ISSN 2321–8355 Research Article IJARSGG (2016) Vol.4, No.1, 42-52 International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography TRANSHUMANCE OR SEDENTARIZATION OF NOMADIC HERDERS: WHAT FUTURE FOR A SUSTAINABLE LIVESTOCKING IN THE TUBAH UPLANDS, NORTH WEST CAMEROON Fokeng M. Reeves Department of Geography, Faculty of Letters and Social Sciences (F.L.S.S), University of Dschang, Cameroon ([email protected]) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ABSTRACT: Prior to the migration and settlement of the Mbororo in the Tubah Uplands alongside their main economic activity (livestock keeping), the landscape of the area has not been left intact. Within this ethnic group, pastoralism is a lifelong issue which is inherited at birth and passed on to successive generations. The subsistent economy of these transhumant pastoralists or semi-settled pastoralist is based on the herding of cattle, sheep and goats (grazed animals). The study seeks to analyse the impacts of transhumance and sedentarization of nomadic herders on the landscape and proposed sustainable livestock farming in Tubah. The study exploits both written literature on the theme and area alongside a complimentary fieldwork using semi-closed and opened questionnaires and a Global Positioning System (GPS). The results showed the major transhumance destinations from the Tubah Uplands and the tendencies towards the sedentarization of nomadic herders. It appears that, there are two types of pastoralists in the area; semi-nomads who practice agriculture and transhumance and fully settled Fulani (real sedentary nomads). Grazing activities is also responsible for the savannisation process of the Tubah Uplands. It therefore becomes important to rethink montane forest and pasture conservation and management strategies at the face of a continual sedentarization process of nomadic herders. KEYWORDS: Transhumant pastoralists, Sedentary nomads, Mbororo, Landscape degradation, Cattle foot tract topography. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. INTRODUCTION: Since time immemorial, when we talk of pastoralists or nomadic herders we make allusion to the nomadic herder of the Sahara or semi-arid areas who migrates from one water point to the other of the drylands with his herds in search of pastures and who lives on date palms. The lives of these nomads all over the world are commanded by the capricious nature of the climate that induces changes in seasons and droughts as well as the seasonal displacement of cattle and herdsmen as a response. Several factors are responsible for the decline of nomadism as a livestock production system. This livestock production system is responsible for the continuous degradation of the Sahel and Savanna regions and the progression of desertification. Most grazers today have to mingle between partial nomadism, transhumance and sedentarization. Transhumance has been defined as « a regular movement of cattle, to the south direction during the dry season as a response to lack of pasture and water in the area where they belong » (Stenning1959; cited in (1)). The general mechanisms of transhumance are simple; in search of pasture and water, herdsmen and their herds follow the rainfall southward and flocks return to the village in its rainy season (2).Transhumance has been identified as one of the major constraints to attaining the objectives of biodiversity conservation in national and trans-border parks (see [(1), (3)]). Most countries in the world especially African countries either before or after independence have been putting in place strategies and policies in favour of the sedentarization of nomadic herders. A number of communities have settled in response to state-enforced measures, others have settled in response to changing environment, while others have responded to economic opportunities (4). This is because the sustainability of grazing systems and the lives of these nomads is not secured under a subsistent nomadic herding. The contradictions between administrative logic and the practice of an extensive livestock explains that several forced or framed sedentarization, some very old ones have failed; either herders do remobilise, either abandon livestocking, are marginalise in other activities and migrate to towns (5). But however this initiative of stabilising or sedentarizing the nomadic herder had failed in some West and East Africa countries. Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 43 1.1. THE RESEARCH AREA: The Tubah Sub-division lies between longitude 10°15’25” and 10°16’05” east of the Greenwich Meridian and latitude 5°54’95” and 6°09’56” north of the equator, and forms part of the Bamenda Highlands or the Grassfields (Figure I). View the 2005 population census published in 2010, the population of Tubah stood at 48542 inhabitants over a surface area of 450 Km². Most of the villages are rural and the settlements are sparsely populated with expansive agriculture and grazing. Big Babanki, Babanki Tungo, Bambui and Bambili are the main localities. Sabga (a grazing land in Fulfulde), is a Moslem (Mbororo) settled community located in Tingeh, a neighbourhood of Babanki Tungo. Information on the nomadic way of life of herdsmen is replete in literature, but little has been done to assess the degree of stabilisation, immobilisation or better still the sedentarization of these nomadic herdsmen. The Tubah Uplands with extensive grazing practices is a cause for concern. This is important for sustainable grazing and rangeland management initiatives. Fig I: Location of the study area 2. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The research exploited structured and semi-structured questionnaires. A complimentary fieldwork alongside the help of village Ardos (Fulani leaders) permitted an estimation of the total number of cattle grazers (146). Of the total grazers, 35 were effectively and randomly sampled disproportionately distributed by Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 44 studied sites (Table I). The sample was expressed as a ratio of 1: 4 grazers (base). Thus the sample size = total population of grazers/base. That is, 146/4 = 37 grazers. This was applied to the estimated population of grazers by site using the formula;- estimated grazers in a village/base. Further fieldwork was conducted using a Global Positioning System (GPS) alongside observations and the use of high resolution Google Earth images in a GIS environment to successfully evaluate grazing activities, its implications on land cover and the tendencies towards sedentarization of nomadic herders. Village Babanki Tungo Bambili Bambui Big Babanki Sabga Total Estimated cattle grazers 48 Realised Percent (%) 12 34.3 9 8 7 2 2 2 5.7 5.7 5.7 74 17 48.6 146 35 100.0 Table I: Sample size for questionnaire administration Questionnaires were analysed using Microsoft Excel from which linear correlations and regression analysis were made at 0.05 significance. Data on pasture land coverage was obtained from published analysis of Landsat images of the study area (Table II) and other secondary data was equally acquired where relevant and analysed. 1988 6263.15 Grassland/Pasture (ha) 2001 9078.08 2007 9407.17 2014 14061.60 Table II: Grassland/pasture land surface coverage in hectares for different periods Source: (6) 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS: The Fulani settled population in the Tubah Uplands originated from several places. From the Adamawa came the Foulbes, led by the first founder of Sabga; Adoulahi Sabga who migrated from Banyo in the Adamawa since the 1900’s to settle within the Bamenda Highlands particularly in the Tubah Uplands. Other Mbororo (the Djafouns) came in later around the 1920’s from the Bamoun plateau migrating all the way from Northern Nigeria. The main activity of this founder was cattle grazing. Within this ethnic group, pastoralism is a lifelong activity which is inherited at birth and is passed on to successive generations. The degree of wealth is measured on the number of herds own. The Mbororo of the Tubah Uplands have a diverse socio-demographic background (Table III). Elements Nationality Region of birth* Sub-division of birth* Ethnic group (Mbororo)× Status Status of Grazer Languages of expression Indicators Cameroonian North West Adamawa Tubah Banyo Bui Balikumbat Djafoun Foulbe Tikars Family head Son Herdsman (paid) Fulbe ladde (nomadic herder Fulbe wuro (sedentary grazer) Both Frequency (n=35) 35 31 4 29 4 1 1 11 19 5 22 10 3 31 Percent (%) 100 88.6 11.4 82.9 11.4 2.9 2.9 31.4 54.3 14.3 62.9 28.6 8.6 88.6 1 2.9 3 8.6 Pidgin English + Fulfulde French + Fulfulde Pidgin English + Fulfulde + local languages Pidgin English + Local 17 1 8 48.6 2.9 22.9 6 17.1 Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 Marital status Matrimonial regime Fulfulde French + English + Fulfulde Married Single Polygamy Monogamy 1 2 2.9 5.7 24 11 11 15 68.6 31.4 31.4 42.9 45 *Not implying the region and sub-division of origin of herders. × Origin of herders. Table III: Socio-demographic characteristics of respondents All sampled households are Cameroonians who originated either from Northern Nigeria or Adamawa region of Cameroon. Even though 82.9% of households were born in Tubah, amongst these 82.9%, the Foulbes who originated from the Adamawa represented 54.3%, Djafouns (31.4%) from Northern Nigeria and the Tikars who are non-Moslems represented just 14.3% of the sample grazing households (Table III). Has the stabilisation and complete settlement of Mbororo led to the lost of their identity? It is a question of debate as far as their cultural and linguistic character is never replaced. Rather they are adopting a plura-linguistic character as they adopt the national and local languages of expression where they settle (Table III). 3.1.BETWEEN PASTORAL NOMADISM AND TRANSHUMANCE: It has not been able for the Mbororo of this part of the Bamenda Highlands to completely abandon their nomadic way of life as despite the struggle to settle down, their activities are being controlled by the capricious nature of the prevailing climate. Pastoralism is a response to climatic conditions, and the common ways herders do respond to changing rainfall patterns and seasons is through transhumance to wet valleys, inter-montane basins and plains. Change in seasons over the national territory is commanded by the harmattan and monsoon air mass displacements which induce the migration of the Inter-tropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ). In January, the anticyclone of Azores located in the Sahara Desert is enforced and the harmattan wind becomes stronger than the monsoon, engulfing a greater part of the country thereby bringing about the dry season. The reverse takes place in July when the anticyclone of Saint Helena located in the Atlantic Ocean is enforced and the monsoon becomes stronger than the harmattan (Figure II). This commands the onset of transhumance and the return of nomads from transhumance over the national territory. Fig II: Displacement of air masses and changes in seasons inducing transhumance over the national territory Gazers within this watershed prepare for transhumance during the months of November-December and they return with the approach of March (Figure III). Because of the quest for sufficient grazing lands and the need for the continuous provision of quality and sufficient pastures to cattle, grazers just have to mingle between nomadism, transhumance and Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 46 sedentarization. Consequently, finding it difficult to completely abandon their nomadic way of life. Their life is a response of climatic fluctuations and the desire to better graze their numerous herds. Fulbe ladde (nomadic herder in Fulfulde) is a common name of the Mbororo herder in the Tubah Uplands as this category of grazers represented up to 88.6% (Table III). 62.5% of grazers practice transhumance as against 37.5% who practiced permanent grazing, but concentrated around the permanently fresh parts of the watershed like around Lake Bambili and sabpal (cool grazing land in Fulfulde) in Sabga, thereby aggravating the already existing pressure on pastures. During the wet season, herders with their stocks undergo some periodic displacements within the Uplands. In the dry season, herders direct their herds towards valleys, stream courses and inter-montane basins to benefit from fresh pastures in preparation for transhumance, and a consequent displacement of herds towards mountain summits following the onset of the rainy season (Figure III). These are potential sources of farmer-grazer conflicts in the watershed because of agriculture-grazing contact. Fig III: Grazing patterns, periodic displacements and transhumance Source: GPS projections, May (2014) and complimentary fieldwork (2015) The main transhumance destinations are from Sabga to Bamessing, Dumbo ranch, Bambalang and Bafut as well. Those in Babanki Tungo at times either stay within their grazing territory, or move towards Lake Bambili or to Bamessing and Bambalang. Grazers at Big Babanki go to Bafut for transhumance while those of Bambili and Bambui grazed their Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 47 herds all year round. The seasonal displacement of herds is compounded by reduced average grazing land by households and increasing herds (Table IV). Years 2007 2009 2011 2012 2013 2014 Cows 7092 8953 8767 8156 8767 8767 Sheep 1790 1762 1750 2757 2757 2761 Goats 4030 2455 3850 3595 3800 3595 Horses 584 434 450 378 378 459 Total 13496 13604 14817 14886 15702 15582 Table IV: Ruminant livestock production in Tubah Source: Sub-divisional Delegation for MINEPIA, Tubah (2014 and 2015) Within the Uplands, each grazing household is accorded a minimum of 5 hectares of grazing land with which it graze about 25-200 herds (Table V). Because of increasing cattle numbers and poor pasture quality in some parts, or where the pasture is on very steep slopes or accidental areas, the grazing land tends to be insufficient, consequently, herders resort to access other pasture land different from their own parcels and to transhumance. A minimum of 30 herds and a maximum 180 herds per grazed households do go on transhumance (Table V). Family size Number of herds Average land size Herds that don't go on transhumance Herds that go on transhumance N 29 35 34 Minimum 2 25 5 Maximum 28 200 30 Sum 258 2427 486 Mean 8.90 69.34 14.29 33 10 61 468 14.18 33 30 180 1168 35.39 Table V: Average family size, land size and transhumant cattle by grazed households in Tubah In Cameroon, almost no work has been done on range management and development except on university farms or research stations, so grazing livestock depend on poor and degraded rangeland that is often of very low nutritional quality (2), consequently, cattle grazers are forced to access other pasture resources different from owned parcels (Figure IV). 54.3% of sampled grazing households access parcels other than their own parcels most often as compared to 34.3% that access it rarely. 60.00% Percent 50.00% 40.00% 30.00% 20.00% 10.00% 0.00% Type of grazing land Figure IV: Other parcels grazing households’ access apart from owned parcel In the absence of sufficient grazing land as reported by 45.5% of livestock keeping households in 2014, livestock grazing households must look for new areas for grazing. Grazing on other households parcel is now the norm rather than the exception within these Uplands especially in inter-montane basins. The frequency of visiting these pasture lands alongside Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 48 farmlands after crop harvest and at times in the growing season are potential sources of farmer-grazer conflicts in the Tubah Uplands. 3.1.1. FROM A FULBE LADDE TO A FULBE WURO (SEDENTARY HERDER IN FULFULDE): MYTH OR REALITY: Stricto sensu, the Mbororo of the Bamenda Highlands and those of the Tubah Uplands in particular are regarded as nomads. But most of them are neither transhumant nor sedentary grazers. Are they really sedentarized? The stabilisation of nomads on their grazing sites has manifested a lot of change in their lives. It has led to the end of eggol (displacement or migration without an objective of ever returning to the departure point). The stabilisation of the settled Mbororo groups in the Tubah Uplands dates far back from the 1900’s (Figure V) prior to the arrival Adoulahi Sabga. Figure V: Approximate years grazing households arrived the Tubah Uplands The different groups of Mbororo are named according to the type of cattle reared and ancienity. The Djafouns (15 000 people) from Northern Nigeria arrived the Tubah Uplands around the 1920’s whereas the Foulbes of the Adamawa arrived since the 1900’s and more recent arrival of Mbororo was from the 1950. The migration and settlement of the Foulbes of the Adamawa is thought to have brought in the dominant species of the Adamawa to the Tubah Uplands; the Zebu Goudali (dominant breed of the Adamawa). This breed accounted for 40% of local breed on these Highlands (Table VI). It is thought that since they arrived before the Djafouns, the Djafouns on their part brought in the Red Mbororo Zebu or mbororodi (red zebu mbororo breed in Fulfulde). The Djafouns who are traced to have settled in Bamoun alongside the Akous (10 000 people) who according to (5) arrived the Bamenda Highlands since the 1950’s led to the acquisition of some Akoudi (White Fulani or mbororo breed in Fulfulde) which is a dominant species amongst this group of Mbororo. The Akous according to (5) descended from North Nigeria (Bauchi, Jos). This has permitted cross breeding and a complete mixture of local breeds within a framework of cohabitation and sedentarization efforts. Breeds Red Mbororo Zebu (mbororodi Zebu Goudali Mix of red + white + Goudali *Mix + high breed species Frequency (n=35) 1 14 18 2 Percent (%) 2.9 40.0 51.4 5.7 *Flocks with mixture of Red Zebu, White Fulani and Goudali Table VI: Dominance of local breeds reared The stabilisation of different Mbororo groups within these grazing lands has given rise to a new breed;- mixed breeds which dominate most flocks (Plate I). There is a greater diversification of the activities of nomadic herders; 91.4% of sample households practiced farming as a means of subsistence and each homestead of Mbororo have a small or an extensive farmland especially within the neighbourhood of a Mbororo settled community (Sabga, Figure VI).This corresponds to 94.3% of grazing households who own grazing lands and carry out grazing within their land area or parcel. Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 49 Mbororodi Goudali Akoudi Plate I: Common breeds reared in the watershed Fig VI: Sedentarization tendencies and its implications on land cover in Sabga (a Mbororo settled locality) Source: Extracted from Google Earth image of 2015 and complimentary fieldwork (2016) Though most grazers still hold the name Fulbe ladde, because of their continuous transhumant character, their activities are more of that of a Fulbe wuro. Sabga is progressively being transformed in to a Moslem settled home or Mbororo village. The land cover of this settled area is now contested between farming, grazing and constructional needs. The most visible aftermath of sedentarization and uncontrolled grazing in the area is the development of cattle foot tract topography (Figure VI, Plate II, photos a, b and c). Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 a) Initial phase 50 b) Rill and gully development in Sabga c) Advanced rills and gullies in Sabga d) Cattle pressure on stream course in Tingeh Plate II:a, b and c (cattle foot tract topography and the development of rills and gullies), and d (cattle pressure on stream banks) Cattle foot tract topography is a common trigger of rill and gully erosion in the watershed as most cattle foot tract areas in Sabga and Tingeh (Babanki Tungo) have been transformed in to a landscape of rill and gully systems. The misuse of stream courses for cattle drinking points commonly facilitates stream bank erosion and the degradation of water quality amongst others. 3.1.2. IMPACTS OF SEDENTARIZATION: Though most governments are thriving to sedentarize nomadic herders, the aftermath of sedentarization efforts on the natural environment are manifold. Landscape degradation is commonplace within the Tubah Upland Watershed because of free grazing, overgrazing and transhumance related activities. The present grassland scenery of the Uplands is thought to have been extended and maintained as a result of long periods of grazing of herds that enhanced a savannisation process of these Uplands (Figure VII). Surface area change (ha) 16000 14000 12000 y = 272.9x - 536776 R² = 0.8682 Grassland Montane forest 10000 8000 Linear (Grassland) 6000 Linear (Montane forest) 4000 2000 0 1980 y = -482.97x + 972875 R² = 0.9491 1990 2000 Years 2010 2020 Fig VII: Montane forest loss and extension of area under grassland Source: Analysed from table II Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 51 Montane forest is now only on some patches (remnant) and on very steep slopes alongside degrading gallery forest. Montane forest receded from 63.03%, 26.04%, 10.93% to 6.52% in 1988, 2001, 2007 and 2014 respectively (6). The constant use of fire as a method of regeneration of pastures with the onset of the rainy season is a cause for concern. The sedentary nomad is also a potential wood harvester for either firewood or for the construction of fences to keep cattle at night. According to (3), the cutting of branches and even trees is becoming a very important activity of the pastoralist in the Benue, Faro, Bouba Ndjidda Complex (FBBNC). It is going to be an overstatement if the savannisation of the Tubah Uplands is attributed only to grazing activities, for important agricultural encroachment, wood harvesting and settlement related activities are common causes of montane forest loss and watershed degradation. The most remarkable effect of sedentarization is the development of cattle foot tract topography in Sabga and Babanki Tungo with attendant rill and gully erosional systems. 4. CONCLUSION: During their history, the Mbororo settled at certain periods and afterwards, they returned to a nomadic way of living (5). But in reality they are semi-nomads or semi-settled pastoralists who settle and practice agriculture and grazing, and displaces with their herds during the dry season. Added to this is a last category, even though minute (the fully settled Fulani) who settled and gave more importance to agriculture and does not displace their cattle with season. They are the real sedentary nomads. This pattern is an intermediate stage leading to full sedentarization. According to Febvre (1970; cited in (5)), once settled, it seems that groups seldom revert to transhumance.... The grazing system in majority still remains a transhumant type. Just 42.9% of households have ever heard of and planted supplementary pastures like Bracharia grass as against 57.1% who have no idea about this. In order to enhance a complete sedentarization of semi-pastoralists of the Tubah Uplands alongside a sustainable livestocking in a region that ranks third (that is, the North West) in livestock production in Cameroon, the study recommends the following;Education/sensitization of semi-nomadic herders on the negative effects of transhumance on soil and rangeland and the importance of the use of fodders like browse trees which are very nutritive and important forage in the dry season. This will reduce transhumance; Enhance rangeland management through research on indigenous legumes to identify those that a suitable to this agro-ecological zone and also their methods of establishment and dissemination; Introduction of supplementary pastures or fodders and good grass cover for these Uplands through the elaboration and effective implementation of a grazing management plan; Enhance concertation between farmers and grazers to reduce the frequency of land use conflicts. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I am very grateful to the Textbook and Academic Authors Association (TAA) publication grant that helped in paying the article processing and publication charges and also my best regards to the entire IJARSGG editorial team. REFERENCES: Convers A., Chaibou I., Binot A., Dulieu D., 2007, La gestion de la transhumance dans la zone d’influence du parc régional du w par le programme ecopas : une « approche projet » pour l’aménagement de la périphérie du parc, Vertigo - la revue électronique en sciences de l’environnement, Hors Série, 4: 1-9. 2. Pamo E. T., 2008, Country Pasture/Forage Resource Profiles, Food and Agricultural Organisation, 52p. 3. Mbanga L. A., Gonne B., 2013, Rethinking biodiversity conservation strategies: an analysis of transhumance and grazing in the Benue, Faro, Bouba Ndjidda Complex, (FBBNC) in the North region of Cameroon, Annals of Faculty of Arts, Letters and Social Sciences, 15: 246-292. 4. Ekaya WN., 2005, the shift from mobile pastoralism to sedentary crop-livestock farming in the drylands of eastern Africa: Some issues and challenges for research. Proceedings of African Crop Science. Uganda, 7:1513-1519. 5. Boutrais J., 1983, Entre nomadisme et sédentarité: Les Mbororo à l’Ouest du Cameroun, Systèmes Agraires en Mouvement, ORSTOM, 225-256. 6. Achankeng E., Fokeng M.R., 2015, Montane forest loss and watershed degradation: Case of the Tubah Uplands of the North West Region of Cameroon,African Journal of Special Education, 3:(1) 16. 7. Boureima A., Boutrais J., 2012, Logiques pastorales et de conservation de la nature : Les transhumances et le Parc du W (Niger, Burkina Faso, Bénin), Presses de Sciences Po (P.F.N.S.P.) | Autrepart, 6: 55-75. 8. Boutrais J., 1992, L’élevage en Afrique : une activité dégradante, L‘environnement en Afrique contemporaine, 161:109-1 25. 9. Boutrais J., 1978, Deux études sur l’élevage en zone tropicale humide, Paris, ORSTOM, 193p. 10. Boutrais J., 1981, « L'expansion des éleveurs peuls dans les Savanes humides du Cameroun », Cahiers de Sciences Humaines, ORSTOM, 18 (1): 31-46. 11. Boutrais J., 1987, MBozo-Wazan, Peul et Montagnards au nord du Cameroun, Coll. Atlas des structures agraires au sud du Sahara, ed. ORSTOM, 22: 53. 12. Dongmo A-L., Vall E., Diallo M.A, Dugue P., Njoya A., Lossouarn J., 2012, Herding territories in Northern Cameroon and Western Burkina Faso: spatial arrangements and herd management, Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice, 2, 26:1-21. 1. Reeves, F. M./International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, Vol.4, No. 1 52 13. Gonin A., Gautier D., 2015, Shift in herders’ territorialities from regional to local scale: the political ecology of pastoral herding in western Burkina Faso, Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice, 5:7, 12. 14. Kitchell E., Turner M.D., McPeak J. G., 2014, Mapping of pastoral corridors: practices and politics in eastern Senegal, Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice, 4:17, 1. 15. Manoli C., Ancey V., Corniaux C., Ickowicz A., Dedieu B., Moulin C.H., 2014, How do pastoral families combine livestock herds with other livelihood security means to survive? The case of the Ferlo area in Senegal, Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice, 4:3, 11. 16. Olaotswe E. K., Nnyaladzi B., 2014, Livestock population dynamics and pastoral communities? adaptation to rainfall variability in communal lands of Kgalagadi South, Botswana, Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice, 4, 19: 1-19. 17. Ptackova J., 2011, sedentarisation of Tibetan nomads in China: implementation of the Nomadic settlement project in the Tibetan Amdo area; Qinghai and Sichuan Provinces, Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice, 1, 4:11. 18. Requier-Desjardins M., 2001, élevages et transhumances à l’Extrême-Nord du Cameroun, une étude des Contrats d’accès aux pâturages communs, Thèse de doctorat en sciences économiques, avaliable online at. www.mandaras.info, accessed on the 20th April 2015, 625p. 19. Fokeng M.R., 2016, The rebirth of rice cultivation and expansion of area under paddy cultivation in Santchou, West Cameroon, International Journal of Advancement in Remote Sensing, GIS and Geography, 4 (1) 15-22. 20. Fokeng M.R, Meli M.V., 2015, Modelling Drivers of Forest Cover Change in the Santchou Wildlife Reserve, West Cameroon using Remote Sensing and Land Use Dynamic Degree Indexes, Canadian journal of tropical geography/Revue canadienne de géographie tropicale [Online], Vol. (2) 2. Online in November 15, 2015, pp. 29-42. URL: http://laurentian.ca/cjtg 21. Senépart I., 2012, nomades ou sédentaires mobiles ? Ancrage archéologique et historique de l’habitat temporaire,Techniques & Culture, 56: 32-47 22. Tefera S., 2013, from cattle herding to sedentary agriculture: the role of Hamer women in the transition, African Study Monographs, Suppl., 46: 121–133.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz