Poverty & Race
1%234)+$'/556 7 8,#9':;<'=,9'>
Race, Wealth and the Commons
!"# $%&'()*# +,-.//.&# 0# 1-,)*# 1233(45
!-%#63.)*78-(9%#'.)(.3#:%.39-#&(7
;(&%#(5#.#<'(/.'"#2!59.)3%#92#'.)(.3#'%)7
24)(3(.9(24#(4#9-%#=4(9%&#>9.9%5?#@-%
)%3%!'.9%&#!,9#!'(%A#-%"&."#2A#9-%#1(;(3
B(C-95#+2;%/%49#%4&%&#3%C.3#5.4)9(24
2A#:-(9%#5,<'%/.)"D#"%9#;.59#(4%E,.3(7
9(%5#2A#:%.39-#<%'5(59?
@-%'%#-.;%#!%%4#52/%#.&;.4)%5#(4
'%&,)(4C#9-%#63.)*78-(9%#(4)2/%#C.<?
6,9#(A#63.)*#(4)2/%5#'25%#.9#9-%#5./%
'.9%# .5# 9-%"# &(&# !%9:%%4# FGHI# .4&
JKKFD# (9# :2,3&# 9.*%# LIF# "%.'5# A2'
63.)*5#92#'%.)-#<%'7).<(9.#(4)2/%#<.'7
(9"#:(9-#:-(9%#M/%'().?
N9#(5#(4#9-%#.'%.#2A#:%.39-#9-.9#:%
!%59#5%%#9-%#5%&(/%49.'"#'%5,395#2A#(47
9%'7C%4%'.9(24.3#(4%E,.3(9"?##N4#JKKOD
9-%#/%&(.4#A./(3"#4%9#:2'9-#2A#63.)*5
:.5#PJKDOKKD#243"#FO?LQ#2A#9-%#/%7
&(.4#:-(9%#4%9#:2'9-#2A#PFOKDRKK?#@-%
/%&(.4#4%9#:2'9-#A2'#S.9(42#A./(3(%5
:.5#PJRDFKK?
8%.39-#.4&#5.;(4C5#.'%#.#59.!(3(T7
(4C# A2')%# A2'# A./(3(%5D# .4&# (49%'7
C%4%'.9(24.3#9'.45A%'5#2<%4#,<#.))%55
92#-(C-%'#%&,).9(24D#-2/%2:4%'5-(<D
5.;(4C5#.4&#(4;%59/%495?#M5#.#C'2:7
(4C# ./2,49# 2A# 52)(232C().3# '%5%.')'%;%.35D#9-%#4%9#:2'9-#2A#24%#C%4%'.7
9(24# )249'(!,9%5# 5(C4(A().493"# 92# 9-%
:%.39-#<'25<%)95#2A#9-%#4%U9#C%4%'.7
9(24?
V,'#4.9(24#4%%&5#92#/.*%#.#&'./.9()
'%7(4;%59/%49# (4# !'2.&%4(4C# :%.39.4&# 2<<2'9,4(9"?# @-%# /.55(;%# <.59
C2;%'4/%49# (4;%59/%495# (4# :%.39-7
!,(3&(4CD#5,)-#.5#9-%#W2/%59%.&#M)9
.4&# <259782'3&# 8.'# NN# X-2,5(4C
!22/DY#:%'%#%AA%)9(;%3"#X:-(9%#243"Y
<'2C'./5#9-.9#!2359%'%&#9-%#%)242/()
5,<'%/.)"#2A#:-(9%5?#>(4)%#9-%#%4&#2A
3%C.3#5%C'%C.9(24#.4&#&(5)'(/(4.9(24D
9-%'%#-.5#429#!%%4#.#5(/(3.'#/.55#(47
;%59/%49#9-.9#63.)*5#.4&#29-%'#<%2<3%
2A#)232'#)2,3&#!%4%A(9#A'2/#.5#%E,.3
)(9(T%45?
The Commons Sector:
Source of Wealth
V4%#!.''(%'#92#5,)-#.#/.55#(4;%597
/%49#(5#.#/"9-232C"#2A#-2:#<'(;.9%
:%.39-#(5#)'%.9%&?##Z2#24%#!,(3&5#:%.39.324%D#9-2,C-#9-%#/"9-#2A#(4&(;(&,.3
:%.39-#<(24%%'5#(5#&%%<3"#<.'9#2A#2,'
),39,'%?#N4#=?>?#52)(%9"D#<'(;.9%#:%.39[5.;(4C5D#-2/%2:4%'5-(<D#(4;%59/%49
:%.39-\#(5#&%'(;%&#A'2/#.#)2/!(4.9(24
2A# (4&(;(&,.3# .)9(;(9"# .4&# 9-%# X)2/7
/245?Y
@-%#)2//245#'%A%'5#92#9-%#;.'(2,5
A2'/5#2A#)2//24#:%.39-#.'2,4&#,5D
:-.9#:%#-.;%#92C%9-%'?##@-(5#(4)3,&%5
9-%#4.9,'.3!)2//245D#5,)-#.5#A(5-%'7
(%5D#5%%&5D#.4(/.35D#.('D#3.4&D#:.9%'D
52(3#.4&#.(':.;%5?##N9#(4)3,&%5#9-%#527
)(.3#2'#)2//,4(9"#)2//245D#5,)-#.5
3(!'.'(%5D#9'.45<2'9.9(24#(4A'.59',)9,'%D
<'2<%'9"#.4&#(49%33%)9,.3#<'2<%'9"?#N9
There is a mythology of
how private wealth is
created.
.352#(4)3,&%5#9-%#),39,'.3#2'#*42:3%&C%
)2//245D#5,)-#.5#/,5()D#(4&(C%42,5
/%&()(4%D#9-%#N49%'4%9D#3.4C,.C%5?
>2/%#2A#9-%5%#)2//245#.'%#C(A95
A'2/# 4.9,'%?# V9-%'5# :%'%# !,(39# !"
<%2<3%#2'#!"#)2//,4(9"#(459(9,9(245D
&%'(;%&#A'2/#5-.'%&#A,4&(4C#.4&#9.U.7
9(24?##V4%#:."#2A#;(%:(4C#9-%#)2/7
/245D#.'9(),3.9%&#!"#)2//245#9-(4*%'
]%9%'#6.'4%5D#(5#X9-%#C(A95#2A#4.9,'%D
<3,5#9-%#C(A95#2A#52)(%9"#9-.9#:%#5-.'%
.4&#(4-%'(9#92C%9-%'^.4&#9-.9#:%#-.;%
.4#2!3(C.9(24#92#<.55#2492#2,'#-%('5D
,4&(/(4(5-%&# .4&# /2'%# 2'# 3%55
%E,.33"?Y#@-%#)2//245#'%A%'5#92#A2'/5
2A#'%.3#:%.39-#.4&#<'2<%'9"#9-.9#).4
!%# )2,49%&# .4&# 3%C.33"# <'29%)9%&?
V9-%'#A2'/5#2A#)2//24#:%.39-D#-2:7
%;%'D# &24_9# -.;%# 3%C.3# 59.4&(4C# .4&
/."#!%#&(AA(),39#92#E,.49(A"?
N9# (5# (/<2'9.49# 92# )245(&%'# 9-%
59',CC3%# 2;%'# 9-%# :%.39-# &(;(&%# .5# .
)249%59#2;%'#9-%#&(59'(!,9(24#2A#)2/7
/24# :%.39-?# # 12'<2'.9(245D# !%4%A(97
(4C#9-%('#3.'C%3"#:-(9%#.4&#<'(;(3%C%&
5-.'%-23&%'5D#-.;%#3229%&#9-%#)2//245
2'#5-(A9%&#9-%('#)2595#2492#(9?##6%).,5%
/259# A2'/5# 2A# )2//24# :%.39-# .'%
<22'3"#&%A(4%&D#3.)*#<'2<%'9"#'(C-95#2'
.'%#<22'3"#/.4.C%&D#)2'<2'.9(245#5%%
)2//24#.55%95#.5#3.'C%3"#A'%%#A2'#9-%
9.*(4C?#`2'#%U./<3%D#/259#%U9'.)9(;%
(4&,59'(%5^5,)-#.5#A(5-(4CD#2(3D#)2.3D
/(4(4C#.4&#9(/!%'^9.*%#:%.39-#A'2/
9-%#%)232C().3#)2//245#:-(3%#<."(4C
3(993%#2'#429-(4C?
12'<2'.9(245#'%3.9%#92#9-%#)2//245
(4# 5%;%'.3# :."5?# @-%"# 5(<-24# 2AA
:%.39-#)'%.9%&#!"#<,!3()#.4&#)2//,7
4(9"#(4;%59/%495#A2'#<'(;.9%#C.(4?#@-%"
%43.'C%#9-%('#<'2A(95#!"#5-(A9(4C#)2595
2AA#9-%('#!.3.4)%#5-%%95#.4&#2492#9-%
)2//245#3%&C%'?##@-(5#(5#&24%#!"#%U7
9%'4.3(T(4C#)2595#5,)-#.5#<233,9(24D#(47
A'.59',)9,'%#.4&#%/<32"%%#-%.39-#).'%?
`(4.33"D#)2'<2'.9(245#%4)325%#52)(.33"7
)'%.9%&# .4&# *42:3%&C%# )2//245D
<3.)(4C#9-%/#(4#<'(;.9%#2:4%'5-(<#.4&
2A9%4#)-.'C(4C#,5#A2'#9-%('#,5%?##a42'7
/2,5#<'2A(95#.'%#/.&%#!"#)2'<2'.9(245
%4)325(4C# )2//245# 5,)-# .5# <2<,3.'
.'9D#),39,'%D#N49%'4%9#.4&#/,)-#/2'%?
M33# 9-(5# (5# &24%# 3.'C%3"# :(9-(4# 9-%
A'./%:2'*# 2A# 9-%# %U(59(4C# 3%C.3# .4&
%)242/()#!%3(%A#5"59%/5?
N4#FGGLD#&,'(4C#9-%#5-(A9#A'2/#.4.7
32C#92#&(C(9.3#9%3%;(5(24D#.#4%:#5%9#2A
!'2.&).59#A'%E,%4)(%5#:%'%#'%E,('%&?
124C'%55#2!3(C(4C3"#C.;%#9-%/#.:."
^A'%%#2A#)-.'C%^92#9-%#5./%#/%&(.
)2/<.4(%5#92#:-()-#(9#-.&#<'%;(2,53"
C(;%4#.4.32C#A'%E,%4)(%5?##@-(5#:.5
.4#%59(/.9%&#PRK#!(33(24#C(;%7.:."#92
52/%#2A#9-%#3.'C%59#.4&#:%.39-(%59#)2'7
<2'.9(245#(4#9-%#)2,49'"?#`%:#63.)*
!,5(4%55%5# 2'# )2'<2'.9(245# !%4%A(9%&
A'2/#9-(5#-(592'()#5,!5(&"D#'%(4A2')(4C
:-(9%#&2/(4.4)%#(4#9-%#!'2.&).59#(47
&,59'"?
@-'2,C-2,9# =?>?# -(592'"D# :-(9%5
-.;%#-.&#<'(;(3%C%&#.))%55#92#&(AA%'7
%49# A2'/5# 2A# 9-%# )2//245?# # M9# 9-%
5./%#9(/%D#63.)*#3.!2'#-.5#.&&%&#92
9-%#)2//24#:%.39-#:(9-2,9#.&%E,.9%
)2/<%45.9(24#2'#)3.(/?##`2'/%'#>%)7
'%9.'"# 2A# 9-%# N49%'(2'# 8.39%'# W()*%3
E,(<<%&D# XNA# "2,# 59%.3# PFK# A'2/# .
/.4_5#:.33%9D#"2,_'%#3(*%3"#92#C%9#(492
.#A(C-9D#!,9#(A#"2,#59%.3#!(33(245#A'2/
9-%#)2//245D#)272:4%&#!"#-(/#.4&
-(5#&%5)%4&.495D#-%#/."#429#%;%4#427
!"#$%&$'()*+'(,'-%.$'/0
!IJ11J=KL'I,+(G+)$M'F*,H'-%.$':0
9()%?Y#M#)2//245#<%'5<%)9(;%#(5#(/7
<2'9.49# (4# 322*(4C# .9# ),''%49# :%.39(4%E,.3(9(%5#.4&#523,9(245?
White-Privileged
Wealth Creation
@-%#592'"#2A#X:%.39-#)'%.9(24Y#(4
9-%#=?>?#4%%&5#92#!%#'%;(5(9%&#9-'2,C.# '.)%# .4&# )2//245# <%'5<%)9(;%?
@-%'%#(5#.#324C#.4&#,45%%/3"#-(592'"
2A# 9-%# =?>?# C2;%'4/%49# )-.44%3(4C
)2//24# :%.39-# 92# %U<.4&# 9-%# (4&(7
;(&,.3#:%.39-#.4&#2<<2'9,4(9"#2A#<'(;(7
3%C%&#:-(9%5?
a;%4# !%A2'%# 9-%# %U(59%4)%# 2A# 9-%
=?>?#.5#.#4.9(24D#a,'2<%.45#)24A(57
).9%&# .4&# %4)325%&# 3.4&# .4&# 4.9,'.3
'%52,')%5# A'2/# (4&(C%42,5# <%2<3%5D
)'%.9(4C#9-%#!.5%#2A#:%.39-#A'2/#:-()2,'#/2&%'4#%)242/"#&%'(;%5?#>(/(7
3.'3"D# 9-%# =?>?D# 2A9%4# 9-'2,C-# /(3(7
9.'"#(49%';%49(24D#.<<'2<'(.9%&#9-%#'%7
52,')%5#2A#A2'%(C4#4.9(245D#:-%9-%'#(9
!%#9-%('#4.9,'.3#'%52,')%5#2'#9-%('#/.'7
*%95D#92#9-%#!%4%A(9#2A#9-%#=?>?
`2'# -,4&'%&5# 2A# "%.'5D# MA'().4
<%2<3%#:%'%#5-(<<%&#2,9#2A#9-%('#4.7
9(;%#3.4&5#92#!%#92235#2A#:%.39-#<'27
&,)9(24#(4#9-%#=?>?##63.)*5#:%'%#)247
5(&%'%&#<.'9#2A#9-%#:%.39-#2:4%&#!"
:-(9%5?##63.)*#3.!2'#!,(39#:%.39-#A2'
:-(9%#M/%'().^:-(3%#9-%('#)2//,7
4(9(%5#-.;%#!%%4#3.9%'#,5%&#.5#&,/<7
(4C#C'2,4&5#A2'#9-%#4%C.9(;%#%U9%'4.3(7
9(%5#<'2&,)%&#!"#(4&,59'(.3(T.9(24?
20% Book
Discount
S%U(4C924
622*5#(5#<'2;(&(4C
"@A#'%.&%'5#:(9.#JKQ#&(5)2,49#24
2,'# 4%:# X!%59# 2A
"@AY# )233%)9(24D
",?$*(2'@'A%B$'G+
EH$*GB%L' ND$
OH$*.G+.' E.$+P
M%&?#=5%#)2&%#"#$%&'()#:-%4
2'&%'(4C#[IKKeOHJ7HOJK\D#.4&#"2,
:(33#'%)%(;%#9-(5#&(5)2,49?
$2/%59().33"D#:%#).4#322*#!.)*#.9
9-%#C'%.9#X'2!!%'#!.'24Y#A2'9,4%5#2A
9-%# N4&,59'(.3# B%;23,9(24# 9-.9# :%'%
!.5%&#24#:-(9%#%3(9%5#C.(4(4C#A'%%#.)7
)%55#92#9-%#4.9(24_5#4.9,'.3#'%52,')%5
92# %U<32(9# A2'# <%'524.3# %4'()-/%49?
b'%.9# %&(A()%5# .4&# )-.'(9.!3%# (459(9,7
9(245#59(33#).''"#9-%#4./%5#2A#9-%#(4&(7
;(&,.35#:-2#)2'4%'%&#/.'*%95#!,(39#24
9-%# 4.9,'.3# )2//245D# (4)3,&(4C# 2(3D
9(/!%'# .4&# /(4%'.35^.5# :%33# .5# 527
)(.33"7)'%.9%&#:%.39-#5,)-#.5#'.(3'2.&5
.4&#).<(9.3#/.'*%95?
6,9#%;%4#9-%#-(592'().3#C2;%'4/%49
<'2C'./5#/259#)%3%!'.9%&#A2'#!,(3&(4C
:%.39-#A2'#2'&(4.'"#)(9(T%45#:%'%#,5,7
.33"# A2'/5# 2A# Xc(/# 1'2:# %)242/()
&%;%32</%49Y^<'2;(&(4C# :-(9%5
<'(;(3%C%&#.))%55#92#9-%#)2//245?##@-%
W2/%59%.&#M)9#2A#9-%#FIIK5D#9-%#3.'C7
%59# FG9-# 1%49,'"# (4(9(.9(;%# A2'# (4&(7
The commons is the
gifts of nature, plus the
gifts of society that we
share and inherit
together.
;(&,.3#:%.39-7!,(3&(4CD#%55%49(.33"#%U7
<'2<'(.9%&#(4&(C%42,5#<%2<3%5_#3.4&5
^.4&#%4)325%&#3.'C%#9'.)95#2A#)2//24
<'2<%'9"^92# C'.49# <'(;.9%# <'2<%'9"
9(93%5#92#:-(9%#-2/%59%.&%'5?
N4#.#5(/(3.'#:."D#9-%#:%.39-7!'2.&7
%4(4C#<'2C'./5#2A#9-%#Z%:#$%.3#.4&
bN#6(33#.'%#2A9%4#3(A9%&#,<#.5#!23&#(4(7
9(.9(;%5#92#!'2.&%4#2,'#/(&&3%#)3.55?
6,9# .5# N'.# d.9T4%3524# )-'24()3%5# (4
CD$+' EFFG*H%(G?$' EB(G,+' C%&' CDG($
[5%%#-(5#5,//.'"#2A#9-%#!22*#(4#9-%
+.')-eM<'(3#JKKH#",?$*(2'@'B.)%\D
>2)(.3#>%),'(9"D#9-%#%&,).9(24.3#!%47
%A(95#2A#9-%#bN#6(33#.4&#-2/%2:4%'5-(<
<'2C'./5#2A#9-%#FGLK5#.33#:2'5%4%&#9-%
'.)(.3#:%.39-#&(;(&%?
@-%5%#<'2C'./5#:%'%#&%5(C4%&#!"
.# 124C'%55# )249'233%&# !"# :-(9%# 5,7
<'%/.)(595# .4&# (/<3%/%49%&# (4# c(/
1'2:# 59.9%5# 52# .5# 429# 92# ,<5%9# 32).3
:-(9%#',3%?#M5#.#'%5,39D#9-%#A('59#9:2
&%).&%5# 2A# >2)(.3# >%),'(9"# %U)3,&%&
.C'(),39,'.3#.4&#&2/%59()#:2'*%'5D#2)7
),<.9(245# &(5<'2<2'9(24.9%3"# -%3&# !"
63.)*5?##$,'(4C#82'3&#8.'#NND#63.)*5
A.)%&#,4%E,.3#9'%.9/%49#(4#9-%#5%C'%7
/ 7 ",?$*(2'@'A%B$ 7 8,#9':;<'=,9'> 7 1%234)+$'/556
C.9%&#/(3(9.'"#.4&#(4#9-%('#.!(3(9"#92
.))%55#9-%#!2,49(A,3#!%4%A(95#2A#9-%#bN
6(33#,<24#9-%('#'%9,'4?
@-%#<2597:.'#-2,5(4C#!22/#:.5#A,7
%3%&#!"#5,!5(&(T%&#.55(59.4)%#92#2;%'
fL#/(33(24#M/%'().45#!%9:%%4#FGOI
.4&#FGRJ?#$,'(4C#9-%5%#"%.'5D#FF#/(37
3(24#A./(3(%5#!2,C-9#-2/%5#.4&#.429-%'
JJ#/(33(24#(/<'2;%&#9-%('#<'2<%'9(%5?
@-%#!(CC%59#!%4%A()(.'"#:.5#X:-(9%5
243"Y#5,!,'!(.D#:-%'%#-.3A#2A#.33#-2,57
(4C#)2,3&#)3.(/#`WM#2'#gM#A(4.4)(4C
(4#9-%#FGLK_5#.4&#FGHK_5?#@-%#-2/%
/2'9C.C%#(49%'%59#.4&#<'2<%'9"#9.U#&%7
&,)9(24# .352# &(5<'2<2'9(24.9%3"# !%47
%A(9%&#5,!,'!.4#-2/%2:4%'5D#.4&#(47
9%'59.9%#-(C-:."#)2459',)9(24#5%';%&#.5
.4# (4&('%)9# 5,!5(&"D# .5# (9# 2<%4%&# ,<
(4%U<%45(;%# 3.4&# A2'# 5,!,'!.4# )2/7
/,9%'5?
=4A2'9,4.9%3"D#&,%#92#%)242/()#(47
%E,.3(9"#.4&#;.'(2,5#:-(9%#'.)(59#<'.)7
9()%5^(4)3,&(4C#&(5)'(/(4.92'"#/2'97
C.C%73%4&(4CD# !(C29%&# '%.392'5# .4&
2,9'(C-9#:-(9%#'.)(59#;(23%4)%#,5%&#92
/.(49.(4#5%C'%C.9%&#-2,5(4C#<.99%'45
^/259#63.)*#A./(3(%5#:%'%#<'2-(!(9%&
A'2/#9-(5#C2;%'4/%49#(4;%59/%49#(492
9-%#<'(;.9%#:%.39-#2A#M/%'().?##8-(9%5D
24#9-%#29-%'#-.4&D#'%)%(;%&#<'(;(3%C%&
.))%55# 92# &%%<3"# 5,!5(&(T%&# C2;%'47
/%49#<'2C'./5#.4&#)2//24#'%52,')%5
9-.9#).9.<,39%&#9-%/#A2':.'&?#M9#9-%
%4&# 2A# 82'3&# 8.'# NND# OOQ# 2A# =?>?
)(9(T%45#2:4%&#9-%('##-2/%?#N4#JKKOD
RHQ#2A#:-(9%5#2:4%&#9-%('#-2/%D#)2/7
<.'%&#92#OG?FQ#2A#63.)*5#.4&#OI?FQ
2A#S.9(425?
@2&."D#9-%#)-(3&'%4#.4&#C'.4&)-(37
&'%4#2A#bN#6(33#'%)(<(%495#!%4%A(9#A'2/
(49%'C%4%'.9(24.3#:%.39-#9'.45A%'5#9-.9
%4.!3%#9-%/#92#<,')-.5%#-2/%5D#.99%4&
<'(;.9%#5)-2235#.4&#59.'9#!,5(4%55%5?
6,9#9-%"#<'2!.!3"#&24_9#9-(4*#2A#9-%/7
5%3;%5#.5#!%4%A()(.'(%5#2A#X:-(9%#.AA('7
/.9(;%#.)9(24?Y
The Myth of
Self-Made Wealth
N9#:(33#!%#&(AA(),39#92#2;%')2/%#9-%
'.)(.3#:%.39-#&(;(&%#(A#:%#.&2<9#.#4.'7
'.9(;%#2A#:%.39-#)'%.9(24#9-.9#(C42'%5
9-%#'23%#2A#9-%#)2//245?##8%#/,59
59.'9# :(9-# 9-%# 5%3&2/# '%)2C4(T%&
<'%/(5%# 9-.9# /,)-# 2A# :-.9# :%# )247
5(&%'#X:%.39-Y#&%'(;%5#A'2/#)2//24
:%.39-?
V)).5(24.33"D#9-%#/"9-#(5#%U<25%&?
N4#9-%#&%!.9%#2;%'#9-%#A%&%'.3#(4-%'(97
.4)%#9.UD#5%;%'.3#9-2,5.4&#/,39(7/(37
3(24.('%5#.4&#!(33(24.('%5#5(C4%&#.#<,!7
3()#<%9(9(24#2<<25(4C#'%<%.3#2A#9-%#%57
9.9%#9.U?##+.4"#59.9%&#9-.9#9-%#9.U#:.5
h,59(A(%&#!%).,5%#9-%('#<%'524.3#:%.39:.5# 9-%# '%5,39# 2A# &('%)9# .4&# (4&('%)9
<,!3()#(4;%59/%495#(4#9-%#)2//245?
6(33#b.9%5D#>'?D#A.9-%'#2A#9-%#<3.4%9_5
:%.39-(%59#/.4D#:'29%i
8-%4#52/%24%#-.5#.)),/,3.9%&
PFK# /(33(24# 2'# PLK# /(33(24# 2'# PLK
!(33(24#[N#).4#243"#9-(4*#2A#24%#<%'7
524#(4#9-%#3.59#).9%C2'"\D#9-%"#-.;%
!%4%A(9%&# &(5<'2<2'9(24.9%3"# A'2/
52)(%9"_5# (4;%59/%495# (4# %&,).9(24D
<,!3()# (4A'.59',)9,'%D# 5)(%49(A()# '%7
5%.')-#.4&#29-%'#A2'/5#2A#52)(%9"_5
)2//24#:%.39-?
>-2:# /%# .# A('597C%4%'.9(24# A2'7
9,4%#.4&#N_33#5-2:#"2,#.#5,))%55A,3
<.'94%'5-(<# !%9:%%4# .# 9.3%49%&# (47
&(;(&,.3#.4&#52)(%9"_5#(4;(5(!3%#;%47
9,'%# ).<(9.3(59D# 9-%# )2//245j?
Z24%# 2A# ,5# ).4# (4&(;(&,.33"# )3.(/
92# 2:4# 9-%# )2//245# !,9# .33# 2A# ,5
!%4%A(9#A'2/#(9?
>9(33D#9-%#/"9-#)249(4,%5#9-.9#24%_5
:%.39-#59.9,5#(5#.#'%A3%)9(24#2A#24%_5
(4&(;(&,.3#%AA2'9#.4&#.)-(%;%/%49?##M5
324C#.5#:-(9%5#.4&#<'(;(3%C%&#(4&(;(&,7
.35#!%3(%;%#9-%('#:%.39-#&%'(;%5#3.'C%3"
A'2/#9-%('#2:4#%AA2'9D#(9#:(33#!%#&(AA(7
),39#92#!,(3&#<23(9().3#5,<<2'9#A2'#.4
(4)3,5(;%#:%.39-7!'2.&%4(4C#(4(9(.9(;%D
3%9#.324%#.4"#A2'/#2A#'%<.'.9(245?
N4# ND$' EH$*GB%+' R*$%H' %+M' (D$
",S$*',F'C$%#(D<'52)(232C(59#W%.9-%'
6%9-# c2-4524# (49%';(%:%&# 2;%'# JKK
<'(;(3%C%&#:-(9%#A./(3(%5#.!2,9#9-%('
.99(9,&%5#92:.'&#A./(3"#:%.39-#.4&#%&,7
).9(24.3#2<<2'9,4(9"?##8-(3%#9-%5%#(47
&(;(&,.35#5.:#9-%#(/<2'9.49#'23%#9-.9
/2&%59# X(49%'C%4%'.9(24.3# :%.399'.45A%'5Y#A'2/#9-%('#<.'%495#/.&%#(4
C(;(4C#9-%/5%3;%5#.4&#9-%('#)-(3&'%4
9'%/%4&2,5# %&,).9(24.3# .&;.49.C%5D
9-%"#59(33#&%%<3"#!%3(%;%&#24%_5#59.9(24
(4#3(A%#(5#&%9%'/(4%&#!"#(4&(;(&,.3#%A7
A2'9?##@-%5%#(49%';(%:#5,!h%)95#5.:#42
'%3.9(245-(<#!%9:%%4#9-%#<2:%'#2A#9-%('
:%.39-# (4# )'%.9(4C# <'(;(3%C%&# .&;.47
9.C%5# .4&# 9-%# (4.!(3(9"# 2A# 29-%'5# 92
.)-(%;%#9-%#XM/%'().4#$'%./?Y
PRRAC Research/Advocacy Grants
8%_;%#3%.'4%&#9-.9#9-%#+.')-eM<'(3#"@A^:-()-D#./24C#29-%'#9-(4C5D
.442,4)%&#'%72<%4(4C#2A#]BBM1_5#5/.33#C'.495#<'2C'./#^.''(;%&#E,(9%
3.9%#92#/.4"#'%.&%'5#[9-%#-.T.'&5#2A#9-%#=>]V_5#!,3*#/.(3#&%3(;%'"#5"59%/\?
NA#"2,'#)2<"#&(&#429#.''(;%#[3%.&#.'9()3%#(5#!"#+()-.%3#W24%"D#24#+.'9(4
S,9-%'#d(4C_5#3.59D#+%/<-(5#)./<.(C4\D#3%9#,5#*42:#.4&#:%_33#C%9#"2,#9-%
(55,%#'(C-9#.:."?
N4#9-(5#)249%U9D#:%.39-7#.4&#.55%97
!,(3&(4C# <'2C'./5# .55(59(4C# 32:7(47
)2/%#<%2<3%#.4&#<%2<3%#2A#)232'#9-.9
9%.)-#X5%3A#5,AA()(%4)"Y#.352#'(5*#<%'7
<%9,.9(4C#9-%#/"9-#9-.9#:-(9%#.4&#.A7
A3,%49#<%2<3%#.)-(%;%&#9-%('#:%.39-#59.7
9,5#9-'2,C-#52/%#A2'/#2A#(4&%<%4&%49
%AA2'9?
The Real Wealth Story
M#/2'%#.)),'.9%#4.''.9(;%#2A#(4&(7
;(&,.3#:%.39-#)'%.9(24#59.'95#:(9-#9-%
A,4&./%49.3# 9',9-# 9-.9# .4"24%# :(95,!59.49(.3#:%.39-#-.5#C299%4#.#329#2A
-%3<#A'2/#9-%#)2//245?#M4"24%#:-2
!2.595#9-.9#9-%"#.'%#X5%3A7/.&%Y#(5#(C7
The story of “wealth
creation” in the U.S.
needs to be revisited
through a commons
perspective.
42'(4C# 9-%# '%/.'*.!3%# A%'9(3%# 52(3# 2A
)2//24#:%.39-#9-.9#:%#-.;%#.33#!,(39
92C%9-%'?##N4&(;(&,.3#(4(9(.9(;%#/.99%'5D
2A#)2,'5%D#!,9#(5#2A9%4#.*(4#92#.&&(4C
9-%#)-%''"#.4&#:-(<<%&#)'%./#92#92<
2A# 9-%# %U(59(4C# 5,4&.%# 2A# )2//24
:%.39-?
1%49'.3#92#9-%#/2'.3#)3.(/#92#%3(/(7
4.9%#9-%#-(592'().3#'.)(.3#:%.39-#&(;(&%
(5# '%)2C4(9(24# 9-.9# %.)-# 2A# ,5# -.5# .
!('9-'(C-9# 92# .# <.'9# 2A# 2,'# (4-%'(9%&
)2//245#A2'#2,'#5,59%4.4)%#.4&#3(;%7
3(-22&?##]%2<3%#)-.A%#.9#9-%#429(24#2A
XC(;(4C# <%2<3%# 52/%9-(4C# A2'# 429-7
(4C?Y##k%9#:%#&24_9#9-(4*#9:()%#.!2,9
)2'<2'.9(245#.4&#C%4%'.9(245#2A#:-(9%7
<'(;(3%C%&#(4&(;(&,.35#'%)%(;(4C#A'2/
9-%#)2//245#A2'#429-(4C?
@-%5%# (4&(;(&,.3# :%.39-# X5,))%55
592'(%5Y# 4%%&# 92# !%# ,4<.)*%&?# a;%4
:-(9%#/(&&3%7)3.55#.)-(%;%/%49#4%%&5
92#!%#,4&%'5922&#.5#<'(;(3%C%&#.))%55
92#C2;%'4/%49#<'2C'./5#.4&#)2//24
:%.39-#9-.9#:.5#!,(39#9-'2,C-#9-%#%A7
A2'95# 2A# /.4"D# 52/%# 2A# :-2/# -.;%
429#!%4%A(9%&#A'2/#9-%('#2:4#%AA2'95?
Common Wealth for
the Common Good
N4#I%-G(%#G&H'>95L'E'T)GM$'(,'A$P
B#%GHG+.'(D$'I,HH,+&D#]%9%'#6.'4%5
.'C,%5#9-.9#:%#.'%#.9#.#-(592'().3#/27
/%49#:-%'%#2,'#)2//24#:%.39-#/,59
!%#'%)3.(/%&#.4&#5%),'%&#2'#:%#'(5*
<%'/.4%49#3255#2A#9-.9#:-()-#).4429
!%#'%<3.)%&?#8%#4%%&#92#A(4&#:."5#92
<'29%)9# 9-%# )2//245^.4&# ,5%# (95
!2,49"#A2'#9-%#)2//24#C22&D#429#A2'
h,59#9-%#<'(;(3%C%&#A%:?
8-(3%#<'(;.9%#:%.39-#(5#&(59'(!,9%&
,4%E,.33"D#)2//24#:%.39-#!%324C5#92
.33D#.4&#(95#!%4%A(95#5-2,3&D#:-%'%;%'
<255(!3%D# !%# ,4(;%'5.33"# 5-.'%&?# N47
)2/%# A'2/# )2//2457!.5%&# 52,')%5
5-2,3&#!%#,5%&#92#'%&,)%#(4%E,.3(9"#.4&
%U<.4&#2<<2'9,4(9"?
M9#9-%#5./%#9(/%D#)2//24#:%.395-2,3&#!%#/.4.C%&#429#h,59#24#!%-.3A
2A#9-25%#3(;(4C#42:D#!,9#.352#24#!%7
-.3A#2A#A,9,'%#C%4%'.9(245?##a.)-#C%47
%'.9(24#-.5#.4#2!3(C.9(24#92#<'%5%';%
(95#5-.'%&#(4-%'(9.4)%5#.4&#<.55#9-%/
24D#,4&(/(4(5-%&D#92#9-%#4%U9?
]%9%'#6.'4%5#5,CC%595#9-.9#9-%'%#.'%
9-'%%#3.'C%#<2235#2A#)2//24#:%.399-.9#5-2,3&#!%#9.<<%&#.9#.#4.9(24.3#3%;%3
92#%4-.4)%#9-%#)2//24#C22&?##@-%5%
.'%i#9-%#:.59%#.!52'<9(24#).<.)(9"#2A
4.9,'%l# 52)(.33"7)'%.9%&# :%.39-# ).<7
9,'%&#!"#(4&(;(&,.35l#.4&#52)(.33"7)'%7
.9%&#:%.39-#).<9,'%&#!"#)2'<2'.9(245?
@.*%4#92C%9-%'D#9-%5%#<2235#'%<'%5%49
!"#$%&$'()*+'(,'-%.$'Q0
1%234)+$'/556 7 ",?$*(2'@'A%B$ 7 8,#9':;<'=,9'> 7 >
!IJ11J=KL'I,+(G+)$M'F*,H'-%.$'>0
9'(33(245#2A#&233.'5#:2'9-#2A#5-.'%&#'%7
52,')%5# .4&# -,4&'%&5# 2A# !(33(245# 2A
&233.'5#(4#<29%49(.3#.44,.3#'%;%4,%?
V,'#)-.33%4C%#(5#92#(&%49(A"#<255(!3%
,5%5#2A#9-%5%#<2235#2A#)2//24#:%.39.4&#2'C.4(T%#92#%45,'%#9-%('#A.('#.3327
).9(24?##6.'4%5#5,CC%595#9-.9#9-%#)'(9%7
'(.#A2'#5%3%)9(4C#<29%49(.3#,5%5#5-2,3&
!%#9-.9#9-%"#.'%i#[F\#,4(;%'5.3D#[J\#<%'7
/.4%49#2'#<%'<%9,.3D#.4&#[f\#.(/%&#.9
'%&'%55(4C#-(592'().3#(4%E,(9(%5#).,5%&
!"# ,4%E,.3# &(59'(!,9(24# 2A# )2//24
:%.39-?# 8%# 4%%&# 92# -.;%# .# <'.)9().3
.4&# <23(9().3# &(5),55(24# .!2,9# :-())2//24#'%52,')%5#5-2,3&#!%#,5%&#A2'
:-()-#)2//24#C22&5?
1233%)9(;%3"D#:%#-.;%#.#<'%99"#C22&
5%45%# 2A# :-.9# 4%%&5# 92# !%# &24%# 92
!'2.&%4#:%.39-#.4&#2<<2'9,4(9"?##@-%
X:-(9%#243"Y#<'2C'./5#2A#9-%#3.59#HK
"%.'5#:%'%#5,))%55A,3#(4#3(A9(4C#9-%#2<7
<2'9,4(9(%5#A2'#.#5%C/%49#2A#9-%#<2<,7
3.9(24?# 12/!(4%&# :(9-# 52/%# 2A# 9-%
4%:#(442;.9(245#.'2,4&#.55%9#)'%.9(24D
:%#).4#&%9.(3#.#:%.39-7!'2.&%4(4C#<'27
C'./#9-.9#:2,3&#)325%#9-%#'.)(.3#:%.39&(;(&%?##@-%#%3%/%495#(4)3,&%i
m $%!97A'%%#-(C-%'#%&,).9(24D#3(*%
9-%#b?N?#6(33#.4&#]%33#C'.495#9-.9
%4.!3%&# /(33(245# 92# C'.&,.9%
A'2/#)233%C%#:(9-2,9#&%%<#&%!95?
m +.9)-(4C# 5.;(4C5# <'2C'./5D
5,)-#.5#N4&(;(&,.3#$%;%32</%49
M))2,495#[N$M5\#9-.9#!2359%'#<'(7
;.9%#:%.39-?
m d(&#>.;%#.))2,495#9-.9#)249'(!7
,9%#92#C'%.9%'#.55%97!,(3&(4C#.4&
2<<2'9,4(9"?#V4%#<'2<25.3#(5#92
.332).9%# 92# %;%'"# )-(3&# !2'4# (4
=?>?# .# 9.U7A'%%# (4-%'(9.4)%# 2A
PLDKKK?#8-%4#9-%#)-(3&#'%.)-%5
FID# A,4&5# [C'%.93"# .<<'%)(.9%&
2;%'#4%.'3"#9:2#&%).&%5\#)2,3&
!%# :(9-&'.:4# A2'# %&,).9(24D
A('59#-2/%#<,')-.5%#2'#59.'9(4C#.
!,5(4%55?
m aU<.4&%&# -2/%2:4%'5-(<D
9-'2,C-#;.'(2,5#A('5979(/%#-2/%7
2:4%'#/%)-.4(5/5#5,)-#.5#52A9
5%)24&#/2'9C.C%5#.4&#5,!5(&(T%&
(49%'%59#'.9%5?
m M44,.3#&(;(&%4&5#92#5,<<3%/%49
:.C%5?##M3.5*.#'%5(&%495#'%)%(;%
.4# .44,.3# &(;(&%4&# A'2/# 9-%
Anyone with substantial
wealth has gotten a
lot of help from the
commons.
M3.5*.#]%'/.4%49#`,4&D#.#<2'7
9(24#2A#9-%#59.9%_5#2(3#:%.39-?
m a59.!3(5-/%49# 2A# X12//,4(9"
8%.39-76,(3&(4CY# A,4&5D# <2235
2A#).<(9.3#92#<'2;(&%#5,<<2'9#A2'
)2//,4(9"#&%;%32</%49#)2'<27
'.9(245D#424<'2A(9#-2,5(4C#2'C.7
4(T.9(245D# %/<32"%%72:4%&
A('/5D# 52)(.3# %49%'<'(5%5D# )2/7
/,4(9"#3.4&#9',595#.4&#29-%'#)2/7
/,4(9"75%';(4CD# .55%97!,(3&(4C
%AA2'95?
Rep. Cohen’s Apology for Slavery Resolution
+%/<-(5# 124C'%55/.4# >9%;%
12-%4D# :-25%# )2//%495# 24
+()-.%3#W24%"_5#!22*#24#+Sd_5
3.59# )./<.(C4# .<<%.'%&# (4# 9-%
+.')-eM<'(3#"@AD#-.5#(49'2&,)%&
W?#B%5?#FGOD#.#B%523,9(24#XM<2327
C(T(4C#A2'#9-%#%453.;%/%49#.4&#'.7
)(.3#5%C'%C.9(24#2A#MA'().47#M/%'(7
).45?Y##N49'2&,)%&#24#`%!?#JR#:(9fH#2'(C(4.3#)275<2452'5D#(9#42:#-.5
RJ# )275<2452'5# .4&# -.5# !%%4# '%7
A%''%&#92#9-%#c,&()(.'"#12//?#A2'
/.'*,<?#@-%#X8-%'%.5Y#)3.,5%5#.'%
9',3"#%32E,%49#.4&#)2/<'%-%45(;%D
.4&#9-%#3.59#2A#9-%#9-'%%#XB%523;%&5Y
'%.&5#[email protected]#9-%#W2,5%#2A#B%<'%5%47
9.9(;%5#%U<'%55%5#(95#)2//(9/%49#92
'%)9(A"#9-%#3(4C%'(4C#)245%E,%4)%5#2A
9-%# /(5&%%&5# )2//(99%&# .C.(459
MA'().47M/%'().45# ,4&%'# 53.;%'"
.4&#c(/#1'2:#.4&#92#592<#9-%#2)7
),''%4)%#2A#-,/.4#'(C-95#;(23.9(245
(4#9-%#A,9,'%?Y#`,'9-%'#(4A?#(5#.;.(37
.!3%#A'2/#c./%5#].'*D#B%<?#12-%4_5
S%C(53.9(;%# M559?D# JKJeJJL7fJHLD
c./%5?].'*o/.(3?-2,5%?C2;?
Q 7 ",?$*(2'@'A%B$ 7 8,#9':;<'=,9'> 7 1%234)+$'/556
12//2457!.5%&#'%;%4,%#).4#C2#92
(4&(;(&,.35#2'#5,<<2'9#)2//245#(459(7
9,9(245# 9-.9# %U<.4&# 2<<2'9,4(9"?# N4
@%U.5D#.#<%')%49.C%#2A#2(3#:%.39-#)247
9'(!,9%5#92#5%;%'.3#9',59#A,4&5#9-.9#<."
A2'#d7FJ#.4&#-(C-%'#%&,).9(24?
W2:#:(33#:%#<."#A2'#9-(5#:%.39-7
!'2.&%4(4C#<'2C'./n##M4#(/<2'9.49
52,')%#2A#'%;%4,%#(5#92#-.'4%55#(4)2/%
A'2/#)2//2457!.5%&#52,')%5?
#*+,*-./0 (12.30 45,0 6+.7,+80 (19
357,*13?##W(592'().33"D#<233,9%'5#-.;%
&,/<%&#(492#9-%#5).')%#4.9,'.3#)2/7
/245#:(9-2,9#)259?##NA#:%#)-.'C%#A2'
9-%#,5%#2A#2,'#5-.'%&#4.9,'.3#'%52,')%5D
:%#)'%.9%#!29-#<'()%#(4)%49(;%5#92#'%7
&,)%#<233,9(24#.4&#C%4%'.9%#.#'%;%4,%
59'%./#A2'#9-%#)2//247C22&#,5%5#&%7
5)'(!%&#.!2;%?##8(9-#9-%#9'%/%4&2,5
<,5-#92#'%&,)%#).'!24#%/(55(245#.4&
.&&'%55#2,'#)3(/.9%#)'(5(5D#9-%'%#:(33
!%#4%:#/%)-.4(5/5#92#).<#).'!24#.4&
.55%55#A%%5?#@-%#9'2,!3%#:(9-#).<7.4&7
9'.&%#5"59%/5#92#&.9%#(5#9-%"#-.;%#!%%4
XC(;%7.:."5Y#92#-(592'()#<233,9%'5?##M
X5*"#9',59Y#)2,3&#).<9,'%#9-(5#5,!59.47
9(.3#'%;%4,%D#<'2!.!3"#(4#9-%#'.4C%#2A
!(33(245#2A#&233.'5#<%'#"%.'D#92#!'2.&%4
:%.39-#.4&#2<<2'9,4(9"?
:5;;520<1+8.=0(1*/*8-2>0%,59
>,+;?##NA#:%#'%)2C4(T%#9-.9#3.'C%#.)7
),/,3.9(245# 2A# <'(;.9%# (4&(;(&,.3
:%.39-#.'%#9-%#'%5,39#2A#)2//245D#:%
5-2,3&#/2'%#.CC'%55(;%3"#9.U#(4-%'(97
.4)%5#.4&#'%)")3%#9-%5%#2<<2'9,4(9(%5?
@-%'%#(5#.#)3%.'#/2'.3#'.9(24.3%#A2'#9.U7
(4C# (4-%'(9.4)%5i# >2)(.33"7)'%.9%&
:%.39-#/."#!%#9%/<2'.'(3"#)3.(/%&#!"
(4&(;(&,.35D#!,9#.9#52/%#<2(49#5-2,3&
'%9,'4# 92# 52)(%9"?# # N4-%'(9.4)%# 9.U%5
)2,3&# !%# &%&().9%&# 92# .# 8%.39-# V<7
<2'9,4(9"#`,4&#92#5%';%#.5#.#52,')%#A2'
5%;%'.3#2A#9-%#,5%5#&%5)'(!%&#.!2;%?
N4#8.5-(4C924#>9.9%D#9-%#59.9%_5#%57
9.9%# 9.U# (5# 3%;(%&# 24# %59.9%5# 2;%'# PJ
/(33(24#[PO#/(33(24#A2'#.#)2,<3%\?#@-(5
C%4%'.9%5# .!2,9# PFKK# /(33(24# .# "%.'
9-.9# (5# )-.44%3%&# (492# 9-%# a&,).9(24
S%C.)"# @',59# M))2,49?# # `,4&5# .'%
,5%&#92#'%&,)%#)3.55#5(T%#(4#d7FJ#%&,7
).9(24# 59.9%:(&%# .4&# <'2;(&%# -(C-%'
%&,).9(24# 5)-23.'5-(<5# A2'# RDGKK
32:%'7(4)2/%#59,&%495?##6(33#b.9%5D#>'?
&%A%4&%&#9-%#9.UD#2!5%';(4C#9-.9i#XNA
:%#.!23(5-#9-%#59.9%_5#(4-%'(9.4)%#9.U
:%#592<#9-%#2<<2'9,4(9"7'%)")3(4C#<'27
C'./?#8%#.332:#9-%#)2//24#:%.39-
92#592<#A32:(4C#.4&#)24)%49'.9%#(9#(4
9-%# -.4&5# 2A# .# A%:?# M4&# :2'5%D# :%
532:# 9-%# (4;%59/%495# (4# 2<<2'9,4(9"
9-.9#.(/#92#<'2;(&%#%;%'"#"2,4C#<%'7
524#.#)-.4)%D#:-%9-%'#9-%"#:%'%#!2'4
(4#>2,9-#>%.993%#2'#+%')%'#N53.4&?Y
Socially-Created
Wealth Captured
by Corporations
12'<2'.9(245#.352#-23&#52)(.33"7)'%7
.9%&# :%.39-^.4&# :%# 5-2,3&# 322*# .9
/%.45#92#'%).<9,'%#52/%#2A#9-(5#:%.39A2'#9-%#)2//24#C22&?##]%9%'#6.'4%5
&%5)'(!%5#9-%#4,/%'2,5#:."5#9-.9#527
)(%9"#9'.45A%'5#:%.39-#92#)2'<2'.9(245?
`('59D#:%#C'.49#9-%/#5<%)(.3#<'(;(3%C%5
9-.9# .'%# 429# .;.(3.!3%# 92# '%.3# -,/.4
!%(4C5D#5,)-#.5#3(/(9%&#3(.!(3(9"D#<%'<%7
9,.3#3(A%#.4&#9-%#.!(3(9"#92#C'2:#:(9-7
2,9#3(/(9?##8%#5,<<3%/%49#9-%5%#C(A95
:(9-#29-%'#<'(;(3%C%5D#5,)-#.5#<.9%495
.4&# )2<"'(C-95# 9-.9# %4.!3%# 9-%/# 92
)-.'C%#-(C-%'#<'()%5#9-.4#.#9',3"#)2/7
<%9(9(;%#/.'*%9#:2,3&#.332:?##V4#92<
2A# 9-.9D# 52)(%9"# )'%.9%5# <,!3()# (4A'.7
59',)9,'%^'2.&5D# 9-%# N49%'4%9D# '%C,7
3.9%&#).<(9.3#/.'*%95#.4&#9'.&%#<23(7
)(%5^9-.9#C'%.93"#%4-.4)%5#)2'<2'.9%
:%.39-?##M4&#24#92<#2A#9-.9D#:%#2A9%4
C(;%#)2'<2'.9(245#)2//24#'%52,')%5
[3.4&#92#'.(3'2.&#)2/<.4(%5D#/(4%'.35
92# /(4(4C# )2/<.4(%5D# 5<%)9',/# 92
!'2.&).59%'5D#<233,9(24#'(C-95#92#<237
3,9%'5\#:2'9-#!(33(245?
8%# '.9(24.3(T%# 9-%5%# )2//24
:%.39-#C(A95#92#)2'<2'.9(245#!"#.'C,7
(4C#9-.9#)2'<2'.9(245#)'%.9%#h2!5#.4&
59'%4C9-%4#2,'#%)242/"?##6,9#(4#'%.37
(9"D# /259# 2A# 9-%5%# !%4%A(95# A32:# 92
<'(;(3%C%&#%3(9%5#:-2#2:4#/259#2A#9-%
)2'<2'.9(24_5#592)*#.4&#.'%#&(5<'2<2'7
9(24.9%3"# :-(9%?# # 12'<2'.9(245# <."
!.)*#.#<2'9(24#2A#9-(5#9-'2,C-#)2'<27
'.9%#(4)2/%#9.U%5D#!,9#9-(5#)249'(!,7
9(24#(5#5-'(4*(4C#92#429-(4C#A2'#52/%
2A# 9-%# )2,49'"_5# /259# <'2A(9.!3%# %47
9%'<'(5%5?##6.'4%5#<'2<25%5#.#3%;"#24
)2'<2'.9%# :%.39-D# <3.)(4C# .# <%')%497
.C%#2A#592)*#(492#.4#M/%'().4#]%'/.7
4%49#`,4&D#92#!%#/.4.C%&#24#!%-.3A
2A#9-%#)2//24#C22&?
@-%5%#.'%#h,59#.#A%:#%U./<3%5#2A
:."5#92#)'%.9(;%3"#<.('#52,')%5#2A#)2/7
/24#:%.39-#:(9-#)2//247C22&#,5%5?
Michael Honey
]'2A?# W24%"D# .,9-2'# 2A# T,G+.
R,S+'4$*GBD,'A,%ML'ND$'1$H-DG&
K(*GV$<'1%*(G+'^)(D$*'_G+.`&'^%&(
I%H-%G.+'[-(5#<'%)(5#2A#:-()-#:.5
9-%#3%.&#.'9()3%#(4#9-%#+.')-eM<'(3
"@A\D# :(33# 5<%.*# 24# +."# FLD
H7RifK# </# .9# 6,5!2"5# 0# ]2%95
[FO9-#0#g#Z8\D#$1_5#C'%.9#4%:
!22*592'%#[',4#!"#2,'#<.'94%'#2'7
C.4(T.9(24#@%.)-(4C#A2'#1-.4C%\e
/%%9(4C# <3.)%e'%59.,'.49?# M352
5<%.*(4C#.!2,9#-(5#4%:#!22*D#X*,H
IG?G#'AG.D(&'(,'a)H%+'AG.D(&L'1%*P
@-%#@2/.3%5#6."#N459(9,9%#(5#5<2452'7
(4C#.#5%'(%5#2A#)24A%'%4)%5#.4&#&(5),57
5(245#.(/%&#.9#A3%5-(4C#2,9#.#5%'(%5#2A
<23()"#(4(9(.9(;%5#[5%%#!%32:\?
We need to find ways to
protect the commons—
and use its bounty for
the common good, not
the privileged few.
@.<<(4C#9-%#)2//245#A2'#(4(9(.9(;%5
92#'%&,)%#9-%#'.)(.3#:%.39-#&(;(&%#(5#.4
.<<'2<'(.9%#.4&#4%)%55.'"#'%/%&"#92
)%49,'(%5#2A#%U)3,5(24#A'2/#)2//24
:%.39-?##1,''%49#)249%595#2;%'#).<<(4C
2A#).'!24#%/(55(245#.4&#<'%5%';(4C#9-%
A%&%'.3#%59.9%#9.U#<'2;(&%#(//%&(.9%
2<<2'9,4(9(%5#92#(4h%)9#9-(5#)2//245
<%'5<%)9(;%#(492#<,!3()#<23()"#.4&#9-%
<,!3()#)245)(2,54%55?
R$M*GBV' 1)D%HH%M' !M$M*GBVHW
.H%G#9B,H0'G&'E&&,BG%($'X$##,S'%('(D$
Y+&(G()($'F,*'",#GB2'K()MG$&'%+M'B,P%)P
(D,*',F'ZK(%($',F'(D$'R*$%H'/55Q['%+M
ZK(%($',F'(D$'R*$%H'/55U9[
ID)BV'I,##G+&'!BD)BVWG-&PMB9,*.0
G&'%'&$+G,*'&BD,#%*'%('(D$'Y+&(G()($'F,*
",#GB2'K()MG$&'%+M'B,P%)(D,*',F'@-%
+2'.3# +%.5,'%# 2A# 9-%# a)242/"
!J*\G&<' /5560' %+M' a)242/()# M<.'97
-%(&#(4#M/%'().'!=$S'"*$&&<'/55U09
NDG&'&)HH$*<'(D$'N,H%#$&']%2'Y+P
&(G()($'G&'B,+?$+G+.'%'I,HH,+'C$%#(D
(G+'^)(D$*'_G+.<'4*9'%+M'(D$'K(*)..#$
F,*'OB,+,HGB'4)&(GB$D#:(33#!%#]'2A?
@-2/.5# c.)*524# 2A# 9-%# =Z17
b'%%45!2'2#W(592'"#$%<9?##8(33(./
S,)"D#]'%5?#2A#9-%#12.3?#2A#63.)*
@'.&%#=4(24(595#.4&#>%)?e@'%.5?#2A
M`>1+aD#:(33#!%#.#)2//%49.92'D
.4&# 9-%'%# :(33# !%# /,5()# !"# a3(5%
6'".49#.4&#9-%#$1#S.!2'#1-2',5?
]BBM1#(5#)275<2452'(4C#9-%#%;%49?
NA#"2,_'%#.4":-%'%#4%.'#$1D#)2/%
[.4&#-.;%#.#C22&#/%.3#!%A2'%D#&,'7
(4C#2'#.A9%'\?
N%&V'X,*B$'(,'\)G#M'&)--,*('F,*'-,#GB2
G+G(G%(G?$&'(,'-*,($B('(D$'B,HH,+&'%+M
*$MG*$B('B,HH,+&P\%&$M'*$?$+)$'(,'(D$
B,HH,+'.,,M9''X,*'H,*$'G+F,*H%(G,+<
B,+(%B('(D$'%)(D,*&9'N]Y'-*,H,($&'-)\P
#GB' )+M$*&(%+MG+.' ,F' (D$' B,HH,+&
(D*,).D'-)\#GB%(G,+&<'.%(D$*G+.&<'H$P
MG%',)(*$%BD'%+M'%'?%*G$(2',F'-*,b$B(&9
X,*'H,*$'G+F,*H%(G,+'%\,)('(D$'B,HP
H,+&' %+M' &$?$*%#' F*$$' %+M' M,S+P
#,%M%\#$' -)\#GB%(G,+&<' &$$' SSS9
,+(D$B,HH,+&9,*.'❏
Further Readings
]%9%'# 6.'4%5D# I%-G(%#G&H' >95L' E
T)GM$' (,' A$B#%GHG+.' (D$' I,HP
H,+&# [6%''%99# d2%-3%'D# JKKH\
$.3924# 1243%"D# ]$G+.' ]#%BV<' ^G?P
G+.' G+' (D$' A$M# [=4(;%'5(9"# 2A
1.3(A2'4(.# ]'%55D# FGGG\
d%44%9-# c.)*524<' I*%\.*%&&' X*,+P
(G$*# [VUA2'&# =4(;%'5(9"# ]'%55D
FGIR\
W%.9-%'# 6%9-# c2-4524D# ND$' EH$*GP
B%+' R*$%H' %+M' (D$' ",S$*' ,F
C$%#(D# # [B2,93%&C%D# JKKH\
N'.# d.9T4%3524D# CD$+' EFFG*H%(G?$
EB(G,+' C%&' CDG($# [8?8?
Z2'924D# JKKL\
+%(T-,#S,(D#6.'!.'.#B2!3%5D#6%95"
S%24&.'78'(C-9D# ND$' I,#,*' ,F
C$%#(D# [Z%:# ]'%55D# JKKH\
+%3;(4# V3(;%'# .4&# @-2/.5
>-.<('2D# ]#%BV' C$%#(D<' CDG($
C$%#(D# [B2,93%&C%D# FGGL\
@-2/.5# >-.<('2D# ND$' aGMM$+' I,&(
,F']$G+.'EF*GB%+'EH$*GB%+#[VU7
A2'&# =4(;%'5(9"# ]'%55D# JKKO\
1%234)+$'/556 7 ",?$*(2'@'A%B$ 7 8,#9':;<'=,9'> 7 U