Wolvercote Railway Tunnel

Wolvercote Railway Tunnel
Geoff Billington
Greena Ecological Consultancy
• Wolvercote railway tunnel is 133m long carrying the local Chilterns
Oxford to Banbury rail line
• The tunnel contains a single track set slightly off centre
• In the past it contained two tracks set at a lower level
• It is formed with a roof lining of brick over stone abutments
• There are a couple of cracks and five deep drain holes in the roof and
holes in the walls where mortar is missing
The tunnel lies beneath the very busy and highly
illuminated Oxford northern ring road
A40
A34
OXFORD
 The line is used by local passenger trains and a small
number of freight trains, restricted to a maximum
speed around 30mph up to a couple of dozen trains
use the line through the tunnel in a 24hr period
 Few or no trains run between 2200 and 0500
 The proposal is to upgrade the line back to a twin
track with increased frequency and speed, with
maximum of up to 80 trains per day, around a dozen
trains passing between 2130 & 0630 only a couple of
freight trains passing between 0030 & 0530
 Passenger trains to be able to travel up to 70 mph,
freight trains continue restricted to 30 mph
 The scheme has been the subject of a public inquiry
November 2010 to January 2011 the Inquiry was reopened in May 2012 mainly because of concerns
over the potential effects to bats
 Approval for the scheme was given in October 2012
Initial surveys
A series of surveys were undertaken by between July
2009 and May 2010 to inform an Environmental
Statement
 7 dusk emergence surveys
 1 dawn re-entry survey
 Full night of monitoring in autumn
 3 night roost counts
 4 separate nights of Anabat monitoring
 17 continuous nights of Anabat monitoring in spring
 3 hibernation surveys
 Single night of autumn trapping
2009/ 2010 findings
 Maximum of 13 myotis bats day roosting in the tunnel
during September, none in April & May
 Two Natterer’s hibernating
 Daubenton’s, Natterer’s, Common & Soprano pipistrelle
bats day roosting
 Brown long-eared night roost
 A low level of swarming possibly occurring in early
September
 The tunnel provides an important corridor for
Daubenton’s, Natterer’s, Pipistrelle and Long-eared bats
 Noctule and Leislers bats feed in the northern cutting
Initial 2010 proposed
solution/ mitigation
 Exclude bats from roosting in the tunnel
 Use lighting to prevent bats from using the
tunnel
 Create a small scale replacement tunnel into the
embankment to function as a year round roost and
possibly a swarming site as well
2010 proposal for hibernacula within
embankment
Taken from the
Environmental
Statement
Taken from the
Environmental
Statement
Summer 2010 onwards
A series of surveys undertaken by Greena 2010 - 2012
 Annually
2 dusk emergence surveys in September
Bat box inspection in September
Up to 8 weeks Anabat or Batcorder static bat detector monitoring
between August & October
Hibernation survey
 2010
3 nights of autumn trapping survey in 2010
 2011
42 nights of lighting trial study in August & September including 9
nights of observations & 7 emergence surveys
 2012
April 2012 Batcorder static bat detector monitoring for 4 weeks
2 radio tracking studies in May & September
Off site transect and static bat detector monitoring
Casualty survey
2010 late summer/ autumn swarming survey
• Three
sessions were carried out during August &
September 2010
• Surveyors set up mist nets and harp traps across both
entrances to catch bats after the trains had finished for
the night
• Two harp traps were set up side by side at one
entrance with shielding netting attached to either side
and beneath traps to divert bats into them
• Two levels of mist nets were set up across the other
entrance
• Surveyors stationed themselves close to the mist nets
and remained there for most of the remainder of the
night leaving by 0500
2010 autumn swarming survey captures
10
9
8
7
6
27/08/2010
5
01/09/2010
4
13/09/2010
3
2
13/09/2010
1
01/09/2010
0
Daubenton's
Natterer's
27/08/2010
Pipistrelle
Long-eared
Emergence surveys
• Two emergence counts have been carried out each
September as peak bat numbers have been found to
occur at this time of year
• Surveyors stationed themselves at each tunnel
entrance equipped with radio sets so overall
movements of bats in or out of either entrance could
be determined
• The emergence surveys were conducted when trains
were still operating
Maximum monthly emergence counts
14
12
10
8
Myotis
6
Pipistrelle
Long-eared
4
2
0
Long-eared
Pipistrelle
Myotis
Hibernation
2.5
2
1.5
Natterer's
Daubenton's
1
0.5
0
Jan-10
Jan-11
Jan-12
Static bat detector monitoring
• Initially in 2009 & 2010 monitoring was just carried out
at one of the entrances this was extended to both
entrances and the middle of the tunnel in 2011
• Over the first three years Anabat detectors were used
• In 2012 the system has been changed to Batcorders as
they provide much higher quality results, are calibrated
to all be of the same sensitivity and have bespoke auto
ID software that facilitates relatively easy handling of
thousands of files and produces consistent analysis
• To compare Anabat and Batcorder results a conversion
factor based on comparison research by Adams,
Jantzen, Hamilton & Fenton published in 2012 has been
used
Batcorders in 2012
• Box units were used that
contain their own waterproof
microphone, the Batcorder, a
control unit and 10A lead acid
battery they will operate for
around 5 weeks
• Daily after the end of recording
sequence the control unit
transmits: battery voltage, SDHC
card space, number of files
recorded the previous night and
a test tone transmission to check
the microphone performance
• Monitoring is carried
out for two months
August - October and
will carry on until 2017
Anabat recordings 2010 & 2011
Bat boxes
 A variety of 20 Schwegler bat boxes were installed
in early 2011 on trees in the cuttings either side of the
tunnel as alternative roosting sites
 Inspection in September 2011 showed two being
used by individual Pipistrelle bats, a male Soprano
pipistrelle was present in one
 September 2012 found the male bat with a harem
of 6 females in one of boxes
 Monitoring will carry on until 2017
2011 lighting trial research study
At the request of Natural England a full scale trial of a lighting system
outlined in a draft EPS licence application was conducted in August,
September & October 2011
• A computer controlled
system was installed to
control light sequences
• Lighting commences
in the middle of the
tunnel and then within
half a minute spreading
out to both entrances
Lighting system design
Lighting trial
o The design brief was to work with minimum level of lighting to avoid dazzle
risk to train drivers.
o First set of lights produced around 40 lux, the effects on bats started to
decrease markedly within a week, suggesting a number of them were rapidly
getting aclimatised to the lighting levels
o Lights were changed and the level increased to around 80 lux, this had a
pronounced and sustained effect of positive displacement to safety of around
2/3 of the bats.
o The sequence of lighting was designed to replicate the maximum possible
number and length of trains in any night expected to occur in the future
o Four surveyors stationed themselves at entrances and in the tunnel and
recorded over a continuous period of up to 6hrs with up to 43 sequences
o 8 min total sequence: 1 minute observation before lights start, 2min
illumination, 2 minutes until after lights off, then 3 minute break before
starting again, bats scored negative if staying in flight in the tunnel and
positive if they headed rapidly out or went to roost
Displacements
Lighting trial conclusions
 Bats are
not disturbed from night roosting in crevices some
actively seek to enter into crevices when the lights come on
particularly looking for places in less illuminated places such as
immediately above the light units
 Over 60% of bats were displaced to safety by the 80 lux
lighting
 The effects on the bats are very short term within seconds
the majority of bats that had exited from the tunnel re-entered
 Higher light levels will increase the percentage of positive
displacement
 To ensure bats have sufficient night roost sites boards/ tiles
will be fastened to walls above each of the lighting units to
provide night roosting sites
2012 baseline survey year
Hibernation
Winter inspection
Radio tracking
Two sessions of trapping, tagging and ringing bats
tracking 18 bats in May and 23 in September for two
week periods, including use of unmanned radio tag
loggers to record when tagged bats visit the tunnel area
Bat detector survey transects
Three 7km long transects of the wider area along rivers
and the canal with 1 week static monitoring both
carried out in August and repeated in September
2012
Casualty surveys
Carried out whilst attending for other surveys or
equipment maintenance on 21 nights
Static bat detector monitoring surveys
12 weeks: 4 in April, 8 between August & October
Bat boxes
Inspection in September
Emergence surveys
Two surveys in September
Casualty scavenger survey
Using 10 wildlife video cameras running for a month
14 bat species recorded using the
railway corridor 2009 - 2012
• Common Pipistrelle (Pipistrellus pipistrellus)
• Soprano Pipistrelle (Pipistrellus pygmaeus)
• Nathusius Pipistrelle (Pipistrellus nathusii)
• Noctule (Nyctalus noctula)
• Natterer’s (Myotis nattereri)
• Daubenton’s (Myotis daubentonii)
• Alcathoe (Myotis alcathoe)
• Brandt’s (Myotis brandtii)
• Whiskered (Myotis mystacinus)
• Bechstein’s (Myotis bechsteinii)
• Long Eared (Plecotus spp.)
• Barbastelle (Barbastella barbastellus)
• Leislers (Nyctalus leisleri)
• Lesser Horseshoe (Rhinolophus hipposideros)
Conclusions
 Surveys to date have revealed the importance of the railway corridor and
tunnel as a bat flight route of at least 14 bat species
 The original proposal to lose the tunnel roosts and corridor and has been
abandoned
 The current proposal is to retain the flight corridor through the tunnel,
retain and enhance roosting sites in the tunnel and provide a lighting system
that triggers when a train is coming to alert and move bats out of the way of
trains
 Bats do not breed in the tunnel and only individuals hibernate in winter
 Myotis swarming does not appear to occur here
 Small numbers of Common & Soprano pipistrelle bats occasionally roost in
the tunnel and individual males use it as a lekking site in autumn
 Individuals/ small numbers of Brown long-eared bats roost in the tunnel in
August/ September 2011 swarming activity took place, none was recorded in
2012
 Monitoring will be carried out until 2017
Acknowledgements
• Chilterns Railway for funding the surveys and
research through ERM
• Atkins for providing safety, maintenance & COSS staff
• ERM the overall ecologists
• Natural England for licensing activities
• The residents in Oxford area for tolerating our night
activities
Greena courses & workshops
We run specialist training courses & survey workshops that have included to France & Crete
Bat in Woodlands held in West Somerset has been running since 2002 a
comprehensive view on surveying woodlands with workshops on the techniques including
trapping and visits to tree roosts in Horner Woods where Barbastelle’s roost.
Advanced bat survey techniques
held at Stourhead Estate in Wilts running for
last couple of years, a really good place with lakes for bats in 2011 53 bats of 12 species
were caught, 11 species on the first night, course includes trapping and radio tracking.
European bat workshops 3 years in France and the last two in Crete, running for
the last 5 years, week long trips staying in comfortable Gites, Hotels or Apartments.
Trapping and bat detector surveys in collaboration with local biologists.
Our last trip to Crete in May 2012 we caught nearly 800 bats over the week.
On these workshops we encounter a mixture of bats some we see in the UK and other
species particularly in Crete are unique to the eastern Mediterranean, extensive handling
opportunities.
Intensive training we have supplied small groups or individuals with specialist
technique training including for handling, trapping and radio tracking.
If you are interested in details email me: [email protected] or see our
web site: greenaeco.co.uk or give me a ring 077487 42475