which adjusted attributable fractions for all singles, pairs, and triples

Letters to the Editor
which adjusted attributable fractions for all singles, pairs,
and triples of four risk factors were estimated by means of
a logistic model, this phenomenon of subadditivity of
adjusted attributable fractions was observed in more than
half of all reported pairs of factors (11 of 20) in different
models.
Finally, the nonadditivity of individual attributable fractions has been given considerable attention in the epidemiologic literature. Walter (9) and others (10, 11) showed that
for conventional attributable fraction parameters, additivity
is generally obtained only under conditions that seldom are
fulfilled in practice, and Coughlin et al. (12) used additivity of attributable fractions to advocate the use of additive
(without interaction terms) rather than multiplicative models. The property of additivity is obviously attractive for
ease of interpretation of attributable fraction estimates and
especially useful in tort-law liability situations. Therefore,
readers of the Journal should note our definition of the concept of average attributable fraction for multifactorial risk
attribution in epidemiology (7). In the multifactorial situation, this approach provides the unique solution (under reasonable conditions) to the problem of dividing the total proportion of cases attributable to the entire set of exposures
under study into exposure-specific components. These
average attributable fractions for the single exposures in the
set of factors under study do indeed sum to their combined
attributable fraction. Further discussion and justification of
this approach is provided elsewhere (7, 13-15).
REFERENCES
1. Walter SD. Attributable risk in practice. (Editorial). Am J
Epidemiol 1998;148:411-13.
2. Benichou J, Chow WH, McLaughlin JK, et al. Population
attributable risk of renal cell cancer in Minnesota. Am J
Epidemiol 1998; 148:424-30.
3. Wilson PD, Loffredo CA, Correa-Villasefior A, et al.
Attributable fractions for cardiac malformations. Am J
Epidemiol 1998;148:414-23.
4. Greenland S, Robins JM. Conceptual problems in the definition and interpretation of attributable fractions. Am J
Epidemiol 1988; 128:1185-97.
5. Gefeller O. Definitions of attributable risk—revisited. Public
Health Rev 1995;23:343-55.
6. Rockhill B, Newman B, Weinberg C. Use and misuse of population attributable fractions. Am J Public Health 1998;88:
15-19.
7. Eide GE, Gefeller O. Sequential and average attributable fractions as aids in the selection of preventive strategies. J Clin
Epidemiol 1995;48:645-55.
8. Mezzetti M, La Vecchia C, Decarli A, et al. Population attributable risk for breast cancer diet, nutrition, and physical exercise. J Natl Cancer Inst 1998;90:389-94.
9. Walter SD. Prevention for multifactorial diseases. Am J
Epidemiol 1980;112:409-16.
10. O'Neill TJ. Positive bias of the combined effect of risk factors
estimated by marginal aetiological fractions. Int J Epidemiol
1991;20:1137-9.
11. Gefeller O, Eide GE. The attributable fraction of the combined
effect of two risk factors. (Letter). Int J Epidemiol 1992;21:
819-20.
12. Coughlin SS, Nass CC, Pickle LW, et al. Regression methods
for estimating attributable risk in population-based casecontrol studies: a comparison of additive and multiplicative
models. Am I Epidemiol 1991; 133:305-13.
13. Land M, Gefeller O. Variations on the Shapley solution for
partitioning risks in epidemiology. In: Klar R, Opitz O, eds.
Classification and knowledge organization. Heidelberg,
Am J Epidemiol
Vol. 151, No. 2, 2000
209
Germany: Springer-Verlag, 1997:458-66.
14. Land M, Gefeller O. A game-theoretic approach to partitioning attributable risks in epidemiology. Biom J 1997;39:
777-92.
15. Gefeller O, Land M, Eide GE. Averaging attributable fractions
in the multifactorial situation: assumptions and interpretation.
J Clin Epidemiol 1998;51:437^*1.
Geir Egil Eide
Section of Mathematics and Statistics
Norwegian School of Economics and
Business Administration
N-5045 Bergen-Sandviken
Norway
Olaf Gefeller
Department of Medical Informatics,
Biometry and Epidemiology
Medical School
University of Erlangen-Nuremberg
Germany
DR. WALTER REPLIES
The helpful comments from Eide and Gefeller (1) regarding my editorial (2) underscore the need for clarity when
discussing attributable risk estimates. In particular, one
must define which factors or combination of factors are
being evaluated, state which other factors are to be taken
into account, and specify the implied changes in risk exposure that are envisaged. Several typical possibilities exist,
as follows.
First (case A), epidemiologists, particularly those contemplating preventive interventions, will wish to consider
the number of cases associated with a specific risk factor, in
an environment in which other risk exposures exist but may
not change as a result of the intervention. For example,
smoking cessation campaigns are directed primarily at the
elimination of smoking. Secondary effects on other risk factors, such as exercise and diet, may occur but are not the target of the intervention. Here one should calculate the attributable risk for the factor in question (smoking) by regarding
it as \ht first exposure to change in the population, leaving
the other exposures unchanged. If they are available, data
on other exposures can become part of the calculation, in
which empirical methods (3) or a logistic regression model
(4) is used.
Second (case B), Wilson et al.'s approach (5) considers
the extra attributable risk for a factor. It is intended to indicate the effect of eliminating an exposure assuming that the
other factors remain unchanged. In contrast to case A, however, the factor in question is implicitly assumed to be the
last to be taken into account, as pointed out by Eide and
Gefeller (1). Wilson et al.'s approach calculates the difference from the summary attributable risk for all factors and
the summary attributable risk for all factors except the one
under study.
An example would be if one wanted to estimate the proportion of disease cases associated with an occupational
toxin while recognizing that some employees smoke. In a
compensation or tort case, the employer would argue that
the smoking is the employees' responsibility and that the
toxic hazards of the job are secondary to those of smoking.
210
Letters to the Editor
The employer would therefore want to calculate Wilson et
al.'s (5) (extra) attributable risk for the occupation, after
allowing for smoking (case B). The employees would argue
the opposite case, that they have a right to smoke and that
the occupational hazard should be assessed first.
Conceptually, they require the estimate of the change in risk
if the occupational hazard were eliminated while leaving
the distribution of smoking unchanged; they would therefore adopt the method of calculation used in case A. If suitable data are available, an alternative for either party would
be to consider the attributable risk of occupation within
strata of smokers and nonsmokers. In general, doing so
would lead to different estimates (and presumably compensation) for smokers and nonsmokers.
Third (case C), for academic interest or to set priorities
for disease prevention, one might want to assess simultaneously the attributable risks associated with several factors.
Here, Eide and Gefeller's (1) average attributable risk estimates are attractive if one values the concept of additivity.
While their approach is equitable from a societal viewpoint,
I am not certain that it will be accepted in adversarial litigation, where contending parties try to ascribe liability for
the disease to one factor or another rather than share the
risk. Furthermore, alternative preventive interventions
should still be evaluated by using the case A method, for
single factors or combinations, as appropriate.
I am grateful to Dr. L. Magder (University of Maryland,
personal communication, 1999) for pointing out an algebraic similarity between an expression in an earlier paper
(6) and expression 1 in my editorial (2). In the former
paper, the expression near the end of page 601 gives the
difference between the sum of the factor-specific public
health effects (with each calculated as the first exposure to
be changed) and the summary effect. It shows that the summary estimate is smaller if the rates are supra-additive.
Expression 1 in my editorial refers to the difference
between the summary attributable risk and the sum of
Wilson et al.'s (5) extra attributable risk estimates for each
factor. It shows that the summary estimate is greater if the
disease risks are supra-additive. (Note that the two differences are in the opposite order.) Thus, both methods of calculation provide equality between the factor-specific estimates and the summary estimates if the disease rates are
additive; however, interestingly, departures from rate additivity cause the methods to diverge with respect to the sign
of the difference. On a related point, Eide and Gefeller (1)
note that both sub- and supra-additive attributable risks
have been observed empirically.
Epidemiologists are familiar with the ideas of adjusted
and unadjusted risks (e.g., using odds ratios). The present
discussion indicates that the situation is more complex with
attributable risks, because both the risks and the distribution
of exposure to risk in the population have to be taken into
account. To avoid ambiguity, careful specification of both is
needed.
REFERENCES
1. Eide GE, Gefeller O. Re: "attributable risk in practice."
(Letter). Am J Epidemiol 2000; 151:208-9.
2. Walter SD. Attributable risk in practice. (Editorial). Am J
Epidemiol 1998;148:411-13.
3. Walter SD. Prevention for multifactorial diseases. Am J
Epidemiol 1980; 112:409-16.
4. Bruzzi P, Green SB, Byar DP, et al. Estimating the population
attributable risk for multiple risk factors using case-control
data. Am J Epidemiol 1985;122:9O4-14.
5. Wilson PD, Loffredo CA, Correa-Villasefior A, et al.
Attributable fractions for cardiac malformations. Am J
Epidemiol 1998;148:414-23.
6. Walter SD. Effects of interaction, confounding and observational error on attributable risk estimation. Am J Epidemiol
1983; 117:598-604.
S. D. Walter
Department of Clinical Epidemiology
and Biostatistics
McMaster University
Hamilton, Ontario L8N 3Z5
Canada
WILSON ETAL REPLY
In 1998, we published population attributable fractions
for cardiovascular malformations to emphasize the possible
effect of preventive intervention on potentially causal risk
factors (1). We presented what we termed "extra attributable fractions" for each risk factor for a given malformation. These were calculated as the summary attributable
fraction for the set of all risk factors jointly minus that for
all but the factor of interest. We interpreted the extra attributable fraction for factor x as "the fraction of the cases in
the population that would not have occurred if exposure to
x were removed, but the exposures to the other factors
remained unchanged" (1, p. 417). In their letter, Eide and
Gefeller pointed out that the correct interpretation is the
fraction of the cases that would not occur if exposure to x
were removed after having removed the risks for all other
factors under consideration (2). We thank Eide and Gefeller
for this correct interpretation.
Given the correct interpretation, our extra attributable
fractions are not useful in intervention because it will be
impractical or impossible to eliminate all other risk factors
before focusing on the one of interest. However, the interpretation we previously gave to our extra attributable fractions (1) does apply to the "adjusted attributable risk" of
Bruzzi et al. (3). In verifying that this adjusted attributable
risk is indeed, as described by Bruzzi et al., the fraction of
the cases in the population that would not have occurred if
the factor of interest were eliminated while exposures to the
other factors remained unchanged, we benefitted from discussions with Laurence Magder, our faculty colleague at the
University of Maryland.
Following Bruzzi et al. (3), we have computed these
adjusted population attributable fractions/risks from the
data used in our 1998 article (1). We present them here
along with the extra attributable fractions for comparison.
Table 1 is structured the same way as table 1 in our 1998
article (1), except that here we also present the adjusted
attributable fractions, both based on risk factors significant
at the 0.05 level. The summary attributable fractions remain
unchanged. The adjusted attributable fractions are generally larger than the extra attributable fractions (except when
the exposures are disjoint), which is consistent with their
interpretations. Unlike the extra attributable fractions, the
sum of the adjusted attributable fractions generally exceeds
the summary attributable fraction except in the case of
mutually disjoint exposures. Nevertheless, our discussion
Am J Epidemiol Vol. 151, No. 2, 2000