2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Poll Summary - Generated by BallotBox (www.BallotBoxOnline.com)
Name
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Description
Purpose of this poll: The Austin Bar Association is conducting this poll to evaluate the performance
Online Voting
02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Voter Information
Eligible Voters
Cast Online Ballots
3815
673
% of eligible voters
17.64%
Report Information
Report Generated
02/22/17 05:03pm CST
1: gender
Question Type
No. of Respondents
2: ethnicity
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
673
SINGLE
673
What is your gender?
Male
Female
Number of Votes
373
239
% of Respondents
55.42%
35.51%
% of Answers
60.95%
39.05%
612
90.94%
100.00%
Number of Votes
18
10
50
13
2
489
% of Respondents
2.67%
1.49%
7.43%
1.93%
0.30%
72.66%
% of Answers
3.07%
1.70%
8.52%
2.21%
0.34%
83.30%
1
1
1
1
1
587
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
87.22%
0.17%
0.17%
0.17%
0.17%
0.17%
100.00%
Number of Votes
446
11
108
29
13
12
% of Respondents
66.27%
1.63%
16.05%
4.31%
1.93%
1.78%
% of Answers
72.05%
1.78%
17.45%
4.68%
2.10%
1.94%
619
91.98%
100.00%
Number of Votes
96
273
109
70
26
18
% of Respondents
14.26%
40.56%
16.20%
10.40%
3.86%
2.67%
% of Answers
16.22%
46.11%
18.41%
11.82%
4.39%
3.04%
592
87.96%
100.00%
How many lawyers work for your employer in all of Number
its offices?
of Votes
Solo
87
2 - 15 lawyers
214
16 - 50 lawyers
78
51 - 100 lawyers
63
101 - 250 lawyers
26
Over 250 lawyers
106
% of Respondents
12.93%
31.80%
11.59%
9.36%
3.86%
15.75%
% of Answers
15.16%
37.28%
13.59%
10.98%
4.53%
18.47%
574
85.29%
100.00%
Number of Votes
15
39
68
68
% of Respondents
2.23%
5.79%
10.10%
10.10%
% of Answers
2.46%
6.39%
11.15%
11.15%
Not answered
What is your ethnicity?
African American
Asian
Hispanic
Multi-Ethnic
Native American
Caucasian
Not answered
Greek
Hispanic and Caucasian
Klingon
Scots-Irish, Serbo-Croation
White
3: employer
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
673
Please describe your employment:
Private Law Firm
In-House/Corporate Legal Department
Governmental Agency (federal, state, or local)
Judge/Judicial Clerk (federal or state)
Public Interest Group
Other
Not answered
4: local office size
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
673
How many lawyers work in your local office?
Solo
2 - 15 lawyers
16 - 50 lawyers
51 - 100 lawyers
101 - 250 lawyers
Over 250 lawyers
Not answered
5: entity size
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
673
Not answered
6: years
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
673
How many years have you practiced law?
1 - 2 years
3 - 5 years
6 - 10 years
11 - 15 years
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
61
86
54
81
99
9.06%
12.78%
8.02%
12.04%
14.71%
Page 1 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
16 - 20 years
21 or more years
77
343
11.44%
50.97%
12.62%
56.23%
610
90.64%
100.00%
In which of the following areas do you practice? (optional)
Number of Votes
Administrative
110
Appellate
109
Bankruptcy
13
Criminal
63
Family
95
Government
95
Intellectual Property
26
Litigation
306
Oil and Gas
23
Probate
62
Transactional / Corporate
70
ADR
4
Banking
1
CPS
1
Constitutional
2
Construction
5
Construction Litigation
1
Consumer
2
Consumer/Commercial
1
Development code enforcement
1
Education
2
Elder Law
1
Eminent Domain
1
Employment
7
Entertianment
1
Environmental
3
Estate Planning
2
Estate Planning/Trusts/Guardianships
1
Estate planning
4
Estates
1
Federal Tax
1
Finance
2
Franchise
1
General civil & criminal
1
General practice
1
Government Affairs
1
Government Ethics
1
Guardianship
1
Guardianship litigation
1
Health
2
Health Care
2
Health law
1
Healthcare
2
Healthcare/Medicaid
1
Insurance
1
Insurance Insolvency
1
Insurance Regulation
1
Labor & Employment
2
Labor and Employment
2
Labor/Employment
1
Legislation
1
Personal Injury
3
Poverty Law
1
Pro Bono Family (VLS)
1
Product Liability
1
Professional Liability
1
Professional licensing/ethics/malpractice
1
Property/Real Estate
1
Reaal Estate
1
Real Estate
19
Real Estate, Insurance
1
Real estate
1
% of Respondents
16.34%
16.20%
1.93%
9.36%
14.12%
14.12%
3.86%
45.47%
3.42%
9.21%
10.40%
0.59%
0.15%
0.15%
0.30%
0.74%
0.15%
0.30%
0.15%
0.15%
0.30%
0.15%
0.15%
1.04%
0.15%
0.45%
0.30%
0.15%
0.59%
0.15%
0.15%
0.30%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.30%
0.30%
0.15%
0.30%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.30%
0.30%
0.15%
0.15%
0.45%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
2.82%
0.15%
0.15%
% of Answers
9.75%
9.66%
1.15%
5.59%
8.42%
8.42%
2.30%
27.13%
2.04%
5.50%
6.21%
0.35%
0.09%
0.09%
0.18%
0.44%
0.09%
0.18%
0.09%
0.09%
0.18%
0.09%
0.09%
0.62%
0.09%
0.27%
0.18%
0.09%
0.35%
0.09%
0.09%
0.18%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.18%
0.18%
0.09%
0.18%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.18%
0.18%
0.09%
0.09%
0.27%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
1.68%
0.09%
0.09%
Not answered
7: practice areas
Question Type
No. of Respondents
MULTIPLE
673
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
63
9.36%
Page 2 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Real estate litigation / condemnation
School
School Law
Securities
Special Education
Special Needs
TAX
Tax
Taxation
Texas Tax
The ADR and Family Law are currently pro bono only.
Trial
Trust litigation
Wills and Estate Planning
civil litigation
civil rights
consumer
consumer protection
debt collection
eminent domain
employment
employment law
environmental
gov't service, on bar leave
insurance
insurance receivership
labor
labor and employment
municipal
non-profits
nonprofit law
personal injury
privacy
real estate
school law
small business and microenterprise
tax
taxation
water
workers' compensation
8: Judge selection - federal
Question Type
MULTIPLE
No. of Respondents
673
1
1
2
1
1
1
1
7
2
1
1
1
1
2
1
2
3
1
1
1
3
1
1
1
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
1
1
1
1
1
1
1128
0.15%
0.15%
0.30%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
1.04%
0.30%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.30%
0.15%
0.30%
0.45%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.45%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.30%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.45%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.15%
0.09%
0.09%
0.18%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.62%
0.18%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.18%
0.09%
0.18%
0.27%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.27%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.18%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.27%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
0.09%
100.00%
Federal Courts
Number of Votes % of Respondents
% of Answers
Hon. Sam Sparks (Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District
196 of Texas)
29.12%
23.93%
Hon. Lee Yeakel (Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District
225of Texas)
33.43%
27.47%
Hon. Robert Pitman, (Judge, U.S. District Court of the Western District
144 of Texas) 21.40%
17.58%
Hon. David Ezra (Judge, U.S. District Court of the Western District36
of Texas)
5.35%
4.40%
Hon. Andrew Austin (Magistrate Judge, U.S. District Court for the 91
Western District13.52%
of Texas)
11.11%
Hon. Mark Lane (Magistrate Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western
88 District of Texas
13.08%
10.74%
Hon. Tony Davis (Judge, U.S. Bankruptcy Court)
22
3.27%
2.69%
Hon. Christopher Mott (Judge, U.S. Bankruptcy Court)
17
2.53%
2.08%
819
100.00%
9: Judge selection - state appellateState Appellate Courts
Number of Votes
Hon. Jeff Rose (Chief Justice, Third Court of Appeals)
Question Type
MULTIPLE
188
Hon. Cindy Olson Bourland (Justice, Third Court of Appeals)
No. of Respondents
673
111
Hon. Scott Field (Justice, Third Court of Appeals)
135
Hon. Melissa Goodwin (Justice, Third Court of Appeals)
143
Hon. Bob Pemberton (Justice, Third Court of Appeals)
188
Hon. David Puryear (Justice, Third Court of Appeals)
161
926
% of Respondents
27.93%
16.49%
20.06%
21.25%
27.93%
23.92%
% of Answers
20.30%
11.99%
14.58%
15.44%
20.30%
17.39%
100.00%
10: Judge selection - state civil
Question Type
MULTIPLE
No. of Respondents
673
% of Respondents
43.24%
28.83%
30.91%
47.55%
46.51%
% of Answers
11.41%
7.61%
8.16%
12.55%
12.27%
State District Courts - Civil
Number of Votes
Hon. Scott Jenkins (53rd Judicial District)
291
Hon. Rhonda Hurley (98th Judicial District)
194
Hon. Darlene Byrne (126th Judicial District Court)
208
Hon. Gisela Triana (200th Judicial District Court)
320
Hon. Amy Clark Meachum (201st Judicial District Court)
313
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
Page 3 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Hon.
Hon.
Hon.
Hon.
Karin Crump (250th Judicial District Court)
Lora Livingston (261st Judicial District Court)
Tim Sulak (353rd Judicial District Court)
Orlinda Naranjo (419th Judicial District Court)
266
317
331
310
2550
39.52%
47.10%
49.18%
46.06%
10.43%
12.43%
12.98%
12.16%
100.00%
11: Judge selection - state criminalState District Courts - Criminal
Number of Votes
Hon. Cliff Brown (147th Judicial District Court)
Question Type
MULTIPLE
68
Hon. David Wahlberg (167th Judicial District Court)
No. of Respondents
673
69
Hon. Karen Sage (299th Judicial District Court)
60
Hon. David Crain (331st Judicial District Court)
62
Hon. Julie Kocurek (390th Judicial District Court)
71
Hon. Brenda Kennedy (403rd Judicial District Court)
68
Hon. Leon Grizzard (Magistrate)
59
457
% of Respondents
10.10%
10.25%
8.92%
9.21%
10.55%
10.10%
8.77%
% of Answers
14.88%
15.10%
13.13%
13.57%
15.54%
14.88%
12.91%
100.00%
12: Judge selection - Associate Judges
Associate Judges
Number of Votes
Hon. Jim Arth
Question Type
MULTIPLE
112
Hon. J. Andrew Hathcock
No. of Respondents
673
123
Hon. Aurora Martinez-Jones
49
Hon. Leonard Saenz
102
Hon. Texanna Davis
26
Hon. John Hathaway
47
Hon. Ami Larson
26
Hon. Angelita Mendoza-Waterhouse (Title IV-D Child Support)
30
Hon. Dulce Madrigal (Title IV-D Child Support)
27
542
% of Respondents
16.64%
18.28%
7.28%
15.16%
3.86%
6.98%
3.86%
4.46%
4.01%
% of Answers
20.66%
22.69%
9.04%
18.82%
4.80%
8.67%
4.80%
5.54%
4.98%
100.00%
13: Judge selection - county courtsCounty
at lawCourts at Law
Number of Votes
Hon. Todd Wong (County Court at Law No. 1)
Question Type
MULTIPLE
193
Hon. Eric Shepperd (County Court at Law No. 2)
No. of Respondents
673
224
Hon. John Lipscombe (County Court at Law No. 3)
57
Hon. Mike Denton (County Court at Law No. 4)
63
Hon. Nancy Hohengarten (County Court at Law No. 5)
65
Hon. Brandy Mueller (County Court at Law No. 6)
58
Hon. Elisabeth Earle (County Court at Law No. 7)
84
Hon. Carlos H. Barrera (County Court at Law No. 8)
52
796
% of Respondents
28.68%
33.28%
8.47%
9.36%
9.66%
8.62%
12.48%
7.73%
% of Answers
24.25%
28.14%
7.16%
7.91%
8.17%
7.29%
10.55%
6.53%
100.00%
14: Judge selection - state JPs
Question Type
MULTIPLE
No. of Respondents
673
Justice of the Peace Courts
Number of Votes
Hon. Yvonne Williams (Justice of the Peace, Precinct 1)
55
Hon. Randall Slagle (Justice of the Peace, Precinct 2)
72
Hon. Susan Steeg (Justice of the Peace, Precinct 3)
68
Hon. Raul Gonzalez (Justice of the Peace, Precinct 4)
71
Hon. Herb Evans (Justice of the Peace, Precinct 5)
97
363
% of Respondents
8.17%
10.70%
10.10%
10.55%
14.41%
% of Answers
15.15%
19.83%
18.73%
19.56%
26.72%
100.00%
15: Judge selection - probate courts
Probate Courts
Number of Votes
Hon. Guy Herman (Probate Court No. 1)
Question Type
MULTIPLE
200
Hon. Dan Prashner (Associate Judge, Probate Court)
No. of Respondents
673
91
291
% of Respondents
29.72%
13.52%
% of Answers
68.73%
31.27%
100.00%
% of Respondents
77.55%
16.33%
3.57%
% of Answers
79.58%
16.75%
3.66%
97.45%
100.00%
% of Respondents
54.08%
29.59%
13.78%
% of Answers
55.50%
30.37%
14.14%
97.45%
100.00%
16: Hon. Sam Sparks (Judge, U.S. District
Please answer
Court each
for the
of the
Western
following
District
questions
of Texas)
about this judge.
16.1: Question 1
16.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
152
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
196
32
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Sam Sparks (Judge,
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
7
% of Ballots
29.12%
No opinion
5
191
16.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
106
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
196
58
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Sam Sparks (Judge,
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
27
% of Ballots
29.12%
No opinion
5
191
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
2.55%
2.55%
Page 4 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
16.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
119
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
196
54
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Sam Sparks (Judge,
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
17
% of Ballots
29.12%
No opinion
6
190
% of Respondents
60.71%
27.55%
8.67%
% of Answers
62.63%
28.42%
8.95%
96.94%
100.00%
16.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
51
26.02%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
196
73
37.24%
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Sam Sparks (Judge,
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
66
33.67%
% of Ballots
29.12%
No opinion
6
3.06%
190
96.94%
% of Answers
26.84%
38.42%
34.74%
16.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
114
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
196
52
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Sam Sparks (Judge,
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
26
% of Ballots
29.12%
No opinion
4
192
% of Respondents
58.16%
26.53%
13.27%
% of Answers
59.38%
27.08%
13.54%
97.96%
100.00%
% of Respondents
60.71%
27.55%
7.65%
% of Answers
63.30%
28.72%
7.98%
95.92%
100.00%
% of Respondents
80.44%
13.33%
3.11%
% of Answers
83.03%
13.76%
3.21%
96.89%
100.00%
17.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
192
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
225
24
Needs
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Lee Yeakel (Judge,
U.S.
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
3
% of Ballots
33.43%
No opinion
6
219
% of Respondents
85.33%
10.67%
1.33%
% of Answers
87.67%
10.96%
1.37%
97.33%
100.00%
17.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
181
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
225
34
Needs
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Lee Yeakel (Judge,
U.S.
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
3
% of Ballots
33.43%
No opinion
7
218
% of Respondents
80.44%
15.11%
1.33%
% of Answers
83.03%
15.60%
1.38%
96.89%
100.00%
17.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
197
87.56%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
225
18
8.00%
Needs
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Lee Yeakel (Judge,
U.S.
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
2
0.89%
% of Ballots
33.43%
No opinion
8
3.56%
217
96.44%
% of Answers
90.78%
8.29%
0.92%
17.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
188
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
225
24
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Lee Yeakel (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
5
% of Ballots
33.43%
No opinion
8
217
% of Respondents
83.56%
10.67%
2.22%
% of Answers
86.64%
11.06%
2.30%
96.44%
100.00%
% of Respondents
% of Answers
16.2: Question 2
16.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
119
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
196
54
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Sam Sparks (Judge,
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
15
% of Ballots
29.12%
No opinion
8
188
17: Hon. Lee Yeakel (Judge, U.S. District
Please answer
Court for
each
the
of Western
the following
District
questions
of Texas)
about this judge.
17.1: Question 1
17.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
181
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
225
30
Needs
Improvement
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Lee Yeakel (Judge,
U.S.
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
7
% of Ballots
33.43%
No opinion
7
218
17.2: Question 2
17.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
3.06%
2.04%
4.08%
3.11%
2.67%
3.11%
3.56%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 5 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
225
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Lee Yeakel (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
% of Ballots
33.43%
No opinion
154
41
19
68.44%
18.22%
8.44%
71.96%
19.16%
8.88%
214
95.11%
100.00%
18: Hon. Robert Pitman, (Judge, U.S. District
of each
the Western
District ofquestions
Texas) about this judge.
Please Court
answer
of the following
18.1: Question 1
18.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
127
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
144
10
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Robert Pitman,Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
2
% of Ballots
21.40%
No opinion
5
139
% of Respondents
88.19%
6.94%
1.39%
% of Answers
91.37%
7.19%
1.44%
96.53%
100.00%
18.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
122
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
144
14
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Robert Pitman,Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
1
% of Ballots
21.40%
No opinion
7
137
% of Respondents
84.72%
9.72%
0.69%
% of Answers
89.05%
10.22%
0.73%
95.14%
100.00%
18.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
119
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
144
16
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Robert Pitman,Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
1
% of Ballots
21.40%
No opinion
8
136
% of Respondents
82.64%
11.11%
0.69%
% of Answers
87.50%
11.76%
0.74%
94.44%
100.00%
18.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
130
90.28%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
144
7
4.86%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Robert Pitman,Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
2
1.39%
% of Ballots
21.40%
No opinion
5
3.47%
139
96.53%
% of Answers
93.53%
5.04%
1.44%
18.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
126
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
144
11
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Robert Pitman,Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
1
% of Ballots
21.40%
No opinion
6
138
% of Respondents
87.50%
7.64%
0.69%
% of Answers
91.30%
7.97%
0.72%
95.83%
100.00%
% of Respondents
76.39%
12.50%
2.78%
% of Answers
83.33%
13.64%
3.03%
91.67%
100.00%
% of Respondents
44.44%
36.11%
0.00%
% of Answers
55.17%
44.83%
0.00%
80.56%
100.00%
% of Respondents
44.44%
41.67%
0.00%
% of Answers
51.61%
48.39%
0.00%
86.11%
100.00%
% of Respondents
% of Answers
11
18.2: Question 2
18.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
110
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
144
18
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Robert Pitman,Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
4
% of Ballots
21.40%
No opinion
12
132
19: Hon. David Ezra (Judge, U.S. District
Courtanswer
of the Western
District
of Texas)
Please
each of the
following
questions about this judge.
19.1: Question 1
19.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
16
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
36
13
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. David Ezra (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
0
% of Ballots
5.35%
No opinion
7
29
19.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
16
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
36
15
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. David Ezra (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
0
% of Ballots
5.35%
No opinion
5
31
19.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
Number of Votes
4.89%
3.47%
4.86%
5.56%
4.17%
8.33%
19.44%
13.89%
100.00%
Page 6 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
36
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. David Ezra (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
% of Ballots
5.35%
No opinion
11
13
5
7
30.56%
36.11%
13.89%
19.44%
37.93%
44.83%
17.24%
29
80.56%
100.00%
19.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
14
38.89%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
36
14
38.89%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. David Ezra (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
3
8.33%
% of Ballots
5.35%
No opinion
5
13.89%
31
86.11%
% of Answers
45.16%
45.16%
9.68%
19.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
13
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
36
14
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. David Ezra (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
3
% of Ballots
5.35%
No opinion
6
30
% of Respondents
36.11%
38.89%
8.33%
% of Answers
43.33%
46.67%
10.00%
83.33%
100.00%
% of Respondents
44.44%
33.33%
5.56%
% of Answers
53.33%
40.00%
6.67%
83.33%
100.00%
20: Hon. Andrew Austin (Magistrate Judge,
District
Court
for following
the Western
Districtabout
of Texas)
PleaseU.S.
answer
each
of the
questions
this judge.
20.1: Question 1
20.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
77
84.62%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
9
9.89%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Andrew AustinNeeds
(Magistrate
Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
0
0.00%
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
5
5.49%
86
94.51%
% of Answers
89.53%
10.47%
0.00%
19.2: Question 2
19.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
16
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
36
12
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. David Ezra (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
District Court of the Western District of Texas)'
2
% of Ballots
5.35%
No opinion
6
30
16.67%
16.67%
100.00%
100.00%
20.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Number of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
75
82.42%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
11
12.09%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Andrew AustinNeeds
(Magistrate
Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
2
2.20%
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
3
3.30%
88
96.70%
% of Answers
85.23%
12.50%
2.27%
20.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Number of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
71
78.02%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
13
14.29%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Andrew AustinNeeds
(Magistrate
Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
2
2.20%
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
5
5.49%
86
94.51%
% of Answers
82.56%
15.12%
2.33%
20.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
78
85.71%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
7
7.69%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Andrew AustinNeeds
(Magistrate
Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
1
1.10%
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
5
5.49%
86
94.51%
% of Answers
90.70%
8.14%
1.16%
20.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
79
86.81%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
9
9.89%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Andrew AustinNeeds
(Magistrate
Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
0
0.00%
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
3
3.30%
88
96.70%
% of Answers
89.77%
10.23%
0.00%
20.2: Question 2
20.2.1: opinions
Question Type
SINGLE
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
71
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
% of Respondents
78.02%
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
% of Answers
87.65%
Page 7 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
9
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Andrew AustinNeeds
(Magistrate
Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas)'
1
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
10
81
9.89%
1.10%
11.11%
1.23%
89.01%
100.00%
% of Respondents
85.23%
13.64%
0.00%
% of Answers
86.21%
13.79%
0.00%
98.86%
100.00%
21.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
72
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
88
13
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Mark Lane (Magistrate
Needs Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas'1
% of Ballots
13.08%
No opinion
2
86
% of Respondents
81.82%
14.77%
1.14%
% of Answers
83.72%
15.12%
1.16%
97.73%
100.00%
21.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
66
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
88
16
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Mark Lane (Magistrate
Needs Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas'3
% of Ballots
13.08%
No opinion
3
85
% of Respondents
75.00%
18.18%
3.41%
% of Answers
77.65%
18.82%
3.53%
96.59%
100.00%
21.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
78
88.64%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
88
9
10.23%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Mark Lane (Magistrate
Needs Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas'0
0.00%
% of Ballots
13.08%
No opinion
1
1.14%
87
98.86%
% of Answers
89.66%
10.34%
0.00%
21.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
71
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
88
14
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Mark Lane (Magistrate
Needs Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas'1
% of Ballots
13.08%
No opinion
2
86
% of Respondents
80.68%
15.91%
1.14%
% of Answers
82.56%
16.28%
1.16%
97.73%
100.00%
% of Respondents
75.00%
14.77%
3.41%
% of Answers
80.49%
15.85%
3.66%
93.18%
100.00%
% of Respondents
81.82%
4.55%
4.55%
% of Answers
90.00%
5.00%
5.00%
90.91%
100.00%
Number of Votes
14
4
1
% of Respondents
63.64%
18.18%
4.55%
% of Answers
73.68%
21.05%
5.26%
19
86.36%
100.00%
Number of Votes
15
% of Respondents
68.18%
% of Answers
75.00%
21: Hon. Mark Lane (Senior Judge, U.S.Please
District
Court each
for the
District
of Texas)
answer
of Western
the following
questions
about this judge.
21.1: Question 1
21.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
75
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
88
12
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Mark Lane (Magistrate
Needs Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas'0
% of Ballots
13.08%
No opinion
1
87
21.2: Question 2
21.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
66
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
88
13
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Mark Lane (Magistrate
Needs Improvement
Judge, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas'3
% of Ballots
13.08%
No opinion
6
82
22: Hon. Tony Davis (Judge, U.S. Bankruptcy
Court) each of the following questions about this judge.
Please answer
22.1: Question 1
22.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
18
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
22
1
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Tony Davis (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Bankruptcy Court)'
1
% of Ballots
3.27%
No opinion
2
20
22.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
22
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Tony Davis (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Bankruptcy Court)'
% of Ballots
3.27%
No opinion
22.1.3: correct law
Question Type
SINGLE
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
3
10.99%
1.14%
2.27%
3.41%
2.27%
6.82%
9.09%
13.64%
100.00%
Page 8 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
22
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Tony Davis (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Bankruptcy Court)'
% of Ballots
3.27%
No opinion
4
1
18.18%
4.55%
20.00%
5.00%
20
90.91%
100.00%
22.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
15
68.18%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
22
5
22.73%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Tony Davis (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Bankruptcy Court)'
1
4.55%
% of Ballots
3.27%
No opinion
1
4.55%
21
95.45%
% of Answers
71.43%
23.81%
4.76%
22.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
14
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
22
6
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Tony Davis (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Bankruptcy Court)'
1
% of Ballots
3.27%
No opinion
1
21
% of Respondents
63.64%
27.27%
4.55%
% of Answers
66.67%
28.57%
4.76%
95.45%
100.00%
% of Respondents
50.00%
18.18%
4.55%
% of Answers
68.75%
25.00%
6.25%
72.73%
100.00%
% of Respondents
82.35%
0.00%
0.00%
% of Answers
100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
82.35%
100.00%
Number of Votes
13
1
0
% of Respondents
76.47%
5.88%
0.00%
% of Answers
92.86%
7.14%
0.00%
14
82.35%
100.00%
Number of Votes
12
2
0
% of Respondents
70.59%
11.76%
0.00%
% of Answers
85.71%
14.29%
0.00%
14
82.35%
100.00%
23.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
15
88.24%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
17
1
5.88%
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Christopher Mott
Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. Bankruptcy Court)'
0
0.00%
% of Ballots
2.53%
No opinion
1
5.88%
16
94.12%
% of Answers
93.75%
6.25%
0.00%
23.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
14
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
17
2
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Christopher Mott
Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. Bankruptcy Court)'
0
% of Ballots
2.53%
No opinion
1
16
% of Respondents
82.35%
11.76%
0.00%
% of Answers
87.50%
12.50%
0.00%
94.12%
100.00%
% of Respondents
70.59%
11.76%
% of Answers
85.71%
14.29%
2
22.2: Question 2
22.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
11
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
22
4
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Tony Davis (Judge,
NeedsU.S.
Improvement
Bankruptcy Court)'
1
% of Ballots
3.27%
No opinion
6
16
23: Hon. Christopher Mott (Judge, U.S. Please
Bankruptcy
Court)
answer
each of the following questions about this judge.
23.1: Question 1
23.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
14
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
17
0
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Christopher Mott
Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. Bankruptcy Court)'
0
% of Ballots
2.53%
No opinion
3
14
23.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
17
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Christopher Mott
Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. Bankruptcy Court)'
% of Ballots
2.53%
No opinion
23.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
17
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Christopher Mott
Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. Bankruptcy Court)'
% of Ballots
2.53%
No opinion
23.2: Question 2
23.2.1: opinions
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
17
3
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
12
Acceptable
2
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
3
9.09%
4.55%
27.27%
17.65%
17.65%
17.65%
5.88%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 9 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Condition: Q8 has 'Hon. Christopher Mott
Needs
(Judge,
Improvement
U.S. Bankruptcy Court)'
% of Ballots
2.53%
No opinion
3
17.65%
0.00%
0.00%
14
82.35%
100.00%
24: Hon. Jeff Rose (Chief Justice, ThirdPlease
Court answer
of Appeals)
each of the following questions about this judge.
24.1: Question 1
24.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
111
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
47
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Jeff Rose (Chief
Needs
Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
17
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
13
175
% of Respondents
59.04%
25.00%
9.04%
% of Answers
63.43%
26.86%
9.71%
93.09%
100.00%
Number of Votes
104
52
23
% of Respondents
55.32%
27.66%
12.23%
% of Answers
58.10%
29.05%
12.85%
179
95.21%
100.00%
Number of Votes
101
54
22
% of Respondents
53.72%
28.72%
11.70%
% of Answers
57.06%
30.51%
12.43%
177
94.15%
100.00%
24.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
135
71.81%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
34
18.09%
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Jeff Rose (Chief
Needs
Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
10
5.32%
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
9
4.79%
179
95.21%
% of Answers
75.42%
18.99%
5.59%
24.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
107
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
51
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Jeff Rose (Chief
Needs
Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
22
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
8
180
% of Respondents
56.91%
27.13%
11.70%
% of Answers
59.44%
28.33%
12.22%
95.74%
100.00%
% of Respondents
46.81%
25.00%
17.55%
% of Answers
52.38%
27.98%
19.64%
89.36%
100.00%
% of Respondents
45.95%
29.73%
11.71%
% of Answers
52.58%
34.02%
13.40%
87.39%
100.00%
Number of Votes
55
33
10
% of Respondents
49.55%
29.73%
9.01%
% of Answers
56.12%
33.67%
10.20%
98
88.29%
100.00%
Number of Votes
49
36
% of Respondents
44.14%
32.43%
% of Answers
51.04%
37.50%
24.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Jeff Rose (Chief
Needs
Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
24.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Jeff Rose (Chief
Needs
Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
0
9
11
24.2: Question 2
24.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
88
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
47
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Jeff Rose (Chief
Needs
Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
33
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
20
168
25: Hon. Cindy Olson Bourland (Justice,Please
Third answer
Court ofeach
Appeals)
of the following questions about this judge.
25.1: Question 1
25.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
51
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
111
33
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Cindy Olson Bourland
Needs Improvement
(Justice, Third Court of Appeals)'
13
% of Ballots
16.49%
No opinion
14
97
25.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
111
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Cindy Olson Bourland
Needs Improvement
(Justice, Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
16.49%
No opinion
25.1.3: correct law
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
111
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Acceptable
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
13
6.91%
4.79%
5.85%
4.26%
10.64%
12.61%
11.71%
100.00%
Page 10 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Cindy Olson Bourland
Needs Improvement
(Justice, Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
16.49%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
15
11
13.51%
9.91%
11.46%
96
86.49%
100.00%
25.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
65
58.56%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
111
31
27.93%
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Cindy Olson Bourland
Needs Improvement
(Justice, Third Court of Appeals)'
4
3.60%
% of Ballots
16.49%
No opinion
11
9.91%
100
90.09%
% of Answers
65.00%
31.00%
4.00%
25.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
53
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
111
33
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Cindy Olson Bourland
Needs Improvement
(Justice, Third Court of Appeals)'
13
% of Ballots
16.49%
No opinion
12
99
% of Respondents
47.75%
29.73%
11.71%
% of Answers
53.54%
33.33%
13.13%
89.19%
100.00%
% of Respondents
40.54%
27.03%
18.92%
% of Answers
46.88%
31.25%
21.88%
86.49%
100.00%
% of Respondents
67.41%
16.30%
5.19%
% of Answers
75.83%
18.33%
5.83%
88.89%
100.00%
Number of Votes
86
26
12
% of Respondents
63.70%
19.26%
8.89%
% of Answers
69.35%
20.97%
9.68%
124
91.85%
100.00%
Number of Votes
75
33
16
% of Respondents
55.56%
24.44%
11.85%
% of Answers
60.48%
26.61%
12.90%
124
91.85%
100.00%
26.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
101
74.81%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
135
22
16.30%
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Scott Field (Justice,
NeedsThird
Improvement
Court of Appeals)'
2
1.48%
% of Ballots
20.06%
No opinion
10
7.41%
125
92.59%
% of Answers
80.80%
17.60%
1.60%
26.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
84
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
135
34
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Scott Field (Justice,
NeedsThird
Improvement
Court of Appeals)'
8
% of Ballots
20.06%
No opinion
9
126
% of Respondents
62.22%
25.19%
5.93%
% of Answers
66.67%
26.98%
6.35%
93.33%
100.00%
% of Respondents
54.07%
22.96%
8.89%
% of Answers
62.93%
26.72%
10.34%
25.2: Question 2
25.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
45
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
111
30
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Cindy Olson Bourland
Needs Improvement
(Justice, Third Court of Appeals)'
21
% of Ballots
16.49%
No opinion
15
96
26: Hon. Scott Field (Justice, Third Court
of Appeals)
Please
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
26.1: Question 1
26.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
91
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
135
22
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Scott Field (Justice,
NeedsThird
Improvement
Court of Appeals)'
7
% of Ballots
20.06%
No opinion
15
120
26.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
135
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Scott Field (Justice,
NeedsThird
Improvement
Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
20.06%
No opinion
26.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
135
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Scott Field (Justice,
NeedsThird
Improvement
Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
20.06%
No opinion
11
11
26.2: Question 2
26.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
73
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
135
31
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Scott Field (Justice,
NeedsThird
Improvement
Court of Appeals)'
12
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
10.81%
13.51%
11.11%
8.15%
8.15%
6.67%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 11 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
19
14.07%
116
85.93%
100.00%
27: Hon. Melissa Goodwin (Justice, Third
Court
of Appeals)
Please
answer
each of the following questions about this judge.
27.1: Question 1
27.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
65
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
143
45
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Melissa Goodwin
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
21
% of Ballots
21.25%
No opinion
12
131
% of Respondents
45.45%
31.47%
14.69%
% of Answers
49.62%
34.35%
16.03%
91.61%
100.00%
Number of Votes
59
43
32
% of Respondents
41.26%
30.07%
22.38%
% of Answers
44.03%
32.09%
23.88%
134
93.71%
100.00%
Number of Votes
51
48
35
% of Respondents
35.66%
33.57%
24.48%
% of Answers
38.06%
35.82%
26.12%
134
93.71%
100.00%
27.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
72
50.35%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
143
45
31.47%
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Melissa Goodwin
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
17
11.89%
% of Ballots
21.25%
No opinion
9
6.29%
134
93.71%
% of Answers
53.73%
33.58%
12.69%
27.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
59
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
143
50
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Melissa Goodwin
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
27
% of Ballots
21.25%
No opinion
7
136
% of Respondents
41.26%
34.97%
18.88%
% of Answers
43.38%
36.76%
19.85%
95.10%
100.00%
% of Respondents
37.76%
29.37%
22.38%
% of Answers
42.19%
32.81%
25.00%
89.51%
100.00%
% of Respondents
72.34%
14.36%
6.91%
% of Answers
77.27%
15.34%
7.39%
93.62%
100.00%
Number of Votes
109
46
21
% of Respondents
57.98%
24.47%
11.17%
% of Answers
61.93%
26.14%
11.93%
176
93.62%
100.00%
Number of Votes
109
40
25
% of Respondents
57.98%
21.28%
13.30%
% of Answers
62.64%
22.99%
14.37%
% of Ballots
20.06%
No opinion
27.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
143
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Melissa Goodwin
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
21.25%
No opinion
27.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
143
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Melissa Goodwin
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
21.25%
No opinion
9
9
27.2: Question 2
27.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
54
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
143
42
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Melissa Goodwin
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
32
% of Ballots
21.25%
No opinion
15
128
28: Hon. Bob Pemberton (Chief Justice,Please
Third answer
Court ofeach
Appeals)
of the following questions about this judge.
28.1: Question 1
28.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
136
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
27
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Bob Pemberton
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
13
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
12
176
28.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Bob Pemberton
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
28.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Bob Pemberton
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
12
8.39%
6.29%
6.29%
4.90%
10.49%
6.38%
6.38%
100.00%
Page 12 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
14
7.45%
174
92.55%
100.00%
28.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
139
73.94%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
28
14.89%
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Bob Pemberton
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
12
6.38%
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
9
4.79%
179
95.21%
% of Answers
77.65%
15.64%
6.70%
28.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
117
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
44
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Bob Pemberton
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
18
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
9
179
% of Respondents
62.23%
23.40%
9.57%
% of Answers
65.36%
24.58%
10.06%
95.21%
100.00%
% of Respondents
54.26%
20.21%
15.43%
% of Answers
60.36%
22.49%
17.16%
89.89%
100.00%
% of Respondents
43.48%
26.09%
22.98%
% of Answers
46.98%
28.19%
24.83%
92.55%
100.00%
Number of Votes
72
37
38
% of Respondents
44.72%
22.98%
23.60%
% of Answers
48.98%
25.17%
25.85%
147
91.30%
100.00%
Number of Votes
65
45
39
% of Respondents
40.37%
27.95%
24.22%
% of Answers
43.62%
30.20%
26.17%
149
92.55%
100.00%
29.1.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
84
52.17%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
161
40
24.84%
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. David Puryear Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
24
14.91%
% of Ballots
23.92%
No opinion
13
8.07%
148
91.93%
% of Answers
56.76%
27.03%
16.22%
29.1.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
72
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
161
42
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. David Puryear Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
35
% of Ballots
23.92%
No opinion
12
149
% of Respondents
44.72%
26.09%
21.74%
% of Answers
48.32%
28.19%
23.49%
92.55%
100.00%
% of Respondents
40.99%
24.22%
23.60%
% of Answers
46.15%
27.27%
26.57%
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
28.2: Question 2
28.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
102
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
188
38
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. Bob Pemberton
Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
29
% of Ballots
27.93%
No opinion
19
169
29: Hon. David Puryear (Justice, Third Court
Appeals)
Pleaseofanswer
each of the following questions about this judge.
29.1: Question 1
29.1.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
70
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
161
42
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. David Puryear Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
37
% of Ballots
23.92%
No opinion
12
149
29.1.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
161
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. David Puryear Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
23.92%
No opinion
29.1.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
161
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. David Puryear Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
% of Ballots
23.92%
No opinion
14
12
29.2: Question 2
29.2.1: opinions
Does this judge issue timely opinions of good quality?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
66
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
161
39
Condition: Q9 has 'Hon. David Puryear Needs
(Justice,
Improvement
Third Court of Appeals)'
38
% of Ballots
23.92%
No opinion
18
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
4.79%
10.11%
7.45%
8.70%
7.45%
7.45%
11.18%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 13 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
143
88.82%
100.00%
% of Respondents
77.32%
16.15%
2.75%
% of Answers
80.36%
16.79%
2.86%
96.22%
100.00%
Number of Votes
191
76
16
% of Respondents
65.64%
26.12%
5.50%
% of Answers
67.49%
26.86%
5.65%
283
97.25%
100.00%
Number of Votes
188
81
15
% of Respondents
64.60%
27.84%
5.15%
% of Answers
66.20%
28.52%
5.28%
284
97.59%
100.00%
30.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
186
63.92%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
291
68
23.37%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Scott JenkinsNeeds
(53rd Judicial
Improvement
District)'
30
10.31%
% of Ballots
43.24%
No opinion
7
2.41%
284
97.59%
% of Answers
65.49%
23.94%
10.56%
30.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
187
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
291
75
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Scott JenkinsNeeds
(53rd Judicial
Improvement
District)'
20
% of Ballots
43.24%
No opinion
9
282
% of Respondents
64.26%
25.77%
6.87%
% of Answers
66.31%
26.60%
7.09%
96.91%
100.00%
% of Respondents
56.70%
29.38%
4.12%
% of Answers
62.86%
32.57%
4.57%
90.21%
100.00%
Number of Votes
108
54
17
% of Respondents
55.67%
27.84%
8.76%
% of Answers
60.34%
30.17%
9.50%
179
92.27%
100.00%
Number of Votes
99
60
21
% of Respondents
51.03%
30.93%
10.82%
% of Answers
55.00%
33.33%
11.67%
180
92.78%
100.00%
31.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
115
59.28%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
194
48
24.74%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Rhonda Hurley
Needs
(98thImprovement
Judicial District)'
18
9.28%
% of Ballots
28.83%
No opinion
13
6.70%
181
93.30%
% of Answers
63.54%
26.52%
9.94%
30: Hon. Scott Jenkins (53rd Judicial District)
Please answer each of the following questions about this judge.
30.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
225
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
291
47
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Scott JenkinsNeeds
(53rd Judicial
Improvement
District)'
8
% of Ballots
43.24%
No opinion
11
280
30.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
291
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Scott JenkinsNeeds
(53rd Judicial
Improvement
District)'
% of Ballots
43.24%
No opinion
30.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
291
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Scott JenkinsNeeds
(53rd Judicial
Improvement
District)'
% of Ballots
43.24%
No opinion
8
7
31: Hon. Rhonda Hurley (98th Judicial District
Court) each of the following questions about this judge.
Please answer
31.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
110
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
194
57
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Rhonda Hurley
Needs
(98thImprovement
Judicial District)'
8
% of Ballots
28.83%
No opinion
19
175
31.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
194
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Rhonda Hurley
Needs
(98thImprovement
Judicial District)'
% of Ballots
28.83%
No opinion
31.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
194
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Rhonda Hurley
Needs
(98thImprovement
Judicial District)'
% of Ballots
28.83%
No opinion
31.5: overall
14
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
15
3.78%
2.75%
2.41%
3.09%
9.79%
7.73%
7.22%
% of Respondents
100.00%
100.00%
% of Answers
Page 14 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
194
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Rhonda Hurley
Needs
(98thImprovement
Judicial District)'
% of Ballots
28.83%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
104
59
16
53.61%
30.41%
8.25%
58.10%
32.96%
8.94%
179
92.27%
100.00%
% of Respondents
73.08%
16.35%
2.88%
% of Answers
79.17%
17.71%
3.13%
92.31%
100.00%
Number of Votes
141
39
18
% of Respondents
67.79%
18.75%
8.65%
% of Answers
71.21%
19.70%
9.09%
198
95.19%
100.00%
Number of Votes
137
34
24
% of Respondents
65.87%
16.35%
11.54%
% of Answers
70.26%
17.44%
12.31%
195
93.75%
100.00%
32.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
152
73.08%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
208
34
16.35%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Darlene ByrneNeeds
(126th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
9
4.33%
% of Ballots
30.91%
No opinion
13
6.25%
195
93.75%
% of Answers
77.95%
17.44%
4.62%
32.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
140
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
208
45
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Darlene ByrneNeeds
(126th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
10
% of Ballots
30.91%
No opinion
13
195
% of Respondents
67.31%
21.63%
4.81%
% of Answers
71.79%
23.08%
5.13%
93.75%
100.00%
% of Respondents
35.00%
38.44%
20.00%
% of Answers
37.46%
41.14%
21.40%
93.44%
100.00%
Number of Votes
144
119
45
% of Respondents
45.00%
37.19%
14.06%
% of Answers
46.75%
38.64%
14.61%
308
96.25%
100.00%
Number of Votes
116
130
61
% of Respondents
36.25%
40.63%
19.06%
% of Answers
37.79%
42.35%
19.87%
307
95.94%
100.00%
33.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
152
47.50%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
320
98
30.63%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Gisela TrianaNeeds
(200thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
59
18.44%
% of Answers
49.19%
31.72%
19.09%
15
32: Hon. Darlene Byrne (126th Judicial Please
Districtanswer
Court) each of the following questions about this judge.
32.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
152
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
208
34
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Darlene ByrneNeeds
(126th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
6
% of Ballots
30.91%
No opinion
16
192
32.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
208
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Darlene ByrneNeeds
(126th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
30.91%
No opinion
32.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
208
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Darlene ByrneNeeds
(126th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
30.91%
No opinion
10
13
33: Hon. Gisela Triana (200th Judicial District
Please Court)
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
33.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
112
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
320
123
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Gisela TrianaNeeds
(200thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
64
% of Ballots
47.55%
No opinion
21
299
33.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
320
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Gisela TrianaNeeds
(200thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
47.55%
No opinion
33.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
320
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Gisela TrianaNeeds
(200thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
47.55%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
12
13
7.73%
7.69%
4.81%
6.25%
6.25%
6.56%
3.75%
4.06%
100.00%
Page 15 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
11
3.44%
309
96.56%
100.00%
33.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
125
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
320
121
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Gisela TrianaNeeds
(200thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
60
% of Ballots
47.55%
No opinion
14
306
% of Respondents
39.06%
37.81%
18.75%
% of Answers
40.85%
39.54%
19.61%
95.63%
100.00%
% of Respondents
56.55%
29.07%
7.03%
% of Answers
61.03%
31.38%
7.59%
92.65%
100.00%
Number of Votes
178
88
31
% of Respondents
56.87%
28.12%
9.90%
% of Answers
59.93%
29.63%
10.44%
297
94.89%
100.00%
Number of Votes
148
97
47
% of Respondents
47.28%
30.99%
15.02%
% of Answers
50.68%
33.22%
16.10%
292
93.29%
100.00%
34.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
165
52.72%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
313
91
29.07%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Amy Clark Meachum
Needs Improvement
(201st Judicial District Court)'
42
13.42%
% of Ballots
46.51%
No opinion
15
4.79%
298
95.21%
% of Answers
55.37%
30.54%
14.09%
34.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
161
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
313
94
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Amy Clark Meachum
Needs Improvement
(201st Judicial District Court)'
37
% of Ballots
46.51%
No opinion
21
292
% of Respondents
51.44%
30.03%
11.82%
% of Answers
55.14%
32.19%
12.67%
93.29%
100.00%
% of Respondents
67.29%
20.68%
2.63%
% of Answers
74.27%
22.82%
2.90%
90.60%
100.00%
Number of Votes
178
57
9
% of Respondents
66.92%
21.43%
3.38%
% of Answers
72.95%
23.36%
3.69%
244
91.73%
100.00%
Number of Votes
149
65
31
% of Respondents
56.02%
24.44%
11.65%
% of Answers
60.82%
26.53%
12.65%
245
92.11%
100.00%
% of Ballots
47.55%
No opinion
34: Hon. Amy Clark Meachum (201st Judicial
Please District
answerCourt)
each of the following questions about this judge.
34.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
177
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
313
91
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Amy Clark Meachum
Needs Improvement
(201st Judicial District Court)'
22
% of Ballots
46.51%
No opinion
23
290
34.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
313
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Amy Clark Meachum
Needs Improvement
(201st Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
46.51%
No opinion
34.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
313
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Amy Clark Meachum
Needs Improvement
(201st Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
46.51%
No opinion
16
21
35: Hon. Karin Crump (250th Judicial District
PleaseCourt)
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
35.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
179
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
266
55
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Karin Crump Needs
(250th Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
7
% of Ballots
39.52%
No opinion
25
241
35.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
266
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Karin Crump Needs
(250th Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
39.52%
No opinion
35.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
266
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Karin Crump Needs
(250th Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
39.52%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
22
21
4.38%
7.35%
5.11%
6.71%
6.71%
9.40%
8.27%
7.89%
100.00%
Page 16 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
35.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
185
69.55%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
266
54
20.30%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Karin Crump Needs
(250th Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
10
3.76%
% of Ballots
39.52%
No opinion
17
6.39%
249
93.61%
% of Answers
74.30%
21.69%
4.02%
35.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
165
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
266
65
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Karin Crump Needs
(250th Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
16
% of Ballots
39.52%
No opinion
20
246
% of Respondents
62.03%
24.44%
6.02%
% of Answers
67.07%
26.42%
6.50%
92.48%
100.00%
% of Respondents
65.93%
20.50%
5.99%
% of Answers
71.33%
22.18%
6.48%
92.43%
100.00%
Number of Votes
172
89
37
% of Respondents
54.26%
28.08%
11.67%
% of Answers
57.72%
29.87%
12.42%
298
94.01%
100.00%
Number of Votes
171
80
48
% of Respondents
53.94%
25.24%
15.14%
% of Answers
57.19%
26.76%
16.05%
299
94.32%
100.00%
36.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
163
51.42%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
317
87
27.44%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Lora Livingston
Needs
(261st
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
51
16.09%
% of Ballots
47.10%
No opinion
16
5.05%
301
94.95%
% of Answers
54.15%
28.90%
16.94%
36.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
178
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
317
80
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Lora Livingston
Needs
(261st
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
39
% of Ballots
47.10%
No opinion
20
297
% of Respondents
56.15%
25.24%
12.30%
% of Answers
59.93%
26.94%
13.13%
93.69%
100.00%
% of Respondents
81.57%
13.29%
1.21%
% of Answers
84.91%
13.84%
1.26%
96.07%
100.00%
Number of Votes
257
46
18
% of Respondents
77.64%
13.90%
5.44%
% of Answers
80.06%
14.33%
5.61%
321
96.98%
100.00%
Number of Votes
245
57
% of Respondents
74.02%
17.22%
% of Answers
75.85%
17.65%
36: Hon. Lora Livingston (261st JudicialPlease
Districtanswer
Court) each of the following questions about this judge.
36.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
209
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
317
65
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Lora Livingston
Needs
(261st
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
19
% of Ballots
47.10%
No opinion
24
293
36.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
317
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Lora Livingston
Needs
(261st
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
47.10%
No opinion
36.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
317
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Lora Livingston
Needs
(261st
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
47.10%
No opinion
19
18
37: Hon. Tim Sulak (353rd Judicial District
Court)
Please
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
37.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
270
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
331
44
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Tim Sulak (353rd
Needs
Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
4
% of Ballots
49.18%
No opinion
13
318
37.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
331
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Tim Sulak (353rd
Needs
Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
% of Ballots
49.18%
No opinion
37.3: correct law
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
331
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Acceptable
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
10
7.52%
7.57%
5.99%
5.68%
6.31%
3.93%
3.02%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 17 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Tim Sulak (353rd
Needs
Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
% of Ballots
49.18%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
21
8
2.42%
6.34%
6.50%
323
97.58%
100.00%
37.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
280
84.59%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
331
29
8.76%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Tim Sulak (353rd
Needs
Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
11
3.32%
% of Ballots
49.18%
No opinion
11
3.32%
320
96.68%
% of Answers
87.50%
9.06%
3.44%
37.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
260
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
331
48
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Tim Sulak (353rd
Needs
Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
12
% of Ballots
49.18%
No opinion
11
320
% of Respondents
78.55%
14.50%
3.63%
% of Answers
81.25%
15.00%
3.75%
96.68%
100.00%
% of Respondents
58.71%
29.03%
5.81%
% of Answers
62.76%
31.03%
6.21%
93.55%
100.00%
Number of Votes
175
96
25
% of Respondents
56.45%
30.97%
8.06%
% of Answers
59.12%
32.43%
8.45%
296
95.48%
100.00%
Number of Votes
136
113
45
% of Respondents
43.87%
36.45%
14.52%
% of Answers
46.26%
38.44%
15.31%
294
94.84%
100.00%
38.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
212
68.39%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
310
63
20.32%
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Orlinda Naranjo
Needs
(419th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
19
6.13%
% of Ballots
46.06%
No opinion
16
5.16%
294
94.84%
% of Answers
72.11%
21.43%
6.46%
38.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
168
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
310
103
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Orlinda Naranjo
Needs
(419th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
24
% of Ballots
46.06%
No opinion
15
295
% of Respondents
54.19%
33.23%
7.74%
% of Answers
56.95%
34.92%
8.14%
95.16%
100.00%
% of Respondents
76.47%
16.18%
2.94%
% of Answers
80.00%
16.92%
3.08%
95.59%
100.00%
Number of Votes
45
16
3
% of Respondents
66.18%
23.53%
4.41%
% of Answers
70.31%
25.00%
4.69%
64
94.12%
100.00%
38: Hon. Orlinda Naranjo (419th JudicialPlease
District
Court)each of the following questions about this judge.
answer
38.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
182
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
310
90
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Orlinda Naranjo
Needs
(419th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
18
% of Ballots
46.06%
No opinion
20
290
38.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
310
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Orlinda Naranjo
Needs
(419th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
46.06%
No opinion
38.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
310
Condition: Q10 has 'Hon. Orlinda Naranjo
Needs
(419th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
46.06%
No opinion
14
16
39: Hon. Cliff Brown (147th Judicial District
Court)
Please
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
39.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
52
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
11
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Cliff Brown (147th
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
2
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
3
65
39.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Cliff Brown (147th
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
4
3.32%
6.45%
4.52%
5.16%
4.84%
4.41%
5.88%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 18 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
39.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Cliff Brown (147th
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
Number of Votes
43
16
5
% of Respondents
63.24%
23.53%
7.35%
% of Answers
67.19%
25.00%
7.81%
64
94.12%
100.00%
39.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
49
72.06%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
11
16.18%
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Cliff Brown (147th
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
4
5.88%
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
4
5.88%
64
94.12%
% of Answers
76.56%
17.19%
6.25%
39.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
50
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
13
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Cliff Brown (147th
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
2
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
3
65
% of Respondents
73.53%
19.12%
2.94%
% of Answers
76.92%
20.00%
3.08%
95.59%
100.00%
% of Respondents
50.72%
27.54%
13.04%
% of Answers
55.56%
30.16%
14.29%
91.30%
100.00%
Number of Votes
29
12
22
% of Respondents
42.03%
17.39%
31.88%
% of Answers
46.03%
19.05%
34.92%
63
91.30%
100.00%
Number of Votes
32
11
19
% of Respondents
46.38%
15.94%
27.54%
% of Answers
51.61%
17.74%
30.65%
62
89.86%
100.00%
40.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
32
46.38%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
69
17
24.64%
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Wahlberg
Needs
(167th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
15
21.74%
% of Ballots
10.25%
No opinion
5
7.25%
64
92.75%
% of Answers
50.00%
26.56%
23.44%
40.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
32
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
69
14
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Wahlberg
Needs
(167th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
18
% of Ballots
10.25%
No opinion
5
64
% of Respondents
46.38%
20.29%
26.09%
% of Answers
50.00%
21.88%
28.13%
92.75%
100.00%
% of Respondents
53.33%
28.33%
10.00%
% of Answers
58.18%
30.91%
10.91%
91.67%
100.00%
% of Respondents
41.67%
% of Answers
45.45%
4
40: Hon. David Wahlberg (167th Judicial
District
Court)each of the following questions about this judge.
Please
answer
40.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
35
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
69
19
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Wahlberg
Needs
(167th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
9
% of Ballots
10.25%
No opinion
6
63
40.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
69
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Wahlberg
Needs
(167th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
10.25%
No opinion
40.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
69
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Wahlberg
Needs
(167th
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
10.25%
No opinion
6
7
41: Hon. Karen Sage (299th Judicial District
PleaseCourt)
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
41.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
32
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
60
17
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Karen Sage (299th
Needs Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
6
% of Ballots
8.92%
No opinion
5
55
41.2: impartial
Question Type
SINGLE
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
Number of Votes
25
5.88%
4.41%
8.70%
8.70%
10.14%
7.25%
8.33%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 19 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
60
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Karen Sage (299th
Needs Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
% of Ballots
8.92%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
23
7
38.33%
11.67%
41.82%
12.73%
55
91.67%
100.00%
Number of Votes
27
24
4
% of Respondents
45.00%
40.00%
6.67%
% of Answers
49.09%
43.64%
7.27%
55
91.67%
100.00%
41.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
28
46.67%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
60
18
30.00%
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Karen Sage (299th
Needs Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
8
13.33%
% of Ballots
8.92%
No opinion
6
10.00%
54
90.00%
% of Answers
51.85%
33.33%
14.81%
41.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
27
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
60
22
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Karen Sage (299th
Needs Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
5
% of Ballots
8.92%
No opinion
6
54
% of Respondents
45.00%
36.67%
8.33%
% of Answers
50.00%
40.74%
9.26%
90.00%
100.00%
% of Respondents
41.94%
29.03%
19.35%
% of Answers
46.43%
32.14%
21.43%
90.32%
100.00%
Number of Votes
28
16
11
% of Respondents
45.16%
25.81%
17.74%
% of Answers
50.91%
29.09%
20.00%
55
88.71%
100.00%
Number of Votes
27
19
9
% of Respondents
43.55%
30.65%
14.52%
% of Answers
49.09%
34.55%
16.36%
55
88.71%
100.00%
42.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
26
41.94%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
62
18
29.03%
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Crain (331st
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
12
19.35%
% of Ballots
9.21%
No opinion
6
9.68%
56
90.32%
% of Answers
46.43%
32.14%
21.43%
42.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
25
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
62
19
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Crain (331st
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
11
% of Ballots
9.21%
No opinion
7
55
% of Respondents
40.32%
30.65%
17.74%
% of Answers
45.45%
34.55%
20.00%
88.71%
100.00%
% of Respondents
56.34%
25.35%
14.08%
% of Answers
58.82%
26.47%
14.71%
41.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
60
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Karen Sage (299th
Needs Judicial
Improvement
District Court)'
% of Ballots
8.92%
No opinion
5
5
42: Hon. David Crain (331st Judicial District
Court)
Please
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
42.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
26
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
62
18
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Crain (331st
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
12
% of Ballots
9.21%
No opinion
6
56
42.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
62
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Crain (331st
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
% of Ballots
9.21%
No opinion
42.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
62
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. David Crain (331st
NeedsJudicial
Improvement
District Court)'
% of Ballots
9.21%
No opinion
7
7
43: Hon. Julie Kocurek (390th Judicial District
Please Court)
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
43.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
40
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
18
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Julie KocurekNeeds
(390thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
10
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
3
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
8.33%
8.33%
10.00%
9.68%
11.29%
11.29%
11.29%
4.23%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 20 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
68
95.77%
100.00%
Number of Votes
37
18
13
% of Respondents
52.11%
25.35%
18.31%
% of Answers
54.41%
26.47%
19.12%
68
95.77%
100.00%
Number of Votes
38
20
10
% of Respondents
53.52%
28.17%
14.08%
% of Answers
55.88%
29.41%
14.71%
68
95.77%
100.00%
43.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
40
56.34%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
16
22.54%
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Julie KocurekNeeds
(390thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
11
15.49%
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
4
5.63%
67
94.37%
% of Answers
59.70%
23.88%
16.42%
43.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
38
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
20
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Julie KocurekNeeds
(390thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
9
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
4
67
% of Respondents
53.52%
28.17%
12.68%
% of Answers
56.72%
29.85%
13.43%
94.37%
100.00%
% of Respondents
26.47%
32.35%
35.29%
% of Answers
28.13%
34.38%
37.50%
94.12%
100.00%
Number of Votes
20
15
30
% of Respondents
29.41%
22.06%
44.12%
% of Answers
30.77%
23.08%
46.15%
65
95.59%
100.00%
Number of Votes
22
19
22
% of Respondents
32.35%
27.94%
32.35%
% of Answers
34.92%
30.16%
34.92%
63
92.65%
100.00%
44.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
22
32.35%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
12
17.65%
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Brenda Kennedy
Needs
(403rd
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
30
44.12%
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
4
5.88%
64
94.12%
% of Answers
34.38%
18.75%
46.88%
44.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
20
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
18
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Brenda Kennedy
Needs
(403rd
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
25
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
5
63
% of Respondents
29.41%
26.47%
36.76%
% of Answers
31.75%
28.57%
39.68%
92.65%
100.00%
% of Respondents
% of Answers
43.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Julie KocurekNeeds
(390thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
43.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Julie KocurekNeeds
(390thImprovement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
3
3
44: Hon. Brenda Kennedy (403rd Judicial
District
Court)
Please
answer
each of the following questions about this judge.
44.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
18
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
22
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Brenda Kennedy
Needs
(403rd
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
24
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
4
64
44.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Brenda Kennedy
Needs
(403rd
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
44.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Brenda Kennedy
Needs
(403rd
Improvement
Judicial District Court)'
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
45: Hon. Leon Grizzard (Magistrate)
45.1: hard working
5
Please answer each of the following questions about this judge.
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
3
4.23%
4.23%
5.63%
5.88%
4.41%
7.35%
7.35%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 21 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
59
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Leon GrizzardNeeds
(Magistrate)'
Improvement
% of Ballots
8.77%
No opinion
41
9
5
69.49%
15.25%
8.47%
74.55%
16.36%
9.09%
55
93.22%
100.00%
Number of Votes
33
12
9
% of Respondents
55.93%
20.34%
15.25%
% of Answers
61.11%
22.22%
16.67%
54
91.53%
100.00%
Number of Votes
32
17
6
% of Respondents
54.24%
28.81%
10.17%
% of Answers
58.18%
30.91%
10.91%
55
93.22%
100.00%
45.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
37
62.71%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
59
12
20.34%
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Leon GrizzardNeeds
(Magistrate)'
Improvement
5
8.47%
% of Ballots
8.77%
No opinion
5
8.47%
54
91.53%
% of Answers
68.52%
22.22%
9.26%
45.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
31
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
59
18
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Leon GrizzardNeeds
(Magistrate)'
Improvement
6
% of Ballots
8.77%
No opinion
4
55
% of Respondents
52.54%
30.51%
10.17%
% of Answers
56.36%
32.73%
10.91%
93.22%
100.00%
Please answer each of the following questions about this judge.
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
74
Acceptable
25
Needs Improvement
6
% of Respondents
66.07%
22.32%
5.36%
% of Answers
70.48%
23.81%
5.71%
105
93.75%
100.00%
Number of Votes
49
33
26
% of Respondents
43.75%
29.46%
23.21%
% of Answers
45.37%
30.56%
24.07%
108
96.43%
100.00%
Number of Votes
59
33
16
% of Respondents
52.68%
29.46%
14.29%
% of Answers
54.63%
30.56%
14.81%
108
96.43%
100.00%
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
35
31.25%
Acceptable
32
28.57%
Needs Improvement
41
36.61%
% of Answers
32.41%
29.63%
37.96%
45.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
59
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Leon GrizzardNeeds
(Magistrate)'
Improvement
% of Ballots
8.77%
No opinion
45.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
59
Condition: Q11 has 'Hon. Leon GrizzardNeeds
(Magistrate)'
Improvement
% of Ballots
8.77%
No opinion
46: Hon. Jim Arth (Associate Judge)
46.1: hard working
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
112
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Jim Arth'
% of Ballots
16.64%
46.2: impartial
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
112
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Jim Arth'
% of Ballots
16.64%
46.3: correct law
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
112
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Jim Arth'
% of Ballots
16.64%
46.4: temperament
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
112
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Jim Arth'
% of Ballots
16.64%
46.5: overall
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
112
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Jim Arth'
% of Ballots
16.64%
No opinion
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Acceptable
Needs Improvement
No opinion
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Acceptable
Needs Improvement
No opinion
No opinion
5
4
7
4
4
6.78%
8.47%
6.78%
6.78%
6.25%
3.57%
3.57%
100.00%
4
3.57%
108
96.43%
100.00%
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
51
Acceptable
35
Needs Improvement
22
% of Respondents
45.54%
31.25%
19.64%
% of Answers
47.22%
32.41%
20.37%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
4
4
3.57%
Page 22 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
108
96.43%
100.00%
% of Respondents
65.85%
22.76%
4.88%
% of Answers
70.43%
24.35%
5.22%
93.50%
100.00%
Number of Votes
78
32
7
% of Respondents
63.41%
26.02%
5.69%
% of Answers
66.67%
27.35%
5.98%
117
95.12%
100.00%
Number of Votes
68
36
12
% of Respondents
55.28%
29.27%
9.76%
% of Answers
58.62%
31.03%
10.34%
116
94.31%
100.00%
47.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
76
61.79%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
123
24
19.51%
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. J. Andrew Hathcock'
Needs Improvement
16
13.01%
% of Ballots
18.28%
No opinion
7
5.69%
116
94.31%
% of Answers
65.52%
20.69%
13.79%
47.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
70
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
123
37
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. J. Andrew Hathcock'
Needs Improvement
9
% of Ballots
18.28%
No opinion
7
116
% of Respondents
56.91%
30.08%
7.32%
% of Answers
60.34%
31.90%
7.76%
94.31%
100.00%
% of Respondents
57.14%
12.24%
16.33%
% of Answers
66.67%
14.29%
19.05%
85.71%
100.00%
Number of Votes
28
11
5
% of Respondents
57.14%
22.45%
10.20%
% of Answers
63.64%
25.00%
11.36%
44
89.80%
100.00%
Number of Votes
23
14
6
% of Respondents
46.94%
28.57%
12.24%
% of Answers
53.49%
32.56%
13.95%
43
87.76%
100.00%
48.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
29
59.18%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
49
11
22.45%
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Aurora Martinez-Jones'
Needs Improvement
6
12.24%
% of Ballots
7.28%
No opinion
3
6.12%
46
93.88%
% of Answers
63.04%
23.91%
13.04%
47: Hon. J. Andrew Hathcock (Associate
Judge)
Please
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
47.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
81
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
123
28
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. J. Andrew Hathcock'
Needs Improvement
6
% of Ballots
18.28%
No opinion
8
115
47.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
123
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. J. Andrew Hathcock'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
18.28%
No opinion
47.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
123
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. J. Andrew Hathcock'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
18.28%
No opinion
6
7
48: Hon. Aurora Martinez-Jones
Please answer each of the following questions about this judge.
48.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
28
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
49
6
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Aurora Martinez-Jones'
Needs Improvement
8
% of Ballots
7.28%
No opinion
7
42
48.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
49
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Aurora Martinez-Jones'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
7.28%
No opinion
48.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
49
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Aurora Martinez-Jones'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
7.28%
No opinion
48.5: overall
6
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
5
6.50%
4.88%
5.69%
5.69%
14.29%
10.20%
12.24%
% of Respondents
100.00%
100.00%
% of Answers
Page 23 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
49
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Aurora Martinez-Jones'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
7.28%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
26
12
7
53.06%
24.49%
14.29%
57.78%
26.67%
15.56%
45
91.84%
100.00%
% of Respondents
54.90%
30.39%
8.82%
% of Answers
58.33%
32.29%
9.38%
94.12%
100.00%
Number of Votes
56
31
10
% of Respondents
54.90%
30.39%
9.80%
% of Answers
57.73%
31.96%
10.31%
97
95.10%
100.00%
Number of Votes
51
32
14
% of Respondents
50.00%
31.37%
13.73%
% of Answers
52.58%
32.99%
14.43%
97
95.10%
100.00%
49.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
55
53.92%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
102
31
30.39%
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Leonard Saenz'
Needs Improvement
13
12.75%
% of Ballots
15.16%
No opinion
3
2.94%
99
97.06%
% of Answers
55.56%
31.31%
13.13%
49.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
55
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
102
30
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Leonard Saenz'
Needs Improvement
13
% of Ballots
15.16%
No opinion
4
98
% of Respondents
53.92%
29.41%
12.75%
% of Answers
56.12%
30.61%
13.27%
96.08%
100.00%
% of Respondents
46.15%
30.77%
15.38%
% of Answers
50.00%
33.33%
16.67%
92.31%
100.00%
Number of Votes
11
8
5
% of Respondents
42.31%
30.77%
19.23%
% of Answers
45.83%
33.33%
20.83%
24
92.31%
100.00%
Number of Votes
11
8
5
% of Respondents
42.31%
30.77%
19.23%
% of Answers
45.83%
33.33%
20.83%
24
92.31%
100.00%
50.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
12
46.15%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
26
6
23.08%
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Texanna Davis'
Needs Improvement
6
23.08%
% of Answers
50.00%
25.00%
25.00%
4
49: Hon. Leonard Saenz (Associate Judge)
Please answer each of the following questions about this judge.
49.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
56
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
102
31
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Leonard Saenz'
Needs Improvement
9
% of Ballots
15.16%
No opinion
6
96
49.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
102
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Leonard Saenz'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
15.16%
No opinion
49.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
102
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Leonard Saenz'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
15.16%
No opinion
5
5
50: Hon. Texanna Davis (Associate Judge)
Please answer each of the following questions about this judge.
50.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
12
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
26
8
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Texanna Davis'
Needs Improvement
4
% of Ballots
3.86%
No opinion
2
24
50.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
26
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Texanna Davis'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
3.86%
No opinion
50.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
26
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Texanna Davis'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
3.86%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
2
2
8.16%
5.88%
4.90%
4.90%
3.92%
7.69%
7.69%
7.69%
100.00%
Page 24 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
2
7.69%
24
92.31%
100.00%
50.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
11
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
26
8
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Texanna Davis'
Needs Improvement
5
% of Ballots
3.86%
No opinion
2
24
% of Respondents
42.31%
30.77%
19.23%
% of Answers
45.83%
33.33%
20.83%
92.31%
100.00%
% of Respondents
44.68%
27.66%
10.64%
% of Answers
53.85%
33.33%
12.82%
82.98%
100.00%
Number of Votes
21
13
6
% of Respondents
44.68%
27.66%
12.77%
% of Answers
52.50%
32.50%
15.00%
40
85.11%
100.00%
Number of Votes
19
14
7
% of Respondents
40.43%
29.79%
14.89%
% of Answers
47.50%
35.00%
17.50%
40
85.11%
100.00%
51.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
17
36.17%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
47
13
27.66%
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. John Hathaway'
Needs Improvement
10
21.28%
% of Ballots
6.98%
No opinion
7
14.89%
40
85.11%
% of Answers
42.50%
32.50%
25.00%
51.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
20
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
47
13
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. John Hathaway'
Needs Improvement
7
% of Ballots
6.98%
No opinion
7
40
% of Respondents
42.55%
27.66%
14.89%
% of Answers
50.00%
32.50%
17.50%
85.11%
100.00%
% of Respondents
53.85%
11.54%
26.92%
% of Answers
58.33%
12.50%
29.17%
92.31%
100.00%
Number of Votes
11
5
7
% of Respondents
42.31%
19.23%
26.92%
% of Answers
47.83%
21.74%
30.43%
23
88.46%
100.00%
Number of Votes
11
3
8
% of Respondents
42.31%
11.54%
30.77%
% of Answers
50.00%
13.64%
36.36%
22
84.62%
100.00%
% of Ballots
3.86%
No opinion
51: Hon. John Hathaway (Associate Judge)
Please answer each of the following questions about this judge.
51.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
21
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
47
13
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. John Hathaway'
Needs Improvement
5
% of Ballots
6.98%
No opinion
8
39
51.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
47
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. John Hathaway'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
6.98%
No opinion
51.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
47
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. John Hathaway'
Needs Improvement
% of Ballots
6.98%
No opinion
7
7
52: Hon. Ami Larson (Associate Judge)Please answer each of the following questions about this judge.
52.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
14
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
26
3
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Ami Larson' Needs Improvement
7
% of Ballots
3.86%
No opinion
2
24
52.2: impartial
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
26
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Ami Larson'
% of Ballots
3.86%
52.3: correct law
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
26
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Ami Larson'
% of Ballots
3.86%
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Acceptable
Needs Improvement
No opinion
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Acceptable
Needs Improvement
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
3
4
7.69%
17.02%
14.89%
14.89%
14.89%
7.69%
11.54%
15.38%
100.00%
Page 25 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
52.4: temperament
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
26
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Ami Larson'
% of Ballots
3.86%
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
12
46.15%
Acceptable
4
15.38%
Needs Improvement
8
30.77%
2
7.69%
24
92.31%
100.00%
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
12
Acceptable
4
Needs Improvement
8
% of Respondents
46.15%
15.38%
30.77%
% of Answers
50.00%
16.67%
33.33%
24
92.31%
100.00%
% of Respondents
30.00%
43.33%
16.67%
% of Answers
33.33%
48.15%
18.52%
90.00%
100.00%
Number of Votes
7
12
10
% of Respondents
23.33%
40.00%
33.33%
% of Answers
24.14%
41.38%
34.48%
29
96.67%
100.00%
Number of Votes
6
14
10
% of Respondents
20.00%
46.67%
33.33%
% of Answers
20.00%
46.67%
33.33%
30
100.00%
100.00%
53.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
7
23.33%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
30
5
16.67%
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Angelita Mendoza-Waterhouse
Needs Improvement
(Title IV-D Child Support)'
18
60.00%
% of Ballots
4.46%
No opinion
0
0.00%
30
100.00%
% of Answers
23.33%
16.67%
60.00%
53.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
5
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
30
9
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Angelita Mendoza-Waterhouse
Needs Improvement
(Title IV-D Child Support)'
16
% of Ballots
4.46%
No opinion
0
30
% of Respondents
16.67%
30.00%
53.33%
% of Answers
16.67%
30.00%
53.33%
100.00%
100.00%
% of Respondents
55.56%
29.63%
7.41%
% of Answers
60.00%
32.00%
8.00%
92.59%
100.00%
Number of Votes
19
4
3
% of Respondents
70.37%
14.81%
11.11%
% of Answers
73.08%
15.38%
11.54%
26
96.30%
100.00%
Number of Votes
15
6
% of Respondents
55.56%
22.22%
% of Answers
60.00%
24.00%
52.5: overall
Question Type
SINGLE
No. of Respondents
26
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Ami Larson'
% of Ballots
3.86%
No opinion
% of Answers
50.00%
16.67%
33.33%
No opinion
2
53: Hon. Angelita Mendoza-Waterhouse
(Title answer
IV-D Child
Support)
Please
each
of the following questions about this judge.
53.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
9
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
30
13
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Angelita Mendoza-Waterhouse
Needs Improvement
(Title IV-D Child Support)'
5
% of Ballots
4.46%
No opinion
3
27
53.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
30
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Angelita Mendoza-Waterhouse
Needs Improvement
(Title IV-D Child Support)'
% of Ballots
4.46%
No opinion
53.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
30
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Angelita Mendoza-Waterhouse
Needs Improvement
(Title IV-D Child Support)'
% of Ballots
4.46%
No opinion
1
0
54: Hon. Dulce Madrigal (Title IV-D Child
Support)
Please
answer each of the following questions about this judge.
54.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
15
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
27
8
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Dulce Madrigal
Needs
(TitleImprovement
IV-D Child Support)'
2
% of Ballots
4.01%
No opinion
2
25
54.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
27
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Dulce Madrigal
Needs
(TitleImprovement
IV-D Child Support)'
% of Ballots
4.01%
No opinion
54.3: correct law
Question Type
No. of Respondents
SINGLE
27
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Acceptable
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
1
7.69%
10.00%
3.33%
0.00%
0.00%
7.41%
3.70%
100.00%
Page 26 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Dulce Madrigal
Needs
(TitleImprovement
IV-D Child Support)'
% of Ballots
4.01%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
4
14.81%
16.00%
25
92.59%
100.00%
54.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
18
66.67%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
27
6
22.22%
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Dulce Madrigal
Needs
(TitleImprovement
IV-D Child Support)'
2
7.41%
% of Ballots
4.01%
No opinion
1
3.70%
26
96.30%
% of Answers
69.23%
23.08%
7.69%
54.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
13
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
27
8
Condition: Q12 has 'Hon. Dulce Madrigal
Needs
(TitleImprovement
IV-D Child Support)'
3
% of Ballots
4.01%
No opinion
3
24
% of Respondents
48.15%
29.63%
11.11%
% of Answers
54.17%
33.33%
12.50%
88.89%
100.00%
% of Respondents
72.02%
13.99%
3.63%
% of Answers
80.35%
15.61%
4.05%
89.64%
100.00%
Number of Votes
136
28
16
% of Respondents
70.47%
14.51%
8.29%
% of Answers
75.56%
15.56%
8.89%
180
93.26%
100.00%
Number of Votes
130
31
17
% of Respondents
67.36%
16.06%
8.81%
% of Answers
73.03%
17.42%
9.55%
178
92.23%
100.00%
55.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
129
66.84%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
193
30
15.54%
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Todd Wong (County
Needs Improvement
Court at Law No. 1)'
23
11.92%
% of Ballots
28.68%
No opinion
11
5.70%
182
94.30%
% of Answers
70.88%
16.48%
12.64%
55.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
132
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
193
31
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Todd Wong (County
Needs Improvement
Court at Law No. 1)'
17
% of Ballots
28.68%
No opinion
13
180
% of Respondents
68.39%
16.06%
8.81%
% of Answers
73.33%
17.22%
9.44%
93.26%
100.00%
% of Respondents
74.55%
16.96%
2.68%
% of Answers
79.15%
18.01%
2.84%
94.20%
100.00%
Number of Votes
164
38
10
% of Respondents
73.21%
16.96%
4.46%
% of Answers
77.36%
17.92%
4.72%
212
94.64%
100.00%
2
55: Hon. Todd Wong (County Court at Law
No.answer
1)
Please
each of the following questions about this judge.
55.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
139
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
193
27
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Todd Wong (County
Needs Improvement
Court at Law No. 1)'
7
% of Ballots
28.68%
No opinion
20
173
55.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
193
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Todd Wong (County
Needs Improvement
Court at Law No. 1)'
% of Ballots
28.68%
No opinion
55.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
193
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Todd Wong (County
Needs Improvement
Court at Law No. 1)'
% of Ballots
28.68%
No opinion
13
15
56: Hon. Eric Shepperd (County Court at
Law No.
2) each of the following questions about this judge.
Please
answer
56.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
167
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
224
38
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Eric ShepperdNeeds
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 2)'
6
% of Ballots
33.28%
No opinion
13
211
56.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
224
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Eric ShepperdNeeds
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 2)'
% of Ballots
33.28%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
12
7.41%
11.11%
10.36%
6.74%
7.77%
6.74%
5.80%
5.36%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 27 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
56.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
224
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Eric ShepperdNeeds
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 2)'
% of Ballots
33.28%
No opinion
Number of Votes
143
52
14
% of Respondents
63.84%
23.21%
6.25%
% of Answers
68.42%
24.88%
6.70%
209
93.30%
100.00%
56.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
177
79.02%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
224
34
15.18%
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Eric ShepperdNeeds
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 2)'
4
1.79%
% of Ballots
33.28%
No opinion
9
4.02%
215
95.98%
% of Answers
82.33%
15.81%
1.86%
56.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
163
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
224
41
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Eric ShepperdNeeds
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 2)'
9
% of Ballots
33.28%
No opinion
11
213
% of Respondents
72.77%
18.30%
4.02%
% of Answers
76.53%
19.25%
4.23%
95.09%
100.00%
% of Respondents
31.58%
22.81%
42.11%
% of Answers
32.73%
23.64%
43.64%
96.49%
100.00%
Number of Votes
18
13
23
% of Respondents
31.58%
22.81%
40.35%
% of Answers
33.33%
24.07%
42.59%
54
94.74%
100.00%
Number of Votes
16
11
24
% of Respondents
28.07%
19.30%
42.11%
% of Answers
31.37%
21.57%
47.06%
51
89.47%
100.00%
57.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
15
26.32%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
57
14
24.56%
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. John Lipscombe
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 3)'
25
43.86%
% of Ballots
8.47%
No opinion
3
5.26%
54
94.74%
% of Answers
27.78%
25.93%
46.30%
57.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
15
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
57
12
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. John Lipscombe
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 3)'
27
% of Ballots
8.47%
No opinion
3
54
% of Respondents
26.32%
21.05%
47.37%
% of Answers
27.78%
22.22%
50.00%
94.74%
100.00%
% of Respondents
63.49%
14.29%
19.05%
% of Answers
65.57%
14.75%
19.67%
96.83%
100.00%
% of Respondents
41.27%
% of Answers
42.62%
15
57: Hon. John Lipscombe (County Court
at Law
No. 3)each of the following questions about this judge.
Please
answer
57.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
18
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
57
13
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. John Lipscombe
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 3)'
24
% of Ballots
8.47%
No opinion
2
55
57.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
57
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. John Lipscombe
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 3)'
% of Ballots
8.47%
No opinion
57.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
57
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. John Lipscombe
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 3)'
% of Ballots
8.47%
No opinion
3
6
58: Hon. Mike Denton (County Court at Please
Law No.
4)
answer
each of the following questions about this judge.
58.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
40
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
63
9
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Mike Denton Needs
(CountyImprovement
Court at Law No. 4)'
12
% of Ballots
9.36%
No opinion
2
61
58.2: impartial
Question Type
SINGLE
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
Number of Votes
26
6.70%
4.91%
3.51%
5.26%
10.53%
5.26%
3.17%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 28 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
63
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Mike Denton Needs
(CountyImprovement
Court at Law No. 4)'
% of Ballots
9.36%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
11
24
17.46%
38.10%
18.03%
39.34%
61
96.83%
100.00%
Number of Votes
30
13
18
% of Respondents
47.62%
20.63%
28.57%
% of Answers
49.18%
21.31%
29.51%
61
96.83%
100.00%
58.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
36
57.14%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
63
10
15.87%
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Mike Denton Needs
(CountyImprovement
Court at Law No. 4)'
15
23.81%
% of Ballots
9.36%
No opinion
2
3.17%
61
96.83%
% of Answers
59.02%
16.39%
24.59%
58.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
32
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
63
12
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Mike Denton Needs
(CountyImprovement
Court at Law No. 4)'
17
% of Ballots
9.36%
No opinion
2
61
% of Respondents
50.79%
19.05%
26.98%
% of Answers
52.46%
19.67%
27.87%
96.83%
100.00%
% of Respondents
67.69%
18.46%
6.15%
% of Answers
73.33%
20.00%
6.67%
92.31%
100.00%
Number of Votes
36
15
8
% of Respondents
55.38%
23.08%
12.31%
% of Answers
61.02%
25.42%
13.56%
59
90.77%
100.00%
Number of Votes
34
17
7
% of Respondents
52.31%
26.15%
10.77%
% of Answers
58.62%
29.31%
12.07%
58
89.23%
100.00%
59.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
35
53.85%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
65
17
26.15%
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Nancy Hohengarten
Needs Improvement
(County Court at Law No. 5)'
7
10.77%
% of Ballots
9.66%
No opinion
6
9.23%
59
90.77%
% of Answers
59.32%
28.81%
11.86%
59.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
38
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
65
12
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Nancy Hohengarten
Needs Improvement
(County Court at Law No. 5)'
8
% of Ballots
9.66%
No opinion
7
58
% of Respondents
58.46%
18.46%
12.31%
% of Answers
65.52%
20.69%
13.79%
89.23%
100.00%
% of Respondents
56.90%
32.76%
5.17%
% of Answers
60.00%
34.55%
5.45%
58.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
63
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Mike Denton Needs
(CountyImprovement
Court at Law No. 4)'
% of Ballots
9.36%
No opinion
2
2
59: Hon. Nancy Hohengarten (County Court
Law No.
5) of the following questions about this judge.
Pleaseatanswer
each
59.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
44
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
65
12
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Nancy Hohengarten
Needs Improvement
(County Court at Law No. 5)'
4
% of Ballots
9.66%
No opinion
5
60
59.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
65
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Nancy Hohengarten
Needs Improvement
(County Court at Law No. 5)'
% of Ballots
9.66%
No opinion
59.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
65
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Nancy Hohengarten
Needs Improvement
(County Court at Law No. 5)'
% of Ballots
9.66%
No opinion
6
7
60: Hon. Brandy Mueller (County Court Please
at Lawanswer
No. 6) each of the following questions about this judge.
60.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
33
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
58
19
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Brandy Mueller
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 6)'
3
% of Ballots
8.62%
No opinion
3
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
3.17%
3.17%
3.17%
7.69%
9.23%
10.77%
10.77%
5.17%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 29 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
55
94.83%
100.00%
Number of Votes
30
19
6
% of Respondents
51.72%
32.76%
10.34%
% of Answers
54.55%
34.55%
10.91%
55
94.83%
100.00%
Number of Votes
26
18
11
% of Respondents
44.83%
31.03%
18.97%
% of Answers
47.27%
32.73%
20.00%
55
94.83%
100.00%
60.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
34
58.62%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
58
16
27.59%
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Brandy Mueller
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 6)'
6
10.34%
% of Ballots
8.62%
No opinion
2
3.45%
56
96.55%
% of Answers
60.71%
28.57%
10.71%
60.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
29
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
58
19
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Brandy Mueller
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 6)'
7
% of Ballots
8.62%
No opinion
3
55
% of Respondents
50.00%
32.76%
12.07%
% of Answers
52.73%
34.55%
12.73%
94.83%
100.00%
% of Respondents
47.62%
13.10%
28.57%
% of Answers
53.33%
14.67%
32.00%
89.29%
100.00%
Number of Votes
47
19
8
% of Respondents
55.95%
22.62%
9.52%
% of Answers
63.51%
25.68%
10.81%
74
88.10%
100.00%
Number of Votes
39
21
11
% of Respondents
46.43%
25.00%
13.10%
% of Answers
54.93%
29.58%
15.49%
71
84.52%
100.00%
61.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
56
66.67%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
84
13
15.48%
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Elisabeth Earle
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 7)'
8
9.52%
% of Ballots
12.48%
No opinion
7
8.33%
77
91.67%
% of Answers
72.73%
16.88%
10.39%
61.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
47
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
84
17
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Elisabeth Earle
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 7)'
11
% of Ballots
12.48%
No opinion
9
75
% of Respondents
55.95%
20.24%
13.10%
% of Answers
62.67%
22.67%
14.67%
89.29%
100.00%
% of Respondents
% of Answers
60.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
58
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Brandy Mueller
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 6)'
% of Ballots
8.62%
No opinion
60.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
58
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Brandy Mueller
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 6)'
% of Ballots
8.62%
No opinion
3
3
61: Hon. Elisabeth Earle (County Court Please
at Lawanswer
No. 7) each of the following questions about this judge.
61.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
40
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
84
11
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Elisabeth Earle
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 7)'
24
% of Ballots
12.48%
No opinion
9
75
61.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
84
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Elisabeth Earle
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 7)'
% of Ballots
12.48%
No opinion
61.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
84
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Elisabeth Earle
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 7)'
% of Ballots
12.48%
No opinion
10
13
62: Hon. Carlos Barrera (County Court at
Law answer
No. 8) each of the following questions about this judge.
Please
62.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
5.17%
5.17%
5.17%
10.71%
11.90%
15.48%
10.71%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 30 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
52
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Carlos H. Barrera
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 8)'
% of Ballots
7.73%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
33
14
3
63.46%
26.92%
5.77%
66.00%
28.00%
6.00%
50
96.15%
100.00%
Number of Votes
21
16
12
% of Respondents
40.38%
30.77%
23.08%
% of Answers
42.86%
32.65%
24.49%
49
94.23%
100.00%
Number of Votes
23
12
13
% of Respondents
44.23%
23.08%
25.00%
% of Answers
47.92%
25.00%
27.08%
48
92.31%
100.00%
62.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
23
44.23%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
52
22
42.31%
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Carlos H. Barrera
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 8)'
5
9.62%
% of Ballots
7.73%
No opinion
2
3.85%
50
96.15%
% of Answers
46.00%
44.00%
10.00%
62.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
26
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
52
14
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Carlos H. Barrera
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 8)'
9
% of Ballots
7.73%
No opinion
3
49
% of Respondents
50.00%
26.92%
17.31%
% of Answers
53.06%
28.57%
18.37%
94.23%
100.00%
% of Respondents
40.00%
23.64%
25.45%
% of Answers
44.90%
26.53%
28.57%
89.09%
100.00%
Number of Votes
23
13
14
% of Respondents
41.82%
23.64%
25.45%
% of Answers
46.00%
26.00%
28.00%
50
90.91%
100.00%
Number of Votes
23
7
21
% of Respondents
41.82%
12.73%
38.18%
% of Answers
45.10%
13.73%
41.18%
51
92.73%
100.00%
63.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
25
45.45%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
55
15
27.27%
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Yvonne Williams
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 1)'
11
20.00%
% of Ballots
8.17%
No opinion
4
7.27%
51
92.73%
% of Answers
49.02%
29.41%
21.57%
63.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
22
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
55
12
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Yvonne Williams
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 1)'
16
% of Ballots
8.17%
No opinion
5
% of Answers
44.00%
24.00%
32.00%
62.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
52
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Carlos H. Barrera
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 8)'
% of Ballots
7.73%
No opinion
62.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
52
Condition: Q13 has 'Hon. Carlos H. Barrera
Needs
(County
Improvement
Court at Law No. 8)'
% of Ballots
7.73%
No opinion
2
3
4
63: Hon. Yvonne Williams (Justice of the
Peace,
Precinct
Please
answer
eachNo.
of 1)
the following questions about this judge.
63.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
22
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
55
13
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Yvonne Williams
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 1)'
14
% of Ballots
8.17%
No opinion
6
49
63.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
55
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Yvonne Williams
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 1)'
% of Ballots
8.17%
No opinion
63.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
55
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Yvonne Williams
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 1)'
% of Ballots
8.17%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
5
4
3.85%
5.77%
7.69%
5.77%
10.91%
9.09%
7.27%
% of Respondents
40.00%
21.82%
29.09%
9.09%
100.00%
100.00%
Page 31 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
50
90.91%
100.00%
% of Respondents
51.39%
30.56%
9.72%
% of Answers
56.06%
33.33%
10.61%
91.67%
100.00%
Number of Votes
38
19
11
% of Respondents
52.78%
26.39%
15.28%
% of Answers
55.88%
27.94%
16.18%
68
94.44%
100.00%
Number of Votes
35
20
12
% of Respondents
48.61%
27.78%
16.67%
% of Answers
52.24%
29.85%
17.91%
67
93.06%
100.00%
64.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
44
61.11%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
72
22
30.56%
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Randall Slagle
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 2)'
2
2.78%
% of Ballots
10.70%
No opinion
4
5.56%
68
94.44%
% of Answers
64.71%
32.35%
2.94%
64.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
40
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
72
24
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Randall Slagle
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 2)'
4
% of Ballots
10.70%
No opinion
4
68
% of Respondents
55.56%
33.33%
5.56%
% of Answers
58.82%
35.29%
5.88%
94.44%
100.00%
% of Respondents
50.00%
29.41%
14.71%
% of Answers
53.13%
31.25%
15.63%
94.12%
100.00%
Number of Votes
32
14
17
% of Respondents
47.06%
20.59%
25.00%
% of Answers
50.79%
22.22%
26.98%
63
92.65%
100.00%
Number of Votes
25
19
19
% of Respondents
36.76%
27.94%
27.94%
% of Answers
39.68%
30.16%
30.16%
63
92.65%
100.00%
65.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
31
45.59%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
14
20.59%
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Susan Steeg Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 3)'
19
27.94%
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
4
5.88%
64
94.12%
% of Answers
48.44%
21.88%
29.69%
64: Hon. Randall Slagle (Justice of the Peace,
Precincteach
2) of the following questions about this judge.
Please answer
64.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
37
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
72
22
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Randall Slagle
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 2)'
7
% of Ballots
10.70%
No opinion
6
66
64.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
72
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Randall Slagle
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 2)'
% of Ballots
10.70%
No opinion
64.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
72
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Randall Slagle
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 2)'
% of Ballots
10.70%
No opinion
4
5
65: Hon. Susan Steeg (Justice of the Peace,
PleasePrecinct
answer No.
each3)of the following questions about this judge.
65.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
34
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
20
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Susan Steeg Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 3)'
10
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
4
64
65.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Susan Steeg Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 3)'
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
65.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Susan Steeg Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 3)'
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
65.5: overall
5
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
5
8.33%
5.56%
6.94%
5.56%
5.88%
7.35%
7.35%
% of Respondents
100.00%
100.00%
% of Answers
Page 32 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
68
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Susan Steeg Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 3)'
% of Ballots
10.10%
No opinion
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
31
16
16
45.59%
23.53%
23.53%
49.21%
25.40%
25.40%
63
92.65%
100.00%
% of Respondents
56.34%
21.13%
15.49%
% of Answers
60.61%
22.73%
16.67%
92.96%
100.00%
Number of Votes
40
14
12
% of Respondents
56.34%
19.72%
16.90%
% of Answers
60.61%
21.21%
18.18%
66
92.96%
100.00%
Number of Votes
35
15
15
% of Respondents
49.30%
21.13%
21.13%
% of Answers
53.85%
23.08%
23.08%
65
91.55%
100.00%
66.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
42
59.15%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
16
22.54%
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Raul Gonzalez
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 4)'
9
12.68%
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
4
5.63%
67
94.37%
% of Answers
62.69%
23.88%
13.43%
66.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
42
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
10
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Raul Gonzalez
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 4)'
13
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
6
65
% of Respondents
59.15%
14.08%
18.31%
% of Answers
64.62%
15.38%
20.00%
91.55%
100.00%
% of Respondents
53.61%
31.96%
8.25%
% of Answers
57.14%
34.07%
8.79%
93.81%
100.00%
Number of Votes
52
24
15
% of Respondents
53.61%
24.74%
15.46%
% of Answers
57.14%
26.37%
16.48%
91
93.81%
100.00%
Number of Votes
48
28
14
% of Respondents
49.48%
28.87%
14.43%
% of Answers
53.33%
31.11%
15.56%
90
92.78%
100.00%
67.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
43
44.33%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
97
29
29.90%
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Herb Evans (Justice
Needs Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 5)'
19
19.59%
% of Answers
47.25%
31.87%
20.88%
5
66: Hon. Raul Gonzalez (Justice of the Please
Peace,answer
Precincteach
No. of
4) the following questions about this judge.
66.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
40
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
15
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Raul Gonzalez
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 4)'
11
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
5
66
66.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Raul Gonzalez
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 4)'
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
66.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
71
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Raul Gonzalez
Needs
(Justice
Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 4)'
% of Ballots
10.55%
No opinion
5
6
67: Hon. Herb Evans (Justice of the Peace,
Precinct
5) of the following questions about this judge.
Please
answerNo.
each
67.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
52
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
97
31
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Herb Evans (Justice
Needs Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 5)'
8
% of Ballots
14.41%
No opinion
6
91
67.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
97
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Herb Evans (Justice
Needs Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 5)'
% of Ballots
14.41%
No opinion
67.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
97
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Herb Evans (Justice
Needs Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 5)'
% of Ballots
14.41%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
6
7
7.35%
7.04%
7.04%
8.45%
8.45%
6.19%
6.19%
7.22%
100.00%
Page 33 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
6
6.19%
91
93.81%
100.00%
67.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
44
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
97
30
Condition: Q14 has 'Hon. Herb Evans (Justice
Needs Improvement
of the Peace, Precinct 5)'
16
% of Ballots
14.41%
No opinion
7
90
% of Respondents
45.36%
30.93%
16.49%
% of Answers
48.89%
33.33%
17.78%
92.78%
100.00%
% of Respondents
69.50%
19.00%
7.00%
% of Answers
72.77%
19.90%
7.33%
95.50%
100.00%
Number of Votes
125
45
23
% of Respondents
62.50%
22.50%
11.50%
% of Answers
64.77%
23.32%
11.92%
193
96.50%
100.00%
Number of Votes
121
50
19
% of Respondents
60.50%
25.00%
9.50%
% of Answers
63.68%
26.32%
10.00%
190
95.00%
100.00%
68.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
130
65.00%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
200
30
15.00%
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Guy Herman Needs
(Probate
Improvement
Court No. 1)'
31
15.50%
% of Ballots
29.72%
No opinion
9
4.50%
191
95.50%
% of Answers
68.06%
15.71%
16.23%
68.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
133
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
200
36
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Guy Herman Needs
(Probate
Improvement
Court No. 1)'
23
% of Ballots
29.72%
No opinion
8
192
% of Respondents
66.50%
18.00%
11.50%
% of Answers
69.27%
18.75%
11.98%
96.00%
100.00%
% of Respondents
69.23%
18.68%
5.49%
% of Answers
74.12%
20.00%
5.88%
93.41%
100.00%
Number of Votes
63
15
8
% of Respondents
69.23%
16.48%
8.79%
% of Answers
73.26%
17.44%
9.30%
86
94.51%
100.00%
Number of Votes
61
16
8
% of Respondents
67.03%
17.58%
8.79%
% of Answers
71.76%
18.82%
9.41%
85
93.41%
100.00%
% of Ballots
14.41%
No opinion
68: Hon. Guy Herman (Probate Court No.
1) answer each of the following questions about this judge.
Please
68.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
139
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
200
38
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Guy Herman Needs
(Probate
Improvement
Court No. 1)'
14
% of Ballots
29.72%
No opinion
9
191
68.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
200
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Guy Herman Needs
(Probate
Improvement
Court No. 1)'
% of Ballots
29.72%
No opinion
68.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
200
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Guy Herman Needs
(Probate
Improvement
Court No. 1)'
% of Ballots
29.72%
No opinion
7
10
69: Hon. Dan Prashner (Probate Court Please
No. 1) answer each of the following questions about this judge.
69.1: hard working
Is this judge hard working?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
63
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
17
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Dan PrashnerNeeds
(Associate
Improvement
Judge, Probate Court)'
5
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
6
85
69.2: impartial
Is this judge impartial?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Dan PrashnerNeeds
(Associate
Improvement
Judge, Probate Court)'
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
69.3: correct law
Does this judge correctly apply the law?
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Dan PrashnerNeeds
(Associate
Improvement
Judge, Probate Court)'
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
5
6
7.22%
4.50%
3.50%
5.00%
4.00%
6.59%
5.49%
6.59%
100.00%
Page 34 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com
2017 Judicial Evaluation Poll
Austin Bar Association
Online Voting: 02/01/17 03:00pm CST to 02/22/17 05:00pm CST
69.4: temperament
Does this judge display a proper judicial temperament
Number
and demeanor?
of Votes % of Respondents
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
63
69.23%
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
16
17.58%
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Dan PrashnerNeeds
(Associate
Improvement
Judge, Probate Court)'
6
6.59%
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
6
6.59%
85
93.41%
% of Answers
74.12%
18.82%
7.06%
69.5: overall
How would you describe this judge's overall performance?
Number of Votes
Excellent
Question Type
SINGLE
62
Acceptable
No. of Respondents
91
17
Condition: Q15 has 'Hon. Dan PrashnerNeeds
(Associate
Improvement
Judge, Probate Court)'
6
% of Ballots
13.52%
No opinion
6
85
% of Respondents
68.13%
18.68%
6.59%
% of Answers
72.94%
20.00%
7.06%
93.41%
100.00%
Legend
Question Type
No. of Respondents
Condition: ...
% of Ballots
Number of Votes
Number of Votes - Total
% of Respondents
% of Respondents - Total
% of Answers
Write-in response
Not Answered
Type of question (BOOLEAN, RANK, SINGLE, MULTIPLE, PREFERENCE, MEMO or TEXT)
Number of voters eligible to answer this question (based on conditional ballot page logic)
Condition required for question to be included in the poll (only for questions on conditional ballot pages)
% of voters eligible to answer this question (only for questions on conditional ballot pages)
Number of ballots that selected a particular answer
Number of selected answers - excluding 'not answered'
% of voters who were eligible to answer this question and who selected a particular answer
% of respondents who selected an asnwer (excludes 'not answered')
% of votes for a particular answer (always totals to 100%)
A write-in response to a SINGLE or MULTIPLE question
The 'not answered' option for an optional question (actual text specified by the poll designer)
Report Generated 02/22/17 05:03pm CST
Format � BallotBoxOnline LLC
6.59%
100.00%
Page 35 of 35
www.BallotBoxOnline.com