GKE=LA;1K=G>GLMDAFME0GPAF>>=;LK,JG;=KKAF?G>!EGLAGF9D(9F?M9?=
.MFFAF?LALD=GLGP>>=;LK(9F?M9?=
9NA<
$9N9K9
JL@MJ)
#D=F:=J?9:
'9JGD
#MLGOKCA;<
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
)9JC&
(M;9J=DDA;.A;@9J<&
9NA<KGF9
9
=H9JLE=FLG>,KQ;@GDG?Q1FAN=JKALQG>3AK;GFKAF)9<AKGF
:
=H9JLE=FLG>,KQ;@GDG?QJARGF9/L9L=1FAN=JKALQ
;
/;@GGDG>)=<A;AF=1FAN=JKALQG>3AK;GFKAF)9<AKGF
<
,JALRC=J/;@GGDG>)=<A;AF=1FAN=JKALQG>@A;9?G
GJ=KHGF<AF?9ML@GJ 9NA<
$9N9K3
&G@FKGF/L
)9<AKGF3% ,@GF=
"9P!E9AD<9@9N9KOAK;
=<M
GEH=LAF?AFL=J=KLK0@=9ML@GJK<=;D9J=FG;GEH=LAF?AFL=J=KLK
::J=NA9LAGFK 04:GLMDAFMELGPAFLQH=
),;GEHGMF<EMK;D=9;LAGFHGL=FLA9D
!)#=D=;LJGEQG?J9H@Q
)!,EMK;D==NGC=<HGL=FLA9D
0)/LJ9FK;J9FA9DE9?F=LA;KLAEMD9LAGF
:KLJ9;L
(9F?M9?=;9F=NGC=HGO=J>MD=EGLAGFK9F<AF>DM=F;=;GFK=IM=FL9;LAGFKAFJ=9<=JK:MLL@=E=;@9FAKEK
MF<=JDQAF?AFL=J9;LAGFKG>D9F?M9?=9F<=EGLAGF9J=D9J?=DQMFCFGOF
/AF;= 9JOAF=EGLAGF9D
=PHJ=KKAGFK@9N=:==FAEHDA;9L=<AF=EGLAGF9D;G?FALAGF=PH=JA=F;=9F<MF<=JKL9F<AF?:MLL@=
>MF;LAGF9DJGD=G>L@=9>>=;LAN=H=JAH@=JQAK<A>>A;MDLLGL=KL
%F9>AJKL=PH=JAE=FL>9;A9D=D=;LJGEQG?J9H@Q
J=N=9D=<L@9LKAD=FLJ=9<AF?G>=EGLAGF9D9F?JQK9<9F<@9HHQK=FL=F;=K9MLGE9LA;9DDQ=DA;ALK
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
<A>>=J=FLA9DH9LL=JFKG>9;LANALQAF>9;A9DEMK;D=KMK=<AF=PHJ=KKAGFG>;GJJ=KHGF<AF?=EGLAGFKKEADAF?
9F<>JGOFAF?
K=;GF<=PH=JAE=FLL=KL=<L@=>MF;LAGF9DJGD=G>>9;A9D9;LANALQAF=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=
;GEHJ=@=FKAGFAFH9JLA;AH9FLKJ=;=ANAF?AFB=;LAGFKG>:GLMDAFMELGPAF>GJ;GKE=LA;LJ=9LE=FLG>>JGOF
DAF=K
0=EHGJ9JQH9J9DQKAKG>L@=>9;A9DEMK;D=;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADDAJ=KHGFKA:D=>GJHJG<M;AF?9>JGOF
@AF<=J=<HJG;=KKAF?J=D9LAN=LGHJ=AFB=;LAGF:9K=DAF=>GJ9F?JQ9F<K9<K=FL=F;=KO@AD=HJG;=KKAF?>GJ
@9HHQK=FL=F;=KO9KMF9>>=;L=<
0@=H9LL=JFG>=>>=;LK;9FFGL:==PHD9AF=<:Q;@9F?=KAFEGG<
0@=K=
>AF<AF?KKM??=KL9:A<AJ=;LAGF9DDAFC:=LO==F=EGLAGF9F<D9F?M9?=E=<A9L=<AFH9JL:QEGNAF?L@=>9;=
%F9<<ALAGFL@=QG>>=J>J=K@=NA<=F;=>GJ>9;A9D>==<:9;CL@=GJA=KG>=EGLAGF9F<J=HGJL9FGN=D=>>=;LG>
:GLMDAFMELGPAFGF;G?FALAGF
DMJ:
0@AKD9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGFKLM<Q<AK;GN=JKL@9L9KO=KAD=FLDQJ=9<=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=GMJ>9;A9D
EMK;D=K:=;GE=KHGFL9F=GMDQ9;LAN=OAL@;GJJ=KHGF<AF?=EGLAGF9D=PHJ=KKAGFK
)GJ=GN=JH9J9DQKAKG>
>9;A9DEMK;D=KMK=<AF>JGOFAF?KDGOKMF<=JKL9F<AF?G>F=?9LAN=:MLFGLHGKALAN==EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=
%FLJG<M;LAGF
DEGKLGF=@MF<J=<9F<>A>LQQ=9JK9?G 9JOAF:=?9F9F=F<=9NGJLGF9LMJ9DAR=;G?FALAGFOAL@
L@=HM:DA;9LAGFG>0@=!PHJ=KKAGFG>!EGLAGFKAF)9F9F<FAE9DK78
0@==>>GJL;GFLAFM=KLG
;@9DD=F?=AF9J=9K;GFKA<=J=<EGKLMFAIM=DQ@ME9FKM;@9K@A?@GJ<=J;G?FALAGF9F<D9F?M9?=78
0@AK
KLM<QJ=NAKALK 9JOAFXK=9JDQG:K=JN9LAGFKGFL@=JGD=G>>9;A9D=PHJ=KKAGFKAF=EGLAGF9D:=@9NAGJO@AD=AL
K@=<KF=ODA?@LGFL@=AFL=J9;LAGFG>=EGLAGFK9F<D9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGF
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
3@=J=9K;GFL=EHGJ9JQL@=GJA=KG>;G?FALAGF;@9J9;L=JAR=D9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGFAFL=JEKG>
9:KLJ9;LKQE:GDKG>L@GM?@L9F<JMD=K>GJL@=AJE9FAHMD9LAGF78J=;=FL:=@9NAGJ9D9F<F=MJGK;A=FLA>A;
=NA<=F;=KM??=KLKL@9L;GEHJ=@=FKAGFG>OGJ<K9F<K=FL=F;=K<=K;JA:AF?9;LAGFKH=J;=HLAGFK9F<
=EGLAGFKAFNGDN=K9E=FL9DKAEMD9LAGF78L@9L;9DDKGFL@=K9E=F=MJ9DKQKL=EKMK=<AFDAL=J9D9;LAGF
H=J;=HLAGF9F<=EGLAGF78
!NA<=F;=>GJ=EGLAGFKAEMD9LAGFAFD9F?M9?=O9KHJGNA<=<AF9J=;=FL:=@9NAGJ9DKLM<Q
78
,9JLA;AH9FLKJ=9<9F<BM<?=<L@=N9D=F;=G>K=FL=F;=K<=K;JA:AF?HD=9K9FLKALM9LAGFKV5GM=P=;ML=
L@=<A>>A;MDL<AN=>D9OD=KKDQW9F<MFHD=9K9FLKALM9LAGFKV0@=HGDA;=;9JHMDDKMH:=@AF<QGMKAJ=F
:D9JAF?WO@AD=J=9<AF?LAE=KO=J=E=9KMJ=<
MJAF?L@=J=9<AF?L9KCH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=9KC=<LG@GD<9
H=F=AL@=JAFL@=L==L@LGHJG<M;=9KEAD=GJAFL@=DAHKLGHJ=N=FL9KEAD=
0@AKHJG;=<MJ=J=DA9:DQ
AF<M;=K=EGLAGF9DKL9L=KAFH9JLA;AH9FLKAFL@=9:K=F;=G>9O9J=F=KK78
KHJ=<A;L=<J=9<AF?LAE=K>GJ
K=FL=F;=K<=K;JA:AF?HD=9K9FLKALM9LAGFKO=J=>9KL=JO@AD=H9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=KEADAF?L@9FO@AD=L@=QO=J=
HJ=N=FL=<>JGEKEADAF?9F<MFHD=9K9FLK=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=KO=J=>9KL=JO@AD=H9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=
HJ=N=FL=<>JGEKEADAF?L@9FO@AD=L@=QO=J=KEADAF?
0@==>>=;LO9KJ=HDA;9L=<O@=FH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=
9KC=<LGBM<?=O@=L@=JL@=K=FL=F;=KO=J==9KQGJ@9J<LGMF<=JKL9F<
=;9MK=L@=K=FL=F;=K;GFL9AF=<
9DEGKLFG<AJ=;LJ=>=J=F;=LG=EGLAGFKGJ=EGLAGFKL9L=KALO9K;GF;DM<=<L@9L>9;A9D=PHJ=KKAGFK
AF>DM=F;=KAEMD9LAGFG>L@=9;LAGFKAEHDA=<AFL@=K=FL=F;=K9DL@GM?@HJG;=KK=KJ=D9L=<LGNGDMFL9JQ
;GFLJGDG>>9;A9DHGKLMJ=;GMD<9DKGHJGNA<=9:9KAK>GJL@=G:K=JN=<AFL=J9;LAGFK
"9;A9D9;LANALQ9F<>==<:9;C@9N=>A?MJ=<AFLG@QHGL@=K=K;GF;=JFAF?=EGLAGF9D=PH=JA=F;=9F<
:=@9NAGJ78AF;DM<AF?H=J;=HLAGF9F<J=;G?FALAGFG>=EGLAGFK789F<=EH9L@Q78
"9;A9DEMK;D=
J=KHGFK=KLG9>>=;LAN=KLAEMDA9J=9MLGE9LA;9F<G;;MJJ9HA<DQ78AFKG;A9D9F<KGDAL9JQ;GFL=PLK789F<
AF>DM=F;==EGLAGF9D>==DAF?K9F<L@GM?@LK78
ML9JGD=>GJ>9;A9D=PHJ=KKAGFAFMF<=JKL9F<AF?
=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=@9KK;9J;=DQ:==F;GFKA<=J=<
$=J=O=L=KLL@=;9MK9DJGD=G>>9;A9D=PHJ=KKAGFKG>=EGLAGFAFMF<=JKL9F<AF?=EGLAGF9D
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
D9F?M9?=
DL@GM?@=9JDQH=JAH@=J9DL@=GJA=KG>;G?FALAGF78E9<=DALLD=HJG?J=KKAF<=K;JA:AF?
N=J:9D:=@9NAGJ=FLAJ=DQAFH@QKAGDG?A;9DL=JEKF=OL@=GJQ9F<E=L@G<K@9N=HJG<M;=<>J=K@=NA<=F;=>GJ
9JGD=AFD9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGFG>L@=F=MJ9DKQKL=EK;GFLJGDDAF?L@=H=JAH@=JQ9F<L@=H=JAH@=JQ
ALK=D>
1KAF?LJ9FK;J9FA9DE9?F=LA;KLAEMD9LAGF0)/#D=F:=J?9F<;GDD=9?M=K78@9<H9JLA;AH9FLK
J=9<K=FL=F;=KOGJ<:QOGJ<O@AD=9:JA=>0)/HMDK=O9K9HHDA=<LGL@=9J=9G>EGLGJ;GJL=P>GJ
;GFLJGDDAF?H9JLA;AH9FLKX@9F<EGN=E=FLK
)MK;D==NGC=<HGL=FLA9DK)!,KJ=;GJ<=<>JGEL@=9>>=;L=<
@9F<O=J=G:K=JN=<O@=FL@=0)/HMDK=O9K<=DAN=J=<9LL@==F<G>L@=K=FL=F;=9F<<MJAF?
HJ=K=FL9LAGFG>L@=N=J:OAL@L@==>>=;LKLJGF?=KL>GJN=J:KL@9L<=K;JA:=LJ9FK>=J=
?
V?AN=WNK
VKE=DDW
"AF<AF?H=JAH@=J9DEG<MD9LAGF;GFL=EHGJ9F=GMKOAL@N=J:HJ=K=FL9LAGFKM??=KLK9>MF;LAGF
JGD=:=QGF<EGLGJAE9?=JQO@=J=EG<MD9LAGFOGMD<EGKLDAC=DQG;;MJ9LL@==F<G>L@=K=FL=F;=
%FL@AKKLM<QO=L=KL=<O@=L@=J;GEHJ=@=FKAGFG>=EGLAGF9DK=FL=F;=K=DA;ALKKHGFL9F=GMK
>9;A9DEMK;D=9;LANALQ9KKG;A9L=<OAL@L@=;GJJ=KHGF<AF?=EGLAGF9F<O@=L@=JHJ=N=FLAGFG>KM;@
9;LANALQ@AF<=JK=EGLAGF9DK=FL=F;=MF<=JKL9F<AF?
.=KMDLK
!PH=JAE=FL
"GJL@=>AJKL=PH=JAE=FLO=MK=<!)#J=;GJ<AF?>JGEL@=>9;A9DEMK;D=KAFNGDN=<AFHJG<M;AF?
=PHJ=KKAGFKG>@9HHAF=KKRQ?GE9LA;MKE9BGJ9F<GJ:A;MD9JAKG;MDA9F<9F?=J9F<K9<F=KK;GJJM?9LGJ
KMH=J;ADAAO@AD=H9JLA;AH9FLKJ=9<K=FL=F;=K<=K;JA:AF?9F?JQK9<9F<@9HHQKALM9LAGFKK==09:D=
,9JLA;AH9FLKOGE=FE=FNA=O=<K=FL=F;=KHJ=K=FL=<AF<ANA<M9DDQGF9;GEHML=JK;J==FK=H9J9L=<
:QL@J==K=;GF<H9MK=K9F<L@=AJL9KCO9KLGJ=9<9F<MF<=JKL9F<L@=K=FL=F;=
5!/*+
;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGF>GDDGO=<9J9F<GEL@AJ<G>L@=K=FL=F;=KLG=F;GMJ9?=K=FL=F;=;GEHJ=@=FKAGF
*GJ=>=J=F;=LG=EGLAGFO9KE9<=AFL@=L9KCAFKLJM;LAGFK
,9JLA;AH9FLKMK=<L@=AJJA?@L@9F<KLGHJ=KK9
C=Q9>L=JJ=9<AF?L@=K=FL=F;=9F<L@=AJD=>L@9F<KLG9FKO=JL@=;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGFK
,9JLA;AH9FLK
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
O=J=LGD<L@=HMJHGK=G>L@=KLM<QO9KLGE=9KMJ=KCAF;GF<M;L9F;=<MJAF?J=9<AF?
3=;GEH9J=<
9;LANALQ9EGF?L@=L@J==EMK;D=?JGMHK<MJAF?J=9<AF?G>9F?JQK9<9F<@9HHQK=FL=F;=K
"A?MJ=
<=HA;LKL@=LAE=;GMJK=9F<9N=J9?=!)#9;LANALQ;@9F?=>JGE:9K=DAF=AF=9;@EMK;D=?JGMH9;JGKK>GMJ
IM9JL=JKG>K=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=>GJ9F?JQK9<9F<@9HHQK=FL=F;=K
)MK;D=9;LAN9LAGFH9LL=JFK<A>>=J=<9;;GJ<AF?LGL@=K=FL=F;==EGLAGF"
,
OAL@
KA?FA>A;9FL<A>>=J=F;=KG;;MJJAF?AF;GJJM?9LGJ"
,
RQ?GE9LA;MKE9BGJ"
,
9F<GJ:A;MD9JAKG;MDAEMK;D=K"
,
K==)9L=JA9DK9F<)=L@G<K>GJ9F9DQKAK
<=L9AD
"GJL@=>JGOFEMK;D=;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAA:GL@/9<9F<F?JQK=FL=F;=K=DA;AL=<?J=9L=J
9;LANALQL@9F$9HHQK=FL=F;=K
"GJL@=;@==CJ9AKAF?EMK;D=RQ?GE9LA;MKE9BGJ$9HHQK=FL=F;=K
=DA;AL=<?J=9L=J9;LANALQL@9F:GL@/9<9F<F?JQK=FL=F;=K
"GJ9;LANALQAFL@==Q=KIMAFLGJ:A;MD9JAK
G;MDAEMK;D=:GL@$9HHQ9F<F?JQK=FL=F;=K=DA;ALAF??J=9L=J9;LANALQL@9F/9<K=FL=F;=K
0@MK
;GEHJ=@=F<AF?K=FL=F;=K<=K;JA:AF?<A>>=J=FL=EGLAGF9DKALM9LAGFKHJG<M;=K<A>>=J=FLA9D>9;A9DEMK;D=
9;LANALQMK=<AFL@=;GJJ=KHGF<AF?=EGLAGF9D=PHJ=KKAGFK
0@AK>AF<AF?KM??=KLK9E=;@9FAKE:QO@A;@E9FAHMD9LAGFG>>9;A9DHGKLMJ=9>>=;LK=EGLAGF9D
D9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGF78
"9;A9D=D=;LJGEQG?J9H@Q!)#KLM<A=K@9N=>GMF<=EGLAGFKH=;A>A;
EMK;D=J=KHGFK=KAF9J9F?=G>KLAEMDAAF;DM<AF?=EGLAGF9DAE9?=JQ789F<=EGLAGF9D>9;=K78
,9LL=JFKG>>9;A9D>==<:9;CEA?@L;GFLJA:ML=LGL@=KAEMD9LAGFG>=EGLAGFK<=K;JA:=<AFD9F?M9?=EM;@9K
L@=QE9Q<GAFKG;A9DJ=;G?FALAGF9F<MF<=JKL9F<AF?G>=EGLAGFK78
%>KGHJ=N=FLAF?L@=
9HHJGHJA9L=>9;A9D=PHJ=KKAGFK9Q9>JGOFO@=FMF<=JKL9F<AF?9K9<K=FL=F;=V5GMGH=FQGMJ=E9AD
AF:GPGFQGMJ:AJL@<9QLG>AF<FGF=O=E9ADKWE9QEG<MD9L=9;LAN9LAGFG>=EGLAGF9DKQKL=EKAFNGDN=<AF
=PH=JA=F;AF?K9<F=KK9F<L@MK@AF<=J;GEHJ=@=FKAGFG>L@=K=FL=F;=
0@AKE=;@9FAKEJ=;=AN=KKMHHGJL
>JGEL@=>AF<AF?L@9L:DG;CAF?>9;A9DEAEA;JQK=D=;LAN=DQAEH9AJKJ=;G?FALAGFG>=EGLAGF9D>9;A9D
=PHJ=KKAGFK78
%F9<<ALAGF;GEHD=L=H9J9DQKAKG>L@=;GJJM?9LGJEMK;D=<MJAF?9F=EGLAGF=PHJ=KKAGF
AEAL9LAGFL9KCJ=<M;=K9;LAN9LAGFAFF=MJ9D;=FL=JKAFNGDN=<AF=EGLAGFHJG;=KKAF?F9E=DQL@=9EQ?<9D9
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
L@=GJ:ALG>JGFL9D;GJL=P9F<:J9AFKL=E;=FL=JKAFNGDN=<AF9MLGFGEA;J=?MD9LAGF78
!PH=JAE=FL
%F9K=;GF<=PH=JAE=FLO=L=KL=<O@=L@=JH9J9DQKAKG>>9;A9DEMK;D=KMK=<AF=PHJ=KKAF?F=?9LAN=
=EGLAGFK;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAAOGMD<K=D=;LAN=DQ@AF<=J;GEHJ=@=FKAGFG>K=FL=F;=K<=K;JA:AF?9F?JQ
9F<K9<J=D9LAN=LG@9HHQKALM9LAGFK
3=J=;JMAL=<H9JLA;AH9FLKO@GO=J=H9LA=FLKJ=;=ANAF?;GKE=LA;
LJ=9LE=FLG>?D9:=DD9J>JGOFDAF=KOAL@KM:;ML9F=GMKAFB=;LAGFKG>:GLMDAFMELGPAFLQH=
04
,9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=>AJKLLAE=04H9LA=FLKJ=;=ANAF?AFB=;LAGFKMFALKGFDQAFL@=>JGOF
EMK;D=;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAA
04AK9HGL=FLF=MJGLGPAFL@9L;9MK=KL=EHGJ9JQEMK;MD9J<=F=JN9LAGF:Q
HJ=N=FLAF?J=D=9K=G>9;=LQD;@GDAF=>JGEHJ=KQF9HLA;N=KA;D=K9LL@=F=MJGEMK;MD9JBMF;LAGFO@A;@
<=;J=9K=K=PLJ9>MK9DEMK;D=>A:=J9;LANALQ9F<EMK;D=KLJ=F?L@78
0GPA;ALQAK9KKG;A9L=<OAL@9J=<M;LAGF
AFL@=;GEHGMF<EMK;D=9;LAGFHGL=FLA9D),OAL@AF@GMJKG>AFLJ9EMK;MD9JAFB=;LAGFHJG<M;AF?
DG;9DEMK;D=O=9C=FAF?OAL@AF<9QK9F<H=9CO=9C=FAF?G>L@=),9JGMF<<9Q78
%FLOGK=KKAGFK:=>GJ=9F<LOGO==CK9>L=J04LJ=9LE=FL>=E9D=H9JLA;AH9FLKXL9KCO9KLG
J=9<L@=K9E=K=FL=F;=KMK=<AF!PH=JAE=FL<=K;JA:AF?9F?JQ@9HHQ9F<K9<KALM9LAGFK9F<LGHJ=KK9
C=Q:G9J<:MLLGF9KKGGF9KL@=Q@9<MF<=JKLGG<L@=K=FL=F;=
0@=<=H=F<=FLN9JA9:D=O9KK=FL=F;=
J=9<AF?LAE=9F<FGJ=>=J=F;=LG=EGLAGFO9KE9<=AFL@=L9KCAFKLJM;LAGFKK==)9L=JA9DK9F<)=L@G<K
>GJ<=L9AD
)=9KMJAF?L@=;@9F?=AFJ=9<AF?LAE=K:=>GJ=9F<9>L=J04LJ=9LE=FL9DDGO=<MKLGL=KLL@=
HJ=<A;LAGFL@9LH9J9DQKAKG>L@=;GJJM?9LGJEMK;D=K=D=;LAN=DQ@AF<=JK;GEHJ=@=FKAGFG>9F?JQ9F<K9<
K=FL=F;=KJ=D9LAN=LG@9HHQK=FL=F;=K
0@=J=O9K9E9AF=>>=;LG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGF"
,
.=9<AF?LAE=KO=J=KA?FA>A;9FLDQDGF?=J>GJF?JQK=FL=F;=KL@9F>GJ/9<GJ$9HHQK=FL=F;=K
9;;GJ<AF?LGHGKL@G;L=KLK
0@=;@9F?=AFJ=9<AF?LAE=K9;JGKKL@=LOGK=KKAGFK<=H=F<=<GFK=FL=F;=
=EGLAGF"
,
"A?MJ=
,9AJ=<K9EHD=KLL=KLKJ=N=9D=<9F?JQK=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=K
AFEADDAK=;GF<KO=J=KA?FA>A;9FLDQDGF?=JAFL@=K=;GF<K=KKAGFE=9F/ L@9FAFL@=
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
>AJKLK=KKAGFE=9F/ L
,
/AEAD9JDQK9<K=FL=F;=KJ=9<AF?LAE=K
O=J=DGF?=JAFL@=K=;GF<K=KKAGFE=9F/ L@9FAFL@=>AJKLK=KKAGFE=9F
/ L
,
*G;@9F?=KO=J=G:K=JN=<AF@9HHQK=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=K
KAEAD9JH9LL=JFG>KA?FA>A;9F;=O9K>GMF<O@=F;GFLJGDDAF?>GJL@==>>=;LG>K=FL=F;=D=F?L@GFJ=9<AF?
LAE=KK=="A?MJ=9F<)9L=JA9DK9F<)=L@G<K
+F==PHD9F9LAGF>GJL@AKH9LL=JFAK:9K=<GF;@9F?=KAFH9JLA;AH9FLKXEGG<KL9L=
*9E=DQL@=
AF;J=9K=AFH9JLA;AH9FLKXF=?9LAN=K=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=KE9QJ=>D=;L?J=9L=J9FPA=LQ<MJAF?L@=>AJKL
K=KKAGF9F<L@MKL@=H9LL=JFAF<A;9L=K9J=D=9K=>JGEF=?9LAN=9>>=;L
0GL=KLL@AKHGKKA:ADALQL@=
,*/*GO9K=D>J=HGJLE=9KMJ=G>HGKALAN=9F<F=?9LAN=9>>=;LO9K9<EAFAKL=J=<LGH9JLA;AH9FLKAF
L@==PH=JAE=FL9LL@==F<G>=9;@J=9<AF?K=KKAGFK==)9L=JA9DK9F<)=L@G<K
.=KMDLKG>H9AJ=<K9EHD=K
LL=KLKAF<A;9L=9KA?FA>A;9FL<=;J=9K=AFHGKALAN=9>>=;L>JGEK=KKAGFLGK=KKAGFL
,
:ML
FG;@9F?=AFF=?9LAN=9>>=;LL
,
"A?MJ=
3@=J=9KL@=<=;J=9K=AFHGKALAN=EGG<AK
AF;GFKAKL=FLOAL@EGG<;GF?JM=F;Q9;;GMFLKAL;GMD<KMHHGJL9EGG<E9AFL=F9F;=9;;GMFLAFO@A;@
HGKALAN=EGG<AK9KKG;A9L=<OAL@=>>GJLLGHJGDGF?HJG;=KKAF?G>HGKALAN=KLAEMDA9F<LG9NGA<HJG;=KKAF?
G>F=?9LAN=KLAEMDA
$GO=N=J9;;MJ9;QJ9L=K>GJF=?9LAN=KLAEMDA9J=FGLDGO=JAFL@=>AJKLK=KKAGF9KKM;@
9F9;;GMFLOGMD<HJ=<A;L
"MJL@=JEGJ=;@9F?=KAFJ=9<AF?LAE=K9F<J=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?LAE=K>GJ=EGLAGF9D
K=FL=F;=K<A<FGL;GJJ=D9L=KA?FA>A;9FLDQOAL@;@9F?=KAF=AL@=JHGKALAN=GJF=?9LAN=KM:K;9D=KG>L@=
,*/
0@MK;@9F?=KAFEGG<9J=FGLDAC=DQLG:=J=KHGFKA:D=>GJL@==>>=;LAF;GEHJ=@=FKAGFLAE=K
AK;MKKAGF
.=KMDLKG>L@=LOG=PH=JAE=FLK<=EGFKLJ9L=L@9L;GEHJ=@=F<AF?=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=?=F=J9L=K
=EGLAGFKH=;A>A;>9;A9D=>>=J=F;=O@AD=H=JAH@=J9D<=F=JN9LAGFG>L@=>9;A9DEMK;MD9LMJ=K=D=;LAN=DQ
@AF<=JK=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=MF<=JKL9F<AF?
0@=K=>AF<AF?K9J=;GFKAKL=FLOAL@KAEMD9LAGF9;;GMFLKG>
=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGFAFO@A;@L@=F=MJ9DKQKL=EKMK=<AF=PH=JA=F;AF?=EGLAGFK9J=9DKG
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
MK=<LGMF<=JKL9F<=EGLAGFKAFD9F?M9?=78
0@=>AF<AF?K9DKGG>>=J=NA<=F;=G>9>MF;LAGF9DJGD=>GJ
H=JAH@=J9D9;LAN9LAGFAFMF<=JKL9F<AF?=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=O@AD=;GFLJA:MLAF?LGL@==NA<=F;=>GJ>9;A9D
>==<:9;CL@=GJA=KG>=EGLAGFJ=D9L=<HJG;=KKAF?
#AN=FALKCFGOFF=MJGH@QKAGDG?A;9DE=;@9FAKEKG>9;LAGFL@=J=9J=LOGHJAF;AHD=O9QK
04AF<M;=<H9J9DQKAKG>>9;A9DEMK;D=KEA?@L9>>=;L;GEHJ=@=FKAGFG>=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=
%F:GL@
;9K=KO=9KKME=L@9LL@=9>>=;L=<F=MJ9DKQKL=EK9J=J=;JMAL=<<MJAF?9KAEMD9LAGFG>L@=D9F?M9?=
;GFL=FL
"AJKL9KKM??=KL=<:Q=9JDQH=JAH@=J9DL@=GJA=KG>;G?FALAGF04E9QAEH9AJD9F?M9?=HJG;=KKAF?
L@JGM?@ALKH=JAH@=J9DEMK;D=J=D9P9FL=>>=;LK
Q:DG;CAF?;@GDAF=J?A;=PG;QLGKAK9LL@==PLJ9>MK9D
F=MJGEMK;MD9JBMF;LAGF049LL=FM9L=KL@=HGKLKQF9HLA;J=KHGFK=LGNGDMFL9JQ9F<KHGFL9F=GMKEGLGJ
=>>=J=FLHJG;=KK=K78
*=MJGEMK;MD9J:DG;C9<=AK=KL9:DAK@=<OAL@AF@GMJKG>LJ=9LE=FLAFJ9LK78
9DL@GM?@AF@ME9FKDG;9DEMK;D=O=9CF=KKAKFGLG:K=JN=<KGGF=JL@9F@GMJK9>L=JAFB=;LAGF>GJ
;GKE=LA;LJ=9LE=FL78
9K=<GFALKAFALA9DH=JAH@=J9D=>>=;LK04;GMD<<AKJMHL=EGLAGF9DHJG;=KK=KL@9L<=H=F<GF
KL=J=GLQH=<H9LL=JFKG>>9;A9D>==<:9;C78
DL=JF9LAN=DQL@=EGLGJ=P=;MLAN=KQKL=EK>GJ;GFLJGDDAF?
L@=9>>=;L=<EMK;D=KEA?@LJ=KHGF<LGH=JAH@=J9D:DG;C9<=OAL@AF;J=9K=<GMLHML:ML9DGKKG>KH=;A>A;ALQ
9KAKK==FAFL@=;GJLA;9DJ=KHGFK=LGEMK;D=>9LA?M=78
%F=AL@=J;9K=9DGKKG>KH=;A>A;ALQAFL@=
E=;@9FAKE>GJKAEMD9LAF?=EGLAGFKAFD9F?M9?=OGMD<AEH9AJE=9FAF?J=KGDMLAGFAFD9F?M9?=
;GEHJ=@=FKAGF
J9HA<E=;@9FAKEAK;GFKAKL=FLOAL@G:K=JN9LAGFKG>AEE=<A9L==>>=;LKG>>9;A9DHGKLMJ=
E9FAHMD9LAGF78
J=D9L=<;GFKA<=J9LAGFAKL@9L04E9Q@9N=<AJ=;L=>>=;LKGFL@=*/NA9J=LJG?J9<=LJ9FKHGJLAF
L@=9>>=J=FLEGLGF=MJGF
0@GM?@MFLADJ=;=FLDQ=NA<=F;=>GJ<AJ=;L=>>=;LKGFL@=*/O=J=O=9C9J=;=FL
>AF<AF?AFJ9LKK@GO=<L@9L9;LAN=04;9F:=LJ9FKHGJL=<9F<LJ9FK;QLGK=<LG9>>=J=FLKQF9HK=KO@=J=AL
;9F;9MK=F=MJGDG?A;9D;@9F?=KJ=EGL=>JGEL@=AFB=;LAGFKAL=78
$=J=9?9AFA>KM;;=KK>MD=P=;MLAGFG>
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
=>>=J=FLEGLGJH9LL=JFKAKF=;=KK9JQ>GJD9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGFL@=FJ=LJG?J9<=<=F=JN9LAGF;GMD<
;GF;=AN9:DQAFL=J>=J=OAL@D9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGF
/=;GF<04AFB=;LAGFKE9Q9>>=;LD9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGFL@JGM?@;=FLJ9D;@9F?=KK=;GF<9JQLG
H=JAH@=J9D=>>=;LK78
/LM<A=KAFJ9LKKM??=KLL@9L049>>=;LK;@GDAF=J?A;HJG;=KKAF?9LL@=AFLJ9>MK9D
BMF;LAGF:DG;CAF??9EE9EGLGJF=JN==F<AF?K9F<J=<M;AF?LGFA;EMK;D=KHAF<D=9>>=J=FL<AK;@9J?=
78
%FEGLGJ;GFLJGDLGFA;9>>=J=FL>==<:9;CAKL@GM?@LLG;GFLJA:ML=LG>GJE9LAGFG>AFL=JF9DEG<=DKG>
L@=KL9L=G>L@=:G<QMK=>MD>GJKH=;A>QAF?EGLGJ;GEE9F<K:=>GJ=9EGN=E=FL@9K:=?MF
,9LA=FLKOAL@
K=N=J=K=FKGJQF=MJGH9L@Q9DGKKG>9>>=J=FL>==<:9;CK@GOKQKL=E9LA;EGN=E=FL=JJGJK;GFKAKL=FLOAL@
9FAF9;;MJ9L=AFL=JF9DEG<=DG>L@=KL9L=G>L@=:G<Q78
"9;A9D>==<:9;CE9Q:=9;GFL=PLK=FKALAN=KGMJ;=G>AF>GJE9LAGF>GJE9AFL9AFAF?9FAFL=JF9D
EG<=DG>L@==EGLAGF9DKL9L=G>L@=:G<QAEHGJL9FL>GJKH=;A>QAF?9<9HLAN=9;LAGFKL@JGM?@ALKAF>DM=F;=
GF;=FLJ9DF=LOGJCK
"9;A9DH9J9DQKAKGN=J9H=JAG<G>O==CKEA?@L?J9<M9DDQAF<M;=HD9KLA;;@9F?=KAF
L@=F=MJ9D;AJ;MALJQMF<=JDQAF?=EGLAGFKL9L=J=HJ=K=FL9LAGF
GFKAKL=FLOAL@L@AKHGKKA:ADALQH9J9DQKAKG>
L@=;GJJM?9LGJEMK;D=LOGO==CKHJAGJLG9F=EGLAGF=PHJ=KKAGFAEAL9LAGFL9KCJ=<M;=<9;LAN9LAGFAF
F=MJ9D;=FL=JKAFNGDN=<AF=EGLAGFHJG;=KKAF?F9E=DQL@=9EQ?<9D9L@=GJ:ALG>JGFL9D;GJL=P9F<
:J9AFKL=E;=FL=JKAFNGDN=<AF9MLGFGEA;J=?MD9LAGFJ=D9LAN=LG9;LAN9LAGFAFL@=K9E=KM:B=;LK:=>GJ=
AFB=;LAGF78
3@=L@=JL@=K=;@9F?=K9J=<M=LG=9JDQH=JAH@=J9D=>>=;LKGJK=;GF<9JQ;=FLJ9D;@9F?=K
>JGE04AFB=;LAGFK@GMD<:=L=KL=<
%F9<<ALAGFGMJJ=KMDLKKM??=KLL@=F==<>GJ>MJL@=JJ=K=9J;@GFL@=
;G?FALAN=9F<=EGLAGF9D=>>=;LKG>;GKE=LA;04AFB=;LAGF
F9;;GMFLG>@GO>==<:9;C>JGE=EGLAGF9DKL9L=K?MA<=KKAEMD9LAGFAFD9F?M9?=AKKM??=KL=<:Q
9J=;=FLL@=GJQG>J=AF>GJ;=E=FLD=9JFAF?78
=;9MK=L@=EGKLJ=O9J<AF?9;LAGFAF9KALM9LAGF<=H=F<K
GFL@=;MJJ=FLKL9L=G>L@=:G<Q9F<L@=;MJJ=FLKL9L=G>L@==FNAJGFE=FL;@GGKAF?L@=EGKL=>>=;LAN=
9;LAGFAF9KALM9LAGFAK<A>>A;MDL
$GO=N=JHJ=<A;LAF?L@=GHLAE9D9;LAGFAKHGKKA:D=A>9F9?=FL;9F
KAEMD9L=L@=J=O9J<G>9HGL=FLA9D9;LAGF?AN=FL@=;MJJ=FL;GFL=PL
%FJ=AF>GJ;=E=FLD=9JFAF?L@=9;LAGF
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
N9DM=>MF;LAGFAKAFALA9DDQD=9JF=<L@JGM?@>==<:9;C>JGEL@==EGLAGF9DKL9L=HJG<M;=<:Q9?AN=F
9;LAGF
+F;=L@AK>MF;LAGF@9K:==FD=9JF=<KAEMD9LAF?9;LAGFKOADDHJG<M;==EGLAGF9DKL9L=>==<:9;C
MK=>MD>GJ?MA<AF?KM:K=IM=FL9;LAGF78
GFKA<=JJ=9<AF?L@=K=FL=F;=V.==DAF?>JGEL@=>A?@LOAL@L@9LKLM::GJF:A?GLQGMKD9EL@=;9J
<GGJ
W GEHJ=@=F<AF?OGJ<KGJH@J9K=K<=K;JA:AF?9;LAGFK=9JDQAFL@=K=FL=F;=?=F=J9L=K9;LANALQAFL@=
F=MJ9DKQKL=EK9F<H=JAH@=JQAF;DM<AF?>9;A9DEMK;D=KMK=<AFJ=9D9;LAGFKGJ=PH=JA=F;=K=
?
9>A?@LGJ
KLM::GJFH=JKGF
"9;A9D>==<:9;CL@=FOGMD<;GFLJA:ML=LG9MLGFGEA;9F<;=FLJ9D;@9F?=K=
?
9JGMK9D
>GJHJ=H9JAF?KM:K=IM=FL=>>=;LAN=9;LAGFK=
?
KD9EEAF?9;9J<GGJ
=;9MK=ALAK=9KA=JLGKAEMD9L=
KD9EEAF?9;9J<GGJO@AD=L@=:G<QAKAF9F9JGMK=<KL9L=L@=K=FL=F;=AK=9KADQMF<=JKLGG<
0@MKLG
:GJJGOL@=OGJ<KG> 9JOAF78L@=>J===PHJ=KKAGFG>=EGLAGFAFL=FKA>A=KGMJ;GEHJ=@=FKAGFG>
=EGLAGF9DD9F?M9?=O@=J=9KL@=J=HJ=KKAGFG>9DDGMLO9J<KA?FKG>=EGLAGF@AF<=JKAL
)9L=JA9DK9F<)=L@G<K
!L@A;K/L9L=E=FL
0@AKKLM<QO9K;GF<M;L=<9;;GJ<AF?LGL@=HJAF;AHD=K=PHJ=KK=<AFL@= =;D9J9LAGFG>$=DKAFCA
0@=KLM<QO9K9HHJGN=<:QL@=!<M;9LAGF9F</G;A9D9F<=@9NAGJ9D/;A=F;=K%FKLALMLAGF9D.=NA=OG9J<
G>L@=1FAN=JKALQG>3AK;GFKAF)9<AKGFHJGLG;GDFME:=J/!
DDH9JLA;AH9FLKHJGNA<=<
OJALL=FAF>GJE=<;GFK=FL>GJL@=;GDD=;LAGFG><9L99F<KM:K=IM=FL9F9DQKAK
/LAEMDMKK=FL=F;=K "GJ=9;@H9JLA;AH9FLL@=KLAEMDA;GFKAKL=<G>K=FL=F;=K$9HHQ/9<9F<F?JQ
;@GK=F9LJ9F<GE>JGE9EGF?K=FL=F;=KG>=9;@N9D=F;=
0@==EGLAGF9DK=FL=F;=KAF;DM<=<L@GK=
MK=<AF789F<GL@=JK?=F=J9L=<AFL@=D9:
0@==EGLAGF9DALQG>L@=J=KMDLAF?K=FL=F;=KO9KN=JA>A=<AF9
FGJEAF?KLM<Q
"GJL@=FGJEAF?=PH=JAE=FLH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=J=;JMAL=<>JGEL@=K9E=KGMJ;=K9KL@=
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
E9AFKLM<QAF=P;@9F?=>GJ;D9KK;J=<AL
,9JLA;AH9FLKNA=O=<L@=K=FL=F;=KGF=9L9LAE=GF9;GEHML=J
K;J==F9F<L@=QO=J=9KC=<LGJ9L==9;@K=FL=F;=9;;GJ<AF?LG=PL=FLL@9LL@=K=FL=F;=KM??=KL=<=9;@G>
>GMJ=EGLAGFK/9<F=KK"=9J$9HHAF=KK9F<F?=JGF9K;9D=>JGEFGL9L9DDLGN=JQEM;@
F?JQK=FL=F;=KO=J=J9L=<9K<=K;JA:AF?9F?=J)
EGJ=L@9FK9<F=KK)
>=9J)
GJ
@9HHAF=KK)
/9<K=FL=F;=KO=J=J9L=<9K<=K;JA:AF?K9<F=KK)
EGJ=L@9F>=9J)
@9HHAF=KK)
GJ9F?=J)
$9HHQK=FL=F;=KO=J=J9L=<9K<=K;JA:AF?@9HHAF=KK)
EGJ=L@9FK9<F=KK)
>=9J)
GJ9F?=J)
"AN=@9HHQK=FL=F;=KO=J=J=HD9;=<9>L=JL@=
FGJEAF?KLM<Q9F<<A<FGL;GFLJA:ML=LGL@=K=E=9FK
"GJ=9;@K=FL=F;=LOGK@GJL5=K*G;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGFKO=J=;GFKLJM;L=<GF=>GJO@A;@
L@=;GJJ=;L9FKO=JO9KV5=KW9F<GF=>GJO@A;@L@=;GJJ=;L9FKO=JO9KV*G
W"GJ=P9EHD=A>L@=K9<
K=FL=F;=V5GMOAK@9DGF??GG<:Q=LGQGMJ>JA=F<O@GAKD=9NAF?>GJ=N=JWO9K>GDDGO=<:QL@=IM=KLAGF
V GQGM9F<QGMJ>JA=F<K9Q?GG<:Q=W L@=FL@=;GJJ=;L9FKO=JOGMD<:=V5=KWO@=J=9KA>ALO9K
>GDDGO=<:QL@=IM=KLAGFV3ADDQGMK==QGMJ>JA=F<9?9AFWL@=FL@=;GJJ=;L9FKO=JOGMD<:=V*G
W
!PH=JAE=FL,9JLA;AH9FLK
0O=FLQ=A?@LH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=AFALA9DDQJ=;JMAL=<>JGE9EGF?1FAN=JKALQG>3AK;GFKAF)9<AKGF
MF<=J?J9<M9L=KLM<=FLK=FJGDD=<AF9FAFLJG<M;LGJQHKQ;@GDG?Q;GMJK=9F<L@=QO=J=;GEH=FK9L=<OAL@
;GMJK=;J=<AL>GJH9JLA;AH9LAGF
0@J==H9JLA;AH9FLKX<9L9O=J=DGKL<M=LG=IMAHE=FL=JJGJ9F<GF=
H9JLA;AH9FLXK<9L9O=J==P;DM<=<>GJ>9ADMJ=LG>GDDGOAFKLJM;LAGFK
9L9>GJL@=J=E9AFAF?LO=FLQ>GMJ
H9JLA;AH9FLKOGE=F9F<E=FO=J=KM:K=IM=FLDQ9F9DQR=<
!)#9HH9J9LMK
!)#<9L9O=J=9;IMAJ=<MKAF?9%+,),KQKL=EOAL@;I'FGOD=<?=KG>LO9J=
78
/A?F9DKO=J=K9EHD=<9L9J9L=G>$R9EHDA>A=<9F<>ADL=J=<GFDAF=OAL@9DGOH9KKK=LLG
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
$R9F<9@A?@H9KKK=LLG$R
AHGD9JKADN=J;@DGJA<==D=;LJG<=KO=J=9>>AP=<LGL@=E=<A9D
;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAARQ?GE9LA;MKE9BGJ9F<GJ:A;MD9JAKG;MDA9F<9J=>=J=F;=?JGMF<=D=;LJG<=O9K
HD9;=<GFL@=>GJ=@=9<9;;GJ<AF?LGL@=J=;GEE=F<9LAGFKG>09KKAF9JQ9F<9;AGHHG78
0@=KA<=G>
=9;@=D=;LJG<=HD9;=E=FLD=>LGJJA?@LO9K;GMFL=J:9D9F;=<9;JGKKH9JLA;AH9FLK>GJ=9;@EMK;D=
?JGMH
!D=;LJG<=KO=J=GML>ALL=<OAL@9<GM:D=KLA;CK=FKGJQ;GDD9JO@GK=;=FL=JO9K>ADD=<OAL@L@=
;GF<M;LAF?E=<AME!D=;LJG?=D9F<L@==D=;LJG<=KO=J=L@=F9>>AP=<LGL@=KCAF
+F;=H9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=
;GFF=;L=<LGL@=!)#=IMAHE=FLL@=<9L9;GDD=;LAGFHJG;=KK:=?9FOAL@9:JA=>9KK=KKE=FLG>L@=
KLJ=F?L@9F<9;;MJ9;QG>L@=J=;GJ<AF?KA?F9D
%F;9K=KO@=J=L@=AEH=<9F;=O9K?J=9L=JL@9FG@EK
L@=K=FKGJKO=J=9<BMKL=<MFLAD9:=LL=JJ=9<AF?O9KG:L9AF=<
=>GJ=J=;GJ<AF?:=?9FH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=
?AN=F9:JA=>K=JA=KG>AFKLJM;LAGFKLGEGN=L@=EMK;D=KG>L@=>9;=AFGJ<=JLGL=KLL@=J=;GJ<AF?KA?F9D
MJAF?L@=LJA9DKK=FL=F;=GFK=L9F<G>>K=LLAE=KO=J=K=FL>JGE!HJAE=LGL@=%+,KG>LO9J=
;GF;MJJ=FLDQOAL@L@=!)#J=;GJ<AF?<9L9
%F%+,K=H9J9L=;@9FF=DKO=J=MK=<LGJ=;GJ<K=FL=F;=
HJ=K=FL9LAGF<9L9GFK=L9F<G>>K=L=N=FLK>GJF?JQ$9HHQ9F</9<K=FL=F;=K;GF;MJJ=FLDQOAL@!)#
<9L9>JGEL@=L@J==EMK;D=J=;GJ<AF?KAL=K
!)#,JG;=<MJ=
1HGF9JJAN9DH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=9KC=<LG;GEHD=L=9;GFK=FL>GJE9F<O=J=?AN=F9>=OEAFML=KLG
@9:ALM9L=LGL@=AJKMJJGMF<AF?K9KL@==PH=JAE=FL=JK?9L@=J=<<9L9GFL@=AJ?=F<=J@9F<=<F=KK9F<<9L=G>
:AJL@
,9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=LGD<L@9LL@=HMJHGK=G>L@==PH=JAE=FLO9KLGE=9KMJ=>9;A9D=D=;LJA;9D9;LANALQ
L@JGM?@K=FKGJKGFL@=KCAF
0@==EGLAGF9DK=FL=F;=KO=J=HJ=K=FL=<MKAF?!,JAE=KG>LO9J=78AF:DG;CKG>
K=FL=F;=KOAL@=9;@:DG;CK=H9J9L=<:Q9:JA=>H9MK=>GJIM=KLAGFK
,9JLA;AH9FLKHJ=KK=<L@=VWC=QGF
L@=C=Q:G9J<FME:=JH9<OAL@L@=JA?@LAF<=P>AF?=JO@=FL@=Q@9<>AFAK@=<J=9<AF?9K=FL=F;=
1HGF
HJ=KKAF?L@AKC=QL@=K=FL=F;=<AK9HH=9J=<9F<9>AP9LAGF;JGKK9HH=9J=<GFL@=K;J==F>GJL@J==K=;GF<K
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
J9F<GEL@AJ<G>L@=LJA9DKAF=9;@:DG;CO=J=>GDDGO=<:Q95=KGJ*G;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGF
,9JLA;AH9FLK9FKO=J=< V5=KW:QHJ=KKAF?L@=V4WC=QOAL@L@=D=>LAF<=P>AF?=JGJV*GWOAL@L@=V6WC=Q
MKAF?L@=D=>LEA<<D=>AF?=J
.=9<AF?LAE=O9KJ=;GJ<=<>GJ=9;@K=FL=F;=9F<L@=<=H=F<=FLN9JA9:D=G>
AFL=J=KLO9K>9;A9DEMK;D=9;LANALQ<MJAF?L@=GFK;J==FK=FL=F;=HJ=K=FL9LAGF
"GJL@GK=LJA9DK<MJAF?O@A;@9;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGF9HH=9J=<L@=IM=KLAGFO9KHJ=K=FL=<
MF<=JL@=OGJ<KVQ=KGJFGIM=KLAGF
W 0@=J=O9K9L@J==K=;GF<H9MK=:=LO==FLJA9DK9F<9GF=K=;GF<
H9MK=HJAGJLGL@=VQ=KGJFGWIM=KLAGF
!9;@:DG;CO9KK=H9J9L=<:Q9H9MK=<MJAF?O@A;@H9JLA;AH9FLK
@9<L@=GHHGJLMFALQLG9KCIM=KLAGFKGJNGA;=;GF;=JFKL@9LE9Q@9N=;GE=MHAFL@=;GMJK=G>L@=
=PH=JAE=FL
0@==PH=JAE=FL=J9F<H9JLA;AH9FL;GEEMFA;9L=<NA99EA;JGH@GF=
,9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=NAKA:D=
LGL@==PH=JAE=FL=JGF9NA<=GK;J==FNA99;GF;=9D=<;9E=J9
"GDDGOAF?;GEHD=LAGFG>L@=LJA9DK!)#
=IMAHE=FLO9KJ=EGN=<9F<L@=H9JLA;AH9FLXK>9;=O9K;D=9F=<
,9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=L@=F<=:JA=>=<GFL@=F9LMJ=G>L@==PH=JAE=FL?AN=F9;J=<ALJ=;=AHL>GJ
;GEH=FK9LAGF9F<L@9FC=<>GJL@=AJH9JLA;AH9LAGF
!)#<9L9HJG;=KKAF? .9O!)#<9L9O=J=HJG;=KK=<OAL@9E9;JGOJALL=FAF)0(HJG?J9EEAF?KG>LO9J=78
"GJ=9;@K=FL=F;=HJ=K=FL9LAGF=N=FLK=H9J9L==N=FL;@9FF=DKO=J=;J=9L=<>GJK=FL=F;=GFK=L9F<
G>>K=L
0@=;GFLAFMGMK!)#<9L9O=J=H9JK=<AFLGEKOAF<GOKKMJJGMF<AF?=9;@K=FL=F;=GFK=L9F<
G>>K=L=N=FL9F<L@=9N=J9?=HGO=JKH=;LJ9D<=FKALQO9K;GEHML=<MKAF?3=D;@XK78E=L@G<9F<
9??J=?9L=<OAL@AF=9;@OAF<GO
1KAF?/,///L9LAKLA;KKG>LO9J=L@=E=9F!)#9;LANALQ<MJAF?=9;@K=FL=F;=HJ=K=FL9LAGFO9K
;GEHML=<:Q9N=J9?AF?L@=9;LANALQ>JGE9DDEKOAF<GOKOAL@AFL@=<MJ9LAGFG>HJ=K=FL9LAGFK
/APL==F
LJA9DK@9<EAKKAF?<9L9<M=LG=PH=JAE=FL=J=JJGJ9F<O=J==P;DM<=<>JGEKM:K=IM=FL9F9DQK=K
9L9>GJ
LOGK9<K=FL=F;=K9F<O=J=GEALL=<>JGEL@=9F9DQKAK>GJDGO;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGF9;;MJ9;Q
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
J9L=KD=KKL@9L9F<<9L9>JGEGF=KM:B=;LO=J=J=EGN=<<M=LG9FMFMKM9DDQDGF?E=9FJ=KHGFK=
LAE=?J=9L=JL@9FK=;GF<K
0JA9DKO=J=LJAEE=<9LKL9F<9J<<=NA9LAGFK>JGEL@=E=9FJ=KHGFK=
LAE=GJK=;GF<KO@A;@=N=JO9KK@GJL=J
0@=GN=J9DD9;;MJ9;QJ9L=>GJ;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGFKO9K
9F<9GF=O9Q*+2<=L=JEAF=<L@9LL@=J=O=J=FGKA?FA>A;9FL<A>>=J=F;=KAF;GEHJ=@=FKAGF
IM=KLAGF9;;MJ9;QJ9L=K9EGF?F?JQ)
/ /9<)
/ 9F<$9HHQ)
/ K=FL=F;=LQH=K"
H
GF=O9Q*+2AF<A;9L=<FGKA?FA>A;9FL
<A>>=J=F;=KAFJ=9<AF?LAE=K:=LO==FF?JQ)/ /9<)/ 9F<$9HHQ
)/ K=FL=F;=K"
H
@9F?=KAF>9;A9DEMK;D=9;LANALQ<MJAF?K=FL=F;=HJ=K=FL9LAGFO=J=;9D;MD9L=<J=D9LAN=LG9
:9K=DAF=9;LANALQ<=>AF=<9KL@=9N=J9?=9;LANALQ<MJAF?EKAEE=<A9L=DQHJAGJLGK=FL=F;=HJ=K=FL9LAGF
K=FL=F;==EGLAGFF?JQ/9<$9HHQ4EMK;D=?JGMH;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAARQ?GE9LA;MKE9BGJ
GJ:A;MD9JAKG;MDAJ=H=9L=<E=9KMJ=K)*+2H=J>GJE=<GFL@=9N=J9?=;@9F?=KAF!)#9;LANALQ
J=N=9D=<9E9AF=>>=;LG>EMK;D=?JGMH"
,
)MDLAHD=H9AJOAK=;GEH9JAKGFK9EGF?
EMK;D=?JGMHKJ=N=9D=<L@9L9;LANALQAFGJ:A;MD9JAKG;MDAEMK;D=K)
/!
O9KKA?FA>A;9FLDQ
?J=9L=JL@9F9;LANALQAF=AL@=JRQ?GE9LA;MKE9BGJEMK;D=K)
/!
GJ;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAA
EMK;D=K)
/!
0@=J=O9KFG<A>>=J=F;=:=LO==FRQ?GE9LA;MKE9BGJ9F<;GJJM?9LGJ
KMH=J;ADAAEMK;D=9;LANALQ
0@=J=O9K9DKG9FAFL=J9;LAGFG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGF9F<EMK;D=?JGMH"
,
0G
<=;GEHGK=L@AKAFL=J9;LAGF9K=JA=KG>O9Q*+2KO=J=H=J>GJE=<GF<9L9>JGE=9;@EMK;D=?JGMH
OAL@KA?FA>A;9FL=>>=;LK>GDDGO=<:QHGKL@G;EMDLAHD=H9AJOAK=;GEH9JAKGFKOAL@9GF>=JJGFA;GJJ=;LAGF
%F;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAA9;LANALQL@=J=O9K9F=>>=;LG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGF"
,
GEH9JAKGFKO=J=KA?FA>A;9FL>GJ$9HHQE=9F
/ N=JKMKF?JQK=FL=F;=KE=9F
/ L
,
9F<$9HHQN=JKMK/9<K=FL=F;=KE=9F
/ L
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
,
:MLFGL>GJF?JQN=JKMK/9<K=FL=F;=KL
,
%FRQ?GE9LA;MKE9BGJ9;LANALQL@=J=O9K9F=>>=;LG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGF"
,
GEH9JAKGFKO=J=KA?FA>A;9FL>GJ$9HHQE=9F
/ N=JKMK/9<K=FL=F;=K
E=9F
/ L
,
9KO=DD9K$9HHQN=JKMKF?JQK=FL=F;=KE=9F
/ L
,
:MLFGL>GJ/9<N=JKMKF?JQK=FL=F;=KL
,
%FGJ:A;MD9JAKG;MDA9;LANALQL@=J=O9K9F=>>=;LG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGF"
,
GEH9JAKGFKO=J=KA?FA>A;9FL>GJF?JQE=9F
/ N=JKMK/9<K=FL=F;=KE=9F
/ L
,
9F<>GJ$9HHQN=JKMK/9<K=FL=F;=KL
,
:MLFGL>GJ
F?JQN=JKMK$9HHQK=FL=F;=KL
,
!PH=JAE=FL)9L=JA9D9F<)=L@G<K
,9JLA;AH9FLK
"GJLQGF=>=E9D=H9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=J=;JMAL=<>JGE9EGF?>AJKLLAE=H9LA=FLKJ=;=ANAF?AFB=;LAGFKG>
:GLMDAFMELGPAF04AFL@=;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAAEMK;D=GFDQ>GJLJ=9LE=FLG>?D9:=DD9J>JGOFDAF=K
,9LA=FLKO=J=AFALA9DDQAF>GJE=<G>L@==PH=JAE=FLL@JGM?@K=N=J9D9J=9;GKE=LA;KMJ?=JQ;DAFA;K9F<
AFL=J=KL=<H9LA=FLKO=J=K;@=<MD=<>GJLJ=9LE=FL<MJAF?9N9AD9:D==PH=JAE=FLLAE=K
,9LA=FLKO@G9?J==<LG
H9JLA;AH9L=AFL@=KLM<QO=J=?AN=F;J=<ALLGO9J<L@=;GKLG>LJ=9LE=FL
1HGF9JJAN9D9LL@=;DAFA;GF
L@=<9QG>L@=>AJKL=PH=JAE=FL9DK=KKAGF9DDH9JLA;AH9FLKHJGNA<=<L@=AJOJALL=FAF>GJE=<;GFK=FL>GJL@=
J=9<AF?=PH=JAE=FL
+F=H9JLA;AH9FLO9K=P;MK=<>JGEL@=KLM<Q:=;9MK=K@=<A<FGLJ=;=AN=04
AFB=;LAGFK
DDGL@=JH9JLA;AH9FLKKM;;=KK>MDDQ;GEHD=L=<:GL@K=KKAGFKG>L@==PH=JAE=FL
04AFB=;LAGF
,@QKA;A9FK9LH9JLA;AH9LAF?;DAFA;KH=J>GJE=<KM:;ML9F=GMK04AFB=;LAGFKAFL@=E=<A9DLGD9L=J9D
H9JLKG>L@=;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAAEMK;D=>GJ;GKE=LA;LJ=9LE=FLG>?D9:=DD9JDAF=K
DDH9JLA;AH9FLKO@GK=
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
<9L9O=J=9F9DQR=<J=;=AN=<AFB=;LAGFKG>:=LO==F9F<EGMK=MFALKG>GLGP:GLMDAFMELGPAF
LQH=E9FM>9;LMJ=<:QDD=J?9F%F;
78
H@QKA;A9F9KK=KK=<LJ=9LE=FL=>>A;9;Q<MJAF?L@=K=;GF<
K=KKAGF=P9;LDQLOGO==CK9>L=JAFALA9DAFB=;LAGF
%F9DD;9K=KL@=LJ=9LE=FLKM;;=KK>MDDQAF<M;=<;GEHD=L=
GJH9JLA9DH9J9DQKAKG>L@=;GJJM?9LGJKMH=J;ADAAEMK;D=:QL@=LAE=G>L@=K=;GF<K=KKAGF
/LAEMDMKK=FL=F;=K
0@=K=FL=F;=K9F<K=FL=F;=HJ=K=FL9LAGFHJG;=<MJ=O=J=A<=FLA;9DLGL@GK=MK=<AF!PH=JAE=FL
=P;=HLL@9LK=FL=F;=KO=J=HJ=K=FL=<MKAF?=AL@=J9F%)0@AFCH9<0(9HLGH;GEHML=JOAL@9
#$R,=FLAME%%%HJG;=KKGJ9F<).)JMFFAF?3AF<GOK4,,JG>=KKAGF9DGJ9F$,GEH9I
F;(9HLGH;GEHML=JOAL@9
#$R,=FLAME)HJG;=KKGJ9F<).)JMFFAF?3AF<GOK4,
,JG>=KKAGF9D
,JG;=<MJ=
1HGF9JJAN9D9LL@=;DAFA;>GJL@=>AJKLK=KKAGFH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=D=<LG9HJAN9L=JGGE:QL@=
=PH=JAE=FL=JAF>GJE=<9:GMLL@=?=F=J9DF9LMJ=G>L@=KLM<Q9F<KA?F=<9;GFK=FL>GJE>GJH9JLA;AH9LAGF
AFL@=J=9<AF?=PH=JAE=FL
,9JLA;AH9FLKJ=;=AN=<AFKLJM;LAGFK>GJL@=J=9<AF?L9KC9F<L@=QO=J=?AN=F
>AN=HJ9;LA;=LJA9DK9F<9FGHHGJLMFALQLG9KCIM=KLAGFK
0@=QO=J=L@=FD=>LLG>AFAK@L@=J=9<AF?L9KC
1HGF;GEHD=LAGFG>L@=J=9<AF?L9KCH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=L@9FC=<>GJL@=AJH9JLA;AH9LAGF9F<<AJ=;L=<LGK==
L@=H@QKA;A9F>GJAFB=;LAGF
1HGF9JJAN9D9LL@=;DAFA;LOGO==CKD9L=J>GJL@=K=;GF<K=KKAGFH9JLA;AH9FLK
O=J=D=<AFLG9HJAN9L=JGGE9F<?AN=FAFKLJM;LAGFK>GJL@=J=9<AF?L9KC
>L=J>AN=HJ9;LA;=LJA9DK9F<9F
GHHGJLMFALQLG9KCIM=KLAGFKH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=D=>L9DGF=LG;GEHD=L=L@=J=9<AF?L9KC
1HGF;GEHD=LAGF
G>L@=L9KCH9JLA;AH9FLKO=J=;GEH=FK9L=<>GJL@=AJH9JLA;AH9LAGFL@9FC=<>GJL@=AJH9JLA;AH9LAGF9F<
<AJ=;L=<LGK==L@=H@QKA;A9F>GJL@=;@=;CMH
"GJL@=D9KLH9JLA;AH9FLKAFL@=KLM<QL@=AL=E
,*/*+3KMJN=QO9K9<EAFAKL=J=<AEE=<A9L=DQMHGF;GEHD=LAGFG>:GL@L@=>AJKL9F<K=;GF<
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
K=KKAGFJ=9<AF?L9KCK
.=9<AF?LAE=9F9DQKAK
9L9O=J==P;DM<=<>JGE9F9DQKAK>GJGF=H9JLA;AH9FL9FGFF9LAN=!F?DAK@KH=9C=JOAL@9F
MFMKM9DDQ@A?@9N=J9?=K=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=K?J=9L=JL@9FEK
%F9<<ALAGFLJA9DKOAL@K=FL=F;=
J=9<AF?LAE=KDGF?=JL@9FK=;GF<KO=J=J=EGN=<>GJ9DDH9JLA;AH9FLK
0@=GN=J9DD9;;MJ9;QJ9L=>GJ
;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGFKO9K
GF<ALAGFE=9FK>GJ;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGF9;;MJ9;Q9J=J=HGJL=<
AF09:D=
"GJ=9;@KM:B=;LJ=9<AF?LAE=KO=J=KM:B=;L=<LG9J=?J=KKAGF9F9DQKAKMKAF?K=FL=F;=D=F?L@9K9
HJ=<A;LGJ
0JA9DKO=J=KM:K=IM=FLDQLJAEE=<9L
KL9F<9J<<=NA9LAGFK>JGEL@=E=9FJ=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?
LAE=>GJ=9;@;GF<ALAGF
K=JA=KG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGFF?JQ/9<$9HHQ4K=KKAGFHJ=AFB=;LAGFHGKLAFB=;LAGF
J=H=9L=<E=9KMJ=K*+2KO=J=;GF<M;L=<GFJ9O9F<J=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?LAE=K9F<GF;GEHJ=@=FKAGF
9;;MJ9;QJ9L=K
%FJ9OJ=9<AF?LAE=KL@=J=O9K9E9AF=>>=;LG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGFO@=J=J=9<AF?LAE=K
AFEADDAK=;GF<KO=J=DGF?=J>GJF?JQK=FL=F;=K)/!L@9F>GJ/9<)/!GJ
$9HHQK=FL=F;=K)/!"
,
0@=E9AF=>>=;LG>K=KKAGF9HHJG9;@=<
KA?FA>A;9F;=OAL@HGKLAFB=;LAGFJ=9<AF?LAE=K)/!DGF?=JL@9FHJ=AFB=;LAGFJ=9<AF?LAE=K
)/!"
,
0@=J=O9K9KA?FA>A;9FLAFL=J9;LAGFG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGF9F<
K=KKAGF"
,
,9AJ=<K9EHD=KLL=KLKJ=N=9D=<F?JQK=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=KAF
EADDAK=;GF<KO=J=KA?FA>A;9FLDQDGF?=JAFL@=K=;GF<K=KKAGF)/!L@9FAFL@=>AJKLK=KKAGF
)/!L
,
/AEAD9JDQ/9<K=FL=F;=KJ=9<AF?LAE=KO=J=DGF?=JAFL@=
K=;GF<K=KKAGF)/!L@9FAFL@=>AJKLK=KKAGF)/!L
,
*G
;@9F?=KO=J=G:K=JN=<AF$9HHQK=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=K:=LO==FL@=>AJKLK=KKAGF)/!9F<
K=;GF<K=KKAGF)/!L
,
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
%FJ=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?LAE=KL@=J=O9K9E9AF=>>=;LG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGFO@=J=J=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?
LAE=KO=J=DGF?=J>GJF?JQK=FL=F;=K)/!L@9F>GJ/9<)/!GJ$9HHQ
K=FL=F;=K)/!"
,
0@=AFL=J9;LAGFG>K=FL=F;==EGLAGF9F<K=KKAGFO9K
KA?FA>A;9FL"
,
,9AJ=<K9EHD=KLL=KLKJ=N=9D=<L@9LF?JQK=FL=F;=J=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?
LAE=KAFEADDAK=;GF<KO=J=DGF?=JAFL@=K=;GF<K=KKAGF)/!L@9FAFL@=>AJKLK=KKAGF
)/!L
,
/AEAD9JDQ/9<K=FL=F;=J=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?LAE=KO=J=DGF?=JAFL@=
K=;GF<K=KKAGF)/!L@9FAFL@=>AJKLK=KKAGF)/!L
,
"GJ
$9HHQK=FL=F;=KL@=J=O9KFG<A>>=J=F;=AFJ=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?LAE=K:=LO==FL@=K=;GF<K=KKAGF)
/!9F<L@=>AJKLK=KKAGF)/!L
,
0@=*+2GF;GEHJ=@=FKAGF9;;MJ9;QJ9L=KJ=N=9D=<FGKA?FA>A;9FLE9AF=>>=;LKGJAFL=J9;LAGF
9DD"
,*/*+39F9DQKAK
"GJ=9;@K=KKAGFK;GJ=KGFAF<ANA<M9DAL=EKG>L@=HGKALAN=9F<F=?9LAN=KM:K;9D=KG>L@=
,*/*+378O=J=KMEE=<LG>GJEHGKALAN=9F<F=?9LAN=9>>=;L;GEHGKAL=K;GJ=K9F<L@=
;GEHGKAL=K;GJ=KO=J=KM:B=;L=<LGH9AJ=<K9EHD=KLL=KLK
"GJL@=HGKALAN=9>>=;L;GEHGKAL=K;GJ=KL@=J=
O9K9KA?FA>A;9FL<=;J=9K=>JGEL@=>AJKLK=KKAGF)/!
LGL@=K=;GF<K=KKAGF)/!
L
,
"GJF=?9LAN=9>>=;LK;GJ=KL@=J=O9KFGKA?FA>A;9FL;@9F?=>JGEL@=>AJKLK=KKAGF
)/!
LGL@=K=;GF<K=KKAGF)/!
L
,
3=;GEHML=<,=9JKGFXK;GJJ=D9LAGF;G=>>A;A=FLK9EGF?H9JLA;AH9FLKX;@9F?=AFJ=9<AF?LAE=K9F<
;@9F?=AFK;GJ=KGFL@=,*/
"GJ=9;@H9JLA;AH9FL<A>>=J=F;=K;GJ=K>JGEK=KKAGFLGK=KKAGFO=J=
;9D;MD9L=<K=H9J9L=DQ>GJ9F?JQK9<9F<@9HHQK=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=K9F<>GJL@=HGKALAN=9F<F=?9LAN=
KM:K;9D=K;GJ=KGFL@=,*/*+3
0OGL9AD=<:AN9JA9L=;GJJ=D9LAGF9F9DQK=KJ=N=9D=<FGKA?FA>A;9FL
;GJJ=D9LAGFK:=LO==F;@9F?=AFHGKALAN=9>>=;L9F<;@9F?=AFJ=9<AF?LAE=K>GJ9F?JQ.
K9<
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
.
GJ@9HHQK=FL=F;=K.
9DD,
GJJ=D9LAGFKO=J=KLJGF?=JL@GM?@FGLKA?FA>A;9FL
:=LO==F;@9F?=AFF=?9LAN=9>>=;L9F<9F?JQ.
K9<.
9F<@9HHQK=FL=F;=K.
9DD
,
KAEAD9J9F9DQKAKMKAF?J=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?LAE=KAFKL=9<G>J9OJ=9<AF?LAE=K9DKGQA=D<=<FG
KA?FA>A;9FL;GJJ=D9LAGFKG>;@9F?=AFHGKALAN=9>>=;L9F<;@9F?=KAFJ=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?LAE=K>GJ9F?JQ
.
K9<.
9F<@9HHQK=FL=F;=K.
9DD,
KOAL@J9OJ=9<AF?LAE=K
;GJJ=D9LAGFKO=J=D9J?=J:MLFGLKA?FA>A;9FL:=LO==F;@9F?=AFF=?9LAN=9>>=;L9F<;@9F?=KAFJ=KA<M9D
J=9<AF?LAE=K>GJ9F?JQ.
K9<.
9F<@9HHQK=FL=F;=K.
9DD,
;CFGOD=<?E=FLK
3=L@9FC
3=:KL=J/
)DAF9R
=E=L(
$9R=F(
#J=AK;@9J
N9F.==CME9F<
MGD
>GJJ=K=9J;@9KKAKL9F;=
"MF<AF?O9KHJGNA<=<:QL@=*9LAGF9D/;A=F;="GMF<9LAGFMF<=J#J9FLK
/9F</LG
)
#
L@=*9LAGF9D%FKLALML=G>)=FL9D$=9DL@MF<=J?J9FLK
)$9F<,)$LG.
&
9F<:Q9FMFJ=KLJA;L=<?J9FL>JGE.=K=9J;@0G,J=N=FL
DAF<F=KK%F;
*
5
*
5
LGL@= =H9JLE=FLG>+H@L@9DEGDG?Q9F<2AKM9D/;A=F;=K9LL@=1FAN=JKALQG>
3AK;GFKAFU)9<AKGF
FQGHAFAGFK>AF<AF?K9F<;GF;DMKAGFKGJJ=;GEE=F<9LAGFK=PHJ=KK=<AFL@AK
E9L=JA9D9J=L@GK=G>L@=9ML@GJK9F<<GFGLF=;=KK9JADQJ=>D=;LL@=NA=OKG>L@=*9LAGF9D/;A=F;=
"GMF<9LAGFGJGL@=J>MF<AF?9?=F;A=K
.=>=J=F;=K
9JOAF.0@=!PHJ=KKAGFG>!EGLAGFKAF)9F9F<FAE9DK&G@F)MJJ9Q(GF<GF
,=FF $GDQG9C'&,GNAF=DDA & 9JOAFXKEAKL9C=!PHD9AFAF?L@=<AK;GFLAFMALQ:=LO==F
@ME9F9F<FGF@ME9FEAF<K
=@9NJ9AF/;A
,AFC=J/&3GJ<K9F<JMD=K
$9JH=JGDDAFK
H
9JK9DGM( ,=J;=HLM9DKQE:GDKQKL=EK
=@9NJ9AF/;A
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
#D=F:=J?)'9K;@9C),#JGMF<AF?D9F?M9?=AF9;LAGF
,KQ;@GFMDD.=N
*A=<=FL@9D,) !E:G<QAF?=EGLAGF
/;A=F;=
,MDN=JESDD=J" J9AFE=;@9FAKEKDAFCAF?D9F?M9?=9F<9;LAGF
*9LMJ=.=N*=MJGK;A
$9N9K #D=F:=J?).AF;C) !EGLAGFKAEMD9LAGF<MJAF?D9F?M9?=;GEHJ=@=FKAGF
,KQ;@GFMDD.=N
/LJ9;C")9JLAF((/L=HH=J/%F@A:ALAF?9F<>9;ADAL9LAF?;GF<ALAGFKG>L@=@ME9FKEAD=9
FGFG:LJMKAN=L=KLG>L@=>9;A9D>==<:9;C@QHGL@=KAK
&,=JK/G;,KQ;@GD
/GMKKA?F9F. M;@=FF=KEAD==EGLAGF9D=PH=JA=F;=9F<9MLGFGEA;J=9;LANALQL=KLG>L@=
>9;A9D>==<:9;C@QHGL@=KAK
!EGLAGF
+:=JE9F()3AFCA=DE9F,.9E9;@9F<J9F2/ "9;=LG>9;=:DG;CAF?>9;A9DEAEA;JQ;9F
K=D=;LAN=DQAEH9AJJ=;G?FALAGFG>=EGLAGF9D=PHJ=KKAGFK
/G;*=MJGK;A
9JJ(%9;G:GFA) M:=9M))9RRAGLL9&(=FRA#(*=MJ9DE=;@9FAKEKG>=EH9L@QAF
@ME9FKJ=D9Q>JGEF=MJ9DKQKL=EK>GJAEAL9LAGFLGDAE:A;9J=9K
,JG;*9LD;9</;A1/
AE:=J?1"9;A9DJ=9;LAGFK.9HA<DQ=NGC=<=EGLAGF9DJ=KHGFK=K
&,KQ;@GH@QKAGD
!CE9F, 9NA<KGF.&"JA=K=F320@= M;@=FF=KEAD=!EGLAGF9D=PHJ=KKAGF9F<:J9AF
H@QKAGDG?Q%%
&,=JK/G;,KQ;@GD
);#MA?9F"&0@AFCAF?/LM<A=KG>;GN=JLD9F?M9?=HJG;=KK=KHHD=LGF=FLMJQJG>LK*=O
5GJC
39LKGF&0@=HD9;=G>CAF9=KL@=LA;NAK;=J9D9F<D9JQF?=9DGJ?9FAR9LAGFAFL@AFCAF?
,KQ;@GD
.=N
#D=F:=J?)/9LG)9LL9F=G(.A??AG(,9DME:G =L9D
,JG;=KKAF?9:KLJ9;LD9F?M9?=
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
EG<MD9L=KEGLGJKQKL=E9;LANALQ
-&!PH,KQ;@GD
/;@O9JLR#!"9AJ,(/9DL,)9F<=D).'D=JE9F#("9;A9DEMK;D=H9LL=JFAF?LG9>>=;LAN=
AE9?=JQAF<=HJ=KK=<9F<FGF<=HJ=KK=<KM:B=;LK
/;A=F;=
$=FF=FDGLL=J=L9D
0@=DAFC:=LO==F>9;A9D>==<:9;C9F<F=MJ9D9;LANALQOAL@AF;=FLJ9D
;AJ;MALJA=KG>=EGLAGFU*=OAFKA?@LK>JGEGLMDAFME0GPAFAF<M;=<<=F=JN9LAGFG>>JGOFEMK;D=K
=J=:GJL=P&MF=
/AEHKGF((0@=GJA?AFKLJM;LMJ=9F<H@9JE9;GDG?A;9D9;LANALQG>:GLMDAFMELGPAF
,@9JE9;GD.=N
,=KLJGFC J9;@E9F #JA>>AF&3!>>=;LG>:GLMDAFMELGPAFGFLJGH@A;J=?MD9LAGFG>
9;=LQ;@GDAF=J=;=HLGJK
*9LMJ=
$9EBA9F&39DC=J"+/=JA9DF=MJGH@QKAGDG?A;9DKLM<A=KG>AFLJ9EMK;MD9J:GLMDAFME
LGPAFAF@ME9FK
)MK;D=*=JN=
#9F<=NA9//HAF9D9F<KMHJ9KHAF9D>9;LGJKAF@ME9FEMK;D=>9LA?M=
,@QKAGD.=N
FLGFM;;A".GKKA#A9F>J9F;=K;@A(.GKK=LLG+9D=G)(GF?<AKL9F;=J=LJG?J9<=
=>>=;LKG>:GLMDAFMEF=MJGLGPAF
&*=MJGK;A
::JMRR=K=#=J9J<=DDA*=MJGH@QKAGDG?A;9D=>>=;LKG>:GLMDAFMELGPAFLQH=
*=MJGLGPA;ALQ.=K=9J;@
.GK9D=K.(JAEMJ9'09C=F9?9/+K9E=)!PLJ9>MK9D9F<AFLJ9>MK9DEMK;D==>>=;LKAF
=PH=JAE=FL9D:GLMDAFMELGPAFAFB=;LAGF
)MK;D=*=JN=
#@=R#GJ<GF&#AD9J<A)"@JAKL9CGK*GGH=J/!%EH9AJE=FLKG>J=9;@AF?
EGN=E=FLKAFH9LA=FLKOAL@GMLHJGHJAG;=HLAGF
%%
!>>=;LKG>NAKM9DAF>GJE9LAGFGF9;;MJ9;Q
&
*=MJGH@QKAGD
GQ9'.=AF>GJ;=E=FLD=9JFAF?GEHML9LAGF9DL@=GJQ9F<:AGDG?A;9DE=;@9FAKEK
$"/,
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
&GMJF9D
GQ9')G<MD9LGJKG><=;AKAGFE9CAF?
*9LMJ=*=MJGK;A
%+,/QKL=EK%F;
#GD=L9
09KKAF9JQ(#9;AGHHG&0AF$9F<:GGCG>HKQ;@GH@QKAGDG?Q=<K9;AGHHG&009KKAF9JQ
(#=JFLKGF##9E:JA<?=1FAN=JKALQ,J=KK*=O5GJCHH
,KQ;@GDG?Q/G>LO9J=0GGDK%F;
,ALLK:MJ?@,
)9L@OGJCK%F;
/@=J:GF)
3=D;@, 0@=MK=G>"9KL"GMJA=J0J9FK>GJE>GJL@==KLAE9LAGFG>HGO=JKH=;LJ9E=L@G<
:9K=<GFLAE=9N=J9?AF?GN=JK@GJLEG<A>A=<H=JAG<G?J9EK
%!!!0J9FK9;LAGFKM<AG9F<
!D=;LJG9;GMKLA;1
DD=J?9F%F;
%JNAF=
39LKGF D9JC( =N=DGHE=FL9F<N9DA<9LAGFG>:JA=>E=9KMJ=KG>HGKALAN=9F<F=?9LAN=
=>>=;L0@=,*//;9D=K
&,=JK/G;,KQ;@GD
"A?MJ=(=?=F<K
"A?MJ=
Facial muscle activity during reading of emotional sentences.!)#;@9F?=AFEA;JGNGDLK
>JGE:9K=DAF=EK:=>GJ=K=FL=F;=GFK=L>GJ=EGLAGF9DK=FL=F;=K9;JGKKK=FL=F;=IM9JL=JK9F<
GN=J9DD%FK=LN=JLA;9D:9JKJ=HJ=K=FLE=9F!)#;@9F?=<MJAF?K=FL=F;=HJ=K=FL9LAGF9F<@GJARGFL9D:9JK
AF<A;9L=KA?FA>A;9FL;GEH9JAKGFK>JGE!PH=JAE=FL
GDGJK<=FGL=K=FL=F;==EGLAGF9DALQJ=<9F?JQ
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
K=FL=F;=K?J==F@9HHQK=FL=F;=K:DM=K9<K=FL=F;=K
"A?MJ=
Reading times for emotional sentences before and after BTX treatment.F?JQK9<9F<
@9HHQK=FL=F;=J=9<AF?LAE=K:=>GJ=KLK=KKAGF9F<9>L=JF<K=KKAGF04AFB=;LAGFAF;GJJM?9LGJ
EMK;D=AF!PH=JAE=FL
!JJGJ:9JKAF<A;9L=K
=
E
/A?FA>A;9FL;GEH9JAKGFK9J=AF<A;9L=<OAL@9F
9KL=JAKC
"A?MJ=
Residual reading times for emotional sentences before and after BTX treatment.F?JQ
K9<9F<@9HHQK=FL=F;=J=KA<M9DJ=9<AF?LAE=K;GFLJGDDAF?>GJK=FL=F;=D=F?L@9;JGKK:GL@K=KKAGFK
;GFLJGDDAF?>GJK=FL=F;=D=F?L@AF!PH=JAE=FL
!JJGJ:9JKAF<A;9L=K
=
E
/A?FA>A;9FL;GEH9JAKGFK
9J=AF<A;9L=<OAL@9F9KL=JAKC
"A?MJ=
Positive and negative affect ratings before and after BTX treatment.,GKALAN=9F<F=?9LAN=
9>>=;LKM:K;9D=K;GJ=K:=>GJ=KLK=KKAGF9F<9>L=JF<K=KKAGF04AFB=;LAGFAF;GJJM?9LGJEMK;D=>GJ
H9JLA;AH9FLKAF!PH=JAE=FL
!JJGJ:9JKAF<A;9L=K
=
E
/A?FA>A;9FL;GEH9JAKGFK9J=AF<A;9L=<
OAL@9F9KL=JAKC
09:D=(=?=F<K
09:D=
!P9EHD=KG>L@=F?JQ$9HHQ9F</9</=FL=F;=K1K=<AF!PH=JAE=FLK9F<
09:D=
)=9FK9F<KL9F<9J<<=NA9LAGFKG>9;;MJ9;QGF;GEHJ=@=FKAGFIM=KLAGFK>GJ=EGLAGF9D
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
K=FL=F;=K9;JGKKK=KKAGFK>JGE!PH=JAE=FL
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
Table 1.
Angry sentences
Reeling from the fight with that stubborn bigot, you slam the car door.
The pushy telemarketer won't let you return to your dinner.
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
The workload from your pompous professor is unreasonable.
Happy sentences
The water park is refreshing on the hot summer day.
Finally, you reach the summit of the tall mountain.
You spring up the stairs to your lover’s apartment.
Sad sentences
You hold back your tears as you enter the funeral home.
You open your email in-box on your birthday to find no new emails.
Your closest friend has just been hospitalized for a mental illness.
Table 2.
Nature Precedings : hdl:10101/npre.2009.3683.1 : Posted 24 Aug 2009
Session
Angry sentences Sad sentences Happy sentences
Session 1 .90 (.306) .92 (.271) .91 (.286)
Session 2 .86 (.344) .85 (.354) .92 (.266)