The Iowa Review Volume 8 Issue 1 Winter Article 32 1977 To Be Quiet in the Hands of the Marvelous: The Poetry of A. R. Ammons Frederick Buell Follow this and additional works at: http://ir.uiowa.edu/iowareview Part of the Creative Writing Commons Recommended Citation Buell, Frederick. "To Be Quiet in the Hands of the Marvelous: The Poetry of A. R. Ammons." The Iowa Review 8.1 (1977): 67-85. Web. Available at: http://ir.uiowa.edu/iowareview/vol8/iss1/32 This Contents is brought to you for free and open access by Iowa Research Online. It has been accepted for inclusion in The Iowa Review by an authorized administrator of Iowa Research Online. For more information, please contact [email protected]. It is damp there, the cement floors are cool. But you keep your place in line. It is a penance you impose upon yourself Uke kneeling on unpadded prie-dieux. You owe her that much. Whether you loved her or not you owe her that much. OF ACTION FIELDS AND POETRY / CRITICISM "To Be Quiet in the Hands of the Marvelous": The Poetry of A. R. Ammons / Frederick Buell first became with the work of A. R. Ammons acquainted by more his recent have been surprised by looking poetry reading probably in his Collected back to the early poems reprinted Poems: 1951-71. A large of the poems dated between number the years 1951 and 1955 (the date was when his first volume of poetry, Ommateum, do not seem pubUshed) to be characteristic of his mature work. Ammons has set these poems in a at times world of and death, shame, grief, grim, overtly Gothic, unexplained or them around gestures of mysterious loss, and he has centered impotence move failure. Even where the poems' toward the self-extinction, speakers result is neither peace nor catharsis, but a state of sensibility that is haunt a want to For of I describe. better call it a would ingly difficult phrase, is state of incomplete An suffocation.1 the conclusion of the vol example ume's best-known poem, "So I Said I Am Ezra": Those who Imoved my feet and turning from the wind that ripped sheets of sand from the beach and threw them Uke seamists across the dunes swayed and said as if the wind were taking me away I am Ezra 67 University of Iowa is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve, and extend access to The Iowa Review ® www.jstor.org As a word too much repeated falls out of being so I Ezra went out into the night Uke a drift of sand and splashed among the windy that clutch the dunes of unremembered oats seas2 "fall out of being" is not a metaphysical It is not a loss of fulfillment. self to a cosmos, to a larger order. Ezra falls out of being into a partly psy limbo; this place does not bring peace, but the partly mythical chological, sense of suffocation in the way and unexplained that is expressed turbulence the oats "clutch" the "dunes of unremembered seas." The poem's Ezra, a to a hunchback reference of Ammons' playmate youth and also ironically the of cannot assert Ezra the bibUcal his name against scribe, suggestive ocean. of the wind indifference and visionary native rural The landscape that haunts these early poems is less Ammons' It is the landscape of Sumerian South than it is the ancient Near East. Ezra's is unap Its God in reference. to which abound these poems is one of dust, sand, wind, and desert. One feels and its earth proachable, that is stifling to the is burdened with a timelessness that the landscape in creatures of time; for, is it, apocalyptic transformation, though yearned into of the domain thus blends imperceptibly inconceivable. The landscape "none from which the realm of the Queen of Darkness epic, the Gilgamesh there is no coming back." who enters ever returns . . . the road from where a is place of suffocation where As Enkidu's dream reveals, the underworld men endure forever, retaining selfhood but not their vitaUty, their connec no one can escape death, tion with Being. In the Gilgamesh epic, moreover, two-thirds a god, nor the "priests of the incan neither the hero Gilgamesh, in examples of failed abound tation and ecstasy"; Ammons' early poems heroes and seers.3 in his early poetry is that of a seer who has no social Ammons' lyric voice of more than ordinary but is instead a presence or individual characteristics is one who has lost or never awareness and longing. The seer, moreover, one could say that he or a special revelation; saving message securely had a its faith in the "good had lost which Christian of is the creation sensibility into had the eschatological and delved back news" of the New Testament of the older Jews and Sumerians. The poems begin as the seer en pessimism time. in place and historical unlocated ters their largely mythic landscapes, such statements bibUcal and visionary overtones, that have with They begin I said Oh," "I came as "I went out to the sun," "Turning from the waterhole or "I came upon a in a dark woods upon / an ineffaceable difference," pla mythology, 68 seer then moves the mysteriously, often whimsically, or encounters into with ominously landscape phantas changing gods are and indefinite. that magora intentionally Though magically suggestively movement of extraordinary ("So I left and walked up into the capable seer an to is in the damned indeterminate failure air"),5 curiously unfree, the fields of the ("How shall I / coming from these fields / water quest earth / and I said Oh, / and fell down in the dust"),6 or to protracted wan or to a quest for failure that ends without attainment of self-annihi derings, teau."4 The through often lation: PeeUng off my being I plunged into the well... went on deeper innertubes beer cans finding patched and black roothairs along the way but went on deeper till darkness snuffed the shafts of light against the well's side night kissing the last bubbles from my Ups7 a pressure are filled with that one feels journeys and encounters if time and the transformation have been a hunger for apocalyptic not of meaningful ceased. Of that change had possibihty already effectively in remains the consciousness there the of there having poems only hunger, a as In in been the well, Enkidus dream, vitaUty is lost, while great longing. These would consciousness remains. one of the proximate sources for these poems, Though EUot's poetry is they are far more turbulent with their unsatisfied Land" desire than "The Waste and related poems. Behind Ammons' looms a desire too large early work or too corrupted by indefinite and sometimes sin decay to be able to find in nature an image for itself or to be able to make, nature, going beyond is so The behind the itself. failures for longing poems' incomplete objects across the poem "This Black Rich comes one when that, strong Country," one reads it as a result of a It begins with the Une nearly heroic endeavor. me of beUef"; in of his longing and the absoluteness renouncing "Dispossess in attempting to claim for himself a world of ordinary the poet, mortaUty, who is now as much a man as he is a seer, appeals to an unnamed force to leave me this black rich country, labor, fear: do not uncertainty, steal the rewards 69 of my mortaUty.8 sus It is one of the first poems to end with a period rather than a timeless are it in and for searches of the achieve earlier what, poems, pension, light ments. It would find uncertainty, rather than a Umbo in which all possibiU ties are suffocatingly it would have labor rather voided, though unstilled; means ex than an impotent to realize itself; and it would longing without a seems to be alienated fear rather than state of that perience sensibility from all merely human emotions. Ammons' thus seems to lie far afield from the poetry that early work to leads immediately "Corsons and Inlet" then into his up major long as an Emer it seems to have Uttle to do with Ammons' poems; reputation sonian "nature the distance between the absoluteness of the poet." Though and the is later liveliness of the work early poems speculative great, the no means is to rela Ammons has achievement been change by arbitrary. tivize and multiply the absolute for the sake of imaginative survival and the promise of a nearly unlimited He intellectual the seer abandons growth. for an astonishing of the early poems of inventions of voices and variety as one becomes of which clear the personae, surveys a large variety only number of poems. Ammons humanizes the seer and gives him specific iden tities. Though Ammons of his vision compromises thereby the absoluteness more absorbs of he and knowl the ary quest, though imperfect properties is of he freer within limitations. He has these time, edges imaginatively an to himself humbled accept consciously object, imperfect earthly nature, for his now controlled but always resurgent longings. to expand his work in two directions. In doing this, Ammons He begins a it to it to the American closer and he opens broad brings commonplace, eclecticism of knowledge and wisdom. He enters, in short, the mainstream re of American poetry. The poetry after Ommateum visionary gradually sources for Ammons' veals the extent of and the principal spiritual eclecti cism. Behind the bulk of it ( the only major exception being perhaps Tape for the Turn of the Year) lies a varied use of Greek thought, the Ionian na ture philosophy that is the point of origin of Western science, and a person that comes from Eastern aUzed use of ideas and terminology thought, ulti as source in its most Ammons his named "philosophical by mately Laotse, Most of Ammons' mature writings?in and strategy idea version."9 complete ?are made up of his interweaving of these separate sources, and their union Ammons' of in is Uke the union of compensatory opposities. juxtaposition or to vir his his references the void, tellectual emptiness speculations with to to give precise idea and perception tuosic capacity though fluid form within the his with attainment, rapid flow of his verse, of repeated coupled moments of stillness or serenity reveal how he has united his two very dif of sudden rest in his verse, moreover, free ferent sources. These moments idea and perception from logic and referential 70 knowledge; by them the mind so that it is and per and refreshed speculation ready for renewed use of these sources, then, ideas for the The ception. controlUng provides as well as resources of mood and mode. Ammons' use, for poetry example, of is a derivation from the colon as a structural device these polari sty?stic ties. Perhaps the best summary of how the two sources help constitute Ammons' vision would be to say that the one is the basis for his active is stilled in the and the other is the wisdom that enables him to engage knowledge of activity knowledge. Ammons' creation of a nature with which he could initiate a richly pro was a conscious visional expressive reaction against the direc relationship tion of his early poetry. Ammons' mature poetry is not a rebellion against a Unitarianism. As Ammons' indicate, his re corpse-cold early poems would too too to if was, hot, ligious background passionately anything, apocalyptic was To naturalize his imagination thus a saving be dealt with directly. as "This Black Rich and the pro indicate, achievement, Country" would visional accords with nature in Ammons' work should be seen as an accomp that is often most it is most humble, Ushment sub?me when brilUantly comic. and equivocating, overtly in the Collected Poems immediately striking in the poetry dated 1956 and 1966 is the great variety of voices and lyric selves that or serious Ammons has created. celebrant, country inquirer, chanter, Sly reasoner: from the the speakers range in utterance skeptic, diarist, observer, or celebrative Whitmanian chanter of songs to the wry, formal, hortatory, ironic doubter Ammons of prophecy. often addresses the reader directly, Most between he will address the absoluteness of the early lyrics. Sometimes, rupturing the reader's soul with Whitmanian sometimes and he will appeal urgency, to the reader's interests and a manner. in breezily sympathies chatty Equal in these poems for metaphysical ly various are the terms that he employs and for definition of the nature of temporal process. He writes speculation the of, reasons about, or chants the one, unity, the overall, the underlying, in different poems, and he uses terms and the divine void, the changeless, and weaving and unweav like motion, order, entropy, accident, mechanism, of nature in time.10 ing to present in different poems the processes in It would be incorrect, I think, to call these poems mere experiments for the longer, voice and idea, though they do estabUsh many of the modes more poems to come. (One could even say they require Am encyclopaedic as acts of mons to attempt the ) Their variety self-integration. longer poems a a mode of comes instead form and organic impulse: to develop pragmatic or mood that is suited to the different Some expression subject presented. are to and wisdoms Ammons' modes direct the Christian peripheral. appeal in "Christmas Eve" is unusual, of the incarnation the mystery although 71 book Tape for mode and tonaUty of the poem are crucial for the wonderful an amniotic into the Turn of the Year; Ammons' regression unity in "Sphere" is most unusual; and his weaving and unweaving of self in "Muse" is unusual in the Whitmanian and direct cadences of the first half and the immediacy ness with which of In overt recreations this theme is handled. the general, in not endure it in abounds Ammons' Whitman's do work, although style him. indirect echoes of wonderfully Ammons' main interest, as it emerges from the variety of his middle poems, to the mind. in nature and its accessibiUty of the changing to this theme. The most two complementary discovers approaches to rationaUze process is Ammons' into flowing fami?ar remarkable abiUty means it intelUgible Ionian of the order and to make of the concepts by one and the many. This is a realm of intellection at which Ammons is an un not to be his "one" as ungraspable, master. Ammons presents paralleled sees experience or it as a destruction of self. he of fully thought experienced; one is realm. Ammons the human In exercises the of the The world short it, or into the world of multipUcity full play of his mind; he brings changing un as an is fluid and resourcefulness intellectual which of ders by means as natural process. It is not logical reasoning, but an underlying dogmatic the motions of things. Am in the mind which parallels, precariously, motion in the mind in the act of poetry, mons motion and he that experiences is in the realm Ammons images it as the wind: but the music in poems is different, points to nothing, traps no reaUties, takes no game, but by the motion of its motion resembles is? what, moving, the wind underleaf, white the tree.11 against a destruction; it ends the motion try for totaUty is and the creative mind. The less famiUar strain in Ammons' poetry is a mode in both and the mind, but of an underlying receptivity To 72 that informs nature that is not of motion the cosmos and man. as or self; it is his sees this to receptivity identity something prior or void. In the cosmos, the void contains pro version of Taoist emptiness of inner stillness and re cess, and, in the person, the void is a cultivation Ammons arrives at a statement ceptivity. Ammons a about the soul: "Terrain," poem of it at the end of the fine poem it is an area of poise, really, held from tipping, dark wild water, fierce eels, countercurrents: a habitat, precise ecology of forms to some extent mutually a crust afloat: tolerable, not entirely self-destroying; a scum, foam to the and other-natured: deep but deeper than depth, too: a vacancy and swirl: itmay be spherical, Ught and knowledge merely iris and opening the of its sight: how it comes and to the dark methods whirls goes, ruptures and heals, and stands still: the moon comes: terrain.12 is, according essay, "A Poem Is A Walk," which so not is dark once Emersonian," perhaps "infuriatingly work is recognized. A poem, as Bloom quotes Ammons, Ammons' is a motion reaUzation. to no-motion, Its knowledges to the still point are all negative to Harold Bloom, this strain in his of contemplation and, therefore, and deep more posi tive than any knowledge.13 argues that the poem, as well as the self and cosmos, has an inner even where It is a wholeness in accessible stillness and vacancy. the mind fails to attain the one, rebuffed by the provisionaUty of its orders. It motion of motion has meaning the provisionaUty and is the stillness against which as two fact that coexist the makes these modes form. Ammons exphcit Motions." in his "Two his in poem imagination parallels Inlet" integrates rather than The justifiably well-known poem "Corsons as does "Two Motions," modes of these The poet's imagination. juxtaposes, an external wind, but is into motion is no longer animated active mind by and it is fused with in his possession, the full acceptance that completely an is "Overall that, fully reaUzed, yields "serenity." acceptance beyond me," of the active and the passive, not a The poem is a walk and thus a mixture terms of "Two Motions." the opposing The fact that voyage or a nonvoyage, Ammons it is a casual walk, yet a walk for meditative 73 discovery, locates it somewhere and goal-directedness of a quest and a passive va the uniqueness a to its In of walk, one loiters and absorbs cancy receptivity surroundings. as one a as much in to this attempts get anywhere; repeated, daily walk, is in Ammons' idea absorbtiveness the poem passive controlling emphasized. is active. It is the mind's ever recrudescent and expanding capacity to "fasten between to combat grasps of disorder," increasing enlarging an rest in is to that related the finds, however, insight passive in the walk: elements into order entropy. He or receptive there is no finaUty of vision, that I have perceived nothing completely, that tomorrow a new walk is a new walk.14 thus reveals how the activity of mind and the receptive stillness are are to each other. When related of wisdom necessarily they integrated forever with each other, the poet can achieve a fuller and fuller (though nature. his naturaUzation of humanizaci?n of and imagination incomplete) can become more and more a part of and of the poet's mind The motions to nature's active motions. "wind," They neither need be merely supplement in the human mind of something for moments the appearance essentially a or autonomy nor need that would be threat nonhuman, they attain finality in its conclusiveness. They need neither be too natural ening and unnatural nor too human and conscious to consciousness to human in origin include resources a wis intellection and the of find place in natural process. With can locate himself within of natural process, the mid-world dom, Ammons can root himself precariously within the the realm of time and change. He use of the colon, a staple now of his poetic syn In his this context, flowing. In Emerson's luminous. tax and to remain so, becomes prose style, each sentence often seems to be a unique origin, and an essay is at best a cumu re at worst a collection of mutually lative series of original insights and accents in continuation Ammons' contrast, poetry, by particles. pellent in natural fate or law as much as it does surprise and involvement process into a balance as it does freedom. Ammons mitigates and brings as much in "Cor in Emerson's terms that are paradoxical Indeed, thought. polarities the terms 'law" or "fate" in order to make son's Inlet," Ammons modifies Ammons to his scientific understanding of a total of original discontinuity law or fate. Nature adamantine bound by thing order and disorder, cause and process of mingled them responsive sees as neither natural process, which he nor some self-recreations a the is, Uke poet's mind, event and prob accident, ability. nature and The "freedom" of "Corson's Inlet" is the unfinished qua?ty of a maximum in order with of possibil of vision. The poem balances subtlety 74 of free allows the experience ity, and this balance of order and possibility attains is risk: the risk of possi dom. The price for the freedom Ammons of death will shatter time, and the risk of biUty, the risk that the accident an apparent risk the that the order, imagination will quail before rigidity of food-chain the of death. order, tight In its celebration of provisionaUty, "Corson's Inlet" is a self-conscious to of Ammons' that work to ration summary point. In it, Ammons attempts a mid-world alize his diversity of thought and voice. In firmly estabUshing of imaginative existence within and in its attainment of temporal process, inner and outer coherence within the changing, the poem looks forward to the impressive for the Turn Poems, of Ammons' later work, the Tape particularly in that the Collected appear long poems "Extremes and Moderations," and "Hibernacu developments of the Year, on Poetics," "Essay lum," and the book-length the poem Sphere. In Tape for the Turn of the Year, Ammons takes the wisdom of "Cor as one could wish. A son's Inlet" as far into the American commonplace on an found long, skinny poem, written adding machine tape that Ammons it at a home and extends several hundred store, pages garden supply through and a five-week period of time his achievement of freedom within time, his and surprise. precarious balance of continuum Ammons bases his Tape upon an affectionate He parody of the Odyssey. account of his passage a Uttle relocates the epic story to a diary-like through over a month's time, and he breaks the voyage of Odysseus up into a series of internal and external side-trips or forays and encounters with even daily or a a tuaUties accidents. Like Odysseus, Ammons has home he destination, themes of the poem. With dis seeks; this is one of the main wonderfully seeks another Ithaca, as he is waiting to hear about guised slyness, Ammons a Ithaca, New York. The theme of home job offer from Cornell University, more itself far sections of the is, however, coming complex. The opening it as a story of "how / a man comes home / from haunted / poem announce to an "acceptance of his place / and time."15 The lands and transformations" in in and theme overall thus of a way becomes, form, the attainment poem resources are those of of "going along with this / world as it is."16 Ammons' and receptive wisdom; "Corson's Inlet," active intellection the goal of his can also be put in the terms of "Corson's Inlet" as the and quest continuing ever unfinished of a partial humanization attainment of nature and naturali to deal with the zation of the imagination. Ammons attempts continuously at the end of the poem: raises he question have our minds far, out of nature, complete taken us too out of acceptance?17 75 The home tion; Ammons sought is thus finally realizes that those who fooUshly it that not a fixed rely haven't residence. It is a home in mo on any shore faced stream is only the reUable:18 includes in the poem a number Indeed, "home is every minute."19 Ammons vivid and clear remembrances of his boyhood in the South; of wonderfully are too for he reaUzed for recollects them with the in they finely nostalgia, is no way home in going back. Ammons thus that there sight distinguishes in lost. He also distinguishes for paradises himself himself from a yearning a to it for that his be clear from yearning Tape paradises regained, making but not the ideological of time retains the irreversibiUty conception goal of Christian history. Miltonic echoes Ammons intends; he also expUcitly echoes Words not to His of God to worth's justify the ways high quest is "Prospectus." the mind man nor to effect a marriage, with apocalyptic overtones, between of changing of man and the external world, but to come to an acceptance as a a reconciliation he describes this / "going along with place and time, nor final as a mar as it is." This reconciliation is never so world complete a blend of continuous activity of wit and intellect riage. Instead, it involves to being abandonment of acceptance, with a large draught swept along, a poem that is as in and ending as is and it necessitates arbitrary beginning sense of the Tape, a going along with a section of the poet's time. Ammons' was more in even in his extreme this than is Emerson's transience poem These nature. of apocalyptic with itself a resistance essay "Circles," marriage awareness about himself, each Rather than draw larger and larger circles of a return to time and which neces one an attainment which is dissipated by to ride a "moment- / to Ammons sitates a further self-recovery, attempts in short, to ride rather than to circumscribe. moment crest."20 He attempts, now a of daily Ufe, of "Corson's Inlet" has become The wisdom possession attained at the end of a medita not the sublime assertion of a recognition tests that assertion to see if it will be capable of sustain tive walk. Ammons man in the disorder and homeUness an of daily life in a house ing ordinary from the ocean margin). in inland New Jersey (a location now removed of "Corson's Inlet," a world whose The Tape is thus set in the mid-world in is rooted the active knowledge of Greek and clarity of form visibiUty is of Taoism. that and receptive wisdom Something specific to philosophy an of Ammons' is the Tape, however, expansion religious and philosophical 76 than in any other poem, save most recent long perhaps the Ammons this in mid-world darkness, a darkness out poem, Sphere, suspends as in of which sweetness the clarity of fact emerges with the same attained vests the "natural at the end of the atypical poem "Bridge." Ught" attained In writing that the eclecticism. More eternal significance is of some to me: I significance how: but don't know just is temporal significance a world I can partly make, loss & gain:21 the processes of time with something larger, something in terms of inner need and external knowledge; Ammons surrounds unknown and unknowable is still beyond in the the "Overall" him, it is very much though a natural if only in the background winter of the New Jersey nights, ness. This darkness, more however, may at times suggest something nature to "the terror-ridden / homeless man / wandering through / verse of horror"; this homeless man haunts the wandering always even to of "man at the Ammons seeks be the poem, ground though in a universe of Ught," saying poem, dark than a uni back ease / let's tend our feelings & leave the Lord His problems (if any): He got us this far on His own: & milUons have come and gone in joy (predominantly ) :22 leaves the Lord on his own and only comically Though Ammons gives one could not call even the moment Him personal identity, and though in intention, his acceptance Ammons of un speaks of the Lord devotional overtone. in is Judeo-Christian The atmosphere of the Christmas certainty to a certain extent its tone and substance. setting for the Tape determines to an unknownable Between of Abraham, the obedience will, submitting of PauUne faith, a death and rebirth to a new world, and the regeneration the poet of the Tape is to be found. Of 77 course, Ammons follows neither of and whimsy and he tries to these paths. He retains his Umited freedoms as mere time But Ammons' middle road is flanked within that stay ongoing. is from clear his the these credo, by Judeo-Christian paths Tape's central a an after service in which of afternoon church moment, description spoken to / each row / & the "the deacons went down / the aisles & gave light Ught poured / down the rows & / the singing started": though the forces have different names in different & places are times, they real forces which we don't understand: I can either beUeve in them or doubt them & I beUeve: I believe that man is small & of short duration in the great, incomprehensible, & eternal: I believe it's necessary to do good as we best can define I believe we must & accept discover it: the terms that best testify: I'm on the side of whatever we the reasons are are here: we do the best we & it's not enough:23 can terms of this poem are finally a nonintellectual and Umited humiUty an not and of the void. The acceptance entropy and order serenity, hope, indicates what lies beneath the poem's rich play of the credo's humiUty it comes from choice, faith, mind, and the highly conditional hope?whether or the comic of the American desire to be on "the rendering deUghtfully for the from within side of acceptance poem's quest right things"?underUes and always hopeful fabric of daily American time. Just as it is the humble The 78 is this poem as its imaginative setting, it humiUty and pro sustains the that speaker. hope his speculative Ammons thus deprecates of ideas to the nonintellectuality and hope and to the routines of daily life they inform. It Christian humility be doing an injustice to the Tape, both in its own right and would, moreover, in its position as forerunner to the more difficult and intellectually brilUant to omit a notation later long poems, of the poem's range of thought. Am mons in this poem to take account of the whole attempts range of man's life that sustains visional he deals with questions aesthetical, knowledge: epistemological, metaphysi cal, re?gious, psychological, social, sexual, and scientific. The sociological, to find models the later poems' attempts that include and Tape previsions some at in con I shall this all realms. discuss these later point unify length nection with the "Essay on Poetics"; here I only wish to note that the Tape cosmoses. is the herald of the later poems' intellectual In the Tape, Ammons does not yet assert ideas as ideals, saying "ideas are human products, / & full this he modifies but of process"; temporal description sig slightly in the later ideas undercuts nificantly long poems.24 In the Tape, Ammons them to the fabric of daily life, a poetic resource which pro by juxtaposing as well as wisdom vides much of the entertainment of the poem. Ammons will, while on a flight of thought, frequently interrupt himself with a paren thesis "(just went to take a leak: / jay on the back lawn, / hopping, looking in a around, / turning leaves)"25 or refer back to a past speculative flight not is comic that but had lunch after who / / "(I way deflating completely cannot love')".26 some of the poem of America. Whereas Inlet" echo Whitman's mode and with poems prior directly is both in in and rich remarkable success, the Tape highly personaUzed a self, however, it as a song of myself, direct echoes. Ammons writes empiri man the poet remains the representative cized and provinciaUzed. Though and the poem is a poem of America, the poet and poem attain this status or homeliness and smallness their provinciaUty of deUneation. through uses the word "we," his tone is f amiUal and some Ammons When sharing, a poem about a quest for home and to a poem that is to thing appropriate rich with the Christmas winter atmosphere. He seeks to temper the external the weather, the long dark winter nights of ice, and the near of adversity ness of an inscrutable mystery the internal hearth warmth of by recreating are a event and shared daily eventuaUties. voices These and attitudes family is a rebel against the barbaric yawp, a genuine one for our day. Ammons in American in the and humble, casual, "Uterary" catching provincial speech a an an event re American of and event; Christmas, sympathetic portrayal as the f ountainhead of kitsch, is a remarkable literary garded by the merely in aWhitmanian vein. achievement The Tape is Ammons' essential to "Corson's 79 for the Turn of the Year?the major ones and and Moderations," "Hibernaculum," "Essay a a Form Motion and the book-length The of poem Sphere: comparatively one is "Summer Session"?make use of the con minor, but sheerly deUghtful tinuous form of the Tape, but alter its import and effect in a number of ways. I shall focus on "Essay on Poetics' as representative of the major long poems to the others, for, even and content myself mainly with references taking on Poetics" alone, I am all too conscious that justice cannot be done "Essay to its richness in a brief survey of Ammons' whole body of work. The speaker of the "Essay" has a somewhat different than had identity as a identifiable the speaker of Tape. No longer primarily provincial Ameri and mock-Victorian can, he emerges more vividly as an ironic Stevensian a in a The essayist writes essayist-comedian. lang language of propositions, as as not is various that its of that of the uage variety Tape, though thought is stunning. The language of the "Essay" rehes heavily upon and expression and aphor the resources of connective syntax, as its propositions, thoughts, not continuation and isms are connected of the the the surge colon only by or that modify of continuation of thought, but also by a host of connectives etc. of the thought, such as "indeed," direction the "still," "but," qualify to at one "point that the essayist himself calls attention (This is a language in the poem.)27 The effect of the poem's freedom of provisional summation" is to multiply its thought rather than to restrict it. Like the with connectives in motion, is far more rapid and is but this motion the Tape, "Essay" always more in the other long still than that of the Tape, and it quickens sustained mood of an essay. poems, less tied to the meandering The "Essay" has a quotidian setting, for it is written during the "natural a snowstorm, it refers often to the weather and and the look of suspension" of the land outdoors.28 In contrast to the setting for the Tape, the snowstorm in which is a "natural suspension," the poet distances himself sUghtly from a a not has his normal life in order to write essay, poetic diary. Thought as even autonomy. a and of primacy Though, sUghtly greater degree gained it is now a middle hews a "middle way," of in the Tape, Ammons way a way cut between an "artificial rather than experience, Unearity" thought Ammons' are and long poems on Poetics," since Tape "Extremes "nonsense."29 an in mode away from important development signifies change a to from his former naturaUze the it is the Tape; attempt sUght push away an autonomous assert to the freedom of the and toward attempt imagination a Uberation avoids from nature, Ammons complete expUcitly imagination. is an important and subtle one. At one point, early the distinction however; " in the "what this is about," the in the poem, Ammons writes 'gathering / so to trove of mind, tested / experience, the only place to the speak, sky' . . . the of civiUzation, the Sumerians stay holy bundle of / the elements Ammons' 80 un in the sky" is akin to the "gathering Heavenly City and the a no now Overall of Ammons' earlier it is de poems, though grasped longer an is is struction. It it ideal that guides human action, "impossibly difficult"; in a literal sense, but nevertheless an ideal to be nonexistent inaccessible, said."30 This feels an immense risk of loss and a profound pa out of nature is clear from the for something slightly that begins the book Sphere. (for Harold Bloom) poem moving dedicatory returns to the mood and Sumerian In it, Ammons setting of his earUest poetry as he was removed from nature himself identifies with who Enkidu, covertly at the cost of his converse to and humanized ability directly and Uve in har it. with Ammons his concludes lament with the Unes: mony magnificent striven thos for. That Ammons in his quest now this place has provided firm impUcation and answering but where here is the image for longing: so I touched the rocks, their interesting crusts: I flaked the bark of stunt-fir: I looked into space and into the sun answered my word longing: I said, nature so goodbye, goodbye, grand and are into healed their own reticent, your tongues up element and as you have shut up you have shut me out: I am as as if I had landed, a visitor: foreign here so Iwent back down and gathered mud and with my hands made an image for longing: and nothing I took this image to the summit: first I set it here, on the top rock, but it completed then I set it there among the tiny firs nothing: but it would not fit: so I returned to the city and built a house to set the image in and men came into my house and said that is an image for longing and nothing will ever be the same again31 in the Collected and the other long poems Poems do not, to attain or give themselves up to such finaUty. Instead, Am draws in them the line between naturalization and apocalyp the imagination; he makes the distinction clear in two pas The first expUcitly resists apocalypse: sages in "Hibernaculum." The "Essay" seek however, mons carefully tic freedom of some think mind will continue 81 of its own self growing out of nature until possessed itwill bespeak its own change, turn with second-nature or it grew: I'm pessimistic: against the loam out of which 23 for my Uttle faith, such as it is, is that mind and nature grew out of a common motions The second the previous passage, one: ... node and so must obey common :32 however, the mind's one: it pre-existed, sets itself against the apparent I think: even before naturaUsm of it was it was mind it was the earth: when plausible: it will be another born, earth, just Uke fully the earth, but visionary, earth luminous with sight:33 mind it is are not the second passage the echoes These finally. Though oppositions, new heaven and earth of Revelation, it is a new earth exactly Uke the old, and the progress toward it is not a second birth but a continuation of the Emerson wrote of extremes, the poetic recreation of a second first. Whereas naturaUzation of the mind, Ammons and the complete world precariously holds both and together possibi?ties. edges against on Poetics" is a poem that quite obviously is about poetry. It is, "Essay was an as it the and also what however, poem, attempts Tape, encyclopaedic an realms of knowledge of the different that the Tape avoided, integration serves as the of the ideal poem which it draws on. Ammons builds a model whether of the ideal organization, / the cell, the "symboUcal representation or the the the business, university, computer, /group, re?gious body poUtic, a from nature and not what "Ideal" means level of abstraction whatever."34 but which constitutes nature; as an ideal, it is something nonexistent guides human striving. a model for the ideal organization To understand just how poetry forms an to the controlUng some reference necessitates image for the "Essay," new form of con comes from the field of cybernetics. Ammons' that image of nature involves transforming and thus partial humanization ceptuaUzation means this transformation first an act of ab bits: nature into information reworks straction and second a kinetic act of relation of the parts. Ammons of order and entropy he used in "Corson's Inlet" into the model the model It is a cooler and a higher-speed and this determines of cybernetics. model, now in in the tone of the verse. Interpreting a processes physical change terms in than of "laws of rather nature" terms of conceptual which processes, 82 are prior to and perhaps antagonistic Ammons has made a subtle change His to those that govern mental processes, in both the mode and the vision of his is precarious, into information-bits and abstraction of reality must / not violate concrete the bit, event, percept, / fact?the "language means that otherwise the separation / the death of language shows"; how con this is, and how impotent we are to control the processes precarious on the word "true." The word sciously, is illustrated by Ammons' meditation to "tree" and therefore the elm tree of the "true," related etymologically more itself of "bits" than mind can handle, the essay, composed physically is shown to contain greater resonance and rootage of than a logical meaning can a medium in in mind Not but poetry, comprehend. logic then, only in is of with abstraction motion, greater complexity pos capable deaUng sible. To accomplish this end, poetry has, for one thing, the capacity for il the bits are ab lusion, as it can heighten "by dismissing rea?ty."35 Once as a of that into stracted, they are immediately, abstraction, part brought relational motion: are es both speed in motion and intellectual virtuosity on of variations sential, as one can see from Ammons' stunning printout "no ideas but in things."36 If Ammons WilUam Carlos WilUams' should stop on any word, gives way; / melting "language through, and reaUty's cold waters / accept the failure."37 Just as computers in action retain in murky verse retains its circulation formation by rapid electronic of it, so Ammons' in its meaning mobility. Ammons' of poetry as bits thrown into motion is based cybernetic model on an ideal of into his He feeds of dif bits poems organization. gradually and then, in the course of the poem's ferent information (ideas, themes) or of the high-speed motion, he produces different clusterings core-tang?ngs are Ammons' new approach to the famiUar one: bits. These core-tanglings and they form a model for societies, businesses?whatever? many problem, as well as for and for of unity computers poetry. The ideal is a maximum or without is distortion of of the bits. the any suppression Poetry highest it has resources beyond model: those of computers. It has forms of order that are more than merely an increase of the motion's speed: poetry. nothing defined can be still: the verbal moves, depends there, or sinks into unfocused is mind the when but brought to silence, the irreaUty; ah, it's the whole and still, non-verbal, again to see how motion goes:38 and China in the long poems in Collected again in Greece are or intellection and the quieting Poems, the themes of which giving up A familiar of the that represents wisdom. and of the technique "Essay" is something that echoes classic American later poems generally silent films. We are back 83 Ammons will multiply information, pour more into the poem than a rational is an is not the re of nonsense analysis capable of, will then, if explosion recover a himself with sud sult, gesture of giving up that returns the mind, to integration. After the considerations it that im make denly, multiplying to ever determine location in the of elm his the let alone possible backyard, falls back into a wonderful say anything about its inner structure, Ammons that also recovers the wholeness of the elm: self-recovery I am just going to take it for granted that the tree is in my backyard: to be quiet in the hands of the marvelous:39 it's necessary NOTES 1 Examples of these poems are: "So I Said I am Ezra," "The Sap Is Gone out of the a Moment in 1349," to "Rack," Strasbourg "Turning Say So Long," "Dying a Diminished "With Ropes of Hemp," "I Struck Place," "Eolith," Seventh," '1 Assume the World Is Curious about "One a "I Came Me," upon Composing," and "Whose Timeless Reach." Plateau," "Sumerian," "Gilgamesh," "In Trees," in a Mirthful 2 A. R. Ammons, Collected Poems 1951-1971 be 3 The 4 5 6 of Gilgamesh, 10, p. 14, Epic CP, p. CP, p. 6, p. 3. CP, p. 2. 7CF, 8 CP, pp. to trans. p. 27, from an N. K. and Sandars p. (Baltimore, 1972), 92. p. 31. 10-11. p. 37. 9 The comes comment p. 51. mature (1973), Ammons' to "discredit as he (New York, 1972), p. 1. Hereafter to as CP. referred uses interview The verse rehgiously the present reveals is; the rural South, and intellectually" tense in the in the Ammons interview also how in which and interview?"no issue self-conscious and was Ammons thus a man became culture." His of Diacritics, a chosen iv III, creation came up, he had?and brought who transformation has, of himself into a poet of the tradition of the New England mind would have something in it of of a provisional assumption on not so, based overtly it resembles, that unobtrusive for Ammons question tantalizing the when his individual to the To view deal talent; later poems with these have reveals, framework ceptual 10 A list of the the than spirit Eliot's disguise. an allusive ever so Indeed, revision is often poetry tradition literary tall tale told with his of a slightly, will be, I predict, Possum be more may criticism of Old poetry was the question or, overtly parodie that is so wry yet a face. A straight of in tradition indirect important, the influence upon early as the Diacritics criticism will, as a direct and ways, poems. inter Ammons questions adequately, a different?both to more subde and more American?con provide in his articles on Ammons. than that employed Harold Bloom by I consider most in this connection be helpful poems important may 84 "The Golden "Come Prima," "Mechanism," "Guide," Mean," "Prodigal," "Hymn," " and Possibilities," "Unsaid," "Terrain," "Uh, Philosophy," "Sphere "Bridge," "Christmas "What "The Strait," Eve," "Muse," "River," "Catalyst," "Open," "Identity," Sea Level," for Motion," of This Mode of Motion "Motion "One: Said," "Expressions here: "Risks "Two Motions," "Corson's Many," 11 146-147. CP, pp. 12 CP, p. 90. 13 Harold You "When Bloom, Inlet," Consider and the "Saliences." Radiance," The Ringers in the Tower (Chicago, 1971), pp. 270-271. 14 CP, 151. p. 15A. R. Ammons, Tape for the Turn of the Year (Ithaca, 1965), pp. 9-10. 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 p. 203. Tape, p. 202. Tape, p. 19. Tape, p. 31. Tape, Tape, p. 37 26. Tape, p. Tape, p. 155. Tape, p. 98. Tape, p. 32. Tape, p. 38. p. 61. Tape, 27 CP, p. 299. 28 CP, p. 317. 29 CP, pp. 301-302. 30 CP, p. 300. 31 A. R. Ammons, Sphere: The Form of a Motion 32 CP, p. 358. 33 CP, p. 367. 34 p. 315. CP, p. 298. CP, p. 310. CP, p. 304. CP, (New York, 1974), dedicatory page. 35 CP, p. 298. 36 CP, p. 308. 37 38 39 POETRY / A. R. AMMONS When IWas Young the Silk I was young the silk of my mind hard as a peony head When 85
© Copyright 2024 Paperzz