Crossing the Road to E`cient ID8As for Permutation Problems Peter

!
"#%$&(')+*,-.0/2134 "
5-6"798 !/
:!;=<>;=?3@BA CDAE"FHG>IKJML
NPOQ?SRUTWVOX;=?Y;ZLG
[]\ ^_\ `a b!cSdfehgYikjlfda mnmoa iop
qWrs`utvaxwzyZrX\ `u\ iMdYjlfda mnmoa iop
{}|=~€x x‚vxƒ…„†%{}|v†‡„ˆx‰WŠ x „>|hŠ|Z‹Œ„>‰Ž=‚vx |=,‘’ ƒ’|=‘’ƒ’~’“Z”•_ˆxƒ’‘—–Y”˜|= ™Sƒuˆx~_ }š
›zœ !œZž„fŸ >¡,œ ¡> >¢,“M£S¤¡> ¥žD”•_ˆxƒ’‘—–Yf“=¥–=ƒ]¦˜ƒux–=ƒuˆx§ Š|Z‹v~
ª¨ ©4«v¬n­M®¯H¬
°_±³²u´Mµ‡¶·o¸,·H¹º>»¼˜¹½µ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ ¹½²u´M¹½ÂvÃ0ÄÆÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹ È
¼˜¾vºuÉʵ ±¼]´Mµ‡Á’´)Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹ºÌÅQºu¾vÇÎÍv¹±M¹ ²uµ‡Áϸ,Ð È
Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶DÑ}ÒÔÓ!¶’Õ3µ‡¶Pµ ±oÁ ¾vºu·H¾vº’¸Y²u¹>¿Öµ ±µ ²u¹º’¸Y²u¹>¿
¿n¹±o¶—µ ²xר¹>¶x²uµ Çh¸Y²uµ ¾v±¹Ëv¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¸,ºu×6¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶
ÑQ°xÙÄkÓ!¶’ÕfÚÜÛ(¹UÅQ¾nÁ Ào¶D¾v±6·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±6¾v·n²uµ È
Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±³·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶W¸,±o¿³¶—´M¾Y¼Ø´M¾Y¼·MÀMºu¹3Á ¾v±nÈ
²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶˜°xÙÄkÓ!¶Á¸,±½ÞH¹¸,·M·MÐ µ ¹>¿½Ào¶—µ ±MͲu´M¹4º’¸,±nÈ
¿n¾vÇÊÉv¹×n¶˜ºu¹·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚà…´M¹Ô·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶•²u´o¸Y²
¸,ºu¹"´M¹ºu¹ÞZ×9¹±oÁ ¾vÀM±=²u¹ºu¹>¿%»ßǍ¾,²uµ ËY¸Y²u¹"²u´M¹Ào¶—¹¾,Å
ÂvÃ0Ä%ÚÓ!¶!¸hºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²>»o·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±9Ð µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹Wµ ±nÅQ¾vº—È
Çh¸Y²uµ ¾v±Æµ‡¶h¹ áz¹>Áf²uµ Ëv¹Ð ×U·Mºu¾nÁ ¹>¶u¶—¹>¿%»…ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±Mͳµ ±
¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²h¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ì¾,Å4¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±Ì·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶"¾,Å4¸ãÞH¾vÀM±o¿n¹>¿Ì¾vº’¿n¹º>ÚKäån·H¹ºuµ È
Ǎ¹±=²’¶!¶—´M¾Y¼Ö²u´o¸Y²Â=Ã0ÄD¾vÀn²u·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇh¶…·MÀMºu¹Á ¾v±nÈ
²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶Ô°xÙÄkÓ!¶ÚãæMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»ß¼˜¹h¶—´M¾Y¼Ï²u´o¸Y²
ÂvÃ0ÄÍvµ Ëv¹>¶µ ±o¶—µ Ív´=²µ ±=²u¾(´M¾Y¼Ê±M¹¼Ê°xÙÄkÓ!¶9Á¸,±
ÞH¹P¿n¹>¶—µ Ív±M¹>¿ã²u´o¸Y²"¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²uÐ ×(¼˜¾vºuÉ(¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×(µ ±
²u´M¹·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´P¶—·o¸vÁ ¹vÚ
ç è=é ¬n­Mê]ë!ì!¯H¬Míxê é
æµ ±o¿nµ ±MÍ̸,±o¿UÀo¶—µ ±MÍD²u´M¹ã¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹9¾,ÅÔ²u´M¹9îM²u±M¹>¶u¶½Ð‡¸,±o¿ZÈ
¶uÁ¸,·H¹hÁ¸,±D¸,µ‡¿(¹Ëv¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¸,ºu×9¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶hÑXä•Ó!¶’Õ!µ ±D¾v·n²uµ È
Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚWï!±M¹"¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´²u¾P¿n¾vµ ±MÍP¶—¾o»zµ‡¶!ÞZ×Ð ¹>¸,ºu±Mµ ±MÍ3¸
·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ‡¶x²uµ‡ÁWǍ¾n¿n¹ÐkÅQºu¾vÇð²u´M¹¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿B¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶4¸,±o¿9ÞZ×
Ào¶—µ ±MÍãµ ²"µ ±U¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ µ ±MÍB±M¹¼ñ¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú(òZÀoÁ’´Ì¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶
´o¸SËv¹WÞH¹¹±ã¶—ÀoÁÁ ¹>¶u¶xÅQÀMÐ Ð ×9¸,·M·MÐ µ ¹>¿²u¾3ËY¸,ºuµ ¾vÀo¶·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶µ ±
²u´M¹]Á¸v¶—¹˜¾,ÅH¿nµ‡¶uÁ ºu¹ ²u¹ÔÑQÞMµ ±o¸,ºu×MÕßËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶…ó ôn»nõöM»nõS÷Z»Zõ>øn»nõYùú
¸,±o¿PÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶ÑQºu¹>¸,ÐsՕËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶ó öM»zù=»ßõ>ûSú€Ú
°_±U²u´Mµ‡¶½·o¸,·H¹º>»˜¼˜¹ÅQ¾nÁ Ào¶h¾v±U²u´M¹ãÁ Ї¸v¶u¶¾,ÅÔ·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±
¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Ú•à…´Mµ‡¶Á Ї¸v¶u¶…¾,Å·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶…µ‡¶]Ëv¹ºu×
µ ±=²u¹ºu¹>¶x²uµ ±MÍoÚ"ï!±B²u´M¹·Mº’¸vÁf²uµ‡Á¸,ж—µ‡¿n¹v»%µ Ǎ·H¾vº—²’¸,±=²Ôºu¹>¸,ÐÐ µ ÅQ¹
·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶"¶—ÀoÁ’´U¸v¶"¶uÁ’´M¹>¿nÀMÐ µ ±MÍ(¸,±o¿³²u´M¹3²uº’¸SËv¹Ð µ ±MÍã¶u¸,Ð ¹>¶xÈ
Çh¸,±3¸,ºu¹!¼]µ ²u´Mµ ±½²u´Mµ‡¶…Á Ї¸v¶u¶Ú0ï!±h²u´M¹!²u´M¹¾vºu¹ ²uµ‡Á¸,Ðz¶—µ‡¿n¹v»=²u´M¹
¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´ª¶—·o¸vÁ ¹9Ívºu¾Y¼¶ü gvl ^_cY`frXgYpsp ýƸv¶²u´M¹ã¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²3¾,Å¿n¹ È
Á µ‡¶—µ ¾v±ÌËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶Wµ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶Ú³æMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»²u´M¹9¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±
¶—·o¸vÁ ¹•Á ¾v±o¶—µ‡¶x²’¶k¾,ÅM·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶»S¼]´Mµ‡Á’´Wµ‡¶ßÅQÀM±o¿M¸,Ǎ¹±=²’¸,Ð Ð ×
¿nµ áz¹ºu¹±=²3ÅQºu¾vÇþ²u´o¸Y²¾,ÅÔ²u´M¹(ÞMµ ±o¸,ºu×U¾vº3ºu¹>¸,Ð4¶—·o¸vÁ ¹9²u´o¸Y²
Ǎ¾=¶x²Wä•Ó!¶´o¸SËv¹"ÞH¹¹±³¿n¹>¶—µ Ív±M¹>¿BÅQ¾vº>Úhä•Ó!¶4²u´o¸Y²¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×
¼˜¾vºuÉ3¾v±9·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶¸,ºu¹Ào¶—Ào¸,Ð Ð ×P¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ·M·H¹>¿9¼]µ ²u´B¶—·H¹ È
Á µ‡¸,Ð µ ݹ>¿ÌÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º¾v·H¹º’¸Y²u¾vº’¶²u´o¸Y²h¹±o¶—ÀMºu¹½ÅQ¹>¸v¶—µ ÞMµ Ð µ ²x׳¾,Å
²u´M¹W¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú0Ó±¹ åMÁ ¹·n²uµ ¾v±Pµ‡¶…²u´M¹ ÔÒÔÓ ÞZ× ˜¹>¸,±Dó õ ú
µ ±³¼]´Mµ‡Á’´(²u´M¹3¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¶¸,ºu¹hÁ ¾n¿n¹>¿Dµ ±(²u´M¹½ºu¹>¸,Ð0¶—·o¸vÁ ¹hµ ±
¶—ÀoÁ’´³¸¼…¸Sײu´o¸Y²"¸,РЕÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º4¾v·H¹º’¸Y²u¾vº’¶4Ív¹±M¹º’¸Y²u¹"ÅQ¹>¸YÈ
¶—µ ÞMÐ ¹W¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú0à…´M¹ ÔÒÔÓ ´o¸v¶]¾vÞn²’¸,µ ±M¹>¿3Ív¾Z¾n¿Pºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶
¹>¶—·H¹>Á µ‡¸,Ð Ð ×½µ ±P²u´M¹Ôîo¹Ð‡¿P¾,ŶuÁ’´M¹>¿nÀMÐ µ ±MÍoÚ
ÛÆµ ²u´Ì²u´M¹¹ åMÁ ¹·n²uµ ¾v±Ì¾,Ųu´M¹ãï!Ǎ¹SÒÔÓñÞZ× Ô±o¸,Ý x¹¼ñ¸,±o¿
Ò4¾vЇ¿nÞH¹ºuÍKó õ >ú€»±M¾B¸Y²—²u¹Ç·n²’¶W´o¸SËv¹hÞH¹¹±³Çh¸v¿n¹²u¾BÐ ¹>¸,ºu±
¸,±o¿6Ào¶—¹ª²u´M¹Ö¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹ª¾,ÅP·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ø¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±
·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Ú+à…´M¹Uï!Ǎ¹SÒÔÓ µ‡¶9¹>¶u¶—¹±=²uµ‡¸,Ð Ð ×.¸³ü gSdf^Peh\fd’dfý
ó YúzÑsÅQǽÒÔÓ4Õ%²u´o¸Y²k´o¸v¶ßÞH¹¹±W¸v¿M¸,·n²u¹>¿4²u¾¼˜¾vºuÉ!¼]µ ²u´²u´M¹
¶u¸,Ǎ¹"Á ¾n¿nµ ±MÍP¸v¶!Ào¶—¹>¿Bµ ±B²u´M¹ ÔÒÔÓWÚzà…´M¹½ï!Ǎ¹SÒÔÓ6´o¸v¶
ÞH¹¹±(¶—´M¾Y¼]±9²u¾P¹ áz¹>Áf²uµ Ëv¹Ð ×B¶—¾vÐ Ëv¹¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹"·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶!¾,Å
ÞH¾vÀM±o¿n¹>¿Ì¿nµ â½Á ÀMÐ ²xׯó õvõfú€ÚDæMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»µ ²h¶—µ Ív±Mµ îHÁ¸,±=²uÐ ×
¾vÀn²u·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇh¶²u´M¹ ÔÒÔÓW»µ ±o¿nµ‡Á¸Y²uµ ±MÍã²u´M¹Ào¶—¹ ÅQÀMÐ ±M¹>¶u¶¾,Å
îo±o¿nµ ±Mͽ¸,±o¿3Ào¶—µ ±M͍·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çð¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹vÚ
à…´M¹]°xÙÄßÓ ÞZ× ˜¾=¶—Çh¸,±"¸,±o¿à…´Mµ ¹ºu¹±o¶]ó öYúoµ‡¶0¸!ÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉ
ÅQ¾vº…ä•Ó!¶•µ ±3¼]´Mµ‡Á’´3·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ‡¶x²uµ‡Á]Ǎ¾n¿n¹Ð‡¶…¸,ºu¹Ào¶—¹>¿%Ú°€²…´o¸v¶
Ǎ¾=¶x²uÐ ×(ÞH¹¹±KÀo¶—¹>¿D²u¾9ÅQ¾nÁ Ào¶¾v±ÌÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶ºu¹·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²’¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±o¶P¸,±o¿Æ¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ö·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Ú òZµ ±oÁ ¹B²u´M¹ ÔÒÔÓ
µ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ ¹>¶W¸ºu¹>¸,ЕÁ ¾n¿nµ ±MÍB¾,Ņ·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶»Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶
°xÙÄkÓ!¶˜Á¸,±ÔÞH¹˜¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×Ô¸,·M·MÐ µ ¹>¿%Ú ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»¶—µ ±oÁ ¹²u´M¹0·H¹º—È
ÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±"¶—·o¸vÁ ¹˜µ‡¶¿nµ‡¶uÁ ºu¹ ²u¹v»,¶—ÀoÁ’´"¸,±"¸,·M·MÐ µ‡Á¸Y²uµ ¾v±µ‡¶Ð µ Év¹Ð ×
²u¾9¹±oÁ ¾vÀM±=²u¹º·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Úh°_±D²u´Mµ‡¶·o¸,·H¹º>»k¼˜¹µ ±ZËv¹>¶x²uµ Í=¸Y²u¹
²u´M¹4·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇh¸,±oÁ ¹¾,ÅÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶0°xÙÄkÓ!¶4¾v±½·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±
·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Ô¸v¶¸½îoº’¶x²W¸Y²—²u¹Ç·n²²u¾9¿n¹>¶—µ Ív±ã¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²W·Mºu¾vÞo¸YÈ
ÞMµ Ð µ‡¶x²uµ‡ÁǍ¾n¿n¹ÐoÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍä•Ó!¶ÅQ¾vº•·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±h·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Ú
æMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»•¼˜¹¹ ån·MЇ¸,µ ±Ì²u´M¹9·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶¼]µ ²u´Æ¶—ÀoÁ’´ª¸,±
¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´¸,±o¿W·Mºu¾v·H¾=¶—¹…¸4¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±ÅQ¾vº²u´M¹ÇÏÞZ×Wµ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁfÈ
µ ±MÍ3Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º>Ú…à…´M¹ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±MÍ3¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇ𶗴M¾Y¼¶¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²
¶uÁ¸,Ð µ ±MÍ3ÞH¹´o¸SËZµ ¾vº4¾v±(·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶!¾,ŘÞH¾vÀM±o¿n¹>¿(Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ ånµ ²x×vÚ
à…´M¹Ôºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶…µ ±o¿nµ‡Á¸Y²u¹4²u´o¸Y²]°xÙÄkÓ!¶WÁ¸,±PÞH¹¿n¹>¶—µ Ív±M¹>¿½²u´o¸Y²
¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²uÐ ×3¼˜¾vºuɽ¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×½µ ±P²u´M¹W¶—·o¸vÁ ¹Ô¾,Å·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú
à…´M¹Pºu¹Çh¸,µ ±o¿n¹º¾,Ųu´Mµ‡¶·o¸,·H¹ºµ‡¶"¾vºuÍ=¸,±Mµ ݹ>¿³¸v¶ÅQ¾vÐ Ð ¾Y¼¶Ú
°_±U¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v± 9¼˜¹P¿nµ‡¶uÁ Ào¶u¶W²u´M¹P°xÙÄßÓ ÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉzÚ ¹ åZ²>»
¼˜¹3Ív¾ã¾YËv¹ºW²u´M¹9Á ¾n¿nµ ±MÍB²u´o¸Y²µ‡¶"Ào¶—¹>¿Kµ ±K²u´M¹ ÔÒÔÓñµ ±
¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±(ûP¸,±o¿B·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²4²u´M¹·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ã·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶!²u´o¸Y²
¼˜¹²u¹>¶x²²u´M¹h¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶!¾v±ßڍòZÀMÞo¶—¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±=²uÐ ×v»ß¼˜¹"²u¹>¶x²Ô²u´M¹
Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶4°xÙÄßÓ4¶µ ±D¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±ãöoÚW°_±D¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±D÷n»%¼˜¹"·Mºu¾,È
·H¾=¶—¹"²u¾Ào¶—¹hÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º!µ ±ã²u´M¹h°xÙÄßÓ ²u¾¾YËv¹º’Á ¾vǍ¹"¶—¾vǍ¹
¾,Ųu´M¹·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶¾,Ųu´M¹"Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶]°xÙÄkÓñ¾v±B·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±3·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶ÚÛ(¹!²u¹>¶x²˜²u´M¹4ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±MÍ"ä•Ó!¶•µ ±P¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±3øMÚ
°_±³¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±Kù3¼˜¹ºu¹ ¹>Áf²W¾v±ã²u´M¹½Á ¾vǍ·MÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¸,кu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹ È
Ǎ¹±=²’¶P¾,ÅWÐ ¹>¸,ºu±Mµ ±MÍU¸,±o¿ÆÀo¶—µ ±MÍÌ·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ‡¶x²uµ‡ÁBǍ¾n¿n¹Ð‡¶Pµ ±
¹Ëv¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¸,ºu×"¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚÛ(¹¿nµ‡¶uÁ Ào¶u¶•ÅQÀn²uÀMºu¹4ºu¹>¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´
µ ±9¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v± ¸,±o¿P·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²]¾vÀMº]Á ¾v±oÁ Ð Ào¶—µ ¾v±o¶…µ ±9¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±ôMÚ
¨ ’­M® ê0­ è à…´M¹P°xÙÄkÓ ÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉ(µ‡¶¸ãÍv¹±M¹º’¸,И¿n¹ îo±Mµ ²uµ ¾v±U¾,Å f^_\ ` gY^_\ q"\ iMdfrs^}ý •df^}rsehgY^}rXcYi YcYp mn^}rXcYizgY`fý p =cY`frs^QyZed˜²u´o¸Y²
´o¸v¶DǍ¾=¶x²uÐ ×ÏÞH¹¹±Ào¶—¹>¿Ï²u¾.ÅQ¾nÁ Ào¶D¾v±Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶Dºu¹·nÈ
ºu¹>¶—¹±=²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶ã¸,±o¿ ¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ï·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶!
Ú ß¹ #² "%$
'Ñ &()õ (+*+*+*,(.-0/ÖõSÕfÚà…´M¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð ¹"ÞH¹´Mµ ±o¿ã²u´M¹"ÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉ
Á¸,±ÞH¹0¹ ån·MЇ¸,µ ±M¹>¿ÔÞZ×Ô¸v¶u¶—ÀMǍµ ±Mͅ²u¾´o¸SËv¹0¸,1± -32n¿nµ Ǎ¹±o¶—µ ¾v±o¸,Ð
¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹5Ç 47Ñ 689"1:—;Õ $<4Ñ—7Ñ 6>=(?6A@B(+*+*+*,(?6>CED0@ ՗ÕfÚ
ÛÆµ ²u´M¾vÀn²½Ð ¾=¶u¶"¾,Å4Ív¹±M¹º’¸,Ð µ ²x×v»0¼˜¹9¸v¶u¶—ÀMǍ¹3²u´o¸Y²h¼˜¹¼…¸,±=²
²u¾ e"rsiorse"r F>G\ 47Ñ 689"1:—ÕfÚ ÛÆµ ²u´¹Ëv¹ºu× ·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç5ËY¸,ºuµ È
¸,ÞMÐ #¹ 6)Hx»¼˜¹³¸v¶u¶—¾nÁ µ‡¸Y²u¹³¸ªÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹
IJH—Ú ÛÆµ ²u´M¾vÀn²¸,±Z×Ì·Mºuµ ¾vº½µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ª¾v<
± 47Ñ 689"1:—Õf»]¼˜¹
Ǎµ Ív´=²Ö¸v¶ª¼˜¹Ð Ð9¸v¶u¶—ÀMǍ¹ ¸ØÀM±Mµ ÅQ¾vºuÇοnµ‡¶x²uºuµ ÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±ð¾YËv¹º
KL$ 'Ñ IM=)(.I@N(+*+*+*,(.IMCED0@ÕfÚ à…´M¹ºu¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹v»Ô¼˜¹³Ív¹±M¹º’¸Y²u¹³¸,±
µ ±Mµ ²uµ‡¸,ÐhÑQ·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v±HÕ3Ëv¹>Áf²u¾vºP¾,PÅ O6¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶¸Y²º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇÚ
¾Y¼6¼˜¹hÐ ¹ P
² Q1Rv'Ñ K½Õ4ÞH¹½¸·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×ã¿nµ‡¶x²uºuµ ÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±(²u´o¸Y²
µ‡¶hÀM±Mµ ÅQ¾vºuÇþ¾YËv¹º½¸,Ð ÐËv¹>Áf²u¾vº’S¶ 689"T:¼]µ ²u<´ 47Ñ 689"1:—VÕ UXWMÚ
òn¸,Ǎ·MÐ µ ±MÍBÅQºu¾vY
Ç Q1Rv'Ñ K½ÕWÍvµ Ëv¹>¶WǍ¾vºu¹P¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶W²u´o¸Y²¹ËY¸,Ð È
Ào¸Y²u¹²u¾B¸PËY¸,Ð ÀM¹hÞH¹Ð ¾YZ¼ WM\Ú [9¾vºu¹¾YËv¹º>»zµ Ҽ˜¹hÉZ±M¾YZ¼ WA]$
Ǎµ M± ^N_ `ba.cN47Ñ 689"T:—Õ d=»˜¸(¶—µ ±MÍvÐ ¹¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹Ívµ Ëv¹>¶"¸,±Ì¾v·n²uµ Çh¸,Ð
¶—eE¾vf Ð Àn²uµ ¾v±ßÚàk¾]Ào¶—¹0²u´Mµ‡¶ßµ ±¸,±µ ²u¹º’¸Y²u¹>¿¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇ»¼˜¹•¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²
Ohg¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶µ ±"¹>¸vÁ’´µ ²u¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾vP± i¸,±o¿WÐ ¹ ² WBjßÞH¹˜²u´M¹…¼˜¾vº’¶x²
¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿(¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹hÁ ¾=¶x²>ڍÛ(¹"²u´M¹±D¹>¶x²uµ Çh¸Y²u¹²u´M¹h¿nµ‡¶x²uºuµ ÞMÀnÈ
²uk µ ¾v±ª¾,Å4²u´M¹B¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿ª¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶h¸,±o¿U¾vÞn²’¸,µ ±Æ¸,±U¹>¶x²uµ Çh¸Y²u¹
Q1Rml 'Ñ K½ÕW¸v¶W¸,±³¸,·M·Mºu¾Sånµ Çh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ã²u¾9²u´M¹h²uºuÀM¹3¿nµ‡¶x²uºuµ kÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±
Q1Rml 'Ñ K½ÕfÚ ¹¼ª¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶0Á¸,±²u´M¹±ÞH¹!¿nº’¸S¼]±ÅQºu¾vÇ Q1Rml 'Ñ K3Õ
¸,±o¿ÞH¹Ào¶—¹>¿²u¾Wºu¹·MЇ¸vÁ ¹¶—¾vǍ¹]¾,Åz²u´M¹!Á ÀMºuºu¹±=²•¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶ÚÓ
ÅQ¾vºuÇh¸,ÐM¿n¹ îo±Mµ ²uµ ¾v±¸,±o¿Ç¾vºu¹]¿n¹ ²’¸,µ Ї¶¾v±²u´M¹…°xÙÄkÓ ÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹ È
¼˜¾vºuɽÁ¸,±PÞH¹ÔÅQ¾vÀM±o¿P¹Ð‡¶—¹¼]´M¹ºu¹hó ö,ú€Ú
Ó.¶—·H¹>Á µ‡¸,ÐHµ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹4¾,Å%²u´M¹4°xÙÄkÓ6ÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉ"µ‡¶•¾vÞn²’¸,µ ±M¹>¿
µ Å!¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±³µ‡¶¿n¾v±M¹½ÞZ×㲒¸,ÉZµ ±MÍ9²u´M¹½ÞH¹>¶x² eEf OhgeEf¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶»
²u´M¹(¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²P¾,Žiz,\ n¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶½µ‡¶P¶—¹ ²½²uo¾ Oo/ OhgD¸,±o¿
¸,Ð Ð%¾,Åk²u´M¹>¶—¹Ô±M¹¼ ¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶…¸,ºu¹4Ào¶—¹>¿½²u¾hºu¹·MЇ¸vÁ ¹!²u´M¹Ô¼˜¾vº’¶x²
O;/ eEf Ohg…¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶Úkà…´Mµ‡¶ßºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶ßµ ±Ô²u´M¹0Ào¶—¹0¾,Åk\ p rs^}r‡dfe ¶—ÀoÁ’´
²u´o¸Y²•²u´M¹4¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´ÅQ¾vpº WA]µ‡¶•Á ¾v±ZËv¹×v¹>¿²u´Mºu¾vÀMÍv´3¸Ç¾v±M¾,²u¾v±nÈ
µ‡Á¸,Ð Ð ×P¿n¹>Á ºu¹>¸v¶—µ ±Mͽ¶—¹ºuµ ¹>q¶ WB=PrsW)@rt*+*+*JrsWBjEuwv+xzڅÛ(¹Á¸,Ð Ð
²u´M¹ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±MÍh¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇʸehcYizcY^_cYiorXlÔ°xÙÄkÓWÚ
ï!±M¹˜¾,Ån²u´M¹…Ǎ¾=¶x²µ Ǎ·H¾vº—²’¸,±=²·o¸,º—²’¶kµ ±W²u´M¹…°xÙÄßÓ µ‡¶ß²u´M¹…¹>¶xÈ
²uµ Çh¸Y²uµ ¾v±½¾,Åz²u´M¹!·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x׍¿nµ‡¶x²uºuµ ÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±½¾,Åz²u´M¹4¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿
¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶ÚÆï!±M¹P¼…¸S׳¾,Å4¸vÁ’´Mµ ¹ËZµ ±MÍã²u´Mµ‡¶»•µ‡¶ÞZ׳îo±o¿nµ ±MÍD¸
ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ ݹ>¿½·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×½¿nµ‡¶x²uºuµ ÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±ß»n¼]´Mµ‡Á’´3µ‡¶]¸·Mºu¾n¿nÀoÁf²
¾,Å·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×½¿n¹±o¶—µ ²x×½ÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±o¶ÑQ·z¿ZÅX¶’ÕfÚ
°€Å¾v±MÐ ×PÇÀMÐ ²uµ ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹ x¾vµ ±=²!·z¿ZÅX¶4¸,ºu¹Ào¶—¹>¿%»M²u´M¹WÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±(ÞH¹>Á ¾vǍ¹>¶Ô¸ãehgY9` ,rsizgYhp yz`uzc Ymol ^ehzc v\ p Ú"Û(¹h¸,Ї¶—¾PÁ¸,Ð Ð
²u´Mµ‡¶!¸,±Dmnizl’cYhi Yrs^}rXcYizgYpZü gvl ^_cY`fr F>gY^}rXcYioÚ!æM¾vº]²u´M¹ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±B²u¾PÞH¹"ËY¸,Ð µ‡¿%»%¹>¸vÁ’´BÇÀMÐ ²uµ ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹ x¾vµ ±=²Ô·z¿ZŘÇÀo¶x²¿n¹ È
¶uÁ ºuµ ÞH¹!¸WÀM±Mµ‡ÿ=ÀM¹4¶—¹ ²•¾,ÅßËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶Úàk¾²u´Mµ‡¶•¹±o¿%»=¼˜¹4¿n¹ îo±M¹
²u´M¹"izzc v\ Y\’l ^_cY1` {ã²u¾"ÞH¹Ô¸WËv¹>Áf²u¾vº•¾,ÅkÇÀn²uÀo¸,РР׍¹ åMÁ Ð Ào¶—µ Ëv¹
Ëv¹>Áf²u¾vº’¶²u´o¸Y²˜¹>¸vÁ’´´M¾vЇ¿"²u´M¹µ ±o¿nµ‡Á ¹>¶0¾,Åz²u´M¹ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶²u´o¸Y²
¸,ºu¹hÁ ¾v±=²’¸,µ ±M¹>¿(µ ±³¸9¶—µ ±MÍvÐ ¹ÇÀMÐ ²uµ ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹ x¾vµ ±=²W·z¿ZÅxÚà…´M¹
ÀM±Mµ ¾v±ã¾,ظ,Ро,Å0²u´M¹>¶—¹"ÇÀn²uÀo¸,Ð Ð ×9¹ åMÁ Ð Ào¶—µ Ëv¹Ëv¹>Áf²u¾vº’¶µ‡¶4¹ åZÈ
¸vÁf²uÐ ×9¹>ÿ=Ào¸,вu|¾ ""Ú"æM¾vº4¹ åM¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹v»ß¸3ËY¸,Ð µ‡¿BÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð
ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±½ÅQ¾vº -}$Ö÷"µ‡q¶ {~$ ї'Ñ &(—öZÕ (>ÑxõSÕ (>ÑXû ( v՗ÕfÚ
°€Å"ÇÀMÐ ²uµ ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹DÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐÔ·z¿ZÅX¶9¸,ºu¹(Ào¶—¹>¿%»!²u´M¹D·Mºu¾n¿ZÈ
ÀoÁf²BÁ ¾v±o¶—µ‡¶x²’¶¾,Å"¹ åM¸vÁf²uÐ × -WÅX¸vÁf²u¾vº’¶Ú æM¾vº¹>¸vÁ’´ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹
IJH—»4¼˜¹(´o¸SËv¹ã¹ åM¸vÁf²uÐ ×Æ¾v±M¹ãÅX¸vÁf²u¾v|º Qh'Ñ IJH€ I87‚07Ñ ƒx?Õ :—ÕfÚ à…´M¹
·o¸,ºu¹±=²ãËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>V¶ I87‚07Ñ ƒx?Õ :9²u´o¸Y~² IJH½µ‡¶ãÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±M¹>¿ ¾v±ß»
¸,ºu¹µ ±o¿nµ‡Á¸Y²u¹>¿ªÞZ×U¸(ÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾vs± ‚0mÑ „ Ս²u´o¸Y²½ºu¹ ²uÀMºu±o¶½¸DËv¹>ÁfÈ
²u¾vº ‚07Ñ ƒx<Õ $57Ñ ‚07Ñ ƒxwÕ =(?‚07Ñ ƒx.Õ @N(+*+*+*,(?‚07Ñ ƒx,Õ … †A‡ H ˆ … D0@ ÕfÚà…´Mµ‡¶(Á¸,±
ÞH¹Pµ‡¿n¹±=²uµ îo¹>¿K¼]µ ²u´U¸ã¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²u¹>¿³Ívº’¸,·M´³ÞZ׳µ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ µ ±MÍã¸
±M¾n¿n¹ ƒ"ÅQ¾vºP¹Ëv¹ºuתº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ2ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹ IJH—Ú æMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»
¸,±D¸,º’‰Á IJHqŠ‹IŒµ ±ã²u´M¹hÍvº’¸,·M´ãºu¹·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²’¶²u´M¹ÅX¸vÁf²Ô²u´o¸Y²
ƒŽ‚0Ñ ‘ZÕfÚØàk¾ÌÞH¹(¸,ÞMÐ ¹B²u¾Ì¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹BÅQºu¾vÇþ²u´M¹(ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±MÍ
ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ ݹ>¿Ì·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×K¿nµ‡¶x²uºuµ ÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±ß»˜ËY¸,Ð ÀM¹>¶hÇÀo¶x²h´o¸SËv¹
ÞH¹¹±(¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¿ÅQ¾vº!²u´M¹"·o¸,ºu¹±=²’¶!¾,Å IJH•ÞH¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹"¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ µ ±MÍP¸
ËY¸,Ð ÀM¹BÅQ¾v\º IJHµ ²’¶—¹Ð ÅxÚ6àk¾Ì¹±o¶—ÀMºu¹9²u´Mµ‡¶»¼˜¹BÀo¶—¹(¸³Ëv¹>Áf²u¾vº
¾,Å]¾vº’¿n¹ºuµ ±MÍ9ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹½µ ±o¿nµ‡Á ¹>1¶ ’“$•”89"1:fÚBÛ(¹PÁ¸,±³±M¾Y¼
¹±nÅQ¾vº’Á ¹9²u´o¸Y²P¼]´Mµ Ð ¹D¶uÁ¸,±M±Mµ ±Mͳ²u´M¹ãËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶½µ ±Æ²u´M¹ã¾vº—È
¿n¹–º IM—A˜ ™Ašz(.IM—A˜ ™)›>(+*+*+*,(.IM—œ,»=²u´M¹!ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶²u´o¸Y²…¶—¾vǍ¹!ËY¸,ºuµ È
¸,ÞMÐ ¹µ‡¶kÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±M¹>¿Ô¾v±ß»>¼]µ Ð Ð=¸,Ð ºu¹>¸v¿n×´o¸SËv¹ÞH¹¹±ºu¹Í=¸,º’¿n¹>¿%Ú
à…´Mµ‡¶]¾vº’¿n¹ºuµ ±MÍhÁ¸,±PÞH¹ÅQ¾vÀM±o¿PÞZ×3·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuǍµ ±Mͽ¸²u¾v·H¾vÐ ¾vÍvµ È
Á¸,Ðn¶—¾vº—²¾v±W²u´M¹˜ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±WÍvº’¸,·M´ßÚÓÌËY¸,Ð µ‡¿"Á ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð
ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±hÅQ¾v–º -}$Ö÷Wµ‡;¶ Hnó ”žH}$sƒ})ú (?‚0'Ñ &=;Õ $ÏÑ vÕ (?‚0ÑxõS;Õ $
Ñ (uû (—öZÕ (?‚0Ñ vÕ $ÏÑXû (—öZÕ (?‚0ÑXû=;Õ $ ÑQöZÕ (?‚0ÑQöZpÕ $ 'Ñ &=ÕfÚ
àk¾(îo±o¿ª¸(Ív¾Z¾n¿KÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»0¼˜¹Ào¶—¹B¸,±Uµ ±oÁ ºu¹Ç¹±=²’¸,Ð
¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇ ²u´o¸Y²ã¶x²’¸,º—²’¶PÅQºu¾vÇ ²u´M¹KÀM±Mµ ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹(ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±ªµ ±ª¼]´Mµ‡Á’´U¹>¸vÁ’´UËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹µ‡¶hµ ±o¿n¹·H¹±o¿n¹±=²hÅQºu¾vDzu´M¹
¾,²u´M¹º’¶ÚÊæM¾vºPÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð4ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶h²u´Mµ‡¶Ç¹>¸,±o¶
{Z$ ї'Ñ &=Õ (>ÑxõSÕ (+*+*+*+(>'Ñ -ž/.õS՗ÕfÚ³æM¾vºÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ЕÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±o¶3¼˜¹ã´o¸SËv¹ € ‚07Ñ ƒx+Õ €$Ÿ&(?ƒŽ ""Ú䕸vÁ’´Öµ ²u¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»¸
¶—µ ±MÍvÐ ¹]¾v·H¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±µ‡¶0·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuǍ¹>¿"¾v±²u´M¹]ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±"²u´o¸Y²
µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶¶—¾vǍ¹WǍ¹ ²uºuµ‡ÁÔ²u´M¹Ç¾=¶x²>Ú°_±9²u´M¹WÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð
Á¸v¶—¹v»M²u´M¹¾v±MÐ ×P¾v·H¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±¼˜¹¸,Ð Ð ¾Y¼.µ‡¶Ç¹ºuÍvµ ±M͍²x¼˜¾½Ëv¹>ÁfÈ
²u¾vº’¶ÚK°_±K²u´M¹9Á ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð]Á¸v¶—¹v»0¼˜¹P¾v±MÐ ×K¸,Ð Ð ¾Y¼²u´M¹9¸v¿ZÈ
¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±.¾,ō¸UËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹B²u¾U²u´M¹DËv¹>Áf²u¾vº¾,Å"·o¸,ºu¹±=²’¶P¾,ō¸,±nÈ
¾,²u´M¹ºËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹vÚÊà…´Mµ‡¶9Á ¾vºuºu¹>¶—·H¾v±o¿M¶½²u¾ª¸v¿M¿nµ ±Mͪ¸,º’Á¶½²u¾
²u´M¹ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ãÍvº’¸,·M´ßÚ ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»H²u¾¹±o¶—ÀMºu¹"²u´o¸Y²²u´M¹
Á ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ИÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ìµ‡¶h¶x²uµ Ð Ð]ËY¸,Ð µ‡¿%»…¸,±ª¸,º’Á3µ‡¶"¾v±MÐ ×
¸,Ð Ð ¾Y¼˜¹>¿ã²u¾BÞH¹P¸v¿M¿n¹>¿Dµ ŵ ²¿n¾Z¹>¶W±M¾,²µ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ ¹3¸,±Z×DÁ ×=È
Á Ð ¹>¶Úʰ€Å"±M¾U¾v·H¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±Æ²u´o¸Y²9µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶h²u´M¹DǍ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á(Á¸,±
ÞH¹·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuǍ¹>¿(¸,±Z×ZǍ¾vºu¹v»H²u´M¹ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ã¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´(¸,Ð Ív¾,È
ºuµ ²u´MÇ ¶x²u¾v·o¶Ú(°_±³²u´Mµ‡¶"·o¸,·H¹º>»¼˜¹3Ào¶—¹½²x¼˜¾ãǍ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á¶W²u´o¸Y²
1e+007
Univariate
AIC
BIC
Perfect mixing
1e+006
Average amount of evaluations
¶—´M¾vÀMЇ¿ãÞH¹½Çµ ±Mµ Ǎµ ݹ>¿%»k¼]´Mµ‡Á’´³¸,ºu¹"²u´M¹ tvgYr tv\‰fi>ü cY`fehgN
^}rXcYi`frs^_\ `frXcYi ÑXÓ°uÅս¸,±o¿U²u´M¹³b!gYýv\fdfrXgYifi>ü cY`fehgY^}rXcYi
`frs^_\ `frXcYi.Ñ ˜°uÅÕfÚæM¾vºW¸¿n¹ºuµ ËY¸Y²uµ ¾v±(¾,Ř²u´M¹>¶—¹Ç¹ ²uºuµ‡Á¶µ ±
²u´M¹h°xÙÄkÓÁ ¾v±=²u¹ åZ²>»k¼˜¹ºu¹ ÅQ¹º4²u´M¹hºu¹>¸v¿n¹º4²u¾B¸PǍ¾vºu¹¿n¹ È
²’¸,µ Ð ¹>¿Wºu¹·H¾vº—²…ó ÷>ú€Úà…´M¹˜Ç¹ ²uºuµ‡Á¶¸,ºu¹0µ ±=²u¹±o¿n¹>¿W²u¾!·Mºu¾YËZµ‡¿n¹•¸
Ào¶—¹ ÅQÀMÐ=²uº’¸v¿n¹¾,áhÞH¹ ²x¼˜¹¹±"Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ ånµ ²x׸,±o¿WÍv¾Z¾n¿n±M¹>¶u¶k¾,ÅMîM²>Ú
˜¾,²u´hǍ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á¶•µ ±Mµ ²uµ‡¸,РР׍¶uÁ ¾vºu¹¸ÔÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±hÞZײu´M¹!±M¹Í,È
¸Y²uµ Ëv¹3Ð ¾vNÍ 2ZÐ µ Év¹Ð µ ´M¾Z¾n¿D¾,Ųu´M¹3ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ ݹ>¿³·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×D¿nµ‡¶xÈ
²uºuµ ÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±ßÚ6à…´M¹ãÓ°uÃñǍ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á9·H¹±o¸,Ð µ ݹ>¶3Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ ånµ ²x×UÞZ×
¸v¿M¿nµ ±MÍB²u´M¹¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²"¾,Å·o¸,º’¸,Ǎ¹ ²u¹º’\¶ € ž €ß²u´o¸Y²"´o¸v¶W²u¾(ÞH¹
îM²>Ú ¾,²u¹9²u´o¸Y²½²u´M¹B¾v·H¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶h¾v±ªÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶"²u´o¸Y²
¼˜¹´o¸SËv¹·Mºu¾v·H¾=¶—¹>¿%»z¸,Ð ¼…¸S×n¶µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹²u´M¹¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²4¾,ŕ·o¸YÈ
º’¸,Ǎ¹ ²u¹º’¶Úà…´M¹ ˜°uÃǍ¹ ²uºuµ‡ÁWµ‡¶!·o¸,º’¸,Ǎ¹ ²u¹ºuµ ݹ>¿PÞZ×9¸hºu¹Í,È
ÀMЇ¸,ºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±³·o¸,º’¸,Ǎ¹ ²u¹º³²u´o¸Y²h¿n¹ ²u¹ºuǍµ ±M¹>¶²u´M¹¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²
¾,Å%·H¹±o¸,Ð µ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±h¾,Å%Ǎ¾vºu¹!Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ åÇ¾n¿n¹Ð‡¶0µ ±h¾vº’¿n¹º²u¾ÅX¸YÈ
Ëv¾vº…Ǎ¾vºu¹¶—µ Ǎ·MÐ ¹Ç¾n¿n¹Ð‡¶Ú0à…´M¹·H¹±o¸,Ð µ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±Pµ ±P²u´M¹ ˜°uÃ
Ǎ¹ ²uºuµ‡Áµ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶Ð ¾vÍ=¸,ºuµ ²u´MǍµ‡Á¸,Ð Ð ×K¼]µ ²u´ª²u´M¹B¶—µ ݹ9¾,ÅÔ²u´M¹
¶u¸,Ǎ·M@ Ð ¹Ëv¹>Áf²u¾vºMÐ ±k.Ñ €  € +Õ € € Ú°_±h²u´Mµ‡¶•·o¸,·H¹º>»v¼˜¹!´o¸SËv¹]Ào¶—¹>¿
\ $ ڕÓ!¶]²u´M¹W¶—µ ݹ¾,Åk²u´M¹¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹ÔËv¹>Áf²u¾vº]µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶»Z²u´M¹
˜°uÃÖ Ç¹ ²uºuµ‡ÁÔ´o¸v¶!¸h¶x²uºu¾v±MÍv¹º]·H¹±o¸,Ð µ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±P²u@ ´o¸,±B¿n¾Z¹>¶]²u´M¹
Ó°uÃØÇ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á,ÚKòZµ ±oÁ ¹P¼˜¹3´o¸SËv¹hîMån¹>¿K²u¾ »²u´Mµ‡¶"µ‡¶²u´M¹
Á¸v¶—¹4ÅQ¾vº¸,±Z×½·Mº’¸vÁf²uµ‡Á¸,Ðz·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v±9¶—µ ݹvÚ ® é ëpê «³® é ë M­ Ïì]¬n®¬Míxê é
!­Mê0© «
¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶ÔÁ¸,±ãÞH¹h¹±oÁ ¾n¿n¹>¿ãµ ±(²u´M¹hºu¹>¸,ж—·o¸vÁ ¹"Ào¶—µ ±MÍ
º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ)Év¹×n¶Ú½°_±D²u´Mµ‡¶W¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±ß»k¼˜¹hÞMºuµ ¹ ×ãÍv¾¾YËv¹ºÔ²u´Mµ‡¶
¹±oÁ ¾n¿nµ ±MÍ(¸,±o¿³·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²"¶—¾vǍ¹3·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±K·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶W¾,Å
²uÀM±o¸,ÞMÐ ¹ÞH¾vÀM±o¿n¹>¿¿nµ â½Á ÀMÐ ²x×vÚ
A :!;=?YIk<>Jn<>OXFHLÆ;ZLvFOXL
à…´M¹¹±oÁ ¾n¿nµ ±M;,Å%·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶ÞZ×"º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ6Év¹×n¶¼…¸v¶µ ±nÈ
²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ ¹>¿½ÞZ× ˜¹>¸,±ãó õ ú€Úà…´M¹4Çh¸,µ ±3¸v¿nËY¸,±=²’¸,Ív¹¾,Åkº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ
Év¹×n¶µ‡¶"²u´o¸Y²½±M¾³Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º¾v·H¹º’¸Y²u¾vºhÁ¸,±ªÁ ºu¹>¸Y²u¹PÀM±nÅQ¹>¸YÈ
¶—µ ÞMÐ ¹9¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¶h¶—µ ±oÁ ¹9¹>¸vÁ’´Ì¹±oÁ ¾n¿nµ ±MÍDºu¹·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²’¶¸(·H¹º—È
ÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚWàk¾3¹±oÁ ¾n¿n¹¸3·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ã¾,Å0Ð ¹±MÍ,²u~´ -x»z¹>¸vÁ’´
µ ±=²u¹Ív¹º4µ #± " µ‡¶Ô¸v¶u¶—µ Ív±M¹>¿B¸3ËY¸,Ð ÀM¹ÑQÉv¹×MÕ]ÅQºu¾vÇ)¶—¾vǍ¹"ºu¹>¸,Ð
¿n¾vÇh¸,µ ±ß»]¼]´Mµ‡Á’´Öµ‡¶3Ào¶—Ào¸,Ð Ð ×̲’¸,Év¹±ª²u¾ÌÞH¹Uó &(õ ú€Ú6òZÀMÞo¶—¹ È
ÿ=ÀM¹±=²uÐ ×v»²u´M¹½±ZÀMÇÞH¹º’¶µ ± "ð¸,ºu¹½¶—¾vº—²u¹>¿(¾v±D²u´M¹½Év¹×n¶Ô²u¾
Ív¹ ²4²u´M¹"ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±MÍ3·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚWæM¾vº4¹ åM¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹v»z²u´M¹"º’¸,±nÈ
¿n¾vÇÉv¹×9¶x²uºuµ ±MÍ('Ñ &* v÷ (.&* )õ (.&* ô=՘ºu¹·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²’¶²u´M¹"¾vº’¿n¹ºuµ ±MÍ
Ñx)õ (.&( vÕfÚà…´Mµ‡¶]¿n¹>Á ¾n¿nµ ±MÍhºu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹>¶½'Ñ -YÐ ¾vpÍ -}Õ0²uµ Ǎ¹vÚ
A :Ô?YF!#"X;ZIKG"F%$&•F%L;'ªFo?(;=?
Ô±o¸,Ý x¹¼ñó õvõfú´o¸v¶4µ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ ¹>¿ã¸3Ív¹±M¹º’¸,пn¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹"·H¹º—È
ÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹ÇÚkà…´M¹•¸v¿nËY¸,±=²’¸,Ív¹¾,ÅZ²u´Mµ‡¶ß·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç.¾YËv¹º
Ǎ¾=¶x²½²u¹>¶x²3·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶hµ‡¶h²u´o¸Y²½²u´M¹Bµ ±=²u¹º’¸vÁf²uµ ¾v±o¶hÞH¹ ²x¼˜¹¹±
²u´M¹hº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ)Év¹×n¶W¸,ºu¹ºu¹>¶x²uºuµ‡Áf²u¹>¿B²u¾9ÞH¹h¾,Å]¸9Á ¹º—²’¸,µ ±(¾vº—È
¿n¹º -))ÚÓÏÅQÀMº—²u´M¹ºÔ¸v¿nËY¸,±=²’¸,Ív¹Wµ‡¶!²u´o¸Y²4µ ²Ôµ‡¶Ô¿n¹ îo±M¹>¿9ÅQ¾vº
¸,±Z1× -))»YÀM±MÐ µ Év¹˜ÅQ¾vºµ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹•²u´M¹]¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹˜·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±
·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶…ÞZ× ¸,ºuÍvÀM·n²’¸M»nÙ!¹Þ9¸,±o¿9Ò4¾vЇ¿nÞH¹ºuÍó zõ &Yú€Ú
100000
10000
1000
æ µ ÍvÀMºu¹Dõ+*9ÓǍ¾vÀM±=²½¾,ÅÔ¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶ÅQ¾vº²u´M¹BÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶
°xÙÄkÓW»b-))o$ªöoÚ
Ô±o¸,Ý x¹¼-, ¶h¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ª·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çµ‡¶½¿n¹ îo±M¹>¿
Ào¶—µ ±Mͽ¸¿nµ‡¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹ÞH¹ ²x¼˜¹¹±P²x¼˜¾·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú0à…´Mµ‡¶¿nµ‡¶xÈ
²’¸,±oÁ ¹µ‡¶Ô¿n¹ îo±M¹>¿D¸v¶!²u´M¹Çµ ±Mµ ÇÀMÇ ±ZÀMÇÞH¹ºÔ¾,Ř¹Ð ¹Ç¹±=²’¶
µ ±(¾v±M¹¶x²uºuµ ±MÍ3²u¾PÞH¹Ç¾YËv¹>¿²u¾¾vÞn²’¸,µ ±B²u´M¹¾,²u´M¹º¶x²uºuµ ±MÍoÚ
æMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»z²u´M¹h¾v·n²uµ ÇÀMÇ)µ‡¶4²u´M¹²uºuµ ËZµ‡¸,зH¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±
'Ñ &()õ (+*+*+*,(.-)) /.õSÕfÚDà…´M¹P¿nµ‡¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹½ÅQºu¾vÇ ¸,±Z×D·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±. ²u¾(²u´M¹¾v·n²uµ ÇÀMÇþ¹>ÿ=Ào¸,ЇS¶ -)) / € /1032,Ñ3.+Õ € »˜¼]´M¹ºu¹
/1032,Ñ3.՘µ‡¶…²u´M¹WÐ ¾v±MÍv¹>¶x²]µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—µ ±MÍh¶—ÀMÞo¶—¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±oÁ ¹Ôµ ±4.•Ú˜æM¾vº
¹ åM¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹v»•µ Å5. $þÑQMö (.&(uû ()õ ( vÕf»²u´M¹±6/1032,Ñ3.Õ $þ'Ñ &()õ ( vÕ
¸,±oo¿ -)) / € /1032YÑ3.+Õ €p$ S÷ /Æû $ nÚÌà…´M¹3²x¼˜¾(¹Ð ¹Ç¹±=²’¶
²u¾PǍ¾YËv¹¸,ºu¹¾,ŘÁ ¾vÀMº’¶—¹Wö¸,±o¿BûMÚ ¾,²u¹²u´o¸Y²4²u´M¹"ºu¹Ëv¹º’¶—¹
·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±K'Ñ -)#) /ª)õ (.-)~) /(+*+*+*,(.&=Յµ‡¶]²u´M¹W¾v±MÐ ×3·H¹º—È
ÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±³¼]µ ²u´Ì¸B¿nµ‡¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹3¾,Å -)) /.õvÚBà…´M¹3¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹
¾vº’¿n¹ºuµ ±MÍã·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç ÅQ¾vº½¸(¶—µ ±MÍvÐ ¹87 mnrsp YrsAi 97 p c>l’t.Ñ ]Õ¾,Å
Ð ¹±MÍ,²u|´ -))»nµ‡¶¿n¹ îo±M¹>¿¸v¶˜ÅQ¾vÐ Ð ¾Y¼¶:*
… >@? wA ‡ B ˆ …
; ))Ñ3.;Õ $=< qõõ / C CDC µµ Åŀ€ /1/103032,2,Ñ3Ñ3..+ÕÕ+€'€)$E --)))) ÑxõSÕ
ÓÆÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍÞMÐ ¾nÁ’ɵ‡¶0¸¶—ÀMÞo¶—¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±oÁ ¹…¾,ÅH²u´M¹!Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ ²u¹]º’¸,±nÈ
¿n¾vÇ Év¹×D¶x²uºuµ ±MÍoÚãà…´M¹P¸vÁf²uÀo¸,ЕîM²u±M¹>¶u¶WÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±³²u´o¸Y²"¼˜¹
Ào¶—¹v»v´o¸v¶0Ð ¹±MÍ,²u´ -}$ O)p) -))»=¼]´M¹ºuq¹ O))³µ‡¶²u´M¹4¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²
¾,Å"ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MͪÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶Úðà…´M¹³Ð ¾nÁ¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶P¾,Ųu´M¹Dµ ±o¿nµ ËZµ‡¿nÀo¸,Ð
ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MͽÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶]´o¸SËv¹ÞH¹¹±BÁ ¾n¿n¹>¿Dp c>cSd\ p ýYÚà…´Mµ‡¶µ Ǎ·MÐ µ ¹>¶
²u´o¸Y²ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍÞMÐ ¾nÁ’É &|Utƒ55E O)) Á ¾v±o¶—µ‡¶x²’¶4¾,ŕ²u´M¹º’¸,±nÈ
¿n¾vÇØÉv¹×n¶ÅQ¾vÀM±o¿h¸Y²•Ð ¾nÁ¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶!7Ñ ƒ(?ƒ1\F O)q) (+*+*+*+(?ƒ1FD'Ñ -)) /
õSwÕ O))˜ÕfÚ…à…´M¹ÅX¸vÁf²²u´o¸Y²²u´M¹W·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çñµ‡¶]ÅQÀMРР׿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹v»
Ǎ¹>¸,±o¶z²u´o¸Y²¸,Ð Ðv¶uÁ’´M¹Çh¸Y²’¸…¾,Ån¸,±Ô¾vº’¿n¹ºk¶—Çh¸,Ð Ð ¹ºz²u´o¸,±HG!Ð ¹>¸v¿
²u¾³²u´M¹(¶—ÀMÞH¾v·n²uµ ÇÀMÇ ¾,ÅÔ²u´M¹ãºu¹Ëv¹º’¶—¹9·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ïó zõ &Sú€Ú
à…´Mµ‡¶Çh¸,Év¹>¶4²u´M¹½·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç ´o¸,º’¿ãÅQ¾vºW¸,±Z×ã¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ ݹº²u´o¸Y²
¿n¾Z¹>¶—±, ²Ôµ‡¿n¹±=²uµ ÅQ×9¼]´Mµ‡Á’´Bº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ Év¹×·H¾=¶—µ ²uµ ¾v±o¶²u¾vÍv¹ ²u´M¹º
Á ¾v±o¶x²uµ ²uÀn²u¹"¸½ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ3ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’ÉDó ûYú€Ú4æMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»oÞH¹>Á¸,Ào¶—¹
¾,Å0²u´M¹"Ð ¾Z¾=¶—¹"Á ¾n¿nµ ±MÍo»%¶—µ Ǎ·MÐ ¹hÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º¶uÁ’´M¹Ç¹>¶4¶—ÀoÁ’´(¸v¶
¾v±M¹Ô·H¾vµ ±=²!Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º˜¸,ºu¹Ô±M¾,²]¹ áz¹>Áf²uµ Ëv¹¹µ ²u´M¹º>Ú
I è ¨Æ«Ö©!®« ëê éé ê0M­ Ø®JHWë fo« ’ê0­
M­ Ïì]¬n®¬Míxê é !­Mê0© «
òZµ ±oÁ ¹4º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇØÉv¹×h¶x²uºuµ ±MÍ=¶•¸,ºu¹ºu¹>¸,ÐH±ZÀMÇÞH¹º’¶»=¼˜¹4Á¸,±3¿nµ È
ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×ã¸,·M·MÐ ×(Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶4°xÙÄkÓ!¶h²u¾9·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±(·Mºu¾vÞnÈ
100
1
2
3
4
5
6
Amount of building blocks
7
8
9
10
10000
1
Univariate
AIC
BIC
Perfect mixing
Univariate
AIC
BIC
Perfect mixing
Percentile building blocks correct
0.8
n
1000
100
0.6
0.4
0.2
10
1
2
3
4
5
6
Amount of building blocks
7
8
9
10
æ µ ÍvÀMºu¹û *0ï!·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇh¸,±oÁ ¹…¾,Åz²u´M¹!Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶
°xÙÄkÓÅQ¾vº]µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—µ ±MÍ f »M-))o$sO))o$÷n» eEf Ohg$ v÷>&MÚ
0
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Tau
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
0.5
450000
Univariate
AIC
BIC
Perfect mixing
400000
350000
Average amount of evaluations
æ µ ÍvÀMºu¹D* ]¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹>¿P·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v±¶—µ ݹ4ÅQ¾vº…²u´M¹WÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶
°xÙÄkÓW»b-))o$ªöoÚ
Ð ¹Çh¶ÚÖ°_±U²u´Mµ‡¶h·o¸,·H¹º>»˜¼˜¹9Ào¶—¹P²u´M¹B±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ѕ·z¿ZÅÔÅQ¾vºh²u´M¹
·z¿ZÅX¶]µ Ǎ·MÐ µ ¹>¿PÞZ×h²u´M¹4ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚÛ(¹Ôºu¹ ÅQ¹º…²u´M¹ºu¹>¸v¿n¹º
²u¾·Mºu¹ËZµ ¾vÀo¶…¼˜¾vºuÉBó ö,ú%ÅQ¾vº]µ Ǎ·MÐ ¹Ç¹±=²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±9¿n¹ ²’¸,µ Ї¶Ú
°_±h¸,Ð ÐM¾vÀMº²u¹>¶x²uµ ±MÍo»,¼˜¹]Ào¶—¹>¿"Ǎ¾v±M¾,²u¾v±Mµ‡Á˜°xÙÄkÓ!¶Ú…Û(¹]Ào¶—¹>¿
²u´M¹ÔºuÀMÐ ¹Ô¾,Åk²u´ZÀMÇÞPÞZ× [ÀM´MÐ ¹±ZÞH¹µ ±¸,±o\¿ [B¸,´M±Mµ Íó õö,ú%ÅQ¾vº
æÙÓ̸,±o¿¶—¹ ² f ²u¾ &* ûMÚkÓÐ Ð=ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶ß¼˜¹ºu¹•¸SËv¹º’¸,Ív¹>¿¾YËv¹ºk)û &
µ ±o¿n¹·H¹±o¿n¹±=²ºuÀM±o¶Ú"Ó!¶Ô¸PǍ¹>¸v¶—ÀMºu¹¾,Ř¹ â½Á µ ¹±oÁ ×v»%¼˜¹"Ào¶—¹
²u´M¹W¸SËv¹º’¸,Ív¹4¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²]¾,źu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹>¿½ÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú
°_±9îoÍvÀMºu¹>¶õ"¸,±o¿ n»o²u´M¹"¸SËv¹º’¸,Ív¹Ô¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²!¾,Å0¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶
¸,±o¿Ö²u´M¹³ºu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹>¿Ö·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v± ¶—µ ݹ³¸,ºu¹D¶—´M¾Y¼]±.ºu¹>¶—·H¹>ÁfÈ
²uµ Ëv¹Ð ׳¾v±Ì¸ãÐ ¾vÍ=¸,ºuµ ²u´MǍµ‡Á3¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹½ÅQ¾v‰º O)) Ž c=)õ ( (+*+*+*fzõ &d
¸,±o¿ -)) $Æöoڕ°€²µ‡¶Á Ð ¹>¸,º…²u´o¸Y²!Ào¶—µ ±MÍ"²u´M¹WÀM±Mµ ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹ÔÅX¸vÁfÈ
²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±½µ ±½¼]´Mµ‡Á’´3¹>¸vÁ’´½ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹!µ‡¶0²’¸,Év¹±½µ ±o¿n¹·H¹±o¿n¹±=²
¾,ŕ¸,Ро,Ųu´M¹"¾,²u´M¹º’¶»H¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹>¶ÀM·(¶—µ Ív±Mµ îHÁ¸,±=²uÐ ×P¼˜¾vº’¶—¹Ô²u´o¸,±
¼]´M¹±ª·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çþ¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹9µ‡¶¹ ån·MÐ ¾vµ ²u¹>¿%Úà…´M¹B¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹
¾,Å%²u´M¹4·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çص‡¶•ÞH¹>¶x²…ºu¹·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²u¹>¿µ ±P¸,±hÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð
ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±µ ±"¼]´Mµ‡Á’´²u´M¹…ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶¸,ºu¹˜·H¹º—ÅQ¹>Áf²uÐ ×
¶—¹·o¸,º’¸Y²u¹>¿(µ ±³²u´M¹P±M¾n¿n¹½Ëv¹>Áf²u¾v‰º {•ÚãÛ(¹PÁ¸,Ð Ð0²u´Mµ‡T¶ yo\ `Qü \’l ^
e"r rsAi µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚ !¶—µ ±Mͽ²u´Mµ‡¶4¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹Á¸,±BÞH¹"¶—¹¹±
²u¾B ¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹ÀM·³·H¾vÐ ×Z±M¾vǍµ‡¸,Ð Ð ×vÚ½à…´M¹ºu¹hµ‡¶±M¾9¾vÞZËZµ ¾vÀo¶Ô¿nµ áz¹º—È
¹±oÁ ¹ÔÞH¹ ²x¼˜¹¹±P²u´M¹WÓ°uÃÆ¾vº ˜°uÃÆ¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´3Ǎ¹ ²uºuµ‡ÁÔ´M¹ºu¹vÚ
¾,²u¹²u´o¸Y²Ô²u´M¹h¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²Ô¾,ŕµ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹>¶!ÅQ¾vºÔ¸3·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±
¾,0Å -)o) $ÆöWµ‡¶0ö A$ Yöo»=¼]´Mµ‡Á’´½¶x²uµ Ð ÐM²uº’¸vÁf²’¸,ÞMÐ ¹vÚ°€Åß¼˜¹Ç¾YËv¹
²u\¾ -)<) $6÷h´M¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»M²u´M¹¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²4¾,ŕµ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹>¶4¸,Ð ºu¹>¸v¿n×
ÞH¹>Á ¾vǍ¹>¶
õ >&M»•¼]´Mµ‡Á’´ª¶—µ Ív±Mµ îHÁ¸,±=²uР׳µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶²u´M¹9·Mºu¾vÞnÈ
Ð ¹Çþ¿nµ â½Á ÀMÐ ²x×vÚUà…´Mµ‡¶µ‡¶"ºu¹ ¹>Áf²u¹>¿ÌÞZ×D²u´M¹PÅX¸vÁf²²u´o¸Y²²u´M¹
Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶°xÙÄkÓ!¶ã¸,ºu¹ÀM±o¸,ÞMÐ ¹P²u¾K¶—¾vÐ Ëv¹P²u´M¹B¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹
·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶ÅQ¾v;º O)) ŽcSû (—Mö (+*+*+*fzõ &d¼]µ ²u´ OU.)õ * &„fzõ &SÚ°_±
²u´M¹!Á¸v¶—¹…¾,Å%·H¹º—ÅQ¹>Áf²0Ǎµ ånµ ±MÍWµ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»,¼˜¹]Ív¾,² * & …¶
¾v±h¸SËv¹º’¸,Ív¹˜Ào¶—µ ±MÍWû * }õ „uzõ &…¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶¸,±o‰¿ OV$Öû * &;„uzõ &
,Ú
à…´M¹ï!Ǎ¹SÒÔÓ.¶—µ Ív±Mµ îHÁ¸,±=²uÐ ×h¾vÀn²u·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇh¶0²u´M¹Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶
°xÙÄkÓW»o¼]´Mµ‡Á’´·H¾vµ ±=²’¶¾vÀn²²u´o¸Y²²u´M¹Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶°xÙÄkÓϸ,·nÈ
·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´3Ð ¹>¶u¶…¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²uÐ ×3·Mºu¾nÁ ¹>¶u¶—¹>¶•²u´M¹ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍhÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶Ú
V
’­M® ê0­ à…´M¹3ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶W¾,Ҳu´M¹PÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶W°xÙÄkÓ+Á¸,±M±M¾,²"Á ¾vǍ·H¹ ²u¹
ÅQ¾vºÔµ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹"¼]µ ²u´(²u´M¹3ï!Ǎ¹SÒÔÓWÚ ˜¾,²u´D¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶!´M¾Y¼…È
300000
250000
200000
150000
100000
50000
æ µ ÍvÀMºu¹ö!*ßæMÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±W¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶%¾,ÅZ²u´M¹•Á ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶%°xÙÄkÓ
ÅQ¾vº]µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—µ ±MÍ f »J-))o$ O))o$÷n» eEf OhgT$ v÷>&MÚ
¹Ëv¹º¸Y²—²u¹Ç·n²²u¾Uîo±o¿.¸,±o¿ÖÀo¶—¹ã²u´M¹Dºu¹Ð‡¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶3ÞH¹ ²x¼˜¹¹±
²u´M¹9º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇÉv¹×n¶ÚÆà…´M¹9Çh¸,µ ±ª·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç¼]µ ²u´ª²u´M¹BÁ ¾v±nÈ
²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶"°xÙÄkÓ µ‡¶²u´M¹9¿n¹±o¶—µ ²x×K¹>¶x²uµ Çh¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ì¾,Å4¸,±o¿U¶u¸,Ç"È
·MÐ µ ±MÍ"ÅQºu¾vÇʸ±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ðz·z¿ZÅxÚ0°€²]´o¸v¶…¶—¾vǍ¹4Ð µ Ǎµ ²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶…¼]µ ²u´
ºu¹>¶—·H¹>Áf²Ô²u¾±M¾vA± 2ZÐ µ ±M¹>¸,ºuµ ²x×B¸,±o¿ãÇÀMÐ ²uµ Ǎ¾n¿M¸,Ð µ ²x×vÚ½æMÀMº—²u´M¹º—È
Ǎ¾vºu¹v»²u´M¹P·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ì¶—·o¸vÁ ¹3µ‡¶"µ ±ZÞH¹>¿M¿n¹>¿Kµ ±K²u´M¹Pºu¹>¸,Ð
¶—·o¸vÁ ¹v»nǍ¹>¸,±Mµ ±MͲu´o¸Y²]²u´M¹¸vÁfC²uÀo¸,Ðß¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´P¶—·o¸vÁ ¹4µ‡¶]¸ÑX¶—·H¹ È
Á µ‡¸,ÐsÕ4¿nµ‡¶uÁ ºu¹ ²uµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ã¾,ÅÔó &(õ ú ÚhæM¾vº¸,~± -)ž) 2n¿nµ Ǎ¹±o¶—µ ¾v±o¸,Ð
; ))ÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±ß»ß²u´M¹¾v·n²uµ ÇÀMÇ ¸,±o¿B²u´M¹½¶—ÀMÞH¾v·n²uµ ÇÀMÇ ¸,ºu¹
Á ¾v±=²’¸,µ ±M¹>¿UC CDµC ±Ö¸KÁ ¾v±ZËv¹ å̺u¹Ívµ ¾v±ÆÁ ¾v±o¶—µ‡¶x²uµ ±Mͳ¾,Å C @wCD=.C = ¾,Å
²u´M¹Ìó &(õ ú ´Z×Z·H¹º’Á ÀMÞH¹vÚ.æMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»•²u´M¹>¶—¹²x¼˜¾³ºu¹ È
Ívµ ¾v±o¶P¸,ºu¹ã¶—¹·o¸,º’¸Y²u¹>¿ÆÞZ×U²u´M¹D¶—µ ±MÍvÐ ¹ãÐ µ ±M¹(¾v±Ö¼]´Mµ‡Á’´¹Ë=È
¹ºu׳º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ Év¹×K´o¸v¶¸,±Uµ‡¿n¹±=²uµ‡Á¸,ЅËY¸,Ð ÀM¹v򻾵 ±o¸,Ð Ð ×v»•²u´M¹
¾,²u´M¹º…²x×Z·H¹>¶…¾,ÅÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±M͍ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶…´o¸SËv¹!²u´M¹Ô´Mµ Ív´M¹>¶x²…îM²u±M¹>¶u¶
µ ±Æ²u´M¹B±M¹µ Ív´ZÞH¾vºu´M¾Z¾n¿ª¾,ÅÔ²u´M¹(¶—ÀMÞH¾v·n²uµ Çh¸,Ð!ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’ÉzÚÏà…´Mµ‡¶
Ǎ¹>¸,±o¶4²u´o¸Y²>»¹>¶—·H¹>Á µ‡¸,Ð Ð ×ã¸vT¶ -)) Ív¾Z¹>¶ÔÀM·ß»ß²u´M¹hÍv¹¾vǍ¹ ²uºuµ È
Á¸,ÐH¸,·M·Mºu¾Sånµ Çh¸Y²uµ ¾v±"¾,Åz²u´M¹±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ðo¿nµ‡¶x²uºuµ ÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±h¼]µ Ð Ðo´o¸SËv¹
Ívºu¹>¸Y²4¿nµ â½Á ÀMÐ ²x×P²u¾3ºu¹·Mºu¹>¶—¹±=²ÅQ¾vº4µ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹W²u´M¹W²uº’¸v¿n¹ 2Z¾,á
ÞH¹ ²x¼˜¹¹±²u´M¹"¶—ÀMÞH¾v·n²uµ Çh¸,ÐÞMÐ ¾nÁ’ÉP¸,±o¿²u´M¹W¾v·n²uµ Çh¸,ÐÞMÐ ¾nÁ’ÉzÚ
àk¾Kµ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹²u´M¹µ º¶—¹·o¸,º’¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×v»˜²u´M¹ã¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±Æ·Mºu¹>¶u¶—ÀMºu¹
¶—´M¾vÀMЇ¿µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹¾vº0²u´M¹!·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v±½¶—µ ݹ4¶—´M¾vÀMЇ¿µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹vÚ
æM¾vºµ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹v»ßµ ±(¾vº’¿n¹º4²u¾µ‡¶—¾vЇ¸Y²u¹²u´M¹h¾v·n²uµ Çh¸,ÐÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ
ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’É9µ ±(@w=.¸3= º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ ·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»ß¸P¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±B·H¹º’Á ¹±=²’¸,Ív¹
¾,Å f $ C CDC µ‡¶ºu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹>¿%Ú…à…´M¹·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇh¸,±oÁ ¹ÔÅQ¾vº!¿nµ áz¹º—È
¹±=²˜ËY¸,Ð ÀM¹>¶0¾,Å f µ‡¶˜¿nµ‡¶—·MЇ¸S×v¹>¿"eEfµ ±hîoÍvÀMºu¹>¶•ûW¸,±o¿höoÚ°_±h²u´M¹>¶—¹
îoÍvÀMºu¹>¶»%²u´M¹½¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±D¶—µ ݹ Ohg½µ‡¶Év¹·n²WÁ ¾v±o¶x²’¸,±=²>Úhà…´M¹
0
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Tau
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
0.5
º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð ¹ÅQ¾vº…²u´Mµ‡¶…µ‡¶•²u´o¸Y²…²u´M¹Ív¾Z¾n¿n±M¹>¶u¶•¾,Ÿ±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ðz·z¿ZÅ
îM²¿n¾Z¹>¶!±M¾3Ð ¾v±MÍv¹º4¶—µ Ív±Mµ îHÁ¸,±=²uÐ ×µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹Wµ Å0²u´M¹¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²
¾,ÅÔ¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶"µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶ÚKà…´M¹¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ì·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇh¸,±oÁ ¹
µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶]µ Ųu´M¹"¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±9·Mºu¹>¶u¶—ÀMºu¹µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶Ú ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»
²u´Mµ‡¶Á ¾vǍ¹>¶W¸Y²W²u´M¹3¹ ån·H¹±o¶—¹h¾,Ҳu´M¹P¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²W¾,Å]ºu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹>¿
¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú!à…´M¹ºu¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹v»M²u´M¹ºu¹ÇÀo¶x²4ÞH¹¶—¾vǍ¹Wº’¸,±MÍv¹ÅQ¾vº
²u´M¹"ÞH¹>¶x²WÁ’´M¾vµ‡Á ¹WÅQ¾vº f µ ±ã²u´M¹¶—¹±o¶—¹"¾,ŕºu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹>¿B¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²
¾,ŹËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶…²u¾hºu¹>¸vÁ’´3²u´M¹¾v·n²uµ ÇÀMÇڕ°_±B¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±BùZ»M¼˜¹
µ ±ZËv¹>¶x²uµ Í=¸Y²u¹!²u´Mµ‡¶…ÅQÀMº—²u´M¹º>Ú
àk¾"¾YËv¹º’Á ¾vǍ¹²u´M¹Ô·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶˜¼]µ ²u´P²u´M¹Ô±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ðz·z¿Zŵ ±3²u´M¹
ºu¹>¸,И¶—·o¸vÁ ¹3¼]µ ²u´Ìºu¹>¶—·H¹>Áf²²u¾BîM²—²uµ ±MÍã²u´M¹P¹ÇÞH¹>¿M¿n¹>¿³·H¹º—È
ÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±9¶—·o¸vÁ ¹v»M²u´M¹Wº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇÊÉv¹×P¶x²uºuµ ±MÍ=¶¶—´M¾vÀMЇ¿PÞH¹Wµ ±nÈ
²u¹ºu·Mºu¹ ²u¹>¿"µ ±"²u´M¹]·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±h¶—·o¸vÁ ¹vÚ ˜×"¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ µ ±MÍ4ÅQºu¾vÇ
²u´M¹PÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ð0·z¿ZÅx»¼˜¹½µ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ ¹3¸9Ð ¾,²"¾,Å]ºu¹ È
¿nÀM±o¿M¸,±oÁ ×v»…¶—µ ±oÁ ¹P²u´M¹º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ Év¹×̶x²uºuµ ±Mͪ'Ñ &* )õ (.&* (.&* û=Õ
Á ¾n¿n¹>¶²u´M¹"¶u¸,Ǎ¹·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ã¸v¶'Ñ &* ôM)õ (.&* ôvô (.&* ôvôvô=Õfڅàk¾
Á ¾v·H¹¼]µ ²u´U²u´Mµ‡¶ºu¹>¿nÀM±o¿M¸,±oÁ ×v»•µ ±o¶x²u¹>¸v¿Ì¾,ÅÔ¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ µ ±Mͪiz,\ n
ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±M͍ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶•ÅQºu¾vÇñ¸"±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ðz·z¿ZÅx»M¼˜¹4·Mºu¾v·H¾=¶—¹!²u¾e"r ²u´M¹ÇØÀo¶—µ ±MÍWÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º>Úï!±MÐ ×"Á ¾vÇÞMµ ±o¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶¾,ÅH²u´M¹µ ±Mµ ²uµ‡¸,Ð
¶x²uºuµ ±MÍ=¶]¸,ºu¹!²u´M¹ºu¹ÞZ×½Ív¹±M¹º’¸Y²u¹>¿%
» xÀo¶x²!¸v¶…µ‡¶]¿n¾v±M¹µ ±BÒÔÓ!¶Ú
à…´M¹9¼…¸S׳µ ±ª¼]´Mµ‡Á’´ªÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹ºµ‡¶½¿n¾v±M¹v»˜¿n¹ ²u¹ºuǍµ ±M¹>¶²u´M¹
º’¸Y²u¹9¾,Ŷ—ÀoÁÁ ¹>¶u¶Ú.æµ º’¶x²>»…¼˜¹B±M¾,²u¹²u´o¸Y²ãr üƲu´M¹BÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ
ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶]¸,ºu¹4¹ åMÁ’´o¸,±MÍv¹>¿½ÞH¹ ²x¼˜¹¹±·o¸,ºu¹±=²’¶…¸v¶]¸"¼]´M¾vÐ ¹v»n²u´M¹
µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±"µ‡¶Çµ ån¹>¿"µ ±"²u´M¹]Ǎ¾=¶x²¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²0Ǎµ ånµ ±MÍÇh¸,±nÈ
±M¹º>»ßºu¹>¶—¾vÐ ËZµ ±MÍ3²u´M¹hºu¹>¿nÀM±o¿M¸,±oÁ ×B·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹ÇÚ ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»z¾v±
ÞH¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹´o¸,±o¿9¼˜¹Ív¹±M¹º’¸,РР׿n¾v±, ²4ÉZ±M¾Y¼ ²u´M¹"Ð ¾nÁ¸Y²uµ ¾v±B¸,±o¿
¶—µ ݹW¾,Ųu´M¹ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ3ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶Ú]à…´Mµ‡¶µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±9µ‡¶!Á¸,Ð Ð ¹>¿
p rsintv+g =\rsi>ü cY`fehgY^}rXcYioژàk¾"îo±o¿3²u´Mµ‡¶]µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»n¼˜¹ºu¹Ð ×
¾v±ª²u´M¹ãºu¹Çh¸,µ ±o¿n¹º½¾,ÅÔ²u´M¹ã°xÙÄkÓ ÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉK²u¾³îo±o¿Æ¸
¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹²u´o¸Y²Á ¾v±=²’¸,µ ±o¶4²u´Mµ‡¶Ð µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹hµ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚ3æM¾vº
µ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹v»=µ Å%¼˜¹´o¸SËv¹¸,±hÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐMÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»,¼˜¹
¸,ºu¹"Ívµ Ëv¹±ãÍvºu¾vÀM·o¶4¾,Řº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇÉv¹×n¶!²u´o¸Y²¶—´M¾vÀMЇ¿ãÞH¹·Mºu¾,È
Á ¹>¶u¶—¹>¿ªµ ±¸³ÇÀMÐ ²uµ ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹ x¾vµ ±=²3·z¿ZÅxÚØà…´M¹ºu¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹v»˜²u´M¹>¶—¹
º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇÊÉv¹×n¶…¶—´M¾vÀMЇ¿PÞH¹·Mºu¾nÁ ¹>¶u¶—¹>¿h²u¾vÍv¹ ²u´M¹º¸v¶]¸ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’ÉzÚ
Û(¹"´M¾v·H¹²u´o¸Y²4²u´M¹>¶—¹"ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶4¸,ºu¹"¸½Ív¾Z¾n¿B¸,·M·Mºu¾Sånµ Çh¸Y²uµ ¾v±
¾,Ųu´M¹Ô²uºuÀM¹ÔÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍhÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶…µ ±P²u´M¹·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹ÇÚ
˜¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹•Á ¾v·Z×Zµ ±MÍ!¸]ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’É4²u¾]²u´M¹˜¾,á%¶—·Mºuµ ±MÍo»>¹>¸vÁ’´ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’ÉÔÇh¸S×
ÞH¹P²uº’¸,±o¶xÅQ¾vºuǍ¹>¿KÀo¶—µ ±MÍD¸ãÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v± nÑm„ ÕfÚÆà…´Mµ‡¶"ÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±
ºu¹>¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹>¶²u´M¹!º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇØÉv¹×n¶²u¾"¸W¶—ÀMÞMµ ±=²u¹ºuËY¸,Ðo¾,ŕó &(õ úH¼]µ ²u´
·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x× YÚ³°€Å!¼˜¹3ÅQ¾vº"µ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹P¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹('Ñ &* )õ (.&* (.&* û=Õ
²u¾³ó &* ô (.&* ô=÷Sú€»%¼˜¹Ív¹ ²½'Ñ &* ô (.&* ô v÷ (.&* ô=÷vÕfÚ ¾,²u¹"²u´o¸Y²²u´Mµ‡¶
¿n¾Z¹>¶—±, ²4Á’´o¸,±MÍv¹4²u´M¹W·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±²u´o¸Y²!µ‡¶]¹±oÁ ¾n¿n¹>¿%Ú…à…´M¹
¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±K·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç Á¸,±Kºu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹3¸Bºu¹Ð‡¸Y²uµ Ëv¹½¾vº’¿n¹ºuµ ±MÍ
¾,Ųu´M¹ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ3ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶Ú…ÛƵ ²u´M¾vÀn²Ôºu¹>¶uÁ¸,Ð µ ±MÍo»M¼˜¹W´o¸SËv¹Ô²u¾
ºu¹Ð ×¾v±B²u´M¹º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ Év¹×9Á ¾vÇÞMµ ±o¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶²u´o¸Y²¸,ºu¹Ív¹±M¹º—È
¸Y²u¹>¿hµ ±Mµ ²uµ‡¸,Ð Ð ×vÚ ]¹>¶uÁ¸,Ð µ ±MͲu´M¹4ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶0µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶²u´M¹!·Mºu¾vÞnÈ
¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²xײu´o¸Y²0²u´M¹×"¼]µ Ð ÐoÞH¹!Á ¾vÇÞMµ ±M¹>¿·Mºu¾v·H¹ºuÐ ×vÚàk¾W¹±o¶—ÀMºu¹
¸hЇ¸,ºuÍv¹Ô¹±M¾vÀMÍv´B¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²¾,ŵ ±=²u¹ºuËY¸,Ї¶!¶—¾²u´o¸Y²²u´M¹ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶
²u´M¹Çh¶—¹Ð Ëv¹>¶]Á¸,±PÞH¹¾vº’¿n¹ºu¹>¿%»n¼˜¹¶—¹ ²…²u´Mµ‡¶¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²…²u¾ -xÚ
Û(¹˜Á¸,Ð ÐY²u´M¹0ÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉ]ÅQ¾vºß²u´M¹0ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±MÍ!¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶HÂ=Ã0Ä
ÑQ°xÙÄkÓ fhi Ymol’\ kyZ`ucYehcSdcYeh\ ˜p \ eh\ io^Xod l’yMgYAi =\ `,ÕfÚ
°€²’¶h¿n¹ îo±Mµ ²uµ ¾v±ª¹>ÿ=Ào¸,Ї¶²u´o¸Y²½¾,Å!²u´M¹9°xÙÄkÓW»¼]µ ²u´U²u´M¹9¹ åZÈ
Á ¹·n²uµ ¾v±h¾,Åz²u´M¹4Á ºu¹>¸Y²uµ ¾v±¾,Å%¾,á%¶—·Mºuµ ±MÍoÚ°_±hÂvÃ0Äz»H²u´Mµ‡¶•µ‡¶0±M¾,²
¿n¾v±M¹!ÞZ×h¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ µ ±MÍo»=ÞMÀn²…ÞZ׍º’¸,±o¿n¾vǍР׍¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ±MÍW²x¼˜¾W·o¸,º—È
¹±=²’¶ßÅQºu¾vÇ.²u´M¹˜¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿W¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶k¸,±o¿WÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—µ ±M;YËv¹ºßÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶
µ ±U²u´M¹B¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±o¶ÚÆÛÆ´Mµ‡Á’´ªÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶¼˜¹9¸vÁf²uÀo¸,Ð Ð ×Ì·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇ
Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º0¼]µ ²u´ß»nµ‡¶˜¿n¹ ²u¹ºuǍµ ±M¹>¿3ÞZ×"²u´M¹4²x×Z·H¹4¾,ÅßÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±ßÚBòZµ ±oÁ ¹h²u´M¹½ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±MÍB¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇ Ào¶—¹>¶Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º>»%µ ²
Á¸,±WËY¸,Ð µ‡¿nÐ ×ÔÞH¹˜¸,ºuÍvÀM¹>¿4²u´o¸Y²¼˜¹•´o¸SËv¹0¿n¹>¶—µ Ív±M¹>¿W¸!ÒÔÓWÚYà…´M¹
¶—·H¹>Á µ‡¸,Ð ²x×P¾,Ųu´Mµ‡¶ÒÔÓϵ‡¶²u´o¸Y²4µ ²¸Y²—²u¹Ç·n²’¶²u¾3Ð ¹>¸,ºu±9Ð µ ±MÉ=È
¸,Ív¹4µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±3ÅQ¾vº]·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶]¸,±o¿PÀo¶—¹4²u´Mµ‡¶]Ð µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹
µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±"µ ±h¸4Ð µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹…·Mºu¹>¶—¹ºuËZµ ±MÍÔÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º¾v·H¹º’¸Y²u¾vº>Ú
ÂvÃ0Ä
õ +=WwÑ cB&()õ (+*+*+*( eEf Ohg/U>õ dYÕ
N@WwÑ cB&()õ (+*+*+*( eEf Ohgq/³>õ d–/~c
+=>dYÕ
û !2 "2 #$%&5'/ ()#2,+Ñ *SÕ
ö ,/.0 ƒ/ &213.o€ S€N/Uõ 4.
öoÚ 5õ 6WwÑ c
+=)(7
N@zdYÕ
öoÚ 8,/.0‘9 &913.€ H€B/U6õ 4.
öoÚ nÚ :
õ .,;,p‡ <= ˆ?> @nїÑ3. A
BDCZÕ ‡ <= ˆ?> Õ
÷ 6$FEG7Ñ .,;,0Õ
8
H I ¯%Kí JÔ¯¯z­MꕫZ«=ê L ­ªê ­M®¬nê0­o«Kí é V
!¸SËZµ ±M͵ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ ¹>¿ã²u´M¹hÂvÃ0ÄUÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉz»%¼˜¹²u¹>¶x²µ ²W¾v±
²u´M¹9¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹P·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±KÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±o¶ÚÌæµ º’¶x²´M¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»
¼˜¹¹Ð‡¸,ÞH¾vº’¸Y²u¹¾v±½´M¾Y¼ª¼˜¹´o¸SËv¹!¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿²u´M¹!ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶²u¾ÞH¹
Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¹>¿½¾YËv¹º…µ ±¾vÀMº]¹ ån·H¹ºuµ Ǎ¹±=²’¶Ú
NW?YFHG>G>'F PH;=?PRF Q•;=?YJn<>Fo?YG
M AO
Õ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð=ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶¸,Ð Ð ¾Y¼³ÅQ¾vºÇ¾vºu¹…·Mºu¹>Á µ‡¶—¹˜·Mºu¾vÞnÈ
¸,ÞMµ Ð µ‡¶x²uµ‡ÁǍ¾n¿n¹Ð Ð µ ±MÍ6ÞH¹>Á¸,Ào¶—¹ÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐPÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±o¶kÁ¸,±WÞH¹•¹ ån·Mºu¹>¶u¶—¹>¿4Ào¶—µ ±MÍ4Á ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð,ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶»
ÞMÀn²±M¾,²ËZµ‡Á ¹Ëv¹º’¶u¸MÚà…´M¹ºu¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹v»nµ ²µ‡¶]µ ±=²u¹ºu¹>¶x²uµ ±MÍ"²u¾hÞo¸v¶—¹
Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º•¾v·H¹º’¸Y²u¾vº’¶˜¾v±PÞH¾,²u´P²x×Z·H¹>¶]¾,ÅkÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú
SPLvFHLOQ<>OXFHLJ V" U#"XF>RUIK+O WßOXL
M AHAT
˜×BÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—µ ±MÍ3¾YËv¹º²u´M¹º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇÉv¹×n¶!Þo¸v¶—¹>¿B¾v±B²u´M¹±M¾n¿n¹
Ëv¹>Áf²u¾vº {˜»¼˜¹ã¸Y²—²u¹Ç·n²3²u¾U¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×U¹ åMÁ’´o¸,±MÍv¹B¸,±o¿ÆÇµ å
²u´M¹3µ Ǎ·H¾vº—²’¸,±=²ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶W¾,ŵ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚBà…´Mµ‡¶ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶Wµ ±
¸,±¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´P¶—µ Ǎµ Ї¸,º…²u¾"²u´M¹Wä…Ã…ÒÔÓ ÞZ× !¸,ºuµ Éãó ôYú€Ú
!2 "2 #$%&5'/ ()#2,'Ñ {Õ
õ 6$FEG'Ñ {Õ
X
NFHLOQ<>OXFHLJ V" UZQ•FHG>OQ<>OXFHL9OXJMG>;'ªTW: [
M AHAY
àk¾PÀo¶—¹Á ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶»z¼˜¹"Ð ¹>¸,ºu±(¸PÁ’´o¸,µ ±ã¾,Å
¿n¹·H¹±o¿n¹±oÁ µ ¹>¶kµ ±W¼]´Mµ‡Á’´º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ.Év¹×n¶%²u´o¸Y²¸,ºu¹µ Ǎ·H¾vº—²’¸,±=²
²u¾vÍv¹ ²u´M¹º>»v¸,ºu¹…·MЇ¸vÁ ¹>¿Á Ð ¾=¶—¹˜²u¾¹>¸vÁ’´"¾,²u´M¹º>ÚòZÀMÞo¶—¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±=²uÐ ×v»
¼˜¹•Á¸,±¸,·M·MÐ ×!ÅQ¾vºµ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹²x¼˜¾·H¾vµ ±=²Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹º%¶—ÀoÁ’´²u´o¸Y²
²u´M¹Ð µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±µ ±h²u´M¹!Á’´o¸,µ ±hµ‡¶0ºu¹>¶—·H¹>Áf²u¹>¿%Úà…´Mµ‡¶
¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´³¼…¸v¶"ºu¹>Á ¾vÍv±Mµ ݹ>¿³¹>¸,ºuÐ µ ¹ºó ûSú]²u¾(ÞH¹µ ±=²u¹ºu¹>¶x²uµ ±MÍ
ÅQ¾vºh·Mºu¾nÁ ¹>¶u¶—µ ±MÍ(Ð µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚÆàk¾(îo±o¿ª¸³Á’´o¸,µ ±ß»
1e+007
AIC
BIC
Perfect mixing
Gaussian entropy
Permutation entropy
Fixed chain
Permutation IDEA
Average amount of evaluations
1e+006
100000
10000
æµ ÍvÀMºu¹W÷D*ÓǍ¾vÀM±=²¾,ŹËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶˜ÅQ¾vº…ÂvÃ0Äz»b-))o$÷nÚ
1000
1
2
3
4
5
6
Amount of building blocks
7
8
9
10
100000
AIC
BIC
Perfect mixing
Gaussian entropy
Permutation entropy
Fixed chain
Permutation IDEA
n
10000
1000
æ µ ÍvÀMºu¹ø * ]¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹>¿P·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v±¶—µ ݹ4ÅQ¾vº…Â=Ã0Äz»b-))o$Ö÷nÚ
²u´M¹DÍvºu¹¹>¿nת¹±=²uºu¾v·Zׯ¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇ µ ±5[9°m[9°uà ó SúÁ¸,±ÞH¹
Ào¶—¹>¿%Ú…à…´M¹¹±=²uºu¾v·Z×v»M¼]´Mµ‡Á’´9¹>ÿ=Ào¸,Ї¶…²u´M¹W¸SËv¹º’¸,Ív¹4±M¹Í=¸Y²uµ Ëv¹
Ð ¾vNÍ 2ZÐ µ Év¹Ð µ ´M¾Z¾n¿³ÅQ¾vº½±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ð]·z¿ZÅX¶ãó øYú€»]Á¸,±UÞH¹ãÁ ¾vǍ·MÀn²u¹>¿
Ào¶—µ ±M͍²u´M¹W±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ðß·z¿ZÅ0¸v¶]¼˜¹´o¸SËv¹¿n¾v±M¹ÅQ¾vº!¸,Ð ÐkÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀnÈ
¾vÀo¶]°xÙÄßÓ4¶»kÞMÀn²!¼˜¹Á¸,±9¸,Ї¶—¾Ào¶—¹·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±¹±=²uºu¾v·Z×vÚ
à…´Mµ‡¶¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²’¶¹>¸vÁ’´W²uµ Ǎ¹˜²u¾4îo±o¿nµ ±MÍ4²u´M¹…ÀM±o¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿±M¾n¿n¹
IJH b@²u´o¸Y²¾nÁÁ ÀMº’¶ßǍ¾vºu¹0¾,Ås²u¹±Wµ ±¾v±M¹•¾vº’¿n¹ºuµ ±Mͅ²u´o¸,±Wµ ±W²u´M¹
¾,²u´M¹º0¼]kµ ²u´hºu¹>¶—·H¹>Áf²²u¾Ô²u´M¹k Ї¸v¶x²uÐ ×"¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿±M¾n¿n¹ IJH•ÑQÇh¸YåZÈ
µ Ǎµ ÝV¹ € Qh'Ñ IJH E IJH b@pÕ / Qh'Ñ IJH b@ E IJH€+Õ € ÕfÚhà…´M¹ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²uµ ±MÍ
ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶˜²u¾ÞH¹¹ åMÁ’´o¸,±MÍv¹>¿%»MÁ¸,±P±M¾Y¼ÞH¹ÔÅQ¾vÀM±o¿¸v¶˜ÅQ¾vÐ Ð ¾Y¼¶:*
!2 "2 #$%&5'/ ()#2,ї7Ñ ‚(?’Õ—Õ
õ +=WwÑ cB&()õ (+*+*+*(.-wdYÕ
N@WwÑ cB&()õ (+*+*+*(.-wdYÕ
û , N@ +=1
ûMÚ 5õ += N@
ö 6$FEGїїEÑ ”b=(m”;@B(+*+*+*,(m”p‡ œ,D0@mˆ Õ (
EÑ ” œ>(m”p‡ œb@mˆ (+*+*+*,(m”p‡ š D0@mˆ Õ (
EÑ ” š (m”p‡ š b@mˆ (+*+*+*,(m”bCED0@ ՗՗Õ
3;ZG "Q<>G
M A
ÂvÃ0Ä9Ívµ Ëv¹>¶0¶—µ Ív±Mµ îHÁ¸,±=²uÐ ×"ÞH¹ ²—²u¹º˜ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶!ÑsîoÍvÀMºu¹>¶˜÷¸,±o¿hø=ÕfÚ
ÓÐ Ð4²u¹>¶x²u¹>¿Ö¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶»¼]µ ²u´Æ²u´M¹(¹ åMÁ ¹·n²uµ ¾v±Ö¾,ÅÀM±oÁ ¾v±nÈ
¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ð!ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶½µ ±.Á ¾vÇÞMµ ±o¸Y²uµ ¾v±Æ¼]µ ²u´Ö²u´M¹DÓ°uÃ
Ǎ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á,»•¼˜¹ºu¹¸,ÞMÐ ¹P²u¾³¶—¾vÐ Ëv¹¸,РИ²u¹>¶x²u¹>¿U·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶"ÀM·Ì²u¾
O)•
) $+zõ &9ÅQ¾vSº -)•
) $ ÷n»0¼]µ ²u´Ì·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ì¶—µ ݹ>¶PÑQ¼˜¹Ð ÐsÕ
ÞH¹Ð ¾Y¼Êõ „Zzõ & ÚWà…´M¹"¹±=²uºu×¾,Å0²u´M¹"·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ã°xÙÄkÓ𵇶
¹ ån·MЇ¸,µ ±M¹>¿hµ ±3¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v± MÚ ˜¹>Á¸,Ào¶—¹]²u´M¹4¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹!·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç
100
1
2
3
4
5
6
Amount of building blocks
7
8
9
10
µ‡¶ÔÞH¹ ²—²u¹ºW¶—¹·o¸,º’¸,ÞMÐ ¹"µ Ř²u´M¹h¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±(·Mºu¹>¶u¶—ÀMºu¹"µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶»
µ ²¼…¸v¶4¸,Í=¸,µ ±B¾vÞo¶—¹ºuËv¹>¿²u´o¸Y²Ô²u´M¹"·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇh¸,±oÁ ¹"µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶
µ Å f ¿n¹>Á ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶!ÅQ¾vº¸3îMån¹>¿ eEf Ohghµ ±D¸¶—µ Ǎµ Ї¸,º4ÅX¸v¶—´Mµ ¾v±D¸v¶
¾vÞo¶—¹ºuËv¹>¿hÅQ¾vºÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶…°xÙÄßÓ4¶½ÑsîoÍvÀMºu¹>¶]û¸,±o¿PöZÕfÚ
òZµ ±oÁ ¹h²u´M¹3Ó°uà Ǎ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á½¿nµ‡¿D±M¾,²W·H¹±o¸,Ð µ ݹh²u´M¹hÐ µ Év¹Ð µ ´M¾Z¾n¿
¹ áz¹>Áf²uµ Ëv¹Ð ×v»0µ ²ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²u¹>¿Kµ ±ÌÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ИÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶
²u´o¸Y²KÁ ¾vÇÞMµ ±M¹>¿6¹±=²uµ ºu¹UÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶ã²u¾ ¶—¾vǍ¹ ²uµ Ǎ¹>¶
ÅQ¾vºuÇð²u´M¹"Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ ²u¹ x¾vµ ±=²!ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»o¼]´Mµ‡Á’´ã¿n¾Z¹>¶±M¾,²
Ð ¹>¸v¿½²u¾h¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²¹ ån·MÐ ¾vº’¸Y²uµ ¾v±3¾,Åk²u´M¹·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±9¶—·o¸vÁ ¹vÚ
°_±²u´Mµ‡¶0Á¸v¶—¹…²u´M¹ºu¹]µ‡¶²u´ZÀo¶•¸Ô·Mºu¹ ÅQ¹ºu¹±oÁ ¹˜ÅQ¾vº²u´M¹ ˜°uóǍ¹ ²—È
ºuµ‡Á,ÚÌÓРи,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´M¹>¶Á¸,±ÌÞH¹¶—¹¹±K²u¾³¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹3ÀM·U·H¾vÐ ×Z±M¾,È
Ǎµ‡¸,Ð Ð ×vÚ ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»S²u´M¹4Á’´o¸,µ ±h¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´M¹>¶²u´o¸Y²˜Ào¶—¹!¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´
Ǎ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á¶¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹•ÀM·"¶—µ Ív±Mµ îHÁ¸,±=²uÐ ×¼˜¾vº’¶—¹vÚkà…´M¹ºu¹•µ‡¶±M¾,²ÇÀoÁ’´
²u¾9Á’´M¾Z¾=¶—¹ÞH¹ ²x¼˜¹¹±ã²u´M¹h±M¾vºuÇh¸,й±=²uºu¾v·Z×¾vº4²u´M¹·H¹ºuÇÀnÈ
²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±K¹±=²uºu¾v·Z×vÚ9°€Å²u´M¹3ºuµ Ív´=²"¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹3µ‡¶WÅQ¾vÀM±o¿ÖÑsîMån¹>¿
Á’´o¸,µ ±HÕf»%²u´M¹ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶Ô¸,ºu¹·Mºu¾v·o¸,Í=¸Y²u¹>¿9¹ áz¹>Áf²uµ Ëv¹Ð ×
Ào¶—µ ±MÍW·H¾=¶—µ ²uµ ¾v±½ÞMµ‡¸v¶—¹>¿hà& Ú ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»,µ ²˜µ‡¶•´o¸,º’¿"²u¾Wîo±o¿
²u´M¹Bºuµ Ív´=²3¶—¹>Á ¾v±o¿ª¾vº’¿n¹ºhÐ µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹Bµ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»]¸v¶²u´M¹>¶—¹
¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´M¹>¶!Á Ð ¹>¸,ºuÐ ×9¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹ÀM·D¸½Ð ¾,²Ô¼˜¾vº’¶—¹WÅQ¾vºÔµ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—µ ±MÍ
O))ÚUÛ(¹BÁ ¾v±oÁ Ð Ào¿n¹µ ±ª¸D¶—µ Ǎµ Ї¸,º"ÅX¸v¶—´Mµ ¾v±ª¸v¶"´o¸v¶ÞH¹¹±
¿n¾v±M¹•ÅQ¾vºÞMµ ±o¸,ºu×W¶—·o¸vÁ ¹>¶˜ó ûYú€»Y²u´o¸Y²îo±o¿nµ ±MÍÔ¸,±o¿Ào¶—µ ±MÍ4Ð ¾Y¼˜¹º
¾vº’¿n¹º!Ð µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹Wµ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±Bµ‡¶!Ð ¹>¶u¶¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²4²u´o¸,±9îo±o¿nµ ±MÍ
¸,±o¿3Ào¶—µ ±MÍh´Mµ Ív´M¹º]¾vº’¿n¹º…Ð µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹Ôµ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚ
æMºu¾vÇð²u´M¹"ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶4¶—´M¾Y¼]±B¶—¾½ÅX¸,º>»Hµ ²¶—¹¹Çh¶²u´o¸Y²4²u´M¹"ÞH¹>¶x²
¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´µ‡¶•²u¾Ào¶—¹4¸,±½ÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐoÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±h¼]µ ²u´
²u´M¹ ˜°uõ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±BÁ ºuµ ²u¹ºuµ ¾v±ßÚ ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»o¼˜¹´o¸SËv¹W±M¾,²
²u¹>¶x²u¹>¿Bµ ²×v¹ ²4¾v±ã·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶!¼]µ ²u´(Á ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,пn¹·H¹±o¿n¹±nÈ
Á µ ¹>¶Úàk¾h²u¹>¶x²!²u´Mµ‡¶»z¸,Ð ¾v±MÍh¼]µ ²u´9²u´M¹µ ± ÀM¹±oÁ ¹¾,ź’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ
ºu¹>¶uÁ¸,Ð µ ±MÍo»¼˜¹´o¸SËv¹Ào¶—¹>¿Ô¸]¿nµ â½Á ÀMÐ ²k·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç
¼]µ ²u´D¾YËv¹ºuЇ¸,·M·Mµ ±MͽÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ9ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶Ú"ÓРо,ŕ²u´M¹hÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ
ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶¸,ºu¹½±M¾Y¼ÊÁ ¾n¿n¹>¿K¶—¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±=²uµ‡¸,Ð Ð ×(µ ±o¶x²u¹>¸v¿³¾,ÅÐ ¾Z¾=¶—¹Ð ×vÚ
æM¾vº O)“
) $+ûD¸,±o¿ -)) $ öo»•²u´M¹Bµ ±o¿nµ ËZµ‡¿nÀo¸,ÐÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍ
ÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶•¸,ºu¹]ÅQ¾vÀM±o¿½¸Y²˜·H¾=¶—µ ²uµ ¾v±o¶!'Ñ &()õ ( (uû=Õf»HÑXû (—Mö (’÷ (uø=Õ¸,±o¿
ÑXø (fAù ( (uô=Õf»ßÍvµ ËZµ ±M|Í -$ zõ &MÚ ¾,²u¹²u´o¸Y²²u´M¹3¶—¾vÐ ¹¾v·n²uµ Çh¸,Ð
¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±9µ‡¶²u´M¹"Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ ²u¹W²uºuµ ËZµ‡¸,зH¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±9¾,Å0Ð ¹±MÍ,²u´
-xÚÛ(¹²u¹>¶x²u¹>¿h²u´M¹Ô¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶0¾v±3¸W·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç¼]µ ²u\´ -0$Æö &M»
Ívµ ËZµ ±M|Í O)G) $)õ>û9¸Y‰² -)G) $ öoÚÛ(¹½²u¹>¶x²u¹>¿D·H¾v·MÀMЇ¸Y²uµ ¾v±
¶—µ ݹ>¶•ÀM·h²uP¾ OV$ zõ &!¸,±o¿½¸,Ð Ð ¾Y¼˜¹>¿ÅQ¾vº…¸WÇh¸Yånµ ÇÀMǾ,Å0zõ &
¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú!à…´M¹Wºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶4¸,ºu¹¶—´M¾Y¼]±9µ ±9îoÍvÀMºu¹ùZÚ°€²4ÞH¹ È
Á ¾vǍ¹>¶WÁ Ð ¹>¸,ºÔ²u´o¸Y²Ào¶—µ ±MÍBÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Е¿n¹·H¹±o¿n¹±oÁ µ ¹>¶Wµ ±³¸
Á’´o¸,µ ±9Á¸,±9ÞH¹W¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²>»o¹>¶—·H¹>Á µ‡¸,Ð Ð ×P¼]´M¹±9º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇñºu¹>¶uÁ¸,Ð È
µ ±M͍µ‡¶…Ào¶—¹>¿%Ú ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»=²u´M¹Ôºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶]¸,Ї¶—¾¶—´M¾Y¼¸,Í=¸,µ ±½²u´o¸Y²
Ð ¹>¸,ºu±Mµ ±MÍ4²u´M¹!Á’´o¸,µ ±"²u¾Ào¶—¹…ÅQ¾vº·H¾=¶—µ ²uµ ¾v±hÞMµ‡¸v¶—¹>¿"à& Ö¿n¾Z¹>¶
±M¾,²"Ð ¹>¸v¿D²u¾B²u´M¹PÞH¹>¶x²ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶Ú(æMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»µ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁfÈ
µ ±MÍ9º’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ)ºu¹>¶uÁ¸,Ð µ ±MÍ vc>\fd½µ Ǎ·Mºu¾YËv¹²u´M¹½ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶¾,Ř²u´M¹
ÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐHÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚà…´M¹4ÞH¹>¶x²]ºu¹·H¾vº—²u¹>¿½ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶
¾,Å]²u´M¹Bï!Ǎ¹SÒÔÓð¸,ºu¹3¸,·M·Mºu¾Sånµ Çh¸Y²u¹Ð × V$ ô * )ø &B¸YÅs²u¹º
)û &)& „,zõ &4¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú
¨ é ê¬ ê é ¬ ­oì é!é í !é ¬M?í «
ÓÐ Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶²u´o¸Y²BÞMÀMµ Ї¿ ¸,±o¿.Ào¶—¹³·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ‡¶x²uµ‡Á(Ǎ¾n¿n¹Ð‡¶
²’¸,Év¹½ÀM·KǍ¾vºu¹h²uµ Ǎ¹P¹Ëv¹ºu×ãµ ²u¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±K¸v¶²u´M¹Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ ånµ ²x×
43
43
5 76
5 76
žž{_{_ŒŒ ¡,¡ œ ¤
"!$#&%'(
)+*
,
,
- *
- ./ - -
f¡ ¤ ¡
f ,¡,œ œ£
0 12 *
) .
/*
) ,
*
-8- -)
* -
S Y>œ ¡ œ
"!$#&%'(
¦¦ ¡,¡ œ ¤ ¢ ¤¤ YYœœ >¡£
£,£,œœ ¢,
zz{{ ¡,¡ œ ¤ ¡ ¤ f£,>œœ ¡>¡ ¡,,Yœ ¡9œ ¢,£
æµ ÍvÀMºu¹!ù'* ]¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶¾v±²u´M¹]¾YËv¹ºuЇ¸,·M·Mµ ±MÍ4¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹…·H¹ºuÇÀnÈ
²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±³·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çb» -)Z) $ öob» O)Z) $õ>ûM»˜'Ñ -$ ö &M» !Zä $
±M¾vºuÇh¸,Ð%·z¿Zʱ=²uºu¾v·Z×v»Mæ° G$.îMån¹>¿P¾v·n²uµ Çh¸,ÐßÁ’´o¸,µ ±HÕfÚ
1
Scaled results
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
n / 20000
Evaluations / 250000
Seconds scaled to [0,1]
æ µ ÍvÀMºu¹ *ÂvÃ0Ä%»}-))o$÷n»O))o$ õz&M»%õz&)& ¶—ÀoÁÁ ¹>¶u¶—º’¸Y²u¹vÚ
¾,Ҳu´M¹3Ǎ¾n¿n¹Ð‡¶Wµ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶ÚP°€²µ‡¶²u´M¹ºu¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹hµ Ǎ·H¾vº—²’¸,±=²W²u¾
ÞH¹P¸S¼…¸,ºu¹¾,Ҳu´M¹½ºuÀM±M±Mµ ±MÍ9²uµ Ǎ¹3±M¹ åZ²W²u¾9²u´M¹3¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²¾,Å
ÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±Æ¹ËY¸,Ð Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶ÚÖ°€ÅÔ¼˜¹9´o¸SËv¹9¸DËv¹ºu×ÌÁ ¾=¶x²uÐ ×̹ËY¸,Ð È
Ào¸Y²uµ ¾v±(ÅQÀM±oÁf²uµ ¾v±ß»k²u´Mµ‡¶Wµ‡¶¾,ŅР¹>¶u¶µ Ǎ·H¾vº—²’¸,±oÁ ¹vÚ ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»
²u´M¹ºu¹4¸,ºu¹]·MÐ ¹±=²x׍·Mº’¸vÁf²uµ‡Á¸,ÐM¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±½·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶»=¶—ÀoÁ’´
¸v¶…ÉZ±o¸,·o¶u¸vÁ’Éh¸,±o¿½²uº’¸SËv¹Ð µ ±M͍¶u¸,Ð ¹>¶—Çh¸,±ß»=²u´o¸Y²Á¸,±PÞH¹¹ËY¸,Ð È
Ào¸Y²u¹>¿K¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²uÐ ×K¸,±o¿K¹>¸v¶—µ Ð ×Dºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²µ ±U¸ãËv¹ºu×DЇ¸,ºuÍv¹3¿nµ È
Ǎ¹±o¶—µ ¾v±o¸,Ð µ ²x× -xژòZµ ±oÁ ¹Ô²u´M¹Ð ¹>¸,ºu±Mµ ±M͍¾,Å´Mµ Ív´M¹º]¾vº’¿n¹º…ÅX¸vÁfÈ
²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶¾,Ås²u¹±Ö¶uÁ¸,Ð ¹>¶h¸v¶ ½'Ñ -:>Õf»]¹ ån·MÐ ¾vµ ²uµ ±Mͳ·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç
¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹hÞZ×ãÐ ¹>¸,ºu±Mµ ±MÍPÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ô¼]µ Ð Ð0±M¾,²ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²Wµ ±
ÅX¸v¶x²!¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶…¸vq¶ -µ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶Ú
°_± ²u´Mµ‡¶ã·o¸,·H¹º>»W¼˜¹K´o¸SËv¹³Ào¶—¹>¿.²u´M¹ÌºuÀMÐ ¹K¾,ō²u´ZÀMÇÞ ÞZ×
[ÀM´MÐ ¹±ZÞH¹µ ±D¸,±o¿ [B¸,´M±Mµ ÍDó õö,úÅQ¾vºæÙÓWÚ ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»H²u´Mµ‡¶
ºuÀMÐ ¹Ø¾,Å̲u´ZÀMÇÞ+µ‡¶.Þo¸v¶—¹>¿)¾v±+¾vÞo¶—¹ºuËY¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ö¾v±+±M¾vA± 2
¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹½ÞMµ ±o¸,ºu×(·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Ú9æMÀMº—²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»k²u´M¹3¹Ð µ ²uµ‡¶—Ç
µ ±ãæÙÓϵ‡¶ºu¹>¶x²uºuµ‡Áf²u¹>¿3²u¾h²u´M¹"¶—µ ±MÍvÐ ¹WÞH¹>¶x²Ô¶—¾vÐ Àn²uµ ¾v±¾,Ųu´M¹
·Mºu¹ËZµ ¾vÀo¶!Ív¹±M¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚ°_±ãîoÍvÀMºu¹ M»%¼˜¹"´o¸SËv¹·MÐ ¾,²—²u¹>¿B²u´M¹
Ǎ¾=¶x²ß¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²kºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²k¾,Å=ÂvÃ0čÀo¶—µ ±MÍ]²u´M¹ ˜°uÃB¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´4Ǎ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á
¾vf ±(ÀM±oÁ ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶!ÅQ¾vºW¿nµ áz¹ºu¹±=²WËY¸,Ð ÀM¹>¶Ô¾,Å
¼]´M¹±3¹>¸vÁ’´½¾,Å)û &µ ±o¿n¹·H¹±o¿n¹±=²]ºuÀM±o¶•ºu¹>¸vÁ’´M¹>¿h¸,Ð ÐzÞMÀMµ Ї¿ZÈ
µ ±MÍãÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶Á ¾vºuºu¹>Áf²>Ú9ÛÆ´M¹±K¾v±MÐ ×ã²u´M¹P¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²"¾,ŹËY¸,Ð ÀnÈ
¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶4¾vºÔ²u´M¹h¸vÁf²uÀo¸,Ð0Á ¾vǍ·MÐ ¹ ²u¹ºuÀM±M±Mµ ±MÍP²uµ Ǎ¹hµ‡¶Ôµ Ǎ·H¾vº—È
²’¸,±=²>» f $&* ûµ‡¶Á Ð ¹>¸,ºuÐ ×½±M¾,²¾v·n²uµ Çh¸,Ð}ژòZµ ±oÁ ¹²u´M¹W¶—¹·o¸,º’¸YÈ
ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×h¾,Åß²u´M¹¿n¹>Á ¹·n²uµ Ëv¹4·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç ÞH¹>Á ¾vǍ¹>¶•¹>¸v¶—µ ¹º˜¼]´M¹±P¸
Ívºu¹>¸Y²u¹º¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±·Mºu¹>¶u¶—ÀMºu¹0µ‡¶¸,·M·MÐ µ ¹>¿%»>²u´Mµ‡¶µ‡¶k±M¾,²¶—ÀMºu·Mºuµ‡¶xÈ
µ ±MÍoÚæM¾vºß²u´M¹•ÞH¹>¶x²Ç¹Ç¾vºu)× 2nÁ ¾vǍ·MÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±4²uµ Ǎ¹0²uº’¸v¿n¹ 2Z¾,á»
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Tau
0.3
0.35
0.4
f Žó &* õS÷(.&* v÷Sú¶—¹¹Çh¶!²u¾9ÞH¹h¸,±(¹ áz¹>Áf²uµ Ëv¹hÁ’´M¾vµ‡Á ¹vڽÕ¾v±nÈ
Á Ð Ào¿nµ ±MÍo»o¼˜¹¶—ÀMÍvÍv¹>¶x²…ÅQºu¾vÇð¹Ç·Mµ ºuµ‡Á¸,Ðß¾vÞo¶—¹ºuËv¹ºuËY¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶•²u¾
Ào¶—¹ f U &* v÷Wµ ±PÅQÀn²uÀMºu¹¹ ån·H¹ºuµ Ǎ¹±=²’¶Ú
;
헫Z¯%ì!«Z«Zíxê é ® é ë f ì]¬Mì­ ­ « ®­o¯ _° ±ª²u´Mµ‡¶½·o¸,·H¹º>»…¼˜¹9´o¸SËv¹9Ào¶—¹>¿ª·H¹±o¸,Ð µ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ªÇ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á¶²u¾
ÍvÀMµ‡¿n¹B²u´M¹D¶—¹>¸,º’Á’´ªÅQ¾vºP¸KÍv¾Z¾n¿ªÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚ6à…´M¹D¿nµ ÅsÈ
îHÁ ÀMÐ ²xׯ¼]µ ²u´ ¶—ÀoÁ’´.¸,±.¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´Öµ‡¶Á’´M¾Z¾=¶—µ ±MÍK²u´M¹Dºuµ Ív´=²
¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²W¾,Ņºu¹ÍvÀMЇ¸,ºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚhà…´M¹½¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²W¾,Ņºu¹ÍvÀMЇ¸,ºuµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±Á¸,±"ÞH¹¶—¹¹±¸v¶¸4·o¸,º’¸,Ǎ¹ ²u¹º²u´o¸Y²0¿n¹ îo±M¹>¶´M¾Y¼KÇÀoÁ’´
²uµ Ǎ¹˜²u´M¹]¸,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇ µ‡¶¸,Ð Ð ¾Y¼˜¹>¿Ô²u¾Ô¶—·H¹±o¿"¾v±Ç¾n¿n¹ÐnÞMÀMµ Ї¿ZÈ
µ ±MÍoÚ°_±½¸Ô¼…¸S×v»Y²u´Mµ‡¶0µ‡¶0¸¶—ÀMÞo¶x²uµ ²uÀn²u¹]ÅQ¾vº0Ð µ Ǎµ ²uµ ±MͲu´M¹Çh¸YåZÈ
µ ÇÀMǾvº’¿n¹º¾,Åßµ ±=²u¹º’¸vÁf²uµ ¾v±o¶µ ±²u´M¹ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú ¾Y¼…È
¹Ëv¹º>»vÀo¶—µ ±M͸Ǎ¹ ²uºuµ‡Á]µ ±½¸v¿M¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±½µ ± ÀM¹±oÁ ¹>¶²u´M¹4¿n¹>Á µ‡¶—µ ¾v±
¾,Å%¼]´Mµ‡Á’´¾v·H¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶¾v±"²u´M¹]ÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±¸,ºu¹]ÞH¹±M¹ îHÁ µ‡¸,Ð}Ú
òZ¹¹±Dµ ±D²u´Mµ‡¶¼…¸S×v»k¸·H¹±o¸,Ð µ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±DǍ¹ ²uºuµ‡Áµ‡¶¸·Mº’¸vÁf²uµ‡Á¸,Ð
¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´h²u¾hÀo¶—µ ±MÍ"¹ åM¸vÁf²¶x²’¸Y²uµ‡¶x²uµ‡Á¸,Ð%´Z×Z·H¾,²u´M¹>¶—µ‡¶˜²u¹>¶x²’¶˜²u¾
¿n¹ ²u¹ºuǍµ ±M¹¼]´M¹ ²u´M¹ºÔ¶—¾vǍ¹W¾v·H¹º’¸Y²uµ ¾v±9µ‡¶]²uºuÀMÐ ×ÞH¹±M¹ îHÁ µ‡¸,Ð}Ú
ä0Ëv¹±ã²u´M¾vÀMÍv´ã²u´M¹hÀo¶—¹h¾,Ҷx²’¸Y²uµ‡¶x²uµ‡Á¸,дZ×Z·H¾,²u´M¹>¶—µ‡¶Ô²u¹>¶x²’¶Ôµ‡¶
¹ åM¸vÁf²>»,µ ²•µ‡¶0¸,Ї¶—¾4¾,ÅzÐ ¹>¶u¶·Mº’¸vÁf²uµ‡Á¸,ÐnÀo¶—¹…ÞH¹>Á¸,Ào¶—¹]¾,Åzµ ²’¶0Á ¾vÇ"È
·MÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ðvºu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹Ç¹±=²’¶•ó øYú€Úà…´M¹ºu¹ ÅQ¾vºu¹v»>µ ²µ‡¶ß·Mº’¸vÁf²uµ‡Á¸,Ð Ð ×
Ǎ¾vºu¹4µ ±=²u¹ºu¹>¶x²uµ ±MͲu¾Ào¶—¹¸Ç¹ ²uºuµ‡ÁÔ¸v¶…¸,±¸,·M·Mºu¾Sånµ Çh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚ
ò=²uµ Ð Ð}»Mµ ²!¶—´M¾vÀMЇ¿3ÞH¹Ô±M¾,²u¹>¿3²u´o¸Y²¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²uµ ±MÍ"²u´M¹W¶—¹ ²—²uµ ±MÍ=¶˜ÅQ¾vº
¶—ÀoÁ’´¸"Ǎ¹ ²uºuµ‡ÁÔµ‡¶]¸,Ð ¼…¸S×n¶…¶—ÀMÞ x¹>Áf²]²u¾Ào¶—¹º]¹ ån·H¹ºuµ ¹±oÁ ¹vÚ
Û(¹D±M¾,²u¹ã²u´o¸Y²µ ±Ö²u´Mµ‡¶·o¸,·H¹º¼˜¹ã´o¸SËv¹ã¾v±MÐ ×ÆºuÀM±Ö²u¹>¶x²’¶
¾YËv¹º4¸½Ð µ Ǎµ ²u¹>¿(¸,Ǎ¾vÀM±=²4¾,ŕ·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶ÚÔä0Ëv¹±9²u´M¾vÀMÍv´B²u´M¹
ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶¸,ºu¹…¹±oÁ ¾vÀMº’¸,Ívµ ±MÍo»YËv¹ºuµ îHÁ¸Y²uµ ¾v±"¾v±"¾,²u´M¹º0·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶
µ‡¶Ô¿n¹>¶—µ ºu¹>¿%Ú°€²¼˜¾vÀMЇ¿9ÅQ¾vº4µ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹"ÞH¹µ ±=²u¹ºu¹>¶x²uµ ±Mͽ²u¾¶—¹¹
´M¾Y¼ðÂ=Ã0Äϸ,Ð Ív¾vºuµ ²u´MÇh¶½·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇ2¾v±Öºu¹>¸,Ð!Ð µ ÅQ¹D¶uÁ’´M¹>¿nÀMÐ µ ±MÍ
·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶]¸v¶…¾v·M·H¾=¶—¹>¿½²u¾¾,²u´M¹ºä•Ó ¸,·M·Mºu¾=¸vÁ’´M¹>¶Ú
à…´M¹•ÂvÃ0ĽÅQº’¸,Ǎ¹¼˜¾vºuÉ4´o¸v¶·H¾vµ ±=²u¹>¿W¾vÀn²²u´o¸Y²¹ áz¹>Áf²uµ Ëv¹…ä•Ó!¶
ÅQ¾vº·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±W·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶kÁ¸,±WÞH¹…Á ¾v±o¶x²uºuÀoÁf²u¹>¿µ Åo¼˜¹0îo±o¿
¸,±o¿PÀo¶—¹WÐ µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±µ ±²u´M¹W·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±9¶—·o¸vÁ ¹
¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×vÚÆòZµ ±oÁ ¹BÁ ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹ºW¾v±U·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶µ‡¶Ào¶—¹>¿Ìµ ±
ÂvÃ0Ä%»²u´Mµ‡¶Ôµ‡¶Ô¹ËZµ‡¿n¹±oÁ ¹"²u´o¸Y²¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²Ô°xÙÄkÓ!¶½Á¸,±ãÞH¹h¿n¹ È
¶—µ Ív±M¹>¿"ÞZ×"Çh¸,ÉZµ ±MÍÔ²u´M¹ÇØ·Mºu¾nÁ ¹>¶u¶²u´M¹·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±½¶—·o¸vÁ ¹
¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×vÚàk¾¿n¾!¶—¾o»¼˜¹0±M¹¹>¿¸…¼…¸S×]²u¾¹>¶x²uµ Çh¸Y²u¹²u´M¹0ÇÀMÐ ²uµ È
ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹ x¾vµ ±=²•¿nµ‡¶x²uºuµ ÞMÀn²uµ ¾v±¾,Åz¸¶—¹ ²¾,Åzº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇÏÉv¹×n¶Úà…´Mµ‡¶
µ‡¶Ô¶—Ànâ½Á µ ¹±=²4²u¾¸,Ї¶—¾3·Mºu¾nÁ ¹>¶u¶4Á ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶»
¶—µ ±oÁ ¹•¸!Á ¾v±o¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,Ðv·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×!µ‡¶¸ÿ=ÀM¾,²uµ ¹±=²¾,ÅZ²x¼˜¾ÇÀMÐ È
²uµ ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸Y²u¹ x¾vµ ±=²W·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²uµ ¹>¶Úh°_±D¾vº’¿n¹ºÔ²u¾9¹>¶x²uµ Çh¸Y²u¹²u´M¹
·Mºu¾vÞo¸,ÞMµ Ð µ ²x×(¾,Å!¸ã¶—¹ ²¾,ÅGDº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ+Év¹×n¶»¼˜¹3Á¸,±ÌÁ ¾vÀM±=²
²u´M¹ÔÅQºu¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±oÁ ×h¾,ŸÁ ¹º—²’¸,µ ±P·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±Pµ ±o¶x²’¸,±oÁ ¹vÚà…´Mµ‡¶
Ǎ¹>¸,±o¶²u´o¸Y²Ô¼˜¹ºu¹>ÿ=ÀMµ ºu¹¸hÅQºu¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±oÁ ×P²’¸,ÞMÐ ¹"¾,Å0Ǎµ ±Mµ ÇÀMÇ
¶—µ ݹG Ú àk¾KÍv¹±M¹º’¸Y²u¹B¶—ÀoÁ’´Ö¸(²’¸,ÞMÐ ¹B¾,ÅWǍµ ±Mµ ÇÀMÇ ¶—µ ݹv»
¼˜¹Ô±M¹¹>¿3²u¾Çh¸,··H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶…¾v±=²u¾"µ ±=²u¹Ív¹º’¶Úà…´Mµ‡¶]Á¸,±
ÞH¹Ô¿n¾v±M¹4µ ± ½Ñ G˜Ð ¾vÍ GMÕ0²uµ Ǎ¹4¼]´M¹ºu¹>¸v¶•¸±M¹¼Öº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇÉv¹×
¶—¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±oÁ ¹hÁ¸,±(ÞH¹hÇh¸v¿n¹ÅQºu¾vÇ ¸,±(µ ±=²u¹Ív¹ºµ ±9½Ñ GMÕ4²uµ Ǎ¹vÚ
Ò4µ Ëv¹±½²u´Mµ‡¶…Á ¾vºuºu¹>¶—·H¾v±o¿n¹±oÁ ¹v»v²u´M¹!ÅQºu¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±oÁ µ ¹>¶•¾,Åß²u´M¹Ô·H¾=¶xÈ
¶—µ ÞMÐ ¹3·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶"Á¸,±KÞH¹Á ¾vÀM±=²u¹>¿DÅQºu¾vÇ+²u´M¹¶—¹Ð ¹>Áf²u¹>¿
¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶Ú4òZÀMÞo¶—¹>ÿ=ÀM¹±=²uÐ ×v»H±M¹¼Ï¶u¸,Ǎ·MÐ ¹>¶!Á¸,±9ÞH¹"¿nº’¸S¼]±9µ ±
¸¶—µ Ǎµ Ї¸,º…ÅX¸v¶—´Mµ ¾v±¸v¶…µ‡¶¿n¾v±M¹4ÅQ¾vº]ÞMµ ±o¸,ºu×½ËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶Ú
°_±KîoÍvÀMºu¹>¶÷B¸,±o¿ÌøM»²u´M¹Pºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶"¾,Ųu¹>¶x²uµ ±MÍ(¸ã·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±DÞo¸v¶—¹>¿ã°xÙÄkÓ¼]µ ²u´D²u´M¹hÞH¹>¶x²W·H¾=¶u¶—µ ÞMÐ ¹îMån¹>¿(ÀM±oÁ ¾v±nÈ
¿nµ ²uµ ¾v±o¸,ÐÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±ß»k¸,ºu¹"·MÐ ¾,²—²u¹>¿%ڽӘ²²u´Mµ‡¶·H¾vµ ±=²>»ß²u´M¹
¿n¹Ëv¹Ð ¾v·MǍ¹±=²!¾,Ųu´M¹W·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±9Þo¸v¶—¹>¿°xÙÄßÓñ¾v±MР׸,Ð È
Ð ¾Y¼¶0îMån¹>¿hÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶•¸v¶•µ ±M·MÀn²¸v¶•µ‡¶0²u´M¹Á¸v¶—¹]ÅQ¾vº˜²u´M¹
æÙÓÏó õöYú€Ú ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»S²u´M¹]ºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶µ ±²u´Mµ‡¶0¶—¹>Áf²uµ ¾v±µ ±o¿nµ‡Á¸Y²u¹
²u´o¸Y²…°xÙÄßÓ4¶4Çh¸S׍ÞH¹4Á ¾v±o¶x²uºuÀoÁf²u¹>¿hÞZ׍Р¹>¸,ºu±Mµ ±MÍWÅX¸vÁf²u¾vºuµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±o¶4¸,±o¿9²u´M¹ºu¹ÞZ×±M¾3Ð ¾v±MÍv¹ºÔ¸v¶u¶—ÀMǍµ ±MÍ3¸3·Mºuµ ¾vºuµkÉZ±M¾Y¼]Ð È
¹>¿nÍv¹W¾v±²u´M¹¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±9·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹ÇÚà…´M¹Wºu¹>¶—ÀMÐ ²’¶¾,Ųu´M¹
·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±Æ°xÙÄkÓþ¸,ºu¹ã¶—Ð µ Ív´=²uÐ ×ÌÞH¹ ²—²u¹º3²u´o¸,±ª²u´M¾=¶—¹B¾,Å
ÂvÃ0Ä ¼]µ ²u´·H¹º—ÅQ¹>Áf²PǍµ ånµ ±MÍKµ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚ ¾Y¼˜¹Ëv¹º>»˜¼˜¹
´o¸SËv¹]·Mºu¾YËZµ‡¿n¹>¿"²u´M¹!·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±h°xÙÄkÓ6¼]µ ²u´h²u´M¹!·H¹º—ÅQ¹>Áf²
¸·Mºuµ ¾vºuµH¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹4µ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±ßÚ°€²…¼˜¾vÀMЇ¿hÞH¹Ôµ ±=²u¹ºu¹>¶x²uµ ±MÍ
²u¾Ô¶—¹¹˜µ Åz¸!·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±°xÙÄkÓ.²u´o¸Y²Ð ¹>¸,ºu±o¶ß²u´Mµ‡¶¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹
Á¸,±P¾vÀn²u·H¹º—ÅQ¾vºuÇ Â=ÃÄ(¾v±ËY¸,ºuµ ¾vÀo¶˜·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Ú
ê é ¯—ì!«Zíxê é «
æµ ±o¿nµ ±MÍW¸,±o¿"Ào¶—µ ±MÍ·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çضx²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹]Á¸,±h¸,µ‡¿ä•Ó!¶ÚÛ(¹
´o¸SËv¹B¶—´M¾Y¼]±U²u´o¸Y²½²u´Mµ‡¶3µ‡¶½¸,Ї¶—¾D²u´M¹(Á¸v¶—¹9¼]´M¹±Æº’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ
Év¹×n¶¸,ºu¹3Ào¶—¹>¿K²u¾ã²’¸vÁ’ÉZÐ ¹P·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±Ì·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶ÚÌæMÀMº—È
²u´M¹ºuǍ¾vºu¹v»îo±o¿nµ ±MÍÆ¸,±o¿ÖÀo¶—µ ±Mͪ¸U¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹(µ ±.¼]´Mµ‡Á’´.¸
ÇÀMÐ ²uµ ·MÐ ¹!¾,ÅßËY¸,ºuµ‡¸,ÞMÐ ¹>¶µ ±=²u¹º’¸vÁf²>»=µ‡¶˜¶—ÀM·H¹ºuµ ¾vº²u¾Ào¶—µ ±MÍW¾v±MÐ ×
¶—¹>Á ¾v±o¿(¾vº’¿n¹ºÐ µ ±MÉY¸,Ív¹hµ ±nÅQ¾vºuÇh¸Y²uµ ¾v±(¼]´M¹±D²u´M¹½¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸YÈ
²uµ ¾v±·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹ÇñÁ ¾v±=²’¸,µ ±o¶˜´Mµ Ív´M¹º]¾vº’¿n¹º]µ ±=²u¹º’¸vÁf²uµ ¾v±o¶Ú
Û(¹Ö´o¸SËv¹Ö¶—´M¾Y¼]±ÞZרµ ±=²uºu¾n¿nÀoÁ µ ±MÍ ÂvÃ0Äð²u´o¸Y²UÞZ×6Ǎµ åZÈ
µ ±MÍãÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶¾,ź’¸,±o¿n¾vÇ Év¹×n¶»·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±K·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶¾,Å
¸ ÞH¾vÀM±o¿n¹>¿ ¿nµ â½Á ÀMÐ ²x×Á¸,±ÞH¹¶—¾vÐ Ëv¹>¿6¹ â½Á µ ¹±=²uÐ ×vÚÜàk¾
²u´Mµ‡¶Ô¹±o¿%»%¼˜¹"´o¸SËv¹"Ào¶—¹>¿ãÁ ¾v±=²uµ ±ZÀM¾vÀo¶!°xÙÄkÓ!¶²u¾3îo±o¿B²u´M¹
¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹¾,Å4²u´M¹9¾v·n²uµ Ǎµ Ý>¸Y²uµ ¾v±U·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Ç ²u¾vÍv¹ ²u´M¹ºh¼]µ ²u´
Á ºu¾=¶u¶—¾YËv¹ºWÅQºu¾vÇþÒÔÓ!¶"²u¾DǍµ åK²u´M¹9ÞMÀMµ Ї¿nµ ±MÍDÞMÐ ¾nÁ’Én¶Ú ˜×
¿n¾vµ ±MÍU¶—¾o»²u´M¹Dä•Ó ¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×Æ¹ ån·MÐ ¾vºu¹>¶h²u´M¹(·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±
¶—·o¸vÁ ¹v»n¼]´Mµ‡Á’´¶—µ Ív±Mµ îHÁ¸,±=²uÐ ×hµ ±oÁ ºu¹>¸v¶—¹>¶˜µ ²’¶…¹ â½Á µ ¹±oÁ ×vÚ0à…´Mµ‡¶
µ‡¶˜¸,±½µ ±o¿nµ‡Á¸Y²uµ ¾v±½²u´o¸Y²˜°xÙÄkÓ!¶!²u´o¸Y²]¸,ºu¹!¿n¹>¶—µ Ív±M¹>¿²u¾"¼˜¾vºuÉ
¿nµ ºu¹>Áf²uÐ ×(µ ±D²u´M¹3¶—·o¸vÁ ¹h¾,Å]·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±o¶Çh¸S×ã¹ áz¹>Áf²uµ Ëv¹Ð ×
îo±o¿¸,±o¿3Ào¶—¹Ô²u´M¹W¶x²uºuÀoÁf²uÀMºu¹Ô¾,Å·H¹ºuÇÀn²’¸Y²uµ ¾v±P·Mºu¾vÞMÐ ¹Çh¶Ú
­ ké ¯ «
- vœ Œ•œ%žƒfŠ|oœ ˜ƒ’|=ƒux ‘WЧ >„ˆx x–=‰~4Š|Z‹½ˆ—Š|Z‹v„>‰ Sƒušv~…†‡„ˆ
~_ƒ Y‚=ƒ’|=“2‘’. |=-˜¤Š/ |Z‹]- .>„>¡,Žv“&x-f‰¢>¢  f/ Š x „>|oœ
, vœ nœ …ƒ…ž„>|=ƒuf“nŒ•œv{}~ nƒ’§ §s“ZŠ|Z‹›zœ ˜ „>§ Š,œ "{ "{_Œ 5z |Z‹
 |=3„>Žvx ‰WŠ Yš9ƒ’~€x ‰WŠ x |=3Žvˆx„ ZŠ = §  }šB‹vƒ’“M|=¢,~_“$ x-f ƒ’¢>~’¢8œ .
£ Wx›z œ„>|œ ¦!Žvˆxœ„Yž‘’ƒ’„>~_~_~_‰W |=Š|D |hŠ|Z‹v‹  ~€_4ˆx œ=‚v¥x–= „> ƒu|ˆxƒ’ƒ’|=~€~’xœ ‰WoŠ x | „>>|hŠ>Šƒ§ >„|vˆx†‡ „xˆx–=‰W‰Š ~’œ
{}’| „>|oª“ !œ]œ ž˜Š„>| |Z’Šf–Z™>Š Š †}ˆf“ “ 3vœ œ ]SŠ Š, ‹=ƒ’Š,§ Š,“ “vŠ|Zœ 3‹ œ 3ߜ 3 nœvƒ’,|o‰“  3x–oœ “S!ƒfœ‹v …x„Š ˆxˆ~’“
—“ZŽZŠ>ƒ’~ .>¡ .9)Yœ 3œ ԜZ›ß‚ oœ $“ -f¢>¢>¢
/ W›zœ œ ¦!œ0ž„>~_‰WŠ|UŠ|Z‹ 4œ•¥–= ƒuˆxƒ’|=~’œ 3%ŸvŽZŠ|Z‹v |=9† ˆx„>‰
>‹v!„ ~_œ ˆx‘u• xˆx–=ƒu‚Zx‰‹vƒ„>~ § xãŽ=„–o¥“‘’6!„>–=|YƒPœ x { |,Š‚=„v„>8“ ‚=3~Wœœ oƒ’~€{}‚vx| _ ‰Wx„>3Š |oxœ˜“  „>v,|Dœ ‘—v–=œ „„Y"†!ƒ’|Zƒu‹vˆxЁ ƒ’~€‚=_§ ƒu„vˆxˆf “Y=“ Š‚v|ZÔx‹  œ „>!|³…œ ƒ}Š›zo§ “œ
)+*,( 1
.
32
4
$5 35 .
6
2
!2 2
798!&
: ;<=>*,@?A<3!CBDEF%G)+*H@IJ3;<=D=D*, 0
K
L1
NM "
06
2
PO
"
>1
'K
2
G5 Q R 36
S4 SQ
5 'T
IJ3;0UVER),W"<YX$Z[#\#\\]^!_`_`_aX<C<)+*H;8GZ : !
U\#$% ( U
#$E<D<;<
/
b5 c
"2
K
T
71
F.
0g
d1feK
Sh
$I93!, <iIJ3`jF <%! : *,-AE3%k?>!&
)+D<R]lI$IJ?nmCB
F/
K
1
$5
d1feK
fT
9/ `/
/
b. o!o
o
"2o0T
>o "o
o S6
`o
06
!
0
K
p1
0/
\2 06
q1feCK
'K
IJ3;<D<38*,-=YVE'),W"<srC<"),Wat[)q;W]?A<),W"< 8=s#$E<&
<;<Ruv`;WS*,C<fwi<3"*,2
Y5 x
C5
1 h
T
/
ly
2
!2 2
O
"
A 1
>K
2
R5 Q f D
A4 9Q
A5 f T
xIJ3;<D<38*,-=AVE),W"<lX$Z[#\#\\]^!_`_`_
X<C<)+*H;z8{Z : ! )+*H|P#$% ( )q)+*H}#$E<D<;<
/
~5
c
"2
0G1
~
2
~c C1 F2 CQ c
a CQ
T

!2
V6
!"#$%'&
0/
!M
P5
2
! S5
fc \1 F2
AQ 6
6
, ‘—– ƒu†‡ƒ’§s“%ƒf‹v x„ˆxx~’“=“ ŽZŠ>ƒ’~ ) .9) )8) .,œH,Žvˆx |=>ƒuˆf“2,¡>¡>¡
¤ W”˜›zœ |= ™nœ ¦!œ˜œv¥Hžƒ’„>‘—–o~_‰Wœ Š|œ•Š”˜|Z”‹ v4Œœ= ¥–=,¡> ƒu¡>ˆx¡ ƒ’+|=/Y~’¤Yœ œ]"† x ŸvŽ ƒf‹f{† xŽoœ ‘’•~’~’œ ‚=œ‚o”•œ |=_§ ˆfœ
Ž=‚ ”˜” >Œ fxƒ’‘—–vˆxƒ’Ž=~ >Œ ,¡>¡>¡ 8,¡>¡>¡ /Y¤Yœ Ž=~’œ  >“',¡>¡>¡
. W›zœ œ ¦!œž„>~_‰WŠ|Š|Z‹ 4œ¥–= ƒuˆxƒ’|=~’œ ¦˜ƒ’SŠ x ™SƒU§ „>
§~_  S~߃’„§ †n–=‰„Y„,„,‹W‹vƒ’Ч,|Z~_‹Ôƒ’§ ~€ƒ’—‘uŠ xx „> ~€|x  ‘f|4Чn{ –YšvŽn4„~’xœv–={}ƒ’| ~_ ~ßxœ8ƒ’5=~€ƒ’xƒ’ |=§ ‹v!ƒuŠˆx~’~k“Sxƒf–=‹vƒ  xZ„Š ˆf“
œn¥ § =‚vˆx”˜|= ™Sƒuˆx~_ }šY“ ,¡>¡>¡
) 3œ …Ч § Š>–=ƒuˆf“ 3œ5vˆxƒfЉ“vŠ|Z‹¥˜œ …„ 0|=~’œ •ƒfЧ Y™>Ч ‚=ƒf‹
ƒ’‹v™Sƒ’„>|=§ ~_‚v }x𳁠„>|Zƒ’Š~€xˆ_š‰W„>Š Žvxx„ ˆf‰œÏ f{}Š | x „>ª|hœ•‚=~_ž |=ŠW| ’Š –ZŠ Z†}ƒu“ Ÿvv =œ § ƒ]]ŽvŠˆx ‹=„ ZŠ,Š“ = § œ 3}š œ
3߁ œ n3ƒ’œ=|o,“ ‰3 xœ–o!“Sœ ƒf‹v… xŠ „ˆ ˆx’~’„>“ |o“ !œ ˜„>|ZŠf™>Š ˆf“ 3œ SŠ , ƒ’§ Š,“!Š|Z—‹ “
ŽZ˜4ŠŠœ >3Ž=ƒ’œ ~•‹M˜“v „>/SЧ‘’¡ ‹ ‘’,n‚v ƒuˆ—/9ˆxŠ .,vxœ ƒ˜“ "Ԅ>Žv„œ xˆx…S‰Šƒ | o f“ Š!xЁ „>œ ‚v|†‡‰W„Š †%Šˆx>|=‹v‚=| Žv›ß—‘’Š,‚ ‚=“H=§ Ч  |ZŽv~_–=‹ ˆx„ƒu!ˆx=~’§ œƒ’“$‰…-f¢>~Š ¢>ˆx‚=¢  n~ œ
 |=†sŠ~€z‰ƒ’~_~€š…>ƒ’|=ƒux ‘Ч >„ˆx x–=‰~’œS{}|!nœ 5=„ˆ_ˆxƒ’~€f“ƒf‹v x„ˆf“
¢ !|…œ x…–=ƒ Š ˆx3 nŒ œ o | œ>>{}Ч § > ƒ˜x§ ƒf“=WŠ ŽZˆxŠ¥H|=>ƒ’ƒ’|=‘—~…4–o¤œ ™,.  Šœf. ¢>Žv/v¢>ˆxœ ¡„ 3-fZ¡,Š œ œÔ=†  xœZ§ ށ ›ß~€x‚  ‘…fo† œx‰$“ Ž „,-fX¢>‹v§ ¢>§ ƒ’ £§S Š|=§s œ
>ƒ>œ ‚= ‚=‘>œ ƒf‹v‚ Ž=‚ ŽZŠŽnƒuˆx~ {}§ §  o~ ¢>¢>¡ -f¡,œ Ž=~’œ z“ -f¢>¢>¢
-f¡ !œ Š ˆx>‚=Žv—Š,“ Ԝ …ƒ o“HŠ|Z‹ 4œ 3œ ˜„>§ ‹ nƒuˆxvœW•ˆ—‹vƒuˆx |=
>ž•ƒ’œ |=ƒuxЁ ‘4|Z‹vŠƒu§ >ˆx„ ‘ ˆxn x“n–=ƒf‰‹v~…x„Šˆx|Z~’‹h“ ‹vƒ’‘’ƒ’Žvx „>|oœ•{}| œ Š|=|=ƒuˆ…Š|Z‹
x“vŽZŠ>ƒ’~ /+) v¤ .,œo,Žvˆx |=>ƒuˆf“$-f¢>¢9,
-8- 4œ ]|ZŠ €ƒ ]œ •Ž=Ž=§  ‘fŠ x „>|„†Hx–=ƒ•†sŠ~€0‰ƒ’~_~€š>ƒ’|=ƒux ‘]Ч
>§  „ˆx x–=³‰ ¥Hƒ’x„‘—–=Žn|=ƒu ‘fˆx‰4Ч ‚v•—Š ƒ’xŽn „>„|hˆ_"Š,|Z¡>‹"¡>¡>~_¡9‘—–=,8ƒf,Y‹vœß‚=† x§ Ž |=fŽv† xˆxŽ„ =X §§ ƒ’§  ‰SŠ~’§sœœ >{}ƒ>§ œ
‚= ‚=‘>œ ƒf‹v‚ Ž=‚ ŽZŠŽnƒuˆx~ {}§ §  o~ 8,¡>¡>¡>9¡ ,8,Yœ Ž=~’œ z&“ ,¡>¡>¡
-, 4œ ]|ZŠ €ƒ Š|Z‹ 4œ 3œ ˜„>§ ‹ nƒuˆxvœ HŠ ˆx>ƒ Y~_‘fЧ ƒWŽnƒuˆx‰4‚
—ŠŠ § >x„ „>ˆx|だx–=„>‰Žvxœ3 ‰{}| fŠ 3x „>œk| ,‘—0–=„Yxƒ’–9|ZŠx‚=–=ƒuƒˆf“„ˆ—Ô‹vƒuœ ˆx… |=ƒ 3o“ ‰!ƒ’~_œ ~€š•‚Z>‹vƒ’„>|=§ ƒuŽ=x–o ‘ “
6!œ Š„v“ 3œ o‚v_x„>|o“ vœ vœ "ƒuˆxƒ’§ „v“Š|Z‹ !œ }›zœß,‘—– ƒu†‡ƒ’§s“
ƒf‹vx “vx„ŽZˆxŠ~’>“ ƒ’~ .>£ - . /S¡,œH,Žvˆx |=>ƒuˆf2“ ,¡>¡>¡
-f£ W›zœ HŠ ˆ_ˆ—Š |ZŠSŠ,“ 'œ 3%_Ÿvƒ nƒuˆ_ˆx Š,“ vœ œ o„ fŠ|=„v“kŠ|Z‹ vœ 3œ
Z›zŒŠ’ƒ„>šY|Z‚=ƒ’Š,|Y~_œÊ_ Šˆ_š|h˜¥HŠŽv|Zƒ’x‘—‹ ‰–oSœ  Šf‚=Š œ x~_~_3 „> Š˜| |h” Y|=šKƒu §ƒfŠ„ˆxˆ |=,X~’{|=œk³”˜/ Š|=|Z ™n¢>‹K¢,œvœS„~_–Y†z ‰4_xx–=‚=Ž ƒ§ Š žx Š„>~|UY]‚=„ƒ † œ
~_‘>œ ƒ’–,‚oœ ƒ’~ ‘’‘ ZŠ’šYƒ’~ Žn„>~€x~_‘uˆx Žv fŠ>Š X 4}¡ Š…/ ~_}‘f¢>Š¢,§ œ Š Ž==~’§“ƒ•-fƒ’¢>™S¢>„ ¢
- / !œ ‚=–=§ ƒ’| nƒ’ |WŠ|Z‹Ô¥˜œ Š–=|= v$œ 5
§‹v‚vƒ’x‘’ „>„>‰|ZŠ Žnˆ_„>š"~_ƒfŠ‹W§ >„†‡‚=ˆx|= x‘u–=x‰. „>|=†‡„~’ˆœ x–=ƒ˜„>Žvx ‰ fŠ “2x ) „>|"£S¤„£ †%,Š>£9‹=) ‹v.,“&x-f ™S¢>ƒ’¢>§ ¢š
- ¤ œZ˜‘—–=„SŠ,“ !œ ‚=–=§ ƒ’| nƒ’ |o“ZŠ|Z‹ 3œn,„x„vœ K†sŠ‘ux„ˆx ’ƒf‹
|=6!‹vƒuœ~€ _ˆx„Š=ˆ „v‚v,“ x~’3œ³„>|!œ {}o|Ч‚v>3_„xˆx„>œ |ox,–=“ ‘—‰ª–=vœ„Yv‚=ƒ’œ ~_|Z "|=Š‚=0ƒuƒuˆx~_ˆfƒ’ |=“ § „v>ԓ§ ƒœ Š‘’|Z…„>‹ |=ƒ o|=!“ƒ’œ‘u}!x›zƒfœ œß‹ •,Z‘—‚ZŠ’– ‹všYƒ’„>ƒu~_§ Ž=†‡Šƒ’–o|§s““
ƒf‹vx “vx„ŽZˆxŠ~’>“ ƒ’~4) 9) )¢8.,œH,Žvˆx |=>ƒuˆf“2,¡>¡>¡
- . 3œZ›zƒ’§  >Š|o“ 4œ 3œ ˜„>§ ‹ nƒuˆxv“nŠ|Z‹ 3œnŒŠ|Y ‚ }›%Š >œkž
¥vœ –=ƒ ]ZŠŠ’ ‹=šYŠ,ƒ’~_“  Š|œ 3„>Žvœ x3߉ n fƒ’Š |ox“  „>3|Šœ !§ >œ „ˆx… xŠ –=ˆ ‰’„>œM|o{}“ | !ªœ œ,˜ž„>Š|Z| Šf’™>–ZŠ Š ˆf†}““
3œ SŠ , ƒ’§ Š,“•Š|Z‹ œ 3œ,‰ x–o“ƒf‹v x„ˆx~’“
—“nŽZŠ>ƒ’~˜8¤ ,>¤ v¤9£ ,Yœ 3œ ԜZ›ß‚ oœ $“ -f¢>¢>¢
-) 3œH›zƒ’§  >Š|o“ 4œ 3œ ˜„>§ ‹ nƒuˆxv“zŠ|Z‹ ԜHvŠ~€_ˆ_šYœ!žŠ’šYƒ’~_ Š|
ˆ—„>‚=Š Žv ‚=’x„‘> ‰ˆfœ ƒfœh‹vf‚{}Š § x§  Ž= „>‚ |гŽZ§ >Š¥H„Žnƒ’ˆxƒu‘— xˆx–o–=~ œ ‰{}§ “H§ &œ  ‹v,ƒ’¡>‘’¡> o~_¡> ~9¡„>8,|,¡,¡>œß¡>ˆ—† ¡>Šx9¡Ž=Ž ,–=¡,~]fœ Ž=† Šx~’|ZŽ œ z‹½X &“ § „Y§ , ‘’S¡>‘fŠ¡>Чs¡,‰œ >œ ƒ>~ œ
IJ3;<D<38*,-=YVE'),W"<l€$* E),WsBD")d<)+*H!#$E<D<;<
X<C<)+*H;A -`*,),WS%l=
/
b5 c
"2
0Y Q
M "
!2 2
\[K
[KfM
FT
b. o!o 6
o "2o
o
[KfM o
‚
0GQ Cc
~c C1 F2
v1
~
2
T b5aƒ
b5
~I93!, <CIJ3`jF <%„! : *,-fE3%
?>)+D<R]'I$IJ?…B3B
F/
G1 c
d† h ‡K
6
!2
6
[KfM
T
b. o!o 6
o "2o
o
[KfM o
‚
G1 Cc
d† h
1
~
2
lM
/
6
{h
L5
‡c 1 F2 T
~g
‡M
$ 5
ˆQ 6
Sh
SI93!, <`IJ3`jF <%‰! : *,-E3%P?>)+D<9]fI$IJ?
mCB
/
0
M
"Š
$T
F2
$ K ‡M !
ˆ 5
SŠ
‹2
2
dh D
D
T
‡Q 6qcR‚CKfK96 dc[6 So
b. o!oh\h\h
o h92
o
o0 06 S6 6
GQ 5{ƒ
2
5
i1fKz/
2
6
JZ : ! U#$% ( U S. /
K
"Q 5{ƒ
2
5
$K
2
>2
dh D
5
\c $1 F2 T
~g
‡M
$ 5
ˆQ 6
Sh
SI93!, <`IJ3`jF <%‰! : *,-E3%P?>)+D<9]fI$IJ?
mCB
F/
0Y5
1
x
2
CŒ 6 KA.
92
lO
"
R1
YK
2
5 Q ' D
Y4 AQ
5 J zT
IJ3;<D<38*,-=sVE
),W"<X$Z[#\#\\]^!_`_`_vX<C<)+*H;G8'Z : ! )+*H|s#$% ( &
)q)+*Hz#$E<D<;<
F/
~5 c
"2
Y5
b1
i
2
c
@
[KfM
iT
b. o!o 6
o "2o
o
[KfM o
‚