Geophys. J. Int. +- 142, <??<?
Department of Earth Sciences, Parks Road, Oxford UK. E-mail: [email protected]
Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, USA
!" # !$
!" #% ! !!" & ' '( ) !!" $!
& "* ' +!> , - '!" ($!. & ! "! ' & ' .
! & / ! & ' ! " "
. $" !' '
" /!
", .
0"! & '! ! "! " ! /! 10. " !!
!, '" & "! at the time of loading "! '
" /$ ! !'*!$ ! 2
! . ' " ', . ! 10. " !!
!, 3.
& "
! ) ! $!
& 0'" 10. " !!
!, & !
"! " "
(! " !' '"" " !'
). '! && ', 0! (/ '" "! /! "! ' & ' & "
*!
.
"0! /! /2 !
4 !$! "!$ " & / $ $"
'."!*
", $!"! '
" /! ! (
." & 0 !'" 2 '!
! "! ! '"", !$
'" .. ! !$ (, "*"! '
" , ' ! !! & '
" /!
/ '!"! & 10. " !!
!, !' / $ &.
!& . '"
$!!, ! !$! , ( !( "* ' '!"
($!. & ! "! ! 56 '"x )! ' ! 0"!
& 10. " !!
!, both " "
4 " " .
& .(!
."!& ! , & ! !"
! ! $" ! 10. " ' 12 ' "" '."!", $!"!
'
" 0"! !
.(!
&""/ !"
(.!"
! 3.! & "! . $" ! '"", 7 *8 ,.
$". . .
! . /!" ! "! $!"! !
$!!, & ! . ", ! '. ! & ! "/ ", ! && ! ($ ! "! " " !'" ) /!"" & ( ! ' ( $! & ! 10. . , ', ( .
/! ' 9
$". ! ! & !
!$!
." &. & 1 ! ' ! 10. & "! !, ",
!"#$%#!"
) ", & "! ! ! ! . ", &
'. ! ! ,'! ) /, "! "
. ! !' $"
!'"!! & 0'" & .
! .(*
!
."!& ! , & ! ! & " /""
.. " ," $" " (.
! 4
!! 2/"
& "* ' '!" !
& "! ! !' & . .
! & . & 0 ! & . '" $!
. ("/ "! # : & ' 0 !'" 2 '! !'", & 2 ! /! . ' . ! ! ! 0
2 & ' ! &.
'"", !&& /,; ! "!$",
" . & . , & ' (, ( !" & '!
+ , " <- /!" ! "!$", "/ & . . '" , & ' (, .!" 1/ + =>
<- !" & '! . (, & !!" "!
! '""
& . ! 2 :.!" & '! ! . (, ' & ' & '"", !$
'!'
("' /! "( ,*(
.
! ! !'*
" !$"$
." "( , ! <??
<?#
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
! +! xxx# x- / ' /! !
/! "!" ! ' !" + ,- 0!" + !&*, (! & '!- ! /!
,!"", ! x?xx x + @"! A
. $ #% B/' A ! - ". "
&& & ! 2 ! 2/ & ' "( ,
.
! /! 2 ('! /2 ! !
& ' x x# x ", & . '" '. "/ ! & "!" !
", .
((", ( ! / C & '
" !'" ' & ' .
! & /, !
/0! /! & ! "
+
@" ?- :. ! D "! & 0'" " & B ' ! C. / $ (,
! /! . '" ( !
!
! ! 12! ! "!' ".
& ! "
!&
.! . '" E. ! ! /!
/" & 0'" . '" / ."
.! ."!& / "
/ .(!
! 12! ! , '!! &
."!& .(!
' ! ' /! !!
& !" '
" '
& B/! 1.!
", ! ( !(" . & (.
!
$!!, .. & '" .
! & F
!
+FE"
2 - D2 $!"" +4/2! A .8. <
B ' ! +. A "! <- . & 0'"
$!!, & rxr r !$", & /2 ! ", .
"!
"! ", G ' et al +<- .
/ ( $! & "*/$" !'*
$!,
9"
. (! !$ (, "! "!!
!' $!!, & '" ! % ! &/ !' !" & "!" (.
$!
' !& *
'! ! $!
"!*
!1. & & '! 4 !." @"" +#<- /
F
! ."!& 3.! "! "! 0
& 2'
F. ' *"$" ( $! & ' " /
. F!"
+"& <- . "! !2 & "! & < 2' !'!" $". $ ( .
& '
& (.
& !
"! 7!"
8 ! *"!" "2 & B ' ! +"
- F!"", ! $! A "! +- .
.! !$ ! !3. ."!& ! F
! 3.! "! "! ? 2' !2
' /! !'" & "!" . !&! , /$ !'" & "!"
"
! !"" 4& '! & '! &
"! !'" & ' & '
$" !' "
& ' !
"! ! !"
* * ,'
B ", "
& " . ! +> - (. ,
( ' ! "
."
, $ $!
!& '! "* ' '!"
! & "! $ "!$", '"" !" "
& ' .&." '
" ( .
+
=. - !( & '! & "! !
"! " '
" 4 ! '
" "! ! ! "! " $ "! !$!!
.( .' ,
' ! !! & '
" /! ( $! &
10. ! ! & $" !' & 0'" !
( !(" ! "* ' "! !
& "! ! "!! ( " "
+ <% @"
/"" A ). % @>$ et al
<- ! /!
& ! !
:! ! . "! '
" ! !'*!$ ! 2 ! . !(!"!, & ! 10. " ! & "! /! !' F 0'"
/ 2/ & ' ( ! !" 10. .
! "* ' "! !2 & "! ! '. "
!'! !2 ! !'! /$ & . ! $"! , & "!" "
( $! . '
" ! /! !2 & "! '!"", . "
! !!!"", !2
(' ! !' ! 0'" & . '
" ! ! $!"! " $ "! !$!!
.( .' " +- /
!
'
" ."
0"! /, ,. ! "
!"
"! / !
/! ! $". & "!
!2 /!" "
$"! "
! "! "/ $". !" ! !
! $!/ ."
( 0"!
(, "0! !' & # , /! $!!, & "! & ) ! $!"! " '
" & ( ( 3.!
/!
", "!
F 0'" " A "" +#- H.!"
A .' +<- .
'
" 0"! $"'
& &1 ! !' , (! ! B ' !
/!" D'(2 A B2!(". +<- .
! . & "!! (/ 10. " !!
!, "
! !,
. @2 !"
! .* " !9 F!"", $!"! '
" / !$2
! ", !*
/!
'! .
! (, B. A 2 +<- ! ' 0"! /, "
! + . "!- / !
/! "/ $". & "! !2
("' /! ! $!"! " '
" ! ! !'"! $ , " !'" & "! "
& ! , '
" $ "
.' ( $
&. ! F! 0! &
$!, '"! ! "
"
! ! ! !'"!
! "! '!!
& " !
& !' ! ! 2/ & ' $!, !
'"! , . + <- "
$"! "
! "! + C' '.- . (, 10. ! ,*, !! '
"
@. , A .' +<- !>
/!" "!*
"0 / ! ! "
! ! ! && "! "
!'" . ! "! $!"! "
'
" & , .
'."!", $!"! '
"
)! '
" / (
.'! ! '"*
, 2 ! '"", !$
' *
. .. & ! "! ( !(
(,
! ), /
. '
" ."
0"! & "! !2 !' / ( $
/"" !
'" .. & "! , '*
! !! ( $! , '!
!$! , E (" $!!, & "! g( ."
9 ( $!
) "! !2 !' .
(, @. , A .'
+<- / (
'!"! (, ! et al +</! !".
? !' & ' '!
*! !
*
!"
,' ! !"
'.
!$ " ! ! et al +<- .
, ' ?
#
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
additional !' & "! !2 $ ( .("!
&/ & !' + * !"
,'- ! $!. $". /!" "
"! !' (. , (
' . *
, $!, !
'", ) 'E !, & / !' /$ & ' "!" &. !".
! ! et al +<- '!"!
4 ! / . / '!"! & "! !2
!' *0'! 3.! & "* ' '*
!" ! & ! "! F! / ' !' /! !! & ! "! $!*
"! " '
" ' /!" '
"
$ .&." . ! ' !>! ( $! &
10. , 3.", !( / "! ."", ( * "* ' "
. '."!", $!"! '
" & !
"! !'!" !!"", $"
(, @. ,
A .' +<- '! !&& (! ' !0 !3. = 8 &.! !
.
"$ 10. 3.! , ' ! /
'!"! & "! !2 !' /! !! &
'."!", $!"! '
" / '! 7(*98
' & !$! , & $!!,
& ! "! F!"", / 0'! !'"!!
& (*9 ' & .(!
."!& ! , &
!$ /
$"! !"
! , & !
12! '
'
) # ! # ) * Te
:. ! / ( /" & /
' ! "! "
'"
! . & , ' ! $!,
!
'"! !'! 1! 9" & ( & 10
! . !'! & ! $!
& !"
$"!, $ . .. ! ! &
$"! !' , & "
/! !!
& !'" "! '
" ! ( !(" ! "* ' '!" ! & "! ''", .
' ! 10. .
! ! "!
!2 & "! T ) "! !2 ! '. & ! & "! & '!
+! !&&- ! '!
& ' 10. " !!
!,
D (,
D~ETe I({p ) ,
()
/ E ! J.8 '
.". s ! !8 !
)(" ! .'' , & ! T !' ' !'
& ' ' (,' ! &. '
!' $ . , & "! $". F 0'" 9 !' '. ! !"
! F ",! @ , 4"
/ (
", C)?
7 !
8 & (,' ! + @"' <% F!"' A
B. <- ) !' $ .(3.", ( $!
+=
/!""! A % :K(!! et al % et al
- .! / !( !' !
"! $". F 0'" ", !' !"
* ,' + @"
/"" et al #- !
3.", & && & ,!"
! ! ! & !
" . $. +B. <-
$ & *$".
! T "! ", $". !." &. (
( $". $ ! "!
' ) ."! . !' /!
! 0!'", < & " .'( .("!
F! / /$ .
! !"" !"",
!$ (! /!
", ! !(.
$ & / "
8
'! (!
F! / " & T ! !&& ! (/ & .
",! 1 & Te estimates
60
60
0
0
-60
-60
Mid-oceanic
TrenchSeamounts/
Fracture Zones
ridges
Outer Rise
Ocean islands
* + D! & T !' +! ) : ! )(" - .
! ! .
,
#
GJI &'( <??<?
<?
Delta
<?<
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
# + .'' , & !' & "! !2 T
N
?
#
<
?
#
<
?
#
<
?
#
<
?
#
<
?
?
?
?
?
??
?#
),
:
)0
)0
)0
)0
)0
)
)0
)0
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
F. L/!!M4"
'>M@
L/!!*C' = M
5. !"
!
!
".!
!
*"!M!
L/!!M4"
5. !"
L/!!M!
C' M'.
.
.
5.!I.
5."
5."
!M2
!
/,
52.
52.
B!M)2.
6!''.
.!2
.!
)!!
CM!9M!
!
*"!M!
6.M
MF.M!
M"$!M!
B2!
!
"M' !
".!
@ >
3.
!,
!,M)!!
E!
.!2
!
"M' !
.
@!"
5 '
".!
5. !"
!
!
CM!9M!
D.!$!""MG" !
!
"M' !
!""!!
!
!
&
1
+-
1
+, -
&
"
+-
D
+, -
<
?
?
?
??
??
<
?
<
<
<
<
<
<
<
#
?
?
?
<
<
<
<
?<
?
?
#
<
?
<
#
<
<
??
?
<
<?
<
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
<
??
?
?
?
<
<?
?
?#
?<?
?
<
?
?
?
?
??
?
?
?
#
?
?
<
?
?
?
T
& +2'-
T
+2'-
<
<
<
<
<
?
?
?
#
?
#?
?
<#
#
?
#?
?
?
?
?
?
<
#<
#
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
#
?
?
?
?
?
?
+" (+@ + A @ + et al ?+@"
/"" et al #+@"
/"" et al #+@"
/"" et al #+@"
/"" et al #+5>! A /! #+., +
et al <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+ <+B. A <+B. A <+B. A <+@ +@ +B. +: !2 A +@"
/"" A ). +@"
/"" A ). +@"
/"" A ). +@>$ et al <+@>$ et al <+@>$ et al <+D'(2 <(+D'(2 <+ A !( <+ A !( <+B. <+B. <+B. <+B. <+B. <+B. <+B. <+B. <+
et al <+@>$ A :'! <+
A ! <+
A ! <+
A ! <+
A ! <#
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
<?
# + +Continued-
N
),
?
?<
?
#
#
#
#
#
#?
##
#
#<
#
?
#
<
<
<
<
<
<
<?
<#
<
<<
<
?
#
<
?
#
<
#
)
)
)
)
)
0
0
0
0
0
0
'
'
0
@
F. ".!
5. !"
.M
/!
.
. M!
!
M"!M!
3.
CM!9M!
:"
!$$
).(.!
!' !
!
!.
.2
!.2!
)!!
* .!!
3.
='(!
. . C
"M,M='>
5.!
B!!.
B!
B2
!M(2
= M!"
D!!2!
"ML '
!
/,
5'.
:!22.E!
52
E!
B!2.
.!2
6!''.
@MG L/!!M!
'.
""ML!'.
""ML'"
@ ,M4"
&,*B!2!!
4
!MM
&
"!
> @ ! '.
GJI &'( <??<?
&
1
+-
1
+, -
&
"
+-
D
+, -
??
?
?
?
<
<
?
#?
<
<
<?
<
<?
<
<
?
#?
#
?
?
?<
?
?
<
#
#?
<
<
<
?
#
#
??
<
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
#
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
#
?
#
?
?
?
?
?
<
#
?
#?
?
?
?
?
#?
??
?#
#?
#?
?
<
#
?
?
<
?
?
#
?
T
& +2'-
T
+2'-
?
?#
<
<
?
?
#
#
?
<
?
#
??
??
#?
??
?
<
<
?
<
?
?
?
#
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
#
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
<
+
A ! <+
A ! <+
et al <?+
et al <?+
et al <?+/! A !""! <?+F! et al <#+5. A '! <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' A @>$ <#+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+@"' <+B. <<+ A !2 <+ A B. <+'! et al <+'! et al <+F!"' A B. <+5 A !" +5 A !" +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al -
<#
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
# + +Continued-
N
?
#
<
?
#
<
?
#
<
?
#
<
?
?
?
?
?
??
?#
?
?<
?
#
#
#
#
#
#?
##
#
#<
),
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
F. @ .!
= M
@MG @MG !
ML"
,
!.>
. !!.
.!
MC
/ @" !
@" !
@" !
@" !
@" !
@" !
@" !
@"! @"! . ,
. ,
. ,
. ,
N
!$
N
!$
N
!$
N
!$
B M .
.M .
B M@!"
CM!9M!
:"
!! ='(!
!
.!!
!
L.!
)!!
L/!!M !
/
= '
/!
L
2!
:$!
:!2
:
H.M@ "M
H.M@ "M
H.M@ "M
H.M@ "M
H.M@ "M?
H.M@ "M#
H.M@ "M
@ ,M4"
&
1
+
<
#
?
?
?
#
<
##
?
?
<
?#
#<
#?
#
?
#
?
?
<
#?
?
<
?
#
<?
#
#
?
#
??
1
+, ?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
#
#
?
?
?
<
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
&
"
+-
D
+, -
T
+2'-
T
+2'-
#
#
?
?
<
?
?
<
<
<
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
#?
#?
?<
<
?#
#
#
#
?
<
??
??
?
?
#
<
#
?
<
#
#
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
& +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +@"' et al +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +" A L0(, +6.
A B. +6.
A B. +6.
A B. + A @ +=
/!""! A +=
/!""! A +=
/!""! A +=
/!""! A +=
/!""! A +=
/!""! A +=
/!""! A +=
/!""! A +" +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' +L ! A @' + #
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
<#
# + +Continued-
N
),
#
?
#
<
<
<
<
<
<
<?
<#
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
F. @ ,M4"
="O
="O
".!
!""
!
@!"
6
6$
5. !"
!
!
"M' !
.
!""!!
).'.
C MC
MF"!0M!"
!
&
1
+-
1
+, -
&
"
+-
D
+, -
?
?
?
?#<
#
<
#
<
#?
?
<
?
?
?
<
?
?
?
??
<
?
?
T
& +2'-
T
+2'-
?
?
#<
#
#
#
?
?
#
?
#
?
?
?
<
?
?
?
+:K(!! A @" +F! A ! +F! A ! +D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+D$! A /"" ?+4 et al ?+5 . et al +5 . et al +!."" A > -
='.I! !"
; ='.I! !"
! F ",! !% '='. 7(2 28 F ",! !
+ "" '.- )=
* . ! ,' := !$ " ='!
*! !
F=& . >
x= "
$". .(3.", "
(, $". ) $". $ ( "
! F! ? = $". + & . $. /"" (,' ,-
"
) " 9 ' !'" "!! 9 (,
+<- (
'. '"" (/ !
T & "! at the time of loading F. & '
!
+ C' '.- $
"/ T &. & '
&&* !
+ L/!!
4"
- ) / '!"! / 0!'", & T !' &"" /!! # u@
! ! ' (
"! " '
" ) '!
0! !' & ' & . > +
' !"
* ,'- / T ( ,'*
!"", ! ' '. ! !"
!
F ",! ! / T ' ( "/ !' ." / ! F! ! T ! " !'! !2 & ! "! !& & '
. &*/$ .
! 4& / . & 0'" / !'
& B!!'. A F , +<- /! $ ( &
! , & ,. +? - ! . & "
+<# - . T ! ' ?? "
!'! !2 /! ' $". (. " ""/! & !' ! 2 (.!"
.(' !
!9 & ! $" T !' ! F! "
"
4 !'! !*
' (
"
& . ! & &/
&/ .
)! . "
!
!2 & "! '!"", . "
'. & ' ! * ' !'! ! "* '
"! !2 ) !'" $ /! ! "0!
. ! ", ! , ) ! $!
! "! ', !.
"0 $ " !' F 0'" F! / " &
T ! & "! & '. !
!"
) !' ". *
! /!
#
GJI &'( <??<?
"
&. (". ,. ) " .
"
'. ! !"
$ "/ T ,. & !$ & ! "! '
&. + ? E! '.- $ "/ T (.
, / & '
,. "! !' & "
!
/$ + ? "! '.- "
"! / " , 3.! "
!' & "
!
4& " ! F! ! !$ ! .
"! ', "0 !'" " , ) !& & "
*!
.
"0! ! ! "! .!$ & $!"! ($!. !(" 0"! & ! T !' *
& ! ! $!"! " '
" !(
(, B
!
+#- 4 . '
" !!!" 10. ! "! (. $!.
&& (' ! !", !' /! !' +F! -
F! ? / " & D ! "
& '.
! !"
/ '"
! "! >< ) ( $
!' +9""
! "- & '
"! 4
! !9 ) "."
. $
+"!
"!- (
! $!"! " '
" /!
!!!" "! !2 T & 2' ! $".
(. ! ! '!
*/, (/ & !' & !'! !2 + 2'- & >< ! "! (
. &*/$ .
! +B!!'. A F , <- )
9. / ! $!"! " '
" 0"! " ! ( $
! D /! ! ! "
L/$ !" "0! !' 0"! all F. ' "0! !' 0"! ! "
' 4 !." ( $
! D + !"". (, /- ( " !
.! 10
" ! * '+ " & "! !2 & ! "! T ! & "! !' & "
! ) ! ' (
"!*" '
" &
A " +- ) !'! !2 ! (
B!!'. A F , +<- D
! / '!"", !"". && T & * ' + , - "0! ! "! * ,+ " & "! !2 & ! "! T ! & "! '. ! !"
3. / '. ! !"
! F ",! E! "! '. !.
! 0 @! " / '. ! !"
0".
! ! F ",! ) 3. ! " $ ( ". *
& & "
/! !
!! ,. (". "
) " . $
/ , "! '!"", !"". && T & "* ' + , "0! ! "! <#
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
#
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
<#
Load
0
Bulge
Bulge
Depth (km)
5
10
t/τ =1
Airy
Elastic ( To = 90 km)
Viscoelastic plate
15
Flexure
t/τ = 10
Single Layer
E
= Maxwell relaxation time
= viscosity
E = Young's modulus
20
t/τ = 50
25
-800
-600
-400
-200
0
200
ρw = 1030 kg m-3
ρc = 2800
ρinfill = 2800
ρm = 3330
400
600
800
Distance (km)
* &+ F"0. & ! $!"! " $ "! !$!!
1.!
.( .' ) 10. ( '.
& .'
!!!" "!
!2 T & 2' J.8 '
.". & = "
! !(.! / !! & "
' !" !"
(, "
!9""
!, '" & < < 2 'x !$", ! & tIt= ? / t ! 0/"" "0! !' t
! & "
"!'! & /2 ! 9! L/$ $ / $!"! " '
" ! .
/! !".
!!!" /"" 9" "! !2 +5 <- ( $! !"" ( 0"!
, -.%"!% .$!"/ * .#!.))$ -!%).#!%
.!#010))
) ! "! $!"! " '
" ", 0!*
'! "* ' '!" ($!. & "!*
), ! , & "/ & ( !"
.!" & '! & 2 '!
(, ."
& 0 !'" 2 '! B! , 0"!!", 2
! . '" .. & "! (
'
" & /."
( ! ."
& 0 !'" 2 '! /! / 2 ($
(, ( !" & '! ! . . ! .(! '" ! '"", !$
! et al +<- .
'
" ! & ' 0 !'" 2 '! '"
.. "$
& 10. . (! !",
"
), '.
'' !
/! ,!"
$" /! => +<- .
& '
, "8 "/ & ( !" & '! : /
"/ & .!" & '! &.
3.!$" 10. & . ", "! " &""/ /$ & @. , A .' +<- ! ( !" & *
'! 9"
. & ! ! /*&"
F! ( !" & '! 9"
! !"" ", .
! "!" $!
! 10. " ' 12 '. ! !"
& ,!"
! ! & ' & '" &."!
! ' . $ ! *"! ", /! ! "!
"! $!!, ! &.! & ' . ("' & . (! (" "." #
GJI &'( <??<?
10. & multilayered $!"! " '
" /! !
.(E (! !", "
,+
1 2
3
) & '."!", $!"! " "
( !(
+ - (, &""/! $ !
3.!;
pij, j zogdi ~ ,
()
ui,i ~ ,
()
/ r ! !, g ! $!!" " ! uÅi
! $"!, + !"' ! / / 9 "!" 3.!- sij ! C3 +- +- 3.! & '! !.!, !$",
) "!" 3.! & !' !(" $!"!
'
!.' + 0/"" (
,- ( / !
pij z
g
p_ ij ~Pdij zg_eij ,
k
()
/ m g '
.". $!!, !$",
P ! ,'! . e ! ! !
! !$!$ & $ !(" /! !'
.' ! "$! 3 +-+- ( (' . & & & '
" & . & F
!$ "!
"
& '!" ! +
$!!, '
.".- / "$ 3.! !
",!"", .' !"", "." / & '!
"
$ ! /! !' 4 ! ",!" .' !" ( &""/
)! ! (.
/ . "! ", /! !"*
' '"" ' /! " !2 !'!" / &""/
(, +- ! ! .
, &
$".! & "*/$" , & !
("
<#
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
* 4+ @' ! & ( $
!
10. " !!
!, D '. ! !"
& '
>< !
"! @! " / ( $
$". : 2 ! " / "" $". 0 & F ",! D! ! " / & F ",! ) ( $! !
!9
! 0
" (
)(" "!
9", . $ / !
"!!
(/ D & "
(
! $!"! " '
" ) '
" .' !!!" "! !2 T & 2' 0/""
"0! !' & ? # , "!
. $ & "
/! /$" l & ? 2' F!", . $ & "
/!
/$" & ? 2' ) "! / !!!" 10. " !!
!, (
T & "!2", & !'! !2 & >< ! "! ) .9""
/ / !(" ! ,+'
2
D( , .
! / & ' '! " '2 . ! "! ! '"", !$
F 0'" " "/ & ", ,""! "!$! !
!$ + 5 A . - (,
n
m
e_ ~A(pIk) (bId) exp [{(EzPV )IRT] ,
(?)
/ A ! *0!" & s ! b ! " & . $ d ! ! !> n ! 0 m ! !*!> 0 E ! !$!
, P ! '(! . V ! !$! $".' R !
.!$ " T ! ' . ) !
eÇ ! '!
(, $!!, g s ! &""/ & ' 3 +?- p
g~ ~gref exp [(EzPV )IRT] ,
e_
(#)
/ gref ~
k
(pIk){n (bId){m :
A
5 A . +- "". $ !
.
"!" ' & "!$! $ , /!
", & !&& & '! '!' $"!" F 0'"
! !&&.! 0 ! (. ! ',( ! ? & !"! !'!" ", !$!
, $ ! & ' ? 26 '"x & 7
,8 '" 26 '"x & 7/8 '"
#
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
# '+ ,!" ' .
! '."!", $!"!
'
" "."!
. & . !! ! ." & '! '!'
!> "! / &""/ 2 (, @. , A .' +<- .' "!
", +! 0 ! - "! ", ! *
! /! ." & 5 A . +- / ! .
!"! ', ", ( !' "!$", !
' . + '!
*! !
- /!" !&&.!
! !' "/ ' . ! "
&
'. ! !"
"!$", " +> - ! ! "! .
! "0!
!$"$ !!9 ! & ! ""/ / '*
. "!$", "/ +!(", # u@- ) & !&&.! ! ((", (" .'! & "
!
4& / .' "! ", + 3 #- $!!, ( 0 ! ' & & $!!, g & E P V R
T ) ' P V R T "" ( !(
& ! "! + )(" - P ! . '
/! ! !$ (, rgz / r ! $ !, & "! g ! $!!" " ! z ! % V
! !$! $".'% R ! N!$ " = @
T ! ' . ! 2"$! .' T
! !$ (, "! " '
" + A " -
! ! '
" $!
!! & $ !! !
& 1 1/ /, & ' '!
*!
!
F! # !"". $!!, .. & ! "! ." ! $ , !!$ ' . ! (, >? & '!.
/! ) '0!*
'.' & ! ! . ' ?? 2' &
"! /! ,. 1 /! ' !
""/ "
1 " !
'
G".
@ . '" '
.".
)!2 & '"
!8 !
:!, & .
:!, & '"
@ !$! $".'
= $!!" " !
N!$ " = @
(b)
Log10 Viscosity
Age of Seafloor (Ma)
50
100
150
200
0
20
Pa s
30
35
a
M
10
300
25
18
0
450
Depth ( km)
25
0
150
25
? =
2'
?
< 2 'x
2 'x
?rx# mx molx
< ' x
< 6 '"x uKx
P V R T !(
", .2/ *
' g & E & .
3 +#- .
$!!, 9" & "! (
$ !. $".
& g & E 4 "."! $!!, 9" /!
/ 0!'
.'( & ", +! ' #- & $!!, ) ", / !$!
. $!!, ! (/ / E ", / "/,
'"" ? F. ' '0!'.' $!!, / "!'!
< ! ! $!!! !1. "."! "."
& '."!*
", $!"! '
" "
& $ !. !'*
!"!, +! *: *:- . ! '" & "! !' & "
!
(a)
0
<#?
50
600
50
75
900
75
100
100
E = 120 KJ/mol
1330 o C
125
125
η = reference
ref viscosity
* 5+ " & ' . .. $!!, & ! "! &.! & +- : $ . ' . (
"*"! '
" + A " - F!""
!" !
! /! $!!, .. ( '.
! +(- +(- :
$ . " & $!!, (
'
" ! /! ! '" ! '"", !$
) "."! .' !$!
, E & 56 '"x & $!!, g & . $!!, ! . '" + & ? 2'- ! #
GJI &'( <??<?
<##
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
(a)
(b)
* 6+ F"0. & /*", $!"! " '
" "!
"!
/ !
10. 2, 2, , , , &""/! "
'"' B / "! / !!!" +"!- 10. !
"! / & ! ,*, '
" ) "."
. $ .' 2' !2 .
", "/ ", /! $!!, & +- D/*$!!,
. ", +(- L!*$!!, . ", ) '0!'.' 10. & /*", '."!", $!*
"! '
" ! ' /! !! & "!
$!"! " '
" & & "
! F! <
) 10. & ! "! $!"! " '
"
/ '.
/! T= 2' $!!, & !$", 4 ! "! '
" 10. $ ,
/! !' ) 10. & $!"! '
" ! ' & "! '
" & !' < , F " !'
/$ ! $! ! !! & ! ,
'
" & , F! < / !! & '
" /! !*
$!!, . ", /"" /! !! & "!
" '
" " & " "
) '! !&& !
"
)! ! (. ! /*", '."!", $!"! '
" !*$!!, . ", ! .
"! (,
"/ *$!!, ", ) '
" & "0 /"" " !' 4 "! '
" .' " ! .
"! (, !$!!
1.!
L ! !'*
! 10. & "! '
"
) '
" /! "/*$!!, . ", /"" /!
!! & $!"! " '
" ! *
' ! " & " +!> , - & "
L/$ ' $!!, ! .'
& .
",! ", $!!, & < ! /"" 0"!
/ $!!, & > ! ", 0"!
)
& ! ! ! /*", $!"! '
" "/ ", "!2 ! "! $!"! "
'
" ! "!$", /2 ", !& $!!, & "/ ", ! "/ . +!< - " ($
,+, %
2
2 2
2
& ' ! "."
/! !! ! !
, 9 $"!
'."!", $!"! '
"
/, ! ! (, ' ! /! !! & ! "! $!"! " '
" . '
"
! && /*", '
" /! ! "! $!*
"! . ", $ "! !$!!
"/ 7", 8 / ' ! /! !" & /*",
'."!", $!"! '
"
F! / 10. & /*", $!"! "
! "
! . & (, 7
8*!>
'.
)/ !"". ; /! !*$!!, . ",
+F! (- /! "/*$!!, ", +F! - . *", !2 & 2' "/ *", $!!, &
.'
", ! ( ! $!!,
& "/ ", ! less & . ", ! (
" "0 "
! from the base upwards
) 10. !''
!", ( "
! /! !'
! ! '0!'.' $". & " !' "
4 & "/*$!!, . ", 10. ! !
", !! & ! , '
" &
, 4 & !*$!!, . ",
! , $ & , :9
(, (" !. & 2' !. & 2' !
($ . .
! 1 & 2'
: . ; ;II///0"
.IL/!!M E'"
* 7+ @' ! & "."
10. & ! " "!
$!"! " '
" /! & /*", $!"!
" '
" ) "."! / '0!'.' .(!
(
& '.*, $"! "
&.! & "
L$, "!
"! / !! & /*
", $!"! '
" ) 9 .'( ! "(" & $!!, & . ", "/ ", D!
*
"! / !! & ! "! " '
"
/! T= 2' D! "*
"! / ! , +! T= 2'- F!""
! " "! "!
"! / !! & ! " $!"! '
" /! 0/"" "0!
!' & , +3.!$" $!!, & -
#
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
! !'!" /, ! "! $!"! " !
.
"! (, !$!!
1.!
) ' ! ' /!
", .
!
"! $!"! " '
" ( !
!"
7
*''( 8 & '."!", $!"! '
" /*", $!"! '
" /! . ", !
$!!, +! # & '!.
& "/ ", - ! !"", ($! "! " $ *
",! !$!!
1.!
& !'" ! ,
+F! <- " !' .(!
/!"" !&& & ' ! "! " '
" ." ! $!!, ! .'
& . ", $ /*", '
" /! "/*
$!!, . ", ! !"", ($! $!"!
" $ ' !'" $!
$!!, &
"/ ", ! "/ . +! " & '!.
"/ & . ", -
,+&
8
.'( & / 2 $ !
. + D'(2
A B2!(". <- & $!"! " $ "! !$!!
1.!
"
!> /! 10. (! !
& /!
"
& '"" L ."
( & T "
!> )! !
!"". ! F! ? ) 9. . /!" 10. "
!!
!, T & " . "
/! /$" & 2' !&& "!" & ' & " . "
/! /$" & 2' & '"" "
. . "
! ) . (' ' !!9 / "
0
& "0! !'
4 '."!", $!"! '
" / ", /2 & T "
!> )! ! (. '.
& "0! ! ! '
" (' !!!9 " "
'! " & &/ '!""!
, & 0'" ! ""/ . *
' & "! / $!!, ! ! )
" & ($ ' "!"", " !'" .
10. ( "
! !$ & ! !> /!"" !!9", /! !' L/$ T /!"" !>
/ "
! ,. '. & "0! !
!!9
"2 & & T "
!> ! " ! ( $! !'
& 0'" !> & ' <
'. ! !"
/ T ( '!
.! ( . & ! (,' , =C@ (,' !
. 4 !> & &. ! 0 !. ( !. 2 !
) !! (
& ! ." !, & $"!
!9 4 / !9 & ' ' & .(' ! !
!! '!!'.' !' ) 2
! ! ' ! & $"! &. +! .(*
' ! !9 / "!(" .( !" & $"- ($ . .
! 7 '"8 & 1 " & ( !. ! 2 ! / ! F! ". ! , & '"" '. !
!"
( !
/! ,. 1 " F! +- / "", /2 (/ !>
1 ) ! !'!" /2 & !> "
+F! (- F!"", F! +- / "2 &
& !> T
#
GJI &'( <??<?
<#
4& 0! "" ! F! ! . T ! ! &
" '. ! !"
& '"" )!
( !(.
&& & "0! ! ! ((", .
(, & ', & " '. ! !"
&.
"
1 "
1 $ ! T ,. 1 & )#!#) * %#!-#!"
)")/ "$ )*))"%) -!%!#
$ .
'."!", $!"! '
" '.
10. /."
( 0
& "
'"
. & & ! "! & !&& ".
10. ."
( ' ! ", /! ( $! ", &/ ""!! + L/!! @ , 4"
O.!/ !'! !3. $ ! ", !'
10. &
! . ! $!!!, & " $"! "
4
' ""!! 10. ! !& & ' $!, !
( $! & 0 '
""
10. !
' & T 3.!$" 10. " !!
!, D '*
$". ." 10. " & '!
/! ( $!
!&9.", ! ! $!"! " '
" "! ! !&,!
!!!" "! 4 . '."!", '
" !!!"
"! ! '!
(, '
.". "
!> +! '"!.
/$"- !2 & '" 4 ! & !
& $!!, .. ! '" ! "!$", !2 T (!
& ' !!!" +! t=- "! ! " " ) T !$", '"" /! !' .'."
! '" "0 !2 & "! . "
& ' ! * ' !'! !2*
! "* ' !2 .! /$ "."
T & &/ &/ .
', ."", !'! !2 )! ! (.
/ $ $ *!'"!9
"! ! & '"
) !'"!9! ."
/$ && "* '
($!. & "! F! ' ( $
!
!' & 10. " !!
!, '. ! !"
) ( *
$! (
' .
! F! ? '. ! !"
/ "
>< ! "! . "
& / F! !'! !2 !!!" "! !2 & "
! "! ! ."!2",
$ , !!9", ! ! !2 &
" ! " ! && "
*!
.
"0! /!"" " ( '"" ) ( $! $ (
". *
! & "! !'
& "
! /! '. ! !"
& '
,. "! & '
"
"!*
(". ) "."
10. " !!
!, +"!
"!- ! (
!! & '."!", $!"! '
" /!
E= 56 '"x g &= & "!*
!' & "
! & ? )!
' ( $! + ! ! F! - / !! 2 ! & ! "! !' & "
! & F! / !
10. " !!
!, & & "! !' &
"
! & 0"! " 0!*
'", . '!
*! & ( $
4& / 2
<#<
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
Number
15
1e+26
10
5
0
0
30
60
90
120 150 180
Age of lithosphere at time of loading
1e+25
Flexural Rigidity De (N m)
(a)
To = 110 km
Age of lithosphere
at time of
loading (Ma)
To = 70
150
1e+24
100
90
80
150
110 Ma A
70 of lith ge
at timosphere
load e of
30
ing
1e+23
1e+22
(b)
1e+21
0.001
N = 51
Multilayered
Viscoelastic
Model
E = 120 KJ/mol
20
ref = 10 Pa s
0.010
0.100
70
60
50
40
30
20
1.000
10.0
100.0
1000.0 10000.0
Age of Load (Ma)
(c)
* 9+ " & 2 ! ! (" !. & <
'. ! !"
/ !' & . "
T $!"(" ) ! (" !. !' (
=C@ ' !( (,' , 9" ) !'
$ ( ". *
! +- & ! .
+(- "
+- T
! . & & "! !'
& "
! ' & ( $
!' &
10. " !!
!, &"" /!! /!
/ & "."
$".
$ ! ! & "!' & ( $! $ !'!" & "! !' & "
!
" !
. $
!" ' ! & E= 56 '"x g &=
& "", 0"! ( $
10. "
!!
!, +
T- !' *&& F! / & 0'" 10. " !!
!, !' ! F! ."
( 3."", /"" 0"!
(, ! ! & $!!, "/ !$! , "/ $!!, ! !$! ,
) !
!! E g & ', $ , !"",
F 0'" ' & !' & 10. " !!
!,
&"" .!
& !
. $ (" / !' & ' L/!! !
+!
/, .- /
& ' C' '. +52.- / & ' '.
/! !
/! ! 10. " !!
!, 0
!' & ' F ",! + !- & '
* :+ @' ! & ( $
!
10. " !!
!,
D '. ! !"
& '
>< !
"! @! " / ( $
$". /! $ ( ". *
! & "! !' & "
!
"!
. $ / !
"!! (/ D &
"
(
'."!", $!"! " '
" ) '
"
.' !$! , E & 26 '"x & $!!, & & ! "! at the
time of loading & +$, "!
"!- ? ) !
! ' / 2 ! & "! !' &
"
! ! ( $
"! +@ - /! !
/! "/ $".
) '". $". ', !
! !" $ !! !
! !$! , (" $!!, & "! ( & ' " !$", , ',
!" $ !! ! ' . .. & "! ) & $!!, & g &= ! .'
!
F! ( !
(" $!!, "! 3.!$"", !' & $!!, & . '
'" "!" (.
.
! + . A "! <%
G ' et al <- . ! *
(" !' & $!!, & . ' '" (
!"", 3.! !" ! 4& ! $!!, ! "
! & .(! '" / 2 & ! $!
A F +- . ' ! & ( $
!
10. " !!
!! !"". ! F! . 7(*98 !$! , & '" & 56 '"x
)! ! " ? 56 '"x .
(, @. , A
.' +<- .! ' $!!, (. "
T 4 ! " '"" ( .
& ' "( ,
.
! & ", ,""! '" & "!$! 'E '! "
!. & '" 5 A . +- & 0'"
$ !
. !$! , & 7/8 7
,8
'" & ' 56 '"x & "! !&&.!
? 56 '"x & *"! !"! L ! , (/ "( , 79"
*(
8
." ! . & & / 2/ . & ! !
(/ 9"
*(
"( , !' 4& 5 A . +- . !&&.! ! ' "!2",
#
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
Flexural Rigidity De (N m)
1e+26
4
1e+25
E = 300 K
J/mol
1e+24
(a)
240
1e+23
120
20
1e+22
ref = 10 Pa s
60
Seafloor age at time of loading = 70 Ma
1e+21
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
10.0
100.0
1000.0
Age of Load (Ma)
Flexural Rigidity De (N m)
1e+26
1e+25
1e+24
(b)
ref = 10 21
Pa s
1e+23
1e+22
10 20
10 19
10 18
E = 120 KJ/mol
Seafloor age at time of loading = 70 Ma
1e+21
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
10.0
100.0
1000.0
Age of Load (Ma)
* + !!$!, & "!! (/ 10. " !!
!, D
"
& '."!", $!"! '
" +- !$!
, +(- & $!!, ) !>" "!
"! !2 & 2' +"/ "!- 2'
+. "!-
& '! '!' ( ? "
! "!*
!"! /! ! ((", "!'!
!* '"* ! !' & '!
*! !
! , . & & ) & ! , ', ( .
(, . !! ! " &
$"!" /! . ." !
!! " & /
&.!, + / - ! .(! '" /
$!.", . ', !!9", '"
$!!, /! /."
"
! !$! ,
L! A 5"
+#- & 0'" $ .
! . / ( '!
*! !
"/ $!!, & .(! '" & ' < )
("' ! 10. " !!
!, ! F! " ", /
' !!$ !$! , '"
$!!, / '! / '. "/ '" $!!, /."
( ! 0"! T
( $!
) ' ($!. !&& (/ 9"
"( ,
!' ! '. "/ ! !$"$
!
10. " "
! / ("!$ ! ( & , !& '! ! & ! ' ((" . & ! ,
#
GJI &'( <??<?
<#
!1.!%#!"
$ / '."!", $!"! '
" !
10. !''
!", ( '.*, $"!
"
/!"" ! /! "
4!!"", +! t= , - 10. ! "! + F! - "
! .
",! "! "0 !
", . y? &
.(3. 10. ! /!! 2 .(3.
! 10. "/ ! !*$!!, . ' ", & "! )
." ! ! 2 &. , '
'. & 10. . . ! 9 2, & "
!
) ! 10. /! "
$ "!"
!'"!! " !'" ! "!" ! '"!.
/$" & 10. L ! !
7 '8 ( $! & 10. + $!, !
'"! 1 , 10
. &
& ( & .- . , ', ( .
/! 9
+ et al <- !' !
! & (,' ! &. ! ' ! !'" /$ '
" . 10. /!"" 3.! !
", 0'! ' &
!'"!! & & .(!
."!&
! , & !$ /
! !"
/"" ! , & 10. " ' 12 '
4+
0
!
) L/!! 4"
' ! ! & $" /!
,'!"", ! ! & ' ,. 5!". L/!! 4"
+@". A 6 - ) !"
' !
.! & .( !"", .
"2"! (" /! ! & ' ? .!$ $" $ (.!" .
12 & "
$" . ,.
5!". .! . & & !"
/!"
"
.2 .! '"" !" .( !"
(" '2 . ! . & . ! $".' !
'"" +<? - / ' /! & .
",!
.(' ! !9
". .(' ! !9 , ( !""
0 .! . '! !"
*(.!"
! &
L/!! $" ! !
', ( '"
/!!
?? :! ! !
(.!"
*. ((", 3. & ! ! $!
L/!! ( .(*
!
! (, !!9 '. )!
*. + -
& 0'" !
! L/!! ( .(!
! "!$ . & . < '' , x . ! , .! /! ! "
'!
*/, (/ L/!! .
$ .(!
& '' , x . ! ' !
F. ' ! ! "!" +" A "
##- . L/!! ( .(*
!
! & (. '' , x ! @! @28 "
$!! !"
! ?
) ! $!
L/!! ( .(!
! $
" !'" + A F ! <% A @'(""
<% D.
/! et al - :!"
(,' ! &
0'" !
! / & L/!! ! !
& & & ' /! & '
"$" . ! !
& "!$ "! (!"!, '" & ' & ,!"
! ( & ? 2 /!"
'" & ?< ' & ,!"
& ?? 2 + <
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
* '+ !
10. & '.*, $"! "
& ' ! "! ) "*
"! / !!!"
+! t=- 10. "!
"! / 10. 2, 2, , , , ) !! (
7(*98 '
! & !$! , & $!!, 0"! 10. " !!
!, !' ! F! A @'("" <- ) . .(!
& < '' , x & ??? 2 D.
/! et al
+- / '"
$ . !
< '' , x $ ? ) !' ! ( ' /! ." & N !.'*(
! & .( !" (" ! !!9 !"" " ! (. & L!" L/!!
) 1 .(!
& !"
&
L/!! as a whole ! .
& ' ' ! & &
& / & L/!! /! & !'!"
. & D! & .! / "
!"
/ $ " & 2!"' 7. '8 & L/!!
) . !
!$!
." & !"
+ A @'("" <- / . ,
! ! / & L/!! 4"
"
!" !"
& L/!! ( .(!
! "
!"
7. '8 $ 0 !
."!& = ! A 6 +-
& 0'" $ .
*"$" !
! . "
( ! /$*. /$* .' '. & ."!& . .
D! "2! . ! ? , )! .
,'! !&& ! !'! & ."!& " !"
) ."!& . & 0'" ? 2
.! ! / ((", ! 3.! &
'"! & '! .(' ! & !"
(.!"
! L/!! 4 D! 0 !
."!& $ &
?? 2 /! ! /"" ! .( !" L/!!
! . ! &. & ' L/!! , D! ! ."!& . . ! ? 2 10. " (." ', $ '! " & L/!! 4"
&&! . 9 D! ' ",
$ .
'."!", $!"! '
" !$!*
/ " & .(!
."!& L/!! . ' !"
'! ( .
(, ' & '
& "
*!
.
"0! N& .", '."!"
"
! ! , & !"
".
!"
' !
& '
" ( $! L/$ ' !! ! "!$ " & "0! ( (!
!& / .'
+- .(' ! !9 & L/!! ! !' , "
! "! ! & '
!
", / !"",
'"
(, ? % +- /! & .( !" "
/ .(3. ? / '"" ! ' !
/! & .(' ! "
% +- "! .
"! L/!! "
! ' !'!" ! /! '."!", $!"! " /."
! /! '" .. ! !(
(, < ! "! '!" .. ! '!
(, !$!
, & 56 '"x (" $!!, & ! .'! / ', . '."!", '
" ! .(!
."!& ! , & *0!! !"
&""/
'! & $"! "
! L/!!
F! ' ( $
.(!
."!& /!
!! (
'."!", $!"! '
"
) 9. / ."!& D! ( 3.!
/"" .
& (, '
" 4& E= 56 '"x & $!!, < ! " ."!& /!"
$!!, > ! '"" & $!!, & 0"! (", /"" ! 7' 8
& (. ? 2 & !"
! ! D! /."
$ ( ! L/!!8 10. " ' /."
$ (
.(!
! ) & ' ! ! ' /! & ' & /! . .(!
D!
(. 2 + A @'("" <- ) & ."!& D! ". .
t? 2 ! /$ .>>"! ! . '."!", '
" ."!& ."
$ ( . $", (/ !' & ' , !(" 0"! ! ."!&
! & .'! !! L/$ = ! A 6
+- ! . ."!& !(. ! !"
+
"2!- / " $!
& !.. ."!& / &$. ! !! & ."!& D!
!&9." 0"! (, . '
" ! .(!
! , & L/!! !"& ) ( ("'
/$ /! 0"!! "
F
#
GJI &'( <??<?
(a)
Subsidence (m) Uplift (m)
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
19 a s
10 P
150
Lanai
100
20
10
Emergence age
50
Tsunami
deposit ?
0
21
50
10
E = 120 kJ/mol
100
150
Age (Ma)
Molokai
Maui
Oahu
(b)
Hawaii
Lanai
Terraces
Bulge
Migration
Hilo Harbour
Uplift (m)
1000
Hawaii
500
Drowning ages
0
(c)
Subsidence (m)
500
1021Pa s
20
10
1000
19
10
E = 120 kJ/mol
1500
Terraces - Moore and Fornari ( 1984 )
Terraces - Ludwig et al ( 1991 )
Hilo Harbour Scientific Drilling Project
2000
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
Age (Ma)
* ,+ @' ! & !! & '."!", $!"!
'
" /! ( $! & ."!& .(!
! L/!! 4"
)!2 "! / !! (
'."!", $!"! '
"
/! E= 56 '"x & $!!, & x +- D! 4"
"!
! " / ."!& (
= ! A
6 +- ) ! 2 x ' ', ( .'!
! +(- D! ' /! L/!! 4"
:
"! '!"", !"". & L/!!8 10. " (." ! '! & ' . D! +- L/!! 4"
9""
3. / & .(' ! F!""
! "
/ & .( !" "$ '" & ' !!9
!"" " ! L!" L (. L/!!
0'" '
" +F! - ! /! ? ' /
? ' ! !"
/! .(!
/!" ($ "$" /
.(!
("/ "$" 0"!
'!.
& ( $
" .(!
) ("'
! .(!
& ,. ""/ ! !
( 0"!
(, '
" )! ! 9 '
/
0'!! & ' !!9 ( " ! L!" (. $ " & ', !(. 9 .(!
D!2 .'( & ** !"
L/!! ! !
/! ( '!
*" /""
#
GJI &'( <??<?
<
/! ( 0"!
+ " - ! . '" E.$! & "! (, ,'! &&
& .
",! ".' 4 !$ & . ."!&
!
/! /"" & '! ', ' /! "
*
!
.
"0! . "
! .(!
!
"", 71 8 $ "" (! " ", " !(!"!, ! / $ $ *!'"!9
L/!!8 "
! ! , 2/ & 0'" !"
/ ! , & !"
. ! .(' ! !"
*
(.!"
! N
.(
", / .(!
..
! 4 ! !&9." /$ / ! .(!
."
0"! . (. ! /."
$ ( !"",
'" (, ?? , / !' ! 2 & ' .(' ! !9 & !"
"!2", ! '
& ' & "
*!
.
.(!
. ! .( !" "
!
) ("' ! / 2/ "
!
! , & ! & $" (.!"
! ! 4+' ( ( 2 ;
4 ' L/!! ! ..." !"
! ! .
" '. & .(!
, '! ($ "$" )! ! (. !"
! "!$", ,. ! ! !
'!
*" /"" ! !
/! *
!*
(.,,*1.0 '" ".' C$."", & . L/!!
/!"" / & 0'" $ "$!
& L/!! 4"
,'!"", " ! & ' (. ? 2' L/!! <? 2' 5.!
". ' & "$! ( !(.
' /! . !
/! " *
" " " "" ,'! . & . ! ""! & ((", ( 0'" / $ , & /
$"! !"
"" ) &. (.!" . '!", &
" /! ,!"", & ' ! & / . . & & $" 12 ! & (.!"
"$"
! !2 $!
!& '! / $"! !"
.(!
&""/! ! & $"!' F! /
!2 & & !! & .'( & "" ! ! ! !, @' ='(! + <! /! $" ) & !2 & 9$ ,.
/
$"! !"
+! ! ?? -
& 0'" ! ! ?? ' ' /! "
!"
& $ ) .2 /! $
# ' !2 &
+<- .
& !2 .(!
& /
! !"
/ .
(, '"
"! & .
",! "! ) .(!
/*
$ ! !
F! / /."
3.! .
",! ! "! ! '"", * & '!
* !
)! !'"! > & "! !' & "
! /! ! !!9", " 0
/! & ' <? & ! !,
!"
# & ) .2 ! ! !
("!$ /$ !
.(!
& /
$"! !"
! ' "!2", ( ." & "
*!
.
"0! '" E.$! F! / '."!", $!"! '
" /! E= 56 '"x g &= $!
".!(" 0"! & .(*
!
!"", / ! ! !
$"! 7 8
& "" "
! F! ."
$ !&& A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
1500
Initial
Height
1250
1000
750
500
250
Raitea Bora Bora
Depth below sea-level (m)
Thickness of Fringing Reef (m)
Height above sea-level (m)
<
Sea Level
0
Kosrae
Mayotte
250
Moorea
500
1420 m
Ponape
750
1125
Mangareva
1000
1250
Truk
Mid-Oceanic
Ridge
1500
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Depth
after
viscous
relaxation
825
16
Age (Ma)
* &+ " & !2 & & !! & "" &.! & $" F!""
! " / ( $
!2 (
'!"! & +<- ) "!
"! /
!
.(!
(
'."!", $!"! '
"
/! E= 56 '"x & $!!, & !!" $" ! & ? ' ) !2 *
"! /
!
. $ !&
. ! &
) .2 ) !2 "*
"! / .(!
/."
( 0
!& '. (.!" . "$" ! "! & > +! '!
*! !
- .(!
/! ! "$! ) 9. / / & "! !' & "
! ! 2 ! . !2 & !
!$!
." & !! & ( 0"!
(, '."!", $!"! '
" & ! "$! ! < '
& !$2 '" E.$!
& "! ! 0"! !
.(!
&
"" !" ! ' / ! ,!
' 0"! ' . '!
*"
/"" +: !2 A @ . <- ! ! 3.! 0"! .(!
& /
$"! !"
4
'(!!
& "
*!
.
"0! '" ! &
.
",! "! ( "" '! (
, ! 0"! .(!
! , & ""
! .(' . .,
F! ? / ! ! !'"!! & '."!*
", $!"! " '
" )/ '
" $ ( *
.
4 ( '
" ! ( .'
. ! !." "0! 7$8 !' , ' !" ( (" !9"" 10. " ' . !>" . &
4 F! ?+- ! ! .'
' ' , ! !$ (,
& '! ( & 10
! . +! - / ! F! ?+(- +- ! &""/ & . & , ) ", !&& (/ F! ?+(
+- / & .(!
! "
"
.'." !' ' !' ' 9""
) '! ." / ! F! ? ! '."!", '
" ! & &1 /! !*
! ! /!
& ' ! .
",! "! "0 !! &1
73.8 / " /! 1 ." 9""! . &
' )! ! !"". ! F! ?+(- +- /! /
' , & *1 ! ! !> ! ' & '
! !
2, ) !
& &1 " ! 10. "
' ! " ' /! ( $! F 0'"
!2 A +<?- et al +- $ .
!'!
* 4+ !
! , & 10. " ' 12
'. ! !"
(
'."!", $!"!
" '
" ) ! , ( '.
& !0 !' :. ! ' ' , ( '.
.!
'."!", $!"! '
" /! E= 56 '"x & $!!, & !' .'
9"" ' . !>" . & +- ' , !$ (, 10. ( & ! . +! - +(- ' ,
!$ (, & ! . /! !".
$"! "
+- +(- 0 !' .'
.'." & "
"
4+, 2
<
) .(!
."!& ! , & ! !"
! '!&
", ! !
*. "!" " & (.
" ! ! , & 10. " ' 12 '
) ! / $!
+ et al <- &
0'" 12 & ! !"
'. .(E " *" " &!". ) ' !" !$"$
!
&!". '$ /" ! 12! ' 4&
' ' , /! !' . '."!", $!*
"! " '
" ! + F! - ! ! !
7 !. 8 ',( 7* 8 & #
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
1! 9" !> ! ! . ! L/!! ' ), / *'
9" ' ! !>
(, "/ ' .! " 10. " (." '!
" &1! .! '! (2 / !"
. ' .! ! & ' ), !(. &1 $ !! ! 1.0 & !' , ' !" ! '
. & 0'" & !
!$!
." !"
! !
.(E " *" 12 "" !&& !'
et al +- " 0'!
"*'
9" ), /
& &1 " "
! "*' 9" ), !(.
!$ "
! & "! " (, .!$ $"
! !
!" / . /! et al +- &1 "
"*' 9" . !$ "
!
& / ! !"", "! " / ! /! !
! ! & &1 *' 9"
) '
" ! F! ? . $ !! ! ' !" 1.0
, & ' (, !"
", ' & 0"!!
&1 $" ! 10. " ' ) &1 ."
( 3. & .! ! /!
& ' .
"0! ! .
",! "! N& .",
! ! !9"" ! 10. " ' ( ! ", &/ ""!! ! ! , !(" .! . ! ,! &."",
5
%"%.!"
/ &""/! ".! & ' ! .
,
+- ) "! !2 & ! "! T !
.
(, $!. .
! &.! & '" & "! !' & "
! (! /"" !(
(, # u@ ! ! ' (
"*"! '
"
+- ) ! $!
+ F! - & !."
'" ! T /! &""/! "
!
) ! ' !
. ! 9 , &
"
! (. !. " !'" ".
. ! , '""
+- ) & T '" "
(
0"!
(, '
" ! /! ! ! .'
"! . & "
! ! ' !'!" ! /!
'."!", $!"! " /."
) '
" ! (
." & "( , .
! /! . ! '"", !$
( $! & &
1 /! . '" .. & "! ! !$ (, "*"! '
"
+- @' ! & !! & /*", '."!*
", $!"! '
" /! ' /!
", .
!
$!"! "! " '
" / ' ( !"
7
*''( 8 ) /!
. & "! "
'
" ! !(.
& . ' & ! "! . ! $!!, ! ($ !
&& "! " " !'"
+?- ) 10. " !!
!, '. ! !"
& '
>< "
"! ( 0"!
(, '."!", $!"! '
" /! & $!!, &
!$! , & 56 '"x !
!$! , /."
3.! "/ $!!, /!" "/
!$! , /."
3.! ! $!!, 4& / .'
#
GJI &'( <??<?
<
& $!!, & ! "! ( !
/! !!9", '"" !$!
, ! !
!
& ' 0 !'" .
! & !&&.!
!"! +#- '."!", $!"! '
" 0"! & .(!
."!& &""/
.(' ! & $"!' L/!! ? 4 !." '
"
0"! & 9 . D! 0 !
."!& !' L/!! / !2! !&9."
0"! (, '
" ! !"
.(!
! , &
L/!! ((", (. & . !! ! !"
8
"
! ! ,
+- '."!", $!"! '
" 0"! !
.(*
!
& "" !
!
! !2 & ! & !!
& 3.! "! ( '
/ 0!$", !
!' & "
!
+<- '."!", $!"! '
" " 0"! ! ! $" ! 10. " ' 12 ! !"
4 !." '
" ! & &1 /! 1 "0! " ' !9""
(, 1*",! ' !"
+- ". ! "! ! !>
(,
"* ' "0! ! ! !!9 . $ . & T !' . $ &
'. ! !"
) , ' ( ! 7 '8 ( $! & 10. /!
(" ! ! & (,' ! &. 1 ( !& ! ", & ' ! T .. %"=.)$/)"#
)! / 2 / '"
/!" / @ (, G!!!
& 4) 2/"
. & BC@
2/"
. & B : ! .( F! / .
.! =) &/ +" A '! -
)*))"%)
" A "
= ## ) ! & "$"
! ' , !' L.. L/!! Paci®c Sci., 20,
?#
! 6L 2" A < ( $! &
10. ", & ! "! J. geophys. Res.,
86, #?
/! @ A !""! 6 <? B!$ $!, '", $
! !& $"",; !
*"! !
#uB Tectonophysics,
113, ?#
, " 6: < F !! & 2 Pageoph, 116, #?##
@"
/"" 6= L0(, F 5 ! :C A ). :D # "!(!"!, & .!$ " "! 9" Earth planet. Sci.
Lett., 31, #
@"
/"" 6= A ). :D :
& "!
!2 & ! "! J. geophys. Res., 84,
??#
@"' < ) "! !2 & "! ! !9
Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 85, <<
@"' A @>$ <# ) &&!$ "! "! .
@2*. " !, !"
Earth planet. Sci. Lett.,
77, <
@"' F . 6 A @>$ C"! ",
!2! /! & ! "! Geophys. J., 100,
?#
<
A. B. Watts and S. Zhong
@" D ? The Viscosity of the Earth's Mantle, !
N!$ !, !
@>$ A :'! 5 < =!
! $ D.!$!""
!
+. !9- J. geophys. Res., 89, @>$ D :'! 5 A D'(2 5 < & "! '. "
& ' = ""! "!' ( $! Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 63,
?
@". : A 6 : ) ! , !9 " '!
.
& ' L/!!C' @! Geol. Soc. Am. Bull.,
84, ??
@"! A . $ C # ) ''!" .. & C. !" "! ; ! & ' "!"
9" CC) !' Geophys. J. Int., 124, #?
@ 6 = $!, '! !$!! ! =.! ! C3. !" "! Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 84,
#<
@ 6 ",! & !, ! / "
8 !
!
J. geophys. Res., 84, @. , @ A .' @ < ) '"",*!$
10. & ! "! Nature, 305, :K(!! 66 A @" 6 !'! & "!
!2 & "! ! @ , !" .!
'! &.! Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, ##?
:K(!! 66 @" 6 A :! = !'!
& "! !2 & "! ! @ , !"
.! '! &.! Geophys. Res. Lett., 21, ##?
: !2 A @ . ) < 4"
.(!
"! ! !! J. geophys. Res., 83, #
: !2 A ",! & !, ! / "
8 !'! !
J. geophys. Res., 84, ##?
F! A ! D! ! .. '! '!' & =" J. geophys. Res., 99,
##
F!"' C A B. 5 < =!
'"! $ @ ,
4"
= . Mar. geophys. Res., 11, <
F! 5 B. 5 A . D <# ) '" '!" ! "! ( 3.
/"" Nature, 332, #
FE"
2 G!!, !2 & & ' F
! ."!& Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 126,
=> @ < ) '!' & ! "!$! Phil. Trans. R.
Soc. Lond., 288, =
/!""! A "!' ! (,' !
.
, & "! !2 ! " !9 Earth. planet.
Sci. Lett., 118, #
= ! A 6 ) N"!& .
(, "! ! 10. ! L/!! !" $"
(, "$
" !
Mar. Geol., 141, ?
=. 3.!!$ $".! & !1. &
"! '"! & $!, Franklin Inst. J., 236,
#?
L ! B A @' : ' ! & '!"
!2 !' & ' . '. "
! ! . =."& & "2 J. geophys. Res., 99, L! = A 5"
:D # ! ! . '";
!'"!! & ", '" 0 ! $".! & "! Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 144, <
4 = B. 5 A =!( D ? @ ." .. & ).'. ". ? !'"!! & ! !! J. geophys.
Res., 100, <<
4/2! ) A .8. < H.!*! ." & '!
. . & "
; "!" .. & C 8 . . '" J. Phys. Earth, 30, #?<
6.
G A B. 5 ) "!! (/ "
. $. "! " !2; .
, & .@!"
J. geophys. Res., 96, # #?# #
5 A . ", & N " Science,
260, <
5 =: < " ! & !! '
" BMR
J. Aust. Geol. Geophys., 7, ??#
5 =: A !" 65 F ""! "!
& ' !" & '! & ! "! ! @ "
4
! J. geophys. Res., 95, ? <
5 . C D!. 6 B :F A :. C&&!$
"! !2 & "! " C '. @!
J. geophys. Res., 102, ? 5. J A '! C <# F"0. !2! &
"! C !9 ! Geophys. Res. Lett., 13,
#<#<
D'(2 5 < F"0. & "! & ' !"
."!& (,' , !
! ( $!; !, 4"
Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 67, D'(2 5 <( D! ! $"! "
! ! . @2 4"
Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 55, <#
D'(2 5 A B2!(". < '. "
! !
"! G!"! "!*$!"! '
"
J. geophys. Res., 86, ###<
D$! : A /"" :) ? D! ! (
! .(
.! > (
.
! ""! $!,
J. geophys. Res., 100, D.
/! 5 >( 6 6= A !'' 5 @ ." .(!
& L/!! '!
& ' NI<N &
/
" & Geology, 19, :@ A ! @F < ( $! &
"! ! 10. / & J. geophys. Res., 89,
:@ @"
/"" 6= A ). :D < "!
&", "! (
! & "! .
"!>
"
!
/! "!! 5. !" ) Geophys. J. Int., 54, #
: ! @F A .". <? ( $!
& 10. ; C$!
& "! Tectonophysics, 116,
@"" 5 #< G!!, & '" & ' "0! !'
& !! E.' J. geophys. Res., 73, <?
5>! : A /! @ # ) "!! (/
(,' , $!, ! "! J. geophys. Res., 81,
?
B. 5 @'! & ! ,; "!! & &.! !3. . $,
J. geophys. Res., 84, ?<?<
B. 5 < D! ! 10. '" '"!
J. geophys. Res., 89, < B. 5 << ) '" '!" ! & @
G ! J. geophys. Res., 93, <
B. 5 A L < D! ! 10. ."!&
"" J. geophys. Res., 83, #
B. 5 A 2 D < 4, ! . "! $".! & '! '!' Science, 199, ?
6 F , : A : !2 < / !*
! '
" & C !9 ! @ J. geophys. Res., 89,
#
L < 4." ! !, .(!
Science,
220, !."" ) A > 6 = $!, '"! 10. & "! ! 4"
Geophys. J. Int.,
131, #
! $! 6 A F !" 9" & '" $!!,;
." & ' E! !$ ! & $! *"!"
(.
( $(" J. geophys. Res., 102, ?#
! $! 6 A "! ) !& & '" $!!,
& ' !$ ! & F
! "0! .'
Geophys. J. Int., 114, ?#
6= "!! (/ .(!
$"! "
L/!! Bull. Volcanol., 34, ?#?#
#
GJI &'( <??<?
Flexure and rheology of oceanic lithosphere
6= A @'("" 6F < & !"
& L/!!
J. geophys. Res., 92, ###
6 A F ! :6 < : /
& !
! & & .(!
& !"
& L/!! J. Geol., 92, ??
6= @". : L"'( ) D!' B ' 2 A ) C < !. .(' ! "
*
"!
L/!! !
J. geophys. Res., 94, #? <
B
! # Theory of Flow and Fracture of Solids G" = /*L!"" B/ J 2
B/' A ! B ", & !" "!*
!& & ' !' , (! Nature, 385, ##
B!!'. @C A F , : < ) ! ! .. &
. '" ! !9 Geophys. J., 96, C A " 6= ",! & $ !! &
1 (,' , 1/ /! J. geophys. Res., 82,
<<
H.!" = A .' @ < "! .!
"! ! 10. ">! ! , & 4 ! & B ' ! Can. J. Earth Sci., 21, #
: !2 A @2", 6 !'! ! , &
L/!! 10. " ' Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 105, <?
F A B. 5 < @ ! '" '!" .. & ! "! '.
!
& ' !
! '"! Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 93,
" BL L $"!' '" ".' Ann. Rev.
Earth planet. Sci., 20, " BL A "" B # ) '" ! 10. & '!
*! "! ' !" (! Geophys. J. R. astr.
Soc., 45, ??
'! LF .
!" L A !" <
) "" '.; C ", @ . & .
!9 !! '" '", J. geophys. Res., 94,
? ?
., C & '! ! . & "
!;
"!! & '! & L/!! !
PhD thesis,
N!$ !, & L/!! L/!!
!2 N A <? !'! ! , & 10. " ' 12! L/!! 4"
Nature, 317, G ' DD (
!! :$! D. ! G .!"!
! @ A ! = < " $!!, !& & ' E! !$ ! & "! "!!*!
.
!
!" /! / D ",! " /
Geophys.
Res. Lett., 25, ##
" 4 F"0. " !!
!, $!!, & "! J. geophys. Res., 75, ?
#
GJI &'( <??<?
<?
" 4 ( F"0. & "! L/!!
Tectonophysics, 9, ?#
" 4 4! "
! & . !
@
Can. J. Earth Sci., 7, #
A @ 6 = $!, '"! !, '" 1/ C !9 ! J. geophys. Res., 98,
?? ?
< ",! & !, ! / "
8 ; L/!!C' '. ! J. geophys. Res., 83, ?<#
@ ." .. $!, '"! 10. & "! ! @ , 4"
Geophys. J. Int., 119,
#<###
A @ 6 = $!, '"! 10. & "! " L/!!C' '. !
Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 38, A !( B < !
! 10. & "! '. J. geophys Res., 89, ? A !2 N < @ ." .. 10. .(!
! , & L/!! 4"
J. geophys. Res., 94,
?
@ 6 A "> = ? = $!, '"!
10. & "! ; *
!'!" .
, & = '. BC "! J. geophys. Res., 80,
<
! 6L A !( B < ( $! & 10. "!" $".! & !9 (! Nature, 283,
??
! @ @""! 6 :"/
@" 6 A
L2 )6 !'! .
, & "! ! 10. ! $!!!, & ) !& @ , 4"
Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 146,
" *0'!! & 10. " & '! (
L/!! 4"
J. geophys. Res., 98, " A L0(, F ) '" !&& !" .(*
!
10. ! & . > J. geophys. Res., 95,
?
" A '! LF F &/ " ' !",
EOS, Trans. Am. geophys. Un., 72, #
"& : < . (.
"! !2 & '
"!!! E.' ! F
! J. Geophys., 61, . A "! < ="!" !! E.' & *! $!, '", ! '" $!!,
Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 74, :,'! & ." '! ! !1.
." !, J. geophys. Res., 102, ? <?