Prepared by NorthStar Destination Strategies Lauderdale Lakes, FL BrandPrint Understanding & Insights Presentation Community Understanding g Consumer Insights Imagination Competition Evaluation You are Here Brand Identity & Brand Action What differentiates Lauderdale Lakes? Community Consumer Competition How have we learned about the Lauderdale Lakes Community? • Research & Materials Audit • In-Market In Market Trip Community – – – – FAM Tour Intercept Interviews Stakeholder Interviews Focus Group • Resident Tapestry Profiling • Stakeholder S k h ld Vision V Survey S • Online Community Survey Community Understanding Lauderdale Lakes I M k Observations In-Market Ob i You mayy disagree g with some information that follows. But these are perceptions gained during the research. There are negative perceptions included; identifying these can be just as important as praise. Community R Research h & Materials M l Audit A d FROM THE CITY, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT & CHAMBER OFFICES City of Lauderdale Lakes • The Heart of Broward County by the Community Redevelopment Agency booklet • “We Care” Tool Box 1st Annual Black History Month Community Parade flyer • • 9th Annual Holiday Lighting Ceremony • Barrington Irving Bridge Dedication flyer • Building Permits and Processes: A Helpful Guide to Planning and Building • Department of Parks and Leisure • Kick off Black History Month with the City of Lauderdale Lakes flyer • Lakes Days: A 45th Anniversary Celebration • Lakes Live: Grammy Award Winner Regina Belle flyer • L d d l L Lauderdale Lakes k N New: A publication bli ti for f the th residents id t • Lauderdale Lakes ONE City Pride flyer • Streetscape Master Plan Volume 1&2 • The Heart of Broward County CD • Lauderdale Lakes City Street Map & Resource Guide Community R Research h & Materials M l Audit A d FROM THE CITY, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT & CHAMBER OFFICES Economic Development Materials • The Right Choice for Business pamphlet • Amendment #1: Property Tax Reform • Lauderdale Lakes Chamber of Commerce 1st Annual Dinner program p y Tax Update p • Property Broward County • Broward County Library flyer NaturesScape Broward • Other Materials • Bella Vista: Building a Way of Life packet • Eggstravaganza Spring Festival Flyer • Halloween Spooktacular flyer • International Tertiary drawing • Lauderdale Lakes Citizens Academy pamphlet • L d d l L Lauderdale Lakes k N News F Fall ll 2006 Community Assets WHAT WE HEARD FROM FAM TOUR | STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS | FOCUS GROUP International reputation Great location • • • • Center of Broward County Located at intersection of Oakland Park Boulevard and State Road 7 Close to turnpike, I-95 & major roadways. Minutes from beaches and airport 120,000+ motorists travel through everyday (most working in Ft. Lauderdale) Parks and Recreation • • • • • • • • • C-13 Canal Greenway Trail Vincent Torres Memorial Parks (ball fields) Willie Webb Sr. Park and Community Center with Boundless Playground Cypress Preserve Conservation Park Otis Gray, Northgate and Westgate Neighborhood parks Swimming pool complex Adult and Youth sports leagues and SPARKS program Named a “Playful City” and “Tree City” Citizen’ss Academy Citizen Academy, Community Center and Alzheimer's Alzheimer s Facility Events • • • • UniFest on city’s birthday in June sponsored by Greater CaribbeanAmerican Chamber of Commerce and City of Lauderdale Lakes p Black Historyy Month events and parade Holiday Fest and Lighting Community events including Eggstravaganza Community Assets WHAT WE HEARD FROM FAM TOUR | STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS | FOCUS GROUP Distinct Community • • • • • • • • Proud P d off diversity; di it 60 languages l spoken k att Boyd B d Anderson A d High Hi h School; S h l greatt food f d and d music i Friendly population always willing to assist others Affordable housing in Broward County Sports; surrounding communities’ kids want to play on Lauderdale Lakes teams Strong fire and police response; equipped with T3 vehicles and Segways County leaders and educators live in Lauderdale Lakes (known for strong planning) CRA Agency; progressive:1st Broward community with Master Plan Many churches (draw from outside Lauderdale Lakes) Major Employers • Florida Medical Center, City of Lauderdale Lakes, Interactive Response Technologies (call center), Walmart Education • • Florida Memorial University Broward campus Phyl’s Academy private secondary school New construction and development • • • • Library and cultural center; Bella Vista development, residential and commercial St. Croix mixed-use development Walmart ; New tenants in Lakes Mall: Ross Dress for Less Masonry bus shelters; highest ridership in county Community Challenges WHAT WE HEARD FROM FAM TOUR | STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS | FOCUS GROUP Community • Lack of cohesion • Areas of blight; larger rental community and absentee landlords • Unknown number of Section 8 vouchers; poor upkeep of properties ; no local Housing Authority • Ethnic struggle between African Americans and Jamaicans; affects residents moving in • Youth lack direction • No housing stock larger than 2000 sq feet; no mid-higher end housing Government • Perception that Jamaicans are disproportionately in control; leadership chasing trends • Chamber isn’t isn t well organized or managed • Funding; sales tax based on population not where the money is spent • Not an entitlement community; go through county for development grants (snowbirds not in census) • Insufficient code enforcement; lax zoning • BSO Sheriffs’ beats are inconsistent and rotations prevent building relationships with community Perceptions • Perceived as black, poor, unsafe/dangerous (press misreporting Ft. Lauderdale and Lauderhill crimes) • Older whites do not see a p place for themselves in Lauderdale Lakes • Disjointed leadership; inaccurate perception of financial difficulties • Characterized as a Caribbean city however African American population is larger Community Challenges g WHAT WE HEARD FROM FAM TOUR | STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS | FOCUS GROUP Competition • Lauderhill better caters to the Caribbean population; Lauderhill looks newer and better • Tamarac T i perceived is i d as the h most safe; f Lauderhill L d hill the h most d dangerous • Retail traffic drawn west to Sawgrass Mills Mall Schools • Low test scores and ppoor schools; Need community-wide y effort to improve p schools • Boyd Anderson does not get same resources; County money goes west to newer schools Businesses • Small business owners are apathetic towards growth • Lauderdale Lakes does not offer the restaurants/retail that cause people to stop • Few white-collar or creative-class jobs for youth; not perceived as place of opportunity Image/message • Bad reputation • Lack marketing and PR efforts; No distinct message to rally community • Does not leverage diversity well Tourism attractions destination retail, retail hotels or large events drawing from across South Florida • No attractions, Infrastructure • Corridors into village are not distinct (shared) and dirty; sign blight Community Opportunities WHAT WE HEARD FROM FAM TOUR | STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS | FOCUS GROUP Community Redevelopment • • • • • • • • • CRA plan and streetscapes for Oakland Park Boulevard and SR 7 intersection F d program for Facade f refurbished f bi h d commercial i l areas Additional small business development in front of Walmart Town Center Stimulus funding Focus on green programs; become a walk-able suburb 20 acres for development p in Tarragon g bankruptcy; p y; warehouse space p for distribution Improve city-wide landscaping Diversity in housing stock; Bella Vista development WiFi hub in center city; potential stop on light rail to Miami Youth and Schools • • • • • Improve schools in order to attract more residents Multi-use sports fields/stadium for soccer, rugby, cricket, netball and lacrosse Acknowledge and celebrate educators p education system y Solicit ggrants to improve Connect youth with senior mentors Leadership • • • Need more transparency Need to engage the greatest thinkers in Lauderdale Lakes Need more rules and enforcement Bella Vista Development Community Opportunities WHAT WE HEARD FROM FAM TOUR | STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS | FOCUS GROUP Events • • Broaden UniFest; consider sole sponsorship p p to expand p offerings g beyond y Caribbean Taste of the Lakes bringing together international flavors of Lauderdale Lakes Community Organization • • • • Cultivate community pride and involvement Bring people together to clean up the city and waterways Programs at new Library and Cultural Center Childrens’ activities bring residents together; add more to the calendar Message • • • Counter negative headlines with strong marketing and PR Safer, affordable alternative to nearby Dade County Market area more frequently, loudly, and efficiently Additional Assets • • • • • • Larger chain restaurants (not fast food) Large bookstore Additional destination retailers and food brokers like Broward Meat and Fish Company Attract independent specialty restaurants and boutiques Need night life options Golf course or driving range Community Understanding Lauderdale Lakes Residents Community Tapestry “Who” Report Community • Ab t T About Tapestry t P Profiling fili Tapestry: – SSegmentation operates on the h principle l off like l k seeks k like l k – that h people l withh similar l tastes, lifestyles, and behaviors seek others with the same. – Tapestry combines the “who” of lifestyle demography with the “where” of local neighborhood geography to paint a picture of exactly who your residents are are, what types of jobs they hold, what their buying preferences are, what lifestage they are in and finally how they compare to the general US population. • About the Data: – Tapestry mines both public (Census) and private databases (including credit card data, etc) to combines traditional statistical methodology of cluster analysis with the latest data mining techniques to provide the most compelling segmentation of US neighborhoods. Community U d Understanding d Tapestry T Classifications Cl f Every neighborhood in the United States has been clustered into one of 65 Segments. These segments belong to 12 Groups. • LifeMode Groups: – 12 summary groups based on lifestyle and lifestage – Members share an experience (being born in the same time period, period facing the same lifestage, having a certain level of affluence, etc.) • Community Tapestry Segments: – 65 groups based on sociographic and demographic composition. – Considers: Income, occupation, educational attainment, ethnic origin, household composition, marital/living arrangements, patterns of migration, i i mobility bili and d communication, i i lif lifestyle l and d media di patterns – Most distinct level of segmentation. Community L f M d Groups LifeMode G • • • • • • • • • • • • L1. High Society L1 L2. Upscale Avenues L3. Metropolis L4. Solo Acts L5. Senior Styles L6. Scholars & Patriots L7. High Hopes L8. Global Roots L9 Family Portrait L9. L10. Traditional Living L11. Factories & Farms L12. American Quilt Community LifeMode Breakout Over 50% (57.9%) of Lauderdale Lakes residents fit either in the Senior Styles or Global Roots LifeModes Tapestry LifeModes | Lauderdale Lakes Residents L01. High Society L02. Upscale Avenues L03. Metropolis L04. Solo Acts L05. Senior Styles L06. Scholars & Patriots L07. High Hopes L08. Global Roots L09. Family Portrait L10. Traditional Living L11. Factories & Farms L12. American Quilt 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% Community Segment Breakout The top 4 resident segments comprise 69.5% of the population Tapestry p y Segments g | Lauderdale Lakes Residents 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% Top Segments: Descriptions to follow 1. 65 Social Security Set (25%) 2 60 Ci 2. City Di Dimensions i (20%) 3. 34 Family Foundations (15.3%) 4. 51 Metro City Edge (9.2%) 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 0.0% $$$ Affluence Range $ Community Segment Spotlight 65 Social Security Set (25%): Indexed 3864 against the US average • 40% are elderly households over 65 years old. • Median HHI is $15,700. • Limited resources restrict their activities and purchases. Shop at discount stores. • Dependent on Medicare and Medicaid to cover health care costs. • Bank in pperson and ppayy cash when theyy shop. p • Watch daytime and primetime television, especially sports entertainment. Enjoy football, basketball, boxing, wrestling, figure skating and golf. 60 City y Dimensions (20%): ( ) Indexed 2313 against g the US average g • This segment is characterized by diversity in household type and ethnicity. • Primarily young and single with a median age of 28.7. • The median HHI is $26,000. • They are frequent viewers of cable television and most homes own more than one television. These residents are avid watchers of sports but rarely participants. • Prefer to shop at discount stores • For entertainment entertainment, they enjoy dining out, out going dancing and attending music performances. Community Segment Spotlight 34 Family Foundations (15.3%): Indexed 1805 • There is little diversity in this segment; most of the population is black. • The median age is 38 years and the median household income is $42,000. • Family Foundations residents are active in their communities, attending church services, helping with fund-raising projects and participating in civic activities. • Theyy spend p moneyy on home maintenance and their families. Watch their budgets closely, opting to prepare meals at home and shop at Walmart and Kmart. • Style is important to these residents. 51 Metro City Edge (9.2%): Indexed 977 • Single parents, singles, and multigenerational families. • Median age is 28.8 and median HHI is $30,200. • Unemployment rate is high and less than 10% hold a Bachelor Bachelor’ss degree. Primary concern is welfare of children, so they spend money wisely at grocery stores like Food Lion and Kroger, and shop at Walmart. • Newspapers and the Yellow Pages are their sources of information since Internet access at home is not a necessity. necessity • Exercise at home and enjoy participating in community sports. Most meals are made at home; they rarely dine out. Community Segment Comparison Lauderdale Lakes residents skew to the right, less affluent side of the chart and tend not to mirror the US averages Tapestry Segments | Lauderdale Lakes Residents vs. U.S. Average 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 0.0% Lauderdale Lakes Residents US Community Understanding Resident’s Lifestyle Communityy Tapestry p y “What” Report Community Resident’s Lifestyle Once segments have been identified, identified we can draw conclusions about consumer habits and lifestyle preferences. Lifestyle/Media Lif l /M di G Groups: Apparel, Appliances, Attitudes, Automobiles, Auto/Aftermarket, Baby Products, Alcohol, Books, C Cameras, C Civic Activities, A C Convenience Stores, S Electronics, Financials, Furniture, Garden/Lawn, Grocery, Health, Home Improvement, Insurance, Internet Leisure Internet, Leisure, Yellow Pages Pages, Watch Watch, Read, Read Listen, Personal Core, Pets, Restaurant, Shopping, Smoking, Sports, Telephone, Tools, Toys/Games, Travel Video/DVDs, Travel, Video/DVDs Miscellaneous. Miscellaneous Resident’s Lifestyle Community Data includes national chains that may not be present in your region but represent the type of consumer behavior likely. Lower income and proximity to a larger metropolitan area dictates many consumer preferences: • • • • • • • Leisure & Travel – Residents do not travel often. Enjoy gambling and often purchase lottery tickets. Attend NFL and NBA games and are likely to play soccer Lifestyle – Residents are likely to smoke, especially menthols, with a higher than average percentage smoking 9+ packs a week Auto – Likelyy to have one leased vehicle and purchase p aftermarket struts or mufflers. Do not drive trucks or belong to AAA Finances – Unlikely to own stocks, bonds or 401K retirement savings Computers and Electronics – Not likely to own a computer or to use the h iinternet often f Dining – 2 to 3 times as likely to eat at Church’s Fried Chicken, Popeyes, White Castle, Ryans and El Pollo Loco TV, radio, books – Watch BET, Judge Mathias, the Bernie Mac Show and Jerry Springer. Five times as likely to listen to Hispanic and gospel radio. Likely to read bridal or music magazines. Community Resident’s Lifestyle Data includes national chains that may not be present in your region but represent the type of consumer behavior likely. Watch Leisure Category Watched last week: BET (Black Entertainment TV) Watch Syndicated TV (M-F): Judge Mathis Watch TV aired once/wk: The Bernie Mac Show Watch Syndicated TV (M-F): Divorce Court Watch on TV: rodeo/bull riding HH has satellite dish Index 338 321 299 293 59 58 Category Gambled in Atlantic City in last 12 months Bought lottery ticket in last 12 mo: Daily Drawing Attended movies in last 90 days: once/week or more Member of church board Dine out 2+ times per week Dine out once a week 182 167 141 131 68 66 Category Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: Used nectars in last 6 months Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: 548 501 326 235 53 44 Category Fast food/drive-in last 6 mo: Church`s Fr. Chicken Fast food/drive-in last 6 mo: Popeyes Fast food/drive-in last 6 mo: White Castle Fam rest/steak hse last 6 mo: Ryan`s Fam rest/steak hse last 6 mo: Olive Garden Fam rest/steak hse last 6 mo: Chili`s Grill & Bar Read 219 202 177 154 51 51 Grocery Category Read music magazines g Read bridal magazines Read women`s fashion magazines Light newspaper reader Read newspaper: business/finance section Read airline magazines Index Listen Category Radio format Radio format Radio format Radio format Radio format Radio format Index Index Piggly Wiggly 280 233 183 147 145 144 Aldi Winn Dixie Food Lion GNC Restaurant Index listen to: listen to: listen to: listen to: listen to: listen to: Hispanic gospel urban jazz country news/talk Index 321 285 281 217 64 54 Community Understandingg Communityy Leader Perceptions Stakeholder Vision Survey Community Community Leader Perceptions DEFINING LAUDERDALE LAKES When you first think of Lauderdale Lakes, which three adjectives come to mind? • Small • Caring • Diverse Describe Lauderdale Lakes to someone who has never heard of it before. • A small but centrally located residential community – In the heart of Broward County • A progressive, culturally diverse community – A distinctive Caribbean flair • Affordable – Provides what you need in a close proximity Community C Community it Leader L d P Perceptions ti ATTRACTING PEOPLE TO LAUDERDALE LAKES What in Lauderdale Lakes attracts most… most Residents: • • • Location Affordable housing Accessibility to public transportation Visitors: • • • • Ethnic restaurants Walmart Shopping The beach Businesses: • • • • Location Affordability Steady flow of customers Good supply pp y of willing workforce Community Community Leader Perceptions INSIDE LAUDERDALE LAKES What is Lauderdale Lake’s single greatest asset? • Diversity • Location o Easy access to I-95 o The intersection of Oakland Park Boulevard and State Road 7 • Its people If you could add something to Lauderdale Lakes, what would you add? • More restaurants o Specifically chains chains, such as TGIF or Applebee Applebee’ss • Major retail businesses • Community center o For seniors /youth programming / after school activities If you could take away something from Lauderdale Lakes, what would it be? • Negative stereotypes o Concerning crime, drugs, and even race-based fear • Low income housingg o Unsupervised tenement housing • Traffic: Multi-lane highways Community Community Leader Perceptions INSIDE LAUDERDALE LAKES In your opinion, what would be the best way for Lauderdale Lakes to attract more b i business d development? l ? • Tax incentives • Proactive marketing – Media blitz – More billboards • Redevelopment of existing property – Generous rezoning – Reconstruct areas to make them more aesthetically pleasing for the community How would outsiders (residents of other communities in South Florida) describe Lauderdale Lakes? • Small • Diverse • Affordable • Poor • Suburban – In need of characteristics that distinguish it from other suburban communities Community Community Leader Perceptions DEFINING THE COMPETITION Whatt iis the Wh th first fi t adjective dj ti th thatt comes to t mind i d when h describing d ibi the th following f ll i communities? Plantation • Big • Wealthy • Vibrant Fort Lauderdale • Busy B • Big • Beautiful Lauderhill • Progressive • Growing Sunrise • Active • Growing Tamarac • Elderly • Beautiful Oakland Park • Congested • Developing Community C Community it Leader L d P Perceptions ti DEFINING THE COMPETITION Wh t sets What t L Lauderdale d d l L Lakes k apartt ffrom its it competition? titi ? • • • More culturally diverse Smaller o More M subdued bd d Vision for the future o Great opportunity for development What unites Lauderdale Lakes? • • • A common heritage Integrity g y of the government g People in the neighborhood o Support activities in the city Community C Community i Leader L d P Perceptions i CHALLENGES & OPPORTUNITIES What are the biggest challenges currently facing Lauderdale Lakes? • Crime • Poor schools • Lack of major j retail businesses – Highlights need to attract new business • Low GDP What are the biggest gg opportunities pp for g growth in Lauderdale Lakes? • Residential development: More middle-class housing • Commercial development: Available spaces for mixed-use development – Shopping malls and restaurants • Development of better schools Describe Lauderdale Lakes in 10 years: • Redeveloped with better aesthetics: A city people would move back to • Improved residential areas: Better diversity of housing options • Younger and more diverse Community Community Leader Perceptions OTHER FACETS OF THE COMMUNITY Comment on diversity in Lauderdale Lakes. How important is diversity to the city? • Most view it as an asset that defines the community – Brings talent and ideas that cohesively mold the city – Important to the continued growth of the area • A few concerned it has become the controlling interest in the city Where is the one place in Lauderdale Lakes that you would take a visitor so they would always remember their visit? • City Hall • The city parks • Bella Vista • New city library You have been instructed to take ONE picture of something in Lauderdale Lakes that best represents the h community. i What Wh do d you take k the h picture i of, f and d why? h ? • Linear Park • City library – Represents p pprogress g • Bella Vista development • Picture of the Mayor and City Council Community C Community it Leader L d P Perceptions ti PERSONIFICATION OF LAUDERDALE LAKES What consumer product brand does Lauderdale Lakes most resemble? Why? • Timex Watches : “Not too flashy but they work and they do not cost as much as other th watches” t h ” • Chevrolet : “A good product at a fair price.” • Walmart : “It has the same items to offer as any other brand yet is less expensive.” Community Community Leader Perceptions PERSONIFICATION OF LAUDERDALE LAKES If Lauderdale Lakes were a famous p person, who would it be? Why? y • President Obama : He was underestimated, determined, tenacious and ultimately successful. He did it and so can Lauderdale Lakes. If we truly want to.” • Robert Downy Jr. : “For a long time he was in the dumps and didn’t care for himself; more recently he has come back alive and is doing very well for himself and his career. career ” • Rosa Parks : “Because Rosa Parks looked like a shy and unassuming person but when the time came she put aside her fear and shyness and stepped up to the plate to do what needed to be done in the name of humanity.” • Whoopi Goldberg : “Free spirited and has the ability to see disappointments as opportunities.” Community Understanding Resident Promotion of the Brand Community Brand Barometer On a scale of 1 to 10 with 1 being "not at all likely" and 10 being "extremely likely", would you recommend… [living in, conducting business in, in visiting] visiting]… Lauderdale Lakes to a friend or colleague? Community B dB Brand Barometer t On a scale of 1 to 10 with 1 being "not at all likely" and 10 being "extremely extremely likely likely", would you recommend living in Lauderdale Lakes to a friend or colleague? Living in Lauderdale Lakes 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 4.67% 4.67% 5.61% 3.74% 6.54% 6.54% 5.61% 12.15% 14.95% 35.51% 31.77% Detractors 17.76% Passives 50.46% Promoters Community Brand Barometer On a scale of 1 to 10 with 1 being "not at all likely" and 10 being "extremely likely", would you recommend living in Lauderdale Lakes to a friend or colleague? Living in Lauderdale Lakes 40.00% 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 20.00% 15.00% 10.00% 5.00% 0.00% 1 Observations: • • • 2 3 Detractors 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Promoters 50.46% of residents are Promoters of living in Lauderdale Lakes. 35% gave living in Lauderdale Lakes a score of perfect “10” Detractors make up 31 31.8% 8% of your residents With only 17% of residents being brand Passives, it is clear that residents tend to be polarized in terms promoting or detracting from the city’s reputation Community Brand Barometer On a scale of 1 to 10 with 1 being "not at all likely" and 10 being "extremely likely", would you recommend visiting Lauderdale Lakes to a friend or colleague? Visiting Lauderdale Lakes 1 6.67% 2 0.00% 3 6 67% 6.67% 4 5.56% 5 7.78% 6 6.67% 7 5.56% 8 16.67% 9 15.56% 10 28.89% Visiting Lauderdale Lakes 45.00% 40.00% 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 33.35% Detractors 20.00% 15.00% 22.23% Passives 10.00% 5.00% 44.45% Promoters 0.00% 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Observations: • • Promoters (44.45%) make up the majority of respondents when considering recommending Lauderdale Lakes as a place to visit. A score of perfect “10” 10 was the highest individual numbered response with 28 28.89%. 89% However However, the second largest majority gave visiting Lauderdale Lakes a score of “8.” These individuals represent significant opportunity for positive conversion into brand Promoters. 10 Community Brand Barometer On a scale of 1 to 10 with 1 being "not at all likely" and 10 being "extremely likely", would you recommend conducting business in Lauderdale Lakes to a friend or colleague? Conducting Business in Lauderdale Lakes 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 10.23% 3 41% 3.41% 3.41% 3.41% 12.50% 6.82% 9 10% 9.10% 11.36% 6.82% 32.95% Conducting Business in Lauderdale Lakes 45.00% 40.00% 35.00% 30.00% 25.00% 20.00% 39.78% Detractors 15.00% 10.00% 20.46% Passives 5.00% 0.00% 39.77% Promoters 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Observations: • • • Lauderdale Lakes has an equal number of Promoters and Detractors when recommending the city as a pplace to conduct business. 32.95% gave conducting business in Lauderdale Lakes a perfect “10” Passives make up the smallest majority of respondents with 20.46% Community Brand Barometer Lauderdale Lakes has more Promoters, but also more Detractors th th than the national ti l average when h recommending di the city as a place to live As a place to live... As a place to live... 60.0% 50.5% 46.2% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 31.8% 22.0% 31.8% National Lauderdale Lakes 17 8% 17.8% 20 0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Detractors Passives Promoters Community Brand Barometer Lauderdale Lakes falls below the national average of Promoters and above the detractor average when considering it as a place to visit As a place to visit... As a place to visit... 70.0% 60.0% 49.8% 44.5% 50 0% 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 33.4% 24.6% National 25.6% 22.2% Lauderdale Lakes 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Detractors Passives Promoters Community Brand Barometer Lauderdale Lakes scores significantly higher than the national average when h recommending di the h city i as a place l to conduct d business b i As a place to conduct business... p 70.0% 60.0% 50 0% 50.0% 40.0% 45.8% % 39.8% 39.8% 29.8% National 30.0% 20 5% 20.5% 20.0% 24.4% 10.0% 0.0% Detractors Passives Promoters Lauderdale Lakes Community B d Barometer Brand B t Brand Advocacy Score = % Promoters – % Detractors g in both recommendingg the Lauderdale Lakes scores below the national average city as a place to live and visit, but scores significantly higher than average as a place to conduct business Brand Advocacy y Comparison p National Score 30.00% 25.20% 24.20% 20.00% Lauderdale Lakes Score 18.69% 10.00% 11.10% 0.00% Living Visiting ‐0.01% Conducting Business ‐10.00% ‐20.00% ‐21.40% ‐30.00% Community Understanding Resident Perceptions Online Community Survey Community Resident Demographics Which of the following includes your age? Answer Options Under 18 18 - 24 25 - 34 35 - 44 45 - 54 55 - 64 65 - 74 75 or over Response Percent e ce t 16.2% 2.9% 10.5% 11.40% 16.2% 20.0% 13.3% 9.5% 16% of respondents are under the age of 18 Which of the following includes your ethnicity? Answer Options African Af i American A i Black (of Caribbean origin) White (not of Hispanic origin) Other (please specify) A i or Pacific Asian P ifi Islander Il d Hispanic American Indian or Alaskan Native Response Percent 44 8% 44.8% 37.1% 14.3% 2.90% 1 9% 1.9% 1.9% 0.0% 82% of respondents are African American or Black of Caribbean origin g Community Resident Perceptions Seen primarily as caring, diverse, and Caribbean If you had to pick one word to describe Lauderdale Lakes it would be… Lakes, be 1.8% 3.6% 3.6% 3.6% 25.0% 12.5% 18.8% 13.4% 17.9% Caring Diverse Caribbean Promising Accessible Divisive Struggling Other (please specify) Small Community Resident Perceptions “Central location” and “parks and recreation” are seen as your greatest assets Lauderdale Lakes' g greatest asset is… 8.8% Central location in Broward County near I-95 and the Florida Turnpike Parks and recreation 1.8% 9.7% 37.2% 25.7% 16.8% Diversity Affordable housing Friendly people and close-knit community Other (please ( lease sspecify) ecif ) Community Resident Perceptions Most visitors are attracted by family and friends Most visitors to Lauderdale Lakes are attracted by… Family and friends Parks and Recreation (including sports leagues) 7.4% 3.5% 32 4% 32.4% 10.2% 15.7% 11.1% Community events like Black History Parade or Holiday Tree Lighting Friendly, welcoming attitude of community Ethnic restaurants 14.8% Unifest Celebration Other (please specify) Community Resident Perceptions Businesses are attracted by the central location in Broward County Most businesses in Lauderdale Lakes are attracted by… 10.2% Central location in Broward County 3.5% 40.7% 11.1% 14.8% 17.6% Available customers (120,000+ people p p movingg through g area daily) Low cost of doing business Affordable workforce Cityy services and communityy support Other (please specify) Community Resident Perceptions Residents most value the central location and parks and recreation What do Lauderdale Lakes residents value and appreciate most about their community? 9.2% 4.6% Central location in Broward County 23.9% 11 9% 11.9% Parks and recreation Affordable housing 18.3% 15.6% Diversity Close-knit, friendly community 16.5% Integrity in government Other (please specify) Community Resident Perceptions Outsiders view Lauderdale Lakes as a Caribbean community Lauderdale Lakes' reputation to outsiders is best described as… 8.2% Small and friendly 28 2% 28.2% 9.1% 14.5% Caribbean 3.6% 1.8% 0.9% Di Diverse Affordable 16.4% 17.3% Suburban and average High Crime Poor Other (please specify) Depressed Community Resident Perceptions Unemployment and attracting retail/dining are seen as greatest challenges The single greatest challenge currently facing Lauderdale Lakes is… Unemployment and weak job base 8.1% 1.8% 0.9% 24 3% 24.3% 11.7% 13.5% 18.9% 20.7% Attracting major retail and national sit-down restaurants Perception as poor and unsafe Struggling schools Cleanliness and code enforcement (rental properties) Distinction amongg neighboring g g communities Other (please specify) Traffic Community Resident Perceptions Improving schools is seen as greatest opportunity The single greatest opportunity for growth in L d d l Lakes Lauderdale L k is… i Improving schools 7.3% 6.4% 3.6% Better marketing for the community 27 3% 27.3% 11.8% 16.4% 11.8% 15.5% Mi d Mixed-use d l development Development of State Route 7 and Oakland Park Boulevard Community beautification efforts Residential development (more middle class housing) Destination retail and restaurants Other (please specify) Community Resident Perceptions Tax incentives for business are seen to have the most economic impact In your opinion, which of the following additions to L d d l L Lauderdale Lakes k would ld have h the th mostt economic i impact? 6.8% 11.7% 4.9% Tax incentives for businesses 29 1% 29.1% 19.4% 12.6% 15.5% Redevelopment projects and facade programs (SR 7 and Oakland Park) More retail and larger chain restaurants Residential developments like Bella Vista Pedestrian friendly entertainment core Other (please specify) Community Resident Perceptions Resident believe varied cultures bring unique ideas and flavors to the community What best describes the impact/influence of L d d l Lakes' Lauderdale L k ' diversity di it in i the th community? it ? 8.4% 11.2% 1.9% Varied cultures bring unique ideas and flavors to the community 29 0% 29.0% 12.1% 22.4% 15.0% Being mutli-cultural presents Lauderdale Lakes as a welcoming community to residents and visitors While the community is diverse, influence is concentrated with only a few The diverse cultures are not integrated well Community Resident Perceptions Lauderdale Lakes best delivers in location and recreation opportunities O a scale On l off 1 tto 10 with ith 1 being b i "poor " delivery" d li " and d 10 being b i "excellent " ll t delivery," how well does Lauderdale Lakes deliver the following attributes? Good location 8.04 Recreation opportunities 7.51 Overall quality of life 7.07 Welcoming community 6.94 Natural beauty 6.75 Affordable cost of living 6.72 Great place to raise a … 6.64 Business-friendly culture 6.41 Distinct identity 6.23 Great place for young … 6.23 Skill d workforce Skilled kf 5 98 5.98 Good K-12 education … 5.92 Vibrant downtown 5.28 Employment opportunities 5.27 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 Community Resident Perceptions OPEN-ENDED QUESTIONS What in Lauderdale Lakes are you most proud of? • Parks and recreation, the community, the people, diversity and the government What does Lauderdale Lakes look like in 10 years? • Residents believe it will look better, more like a city, more diverse and beautiful In your opinion, what is the best way for Lauderdale Lakes to better promote the community? • Local media and community initiatives Community Consumer Competition How have we learned about Lauderdale Lakes Consumers? • In-Market Trip Consumer – Intercept Interviews – Stakeholder Interviews – Focus Group • Consumer Awareness & Perception (CAP) Study • Perception Studies Consumer Understanding Lauderdale Lakes Consumers Community Tapestry Profiling Consumer Community Tapestry “Who” Report Profile of Broward County (excluding Lauderdale Lakes) Consumer LifeMode Breakout As with the Lauderdale Lakes resident profile, Senior Styles is the most represented LifeMode. However, Broward County also has High Society and Upscale Avenues in their h i top three, h which hi h are the h wealthiest l hi andd most educated d d LifeModes Lif M d Tapestry LifeModes | Lauderdale Lakes vs. Broward County Residents L01 Hi h S i t L01. High Society L02. Upscale Avenues L03. Metropolis L04. Solo Acts L05 S i St l L05. Senior Styles L06. Scholars & Patriots L07. High Hopes L08. Global Roots L09 Famil Portrait L09. Family Portrait L10. Traditional Living L11. Factories & Farms L12. American Quilt 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% Lauderdale Lakes Residents 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% Broward County Residents 30.0% 35.0% Consumer Tapestry Segments Lauderdale Lakes and Broward County share few Segments in common with Broward County skewing to the left, more affluent side of the chart Tapestry Segments | Lauderdale Lakes vs. Broward County Residents 30.0% 25.0% 20.0% Top Segments: Descriptions to follow 1. 30 Retirement Communities (11.6%) 2. 04 Boomburbs (8.6%) 3. 43 The Elders (6.6%) 4. 36 Old and Newcomers (6.1%) 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 0.0% Lauderdale Lakes Residents Broward County Residents Consumer Segment Spotlight 30 Retirement Communities (11.6%) • Single-person households and married-couple families with no children. • Median age is 50.3 50 3 years and median HHI is $44,400. $44 400 • They spend their time playing golf, horseback riding, gambling in Atlantic City or playing a musical instrument. • They love to spend time with their grandchildren and spoil them. • Good health is a priority for the Retirement Communities population so they see their internists regularly, use Weight Watchers, use a stationary bike and take dietary supplements. 04 Boomburbs B b b (8.6%) (8 6%) • Newest additions to the suburbs; younger families with a busy upscale lifestyle. • Many work outside their resident county; 36% cross county lines to work ((compared p to 24% ppercent for the U.S.)) • Median age is < 34 and median HHI is $120,000++ • Little ethnic diversity; population is predominantly white • Product preferences reflect suburban lifestyle • Boomburbs drive SUV’s and are active; favor golf, tennis and swimming. • Buy food at upscale grocery stores like Harris Teeter. Technically savvy Consumer Segment Spotlight 43 The Elders (6.6%) • Mainly retirees. Median age of 73 and median HHI of $37,000. • Favor communities designed for senior living. • Enjoy golfing and eating out. out Pay attention to their diets and require prescription drugs for health conditions. • With the freedom of retirement, many enjoy traveling. • Watch television, especially cables news programs such as CNN and Fox News. Read the newspaper regularly, regularly but not magazines. magazines Make long long-distance distance telephone calls to friends and families. 36 Old and Newcomers (6.1%) • Spread throughout metropolitan areas of the United States, neighborhoods of Old and Newcomers sustain a lot of transition. More than half of the residents moved in the last five years • Populated by renters who are starting their careers or retiring. • Householders are either in their twenties or over 75, the median age is 36 years. The median HHI is $40,400. • Purchasing preferences reflects their unencumbered lifestyles. • Compact cars are popular to fit the needs of the nonfamily households. • They love reading books and have the highest readership of any segment. • They play racquetball and golf, as well as jogging or walking. Age is not always obvious from their choices. Consumer Top Tapestry Segments The Segments highlighted in green are commuter Segments Top p Broward County y Segments g 1 30 Retirement Communities % of Population p 11.60% 2 4 Boomburbs 8.60% 3 43 Elders 6 60% 6.60% 4 36 Old and Newcomers 6.10% 5 28 Aspiring Young Families 5.30% 6 24 Main Street USA 5.10% 7 13 In Style 4.40% 8 16 Enterprising Professionals 4.20% 9 52 Inner City Tenants 4.00% 10 38 Industrious Urban Fringe 3.80% 11 6 Sophisticated Squires 3 70% 3.70% Total 63.40% Consumer Top Tapestry Segments Top Tapestry Segments | Lauderdale Lakes Residents 7% 6% 65. Social Security Set 4% 3% 3% 60. City Dimensions 25% 34. Family Foundations 51. Metro City Edge 8% 45. City Strivers 20% 9% 58. NeWest Residents 57. Simple Living 15% 28. Aspiring Young Families 18. Cozy and Comfortable 19. Milk and Cookies OTHER Top Tapestry Segments | Broward County Residents 30. Retirement Communities 04. Boomburbs 12% OTHER 40.3% 43 The 43. Th Elders Eld 9% 7% 6% 4% 4% 4% 4% 5% 5% 36. Old and Newcomers 28. Aspiring Young Families 24. Main Street, USA 13. In Style 16. Enterprising Professionals 52. Inner City Tenants 38. Industrious Urban Fringe OTHER Lauderdale Lakes Lakes’ low diversity across Segments is especially evident when comparing p i th the ppercentage t of the “other” categories with the Broward County profile. fil 100% off LLauderdale d d l Lakes’ residents fit neatly into 10 Segments. Broward C County has h 40.3% 40 3% falling f ll in the “other” category outside the top 10 Segments. Consumer Understanding Consumers’ Lifestyle Communityy Tapestry p y “What” Report Consumer Consumer’s Lifestyle Once segments have been identified, identified we can draw conclusions about consumer habits and lifestyle preferences. Lifestyle/Media Lif l /M di G Groups: Apparel, Appliances, Attitudes, Automobiles, Auto/Aftermarket, Baby Products, Alcohol, Books, C Cameras, C Civic Activities, A C Convenience Stores, S Electronics, Financials, Furniture, Garden/Lawn, Grocery, Health, Home Improvement, Insurance, Internet Leisure Internet, Leisure, Yellow Pages Pages, Watch Watch, Read, Read Listen, Personal Core, Pets, Restaurant, Shopping, Smoking, Sports, Telephone, Tools, Toys/Games, Travel Video/DVDs, Travel, Video/DVDs Miscellaneous. Miscellaneous Consumer’s Lifestyle Consumer Data includes national chains that may not be present in your region but represent the type of consumer behavior likely. Higher than average income dictates many consumer preferences: • • • • • • • Leisure & Travel – Residents often visit Disney World and Universal Studios Florida. Fairly likely to take 3+ domestic flights per year Lifestyle – Slightly more likely to play golf and tennis. Shop at Harris Teeter, Giant and Publix Auto – Likely to have an SUV and rent cars for personal use Finances – Likely to own high valued stock, 401k retirement savings and own a money market account Computers and Electronics – Likely to use internet daily, track investments and make travel purchases online. Dining – Often choose Don Pablo’s, Fuddruckers, Red Robin, and Jack in the Box. TV, radio, books – Watch the Golf Channel, listen to Hispanic radio and read airline magazines. Consumer Consumer’s Lifestyle y Data includes national chains that may not be present in your region but represent the type of consumer behavior likely. Watch Category Watched last week: Golf Channel Watch Syndicated TV (M-F): Inside Edition HH subscribes to digital cable TV Watched last week: E! Read Index 154 135 127 126 Listen Category Radio format listen to: Hispanic Radio format listen to: classic hits R di fformatt lilisten Radio t tto: sports t Radio format listen to: soft adult contemporary Radio format listen to: all talk Radio format listen to: news/talk Index 159 127 126 Grocery Index 175 136 136 135 133 131 Leisure Category Visited Disney World (FL)/12 mo: Magic Kingdom Visited Universal Studios (FL) in last 12 months Visited Disney World (FL)/12 mo: MGM Studios Visited Disney World (FL)/12 mo: Epcot Center Attended movies in last 90 days: once/week or more Attended horse races in last 12 months Category Read airline magazines Read computer magazines Read business/finance magazines Category Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: Harris Teeter Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: Giant Sh Shopped d att grocery store/6 t /6 mo: P Publix bli Used whole coffee beans last 6 mo: Starbucks Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: Piggly Wiggly Shopped at grocery store/6 mo: IGA Index 187 161 152 152 73 70 Restaurant Index 146 143 140 137 134 132 Category Fam rest/steak hse last 6 mo: Don Pablo`s Fast food/drive-in last 6 mo: Fuddruckers Fam rest/steak hse last 6 mo: Red Robin Fast food/drive-in food/drive in last 6 mo: Jack in the Box Fast food/drive-in last 6 mo: Chick-fil-A Fam rest/steak hse last 6 mo: Ryan`s Index 148 146 146 145 145 69 Consumer U d t di Outside Understanding O t id Perceptions P ti CONSUMER AWARENESS & PERCEPTION STUDY Conducted in Broward County (excluding Lauderdale Lakes) Consumer CAP Study DEMOGRAPHICS Which of the following includes your age? Answer Options 18-24 25-34 35 44 35-44 45-54 55-64 65-74 75 or over Response Percent 1.1% 21.9% 25 1% 25.1% 22.5% 23.0% 5.9% 0.5% Which of the following best describes your race? Response Answer Options Percent Caucasian 66.1% African American 12.4% Hispanic 12.4% Black of Caribbean or Latin 3.8% descent Other (please specify) 3.2% Asian or Pacific Islander 2.2% Which of the following levels matches your total household income? Response Answer Options Percent $24,999 or less 5.7% $25 000 - $34,999 $25,000 $34 999 3 4% 3.4% $35,000 - $49,999 14.3% $50,000 - $74,999 26.3% $75,000 - $99,999 22.3% $100,000 + 28.0% Gender Answer Options Female Male Response Percent 66.0% 34.0% Consumer CAP Study TOP OF MIND PERCEPTIONS What adjective j best describes Lauderdale Lakes? • Small (29.8%), diverse (21.7%), Caribbean (16.2%) What comes to mind when you think of the following locations? • Lauderdale Lakes: Nothing/don’t know (30.1%), small town, suburb, bad area • Ft. F LLauderdale: d d l B Beaches, h sunshine, hi restaurants, tourists, i nightlife i h lif • Coral Springs: Affluent, shopping, families • Plantation: Broward Mall, shopping, nice neighborhoods, family and friends • Margate: Nothing, senior citizens, many homes • Lauderhill: Nothing, g bad neighborhoods, g ghetto g • Sunrise: Sawgrass Mills Mall, shopping, retirement community Consumer CAP Study VISITATION TRENDS Visitor Vi it Frequency: F • 67% of the respondents had visited Lauderdale Lakes in the past three years. Of those, over 43% have visited 5 or more times in that three year time span. Primary Trip Purpose: • 38.2% stopped over on the way to somewhere else as their primary purpose of trip “Other Other Responses Responses” – Passing through, through shopping Primary Purpose of Trip Stop over on the way to somewhere else 38.2% Business 17.6% Other (please specify) 16.8% Visit family/friends 16.0% Parks and recreation or sports league Parks and recreation or sports league 6 9% 6.9% Attend a special event 0.0% 4.6% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% Consumer CAP Study ATTRIBUTE RATINGS Using a scale of 1 to 10 with one indicating Using a scale of 1 to 10 with one indicating “poor” poor and 10 indicating and 10 indicating “excellent” how would you rate the following regarding Lauderdale Lakes, Florida? Parks and recreation 4.60 Restaurant offerings 4.48 Convenience of retail 4.37 Overall value 4.29 Appearance of the city 4.26 Place of interesting flavors 4.24 Shopping options 4.18 Special events 4.17 Social gathering spots 3.93 Arts and cultural offerings 3.88 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Consumer CAP Study MOST DISTINGUISHABLE ASSET Using a scale of 1 to 10 with one indicating “least distinguishable characteristic” and 10 indicating “most distinguishable characteristic” how would you rate the following characteristics in Lauderdale Lakes? Intersection of State Road 7 and Oakland Park Blvd. 6.21 A diverse community 5.42 Caribbean culture 5.18 Friendly, family‐oriented community 4.41 Central location in South Florida 4.36 Strong business district 4.26 A town with great sports, parks and recreation 4.25 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 Consumer CAP Study 22.4% travel on State Road 7 or Oakland Park Boulevard through Lauderdale Lakes on a regular basis – 39.2% 39 2% said they were commuting When you travel to or through Lauderdale Lakes, do you stop at retail establishments and/or restaurants? – Do not stop in Lauderdale Lakes: 65.8% – Both restaurants and retail: 14.2% – Retail establishments only: 11.1% – Restaurants only: 8.9% In each of the following categories, what types of businesses would cause you to stop in Lauderdale Lakes? – Restaurant/bar: Fast food (9.5%), ethnic restaurants (Caribbean and others) (8.3%) – Grocery/specialty Food Store: Publix (24.4%), (24 4%) Jamaican grocery store (7 (7.3%), 3%) Winn Dixie (7.3%), Walmart (7.3%) – Retail outlet: Walmart (20.3%), a mall (5.1%), Target (6.33%) – Service type business: Gas station (20.3%), doctor’s office (4.8%) – Convenience business (not quick marts): None (23.6%), gas station (12.5%), Walmart (4.2%) Consumer CAP Study Do you associate Lauderdale Lakes with…? ( ) • Caribbean culture: Yes (43.8%) • Music and art: Yes (10.5%) • Sports: Yes (12.7%) Other facets of the community • Only 8.3% had attended a youth or adult league sports event in Lauderdale Lakes. • Only 3.1% of respondents have attended UniFest in the past – Respondents said it was memorable. One person said he did not feel welcomed as someone of non-Caribbean descent • 20.4% Have heard of Black Historyy Month events in Lauderdale Lakes – 12.5% have attended one of those Black History Month events • 33% (the largest majority) of respondents ranked Lauderdale Lakes as the second g city. y 50% of respondents p felt that Lauderhill was most dangerous. g most dangerous (Lauderhill, Lauderdale Lakes, Ft. Lauderdale, Sunrise, Margate, Plantation, Coral Springs) Consumer CAP Study Only 7% stated that they are aware of improvements being done to the city • Some of the improvements acknowledged include: – Building a new library along Oakland Park Blvd. – “Oakland Park Blvd being repaved and adding new islands, irrigation and plantings” – Streets were widened and repaved and hurricane street lights were installed – New parks – Sports park • Suggested improvements include: – “Refurbish and attract higher profile, well-known vendors to shopping areas; beautify higher-traffic areas; schedule events encouraging more diversity” – Clean up the city – Crime reduction Consumer CAP Study Is Lauderdale Lakes, Florida a place you would consider living? – 94.6% said it is not a place they would consider living • Negatives – Crime rate is high there – do not see it as a family-friendly area where I would want to raise my family – I live in a better city – Lack of amenities and safety. Also it is not aesthetically pleasing to the eye • Positives – I would consider living at Lauderdale Lakes because of the cultural di diversity it In your opinion, what is missing from Lauderdale Lakes? – Cleanliness – Many M know k very little li l about b it i and d said id more advertising d i i would ld help h l – Newer development- retail, housing Consumer Understanding Stakeholder and Economic Development Perceptions PERCEPTION STUDY Business and Community Leaders in Lauderdale Lakes State and Regional g Economic Development p & Communityy Development p Officers Consumer Perception Study LAUDERDALE LAKES STAKEHOLDERS AND STATE/REGIONAL PROFESSIONALS Stakeholders Caribbean Transitioning Mom and pop shops Retirees/snowbirds Progressive State/Regional Professionals African American International Vibrant, emerging, teeming Committed to improving, collaborative, growth growth-oriented oriented Same as many others, insignificant, underdeveloped Major intersection, pass through, central location Downtrodden, congested Unknown, no reputation Assets Community involvement Redevelopment efforts Library Community Center Parks and recreation Caring people committed to growth Entrepreneurial, multi-cultural businesses Location, State Rd 7 & Oakland Park Blvd, improvements, Canals, Cricket Stadium Strong leadership: City Manager, CRA Staff & Board, Mayor, Council Convergence of opportunity International reputation (Canada, (Canada Caribbean, Caribbean others) Home to many county leaders, teachers, firemen, educated class Add to Lauderdale Lakes Outreach Promotion Larger businesses Advocacyy from ggovernment Business friendly practices/community Sustain and empower more community involvement Continued visioning and planning Significant, interesting retail Concentrate retail densityy and develop p reasons to stop p Increase skills and education of workforce Create basic industry to own in marketplace Positive image Insular behavior Loiterers U kill d/idl youth Unskilled/idle th In fighting between groups Public squabbles between government officials (resolve and 1 voice) S lfi h/t it i l bbusiness Selfish/territorial i owners Over-retailed area (concentrate density to free land for development) Stretch of ugly strip malls Blight, rundown buildings, vacancies Unattractive city appearance Adjectives Take Away from Lauderdale Lakes Consumer Perception Study LAUDERDALE LAKES STAKEHOLDERS AND STATE/REGIONAL PROFESSIONALS Add to State Rd 7 & Oakland Park Bl d Blvd Challenges Business best suited Outsiders Stakeholders Effective curbside signage Attractive./interesting design concepts Good supermarket Convenient public transit Entertainment State/Regional Professionals Signage Destination attraction Interesting entertainment with programming Grocery, shopping and dining not mirrored in neighboring cities Public transit hub Commercial Vacancies Funding, tax pressures Little local support for businesses Negative perceptions: crime, unsafe, uneducated, nothing to offer Perception as unsafe area Hometown democracy initiative 2010 referendum Lauderdale Lakes and Greater Caribbean Chamber are not Leadership often copying others, needs to take risk & do the unique aligned and complementary UniFest not known outside Caribbean community, not unique Some businesses don’t identify themselves as Lauderdale Lakes Confusion with Lauderhill but as Fort Lauderdale instead Location not on major expressway, no proximity to industry clusters Available land for development Crime Too much land devoted to CRA, should divest some to get more money moving in community community, release chokehold Shipping/distribution Medical/healthcare Warehousing Entertainment production High tech and data Retail Warehouse/distribution Need to create a There for ppeople p to go g to Nothing in particular Not a desirable place to live Low income Rundown Poorly maintained shopping plazas Loiterers Unsafe Not easy to do business Most unaware of where Lauderdale Lakes is Minority community Low income Lots of potential Nice, well run black city Unaware Consumer Perception Study LAUDERDALE LAKES STAKEHOLDERS AND STATE/REGIONAL PROFESSIONALS Mi i Missing Stakeholders Upwardly mobile attitude Good supermarket Ability to embrace potential E Extensive i youth h programming i Community support State/Regional Professionals Funding, PR problem that communities don’t spend $$ wisely No reason to go or stop Envisioned identity that is unique T Town center, regional i l attraction, i d destination i i retailil East/West public transport in Broward County Available land for development Commercial and residential investment and development Publicity of affordable community Multi-ethnic Multi ethnic shopping mecca State Rd 7 & Oakland Park Blvd development (not a mall experience) Focus on unique interests and multi-cultural density Concentration of international interests: dining, dining shopping, shopping fun, fun destination grocery (like Publix Sabor concept), entertainment Incorporate lakes in redevelopment Create a more dense urban center South Florida mass transit plans Draw traffic with stronger job base Small business diversity (focus on international arena) Foreign Trade Zone, import/export training Import/export entrepreneurs reaching international markets Entertainment production, soundstages, digital animation studios St Rd 7 tourist enjoyment between Hollywood and Coconut Creek Caribbean segment networks together Caribbean population and African Americans don don’tt always collaborate Lack of trust between two groups No association with Caribbean Great asset, asset should capitalize on it more Caribbean Fest is in Lauderhill Cross-section of cultures Caribbean,, Afro-American,, JJamaican,, Indian,, Chinese,, Thai,, Vietnamese, Arabian, Trinidadian Significant immigrant community Affordable sports for youth Uniqueness Central location Successful African American city Diversity within black community Nothing (same as so many others) Opportunities Caribbean Culture Only Lauderdale Lakes Offers Consumer Perception p Studyy LAUDERDALE LAKES STAKEHOLDERS AND STATE/REGIONAL PROFESSIONALS “Lauderhill gets our positive headlines and we get their negative ones.” “Broward cities all run together and are all referred to as Fort Lauderdale. They blend; you never know when you’ve left one and entered another.” “Crime is exaggerated. We don’t see many gun or knife injuries in our ER.” “African American and the Caribbean population want the same things but can’t ’ seem to workk together.” h ” “State Road 7 is looking fabulous!” “Great traffic. Don’t have to create the traffic. Just have to develop and publicize reasons to stop.” “Our sports programs are popular regardless of race or nationality. White kids from Davie and minorities from West Palm.” Consumer Perception p Studyy LAUDERDALE LAKES STAKEHOLDERS AND STATE/REGIONAL PROFESSIONALS “Showing Showing me a shopping center and telling me I can do what I want with it tells me Lauderdale Lakes is desperate.” “Lauderdale Lakes needs to make a statement with its main intersection. The look is more important than the use.” “The city made a decision to be like somewhere else rather than being themselves.” “Find your schtick. And promote the hell out of it.” “Ethnic-centric activity is a great opportunity. Cheaper than going to the islands.” “Outside perception is one of little security. Lock your doors.” Consumer Perception p Studyy LAUDERDALE LAKES STAKEHOLDERS AND STATE/REGIONAL PROFESSIONALS “State Road 7 is like the I-95 of Broward County but you can pull on and off easily.” “Delray Beach should be a model for Lauderdale Lakes. All efforts and entities work together. One voice. One team.” “Too many of the cities in redevelopment used the same or similar consultants; all the plans look the same and so will the cities. Lauderdale Lakes needs to focus on the unique and different different. Corridor communities have to distinguish themselves. Find a way to make those cutesy Mediterranean buildings unique.” “Lauderdale Lauderdale Lakes amazingly has no real ghetto. ghetto ” “City leadership needs to get out of the weeds and focus on the big picture.” “There’s nothing wrong with being the bedroom. Lauderdale Lakes can enjoy good tax base and promote quality of life and affordable housing.” Community Consumer Competition How do we know about Lauderdale Lakes’ Lakes Competition? • In-Market Trip Competition – Intercept Interviews – Stakeholder Interviews – Focus Group • CAP Study • Research & Materials Audit • Perception Study Competition Understanding How Your Competition Communicates Competitive Analysis Competition Id tifi d C Identified Competitors tit FROM SITUATION ANALYSIS & RESEARCH Identified competitors: • Ft. Lauderdale • Coral Springs • Plantation • Lauderhill • Sunrise • Weston • Miramar Mi • Margate Competition Identified Competitors Ft. Lauderdale, “Venice of America” Distance: 8 Miles Southeast • The largest of Broward County's 30 municipalities and the seventh largest city in Florida • Home to Broward Community College, Florida Atlantic University, Florida International University, the award-winning Broward County Main Library, federal, county and school district offices Tourism • O off Florida’s One ’ premier tourist destinations • 10.35 million visitors annually • Awarded “Best gay resort town” • Home to the picturesque Riverwalk and Las Olas Boulevard Economic Development • 100 Best Places to Live and Launch by CNN Money • One of the top 10 most “fiscally fit” cities in America • Hosts a 600,000-square-foot convention center • More than 40% of local businesses engaged in or supporting i international i l commerce • The Fort Lauderdale metropolitan area foreclosures increased 127.4% from 2006 to 2007 • Fort Lauderdale ranks fourth in the list of top 10 metropolitan areas ranked by foreclosure filings per household for the third quarter of 2007 Summary • Strengths: Strong tourism industry and growing industry • Weaknesses: Hit hard by the subprime lending crisis Competition Identified Competitors p Coral Springs, “Community of Excellence” Distance: 12 Miles North Economic Development • The city reached residential build-out in 2003 and is very close to a commercial build-out • 27th best city in the United States in which to live by Money Magazine • 10th safest city in the US by Morgan Quitno • Voted 100 best communities for kids by America’s Promise • The city has twice received the Florida Sterling Award for excellence in administration p g became the first state or local ggovernment in the • In 2007,, Coral Springs nation to receive the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award • Real estate values in the city are significantly higher than the county as a whole • Fitch, Moody's, and Standard & Poor's rate Coral Springs bonds as AAA. • Lowest city tax in Broward County of cities with more than 70,000 people General • Strong social media: The city is on both Facebook and Twitter Summary • Strengths: Family-friend city, Fiscally savvy government, • Weaknesses: Few tourism efforts, weak website Competition Identified Competitors p Plantation, “The grass is greener” Distance: 5 Miles South Tourism • 42 parks and playgrounds, 6 golf courses including the City’s own Plantation Preserve Golf Course and extensive recreation programs for children • Plantation City Hall was the backdrop for part of the film There's Something About Mary • Broward Mall Economic Development • The Midtown District – Home of more than 50 Fortune 500 companies including DHL, American Express, and Tradestation. Hosts “LEED” LEED Super Class A offices. (US Green Building Council Member) • Many schools have received the "Five Star School Award" from the Florida Department of Education • Home to American Intercontinental University and the University of Phoenix • High household income:: Plantation: $53,700/Broward County: $41,700 Summary • S Strengths: h Growing G industrial d l complexes l • Weaknesses: Weak tourism efforts and limited economic development promotion Competition Identified Competitors p Lauderhill – No recognizable brand Distance: 3 Miles North • 33.65% of Lauderhill's population was born outside of the United States. 24.63% were born in the Caribbean • Lauderhill had the third highest percentage of Jamaican residents in the United States • All-America City Award Economic Development • City facilities include several award winning parks, the Lauderhill Sports Complex, two community centers, two public swimming pools, bridge clubs, scrabble clubs, dance nights, dive dive-in in pool evenings • The City of Lauderhill has been approved to receive $4,293,288 in emergency assistance from the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) through the Community Development Block Grant ; Lauderhill CRA plans include Carishoca mixed-use Caribbean development, All Americas Cultural Mall, Gospel Center • Strong public transportation system Summary Strengths: Focused on city redevelopment Weaknesses: No identifiable tourism or economic development Competition Identified Competitors p Sunrise, “Rise and shine with Sunrise” (Not wide-spread) Distance: 5 Miles West Tourism and Economic Development: • Home of Sawgrass Mills Mall: – 2.7-million-square-foot 2 7-million-square-foot shopping Mecca welcomes approximately 25 million visitors each year, making it the state's second-biggest tourist attraction after Disney World • Home H tto the th BankAtlantic B kAtl ti Center, C t a 20,000+-seat, 20 000+ t $225 million multi-purpose venue. This world-class facility. Hosts more than 100 major entertainment events annually • Home of the Florida Panthers NHL Team Summary Strengths: Huge mall and BankAtlantic Center Weaknesses: Does not actively promote its strengths Competition Identified Competitors p Weston – “Foundation for our Future,” “Planting seeds for the future” (unclear if either is actually the city’s tagg line)) Distance: 17 Miles West Economic Development • In 2008, Money Magazine ranked Weston as the 73rd best place to live in America, making it the best place to live in the state of Florida • In 2006, Money Magazine ranked Weston 20th in America in the "Biggest Earners" category g job j growth g in Florida and • It was also ranked as the cityy with largest 18th largest in the nation • Due to it being a fully planned community, local realtors often state that "everything is located exactly where it should be” • According to the 2008 CNN Money estimate, the median income for a household in the city is $91,148 • All public schools in Weston have been given an “A” rating based on their FCAT scores for 4 years running Summary • Strengths: Many city awards and strong schools • Weaknesses: Weak tourism effort, no consistent brand Competition Identified Competitors Miramar, “at the center of everything” not widely used Distance: 14 Miles South Tourism • Borders the Everglades National Park Economic Development • Miramar had the fifth highest percentage of Jamaican residents in the US, with 15.4% of the populace • Spirit Airlines is headquartered in Miramar • 100 of “America’s Best Places to Live” by Money Magazine for 2008 • Strong redevelopment and beautification programs M Margate – No N recognizable i bl b brand d Distance: 6 Miles North Tourism • The City is home to 105 acres of parks including the Calypso Cove Aquatic Facility, a water park opened in 2005 that has received national and international recognition for excellence in design Economic Development • Margate Community Redevelopment Agency: A Progressive city b tifi ti and beautification d business b i recruitment it t program Strengths: Focused on city redevelopment Weaknesses: No identifiable tourism or economic development Insights g Conclusions based on research Insights Insights “I began to see the marvelous gift and the great benefit of my experience. I act as a kind of bridge. I bring together in my person, and hopefully in my work, many cultures.” -- Paule Marshall, American writer with roots in Barbados Insights Lauderdale Lakes serves as a bridge that g together g manyy of the cultures brings of the world. Insights "Diversity Diversity is the magic. magic It is the first manifestation, the first beginning off the h differentiation diff i i off a thing hi and d off simple identity. The greater the diversity, the h greater the h perfection." f i " -- Thomas Berry, cultural historian Insights Diversity truly is the magic in Lauderdale Lakes. Lakes Your community is like a metaphor for many of the cultures of the world – a microcosm of the welcoming philosophy that has distinguished the United States. Insights Insights • Research points to diversity as an asset – “What we have that other communities don’t have is a cross-section of cultures: Caribbean, Afro-American, Jamaican, Indian, Chinese, T i id di Arabian, Trinidadian, A bi IIrish, i h German, G C Canadian; di a significant immigrant community.” – Perception Interview Insights Insights • Diversity as an asset – Outsiders who said they would consider moving to Lauderdale Lakes cited cultural diversity as the reason. – Ethnic restaurants and groceries are named as top attractions. – Residents sayy diversityy is one of the community’s y topp assets and the thing they are most proud of. – Stakeholders point to diversity coupled with vision as the community’s community s hope for the future. future It attracts talent and leads the city. Insights Insights • Diversity as an asset – Caribbean culture is a significant part of your diversity. – Caribbean itself is multi-cultural. multi cultural – Caribbean Americans live throughout Broward County. Insights Insights And when your community offers so much international flavor, why limit the palate to a single taste! Insights Insights In fact, Lauderdale Lakes is much like fusion cooking. You are: – – – – – – EEclectic l i Original A combination of flavors A variety of ingredients Familiar yet nontraditional Always experimenting, improving. Insights Insights • Eclectic – International restaurants are a top attraction – International sports such as cricket, rugby and netball are found alongg with traditional American team sports p – Festivals feature a multicultural musical experience – Events like Black History Month celebrate cultural differences – Religious freedom is celebrated with choice ranging from Methodists to Muslims – Multiple languages are spoken throughout the community • 60 languages represented in schools (heard during In-Market) a y bus businesses esses are a e multi-lingual u t gua including c u g hospital osp ta which w c iss • Many hiring docs who speak Spanish and Creole. Insights Insights • Original – The intersection of so many unique ideas and flavors has created a one-of-a-kind community – Unrivaled youth sports leagues with the lowest fees in the region – Unique food including Middle Eastern bakery and Halal grocery – Original location of Broward Meat and Fish Fish, a destination grocery – One of the leading CRAs in South Florida with visionary planning. Insights Insights • A combination bi ti off flavors fl – Spicy music, food and personalities – Sweet, Sweet friendly and welcoming residents – Zesty leadership that is willing to fight to make things better – Peppery economic development that works hard to enhance and heat up development opportunities in the area – Salty natural greenspaces and fresh waterways throughout the community providing natural beauty and enjoyment. enjoyment Insights Insights • A variety of ingredients – The meat and substance are your warm, interesting, hardworking, diverse residents – The vegetables and greens are the programs/initiatives in place that improve the health and welfare of residents including parks and d recreation, ti schools, h l city it lib library, city it government and community events. – The spice p that flavors everything y g is your y diversity – The sauce that brings it all together is central location in Broward County (I/95/Turnpike/SR 7/Oakland Park Blvd). Insights Insights • Familiar, F ili yett non-traditional t diti l – For the many residents – including a significant i immigrant i population l i – who h callll Lauderdale L d d l Lakes home, there is the comfort and familiarity of their original culture. culture The food, the religion, the music are as close as the next block. – But as these many cultures fuse and assimilate they create a unique dish that offer an entirely new rendition of the familiar flavors. Insights Insights • Always y experimenting, p g improving p g – In fusion cooking, the possibilities for combining, improving and changing are endless. – Current leadership in Lauderdale Lakes feels the same about their community. They are willing to explore new ways for a better outcome including: • Thi This bbranding di iinitiative iti ti • Infrastructure improvements including new library, Oakland Park Blvd and St Rd 7 streetscapes, widened streets, h i hurricane street t t lilights, ht new parks, k sports t park, k bbus shelters h lt • Designation as both a Tree City USA and a Playful City USA. Insights Insights “Variety is the very spice of life. That gives it all its flavor.” – William Cowper, English poet Insights Insights And that is what makes Lauderdale Lakes unique. q The wide variety of cultural influences have fused to create a community where flavors are spicier, richer, more colorful. Where life is eclectic and interesting. Where opportunity is available to all and comes in all shapes and forms. forms Lauderdale Lakes naturally has flavors many only dream about. Just a bit of salt can bring out those flavors and keep the city from the dangers of the bland sameness that others battle daily. Lauderdale Lakes Brand Positioning Platform Target Audience: For hardworking people committed to community involvement, Frame-of-Reference: Lauderdale Lakes is an affordable, accessible city in the center of Broward County Point-of-Difference: where cultures intersect Benefit: for a fusion of flavors that makes life more interesting. Lauderdale Lakes Brand Platform Rationale Target Audience: For hardworking people committed to community involvement, •Lauderdale Lakes is home to people with a strong work ethic and interest in elevating their community. Many Broward County leaders and community role models live in Lauderdale Lakes, reasons to attract more. •Attracting civic-minded civic minded people will bring the community closer closer. Schools will improve with more parental involvement. •People P l and d bbusinesses i are attracted tt t d to t communities iti that th t are connected t d and active, communities in which all perspectives are welcome. •The level of engagement is directly proportionate to pride and progress. Creating brand ambassadors is key to furthering a new brand. Lauderdale Lakes Brand Platform Rationale Frame-of-Reference: Lauderdale Lakes is an affordable, accessible city in the center of Broward County •Right between I-95 and the Florida Turnpike with easy access throughout h h South S h Florida Fl d •Located on State Road 7 at Oakland Park Boulevard in the exact center of Broward County; State Road 7 is a major artery in South Florida p did not become as inflated in Lauderdale Lakes;; homes •Housingg prices are more affordable in Lauderdale Lakes than elsewhere in Broward Co. Cost of living is lower, lower an affordable alternative in South Florida Florida. •Cost Western suburbs are building out, fueling redevelopment back East. Lauderdale Lakes Brand Platform Rationale Point-of-Difference: where cultures intersect •African Af i A American, i J Jamaican, i C Canadian, di Haitian, H i i Hispanic, Hi i B Barbadian, b di IIrish, ih Bahamian, German, Syrian, Trinidadian, Chinese, Lebanese, Thai, Indian, Vietnamese, and many more. Not just Caribbean but international. •Diverse cultures bring all of their traditions, food, music, arts, sports, and faiths with them. Only Lauderdale Lakes can offer Broward County this concentration i off unique i cultures l iin one accessible ibl llocation, i a community i that welcomes all and encourages individuality. •Major roads come together in Lauderdale Lakes along with the travelers on them. The roads bring 120,000+ motorists through daily. •Many things beyond culture intersect here: strong leadership ideas, inclusive political structures, commerce/distribution, canals/greenways. Lauderdale Lakes Brand Platform Rationale Benefit: for a fusion of flavors that makes life more interesting. •Have you ever enjoyed a marvelous meal where you assembled the perfect bite when all of the flavors mingled for the ultimate taste? That is analogous for life in Lauderdale Lakes. Flavorful. Smile Smile-inducing. inducing. Satisfying. Rewarding. •The diverse cultures offer residents many unique opportunities for discovery. y That “same old” has no pplace here. You don’t have to travel far in Lauderdale Lakes to taste the world, whether purist preparations or cross-cultural blends. It may be across town at Broward Meat and Fish or acoustic hymns next door at your neighbors. People will drive far to experience authenticity. It’s here. You just have to package and promote it including PR, marketing, large-scale events, and other implementation efforts. •There is a richness that is inherent in a life in Lauderdale Lakes. That unique place in the road. Lauderdale Lakes Brand Positioning Platform Target Audience: For hardworking people committed to community involvement, Frame-of-Reference: Lauderdale Lakes is an affordable, accessible city in the center of Broward County Point-of-Difference: where cultures intersect Benefit: for a fusion of flavors that makes life more interesting. Next Steps • Approval of Brand Platform • Development/Approval of Written Creative Concepts •Development of Creative Elements -Logos, Strapline, Creative Expressions of the Brand • Assembly of Final BrandPrint Report • Final Presentation and Deliverables Lauderdale Lakes, FL BrandPrint Understanding & Insights Presentation
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz