Fbgg^lhmZÍl
@k^Zm^lm@^g^kZmbhg
@KHPLNI
= Zo ^ D ^ g g ^ r
Ma^\ZmZ\erlfh_Phke]PZkBB
_hn`amZphke]pZk%[nbem\Zk^^kl%Zg]
kZbl^]_Zfbeb^lh_ma^bkhpg'
e^_mZihp^k_nebfikbgmhgma^`^g&
^kZmbhgh_f^gZg]phf^gpah
Hgbmllbfie^lme^o^e%ma^@k^Zm
\Zf^h_Z`^]nkbg`mahl^r^Zkl'Cnlm
=^ik^llbhgpZlZg^\hghfb\\kblbl'
Zl\kbmb\Ze%ahp^o^k%mhlaZibg`mabl
;^mp^^g*2+2Zg]*2,,%ma^Zo^kZ`^
Ê`k^Zm^lmË`^g^kZmbhgÍl\aZkZ\m^kp^k^ _Zfberbgma^Ngbm^]LmZm^llZpbml
ma^bk^qi^kb^g\^lZl\abe]k^gZg]
bg\hf^]khi[rfhk^maZghg^&mabk]'
Z]he^l\^gml]nkbg`ma^@k^Zm=^ik^l& Ma^gZmbhgZech[e^llkZm^%pab\almhh]
lbhg'Ma^]^ik^llbhg`kZ[[^]ahe]
ZmZ[hnmmak^^i^k\^gmbgH\mh[^k
h_Fbgg^lhmZÉZg]ma^k^lmh_ma^
*2+2%k^Z\a^]Zme^Zlm+.i^k\^gme^ll
\hngmkrÉ]nkbg`ma^^Zkeb^lmfhgmal maZg_hnkr^ZkleZm^k'Ma^gnf[^kl
h_ma^*2,)lZg]]b]ghme^m`h_hk
bgFbgg^lhmZp^k^\hfiZkZ[e^%Ze&
g^ZkerZ]^\Z]^'Ma^chrlZg]a^Zkm&
mahn`ak^lb]^gmlbglhf^iZkmlh_ma^
Z\a^lh_`khpbg`nibgFbgg^lhmZ
lmZm^Éma^BkhgKZg`^%_hk^qZfie^%
]nkbg`mahl^r^ZkllmZr^]pbmama^
pa^k^ma^ng^fiehrf^gmkZm^abm0)
lnkobohklho^kma^]^\Z]^lZlma^r
i^k\^gmÉln__^k^]fhk^maZghma^kl'*
<abe]k^glZpma^bk_Zma^kl\hf^ahf^
:[ho^3<hfbg`h_Z`^3M^^gZ`^klihl^]
:[ho^3
<hfbg`h_Z`^3M^^gZ`^klihl^]
pbmag^plh_eZrh__lZg]ma^bkfhma^kl
hgZ\Zk%Lm'IZne%*2,0
lmkn``ebg`mhfZd^Z_^p]ZrlÍ_hh]
;^ehp3;Zk^_hhm[hrZmphkd%*2+)l
;^ehp3
;Zk^_hhm[hrZmphkd%*2+)l
eZlmZg^gmbk^p^^d'Beeg^ll^lp^gm
ngmk^Zm^]'<ehma^lphk^hnmZg]p^k^
l^e]hfk^ieZ\^]'FZgrdb]ll\Zo^g`^]
_hk_hh]'Hma^klmhhdehp&iZrbg`ch[l
mha^eima^bk_Zfbeb^llnkobo^'
Chl^iabg^Le^mmhh_:e^qZg]kbZ
k^\Zee^]maZmma^]^ik^llbhg%\hnie^]
pbmaZl^kbhnl]khn`am%fZ]^bm]b_&
Ö\nem_hka^k_Zfber3ÊP^fZgZ`^]mh
`^mZehg`''''Bml^^f^]ebd^p^aZ]
f^Zm'P^aZ]hnk^``l'Bdghpfr
fhma^kmkb^]mhkZbl^Z`Zk]^g[nm
la^]b]gÍm`^mfn\ahnmh_a^k`Zk]^g
ZmmaZmmbf^[^\Znl^bmZeecnlm]kb^]
=Zo^D^gg^rblZ_k^^eZg\^pkbm^kli^&
\bZebsbg`bgFbgg^lhmZablmhkr'Abl
g^qm[hhd%Zablmhkrh_fhob^&`hbg`
Zg]fhob^^qab[bmbhgbgma^Mpbg
<bmb^l%pbee[^in[ebla^][rma^Fbgg^&
lhmZAblmhkb\ZeLh\b^mrIk^llbg+))0'
159
pZlmbg`ahmpZm^k%[nkgbg`ngg^^]^]
pZlmbg` ahm
^e^\mkb\eb`aml%aZobg`fhk^lah^lhk
^e^\mkb\ eb`a
\ehma^lmaZgB\Zgnl^%aZobg`ma^
\ehma^l maZg
ahnl^m^fi^kZmnk^Z[ho^/1]^`k^^l
ahnl^ m^fi
,
'''ma^eblmbl^g]e^llË
' ' ' ma^ eblm b
<abe]k^gh_ma^@k^Zm
<abe]k^gh_ma^@k^Zm
=^ik^llbhgjnb\der
=^ik^llbhgjnb\der
[^\Zf^Z]^imZmma^
[^\Zf^Z]^imZmma^
Zkmh_`^mmbg`[r'
Ma^@k^Zm=^ik^llbhgi^kfZ&
<abe]k^gh__Zkf^klpahlhn`am
<abe]k^gh__Zkf^klpahlhn`am
gh__Zkf^klpahlhn`am
lmZm^Zb]%AheeZg]Ze^%*2+2
]%AheeZg]Ze^%*2+2
ni':g]p^aZ]lmhkflmaZmrhn
cnlmphne]gÍm[^eb^o^'P^\hne]gÍm
^o^gl^^ma^[ZkgZmmbf^l[^\Znl^
h_ma^]nlmlmhkfl'ËG^elhgI^^krh_
PZ[ZlaZk^f^f[^k^]p^eeahpma^
]^ik^llbhgmhhdZmheehgabl_Zma^k'
ÊIhi`hmZghma^kpZ`^\nmZg]%_hk
ma^Öklmmbf^%BlZpabf\hf^ahf^
]kngd'A^mkb^]aZk]mhpZedlmkZb`am
Zg]mhmZedghkfZeer%[nma^]b]gÍm
_hhenl'>o^gmahn`ap^eZn`a^]
Z[hnmbm%]^^i]hpgbmankm'Lhf^&
ahpp^ng]^klmhh]maZmhnkIhi
pZlgÍmZllmkhg`Zlp^aZ][^eb^o^]'Ë +
<abe]k^gh_ma^@k^Zm=^ik^llbhg
jnb\der[^\Zf^Z]^imZmma^Zkmh_
`^mmbg`[r'Fbd^DhlbZdZg]abllb[&
ebg`lbg<ablahefZ]]^]mhma^_Zf&
berbg\hf^[rZ\\^imbg`Zch[_neeh_
Êlnli^gl^%bgmkb`n^%Zg]^q\bm^f^gmË3
160 Minnesota Histor y
ma^r
ma^r]^ebo^k^]bee^`Zefhhglabg^
^`Ze fhhglabg^
ahnl^&mh&ahnl^_hkZg^b`a[hkahh]
ahn
hk Z g^b`a[hkahh]
Ê]blmbee^k'ËKb\aZk]AZeefZ]^m^g
Ê]blm
] AZee fZ]^ m^g
\^gmlZlZ\dpa^ga^\hee^\m^]ma^
\angdlh_Ê_k^^Ë\hZemaZmbg^obmZ[er
libee^]hgma^`khng]pa^gphkd^kl
ehZ]^]Zg]ngehZ]^]mkn\dlZmma^
:nlmbgkZberZk]l'?hkma^db]lh_ma^
*2,)l%ibg\abg`i^ggb^l[^\Zf^Z
aZ[bmma^rg^o^khnm`k^p'ÊMa^]^&
ik^llbhgpZlma^hkb`bgh_frmakb_mb&
g^ll%ËPZem^k;^gcZfbgk^\Zee^]h_
abl[hrahh]bgIbi^lmhg^'ÊTBmpZlV
ma^lhnk\^h_fr_^^ebg``nbemrZ[hnm
li^g]bg`fhg^rhgenqnkb^l%makhp&
bg`ZpZre^_mho^k_hh]%]bl\Zk]bg`
\ehma^l[^_hk^ma^rZk^phkghnm%
g^gmer\aZg`^]ma^k^eZmbhglabi[^&
mp^^gma^:f^kb\Zgi^hie^Zg]ma^bk
`ho^kgf^gm'Bff^]bZm^erhgmZdbg`
h_Ö\^bg*2,,%Ik^lb]^gm?kZgdebg='
Khhl^o^em
Khhl^o^emeZng\a^]Zl^kb^lh_bgghoZ&
eZng
mbo^
mbo^ikh`kZflmha^ei:f^kb\Zgl\hi^
ikh`kZfl
pbma
pbmapaZmpZlmnkgbg`hnmmh[^Zg
paZm pZl
bgmkZ\mZ[e^
bgmkZ\mZ[e^^\hghfb\\ZeZfbmr'Ng]^k
^\h
mabl
mablG^p=^Ze%ma^_^]^kZe`ho^kgf^gm
G^p =^Ze
Zllnf^]
Zllnf^]ZgZ\mbo^khe^bgma^ebo^lh_
Zg Z\
fZgr%
fZgr%b_ghmfhlm%N'L'\bmbs^gl'
b_ ghm f
Ma^ÖklmG^p=^Zeikh`kZfmh
Ma^
Öklm G
`^mh__ma^`khng]pZlma^<bobebZg
`^m
h__ ma^ `kh
<hgl^koZmbhg<hkil!<<<"%pab\a
<hgl^
Zmbhg
^o^gmnZeerpZlmh^fiehrfhk^maZg
,fbeebhgrhng`f^ghg\hgl^koZ&
mbhgZg]iZkd&\hglmkn\mbhgikhc^\ml'-
MahnlZg]lh_Fbgg^lhmZgl^gkhee^]
bgma^<<<]nkbg`ma^gbg^r^Zklbm
hi^kZm^]'H_Ö\bZeer%k^\knbmlp^k^
lniihl^]mh[^[^mp^^g*1Zg]+.
r^Zklh_Z`^%[nmbmpZlgÍmng\hffhg
_hkZ*.&hk*/&r^Zk&he]mh[en__abl
pZrbgÉhkmhaZo^abliZk^gmla^ei
abfeb^Z[hnmablZ`^'
@^hk`^Fhkkblhg%Zf^f[^kh_
ma^@kZg]IhkmZ`^[Zg]h_Hcb[p^%
pZlhger*0pa^ga^chbg^]ma^Bg&
To read additional personal accounts of the era, visit “In Their Words:
Stories of Minnesota’s Greatest Generation” on the Society’s website
at www.mngreatestgeneration.org.
]bZg=boblbhgh_ma^<bobebZg<hg&
blbhg h_ ma^ <bobebZg <hg
<hg&&
l^koZmbhg<hkilbg@kZg]IhkmZ`^'
g <hkil bg @kZg] IhkmZ`^'
ÊHg^r^ZkBphkd^]bgma^dbm\a^g'
d ]
a d a
Ma^gBphkd^]hnmlb]^bgma^phh]l'
?hk^lm^klp^k^ma^_hk^f^gZg]mhe]
nlpaZmmh]h'P^li^gm^o^kr]Zr
ineebg`nilfZeemk^^lmaZmp^k^[^&
`bggbg`mh[^]bl^Zl^]''''P^inee^]
ma^fhnmh_ma^`khng]lhma^]bl^Zl^
phne]gÍmlik^Z]'Ë .
Ma^rhng`Fbgg^lhmZgl
Ma^rhng`Fbgg^lhmZgl
pahchbg^]ma^<<<
pahchbg^]ma^<<<
e^Zkg^]e^llhglmaZm
e^Zkg^]e^llhglmaZm
lmZr^]pbmama^f_hk
lmZr^]pbmama^f_hk
fZgrr^Zklmh\hf^'
Bghma^kiZkmlh_Fbgg^lhmZ%
<<<k^\knbmlp^k^l^gmmhaZlmber
\hglmkn\m^]\Zfilpa^k^ma^rlhhg
l^mme^]bgmhZoZ`n^erfbebmZkrk^`b&
f^g'Ma^rieZgm^]mk^^l%bfikho^]
eZg]Zg]lmk^Zfl]ZfZ`^][rlhbe
^khlbhg%Zg][nbemÖk^[k^Zdl%Ök^
mhp^kl%]Zfl%_hk^lmkhZ]l%Zg]
\Zfi
\Zfi`khng]l'Ma^r^gkhee^]_hkaZe_
ZZr^ZkZg]p^k^iZb],)]heeZklZ
r^Zk
fhgma%+.h_pab\ap^gm]bk^\mermh
ma^bk_Zfbeb^l'Ma^rhng`Fbgg^lh&
mZglpahchbg^]ma^<<<e^Zkg^]e^l&
lhglmaZmlmZr^]pbmama^f_hkfZgr
r^Zklmh\hf^'?hkmahl^pahp^gm
hgmhl^ko^bgma^Zkf^]_hk\^l]nk&
bg`ma^pZk%ma^<<<l^ko^]ZlZdbg]
h_pZkf&ni'ÊBfnlmlZrbmmZn`amf^
ma^k^li^\mh_Znmahkbmr%h_bg]bob]nZe
k^lihglb[bebmr%ahpmhphkdZg]`^m
Zehg`pbmahma^kl%Ëk^\Zee^]K'Chag
;nldhpbZdh_Lm'<aZke^l'ÊFr]Zrl
bgma^<Íl]^o^ehi^]f^bgmhZfZg'Ë /
>o^gZl\abe]k^gZg]Z]he^l&
\^gmllmkn``e^]mh\hi^pbma]Zber
]^ikboZmbhgl]nkbg`ma^*2,)l%ma^r
^f[kZ\^]g^p\hglnf^kikh]n\ml
Zg]g^p_hkflh_^gm^kmZbgf^gmÉ
^li^\bZeerkZ]bhÉmaZma^ei^]ma^f
_^^e\hgg^\m^]mhebd^fbg]^]rhng`&
lm^kl^el^pa^k^bgma^Ngbm^]LmZm^l'
Pabe^lZe^lh_fhlm\hglnf^k`hh]l
]khii^]Z_m^kma^lmh\dfZkd^m\kZla
bg*2+2%kZ]bhl\hgmbgn^]mh×rh__
ma^la^eo^l':lma^Zn]b^g\^`k^p%
Hcb[p^<<<phkd^kl%@kZg]IhkmZ`^
d^kl%@kZg]IhkmZ`^
lmh\dZ]^lbm^%*2,0'Bgmphl^Zlhglh_Zk&
lmh\dZ]^lbm^%*2,0'Bgmphl^Zlhglh_Zk
0'Bgmphl^Zlhglh_Zk&&
0'Bgmphl^Zlhglh_Zk
\aZ^heh`b\Zephkd%\hkilf^gng\ho^k^]
d%\hkilf^gng\ho^k^]
^ob]^g\^e^Z]bg`mhma^k^\hglmkn\mbhgh_
ma^Ghkmap^lm<hfiZgr_nkihlm'
[khZ]\Zlm^klZ]]^]fhk^ikh`kZf&
fbg`Ébg\en]bg`lahplmZk`^m^]
]bk^\merZm\abe]k^g'Ikh`kZflebd^
CZ\d:kflmkhg`%Ma^:ee:f^kb\Zg
;hr%Ma^Ehg^KZg`^k%Zg]ma^
Ebmme^HkiaZg:ggb^Lahpkbo^m^]
rhng`eblm^g^kl'Lihglhkl%ehhdbg`
mh]^o^ehiZg^p`^g^kZmbhgh_ehrZe
\nlmhf^kl%h__^k^]db]likbs^lbg^q&
\aZg`^_hk[hqmhilZg]hma^kikhh_l
h_ink\aZl^'Ibi^lmhg^ÍlPZem^k;^g&
cZfbgpZlZfhg`ma^fZgrrhng`
Fbgg^lhmZglpahln\\nf[^]mhma^
k^e^gme^llkZ]bhibm\a^l'
>Z\aikh`kZfnk`^]eblm^g^klmh
ÊL>G=MAHL>;HQMHILBGË
bghk]^kmh^ZkgZli^\bZeikbs^
maZmphne][^fZbe^]mhnl'BaZ]
Zmhn`ambf^l^\nkbg`ma^ikhi^k
[hqmhil[^\Znl^?Zma^k]^\k^^]
maZmma^;^gcZfbg[k^Zd_ZlmaZ]
Winter 2006–07 161
mh[^ahmÉhZmf^Ze%FZem&H&F^Ze%
hZmf^Ze% FZem&H&F^Ze%
kZeer eZ\^] pbma kZblbgl
hkkr^Éeb[^kZeereZ\^]pbmakZblbgl
maZmaZ][^^glhZd^]ho^kgb`am'B
^g lhZd^] ho^kgb`am' B
[^``^]Fhma^kmh[nrma^ikhi^k
\he]\^k^Zelhgma^lerlhmaZmB
\hne]`^mma^ikbs^l'
0
Hma^k_hkflh_^gm^kmZbgf^gm
k^bg_hk\^]ma^\hffhggZmbhgZe
\nemnk^maZm]^o^ehi^]Zlma^]^ik^l&
lbhgleh``^]hg'<abe]k^g×h\d^]
mhma^fhob^lpa^gma^Zm^khpg^kl
ehp^k^]Z]fbllbhgikb\^lbgk^lihgl^
mhphkl^gbg`^\hghfb\\hg]bmbhgl'
:grdb]pbmaZ]bf^mhliZk^\hne]
li^g]Zg^gmbk^Z_m^kghhghk^o^gbg`
pZm\abg`ma^lZf^ÖeflmaZmhma^k
:f^kb\Zglp^k^pZm\abg`Éfhglm^k
×b\dlebd^?kZgd^glm^bgZg]Dbg`
Dhg`%p^lm^kgl^kbZelpbmaKhrKh`&
^klZg]@^g^:nmkr%Zg]`Zg`lm^k
]kZfZlebd^Ma^In[eb\>g^frZg]
L\Zk_Z\^'Lhf^h_ma^mhi[hq&h_Ö\^
lmZklh_ma^]^\Z]^p^k^\abe]k^ghk
162 Minnesota Histor y
Z]he^l\^gmlÉLabke^rM^fie^%Fb\d^r
Z]he^l\^gm
Khhg^r%Cn]r@ZkeZg]%=^ZggZ
Khhg^r% Cn
=nk[bg'Hma^krhng`lm^klli^gmma^bk
=nk[bg' Hm
ik^\bhnli^ggb^lhgZghma^kg^p
_hkfh_^gm^kmZbgf^gm3\hfb\[hhdl'
Bg*2,1%='<'<hfb\lin[ebla^]ma^
Öklmblln^h_Lni^kfZg'Bgma^r^Zkl
maZm_heehp^]%in[ebla^klbgmkh]n\^]
ang]k^]lh_hma^k\hfb\[hhdlni^k&
a^kh^l'Db]lp^k^^gmkZg\^]'FZgr
iZk^gmlp^k^ZiiZee^]'Ê:emahn`a
hma^kdb]laZ]\hfb\[hhdl!pab\a
ma^rk^Z]lnkk^imbmbhnlerbglmn]r
aZee"%Fhfphne]ghme^mnl[nr
ma^f%Ëpkhm^>ZkeK^bmZg%k^\Zeebg`
Rhng`lm^kl`Zma^kZkhng]ma^kZ]bhZm
Zkhng]ma^kZ]bhZm
La^em^kbg`:kfl%ZFbgg^Ziheblahf^_hk
ZFbgg^Ziheblahf^_hk
hkiaZg^]Zg]]^i^g]^gm\abe]k^g'
abl\abe]ahh]bg:e[^kmZ%Fbgg^lhmZ'
ÊLa^lZb]ma^rp^k^ZpZlm^h_fhg^r'
Blnli^\mla^mahn`amma^rphne]aZo^
[Z]fhkZe^__^\ml'ËHl\Zk;Z\deng]
k^f^f[^kl^qZ\merpaZma^pZl]hbg`
pa^g%ZlZ*.&r^Zk&he]%a^a^Zk]
Z[hnmma^ZmmZ\dhgI^ZkeAZk[hk3ÊB
pZlk^Z]bg`Z;ZmfZg\hfb\[hhd%
lbmmbg`bgZ[hhmaZmMb[[ÍlIaZkfZ\r
Zmma^\hkg^kh_Mabkmr&>b`amaLmk^^m
Zg];ehhfbg`mhg:o^gn^'Ë 1
Ma^=^ik^llbhg]b]ghmfZd^bm
<abe]k^g×h\d^]mhma^
<abe]k^g×h\d^]mhma^
fhob^lpa^gma^Zm^khpg^kl
ehp^k^]Z]fbllbhgikb\^l
ehp^k^]Z]fbllbhgikb\^l
bgk^lihgl^mhphkl^gbg`
bgk^lihgl^mhphkl^gbg`
^\hghfb\\hg]bmbhgl'
^Zlrmh[^Z\abe]%_hk\bg`fZgrmh
`khpnikZma^kjnb\der';nmehhdbg`
[Z\d%fhlmf^f[^klh_Fbgg^lhmZÍl
`k^Zm^lm`^g^kZmbhglZrmaZmma^r]b]
ghm_^^e\hfie^m^erl^bs^][raZk]
mbf^l':lFZkrChr;k^mhg%pahebo^]
bgma^ma^g&[Zkk^geZg]l\Zi^h_>]^g
<abe]k^ghnmlb]^Zgngb]^gmbÖ^][nm
hnmlb]^Zgngb]^gmbÖ^][nm
`kZg]ma^Zm^kÉ-%+))l^ZmlÉlahpbg`
^Zm^kÉ-%+))l^ZmlÉlahpbg`
Ho^kma^Abee%Z*2,*f^eh]kZfZ
Ho^kma^Abee%
Abee%Z*2,*f^eh]kZfZ
Z*2,*f^eh]kZfZ
IkZbkb^%k^f^f[^k^]3ÊMabl\abe]&
ahh]^qi^kb^g\^]nkbg`ma^@k^Zm
=^ik^llbhglhf^mbf^ll^^f^]fbl^k&
Z[e^mhf^%[nmbmmZn`amnldb]lbf&
ihkmZgme^llhglZ[hnmma^phkd^mab\%
laZkbg`%l^e_&ln_Ö\b^g\r%m^Zfphkd%
k^lhnk\^\hgl^koZmbhg%Zg]ma^oZen^
h_fhg^r':g]ma^k^p^k^fZgr_ng
mbf^lmhh%bglibm^h_bmZee'Ë 2
Ma^Fbgg^lhmZglpah`k^pni
]nkbg`ma^@k^Zm=^ik^llbhgp^k^iZkm
h_ma^`^g^kZmbhgmaZmp^gmhgmh_Z\^
fZgrmabg`lbgpZkZg]i^Z\^'Lhf^
ebo^]ebo^lh_jnb^m]b`gbmrZg]`kZ\^%
Zg]hma^kl\hgmbgn^]mh[Zmme^Z]o^k&
lbmrmakhn`ahnmma^bkZ]nemebo^l'Ma^bk
^qi^kb^g\^l]nkbg`ma^@k^Zm=^ik^l&
lbhgp^k^bglmknf^gmZebglaZibg`
ma^fbgmhma^i^hie^ma^r[^\Zf^' Not es
*'Dkblm^Ebg]^gf^r^k%Ma^@k^Zm^lm
*'
D
@^g^kZmbhg@khplNi3:f^kb\Zg<abe]ahh]
@^g^k
bgma^*2,)l!<ab\Z`h3BoZgK'=^^%+))."%
*.4=Zob]>'Drob`%=ZberEb_^bgma^Ngbm^]
LmZm^l%*2+)È*2-)3Ahp:f^kb\ZglEbo^]
=nkbg`ma^KhZkbg`Mp^gmb^lZg]ma^@k^Zm
=^ik^llbhg!<ab\Z`h3BoZgK'=^^%+))+"%
++*4GhkfZgD'Kblchk]%:IhineZkAblmhkr
h_Fbgg^lhmZ!Lm'IZne3Fbgg^lhmZAblmhkb&
\ZeLh\b^mrIk^ll%+))."%*2+4Ma^h]hk^<'
;e^`^g%Fbgg^lhmZ3:Ablmhkrh_ma^LmZm^
!Fbgg^Zihebl3Ngbo^klbmrh_Fbgg^lhmZ
Ik^ll%*2/,"%.+-'
+'Chl^iabg^Le^mmh%bgm^kob^p[rIZmkb\d
C'Fhhk^%:n`'-%*21)%mkZgl\kbim%\hirbg
Fbgg^lhmZAblmhkb\ZeLh\b^mr%Lm'IZne4
G^elhgI^^kr%;eZ\d?bk^3Ma^FZdbg`h_
Zg:f^kb\ZgK^ohenmbhgZkr!G^pRhkd3
G^pIk^ll%*22-"%2'
,'Fb\aZ^eDhlbZd%@khpbg`Nibg
<ablahefhgma^F^lZ[bBkhgKZg`^!Lm'
<ehn]3GhkmaLmZkIk^ll%+))."%+*)4
Kb\aZk]>'AZee%<abe]h_ma^@k^Zm=^ik^l&
lbhg!:nlmbg%FG3Fhp^k<hngmrAblmhkb&
\ZeLh\b^mr%*22*"%/04PZem^kP';^gcZfbg%
Ma^FZ`b\ZeR^Zkl3:;hrahh]K^f^f&
[kZg\^!>]bgZ%FG3;^Zo^kÍlIhg]Ik^ll%
*222"%**.'
-'=Zob]F'D^gg^]r%?k^^]hf?khf
?^Zk3Ma^:f^kb\ZgI^hie^bg=^ik^llbhg
Zg]PZk%*2+2È*2-.!G^pRhkd3Hq_hk]
Ngbo^klbmrIk^ll%*222"%*--'
222"% *--'
.'@^hk`^FhkkblhgpbmaFZk`hm?hkmn&
lhg pbma FZk`hm ?hkmn
?hkmn&&
gZmh@Zem%Mnkgbg`ma^?^Zma^k:khng]3Fr
ma^?^Zma^k:khng]3Fr
Eb_^bg:km!Lm'IZne3Fbgg^lhmZAblmhkb\Ze
Lh\b^mrIk^ll%*221"%-/'
/'K'Chag;nldhpbZd%ÊFr=Zrlbgma^
<'<'<'Íl%Ëmri^l\kbim%*22,%\hirbgFbgg^&
lhmZAblmhkb\ZeLh\b^mr'
0';^gcZfbg%FZ`b\ZeR^Zkl%+,-È,.'
1'>Zke:'K^bmZg%<khllbg`ma^;kb]`^3
@khpbg`NiGhkp^`bZg&:f^kb\Zgbg
=^ik^llbhgZg]PZk!Kh\a^lm^k%FG3Ehg^
HZdIk^ll%*222"%2)4KhgZe]@'I^kkb^k%
:L^gl^h_Ahghk3K^f^f[kZg\^lh_Phke]
PZkBBO^m^kZgl!Fbgg^Zihebl3:k\ab^In[&
eb\Zmbhgl%+))."%*2.!;Z\deng]jnhm^"'L^^
ZelhEbg]^gf^r^k%@k^Zm^lm@^g^kZmbhg
@khplNi%\aZim^k-'
2'FZkrChr;k^mhg%ÊIZkmOBB3K^\ho^kr
Zg]K^eb^_%ËLaZk^RhnkLmhkr%ppp'fgal'
hk`(i^hie^(fg``'
:eebfZ`^lZk^bgFAL\hee^\mbhgl'
Winter 2006–07 163
Book Reviews
;HHDK>OB>PL
Lm'IZneÍl:k\abm^\mnk^3:Ablmhkr
;rC^__k^r:'A^llZg]IZne<eb__hk]EZklhg
!Fbgg^Zihebl3Ngbo^klbmrh_Fbgg^lhmZIk^ll%+))/'
+01i'<ehma%,-'2.'"
Lm'IZneÍl:k\abm^\mnk^pZlr^Zklbg
ma^fZdbg`'LhfZgrr^Zkl%bg_Z\m%
maZmlhf^ikh[Z[erphg]^k^]b_bm
phne]^o^k[^Ögbla^]'Ma^[hhd
k^lnem^]_khfma^Lm'IZneA^kbmZ`^
Ik^l^koZmbhg<hffbllbhgÍl]^lbk^mh
lahp\Zl^ma^lie^g]b]Zk\abm^\mnk^
h_ma^\ZibmZe\bmrmakhn`aablmhkb\Ze
gZkkZmbo^%ZgZiikhZ\amaZmblZlm^iniÉZ`bZgmlm^iniÉ
_khfma^ÊÖ^e]`nb]^Ë_hkfZmfZgr\bmb^lZ]himmhlahp\Zl^
\hffngbmrZk\abm^\mnk^'Ma^gZkkZmbo^lm^fl_khfma^\bmrÍl
Ablmhkb\Lbm^lLnko^r%Z*21)llmn]rmaZmbgoheo^]^qZfbgbg`
ma^[nbem^gobkhgf^gmhgobkmnZeer^o^krlmk^^m'Bg^ll^g\^%
bml`hZepZlmhibg]hpgik^\bl^erpaZmLm'IZneh__^k^]bg
ma^pZrh_lmkn\mnkZee^`Z\r'Pbmalnko^rbgaZg]%A^llZg]
EZklhgl^mZ[hnmikh]n\bg`ma^fhlmmahkhn`aZ\\hngmh_
Lm'IZneÍlZk\abm^\mnkZelmhkr'
:emahn`ama^[hhdmhhdehg`^kmaZgfZgr%bg\en]bg`ma^
Znmahkl%aZ]ahi^]%ma^Ögbla^]ikh]n\m]^fhglmkZm^lpaZm
\Zg[^Z\\hfiebla^]pbmakb`hkhnlk^l^Zk\aZg]f^mb\nehnl
pkbmbg`%\aZkZ\m^kblmb\lmaZmZk^aZeefZkdlh_[hmaZnmahkl'
A^llblZ\nemnkZeablmhkbZgpah_hng]^]hg^h_ma^\hngmkrÍl
^Zkeb^lmablmhkb\Ze\hglnembg`Ökflbgma^Mpbg<bmb^l%pabe^
EZklhgblZFbgg^lhmZin[eb\ablmhkbZgpbmal^o^kZeZk\abm^\&
mnk^&k^eZm^][hhdlmhabl\k^]bm';hmabgmbfZm^erng]^klmZg]
Lm'IZneÍl[nbema^kbmZ`^'
MablbgmbfZm^dghpe^]`^bl^ob]^gm^ZkerZg]h_m^g%Zl
ma^Znmahklpkbm^Zlb_Zkmb\neZmbg`ma^eb_^lmhkrh_Zghe]
_kb^g]Épab\ablik^\bl^erpaZmma^rZk^]hbg`'Ma^ikhl^bl
laZkiZg]pbmmr'?hkbglmZg\^%pabe^]^l\kb[bg`ma^mhp^kbg`
ikhÖe^h_ma^Lm'IZne<bmrAZeeZg]KZfl^r<hngmr<hnkm&
ahnl^%maZmphg]^k_neerFh]^kg^fhgnf^gm%A^llh[l^ko^l
maZmma^lmkn\mnk^m^kfbgZm^lÊbgZmabg_kb^s^%Zlb_ma^[nbe]&
bg`fb`amfhf^gmZkberk^lnf^bmlo^kmb\Ze`khpma'ËLn\apbm&
mb\blfbli^ii^k^]makhn`ahnmma^eZoblaerbeenlmkZm^][hhd'
Ma^lmZklh_mablphkdZk^ma^[nbe]bg`lh_Lm'IZne%h_
\hnkl^%Zg]gnf^khnlin[eb\%\hff^k\bZe%k^lb]^gmbZe%Zg]
libkbmnZelmkn\mnk^lZk^ab`aeb`am^]%bg\en]bg`ikhfbg^gm
hg^lebd^ma^N'L'<hnkmahnl^Zg]IhlmH_Ö\^!EZg]fZkd
<^gm^k"%ma^<Zma^]kZeh_Lm'IZne%Zg]ma^Lm'IZneIn[eb\
Eb[kZkrZg]CZf^lC'AbeeK^_^k^g\^Eb[kZkr';nmie^gmb_ne
e^ll^k&dghpg[nbe]bg`lZk^Zelha^k^%ln\aZlma^]^eb`am_ne
PbeebZfA'Zg]B]Z@ZkeZg]Ahnl^Zg]ma^hk`Zgb\&ehhdbg`
;^mae^a^f@^kfZgIk^l[rm^kbZg<ank\a%Zlp^eeZlma^G^p
RhkdEb_^BglnkZg\^<hfiZgr;nbe]bg`%Z_ZgmZlmb\]nZe&
164 Minnesota Histor y
mhp^k^]K^gZbllZg\^&K^oboZe^]bÖ\^maZmpZlkZs^]bgma^
*2/)lmhfZd^pZr_hkma^e^ll&bl&fhk^iabehlhiarh_fh]&
^kgblf'Ebd^mabl[nbe]bg`%lhf^h_ma^lmkn\mnk^l_^Zmnk^]
bgmabl[hhdZk^ghp`hg^%r^mfZgrk^fZbg'
A^llZg]EZklhg]hghmmk^Zmma^[nbe]bg`lbgblheZm^]
ob`g^mm^l[nmp^Zo^^Z\abgmhZmZi^lmkrmaZmblma^mZe^h_
Lm'IZneÍlZk\abm^\mnkZefZmnkbmr'Bg]^^]%ma^Znmahkl^fiehr
ma^\bmrÍlZk\abm^\mnkZe\hfihg^gmlmhfho^ma^gZkkZmbo^
_hkpZk]makhn`ambf^%l^Zfe^ller[e^g]bg`ma^k^\hk]h_
hg^bgmhma^g^qm'Fhk^ho^k%ma^Znmahkl^glnk^maZmma^
Zk\abm^\mlpahlaZi^]Lm'IZnek^\^bo^ln[lmZgmbZeZ\dghpe&
^]`^f^gm_hkma^bkeZ[hkl'Ma^r%mhh%Zk^o^ab\e^lmaZma^ei
Z]oZg\^ma^lmhkrh_Lm'IZneÍlZk\abm^\mnkZechnkg^r_khf
kZpg^llZg]\kn]bmrmh^Zker<eZllb\ZeK^oboZe%Ob\mhkbZg%
Zg]Ib\mnk^ljn^lmre^l%ikh`k^llbg`mhma^fh]^kgblfh_
ma^k^\^gmiZlmZg]%ÖgZeer%mhma^Zk\abm^\mnk^h_mh]Zr'Bg
Zl^gl^%paZmp^^g]pbmablZg^ehjn^gmablmhkrh_Lm'IZne
mhe]makhn`abmllmkn\mnkZe_Z\^'
:mahkhn`aerbg_hkfZmbo^Zg]^gchrZ[e^k^Z]%Lm'IZneÍl
:k\abm^\mnk^blZfnlm_hkmahl^pahob^pZk\abm^\mnk^Zl
Zk^×^\mbhgh_lh\b^mZe]blihlbmbhg'>o^gfhk^%ma^phkd
lahne][^hgma^la^e_h_Zgrpah\ZeeLm'IZneahf^%_hkbm
blma^bklmhkr%^fZgZmbg`_khfma^_Z\Z]^lh_ma^g^b`a[hk&
ahh]lZg]\hff^k\bZe]blmkb\mlmaZmfZd^nihg^h_:f^kb&
\ZÍlfhlmZmmkZ\mbo^fZchknk[Zg\^gm^kl'
K^ob^p^][r=^gblI'@Zk]g^k%Znmahkh_ma^ZpZk]&pbggbg`
Fbgg^lhmZMk^Zlnk^l3Lmhkb^l;^abg]ma^LmZm^ÍlAblmhkb\
IeZ\^l!+))-"'
<abe]ahh]hgma^?Zkf3
<abe]ahh]hgma^?Zkf3
Phkd%IeZr%Zg]<hfbg`
Phkd%IeZr%Zg]<hfbg`
h_:`^bgma^Fb]p^lm
;rIZf^eZKbg^r&D^ak[^k`
!EZpk^g\^3Ngbo^klbmrIk^llh_DZglZl%
+)).',))i'<ehma%,-'2.'"
Makhn`a^qm^glbo^Zg]iZbglmZdbg`
k^l^Zk\a%IZf^eZKbg^r&D^ak[^k`aZl
pkbmm^gma^lmhkrh_ma^\abe]k^gpah
`k^pnihgfb]p^lm^kg_Zkfl[^mp^^g*10)Zg]*2+)'La^
m^eelma^lmhkrg^Zmerbg\aZim^kl]^ohm^]mhphkd%ieZr%^]n&
\Zmbhg%\abe]p^e_Zk^%Zg]`khpbg`niZg]e^Zobg`ma^_Zkf
_hkma^\bmr'MablblZmhn`aln[c^\mmhk^l^Zk\a%[nmla^aZl
]hg^ZÖg^ch[h_eh\Zmbg`\abe]k^gÍl]bZkb^l%e^mm^kl%f^fhbkl
h_Z]nemlpah`k^pnihg_Zkfl%Zg]]h\nf^gml\k^Zm^][r
ma^bkiZk^gml%m^Z\a^kl%Zg]`ho^kgf^gmZ`^gmlpahehhd^]
Z_m^kma^bkp^ee[^bg`'
Copyright of Minnesota History is the property of the Minnesota
Historical Society and its content may not be copied or emailed to
multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder’s
express written permission. Users may print, download, or email
articles, however, for individual use.
To request permission for educational or commercial use, contact us.
www.mnhs.org/mnhistory