Shares Outstanding EOP (mln) 647 Market Capitalization ($mln) $50,263 S&P/TSX Composite Weighting 2.66% 2014A 2015A 2016E 2017E $6.59 $7.00 $7.42 $7.57 6% 6% 6% 2% $6.41 $6.57 $7.18 $7.38 4% 3% 9% 3% Dividend / Share $3.08 $3.24 $3.40 $3.48 F/D Avg. Shares 648 647 646 650 9.7x 9.5x Core Cash EPS % Grow th Net Inc. to Common EPS % Grow th Price / Earnings Strengthening U.S. Platform and Solid Capital Position Support Dividend Increases 19% Stock Data: (Year-End 10/31) NBF Dividend All-Star 10.9x 10.2x Core Cash Net Income $4,277 $4,529 $4,797 $4,925 NI to Equity Holders $4,277 $4,370 $4,788 $4,950 Canadian P&C 2,016 2,104 2,196 2,093 U.S. P&C 654 827 949 1,070 Wealth Management 777 845 966 1,090 Capital Markets 1,077 1,032 1,071 1,155 Corporate Services (247) (438) (394) (458) Financial Data: (As of last quarter-end) Price / Book Value 1.3x Dividend Inform ation: Quarterly Dividend Per Share $0.84 Dividend Yield 4.7% Industry Rating: Overweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Bank of Montreal is the fourth largest Canadian bank in terms of assets. BMO offers financial services in Canada and in the U.S. (using its Harris brand) through three lines of business. The Personal & Commercial Banking Group provides a full range of financial products and services to consumers and small businesses. The Private Client Group encompasses all of BMO’s wealth management operations. The Investment Banking Group (BMO Capital Markets) offers full financial services to institutional and government clients. Peter Routledge - (416) 869-7442 [email protected] Associate: Parham Fini - (416) 869-6515 [email protected] Associate: Paul Poon - (416) 507-8006 [email protected] BMO has a dividend yield of 4.7%, supported by a solid capital position and favourable relative exposure to U.S. retail banking. We expect that BMO will increase its dividend in Q3 f2016 and every four quarters thereafter. BMO announced a dividend raise of $0.02/share (3%) to $0.84/share effective in Q1 f2016. The bank’s dividend payout ratio of 45% sits in the middle of the board of directors’ target payout range of 40%-50%. We project BMO to remain in the top half of its target range owing to ongoing dividend raises. We forecast that BMO will raise dividends/share by 5% in f2016 (including the aforementioned dividend increase) and 2% in f2017. BMO maintains a solid capital position. The bank reported a Basel III common equity tier 1 (CET1) ratio of 10.7% at the end of Q4 f2015, trailing only CM amongst its Big Six bank peers. Management has expressed confidence that 10.0% - 10.5% represents an appropriate CET1 target ratio for the foreseeable future. BMO is well positioned to manage commodities risk and take advantage of U.S. economic growth. The bank has proportionally less credit exposure to the commodities sector (including oil & gas) and proportionally greater exposure to the U.S. consumer than its domestic peers. The latter upside will only be bolstered by the bank’s recently completed acquisition of General Electric Capital Corporation’s Transportation Finance business. The addition of this business should build materially on existing (macro-economic) momentum and act as a greater catalyst for growth both directly through organic growth and indirectly by broadening the reach of BMO’s U.S. commercial banking business. BMO is rated Sector Perform; price target of $82.00. As the U.S. economy continues to build momentum, with favourable implications for interest rates, we expect BMO’s U.S. retail banking platform to benefit from increased economic activity and reduced pressure on loan spreads. Our price target is 10.8x our estimated NTM EPS one year from today, a 5% premium to the average of BMO’s rated peers. Stock Performance Page 8 Title: Innergex Renewable Energy Inc. - INE (T) Cdn$9.53 Price: Cdn$9.53 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$11.25 Headline: Recent dip creates attractive entry point Department Theme Piece Independent Power Producers & Energy Traders Boralex Inc. Cdn$14.51 BLX (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$17.00 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return HIGHLIGHTS 52-w eek High-Low (Canada) $14.75 - $11.79 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada BLX CN / BLX-T (Year-End Dec 31) 2014a 2015e 2016e $ 195.2 $ 267.3 $ 318.5 adj. EBITDA (mln) $ 137.6 $ 207.7 $ 247.9 adj. EPS (diluted) $ CAFD/sh $ 0.57 Dividends/sh $ 0.52 Dividend Yield Payout Ratio (0.29) $ 3.6% 92% 0.06 $ 0.54 $ 0.74 $ 1.15 $ 0.52 $ 0.52 3.6% 3.6% 70% 45% P/ CAFD 25.6x 19.5x 12.6x adj. EV/EBITDA 15.9x 12.3x 10.2x Financial Data: Market Capitalization (mln) $ Total Debt1 (mln) $ 1,424 Price/Book Ratio 1.70x Debt/Capital Sh/O Basic (mln) 0.63x 952 64.8 Source: Thomson Financial and NBF estimates 1 Undervalued power developer; Additional 10%+ growth to CAFD/sh beyond 2017E 21% Stock Data: Revenue (mln) NBF Dividend All-Star September 30, 2015 Industry Rating: Underweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Boralex Inc. is a renewable energy producer with assets in the USA, France, and Canada. The company has over 1090 MW (net) of generation assets, mostly under long term contracts with an average contract life of ~16 years. The company is constructing 3 additional renewable projects that are expected to come on line by the end of 2017E. It continues to target the development of additional renewable generation projects in Canada and Europe and has excess capital to deploy for further growth. Stable power developer with a dividend yield of 3.6% BLX’s has a stable business model of developing & operating power assets (mostly wind and hydro) with long-term off-take contracts; its weighted average contract duration is about 16 years. BLX has about 1,100 MW in operation and following the acquisition of a 350 MW project pipeline in France, it has a development portfolio of about 850 MW with about 150 MW under construction. BLX currently pays a quarterly dividend of $0.13/sh, or $0.52/sh annually. Acquisitions could be funded from available liquidity We believe that BLX has ~$100 mln of cash and available credit to fund additional growth. With its current payout, it could generate $30-$40 mln/yr of free cash to fund growth internally for a few years (unless more growth is sourced). Additional 10% + growth to CAFD/sh beyond 2017E We estimated CAFD of $82 mln in ‘17E, up from $40 mln in 2015E. BLX had limited visibility on growth beyond 2017E, but if it can build another 150 MW/yr from its pipeline, we think it would need about $80 mln/yr in equity and could drive CAFD growth of >$10 mln/yr. If funded internally, this could drive >10%/yr in CAFD/sh growth. COP 21 could drive growth; U.S. tax credit extension To reduce global GHG emissions, the world needs more renewable power. The U.S. Congress extended tax credits (PTC/ITC) for solar and wind power that could drive growth. $17 target and OP rating; BLX continues to execute In Q4, BLX commissioned 100 MW of wind, bringing its operations to 1,100 MW. Our target is based on a DCF with an 8.5% discount rate and is equal to 11x 2016E EV/EBITDA. With its 2016E payout ratio at about 40%, dividend increases could come and visibility on growth could support a higher target. Stock Performance Daily BLX.TO 2015-01-26 - 2016-02-11 (TOR) Line, BLX.TO, 2016-01-25, 14.51-0.16, (-1.09%) Price 14.51 CAD 14 13.5 13 Rupert M. Merer, P.Eng CFA - (416) 869-8008 [email protected] Associates: Ryan Wong, P.Eng MBA – (416) 869-6763 [email protected] Steven Hong – (416) 869-7538 [email protected] 12.5 12 Vol, BLX.TO, 2016-01-25, 86,278.00 Volume 86,278.00 0 Feb Mar Apr Q1 2015 May Jun Q2 2015 Source: Reuters Jul Aug Sep Q3 2015 Oct Nov Dec Q4 2015 Jan Feb Q1 16 Page 9 Title: Chorus Aviation Inc. - CHR.B / CHR.A (T) $6.10 / $6.08 Price: $6.10 / $6.08 StockRating: Sector Perform TargetPrice: $6.25 Headline: Target and rating unchanged following in-line quarter Department Theme Piece Airlines Chorus Aviation Inc. $5.34 / $5.32 CHR.B / CHR.A (T) Sector Perform Stock Rating: $6.00 Target: NBF Dividend All-Star Attractive (and safe) 9% yield Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 21% HIGHLIGHTS Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada 52-week High-Low: CHR.b $6.77 - $4.91 52-week High-Low: CHR.a $6.77 - $4.91 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada Sustainable dividend yield of 9% Chorus Aviation’s dividend is currently a very attractive 9.0%. Importantly, because Chorus’s capacity purchase agreement guarantees a fixed fee per aircraft regardless of how much the aircraft flies, and the agreement sees highly variable cost items (such as fuel) passed through to Air Canada, we view the dividend as highly sustainable (dividend payout ratio of ~60% based on our 2015 estimate). Growing higher margin leasing revenue The $111 million annual fixed fee Air Canada pays Chorus steps down for the 2021-2025 contract period (by 42%), but the number of aircraft Chorus leases into Air Canada under the CPA (at better margin market lease rates) will increase from 21 Q400s today to 34 Q400s and 19 Dash 8-300s by 2020. Leasing revenue will increase from ~$64 million/year today to ~$105 million/year by 2020. Business development could provide upside Chorus’ recent purchase of charter operator Voyageur diversifies the company away from Air Canada and provides opportunities for growth in good margin contract flying around the world. In addition, Chorus is developing a third party leasing business that will allow it to potentially lease out 19 of its owned Dash 8-100 turboprops that are exiting the Air Canada operations. Valuation Our $6.00 target is based on 6.0x EV/EBITDAR applied to our forecast for next four quarter EBITDAR. CHR/b CN / CHR.b CHR/a CN / CHR.a (Cdn$ mln.unless otherwise noted) (FYE Dec. 31) 2014A 2015E 2016E Revenue $1,666 $1,585 $1,693 $297 $309 $341 $65 $42 $106 Adj. EPS (FD) $0.78 $0.76 $0.87 Free Cash Flow $137 Net Debt* $990 $1,251 $1,352 EBITDA / Int Exp 10.6x EBITDAR Net Income ($61) $26 13.0x 13.2x EV / EBITDAR 6.1x 5.9x 5.3x P/E 6.8x 7.0x 6.2x *Includes off balance sheet operating leases Other Data: Shares Outstanding (mln) Market Capitalization (mln) Net Debt (mln) (incl. leases) Net Debt-to-Cap. (incl. leases) Enterprise Value (mln) 122 $653 $1,165 54% $1,817 Dividend per share $0.48 Dividend yield 9.0% Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Chorus Aviation is the largest regional airline and the second largest airline in Canada based on fleet size and number of routes operated. Chorus and Air Canada are parties to a capacity purchase agreement under which Air Canada purchases Chorus’s capacity based on predetermined rates. Cameron Doerksen, CFA - (514) 879-2579 [email protected] Associate: Umayr Allem, CFA, MBA - (416) 869-8577 [email protected] Stock Performance Page 10 Title: Artis REIT - AX.UN (T) Cdn $xx Price: Cdn $xx TargetPrice: Cdn $18.00 Headline: A Good Choice for Extra Yield Department Theme Piece Real Estate Cominar REIT Cdn$14.20 CUF.UN (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$18.75 Target: Below Average Risk Rating: 42.4% Stock Data: 52-w eek Low $13.70 52-w eek High $19.97 Bloomberg/Reuters: (Year-End Dec. 31) 13A 14A 15E 16E 17E $1.77 $1.85 $1.80 $1.81 $1.87 AFFO $1.49 $1.57 $1.54 $1.55 $1.61 % change (FFO) 4.4% -2.5% 0.4% 3.4% 8.0x 7.7x 7.9x 7.9x 7.6x 9.6x 9.0x 9.2x 9.2x 8.8x Targe t Multiples Target / FFO 10.6x 10.2x 10.4x 10.4x 10.0x Target / AFFO 12.6x 11.9x 12.1x 12.1x 11.6x $1.44 $1.46 $1.47 $1.47 $1.47 P / AFFO Distribution HIGHLIGHTS Attractive Distribution Yield: Cominar offers investors an attractive 10.4% yield when compared with the large Diversified and Office REITs at 7.8% and 8.2%, respectively. Looking at AFFO yield, which adjusts for differences in payout ratios, CUF also offers a premium to both its diversified and office peers. Geographic Exposure: Amid the weakness seen in W. Canada, Cominar provides investors a portfolio that is largely insulated from these risks (AB is only ~5% of NOI). The majority of its portfolio is located in Quebec (>75% of NOI) which should provide downside protection on the back of stable economic and property market fundamentals. Strong Internal Management Team: Michel Dallaire and his team have been a part of the internal management of Cominar since it went public in 1998 and are the continuation of a family legacy in the Quebec real estate market since Cominar’s founding in 1965 by Jules Dallaire. As the largest commercial property owner in the province, it has a thorough understanding of the market dynamics, leasing environment and is the go-to REIT for off-market transactions. While Cominar is actively pursuing a targeted cross-Canada diversification strategy in order to complement its Quebec exposure, we view its concentration and expertise in the province as a competitive advantage not easily replicated in other public entities. Valuation Discount: Cominar currently trades at a discount to its large diversified peers, trading at 9.1x our 2016 AFFO vs. the diversified and office comps at 10.6x and 13.4x, respectively. CUF sold off significantly in 2015 and has come close to trough 08/09 multiples. As one of the largest diversified REITs with a strong internal management team and balance sheet, we view the current correction as overdone. Through unit buybacks, asset sales and leasing at Target we expect a return to FFO/unit growth in late 2016 and de-leveraging. CUF-U / CUF.un FFO Curre nt Multiple s P / FFO Price Decline Presents Value Opportunity Given Central Canada Focussed Portfolio AFFO Payout 97% 93% 95% 95% 91% Tax Deferral 75% 82% 82% 82% 82% Financial Data: Units Outstanding (mln) - Diluted for ITM Options 169.8 Market Capitalization (mln) $2,411 Net debt (including convertible debt & cash from options, mln) $4,492 Enterprise Value (mln) $6,903 Debt / Total Assets (current) 54% Debt / Total Assets (including convertible debt, current) 54% Net Asset Value (NAV) / Cap rate $18.65 / 6.60% Debt / Market Value of Assets (using NAV, excl' converts) 58% Debt / Market Value of Assets (using NAV, incl' converts) 58% Premium to NAV -23.9% Current Distribution (annualized) $1.47 Current Distribution yield (annualized) 10.4% M ajo r Unitho lders (mln) (as per Tho mso n One, 26-Jan-16) Units % Ivanhoe Cambridge 13.2 7.8% CIBC Asset Management 10.5 6.2% Dallaire Family (incl' units held through AM Investments) 8.3 4.9% Sources: NBF, Thomson One, OSC Bullet in Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Stock Performance $20.00 9.0 $19.50 8.0 $19.00 $18.50 7.0 $18.00 6.0 $17.50 Unit Price ($) Company Profile: Cominar is the largest commercial property owner in the Province of Quebec and one of the largest diversified REITs in Canada. CUF owns a real estate portfolio of 564 properties consisting of office, retail and industrial / mixed-use buildings totalling ~45 million sq. ft. in Quebec, Ontario, Western and Atlantic Canada. The REIT is led by Michel Dallaire, one of Quebec’s foremost entrepreneurs with a long track record of creating wealth through various real estate cycles. Matt Kornack - (416) 507-8104 [email protected] $17.00 5.0 $16.50 4.0 $16.00 $15.50 Associate: Dawoon Chung - (416) 507-8102 [email protected] Associate: Ammar Shah - (416) 869-7476 [email protected] 3.0 $15.00 2.0 $14.50 $14.00 1.0 $13.50 $13.00 Jan-14 Source: Bloomberg Apr-14 Jul-14 Oct-14 Jan-15 Apr-15 Jul-15 Oct-15 0.0 Jan-16 Trading Volume (Millions) Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Page 11 Title: Artis REIT - AX.UN (T) Cdn $xx Price: Cdn $xx TargetPrice: Cdn $18.00 Headline: A Good Choice for Extra Yield Department Theme Piece Real Estate Crombie REIT Cdn$13.08 CRR.UN (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$14.75 Target: Below Average Risk Rating: Defensive Name with Internal Growth Opportunities and Intensification Potential 19.6% Stock Data: 52-w eek Low $12.26 52-w eek High $13.79 Bloomberg/Reuters: (Year-End Dec. 31) HIGHLIGHTS Attractive Yield: Crombie offers an attractive yield of 6.8% vs. 5.3% for its large-cap retail comparables (REI.un, FCR, CHP.un, SRU.un & CRT.un). Adjusting for differences in payout ratios, the REIT’s AFFO yield still trades at an attractive ~100 bps premium to this same peer group. Defensive Structure & Diversification: CRR has one of the longest weighted average terms to maturity on leases in the Canadian public retail REIT universe at 11.3 years. Likewise, its weighted average debt maturity is 7.1 years. The REIT’s portfolio of defensive grocery and drug store anchored retail plazas jives well with its conservative structure. Transformational Safeway Acquisition: Through the Canada Safeway portfolio acquisition, Crombie enhanced geographic diversification, and increased its exposure to high growth urban centres such as Vancouver, Calgary, and Edmonton. The acquired portfolio also contains development / intensification opportunities for the REIT to pursue with Sobeys on a 50/50 JV basis. Development Pipeline: With 10 redevelopment projects in progress and an additional 14 major developments available (with a total estimated cost of $1-2 billion) Crombie is well positioned to grow through adding density to its existing properties by expanding its retail and multi-family GLA. Attractive Valuation: We continue to view Crombie as an attractive investment opportunity in the current slow growth, low interest rate environment as its long-term leases provide for stable / contractual income with upside potential through development in W. Canada. CRR is trading at 13.6x 2016 AFFO vs. its large-cap peers at 15.5x and we believe our Target of 14.7x is reasonable in the context of the comps. CRR-U / CRR.un 13A 14A 15E 16E 17E FFO $1.10 $1.10 $1.12 $1.14 $1.19 AFFO $0.90 $0.91 $0.93 $0.97 $1.01 % change (FFO) 0.3% 1.5% 2.6% 3.6% Current Multiples P / FFO P / AFFO 11.5x 11.4x 11.3x 11.0x 10.6x 13.9x 13.8x 13.5x 13.0x 12.5x Target Multiples Target / FFO 13.5x 13.4x 13.2x 12.9x 12.4x Target / AFFO 16.3x 16.2x 15.9x 15.3x 14.7x $0.89 $0.89 $0.89 $0.89 $0.89 Distribution AFFO Payout 99% 98% 96% 92% 88% Tax Deferral 90% 64% 64% 64% 64% Units Outstanding (mln) 131.3 Market Capitalization (mln) $1,647 Net debt (including convertible debt, mln) $2,181 Enterprise Value (mln) $3,828 Debt / GBV (current - IFRS FV) 50% Debt / GBV (including conv., current - IFRS FV) 53% Net Asset Value (NAV) / Cap rate $14.80 / 6.25% Debt / Market Value of Assets (using NAV, excl' converts) 49% Debt / Market Value of Assets (using NAV, incl' converts) 52% Premium to NAV (Current) -15.2% Current Distribution (annualized) $0.89 Current Distribution yield (annualized) 7.1% Major Unitholders(mln)(as per ThomsonOne & SEDI) Empire Company Limited 54.6 41.6% RBC Global Asset Management 4.6 3.5% Units % IA Clarington Investments 2.9 2.2% Black Rock Asset Management 2.6 2.0% So urces: NB F, Thomson One, OSC Bulletin Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Matt Kornack - (416) 507-8104 [email protected] Associate: Dawoon Chung - (416) 507-8102 [email protected] Associate: Ammar Shah - (416) 869-7476 [email protected] Stock Performance Unit Price ($) Company Profile: Crombie REIT was formed in March 2006 when Empire Company Limited transferred 44 of its commercial properties into the REIT. Crombie’s portfolio consists primarily of defensive grocery-anchored retail plus a small office and mixed-use component. In total the REIT currently has 256 properties (17.4 million sq. ft.), located in ten provinces. Sobeys is the REIT’s largest tenant. $14.00 3.0 $13.67 2.5 $13.33 2.0 $13.00 1.5 $12.67 1.0 $12.33 0.5 $12.00 Jan-14 Source: Bloomberg Apr-14 Jul-14 Oct-14 Jan-15 Apr-15 Jul-15 Oct-15 0.0 Jan-16 Trading Volume (Millions) Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Page 12 Title: Pembina Pipeline Corp. - PPL / PBA (T/N) $38.03 / US$34.32 Price: $38.03 / StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$45.00 Headline: NBF Dividend All-Star Department Theme Piece Pipelines, Utilities & Energy Infrastructure Enbridge Inc. $44.98 / US$31.55 ENB (T / N) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$59.00 Target: 35.9% Low-teens dividend growth through 2019e On the dividend front, we forecast 14% annual dividend growth through 2019e – underpinned by ~$17 bln of commercially secured projects entering service through 2019e. Post 2019e, we call for 3% annual dividend growth supported by ‘tilted return’ profiles embedded within certain projects. Valuation and rating Our $59.00 target is based on a risk-adjusted dividend yield of 4.0% applied to our 2017e dividend of $2.42/sh, a 16.25x multiple of our 2017e Free-EBITDA of $6.4 bln, and our DCF valuation of $57.50/sh. We currently rate ENB an Outperform. 10.2x $2.12 3.1% 4.6% $2.42 5.4% Adj. Payout Ratio 55% 52% 55% D/EBITDA 7.7x 7.5x 7.1x Financial Data: Shares Outstanding (mln) 866.7 Market Capitalization (mln) 38,983 Net Debt (mln) Enterprise Value (mln) Total Debt/Enterprise Value Total Return 55,555 $94,538 59% 35.9% Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Enbridge Inc. holds energy infrastructure assets within the following business segments: Liquids (55%), Gas Distribution (25%), Sponsored Investments (15%), and Gas Pipelines (5%). The Enbridge System, the Company's Mainline System which represents 60% of the Liquids segment, has a capacity of ~2.5 mmbpd, transporting various grades of crude oil and diluted bitum en from Western Canada to the Chicago area and Eastern Canada. The Company also owns a 50% interest in the Alliance Pipeline, transporting approximately 1.6 bcf/d of natural gas from Western Canada to the Chicago area. Patrick Kenny, CFA – 403-290-5451 [email protected] Associate: Michael Nguyen – 416-869-7566 [email protected] Stock Performance Vol. (mln) Enbridge Inc. $72 12.0 $60 10.0 $48 8.0 $36 6.0 $24 4.0 $12 2.0 $0 0.0 Source: Bloomberg Jan-16 $1.86 Dividend Yield Jan-15 11.2x 20.4x $4.40 Jan-14 17.4x 21.5x $4.12 14.7x $2.20 Jan-13 Dividend per Share 28.8x $3.43 15.5x $2.13 Jan-12 P/AFFO 18.7x $2.07 Jan-11 $850 $6,420 Jan-10 $850 $5,805 Jan-09 $725 $5,090 AFFO/sh (Basic) Counterparty risk ~2/3 of ENB’s cash flows are supported by contracts with Supermajors / Integrates – i.e., well positioned to weather the commodity price downturn and perhaps benefit from cheap Canadian refinery feedstock flowing down ENB’s pipelines. Combined with the rate regulated gas distribution business and long-term PPAs, less than 20% of ENB’s business is exposed to material counterparty risk (namely Bakken oil producers, Texas gas producers). 2017e $7,270 Jan-08 2016e $6,655 Jan-07 2015e $5,815 Free-EBITDA (mln) P/E ENB US / ENB Maint. Capex (mln) EPS (Basic) Highlighting cash flow quality ~75% of ENB’s cash flows are generated by cost-of-service / take-or-pay agreements, with ~20% from fee-based contracts, and just 5% from margin-based or commodity-based operations. Of note, we classify the 2.85 mmbpd Mainline (~20% of EBITDA) as half cost-of-service, half fee-based given the provision with the CTS (Competitive Toll Settlement) to revert back to cost-of-service should volumes decline to 1.35 mmbpd (currently ~2.4 mmbpd). Overall, we calculate a weighted average contract duration of ~15-yrs on ENB’s assets. Jan-06 Bloomberg/Reuters: U.S. EV/Free-EBITDA ENB CT / ENB.TO Jan-05 $54.42 - $33.42 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada Jan-04 52-week High-Low (U.S.) HIGHLIGHTS Jan-03 $66.14 - $44.56 Jan-02 52-week High-Low (Canada) Jan-01 Stock Data: Jan-00 Est. Total Return EBITDA (mln) 14% annual dividend growth through 2019e Above Average Risk Rating: (Year-End Dec.31) NBF Dividend All-Star Page 13 Title: Pembina Pipeline Corp. - PPL / PBA (T/N) $38.03 / US$34.32 Price: $38.03 / StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$45.00 Headline: NBF Dividend All-Star Department Theme Piece Pipelines, Utilities & Energy Infrastructure Enbridge Income Fund $26.78 ENF (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$35.00 Target: 37.6% AFFO/sh (FD) 8.4x 14.2x 13.6x $2.64 $2.59 $2.69 P/AFFO 15.3x 10.5x 10.0x Dividend per Share $1.59 $1.85 $2.04 Dividend Yield 3.9% 6.8% 7.6% Adj. Payout Ratio D/Free-EBITDA 77% 12.6x 71% 6.2x 75% 5.8x Counterparty risk ~70% of ENF’s cash flows are underpinned by Supermajors / Integrateds or downstream refiners – i.e., well positioned to weather the downturn in commodity prices and remain heavily reliant on the Enbridge Mainline for base load transportation requirements. The ~20% of cash flows generated by the “regular E&P sector” and/or other midstream companies is further mitigated by letters of credit / security received. Meanwhile, the Power PPAs are all backed by high creditworthy utility counterparties. Long-term dividend growth of 10% On the dividend front, we forecast 10% annual dividend growth through 2019e. Valuation and rating Our $35.00 target is based on a risk-adjusted dividend yield of 5.75% applied to our 2017e dividend of $2.04/sh, a 15.5x multiple of our 2017e Free-EBITDA of $2.7 bln, and our DCF valuation of $35.25/sh. We currently rate ENF an Outperform. Financial Data: Shares Outstanding (mln) 785.8 Market Capitalization (mln) 21,044 Net Debt (mln) Enterprise Value (mln) Net Debt/Enterprise Value Total Return 16,042 $37,086 43% 37.6% Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Created in 2003, Enbridge Incom e Fund's asset base includes: Canadian portion of the Mainline, Regional Oil Sands System in Alberta, Southern Lights Canada and Class A units in Southern Lights U.S., the Saskatchewan and Bakken System, Line 7-11, Hardisty storage, the Alliance Pipeline, and Canadian Renewable assets. . Patrick Kenny, CFA – 403-290-5451 [email protected] Associate: Michael Nguyen – 416-869-7566 [email protected] Stock Performance Vol. (mln) Enbridge Income Fund $50 1.0 $40 0.8 $30 0.6 $20 0.4 $10 0.2 $0 0.0 Source: Bloomberg Jun-15 EV/Free-EBITDA Jun-14 $2,722 Jun-13 $150 $2,430 Jun-12 $150 $1,115 Jun-11 $72 Free-EBITDA (mln) Jun-10 Maint. Capex (mln) Jun-09 2017e $2,872 Highlighting cash flow quality ENF’s cash flows are ~60% cost-of-service / take-or-pay and 40% fee-based. Of note, we classify the fixed-fee Mainline (~55% of EBITDA) as half cost-of-service, half fee-based – given a provision within the CTS (Competitive Toll Settlement) under which Enbridge can revert back to the cost-of-service model should volumes decline to 1.35 mmbpd (from current levels of ~2.4 mmbpd). Although the CTS expires in mid-2021, the pipeline remains ~20% oversubscribed (i.e., clearly baseload export capacity for the WCSB’s ~3.9 mmbpd of production). Overall, we calculate a weighted average contract duration of ~16 years on ENF’s assets. Jun-08 2016e $2,580 Jun-07 2015e $1,186 HIGHLIGHTS Jun-06 $44.93 - $27.49 ENF.TO Jun-05 52-week High-Low (Canada) Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada Jun-04 Stock Data: Jun-03 Est. Total Return EBITDA (mln) 10% annual dividend growth through 2019e Above Average Risk Rating: (Year-End December 31) NBF Dividend All-Star Page 14 Title: Exchange Income Corporation - EIF (T) Cdn$27.72 Price: Cdn$27.72 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$32.00 Headline: NBF Dividend All-Star Department Theme Piece Airlines Exchange Income Corporation Cdn$23.22 EIF (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$31.00 Target: NBF Dividend All-Star Diversified Model Paying Dividends Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 41.8% HIGHLIGHTS Stock Data: Cash Yield 8.3% Implied Price Return 33.5% 52-week High-Low Bloomberg/Reuters: $28.73 - $20.01 EIF CN / EIF.TO Forecasts: Dec. 31 YE 2014a 2015a 2016e Revenue $542.5 $784.5 $859.4 EBITDA $94.3 $178.6 $186.4 EPS (basic) $0.66 $1.48 $1.26 DCPS (basic) $1.59 $2.90 $2.80 Dividend $1.69 $1.80 $1.92 Payout Ratio (basic) 106% 62% 69% DC Yield 6.8% 12.5% 12.0% EV/EBITDA 12.0x 6.4x 6.1x P/DCPS 14.6x 8.0x 8.3x P/E 35.2x 15.7x 18.4x Financial Data: Shares Outstanding (mln) Market Capitalization (mln) Net Debt (mln) Enterprise Value (mln) 23.1 $536.4 $495.8 $1,032.2 Net Debt to Capitalization 48% Net Debt (incl converts) to 2016e EBITDA 2.7x Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Exchange Income Corporation is a diversified, acquisition-oriented company currently focused on specialty aviation, specialty manufacturing and specialty communication towers. Trevor Johnson, CFA, MBA - 416-869-8511 [email protected] Associates: Endri Leno - (416) 869-8047 [email protected] Kyle Stanley - (416) 507-8108 [email protected] Alex Bauer - (416) 869-7535 [email protected] Positive track record of acquisition growth Exchange Income Corporation is a diversified, acquisition-oriented company focused on specialty aviation and specialty manufacturing. Exchange uses disciplined acquisition criteria and targets cash flow rich businesses that can generate an immediate return for shareholders. Aviation set to continue robust momentum The outlook for EIF’s aviation portfolio remains promising, this segment performing the best we have seen and further poised to take advantage of lower fuel prices, significant prior fleet/infrastructure investments and incremental contributions from Provincial Aerospace (PAL). The manufacturing portfolio is collectively underperforming, but its relatively small contribution (<10% of run-rate EBITDA), incremental gains from the LTM acquisition of Ben Machine Products and favorable FX helps to mitigate western Canadian headwinds. Complementary acquisitions expected to persist The company has achieved a robust acquisition pace in 2015, purchasing PAL in Q1/15 and Ben Machine in Q3/15 for a combined total of ~$294 mln. Given the deep pipeline of opportunities, we expect EIF to continue growing accretively by way of acquisition, currently equipped with ~$300 mln in dry powder and leverage a manageable 2.7x net debt / 2016e EBITDA. Attractive yield opportunity EIF’s 8.3% cash yield is attractive relative to its 69% 2016e payout, one of the best combinations in the TSX diversified yield universe. We rate EIF shares Outperform with a price target of $31, implying~7x and ~8x 2016e EV/EBITDA and P/DCPS, respectively. Stock Performance (Source: Reuters) Page 15 Title: Artis REIT - AX.UN (T) Cdn $xx Price: Cdn $xx TargetPrice: Cdn $18.00 Headline: A Good Choice for Extra Yield Department Theme Piece Real Estate First Capital Realty Cdn$18.24 FCR (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$20.50 Target: Below Average Risk Rating: Defensive Name with Urban Redevelopment Upside 17.1% Stock Data: 52-w eek Low $17.09 52-w eek High $20.25 Bloomberg/ThomsonOne HIGHLIGHTS Best-in-class Portfolio of Non-discretionary Retailer Focused Shopping Centres: FCR owns a portfolio of retail properties in primarily urban markets with a defensive tenant base that is less sensitive to economic cycles. The company purchases properties in locations with strong demographic and leasing fundamentals and high barriers to entry. Furthermore, First Capital’s portfolio is geographically diverse, allowing it to spread its exposure to the various economic drivers in each of Canada’s metropolitan areas, and it has a strong covenant tenant base. Solid Balance Sheet and Advantageous Investment Grade Pricing: First Capital’s balance sheet affords equity investors significant protection in the form of low relative leverage levels and a higher percentage of unsecured financing. An impressive 68.2% of First Capital’s over $7.9 billion in total assets are unencumbered, which allows the company greater flexibility. As the highest rated Canadian publicly-traded real estate entity (BBB(h) from DBRS and Baa2 from Moody’s) FCR has access to some of the most competitively priced unsecured debt. Management is intent on improving this rating through earnings growth and increasing the pool of unencumbered assets while terming out the company’s debt maturity profile. Building an Irreplaceable Real Estate Portfolio in Prime Downtown: First Capital is in the process of building out a pipeline of development and intensification projects on its existing property sites and land bought specifically for development. These properties offer some of the finest retail locations in Canada and command higher rents and quality tenants. FCR has made material progress on its major development projects such as Yorkville Village (93% leased) and Mount Royal Village which saw enough pre-leasing activity to justify construction commencement. In addition, First Capital is actively seeking various strategic opportunities through incremental site density – we anticipate potential JV projects or sales of land / air rights. FCR (Year-End Dec. 31) 13A 14A 15E 16E 17E FFO $1.03 $1.04 $1.04 $1.09 $1.13 AFFO $0.91 $0.94 $0.96 $1.00 $1.04 % change (FFO) 0.5% 0.7% 4.4% 4.1% Current M ultiples P / FFO 17.7x 17.6x 17.5x 16.7x 16.1x P / AFFO 20.1x 19.4x 19.0x 18.3x 17.5x Target Multiples Target / FFO 19.9x 19.8x 19.6x 18.8x 18.1x Target / AFFO 22.6x 21.8x 21.4x 20.5x 19.7x $0.84 $0.85 $0.86 $0.86 $0.86 Dividend AFFO Payout 92% 90% 90% 86% 83% Financial Data: Basic Shares Outstanding (mln - diluted for ITM options) 228.1 Market Capitalization (mln) $4,160 Net debt (mln) $3,758 Enterprise value (mln) $7,919 Debt / Total Assets (current - excl. converts) 42% Debt / Total Assets (current - incl. converts) 46% Net Asset Value (NAV) / Cap Rate $19.10 / 5.70% Debt / Market Value of Assets (using NAV - excl. converts) 41% Debt / Market Value of Assets (using NAV - incl. converts) 45% Premium to NAV -4.5% Current Dividend (annualized) $0.86 Current Dividend yield (annualized) M ajo r Shareholders (mln) (as per ThomsonOne & SEDI) Shares 4.7% % 41.7% Gazit-Globe Ltd. 95.1 Alony-Hetz Properties & Investments Ltd. 14.0 6.1% RBC Global Asset Management 8.1 3.6% Source: NBF, Thomson One & Bloomberg Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Associate: Dawoon Chung - (416) 507-8102 [email protected] Associate: Ammar Shah - (416) 869-7476 [email protected] Stock Performance Unit Price ($) Company Profile: First Capital Realty (FCR) owns and manages a portfolio of well-located, supermarket and drugstore-anchored neighbourhood and community shopping centres. FCR’s portfolio is primarily located in Canada’s largest urban areas including the GTA, Calgary and Montreal along with a growing presence in Vancouver. The majority of the company’s revenues are derived from leases with tenants offering basic necessities including supermarkets, drugstores, banks, liquor stores and fast food outlets. Matt Kornack - (416) 507-8104 [email protected] $20.50 9.0 $20.00 8.0 $19.50 7.0 $19.00 6.0 $18.50 5.0 $18.00 4.0 $17.50 3.0 $17.00 2.0 $16.50 1.0 $16.00 Jan-14 Source: Bloomberg Apr-14 Jul-14 Oct-14 Jan-15 Apr-15 Jul-15 Oct-15 0.0 Jan-16 Trading Volume (Millions) Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Page 16 Title: First National Financial Corp. - FN (T) Cdn$22.32 Price: Cdn$22.32 StockRating: Sector Perform TargetPrice: Cdn$24.00 Headline: Yield Adequately Compensates for Housing Market Risks Department Theme Piece Diversified Financials First National Financial Corp. Cdn$19.91 FN (T) Sector Perform Stock Rating: Cdn$21.00 Target: Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 52-w eek Low -High $16.00 - $23.00 Shares Outstanding (millions) Market Capitalization (millions) Core EPS Y/Y Growth Yield Adequately Compensates for Housing Market Risks 13.3% Stock Data: Year-End 12/31 NBF Dividend All-Star 60.0 HIGHLIGHTS One of Canada’s largest non-bank mortgage companies First National Financial Corporation ranks as one of Canada’s largest originators, underwriters and servicers of residential mortgages. The company originated over $17 billion of mortgages in the 12 months to September 2015, and currently services a portfolio of $93 billion in mortgages. Impact of slowing housing activity could be dampened FN has seen rapid growth over the years, with mortgages under administration growing at an average annual rate of 17% from 2006 to Q3 2015. The rapid growth of the portfolio in recent years has resulted in strong earnings growth. Earnings proved resilient even through the most recent financial crisis, buoyed by the strong demand for low-risk, government-insured MBS backed by prime residential mortgages. Housing concerns do not put dividend at risk Despite mounting concerns about burgeoning household credit levels in Canada and the possibility of a sharp correction in home prices, we believe FN has an adequate cushion to maintain its dividend. For one, the company earns a steady stream of fee income from mortgages under administration. In addition, FN has little need to retain earnings. $1,194 2014A 2015E 2016E 2017E $2.04 $2.34 $2.52 $2.86 (9.1%) 14.7% 7.9% 13.5% Price / Earnings 9.8x 8.5x 7.9x 7.0x Revenue $368 $412 $485 $523 Expenses $228 $265 $271 $281 Net Income $100 $104 $153 $173 Less: Non-Core Income $25 $39 $0 $0 Core Net Income $125 $142 $153 $173 Book Value Per Share $5.90 $6.00 $7.00 $8.22 Financial Data: (Quarter-End 9/30/2015) Book Value per Share $5.73 Price/Book Value 3.47x Distribution/Dividend Information: Dividend/Share (Quarterly) Payout Ratio Yield $0.388 81.2% 7.8% Yield adequately compensates for housing market risks We use a target P/E multiple on blended 2016/2016 EPS of 7.5x to reflect housing market concerns that have weighed on valuation for all mortgage-related stocks. However, we believe the 7.8% yield adequately compensates for housing market risks. Stock Performance Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: First National Financial Corporation is an originator, underwriter and servicer of mainly prime single-family and multi-unit residential mortgages, as well as commercial mortgages. First National is Canada’s largest non-bank originator and underwriter of mortgages with over $90 billion in mortgages under administration. Shubha Khan - (416) 869- 6425 [email protected] Associate: Jaeme Gloyn, CFA - (416) 869-8042 [email protected] Q4 AheTitle: High Arctic Energy Services Inc. - HWO (T) $2.18 Price: $2.18 StockRating: Outperform Page 17 TargetPrice: Cdn$3.00 Headline: PNG Operations Continue to Grow; HWO Remains the Best Department Theme Piece Oil and Gas Services High Arctic Energy Services Inc. $3.08 HWO (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$5.50 Target: 85% n/a n/a 2015E 2016E 6.3x 2.3x 4.5x 7.3x 1.9x 4.0x All amounts in Cdn$ unless otherwise noted. Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: High Arctic Energy Services Inc. (“HWO” or “High Arctic”) is Canada’s largest provider of snubbing services in addition to being one of the most active providers of drilling and workover services in Papua New Guinea (“PNG”). The business model employed by HWO in PNG has led to returns on capital that are among the highest in our energy services universe. Since taking over during the heart of the financial crisis in 2009, current management has shown to be prudent operators, resulting in impressive cash flow generation over this period. Greg Colman - (416) 869-6775 [email protected] Andrew Jacklin, CFA – (416) 869-7571 [email protected] Michael Storry-Robertson – (416) 507-8007 [email protected] Westley MacDonald-Nixon - (416) 507-9568 [email protected] Pristine balance sheet supports OP rating & $5.50 target With an estimated net cash position of ~$28 mln at the exit of 2015, HWO is an ideal position to weather the current commodity market conditions. At 1.7x 2016e EV/EBITDA, HWO’s valuation is the lowest of the mid cap drilling peers, below High Arctic’s post-2009 average of 3.0x and a 66% discount to the peer average of 5.0x. Our $5.50 target is driven by 4.0x 2016e EV/EBITDA. Outperform. Stock Performance $4.60 1.4 $4.40 1.2 $4.20 1.0 $4.00 0.8 $3.80 0.6 $3.60 0.4 $3.40 $3.20 0.2 $3.00 0.0 Source: Thomson ONE, NBF Volume (mm) 2016E n/a n/a Dec-15 5.7x 2.7x 5.5x 2015E Nov-15 2014 Attractive dividend with sustainable 18% payout ratio The annual dividend of $0.20/sh (yielding ~6% based on the current price) results in a relatively low 18% payout ratio (after maintenance capital expenditures). We thereby believe HWO can continue to increase dividends and model $0.28/sh in 2016 (for an implied yield of ~9% based on the current price and a manageable payout ratio of 32%). Oct-15 Valuation 223.2 63.3 1.00 0.28 0.42 Sep-15 -0.8x n/a 2016E $ $ $ $ $ Aug-15 2014 Debt/EBITDA Interest Coverage 218.0 60.3 0.84 0.20 0.49 Jul-15 Balance Sheet 2015E $ $ $ $ $ Revenue and EBITDA expected to increase in 2016 y/y High Arctic is the only company in our energy services space that we forecast to increase both revenue and EBITDA sequentially in 2015 and 2016. Our 2016 estimate calls for EBITDA of $63.3 mln in in 2016 (up from $60.3 mln in 2015 and $49.3 mln in 2014) vs. consensus of $69.3 mln. Jun-15 171.8 49.3 0.82 0.18 0.54 May-15 2014 $ $ $ $ $ We like HWO’s defensive positioning through the downturn… High Arctic benefits from a largely contracted revenue stream from operations in Papua New Guinea, where HWO derives approximately 90% of annual revenue. We believe HWO can continue to offer investors shelter from the downtrodden commodity price market as we expect rig utilization levels in PNG to remain flat in 2016 relative to 2015 and 2014. Jan-15 Estim ates $4.34 - $3.02 355,220 $3.50 Price 52-w eek High-Low Average Weekly Volume Net Tangible Book Value per Share HIGHLIGHTS Apr-15 54.9 $169.1 -$12.5 $156.6 6.4% Mar-15 Shares Outstanding (mm) Market Capitalization (mm) Net Debt (mm) 1 Enterprise Value (mm) Dividend Yield Feb-15 Est. Total Return P/E (x) EV/EBITDA (x) Target EV/EBITDA Defensive Driller with Durable Dividend Above Average Risk Rating: Revenue (mm) EBITDA (mm) CFPS DPS EPS NBF Dividend All-Star Page 18 Title: Innergex Renewable Energy Inc. - INE (T) Cdn$9.53 Price: Cdn$9.53 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$11.25 Headline: Recent dip creates attractive entry point Department Theme Piece Independent Power Producers & Energy Traders Innergex Renewable Energy Inc. Cdn$10.64 INE (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$14.00 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Hydro assets with steady growth should provide certainty in uncertain times 37% Stock Data: 22-Jan-16 52-w eek High-Low (Canada) $12.36 - $9.51 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada INE CN / INE-T (Year-End De c 31) 2014a 2015e 2016e Revenue (mln) $ 241.8 $ 248.7 $ 301.6 adj. EBITDA (mln) $ 171.2 $ 180.6 $ 216.9 adj. EPS (diluted) $ 0.16 $ 0.15 $ 0.46 CAFD/sh $ 0.69 $ 0.70 $ 0.90 Dividends/sh $ 0.60 $ 0.62 $ 0.62 Dividend Yield 5.7% 5.9% 5.9% Payout Ratio 88% 88% 69% P/ CAFD 15.3x 14.9x 11.7x adj. EV/EBITDA 13.0x 13.4x 12.4x HIGHLIGHTS Financial Data: Market Capitalization (mln) $ 1,083 Total Debt1 (mln) $ 2,239 Net Debt/Capital 0.80x Sh/O Basic 1 (mln) FD Outstanding1 (mln) 103.0 103.2 Source: Thomson Financial and NBF estimates 1 September 30, 2015 Industry Rating: Underweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Innergex is one of Canada’s largest Independent Power Producers with a pure-play focus on renewable power. The company operates 1215 MW (net 708 MW) of renewable projects (34) mostly under long term power purchase agreements (PPA) with an average remaining life of close to 20 years. It has wind, hydro and solar assets and operates in Quebec, Ontario, B.C. and Idaho. Innergex also has 297 MW (net 186 MW) of new projects with PPAs with construction planned over the next two years and has a pipeline of more than 3 GW of future opportunities. Stable business model with relatively low risk INE consists mainly of hydro assets which typically have the longest asset life among renewables. It also has the longest weighted average life remaining on its PPA contracts compared to its peers, at >18 years. As a developer of projects, INE can achieve attractive IRRs (typically in the 9-19% range) and use operational expertise to reduce capital costs. Combined with hedged FX and fixed interest rate costs on non-recourse debt, INE reduces its risk profile dramatically. Growth continues to materialize With ~300 MW of gross installed capacity under construction and a strong development pipeline, INE has a runway of projects that will contribute to growth. In addition, INE recently signed a memorandum of understanding with the Federal Electricity Commission of Mexico to jointly develop hydro projects and expand its international presence. INE tends to acquire and aggregate smaller scale projects (10-30 MW range) which they can typically purchase at lower prices. Sustainable dividend and NCIB INE currently has a ~6% dividend yield and with a payout ratio target of 80%, they remain prudent with cash. As projects come on line, investors should see dividend increases over the coming 12 months. They also have an NCIB in place and are approved to buyback up to 2 million common shares. Valuation and Rating Our target assumes an 8.5% equity discount rate and is equal to 11.9x EV/EBITDA on 2017E. INE’s projects under construction should largely be completed by the end of 2016E, supporting an increase in adj. EBITDA by >60% for 2017E and payout ratios below INE’s 80% target. We have currently assigned INE an Outperform rating. Stock Performance Rupert M. Merer, P.Eng CFA - (416) 869-8008 [email protected] Ryan Wong, P.Eng MBA - (416) 869-6763 ryan.wong @nbc.ca Steven Hong - (416) 869-7538 [email protected] Source: Reuters Page 19 Title: Inter Pipeline Ltd. - IPL (T) Cdn$26.37 Price: Cdn$26.37 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$31.00 Headline: NBF Dividend All-Star Department Theme Piece Pipelines, Utilities & Energy Infrastructure Inter Pipeline Ltd. Cdn$20.61 IPL (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$28.00 Target: 43.4% EV/Free-EBITDA 19.3x 15.0x 14.6x AFFO/sh (FD) $1.99 $2.09 $2.16 P/AFFO 18.0x 9.8x 9.6x Dividend per Share $1.48 $1.56 $1.65 Dividend Yield 4.1% 7.6% 8.0% Adj. Payout Ratio 74% 74% 77% D/EBITDA 5.4x 5.1x 4.8x Counterparty risk 76% of IPL’s cash flows are supported by Supermajors / Integrates – mainly within the oil sands segment but also ~60% on the Bow River conventional pipeline system. Elsewhere, NOVA and DOW Chemical represent strong counterparties within the NGL Extraction segment, contributing another 5% to IPL’s consolidated cash flows. As such, we estimate 19% of IPL’s cash flows are exposed to material counterparty risk. 6% annual dividend growth through 2018e On the dividend front, we forecast two more dividend increases of 6% per year for 2017 and 2018 – i.e., until the company’s payout ratio reaches 80%. Valuation and rating Our $28.00 target is based on a risk-adjusted dividend yield of 6.0% applied to our 2017e dividend of $1.65/sh, a 15.0x multiple of our 2017e Free-EBITDA of $940 mln, and our discounted cash flow valuation of $27.00/sh. We currently rate IPL an Outperform. Financial Data: Shares Outstanding (mln) 336.5 Market Capitalization (mln) $8,388 Net Debt (mln) Enterprise Value (mln) Net Debt/Enterprise Value Total Return $5,317 $13,705 39% 43.4% Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Patrick Kenny, CFA – 403-290-5451 [email protected] Associate: Michael Nguyen – 416-869-7566 [email protected] Stock Performance Vol. (mln) Inter Pipeline Ltd. $40 2.5 $32 2.0 $24 1.5 $16 1.0 $8 0.5 $0 0.0 Jan-00 Company Profile: Inter Pipeline Limited has four lines of business. The pipeline business has both conventional and oil sands assets. In July 2004; Inter Pipeline acquired three natural gas processing plants from Williams Canada Inc. for $715 million that now make up its NGL extraction business, and in October 2005, Inter Pipeline completed its acquisition of Simon Storage Limited, a petroleum and petrochemical storage business in the United Kingdom for £120 million British Pounds or $250 million. . Source: Bloomberg Jan-16 $940 Jan-15 $915 Jan-14 $863 Jan-13 $50 Free-EBITDA (mln) Jan-12 $60 Jan-11 $55 Jan-10 $990 Maint. Capex (mln) Jan-09 2017e $975 Jan-08 2016e $918 Highlighting cash flow quality IPL’s cash flows are 63% underpinned by cost-of-service / take-or-pay contracts that bear no commodity or volume risk. Meanwhile, 33% of cash flows are fee-based (volume risk), while just 4% is exposed to commodity and volume risk (NGL frac). That said, the majority of IPL’s cost-of-service / take-or-pay cash flows are long-term contracts (~20-yrs) on its oil sands pipeline system, which services long-life projects with sunk capital. Furthermore, despite the potential for volume decline across IPL’s fee-based business we note IPL’s ability to bump up tolls to partially mitigate the impact to margins. Overall, we calculate a weighted average contract duration of ~13 years on IPL’s assets. Jan-07 2015e Jan-06 IPL CT / IPL.TO Jan-05 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada HIGHLIGHTS Jan-04 $36.12 - $21.23 Jan-03 52-week High-Low (Canada) Jan-02 Stock Data: Jan-01 Est. Total Return EBITDA (mln) 6% annual dividend growth through 2018e Above Average Risk Rating: (Year-End December 31) NBF Dividend All-Star Page 20 Title: Thomson Reuters Corporation - TRI/TRI (T;N) $28.06;US$28.20 Price: StockRating: Sector Perform TargetPrice: Cdn$30.00 Headline: Q3 Revs/EBITDA Miss, EPS Helped By Tax Resolutions, Q4 Net Sales Department Theme Piece Telecom Services Manitoba Telecom Services Inc. $29.70 MBT (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$32.00 Target: Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return HIGHLIGHTS 52-w eek High-Low (Canada) $30.60 - $23.13 52-w eek High-Low (U.S.) NA Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada MBT / MBT-T Bloomberg/Reuters: U.S. Revenue (mln) Following Allstream Sale Attention Turns To Use Of Proceeds & MTS’ Transformation Plan 12.1% Stock Data: (FYE De c. 31) NBF Dividend All-Star NA 2014a 2015e* 2016e $1,003 $1,600 $1,008 EBITDA (mln) $566 $458 $467 Adjusted EPS $1.70 $1.06 $1.26 P/E 23.6x 17.5x 27.9x EV/EBITDA* 5.6x 5.8x 5.8x EV/EBITDA** 6.5x 7.1x 7.3x FCF/Share*** $1.96 $2.05 $2.12 FCF Yield 6.6% 6.9% 7.1% *Estimates are ex-Allstream; 2015e EV/EBITDA is P F **EV/EBITDA adjusted fo r deferred wireless costs ***Ex-spend on wireless spectrum & voluntary pensio n payments Financial Data (as at Septem ber 30, 2015): Shares Outstanding (mln) 78.8 Float (mln) Market Capitalization (mln) 79.2 $2,340 Net Debt as per B/S (mln) $874 Common Shareholders' Equity (mln) $1,207 Net Debt to Capital 31.3% Leverage (Net Debt to EBITDA) BVPS / Price/Book 1.6x $15.23/2.0x Dividend $1.30 Dividend Yield 4.4% Industry Rating (Telecom Services): Underweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Manitoba Telecom Services is one of Canada's leading national communications providers. MTS is the incumbent communications provider for residential and business customers across Manitoba offering wireless, voice, broadband, TV, and home security services. On Nov. 23, 2015, MTS announced the sale of Allstream, a national communications provider serving business customers with voice, data & security services, which closed Jan. 15, 2016. Allstream sale yielded net proceeds of $420 million. After being deemed non-core and undergoing further restructuring in 2015, Allstream was successfully sold to U.S.-based Zayo in a deal which closed on Jan. 15. MTS will keep obligations for retired/deferred employees of Allstream, but also keeps most of the tax shield (NPV of $275 million). Use of Allstream proceeds to be disclosed on Feb. 4. Along with its 4Q15 results, MTS will disclose how it will allocate the Allstream proceeds after reviewing its options which include the retirement of debt incurred to fund its pension funding pre-payment & spectrum purchases in 2015. MTS 3-year transformation plan launched with 3 phases. Following the reporting of its 3Q15 results which produced lower than expected profits and subscriber metrics, the company noted that it’s now turned its attention to MTS with a newly-established Transformation Management Office tasked with a 3-year plan to unlock $100 million in FCF (same level of costs to be incurred), as it streamlines processes, improves customer service, refreshes the brand & rejuvenates growth. Regulatory hurdles to be overcome for future MTS sale. It’s long been anticipated that any sale of Allstream sets a timer on a possible sale of MTS, quite possibly at some point during the course of its transformation program. Regulations related to Wireless and the prior government’s desire to have four players in each market serve as obstacles to be overcome, but we don’t think these make a sale impossible. MTS is rated Outperform, target $32. Our target is based on the average of the 2016E metric in our DCF and 2017E value in our NAV, with implied EV/EBITDA of 7.6x 2016E and 7.1x 2017E including Wireless COA. On May 7, 2015, the dividend was cut 23.5% to its current $1.30 level. Stock Performance (Source: Thomson Reuters) Daily MBT.TO 1/26/2015 - 2/11/2016 (TOR) Price CAD 29.70 29.5 29 28.5 28 27.5 27 26.5 26 25.5 Adam Shine, CFA - 514-879-2302 [email protected] 25 24.5 24 Associates: Luc Troiani, CFA - 416-869-6585 [email protected] Piotr (Peter) Stusio, CFA - 514-879-2564 [email protected] 23.5 23 Volume 1M 550,653.00 0 02 17 02 16 Q1 2015 01 16 01 19 01 Q2 2015 16 02 16 04 17 01 16 Q3 2015 01 16 02 16 01 Q4 2015 16 04 18 01 Q1 2016 Page 21 Title: MCAN Mortgage Corporation - MKP (T) Cdn$13.59 Price: Cdn$13.59 StockRating: Sector Perform TargetPrice: Cdn$16.00 Headline: Healthy Returns in Mortgage Investments Department Theme Piece Diversified Financials MCAN Mortgage Corporation Cdn$11.79 MKP (T) Sector Perform Stock Rating: Cdn$12.50 Target: NBF Dividend All-Star Healthy Returns in Mortgage Investments Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 15.9% Stock Data: 52-w eek Low -High $10.40 - $14.20 Shares Outstanding (millions) 22.8 Market Capitalization ($ millions) $269 Year-End 12/31 2014A 2015E 2016E 2017E Core EPS $1.22 $1.23 $1.23 $1.44 Y/Y Growth (15.2%) 1.0% (0.0%) 16.6% Price / Earnings 9.7x 9.6x 9.6x 8.2x Net Investment Income $37.2 $43.2 $43.4 $51.2 Other Income $2.7 $0.1 $0.0 $0.0 Operating Expenses ($13.4) ($13.9) ($15.3) ($16.6) Pre -Tax Incom e $26.5 $29.3 $28.1 $34.6 Income Tax Provision ($1.0) $0.5 $0.0 $0.0 Net Incom e $25.4 $29.8 $28.1 $34.6 Adjustments ($0.3) ($3.0) $0.0 $0.0 Core Ne t Incom e $25.2 $26.8 $28.1 $34.6 Book Value Per Share $10.83 $11.18 $11.25 $11.60 Financial Data: (Quarter-End 09/30/2015) Book Value per share Price/Book Value HIGHLIGHTS One of Canada’s most attractive MICs MKP qualifies on an ongoing basis as a Mortgage Investment Corporation (MIC) under terms specified in the Income Tax Act of Canada. As such, all dividends paid to shareholders are fully tax deductible. Consequently, the company distributes substantially all of its earnings to shareholders. Among the best-positioned MICs in Canada In our view, MKP is among the MICs best positioned to generate the highest risk-adjusted returns. Unlike other MICs, MKP can exploit its status as a deposit-taking institution to generate leveraged returns. We regard CDIC-insured deposits as a low-cost, stable and reliable source of funding. Abundance of investment opportunities in Alt-A market MKP continues to invest in uninsured Alt-A residential mortgages, a segment in which there continues to be abundant lending opportunities, particularly since the introduction of stricter mortgage underwriting rules in 2012. Securitization mortgages up 96% y/y through Q3 2015 MKP recommenced securitizing insured mortgages in 2014. These mortgages do not affect MKP’s Income Tax Assets-to-Capital Multiple. As such, they generate revenue for MKP, but do not constrain lending capacity. $11.19 1.05x Dividend Inform ation: Dividends/Share (NTM) Payout Ratio (NTM) Dividend Yield (NTM) $1.16 100.0% 9.8% Capital: Tier 1 Ratio Income Tax Assets to Capital Multiple (ACM) 25.2% 4.89x Generating attractive risk-adjusted return We believe the projected dividend yield of 9.8% (vs. the average yield of 8.2% for other publicly-traded MICs and ~5% for other mortgage market comparables) is attractive, particularly in view of MKP's low balance sheet risk relative to peers. We use a target P/BV multiple of 1.1x Q3 2016 BV. Stock Performance Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: MCAN Mortgage Corporation (MKP) qualifies on an ongoing basis as a Mortgage Investment Corporation (MIC), whereby all dividends paid to shareholders are fully tax deductible. Consequently, the company distributes substantially all of its earnings to shareholders. As a MIC, the company is able to invest in a wide variety of real estate-related loans, but primarily residential mortgages and residential construction loans. These investments are funded by term deposits eligible for CDIC insurance, as well as shareholders’ equity. Shubha Khan - (416) 869- 6425 [email protected] Associate: Jaeme Gloyn, CFA - (416) 869-8042 [email protected] Page 22 Title: Artis REIT - AX.UN (T) Cdn $xx Price: Cdn $xx TargetPrice: Cdn $18.00 Headline: A Good Choice for Extra Yield Department Theme Piece Real Estate Milestone Apartments REIT Cdn$15.00 MST.UN (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$19.50 Target: Average Risk Rating: 35.3% Stock Data: 52-w eek Low $12.39 52-w eek High $16.03 Bloomberg/Reuters: (Year-End Dec. 31) 13A(1) 14A 15E 16E Relative Valuation & Supportive Financial Metrics: On a currency adjusted basis Milestone now trades at in excess of a 27% discount to NAV and a ~10x AFFO multiple. From a leverage standpoint MST’s debt levels remain reasonable at a ~53% Debt / Total Assets and after taking into account currency appreciation the AFFO payout ratio is in the low 50% range – allowing for future distribution increases. Interest Rate & Currency Environment: Global growth concerns have driven government bond yields (even in the US, which is expected to be one of the few better performing outliers) to all time lows – providing support for valuations as lower risk free return hurdles are incorporated into cap rates. This while apartment rental fundamentals continue to drive top-line expansion. Meanwhile the Canadian Dollar has continued to slide relative to the US due to the divergence in central bankers’ stance on monetary policies. US Investors Continue to Have Confidence in Domestic Multi-Family Issuers Driving Price Appreciation: While Milestone had a positive year, performance wise, in 2015 as one of the leading TSX REITs from a total return perspective, most of this growth could be attributed to currency appreciation. Since September 2013 US comps have seen ~76% appreciation in values while MST was up 53% in spite of a relatively similar expected growth in AFFO/unit. Positive Operating Performance May Slow but Likely Still Better than Canada: Despite the concerns surrounding fundamentals in energy-related markets particularly in Houston, MST’s properties from that region posted SP Rent of +5.9% in Q3 2015. We continue to expect that B&C properties will see higher rent and occupancy growth than A class apartments as they are less sensitive to new supply and are supported by job growth and lower homeownership rates in the US. 17E US$0.98 US$0.99 US$1.07 US$1.16 US$1.25 AFFO per Unit US$0.75 US$0.80 US$0.90 US$0.98 US$1.07 Grow th (FFO per Unit) 1.4% 8.4% 8.1% Current Multiples (Converted at Current Spot FX Rate) P / FFO 10.4x 10.2x 9.4x 7.8% 8.7x 8.1x 11.3x 10.3x 9.5x Target Multiples (Converted at Curre nt Spot FX Rate) P / FFO 13.9x 13.7x 12.7x 11.7x 10.9x 13.8x 12.7x 13.5x 12.7x P / AFFO 18.0x 17.0x Distribution C$0.65 C$0.65 AFFO Payout (No Conversion) Tax Deferral HIGHLIGHTS MST-U / MST.un FFO per Unit P / AFFO Ongoing Solid Performance + M&A Activity to Provide Economies of Scale 15.1x C$0.65 US$0.55 US$0.55 86% 82% 72% 56% 51% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% Financial Data: Units Outstanding 75.8 Market Capitalization C$1,104 Net Debt C$1,717 Enterprise Value C$2,821 Debt / Total Assets (Current - Incl. Converts) 52% Debt / Total Assets (Current - Excl. Converts) 52% Net Asset Value ("NAV") / Cap Rate US$13.85 / 6.35% Premium to NAV (Incl. FX Impact @ Spot) -26.9% Debt / Market Value (Using NAV, Incl. Converts) 53% Current Distribution (Annualized PF Announced Increase) C$0.79 Current Distribution Yield (Annualized) 5.4% Units Major Unitholders (mln) MileSouth 11.8 % 15.6% MST Investors 5.5 7.3% 1832 Asset Management 5.3 7.0% Sources: Company Prospectus & Report s, Thomson One 1) Normalized f or a f ull year of operations Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Matt Kornack - (416) 507-8104 [email protected] Associate: Dawoon Chung - (416) 507-8102 [email protected] Associate: Ammar Shah - (416) 869-7476 [email protected] Stock Performance Price ($ / Unit) Company Profile: Milestone Apartments REIT is a multi-family residential property owner focused on investing in garden-style properties in the Southern U.S. The REIT was created on January 17, 2013 and went public via an IPO on the TSX. Milestone currently owns (PF transactions announced) 72 properties with 22,546 units – the REIT also manages additional units, which provide fee income in the near term and a longer-term acquisition pipeline. $16.50 2,000 $15.70 1,800 $14.90 1,600 $14.10 1,400 $13.30 1,200 $12.50 1,000 $11.70 800 $10.90 600 $10.10 400 $9.30 200 $8.50 24-Jan-14 24-Apr-14 Source: Bloomberg 23-Jul-14 21-Oct-14 19-Jan-15 19-Apr-15 18-Jul-15 16-Oct-15 0 14-Jan-16 Volum e (000s) Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Page 23 Title: Morneau Shepell Inc. - MS I (T) Cdn$14.65 Price: Cdn$14.65 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$19.00 Headline: Organic Growth Remains Encouraging; Profitability Challenged Department Theme Piece Commercial Services & Supplies Morneau Shepell Inc. Cdn$14.65 MSI (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$19.00 Target: Below Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Recurring Revenue Model Ideal for Yield Predictability 35.0% HIGHLIGHTS Stock Data: Cash Yield 5.3% Implied Price Return 29.7% 52-week High-Low Bloomberg/Reuters: $18.18-$13.35 MSI CN / MSI.TO Forecasts: FYE Dec. 31 2014a 2015e 2016e Revenue (mln) $535.9 $561.3 $624.9 EBITDA (mln) $98.9 $105.1 $119.0 DCPS $0.92 $1.06 $1.03 Dividend $0.78 $0.78 $0.78 Payout Ratio 84% 74% 76% DC Yield 6.3% 7.2% 7.0% EV/EBITDA 10.1x 9.7x 8.6x P/DCPS 15.8x 13.8x 14.2x Financial Data: Shares Outstanding (mln) 48.0 Market Capitalization (mln) $704 Net Debt (mln) Enterprise Value (mln) Net Debt to Capitalization $327 $1,031 32% Net Debt to TTM EBITDA 3.2x Net Debt to TTM EBITDA ex-converts 2.5x Industry Rating: Underweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Morneau Shepell Inc. is the largest Canadian-owned provider of human resource consulting and outsourcing services. The firm delivers solutions to assist employers in managing the financial security, health and productivity of staff. With almost 4,000 employees in offices across North America, Morneau Shepell offers its services to over 20,000 organizations. Largest domestic HR consulting firm MSI has grown to become the largest Canadian provider of human resources consulting and pension/benefit services, offerings that are increasingly sought after by firms given: 1) ongoing regulations and complexities associated with accounting/reporting standards and employee assistance programs (i.e., Obamacare health insurance exchanges); and 2) an increased emphasis on employee well-being and morale, given the resulting positive effects on productivity and profitability shown to be realized. Recurring revenue base and high cash flow stability The average client relationship exceeds 20 years, with 96-99% of revenue typically recurring each year. Once MSI wins a mandate it is well positioned to maintain the business, as its service is generally considered excellent and it takes a lot of time and effort to transition to a new partner for most offerings provided. As a result MSI’s margins and cash flows have shown to be amongst the more stable and predictable within the TSX diversified yield universe. Solid track record of organic top-line growth MSI has achieved positive y/y organic revenue gains the last 21 quarters, and we expect mid-single digit growth to persist 2016+. The company continues to win large new domestic mandates, gain traction in the US, and we believe there is still cross-selling upside from the marriage of Morneau & Shepell. Balance sheet manageable MSI has a net debt to TTM EBITDA ratio of 3.2x (2.5x excluding converts) which is higher than diversified yield peers, but not unreasonable given the relative stability of MSI’s operations. Defensive yield with cushion MSI’s 5.3% cash yield is well supported by the defensive, recurring nature of its offering and a 76% 2016e payout ratio. We rate MSI shares Outperform with a price target of $19, implying ~10x 2016e EV/EBITDA & ~18x P/DCPS. Stock Performance (Source: Reuters) 17.00 16.00 15.00 Trevor Johnson, CFA, MBA - (416) 869-8511 [email protected] Associates: Endri Leno - (416) 869-8047 [email protected] Kyle Stanley - (416) 507-8108 [email protected] Alex Bauer - (416) 869-7535 [email protected] 14.00 600,000 300,000 0 Feb Mar Q1 2015 Apr May Jun Q2 2015 Jul Aug Sep Q3 2015 Oct Nov Dec Q4 2015 Jan Page 24 itle: Innerg ex Renewable Energy Inc. - INE (T) Cdn$9.53 Price: Cdn$9.53 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$11.25 Headline: Recent dip creates attractive entry point Department Theme Piece Independent Power Producers & Energy Traders Northland Power Inc. Cdn$18.41 NPI (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$21.00 Target: Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 22-Jan-16 52-w eek High-Low $19.20 - $14.45 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada (Year-End Dec 31) NPI CN / NPI-T 2014a 2015e 2016e Revenue (mln) $ 760 $ 736 $ 784 adj. EBITDA (mln) $ 363 $ 402 $ 422 maint capex (mln) $ 2 $ 2 $ EV/EBITDA 19.8x 23.3x $ 1,048 $ 2,263 $ 3,610 11.9x 11.1x $ P/ CAFD 1.13 $ 16.1x Dividends/sh 2 16.1x adj EV/EBITDA CAFD/sh $ Dividend Yield 1.08 1.08 11.0x $ 16.9x $ 1.08 5.9% 5.9% Payout Ratio 95% 100% Debt /EBITDA 6.9x 8.6x 1.13 16.2x $ 1.08 5.9% 96% 11.5x Financial Data: Market Capitalization (mln) $ 3,099 Total Debt1 (mln) $ 3,679 Net Debt/Capital Sh/O Basic 1 (mln) 1 FD Outstanding (mln) 0.8x 170.1 170.1 Source: Thomson Financial and NBF estimates 1 NPI has taken the road less traveled with offshore wind, but it’s paying dividends 20% Stock Data: Construction assets NBF Dividend All-Star September 30, 2015 Industry Rating: Underweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Northland Power holds an economic interest of 1,345 MW in natural gas-fired and renewable power generation. The company has an active growth pipeline, including a net interest of 642 MW in two offshore wind farms in Europe that are targeting commercial operations in late 2017E. HIGHLIGHTS Diversity and locked-in cash flow support dividend NPI has a range of assets across geographies (Canada and Europe) and segments (thermal, wind and solar) to diversify risk. With more than 1,300 MW of installed capacity and 98% of revenues tied to long term PPA contracts, we believe NPI has predictable cash flows and a sustainable dividend. It has a weighted average life of ~14 years remaining on its PPAs. NPI stands out from the crowd with offshore wind Unlike many of its peers who have aggregated smaller conventional projects, NPI ventured into offshore wind with its Gemini and Nordsee One projects, with combined net capacity of 642 MW. Once considered risky, offshore wind has significantly matured with experienced contractors and improved business practices. NPI has signed long term PPA contracts with credit worthy off-takers and retained high quality partners to de-risk the projects. It also has O&M contracts which lock-in a large portion of the operating costs. With expected COD in the H2 2017E, NPI could double EBITDA in 2018E and drop its payout ratio to below 50%. This may present an opportunity for NPI to increase its dividend. Additional growth not far away Besides its two offshore wind farms, NPI has another 100 MW of gross installed capacity under construction and more than 2 GW of development projects in the pipeline. There are also expansion opportunities in the offshore wind segment with Nordsee Two and Three. Valuation and Rating Our target is based on a DCF with an 8.5% discount rate and an 8.7x adj EV/EBITDA on 2018E. We believe that as NPI’s offshore projects are further de-risked, the stock should benefit. We rate NPI an Outperform. Stock Performance Rupert M. Merer, P.Eng CFA - (416) 869-8008 [email protected] Associates: Ryan Wong, P.Eng MBA – (416) 869-6763 [email protected] Steven Hong – (416) 869-7538 [email protected] Source: Reuters Page 25 Title: Pembina Pipeline Corp. - PPL / PBA (T/N) $38.03 / US$34.32 Price: $38.03 / StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$45.00 Headline: NBF Dividend All-Star Department Theme Piece Pipelines, Utilities & Energy Infrastructure Pembina Pipeline Corp. $29.38 / US$20.60 PPL / PBA (T/N) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$38.00 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: 35.7% Improving cash flow quality with take-or-pay commitments By 2018e (pro forma secured growth), PPL’s cash flows will be ~50% cost-of-service / take-or-pay, with the majority of its conventional pipeline system contracts recently converted to long-term commitments, combined with the 100% take-or-pay Redwater fractionation II & III expansions, as well as legacy oil sands pipelines. Meanwhile, 33% of cash flows are fee-based and largely comprised of Montney-based gas processing and NGL Infrastructure services – leaving 17% of cash flows driven by margin-based activities and just 2% from commodity-based activities. Overall, we calculate a weighted average contract duration of ~7 years on PPL’s assets. Counterparty risk We estimate ~40% of PPL’s cash flows are supported by Supermajors / Integrateds – well positioned to weather the downturn. Meanwhile, as a barometer for the ~35% of cash flows supported by the “regular E&P sector”, of the 42 customers signed up for the 420 mpbd, $2.4 bln Phase III conventional pipeline system expansion, ~90% of shippers recently confirmed their take-or-pay nominations, with the other ~10% remaining committed, but with delayed volumes. Long-term dividend growth of ~10% On the dividend front, we forecast a 5% dividend increase for mid-2016e, moving up to 10% increases for mid-2017e and mid-2018, while maintaining a long-term AFFO payout ratio of ~75%. Valuation and rating Our $38.00 target is based on a risk-adjusted dividend yield of 5.25% applied to our 2017e dividend of $2.02/sh, a 16.0x multiple of our 2017e Free-EBITDA of $1.3 bln, and our DCF valuation of $37.00/sh. We currently rate PPL an Outperform. PBA CT / PBA 19.2x 14.9x 13.7x AFFO/sh (FD) $2.26 $2.14 $2.54 P/AFFO 18.7x 14.1x 11.6x Dividend per Share $1.79 $1.88 $2.02 Dividend Yield 4.2% 6.2% Adj. Payout Ratio 78% 86% 6.9% 79% D/EBITDA 4.4x 5.3x 4.7x Financial Data: Shares Outstanding (mln) 385.4 Market Capitalization (mln) 11,322 Net Debt (mln) Enterprise Value (mln) Net Debt/Enterprise Value Total Return 6,293 $17,616 36% 35.7% Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Pembina directly or indirectly owns interests in several oil and NGLs pipeline systems and a 50% interest in an ethylene storage facility. Pembina has four lines of business - conventional toll pipelines, oil sands pipelines, gas services and the midstream business. The conventional toll pipelines transport crude oil and NGLs volumes for a toll rate, while the oil sands pipelines earn a rate of return on capital invested. Patrick Kenny, CFA – 403-290-5451 [email protected] Associate: Michael Nguyen – 416-869-7566 [email protected] Stock Performance Vol. (mln) Pembina Pipeline $60 2.5 $48 2.0 $36 1.5 $24 1.0 $12 0.5 $0 0.0 Source: Bloomberg Jan-16 EV/Free-EBITDA Jan-15 $1,289 Jan-14 $0 $1,069 Jan-13 $0 $942 Jan-12 $0 Free-EBITDA (mln) Jan-11 Maint. Capex (mln) Jan-10 $1,289 Jan-09 2017e $1,069 Jan-08 2016e $942 Jan-07 2015e Jan-06 Bloomberg/Reuters: U.S. EBITDA (mln) PPL CT / PPL.TO Jan-05 $37.21 - $22.95 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada Jan-04 52-week High-Low (U.S.) HIGHLIGHTS Jan-03 $43.66 - $30.51 Jan-02 52-week High-Low (Canada) Jan-01 Stock Data: (Year-End December 31) One stop midstream shop, with dividend growth intact! Jan-00 Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Page 26 Title: Pure Multi-Family REIT - RUF.U (V) US$4.70 Price: US$4.70 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: US$6.00 Headline: Portfolio Fundamentals Support Elevated Yield Department Theme Piece Real Estate Pure Multi-Family REIT US$4.70 RUF.U (V) Outperform Stock Rating: Target: US$6.00 Risk Rating: Average Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Portfolio Fundamentals Support Elevated Yield 35.7% HIGHLIGHTS Stock Data Cash Yield 8.0% Implied Price Return 27.7% 52-week High-Low US$5.70 - US$4.27 Bloomberg/Reuters: RUF/U.CN / RUFu.V Forecasts (US$): FYE Dec 31 2014a 2015e 2016e Revenue $48.1 $58.6 $80.1 EBITDA $25.5 $32.3 $45.5 FFO / Class A Unit $0.46 $0.45 $0.53 AFFO / Class A Unit $0.43 $0.43 $0.49 Distribution $0.38 $0.38 $0.38 FFO Payout 82.8% 84.4% 68.9% AFFO Payout 89.8% 89.6% 73.8% EV/EBITDA 21.2x 15.4x 15.7x P/FFO 10.1x 10.4x 8.9x P/AFFO 11.0x 11.0x 9.5x Financial Data (US$): Class A Units Outstanding (mln) 49.1 Market Capitalization (mln) $230.7 Net Debt (mln) $308.3 Net Debt to GBV 57% Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Pure Multi-Family REIT is a Canadian-based, publicly traded multi-family investment trust offering investors USD denominated exposure to real estate in the southwestern United States. Pure currently owns 15 multi-unit properties throughout Texas and one interest in Arizona, seeking to expand its asset base through accretive acquisitions of high quality multi-unit properties in the Sunbelt region. Trevor Johnson, CFA, MBA - (416) 869-8511 [email protected] Associates: Endri Leno - (416) 869-8047 [email protected] Kyle Stanley - (416) 507-8108 [email protected] Alex Bauer - (416) 869-7535 [email protected] Exclusively US Sunbelt multi residential portfolio RUF owns and operates a portfolio of 14 properties (16 following closing of TPC portfolio) that comprise ~4,700 units, ~267 buildings, ~253 acres of land and ~4.2 mln of rentable square feet located throughout Texas and one property in Arizona as of Q3/15. RUF’s portfolio is well positioned to capture the ongoing U.S. economic recovery, which has generally been more pronounced in the Sunbelt region with above-average growth rates in population, employment & GDP. Positive occupancy and rental rate growth This favorable market backdrop and RUF’s high quality new portfolio have contributed nicely to occupancy and same-property rental rates, both growing aggressively since the July 2012 IPO. At ~98% current occupancy portfolio upside is constrained in 2015, but we continue to expect rent increases in the mid-single digit range to contribute to organic growth. High grading portfolio a source of cash RUF’s strategy is to profitably dispose older assets (Class B properties) and apply the proceeds towards the acquisition of newer Class A properties (which comprise almost the entire portfolio). RUF recently announced the acquisition of two Class A multi-family apartment communities for a purchase price of ~US$118 mln following the disposition of several assets over 2015 amounting to ~US$67.8 mln in proceeds. Balance sheet not a concern RUF’s net debt to GBV ratio of ~57% sits slightly above its peer group (~55%) but poses no concern given the predictability of its cash flows. Low payout supports elevated yield There is some investor concern that the Texas housing market could get impacted by the oil price decline, but evidence suggests RUF is well-positioned to weather headwinds (about 70% the portfolio is in Dallas which is less exposed). We argue this risk is more than adequately reflected in RUF’s 8.0% yield, which is well-covered by a 74% 2016e AFFO payout ratio. Our US$6 target price is derived using a ~12x P/AFFO multiple, Outperform rating. Stock Performance (Reuters) Page 27 Title: Premium Brands Holdings Corp. - PBH (T) Cdn$17.32 Price: Cdn$17.32 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$19.50 Headline: NBF Dividend All-Star Department Theme Piece Industrial Products Savaria Corporation $4.92 SIS (T) Outperform Stock Rating: $6.50 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 4% yield is icing on the cake for this strong performer with a compelling valuation 36.2% Stock Data: 52-w eek High-Low $6.30 - $4.10 Bloomberg/Reuters SIS CN / SIS.TO Shares Outstanding (basic) (mln) Market Capitalization (mln) (Year-End Dec. 31) HIGHLIGHTS Expanding presence in aging market As one of the leaders in the North American personal mobility products market, Savaria is expected to benefit from a clear demographic trend (aging population). In addition, we see company-specific organic growth opportunities such as increasing volume at existing dealers, adding new dealers and expanding its network of Silver Cross-bannered stores. Ended 2015 on a strong note, which bodes well for 2016 Last week, Savaria announced better-than-expected preliminary Q4/15 sales and EBITDA, which rose 24% and 40% y/y respectively. These results imply that Savaria will beat its prior 2015 sales guidance of $92 million and be at the upper end of its targeted EBITDA range. Savaria’s strong momentum at the end of 2015 and strong bookings year-to-date bode well for 2016 in our view. Rock-solid balance sheet A $27.5 million cash position (net cash of $9.8 million), $7.1 million in unused credit and projected free cash flow generation are supportive of the organic and acquisition driven growth strategy as well as dividends. We estimate that Savaria could add $3-5 million in pre-synergy EBITDA using this ammunition. Dividend increased 25% in 2015; Now yields 4.1% Savaria increased its quarterly dividend to $0.05 per share in Sept. 2015, a 25% jump. The 4.1% dividend yield looks safe based on projected payouts of ~50% on free cash flow. Current valuation at low end of historical range Our $6.50 target implies 12x EV/EBITDA on our 2016 estimates. The current 8.8x multiple on 2016e is at the low-end of SIS’ historical range of ~8x to 14x, unwarranted in our view given strong operational momentum, attractive dividend and potential M&A. 32.6 $160 2014A 2015E 2016E Revenues (mln) $82.9 $95.3 $109.6 EBITDA (mln) $11.2 $14.4 $17.0 EBITDA Margin 13.5% 15.2% 15.5% EPS (f d) $0.23 $0.27 $0.32 P/E 21.6x 18.1x 15.6x EV/EBITDA* *Using current EV 13.5x 10.4x 8.8x Financial Data: NBF Dividend All-Star As at Se ptem be r 30, 2015 (Q3 2015) Net Debt (Net Cash) (mln) -$9.8 Net Debt / EBITDA -0.7x Dividend per share Dividend yield $0.20 4.1% Industry Rating: Overweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Savaria is a North American leader in personal mobility products and does business in two segments: Accessibility (stairlifts, elevators, wheelchair lifts, etc.) and Adapted Vehicles (van conversions). Stock Performance Leon Aghazarian, M.Sc. – (514) 879-2574 [email protected] Associates: Frederic Tremblay, M.Sc., CFA – (514) 412-0021 [email protected] Connor Sedgewick - (514) 390-7825 [email protected] Source: www.bigcharts.com Page 28 Title: Slate Retail RE IT - SRT.U/SRT.UN (TSX) US$9.75/C$14.19 Price: US$9.75/C$14.19 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: US$12.75 Headline: Grocery-Anchored Portfolio Supports Attractive Department Theme Piece Real Estate Slate Retail REIT US$9.75/C$14.19 SRT.U/SRT.UN (TSX) Outperform Stock Rating: US$12.75 Target: Below Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Grocery-Anchored Portfolio Supports Attractive Distribution 38.8% HIGHLIGHTS Stock Data (US$): Cash Yield 8.0% Implied Price Return 30.8% 52-week High-Low US$11.49 - US$9.65 Bloomberg/Reuters: SRT/U CN / SRT.U-T Forecasts (US$): 2014a* 2015e 2016e Revenue (US$ mln) 35.8 79.5 95.9 NOI (US$ mln) 25.0 56.4 67.4 69.8% 71.0% 71.7% FYE Dec 31 NOI % 19.6 49.6 60.2 EBITDA % 54.8% 62.3% 62.7% Distribution (US$) $0.55 $0.76 $0.78 EBITDA (US$ mln) FFO/unit (IUS$) $0.89 $1.34 $1.40 FFO Payout 61.5% 56.6% 55.7% AFFO/unit (US$) $0.80 $1.16 $1.20 AFFO Payout 68.0% 65.6% 65.1% EV/EBITDA 39.7x 15.7x 13.0x P/FFO 11.0x 7.3x 7.0x P/AFFO 12.1x 8.4x 8.1x * April 2014 TSX listing onward Financial Data: Units Outstanding (mln) 28.7 Units Outstanding - Diluted (mln) 32.0 Market Capitalization (US$ mln) 279.4 Debt to GBV NAV per unit (NBF est) 55% US$12.75 Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Slate Retail REIT holds a portfolio of grocery-anchored retail properties in secondary U.S. markets. The portfolio is comprised of 66 properties across 7.6 million square feet in 20 U.S. States. Slate Retail REIT is externally managed by Slate Asset Management. Pure-play U.S. grocery-anchored portfolio Slate Retail REIT (SRT) owns and operates a portfolio of 66 properties totalling 7.6 million square feet across 20 U.S. states. The properties are primarily concentrated in secondary markets in Florida (11% of GLA), North Carolina (10% of GLA) and Pennsylvania (10% of GLA). The properties are anchored by large, non-cyclical, international grocer tenants such as Walmart, Kroger, Delhaize, etc. These blue-chip tenants have stable sales and outlooks, long-term tenancies and minimal impact from e-commerce. Below market rents to drive organic growth SRT’s weighted average in-place rent of US$10.05 per square foot is ~20% below comparable market rents, a discount we expect to narrow over coming quarters as the REIT continues to renew rents to market. Acquisitions expected to continue The REIT has more than doubled its portfolio in less than two years (66 properties 7.6 mln square feet currently vs. 29 properties 3.5 mln square feet at 2014 TSX-listing), a trend we expect to continue due to: 1) a fragmented U.S. retail property market (only ~5% of retail centres are owned by the top 25 landlords); 2) ~$222 bln of commercial mortgage backed securities issued with loose credit standards in 2006-07 will need refinancing in 2016-17; 3) the pricing gap between secondary vs. primary markets has widened suggesting relative undervaluation in secondary markets. High yield and low payout support US$12.75 target price Our US$12.75 target price is in line with our NAV and well complemented by a high yield / low payout combination (8.2% distribution yield vs. 2016e AFFO payout of 65%). Stock Performance (Reuters) SRTu.TO Price 12 11.5 11 10.5 Endri Leno, MSc, MBA - (416) 869-8047 [email protected] 10 9.5 Volume 0 M J J S N D J 2014 F M A M J J A S ON D 2015 J F 2016 Page 29 Title: Student Transportation Inc. - STB/STB (T; N) Cdn$6.65; $5.47 Price: Cdn$6.65; StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$8.50 Headline: Grocery-Anchored Portfolio Supports Attractive Department Theme Piece Transportation Student Transportation Inc. Cdn$4.76; $3.32 STB/STB (T; N) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$7.75 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 96.5 Market Capitalization (mln) Net Debt (mln) Enterprise Value (mln) Dividend Yield $459.3 $274.2 $733.5 13.2% 52-w eek High-Low Average Weekly Volume Net Tangible Book Value per Share Revenue (mln) EBITDA (mln) CFPS DPS EPS Steady at the Wheel with an Enticing 13% Yield and an Estimated 66% Payout Ratio 72% Shares Outstanding (mln) Estim ates NBF Dividend All-Star 2015 $ 554.8 $ 72.5 $ 0.42 $ 0.44 $0.04 HIGHLIGHTS USD$0.44/sh dividend looking better as CAD slides… Recall Student Transportation’s dividend is paid in USD, aligning with approximately 90% of STB’s revenue and cash flow. The USD$0.44/sh (annualized) dividend yields an attractive 13% at the current price. With the U.S. dollar currently worth approximately $1.43 Canadian dollars, foreign exchange winds are blowing on the backs of Canadian STB shareholders. ...with a falling payout ratio that suggests sustainability… The dividend continues to appear viable as the payout ratio trends lower. We calculate a manageable 66% gross payout ratio in f2016 falling from 97% in f2015. STB’s balance sheet also continues to improve, as net debt/ttm EBITDA has decreased from 3.8x in f2014, to 2.8x in f2015, to an expected 2.4x in f2016. …and macro trends staying in favor… In addition to the aforementioned f/x tailwinds, management continues to highlight falling fuel expense y/y in both fiscal 2016 and 2017 as oppressed commodity prices continue to slump, believing the savings could increase EBITDA margins by 150-200 basis points relative to f2015. $7.44 - $4.34 1,081,837 -$0.15 2016E 2017E $ 601.2 $ 90.9 $ 0.77 $ 0.44 $0.17 $ 657.9 $ 107.2 $ 0.90 $ 0.44 $0.29 Balance Sheet 2015 2016E 2017E Debt/EBITDA 1 Interest Coverage 2.8x 4.2x 2.4x 6.6x 2.2x 7.1x Valuation 2015 2016E 2017E P/E EV/EBITDA Target EV/EBITDA nmf 8.5x 12.1x nmf 7.4x 10.6x nmf 6.5x 9.2x 1: year end debt net of cash vs. TTM EBITDA All amounts in Cdn$ unless otherwise noted. Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Student Transportation is the 3rd largest provider of school bus transportation services in the US. STB is a leading school bus company aggregating operations through consolidation of existing providers, targeted bid-ins, and conversion of in-house operations. Outperform Rating and $7.75 target Management has guided towards a secured increase in annual revenue of 7% in f2016 relative to 2015 (with the possibility of additional growth), in line with our current forecast which calls for 8% y/y revenue growth ($601.2 mln in f2016). Our $7.75 target is driven by 9.2x 2017 EV/EBITDA, in line with the long term average. Outperform. Stock Performance $8.00 6.0 $7.00 5.0 Greg Colman - (416) 869-6775 [email protected] Michael Storry-Robertson - (416) 507-8007 [email protected] Westley Macdonald-Nixon – (416) 507-9568 [email protected] Price Andrew Jacklin - (416) 869-7571 [email protected] 4.0 $5.00 $4.00 3.0 $3.00 2.0 $2.00 1.0 $1.00 $0.00 2015-01-29 0.0 2015-04-29 Source: Thomson ONE, NBF 2015-07-29 2015-10-29 Volume (mm) $6.00 Page 30 Title: Bank of Montreal - BMO (T) Cdn$59.12 Price: Cdn$59.12 StockRating: Sector Perform TargetPrice: Cdn$64.00 Headline: Title Department Theme Piece Life Insurance Sun Life Financial Cdn$38.20 SLF (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$44.00 Target: (Unchanged) Average Risk Rating: 19% Stock Data: 52-week Low-High $36.88 - $45.65 Shares Outstanding EOP (mln) 611 Market Capitalization ($mln) $26,807 Quarterly Dividend Per Share $0.39 Dividend Yield 4.1% Price-to-Book 1.27x S&P/TSX Composite Weighting 1.30% 2014A 2015E 2016E 2017E $2.86 $3.60 $3.86 $4.01 Y/Y Growth 9% 18% 9% 10% NBF Core EPS $2.98 $3.53 $3.84 $4.21 IFRS EPS Y/Y Growth 83% 26% 7% 4% Dividend / Share $1.44 $1.51 $1.64 $1.80 IFRS F/D Avg. Shares O/S Book Value / Share Price / Book Price / IFRS Earnings Net Income to Common 618 618 617 614 $26.87 $31.03 $32.99 $34.87 1.4x 1.2x 1.2x 1.1x 13.4x 10.6x 9.9x 9.5x 1,762 2,210 2,367 2,451 SLF Canada 972 925 957 1,022 SLF U.S. 409 449 485 528 SLF Asset Management 823 1,118 1,265 1,373 SLF Asia Corporate 220 (14) 300 2 325 18 345 23 2,793 3,056 3,330 (607) (100) (661) (100) 2,349 2,569 Core Earn. from Ops. Core Earn. (pre-tax) Taxes Pref. Div. Core Earn. (after-tax) Positive Cash Flow Dynamics Underpin Increasing Return of Capital (Unchanged) Est. Total Return (Year-End 12/31) NBF Dividend All-Star (Unchanged) 2,410 (469) (111) 1,830 (530) (101) 2,162 Industry Rating: Overweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Sun Life Financial is the third largest Canadian lifeco by market capitalization. The company offers a diverse range of life and health insurance, investment management and retirement products for both individuals and groups. Although SLF's primary operations are in the United States and Canada, it also has a sizeable presence in the United Kingdom and several Asian markets (China, India, Hong Kong, the Philippines and Indonesia). Peter Routledge - (416) 869-7442 [email protected] Associate: Parham Fini - (416) 869-6515 [email protected] Associate: Paul Poon - (416) 507-8006 [email protected] HIGHLIGHTS SLF has a dividend yield of 4.1%, the highest amongst the four life insurers in our coverage universe, supported by the positive cash flow dynamics at its two primary franchises (insurance and wealth management). We expect that SLF to continue to raise its dividend every two quarters. Last quarter, consistent with our forecast, SLF announced a dividend increase to take into effect in Q4 f2015. However, the quantum of the raise ($0.01/share or 3%) fell short of our forecast ($0.03/share or 8%). SLF’s payout ratio of 48% sits at the upper range of its target dividend payout ratio range of 40% - 50%. At our 2015 Financial Services Conference, SLF CFO Colm Freyne stated that SLF’s robust cash flows will enable the insurer to remain at the high end of its target payout range. We forecast that SLF will raise dividends/share by 9% in f2016 and 10% in f2017. SLF well-positioned to build on asset management platform. Last quarter, SLF consolidated its asset management operations, including recent acquisitions (Prime Advisors Inc., the Bentall Kennedy Group, and Ryan Labs Asset Management) under Sun Life Investment Management (SLIM) in addition to MFS, within a new segment titled SLF Asset Management. We consider SLF to have the most complete asset management platform amongst its life insurer peers and view the company’s emerging institutional wealth management strategy, built around liability-driven investing, to be a viable one that is both focused and leverages the company’s competitive strengths. MFS continues to anchor SLF’s U.S. presence, continuing to earn through a challenging environment. SLF is rated Outperform rating; price target of $44. We have rated SLF Outperform since March 2015 because, we argued, the company would continue to benefit from the positive cash flow dynamics at its two primary franchises. This condition gives SLF the financial flexibility to not only consider adding to its franchises via acquisitions but to also return more capital to shareholders in the form of common share buybacks and dividend increases. Our target is 11.0x our estimated f2017 EPS, a 5% premium to peers versus 9.9x our forecasted f2016 EPS today. Stock Performance Page 31 Title: Bank of Montreal - BMO (T) Cdn$59.12 Price: Cdn$59.12 StockRating: Sector Perform TargetPrice: Cdn$64.00 Headline: Title Department Theme Piece Banking Toronto-Dominion Bank Cdn$50.18 TD (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$59.00 Target: Est. Total Return 22% Stock Data: 52-w eek Low -High $47.75 - $56.48 Shares Outstanding EOP (mln) 1,855 Market Capitalization ($mln) $91,714 S&P/TSX Composite Weighting 6.20% 2014A 2015A 2016E 2017E $5.33 Core Cash EPS $4.27 $4.61 $4.93 % Grow th 15% 8% 7% 8% $4.14 $4.21 $4.80 $5.21 Net Inc. to Common EPS % Grow th 20% 2% 14% 8% Dividend / Share $1.84 $2.00 $2.16 $2.32 1,877 F/D Avg. Shares 1,845 1,854 1,866 Price / Earnings 11.8x 10.9x 10.2x 9.4x Core Cash Net Income $7,877 $8,543 $9,205 $10,006 NI to Equity Holders $7,776 $7,912 $9,061 $9,876 Canadian P&C 3,929 4,430 4,515 U.S. Retail 2,110 2,488 2,997 3,541 Canadian Wealth & Insurance 1,305 1,508 1,591 1,727 813 873 843 896 (381) (1,387) (886) (847) Wholesale Banking Corporate Segment Strengthening Outlook for U.S. Platform Below Average Risk Rating: (Year-End 10/31) NBF Dividend All-Star 4,560 Financial Data: (As of last quarter-end) Price / Book Value 1.5x Dividend Inform ation: Quarterly Dividend Per Share $0.51 Dividend Yield 4.1% Industry Rating: Overweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: TD Bank is the second largest Canadian bank in terms of assets. TD operates along four business lines. Canadian and U.S. Personal and Commercial Banking provide a wide range of personal banking services in their respective jurisdictions. Wealth Management offers self-directed brokerage services and full service brokerage to individual investors, as well as investment management services for institutional and high net worth individuals. The Wholesale Bank provides capital market products and services. Peter Routledge - (416) 869-7442 [email protected] Associate: Parham Fini - (416) 869-6515 [email protected] Associate: Paul Poon - (416) 507-8006 [email protected] HIGHLIGHTS TD has a dividend yield of 4.1% supported by a strengthening outlook for its sizeable U.S. platform and accelerating earnings growth from its Wholesale Banking segment. We expect that TD will continue to raise dividends every four quarters. We remind readers that last year, TD’s management indicated that the bank would break from the pattern of a dividend increase every other quarter, as had occurred since Q2 f2011. TD will continue to aim for common share dividend payout ratio towards the middle of its 40% to 50% target range but reduce the incidence of dividend increases to give the bank more financial flexibility. We expect TD to announce its next dividend increase of $0.04/share (8%) to $0.55/share in the first quarter of f2016, taking effect in Q2 f2016 with a similar increase (7%) in f2017. Capital position to strengthen. TD reported a Basel III common equity tier 1 (CET1) ratio of 9.9% at the end of Q4 f2015, trailing most of its Big Six bank peer group. Growth in risk-weighted assets, reflecting strong loan growth in wholesale and the U.S., and restructuring charges offset internal capital generation last quarter. However, we expect TD to reach a CET1 ratio of 10.4% by the end of f2016, in line with peers. TD is rated Outperform; price target of $59. We maintain our Outperform rating for three reasons. First, amongst its peers, TD has the strongest U.S. retail banking platform along with the greatest gearing to a rising interest rate environment in the United States – a by-product of its core deposit-heavy funding mix in that country. Second, we expect TD’s Wholesale Banking segment to accelerate its earnings growth over the next few years as the investment bank expands its appetite for wholesale credit risk, boosts underwriting revenue and does better with cost control. Third, we think the bank protests too much on EPS growth – even after incorporating our bearish outlook on Canadian P&C Banking loan losses, we still get to 7% EPS growth without assuming any common share repurchases. Our price target is 11.1x our four quarter forward EPS estimate one year from today, an 8% premium to the average of TD’s rated peers. Stock Performance Page 32 Title: Innergex Renewable Energy Inc. - INE (T) Cdn$9.53 Price: Cdn$9.53 TargetPrice: Cdn$11.25 Headline: Recent dip creates attractive entry point Department Theme Piece Independent Power Producers & Energy Traders TransAlta Renewables Inc. Cdn$9.42 RNW (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$12.50 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star Sustainable dividend payments with steady cash flow growth 42% HIGHLIGHTS Stock Data: 52-w eek High-Low (Canada) $13.50 - $8.99 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada (Year-End Dec 31) RNW CN / RNW-T 2014a 2015e 2016e Revenue (mln) $ 233.4 $ 227.3 $ 239.5 adj. EBITDA (mln) $ 170.0 $ 239.1 $ 289.3 adj. EPS (diluted) $ 0.43 $ 0.54 $ 0.69 CAFD/sh $ 0.78 $ 0.85 $ 0.93 Dividends/sh $ 0.77 $ 0.82 $ 0.88 Dividend Yield 8.2% 8.7% Payout Ratio 98% 90% 9.3% 94% P/ CAFD 12.0x 11.1x 10.1x adj. EV/EBITDA 10.1x 10.3x 12.0x Financial Data: Market Capitalization (mln) $ 2,188 Total Debt1 (mln) $ 762 Price/Book Ratio 0.96x Debt/Capital 0.23x 2 190.8 Sh/O Basic (mln) FD Outstanding2 (mln) 232.3 Source: Thomson Financial and NBF estimates 1 Sept 30th, 2015 2 Proforma Industry Rating: Underweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: TransAlta Renewables (RNW) operates 1,680 MW (net) of generating assets in North America and Australia and a gas pipeline asset in Australia, all under long-term off-take contracts. The company operates as a “Yield Co.”, with assets dropped down from its parent company, TransAlta Corp. (TA-TSX). TA maintains an interest of roughly 64% in RNW. Dividend all-star that raised dividend every year RNW has raised its dividend every year since its IPO in 2013 and we expect this trend to continue as long as RNW’s dropdown inventory grows. RNW has recently announced a 4.8% increase to its dividend to $0.073/sh (monthly) and it expects a further 6-7% increase in the dividend mid 2017E. RNW’s yield is high at 9.1% but sustainable over long-term. Dropdown inventory continues to grow RNW’s parent, TransAlta (TA), plans to increase its focus on renewables and to drop down more assets into RNW. Recently, RNW has agreed to purchase preferred shares that track the cash flows for three of TA’s assets for $540 mln and also retains a ROFO for expansion opportunities at the site. Alberta GHG plan will benefit RNW over long-run Alberta released a plan to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions which includes phasing out coal power by 2030. RNW has the strongest Alberta presence in our universe, including 4 hydro and 10 wind assets. With the government pushing for renewable energy in Alberta, RNW could benefit from government subsidies and higher energy prices for its current and future growth pipeline. New shareholder, AIMCo, could support future liquidity TA sold $200 mln in shares of RNW to the Alberta Investment Management Corporation (AIMCo). With this, TA’s proforma ownership in RNW will drop from about 76% to 64%. Target at $12.50/sh, with Outperform rating Our target uses a discount rate of 8.5%, consistent with its peer group and implies an adj. EV/EBITDA of 9.9x 2017E. We believe the dividend is attractive and should increase by 6 to 7% with the start of the South Hedland facility in H2 2017E Stock Performance Rupert M. Merer, P.Eng CFA - (416) 869-8008 [email protected] Associates: Ryan Wong, P.Eng MBA – (416) 869-6763 [email protected] Steven Hong – (416) 869-7538 [email protected] Source: Reuters Page 33 Title: Groupe Aeroplan Inc. - AER (T) Cdn$10.42 Price: Cdn$10.42 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$13.50 Headline: Q2 EBITDA Ex-Items Beats, NCIB Expands, Air Canada Issues Department Theme Piece Media Transcontinental Inc. Cdn$17.86 TCL.A (T) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$22.50 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return HIGHLIGHTS 52-week High-Low (Canada) $21.85 - $13.18 52-week High-Low (U.S.) NA Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada Bloomberg/Reuters: U.S. Revenue (mln) EBITDA (mln) 2015a 2016e 2017e $2,025.2 $1,903.0 $378.7 $394.0 $380.2 $2.39 $2.40 $2.39 7.5 7.4 7.5 P/E EV/EBITDA 4.4 3.9 3.7 $223.3 $241.0 $188.7 $2.86 $3.09 $2.42 FCF per share Dividend Dividend / FCF TCL/A / TCL'A-T NA $2,002.2 FD EPS ex-items Free Cash (mln) Declining Leverage & Robust FCF Profile Support M&A & Sustained Dividend Growth 29.8% Stock Data: (FYE Oct. 31) NBF Dividend All-Star $0.67 $0.72 $0.78 23.4% 23.2% 32.1% F2016e FCF includes $31MM payment from The Globe and Mail and $9MM payment from Revenue Québec. Financial Data (as at October 31, 2015): Shares Outstanding (mln) 78.0 Float (mln) 64.8 Market Capitalization (mln) Net Debt Shareholders' Equity (mln) $1,393.4 $345.5 $1,016.3 Net Debt/Capital BVPS / Price/Book Dividend / Yield 25.4% $13.03/1.4x $0.68/3.8% Industry Rating: (Media): Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: Transcontinental is one of North America’s largest commercial printers (#1 in Canada) with operations primarily in Canada and, to a lesser extent, in the U.S. The company is a leading publisher of weekly newspapers & door-to-door flyer distribution. It acquired U.S.-based Capri Packaging in May 2014 to add a third leg to its platform, with the purchase of Ultra Flex Packaging on Sept. 30, 2015 helping to bulk up the contribution from Packaging. Canada’s largest printer building up packaging division. Transcontinental is Canada’s largest commercial printer and one of the biggest in North America. Its media division consists of Local Solutions, Interactive Marketing Solutions, and Business Information Solutions & Education. Following the acquisitions of Capri Packaging in 2014 and Ultra Flex Packaging last year, packaging is emerging as a key 3rd piece of the story. Based on PF2015, the revenue split between Printing/Media/Packaging was 64%/27%/9%, respectively. Stable capex & ongoing optimization efforts drive FCF. Between f2008 and f2009, the company invested over $500 million in its printing platform to satisfy new and/or expanded mandates, gain share, and establish a national retail flyer platform. Since then spending on capex (incl. intangibles) has declined to $70-$75 million per year. Management continues to extract efficiencies across the organization. We think more plant consolidation is likely to be pursued, as the company continues to optimize its printing platform. Transcontinental now operates 23 plants, down from 29 in 2012 and 54 in 2008. Low payout signals plenty of room to grow the dividend. At Q4/15, net debt to EBITDA stood at 0.9x, below the company’s historical target range of 1.0x to 2.0x. In the absence of M&A which is expected or buybacks, we forecast leverage to drop to 0.4x in f2016 and to 0.1x in f2017. We look for annual dividend growth to continue with the reporting of Q1/16 results in March (+6.3% with Q1/15, +10% with Q1/14). Transcontinental is rated Outperform, $22.50 target. Our target, based on our NAV, implies EV/EBITDA multiples of 4.9x f2016E and 4.7x f2017E. The company’s forward EV/EBITDA multiple averaged 5.3x over the past 13 years and 4.5x over the past 8 years. We upgraded the stock to Outperform from Sector Perform on Jan. 20, 2015. Stock Performance (source: Thomson Reuters) Daily TCLa.TO 1/26/2015 - 2/11/2016 (TOR) Line, TCLa.TO, Trade Price(Last), 1/25/2016, 17.86, +0.18, (+1.02%) Price CAD 21 20.5 20 19.5 19 18.5 Rémi Marcoux, founder and chairman, controls 16.5% equity and 71.7% votes. 18 17.86 17.5 17 16.5 16 15.5 Adam Shine, CFA - 514-879-2302 [email protected] 15 14.5 14 Associates: Piotr (Peter) Stusio, CFA – 514-879-2564 [email protected] Luc Troiani, CFA – 416-869-6585 [email protected] Auto Vol, TCLa.TO, Trade Price, 1/25/2016, 218,060.00 Volume 500,000 218,060.00 Auto 02 17 02 16 01 16 01 19 01 16 02 16 04 17 01 16 01 16 02 16 01 16 04 18 01 Feb 15 Mar 15 Apr 15 May 15 Jun 15 Jul 15 Aug 15 Sep 15 Oct 15 Nov 15 Dec 15 Jan 16 Page 34 Title: Baytex Energy Corp. - BTE (T/NYSE) Cdn$44.46 Price: Cdn$44.46 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$52.00 Headline: NBF Dividend All-Star Department Theme Piece Oil & Gas Exploration and Production Vermilion Energy Inc. Cdn$33.60 VET (T;N) Outperform Stock Rating: Cdn$48.00 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return 52-week High-Low (Cdn$) $29.71 - $62.80 Dividend Yield 110.8 Market Cap. (mln) $3,723.5 Net Debt (mln) $1,400.4 Enterprise Value (mln) $5,123.9 Production 2015e 2016e 2017e Oil & NGL's (bbls/d) 33,048 35,950 37,309 % Nat. Gas Pricing* 131.0 162.3 172.1 54,874 63,000 66,000 40% 43% 43% 2015e 2016e 2017e WTI (US$/bbl) $49.00 $39.00 $44.00 Brent (US$/bbl) $53.58 $39.00 $45.00 AECO (Cdn$/mcf) $2.56 $2.70 $3.10 Estimates 2015e 2016e 2017e CFPS $4.54 $4.32 $5.16 -$0.97 -$0.71 -$0.19 EPS DPS Cash Flow (mln) Capex (mln) $2.58 $2.58 $2.58 $502.0 $492.5 $601.8 $485.0 $285.0 $350.0 $1,437.9 $1,401.3 $1,383.3 D/CF 2.9 x 2.8 x 2.3 x Basic Payout (%) 56% 59% 50% Total Payout (%) 153% 117% 108% Total Net Payout (%) 122% 88% 84% Net Debt (mln) NAV ($/sh) $34.56 CNAV ($/sh) $40.50 Valuation 2015e 2016e EV/DACF 9.4 x 9.7 x 8.2 x $96,437 $85,155 $82,032 $37.24 $23.91 EV/BOE/D EV/boe P+P HIGHLIGHTS 7.7% Shares Outstanding (mln) Boe/d (6:1) Diversified International Asset Base with Leverage to Premium European Gas 51% Stock Data - Q3a 2015: Nat. Gas (mmcf/d) NBF Dividend All-Star P/CNAVPS Diversified Asset Base with Leverage to European Gas Vermilion has a globally diversified asset base with production coming from France, Netherlands, Germany, Ireland, Australia, Canada and the U.S.A. This globally diversified portfolio provides access to premium global pricing and top-quartile netbacks, with significant leverage to European gas prices (~40%), which are currently trading ~C$6.25/mcf and more than double North American gas prices. Conservative Budget Ensures Sustainability Vermilion recently announced a formal 2016 capital budget of $285 mln which is down -41% Y/Y and -19% from its preliminary guidance in November. However, with first gas from the Corrib gas project (offshore Ireland) achieved in late 2015, production for the year is expected to grow 15% Y/Y to a range of 62,500-63,500 boe/d, while increasing European gas exposure. Capital Program & Dividend Expected to be Fully Funded The current 2016 capital program along with the cash dividend is expected to be fully funded by operating cash flow down to the mid US$30/bbl WTI range, while the company also noted that the budget is flexible with the ability to increase or decrease spending, depending on what happens with commodity prices. Outperform Rating with a $48.00 Target Despite the commodity downturn, VET has been able to demonstrate strong capital discipline and flexibility which we believe will allow them to maintain the dividend while delivering impressive Y/Y production growth. We currently rate Vermilion as Outperform and have a 12-month target price of $48.00 which is based on a 1.2x CNAV multiple and reflects a 2016 EV/DACF multiple of 12.8x. 2017e 0.8x Source: Company reports, NBF estimates Note: Debt figures include convertible debentures All figures in Cdn$ unless otherwise noted Industry Rating (Oil & Gas Exploration and Production): Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Associate: John Hunt - (403) 441-0955 [email protected] Associate: Jason Wai - (403) 355-6643 [email protected] $65 1,800 1,600 $60 1,400 $55 Price ($/sh) Kyle Preston, CFA, CMA - (403) 290-5102 [email protected] Stock Performance 1,200 $50 1,000 $45 800 600 $40 400 $35 $30 Jan-15 Source: Bloomberg 200 Mar-15 May-15 Jul-15 Sep-15 Nov-15 0 Jan-16 Volume (000's) Company Profile: Vermilion Energy is an internationally diversified and oil-weighted Intermediate Yield E&P pursuing a growth and income business model. The company has a globally diversified portfolio of assets located in France, Netherlands, Ireland, Australia, Germany and Canada. Approximately 60% of current production is sourced outside of Canada, which provides the company with diversification across geographic areas, regulatory regimes and commodity price benchmarks. Title: Whitecap Resources Inc. - WCP (T) $9.38 Price: $9.38 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: $12.50 Headline: Stands out from its energy peers across a number of Department Theme Page 35 Piece Oil & Gas Production and Exploration Whitecap Resources Inc. $6.97 WCP (T) Outperform Stock Rating: $11.00 Target: Above Average Risk Rating: 64% Stock Data Q4/15e 52-week High-Low (Cdn$) $5.80 - $15.62 Shares Outstanding (mln) 298.9 Current Dividend Yield 6.5% Net Debt (mln) $848 Market Cap. (mln) $2,083 Enterprise Value (mln) $2,931 Production 2015e 2016e 2017e Oil & NGL's (bbls/d) 31,027 27,750 24,750 Nat. Gas (mcf/d) 58,788 55,500 49,500 Boe/d (6:1) 40,825 37,000 33,000 % Nat. Gas 24% 25% 25% Pricing 2015e 2016e 2017e WTI (US$/bbl) $48.74 $38.75 $44.50 AECO (Cdn$/mcf) Corp. Oil & NGL's ($/bbl) $2.57 $2.70 $3.10 $49.94 $43.00 $50.67 Corp. Nat. Gas ($/mcf) $2.70 $2.71 $3.18 Corp. Wellhead ($/boe) $41.84 $36.31 $42.77 * Strip pricing 15/16 (as at 01/06/2016) Estimates 2015e Cash Flow (mln) $483.3 CFPS - diluted 2016e 2017e $266.4 $250.2 $1.67 $0.88 $0.82 CF Netback ($/boe) $32.44 $19.67 $20.77 Capex (mln) $370.8 $0.0 $100.0 Net Debt (mln) $848.0 $731.0 $715.3 Valuation 2017e 2015e 2016e P/CF 7.4 x 7.9 x 8.5 x EV/DACF 8.0 x 9.3 x 9.8 x Net Debt / CF EV/BOE/D Defensive Model in Today’s Commodity Storm 1.8 x 2.7 x 2.9 x $103,379 $76,057 $84,800 P/NAVPS EV/boe P+P 1.4x $11.74 Source: Company Reports, NBF Estimates Industry Rating (Oil & Gas Exploration and Production): Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Sustainability Measures Migrate to More Favourable Levels. As a means of improving financial flexibility in today’s tough commodity price environment, Whitecap recently revised the 2016 budget (decreased 53% to $70 million), reduced the dividend (by 40%) and disposed of production facilities for proceeds of $70 million. In turn, Whitecap’s sustainability measures migrate to more favourable levels, underscored by a 2016e total payout ratio of 104% and a D/CF of 3.7x (strip). Moreover, ample liquidity on the bank line provides the company with a meaningful buffer in the event that commodity prices deteriorate further. 2016 Budget: Under the company’s 2016 pricing assumption of US$37.50/bbl, Whitecap revealed a capital program of $70 million (down 53% from $150 million), which is expected to drive production to an annual average of 37.0 mboe/d (from 40.1 mboe/d). Based on management’s conservative nature (WCP has a history of beating expectations), we believe there is a healthy degree of defensibility built into the budget (providing some potential to see incremental upside to valuation and sustainability). Facility Disposition: Whitecap will fund its 2016 capital program by way of a $70 million infrastructure disposition. Under the terms of the arrangement, Whitecap will remain as operator and retain third party revenues generated for an annual tariff paid to the purchaser. In our view, Whitecap’s cost of capital on the transaction is quite favourable, given that the annual tariff behind the arrangement is offset by internally generated operating cost enhancements and through G&A reductions. Moreover, Whitecap will have the option to repurchase the facilities at any time. Outperform Rating and $11.00/sh Target Price: Our view for continued outperformance of peers is backstopped by the relative strength of sustainability measures, management’s track record of meeting/exceeding expectations and the Street’s general bias toward companies with relative financial flexibility and low risk operations in today’s challenged energy environment. Whitecap remains as one of the strongest operators/capital allocators in the basin and a history of financial discipline gives us comfort that the company will find ways of maintaining its sustainability even under weaker commodity prices. Whitecap trades at a 2016e EV/DACF of 9.3x vs peers at 8.0x Stock Performance (source: Bloomberg) $16 14,000 $14 12,000 Volume (000's) Company Profile: Whitecap Resources entered the market through a reverse takeover of Spitfire Energy in June 2010. The company has a diversified asset base with a primary focus on the Cardium in West Central Alberta and the Viking in Saskatchewan. Through a combination of a focused drilling program and accretive acquisitions the company has transitioned itself into an intermediate yield growth company. HIGHLIGHTS Price ($/sh) Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star 10,000 $12 8,000 $10 Brian Milne – (403) 290-5625 [email protected] $8 Associate: Mark Hirsch, P. Eng. – (403) 441-0928 [email protected] $6 Jan-15 6,000 4,000 2,000 Mar-15 May-15 Jul-15 Sep-15 Nov-15 0 Jan-16 Page 36 Title: WPT Industrial REIT - WIR.U (TSX) US$10.00 Price: US$10.00 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: US$12.50 Headline: Attractive U.S. Based Yield Opportunity Department Theme Piece Real Estate WPT Industrial REIT US$10.00 WIR.U (TSX) Outperform Stock Rating: US$12.50 Target: Average Risk Rating: Est. Total Return NBF Dividend All-Star US$ Yield Opportunity Backstopped By Strong Portfolio Fundamentals 32.6% HIGHLIGHTS Stock Data Cash Yield 7.6% Implied Price Return 25.0% 52-week High-Low US$12.20 - US$9.50 Bloomberg/Reuters: WIR/U.CN / WIRu.TO Forecasts (US$): FYE Dec 31 2014a 2015e 2016e Revenue $57.4 $69.4 $75.2 EBITDA $39.2 $47.2 $52.6 FFO/Unit $1.00 $1.02 $1.15 AFFO/Unit $0.82 $0.84 $0.87 Distribution $0.70 $0.71 $0.76 FFO Payout 70.0% 70.0% 66.2% AFFO Payout 85.5% 85.0% 87.5% EV/EBITDA 16.7x 14.7x 13.7x P/FFO 10.0x 9.8x 8.7x P/AFFO 12.2x 11.9x 11.5x Financial Data (US$): Public Units Outstanding (mln) Public Market Capitalization (mln) Class B Units Outstanding (mln) Net Debt (mln) Net Debt to GBV 27.0 $270.3 6.7 $354.7 49% Industry Rating: Market Weight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: WPT Industrial REIT offers investors USD denominated exposure to industrial warehouses and distribution centres across the U.S. WPT currently owns 48 warehouses / distribution facilities and two office properties totaling 15.1 million square feet of gross leasable area across 13 states. Dedicated U.S. industrial portfolio WPT Industrial REIT owns 48 distribution facilities / warehouses and two office properties totaling ~15.1 million square feet of gross leasable area with total portfolio occupancy of 98.1%. The portfolio’s avg. age is ~13 years and its properties are located in key U.S. distribution markets across 13 states, including Georgia (19%), Tennessee (15.4%), Kentucky (12.6%), Indiana (12.6%), Ohio (10.5%) and Illinois (9.9%). Warehouse/distribution tenants attractive counterparties Characterized by high occupancy (~97.7% since IPO), long-term tenancy, recurring revenues, visible cash flows and stable, growing rents (+2.5% y/y forecast through 2016e). WPT’s focus on US ecommerce & online retailers is a compelling vertical with this space projected to continue growing immensely (sales 20%+ CAGR through 2017e). Culmination of strategic review adds high-quality unitholder Alberta Investment Management Corporation (AIMCo) acquired 4.8 mln units of WPT (representing a 19% interest, ~16% fully diluted) at US$11.75 per unit from WPT’s parent company Welsh Property Trust, LLC following the completion of the recent strategic review. The acquisition of units, in our view, serves as validation WPT’s intrinsic value and allows management to refocus efforts on REIT operations. In conjunction with the transaction, the creation of WPT Capital Advisors, a new entity owned by AIMCo and senior management of Welsh, was announced. WPT Capital will assume the role as WPT’s property manager and will also have the ability to invest in and develop value-add real estate properties, which provides a captive pipeline of investment opportunities for WPT. Elevated, sustainable yield Investors receive a sustainable 7.6% distribution vs. a 2016e AFFO payout of 87.5%. Our target price of US$12.50 reflects a 6.6% cap rate and ~14x 2016e P/AFFO & we reiterate an Outperform rating. Stock Performance (Reuters) 12.50 12.00 11.50 11.00 10.50 Trevor Johnson, CFA, MBA - (416) 869-8511 [email protected] 10.00 Associates: Endri Leno - (416) 869-8047 [email protected] Kyle Stanley - (416) 507-8108 [email protected] Alex Bauer - (416) 869-7535 [email protected] 200,000 0 Feb Mar Q1 2015 Apr May Jun Q2 2015 Jul Aug Sep Q3 2015 Oct Nov Dec Q4 2015 Jan Page 37 Title: Premium Brands Holdings Corp. - PBH (T) Cdn$17.32 Price: Cdn$17.32 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$19.50 Headline: NBF Dividend All-Star Department Theme Piece Construction & Engineering WSP Global Inc. $38.33 WSP (T) Outperform Stock Rating: $51.00 Target: Est. Total Return 37.0% HIGHLIGHTS Stock Data: 52-w eek range $31.13 - $49.18 Bloomberg/Reuters: Canada WSP CN / WSP Shares Outstanding (mln) Adj. EBITDA (mln) Adj. EBITDA Margin Strong, sustainable dividend yield At 3.9%, the current dividend yield is the highest among the pure-play engineering firm peer group. Moreover, we consider the dividend payment to be safe as it represents a payout ratio of 37% over our 2016 FCF estimate. Well diversified global platform With over 80 acquisitions since 2006, including PB ($1.4 billion) and MMM ($425 million) WSP is now a truly global pure-play consultancy: Canada (22%), Americas (29%), EMEIA (36%), APAC (14%). WSP’s diversified platform is supported by a record backlog of $4.8 billion (as of Q3/15). Conservative debt level, room for leverage As of Q3/15, Net Debt/EBITDA is at 1.2x. We expect WSP to continue to use FCF to pay down debt while remaining opportunistic, in line with their acquisition strategy. Management maintains a Net Debt/EBITDA target of 1.5x-2.0x. Poised to achieve guidance Our 2016 numbers are supported by a solid track record of acquisition integration, minimal exposure to O&G (~5% of total workforce) and favourable FX positioning (<25% revenues in CAD ~30% revenues in USD). Our 2016 revenue estimate of $5 billion is well on the way towards management’s roadmap revenue target of $6 billion by 2018. $51.00 target – Outperform rating Our $51.00 target (10x 2016e EV/EBITDA) results in a 37.0% potential upside (including the 3.9% dividend yield). $3,768 2014a 2015e 2016e $2,349.9 $4,451.8 $5,008.0 $253.5 $439.5 $526.2 10.8% 9.9% 10.5% Adj. EPS (fd) $1.83 $2.15 $2.59 P/E 21.0x 17.8x 14.8x EV/EBITDA 1 16.8x 9.7x 8.1x 1. Using current EV. Financial Data: 98.3 Market Capitalization (mln)(Cdn$) Net Revenue (mln) 3.9% yield backed by robust financials Average Risk Rating: (Year-End Dec 31) NBF Dividend All-Star As at Septem ber 30, 2015 (Q3 2015) Net Debt (mln) $502.4 Net Debt / EBITDA 1.2x Dividend per Share (annualized) $1.50 Dividend Yield 3.9% Industry Rating: Overweight (NBF Economics & Strategy Group) Company Profile: WSP is a leading engineering services firm providing private and public-sector clients with a full range of professional consulting services through all project phases, including planning, design, construction and maintenance. Leon Aghazarian, M.Sc. – (514) 879-2574 [email protected] Associates: Frederic Tremblay, M.Sc., CFA – (514) 412-0021 [email protected] Connor Sedgewick - (514) 390-7825 [email protected] Stock Performance Page 38 DISCLOSURES: Ratings And What They Mean: PRIMARY STOCK RATING: NBF has a three-tiered rating system that is relative to the coverage universe of the particular analyst. Here is a brief description of each: Outperform – The stock is expected to outperform the analyst’s coverage universe over the next 12 months; Sector Perform – The stock is projected to perform in line with the sector over the next 12 months; Underperform – The stock is expected to underperform the sector over the next 12 months. SECONDARY STOCK RATING: Under Review − Our analyst has withdrawn the rating because of insufficient information and is awaiting more information and/or clarification; Tender − Our analyst is recommending that investors tender to a specific offering for the company’s stock; Restricted − Because of ongoing investment banking transactions or because of other circumstances, NBF policy and/or laws or regulations preclude our analyst from rating a company’s stock. INDUSTRY RATING: NBF has an Industry Weighting system that reflects the view of our Economics & Strategy Group, using its sector rotation strategy. The three-tiered system rates industries as Overweight, Market Weight and Underweight, depending on the sector’s projected performance against broader market averages over the next 12 months. RISK RATING: NBF utilizes a four-tiered risk rating system, Below Average, Average, Above Average and Speculative. The system attempts to evaluate risk against the overall market. In addition to sector-specific criteria, analysts also utilize quantitative and qualitative criteria in choosing a rating. The criteria include predictability of financial results, share price volatility, credit ratings, share liquidity and balance sheet quality. General – National Bank Financial (NBF) is an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of National Bank of Canada. National Bank of Canada is a public company listed on Canadian stock exchanges. The particulars contained herein were obtained from sources which we believe to be reliable but are not guaranteed by us and may be incomplete. The opinions expressed are based upon our analysis and interpretation of these particulars and are not to be construed as a solicitation or offer to buy or sell the securities mentioned herein. Research Analysts – The Research Analyst(s) who prepare these reports certify that their respective report accurately reflects his or her personal opinion and that no part of his/her compensation was, is, or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific recommendations or views as to the securities or companies. NBF compensates its Research Analysts from a variety of sources. The Research Department is a cost centre and is funded by the business activities of NBF including, Institutional Equity Sales and Trading, Retail Sales, the correspondent clearing business, and Corporate and Investment Banking. Since the revenues from these businesses vary, the funds for research compensation vary. No one business line has a greater influence than any other for Research Analyst compensation. Canadian Residents – In respect of the distribution of this report in Canada, NBF accepts responsibility for its contents. To make further inquiry related to this report, Canadian residents should contact their NBF professional representative. To effect any transaction, Canadian residents should contact their NBF Investment advisor. U.S. Residents – With respect to the distribution of this report in the United States, National Bank of Canada Financial Inc. (NBCFI) is regulated by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and a member of the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC). This report has been prepared in whole or in part by, research analysts employed by non-US affiliates of NBCFI that are not registered as broker/dealers in the US. These non-US research analysts are not registered as associated persons of NBCFI and are not licensed or qualified as research analysts with FINRA or any other US regulatory authority and, accordingly, may not be subject (among other things) to FINRA restrictions regarding communications by a research analyst with the subject company, public appearances by research analysts and trading securities held a research analyst account. All of the views expressed in this research report accurately reflect the research analysts’ personal views regarding any and all of the subject securities or issuers. No part of the analysts’ compensation was, is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the specific recommendations or views expressed in this research report. The analyst responsible for the production of this report certifies that the views expressed herein reflect his or her accurate personal and technical judgment at the moment of publication. Because the views of analysts may differ, members of the National Bank Financial Group may have or may in the future issue reports that are inconsistent with this report, or that reach conclusions different from those in this report. To make further inquiry related to this report, United States residents should contact their NBCFI registered representative. UK Residents – In respect of the distribution of this report to UK residents, National Bank Financial Inc. has approved the contents (including, where necessary, for the purposes of Section 21(1) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000). National Bank Financial Inc. and/or its parent and/or any companies within or affiliates of the National Bank of Canada group and/or any of their directors, officers and employees may have or may have had interests or long or short positions in, and may at any time make purchases and/or sales as principal or agent, or may act or may have acted as market maker in the relevant securities or related financial instruments discussed in this report, or may act or have acted as investment and/or commercial banker with respect thereto. The value of investments can go down as well as up. Past performance will not necessarily be repeated in the future. The investments contained in this report are not available to retail customers. This report does not constitute or form part of any offer for sale or subscription of or solicitation of any offer to buy or subscribe for the securities described herein nor shall it or any part of it form the basis of or be relied on in connection with any contract or commitment whatsoever. This information is only for distribution to Eligible Counterparties and Professional Clients in the United Kingdom within the meaning of the rules of the Financial Conduct Authority. National Bank Financial Inc. is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and has its registered office at 71 Fenchurch Street, London, EC3M 4HD.. National Bank Financial Inc. is not authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority to accept deposits in the United Kingdom. Copyright – This report may not be reproduced in whole or in part, or further distributed or published or referred to in any manner whatsoever, nor may the information, opinions or conclusions contained in it be referred to without in each case the prior express written consent of National Bank Financial. NBF is a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund. NBF quarterly ratings summary and the total ratings by month can be found on our website under Research and Analysis/Equities/About NBF Research/Quarterly Ratings Summary (link attached) http://www.nbcn.ca/cmst/site/index.jhtml?navid=803&templateID=249 The NBF Research Dissemination Policy is available on our website under Legal/Research Policy (link attached) http://www.nbcn.ca/cmst/site/index.jhtml?navid=712&templateid=243 Click on the following link to see the company specific disclosures http://www.nbcn.ca/contactus/disclosures.html Click on the following link to see National Bank Financial Markets Statement of Policies http://nbfm.ca/en/statement-of-policies/ If a company specific disclosure is not found herein for a listed company, NBF at this time does not provide research coverage or stock rating for the company in question. Page 39 Additional company related disclosures for American Hotel Income Properties REIT LP (2,3,4,5,7) Bank of Montreal (2,3,4,5,7) Crombie REIT (2,3,4,5,7) First Capital Realty (2,3,4,5,7) Milestone Apartments REIT (2,3,4,5,7) Pure Multi-Family REIT LP (2,3,4,5,7) Savaria Corporation (2,3,4,5,7) Slate Retail REIT (2,3,4,5,7) AG Growth International Inc. (2,3,4,5,6,7) Enbridge Income Fund Holdings (2,3,4,5,6,7) Exchange Income Corporation (2,3,4,5,6,7) First National Financial Corporation (2,3,4,5,6,7) Innergex Renewable Energy Inc. (2,3,4,5,6,7) Inter Pipeline Ltd. (2,3,4,5,6,7) Northland Power Inc. (2,3,4,5,6,7) Student Transportation Inc. (2,3,4,5,6,7) Whitecap Resources Inc. (2,3,4,5,6,7) Pembina Pipeline Corp. (2,3,4,5,7,10) Toronto-Dominion Bank (2,3,4,5,7,10) Boralex Inc. (2,3,4,5,6,7,10) Cominar REIT (2,3,4,5,6,7,10) TransAlta Renewables Inc. (2,3,4,5,6,7,10) WSP Global Inc. (2,3,4,5,6,7,10) Vermilion Energy Inc. (6,7,10) Morneau Shepell Inc. (6,7,14) Transcontinental Inc. (6,7,10,14) Chorus Aviation Inc. (6,7) Enbridge Inc (6,7) Manitoba Telecom Services Inc. (6,7) MCAN Mortgage Corporation (6,7) Sun Life Financial (6,7) 2 National Bank Financial Inc. has acted as an underwriter with respect to this issuer within the past 12 months. 3 National Bank Financial Inc. has provided investment banking services for this issuer within the past 12 months. 4 National Bank Financial Inc. or an affiliate has managed or co-managed a public offering of securities with respect to this issuer within the past 12 months. 5 National Bank Financial Inc. or an affiliate has received compensation for investment banking services from this issuer within the past 12 months. 6 National Bank Financial Inc. or an affiliate has a non-investment banking services related relationship during the past 12 months. 7 The issuer is a client, or was a client, of National Bank Financial Inc. or an affiliate within the past 12 months. 10 National Bank Financial Inc. makes a market in the securities of this issuer, at the time of this report publication. 14 A member of the Board of Directors of National Bank Financial Inc. is also a member of the Board of Directors or is an officer of this issuer.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz