Photoelectrical detection of electron spin resonance of nitrogen-vacancy centres in
diamond
E. Bourgeois1,2, A. Jarmola3, M. Gulka1,4, J. Hruby1,4, D. Budker3,5 and M. Nesladek1,2*
1
IMOMEC division, IMEC, Kapeldreef 75, B 3001 Leuven, Belgium
Hasselt University, Martelarenlaan 42, B-3500 Hasselt, Belgium
3
Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, California 94720-7300, USA
4
Czech Technical University in Prague, Sitna sq. 3105, 272 01, Kladno, Czech Republic
5
Helmholtz Institute, Johannes Gutenberg University, Mainz, Germany
2
*Correspondence to: [email protected]
Abstract:
The protocols for the control and readout of Nitrogen Vacancy (NV) centres electron spins in diamond
offer an advanced platform for quantum computation, metrology and sensing. These protocols are based
on the optical readout of photons emitted from NV centres, which process is limited by the yield of
photons collection. Here we report on a novel principle for the detection of NV centres magnetic
resonance in diamond by directly monitoring spin-preserving electron transitions through measurement of
NV centre related photocurrent. The demonstrated direct detection technique offers a sensitive way for
the readout of diamond NV sensors and diamond quantum devices on diamond chips. The Photocurrent
Detection of Magnetic Resonance (PDMR) scheme is based on the detection of charge carriers promoted
to the conduction band of diamond by the two-photon ionization of NV- centres. Optical detection of
magnetic resonance (ODMR) and PDMR are compared, by performing both measurements
simultaneously. The minima detected in the measured photocurrent at resonant microwave frequencies
are attributed to the spin-dependent occupation probability of the NV- ground state, originating from spinselective non-radiative transitions.
One Sentence Summary:
We report novel photoelectrical readout of NV centres magnetic resonance in diamond and describe the
mechanism allowing this novel detection scheme.
Main Text:
Addressing and reading the electron spin of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centres in diamond hold great
promise for quantum computing and secure communication (1, 2), as well as for nanoscale magnetic and
electric sensing (3, 4, 5) and for non-perturbing sensing and imaging of quantum objects (6, 7). At
present, the readout of NV centres electron spin state is only performed optically, by detecting photons
using confocal microscopy. No simple spin read-out techniques allowing for integration with electronic
chips are available. One of the limiting factors of the optical detection scheme is the low collection
efficiency of photons emitted by NV centres in bulk diamond. Due to the limitations of objective optics
and to the diamond index of refraction, detection efficiency higher than a few percent can only be
obtained by complex micro-fabrication (8). Additionally, NV centres-based quantum computing involves
positioning adjacent NV centres at a distance of approximately 10 nm (9). The individual optical readout
of such close NV centres is difficult, since it requires a resolution below the diffraction limit. In this
report we describe a novel non-optical technique based on the direct photoelectrical read-out of NV
centres electron spin resonance. Contrary to a recently proposed scheme, in which the read-out of NV
centres is performed via the monitoring of non-radiative energy transfers to graphene (10), our method
relies on the direct photo-excitation of charge carriers from NV centres to the diamond conduction band
and on the collection of charge carriers by electrodes fabricated on the diamond chip. This scheme is
denoted as photocurrent detection of magnetic resonance (PDMR). The presented technique avoids the
complexity of confocal imaging and allows the detection of NV spin resonance in light scattering media,
which will be an advantage for various sensing applications. The PDMR technique, demonstrated here on
spin ensembles, can be used for the readout of individual NV centres spins. It may in addition
significantly outperform the efficiency of optical detection since every photon has the ability to generate
more than one electron-hole pair, due to the photocurrent gain mechanism (11).
The detailed mechanism for the photoelectrical detection of NV centre electron spin resonance is reported
below. To demonstrate this detection principle, optical detection of magnetic resonance (ODMR) and
PDMR are performed simultaneously on a type-Ib single-crystal diamond plate of [100] crystallographic
orientation. A crystal with an initial concentration of approximately 200 ppm of substitutional nitrogen
(Ns0) is electron-irradiated and thermally annealed, leading to a concentration of NV- centres around 20
ppm. Coplanar interdigitated electrodes are prepared on the oxidized diamond surface. A green linearly
polarized laser beam (532 nm) pulsed by an acousto-optical modulator is focused onto the diamond
surface, in between the coplanar electrodes. Photoluminescence light emitted under the effect of green
excitation is collected, filtered and focused onto a pyroelectric detector connected to a lock-in amplifier.
For photocurrent measurements, the photo-carriers generated upon green illumination are driven towards
electrodes by an electric field, created by applying a DC voltage between electrodes [Fig. 1(A)]. The
photocurrent is amplified with a low-noise current preamplifier and measured using a lock-in amplifier.
Lock-in amplification leads to a high signal-to-noise ratio and allows us to detect a photocurrent in the
range of 10 to 100 pA with a four digit precision. A microwave field of fixed power is produced using a
metal wire pressed across the diamond surface, and insulated from coplanar electrodes by a coating (see
Supplementary materials for details on sample preparation and experimental set-up).
The intensity of photoluminescence and photocurrent are measured simultaneously while scanning the
microwave frequency, in the absence and in the presence of an external magnetic field [Fig. 1(B)].
Minima in the photoluminescence intensity are observed at microwave frequencies inducing resonant
transitions between the |0> and the |±1> spin sublevels of the NV- spin triplet ground state (3A2), as
classically reported in ODMR measurements (12). Minima in photocurrent are clearly detected at
identical frequencies, demonstrating that photocurrent measurements can be used to detect the spin
resonances of NV- centres.
The two resonances observed in ODMR and PDMR spectra in the absence of an external magnetic field
indicate the existence of a zero-field splitting between linear combinations of the |+1> and |-1> spin
sublevels of NV-, induced by local strain in the material (13). The origin of the small difference (< 1.5
MHz) in the position of the minima observed in ODMR and PDMR spectra is discussed in
Supplementary materials. In the presence of an external static magnetic field applied using a permanent
magnet, a further splitting of resonant frequencies is observed, both in ODMR and PDMR spectra,
reflecting the shift of |-1> and |+1> spin sublevels of NV- ground state due to the Zeeman effect. As
expected (14), two magnetic resonances are observed when the magnetic field is applied along the [100]
direction of the diamond crystal and four when it is applied along the [111] direction [Fig. 1(B)].
A
1.04
No extern
nal magnetic field
External magnetic field along
a
[100] direcction
External magnetic field along
a
[111] direcction
1.011
1.008
1.00
1.005
0.96
1.002
0.92
0.999
0.88
0.996
0.84
2800
2820
2840
2860
2880
0
2900
292
20
Photocurrent intensity (arb. units)
Photoluminescence intensity (arb. units)
B
2940
Micro
owave frequenccy (MHz)
Fig. 1: Schem
matic represenntation of the sset-up used forr PDMR (A). Comparison oof ODMR (topp part of the fiigure, left axiss) and
PDMR (bottoom part of thee figure, right axis) spectra recorded sim
multaneously (ggreen light poower: 100 mW
W) (B). Spectrra are
normalized foor clarity.
To determiine the photto-ionizationn mechanissm inducingg the photoccurrent miniima at NV- spin resonaance
frequenciess, the photocurrent inteensity has beeen measureed as a funcction of the green light power (Figg. 2).
A good fitt to the expperimental data is obttained usingg the sum oof a linear and a quadratic functtion,
indicating that the meeasured phootocurrent rresults from
m the superpposition off a one-photton and a twot
photon ionnization proocess (15). In previouss experimennts dealing with NV ccentre physics (15) annd in
theoretical studies (166, 17) it haas been demonstrated that a phooton energyy higher thaan 2.6 eV was
necessary to
t induce thhe photo-ioonization off NV- via a one-photonn process, i.e.
i to direcctly promotee an
electron from the groound state of
o NV to the conducction band. Based on this argum
ment and onn the
quadratic power
p
depenndence of tthe photocuurrent, we cconclude thaat a two-phhoton absorpption processs is
responsiblee for the NV
V-related paart of the photocurrent iinduced by green light (2.33 eV). The
T mechannism
for the twoo-photon ionnization of NV
N centres in diamondd has been eexperimentaally establishhed (15, 18,, 19)
and modellled (19). Inn this process, the absoorption of a first photoon promotess an electroon from the 3A2
triplet grouund state off NV- to its 3E triplet eexcited statee [Fig. 3(A)), transitionn (1)] and a second photon
excites thiss electron too the conducction band oof diamond [[Fig. 3(B), ((4)], which rresults in thhe conversioon of
the NV cenntre to its neeutral state NV0 and inn the promottion of an eelectron intoo the conducction band [[Fig.
3(C)]. To eensure the ccharge neutrrality and thhe photocurrrent stabiliity in the PD
DMR detection circuit,, the
0
NV centrees formed byy ionisationn of NV havve to be subbsequently cconverted back to the N
NV- state, eiither
by capturinng an electroon from a ddonor defectt (in particuular from Ns0, present iin high conccentration inn the
1b sample under studyy) (20, 21) oor by two-pphoton conversion from
m NV0 to NV
V-. In the lattter process, the
0
p
excittes the NV centre [Figg. 3(C), (5)]], while a second photoon promotees an
absorption of a first photon
NV0 [Fig. 3(C), (6)], leeaving a hole in the valeence
electron froom the valennce band to the vacatedd orbital of N
band (15, 119).
Photocurrent intensity (arb. units)
The linear fraction of the measured photocurrent (Fig. 2) is most probably associated with the one-photon
ionization of NS0. NS0 is indeed the dominant point defect in our sample and the threshold energy for the
photoionization of this defect is well below the 2.33 eV excitation energy used in our experiment, as
reported in (22, 23).
0.08
Measured photocurrent intensity
2
Fit to photocurrent intensity (f(p) = ap + bp)
Linear fraction of photocurrent intensity
(calculated from fit)
0.07
0.06
2-photon
ionization
0.05
0.04
0.03
1-photon
ionization
0.02
0.01
0.00
0
30
60
90
120
150
180
Green light power (mW)
Fig. 2: Influence of the 532 nm light power on the photocurrent intensity.
Fig. 3: Enerrgy level scheeme of the NV
V- centre and description of tthe mechanism
m proposed to explain PDMR
R measuremennts.
For the purppose of illustraation, the distaance between tthe top of the ddiamond valennce band (VB)) and the grouund state of NV
V- is
3
not represennted at the corrrect scale. Thee absorption oof a first photoon promotes ann electron from
m the A2 grouund state to thee 3E
3
3
excited sttate of NV (A
A, transition (11)). From E, eelectrons can rradiatively deccay to A2 (2) or be excited to
t the diamondd
conductionn band (CB) bby the absorptiion of a secondd photon (4). The
T spin-selecctive non-radiaative decay off electrons to tthe
metastable siinglet state 1A1 (3) enables P
PDMR (B). Tw
wo-photon ionnization of NV
V- results in the formation off a NV0 centree and
a free electtron in the CB (C). By a twoo-photon proceess (5) (6) the NV centre caan finally be coonverted backk to its negatively
charged statee (D).
MR detectioon scheme aallows for thhe detectionn of NV- spiin resonancee, by
Figure 1(B) confirms tthat our PDM
T minima observed inn photocurrrent correspond to resonant
monitoringg the spin-prreserving transitions. The
MW frequeencies induccing transitiions from thhe |0> to thee |±1> electrron spin subblevels of N
NV- ground state
s
(3A2). From
m this obseervation, it can be innferred that electrons in the |±1>
> sublevelss have a loower
probabilityy to be prom
moted to the conduction band than eelectrons iniitially situatted in the |0>
> spin subleevel.
In ODMR
R, the contrrast in phootoluminesceence intenssity between NV |0> and |±1> spin subleevels
originates ffrom the exxistence of the singlet states (1A1 and 1E) inn the electroonic structurre of NV- ((24).
Under the effect of grreen illuminnation, elecctrons are innitially pum
mped into thhe 3A2 |0> sspin state, ffrom
which theyy are cohereently drivenn to the 3A2 |±1> spin sublevels by
b the resonnant microw
wave field ((25).
Since opticcal transitionns betweenn NV grounnd and excitted state aree spin conseerving, the absorption of a
photon proomotes elecctrons initiaally in the |0> (respeectively |±11>) spin suublevel of 3A2 to the |0>
(respectively |±1>) spiin sublevel of 3E [Fig. 3(A), (1)]. Photoluminnescence orriginates froom the radiaative
decay of electrons to thhe ground state [Fig. 3((B), (2)]. Hoowever, duee to spin-selective interssystem crosssing
(26), electrrons in the 3E |±1> sublevels have a much highher probabillity than eleectrons in thhe 3E |0> state to
decay non--radiatively to the 1A1 singlet staate [lifetimee ≤ 1 ns (224)], from which theyy fall to thee 1E
metastable singlet statte [Fig. 3(B
B)]. This noon-radiative decay pathh [Fig. 3(B)), (3)] inducces a differeence
between thhe photolum
minescence bbrightness off the differeent NV- spinn sublevels and enabless ODMR. Inn the
same way, the photoccurrent deteection of maagnetic resoonances is enabled
e
by the existennce of this nonn
radiative decay path. Since the 3E |±1> spin sublevels present a shorter lifetime (7.3 ns) than the 3E |0>
sublevel (13.7 ns) (27), an electron excited to the 3E |±1> spin sublevels has a lower probability to be
promoted to the conduction band by the absorption of a second photon [Fig. 3(B), (4)] than an electron
occupying the 3E |0> sublevels. In addition, for the time during which the 3E |±1> electron undergoes the
cycle of optical transitions via inter-state crossing to the 3A2 |0> sublevel, it does not contribute to the
photocurrent. The 1E metastable state has a lifetime of 220 ns at room temperature (24). For that period,
the 1E state stores the electron, leading to a temporary decrease in the occupation of NV- ground state and
reducing the rate of two-photon ionization (proportional to the occupation of 3A2).
Figure 4 depicts the influence of the green light power on the ODMR and PDMR contrasts. The maximal
observed contrast is ~1 % for PDMR and 10.7 % for ODMR. This is to a large degree due to the fact that
for the measured sample only the two-photon fraction of the photocurrent (associated to the ionization of
NV-) gives rise to detectable electron spin resonances, while its linear fraction is not affected by the
microwaves. The monotonous increase in the PDMR contrast with the incident light power (Fig. 4) can
thus be explained by the increase in the two-photon quadratic fraction of the photocurrent with respect to
the linear fraction. However, while the quadratic fraction of the photocurrent increases by a factor 4
between 30 mW and 180 mW (Fig. 2), the PDMR contrast only increases by a factor 2. This can be partly
explained by the fact that in the same range of laser power the ODMR contrast decreases (Fig.4), which
has been attributed to saturation (14).
ODMR contrast
PDMR contrast
Linear fit to PDMR constrast
1.0
10.5
0.9
10.0
0.8
9.5
0.7
9.0
0.6
8.5
0.5
0
30
60
90
120
150
PDMR contrast (%)
ODMR constrast (%)
11.0
180
Green light power (mW)
Fig. 4: Influence of the 532 nm light power on the ODMR and PDMR contrasts [defined as the depth of the drop in the
photoluminescence or photocurrent signal at the second zero-magnetic field resonance (F2 ~ 2873 MHz)].
An increase in the PDMR contrast could be obtained by further increasing the power of the green
excitation, or by using photons of lower energy to induce the ionization of NV- centres without ionizing
Ns0 or other defects in diamond.
The presented experiment demonstrates a new principle for the readout of the magnetic resonance of
NV centres electron spins in diamond. By reducing the contact area, this technique has the potential to
address single NV centres. This paradigm may lead to a sensitive way for the construction of diamond
nanoscale sensors and quantum devices and their direct readout, allowing directly performing quantum
operation on chip.
References:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
P. C. Maurer et al., Science 336, 1283-1286 (2012)
W. Pfaff et al., Science 345, 532-535 (2014)
J. R. Maze et al., Nature 455, 644-647 (2008)
T. Häberle, D. Schmid-Lorch, K. Karrai, F. Reinhard, J. Wrachtrup, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 170801
(2013)
F. Dolde et al., PRL 112, 097603 (2014)
T. Staudacher et al., Science 339, 561-563 (2013)
L. P. McGuinness et al., New J. Phys. 15, 073042 (2013)
J. P. Hadden et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 97, 241901 (2010)
L. Childress, R. Hanson, MRS Bulletin 38, 134-138 (2013)
A. Brenneis et al., Nat. Nanotechnol., doi:10-1038 (2014)
Z. Remes, R. Petersen, K. Haenen, M. Nesladek, M. D'Olieslaeger, Diamond Relat. Mater. 14, 556560 (2005)
M. Simanovskaia et al., Phys. Rev. B 87, 224106 (2013)
L. Rondin et al., Reports on Progress in Physics 77, 056503 (2014)
K. Jensen, V. M. Acosta, A. Jarmola, D. Budker, Phys. Rev. B 87, 014115 (2013)
N. Aslam, G. Waldherr, P. Neumann, F. Jelezko, J. Wrachtrup, New J. Phys. 15, 013064 (2013)
J. R. Weber et al., PNAS 107, 8513-8518 (2010)
P. Deak, B. Aradi, M. Kaviani, T. Frauenheim, A. Gali, Phys. Rev. B 89, 075202 (2014)
K. Beha, A. Batalov, N. B. Manson, R. Bratschitsh, A. Leitenstorfer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 097404
(2012)
P. Siyuchev et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 167402 (2013)
A. T. Collins, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 14, 3743-3750 (2002)
A. Wotherspoon, J. W. Steeds, B. Catmull, J. Butler, Diamond Relat. Mater. 12, 652-657 (2003)
J. Rosa et al., Diamond Relat. Mater. 7, 1048-1053 (1998)
F. J. Heremans, G.D. Fuchs, C. F. Wang, R. Hanson, D. D. Awschalom, APL 94, 152102 (2009)
V. M. Acosta, A. Jarmola, E. Bauch, D. Budker, Phys. Rev. B. 82, 201202 (2010)
R. Hanson, O. Gywat, D. D. Awschalom, Phys. Rev. B 74, 161203 (2006)
J. P. Tetienne et al., New J. Phys. 14, 103033 (2012)
L. Robledo, H. Bernien, T. van der Sar, R. Hanson, New J. Phys. 13, 025013 (2011)
Acknowledgments: This work was supported by the AFOSR/DARPA QuASAR program, The Research
Foundation - Flanders (FWO) (Grant agreement G.088812N), the European Union Seventh Framework
Programme (FP7/2007-2013) under the project DIADEMS (grant agreement n°611143) and the Ministry
of Science and Education of the Czech Republic (Contract CZ.1.07/2.3.00/20.0306). The authors are
grateful to F. Jelezko and P. Kehayias for helpful discussions, to K. Aulenbacher and the MAMI staff for
electron irradiation, and to Y. Balasubramaniam and P. Robaeys for electrodes fabrication.