Postmodern theatre - The Wooster Group – - Forced Entertainment - © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Lecture: Part 1 20 minute break Lecture: Part 2 Main questions we will tackle: • • • • • What is Postmodernism? What relationship does it have to Modernism? What are the key philosophical concepts related to Postmodernism? How does Postmodernism manifest in the arts? And in theatre? Use the Wooster Group (and Forced Entertainment) as examples. © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Postmodernism = post - Modernism (after?) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com (against?) Why is Postmodernism hard to define? • It is a concept that appears in a variety of disciplines and subject eg. art, architecture, literature, communication, music... • Does not have a unified doctrine , it is not a style or a movement (ZEITGEIST! Zeit= time, geist= spirit/ghost) • Its hard to locate as a historical time frame - not clear when it © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com began – in each disciplines it manifested at a different time (after WWII? 1960S? 1970s? 1980s?) • It is best described rather than defined, and can be described as a set of strategic and critical practices that destabilised Modernist understandings of concepts such as existence, presence, identity, and meaning. • Postmodernism need not necessarily a BREAK from Modernism, it could be seen as an extension of it (a reworking and exacerbation of Modernist ideals and practices). MODERNISM • Artistic trend emerging at the end of the nineteenth century and extending, depending on the artistic genre, into the second half of the 20th century These are all continued / extended by Postmodernism - - emphasis on HOW seeing takes place rather than on WHAT is perceived (rethinking representation, radical experimentation in form, the focus became reading/perception itself rather than the content) blurring of distinctions between genres and between ‘high’ and ‘low’ culture emphasis on discontinuous narratives and collages of different materials tendency toward self-consciousness exploration of the psychological and subjective use of parody and irony BREAK AWAY (characteristics rejected by Postmodernism) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com - each separate movement endeavoured, in its turn, to depict reality in terms of a singular fundamental truth that developed during the Modernist era - attempting to construct a coherent world-view - art is intrinsically related to progress and improvement - emphasis on originality, autonomy and authenticity of the artwork - form follows function - rejection of elaborate formal aesthetics in favour of minimalist design © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com POSTMODERNISM (in art) • Certain Modernist approaches continue to be explored in a more radical way: selfconsciousness, parody, irony, fragmentation, mixing of genres, ambiguity, and simultaneity... • • • • • • • • • Form no longer follows function (or content) Celebration of surface rather than depth Rejection of the need for a unified/unifying aesthetic (pastiche, bricolage) Emphasis on process rather than product Hybridisation of art forms Complete breakdown of distinctions between ‘high’ and ‘low’ culture (kitsch, parody...) Extreme self-reflexivity (in a more playful and irreverent way) Intertextuality (artworks reference/quote other artworks rather than ‘reality’) Subversive attitude that debunks the authority of art institutions (i.e. reject museums) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1NLSvlkwfH0 © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Careful, don’t get caught up in simplistic binaries / oppositions © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com 1975 1913 V&A 'Postmodernism: Style and Subversion 1970-1990' (September 2011 - January 2012) https://vimeo.com/32207784 © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Other videos on Postmodern art: http:// www.tate.org.uk/learn/online-resourc es/glossary/p/postmodernism https:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=zs0zzsH iVWc © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c0DwRAVJZ4A Postmodernism is not just a question of style but aPakula new relationship to the world © Pablo www.pablopakula.com © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Key philosophical concepts relating to Postmodernism: ‘Postmodern condition’ ‘end of grand narratives’ © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com ‘simulacrum’ ‘hyperreality’ ‘death of the author’ ‘deconstruction’ ‘différance’ Jean-Françoise Llyotard (1924- 1998) The Postmodern Condition. A Report on Knowledge (1979) • commissioned by the government of Quebec • identified trends in knowledge, science and technology Postmodernism is the condition of culture in our advanced capitalist society. "I define postmodern as incredulity toward metanarratives." (Llyotard, 1979:xxiv) © Postmodernism Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com = the end of grand narratives Other characteristics of the Postmodern condition: • The industrial production and the ‘proletariat‘, has been moved out of sight, into the ‘3rd World‘ • Western societies have turned into consumer cultures • Each and every aspect of social and cultural life has been integrated into a global capitalist order (globalization) • MASS MEDIA play a vital role: the ‘late capitalist culture‘ is above all an information and media society Metanarratives / grand narratives: • dominating ideologies • reality can be explained and represented in its totality • used to unify our understanding • attempted to explain the world through a single prism (story) i.e. religion, Marx, Freud © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGZiLMGdCE0 Jean Baudrillard (1929- 2007) He devised theory of simulation and constructed notion of ‘simulacrum’: we live in a world of simulations. - we live in Disneyland - everything is a model or an image Simulation: where the copy has replaced the original. Simulation is “different from a fiction or a lie in that it not only presents an absence as a presence, the imaginary as the real, it also undermines any contrast to the real, absorbing the real in itself” (Baudrillard, 1994:3) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com When the copy becomes more real than the real: hyperreality Some of his provocative statements: • “the Gulf War did not take place“ The image of war preceded and ‘stood in’ for war. Hyperreality: Where the real object has been effaced by the signs of its existence (The Matrix, or The Trumann Show) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Roland Barthes (1915- 1980) Image – Music - Text (1977) • ‘From Work to Text’ • ‘ The Death of the Author ’ “The birth of the reader must be at the cost of the death of the author.” Key ideas: • meaning is not something definitive, bestowed on the text by its author, but only ever activated in the process of reading (lecture) – or performance • the text is not a finished artistic product (a ‘work‘ of art), but an active process involving the reader © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Therefore: • the popular questions ‘What does it mean?‘ and ‘What does the author/director want to tell me?‘ are utterly useless and irrelevant • meaning is not a matter of authorial intention, but the reader (audience) gives the meaning in the encounter with a book/show • analysing/interpreting a text should mean to “appreciate the plural“, not to narrow it down to the one meaning Jaques Derrida (1930- 2004) Key terms: ‘deconstruction’ ‘différance’ • relativist attitude • concepts are not ‘givens’ but constructed • all signs are invested with power • there are always traces of the disavowed workings of ideology in the text (i.e. implicit contradictions, presuppositions) • nothing expressed in language has a ‘natural’ meaning • opposing concepts rely/contain each other • meaning is endlessly deferred and always differs (it slips away) destruct + reconstruct = deconstruction because • strategy to challenge the power of a text • seeks to unearth and expose these hidden traces (of exclusion and repression) • subvert out confidence in commonplaces (turns words, meanings, and concepts on their head) • a sign does not mean something to us because of its ‘original’ substance or unique identity (which it doesn’t have) • each sign brings with an excess of meaning that must be excluded and muted for it to work as a signifier © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgwOjjoYtco Questions? © Pablo Pakula Further www.pablopakula.com reading: Richard Appignanesi & Chris Garratt, Postmodernism for beginners Christopher Butler, Postmodernism, a very short introduction Fredric Jameson, Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism Philip Auslander, From Acting to Performance Nick Kaye, Postmodernism and Performance © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCTOpdlZJ8U&index=1&list=RDVCTOpdlZJ8U POSTMODERNISM IN THEATRE © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com “a range of cultural practices and sensibilities that have developed since the 1980s especially and that reject some of the apparent certainties, or 'grand narratives', of modern paradigms of thought. Challenging ideas of coherent identity and universal value and truth as not only impossible but also duplicitous, it proposes that these 'grand narratives' only pretend to represent everyone's interest and actually represent dominant class interests.” (Allain & Harvie, 2014:231) POSTMODERNISM IN THEATRE - movement away from text-based theatre - unconcerned with the author's intention - devising approaches - non-linear composition - here-and-now of performance - hybridisation of performance disciplines - intertextuality (mixing high and low cultural source materials) - playful and destabilising approach to identity - performer vs actor / performing vs acting © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com PERFORMING ACTING - actor portrays a character - takes place within a fictional framework - text-based - 'truthfully' conveys emotion - essentially naturalistic - director-led © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com PERFORMING - expression of Postmodernism's interrogation of the idea of a unified subject - resists psychological characterisation - playfully self-aware / self-reflexive (conventions, pastiche) - here-and-now of the performance event - frequently prioritises the actor's role as a scenographic elements - performer-led - possibility of autobiographical materials POSTDRAMATIC THEATRE Hans-Thies Lehmann, 1999 (English translation 2006) - challenges dominant theatre hierarchies which invest authority in the text (de-prioritises narrative text/drama based in psychologically coherent characterisation/plot) - foregrounds theatrical aspects - non-linear structuring - often more about the sensory than rational (time/space/image for what they are as experiences not how they convey narrative) - often situated in the here-and-now of performance rather than within a fictional frame - tends to be self-reflexive, metatheatrical - demands the audience to construct meaning, acknowledging © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com “What makes the theory of postdramatic theatre distinctive and most constructive within theatre and performance studies is that is is specifically a theory of theatre practice, generated from within theatre.” (Allain & Harvie, 2014:231) The Wooster Group http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zvHgJwU4TfY © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com The Wooster Group • Offspring of Richard Schechner’s Performance Group • Founded in 1980 (had been working in parallel since 1975) • Work collaboratively • Elizabeth LeCompte (director/dramaturg) • Performances are text-based Yet they use text in a totally different way to traditional stagings of plays © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Productions include: Nayatt School (1978) T.S. Eliot‘s The Cocktail Party Route 1 & 9 (1981) Thornton Wilder‘s Our Town L.S.D. (just the high points) (1984) Arthur Miller‘s The Crucible Brace Up! (1991) Chekhov‘s Three Sisters House/Lights (1999) Gertrud Stein‘s Doctor Faustus Lights the Lights To You, The Birdie! (2002) Racine‘s Phèdre Poor Theatre (2004) based on J. Grotowski and W. Forsythe Intertextuality ‘Source‘ texts are: Intertextuality • open to interrogation (deconstructed, decentered) & • quoted rather than staged in their entirety Deconstruction • juxtaposed / collaged with other 'texts' •(fragments of popular culture, media, films, personal recollections, etc) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Route 1 and 9 Route 1 & 9 disrupted Our Town’s universalizing fantasy of a white, middleclass, puritan American idyll by introducing the racial and cultural difference Wilder’s play omitted. (Allain & Harvie, 2014:131) • Wilder‘s Our Town • Blackface performers • Comedy routine by Pigmeat Markham • Home movies (journey away from New York on the New Jersey thoroughfare, and a homemade porno) LSD (just the high points) • Miller‘s The Cruicible • Beat generation authors • Writings and recordings by Dr. Timothy Leary (LSD advocate) – including a debate with Gordon Liddy (involved in Watergate) • Re-staging of a rehearsal (on LSD?) Vieux Carré (2009) “Juxtapositions like these produce new resonances in both sources of material, often working to deconstruct the assumed elitism of the ‘classic’ texts and to expose some of the prejudices – about race, gender, and age for example – on which they rely” (Allain & Harvie, 2014:92) ©“OurPablo texts stand Pakula as an alternativewww.pablopakula.com theatre language which redefines the traditional devices of story-line, character and theme. Each production reflects a continuing refinement of a nonlinear, abstract aesthetic which at once subverts and pays homage to modern theatrical ‘realism‘.“ (Wooster Group press release, quoted in Aronson, 1985:152) Vieux Carré (2009) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=257qO9UgrD8 © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJ7VXojxyTM Deconstruct realism's claim to portray 'the truth' “While acknowledging the power and seduction of naturalism’s illusionistic performance, the Group’s work also challenges its cultural dominance and perceived truth through a number of alienation techniques – for example, showing the actor putting drops in his eyes to simulate tears, and replaying a monologue, first as emotionally-charged realism and a second time accelerated and ridiculous” (Allain & Harvie, 2014:93) Fish Story (1994) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvfKKV8Mxyg © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Fish Story (1994) Approaches to performance/acting: North Atlantic (1985) • No consistent emotions or psychology • Acting in quotation marks • Persona rather than character • Self-aware • Use of ‘non-matrixed‘ acting (task based) • On a par with technology • Juxtaposes realism with stylisation and dance/movement • Eclectic aesthetics (no single, unified style) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com The Emperor Jones (1993) https:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cf6uSn nX9Ig Pastiche Poor Theatre (2004) North Atlantic (1984) https:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTwgh1g8 N7Q Poor Theatre (2004) https:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=43O_4vhtT Dk © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com https:// Shakonnet Point (1975) www.youtube.com/watch?v=nsDsIDzuP8 Y Shakonnet Point (1975) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8m hKCFEIRCc https:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSBKh6O75 _o “The company began not with a play but with improvisations based on objects and images brought in by Spalding Gray that had personal associations for him. ''We began to structure it,'' Mr. Gray wrote in an article at the time, ''like a piece of music (concern with rhythm), like a painting (concern with light and color), and like a dance (concern with movement).'' Out of this process came ''Sakonnet Point,'' an almost wordless evocation of childhood and the first of ''Three Places in Rhode Island.'' The second and the most autobiographical of the Wooster Group's work was ''Rumstick Road.'' Using taped conversations with his relatives and his own remembrances, Mr. Gray presented an emotional documentary about his mother, who committed suicide in 1967. The documentary elements appeared alongside choreographed movement and visual images inspired by themes of madness, religion, and medical treatment that surfaced in the story of Spalding Gray's mother and would reappear in the group's later work. (...) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com ''Nayatt School,'' for instance, examines medicine and religion as healing forces. It uses three comichorror stories performed as slapstick routines, a scene from T.S. Eliot's ''The Cocktail Party'' with several roles played by children, and some autobiographical vestiges from ''Rumstick Road''; the piece opens with a monologue in which Mr. Gray discusses his acting career, his mother's psychiatric treatment, and her Christian Science faith. 'Point Judith,'' according to Miss LeCompte, is about ''forming new structures for the family.'' It juxtaposes three examples of community: the all-male crew of an oil rig, as characterized in a short play called ''Rig,'' written for the company by Jim Strahs; a group of nuns (played by the same male actors), seen on film frolicking by the sea; and the family in ''Long Day's Journey Into Night,'' a portion of which is surreally acted out. (Shewey, 1982) www.nytimes.com/1982/05/16/theater/the-wooster-group-stirs-controversy-with-an-avant-garde-series.html?pagewanted=all Pastiche Rumstick Road (1977) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_cOmMw45NQc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VEtpx2d8Ry4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZCHgXHbz2AI © Pablo PakulaNayatt www.pablopakula.com School (1978) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZaD_dszXtEA Point Judith (1979) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbiRxWV_njU Use of multimedia: • Simulacrum: everything is simulation (media saturation of consumer culture makes it impossible to distinguish between 'the real' and the representation) • Non-hierarchical relationship between life performers and technology (pre-recorded or live feed, mics, voice alteration…) • Distancing effect: highlights that this is a performance/artifice © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com • Structural fragmentation, conflicting points of view, quoting other ‘texts’ To You, The Birdie! (2002) Hamlet (2007) Route 1 & 9 (1981) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRRa6LwPyEk Brace Up! (1991) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pso5vlO7PeY House/Lights (1999) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mqd3kLN12oA Hamlet (2007) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9gDb9mq4uMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_10u984AvzE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SHhKHEE9LE Further characteristics: • Self-referential / self-reflexive making reference to the process of making the piece, as well as quoting previous productions (since Postmodernism is concerned with meaning-making and meaning-representation it’s often self-conscious / self-reflexive, emphasising process over production) • Offers many readings (ambiguous, contradictory) (meaning is always multiple and contingent on contexts, ‘The Death of the Author': democratic understanding of the production of meaning - produced by the audience) • Theatre exposed as a medium deconstructing its own materiality and conventions, as well as acknowledging the stage apparatus © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Brace up! (1991) La Didone (2008) What about the audience? • Not silent and distant consumers • Have to make sense of the fragments (associatively) • Thus they are activate in the meaning-making process • The work fosters plurality • Accusation: ‘super-competent spectator' (think about Shrek – multilayered viewing experience?) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com House/Lights (1999) North Atlantic (2010 restaging) The South Bank Show: The Wooster Group (1987, ITV) http://www.ubu.com/film/wooster_south-bank_part-1.html http://www.ubu.com/film/wooster_south-bank_part-2.html © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Liz LeCompte and William Forsythe in conversation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yYW9HQ_f4E A practical invitation... Here's a little something to do before your seminar next week. Think of it like a recipe of sorts, interpret it and adapt it as you see fit. In your independent study groups (or individually): Pick an existing play or fairy-tale you know well. © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Consider what other ‘texts’ you might be able to collage it with. Remember we are using the word ‘text’ in its broadest sense: an actual text, quoted movement/dances, tasks, songs, autobiographical material… Consider what each new ‘text’ will add/highlight/deconstruct in the original source play/fairy-tale. You may want to use post-its to come up with a preliminary structure (channel surf) And in the UK? © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com North Atlantic (1984) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U-frxRMzxY Hula (1981) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F3vBZYoZdNM Forced Entertainment Since 1984 (UK) © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com The company was founded by six graduates from Exeter University (since then they have been joined by a number of different performers – including a Kent graduate). They create performances in a collaborative process where Tim Etchells functions as an ‘editor‘, not as author. Their rehearsals are not focused towards a ‘product outcome‘’, but to find a structure of rules within which to play and develop material. Projects range from stage shows, site-specific or durational performances, online/CDs... © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com 200% and Blood Thirsty (1987) Bloody Mess (2004) KEY CARACTERISTICS Postmodern approach • don’t produce one clear-cut meaning but the audience constructs their own • often ambiguous, contradicting tensions in the work (use of humour) • theatre exposed as a medium: it deconstructs its own (usually hidden) materiality and conventions (performances about performance) Not presentations of a fictional world, but are situated in the here and now of the performance event • liveness • performances are open and may change • audience acknowledged in their role as audience • DIY aesthetics • ‘Poetics of failure’ • performers not actors • ‘task-based’ • acting ‘between quotation marks’ • no emotions, no psychology or characterisation but persona • a list as ‘the loosest collection of material’ © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com How We Work https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jw2RbmuvuW0 On Making Performance - Tim Etchells speaking http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m2fRfN5U7GA ‘Early Years Mix’ (various works) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35Rev3xVs5o&feature=related Hidden J (1994) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WkVzofQSqBo Extract of First Night (2001) and Speak Bitterness (1994) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJCVdaGA04I Spectacular (2008) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7OO83wpfSBs © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com The Thrill of It All (2010) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3d02U0u_1sk Tomorrow's Parties (2011) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fig0PWCwSpM The Coming Storm (2012) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6lc4bEDcNw On The Coming Storm (2012) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gROamn4bEfc Durational work: On duration https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7mLlozWPbVs 12am: Awake & Looking Down (1993) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ljsUnsNcSjk Speak Bitterness (1994) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgwAQ_-VwWY On Speak Bitterness https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gjCjHvuCb_8 © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Quizoola! (1996) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGOr-DrXieU&feature=related Quizoola! (2013) 24 hour version – check out #Quizoola24 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9bm_8WgqIvg And on the Thousandth Night... (2000) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjsrLtpx2EI On scripted improvisation https:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=s8nsllBp5lw&list=PL-blz3DjyJIwdaVJHtKE7pjmPKf0YxRjf&ind ex=13 OPPORTUNITY TO SEE FORCED ENTERTAINMENT! © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com 1st - 6th March 2016 Barbican, London Complete Works: Table Top Shakespeare (2015) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufVne7LqAag https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_OhS3WexV4 Just £3 per play! http://www.barbican.org.uk/theatre/event-detail.asp?ID=18680 www.forcedentertainment.com BIBLIOGRAPHY Allain, P. & Harvie, J. The Routledge Companion to Theatre and Performance Appignanesi, R. & Garratt, C. , Postmodernism for beginners Aronson, A. American Avant-garde Theatre: A History Auslander, P. From Acting to Performance Butler, C. Postmodernism, a very short introduction Callens, J. ed., The Wooster Group and its Traditions Jameson, F. Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism Kaye, N. Postmodernism and Performance Quick, A. ed., The Wooster Group Work Book Shewey, D. ‘The Wooster Group Stirs Controversy with and Avant-garde Series’, New York Times, 16th May © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com Preparation for your seminar: Reading: • three journal articles (you will have to look for them yourself) Revisit some of the screenings mentioned today, and discuss them in your independent study groups. © Pablo Pakula www.pablopakula.com View the documentary: The South Bank Show: The Wooster Group (1987, ITV) http://www.ubu.com/film/wooster_south-bank_part-1.html http://www.ubu.com/film/wooster_south-bank_part-2.html Remember the practical invitation!
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz