Common Core critics cry educational folly - CSMonitor.com
WORLD
Family
USA
COMMENTARY
BUSINESS
ENERGY/ENVIRONMENT
INNOVATION
SCIENCE
CULTURE
BOOKS
Go
Subscribe and save 79 %
Sign up for FREE E-Newsletters: Weekend Edition
All
AllFamily
Family
Search
Common Core critics cry educational folly
Weekly review of
global news and ideas
Balanced, insightful
and trustworthy
Common Core: Critics of the Common Core warn that the new educational standards have never
been tested in real classrooms, place undue stress on students and teachers, and are far too
expensive.
Subscribe in print or
digital
SPECIAL OFFER
By Philip Elliott, Associated Press / December 4, 2013
Print
Common Core critics: Education
Secretary Arne Duncan (l.) speaks to
reporters at Malcolm X Elementary
School in Washington, Nov. 7. Critics
are relentless in warning about what
they see as the folly of the new
Common Core academic standards.
Susan Walsh/AP
Enlarge
WASHINGTON
Critics are relentless in warning about what they see as the folly of the
new Common Core academic standards, designed to prepare students for college or a job by the
time they graduate from high school.
Related stories
Monty Python reunion:
Top 12 videos for
parent-kid bonding
Mom's top 10 book list for toddlers
Common core hits the ground, highlights
critical thinking
Focus
Education reform's next big thing: Common
Core standards ramp up
Modern Parenthood: Is 'zero tolerance' is
bad for education?
The standards are being implemented in 45 states and
the District of Columbia, but critics say they were
written in private and never tested in real classrooms,
and that educators aren't familiar enough with the
standards to use them. The standards also come with a
multi-billion dollar price tag.
"Children are coming home with worksheets and their
parents don't recognize it," said Emmett McGroarty, a
director at the American Principles Project, a
conservative group that opposes the standards.
"Common Core is reckless in what it's doing to
Ads by Google
Online ECE College
children."
Common Core's supporters think the worries are
http://www.csmonitor.com/The-Culture/Family/2013/1204/Common-Core-critics-cry-educational-folly[12/4/2013 2:40:24 PM]
Digital
Common Core critics cry educational folly - CSMonitor.com
Earn an Early Childhood Education
degree from Post University Online!
overblown and miss nuances of the sweeping changes
www.post.edu/Online
that spell out the reading and math skills that students
should have at each grade level, from kindergarten
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
Click Here for your FREE 30 DAYS of
The Christian Science Monitor
Weekly Digital Edition
through high school.
But even the most vocal supporters admit they cannot
guarantee the standards will succeed.
There's one thing both sides agree on: When fully
implemented, Common Core stands to reshape the vast majority of American classrooms.
RECOMMENDED: Monty Python reunion: Top 12 videos for parent-kid bonding
___
Critics – parents, teachers, and tea partyers alike – argue that states were pressured to sign onto
the Common Core standards to get federal economic stimulus money to keep teachers on the job.
In fact, to qualify for more than $4 billion in aid, states had to put into place standards to prepare
About these ads
students for life after high school and test student performance. Common Core wasn't specifically
prescribed, but the Obama administration clearly signaled it was the preferred option starting in
2009.
Toys & Entertainment
"Normally, to go through standards it would take years," said Bill Evers, a researcher at Stanford
University's Hoover Institution. "In California, we had six weeks."
Such quick approval resulted in new standards that some didn't fully understand.
For instance, the standards include tougher approaches to math – such as rigid motion in
geometry – over more common approaches. "It has never successfully been used in K-12
education in the United States, in any state, in any country," Evers said of rigid motion.
___
At the same time, Common Core puts a greater emphasis on critical thinking needed as adults.
There is a greater emphasis on non-fiction and technical selections, more likely needed in the
workplace than sonnets.
To critics, it smacks of a federal reading list.
Teachers can still pick their own passages but Common Core provides examples as suggestions.
If teachers have better ideas, they're free to use them. Literature and history aren't abandoned.
For example, the recommended reading has a Pablo Neruda poem listed on the same page as the
Are you a Helicopter Parent?
Constitution's Bill of Rights and a Ralph Waldo Emerson essay.
"There is no prescription as to how these should be taught. There's no one pedagogical standard
Most viewed
how these should be taught," said William Schmidt, who heads the Center for the Study of
Curriculum at Michigan State University.
1. With relaunch of Obamacare, relaunch of
Obama's presidency (+video)
Adds Robert Rothman, a senior fellow at Alliance for Excellent Education: "There's no such thing
2. PISA test shows 'stagnation.' Is US education
reform failing? (+video)
as a reading list."
But critics aren't buying it.
"Everyone claims there's all this local control and the ability for teachers to do what's best for
teachers," said state Rep. Tom McMillin, a Michigan Republican who has led the push to eliminate
the standards. "But as long as you have the assessment tied to the Common Core, you are
teaching to the tests."
http://www.csmonitor.com/The-Culture/Family/2013/1204/Common-Core-critics-cry-educational-folly[12/4/2013 2:40:24 PM]
3. Tunnels under Rome inspire thumbs up to
Minecraft (+video)
4. Caroline Berg Eriksen's postpartum selfie:
Harming or helping? (+video)
5. Sandy Hook 911 calls being released, ending
legal battle to shield families (+video)
Common Core critics cry educational folly - CSMonitor.com
RECOMMENDED: Monty Python reunion: Top 12 videos for parent-kid bonding
Photos of the day
12.03.13 »
___
Those tests have been a sticking point for Common Core's critics, especially liberals and parents
who worry the tests are too stressful for their children. Other critics worry the tests are giving
government too much information about individual students.
Testing has been part of schools for years. As part of the Bush-era No Child Left Behind
Photos of the day 12/03
education law, testing was mandated so states could identify schools that were working and those
that needed improvement.
But many critics point to the financial cost.
CSMonitor.com on Facebook
The conservative Boston-based Pioneer Institute estimates the total cost of Common Core will be
almost $16 billion over seven years. The new tests alone would cost $1.2 billion during that same
period, the think tank says.
That has inspired concern among parents.
Hundreds gathered at the University of Notre Dame for a conservative conference about the
standards. Activists are trying to stop the standards or roll them back at statehouses. And one
Maryland man was arrested after he interrupted a town hall-style meeting by telling parents, "Don't
sit there like cattle."
"Parents, you need to question these people. You need to do your research," Robert Small
shouted as he was being led from a session meant to explain the new standards. "Is this America?
"
___
According to an Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research poll of parents this
fall, 52 percent of parents said they'd heard "only a little" or "nothing at all" about the standards.
About a third of parents were unsure whether their state was adopting them.
That has left open the door for critics to fill in the blanks.
"Think of it as Obamacare for schools," the conservative American Principals Project says in a
video on its website. "Did you know that they're replacing our American education philosophy of
citizenship, individuality and unlimited potential with a European approach that sees us all as cogs
in a state machine?"
That leaves some education leaders smarting.
"This is political," said Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, a Republican weighing a White House bid in 2016.
"Meanwhile, back at the ranch, we have huge swaths of the next generation of Americans that
can't calculate math, they can't read, their expectations in their own lives are way too low."
Education Secretary Arne Duncan, too, has little patience for the criticism. After Rep. Matt Salmon,
R-Ariz., called Common Core a "federal takeover of the curriculum," Duncan scolded him.
"It's not a black helicopter ploy," Duncan said.
And in Richmond, Duncan sarcastically said parents are just now realizing that their schools aren't
as good as they imagined.
"It's fascinating to me that some of the push back is coming from, sort of, white suburban moms
who – all of a sudden – their child isn't as brilliant as they thought they were and their school isn't
http://www.csmonitor.com/The-Culture/Family/2013/1204/Common-Core-critics-cry-educational-folly[12/4/2013 2:40:24 PM]
Sign Up
Create an account or Log In to
see what your friends recommend.
Are you smarter than an atheist? A
religious quiz
25,785 people recommend this.
Commencement speaker to remember:
David Foster Wallace
11 people recommend this.
'Man From U.N.C.L.E.': Will Tom Cruise
star?
73 people recommend this.
Immigration reform: Is 'amnesty' a
possibility now?
Editors' picks:
Student debt report: More
graduates have it ... and
have more of it
Among 2012 graduates of fouryear colleges in the US, 71 percent finished school in
debt, up from 68 percent in 2008, according to the
report. The average estimated student debt: $29,400.
Amazon UK: A tough place to work, but Brits keep
clicking
When global warming kicks into overdrive, how will
we know? (+video)
Sandy Hook 911 calls being released, ending legal
battle to shield families (+video)
Latin America Monitor: Global corruption: How does
Latin America stack up?
Common Core critics cry educational folly - CSMonitor.com
quite as good as they thought they were, and that's pretty scary," Duncan said.
About these ads
He said later he regretted the remark.
Related stories
Monty Python reunion: Top 12 videos for parent-kid bonding
Mom's top 10 book list for toddlers
Common core hits the ground, highlights critical thinking
Focus
Education reform's next big thing: Common Core standards ramp up
Live discussion: How Philanthropists Make
Modern Parenthood: Is 'zero tolerance' is bad for education?
Their Giving Decisions, Tues. Dec. 3rd @ 1:00
p.m. Eastern Time
About these ads
From The Web
Sponsored Content by Taboola
Annual Giving Guide
A Sudanese 'Lost Boy'
saved by the kindness of
strangers
Guide to giving: Charities
latch onto 'crowdsourcing'
Is This What's Putting Homeowners May Be Biblical ‘Money Code’ Truth About
Tanning Salons Out
Upside Down Again... Exposed
Annuities*
Smart Life Weekly
Moneynews
Senior Annuity Alert
of Business?
Charities mimic retailers'
Tan Physics
Underwritten by:
Become part of the Monitor community
What Kids Who Don't Billionaire Tells
Is It Time To Defund
Eat Vegetables Look Americans to Prepare Obamacare? Cast
Like When They Gr… For "Financial Ruin" Your Vote.
14 Famous Couples
Time Forgot (But We
Never Will)
Nick Mom
Refinery29
Moneynews
Live Like the Rest of Us
Sign up to receive a selection of the most popular stories of the week
every Saturday.
http://www.csmonitor.com/The-Culture/Family/2013/1204/Common-Core-critics-cry-educational-folly[12/4/2013 2:40:24 PM]
Common Core critics cry educational folly - CSMonitor.com
Click here to receive the next full month of the Daily News Briefing - a new news
service from The Christian Science Monitor - ABSOLUTELY FREE!
Innovation
Science
World
Science
The cloud computing race
ramps up with Google
Compute Engine
Did Comet ISON just ruin
Christmas? (+video)
How much do you know
about Ukraine? Take our
quiz!
In one big step for China,
'Jade Rabbit' heads to the
moon (+video)
6th-12th Homeschool
americanonlinehigh.com
Fully-Accredited & Most Electives! $31 Gets You Started Today
About these ads
Home
About
Content Map
Careers
Contact Us
Corrections
Subscribe
Find us online
E-Readers
Text
Advertise With Us
Specials
Multimedia
Make Us Your Home Page
Articles on Christian Science
© The Christian Science Monitor. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Privacy Policy.
http://www.csmonitor.com/The-Culture/Family/2013/1204/Common-Core-critics-cry-educational-folly[12/4/2013 2:40:24 PM]
Common Core critics cry educational folly - CSMonitor.com
http://www.csmonitor.com/The-Culture/Family/2013/1204/Common-Core-critics-cry-educational-folly[12/4/2013 2:40:24 PM]