Permission to Appeal results – December 2014
Case name
Abd Ali Hameed Al Waheed (Appellant) v
Ministry of Defence (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0219
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWHC 2714
IR (Morocco) (Appellant) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0226
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 966
CM (Zimbabwe) (AP) (Appellant) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0197
Neutral Citation No: [2013] EWCA Civ 1303
Mohamed and another (AP) (Respondents) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0232
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 559
The Mayor's Office for Policing and Crime
(Appellant) v
Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Co (Europe) Ltd
and others (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0165
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 682
McDonald (by her litigation friend Duncan J
McDonald) (Appellant) v
McDonald and others (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0234
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1049
R (on the application of Baradaran) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0193
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 854
Justices
Lord Neuberger
Lord Wilson
Lord Hodge
PTA
Granted
8 Dec 2014
Reasons given
Lord Neuberger
Lord Wilson
Lord Hodge
Refused
8 Dec 2014
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
point of law.
Lord Neuberger
Lord Wilson
Lord Hodge
Refused
8 Dec 2014
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time.
Lord Neuberger
Lord Wilson
Lord Hodge
Granted
8 Dec 2014
Lord Neuberger
Lord Wilson
Lord Hodge
Granted in
part
9 Dec 2014
Lord Neuberger
Lord Wilson
Lord Hodge
Granted
9 Dec 2014
Lady Hale
Lord Carnwath
Lord Toulson
Refused
9 Dec 2014
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
point of law. The law is well settled and the Court of Appeal has applied it. The
dispute in any event is academic in this case.
Singh (Appellant) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0188
Neutral Citation No: None given
R (on the application of C) (Appellant) v
The Secretary of State for Justice (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0210
Neutral Citation No: None given
R (on the application of O) (by her litigation
friend the Official Solicitor) (AP) (Appellant) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0227
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 990
OPO (by his litigation friend BHM) and another
(Respondents) v
MLA (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0251
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1277
AA (Iran) (AP) (Appellant) v
Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum
Chamber) and another (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0178
Neutral Citation No: [2013] EWCA Civ 1523
Powlesland (Appellant) v
Director of Public Prosecution (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0083
Neutral Citation No: [2013] EWCH 3864
Morton (Appellant) v
Armagh City and District Council (Respondent)
(Northern Ireland)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0194
Neutral Citation No: None given
Rv
Bradley (Appellant) (Northern Ireland)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0205
Neutral Citation No: [2013] NICA 36
Lady Hale
Lord Carnwath
Lord Toulson
Refused
9 Dec 2014
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
point of law.
Lady Hale
Lord Carnwath
Lord Toulson
Granted
9 Dec 2014
Lady Hale
Lord Carnwath
Lord Toulson
Granted
9 Dec 2014
Lady Hale
Lord Carnwath
Lord Toulson
Granted
9 Dec 2014
Lady Hale
Lord Carnwath
Lord Toulson
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
11 Dec 2014 point of law. The factual findings of the First-tier Tribunal are decisive in this case.
Lord Kerr
Lord Clarke
Lord Hughes
Refused
8 Dec 2014
Lord Kerr
Lord Clarke
Lord Hughes
Refused
8 Dec 2014
Lord Kerr
Lord Clarke
Lord Hughes
Refused
8 Dec 2014
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Daly (AP) (Appellant) v
Breslin and others (AP) (Respondent) (Northern
Ireland)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0167
Neutral Citation No: [2013] NICA 75
Murphy (AP) (Appellant) v
Breslin (AP) (Respondent) and others
(Northern Ireland)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0168
Neutral Citation No: [2013] NICA 75
CW (Jamaica) (Appellant) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0174
Neutral Citation No: [2013] EWCA Civ 915
Macklin (Appellant) v
Her Majesty's Advocate (Respondent) (Scotland)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0173
Neutral Citation No: [2013] HCJAC 41
In the matter of an application by Denise
Brewster for Judicial Review (Northern Ireland)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0180
Neutral Citation No: [2013] NICA 54
In the matter of an application by Robert
McAuley (AP) for Judicial Review (Northern
Ireland)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0198
Neutral Citation No: [2014] NIQB 31
R (on the application of An Taisce, The
National Trust for Ireland) (Appellant) v
Secretary of State for Energy and Climate
Change and another (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0250
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1111
Asda Stores Limited (Appellant) v
Commissioners of Her Majesty's Revenue and
Customs (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0136
Lord Kerr
Lord Clarke
Lord Hughes
Refused
9 Dec 2014
Permission to appeal be refused because the applications do not raise a point of law
of general public importance which ought to be considered by the Supreme Court at
this time.
Lady Hale
Lord Carnwath
Lord Toulson
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
10 Dec 2014 point of law. The law is well settled and the Upper Tribunal and the Court of
Appeal have applied it.
Lord Neuberger
Lady Hale
Lord Reed
Granted
11 Dec 2014
Lord Kerr
Lord Clarke
Lord Hughes
Granted
11 Dec 2014
Lord Kerr
Lord Clarke
Lord Hughes
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
11 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Lord Kerr
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
11 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Lord Kerr
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
11 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 317
R (on the application of Roberts) (Appellant) v
Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis and
another (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0138
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 69
Rv
Walker & Son (Hauliers) Limited (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0154
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Crim 100
Singh (Appellant) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
UKSC 2014/0144
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 438
Sarkar (Appellant) v
The Secretary of State for the Home
Department (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0146
Neutral Citation No: [2013] EWCA Civ 195
Lynn Shellfish Ltd and others (Appellants) v
Loose and another (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0191
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 846
Interfish Limited (Appellant) v
Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue and
Customs (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0196
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 876
Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs
(Respondent) v
British Telecommunications Plc (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0145
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 433
Shop Direct Group (Appellant) v
The Commissioners of Her Majesty's Revenue
and Customs (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0110
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 255
Lord Kerr
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Granted
11 Dec 2014
Lord Kerr
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
11 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the applications do not raise an arguable
11 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the cases have already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Lord Kerr
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Lord Kerr
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Granted
11 Dec 2014
Lord Kerr
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
11 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Lord Kerr
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hodge
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
11 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Lady Hale
Lord Carnwath
Lord Toulson
Granted in
part
15 Dec 2014
Patel (Respondent) v
Mirza (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0218
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1047
Tidal Energy Limited (Appellant) v
Bank of Scotland PLC (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0222
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1107
R (on the application of Solomon Smith) (AP)
(Appellant) v
G4S Care and Justice Services (UK) Limited and
another (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0170
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 380
Young v
Anglo American South Africa Ltd and another
(Respondents)
Case No: UKSC2014/0221
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1130
Rv
William (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0045
Neutral Citation No: None given
Lord Mance
Lord Reed
Lord Sumption
Granted
15 Dec 2014
Lord Mance
Lord Reed
Lord Sumption
Granted
15 Dec 2014
Lord Mance
Lord Reed
Lord Sumption
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
15 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal
Lord Mance
Lord Reed
Lord Sumption
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
16 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance.
Lord Mance
Lord Reed
Lord Sumption
West and another (Appellants) v
Ian Finlay & Associates (a Firm) (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0140
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 316
Anselm (Appellant) v
Buckle and another (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0124
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 311
Barclays Bank plc (Respondent) v
Unicredit Bank AG (formerly known as
Bayerische Hypo-Und Vereinsbank) & anr
(Appellants)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0127
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 302
R (on the application of Nouazli) (Appellant) v
Lady Hale
Lord Sumption
Lord Hughes
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise a point of law
16 Dec 2014 of general public importance which ought to be considered by the Supreme Court at
this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the subject of judicial
decision and reviewed on appeal. The application for an extension of time is refused
because there is no basis for granting permission to appeal.
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
22 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance.
Lord Mance
Lord Wilson
Lord Toulson
Lord Mance
Lord Wilson
Lord Toulson
Lord Mance
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
16 Dec 2014 point of law which ought to be considered by the Supreme Court at this time
bearing in mind that the case has already been the subject of judicial decision and
reviewed on appeal.
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
16 Dec 2014 point of law which ought to be considered by the Supreme Court at this time
bearing in mind that the case has already been the subject of judicial decision and
reviewed on appeal.
Granted
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0139
Neutral Citation No: [2013] EWCA Civ 1608
Akzo Nobel NV (Appellant) v
Competition Commission & others
(Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0149
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 482
Asset Land Investment Plc and another
(Appellants) v
The Financial Conduct Authority (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0150
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 435
Joyce (Appellant) v
Darby & Darby (a firm) (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0171
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 677
R (on the application of United Company Rusal
plc) (Appellant) v The London Metal Exchange
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0246
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1271
The Commissioners of Her Majesty's Revenue
& Customs (Appellant) v
The Executors of Lord Howard of
Henderskelefe (Deceased) (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0123
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 278
Varsani (Appellant) v
Relfo Limited (In Liquidation) (Respondent)
UKSC 2014/0135
Neutral Citation No: [2010] EWCA Civ 560
Friends Life Limited (Respondent) v
Siemens Hearing Instruments Ltd (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0141
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 382
PMS International Limited (Respondent) v
Magmatic Limited (Appellant)
Lord Wilson
Lord Toulson
16 Dec 2014
Lord Mance
Lord Wilson
Lord Toulson
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
16 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Lord Mance
Lord Wilson
Lord Toulson
Granted
16 Dec 2014
Lord Mance
Lord Wilson
Lord Toulson
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
16 Dec 2014 point of law of general public importance which ought to be considered by the
Supreme Court at this time bearing in mind that the case has already been the
subject of judicial decision and reviewed on appeal.
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
17 Dec 2014 point of law.
Lord Neuberger
Lord Clarke
Lord Reed
Lord Neuberger
Lord Clarke
Lord Reed
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
17 Dec 2014 point of law.
Lord Neuberger
Lord Clarke
Lord Reed
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
17 Dec 2014 point of law.
Lord Neuberger
Lord Clarke
Lord Reed
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
17 Dec 2014 point of law.
Lord Neuberger
Lord Clarke
Granted
17 Dec 2014
Case No: UKSC 2014/0147
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 408
Sub One Limited t/a Subway (In Liquidation)
(Appellant) v
The Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue
and Customs (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0186
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 773
UBS AG (Respondent) v
The Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue
and Customs (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0151
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 452
DB Group Services (UK) Ltd (Respondent) v
The Commissioner for Her Majesty's Revenue
and Customs (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0152
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 452
NYK Bulkship (Atlantic) N.V (Respondent) v
Cargill International S.A (Appellant)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0143
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 403
R (on the application of MA and others) (AP)
(Appellants) v
Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0129
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 13
R (on the application of MA and others)
(Appellants) v
Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0125
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 13
Belhaj and another (Respondents) v
Straw and others (Appellants)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0264
Lord Reed
Lord Neuberger
Lord Clarke
Lord Reed
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
17 Dec 2014 point of law. In relation to the point of European Union law said to be raised by or
in response to the application it is not necessary to request the Court of Justice to
give any ruling, because the Court’s existing jurisprudence already provides a
sufficient answer
Lord Neuberger
Lord Clarke
Lord Reed
Granted
17 Dec 2014
Lord Neuberger Granted
Lord Clarke
22 Dec 2014
Lord Reed
Lord Neuberger
Lady Hale
Lord Mance
Granted
22 Dec 2014
Lord Neuberger
Lady Hale
Lord Mance
Granted
22 Dec 2014
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1394
Otkritie International Investment Management
Limited and others (Respondents) v
Urumov (Appellant)
Case No. UKSC 2014/0249
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1315
Tchengiuz and another (Appellant) v
Director of the Serious Fraud Office
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0268
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 1409
R (on the application of Khan) v
Secretary of State for the Home Department
(Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0122
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 88
AKJ and others (Appellant) v
Commissioner of the Police of Metropolis and
another (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0128
Neutral Citation No: [2013] EWCA Civ 1342
R (on the application of Dennis) (AP)
(Appellant) v
The Secretary of State for Justice (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0132
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 194
SXH (Appellant) v
The Crown Prosecution Service (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0148
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 90
Collins (Appellant) v
Secretary of State for Business Innovation &
Skills and another (Respondents)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0169
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 717
Liddington & Others (Appellant) v
Webster & Others (Respondent)
Case No: UKSC 2014/0181
Neutral Citation No: [2014] EWCA Civ 560
Lord Neuberger
Lady Hale
Lord Mance
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
22 Dec 2014 point of law. This was an application of well established principles to a particular
factual situation.
Lord Neuberger
Lady Hale
Lord Mance
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
22 Dec 2014 point of law.
Lady Hale
Lord Sumption
Lord Hughes
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
22 Dec 2014 point of law.
Lady Hale
Lord Sumption
Lord Hughes
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
22 Dec 2014 point of law. The point of jurisdiction raises no arguable point of law.
Lady Hale
Lord Sumption
Lord Hughes
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise a point of law
22 Dec 2014 which ought to be considered by the Supreme Court at this time. This is not the
right case in which to consider the general question of the principles governing the
re-opening of past administrative decisions if the understanding of the law changes.
Lady Hale
Lord Sumption
Lord Hughes
Granted
22 Dec 2014
Lady Hale
Lord Sumption
Lord Hughes
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
22 Dec 2014 point of law.
Lady Hale
Lord Sumption
Lord Hughes
Refused
Permission to appeal be refused because the application does not raise an arguable
22 Dec 2014 point of law. This is the application of settled law to particular facts.