A BACTERIOLOGICALLY OCCLUSIVE USE w. WHYTE, P. From A comparison clothing system convenient than replacement IN V. THE BAILEY, OPERATING D. the University CLOTHING L. HAMBLEN, ofGlasgow and SYSTEM FOR ROOM W. D. the Western FISHER, I. G. Infirmary, KELLY Glasgow made was made in a laminar-flow operating room between total-body exhaust gowns and a from Fabric 450. This disposable clothing was found to be much more comfortable and the total-body exhaust gowns. The average airborne bacterial counts obtained during total from each of the clothing systems were identical when the downflow method of ventilation was used (0.7 per cubic mefre) and no significant difference could be demonstrated when the crossflow system was used (2.2 per cubic mefre with the total-body exhaust gowns and 3.1 per cubic metre with the disposable clothing). Tests in a dispersal chamber were carried out to find the effectiveness of each item of the disposable clothing in reducing bacterial dispersion. These tests demonstrated the relative ineffectiveness of wearing a surgical gown as compared with wearing the complete system. It was confirmed hip operations bacteriologically A recent Medical several bacteria implant showed that, Research compared approximately downflow system in with the study conjunction carried ofjoint sepsis, total-body of bacteria in the by Whyte et al. (1983) counts in the operating and exhaust reduced the rate ofjoint A further publication (Lidwell a direct relation between joint concentration air, that room in systems used room clothing, 1979) quarters. suggested out of airborne orthopaedic This study ventilated air (UCA) operating with to clothing conventionally rate of ventilation with respect Council ultra-clean designed halved (Charnley suggested bacterial the centres demonstrated the importance as a cause of joint sepsis after operations (Lidwell et al. 1982). operating rooms, with conventionally used that of this observation importance when gowns sepsis by three et al. 1983) sepsis and the and it has been very low airborne must be achieved in order to minimise sepsis caused by airborne contamination (a maximum of 10 per cubic metre but 1 per cubic metre if possible.) To achieve the lowest counts of airborne bacteria in a laminar-flow operating room, clothing occlusive to bacteria available gown. cation, must be worn. The most efficacious up till now has been the total-body However, it makes such clothing movement often around hampers the for reprints © 1983 British 0301-620X/83/41 502 should be sent Editorial Society 39 $2.00 to Mr of Bone W. and Whyte. Joint communi- operating W. Whyte, BSc, Research Fellow and Bacteriologist P. V. Bailey, Senior Technician Building Services Research Unit, University of Glasgow, Gardens, Glasgow G12 8RZ, Scotland. D. L. Hamblen, PhD, FRCS, Professor W. D. Fisher, FRCS, Senior Lecturer I. G. Kelly, FRCS, Lecturer University Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Western Dumbarton Road, Glasgow Gl 1 6NT, Scotland. Requests clothing exhaust Surgery table was more and sepsis efficient Infirmary, the crossflow type; the in this paper. more difficult, and it may cause muscular soreness in people of slight build. Normal operating room garments made of cotton are comfortable to wear but, because of the large holes between the threads (often about 80 micrometres), usually ride the airborne on skin scales) ; it has prevent bacteria (despite the fact they have little difficulty in passing through gowns the cloth will only people being Hodgson Ventile 1976). Very tightly woven cotton cloth (which is the cloth used in the total-body been found one third dispersed into the that cotton operating of the bacteria from air (Whyte, Vesley and such as exhaust gowns), if made into conventionally designed operating room suits and gowns, will greatly reduce bacterial dispersion. However, the tight weave ofthe cloth prevents air exchange, fortable making to wear Fabrics clothing made worn the (Hill, of cals ; these materials bacteria and yet are Unfortunately, such and therefore of anti-static clothing Howell during very hot and Blowers synthetic the and materials manufacture uncom- 1974). are used fabrics often in of pharmaceuti- greatly reduce the dispersion reasonably comfortable to a high static regulations have poor of wear. conductivity electrical charge ; thus, because they cannot be used in the operating room. However, 450*, which is a disposable these difficulties. and Johnson and 3 Lilybank than is discussed a material non-woven known fabric, as Fabric overcomes It is supplied worldwide by in the UK by Surgikos Limited. Johnson Most woven cloths depend on a tight weave and small pore size to prevent the passage of airborne bacteria. Fabric 450 is not woven; it is manufactured by pressing a slurry of fibres together and therefore has a deep, randomised, open-fibre structure. This allows good air exchange Bacteria-carrying 5The trade name and is therefore particles from for this THE disposable JOURNAL comfortable personnel material OF BONE are is “FABRIC AND JOINT to wear. forced to 450” SURGERY A BACTERIOLOGICALLY twist and Because tial size turn their way OCCLUSIVE through the maze of bacteria are carried on skin particles they have a high inertia ; they cannot way through This property (Lidwell and and Graham CLOTHING fibres. the cloth and are impacted on to the fibres. of Fabric 450 is fully discussed elsewhere Mackintosh 1978; Whyte, Hodgson, Bailey 1978). Studies in dispersal chambers and in reduction in the count of airborne bacteria FOR noted of substantwist their operating rooms have shown this cloth to be as efficient as the closely woven Ventile material in reducing bacterial dispersion. A surgical gown of Fabric 450 has been tested in a downflow laminar-flow operating room : it gave a 2.9 times SYSTEM that USE IN THE a mask was OPERATING worn hood in place and that the the gown to minimise air area. Dispersal chamber tests. In clothing in preventing the air, a specially designed which volunteers fully in previous 1978) and 503 ROOM over the shoulder leakage hood yoke from previous dispersion dispersal chamber features the studies of the role of of bacteria into the was exercised. This chamber papers (Whyte et al. 1976; its important to keep was worn under round the neck are used in is described Whyte et al. shown in Figure 1. e as compared with a cotton gown (7.3 per cubic metre to 2.5 per cubic metre). The airborne count was not reduced to the low level achieved by the total-body exhaust suit (0.63 per cubic metre) But, at the time (Whyte, Vesley these experiments garments other this disposable In view than surgical material. of the bacteria and joints (Lidwell system should total-body system purpose strong were link in reducing was be between in airborne the count of airborne made study from Fabric It was of a 450. The was to test the effectiveness system. It has that been the downflow than in downflow (Lidwell system a demonstrated (Whyte, airborne concentration UCA system crossflow system was et al. is often Shaw and Barnes of bacteria in a is between 3.5 and nine times less system. The superiority of the confirmed during the MRC study 1982). This is unfortunate, the only one which can existing operating room (architectural considerations often make it difficult system). ness available more comfortable to use. achieved by development of clothing of the present of this 1973) gown but which this could complete gowns 1976). out, no sepsis after orthopaedic implantation of et al. 1982), it was felt that a clothing be developed which was as efficient as the exhaust bacteria, felt that very and Hodgson were carried It was therefore of the occlusive as downflow UCA possibility trations as a crossflow be installed in an and to install decided to assess clothing system systems to obtain engineering a downflow the effective- in crossflow information as well on the of achieving acceptably low airborne of bacteria in crossflow systems. Fig. Diagram concenAir MATERIALS AND METHODS Charnley-Howorth total-body exhaust gown. These gowns were purchased from Howorth Air Engineering Limited. They were made of Ventile L34 material and were used as suggested turer. Disposable made in the clothing. of bacterial instructions Fabric Trousers, 450 dispersion around VOL. the neck the the escape of the were designed. and supplied 65-B, shirts were from as well as to reduce yokes tions supplied No. 4. AUGUST gown, and In skin of the surgical order neck of bacteria-laden full These were by Surgikos 1983 by the manufac- worn. hoods with of gowns to reduce and face, air from shoulder made to our specificaLimited. It should be was dispersal (c) sampling supplied and bacterial height similar situated air taken conditions laminar-flow sampled dispersed bacterial carried described Four chamber. chamber: ports: in a downward samples to that 1 (a) HEPA (d) shelf: and filter: (b) (e) air supply. unidirectional taken at both of the operating found at the surgical wound operating room ; the sum port at a at a port The samples to simulate of the in a downflow of the bacteria both ports would give the total bacteria the volunteer. The bacterial samplers, medium, incubation out by the volunteers in previous papers. ofthe They manner a sampling table and at the bottom of the chamber. at table height were assumed from by metronome: authors stripped times and type were exactly of exercise as those agreed to exercise in the dispersal to their underpants and socks 504 W. and donned, clothing in of disposable with gown and sequence, P. V. BAILEY, the : (1) hospital-issue trousers and conventional and trousers, following and D. four operating-room L. HAMBLEN, sets cotton surgical gown together hood (Surgikos Limited); disposable conventional (4) shirt, disposable disposable WHYTE, of shirt, with a disposable (2) cotton shirt hood and a gown of shirt and trousers but of disposable fabric; throughout final suture. trousers, gown special Air and hood A surgical mask, surgical were worn throughout made the volunteers carried out of gloves and these experi- more dispersal set of clothing. room tests. These experiments installed General were the permeabifity fabrics. allow 1978. exactly in as outlined of millilitres counts experiments to compare (P< to the new system with the Charnley-Howorth gowns during both downflow and To reduce experimental variability special gowns. total attendance wore, for the disposable Sampling clothing of airborne at these operations. entire operation, either or The the the total-body exhaust bacteria was carried out throughout the operation by sampling within 30 centimetres of the wound using a high-volume Casella slit sampler (sampling 700 litres per minute) Table I. Airborne bacterial numbers per minute) Type of surgical Cotton shirt, conventional Cotton gown dispersion and gown, hood shirt and trousers, Fabric and conventional disposable Cotton shirt and trousers, 450 gown and hood and Fabric hood gown 450 with shirt, trousers, an through clothing trousers disposable exchange by testing employed standard. This each was method through one square centimetre and tests. I gives bacteria the obtained for each of the clothing difference exists between room tests. average from the systems studied. each set of results Fourteen seven in which and seven in total hip operations were the total-body exhaust gowns which the special disposable clothing sets were used. Ninety-four 700-litre samples of air were taken, each sampling period lasting for ten minutes. The average counts (median) obtained when the two clothing systems were worn in either downflow or crossflow conditions are It is usual to find that of airborne samples taken a log-normal distribution. shown in Table II. the distribution of the results in hospital areas conforms to This was so with the results we obtained and an analysis was carried out with logarithms taken of each result. The standard deviations given Table II are therefore geometric standard deviations. A statistical analysis revealed that with significant difference the crossflow and (P<0.0l). However, surgical clothing Conditions simulated Downward air supply laminar-flow (t-test) of the results in obtained both sets of clothing there was a between the results obtained from downflow methods of air supply no statistical difference could be (bacterial dispersion measured as in chamber Total from 71 329 25 222 Fabric 12 149 and 2 18 450 hood Table of airborne 0.01). Operating only total hip replacement operations were studied, and to minimise experimental variability caused by any alteration in the dispersion rate of different surgical teams the experimental observations were confined to one such team. Eight individuals accounted for over 80 of the team ofair to second. chamber monitored, were used per cent operating The amount incision RESULTS Dispersal (median) the clothing exhaust ventilation. first was assessed The method that of air passing in one four volUnteers A significant disposable total-body crossflow from measures the amount of air that pa’sses through a known area of fabric at a given pressure (1 centimetre water gauge). The air permeability is then given as the number of the Glas- fully elsewhere features of the the operation, ofthe design, which were used during these experiments, were the system’s ability to change the air speed and direction during an operation (from crossflow to downflow and vice versa). The air speed, as measured one metre from filters, was adjusted throughout 0.35 metres per second. The aim of the experiment was whole of the air was sample taken. continuously carried in one Hospital, gow. This system has been described (Whyte, Shaw and Barnes 1971). Two sterile cone. This apparatus has been (Whyte et a!. 1973). A ten-minute that the fabrics would according to BS.5636: of fabric out in the laminar-flow system operating rooms at Gartnavel I. G. KELLY duct and elsewhere (3) cotton hood made tests than the other three. He wore each set of clothing eight times. The other three volunteers wore each set twice. Thus, a total of 14 results were obtained from each Operating extension described material; special fabric. overshoes D. FISHER, air sample was taken ; then the direction changed, its velocity adjusted and a further Bacterial sampling was carried out almost ments. One W. THE bacteria person JOURNAL dispersed OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY A BACTERIOLOGICALLY Table II. operation Median wounds OCCLUSIVE and when geometric total-body Downflow permeability (operating according and that the 0.7 0.62 25 2.2 2.6 Fabric450 system 21 0.7 0.73 22 3.1 2.2 the total-body clothing. method However, when in BS.5636: 1978. much more comfortable body exhaust system respectively centimetre garment everyone and who more than to the to the cotton be total- clothing. is achieved and hood chamber It is clear disposable mance from these experiments downflow bacteria ventilation at the wound clothing (0.7 ventilation per it was for total-body the was the cubic metre); and identical (2.2 gowns clothing system). results will interest surgeons who find fortable and inconvenient occlusive clothing and and the can hence total-body minimise reduce with many are the the crossflow cubic cubic exhaust but metre metre for orthopaedic gowns aware uncomthat number sepsis of perforWith of airborne both sets of per 3. 1 per the system equal, gowns. concentration identical with almost exhaust the disposable These bacteria that clothing gave a similar, if not to that of total-body exhaust only Total-body exhaust gowns reduce the dispersion of bacteria-carrying particles because Ventile cloth is tightly woven and has a small pore size. However, tests show that the air permeability of Ventile cloth is only 0.39 millilitres per square millilitres centimetre for cotton disposable comfort fabric. Air and to make system comfortable, per second cloth and compared with 15.1 32.7 millilitres for the exchange is an important an all-enveloping Ventile artificial ventilation factor in clothing is necessary; bacterial reduced. Although systems, lighted VOL. 65-B, No. 4. AUGUST 1983 more convenient when trousers, substituted The was were equiva- significantly concerned the dispersal of wearing gown dispersal piece of for a cotton counts study shirt, sampling in the as each additional with UCA chamber also highonly a gown made of in a conventionally ventilated in the room and hence may be deposited (unlike the dispersal with the unidirectional ventilation system wound). Therefore, potentialofocclusive room, into operat- the wounds laminar-flow where the airflow is away from the in order to obtain the full protective clothing in a conventional operating appropriate trousers also must be worn. We agree with previously published work (Whyte et al. 1973 ; Lidwell et al. 1982) that the laminar-flow system with a downflow of air gives lower counts at the wound than the crossflow system (0.7 per cubic metre compared with 2.2 per cubic metre with the total-body exhaust gown cubic and 0.7 per metre with cubic the However, these airborne metre and 3. 1 per cubic system was used with uncommon it was exhaust clothing. from underneath the gown (it is known that the majority of bacteria are dispersed from below the waist ; Whyte et al. 1976). In a conventionally ventilated room, the bacteria dispersed from under the gown mix with the air participated found was our material lower than (around 30 those found (values of study total-body as cotton dispersion results from the limitations hence the total-body exhaust gowns. The air permeability of the disposable fabric suggests that it would be a comfortable clothing system and the surgical staff who in this the ing room. The disposable gown, compared with a cotton gown, only reduced the total dispersal rate from 235 to 160 bacteria per minute (a 32 per cent reduction). The majority of bacteria were obviously still being dispersed of airborne rate. only are worn. Bacterial clearly showed that clothing the occlusive DISCUSSION than as comfortable disposable clothing is therefore a suitable alternative to the total-body exhaust suit. Tests carried out in the dispersal chamber demonstrated that the full benefit in the reduction of bacterial lent in system comfortable was ; it disposable studied. participated 450 convenient similar and dispersion and experiment systems Fabric and 15.1 per second. of the the It was cotton, 0.39, out a scientific found The cotton each Ventile, to carry asked, experiments studied. and testing of the was and system disposable assessed by given comfort gowns of the clothing permeability these exhaust at air supply 26 per square the samples Total body exhaust gowns It was not possible to assess Crossflow bacterial used 505 ROOM Geometric standard deviation fabrics 32.7 millilitres from airborne clothing were OPERATING Median air disposable air supply THE IN Number of observations air of Ventile, fabrics was to the found deviation obtained clothing and disposable USE Geometric standard deviation system and comfort to room) FOR Median between disposable permeability Air standard exhaust SYSTEM Number of observations Clothing studied demonstrated the special CLOTHING metre compared with disposable clothing concentrations metre found the occlusive 3. 1 per system). of 2.2 per cubic when the downflow clothing are much the figures with conventional cotton clothing per cubic metre) and very much lower than in conventionally ventilated operating rooms around 1 50 bacteria per cubic metre are not and our own conventionally ventilated 506 W. operating room gives WHYTE, counts P. V. BAILEY, closer to 450 D. L. HAMBLEN, per cubic airborne metre). sepsis The relation was found, of bacterial dosage to joint during the MRC multicentred be rate defined by = 0.84 + 0. l87A the following ; where A is the equation bacterial when These wound trial, to : W. D. FISHER, count is 3. 1 per cubic were 1982), the small following operations term “joint sepsis had fact between linear. airborne from may be reduced from count inaconventionally concentration the equation about three per cent ventilatedoperating the operating Council, UK. carried will that difference carried be reduced the rates to 1 .0 per cent outwithout prophylactic antibiotics (Lidwell will et al. calculated between sepsis out in different directions of even are further. based confirmed at re-operation likely to be higher). This on This sepsis (the true reduction is despite which deepjoint in sepsis the has been sepsis rate is obtained by use ofocclusive clothing with a crossflow UCA system is therefore substantial and does not differ greatly from the results obtained with a downflow system. It would the is not that the when is 150 per cubic metre (or from 4.7 per cent when is 450 per cubic metre), to 1 .2 per cent when We thank Research 450* airflow where two and operation. No great accuracy is but it is clear that the relation sepsis rate and It can be calculated sepsis rate the airborne room count original equation and antibiotic cover. As the use ofprophylactic reduce the rate ofjoint sepsis to one quarter contamination per cubic metre ofoperating room and the sepsis rate is thejoint sepsis rate (per cent) after operations where no prophylactic antibiotics have been given. The a halfyears ofthe claimed for this metre, the airborne count is reduced to 0.7 per cubic metre. figures ofjoint sepsis are based on results obtained fromoperationsthat sepsis airborne sepsis” was applied only to thosejoints been confirmed at re-operation within I. G. KELLY therefore appear greatestefficiency, the the system used that, although ifit cannot with a downflow be installed, occlusive clothing system has the then acrossflow is a worthwhile alternative. room staffat Gartnavel General Hospital for participating We should also like to thank Surgikos Limited for a supply in this study, of BARRIER1 which was operating supported by a grant from the Medical room clothing made from FABRIC REFERENCES Charnley Hill J. Lowfriction J, Howell arthroplastv A, Blowers R. Effect Lidwell OM, Lowbury total hip or knee EJL, Whyte replacement: Lidwell OM, replacement EJL, variation Lowbury and Lidwell OM, Mackintosh measurements and ofthe hip. of clothing W, Blowers a randomised Berlin, Heidelberg, on dispersal evaluation of fabrics in relation J Hyg (Camb) 1978:81:433-52. W, Hodgson R, Bailey PV, Graham J. The reduction 1978 :65 :469-74. Whyte W, Lidwell OM, Lowbury EJL, Blowers R. Suggested press). Whyte W, Shaw BH, Barnes R. An experimental laminar-flow Whyte W, Shaw BH, Barnes R. A bacteriological evaluation Whyte W, Vesley R. Bacterial : Springer aureus SJ, Lowe D. with bacterial Whyte D, Hodgson York Verlag, by males R, Stanley SJ, Lowe D. Effect of ultraclean study. Br MedJ 1982:285: 10-4. Whyte W, Blowers R, Stanley in the incidence ofjoint sepsis CA. The bench tests. New of Staphylococcus dispersion operating-room. oflaminar-flow in relation to operating use in the bacteriological females. as operating standards Lancet systems clothing. Lancet air in operating Airborne contamination dose to the wound and to their of bacteria 1979. and protective of the between through in the for air in ultraclean on deep wound hospitals. garments room 1974 : ii : 1 131-3. rooms sepsis in the joint after in operations for total joint J Hosp 1nf1983 (in press). nursing and surgery. use of non-woven clothing. operating J Hosp rooms. I : physical Br J Surg Jnf 1983 1971 : ii : 905-6. for orthopaedic J Hyg (Camb) THE surgery. J Hyg 1976: 76 : 367-78. JOURNAL (Camb) OF BONE 1973:71 AND JOINT : 559-64. SURGERY (in
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz