IN THE FIlCH ( (
CIRCVI[ BENC
\A\NA
2ARWND
R
\\
a\TED I HIS THE. 21ST
)P NU\E\IDf N
PREE’T
THE HON’HLE MR Ji S’iiCE RI F1NNJ2NATiI
4.
X.
THE HOVBLE MRJUSTICE FTGO\ INDARAJI.
61
\X?\\Q
BET VV E E
T
raE; GENERAL MARAGE
ST\TE BANK GE H ‘0
REAl) OFF icr;
BANG \LORE-56(
JE DISGIPL
SISTAN 1’
FE BAN
2 NA
I A RSI
LW I)SX MOHA
1
RAA’a HAND
‘2
AG NA
A
2 V
b5
5A (
‘
2W 1
I
C
2
DHARWAD MAIN BRANCH,
DHARWAD-580 001
2.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER & CHAIRMAN
OF CASTE VERIFICATION COMMITFEE,
DHARWAD-58000 1
3.
THE TAHSILDAR & TALUK EXECUTIVE
MAGISTRATE
HUBLI-580020,
DHARWAD DISTRICT.
4.
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE,
CIV1L RIGHTS
ENFORCEMENT CELL,
RESPONDENTS
BELGAUM-5606 001
...
THIS WRIT APPEAL FILED U/S.4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO, SET
ASIDE THE AFORESAID OBSERVATION IN THE
PENULTIMATE SENTENCE IN PARAGRAPH 6 OF THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER IN WP NO.867/2008 (GM-CC)
DATED:09/02/2011 PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE
JUDGE BY ALLOWING THIS WRIT APPEAL.
ON FOR
COMING
THIS WRIT APPEAL
PRELIMINARY HEARING THIS DAY, K.L.MANJUNATH
J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
In this appeal, since the appellants are questioning
only certain remarks made in paragraph 6 of the order
passed by the learned Single Judge, we have condoned
•
9
C
CD
r+
Cr
“
CD
(I)
CD
CD
a
a
-
—
C
rt
ci
rt
CD
a
CD
91
-“
U
a
P
CD
Cr
a
CD
a
CD.
ti
CD
°
gt.
a
a
CD
a
a
CD
D
a
Cr
CD
CD
r±
CD
a
a
9
9
CD
g;
rt
CD
c
C
a
CD
Cr
9:
CD
rn
P
a
CD
a
CD
C
CD
P
9
—
C
CD
CD”
rt
9
(
rt
a
CD
J”
$1)
—
Ii
t
CD
j
(I
C
a
a
CD
CD
Cr
9
9:
Cr
C
a
CD
9:
Cr
(SQ
CD
CD
9
CD
rs-
“
9
CD
CD
—
CD
CD
rt
CD
i
9:.
C
C
aCD
CD
(SD
Cr
pfri
9::
CD
CD
a
9
CD)
CD
CD
C
a
ti
CD
CD
9eD
.
a
CD
,-
9
CD
a
a
CD
CD
Cl
a
rt
Cr
CL
gi
CD
a
CD
,
CD
Cr
r+
CD
CD
9:
CD
C”
9
(
CD
a
CD
gf
C
rt
CD
•9
CD
9
a
A
Li
Crr
rt
CD
r
(ii
CD
CD
C
trCDad$LaCD
CD
Ri
a
CD
CD
CD
P
CD
CD
CD
CD
Cr
rt
C
C
r
C
gi.
(CD
9
Cr
ço
rt
—
—
CD
a
CD
CD
CD
g
a
CD
CD
9
CD
CD
CD
C”
C”
CD
.
a
-
a
C
CD
C
CD
9:CDC
CD
a
r
CD
CS
C
CDCDO
CD
a
a
Li.
C
z..
CD
—
CD
CD
CD
Q
n
CD
9
9’
CD
Di
C)
9
9
—
C)
‘C
(2)
01
‘C
C)
>
‘C
C)
C)
Cod
>
—
cC)
(9
Or)
—
C)
‘C
C)
Di>
9’
-
C)
C)
—k
a
—
C)
C)
12)
H
Or)
L
C)
01
‘C
CL
U)
9’
.
()
29’
CL
‘C
s
H
E
,
•
<
—
—
Di
CL
CD:
(0
C)
(ft
t.’i
—
SH
C)
H
if!)
99
<
C’
Di
Co
CD
(1)
Di
El
OifDico
C) )Co
Di)
<0
H
C)
t
Di)
C)
CD
‘C
rt
9’
‘C
CD
Co
to
Di
Co
CD
.
‘C
9
Co
El
O
iT
C
(CD
Di
o
9:
Co
C)
dl
C)
Co
CD
‘C
9
Co
C)
Co
CD
El
(1
CD
Di)
C)
Di
EL
CD
rt
Ed
‘÷
Di
(9
CL
!
Co
CD
—
to
0
Di
CD
‘C
—
Co
CD
Cl
Di
C)
CL
CD
Di
CD
Co
‘C
12
CL
9
‘C
Co
91
Di
CD
9’
p
Co
C)
C)
CD
(9z
g.R
CoO
‘C
Di
r
‘C
2
CL
CD
=
9’
Co
C’
CD:
Co
9’
CD
dlCo
t
CD
‘C
Co
C)
Co
(9
‘C
‘C
CD
a.
El
Di
CD
CD.
rt
Di
C
Cl
‘C
9
Co
Co
CD
Co
Co
Cl
9’
9
Co
rt
r+
2)
CD
‘C
rt
9)
‘C
Co
9
9!
rt
Di
9)
2
r*
CD
Co
9’
C
El
j
9
Co
•
CL
C)
Co
CD
(9‘C
Di
CL
CD
9’9’
Di
C)
Di
CD
‘C
rt
—
C)
ElSi
CL
(9
Co
>
CD
‘C
CD
C)
r+
(9
0
j
Co
-i
Di
Co
Di
CD
CL
.
91:
Di
9’.
CD
(9
Di
9<
6
C).
12
x
CD
Co
C))
Ci
Di
CL
CT
o
Co
si
Co
CD
2’
Di
CL
‘C
H
9
Di
rt
co
Di
Di
Co
212
CD
212
rt
rt
—
C’
Q
‘C
C)
Co
(CD
Di
El
C)
—
•Co
99’
Co
99’
—
<..‘C
CD
CD
‘C
C)
Co
Di
CD
t
‘C
CD
‘9’‘C
0i•
9
C)
‘C
(0
9
CL
91
Di
CL
CD
‘C
Co
CD
‘C
Co’
9’
25
C)
9)
CD
C)
Co
9 CD
C’
>9’
CD
CD
91
9 a
Co
CD
C)
Co
E)2
Di:
<
‘C
Ct
(9
Di
CD
CD
CD
‘C
ço
r
99’
C
CT
Co
Di
El
9’
Ci
Di
Co
CD
Co
j
P
Di
Di
C)
CD
Co
CD
-i
Co
(0
Di
°
rt
i
95
CD:
Uci..
•:
o
a
a
en
o
‘1
h”
02
a
ci
a
ci
rn
a
-
ci
Si
ci
$
a
a
cio
ci
a
a
a
a
ci
o
ci
0
rt
a
rt
—
o
ci
ci
a
a
rt
o
ci
rt
ci
ci
a
CD
ici
a
-
Sa
ci
a
.
C.
a
cci
a
ci
CU
a
ci
9ç
ci
a
ci
S1)
a
a
5
S
N
ci
ci
ci
Sa
fr4
ci
a
ci
><
a
cr
a
rn
ci
a
a
ci
m
a
a
5
S
o
a
a
a
•
a
r
0
ci
S
ci
.
9
a
0
a
ci
a
a
ci
en
•.
5
.
a
rt
ci
S
a
ci
a
a
a
—
ci
ci.
C)
j
<W
ci
rn.
pci:
a
ci
ci
C)
tj
ci
ci
a
ci
9
ci
a
—
—
ci
ci
ci
R
02
ci
—
ci
ci
a
9
a
—
CD
a
ci
C)
C
ci
a.
g
9ci
ci
a
ci
ci
C
a
a
ci
—
R
C)
—
ci
ci
a
ci
ci
frj
ci
a
ci
ci
a
a
a
ci
9
S
ci
ci
02
ci
ci
—
a
ci
a
a
a
Q
a
3
ci