WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION Piotr Miodunka Cracow University of Economics The Subsistence Crisis of 1845-1847 in Austrian Galicia and Its Socioeconomic Background at the Macro and Micro Levels Introduction In the second half of the 1840s Galicia (nowadays part of Poland and Ukraine) was strongly affected by a subsistence crisis. In 1847 the mortality rate rose to 78‰, i.e. more than twice its ‘normal’ level. Galicia, with a population of 4.9 million (1847), was one of the poorest provinces of the Habsburg Empire, dominated by a rural populace (about 75% in 1880) and a manorial economy based on peasant serfdom. In spite of these circumstances, this was the most substantial crisis caused by harvest failure since the beginning of the Austrian regime (1772). This fact has not attracted particular interest among historians, however, because the consequences of the two (and in some places three) years of poor harvests in the mid-1840s were obscured by political events such as the Kraków Uprising, an attempted Galician uprising (both in 1846), a peasant riot (1846), and finally the Revolution of 1848. The sole fact of the famine and potato blight is known and often mentioned, but there are no detailed studies of this crisis or indeed other similar crises in pre-industrial Poland. The paper will be devoted more to the causes and short-term effects than to the long-term consequences of the 1847 famine. It should be remembered that in 1848 serfdom was abolished in the Austrian Empire and this was a key reason for the fundamental changes to Galician farming in the following years.1 Subsistence Crises from the Mid-17th Century Subsistence crises and famines affecting the territory of Poland have been inadequately examined. As far as we know, like in many places in Europe, the first half of the 1690s was very difficult, but the greatest food crises occurred in 1714/15 and 1736/37, both probably induced by floods. The famines of the first half of the 1770s, which strongly affected Germany and Bohemia, probably did not have such dramatic consequences in Poland. A 1 More precisely in 1848 peasants were granted ownership of the land they possessed, personal serfdom having been abolished in the 1780s. 1 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION similar situation occurred in 1785 – perhaps because of government support for residents (an embargo on grain export, work on the construction of paved roads). There were some mortality crises at the beginning of the 19th century, but mostly on the local scale (e.g. in 1806 in the Rzeszów district). The highest mortality before 1847 was noted in 1831, which was connected with a cholera epidemic. The Crisis of the 1840s in Detail The first half of the 1840s was not favourable for agriculture. The most damaging effects were wrought by torrential summer rains and floods. Table 1. shows information about floods of the Wisłoka river, a tributary of the Vistula, from three different sources. Year Przecław parish chronicle Szewczuk’s Chronicle Comments Yes Rzochów parish chronicle Flood Yes 1839 Yes Church in Rzochów and bridge in Pilzno destroyed 1840 1841 1842 1843 1844 1845 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Extensive damage in Rzochów Table 1. Floods of the Wisłoka river The year of 1843 was fertile and produce was very cheap. The two successive years (1844 and 1845) were described as wet and in both of them big floods occurred. In turn, the year of 1846 was too dry and in addition afflicted by potato blight. The first information about scarcity and famine dates from 1845 and concerns western Galicia. The situation did not change in 1846, and in 1847 took on catastrophic character in western and central Galicia. Both press reports and parish chronicles are full of terrible descriptions of poverty and even cases of cannibalism. Statistical data on harvests released in official publications do not show any crop failures. They are stable throughout the 1840s, so do not reflect the reality. We have no alternative global assessments, so the only sources that can be used are local data. The manorial accounts of Łańcut estate, for instance, have a gap from 1841 to 1848 with reference to potatoes. Nevertheless the quantities of both sowing and harvested potatoes are more or less 2.5 times 2 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION higher in the second half of the 1830s than in the 1850s. Yields of potatoes in the 1850s were nearly half those before the blight. I have looked for other sources which reflect real fluctuations in harvests rather than guesstimates. I have investigated a few tithe registers of parishes located in low-lying areas close to the rivers Dunajec and Wisłoka. Within the parish of Otfinów there were no drops in harvests in 1845 or 1846 with the exception of potatoes. In Książnice parish only in one village was the grain output in 1845 significantly down, at 57% of the previous year’s figure, and in 1846 its records show a volume only 63% of the 1844 harvest. What is somewhat curious is that these registers do not mention potatoes at all. This is probably because potatoes were cultivated on formerly fallow fields. The data on prices are more readily available. The price movements of vital crops after the ‘normal’ year of 1842 for the whole of Galicia (Ga), its two main cities Lviv (Lw) and Kraków (Kr, incorporated into Galicia in 1846)2, and a small market town – Rozwadów (Ro), are shown in table 2. Wheat Rye Potatoes Ga Lw Kr Ro Ga Lw Kr Ro Ga Lw Kr Ro 1843 61 59 63 54 55 48 63 58 74 63 76 60 1844 68 78 74 68 61 76 75 50 79 78 93 83 1845 111 126 121 100 126 152 148 125 163 174 178 - 1846 156 155 138 146 179 187 184 195 200 203 232 255 1847 173 174 168 161 200 206 219 253 305 284 382 281 1848 144 155 102 - 155 161 123 - 289 248 304 - Table 2. Index of prices of selected crops (1842=100) The overall trend was common to both cities (Lviv, Kraków) and the small market town (Rozwadów) and may thus be considered representative for the whole province. After two cheaper years (1843, 1844), in 1845 a marked rise in prices of potatoes began, and in the larger cities the price of rye also rose. Then came two expensive years, when the price of rye at least doubled (or increased even more) and prices of potatoes climbed three or even four times (Kraków). The main export grain – wheat – appreciated least. 2 Krakow before 1846, as a Free City, was closely connected with the Galician grain market as a transit hub for grain imported to Galicia from the Kingdom of Poland. 3 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION The mortality rate in 1847 rapidly rose to 78‰ (from 33‰ in 1846), which was the highest level since 1816. Nevertheless, mortality was not constant across the province. Numbers of deaths exceeded births in 11 out of 18 districts in the west and in the centre. To simplify, I assume that the crisis affected the western part of Galicia, consisting of eight districts, i.e. Wadowice, Bochnia, Nowy Sącz, Jasło, Tarnów, Sanok, Przemyśl 3. Table 3. and graph 1. illustrate that the sudden rise in mortality affected only the western part of Galicia. Western Galicia Eastern Galicia Galicia 1846 32 35 33 1847 113 44 78 Table 3. Mortality rate in western and eastern Galicia in ‰ Graph 1. Deaths in Galicia in 1838-1857 Graph 1. shows crude numbers of deaths in the 20-year perspective of 1838–1857. Between 1838 and 1846 mortality in both parts of Galicia developed at the same rate. Thereafter, we observe a rapid increase in deaths in the west, and a far slower and smaller increment in the east. After 1848 the data for the respective districts was not published so we cannot separate these two geographical regions. The graph shows another peak in mortality in 1855, as well as high numbers of deaths in 1849, 1853 and 1854. 3 In the traditional sense, the term “western Galicia” covered the six districts Wadowice, Bochnia, Nowy Sącz, Jasło, Tarnów and Rzeszów, which were inhabited by Roman Catholic Poles. For the purposes of this paper I have added two central districts, Przemyśl and Sanok, which were ethnically and religiously mixed (Polish and Ukrainian). 4 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION Graph 2. Birthss in Galicia in 1838-1857 Graph 2. presents numbers of births, and we can see that from 1846 in western Galicia there was a progressive but significant drop in this figure. For Galicia as a whole, in 1855 (another peak in the mortality rate), no decline in births is visible. This means that the population shrinkage in 1847 and 1848 (table 4.) was much larger than that around 1855. In the 1840s at least, this was caused by the situation in western Galicia. WG EG Births Deaths Difference Births Deaths Difference 1845 96,171 1846 81,705 72,822 23,349 110,944 87,959 22,985 72,918 8,787 102,339 85,107 17,232 1847 76,636 261,996 -185,360 103,351 106,404 -3,053 1848 53,565 147,831 -94,266 93,592 140,022 -46,430 Table 4. Natural movement in western and eastern Galicia in the 1840s. In consequence, Galicia as a whole had in 1847 a negative growth rate of 3,8%, but in the west of the province it reached -8%. The respective figures for the next year were -3% and 4.4%. If we look at the various individual districts of western Galicia we can also see considerable diversity (table 5.). In the 1847 the highest mortality rates were in the districts of Wadowice, Bochnia and Nowy Sącz, i.e. the westernmost regions. A year later the highest mortality was in Wadowice again, and in Sanok. Generally the most affected regions were western and mountainous ones. 5 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION Wadowice Bochnia Nowy Sącz Jasło Tarnów Rzeszów Sanok Przemyśl 1847 166 1848 97 136 145 114 106 68 105 65 74 71 65 47 83 Table 5. Mortality rate in western districts of Galicia (per mille) 56 49 We can observe the scale of devastation caused by the high mortality rates in even more detail using the church annual directories (schematismus) of the Tarnow diocese, which give the number of Catholics in each parish. The largest decline in the number of parishioners between 1845 and 1850 was in the deanery of Żywiec, the most mountainous in the Wadowice district. Investigation of a few localities situated in the four western districts proves that the crisis lasted a decade, with at least one or two peaks, in 1847 and 1855. But the pattern was not the same everywhere, as the graphs below illustrate clearly (graph 3.). 6 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION Graph 3. Births and deaths in selected parishes of western Galicia in 1838-1857 In the Wadowice and Nowy Sącz districts, the 1847 crisis appeared much worse than in others. In the village of Sucha mortality was almost seven times higher than in “normal” years (the average for 1842–1846). There was a similar pattern in two localities on the slopes of the Gorce mountains, the town of Nowy Targ and the village of Ochotnica, where mortality was respectively nearly six and five times higher than normal. In these places, and also two others (Żmiąca, Borzęcin), the first half of the 1850s was not so dramatic. In the others, the crisis peaked twice, and in some of them the year 1855 was worse than 1847. Most of the examined parish registers indicate that mortality growth was rapid everywhere, with the exception of Krasne and Lipnica villages, where the negative natural increase first became visible in 1846, due above all to the very small number of births. Parish registers include information on causes of death. Even during the greatest intensity of mortality there were very few cases directly related to famine, i.e. starvation. However, in 1847 famine-related causes such as dysentery and dropsy were often noted (Ochotnica, Padew).4 4 A few entries in April and May 1847 in Ochotnica have starvation as the cause of death. 7 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION Causes of the Crisis Grain and Potato Production We have insufficient data on harvests in Galicia in the late 18th and first half of the 19th centuries. The earliest are those generated by the general cadastral survey known as the Josephine Cadastre, from 1785/1787, which is recognized as credible. This is an estimation of total average annual field harvests expressed in terms of the four main cereals: wheat, rye, barley and oats. Other field crops were treated as one of the abovementioned, depending on their price (e.g. buckwheat was entered as barley). Given the different courses of the crisis, we should make a distinction between the western and eastern parts of Galicia. The explanation for the difference might be the dissimilar character of socio-economic development in the two regions. Western Galicia n % Eastern Galicia n % Area of fields in hectares 1,332,573 44.6 1,654,250 55.4 Population (1800) 1,589,554 48.4 1,697,011 51.6 Total crop production (from fields) in tonnes a (1785/1787) Net production for human consumption in tonnesb Potential consumption per standardised consumerc (1800) in kg Average price of a Metze (61.5 l) of rye (Kreuzer) a 456,179 36.3 801,157 63.7 219,926 33.7 432,010 66.3 173 318 67 44 b based on Josephine Cadastre; ¾ of wheat, rye and barley production (does not include seed for sowing); standardised consumers = 80% of population c Table 6. Differences between western and eastern Galicia at the end of the 18th century Table 6. shows the considerable inequalities between the two parts. Though both had almost the same population, plant production in western Galicia was much lower. Western districts had less arable land, much smaller harvests, and even less production for human consumption (just 1/3 of the total), owing to the high proportion of oats in the crop structure. In consequence, an adult (standardised consumer) had only about 173 kg of wheat, rye and barley available for annual consumption. This calculation does not take into account wheat for 8 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION export or rye for vodka production. So we see that local production was insufficient for subsistence. It is quite obvious that the shortfall must have been delivered from eastern districts; imports from the Kingdom of Poland and sometimes from Hungary also played a significant role. Nevertheless, the supply of grain was impeded by the slow development of modern communication (paved roads). We do not have reliable data on harvests in the subsequent years. In 1819/1820 an update to the Josephine Cadastre was made. The individual village registers show that in some cases the soil was classified as worse than on the previous occasion, while newly obtained fields tended to be of poor fertility. In consequence, the Austrian statistics for the 1830s reveal only slightly higher grain harvests but these are still only mean, potential, static estimations of yearly production. They do also, however, include a separate record of harvests of so-called incidental crops, such as buckwheat, maize and peas, previously included among the four main grains. Table 7. shows information about grain production in the 1840s based on official statistics for the basic cereals (wheat, rye, barley and oats). Intake per standardised normal consumer (adult) was very low, even if we calculate higher yields assuming some progress in cultivation. It is worth stressing that calculations for harvests in the 1860s, including buckwheat and millet, show lower volumes than 20 years previously.5 In any case, traditional grain production was already insufficient at the beginning of the 19th century. The solution was potatoes, which emerged as a garden crop in the 1770s, were soon introduced to fields, and replaced rye in vodka production in manorial distilleries. It has been estimated that in the 1840s two-fifths of the approximately 11.8m tonnes of total potato production was used to make alcohol. Contemporary texts, and inventories of both noble estates and the chattels of townsmen and peasants alike confirm the immense importance of potatoes. For manorial estates they were material for vodka production, which was the main branch of the food industry after the collapse of the grain-based economy during the Napoleonic Wars.6 For the rest of the population (in both towns and villages), potatoes became a very important subsistence food. Although official statistical data are rather poor in terms of reliability, there is no doubt that Galicia was the one of the biggest producers within the Austrian Monarchy.7 In terms of local sources, we have few tithe registers covering the first half of the 19th century, 5 The total grain production of Galicia was estimated at 36.7m Austrian Metzen in the 1840s, and in the 1860s at 26.2m Metzen. 6 In 1845 there were a total of 1,517 active distilleries in Galicia and Bukovina, i.e. one per 57 km². 7 Miodunka, 9 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION so our conclusions cannot be made with any degree of certainty.8 Some of them contain tithes of potatoes, some do not. This invites the conclusion that in some places potato farming occupied fallow fields without superseding traditional grain crops. According to statistics for the 1860s, fallow land accounted for only 13.4% of all fields (for example in Lower Austria 25.7%, in Bohemia 17.4%). The same publication indicated that potatoes occupied 6.7% of total arable fields (including fallows).9 Unlike grain, the potato yield was similar in both parts of the province. Western Galicia n Eastern Galicia % n % Area of fields in hectares 1,338,231 44.2 1,747,899 55.8 Population (1846) 2,306,182 48.7 2,428,245 51.3 Population density (per km) 62.6 54.7 Total crop production (from fields) in tonnes 510,112 38.8 805,023 61.2 Net production for human consumption in tonnesa 244,797 36.6 424,605 63.4 Potential grain consumption per standardised consumer 132 (1846) in kg Potato production in tonnes (1860s) 517,800 219 44.8 Potato consumption per standardised normal consumer 639,131 165 (1843) in kg Average price of a Metze (61.5 l) of rye (Kreuzer) 123 113 Average price of a Metze (61.5 l) of potatoes (Kreuzer) 29 25 a 55.2 ¾ of wheat, rye and barley production (does not include seed for sowing) Table 7. Differences within Galicia in the 1840s. In the 1840s total domestic production of grain and potatoes in western Galicia was far from sufficient. Import from eastern districts and foreign countries was necessary even in non-crisis years. Road construction improved transport, and this is reflected in the price discrepancies, which are smaller than 50 years previously. 8 9 During the 19th century many tithes paid in grain were converted into money. Tithing was abolished in 1848. Vergleichende statistik… Wien 1868, pp. 49, 51. 10 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION Despite the shortfall of food, some proportion of the grain output of the manorial farms, above all wheat, were floated down the river Vistula to Gdańsk. The size of the Galician grain trade in a typical year is illustrated in table 8. and graph 4. Import Export Wheat Rye Barley Oats Total Wheat Rye Barley Oats Total tonnes From/to Poland, Prussia, Russia 628 86 Hungary Total 714 2,350 1,189 382 4,549 1,334 34 120 322 1,810 183 107 101 2,938 1,553 646 5,851 1,717 217 227 423 2,584 588 364 264 1,302 383 774 Table 8. Galician export and import of grain in 1840 Graph 4. Galician export and import of grain in 1840 (total) Demographic pressure The population density across Galicia was 61.5 inhabitants per square km in 1846, but there were large differences between the western and eastern parts of the province. The average for western districts was 75 people per square km, with the highest densities in the Bochnia and Wadowice districts, of 103.5 and 96.4 respectively. As such we can regard these regions, and also the submontane district of Jasło (89 people per sq km), as overpopulated. There are also other indicators of the overpopulation of the western part of Galicia. Young people had difficulties marrying and establishing families. The average marriage rate for 1842–1844 was 9.2‰ (in the east 10.2 ‰) and in the years 1845-1847 dropped to 7.6 ‰. At the same time the percentage of children born illegitimate rose – from about 8% c. 1840 to 11 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION over 9% in the years 1843–1845. Thereafter, a gradual decrease in this statistic began in 1846 and by 1848 only 5.8% of children were born outside legal marriages. The reason for this was the sudden increase in marriages in 1848 as a result of the rise in widowed people. This phenomenon is also reflected on the local level. In the Siedliska-Bogusz parish (Tarnów district) the rate of illegitimate births was about 11.5% in the decade of 1838–1847, falling to 6% in the next five-year period. The decrease in illegitimate births in Ochotnica was even sharper – from above 17% in 1842–1847 to 6.8% in 1848–1850.10 Structure of Peasant Farms The abovementioned fluctuations in the illegitimate birth rate were closely connected with the possibility of owning a farm and establishing a family. In the traditional, agriculture-oriented economy, this was the main way of attaining stability in life.11 One very important factor was the manorial economy, with its complex system of duties, i.e. unpaid work on the manorial farm. From the regime of Emperor Joseph II, the nobility could no longer appropriate the peasant’s land, but the legal separation of the peasant’s farm was very difficult. In spite of the strict regulation, however, fragmentation of farmland progressed. From the 1780s to the 1820s (when the Josephine Cadastre was revised) the increase in the number of farms was slow, but gradually became more noticeable, and led to a progressive reduction in farm size. This process is shown in table 9. >50 20-50 10-20 5-10 2-5 0-2 Total N % N % N % N % N % N % N % 1820 4,741 3 19,782 12 30,034 19 36,885 23 35,563 22 33,597 21 160,602 1850 2,162 1 19,826 7 50,174 18 64,747 23 56,471 20 82,475 30 275,855 100 100 Change (1820= 46 100 167 176 159 245 172 100 % Table 9. Size Structure of Peasant Farms in Western Galicia (Austrian Joche, 1 Joch=0.57 ha) To date, however, research has not drawn a distinction between noble and state estates. For the purposes of this paper, a sample survey was made on the basis of materials concerning the 10 The preliminary results for the Padew parish, which was much less affected by the famine in 1847, suggest that the rate of illegitimate births before and after 1847 was fairly stable, at 8-11%. 11 In Galicia rural linen weaving was quite developed at the turn of the 18th and 19th centuries, but there are still few studies on the importance of this domestic craft in the peasant economy. 12 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION land reform of 1848 which shows a structural difference. In former state villages there was a huge predominance of small crofters’ farms between five and ten Joche (Polish: mórg), i.e. c. 2.9–5.8 ha, in size. This was probably due to the long tradition of free turnover of land among peasants living on former estates of the Polish kings, taken over by the Austrian state. Conversely, private owners controlled the structure of peasants’ farms strictly – which was appropriate from their own point of view. Therefore, on properties of this kind, big peasant farms – which supplied labour with their own yoke – survived up to the mid-19th century (see graph 5.). Nevertheless an additional consequence was a greater number of landless people, i.e. those possessing only cottages or living in houses owned by others. a. Former state village: Grochowe, Padew Narodowa, Tuszów (Tarnów district) b. Noble village of Książnice parish, SiedliskaBogusz village (Tarnów district) Graph 5. Size of peasants farm in selected estates c. 1850 in absolute numbers The Subsistence Crisis and the Peasants’ Revolt of 1846 The cereal and potato failure in the mid-1840s tend to be presented by scholars as merely a background to the Peasants’ Revolt of February 1846 (so-called rabacja in Polish).12 It is claimed that the main cause was incitement by Austrian local officers, who exploited the peasants’ anxiety over the return of absolute rule of the nobility and full serfdom. The great famine of 1847, by contrast, is regarded as an important reason for the pacification of the revolt. Looking at the map of the extent of the revolt (graph 6.) it is clear that it went no further than western Galicia. The epicentre was the district of Tarnów, particularly its borderland with the district of Jasło. The wave of attacks on manor houses and manor farms swept across five districts but almost omitted the district of Wadowice and the southern, most mountainous 12 The revolt began on 19th February 1846 in response to the nobles’ attempt to raise an anti-Austrian uprising. In April soldiers put down the revolt in the villages affected. One of the peasant leaders, the best known, was Jakub Szela from Smarzowa village. 13 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION region of the Nowy Sącz district. Neither townsmen nor German colonists took part in it. We also have information that peasants from state (or former state) properties not only did not join the revolt, but also prevented incursion into their villages. One possible explanation for this is the abovementioned structure of farmland possession. The great numbers of poor, landless people could have been a leading force. The economic structure of rural society on former state properties was flatter, and probably also more independent from their owners’ protection and relief. Existing publications stress, however, that it was a revolt of all classes of rural society. Graph 6. Manor houses and manor farms robbed by peasants in 1846 The impact of the revolt on food provision and the severity of the subsistence crisis is another issue that should be taken into consideration. Leaving aside the publicized cases of murders, the main goal of peasants was robbery and destruction of the duties registers. The stolen grain might have aided survival during the severe period ahead of the 1846 harvest, but many manor fields lay fallow that year. This may have exacerbated the lack of food and intensified the famine the next year, 1847. The revolt also destroyed the existing model of poverty relief, 14 WORK IN PROGRESS, DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISS ION which was above all the duty of the lord of the manor. But there is no simple explanation or correlation, because in fact the famine was the most severe in Wadowice district, which was spared by the peasants’ revolt.13 Another region that missed out was the area around Rzeszów, where the famine of 1847 had less drastic effects. Conclusion The main problem I faced in my research into this issue was the lack of sufficient statistical data relating to demography, harvests and prices. Nevertheless, I tried to answer the question about the vulnerability of the rural population to these subsistence crises owing to its socioeconomic structure. There is no doubt that the famine of 1847 was a crisis of the old, i.e. Malthusian type. The crucial cause, in my opinion, was the potato blight; mortality rose suddenly in 1847, i.e. a year after this disease appeared in Galicia. Nevertheless, increasing difficulties had already led to a prior gradual decline in fecundity. Among the longer-term reasons, the poor productivity of west Galician agriculture and the ensuing shrinkage in peasant farm should be taken into consideration. The link between the famine and the peasants’ revolt the previous year is still not clear. The fact is that the sharpest population decline took place in the district of Wadowice, which was almost untouched by the riots. 13 The Wadowice district had also a well-developed road system. 15
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz