Roots of the derivative of a polynomial

!"#$&%'()#
%*()+
,.-0/2143658789:4;<36/=71>-.?@A'BDCEA=F2GBIHJGK@LNMPOBQGRA'LSMGKBTMR@BVUW6MXLNY[Z\NA'C]GWIY<]M^
NL O_<`KA=MR]\aGbBDOcGK@Ad`RBeBIGfMbBIHgGK@AhZiBD\ajeOBDYkLSWI\mlnVlDoqproqpsotvuxw2pro[tzyQw{pso[t}|Dw2~a~N~Spso[t€wXw
GR@iWVG‚LNMKF2BVƒDA{`KA=‚U&@La\NA„UPBD`R…eLNO_kBQO"A2†Z\NLNF{L‡G&HsBD`RY<]\SWQMPHsBQ`&GK@A6ˆ€WQ`R…DBVƒ<GK`KWQOMXHsBQ`KYЉ
‚AxMRF{`RLNC.A'GK@Ah`RAxMX]\aG&WIO‚8GR@A=OcY[A{O‹GRLNBQOŠC`KLaA{Œj[@BVULaG&LNMb`KA{\SWVGRAx‚[[email protected]=WQ]GRLaHs]\
MR]CEA=F2G=‰<@BQZ.AkGR@WIGhGR@A[LNODGKA{`KA=MXGRAx‚€`KA=WQ‚A{`dU&La\N\
F2BDOMX]\‡G yVŽ
BQ`[ |IŽHsBQ`„WQ‚‚L‡GKLaBDOWI\
LNOHsBQ`KYWVGRLNBQO‰
g-0364‘’5‘h“:Š”.38-.•PBQOMRLS‚A{`GK@A'Z.BQ\NjeOBQY[LSWI\D–i—mpsoJw˜opsoht}u™w2prodt"yQw2~a~N~Nprohtcwš‰
›GKM‚A{`KLaƒVWIGRLNƒQA&@WDM
Wh`RBeBQGC.A2GUbA{A=OA=WDFf@TGUbB6WQ‚™EXWDF2A=ODG
`KBeBIGfMBIHe–i—JœeMXB„UbA&YW™j6U&`RLaGRA
—ežmŸ
–.— pso.wP˜ psoct¤p¦¥6§©¨—eª ¡ wXw2«
¡2¢m£
U&@A=`RAhGK@A6¨ —ª ¡ œGK@A„Hs`fWQFšGKLaBDOWI\mZiWI`RGKM&BQHqGK@A6`KB‹BQGKMBQH.– — œiWI`KAhCiA{GUPA=A{O€¬WQO‚­uQ‰P®
Z\NBIGBQHJGR@Ad¨ —eª ¡ WDMWdHs]OiFšGRLNBQOcBIH¥[`KA{ƒQAxWI\SMGR@A'HsBQ\N\aBVU&LNO_„ZLSFšGK]`KATpsLNOGR@LNMA2†WIY[Z\NAQœ
€˜|Q¬‹wš¯
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
10
20
30
° LN_Q]`RA[uQ¯ ° `KWDFšGKLaBDOWI\JZWQ`XGfMBIHGK@A„`KB‹BQGKMBQHi– ± £ ‰
° La_D]`RA[u„MR]_Q_DA=MXGKMPGR@WIG&HsBQ`'¥cZ`KBQZ.A{`K\ajcMKF{WQ\aAx‚GK@A6¨ —ª ¡ WQZZ`KBDWQFf@cGR@A„_D`KWQZ@cBQH
MRBQY[AkF{BQO‹GRLNOe]BQ]iMHs]OiFšGRLNBQO>WQMdv²´³‰<O‚A{Ax‚mœJGR@LNMhLSMdGR`K]AQœgWQO‚4GK@AkHs]OF2GRLNBQO­LNM
_QLNƒQA=OCejc?@A{BQ`KA{YµuQ¯
36¶·e¸¹V·eº»,.-½¼¾I¿TÀVÁÂÁÃdÄÂŀpr¬«{uxw2œ
u
u
u&tzÃ
puxw
—Q\NÆ6LNY Ç ¨ —eªÂÈÊÉ›Ë —VÌ ˜ Í WQ`KF=F2BIGÎ Í \NBQ_Î ÃÐÏ'Ï ~
u
A=`RADœeWQO‚\SWVGKA{`xœ‹WQ`KF=F2BIGbMXLN_QOL AxMGR@A0C`fWIOiFf@BIHmGR@A0LNOeƒQA{`fMRAF2BIGfWIO_DA{O‹G
Hs]OiFšGRLNBQO
GKWQ…eLaO_ƒVWQ\a]AxM&C.A2GUbA{A{O4¬WQO‚ Í œiWIOi‚ so <‚A{OBQGRA=M&GR@A6\SWI`K_QAxMG&LNO‹GRA{_DA{`&OBQG'_Q`KA=WIGRA=`
GR@iWIO8oq‰ ° LN_Q]`RA0yTMX@BVUMGR@A0MR]ZiA=`RZ.BDMRLaGRLNBQO8BQHmGR@A'Hs]OFšGKLaBDOcBDOGR@A0`RLN_Q@‹GR^¦@WQO‚MRLN‚A
BIH6pXuxwbBQOGR@A„`RBeBIGfM{‰
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
10
20
30
° LN_Q]`KA6y¯ ° `fWQF2GRLNBQOWQ\.ZiWI`RGKMBIHGR@A„`RBeBIGfMbBIHJ– ± £ WIO‚cGR@A„\NLNYkLaGRLNO_8F{]`RƒDAQ‰
¿R¾x¾ A2GkÃhMKWVGKLNMXHsj¬ à *uQœ
WQO‚>U&`RLaGRA"¥v˜ Âà Q ‹‰}?@AŠ¥§¨ —eª ¡ WI`KAGR@A
MRBQ\N]GRLNBQOMBQHGK@A„A ‹]WIGRLNBQO
– — pro.w ˜ — u ˜¬~
–i—mpro.w ¢m£ oct
O"BIGK@A{`&UbBQ`f‚M=œ‹UbAh@W™ƒQA
—
¡
u
u
t
˜¬«
¢m£ ¨—eª ¡ § ¥<t
¢¡ Ÿ t¨q—eª ¡ § 6t¥
BQ`xœeGR`fWIOiMHsBD`RY[LNO_TGK@A„LNO‚LSF2A=M=œ
—ež ¡ žmŸ
¡ u
u
t
˜¬~
p yQw
¢m£ ¨—eª ¡ §
¢m£ pXut>¨q—eª ¡ wq§
?@LSM[A ‹]WIGRLNBQO©HsBD`¨ —eª F{WQOOBQGkC.A4MXBD\aƒDA=‚©A{†Z\aLSF2LaGR\Nj prBIGR@A{`KU&LNMRAUbA"UPBD]\S‚©@W™ƒDA
A2†Z\NLSF2LaGqA2†Z`KA=MKMRLaBDOMmHsBD`¡ ¨ —eª ¡ w2œVC]GWIOTWDMXjeY[ZGRBQGRLSFMRBQ\N]GRLNBQOTLNMqA=WDMXLN\ajdBQCGKWILNOAx‚„]MRLaO_
W„UbA{\N\‡^›…eOBVU&O8WQMRjeY[ZGRBQGRLSF&HsBQ`KYT]\NWœIGR@iWVGLNMP`RA=\NWIGRAx‚kGRB ]\NA{` MZ`RB‚]iFšGHsBD`RY<]\SW„HsBQ`
GR@A„_DWIY[YWTHs]OFšGKLaBDOg¯
u ˜t  p w §©\aBD_ip "w§ pu™w p ² ³ wš~
pr|Dw
§
p
w
¢m£
y
"
#
#
%$
$
#
'&
)(
!
*&
A=\NWIGRLNBQO>pr|Dw2œU&@LSFf@@BQ\S‚MHsBQ`WQ\a\ LNOTœxGR`fWIOMXHsBQ`KYM„p yQwGKB
t  prpr¨¨ —e—eª ª ¡ w w §  pXpu&u&t­t>¨¨ —e—eª ª ¡ w w ˜\aBD_ Î Št>¥¥<t¤u Ï § puxw ps€² ³ wš~ p‹w
¡
?@Ad`RLN_Q@‹GR^¦@WQO‚8MRLN‚AdBQHdp ‹wPLNMPGK@A„MRWQYkAhWQMP\NBQ_JpXpubt4ÃXwRnVÃXw.§ puxw2œMXLNOF{Ah¥˜ sà f D‰
?@Az\aA{HÂGX^›@WIO‚ MXLS‚A­LNMA2†WDFšGR\Nj Í F2BIG™p Í ¨ —eª ¡ wzpÂGKB¤MRA{A}GR@LSM{œ'GKWQ…QA€GK@A­\aBD_DWI`KLaGR@Y[LSF
‚A=`RLNƒVWVGRLNƒQABQHiGK@A&LN‚A{O‹GRLaGj p w pXugt w
˜ Í nMRLaOgp Í wRwš‰?@e]M=œQUbA&@W™ƒQA&MR@BVU&OTGK@WVG
Í F2BQG=p Í ¨ —eª ¡ w
˜\NBQ_ Î u&t­ÃÐÃ Ï § pXuxw ps€² ³ wš~
?@Ah\SWQMXG'MGfWVGRA=Y[A{O‹GF{WIOŠC.A„`RA=Z@`fWQMRA=‚
¨—eª ¡ ˜ Í u WQ`KF=F2BIGÎ Í u \NBQ_cÎ u&tzà à ÏÏ § pu™w pr4² ³vw
WQM&F{\NWQLaY[Ax‚m‰
->3T4
‘ c5 Š7 365 1}“ 75 - ?@A{BQ`KA{Y ukF=WIO­CiA[GK@BQ]_D@‹GhBQHbWDMdW
MRZiAxF2LSWI\F{WQMRAcBQH0WIO ÄÂÅ 2¿ šÄr¾VÅ 2¾V¿ ÁaÀzHsBQ`<GR@A4ˆ€WQ`R…DBVƒ€GK`KWQOMHsBD`RY"‰>?@!A €ÀI#¿ "Q$¾ ‚ (BQ)O *’‚A OAx‚€CejŠGR@A
% ¿RÀVÅ 2¾I¿ LNMdWcF{BQ`K`RAxMXZ.BQOi‚A{OF{A6C.A2GUbA{A{O}YkAxWQMR]`KA='M &zWIO)
A ‹]WIGRLNBQO
+-, .l (
p w ˜A{†Z Î +-, \NBQ_ u l.&gp w
p32Qw
Ï psY /1˜0 ¬‹wš~
/ t
/ t
A=`R4A &>LSM„WIOÄÂÅ % 2¿šÁN-À 5{ÄÂ7Å 6!4fÀ 8¿ 4psL¦‰ AD‰a9œ &>LNM„W4MRLN_QOAx‚}Y[A=WDMX]`RA[BIHbGRBQGKWQ\YkAxWQMR]`KA
&gp *
w0˜u0GR@WIGMRWIGRLSM AxM4¬ :;&gpXpXt0³«RoŽs<w : u0HsBD`A=WQFf@o"La=O *wšœqWQO>‚ (œeGK@A„ˆ€WI`K…QBVƒ
GR`fWIOiMHsBD`RY’BQ?H &mœ‹LSM
WhZ`KBQCWQCLa\NLaGj6Y[A=WQMR]`KAQœDU&@BDMRAA2†LNMXGRA=OF2A&LSM_D]WI`fWIO‹GRA=A=‚ŠprMRA{A6 y™Žswš‰
‹]WIGRLNBQO@p 2QwLNMqHrWDMRF{LaOWIGRLNO_0HsBQ`GR@ALNO‹GRA{`KZ\SW™jhL‡GA2†Z`KA=MKMRA=MgC.A2GUbA{A=OTGK@AWQ‚‚LaGRLNƒQA
WIOi‚cY<]\‡GKLaZ\aLSF{WIGRLNƒQA„MGK`R]iFšGR]`RAxMBQOŠL‡GfMbGUPBMRLN‚AxM{‰® OWIGR]`fWI\ ‹]AxMGKLaBDOcGK@WVGWQ`RLSMXAxMbLNM
@BVU!GRB4F{WQ\NF{]\NWIGRAkGR@A<GK`KWQOMXHsBQ`KY A2†Z\NLNF{L‡GK\aj}LaO­GR@ALaY[Z.BQ`RGKWIO‹G6F{WDMXA[U&@A=`RA (¤LNM„WQO
WICiMXBD\a]GKA{\NjkF{BQO‹GRLNOe]BQ]iMY[A=WQMR]`KAQ‰`RAxF2A=ODGK\ajkBQCGKWILNOAx‚[GR@A'HsBQ\N\aBVU&LNO_6ZiWI`RGRLSWI\iWQOMRUPA=`
 |VŽ›¯q›H (©pr@A{OF{AQœeWI\SMXB &wLSMPMR]ZZ.BQ`RGRAx‚[BQOcWQOLaO‹GRA=`RƒVWQ\q Ai« BKŽ›œQGK@A{O8]O‚A{`MRBQY[A&HrWILN`K\aj
_QA=OA{`fWI\mF{BQO‚LaGRLNBQOiML‡GLSMGR@A6F{WQMRA0GR@WIG
.l (
pso.w ˜ u MRLaOp &gpX A.«XoŽswXwA2†
psLÂw
Z C +ED \NBQ_ o8t u .l &gp Hw G
lQo Í Í
F
psLNLÂw
&gpX A.«XoŽÂw˜ u WI`fF{F{BIGIC u + D .l (
t­p o w G«
Í
ÍKJL7MONQP F
U&@A=`RA[GK@AcLNO‹GRA{_D`KWQ\NM„WQ`RAZ`RLNOF2LNZWQ\‡^›ƒVWI\N]ALaO‹GKA{_Q`fJWIN \SM=‰Š?@AcA2†Z`KA=MKMXLNBQO>BQO­GK@Ac`KLa_D@‹G
MRLN‚A<BIH'prLaLÂw`KA{Y[LNO‚M0]M0BIHGR@AT\NLaY[LaGRLNO_ŠF{]`KƒQA6LNO}?@A=BQ`KA{Y uQ‰0O4HrWQF2G=œm?@A{BD`RA=Y u
LSMhGR@AŠMXZ.A=F{LNWQ\F{WDMXALNOU&@LSFfR@ (LNM6GR@A8]OL‡HsBD`RY Y[A=WQMR]`KABQO ¬«=u2Ž0prL ‰ AQ‰Nœ gA{C.A=MR_Q]A
Y[A=WDMX]`KAxw2œgMXBGR@Ak\NLNYkLaGRLNO_4F2]`RƒDATLSM„MXLNY[Z\aj"GK@A[LaOeƒDA{`fMXAkˆ€WI`K…QBVƒŠGR`fWIOiMHsBD`RY*BIHPGR@A
]OLaHsBQ`KY \SW™TU S›G&UWQMPU&@LN\aAdGR`KjeLaO_6GRB Oi‚GR@AdLNOeƒQA=`KMRAHsBD`RY<]\NWŠpsLNLÂw
HsBD`bGR@Ahˆ€WI`K…QBVƒ
GR`fWIOiMHsBD`RY GR@WIGWI`K`RLNƒQAx‚WVG8GK@AzF=WI\SF2]\SWVGKLaBDOLaO ?@A{BQ`KA{Y uQV
‰ UdA=OA{`fWI\NOL W=LaO_GR@A
MKWIY[A8WQMRjeYkZGRBIGKLNFF=WI\SF2]\SWVGKLaBDOgœLaGTLSM6OBQGT@WQ`K‚}GRB€BDCGKWQLaO­GK@A8_QA=OA{`fWI\
HsBQ`KYT]\SW>psLNLSw
Hs`KBQY GK@A{`KAQ‰
|
#
%$
$
$
)(
$
(
$
#
$
#
#
(
)(
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
q-'&:5h364‘d5 5c‘Ic5}“- ‹]WIGRLNBQO8p@2QwmUWQM `KMXGMXGR]i‚LaAx‚„Cejdˆ}WI`K…QBVƒJœ{U&@B
F2BDOMRLN‚A=`RAx‚8LaGLaOŠGK@A6F2BDODGKA2†eG&BIHF2BDODGKLaOe]Ax‚8Hs`fWQF2GRLNBQOŠA2†ZWQOMXLNBQOiM{‰›G@WQM&MRLNOF2A„C.A{A=O
WIZZ\aLNA=‚0GKBY[BQY[A{O‹GZ`KBQC\aA=Y[M=œ{Y[AxWIOMBIH'LN`RLSFf@\NA2GZ`RBF2AxMRMRA=M=œ2GK@A
_D`RBVUGK@0BQHe`fWIOi‚BQY
BQ]O_}‚LSWI_D`KWQY[M=œqWQO‚LNOBIGK@A{`<Z\NWDF2AxM{
‰ hA=`RBVƒ M„MX]`KƒQA=j¤ y™ŽbLNM<W4_QBeB‚>`KA2HsA{`KA{OiF2AQ‰
A=_DWI`f‚LNO_ŠGR@AcA2†Z\NLNF{L‡G6HsBD`RY<]\SWQM=œPpsLÂw„UWQM6Z`RBVƒDA=‚zCej>•PLaHrWI`KA{\N\aLbWIO‚ A=_D$W W W{LNOL'au2Ž
LNO4GR@AkF{WDMXA<U&@A{`KA &€LSM0WcZ`KBQCWQCLa\NLaGjY[A=WDMX]`RATWQO‚"UWQMdF2BQOIEA=FšGK]`KA=‚"Cej hA{`KBVƒ8GRB
@BD\N‚4LNO4GK@AT_DA{OA=`KWQ\F{WDMXAD‰ BQGRA6GK@WVGdL‡GhLSMOBQGdWVGhWI\N\qBDCeƒ‹LNBQ]iMGR@WIG'GK@A<A{†Z`RAxMRMRLNBQO
BQO8GR@A0`RLN_Q@‹GX^›@WQO‚MXLS‚A0BIHpsLÂwLNMbW6Z`KBQCiWICLN\aLaGj[‚A{OMRLaG?j S?@e]M=œMX]CiMGKL‡GK]GRLNO_TƒVWQ`RLNBQ]M
A2†Z`KA=MKMRLaBDOMbHsBQ` &Š_DLaƒDA=M&`KLSMXA„GKBcMRBQY[A6WIY<]MXLNO_8WQO‚"ZiA=`R@iWIZM']O…eOBVU&O"LaO‹GKA{_Q`fWVGKLaBDO
LS‚A{O‹GRLaGRLNA=M=‰
5c
· ›·‹¹V· Q
· au2Ž <‰Qˆ‰‹•PLaHrWI`KA{\N\aLWQO‚ ‰ A=_D$W W W{LNOL¦œ 'LSMXGR`KLaC]GRLNBQOkHs]OF2GRLNBQOMBQHiY[A=WQOMBIHJW 'LN`KLNFf@^
\NA2GZ`KBF2A=MKM=œ 0ÅiÅ % À % Ä % , pXu D¬Dw ‹y 7.‹y‰
 y™Ž J‰ T‰ hA{`KBVƒJœgO‹GRA{`K\SWQF2LNO_4Y[A=WDMX]`RAxM{œqLa"O !<Ä¿šÄÂÁÂÁa$¾ $# kÄÂÅ.ÀV¿Š¾VŤ#¿ &%J#¿ {Å % À % Är¾VÅ
%(' f¾V*¿ )Vœ®Y[A{`x‰"ˆ€WVGK@g+‰ eBFQ‰?q`KWQOMX\¦+‰ A{`x‰ŠyœqOB‰zu ,uQœq®'Y[A{`KLNF=WIOˆ€WVGK@A{YWIGRLSF{WI\
eBF2LNA2GjD
œ -
`KBVƒeLN‚A=OF2ADœJu .,œeZZg‰
7| 2/,Q|‰
 |V0Ž <‰ BQY[LN…Jœ †Z\NLNF{L‡G„HsBD`RY<]\SWQM0HsBQ`„@BeBD…€UbWQ\a…MdBQO>F2BDO‹GRLNO‹]iWI\ BQ]O_4‚LNWQ_Q`fWIYM=‰
21 %%.Á €À %3' J­p yQ¬Q-¬ ‹
w 4D.y 2/
472i‰
5768$9:;6<=9?>3:A@CB?@CD2:;9?8E6?8$>3F.>G<H@ I.JKML=>ON@:=IP>G<
H@ DQ6:A>(IMR
•P]`K`RA=O‹G&WD‚‚`KA=MKM{¯
ST@U6?:<AV@L=<W9?XZY[6<A\=@V6<;>(];I.J^W@>(_`V6L=LbacL?IP<A>G<;d=<;@e9?XZfA]E>3@L?]$@=Jhgh@
i
\?9$N?9?<kj
RAl`mm=J?a*I:;6?@F$n7opqr/stuArvxwpqy&uzErx{q$|`}
}~y|€ycr`