Western Washington University
Western CEDAR
History
Humanities
6-2011
Who are "The People"? Locating Popular Authority
in Postrevolutionary America. A Review of:
Constituent Moments: Enacting the People in
Postrevolutionary America
Johann N. Neem
Western Washington University, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: http://cedar.wwu.edu/history_facpubs
Part of the History Commons
Recommended Citation
Neem, Johann N., "Who are "The People"? Locating Popular Authority in Postrevolutionary America. A Review of: Constituent
Moments: Enacting the People in Postrevolutionary America" (2011). History. 19.
http://cedar.wwu.edu/history_facpubs/19
This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Humanities at Western CEDAR. It has been accepted for inclusion in History by an
authorized administrator of Western CEDAR. For more information, please contact [email protected].
!"#$%&'$()"'$*'#*+',-$
+#.%)/01$*#*2+%&$%2)"#&/)3$/0$$
*#4)&'5#+2)/#0%&3$%6'&/.%
789:;;$0<$0==>
7:?8;$ @A:;B<! !"#$%&%'(#%) *"+(#%$,) -#./%&#0) %1() 2("34() &#) 2"$%5(6"4'%&"#.57)
8+(5&/."!#$%&'()!*"+"!,!#$-.!/012.%3145!6%.33)!7898"!:11!;!<=>!??"!@AA$34%'B
41C03)!0C4.3)!D1DA1CE%'?&5)!'0F!10F.:"!GHI"IJ!KLAC4&MN!G7="IJ!K?'?.%M"
O&.!L&'AA.0E.!CP!F.Q010E!R4&.!?.C?A.)S!?CA141L'A!4&.C%134!T'3C0!U%'0-!V%14.3)!
R&'$043!'AA!4&.C%1.3!CP!F.(CL%'L5!'0F!LC0410$'AA5!2121Q.3!F.(CL%'41L!?%'L41L."S!
O&.!?&%'3.!R4&.!?.C?A.S!&'$043!D.L'$3.)!A1-.!'!3?.L4.%)!14!LA'1(3!4C!3?.'-!PC%!
3C(.4&10E!4&'4!0.2.%!V'3!'0F!13!'AV'53!10!PC%('41C0"!W.4!14!R2121Q.3S!F.(CB
L%'41L!4&.C%5!D.L'$3.!4&.!X(.%1L'0!?CA141L'A!4%'F141C0Y3!A.E141('L5!F.%12.3!P%C(!
?C?$A'%!3C2.%.1E045)!'0F!4&$3!C$431F.%!E%C$?3!L'0!$3.!4&.!1F.'!CP!4&.!?.C?A.!
4C!LA'1(!'!%CA.!PC%!4&.(3.A2.3!V14&10!C$%!F.(CL%'L5"
Z$4!V&C!'%.!4&.!?.C?A.[!UC%!3C(.!LC03414$41C0'A!3L&CA'%3)!10LA$F10E!?CA141L'A!
3L1.041343!'0F!4&.C%1343)!4&.!?.C?A.!'%.!4&.!LC03414$.04!3C2.%.1E0!V&C)!10!LC02.0B
41C03)!F.31E0!4&.1%!EC2.%0(.04"!U%C(!4&13!?.%3?.L412.)!4&.!(C34!1(?C%4'04!C$4B
LC(.!CP!4&.!X(.%1L'0!\.2CA$41C0!V'3!4&.!LC02.041C0!'3!'!(.L&'013(!4C!.0'L4!
4&.!3CL1'A!LC04%'L4"!Z$4!('05!&'2.!L&'AA.0E.F!4&13!LC0LA$31C0"!X3!6%CE%.3312.!
&134C%1'03!'0F!4&.1%!&.1%3!%.(10F!$3)!4&.!+C03414$41C0!V'3!143.AP!LC04.34.F)!F1F!
0C4!P$AA5!.(DCF5!?C?$A'%!V1AA)!'0F!V'3!'0!.A14.!D'L-A'3&!'E'1034!(C%.!?C?$A'%!
F.(CL%'L5"!O&.3.!4VC!?.%3?.L412.3!L%.'4.F!'!4&.C%.41L'A!'0F!?%'L41L'A!?%CDA.(!
4&'4!?A'5.F!C$4!10!4&.!?C34%.2CA$41C0'%5!F.L'F.3"!@P!4&.!34'4.!'$4&C%1].F!D5!
R4&.!?.C?A.S!L'00C4!3?.'-!PC%!4&.!?.C?A.)!&CV!L'0!.A.L4.F!A.'F.%3!%.?%.3.04!
4&.!?$DA1L!V1AA[!XA4.%0'412.A5)!1P!C4&.%3!10!L121A!3CL1.45!&'2.!'!34%C0E.%!LA'1(!
4C!%.?%.3.04!4&.!?.C?A.)!&CV!L'0!%.?%.3.04'412.!EC2.%0(.04!D.!A.E141('4.[
^12.0! 4&13! LC0$0F%$()! 14! 13! 0C! VC0F.%! 4&'4! #'01.A! \CFE.%3! 10! !"#%($%(9)
:5'%1$! K9IH_M! LC031F.%3! R4&.! ?.C?A.S! C0.! CP!X(.%1L'Y3! RLC04.34.F! 4%$4&3)S! '!
?&%'3.!4&'4!L'0!D.!$3.F!D5!4&C3.!10!?CV.%!'0F!D5!C$431F.%!E%C$?3`'3!10!?C?$B
A134!$?%1310E3`V&C!LA'1(!4C!%.?%.3.04!D.44.%!4&.!?.C?A.!4&'0!.A.L4.F!A.'F.%3!
FC"!@4!13!104C!4&.3.!LC0P$310E!V'4.%3!4&'4!U%'0-!V'F.3"!a.!&C?.3!4C!LC04%1D$4.!
4C!F.(CL%'41L!4&.C%5!D5!.:?AC%10E!&CV!?C34%.2CA$41C0'%5!X(.%1L'03!34%$EEA.F!
V14&!4&13!P$0F'(.04'A!?%CDA.()!V&1L&!13)!$A41('4.A5)!C0.!CP!4&.!%.A'41C03&1?!
D.4V..0!%.?%.3.04'412.!EC2.%0(.04!'0F!L121A!3CL1.45"!U%'0-Y3!'03V.%!F%'V3!
;(6&(<$)&#)8+(5&/.#)=&$%"57!<I!K7899M!7>_b7_<!c!7899!D5!O&.!TC&03!aC?-103!/012.%3145!6%.33
DGH
&'5/'!4$/0$%6'&/.%0$"/4)#&3$$C$$720'$DEFF
C0! T'Ld$.3! #.%%1F'Y3! P'(C$3! .33'5! C0! 4&.! #.LA'%'41C0! CP! @0F.?.0F.0L."! OC!
#.%%1F')!4&.!#.LA'%'41C0!31($A4'0.C$3A5!L%.'4.F!R4&.!?.C?A.S!'0F!3?C-.!10!4&.!
0'(.!CP!'!?%..:13410E!?.C?A."9!O&.!#.LA'%'41C0!4&$3!.0'L4.F!V&'4!14!LA'1(.F!
'A%.'F5!V'3"!U%'0-!D.A1.2.3!4&.!3'(.!R?'%'FC:S!13!4%$.!CP!'AA!%.?%.3.04'412.!
EC2.%0(.04!K?"!<9M"!XAA!LA'1(3!('F.!C0!D.&'AP!CP!4&.!?.C?A.!102C-.!4&.!2.%5!
4&10E!4&'4!4&.5)!10!4&.1%!LA'1(3)!L%.'4."!
+.04%'A!4C!U%'0-Y3!4&.313!13!&13!1F.'!CP!'!F.(CL%'41L!RLC03414$412.!3$%?A$3S!
K?"! <M"! O&.! R3$%?A$3S! F.%12.3! P%C(! 4&.! P'L4! 4&'4! 'AA! LA'1(3! 4C! %.?%.3.04! 4&.!
?.C?A.!'%.!?'%41'A)!A.'210E!3?'L.!PC%!C4&.%3!4C!E.0.%'4.!LA'1(3!PC%!10LA$31C0"!
O&.3.!LA'1(3!&'??.0!10!RLC03414$.04!(C(.043S!V&.0!C$431F.%3!'33.%4!'!%1E&4!
4C! 3?.'-! PC%! '! ?.C?A.! 4&'4! 4&.5! '%.! 31($A4'0.C$3A5! 102C-10E! '0F! L%.'410E!
'0.V!.'L&!41(."!U%'0-!(C2.3!D.5C0F!Z%$L.!XL-.%('0Y3!'%E$(.04!10!>()%1()
2("34(!K9II9M!4&'4!L.%4'10!?12C4'A!.A.L41C03!'%.!A1-.!LC03414$41C0'A!LC02.041C03!
10!V&1L&!2C4.%3!'LL.?4!0.V!E%C$0F!%$A.3!4C!10LA$F.!4&.!?C?$A134!.:?%.331C03!
CP! E%'33%CC43! 'L412145! 10! L121A! 3CL1.45)! 0'(.A5! ?C34%.2CA$41C0'%5! L%CVF3! '0F!
4&.!.(.%E.0L.!CP!F.(CL%'41L!3CL1.41.3!10!4&.!9_I83"!
^12.0!4&'4!'AA!LA'1(3!('F.!PC%!4&.!?.C?A.!'%.!'33.%41C03)!3C(.!&134C%1'03!
&'2.! D..0! LC0210L.F! 4&'4! %.?$DA1L'0! EC2.%0(.04! 13! 0C4! 4&'4! F1PP.%.04! P%C(!
C4&.%!PC%(3!CP!EC2.%0(.04"!OC!eF($0F!fC%E'0!10!?#6(#%&#0)%1()2("34(!K9IHIM)!
?C?$A'%!3C2.%.1E045!13!'!RQL41C0S!4&'4!&134C%1L'AA5!&'3!.0'DA.F!0C4!4&.!('05!
4C!L&'AA.0E.!4&.!P.V!D$4)!1034.'F)!4&.!P.V!4C!EC2.%0!4&.!('05"!R^C2.%0(.04!
%.d$1%.3!('-.BD.A1.2.)S!fC%E'0!'%E$.3"!g0L.!V.!D.A1.2.F!4&'4!4&.!h10E!V'3!
F1210.N!0CV!V.!R('-.!D.A1.2.!4&'4!4&.!?.C?A.!1.6(!'!2C1L.!C%!('-.!D.A1.2.!
4&'4! 4&.! %.?%.3.04'412.3! CP! 4&.! ?.C?A.! .5(! 4&.! ?.C?A."S! X041L1?'410E! U%'0-)!
fC%E'0!LC0LA$F.3!4&'4!4&.!QL41C0!%.('103!$3.P$A!'0F!?C4.041'AA5!%.F.(?412.!
1P!4&.!?.C?A.!$3.!14!4C!F.('0F!'!D.44.%!'A1E0(.04!D.4V..0!4&.!%.'A141.3!CP!4&.1%!
%$A.!'0F!?C?$A'%!3C2.%.1E045Y3!'3?1%'41C03"7
f'05! 3L&CA'%3! 'E%..! V14&! fC%E'0! 4&'4! ?C34%.2CA$41C0'%5! %.?%.3.04'412.!
EC2.%0(.043! V.%.! %.'AA5! DCF1.3! CP! .A14.! %$A."! i$L&! 3L&CA'%3! 4'-.! '3! (C%.!
'$4&.041L!4&.!?%CLA'('41C03!('F.!D5!C%F10'%5!?.C?A.!10!L121A!3CL1.45"!O&13!13!
?C?$A13(Y3!.33.0L.)!'3!\C0'AF!UC%(13'0C!('-.3!LA.'%!10!&13!%.L.04!34$F5!CP!
.'%A5!0'41C0'A!?CA141L'A!(C2.(.043)!@"5)%1()2("34(!K788HM"!j'%%5!h%'(.%Y3!:1()
2("34() :1(+$(46($) K788=M! '0F! i'$A! +C%0.AAY3! :1() A%1(5) @"'#9(5$! K9IIIM! $%E.!
3L&CA'%3! 4C! 4'-.! '3! 3.%1C$3A5! F133.04.%3Y! ?C?$A'%! LC03414$41C0'A13(! '3! V.! FC!
CPQL1'A!LC03414$41C03!'0F!.A.L4.F!%.?%.3.04'412.3"!+&%1341'0!U%14]!10!8+(5&/.#)
B"6(5(&0#$! K788HM! LC0LA$F.3! 4&'4! D.4V..0! 4&.1%! \.2CA$41C0! '0F! +121A! k'%)!
X(.%1L'03!D.A1.2.F!0C4!C0A5!10!4&.!.:134.0L.!CP!4&.!RLCAA.L412.!3C2.%.1E0S!D$4!
4&'4!14!LC$AF!'0F!VC$AF!'L4!10F.?.0F.04!CP!.A.L4.F!A.'F.%3)!'3!14!F1F!F$%10E!
4&.! i&'53! '0F! #C%%! %.D.AA1C03"! i.'0! k1A.04]Y3! !1.#%$) C(+"/5.%&/! K9IH=M! '0F!
f1L&'.A!h']10Y3!:1()2"3'4&$%)2(5$'.$&"#!K9IIJM)!10l$.0L.F!D5!e"!6"!O&C(?3C0)!
4%'L.! &CV! 1F.'3! CP! %.?$DA1L'013(! '0F! ?C?$A13(! V.%.! $3.F! D5! VC%-.%3! 4C!
LC0l'4.!4&.(3.A2.3!V14&!R4&.!?.C?A.S!10!4&.1%!LC0l1L43!'E'1034!.A14.!L'?14'A1343!
0''6$C$!98$%A=$()9=$*=8JK=-,
DGI
'0F!?CA141L1'03"!T'(.3!fC%C0.!LC031F.%3!.PPC%43!D5!X(.%1L'03!4C!'A1E0!(C%.!
LAC3.A5!4&.1%!EC2.%010E!103414$41C03!V14&!?C?$A'%!V1AA!10!:1()C(+"/5.%&/)>&$1!
K9II8M"!XAA!4&.3.!3L&CA'%3!'%.!$014.F!10!'0!.PPC%4!4C!Q0F!10!?C?$A'%!'0F!?C?$A134!
?CA141L'A!(C2.(.043!.:?%.331C03!CP!R4&.!?.C?A.S!L&'AA.0E10E!.A14.!LC04%CA!10!
4&.!0'(.!CP!F.(CL%'L5"!
U%'0-!D.A1.2.3!4&'4!V.!($34!'D'0FC0!4&.!3.'%L&!PC%!4&.!'$4&.041L)!'L4$'A!
?C?$A'%! 2C1L."! @034.'F)! U%'0-! $%E.3! %.'F.%3! 4C! .(D%'L.! 4&.! P$0F'(.04'A!
?'%'FC:!CP!F.(CL%'41L!4&.C%5,!'??.'A3!4C!4&.!?.C?A.!'AV'53!%.A5!C0!4&.!LC0B
3414$412.!3$%?A$3!'0F!L%.'412.A5!%.VC%-!4&.!2.%5!L'4.EC%5!C0!V&1L&!4&.5!%.A5!
PC%!4&.1%!'$4&C%145"
U%'0-!F.2.AC?3!&13!'%E$(.04!D5!.:'(1010E!DC4&!E%'33%CC43!'L412145!'0F!.A14.!
V%14.%3"!a.!&C?.3!4C!.:?A'10!V&5!4&.!LC03414$412.!3$%?A$3!3.%2.3!F.(CL%'41L!
?$DA1L!A1P."!a13!Q%34!L&'?4.%!LA.'%3!3?'L.!PC%!&13!F13L$331C0!21'!'!L%141L'A!%.'F10E!
CP!a'00'&!X%.0F4Y3!F13410L41C0!D.4V..0!4&.!X(.%1L'0!'0F!U%.0L&!%.2CA$41C03"!
X%.0F4! '%E$.F! 4&'4!X(.%1L'03! %.P$3.F! 4C! .(D%'L.! 4&.! \C$33.'$1'0! 1F.'! CP!
'! 310EA.! E.0.%'A! V1AA)! 4&$3! ?%.3.%210E! P%..FC(! P%C(! T'LCD10! 45%'005"! U%'0-!
D%10E3!4&.!4VC!%.2CA$41C03!LAC3.%!4C!3$EE.34!4&'4!U%'0L.Y3!F1A.(('`V&.4&.%!
4&.!34'4.!13!4&.!2C1L.DC:!CP!'!%.?$DA1L'0!?.C?A.`V'3!'0!1(?C%4'04!4&.C%.41L'A!
'0F!?%'L41L'A!?%CDA.(!10!4&.!0.V!/014.F!i4'4.3"<
a13!3.LC0F!L&'?4.%!.:'(10.3!?C34%.2CA$41C0'%5!L%CVF!'L41C0"!U%'0-!'%E$.3!
4&'4! L%CVF3Y! LA'1(3! 4C! 3?.'-! PC%! 4&.! ?.C?A.! R?C3.3! '! L&'AA.0E.`4&.C%.41L'A!
'0F!&134C%1L'A`4C!4&.!a'D.%('31'0!(CF.A!CP!4&.!?$DA1L!3?&.%."S!+%CVF3)!4C!
U%'0-)!L&'AA.0E.F!a'D.%('3Y!1F.'A!CP!'!RF13.(DCF1.F!'0F!3CL1'AA5!$0('%-.F!
?$DA1L!D'3.F!C0!%'41C0'A!'%E$(.04'41C0S!K??"!>Hb>IM"!O&.!133$.!LC0L.%03!V&.0!
'0F!&CV!R4&.!?.C?A.S!3?.'-"!OC!a'D.%('3)!?$DA1L!C?101C0!C$E&4!4C!F.2.AC?!
C$4!CP!%'41C0'A!F13L$331C03!10!4&.!?$DA1L!3?&.%."!@0!%.'A145)!U%'0-!LC$04.%3)!%.'A!
?.C?A.! V14&! .(DCF1.F! LA'33! 1F.04141.3! F.('0F.F! 4&'4! 4&.1%! 2C1L.3! D.! 4'-.0!
3.%1C$3A5"!W.4!$0A1-.!3C(.!&134C%1'03!V&C!&'2.!1F.'A1].F!4&.!L%CVF!'3!4&.!4%$.!
?C?$A'%!2C1L.)!U%'0-!'%E$.3!4&'4!4&.!4.031C0!D.4V..0!a'D.%('3Y!1F.'A!'0F!4&.!
L%CVF!F.(C034%'4.3!R4&.!P'1A$%.!CP!'05!'44.(?4!4C!F.Q01412.A5!%.?%.3.04!4&.!
?.C?A."S!+%CVF3)!0C!A.33!4&'0!.A.L4.F!A.'F.%3)!L%.'412.A5!1('E10.!R4&.!?.C?A.S!
10!V&C3.!0'(.!4&.5!'L4)!F.(C034%'410E!4&.!10'F.d$'L5!CP!'AA!3$L&!LA'1(3)!D$4!
'A3C!4&.!F.(CL%'41]10E!?C4.041'A!3$L&!LA'1(3!L'0!&'2.!.2.0!1P)!$A41('4.A5)!4&.5!
'%.!R'!V'5!CP!-..?10E!4&.!?.C?A.!?%.3.04!10!4&.1%!'D3.0L.S!K?"!988M"
@0!L&'?4.%!4&%..)!U%'0-!3&1P43!&13!A.03!4C!6&1A'F.A?&1'0!#%"!Z.0m'(10!\$3&Y3!
4&.C%5!CP!L%CVF!'L412145!'0F!3CL1'A!LC04'E1C0"!i&'?.F!D5!&13!eF10D$%E&!.F$B
L'41C0)!\$3&!D.A1.2.F!4&'4!L%CVF3!V.%.!F'0E.%C$3!D.L'$3.!?C?$A'%!?'331C03!
?'33.F!4&%C$E&!('33!DCF1.3!($L&!A1-.!35(?'4&5!C%!F13.'3.!D.4V..0!4VC!10F1B
21F$'A3"!\$3&!&C?.F!4C!4%'03PC%(!X(.%1L'03!104C!R%.?$DA1L'0!('L&10.3S`&13!
P'(C$3! ?&%'3.`10! C%F.%! 4C! A1(14! 4&.! L%CVFY3! F'0E.%3"! i4%$EEA10E! 4C! L%.'4.!
'0!1F.'A1].F!?$DA1L!10!&13!1('E.)!C0.!LAC3.%!4C!a'D.%('3Y!1F.'A)!\$3&Y3!2131C0!
LC034'04A5!V'3!L&'AA.0E.F!D5!4&.!'L4$'A!L%CVF"!\$3&Y3!1F.'A!?.C?A.)!0C!(C%.!
4&'0!4&.!L%CVFY3!?.C?A.)!V.%.!1('E10.F!3?.L1.3"
DLE
&'5/'!4$/0$%6'&/.%0$"/4)#&3$$C$$720'$DEFF
O&.!4.031C0!D.4V..0!4&.3.!4VC!?.%3?.L412.3!Q0'AA5!30'??.F!F$%10E!F.D'4.3!
C2.%!4&.!F.(CL%'41L!3CL1.41.3)!'!0.4VC%-!CP!?CA141L'A!LA$D3!C%E'01].F!4C!2C1L.!
C??C3141C0! 4C! 4&.! U.F.%'A134! 6'%45Y3! A.'F.%3&1?! '0F! 4C! ?%C(C4.! 4&.! L'$3.! CP!
T.PP.%3C01'0! %.?$DA1L'013("=! OC! U.F.%'A134! A.'F.%3)! 4&.! LA$D3! 4&%.'4.0.F! %.?B
%.3.04'412.3Y!'D1A145!4C!3?.'-`4C!5(D35($(#%`4&.!?.C?A.!D5!CPP.%10E!'!LC$04.%B
?.C?A.! 10! L121A! 3CL1.45"! O&.5! V.%.! %1E&4"! g0.! f'33'L&$3.443! LA$D! 3$??C%4.%)!
V%1410E! 10! ZC34C0Y3! ?#9(3(#9(#%) !15"#&/4(! Ki.?4.(D.%! H)! 9_I=M)! F.P.0F.F! 4&.!
%1E&4!CP!R4&.!?.C?A.!4C!LC02.0.!4&.(3.A2.3!4CE.4&.%S!10!L121A!3CL1.45"!+'AA10E!
4&.(! R3?'L.3! CP! 103$%E.04! L141].03&1?)S! U%'0-! '%E$.3! 4&'4! 4&.! LA$D3! %'13.F!
?%CPC$0F!d$.341C03!'DC$4!?C?$A'%!2C1L."!aCV!LC$AF!L141].03!C%E'01].!'E'1034!
4&.1%!%.?%.3.04'412.3!V&C)!'P4.%!'AA)!3?C-.!PC%!4&.([!O&13!4&.C%.41L'A!L$ABF.B3'L!
13)!PC%!U%'0-)!'!&1E&V'5!D.L'$3.!14!F.(C034%'4.3!&CV!4&.!LA$D3!4CC-!'F2'04'E.!
CP!4&.!LC03414$412.!3$%?A$3!4C!L'%2.!C$4!'!3?'L.!PC%!C??C3141C0'A!?CA141L3"!U%'0-!
LC0LA$F.3!4&'4!3L&CA'%3!3&C$AF!4&.%.PC%.!(C2.!D.5C0F!0.CBOCLd$.21AA1'0!'LB
LC$043!CP!2CA$04'%5!'33CL1'41C03!'3!(.F1'410E!103414$41C03!4&'4!?%C(C4.!RLC0l1L4!
5($"4'%&"#S! 4C! $0F.%34'0F! 4&.1%! (C%.! 1(?C%4'04! %CA.! CP! RLC0l1L4! .5%&/'4.%&"#S!
K?"!9<9M"!Z5!LA'1(10E!4C!3?.'-!PC%!4&.!?.C?A.)!4&.!LA$D3!R.0'L4.F!'!L141].03&1?!
4&'4!V'3!3.APBL%.'4.F!'0F!3.APB'$4&C%1]10ES!K?"!9=<M"J
U%'0-! 4&.0! 3&1P43! D'L-! 4C! .A14.3! '0F! CPP.%3! .:4.0F.F! %.'F10E3! CP! +&'%A.3!
Z%CL-F.0!Z%CV0Y3!>&(4.#9E!k'A4!k&14('0Y3!?C.4%5)!'0F!U%.F.%1L-!#C$EA'33Y!
P'(C$3!UC$%4&!CP!T$A5!3?..L&"!e'L&!L&'?4.%!.:?AC%.3!&CV!.'L&!'$4&C%!0.EC41B
'4.F!4&.!LC03414$412.!3$%?A$3"!Z%CV0Y3!9_IH!>&(4.#9!LC0L.%03!&CV!F13.(DCF1.F!
2C1L.3`.L&C.3`L'$3.F!'L4C%3!4C!FC!4&10E3!4&.5!VC$AF!C4&.%V13.!%.m.L4"!OC!
Z%CV0)! 4&.3.! 2C1L.3! %.l.L4.F! 4&.! '(D1E$145! CP! ?C?$A'%! 3C2.%.1E045"! Z%CV0!
VC0F.%.F!V&.4&.%!'!3CL1.45!E%C$0F.F!C0!3$L&!'!PC$0F'41C0`.PP.L412.A5!0C!
PC$0F'41C0! '4! 'AA`LC$AF! ('104'10! C%F.%"! k&14('0! V'3! (C%.! C?41(1341L"! @0!
k&14('0)!U%'0-!Q0F3!103?1%'41C0!PC%!'!?C34B?C?$A134!F.(CL%'L5!D.L'$3.!k&14B
('0!%.LCE01].F!4&'4!4&.!?.C?A.!'%.!'!R?C.41L!LC034%$L41C0)S!'AV'53!D.LC(10E!
5.4! 0.2.%! ?%.3.04"! @4! 13! k&14('0Y3! RLC03414$412.! P$4$%145S! K?"! 9H<M`4&'4! 4&.!
?.C?A.!'%.!0.2.%!&.%.!D$4!'AV'53!?C331DA.`4&'4!U%'0-!LC031F.%3!4&.!?%1('%5!
34%.0E4&!CP!&13!CV0!F13L$%312.!'??%C'L&!4C!LC03414$.04!(C(.043"
U%'0-!4.343!&13!C?41(13(!'0F!&13!4&.C%5!C0!U%.F.%1L-!#C$EA'33"!#C$EA'33)!
U%'0-! '%E$.3)! L&'AA.0E.F! 4&C3.! V&C! VC$AF! 3?.'-! PC%! 4&.! ?.C?A.! V14&C$4!
'L-0CVA.FE10E!4&'4!.'L&!%.?%.3.04'41C0!13!'0!1(?.%P.L4!1('E."!@0!&13!P'(C$3!
RO&.!f.'010E!CP!T$A5!UC$%4&!PC%!4&.!*.E%CS!K9HJ7M)!F.A12.%.F!4C!'!(C34A5!V&14.!
\CL&.34.%!'$F1.0L.)!#C$EA'33!.:.(?A1Q.F!4&.!?C331D1A141.3!CP!4&.!LC03414$412.!
3$%?A$3"! #C$EA'33! ('F.! 4VC! (C2.3! 10! &13! 3?..L&)! 4&.! 3'(.! (C2.3! U%'0-!
4&.C%1].3"!U1%34)!#C$EA'33!'33.%4.F!4&'4!&13!?%.3.0L.!C0!34'E.!10LA$F.F!&1(!'3!
C0.!CP!4&.!?.C?A."!i.LC0F)!#C$EA'33!0C4.F!4&'4)!'3!'!PC%(.%A5!.03A'2.F!DA'L-!
('0)!&.!%.('10.F!C$431F.!4&.!CPQL1'A!LC03414$4.F!?.C?A."!O'-10E!'F2'04'E.!CP!
4&.!3?'L.!D.4V..0!4&.!4VC!LC0L.?41C03)!#C$EA'33!3C$E&4!'!?.C?A.!4&'4!&'F!5.4!
4C!D.LC(."!\'4&.%!4&'0!LC(PC%4!&13!'$F1.0L.Y3!A1D.%'A145)!#C$EA'33!R3.4!&1(3.AP!
0''6$C$!98$%A=$()9=$*=8JK=-,
DLF
'?'%4!P%C(!&13!'$F1.0L.S!K?"!79JM"!@0!FC10E!3C)!&.!.0A'%E.F!4&.!DC$0F'%1.3!CP!
4&.!?.C?A.!10!'0!'L4!CP!RF.(CL%'41L!3.APBL%.'41C0S!K?"!77<M"
U%'0-! $0LC2.%3! 4&.! F50'(1L! 4&'4! ('-.3! '(D1E$C$3! '05! LA'1(3! 4C! 3?.'-!
PC%!4&.!?.C?A."!U%'0-!13!%1E&4!4&'4!0C!103414$41C0'A!.:?%.331C0!CP!4&.!?.C?A.`
V&.4&.%! 10! 34'4.! &'AA3! C%! 10! L121A! 3CL1.45`L'0! P$AA5! %.?%.3.04! 4&.! .041%.!
?C?$A'41C0"!@4Y3!1(?C331DA."!UC%!&134C%1'03)!&CV.2.%)!'!L&'AA.0E.!%.('103N!'3!
UC%(13'0C)!U%14])!'0F!C4&.%3!F.(C034%'4.)!C%F10'%5!X(.%1L'03!4CC-!3.%1C$3A5!
4&.1%!102CL'41C0!CP!4&.!?.C?A."!+'0)!'0F!3&C$AF)!&134C%1'03!LC0410$.!4C!3.'%L&!
PC%!4&.!?.C?A.[!@3!4&.%.!'!V'5!4C!.2'A$'4.!4&.!%.A'412.!A.E141('L5!CP!2'%1C$3!
?C?$A'%!(C2.(.043Y!LA'1(3[!g0.!?C331D1A145!13!4C!%.P%'(.!4&.!133$.!P%C(!C0.!
CP!%.?%.3.04'41C0!4C!C0.!CP!LC03.04)!'3!TC&0!j"!Z%CC-.!FC.3!10!&13!%.L.04!VC%-!
C0!L121A!3CL1.45!'0F!4&.!?$DA1L!3?&.%.">!@0!FC10E!3C)!V.!L'0!'A3C!(C2.!D.5C0F!
4&.C%.41L'A!d$.341C03!'DC$4!R4&.!?.C?A.S!4C!&CV!'!F12.%3.!3CL1.45!4%'03A'4.F!
4&.!VC%F3!'0F!'L41C03!CP!(5%1'F!10F121F$'A3!'0F!E%C$?3!104C!?CA141L'A!?CV.%!
'0F!?$DA1L!?CA1L5"
Z%CC-.! 102C-.3! a'D.%('3! 10! &13! P%'(.VC%-"! U%'0-! %.m.L43! a'D.%('3!
D.L'$3.! a'D.%('3! LA'1(3! 4&'4! A.E141('4.! ?$DA1L! C?101C0! ($34! .(.%E.! P%C(!
F13.(DCF1.F!%'41C0'A!?$DA1L!F.A1D.%'41C0"!Z%CC-.)!&CV.2.%)!13!(C%.!104.%.34.F!
10! 4&.! 3CL1CACE1L'A! LC034%$L4! 4&'0! 4&.! 1F.'A"! a'D.%('3)! Z%CC-.! 0C4.3)! %.LCEB
01].3!4&.!1(?.%P.L41C03!CP!&13!4&.C%5!10!?%'L41L.)!'0F!.2.0!?C1043!4C!V'53!10!
V&1L&!0C01F.'A!10l$.0L.3!3&'?.!K1AA.E141('4.A5)!P%C(!a'D.%('3Y!?.%3?.L412.M!
?$DA1L!F.A1D.%'41C0"!Z%CC-.!%.m.L43!4&.!1F.'A3!'0F!'LL.?43!4&.!?C104"!#1PP.%.04!
3CL1'A!E%C$?3!V14&!F1PP.%.04!1F.04141.3!'0F!A.2.A3!CP!'LL.33!4C!PC%('A!?CA141L'A!
103414$41C03! 10l$.0L.F! ?CA1L5! PC%('41C0! 10! F1PP.%.04! V'53"! O&.! (C%.! 1F.'A!
a'D.%('31'0!F.A1D.%'41C0!(1E&4!4'-.!?A'L.!'(C0E!A.E'A!.d$'A3`3'5!.0P%'0B
L&13.F! 2C4.%3! C%! (.(D.%3! CP! +C0E%.33`D$4! ($L&! &'??.03! 10! V&'4! Z%CC-.!
L'AA3! 4&.! %.'A(! CP! R?.%3$'31C0)S! V&.%.! L$A4$%.)! E%'33%CC43! (CD1A1]'41C0)! 4&.!
34'4.Y3! &.E.(C01L! ?CV.%)! '0F! C4&.%! PC%(3! CP! LCAA.L412.! 'L41C0! 3&'?.F! 4&.!
&.'%43)!(10F3)!'0F!(C412.3!CP!4&C3.!V14&!A.E'A!'LL.33!4C!PC%('A!?CA141L'A!?CV.%"!
Z.5C0F!?.%3$'31C0!A1.3!PC%L.)!'0F!E%'33%CC43!%.D.A3!'0F!.03A'2.F!?.C?A.!$3.F!
4&.!4&%.'4!CP!21CA.0L.!4C!10l$.0L.!?CA141L'A!'L41C0"!OC!Z%CC-.!V&'4!('44.%3!13!
&CV!4&.3.!F12.%3.!PC%L.3)!?%.33$%.3)!'0F!E%C$?3!'PP.L4.F!?$DA1L!?CA1L5!D5!10l$B
.0L10E!4&C3.!V14&!'LL.33!4C!4&.!F.A1D.%'412.!?$DA1L!3?&.%."!k&1A.!'AA!LA'1(3!4C!
?C?$A'%!2C1L.!('5!D.!?'%41'A!'0F!L%.'412.)!Z%CC-.Y3!P%'(.VC%-!3$EE.343!4&'4!
&134C%1'03!341AA!L'0!'0F!($34!'0'A5].!4&.!%.A'41C03&1?!D.4V..0!4&.!LC03.04!CP!
4&.!(.(D.%3!A1210E!10!'!E12.0!4.%%14C%5!'0F!PC%('A!?CA141L'A!C$4LC(.3"
X3! 1(?C%4'04)! U%'0-! 1E0C%.3! 4&.! 1(?C%4'0L.! CP! LCAA.L412.! 1F.04145)! C%! 0'B
41C0'A13("!f$L&!%.L.04!&134C%1L'A!VC%-!&'3!PCL$3.F!C0!X(.%1L'0!0'41C0'A13(Y3!
F.2.AC?(.04!10!4&.!?C34%.2CA$41C0'%5!.%')!.:'(1010E!10!?'%41L$A'%!&CV!10341B
4$41C03!P%C(!4&.!34'4.!4C!?CA141L'A!?'%41.3!'0F!L&$%L&.3!LC00.L4.F!10F121F$'A3!
4C!'!A'%E.%!1('E10.F!LC(($0145"!O&13!VC%-!&'3!4'$E&4!$3!&CV!'0F!V&5!3C!
DLD
&'5/'!4$/0$%6'&/.%0$"/4)#&3$$C$$720'$DEFF
('05! ?.C?A.! A1210E! 10! 4&.! 4.%%14C%5! EC2.%0.F! D5! 4&.! /014.F! i4'4.3! L'(.! 4C!
3..!4&.(3.A2.3!'3!X(.%1L'0"!UC%!4&.3.!?.C?A.)!'??.'A3!4C!R4&.!?.C?A.S!V.%.!
('F.!C0!D.&'AP!CP!'!DC$0F.F!E%C$?!4C!V&1L&!4&.5!P.A4!.(C41C0'AA5!'44'L&.F"!
k&.0!U%.F.%1L-!#C$EA'33!102C-.F!4&.!L%.'412.!?CV.%!CP!4&.!LC03414$412.!3$%B
?A$3)!&.!F1F!3C!4C!'0!'$F1.0L.!CP!X(.%1L'03!V&C!3'V!4&.!UC$%4&!CP!T$A5!'3!
'!3'L%.F!(C(.04!10!4&.1%!LCAA.L412.!&134C%5"!k&'4!('F.!#C$EA'33Y!'0F!C4&.%!
?C?$A'%)!'0F!?C?$A134)!LA'1(3!?CA141L'AA5!.PQL'L1C$3!13!4&'4!4&.3.!LA'1(3!V.%.!
&.'%F!D5!C4&.%3!V&C!3&'%.F!4&.!3'(.!1F.04145"!X3!3CL1CACE134!+%'1E!+'A&C$0!
&'3! V%144.0! 10! F.%&"#$) *.%%(5E! F.(CL%'41L! ?CA141L3! R%.d$1%.3! 4&10-10E! CP! n4&.!
?.C?A.Y!'3!'L412.!'0F!LC&.%.04!'0F!C0.3.AP!'3!DC4&!'!(.(D.%!'0F!'0!'E.04"S_
*'41C0'A13()! 4&.0)! 13! 214'A! 4C! $0F.%34'0F10E! 4&.! &134C%5! CP! R4&.! ?.C?A."S!
U%'0-! VC$AF! Q0F! 4&13! ?C104! F13LC(PC%410E"! @0! &13! LC0LA$31C0)! &.! %.m.L43! 'AA!
.PPC%43!4C!&C$3.!F.(CL%'L5!10!4%'F141C0"!OC!U%'0-)!LC03414$.04!(C(.043!($34!
ACC-!PC%V'%F!%'4&.%!4&'0!D'L-V'%F)!4C!'!?.C?A.!0.2.%!P$AA5!'L&1.2.F!%'4&.%!
4&'0! 4C! PC$0F10E! (C(.043! 4&'4! VC%-! 4&.(3.A2.3! C$4! 4&%C$E&! &134C%5"! O&.!
0'%%'412.3! CP! LC03414$.04! (C(.043`V&.4&.%! .:?%.33.F! 10! 34%..4! ?CA141L3! C%!
.A14.!V%1410E3`R4%'03(14!'!?%C3?.L412.!%'4&.%!4&'0!'!%.4%C3?.L412.!C%1.04'41C0!
4C! 41(.)! '0! C%1.04'41C0! .0A12.0.F! D5! '! 3.031412145! 4C! 4&.! $0'041L1?'4.F! '0F!
.(.%E.04S! K?"! 7=IM"! O&.! &134C%5! CP! X(.%1L'0! ?C?$A'%! (C2.(.043! 3$EE.343!
C4&.%V13."!@034.'F)!V&'4!('-.3!'??.'A3!4C!4&.!?.C?A.!?CA141L'AA5!21'DA.!'0F)!
'4!41(.3)!4%'03PC%('412.!13!?%.L13.A5!4&'4!3$L&!'??.'A3!DC4&!ACC-!PC%V'%F!4C!'!
F1PP.%.04!P$4$%.!'0F!%.A5!C0!4&.!?'34)!C0!'!&134C%1L'AA5!LC03414$4.F!?.C?A.!V&C!
$0F.%34'0F!4&.(3.A2.3!'3!?'%4!CP!'!3&'%.F!?%Cm.L4"!O&.!LC03414$412.!3$%?A$3!
PCL$3.3!C0!V&C!13!3?.'-10E)!D$4!?.%&'?3!(C%.!1(?C%4'04!13!V&C!13!A134.010E"!@P!
?C?$A'%!'??.'A3!'%.!('F.!4C!C4&.%3!V&C!3&'%.!(.(D.%3&1?!10!'0!1F.041Q'DA.!
1('E10.F!LC(($0145)!4&.0!?.%&'?3!4&C3.!'??.'A3!V1AA!%.3C0'4.!10!V'53!4&'4!
('-.!F.(CL%'41L!?CA141L3!?C331DA."
TC&'00!*"!*..(!13!'33CL1'4.!?%CP.33C%!CP!&134C%5!'4!k.34.%0!k'3&10E4C0!/01B
2.%3145)!'0F!'$4&C%!CP!!5(.%&#0).)F.%&"#)"G)H"&#(5$,)C(+"/5./7).#9)!&6&4)B"/&(%7)&#)
-.547)F.%&"#.4)*.$$./1'$(%%$!K788HM!'0F!RX(.%1L'0!a134C%5!10!'!^ACD'A!XE.)S!
=&$%"57).#9):1("57!J8!K7899M)!=9b_8"
9"!T'Ld$.3!#.%%1F')!R#.LA'%'41C03!CP!@0F.?.0F.0L.)S!F(<)2"4&%&/.4)B/&(#/()8_!K9IH>M)!_b9J"
7"! eF($0F! i"! fC%E'0)! ?#6(#%&#0) %1() 2("34(,) ;&$() "G) 2"3'4.5) B"6(5(&0#%7) &#) -#04.#9) .#9)
8+(5&/.)K9IHHM)!9<)!<8>"
<"!g0!4&.!U%.0L&!F1A.((')!3..!61.%%.!\C3'02'AAC0)!:1()C(+.#9$)"G)I&J(5%7,)!&6&4)B"/&(%7)&#)
@5.#/()$&#/()%1();(6"4'%&"#)K788_M"
="! U%'0-Y3! F13L$331C0! F%'V3! &.'21A5! C0! XAD%.L&4! hC3L&01-Y3! ?'4&D%.'-10E! .33'5)! RO&.!
#.(CL%'41L! iCL1.41.3! CP! 6&1A'F.A?&1'! '0F! 4&.! j1(143! CP! 4&.!X(.%1L'0! 6$DA1L! i?&.%.)! L1%L'!
9_I<b9_IJ)S!>&44&.+).#9)*.57)K'.5%(547)>H!K7889M,!>9Jb<>"
J"! @4! 13! VC%4&! 0C410E! 4&'4! XA.:13! F.! OCLd$.21AA.)! 10! C(+"/5./7) &#) 8+(5&/.E) '%E$.F! 4&'4!
2CA$04'%5!'33CL1'41C03!3.%2.F!DC4&!%CA.3!U%'0-!'331E03!4&.("!g0!4&.!C0.!&'0F)!'33CL1'41C03!
(.F1'4.F! LC0l1L4! D5! L%.'410E! 3CL1'A! 3?'L.3! 10! V&1L&! RP..A10E3! '0F! 1F.'3! '%.! %.0.V.F)! 4&.!
0''6$C$!98$%A=$()9=$*=8JK=-,
DLM
&.'%4!.:?'0F3)!'0F!4&.!&$('0!3?1%14!F.2.AC?3!C0A5!4&%C$E&!4&.!%.L1?%CL'A!'L41C0!CP!&$('0!
D.10E3!C0!C0.!'0C4&.%"S!g0!4&.!C4&.%!&'0F)!OCLd$.21AA.!'%E$.F!4&'4!'33CL1'41C03!.0'DA.F!'!
?CA141L'A!(10C%145!R4C!D%10E!'AA!143!(C%'A!PC%L.!4C!D.'%!C0!4&.!('4.%1'A!?CV.%!4&'4!C??%.33.3!14"S!
@0!3&C%4)!OCLd$.21AA.Y3!L121A!3CL1.45!V'3!'!314.!CP!DC4&!(.F1'41C0!'0F!LC0l1L4"!i..!OCLd$.21AA.)!
C(+"/5./7)&#)8+(5&/.E)4%'03"!X%4&$%!^CAF&'((.%!K788=M)!JIH)!79Hb9I"
>"!TC&0!j"!Z%CC-.)!R+C03.04)!+121A!iCL1.45)!'0F!4&.!6$DA1L!i?&.%.!10!4&.!XE.!CP!\.2CA$41C0!
'0F! 4&.! e'%A5! X(.%1L'0! \.?$DA1L)S! 10! L(7"#9) %1() @"'#9(5$,) F(<) 8335"./1($) %") %1() 2"4&%&/.4)
=&$%"57)"G)%1()-.547)8+(5&/.#);(3'J4&/E).F"!T.PP%.5!j"!6'3A.5!.4!'A"!K788=M)!78_bJ8"
_"!+%'1E!+'A&C$0)!F.%&"#$)*.%%(5,)!'4%'5(E)=&$%"57E).#9)%1()!"$+"3"4&%.#)C5(.+)K788_M)!9=_"