Working with Primary Sources

BEDFORD CUSTOM TUTORIAL FOR HISTORY
Working with Primary Sources
As a student in a history course, you probably have some preconceived
ideas about what you will be studying and how you will study it. But
your college-level history may surprise you. You may have thought that
the study of history is about “facts,” when the study of history has as
much to do with working with and evaluating sources and as evidence as
it does with learning dates, names, events, and places from the past. In
this tutorial, you will learning the following:
•
•
•
•
What exactly are historical sources
The difference between primary and secondary sources
How to read and analyze a written source
How to read and analyze a visual source
What Are Historical Sources?
The stories historians tell in books, articles, and lectures are pieced together
from hundreds, often thousands, of documents, objects, and artifacts. The
challenge is to turn all of those individual pieces of evidence into a convincing, compelling version of the past.
That’s no easy task. Most historical evidence was produced by people
with no direct interest in telling the story of their times. While historians
do have access to the occasional chronicle or official account, far more
typical is the kind of evidence people produce to meet immediate needs,
not to enlighten future generations. A merchant bills his or her customer,
and creates a historical document in the process. A woman is convicted of
theft, an unhappy event that is commemorated in the legal documents
associated with her trial. An artisan crafts an engraved silver chalice for a
wealthy client, and another piece of evidence is produced. The bill, the
records, and the chalice all offer valuable clues about the past, but none
were created for that purpose. It is up to the historian to tease out the
implications of the document or artifact, and to make connections between
the evidence and his or her historical argument or thesis.
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 1
1
11/10/15 12:38 PM
2 Working with Primary Sources
Distinguishing between Primary and
Secondary Sources
Before we go any further in our discussion, it’s important to explain the
distinction between primary and secondary sources. A primary source is a
document, object, or image created during the time period under study.
Such sources are the basic evidence historians use to construct their s­ tories
about the past. Secondary sources, in contrast, offer interpretations or analyses of the past. In other words, primary sources are the subject of historical
research, and secondary sources are the results of historical research.
Your textbook, professional journals, scholarly books, and even Web
sites can all serve as useful secondary sources. Beyond such written secondary sources, there are also many different types of visual secondary
sources. Maps, tables, charts, graphs, and videos can all be used as effective tools for presenting a historian’s analysis of primary sources. Thus,
examples of secondary sources include:
•Textbook
• Scholarly journal presenting recent work in modern history
• Scholarly journal open to the best scholarship in any historical field
• Microhistory that explores the significance of a single event
• Multivolume history that covers many centuries and many places
• Map showing the routes taken by famous sixteenth-century explorers
• Map showing eighteenth-century Atlantic trade patterns
•Chart showing the decline in economic output during the Great
­Depression
• Graph showing changes in average per capita income over time
• Table comparing literacy levels at different places in a given year
• Video exploring the experiences of real soldiers during World War I
• Museum Web site that links objects in its collection to historical
­developments
•Historian’s Web site that includes resources for students and
­instructors
As helpful as secondary sources can be, you need to be careful when
selecting them, particularly when you look for information online. While
professional journals and university publishers review proposed articles
and books, and only publish those that meet their standards, no such vetting process occurs prior to Internet publication. It’s up to you to carefully
examine any Web site you propose to use as a resource to make sure the
information it contains is reliable.
As a student of history, you’ll use both primary and secondary sources,
often in conjunction with each another. For example, your instructor may
ask you to read and analyze a letter written by the colonial minister Cotton
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 2
11/10/15 12:38 PM
Analyzing Written Primary Sources 3
Mather. To get the most out of your reading of this primary source, you’ll
need to examine it carefully, noting the details of Mather’s ideas and arguments. You’ll also need to consult your textbook, a secondary source, to
help you understand the historical context in which Mather’s letter was
written. Thus, the two kinds of sources work together. Primary sources,
like the letter, provide an opportunity for you to develop your own interpretations of the past. Secondary sources, like your textbook, provide a
framework for your analysis, helping you to place primary sources in the
context of the events and developments of their time.
Analyzing Written Primary Sources
Reading and analyzing historical documents can sometimes feel like a
daunting challenge, particularly if the document’s vocabulary, style, and
subject matter are new to you. The task can be made easier, however, if
you proceed in a systematic fashion, starting with the establishment of
basic facts, and then moving toward more complex levels of analysis. With
this in mind, the following six questions provide a step-by-step approach
to the analysis of historical documents.
Who wrote this document, when, and where?
The analysis of historical documents begins with the establishment of the
basic facts: where, when, and by whom was the document written. These
facts are critical because if we want to discover the historical significance of
a document, we need to start by situating it and its author in a specific time
and place. Sometimes these questions have straightforward, precise answers.
We know, for example, that the Stamp Act, a law requiring British colonists
to pay a tax on printed materials, was written by members of the British
government in England in 1765. In other cases, however, we must be content with educated guesses. We may never know exactly when, where, and
by whom an ancient Egyptian papyrus was created. The best we can do is
to use the available evidence to deduce the most likely answers to these
questions, and acknowledge that our conclusions are subject to revision if
new information comes to light.
Identifying the author is also important because it alerts us to the issue
of author bias. In this context, author bias does not necessarily refer to an
intentional effort to distort or deceive. Instead, it refers to the fact that
every author has his or her own agenda and particular point of view. Thus,
it is not enough simply to know an author’s name. We need to know something about the author’s background, about how this author viewed the
world, and about how he or she came to produce the document we’re
examining.
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 3
11/10/15 12:38 PM
4 Working with Primary Sources
What type of document is this?
All written genres have their own their own distinctive rules and characteristics. Sometimes those rules and characteristics are relatively rigid. A formal legal plea, for example, may follow guidelines about content and
organization established by law. In other instances, such as personal letters,
the rules of the genre may be looser. In either case, identifying what type of
document we are dealing with is an important step in establishing its
importance. If we know what kinds of rules and conventions an author was
working within, we’ll be able to discern their influence on the document
the author created. Just as important, we’ll notice when the author deviates
from established practices and produces something new and unique.
Who is the intended audience of the document?
There is often a close connection between a document and its intended
audience. A twentieth-century American crime novel may have been
intended to reach a mass audience that included representatives of all segments of society. In sharp contrast, the readers of a legal decision rendered
by a sixteenth-century high court may have been limited to a small number of highly educated elites. Finally, a personal letter may have had an
intended audience of one, its recipient. Identifying the audience for a document is important because when authors create documents, they often
makes choices of language, style, and content based on their assumptions
about their audience’s preferences and beliefs. Moreover, the historical
importance of a document is determined, at least in part, by who read it
and what influence it had on its readers.
What are the main points of the document?
As you set out on your exploration of a document, you’ll want to start by
identifying its main points. For this reason, while reading, you should
mark words, phrases, and passages that strike you as particularly important. With this task completed, you can go back over the document and
start to make connections between its main points and the specific choices
the author made about style, organization, content, and emphasis.
Why was this document written?
Documents are always written for a reason and that reason shapes the
document’s content and significance. For example, a formal declaration of
war might be intended both to announce the commencement of hostilities
and to present the case that war is necessary. Understanding these intentions leads us to ask follow-up questions. What argument did the authors
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 4
11/10/15 12:38 PM
Working through a Written Primary Source 5
make in favor going to war? Who was this argument meant to convince?
How effective was it? In contrast, a letter from a father to a son offering
advice might have been written solely for the recipient’s benefit. In this
case, we might ask ourselves what light the letter sheds on familial relationships during the period in which it was written. How formal was the
letter? Was it affectionate or businesslike? What kind of advice did the
father offer? Was the advice presented as suggestions or as commands?
What does this document reveal about the time and place in
which it was written?
The point of analyzing a document or artifact is not to produce a mere summary or description. It is to build a case for the document’s or artifact’s
historical meaning. It must be stressed that there is no single right answer to
this question. This is because readers bring their own goals and purposes to
their analyses. A military historian might read an account of a medieval
battle in order to gain insight into the evolution of military strategies and
tactics. A social historian might be more interested in what the account tells
us about who fought medieval battles and how they experienced warfare.
Finally, a political historian might be most interested in the implications of
the battle for future relations between medieval states. As long as the argument presented by each of these historians is grounded in fact and is logically consistent, they are equally valid.
Working through a Written Primary Source
To help you better understand the nature of historical analysis and develop
your own analytical abilities, apply the questions and approaches described
above to the following historical document. Be sure to read the headnote
that introduces the document first. It serves as a secondary source, alerting
you to critical issues of historical context, and thus guides and illuminates
your reading. Once you’ve read the headnote, work through the six questions in order, beginning with the basic facts and finishing with general
conclusions about the document’s historical importance.
TITLE
Jourdon Anderson, “Letter from a Freedman” (1865)
HEADNOTE
In August 1865, just months after the conclusion of the Civil War, Colonel
P. H. Anderson of Tennessee wrote to Jourdon Anderson, his former slave,
with an offer of employment. At the time the letter was written, Jourdon
Anderson was living as a free man in Ohio. His response to his former
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 5
11/10/15 12:38 PM
6 Working with Primary Sources
master’s letter, included below, offers the historian a window into the
master-slave relationship, the nature of life under slavery, and into the
meaning of freedom for the millions of African Americans who were
emancipated as a result of the Civil War.
DOCUMENT
To my old Master, Colonel P. H. Anderson, Big Spring, Tennessee.
Sir: I got your letter, and was glad to find that you had not forgotten
Jourdon, and that you wanted me to come back and live with you again,
promising to do better for me than anybody else can. I have often felt
uneasy about you. I thought the Yankees would have hung you long before this, for harboring Rebs they found at your house. I suppose they
never heard about your going to Colonel Martin’s to kill the Union s­ oldier
that was left by his company in their stable. Although you shot at me
twice before I left you, I did not want to hear of your being hurt, and am
glad you are still living. It would do me good to go back to the dear old
home again, and see Miss Mary and Miss Martha and Allen, Esther,
Green, and Lee. Give my love to them all, and tell them I hope we will
meet in the better world, if not in this. I would have gone back to see you
all when I was working in the Nashville Hospital, but one of the neighbors told me that Henry intended to shoot me if he ever got a chance.
I want to know particularly what the good chance is you propose to
give me. I am doing tolerably well here. I get twenty-five dollars a month,
with victuals and clothing; have a comfortable home for Mandy,—the folks
call her Mrs. Anderson,—and the children—Milly, Jane, and Grundy—go
to school and are learning well. The teacher says Grundy has a head for
a preacher. They go to Sunday school, and Mandy and me attend church
regularly. We are kindly treated. Sometimes we overhear others saying,
“Them colored people were slaves” down in Tennessee. The children feel
hurt when they hear such remarks; but I tell them it was no disgrace in
Tennessee to belong to Colonel Anderson. Many darkeys would have
been proud, as I used to be, to call you master. Now if you will write and
say what wages you will give me, I will be better able to decide whether
it would be to my advantage to move back again.
As to my freedom, which you say I can have, there is nothing to be
gained on that score, as I got my free papers in 1864 from the Provost-­
Marshal-General of the Department of Nashville. Mandy says she would
be afraid to go back without some proof that you were disposed to treat
us justly and kindly; and we have concluded to test your sincerity by
asking you to send us our wages for the time we served you. This will
make us forget and forgive old scores, and rely on your justice and friendship in the future. I served you faithfully for thirty-two years, and Mandy
twenty years. At twenty-five dollars a month for me, and two dollars a
week for Mandy, our earnings would amount to eleven thousand six
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 6
11/10/15 12:38 PM
Working through a Written Primary Source 7
hundred and eighty dollars. Add to this the interest for the time our
wages have been kept back, and deduct what you paid for our clothing,
and three doctor’s visits to me, and pulling a tooth for Mandy, and the
balance will show what we are in justice entitled to. Please send the
money by Adams’s Express, in care of V. Winters, Esq., Dayton, Ohio. If
you fail to pay us for faithful labors in the past, we can have little faith
in your promises in the future. We trust the good Maker has opened your
eyes to the wrongs which you and your fathers have done to me and my
fathers, in making us toil for you for generations without recompense.
Here I draw my wages every Saturday night; but in Tennessee there was
never any pay-day for the negroes any more than for the horses and
cows. Surely there will be a day of reckoning for those who defraud the
laborer of his hire.
In answering this letter, please state if there would be any safety for my
Milly and Jane, who are now grown up, and both good-looking girls. You
know how it was with poor Matilda and Catherine. I would rather stay
here and starve—and die, if it come to that—than have my girls brought to
shame by the violence and wickedness of their young masters. You will
also please state if there has been any schools opened for the colored children in your neighborhood. The great desire of my life now is to give my
children an education, and have them form virtuous habits.
Say howdy to George Carter, and thank him for taking the pistol from
you when you were shooting at me.
From your old servant,
Jourdon Anderson.
Source: Jourdon Anderson, “Letter from a Freedman” in The Freedmen’s Book by L. Maria
Child (Boston: Ticknor and Fields, 1865), 265.
Now, let’s apply our six steps to the document you just read.
Who wrote this document, when, and where?
The letter was dictated by Jourdon Anderson, an ex-slave, in 1865. Anderson was living in Dayton, Ohio, when the letter was written, having left his
former master’s plantation in Big Spring, Tennessee. All of these facts are
important to our analysis. First, the writer was someone who had lived as
a slave and as a free man, and whose perspective with shaped by both
experiences. Second, the letter was written in the immediate aftermath of
the Civil War. Finally, Anderson had moved from Tennessee, a former slave
state, to Ohio, a free state that had been home to a number of leading abolitionists prior to the war. Thus, he was in a position to compare and contrast life for African Americans in two very different societies.
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 7
11/10/15 12:38 PM
8 Working with Primary Sources
What type of document is it?
The document is a personal letter. As such, it is a kind of person-to-person
communication. Unlike a book or a pamphlet, it did not address itself to
anonymous readers. Instead, it spoke specifically to a particular individual, one who knew the author well and with whom the author had a
shared history.
Who is the intended audience of the document?
The most straightforward answer to this question is that the intended audience of the letter was Colonel Anderson. However, the letter’s many references to Colonel Anderson’s family and acquaintances suggest that Jourdon
Anderson expected the contents of the letter to be shared with others.
Beyond this, the letter ultimately appeared in The Freedmen’s Book, an 1865
volume intended to publicize the views and experiences of ex-slaves. Thus,
while initially intended for Colonel Anderson and a handful of other individuals, it became part of Reconstruction-era public discourse.
What are the main points of the document?
Throughout the letter, Jourdon Anderson compared and contrasted his life
in Tennessee as a slave with his new life as free man in Ohio, in every
instance finding conditions in Ohio superior to those in Tennessee. In so
doing, he repeatedly challenged Colonel Anderson’s implicit assumptions
about the nature of the two men’s relationship. While Colonel Anderson
saw his offer of employment as a favor extended from a benevolent superior to a dependent servant, Jourdon Anderson turned the tables on his old
master, reminding Colonel Anderson of his past misdeeds and making
clear that he did not enjoy Anderson’s trust or respect.
Why was the document written?
On the surface, the letter was a response to an offer of employment. As
such, it was written in order to detail the conditions under which Anderson might agree to that offer. It is clear, however, that Jourdon Anderson
had no expectation of his terms being accepted, and even less desire to
move back to Tennessee. Given this, we must ask what his real motives
were for responding to his old master’s letter. After all, he had the option
of simply ignoring Colonel Anderson’s offer. What was it that he wanted
Colonel Anderson to know? Put as concisely as possible, it seems that he
wanted his old master to know that he was, and, in a sense, had always
been, a free man. This assessment is consistent with Jourdon Anderson’s
choice to address Colonel Anderson as a social equal, to enumerate the
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 8
11/10/15 12:38 PM
Analyzing Visual Primary Sources 9
evils of life on the colonel’s plantation, and his clear implication that Colonel
Anderson was beholden to him, not the other way around.
What does this document reveal about the time and place in
which it was written?
The Thirteenth Amendment to the Constitution abolished slavery in the
United States. It did not, however, define the meaning of freedom for
ex-slaves. This issue was at the heart of the conflicts and debates of the
Reconstruction period. Jourdon Anderson’s letter offers a freedman’s
­perspective. In it, he described his life as a free man, pointing out all of
the advantages of his new situation, and making clear the importance he
attached to personal freedom, education, and economic independence. In
so doing, he helped historians answer a crucial question about the Reconstruction era: What did ex-slaves want and why?
Analyzing Visual Primary Sources
Written documents are at the heart of much historical analysis, but they
are not the only sources of historical evidence. Clues about historical
developments can also be discovered in material objects, in art, and in
architecture. Such nonwritten sources present their own distinct challenges. In general, they require more interpretation and extrapolation on
the part of the historian than do written sources, which are often explicit
about their motives and messages. Nonetheless, the process of analyzing
a painting or a photograph is very much like analyzing a document—you
begin with six questions similar to the ones you have already applied to
Jourdon Anderson’s “Letter from a Freedman,” moving from basic facts to
more complex analytical issues.
Who created this image, when, and where?
Just as was the case with written sources, the analysis of visual evidence
begins with the establishment of basic facts: where, when, and by whom
was the image created. And again, as was the case with written sources,
our answers cannot always be as precise as we would like. Sometimes this
is because we simply lack definitive information. In other cases, the circumstances under which the evidence was created complicate the question. For example, most art produced during the Italian Renaissance was
commissioned by wealthy patrons. Such patrons had a significant say in
the size, style, and subject matter of the works they commissioned. Given
this, might we not make the argument that such patrons should be considered as cocreators?
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 9
11/10/15 12:38 PM
10 Working with Primary Sources
What type of image is this?
To fully answer this question, we need go beyond simple answers like “this
is a photograph,” or “this is a painting.” If it is a photograph, is it candid or
is it staged? If it’s a painting, is it a landscape or a formal portrait, a religious scene or a depiction of a historical event? Like written sources, visual
sources often belong to genres. If we can identify an image’s genre, along
with its rules and conventions, we take a big step forward in our process of
interpretation and analysis.
Who are the intended viewers of the image?
The intended audience for an image gives us crucial clues about its importance. Suppose we’re looking at the cover of a popular American magazine
from the 1950s. We may deduce that the image was meant to appeal to a wide
range of people and that’s its meaning was one that most people of that time
and place would have understood at a glance. In contrast, imagine the subject
of our analysis is a religious fresco painted on an interior wall of a chapel.
Confronted with such an image, we might ask ourselves who worshipped in
the chapel and what role the image played in their religious practice.
What is the central message of the image?
Images can convey powerful messages, but they are often challenging to
decipher. Instead of using words, artists use visual elements to communicate
their ideas. As a historian, your task is to learn how to “read” an image, to
make connections between the artist’s choices about composition, color,
and subject matter on the one hand, and his or her intended message on the
other. As you did with written sources, start with the image’s main features,
then move on to the details and their interrelationships.
Why was the image produced?
Like written sources, visual sources are created for a wide range of purposes. A painting, sculpture, or photograph may be meant to educate, to
persuade, to enlighten, or to shock. Understanding this purpose is central
to discovering its historical meaning. For example, the Incas did not commission sculptures and other art objects for their temples simply to serve
as decorations. Temple decorations both explained and were part of the
ceremonies that took place at temples. Thus, without an understanding of
Inca religion, it is impossible to achieve a full appreciation of Inca art.
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 10
11/10/15 12:38 PM
Working through a Primary Visual Source 11
What does this image reveal about the society and time period
in which it was created?
A visual source can often illuminate many different aspects of the past,
and there is no single correct answer to this question. A fifteenth-century
painting of the Madonna and Child, for example, might help us understand
fifteenth-century religious beliefs and practices, social and political hierarchies, and gender roles. This does not mean that the interpretation of a
visual source is simply a matter of opinion. As students of history, we are
interested in understanding the actions and beliefs of the people of the
past. To achieve this goal, we must ground our interpretations in a detailed
understanding of historical context.
Working through a Primary Visual Source
With the guidelines above in mind, let’s examine a visual source. As you
did with the written source, apply the questions and approaches described
above to the example, beginning by establishing the basic facts, and then
moving on to broader, more conceptual issues. Be sure to take the time to
examine the image carefully and to read the headnote and image caption
before you turn to the questions.
TITLE
Women Workers in World War II (1944)
HEADNOTE
During the Second World War, millions of African Americans and women
poured into U.S. war industries to do jobs that had been done by white men
before the war. Recruited by the government to do these critical jobs of wartime production, government propaganda lauded these workers, in this case
emphasizing the role of African Americans and people of other nationalities
in the war effort. The Office of War information wrote this caption about the
image below: “The six plane factories of the Douglas Aircraft Company have
been termed an industrial melting pot, since men and women of fifty-eight
national origins work side by side in pushing America’s plane output. S. O.
Porter, Douglas director of personnel, recently declared that Negros are doing
an outstanding job in all plants. Dora Miles and Dorothy Johnson are employed in the Long Beach Plant of the Douglas Aircraft Company.”
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 11
11/10/15 12:38 PM
Library of Congress
12 Working with Primary Sources
Now, let’s apply our six steps to the image.
Who created this image, when, and where?
The photograph was taken in the United States in 1944 by an employee of
the Office of War Information, a federal agency that was created to coordinate the distribution of American propaganda during World War II. These
facts are crucial to our analysis. They suggest that the image was created
in a time of crisis with an intent to persuade.
What type of image is this?
Here again, the basic facts have significant implications for our analysis.
This is a wartime photograph taken by an employee of a federal propaganda agency. This, in combination with the careful lighting and com­
position of the photograph, allows us to reasonably conclude that the
photograph was staged. This does not necessarily mean that it is wholly
unreflective of reality, but it does indicate a certain degree of manipulation. We are not looking at a candid photograph taken by a neutral photographer, interested solely in capturing a spontaneous and unrehearsed
moment. This is a piece of carefully crafted propaganda and should be
viewed as such.
Who were its intended viewers?
The Office of War Information played a key role in building and maintaining public support for the war effort. Photographs such as this one were
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 12
11/10/15 12:38 PM
Working through a Primary Visual Source 13
printed in newspapers and other periodicals and were intended to
shape the attitudes and behavior of the American people. Beyond this
general audience and purpose, this particular photograph may have been
intended to reassure African Americans that they had equal access to
employment in defense industries and that their contributions were valued. This would help explain the inclusion in the caption of the decla­
ration by Douglas’s director of personnel that “Negroes are doing an
outstanding job in all plants.”
What is the central message of the image?
The photograph shows Dora Miles, an African American woman, and Dorothy Johnson, a white woman, working in close and cheerful cooperation.
Thus, the image suggests that the war effort was characterized by racial
harmony. The probability that race, and not gender, was uppermost in the
mind of the government officials who ordered the creation of this photograph is supported by the caption, which stressed the racial and ethnic
diversity of the Douglas Aircraft plant, and not the fact that the subjects of
the photograph were women.
Why was the image produced?
Having established that the photograph was meant to convey the idea of
racial harmony, we must now ask why the federal government might have
wanted to disseminate such a message. As is often the case with visual
evidence, the photograph and caption do not explicitly address this issue
of motive. Therefore, to answer this question we must go beyond the photograph itself and ask additional questions about the historical context in
which the photograph was taken. What were race relations like in the
United States in the early 1940s? How had the war affected race relations?
Given that the photograph was taken in the midst of a global war, what
role might international developments have played in the federal government’s decision to commission the photograph? Your textbook, a secondary source, is good place to start your search for answers to such questions.
Once you’ve discovered the necessary information about historical context, you’ll be in a position to complete your analysis.
What does this image reveal about the society and time period
in which it was created?
Our analysis so far has suggested a link between this image and the evolving role of the federal government in American race relations. It should be
noted, however, that race relations and racial policies during the war are
not the only subjects on which this image might shed light. For example,
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 13
11/10/15 12:38 PM
14 Working with Primary Sources
historians interested in wartime propaganda or the entry of millions of
American women into the industrial workforce might also find this photograph interesting and provocative. In addition, the photograph might be
equally useful to historians looking back to the war years for antecedents
of later developments, including the civil rights movement of the 1950s
and the women’s movement of the 1960s. As was suggested above, additional research into historical context is necessary if you want to uncover
the motives behind the creation of the photograph and, ultimately, its
importance as a piece of historical evidence. This is an important part of
the analytical process and one you should expect to carry out every time
you analyze a piece of historical evidence.
Conclusion
As our examples have demonstrated, the successful analysis of historical
primary sources requires you to examine the evidence closely, to proceed
carefully and logically, and to use your creativity and imagination. It also
requires you to draw on your knowledge of historical context, adding to
it when necessary by consulting secondary sources such as textbooks,
articles, and Web sites. This last point is crucial. Historical documents and
images cannot be analyzed in isolation. They were created in a particular
time and place. They reflect the experiences, values, and beliefs of their
creators. Thus, your job as a student of history is not simply to describe
the content of a document or image but to bring it back to life by placing
it within the unique context in which it came into being.
Copyright © Bedford/St. Martin’s. Distributed by Bedford/St. Martin’s.
Strictly for use with its products. Not for redistribution.
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 14
11/10/15 12:38 PM
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 15
11/10/15 12:38 PM
216781_09_WorkingPrimarySources_6.5x9.125_r1jh.indd 16
11/10/15 12:38 PM