What are the differences between a democracy and a dictatorship?

CLOSE
28
What are the differences between a democracy
and a dictatorship?
See how quickly you can use your knowledge and understanding to sort out the statements
in the boxes into two groups: Democracy or Dictatorship.
128
People can follow any religion
they wish. They are allowed to
join trade unions.
The government controls the
media. People are only allowed
to see and hear what the
government wants them to.
People have the freedom to
criticise the government and
protest about its policies.
The government is the law! The
secret police and the army keep
people under control.
No choice of government –
there is only one political party.
A government has a limited
time in power, after which
voters can choose a different
government.
Newspapers and the media can
say what they like about the
government.
People who criticise the
government may be imprisoned
or tortured.
Everyone, including the
government, must obey the law.
People are only allowed to
follow beliefs that are approved
by the government. Trade
unions are banned.
SHP History Year 9 Teacher’s Resource Book
© Hodder Education, 2009
© Hodder Education, 2009
How did they change
people’s lives?
(a) work (b) women and
the family (c) young people
How did they keep control?
How did they rise to
power?
What did they believe in?
Early life
Category
Stalin
Hitler similarities
Hitler differences
Similarity rating
(out of 10)
As you work through this enquiry use the information from pages 108–121 to complete the chart. Make sure you summarise in short bullet points
that give the important detail.
How similar were Stalin and Hitler?
29
CLOSE
SHP History Year 9 Teacher’s Resource Book
129
CLOSE
30
What did Stalin believe in?
Use the information on page 108 to answer these questions.
1. Why did Karl Marx think the workers in factories would rise up and take over power for
themselves?
2. What did Marx expect the workers’ government in a communist society to do?
3. In Russia, why do you think communist ideas gained some support?
4. Who was the leader of the Russian communists?
5. Copy and complete the ten bullet points to show changes made by Lenin:
• Factories were run by ...
• Land was ...
• Rich people lost their ...
• The only political party was ...
• Newspapers were ...
• Everyone could enjoy ...
• Men and women were ...
• Everybody called each other ...
• The Tsar and his family ...
• The old Russian Empire was called ...
130
SHP History Year 9 Teacher’s Resource Book
© Hodder Education, 2009
CLOSE
31
How similar were Stalin and Hitler?
You can choose from the two possible starter sentences (a or b) to help you write each
paragraph of your answer to the question about Stalin and Hitler on page 122.
Paragraph 1
a. Comparing
the early lives of dictators may give clues about why they followed the
policies they did.
b. Stalin’s and Hitler’s early lives and beliefs may have influenced how they developed
their political ideas later.
Paragraph 2
a. Stalin and Hitler rose to power in the 1920s.
b. In the 1920s Stalin and Hitler both played an
important role in their political parties
but neither was expected to lead his country.
Paragraph 3
a. Stalin and Hitler had to find ways to keep control after they took over as rulers.
b. In the USSR and in Germany there were people who did not agree with Stalin and
Hitler, so both leaders had to find ways of keeping their power.
Paragraph 4
a. Dictatorships had a big impact on the lives of workers, women and children.
b. The policies that Hitler and Stalin introduced in their countries brought about
important changes in people’s lives.
You can use the following connective words and phrases to complete the middle sections of
the hamburger:
a. There are many similarities in … Or There are many differences in …
b. Stalin and Hitler are similar because … Or Stalin and Hitler are different because
…
c. Stalin and Hitler’s policies on ... are very alike in the way … Or Stalin and
Hitler’s policies on … are very different in the way …
d. One thing about Stalin and Hitler that is virtually the same is … Or One thing
about Stalin and Hitler that is totally different is …
e. Both Stalin and Hitler … Or Stalin … but Hitler … [end the sentence with a
general statement such as ‘needed to get rid of opposition’, then give specific
examples]
Follow these sentences with:
a. For example, … Stalin …
b. An example of this is Stalin’s
In the same kind of way Hitler …
use of …
Hitler also …
Or with:
a. For example, Stalin …
On the other
b. This can be seen in the way Stalin …
c. Stalin …
However, Hitler …
hand, Hitler …
In contrast, Hitler …
End with:
Overall …
Or
© Hodder Education, 2009
In conclusion, …
SHP History Year 9 Teacher’s Resource Book
131
CLOSE
32A
What can Frank’s story tell us about how Jews
were persecuted in countries that the Nazis
occupied?
Use this sheet to help you with the Activity on page 128. Match the restriction cards below to
possible consequences for Jewish families. See Activity sheet 32B. Add any of your own ideas
about how the restrictions may have affected Jewish families.
Restrictions placed on Jews
10.10.1940:
Jews not eligible to obtain clothing
coupons.
22.09.1939:
Handing over of radio receivers.
01.05.1942:
The sale to Jews of German newspapers
is a punishable offence.
20.12.1941:
Confiscation of sewing machines.
16.03.1939:
Jews excluded from being lawyers,
teachers, members of juries, engineers.
Jews cannot be vets, chemists, artists.
Jewish doctors may only treat Jewish
patients.
10.01.1941:
Collection of articles of fur and woollens.
September 1939:
Jews are forbidden to be out of doors
after 20:00.
20.02.1941:
Jews are forbidden to visit cinemas,
theatres and sports events.
20.02.1941:
The shopping period for Jews limited to
between 15:00 and 17:00 hours.
17.05.1940:
Jews are forbidden to enter Prague’s
public parks and gardens.
July 1941:
Jews are to hand in pets, such as dogs,
cats and birds.
24.09.1941:
Jews are excluded from all but one post
office, access limited to between 13:00
and 15:00 hours.
October 1941:
All synagogues and prayer rooms are to
be closed.
17.09.1941:
Distribution of distinguishing Jewish
yellow star.
132
SHP History Year 9 Teacher’s Resource Book
© Hodder Education, 2009
CLOSE
32B
What can Frank’s story tell us about how Jews
were persecuted in countries that the Nazis
occupied?
Use this sheet to help you with the Activity on page 128. Match the restriction cards on
Activity sheet 32A to possible consequences for Jewish families. Add any of your own ideas
about how the restrictions may have affected Jewish families.
Consequences
A This meant that clothing, if it was
spare, could not be easily altered at
home or by Jewish dressmakers and
tailors.
F This together with the fact that their
savings and valuables had been taken
from them meant that many Jews
struggled to survive and lived in
poverty.
B The one post office open to Jews for
the whole of Prague could mean a walk
of several miles for a stamp to send
letters to keep in touch with relatives.
G This was a period of extreme food
shortages and meant that by the
afternoon there was nothing left on the
shelves to eat.
C This was a real problem with growing
children who grew out of their clothes
and shoes.
H This meant living on rumours. The fear
of being called up for transportation to
unknown places from which no one
ever returned made for stress which it
is impossible to convey.
D The winters in Prague are long and
cold; without woollens they were made
harder to bear.
I Jews were made to feel like secondclass citizens. All personal freedoms
had been taken away. It was very
difficult to have any kind of social life.
E This made you feel as if you stood out.
It made you more aware than ever that
you had no civil rights. Also, people
avoided you.
J Jews found it difficult to pray together.
© Hodder Education, 2009
SHP History Year 9 Teacher’s Resource Book
133
CLOSE
33
Who was to blame for the Holocaust?
Use the cards below on your own Ripple Diagram for Activity 2 on page 139.
134
Hitler
Camp
commandants
Engineers
Goebbels
SS camp
guards
Businesses
Herman
Goering
Clerks and civil
servants
The German
people
Heinrich
Himmler
The police
Governments of
other countries
Reinhard
Heydrich
Engine drivers,
firemen, train
guards
SHP History Year 9 Teacher’s Resource Book
© Hodder Education, 2009