raise roof BEYOND PROFIT E-MAGAZINE ISSUE 8 ►December 31, 2010 - January 13, 2011 the Failed solutions in three continents India's urban housing challenge Commonwealth games aftermath R A I S E T H E R O O F CONTENTS 06 11 08 14 13 3 06 COVER STORY 08 FACE-TO-FACE 09 SPOTLIGHT 10 data 12 TOP 5 13 CASE STUDY 14 REPORT REVIEW Rapid urbanization is putting tremendous strain on cities. beyond profit examines failed housing solutions in Chicago, Buenos Aires and Mumbai. Aden Van Noppen from micro Home Solutions talks about an innovative home improvement project in India. Pakistan’s relatively young population struggles to afford urban housing. Low-income initiatives offer options. A look at population and housing patterns around the world. Profiles of developers offering housing solutions for the urban poor. Understanding how this year’s Commonwealth Games in Delhi is likely to inflate housing prices. A recent World Bank working paper on reducing urban slums in India is relevant to reforming housing policy in the country. www.beyondprofit.com RA I S E T H E ROO F comment poverty migration and the problem of Editor-at-Large Lindsay Clinton Managing Editor Chesta Shah urban housing Editorial Team Nisha Kumar Kulkarni Abby Callard Marketing Manager Ritika Ranjan Office Coordinator Veena Shetty Design Studio ASG Infinite Dear Reader, Perhaps one of the most obvious reasons for the poor to move from one location to the other is survival. Various reports have shown that economic factors and types of occupation often influence migration patterns. Incidence Publisher Intellectual Capital Advisory Services Pvt Ltd (Intellecap) 512, Palm Spring, Near D-Mart, Link Road, Malad (W) Mumbai 400 064, India of migration on an average has shown a marked increase in the census of For contributions, email: [email protected] migrants whereas city-to-city migration has shown a decline. To subscribe: Log on to: www.beyondprofit.com Call: +91 22 4035 9222 Email: [email protected] For marketing and advertising: Email: [email protected] Call: +91 22 40359205 For more information, visit: www.beyondprofit.com Disclaimer The views and opinions expressed by the authors are not necessarily those of Intellecap, and they assume no responsibility for the same. All rights reserved throughout the world. Reproduction in any manner is prohibited. 2001 as compared to earlier studies. Migration to urban areas has increased according to inter-state analysis. Rural to urban migration shows a sizeable increase among male and female The total shortage of dwelling units in India at the beginning of the 11th Plan period, i.e. 2007, was 24.71m units. The housing shortage during the plan period (2007-2012), including the backlog, has been estimated to be 26.53m units. With an ever growing urban population, how best can cities in the Indian subcontinent and other developing countries combat this double digit growth? Write to us and share your views. Chesta Shah Managing Editor Issue 8 | December 31, 2010 - January 13, 2011 4 r a I S e T H e r o o F FeeDbacK ideas@beyondprofit.com “India being an agrobased nation is not able to employ its farmers throughout the year at fair wages. That's where development of skill-based vocations is required that can ensure their consistent economic sustenance.” (Round Table: The Business Behind Livelihoods, December 17’, 2010) Priyanka via beyondprofit.com “The concept of building anchor businesses to develop growth will create a harmonized progress. It's truly about working together, trust, support, and recognition.” (Deepening Rural Relationships, December 17, 2010) Dejting via beyondprofit.com “an important initiative - am interested in following its development.” (Interview: Morgan Simon, Founder of Toniic, December 3, 2010) Jesse via beyondprofit.com ISSue 7 | December 17 - 30, 2010 MARK YOUR CALENDER Impact Forum for Social change Hosted by Impact Investment exchange asia (IIX) January 10, 2011 Dhaka, bangladesh www.asiaiix.com Sustainable Foods Summit organized by organic monitor January 18-19, 2011 San Francisco, u.S.a http://www.sustainablefoodssummit. com/ TAKe THe suRVeY MOST READ ONLINE Technology Entrepreneurship GaTe – Global accelerators of Technology entrepreneurship is an initiative aimed at disseminating university research to technology entrepreneurs in emerging markets. boston university and its networking partners have launched a survey to understand the needs and challenges of technology entrepreneurs. This exercise hopes to bridge the gap between university research and the business needs of emerging economies. If you are technology entrepreneur, take the survey here: http://www. surveymonkey.com/s/LRMNWTB Impact Investing: Challenges and Opportunities on november 29, J.P. morgan and the rockefeller Foundation released a report that may serve as a turning point in the development of impact investing. Interview: Morgan Simon, Founder of Toniic morgan Simon talks about the need for impact investors and the challenges they face. Mukesh Ambani’s Antilia: Extravagance or Employership Should we view ambani as a benevolent employer or an excessive billionaire? Facebook F o l l o w 5 u s Twitter LinkedIn o n www.beyondprofit.com RA I S E T H E solutions R O O F COVER STORY failed Photo Courtesy : ©IFAD/Petterik Wiggers By 2030, more than half the world’s population will live in cities. How will they cope? By Abby Callard Cabrini-Green crumbles in the background The world’s quick urbanization—even faster in developing countries—has put a strain on the cities expected to absorb the massive increase in residents. The issue of urbanization is not new, but the UN estimates that by 2030, 60% of the world’s population will live in cities. Most of the growth will come from developing countries. For example, McKinsey Global Institute estimates 40% of India’s population will live in cities by 2030—a net increase of 250 million people. Cities, both in developed and developing countries, have struggled with providing affordable housing for their residents. In an effort to learn from past mistakes, we’re profiling three failed solutions: Cabrini-Green in Chicago, slum redevelopment in Mumbai and FuerteApache in Buenos Aires. Cabrini-Green Located at the intersection of two of Chicago’s richest neighborhoods, Cabrini-Green is one of the most notorious public housing experiments in the world. Construction on the Chicago Housing Authority (CHA) project startedin 1942 and ended in 1962. In the beginning, most of the residents held jobs at nearby factories. After World War II, the factories closed. To cut costs, the cities paved over the lawns to reduce maintenance, neglected repairs and finished the last Issue 8 | December 31, 2010 - January 13, 2011 buildings with questionable quality. Through the years, gangs moved in and controlled single buildings in the complex. Steel fences were put up around the perimeter. The fences made it hard for police officers to see inside the complex, and in 1970, two were killed by snipers from inside. The high balconiesgot to be so dangerous that CHA enclosed the entire height of the buildings with steel mesh.Many say this created the perception that residents were imprisoned. Pipes frequently burst, garbage backed up to the 15th floor in the trash chute and gang violence increased. “Overthe years, gang violence and neglect created terrible conditions forthe residents, and 6 r a I S e the name Cabrini-Green became symbolic of theproblems associated with public housing in this country” said Keith Gottfried, General Counsel of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, at a 2006 housing conference in Chicago. The last of the residents left earlier this month, and demolition of the last standing building, located at 1230 N. Burling, will begin early 2011. “The reality is that 1230 N. Burling is in disrepair and CHA, in good conscience, could not allow good people to stay there any longer than what was necessary,” said CEO Lewis A. Jordan. slum Redevelopment In a city where more than half the population resides in slums, Mumbai’s redevelopment plans are plentiful. So far, no single plan has been able to really pinpoint exactly how to solve the issue. But, many have failed. Unfinished buildings soar above the slums that have materialized waiting for the construction to be completed. Scaffolding and metal stick out at odd angles, and tarps flap in the wind. Below, people wait to move in. One man, with a family of 5, has been waiting for more than three years for an apartment. Construction on the building stalled two years ago and hasn’t started again. While slum dwellers do not 7 T H e own the land on which they live, many own their houses and others pay rent. A 6-foot by 6-foot room can rent for as much as `1,500 (US$33) a month. Most of them are reluctant to leave their homes. Another development, located in the far-east suburbs, was developed as an improvement from slum life, but fell short. Slum dwellers who qualified were entered into a lottery. Winners got a 225-square-foot apartment in the Lallubhai compound, which was completed in 2003. But the complex has been plagued with problems since construction finished. Trash collection is all but non-existent, and two wells serve the 11,000 residents. Because there are no elevators, residents have to carry water up to the apartments. Many of the wells are poorly constructed, and illegal wells are cropping up between buildings. This opens the community up to water-borne diseases. Fuerte Apache Barrio Ejército de los Andes, more commonly known as Fuerte Apache, in Buenos Aires grew from Argentinean dictatorJuan Carlos Onganía’s plan to eliminate illegal settlements, called “emergency villages.”The project, started in 1966, was constructed in phases with one of them leading up to the 1978 World Cup. The settlement was envisioned as a well-protected depository for r O O F cOVer STOry the poor in advance of the World Cup. Many of the residents were pulled from the Villa 31 slum in Retiro, an upper-class residential area. As of the 2001 census, 35,000 people lived in almost 5,000 residences. The number of actual residents is most likely much higher. Some estimate up to 100,000 live in the 26-acre neighborhood. The complex includes 33 towers,linked byhallways in three different groups, and 52 smaller freestanding buildings. This separation has alienated residents of different buildings, and conflicts have erupted because of the lack of communication. The area quickly earned a bad reputation for violence, drugs and crumbling buildings. Better Than Before The failures in Chicago, Mumbai and Buenos Aires can be directly attributed to oversight on behalf of development authorities and their partners. By not accounting for the fundamental building blocks of infrastructure and safety, these housing solutions were doomed from the outset. Now, in today’s world, when exploding populations make the urban housing an ever-more pressing issue, studying failed solutions can ensure that the same mistakes aren’t made time after time bp www.beyondprofit.com R A I S E homes T H E FACE-TO - FACE R O O F Aden Van Noppen, on behalf of micro Home Solutions, spoke to Beyond Profit about an innovative home improvement product in India. By Nisha Kumar Kulkarni Tell us about your organization. What are the "innovative financial terms" you refer to on your website? AVN: micro Home Solutions (mHS) is a for-profit social enterprise that creates solutions for the 40 million people without access to adequate housing in India. mHS was founded in 2009 by Rakhi Mehra and Marco Ferrarioas an interdisciplinary social enterprise that links architectural, financial and social approaches to offer a portfolio of affordable housing options to the urban poor. AVN:For DHS,mHS successfully facilitated financial institutions to accept currently available housing possession documents for home construction and improvements loans up to `300,000 (~US$ 7,000). Over the last 6 months, we conducted the DHS pilot in partnership with BASIX, one of the largest microfinance institutions in India. What makes your business model unique? AVN: We believe our work applies throughout urban India and in other emerging markets, especially those that are rapidly urbanizing. However, we continue to see the importance of designing contextually specific solutions. We cannot ignore the different social and political, even spatial and geographical, circumstances that exist in each new location. Our primary goal is to catalyze solutions by developing viable business models and facilitating partnerships, as opposed to operating and scaling like a traditional social enterprise. For example, once we incubate and prove the DHS model, we will spin it out as an independent business with its own clear path to scale. Our future projects will evolve similarly, building concepts that both grow into viable businesses and serve as alternative examples of how India, and communities around the world, can build socially inclusive cities bp AVN: Our main pilot project, Design Home Solutions (DHS) is a home improvement product that combines customized architectural and design assistance with affordable financing for low-income families. The poor want to live in safe, strong, well-designed homes as much as anyone else. But they are forced to build unsafe structures that lead to potential accidents, greater incidence of diseases, uncomfortable layouts, and virtually no privacy. By increasing security of tenure and providing access to finance and technical expertise, DHS allows people to invest in home improvements and construct long-lasting structures, more comfortable spaces, and even additional floors that they can rent out for added income. Photo courtesy: Aden Van Noppen talk about Aden Van Noppen Aden Van Noppen (AVN) works on Strategic Planning and Partnership Management at mHS. How adaptable is your work in India to other emerging markets? ISSUE 8 | DECEMBER 31, 2010 - JANUARY 13, 2011 The poor want to live in safe, strong, well-designed homes as much as anyone else. FOR MORE INFORMATION micro Home Solutions Basix and micro Home Solutions join hands to provide affordable housing to urban poor 8 R A I S E T H E R O O F SPOTLIGHT low-cost living pakistan's Demand for low-cost housing is expected to grow Seventy percent of the plots are sold to low-income families with household monthly income of US$59 to $177. 9 Photo Courtesy : Shutterstock In Pakistan, the young and poor struggle to afford a home of their own. A successful low-cost initiative offers a solution. By Usha Ganesh With increasing rural-urban migration and the relatively young population of Pakistan, demand for low- income housing is expected to grow to alarming proportions. And yet, this demographic may find it impossible to invest in owning a home in a major urban area. Nearly 30% of Pakistan’s population lives in rented homes. As per a monthly cash flow presented in Acumen Fund’s Working Paper on Property Rights, families with an average monthly income of US$118 (`5,310) end up saving only US$12. With an average plot costing US$4946, it would take over 30 years to meet this cost. Saiban, a Pakistan-based NGO, has a successful model with its Khuda Ki Basti-4 (KKB-4) initiative, currently being implemented near Lahore. It engaged the House Building Finance Corporation (HBFC) to offer mortgage loans to the poor. One of the few developers to apply for legal permits for construction from the local Tehsil Municipal Corporation, the Saiban team had to work very hard to obtain the permits and raise capital for actual construction. Saiban has become an authority in low-cost housing both in the country and internationally. It has been able to do away with investors and to restrict absentee owners. The KKB-4 model adopts a holistic approach to community development and ensures that developers provide plots with electricity, water, sewage lines, as well as access to roads. Sai- ban also facilitates provision of social services such as healthcare, schools and mosques in the localities it develops. Saiban’s sites are typically 20 to 100 acres in size, with 25 houses per acre. Five percent of the land is set aside for commercial plots. Seventy percent of the plots are sold to low-income families with household monthly income of US$59 to $177. Thirty percent of the plots are sold to lower-middle income families with an average monthly household income of US$241. The most interesting aspect of the model is that it is incremental. The communities develop as per the needs and priorities of the residents, and the amount of capital they are able to put together. For example, "one window" booking eliminates bureaucracy, and reduces time, confusion and corruption. The KKB-4 is just one model of a successful low-cost housing initiative. These initiatives must mitigate two of the most pressing concerns of the urban poor in the context of shelter – that of legal sanction and access to formal finance. Transparent systems are an added plus. Saiban’s incremental model not only addresses these concerns, but also offers payment flexibility to the poor, thereby making the model sustainable. Finally, it is able to do all this even as it engenders a sense of ownership in the residents bp FOR MORE INFORMATION Scaling affordable housing for low-income communities in Pakistan. www.beyondprofit.com R A I S E T H E R O O F DATA numbers the state of slums by the In the last decade, 22 million people have moved out of slums annually. Although progress has been made, a report by UN Habitat presents the numbers behind the growing slum problem. By Nisha Kumar Kulkarni 50.6% 227 827.6 55 6 The percentage of the world living in urban areas. MILLION MILLION MILLION MILLION The number of people worldwide who have moved out of slums since 2000. The 2010 estimate of the number of slumdwellers worldwide. The number of new slum-dwellers worldwide since 2000. The projected annual growth rate of the slum population. Issue 8 | December 31, 2010 - January 13, 2011 10 R A I S E T H E R O O F DATA graphics data Rapid urbanization is pushing international cities beyond planned capacity and shifting housing patterns. By Nisha Kumar Kulkarni Fastest Growing Cities in Africa, Asia and Latin America Urban sprawl is not just a problem in developed countries. Cities in developing countries are growing at a significant annual rate, raising serious questions about how these cities will manage greater populations with limited budgets and inadequate infrastructure. 20.8% Santa cruz, Bolivia 13.3% Puente Alto, chile 13.1% Dire Dawa, Ethiopia Data Source: UN Habitat 7.8% Dongguan, china 7.5% Nakuru, Kenya 5.7% Shenzhen, china 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% Housing Tenure Type by Country Income Groups Country Income Group High Income Unauthorized housing is the assumption of privately owned land for agricultural purposes, while squatter housing is the unauthorized occupation of an abandoned or unoccupied space. Owner occupancy is the majority housing tenure type in all country groups except for low-income, where unauthorized housing makes up almost twothirds of housing types. Upper middle income Lower middle income Data Source: Housing Policy in Developing Countries: The Importance of the Informal Sector Low income Squatter housing % 11 Unauthorized housing % Owner occupancy % www.beyondprofit.com R A I S E T H E R O O F TOP 5 affordable housing in india Photo Courtesy : Flickr user orange tuesday 2 3 Shubh Griha, Tata Housing Janadhaar Shubha, Janadhaar Constructions Tanaji Mulusare City (TMC), located in the suburb of Karjat in Mumbai, provides 15,000 affordable apartments over a 100 acre plot. The units range from 156 ft²to 397 ft², and are approximately priced between US$4,500 to US$16,500. TMC has earmarked space for amenities like schools and hospitals, and has social infrastructure like a fire brigade and police station. It is one of the largest affordable housing developments in India today. Shubh Griha is Tata Housing’s flagship plan to bring affordable housing to the bottom of the pyramid (BoP). With two developments in the Mumbai suburbs, it is a great example of well-planned affordable housing. It offers 70% open spaces, eco-friendly design, playground, gym and jogging track. The units range from 283ft²to 489 ft², and are priced between US$8,500 to US$15,000. Janaadhar Shubha is being developed on an 11.5 acre plot in the outskirts of Bengaluru city. The township consist of 1140 apartments that range from 400ft²to 615 ft², with one-bedroom houses priced under US$11,500. The facilities provided include a primary school and play area. Janaadhar discourages affluent buyers according to promoter Ramesh Ramanathan. 4 Navjivan consists of 400 affordable homes being built in Vatva, Ahmedabad, which range from studio to twobedroom apartments, starting at US$6,200. The project is located in an existing residential area with access to schools, markets, basic healthcare facilities and bus transport. It is also one of the few affordable housing projects to incorporate sustainability elements in its design. Navjivan, Atmiya Developers Pvt Ltd ISSUE 8 | DECEMBER 31, 2010 - JANUARY 13, 2011 Photo Courtesy : Flickr user Ahron de Leeuw Tanaji Malusare City, Matheran Realty 5 Ashray Homes, Value Realtors Pvt Ltd Ashray is an affordable housing project spread over 8.5 acres in Lodhana, Rewari, Haryana. It offers a choice between 280 ft² and 450 ft² standalone homes approximately priced at US$6,400 and US$10,900, respectively. A unique aspect of this project is that home owners have the option of adding an extra floor to their home in the future. The project will have 600 homes with facilities like water harvesting, a school, hospital, park as well as a daily needs store. 12 Photo Courtesy : Flickr user utpal 1 Photo Courtesy : Flickr user Carol Mitchell Photo Courtesy : Flickr user Ahron de Leeuw These five affordable housing projects are giving low-income households the chance to live in 200-700 ft² apartments at an average monthly payment of US$90. By Dipika Prasad R A I S E post T H E R O O F CASE STUDY commonwealth housing How could the Commonwealth Games affect housing in New Delhi? By Abby Callard Street workers in New Delhi before the games. Nearly 300,000 slum residents have lost their homeseither by eviction or demolition. FOR MORE INFORMATION Urbanization in India Centre on housing rights & evictions 13 Earlier this year, New Delhi, which overtook Mumbai as India’s largest city this year hosted the 2010 Commonwealth Games. While many are hopeful about the economic effects of the games, other issues could arise. One of those includes housing. The Games Organizing Committee estimated that the overall impact on India’s GDP will be US$4.94bn spread over the years 2008-2012. (For comparison, the 2002 Manchester Games created US $3.4bn and the 2006 Melbourne Games US $1.6bn) Job creation for the same period is estimated at 2.47 million people. Although reliable data is not yet available, history shows that the cost of living increases dramatically after such large-scale events. When Barcelona hosted the Olympics in 1992, the price of renting increased 145% and the price of buying increased 139%. In the period leading up to the Olympics, 59,000 residents actually left Barcelona.In preparation for the 2010 Olympic Games in Vancouver, landlords evicted residents to renovate their properties and put them back on the market at a much higher price. For the poorest of the poor in New Delhi, who are barely making a living, even a slight increase in the cost of living could be disastrous. As it is, nearly 300,000 slum residents have lost their homes—either by eviction or demolition—and only about one third of those have been resettled. Only those residents who could prove they had lived in the same slum for at least eight years were offered resettlement. The World Health Organization reported that the Games will actually increase homelessness in the city because construction projects for the event brought in migrant laborers who, now that the Games are over, are rendered jobless. Will these migrants be forgotten now that the spotlight has moved on? New Delhi residents are already feeling the pinch from the cashstrapped government. The 2010-2011 city budget instituted several direct and non-direct taxes—residents will pay more for diesel, cooking gas, CNG and mobile phones. An increase in the cost of living is an unfortunate legacy of large-scale sporting events. Housing will most certainly be affected by the increase in cost of living and the increase in homeless populations. The question now is how much and how quickly bp www.beyondprofit.com R A I S E the urban T H E R O O F REVIEW housing challenge Photo Courtesy: Flickr user mrkhillary A recent working paper by the World Bank points out the inefficiencies in India’s housing policies and suggests improvements. By Payal Agarwal Housing Challenges in Asia’s largest slums: Dharavi At the present pace, it would take 23 years to house Mumbai’s current slum population with no provisions for new slum dwellers. India’s slum-dwelling population has risen from 27.9m in 1981 to 61.8m in 2001, and now exceeds the entire population of Britain. By 2030, 70% of Indian jobs will be in cities and it is projected that 590m Indians will live in them. A paper entitled Working with the Market: A New Approach to Reducing Urban Slums in India examines the cause of soaring land prices and slum populations, and suggests corrective measures. To prove that faulty government policies and not migration has led to precarious living conditions for the urban poor, it cites the example of Vietnam’s cities that are growing at twice the rate of India’s and have lower incidence of slums. Universal housing is dismissed because it would impose an unsustainable fiscal burden on the government. It is also highlighted that the current policy of mandating private builders to provide low-cost housing will have limited impact. At the present pace, it would take 23 years to house Mumbai’s current slum population with no provisions for new slum dwellers. The paper also illustrates the importance of designing policies based on each city’s unique real estate market conditions. In Mumbai, no dwelling, formal or informal, can be purchased for less than US$6,700. At prices comparable to those for slum dwellings, larger formal apartments can be purchased in the suburbs. In Ahmedabad though, there is practically no overlap in the price of informal and formal housing. Policy reform is a must. The elements of affordable housing for India should focus on city-specific development of infrastructure to increase effective land supply, intensive use of urban land and, in the initial phases, allow for basic housing for the poor bp FOR MORE INFORMATION UN habitat South Asia Analysis ISSUE 8 | DECEMBER 31, 2010 - JANUARY 13, 2011 14 Watch for the fourth edition of Inverting the Pyramid. Coming soon. Highlights of the Fourth Edition: • Overview of trends and activities in the year 2010 • AP Ordinance • MFI Performance Highlights • Investor sentiment • Expectations for the future • Customer centricity- bringing the client back into focus • Investor interest • Recognition for good regulation • Role of technology as an enabler for greater transparency and flexibility Intellecap is a consulting firm that enables innovation, capacity building and investment initiatives in the development sector. Working in direct design and execution as well as indirect strategic advisory roles, Intellecap accelerates the growth of upcoming Microfinance Institutions (MFIs) and micro and small enterprises by coordinating markets, people and capital, nationally and internationally. For more information contact us at [email protected] Catalyzing Impact Investment into Sustainable and Scalable Enterprises Globally Social Enterprise Awards and Investment Forum May 5 - 6, 2011 | Mumbai, India For partnerships & further details, contact Rashmi Pillai: [email protected] or Praveen Nair: [email protected]
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz