%UGENE$EBS"ECKER
F^eje]hWf^[h
F nkkZr Pbe l h g
>n`^g^=';^\d^kÍlib\mnk^lh_Fbg&
g^lhmZZk^Zab]]^g`^fh_ma^
Fbgg^lhmZAblmhkb\ZeLh\b^mrÍliah&
mh`kZia\hee^\mbhg';^\d^k!*2*2È01"
phkd^]_hkma^Lh\b^mr_khf*2-2
mh*201Zl\nkZmhkh_paZmpZlma^g
\Zee^]ma^Ib\mnk^=^iZkmf^gmZg]%
nembfZm^er%[^\Zf^\ab^_iahmh`kZ&
ia^k'<hee^Z`n^l_hg]erk^f^f[^k
abfZlZ`^g^khnlZg]hnm`hbg`i^k&
lhgpahpZl^li^\bZeerghm^]_hkabl
dbg]g^llmhhma^kl'
;^\d^kpZlZo^klZmbe^iahmh`kZ&
ia^kpah[^eb^o^]bg]h\nf^gmbg`
ablmhkrZlbmaZii^g^]'Mhabf%abl&
mhkrpZlgÍmlhf^mabg`Êhe]%he]%he]Ë4
bmpZlZebo^h[c^\mpZbmbg`_hkabl
\Zf^kZ!Lm'IZneIbhg^^kIk^ll%FZr
+2%*2/*%i'-<"'A^ie^Z]^]pbma
:[ho^3>n`^g^=';^\d^k%Z[hnm*2.+
i^hie^mhlZo^ma^bk_Zfberib\mnk^l
Zg]nk`^]ma^fmhmZd^\Zg]b]lahml
h_^o^kr]ZrZ\mbobmb^l'Ablhpgphkd
kZg`^]_khfihkmkZbmlh_ln\aFbg&
g^lhmZenfbgZkb^lZl@hk]hgIZkdl%
Lb`nk]?'Helhg%Zg]Chl^iabg^Enms
Kheebglmh\hgm^fihkZkr^o^gmlln\a
Zlma^*2/)lZgmbpZkikhm^lmlZg]ma^
]^Zmah_An[^kmAnfiak^rbg*201'
A^k^\hk]^]\nemnkZeb\hglbg\en]bg`
OhedlpZ`^g[^^me^l%Zabm\aabd^k%Zg]
Fbgg^ZiheblÍl>e^\mkb\?^mnlk^\hk]
lmhk^Zg]G^pKbo^klb]^<Z_†'
;^\d^kZelhmhhdang]k^]lh_iah&
mh`kZialh_ablmhkb\lbm^lZg][nbe]&
bg`lbgZeeiZkmlh_Fbgg^lhmZ'A^pZl
bgm^k^lm^]bgma^ikh\^llh_ablmhkb\Ze
\aZg`^Zg]ehhd^]_hkieZ\^lmaZm
^f[h]b^]bm%ln\aZllbm^lleZm^]_hk
k^lmhkZmbhghk]^fhebmbhg'Ma^l^iah&
mh`kZiallahpabl]blmbg\mbo^nl^h_
\hfihlbmbhg%k^erbg`hgma^^e^f^gml
h_ablln[c^\mmheb_mma^lbm^hnmh_ma^
hk]bgZkrZg]]kZfZmbs^bm'
:[ho^Zee%;^\d^kÍlib\mnk^l]bl&
ieZrZeho^h_Fbgg^lhmZ':efhlm
Zgrmabg`Z[hnmma^lmZm^pZlphkmar
h_abliahmh`kZiar'G^ZkeraZe_h_
ma^*%).+;^\d^kiahmh`kZialbgma^
FAL\hee^\mbhglaZo^[^^g]b`bmbs^]
Zg]\Zg[^l^^ghgma^Lh\b^mrÍl
p^[lbm^!ammi3((\hee^\mbhgl'fgal'
hk`(oblnZek^lhnk\^l"4ma^hma^klZk^
ZoZbeZ[e^_hkob^pbg`bgma^Ablmhkr
<^gm^keb[kZkrbgLm'IZne'
FnkkZrPbelhg%[kZg\afZgZ`^kh_
ma^A^kbmZ`^Eb[kZkrbgEZd^obee^%
aZlphkd^]_hk=ZdhmZ<hngmr_hk,)
r^Zkl'A^bllmZ__ebZblhgmhma^In[eb\
:km<bmbs^gÍl:]oblhkr<hffbmm^^'
BgFbgg^lhmZMkZo^e<hfiZgbhg%
Kb\aZk]Hel^gbnlpkbm^l%ÊEh\Zm^]
mphfbe^l_khfEZfhbee^hg<hngmr
0%k^lmlma^ib\mnk^ljn^obeeZ`^h_
Ib\dpb\d'ËMa^khZ]makhn`amhpg
iZll^lZ]^\Zrbg`he]fbeelbmnZm^]
hgMkhnm<k^^d';nbembg*1./%ma^
`kblmfbeehkb`bgZeeraZ]lbqlmhkb^l%
[nmma^nii^k×hhklp^k^]^lmkhr^]
[rZmhkgZ]hbg*2)0'I^kaZilpa^g
;^\d^kpZle^Zobg`ma^lbm^a^`eZg\^]
bgablk^Zk&ob^pfbkkhkZg]lZpmabl
ib\mnk^Éf^Zgbg`maZmma^mbk^mkZ\dl
Zk^ablhpg'
Ib\dpb\dFbee%PbghgZ<hngmr%*2.2
B`gZmbnl=hgg^eer%ma^ikhfbg^gm
gbg^m^^gma&\^gmnkrFbgg^lhmZ
ihebmb\bZgpahl^ko^]Zleb^nm^gZgm
`ho^kghk%N'L'\hg`k^llfZg%Zg]
lmZm^e^`bleZmhk%Zelhmkb^]ablaZg]
ZmeZg]li^\neZmbhgZg]mhpgieZg&
gbg`'PbmaiZkmg^kChagGbgbg`^k%
a^^goblbhg^]ma^bk=ZdhmZ<hngmr
mhpglbm^[^\hfbg`ZÊ`k^Zm\bmr%Ë[nm
ma^IZgb\h_*1.0^g]^]ma^ikhc^\m'
FZgrh_bmlk^lb]^gmlÉZmhg^mbf^
gnf[^kbg`Z[hnm*%)))ÉZg]lhf^
h_bml[nbe]bg`lfho^]mhAZlmbg`l'
;r*1/2=hgg^eerÍleZk`^%^e^`Zgm
ahf^pZlZeemaZmk^fZbg^]h_ma^
\bmrh_Gbgbg`^k':_m^kabl]^Zma%ma^
[^Znmb_ne[nbe]bg`]^m^kbhkZm^]'=^&
libm^^__hkmlmhlZo^bm%ma^ahnl^pZl
]^fhebla^]bg*2-2Zg]bmlk^fZbgl
lhe]Zll\kZi_hk-))'
Lbm^h_B`gZmbnl=hgg^eerÍlahf^%Gbgbg`^k%=ZdhmZ<hngmr%*2.1
Summer 2007 235
<ZibmheZiikhZ\aZk^Z%ob^p_khfLmZm^H_Ö\^;nbe]bg`%*2.,
Ma^^qiZglbhgh_ma^lmZm^\ZibmhefZeebgma^*2.)lk^jnbk^]ma^k^fhoZeh_g^Zk[rahnlbg`'
;^\d^kmhhdmabliahmh`kZiahgma^^o^h_ma^]blZii^ZkZg\^h_hg^ln\afh]^lmk^lb]^gmbZe
Zk^Z'Hgmabllbm^%Zmma^bgm^kl^\mbhgh_ik^l^gm&]ZrChagBk^eZg]Zg]<hglmbmnmbhg[hne^oZk]l%
phne]kbl^ma^LmZm^MkZglihkmZmbhg;nbe]bg`bg*2./'A^k^%ma^hk]bgZkrahnl^lZmma^[hmmhf
h_ma^ib\mnk^ÉZg]ma^lnkikblbg`Z[ng]Zg\^h_\ZklÉ\hgmkZlmlaZkierpbmama^fblmrlaZi^
h_ma^Lm'IZne<Zma^]kZeZmma^mhi'
236 Minnesota Histor y
;^\d^kmhhdl^o^kZeiahmhl[^mp^^g
*20*Zg]*20.]h\nf^gmbg`ma^
k^ieZ\^f^gmh_ma^he]mph&eZg^
[kb]`^pbmama^g^p_hnk&eZg^liZg
\hgg^\m^]mhma^bgm^klmZm^ab`apZr'
A^k^%ma^he][kb]`^%]blmbg`nbla^]
[rma^f^mZe`bk]^klmkn\mnk^%]hfb&
gZm^lma^_hk^`khng]pabe^ma^g^p
irehgl!pbmaZlbg`e^lniihkm"Zk^
cnlmoblb[e^[^abg]bm'
;kb]`^ho^kLm'<khbqKbo^kg^ZkAn]lhg%ehhdbg`^Zlm%*20,
LngKZrLahiibg`\^gm^khgLm'
IZneÍl>ZlmLb]^pZl[nbem[rma^
DkZnl:g]^klhg<hfiZgrZmAn]&
lhgZg]F\Dgb`amkhZ]lbg*2.0
Zg]aZl[^^g^geZk`^]l^o^kZembf^l
lbg\^'HgmablCner]Zrma^\hg&
lmkn\mbhglb`gZg]^Zkma&fhobg`
^jnbif^gm%mahn`a]pZk_^][rma^
eZg]l\Zi^%g^o^kma^e^llZgghng\^
maZmma^[n\heb\lbm^pbeelhhg[^
mkZgl_hkf^]bgmhZ\k^lh_lmhk^l
Zg]iZkdbg`ehml'
Lbm^h_LngKZrLahiibg`<^gm^k%Ab`apZr*+Zg]F\Dgb`amKhZ]%Lm'IZne%*2..
Summer 2007 237
Fhlmh_;^\d^kÍliahmh`kZialihk&
mkZreZg]l\Zi^lhkZk\abm^\mnk^'Mabl
blhg^h_ma^_^pmaZmik^l^gmhk]b&
gZkranfZgZ\mbobmr'Bm^Zlber\Zeel
mhfbg]ZaZiir_ZfberoZ\Zmbhg%
\^f^gm^]bgf^fhkr[rma^[^Znmr
h_gZmnk^'Eh\Zm^]*.fbe^l^Zlmh_
Abg\de^r%ma^,)%)))&Z\k^Lm'<khbq
LmZm^IZkdblma^ghkma^kgfhlmbgZ
\aZbgh_k^\k^ZmbhgZeZg]pbe]^kg^ll
Zk^ZlmaZmlmk^m\aZehg`ma^Lm'<khbq
Kbo^k'Ma^lpbffbg`[^Z\a\Zg[^
_hng]ZmEZd^<eZrmhg'
LibeepZrg^Zk[Zmabg`[^Z\a%Lm'<khbqLmZm^IZkd%*2.0
;^\d^kpZle^`^g]Zkrbgabl_kb^g]&
labil'@bo^gma^gnf[^kh_ib\mnk^l
a^mhhdh_Helhg!*122È*21+"%ma^
lmZm^Íl`k^Zmpkbm^khggZmnk^%ma^
mphfnlmaZo^[^^gp^eeZ\jnZbgm^]'
Ma^ebd^erl^mmbg`h_mablib\mnk^bl
HelhgÍlahf^%ma^ÊEblm^gbg`IhbgmË
bg>er'Bgabl[hhdMa^Ehg^erEZg]%
Helhg\Zlmabfl^e_ZlZe^Z]^kbgma^
lmre^h_Z?k^g\a<ZgZ]bZgohrZ`^nk3
ÊHfhg]ehhd^]Zmf^';hnk`^hbl%
a^lZb]%bmÍlnimhrhn'Behhd^]mh&
pZk]ma^\eb__lhg\^fhk^Zg]ma^
pZo^&mhll^]fbe^lbg[^mp^^g'E^mÍl
`h%BlZb]%Zg]pbmahnmfhk^Z]hp^
a^Z]^]hnmbgmhma^hi^g'ËMablihk&
mkZbml^^flmh\Zimnk^lhf^h_maZm
Zbkh_l^e_&\hgÖ]^g\^'
Lb`nk]?'Helhg%Z[hnm*2/)
238 Minnesota Histor y
Chl^iabg^EnmsKheebgl%LmbeepZm^k%*2.-
Chl^iabg^EnmsKheebgl!*12/È*201"pZlZikh_^llhkh_ZkmZmma^Ngbo^klbmrh_Fbgg^lhmZZg]
iZbgm^]hbelZg]pZm^k\hehkl'La^k^lb]^]bgLmbeepZm^kZg]pZl;^\d^kÍlg^b`a[hk'La^pZl
Zdbg]k^]libkbm%mhh'Bga^kZkmb\e^Ê>qiehkbg`pbma;knlaZg]IZe^mm^Ë!Fbgg^lhmZAblmhkr%
Likbg`*2.,"%la^^qieZbg^]%ÊBmpZlfrbgm^k^lmbgFbgg^lhmZablmhkrmaZme^]f^mhng]^kmZd^
ma^iZbgmbg`h_frlmZm^Ílablmhkb\eZg]fZkdlbgpZm^k\hehk'Ë
Summer 2007 239
FZk`^Zg]>n`^g^;^\d^kebo^]bg
:_mhgpbmama^bkmph\abe]k^g%AZgc^
Zg]EZ^e%Zg]ma^mph]h`lib\mnk^]
a^k^'Ma^bkahnl^pZleh\Zm^]hg
LmZ`^\hZ\aMkZbe%hma^kpbl^dghpg
Zl<hngmrKhZ]+*%Zghkma&lhnma
Zkm^kr[^mp^^g:_mhgZg]LmbeepZm^k'
?khfma^ehhdlh_mabliahmh%FZk`^
laZk^]ma^^gmanlbZlfh_fZgrFbg&
g^lhmZgl`eZ]mh[^hnm]hhklZ_m^kZ
ehg`%b\rpbgm^k'
FZk`^;^\d^kZg]a^k`Zk]^g%:_mhg%Z[hnm*20-
240 Minnesota Histor y
;r*20)ma^hiihlbmbhgmhma^pZkbg
Ob^mgZfaZ]`khpgmk^f^g]hnler'
:gmb&pZk]^fhglmkZmbhglh\\nkk^]Zm
\hee^`^\Zfinl^lZ\khllma^\hngmkr
Zg]h_m^gikhohd^]Zobhe^gmk^lihgl^
_khf`ho^kgf^gm'Hg^h_ma^fhlm
mkZ`b\^o^gmlpZlma^lahhmbg`h__hnk
lmn]^gml[rma^GZmbhgZe@nZk]Zm
D^gmLmZm^Ngbo^klbmrbgFZr*20)%
ma^r^Zk;^\d^kmhhdmabliahmh'
@kZ_Ömb%Fbgg^Zihebl%*20)
Ma^>e^\mkb\?^mnlk^\hk]lmhk^Zg]
Êa^Z]lahiË^ibmhfbs^]ma^abi&
ib^^kZh_ma^eZm^*2/)l[^mm^kmaZg
ZefhlmZgrhma^keh\Zebglmbmnmbhg'
?hng]^]bg*2/1hg<^]Zk:o^gn^
g^Zkma^P^lm;Zgdh_ma^Ngbo^k&
lbmrh_Fbgg^lhmZ%bmlhe]Êfnlb\Zg]
fnldhbe%ihlm^klZg]iZkZia^kgZebZ%
\hngm^k\nemnk^`b_mlZg]`hh]ob[^l%Ë
k^eZm^]ma^LmZkMkb[ng^hg:ikbe
.%*210!iZ`^F*-"';rk^\hk]bg`
\hgm^fihkZkrl\^g^lebd^mablhg^%
;^\d^klahp^]maZmbgiahmh`kZiar
ma^ik^l^gmZg]ma^iZlmf^k`^bgmh
hg^É_nkma^k^ob]^g\^h_abl[^eb^_
maZmablmhkrpZlghmg^\^llZkber
Êhe]%he]%he]'Ë Pbg]hplb`g%>e^\mkb\?^mnl%<^]Zk:o^gn^%Fbgg^Zihebl%*20+
Summer 2007 241
Copyright of Minnesota History is the property of the Minnesota
Historical Society and its content may not be copied or emailed to
multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder’s
express written permission. Users may print, download, or email
articles, however, for individual use.
To request permission for educational or commercial use, contact us.
www.mnhs.org/mnhistory