Laser Bioeffects and Protection

Austrian Research Centers GmbH - ARC
16. Oktober 2008
Laser Bioeffects and Protection
Karl Schulmeister
Austrian Research Centers
ƒ Eye
Ultraviolett
100 nm - 400 nm
ƒ Skin
Visible + near IR
400 nm - 1400 nm
Far Infrared
1400 nm - 1mm
UV: Photokeratitis
courtesy of Per Söderberg
Cataract
courtesy of University of Michigan, Kellogg Eye Center
Pulses: Ablation
medicineworld.org
Far IR
Courtesy of Tsutomu Okuno
Effects
superthreshold:
Accidents,
Medical
at threshold: Exposure limits
courtesy of Joe Zuclich
Threshold Experiments
Uncertainty: ~ 20 %
Safety Factor
ƒ 3 for larger spots retina
ƒ 3 for UV
1 h macula
1 h ex-macula
24 h macula
24 h ex-macula
100
Energy [mJ]
ƒ 10 for small spots and retina
10
1
d
Mo
el
E
PL
ME
0,1
1
10
100
Nominal retinal laser beam diameter [µm]
Bioeffect Dependencies
ƒ Wavelength:
100 nm to 1 mm
ƒ Pulse duration:
10-14 s to 10 000 s
ƒ Spot size:
10 µm to 1 m
ƒ Power:
µW to TW
4 orders
18 orders
5 orders
21 orders
1000
Bioeffect for Laser AND broadband radiation
Depends on
ƒ Wavelength
Where?
» Location of absorption
» Type of interaction (thermal, photochem.) How?
ƒ Pulse duration
stu
i
e
L
g
n
Bestrahlungsdauer
ƒ Power/spot area = power density (irradiance W/m2)
How strong?
„Temporal concentration“ – pulse duration
„Spatial concentration“ – spot size
One Photon (light particle) has certain energy
Laser
This energy has „action“ on tissue
(heating, chemical change)
Power = Photons emitted per time
Power = Energy emitted per time
Energy
Power =
Time
Energy = Power x Time
1 Joule
1 Watt =
1 Second
Photon concentration
1 Joule = 1 Ws
How many photons?
1 Joule Energy
10 ns Pulse duration (= 10-8 s)
Power
1 Joule
10-8
Second
= 108 Watt = 100 MW
time [s]
Bioeffect < ~ 10 µs: Microcavitation
Melanosomes
(pigment particle)
in Retinal Pigment Epithelium
(RPE)
„Vapour Bubble“
„Thermomechanical“
Thermomechanical“
Retina
Choroid
5 µm Pigment layer in RPE
Temporal Concentration
Spatial Concentration
ƒ Laser: „point
point source“
source (usually)
ƒ Broadband: „extended source“
Absorbing layer: 5 µm „thick“
ƒ Very high power densities
ƒ (W/m3)
Retina
Choroid
5 µm Pigment layer in RPE
Temporal concentration
low damage thresholds!
Spatial concentration
1.E+07
ED50, visible lasers
ED50, NIR lasers
MPE, visible lasers
MPE, NIR lasers
1.E+06
1.E+05
1.E+04
TIE, μJ
1.E+03
1.E+02
1.E+01
1.E+00
1.E-01
1.E-02
1.E-03
1.E-14
Plot courtesy of
DJ Lund
1.E-12
1.E-10
1.E-08
1.E-06
1.E-04
1.E-02
1.E+00
1.E+02
1.E+04
Exposure Duration, s
Wavelength Dependence Retina
Total Intraocular Energy - μJ
10000000
1000000
100000
Qp - 0.1 s fit
0.1 S data
0.1 s MPE
Qp - ns fit
ns data
OPO data
ns MPE
10000
1000
100
10
1
0.1
400
600
800
1000
WAVELENGTH, nm
David J. Lund
1200
1400
Spot Size Dependence
532 nm, ex-vivo cow eye
-2
Radiant Exposure [J cm ]
1000
100
2s
Thermally induced
Damage
655 ms
10
31 Thresholds
5000 exposures
100 ms
10 ms
1
1 ms
0.1 ms
0,1
10
100
1000
Diameter [µm]
Temporal concentration (high peak powers):
-> temperature rise
„Thermal damage“
damage“
Low powers (no heating)
heating) but long enough to
accumulate photons
for blue and UV:
„Photochemical damage“
damage“
Thermal
Increase of Temp
critical Temperature Æ
damage
(„Burn“, coagulation, enzyme
inactivation)
Photochemical
„High Energy“ Photons
(UV, blue)
Chemical Bonds are changed, Molecules
activated
Æ “Phototoxic“
(e.g. Sunburn)
E= h * ν
Photo-chemical Effects
• Vision (Isomerisation)
• Photo-film exposure
• Vitamin-D production UV-B
• „Sunburn“ of skin and cornea
• Photoretinitis („Sunburn“ of Retina, Blue light hazard“)
Thermal
Photochemical
Additivity of microdamages
„Dose“ relationship – J/m²
mainly by pulses
Leistung
Prolonged exposures,
low power, Energy adds up
Bestrahlungsdauer
spot size dependence
NO spot size dependence
strong wavelength dependence
„action spectrum“
wavelength dependence:
optical absorption
38,46
100
3,85
10
0,38
Laser
ICNIRP broadband incoherent
0,04
1
400
420
440
460
480
500
520
Wavelength [nm]
540
560
580
600
Retinal photochemical Class 1 AEL [mW]
1000
-2
Retinal photochemical MPE [W m ]
Wavelength dependence – photochem Retina
Photochemical and Thermal „compete“
ƒ wavelength
ƒ pulse duration
ƒ spot size
Sun (high in sky)
ƒ naked eye:
ƒ photochemical damage (blue light)
ƒ telescope:
ƒ thermal damage within ~ 100 ms
Overview
Bioeffects
From: „Laser Safety“ Henderson & Schulmeister