OPTIMAL PRICING WITH RECOMMENDER SYSTEMS
BY
DIRK BERGEMANN AND DERAN OZMEN
COWLES FOUNDATION PAPER NO. 1177
COWLES FOUNDATION FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS
YALE UNIVERSITY
Box 208281
New Haven, Connecticut 06520-8281
2006
http://cowles.econ.yale.edu/
$
! #
" ! ! #
" ! @1BD93E<1B 3ECD?=5B G?E<4 <9;5 G85> C85 B5DEB>C D? D85 G52
C9D5 *85 25CD 5H1=@<5 ?6 CE38 1 CICD5= 9C D81D 5=@<?I54 2I
=1J?>3?= &>35 1 3ECD?=5B =1;5C 1 @EB381C5 D85B5 D85
>5HD D9=5 C85 <?7C ?> D? =1J?>3?= 1 B53?==5>41D9?>
@?@C E@ ?> D85 C3B55> 6?B 85B *85B5 1B5 =1>I ?D85B 9>
D5B>5D C5<<5BC CE38 1C %&-3?= (55<3?= %5DL9H3?=
$?F95#5>C?B7 D81D 5=@<?I C?=5 F5BC9?> ?6 1 B53?==5>45B
CICD5=
B?= 1> 53?>?=93 @?9>D ?6 F95G 1 B53?==5>45B CICD5=
B5@B5C5>DC 1> 9>6?B=1D9?>1< <9>;175 D81D 3B51D5C 1449D9?>1<
CEB@<EC 2I B54E39>7 E>35BD19>DI 6?B D85 3ECD?=5BC > D89C
@1@5B G5 @B5C5>D 1 DG?@5B9?4 DG?@B?4E3D =?45< D81D 45
C3B925C D85 9>D5B13D9?> 25DG55> 1 C5<<5B 5=@<?I9>7 1 C9=@<5
B53?==5>45B CICD5= 1>4 1 3?=@5D9D9F5 6B9>75 G9D8 >? CE38
CICD5= D? 1>1<IJ5 D85 CEB@<EC 3B51D54 2I B53?==5>45B CIC
D5= 1>4 D85 49Q5B5>D 4I>1=93C 9D 75>5B1D5C 9> D85 =1B;5D
*85B5 1B5 ECE1<<I DG? C?EB35C ?6 E>35BD19>DI 9>F?<F54 9>
D85 4539C9?> @B?35CC ?6 1 3ECD?=5B )85 =1I 25 E>CEB5 12?ED
85B D1CD5C 1>4
?B 381B13D5B9CD93C ?6 D85 @B?4E3DC > ?EB
=?45< G5 6?3EC ?><I ?> @B?4E3D E>35BD19>DI 9> D85 ?><9>5
=1B;5D 6?B 8?B9J?>D1<<I 49Q5B5>D91D54 @B?4E3DC G85B5 D85
49Q5B5>35 9> 3ECD?=5BCM D1CD5C DB1>C<1D5 9>D? 49Q5B5>35C 9>
D85 G9<<9>7>5CC D? @1I 6?B 453B51C54 E>35BD19>DI &EB B53?=
=5>45B CICD5= 13DC 1C 1 =5381>9C= D81D 3?<<53DC 3ECD?=5B
5F1<E1D9?>C D8B?E78 G8938 D85 C5<<5B 9>65BC =?B5 9>6?B=1D9?>
12?ED D85 @B?4E3DC (1D85B D81> =?45<<9>7 D85 5F1<E1D9?>
@B?35CC 6?B 5138 3ECD?=5B G5 5=@<?I 1> 9>6?B=1D9?> CDBE3
DEB5 D81D 177B571D5C D85C5 5F1<E1D9?>C 9>D? 1 C9>7<5 C97>1<
D81D D85 C5<<5B B5359F5C ?> 5138 @B?4E3D *85 C5<<5B B5F51<C
G81D5F5B 9>65B5>35 85 =1;5C D? 89C N<?I1<O 3ECD?=5BC D8?C5
G8? 81F5 =145 1 @EB381C5 6B?= 89= 256?B5 *8EC 1 <?I1<
3ECD?=5B 81C D85 381>35 D? =1;5 1 25DD5B 9>6?B=54 38?935
EC9>7 D85 9>65B5>35 B5F51<54 D? 85B 2I D85 B53?==5>45B CIC
D5=
*85 CEB@<EC 3B51D54 2I D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 31> 25
49B53D54 D? 9>3B51C5 C1<5C 1>4
?B 9>3B51C5 @B935C > D89C
@1@5B G5 6?3EC ?> D85 B?<5 ?6 @B935C 2I 1CCE=9>7 D81D 5138
2EI5B 81C E>9D 45=1>4 9> 5138 @5B9?4 -5 C55; D? 1>CG5B
8?G =E38 ?6 D85 CEB@<EC 1 C5<<5B G9D8 1 B53?==5>45B CICD5=
31> 5HDB13D 6B?= 3ECD?=5BC D8B?E78 @B939>7 9> D85 @B5C5>35
?6 1 3?=@5D9D9F5 6B9>75
*85 B53?==5>41D9?> 31> 25 3?>C945B54 1C 1> 144?> 9D 9C
1> 1449D9?>1< C5BF935 1 3ECD?=5B B5359F5C ?> D?@ ?6 D85 @EB
381C5 C85 =1;5C C9=9<1B 9>D5B@B5D1D9?> 1<?>7 D85 C1=5
<9>5C 9C D81D 6EDEB5 B53?==5>41D9?>C 1B5 9>6?B=1D9?> 7??4C
D81D 1B5 2E>4<54 G9D8 3EBB5>D @EB381C5C *85 B53?==5>41
D9?>C 1>4 @B?4E3DC 6?B= @EB5 2E>4<5C 1C 45K>54 2I 41=C
1>4 .5<<5> 9D 9C >?D @?CC92<5 D? @EB381C5 D85 2E>4<5
-5 CDE4I ?@D9=1< @B939>7 9> D85 @B5C5>35 ?6 B53?==5>45B
CICD5=C B53?==5>45B CICD5= 1Q53DC D85 =1B;5D 9> DG?
G1IC 9 9D 3B51D5C F1<E5 2I B54E39>7 @B?4E3D E>35BD19>DI 6?B
D85 3ECD?=5BC 1>4 85>35 99 9DC B53?==5>41D9?>C 31> 25 ?6
65B54 1C 144?>C G8938 75>5B1D5 9>6?B=1D9?>1< 5HD5B>1<9D95C
*85 AE1<9DI ?6 D85 B53?==5>41D9?> 144?> 9C 5>4?75>?EC<I
45D5B=9>54 2I C1<5C -5 9>F5CD971D5 D85 9=@13D ?6 D85C5 613
D?BC ?> D85 ?@D9=1< @B939>7 2I 1 C5<<5B G9D8 1 B53?==5>45B
CICD5= 1719>CD 1 3?=@5D9D9F5 6B9>75 G9D8?ED CE38 1 CICD5=
6 D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 9C CEP395>D<I 5Q53D9F5 9> B5
4E39>7 E>35BD19>DI D85> D85 C5<<5B @B935C ?D85BG9C5 CI==5D
B93 @B?4E3DC 49Q5B5>D<I D? 81F5 C?=5 @B?4E3DC 5H@5B95>354
=?B5 177B5CC9F5<I $?B5?F5B D85 C5<<5B C57=5>DC D85 =1B
;5D C? D81D 3ECD?=5BC G9D8 =?B5 9>L5H92<5 D1CD5C @1I 89785B
@B935C D? 75D 25DD5B B53?==5>41D9?>C
.#$*,%#- )" / &#!. #-!,%+.*, /#$'")$# ,()"( %%!)$#(0 $9C35<<1>5?EC
! /$"%*)' %%!)$#(0 )?391< 1>4 581F9?B1< )39
5>35C
#)#,' #,($1>175=5>D $51CEB5=5>D 5C97> 3?>?=93C *85?BI
*85 9>3B51C54 EC5 ?6 D85 9>D5B>5D 6?B 3?==5B391< DB1>C13
D9?>C <514C D? 1 <1B75 133E=E<1D9?> ?6 41D1 12?ED 3ECD?=5BC
1>4 @B?4E3DC ?> D85 9>D5B>5D > @1BD93E<1B D85 C5<<5BC 31>
51C9<I 2E9<4 <1B75 41D121C5C D81D 3?>C9CD ?6 @5BC?>1<9J54 41D1
?> 1<< D859B 3ECD?=5BC D85 3ECD?=5BCM @1CD @EB381C5C 1>4
D85 6554213; 6B?= D8?C5 @EB381C5C > D89C @1@5B G5 1>1
<IJ5 ?>5 @1BD93E<1B EC5 6?B D85 9>6?B=1D9?> 133E=E<1D54 9>
D85C5 41D121C5C NB53?==5>45B CICD5=CO B53?==5>45B
CICD5= 9C 1 C?6DG1B5 @B?7B1= G8938 EC5C D85 133E=E<1D54
41D1 D? =1;5 CD1D9CD931< 9>65B5>35C 12?ED G81D @B?4E3D 1
(# )) %$ *% #! *" %( ( %& ) % "" %( &(* % * ) -%(! %(
&()%$" %( "))(%%# +) ) ($* - *%+* &(%, ** %& ) (
$%* # %( )*( +* %( &(%* %( %##( " ,$* $ ** %& )
( * ) $%* $ * +"" ** %$ %$ * ()* & % %&. %*(- ) *%
(&+" ) *% &%)* %$ )(,() %( *% ( )*( +* *% " )*) ('+ () &( %( )& &(# )) %$ $%( +$ / $$ (%( $ %&.( * 00
0 43
5<5=5>DC C5@1B1D5<I (53?==5>41D9?>C 8?G5F5B 1B5 49Q5B
5>D 6B?= DI@931< 144?>C 1>4 2E>4<5 5<5=5>DC 2531EC5 D859B
AE1<9DI 9C 45D5B=9>54 5>4?75>?EC<I 2I D85 9>6?B=1D9?> 133E
=E<1D54 D8B?E78 D85 C5<<5BMC C1<5C *8EC D85 C5<<5BMC @B939>7
@B?2<5= 9>3?B@?B1D5C D85 1449D9?>1< >554 D? C5D D85 AE1<9DI
?6 D85 144?> 6?B 5138 @B?4E3D ?@D9=1<<I G8938 9C 5AE9F1
<5>D D? 71D85B9>7 D85 ?@D9=1< 1=?E>D ?6 9>6?B=1D9?> ?> 5138
@B?4E3D *85B56?B5 D85 C5<<5BMC 4E1< @B?2<5= ?6 G81D =1B
;5D C81B5 D? 31@DEB5 1>4 8?G D? 49CDB92ED5 D85 2EI5BC ?F5B
49Q5B5>D @B?4E3DC 5>D19<C 9>6?B=1D9?>1< 5HD5B>1<9D95C *85C5
5HD5B>1<9D95C 31> 25 C5@1B1D54 9>D? DG? 5<5=5>DC *85 KBCD
5<5=5>D 9C G81D G5 31<< D85 NF?<E=5 5HD5B>1<9DIO *89C 5H
D5B>1<9DI B5@B5C5>DC D85 75>5B1< 3??B49>1D9?> 5<5=5>D 9>85B
5>D 9> D85 @B?2<5= G8938 9C D81D 1C D85 C5<<5B 81C =?B5
3ECD?=5BC 85 G9<< 25 12<5 D? =1;5 25DD5B B53?==5>41D9?>C
1>4 D8EC 1DDB13D =?B5 3ECD?=5BC *89C 5<5=5>D 45D5B=9>5C
8?G =E38 ?6 D85 =1B;5D D85 C5<<5B G?E<4 <9;5 D? 31@DEB5
*85 C53?>4 ?>5 9C D85 N@B?4E3D 5HD5B>1<9DIO *89C 5HD5B>1<
9DI B5<1D5C D? D85 49CDB92ED9?> ?6 2EI5BC G9D89> ?>5 C5<<5B ?F5B
49Q5B5>D @B?4E3DC 6 D85B5 1B5 1 <?D ?6 3ECD?=5BC 2EI9>7 ?>5
@1BD93E<1B @B?4E3D 9> ?>5 @5B9?4 ?D85BC =1I 25 G9<<9>7 D?
45<1I D85 @EB381C5 ?6 D81D @B?4E3D 1>4 25 49B53D54 D? ?D85B
@B?4E3DC 6?B D81D @5B9?4 *85 CDB5>7D8 ?6 D89C 5Q53D 45D5B
=9>5C G85D85B D85 C5<<5B DB95C D? 133E=E<1D5 5AE1< 1=?E>DC
?6 9>6?B=1D9?> ?> 5138 @B?4E3D ?B G85D85B D85B5 1B5 9>3B51C
9>7 B5DEB>C D? 9>6?B=1D9?> C? D81D D85 C5<<5B DB95C D? 9>4E35
<1B75 F?<E=5 ?6 2EI5BC D? 2EI C?=5 @B?4E3DC 1>4 @B?F945 9>
6?B=1D9?> 1D D85 5H@5>C5 ?6 ?D85B @B?4E3DC ?> G8938 C=1<<5B
F?<E=5 ?6 9>6?B=1D9?> 9C 71D85B54
*85 F?<E=5 1>4 @B?4E3D 5HD5B>1<9D95C 253?=5 CDB?>75B 1C
D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= @5B6?B=C 25DD5B 9> B54E39>7 E>35B
D19>DI -5 K>4 D81D G85> D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= B54E35C
E>35BD19>DI ?><I 2I 1 C=1<< 1=?E>D D85> D85 C5<<5B @B565BC
D? 71D85B 5AE1< 1=?E>D ?6 9>6?B=1D9?> ?> CI==5DB93 @B?4
E3DC 2I @B939>7 D85= E>96?B=<I *85 2EI5BC G9D8 CEP395>D<I
8978 G9<<9>7>5CC D? @1I 6?B B54E354 E>35BD19>DI 17B55 D? @1I
D89C @B935 D? 25>5KD 6B?= D85 B53?==5>41D9?> C5BF935 1>4
D85 ?D85BC C9=@<I 453<9>5 D89C C5BF935 1>4 @EB381C5 6B?= D85
6B9>75 ?B 5H1=@<5 3?>C945B D85 2??; =1B;5D )E@@?C5
DG? >?F5<C N?E2<5 ?=93945O 1>4 N*85 (?3;I (?14 D?
(?=1>35O 1B5 9>DB?4E354 6?B C1<5 1D D85 C1=5 D9=5 D 9C
F5BI 3<51B D81D D85 KBCD ?>5 9C 1 =ICD5BI 1>4 D85 C53?>4 ?>5
9C 1 B?=1>35 >?F5< 5>35 D85B5 G9<< >?D 25 =1>I 2EI5BC
G9<<9>7 D? @1I 1 @B5=9E= D? B5359F5 9>6?B=1D9?> ?> D85 DI@5
?6 59D85B >?F5< *85B5 9C >?D =E38 D85 C5<<5B 31> 719> 2I
C@5549>7 E@ D85 9>6?B=1D9?> 133E=E<1D9?> 85>35 85 @B935C
D85 @B?4E3DC C9=9<1B<I
&EB B5CE<DC C8?G D81D 1C D85 @5B6?B=1>35 ?6 D85 B53?=
=5>45B CICD5= 9>3B51C5C D85 C5<<5B 9=@<5=5>DC 49Q5B5>D91<
@B939>7 G8938 C57=5>DC D85 =1B;5D CE38 D81D C?=5 @B?4E3DC
1B5 5H@5B95>354 2I 1 <1B75B 7B?E@ ?6 2EI5BC D81> ?D85BC *85
2EI5BC G9D8 8978 G9<<9>7>5CC D? @1I 6?B B54E354 E>35BD19>DI
38??C5 D? 25 9> D85 C=1<<5B 7B?E@ D? 25 12<5 D? EC5 D85 9>
6?B=1D9?> @B?F9454 2I D85 <1B75 7B?E@ *8?C5 G9D8 D85 <?G
G9<<9>7>5CC D? @1I 38??C5 D? 25 9> D85 <1B75B 7B?E@ D? 25>5KD
6B?= D85 <?G5B @B935 > C?=5 31C5C D89C @B935 9C C? <?G D81D
9D 9=@<95C 1 <?CC 6?B D85 C5<<5B ?> D81D @1BD93E<1B @B?4E3D
*85 C5<<5B 9C G9<<9>7 D? 251B D89C <?CC 2531EC5 D85 9>6?B=1
D9?> 71D85B54 1<<?GC 89= D? CE2C949J5 9D D8B?E78 CEP395>D<I
89785B @B935C ?> ?D85B @B?4E3DC #5D EC 3?>C945B D85 2??;
=1B;5D 1719> )E@@?C5 N*85 )I=5 '1@5BCO 1>4 N!?>1D81>
)DB1>75 $B %?BB5<< %?F5<O 1B5 2?D8 >5G B5<51C5C
2I >5G 1ED8?BC *85C5 D9D<5C 3<51B<I 4? >?D B5F51< 1>I B5<5
F1>D 9>6?B=1D9?> 12?ED D85 DI@5 ?6 D85C5 2??;C ECD?=5BC
G8? 1B5 F5BI @1BD93E<1B 12?ED D85 DI@5 ?6 2??; D85I B514
D? G?E<4 25 G9<<9>7 D? @1I 1 @B5=9E= 6?B =?B5 9>6?B=1D9?>
256?B5 D85I =1;5 D859B @EB381C5C *? 5HDB13D D89C @B5=9E=
D85 C5<<5B >554C D? 71D85B 5>?E78 9>6?B=1D9?> ?> 1D <51CD ?>5
2??; 5>35 85 D1B75DC ?>5 ?6 D85 DG? 2??;C 381B75C 1 <?G5B
@B935 6?B D81D D? C@554 E@ D85 9>6?B=1D9?> 133E=E<1D9?>
-5 9>F5CD971D5 D85 C57=5>D1D9?> 9> D85 =1B;5D 6EBD85B
> ?EB =?45< D85 3ECD?=5BC 49Q5B 2?D8 9> D85 DI@5 ?6 @B?4
E3D D85I @B565B 1>4 1<C? 9> D85 9>D5>C9DI ?6 D859B @B565B5>35
)?=5 2EI5BC 1B5 =?B5 L5H92<5 9> D859B 38?935C D81> ?D8
5BC D 9C D85 2EI5BC G9D8 9>L5H92<5 D1CD5C G8? B51<<I 25>5KD
6B?= D85 B53?==5>41D9?> C5BF935 *85 9>D5B5CD9>7 AE5CD9?>
D85> 253?=5C G85D85B D85 C5<<5B C57=5>DC 3ECD?=5BC ?6 ?>5
DI@5 ?6 @B?4E3D 6B?= D85 3ECD?=5BC ?6 D85 ?D85B DI@5 ?B
G85D85B 85 C57=5>DC D85 9>L5H92<5 3ECD?=5BC ?6 2?D8 DI@5C
6B?= D85 L5H92<5 2EI5BC -5 K>4 D81D D85 6?B=5B ;9>4 ?6
C57=5>D1D9?> ?33EBC G85> D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 81C 1
<?G @5B6?B=1>35 1>4 D85 <1DD5B ?33EBC G85> 9D 81C 1 8978
@5B6?B=1>35
*85 B?14 =1@ 9C 1C 6?<<?GC -5 49C3ECC D85 B5<1D54 <9D
5B1DEB5 9> )53D9?> *85 =?45< 9C 45C3B9254 9> )53D9?> > )53D9?> G5 1>1<IJ5 D85 ?@D9=1< @B939>7 @?<93I 1>4 D85
B5CE<D9>7 5AE9<92B9E= 1<<?31D9?> )53D9?> 3?>3<E45C 2I 49C
3ECC9>7 @?CC92<5 5HD5>C9?>C 6?B 6EDEB5 B5C51B38
*85C5 >?F5<C 1B5 >5G B5<51C5C D81D 31> 25 6?E>4 ?> =1
J?>3?=
*85C5 2??;C 31> 25 6?E>4 ?> =1J?>3?=MC G52C9D5 1C
G5<<
*85 @?CC929<9DI ?6 9>3B51C9>7 C1<5C D8B?E78 B53?==5>45B
CICD5=C 81C 255> 4?3E=5>D54 2I 85F1<95B 1>4 $1IJ<9>
*85I 5=@9B931<<I 9>F5CD971D5 D85 9=@13D ?6 3ECD?=5B
B5F95GC ?> C1<5C ?6 2??;C 9> =1J?>3?= 1>4 1B>5C1>4%?
2<53?= *85I K>4 D81D D85 B5<1D9F5 =1B;5D C81B5 ?6 1 2??;
13B?CC D85 DG? C9D5C 9C B5<1D54 D? 49Q5B5>35C 13B?CC D85 C9D5C
9> D85 >E=25B ?6 B5F95GC 6?B D85 2??; *89C 5>6?B35C D85 9451
D81D D85 F?<E=5 ?6 B5F95GC 81C 1 @?C9D9F5 9=@13D ?> C1<5C
*85 @?CC929<9DI ?6 1> 5HDB13D9?> D8B?E78 @B935C 1B9C5C 4E5
D? D85 <?I1<DI 613D?B =5>D9?>54 12?F5 EDEB5 B53?==5>41
D9?>C =978D 25 3?>C945B54 1C 144?>C D? 3EBB5>D @EB381C5C
6B?= 1 C5<<5B G9D8 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 5>35 2EI5BC =1I
17B55 D? @1I 89785B @B935C 6?B D85 @B?4E3DC D85I @EB381C5
6B?= 1 C5<<5B G9D8 1 B53?==5>45B CICD5= D?41I C? D81D D85I
31> B5359F5 B53?==5>41D9?>C 9> D85 6EDEB5 BI>:?<6CC?>
1>4 )=9D8 MC 5=@9B931< 9>F5CD971D9?> ?6 3?>CE=5B 25
81F9?B 1D 9>D5B>5D C8?@2?DC 6?B 2??;C @B?F945 5F945>35 6?B
5H9CD5>35 ?6 CE38 2581F9?B 2I 3?>CE=5BC *85I K>4 D81D
?><9>5 2??; 2EI5BC 1B5 G9<<9>7 D? @1I 1 @?C9D9F5 @B5=9E= D?
@EB381C5 6B?= D85 C5<<5BC D85I 81F5 59D85B F9C9D54 ?B C8?@@54
1D 256?B5 &>5 9>D5B@B5D1D9?> ?6 D89C @B5=9E= 9C D81D 9D 9C
D85 655 6?B D85 9>6?B=1D9?> D85 C5<<5BC C5<< D8B?E78 D85 B53
?==5>45B CICD5= D? <?I1< 3ECD?=5BC *85C5 5=@9B931< 613DC
31> CE@@?BD D85 B?<5 ?6 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 9> 9>3B51C9>7
2?D8 D85 C1<5C 1>4 @B935C
,1B91> 1>4 (5C>93; 79F5 1 2B956 45C3B9@D9?> ?6 B53
?==5>45B CICD5=C 1>4 D85 9CCE5C D85I B19C5 *85I 5H@<19>
D81D D85 <1B75B D85 3ECD?=5B 21C5 ?6 1 B53?==5>45B CIC
D5= D85 =?B5 3ECD?=5BC G?E<4 25 G9<<9>7 D? EC5 9D G8938
9C 5AE9F1<5>D D? G81D G5 51B<95B 45C3B9254 1C D85 NF?<E=5
5HD5B>1<9DIO
44
*85 1>1<IC9C ?6 B53?==5>45B CICD5=C 9>85B9DC C?=5 651
DEB5C 6B?= D85 <9D5B1DEB5 ?> @B?4E3D 144?>C 1>4 =E<D9
@B?4E3D 2E>4<9>7 > D85 <9D5B1DEB5 D85B5 81F5 255> =1>I
49Q5B5>D B51C?>C 79F5> D? G8I 1 =?>?@?<9CD =978D @B565B D?
2E>4<5 89C @B?4E3DC @@5> 1>C?> 1>4 $1BD9> 41=C 1>4 .5<<5> )38=1<5>C55 CE775CD B51
C?>C CE38 1C 3?CD C1F9>7C 3?=@<5=5>D1B9D95C 25DG55> 496
65B5>D @B?4E3DC ?B 5HDB13D9?> ?6 =?B5 3?>CE=5B CEB@<EC 1C
D85B5 G9<< 25 <5CC 49F5BC9DI 9> D85 F1<E1D9?>C ?6 D85 3?>CE=5BC
6?B D85 2E>4<5C 3?=@1B54 D? D85 F1<E1D9?>C 6?B 9>49F94E1<
@B?4E3DC > ?EB =?45< D85B5 9C 1 CDB1D5793 B51C?> 2589>4
2E>4<9>7 *85 C5<<5B 9C ?Q5B9>7 1> 9>6?B=1D9?> 7??4 >?D @B?
F9454 2I 89C 3?=@5D9D?BC ?G5F5B D85 F1<E5 ?6 D89C 7??4
45@5>4C ?> D85 F?<E=5 ?6 89C C1<5C ?6 D85 =19> @B?4E3D 6
85 E>2E>4<5C ?> D85 @B?4E3D C945 85 =978D <?C5 2EI5BC D?
?D85B C5<<5BC G8938 453B51C5C D85 F1<E5 ?6 D85 9>6?B=1D9?>
7??4 85 9C ?Q5B9>7 &EB B5CE<DC 1>4 =5D8?4?<?7I G?E<4 1@
@<I D? =?B5 75>5B1< C5DD9>7C D81D 9>F?<F5 3?=@5D9D9F5 C1<5C
?6 @EB5 2E>4<5C G85B5 D85 F1<E5 ?6 1D <51CD ?>5 5<5=5>D 9>
D85 2E>4<5 9C 45D5B=9>54 2I D85 ?F5B1<< C1<5C
> 3?=@ED5B C395>35 D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5=C G5 49C
3ECC 85B5 1B5 6?B=1<<I ;>?G> 1C N3?<<12?B1D9F5 K<D5B9>7 CIC
D5=CO *85 N >D5B>5D ?=@ED9>7 >4ECDBI (5@?BDO
45C3B925C D81D =1J?>3?= EC5C 1 =?49K54 3?<<12?B1D9F5
K<D5B9>7 =5D8?4 B565BB54 D? 1C D85 N9D5=D?9D5= 21C54 3?<
<12?B1D9F5 K<D5B9>7O *89C =5D8?4 3?=@ED5C 1 C9=9<1B9DI
=51CEB5 25DG55> D85 9D5=C B1D85B D81> D85 3ECD?=5BC 1>4
D85> B53?==5>4C D85 9D5=C C9=9<1B D? G81D 1 3ECD?=5B 81C
@EB381C54 256?B5 B55C5 53;5B=1> 1>4 "1495 $9<4 1>4 %1DD5B 1>4 >C1B9 CC57195B 1>4 "?8<9
45C3B925 1>4 3?=@1B5 ?D85B =5D8?4C ?6 @B5493D9?>
G8938 B1>75 6B?= 1I5C91> =5D8?4C ?6 5CD9=1D9?> D? 3<1C
C93 <9>51B B57B5CC9?> =?45<C > 1<< D85C5 31C5C D85 @8IC931<
@B?354EB5 ?6 =1;9>7 EC5 ?6 ?D85B 3ECD?=5BC B1D9>7C D? =1;5
1 B53?==5>41D9?> D? 1 3ECD?=5B 5H@<939D<I B5F51<C 8?G D85
5HD5B>1<9DI 9C 9>3?B@?B1D54 9>D? D85 @B?2<5= > D89C @1@5B
G5 D1;5 D85 3?<<12?B1D9F5 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 1C 79F5> 1>4
=?45< D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= C? 1C D? 75>5B1D5 C?=5 ?6
D85 5HD5B>1<9DI 5Q53DC 9>85B5>D 9> 3?<<12?B1D9F5 K<D5B9>7
Period 0
Period 1
Two products
Prices
Decisions
Evaluations
New product
Prices
Decisions
arrive
announced
made
collected
arrives
announced
made
Recommendations
made
*' )"!#
45>?D54 2I 9> D85 ?><9>5 =1B;5D 6?B 1 @1BD93E<1B @B?4E3D
7B?E@ -9D89> D85 =1B;5D D85B5 1B5 DG? 49Q5B5>D DI@5C ?6
D85 @B?4E3D 45>?D54 2I *85B5 9C 1 3?>D9>EE=
?6 2EI5BC 9> G9D8 E>9D =1CC G85B5 5138 2EI5B 9C
381B13D5B9J54 2I 89C @B565B5>35 9C 49CDB92ED54
E>96?B=<I 9> *85 7B?CC ED9<9DI 1 2EI5B ?6 DI@5 45B9F5C 6B?= 1 DI@5 @B?4E3D 9C C@539K54 1C
C 1> 5H1=@<5 3?>C945B D85 @B?4E3D <9>5 D? 25 2??;C
*85> D85 DG? DI@5C ?6 D85 @B?4E3D 31> B5@B5C5>D N=ICD5BIO
F5BCEC NB?=1>35O >?F5<C -5 31> 3?>C945B D85 2EI5BC G9D8
@B565B5>35 @1B1=5D5BC 3<?C5 D? ?B 1C N9>L5H92<5O 1>4
2EI5BC G9D8 @B565B5>35 @1B1=5D5B 3<?C5 D? 1C NL5H92<5O
2531EC5 D85 6?B=5B 7B?E@ G?E<4 9>C9CD ?> D859B 61F?B9D5 ;9>4
?6 2??; G85B51C D85 <1DD5B 7B?E@ G?E<4 >?D 25 14F5BC5 D?
DBI9>7 ?D85B ;9>4C > 1 =?B5 75>5B1< 3?>D5HD 9D 9C D85 6?B
=5B 7B?E@ G8? 81C =?B5 D? <?C5 96 D85I 75D 1 @B?4E3D G9D8
1 DI@5 6EBD85B 6B?= D859B D1CD5 G85B51C D85 <1DD5B 7B?E@MC
ED9<9DI 453B51C5C 2I <9DD<5 9> D81D C9DE1D9?> *89C =51>C D85
L5H92<5 2EI5BC 3?E<4 @?D5>D91<<I 25 D85 5H@5B9=5>D5BC ?6 >5G
@B?4E3DC 96 D85I 1B5 79F5> 5>?E78 9>35>D9F5C
*85 AE14B1D93 ED9<9DI =?45< 9C 38?C5> 6?B 3?=@ED1D9?>1<
51C5 1>4 1>I ED9<9DI 6E>3D9?> G8938 453B51C5C 9> D85 49CD1>35
25DG55> D85 9451< @B?4E3D DI@5 1>4 D85 3EBB5>D @B?4E3D DI@5
G?E<4 75>5B1D5 D85 C1=5 AE1<9D1D9F5 B5CE<DC
"# # $( *85B5 1B5 DG? @5B9?4C G9D8 L?G
?6 @B?4E3DC 1>4 D85B5 9C E>35BD19>DI 12?ED D859B DI@5C *85
C5<<5BC 1>4 2EI5BC C81B5 1 3?==?> @B9?B ?> D85C5 @B?4E3DCM
DI@5C > @5B9?4 DG? @B?4E3DC 1BB9F5 1D 1<< C5<<5BC 45>?D54
2I 1>4 *85C5 @B?4E3DC 1B5 49Q5B5>D91D54 ?><I G9D8
B5C@53D D? D85 @B9?BC 1DD13854 D? D85= #5D 25 D85 DBE5 DI@5 ?6 @B?4E3D 1>4 -5 1CCE=5 D81D D85 DG? @B?4E3DC 1BB9F5 G9D8 E>35BD19>DI
CI==5DB93 1B?E>4 > D89C C53D9?> G5 9>DB?4E35 1 DG?@5B9?4 =?45< G85B5 1
C5<<5B G9D8 1 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 1>4 1 6B9>75 G9D8 >? CE38
CICD5= 3?=@5D5 9> @B935C 9> 1 =1B;5D 6?B 8?B9J?>D1<<I 49Q5B
5>D91D54 @B?4E3DC > D89C =1B;5D D85B5 1B5 DG? DI@5C ?6 D85
@B?4E3D 1>4 1 3?>D9>EE= ?6 2EI5BC > @5B9?4 DG? 49Q5B5>D
@B?4E3DC 1B5 ?Q5B54 2I D85 C5<<5BC *85 C5<<5BC 1>4 D85 2EI
5BC C81B5 1 3?==?> @B9?B 12?ED D85 DI@5 ?6 5138 @B?4E3D
*85C5 @B?4E3DC 1B5 49Q5B5>D91D54 ?><I G9D8 B5C@53D D? D85
@B9?B D85I 1BB9F5 G9D8 138 2EI5B 38??C5C 1 @B?4E3D D? 2EI
1>4 1 C5<<5B D? 2EI 6B?= 9> @5B9?4 *85 C5<<5B G9D8 B53
?==5>45B CICD5= 3?<<53DC 9>6?B=1D9?> 6B?= 89C 3ECD?=5BC
12?ED D85 @B?4E3DC @EB381C54 6B?= 89= 9> @5B9?4 > D85
C53?>4 @5B9?4 85 B5F51<C D89C 9>6?B=1D9?> 1C B53?==5>41
D9?>C D? D85 2EI5BC G8? @EB381C54 6B?= 89= 9> @5B9?4 >
D85 C53?>4 @5B9?4 1 >5G @B?4E3D 1BB9F5C 1D 1<< C5<<5BC 1>4
2EI5BC 1719> 38??C5 1 @B?4E3D 1>4 1 C5<<5B D? 2EI 6B?= 79F5>
D859B B53?==5>41D9?>C 2EI5BMC @B?4E3D 38?935 > @5B9?4
5138 2EI5B 453945C 25DG55> 1 >5G @B?4E3D 1>4 1 @B?4E3D
G8938 C85 494 >?D @EB381C5 9> @5B9?4 G85B5 5>35 D85 9>9D91< @B9?BC 1B5 49Q5B5>D91D54
2I G8938 G5 G9<< B565B D? 1C D85 N9>9D91< 9>6?B=1D9?>O *85
CI==5DBI @5B=9DC EC D? B5@B5C5>D D85 9>9D91< 9>6?B=1D9?> 2I
1 ?>549=5>C9?>1< @1B1=5D5B 2ED D85 CI==5DBI 2I 9DC5<6 9C
>?D 5CC5>D91< 6?B 59D85B D85 1>1<IC9C ?B D85 B5CE<DC D? 3?=5
> @5B9?4 1 >5G @B?4E3D 1BB9F5C G9D8 @B9?B 1D 1<< C5<<5BC > @5B9?4 >59D85B D85 2EI5BC >?B
D85 C5<<5BC ;>?G G81D D85 5H13D F1<E5 ?6 G9<< 25 9> @5B9?4
2ED D85I 1DD138 @B?2129<9DI D? 259>7 1>4 *85
@B?4E3DC 1>4 3?>D9>E5 D? 25 1F19<12<5 9> @5B9?4 *85 =1B79>1< 3?CD ?6 5138 @B?4E3D 6?B 1<< C5<<5BC 9C -5
1CCE=5 D81D D85 @B935 6?B 5138 @B?4E3D 9> D85 3?=@5D9D9F5
' ) *85B5 9C ?>5 C5<<5B G9D8 1 B53?==5>45B CICD5=
45>?D54 2I 1>4 1 3?=@5D9D9F5 6B9>75 G9D8 >? CE38 CICD5=
45
1<< 2EI5BC D8EC 5138 2EI5B <?7C ?>D? 1<< G52C9D5C 1>4 ?2
C5BF5C 1<< @B935C 1>4 D85> C9=E<D1>5?EC<I 38??C5C 1 @B?4E3D
D? @EB381C5 1>4 1 C5<<5B D? 2EI 6B?= > @5B9?4 C5<<5B 1>>?E>35C @B935C 6?B 5138 @B?4E3D
1>4 B5F51<C D85 B53?==5>41D9?>C D? D85
2EI5BC G8? 81F5 @EB381C54 6B?= 89= 9> @5B9?4 *85 B53
?==5>41D9?> ?6 1 2EI5B G8? @EB381C54 9C 1 B5@?BD
12?ED D85 @B?4E3D C85 494 >?D @EB381C5 I5D 95 1> 5CD9=1D5
12?ED D85 F1<E5 ?6 9F5> D85 B53?==5>41D9?>
1>4 D85 @B935C 5138 2EI5B D85> 453945C G85D85B D? @EB381C5
D85 >5G @B?4E3D ?B D85 @B?4E3D C85 494 >?D @EB381C5 9>
@5B9?4 %?D935 D81D 1 2EI5B 31> 75D D85 B53?==5>41D9?>
6B?= C5<<5B 1>4 CD9<< @EB381C5 6B?= D85 6B9>75 9> @5B9?4 2531EC5 C51B38 3?CDC 1B5 J5B?
6B9>75 5AE1<C 138 2EI5B 2EIC 1D =?CD ?>5 @B?4E3D 5138
@5B9?4 $?B5?F5B 1 2EI5B G9C85C D? 2EI 1 49Q5B5>D @B?4E3D
5138 @5B9?4 -5 1CCE=5 D81D @5B @5B9?4 ?EDC945 ED9<9DI 6?B
5138 2EI5B 9C C=1<<5B D81> C? D81D 12C5>D 1 25DD5B
?Q5B 6B?= D85 C5<<5B G9D8 D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 5138
2EI5B 9C G9<<9>7 D? 2EI ?>5 @B?4E3D 9> 5138 @5B9?4 6B?= D85
6B9>75
'## 5DG55> @5B9?4C 1>4 C5<<5B B5359F5C
9>6?B=1D9?> 6?B= 89C 2EI5BC -5 177B571D5 D85 9>6?B=1D9?>
1C 6?<<?GC #5D 45>?D5 D85 =51CEB5 ?6 2EI5BC G8? 2EI
@B?4E3D 6B?= C5<<5B 9> @5B9?4 )5<<5B B5359F5C 1 B1>4?= C97>1< ! ?> D85 DI@5 ?6
5138 @B?4E3D 25DG55> @5B9?4C 1>4 G85B5
! ! #)'%'))$# *85B5 1B5 DG? @B?4E3DC 1BB9F9>7 G9D8
CI==5DB93 E>35BD19>DI 1DD13854 9> @5B9?4 8978 =51>C
D85B5 9C <5CC E>35BD19>DI 12?ED 5138 @B?4E3DMC DI@5 1>4 D81D
D85 DG? @B?4E3DC 1B5 8978<I 49Q5B5>D91D54 <?G =51>C
E>35BD19>DI 9C 8978 6?B 2?D8 @B?4E3DC 1>4 D81D 9>9D91<<I D85
DG? @B?4E3DC <??; C9=9<1B > D5B=C ?6 D85 2??;C 5H1=@<5 1
8978 G?E<4 =51> D81D 59D85B D85 2??;C 81F5 F5BI B5F51<9>7
D9D<5C ?B D85 1ED8?BCM CDI<5C 1B5 F5BI G5<< ;>?G> )9=9<1B<I
1 <?G 31> 25 75>5B1D54 2I F5BI F17E5 D9D<5C 1>4
?B >5G
1ED8?BC
*8B?E78 D85 C97>1< CDBE3DEB5 G5 45C3B9254 9> 97EB5 C5<<5B 719>C 9>6?B=1D9?> 12?ED D85 DI@5 ?6 D85 DG? @B?4
E3DC )E@@?C5 1 2EI5B 2EIC @B?4E3D 6B?= C5<<5B 9>
@5B9?4 *85> 9> @5B9?4 85B 38?935 C5D 9C *85 B53
?==5>45B CICD5= CE@@<95C 9>6?B=1D9?> D? D85 2EI5B 12?ED
MC DI@5 5>35 D85 2EI5B 31> =1;5 1 25DD5B 9>6?B=54 38?935
25DG55> 1>4 *89C 45C3B925C D85 3?>DB92ED9?> ?6 B53?=
=5>45B CICD5= 1>4 8?G 9D 3B51D5C 1449D9?>1< CEB@<EC *85
5HD5>D ?6 D89C 3?>DB92ED9?> 45@5>4C ?> 1>4 #5D
1>4 G5 9>D5B@B5D 1C D85 N@5B6?B=1>35 ?6 D85 B53?==5>45B
CICD5=O *85 B51C?> 9C D81D G85> 9C 8978 D85 C97>1<C 1B5
=?B5 @B539C5 1>4 D8EC D85 E@41D9>7 G9<< 25 =?B5 3B9D931< 6?B
D85 2EI5BCM 38?935C 1>4 G85> 9C <?G D85 @B?4E3DC 1B5 D??
E>;>?G> 1>4 1>I >5G 9>6?B=1D9?> 9C F5BI F1<E12<5 *8EC 1
8978 13DE1<<I 9>3B51C5C D85 5Q53D ?6 B53?==5>45B CICD5=
9> B54E39>7 E>35BD19>DI
97EB5 C8?GC D81D D85 @B?2129<9DI ?6 B5359F9>7 1 C97>1<
?> 1 @B?4E3D 9>3B51C5C 9> D85 =51CEB5 ?6 2EI5BC 2EI9>7 D81D
@B?4E3D *89C 31@DEB5C D85 5Q53D D81D 1C 1 C5<<5B 81C =?B5
3ECD?=5BC D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= G9<< 81F5 =?B5 9>@ED
1>4 =1;5 25DD5B B53?==5>41D9?>C
-5 31> 9>D5B@B5D 1 C97>1< ?6 1C 3?>D19>9>7 >? 9>6?B=1D9?>
?B C9=@<I D85 619<EB5 D? B5359F5 1> 9>6?B=1D9F5 C97>1< 9F5>
D81D D85 C5<<5B B5359F5C 1 B5<5F1>D C97>1< D85 @B?2129<9DI ?6
D85 C97>1< 259>7 3?BB53D 9C
! ! G85B5 -5 31> 9>D5B@B5D 1C D85 9>6?B=1D9F5>5CC
?6 D85 C97>1< *85 5F5>D DB55 9> 97EB5 CE==1B9J5C D85
C97>1< CDBE3DEB5 G85B5 Signal Arrival
Signal Precision
½+ γҏ
μi
yi
½– γҏ
1 – μi
xi
x' i
0
*' #! )'*)*'
9F5> D85 @B?2129<9CD93 CDBE3DEB5 G5 F95G D85 B53?==5>45B
CICD5= 1C 1 =5381>9C= D81D 3?=@ED5C D85 @?CD5B9?B 25<956C
6?B 5138 @B?4E3D 21C54 ?> D85 C97>1< ! 1>4 B5@?BDC D85=
?><I D? D85 2EI5BC G8? 81F5 2?E78D 6B?= 89= 9> @5B9?4 *85 @?CD5B9?B 6?B @B?4E3D 79F5> C97>1< ! G9<< 25 45>?D54
2I
! ! > D89C C53D9?> G5 9>F5CD971D5 D85 '5B653D 1I5C91> AE9
<92B91 ?6 D85 71=5 25DG55> C5<<5B 1>4 D85 2EI5BC *85
C5<<5B 1>>?E>35C 1 @B935 6?B 5138 @B?4E3D 9> @5B9?4 1>4
5138 2EI5B ?@D9=1<<I 38??C5C 1 C5<<5B 1>4 1 @B?4E3D 79F5> D85
@B935C D 9C 5>D9B5<I CDB1978D6?BG1B4 D? K>4 D85 5AE9<92B9E=
96 D85B5 9C >? B53?==5>45B CICD5= G8938 9C 5AE9F1<5>D D?
?B > 59D85B ?6 D85C5 31C5C C5<<5B 1>4 6B9>75
1B5 5Q53D9F5<I C5<<9>7 945>D931< @B?4E3DC *85 3?=@5D9
D9?> 9C K5B35 1>4 D85 5AE9<92B9E= @B935 G9<< 81F5 D? 5AE1< D85
=1B79>1< 3?CD -85> G5 9>DB?4E35 C?=5 E>35BD19>DI 1>4
9>6?B=1D9F5>5CC 9>D? D85 C5DD9>7 D85 49CDB92ED9?> ?6 2EI5BC
9> @5B9?4 1Q53DC D85 9>6?B=1D9?> 71D85B54 1>4 85>35 D85
ED9<9D95C 9> @5B9?4 C C5<<5B 81C D85 C?<5 3?>DB?< ?F5B D85
-5 1CCE=5 D81D ?><I 2EI5BC G8938 2?E78D 6B?= C5<<5B 25>5KD 6B?= D85 9>6?B=1D9?> ?6 C5<<5B *89C =978D C55=
D? 25 9=@?BD1>D B5CDB93D9?> B5<1D9F5 D? D85 3EBB5>D @B13D935
?6 C?=5 B53?==5>45B CICD5=C G8? @B?F945 9>6?B=1D9?> 5F5>
D? >5G 3ECD?=5BC ?G5F5B G5 ?2C5BF5 D81D 1<< G5 >554 6?B
D85 @B939>7 =?45< 85B5 9C D81D @1CD 3ECD?=5BC B5359F5 CD1
D9CD931<<I =?B5 F1<E12<5 9>6?B=1D9?> D81> >5G 3ECD?=5B >
=1>I B53?==5>45B CICD5=C D89C ?33EBC D8B?E78 @5BC?>1<
9J54 B53?==5>41D9?>C
'# > @5B9?4 C5<<5B 1>>?E>35C @B935C 6?B 5138
@B?4E3D 95 *85 C51B38 3?CD 9C J5B? 6?B
46
49CDB92ED9?> ?6 2EI5BC 9> @5B9?4 85 3?>DB?<C 8?G =E38 9>
6?B=1D9?> 9C 71D85B54 6?B @5B9?4 > @5B9?4 C5<<5B D85>
B5F51<C D85 9>6?B=1D9?> 85 81C 71D85B54 1>4 1>>?E>35C >5G
@B935C *85 613D D81D D85 C5<<5B 31> =1;5 D85 9>6?B=1D9?>
49CDB92ED9?> 3?>49D9?>1< ?> @5B9?4 @EB381C5C 1<<?GC 89= D?
381B75 D85 2EI5BC 9> @5B9?4 6?B D85 9>6?B=1D9?> D85I G9<<
B5359F5 9> @5B9?4 *85B56?B5 85 =1I 5HDB13D C?=5 ?6 D85
9>6?B=1D9?>1< 25>5KDC D8B?E78 89785B @B935C *89C 79F5C 89=
9>35>D9F5C D? 38??C5 89C @B939>7 C385=5 D? 3?<<53D 9>6?B=1
D9?> -5 G9<< CD1BD 1>1<IJ9>7 MC @B?2<5= G9D8 D85 CE271=5
9> @5B9?4 -1
1
h
l
SORTED
-1
l
1
h
l
SHUFFLED
*' $')# # *-# $' ,44) ! "$
!+( /,0,/7/ 24,&( ,0 6+( /$4-(6 ,0 2(4,1' ,0 $0; 2(4)(&6
$;(5,$0 (37,.,%4,7/ (37$.5 /$4*,0$. &156 )14 ($&+ 241'7&6
-1
0
l
*89C <5==1 9C 4E5 D? D85 613D D81D 1 2EI5B 31> 75D D85
B53?==5>41D9?> 6B?= C5<<5B 1>4 I5D @EB381C5 6B?= D85
6B9>75 79F5> D85 B53?==5>41D9?> *85 C5BF935C 1<< C5<<5BC
@B?F945 1B5 945>D931< 9> @5B9?4 1>4 D85 3?=@5D9D9?> 9C 1D
D85 5BDB1>4 <5F5< *85 9>D5B5CD9>7 @1BD ?6 D85 @B?2<5= 9C
@5B9?4 @B935C
-5 KBCD 5H1=9>5 D85 CE271=5 @<1I54 25DG55> D85 2EI5BC
16D5B C5<<5B 1>>?E>35C 9F5> D85 49Q5B5>35
25DG55> D85 DG? @B935C D85 49CDB92ED9?> ?6 2EI5BC 3?E<4 25
49Q5B5>D *85 6?<<?G9>7 DG? @B?@5BD95C ?6 D85 49CDB92ED9?> ?6
2EI5BC ?F5B @B?4E3DC G9<< 25 35>DB1< 6?B D85 45D5B=9>1D9?>
?6 D85 5AE9<92B9E=
h
1
h
F
SORTED WITH A GAP
-1
1
l
F
h
h
l
SHUFFLED WITH A GAP
*' $')# # *-# +) %
97EB5 1>4 9<<ECDB1D5 5K>9D9?> 6 1 49CDB92ED9?> 9C
C8ER54 9D 9C D85 9>L5H92<5 2EI5BC ?6 2?D8 DI@5C D81D 25>5KD
=?B5 6B?= D85 5>4?75>?EC 49Q5B5>D91D9?> 3B51D54 2I D85 E>
21<1>354 49CDB92ED9?> > ?D85B G?B4C ?>5 @B?4E3D 9C 5H@5B9
=5>D54 2I 1 <1B75 7B?E@ ?6 L5H92<5 2EI5BC 1>4 D85 9>L5H92<5
2EI5BC ?6 2?D8 DI@5C B5359F5 7??4 B53?==5>41D9?>C 6B?=
D85 5H@5B95>35C ?6 D85 6?B=5B 7B?E@ &> D85 ?D85B 81>4 96
1 49CDB92ED9?> 9C C?BD54 9D 9C ECE1<<I D85 9>L5H92<5 2EI5BC ?6
?>5 DI@5 B5359F9>7 9>6?B=1D9?> 6B?= D85 5H@5B95>35C ?6 1<<
?D85B 2EI5BC
-9D8 D85C5 45K>9D9?>C 9> =9>4 G5 KBCD 381B13D5B9J5 D85
@5B@5B9?4 5H@53D54 ED9<9DI 1>4 D85> D85 DG?@5B9?4 F1<E5
6E>3D9?> 6?B 5138 2EI5B *85 @5B @5B9?4 5H@53D54 7B?CC
ED9<9DI 6?B 1 2EI5B ?6 DI@5 6B?= @EB381C9>7 @B?4E3D 79F5> 9C
,-050:065 ',564,%76,10 1) %7;(45 ,5 %$.$0&(' ,) $0'
70%$.$0&(' ,) )14 51/( !+( '(*4(( 1)
,/%$.$0&( ,5 -5 G?E<4 <9;5 D? C55 G85D85B D85 C5<<5B 3B51D5C 5>4?75>?EC
49Q5B5>D91D9?> 25DG55> D85 DG? @B?4E3DC D8B?E78 1> E>21<
1>354 49CDB92ED9?> 1>4 96 C? G8938 2EI5BC 25>5KD 6B?= CE38
1> E>21<1>35 > ?D85B G?B4C 96 D85 49CDB92ED9?> 9C E>21<
1>354 ?>5 @B?4E3D 9C 5H@5B9=5>D54 2I 1 <1B75B 7B?E@ ?6
2EI5BC 1>4 D85 C=1<< 7B?E@ ?6 2EI5BC G19D D? 25>5KD 6B?=
D859B 6554213; 6 D89C 9C D85 31C5 D85> 9D 9C 1<C? 9=@?BD1>D
D? ;>?G D85 3?=@?C9D9?> ?6 D85C5 7B?E@C *89C CE775CDC D85
6?<<?G9>7 45K>9D9?>
,-050:065 "!#
',564,%76,10 1) %7;(45 ,5
9BCD 1C G5 49C3ECC54 12?F59> @5B9?4 1<< D85 @B?4E3DC
1B5 C?<4 1D =1B79>1< 3?CD C? D85 2EI5BC =1;5 D859B 38?935 D?
=1H9=9J5 D859B 5H@53D54 ED9<9DI G9D8 B5C@53D D? D85 B5=19>
9>7 38?935 C5D 79F5> D85 B53?==5>41D9?>C )53?>4
>?D935 D81D 5AE1D9?> 9C <9>51B 9> *85C5 DG? 613DC 9=
@<I D81D 6B?= 1 @5B9?4 @?9>D ?6 F95G 9D 9C D85 (:2(&6('
/$:,/$. /,0,/$. 2156(4,14 D81D 45D5B=9>5C D85 5H@53D54
ED9<9DI ?6 1 2EI5B ?6 DI@5 9> @5B9?4 *85C5
@?CD5B9?BC 6?B 1 2EI5B G8? @EB381C5C @B?4E3D 9> @5B9?4 31> 25 45K>54 1C
! ! >5146('? ,) 6+( 5(6 1) %7;(45 %7;,0* 241'7&65 $0' 4(52(&6,8(.; $4( .,0( 5(*/(065 1) 6+( )14/ $0'
>5+7@(' ? ,) )14 51/( $0' 6+( 5(6 1)
%7;(45 %7;,0* 241'7&6 &105,565 1) 691 5(*/(065 1) 6+( )14/5 4(52(&6,8(.; "( 4()(4 61
$5 6+( '(*4(( 1) 5+7@,0*
>2(4)(&6.; 5+7@('? ,) 2EI5B G9D8 DI@5 G8? 2EIC @B?4E3D 9> @5B9?4
5H@53DC D? 75D 1 @B?4E3D G9D8 D89C @?CD5B9?B 9> @5B9?4 ;>?G9>7 D81D C85 G9<< 38??C5 D85 @B?4E3D G9D8 89785CD @B?2
129<9DI ?6 259>7 DI@5 ?>35 C85 B5359F5C 9>6?B=1D9?> ?> 2EI5B G9D8 DI@5 5H@53DC D? 75D 1 @B?4E3D G9D8 1
C9=9<1B @?CD5B9?B G8938 D89C D9=5 9C 3?=@ED54 21C54 ?> D85
>9,6+ $ *$2? ,) 6+( ',564,%76,10 5$6,5=(5 (,6+(4 1) $%18(
&4,6(4,$ (:&(26 6+$6 $ 5(*/(06 $4170' <(41 5(2$4$6(5
(,6+(4 6+( %7;(45 1) ,061 691 5(*/(065 14 5(2$4$6(5
6+( %7;(45 1) $0' 47
'?9>D 1<C? B5F51<C D81D D85 DG?@5B9?4 ED9<9DI 6E>3
D9?> C1D9CK5C D85 C9>7<53B?CC9>7 @B?@5BDI G9D8 B5C@53D D?
D85 =1H9=1< =9>9=1< @?CD5B9?B G85B5 D85 C9>7<53B?CC9>7
@?9>D 9C *85 2EI5B ?6 DI@5 9C 9>49Q5B5>D 25DG55>
D85 DG? @B?4E3DC 1>4 85>35 85B DG?@5B9?4 F1<E5 6E>3D9?>
9C >?D 1Q53D54 2I E>35BD19>DI '?9>D 9=@<95C D81D D85
2EI5BC 6EBD85B 1G1I 6B?= D85 2EI5B ?6 DI@5 CDB?>7<I @B5
65B ?>5 @B?4E3D ?F5B D85 ?D85B 9> @5B9?4 6B?= 1 DG?@5B9?4
@?9>D ?6 F95G
'?9>D 9=@<95C D81D D85 @B565B5>35 B1>;9>7C 6?B 1<< 2EI
5BC G9D8 9C D85 C1=5 1C D85 B1>;9>7C ?6 D85 CE= ?6 KBCD
@5B9?4 @B9?BC 1>4 D85 B5C@53D9F5 5H@53D54 =1H9=1< =9>9
=1< @?CD5B9?BC
*? 45D5B=9>5 1 2EI5BMC C5<<5B 38?935 G5 >554 D? ;>?G
D85 ED9<9DI C85 75DC G85> C85 @EB381C5C 59D85B @B?4E3D 6B?=
D85 6B9>75 %?D935 D81D 96 1 2EI5B @EB381C5C @B?4E3D 6B?=
D85 6B9>75 9> @5B9?4 C85 G9<< =1H9=9J5 85B 5H@53D54 ED9<9DI
38??C9>7 6B?= 9> D85 C53?>4 @5B9?4 G9D8?ED 1>I 1449
D9?>1< 9>6?B=1D9?> *85> D85 5H@53D54 =1H9=1< =9>9=1<
@?CD5B9?B 9> 5AE1D9?> G9D8 45D5B=9>5C 85B
5H@53D54 ED9<9DI 9> @5B9?4 5>35 D85 B5<5F1>D F1B912<5C
1B5 1>4 1>4 D85 DG?@5B9?4 F1<E5 6E>3D9?> 6?B
1 2EI5B ?6 DI@5 3?>49D9?>1< ?> @EB381C9>7 @B?4E3D 6B?=
C5<<5B 9> @5B9?4 9C
613D D81D D85 2EI5B G9<< 38??C5 D85 @B?4E3D G9D8 D85 <?G5CD
@B?2129<9DI ?6 259>7 DI@5 ?>35 C85 B5359F5C 9>6?B=1D9?>
5>35 D85 DG?@5B9?4 7B?CC F1<E5 6E>3D9?> 6?B 1 2EI5B ?6
DI@5 3?>49D9?>1<
@B?4E3D 6B?= C5<<5B 9>
?> @EB381C9>7
@5B9?4 9C 96 96 *85 5H@53D54 =1H9=1< @?CD5B9?BC 3?>49D9?>1< ?> @EB381C9>7
5138 @B?4E3D 31> 25 45B9F54 1C
G85B5
96 96 1>4 D85 5H@53D54 =9>9=1<
@?CD5B9?BC
31>
25 45B9F54 CI=
=5DB931<<I D8B?E78 AE1D9?> C8?GC D81D D85 38?935 ?6 1 2EI5B 9> @5B9?4 1Q53DC 85B 5H@53D54 ED9<9DI 9> @5B9?4 D8B?E78 D85 5H@53D54
=1H9=1< =9>9=1< @?CD5B9?B 79F5> 9> AE1D9?> -5 ?2C5BF5 6B?= 5AE1D9?> D81D D85 DG?@5B9?4 ED9<
9DI ?6 1 2EI5B G9D8 DI@5 9>3B51C5C 453B51C5C
G9D8 D85 5H@53D54 =1H9=1< =9>9=1< @?CD5B9?B 5>35 1
2EI5BMC @B565B5>35 ?F5B D85 DG? @B?4E3DC =1I 381>75 G9D8
D85C5 @?CD5B9?BC 1C G5<< *? K>4 D85 49CDB92ED9?> 79F5> @B935C
G5 >554 D? ;>?G D85 7B?CC @B565B5>35 ?6 5138 2EI5B G8938
3<51B<I 45@5>4C ?> 2?D8 D85 9>9D91< @B9?B 1>4 D85 5H@53D54
=1H9=1< =9>9=1< @?CD5B9?B *85 6?<<?G9>7 <5==1 45B9F5C
@B?@5BD95C 6B?= 5AE1D9?>C 1>4 G8938 45C3B925 8?G
D85 @B565B5>35C 1>4 9> @1BD93E<1B D85 5H@53D54 @?CD5B9?BC 1B5
1Q53D54 2I 9>6?B=1D9?>1< 381>75C *85 @B?@5BD95C 1B5 CD1D54
6?B 2EI5BC G9D8 @?C9D9F5 DI@5C 1>4 5H@53D54 =1H9=1< @?C
D5B9?B 2ED D85 CI==5DB93 @B?@5BD95C 8?<4 6?B 2EI5BC G9D8
>571D9F5 DI@5C
,44) ! $##"
14 $.. $0' $.. $0' *89C <5==1 1>4 @?9>D 9> #5==1 D?75D85B 9=@<I
D81D 96 @EB381C9>7 6B?= D85 6B9>75 2EI5BC ?6 DI@5 38??C5 1>4 2EI5BC ?6 DI@5 38??C5 -5 31> GB9D5 D85 @B?KD ?6 C5<<5B 1C 1 6E>3D9?> ?6 ;>?G9>7 D81D 9D G9<< 75>5B1D5 <D5B>1D9F5<I
G5 31> D1;5 1 4E1< 1@@B?138 1>4 GB9D5 D85 @B?KDC 1C 1 6E>3
D9?> ?6 D85 =1B;5D C81B5C G8938 9=@<I 1 @1BD93E<1B
@B935 F53D?B D81D 75>5B1D5C D85= -5 31>
85>35 GB9D5 D85 @B?KDC 1C 1 6E>3D9?> ?6 1C
,44) %$ !#
14 $.. $0'
)5<<5B 38??C5C D? =1H9=9J5 D85C5 @B?KDC #5D
EC <??; 1D D85 DB145?Q 9>F?<F54 9> 9>3B51C9>7 ,5 572(4/1'7.$4 ,0 $0' $0' ,) $0' 10.; ,) *85 KBCD 2B13;5D B5@B5C5>DC D85 =1B79>1< <?CC 95 D85
453B51C5 9> D81D 9C B5AE9B54 D? 9>3B51C5 *89C 9C D85
DI@931< <?CC 1 =?>?@?<9CD 9>3EBC 9> 1 CD1>41B4 @B?KD =1H
9=9J1D9?> @B?2<5= *85 KBCD D5B= 9> D85 C53?>4 2B13;5D
B5@B5C5>DC D85 49B53D =1B79>1< 719> 95 D85 613D D81D D85
=1B;E@ 9C B5359F54 6B?= 1 89785B =1B;5D C81B5 719> D89C
9C D85 719> G5 G?E<4 C55 9> 1 CD1>41B4 =?>?@?<9CD @B?2<5=
-81D =1;5C D89C @B?2<5= 49Q5B5>D 9C D85 <1CD D5B= 9> D85
C53?>4 2B13;5D G8938 9C 1 49B53D B5L53D9?> ?6 D85 @B?4E3D
5HD5B>1<9DI *85 <1CD D5B= B5@B5C5>DC D85 9>49B53D =1B79>1<
719> G8938 9C 4E5 D? D85 613D D81D 1C 9>3B51C5C D85 DG?
@5B9?4 ED9<9DI 6B?= 9>3B51C5C 85>35 D85 C1=5 3?E<4 25
;5@D 1D 1 89785B *85 DB145?Q 25DG55> D85 <?CC 1>4 719>
45D5B=9>5C D85 ?@D9=1< =1B;5D C81B5C 6?B D85 C5<<5B *85
%?D935 D81D @?9>D 3?=29>54 G9D8 5AE1D9?> B5F51<C
D85 N@B?4E3D 5HD5B>1<9DIO 5Q53D '?9>D 85<@C EC 45D5B
=9>5 G85> D85 C5<<5B =978D 3B51D5 1> E>21<1>354 49CDB92E
D9?> C D85 49CDB92ED9?> 253?=5C E>21<1>354 D85 ED9<9DI ?6
?>5 7B?E@ ?6 2EI5BC 9>3B51C5C 1D D85 5H@5>C5 ?6 D85 ?D85B
7B?E@ '?9>D 9=@<95C D81D D85 719> 6B?= 1> E>21<1>354
49CDB92ED9?> 9C 89785B G85> 9>6?B=1D9?> 9C =?B5 F1<E12<5 9
>1<<I @?9>D B5F51<C D81D D85 719> 9>L5H92<5 2EI5BC B5359F5
6B?= 9>6?B=1D9?> 9C 7B51D5B D81> D85 719> L5H92<5 2EI5BC B5
359F5 D 9C D89C @?9>D D81D 45D5B=9>5C G85D85B D85 C5<<5B
3B51D5C 1 C?BD54 ?B C8ER54 49CDB92ED9?>
48
867690:065 $!$ !+(4( (:,565 57&+ 6+$6 )14 6+(4(
(:,56 691 5;//(64,& (37,.,%4,$ ,'(06,=(' 9,6+ $0'
&+$4$&6(4,<(' %;
,) $0' ,) 6?<<?G9>7 @B?@?C9D9?>C 79F5 D85 C?<ED9?> D? 1<< D85C5 5Q53DC
1>4 B5F51< D85 5AE9<92B91
867690:065 $!$ !+(4( (:,565 $ 70,37( 57&+ 6+$6 )14 6+(
(37,.,%4,7/ ,5 70,37( $0' ,5 &+$4$&6(4,<(' %;
)14 )7.. /$4-(6 5+$4( )14 5(..(4 .(55 6+$0 )7.. /$4-(6 5+$4( )14 5(..(4 $0 70%$.$0&(' $0' 5146(' ',564,%76,10 9,6+ $ %$.$0&(' $0' 5146(' ',564,%76,10 9,6+ $ *$2 9+(4(
6+( 5(6 1) %7;(45 %7;,0*
241'7&65
$0' )41/ 5(..(4
$4( 4(52(&6,8(.; $0' -1
1
l
−1
-1
l
1
3
1
3
F
h
*' (,"")' &*!'*" $' h
'B?@?C9D9?> KBCD B5F51<C D81D D85B5 5H9CDC 9>D5B=5491D5
F1<E5C ?6 6?B G8938 D85 C5<<5B 31@DEB5C D85 G8?<5 =1B;5D
C 5H@<19>54 12?F5 D85 49B53D <?CC 4E5 D? 9>3B51C9>7 D85
=1B;5D C81B5 1>4 D85 457B55 ?6 E>21<1>35 95 D85 49B53D
@B935 453B51C5 9>3B51C5C G9D8 2531EC5 D85 2EI5BC 75D =?B5
49Q5B5>D91D54 G9D8 B5C@53D D? 8?G =E38 D85I @B565B 2EI9>7
6B?= C5<<5B D? D85 6B9>75 ?G5F5B D85 9>49B53D 719> 1<C?
9>3B51C5C 9> C9>35 D85 ED9<9D95C 253?=5 =?B5 B5C@?>C9F5 D?
381>75C 9> D85 =1B;5D C81B5C 'B?@?C9D9?>C 1>4 C1I D81D
D85 9>49B53D 719> 9>3B51C5C 61CD5B D81> D85 49B53D <?CC *85
=?B5 9>DB97E9>7 D89>7 9C D81D 6?B D85 C5<<5B 9C
G9<<9>7 D? =1;5 1 <?CC ?> ?>5 @B?4E3D 2531EC5 D89C 1<<?GC
1 @B935 9>3B51C5 ?> D85 ?D85B @B?4E3D D81D =?B5 D81> 3?F5BC
D85 <?CC *85> 1C 9>3B51C5C ?F5B 5F5> 6?B D85 2EI5BC
G9D8 DI@5 2EI9>7 @B?4E3D 6B?= C5<<5B 253?=5C
1 25DD5B 38?935 D81> 2EI9>7 @B?4E3D 6B?= C5<<5B 1>4
D8EC D85 >535CC9DI D? 453B51C5 D85 @B935 25<?G =1B79>1< 3?CD
49C1@@51BC
*' &*!'*" $' 'B?@?C9D9?> 79F5C D85 E>9AE5 5AE9<92B9E= 6?B <?G <5F5<C
?6 #?G =51>C 59D85B 9C <?G ?B D81D 9C 8978 > 59D85B
31C5 D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= 4?5C >?D @<1I 1 297 B?<5 9>
B54E39>7 E>35BD19>DI *85 KBCD D89>7 D? E>45BCD1>4 9C G8I
D85 C5<<5B @B565BC <5CC D81> 6E<< =1B;5D C81B5 9> D89C 31C5 D
9C 3<51B D81D 9D 31> >?D 25 ?@D9=1< D? 81F5 6E<< =1B;5D C81B5
1>4 1 21<1>354 49CDB92ED9?> 2531EC5 9D I95<4C J5B? @B?KDC
1>4 D85 C5<<5B 35BD19><I 81C ?D85B ?@D9?>C 79F9>7 89= CDB93D<I
@?C9D9F5 @B?KDC > 3?>C5AE5>35 D85 ?@D9=1<9DI ?6 6E<< =1B
;5D C81B5 >535CC9D1D5C 1> E>21<1>354 49CDB92ED9?> >3B51C
9>7 D85 =1B;5D C81B5 81C D85 3?CD 1>4 25>5KDC G8938 G5B5
49C3ECC54 9> =1B79>1< D5B=C 9> 5AE1D9?> *85 49B53D
719> 9C D81D =?B5 2EI5BC @EB381C5 6B?= C5<<5B *85 49B53D
<?CC 9C D81D 9D B5AE9B5C 1> 9>9D91< @B935C 453B51C5 6?B 1D <51CD
?>5 @B?4E3D ?G5F5B D89C <?CC 9C 41=@5>54 2531EC5 D85 9>
3B51C5 9> D85 =1B;5D C81B5 <514C D? 1> 9>3B51C5 9> D85 ED9<9DI
6B?= 2EI9>7 C?=5 @B?4E3D 6B?= C5<<5B *89C 9C 1 B5CE<D
?6 D85 @B?4E3D 5HD5B>1<9DI G5 45C3B9254 51B<95B *85B56?B5
1C 1> 9>49B53D 719> D85 C5<<5B G9<< 59D85B 25 12<5 D? >?D 45
3B51C5 D85 @B935 1C =E38 D? 75>5B1D5 D85 C1=5 =1B;5D C81B5
9>3B51C5 ?B 9>3B51C5 D85 @B935 ?6 ?>5 @B?4E3D G89<5 453B51C
9>7 D85 ?D85B ?>C945B D85 DG?@5B9?4 ED9<9D95C >?B=1<9J54
2I -85> 9C <?G 5AE1D9?>C 1>4 9=@<I D81D D85
ED9<9DI 49Q5B5>35 25DG55> @EB381C9>7 6B?= C5<<5BC 1>4 4?5C >?D 453B51C5 2I =E38 1C D85 2EI5BMC DI@5 75DC =?B5
L5H92<5 5>35 D85 9>9D91< @B935 453B51C5 >55454 D? 75>5B
1D5 1 79F5> =1B;5D C81B5 9>3B51C5 9C >?D <1B75 ?G5F5B D85
9>49B53D 719> 9C >?D <1B75 59D85B 531EC5 2I #5==1 96
9C <?G D85 >?B=1<9J54 ED9<9DI ?6 1 2EI5B 9>3B51C5C 2I F5BI
<9DD<5 1C =1B;5D C81B5 9>3B51C5C 'B?@?C9D9?> C1IC D81D 6?B
<?G D85 9>49B53D 719> 9C >?D CDB?>7 5>?E78 3?=@1B54 D?
D85 49B53D @B935 453B51C5 5Q53D 1>4 D8EC D85 C5<<5B 38??C5C
D? <51F5 ?ED C?=5 2EI5BC *85 C9=9<1B B51C?>9>7 1@@<95C D?
D85 38?935 ?6 457B55 ?6 21<1>35 *85B56?B5 6?B <?G D85
C5<<5B @B565BC D? =1;5 @B?KDC C9=@<I 2I 9>3B51C9>7 D85 @B935
5AE1<<I ?> 2?D8 @B?4E3DC D? 1 <5F5< D81D CEP395>D<I 9>L5H92<5
2EI5BC 1B5 G9<<9>7 D? @1I D? 81F5 1335CC D? >5G 9>6?B=1D9?>
9> @5B9?4 *85 C5<<5BMC @B?2<5= 31> 25 9>D5B@B5D54 1C C5@
1B1D54 9>D? DG? 49C:?9>D =1B;5DC 9> 5138 ?6 G8938 85 C5<<C 1
89785B AE1<9DI @B?4E3D 3?=@1B54 D? D85 6B9>75 1>4 D8EC C5DC
1 89785B @B935
867690:065 $!$ !+(4( (:,565 57&+ 6+$6 )14 6+(4( (:
,56 691 5;//(64,& (37,.,%4,$ ,'(06,=(' 9,6+ $0'
&+$4$&6(4,<(' %;
24,&(5 $0' )7.. /$4-(6 5+$4( )14 5(..(4 $0 70%$.$0&(' $0' 5+7@(' ',564,%76,10 9,6+ -1
1
l
h
l
*' (,"")' &*!'*" $' 'B?@?C9D9?> C8?GC D81D E>D9< D85 9>49B53D 719>
4?=9>1D5C D85 49B53D <?CC $?B5?F5B 85B5 9C C? 8978 D81D
5F5> D85 2EI5BC ?6 DI@5 @B565B @B?4E3D D? @B?4
E3D G85> 2EI9>7 6B?= C5<<5B *85 C5<<5B =1;5C EC5 ?6
D89C @B565B5>35 CDBE3DEB5 2I 9>3<E49>7 D85 9>L5H92<5 2EI5BC
?6 2?D8 DI@5C 9> D85 7B?E@ D81D @1IC 1 8978 @B935 D? B5359F5
D85 9>6?B=1D9?> @B?F9454 2I D85 L5H92<5 2EI5BC *85B56?B5
D85 49CDB92ED9?> 253?=5C C8ER54
49
1 8978 @B935 6?B D85 8978 AE1<9DI C5BF935 1>4 L5H92<5 2EI5BC
G8? 1B5 <56D D? 2EI 5<C5G85B5
?G5F5B G85> D85 3?>DB92ED9?> ?6 D85 B53?==5>45B CIC
D5= 9>3B51C5C D85 C5<<5BMC @B?2<5= 9>3<E45C 3?>35B>C D81D
B5<1D5 D? 71D85B9>7 D85 ?@D9=1< <5F5< ?6 9>6?B=1D9?> ?> 5138
@B?4E3D -5 C8?G54 D81D 9> D89C 31C5 D85 C5<<5B 3B51D5C 5>
4?75>?EC 49Q5B5>D91D9?> 25DG55> ?D85BG9C5 CI==5DB93 @B?4
E3DC 2I C57=5>D9>7 D85 =1B;5D 9>D? DG? 7B?E@C 1 <1B75
7B?E@ ?6 L5H92<5 2EI5BC G8? 3?>CD9DED5 D85 5H@5B9=5>D5BC
1>4 @1I <?G5B @B935C 9> B5DEB> 6?B D85 C5BF935 D85I @B?F945
1 C=1<<5B 7B?E@ ?6 9>L5H92<5 2EI5BC G8? @1I 89785B @B935C
D? 81F5 1335CC D? D85 6554213; 6B?= D85 KBCD 7B?E@ *85 ?@
D9=1< C57=5>D1D9?> 6?B D85 C5<<5B 9C >?D >535CC1B9<I ?@D9=1<
6?B D85 C?395DI *85 6E<< @?D5>D91< ?6 D85 B53?==5>45B CIC
D5= 9C >?D B51<9J54 2I D85 @B939>7 C385=5 9=@<5=5>D54 2I
D85 C5<<5B 2531EC5 D85 C5<<5B =978D G1CD5 C?=5 9>6?B=1D9?>
2I >?D 31@DEB9>7 D85 G8?<5 =1B;5D $?B5?F5B 5F5> G85>
85 31@DEB5C 6E<< =1B;5D C81B5 85 38??C5C D? ?F5BED9<9J5 D85
CICD5= 6?B C?=5 @B?4E3DC 1>4 E>45BED9<9J5 9D 6?B ?D85BC
*85B5 1B5 1 65G D89>7C D81D ?EB =?45< 4?5C >?D 9>3?B@?
B1D5 9BCD B53?==5>45B CICD5= 31> 25 EC54 D? 9>3B51C5
C1<5C D8B?E78 5>3?EB179>7 3B?CCC1<5C ?B DEB>9>7 2B?GC5BC
9>D? C8?@@5BC F5BI C9=@<5 G1I D? D89>; 12?ED D89C @B?2
<5= 9C D? 3?>C945B 1 G?B<4 9> G8938 B9C; 1F5BC5 3ECD?=5BC =1I
>?D @EB381C5 D85 @B?4E3D 2531EC5 ?6 D85 E>35BD19>DI 12?ED
9DC DBE5 F1<E5 ?G5F5B 2I ?Q5B9>7 9>6?B=1D9?> D? D85 2EI5B
G8938 B54E35C D85 E>35BD19>DI D85 C5<<5B 3?E<4 3?>F9>35 D85
2EI5B D? @EB381C5 D85 @B?4E3D )53?>4 9D 9C @?CC92<5 D81D
>?><?I1< 3ECD?=5BC 1B5 1<C? 1C;54 D? <51F5 6554213; 12?ED
D85 @B?4E3DC D85I 81F5 @EB381C54 6B?= ?D85B C5<<5BC ?>35
D85I <?7 ?>D? 1 @1BD93E<1B C5<<5BMC G52C9D5 *89C ?><I 5><1B75C
D85 41D121C5 D85 C5<<5B ;55@C ?> 5138 @B?4E3D 5>81>35C D85
AE1<9DI ?6 D85 C5BF935 85 @B?F945C 1>4 85>35 3?>DB92ED5C D?
89C 6EBD85B 5HDB13D9?> ?6 D85 CEB@<EC *89C =1I <514 D? D85
E>2E>4<9>7 ?6 B53?==5>41D9?> 1>4 @B?4E3D 1>4 3B51D5C D85
@?CC929<9DI 6?B D85 C5<<5B D? 381B75 6?B D85 B53?==5>41D9?>C
C5@1B1D5<I 9>1<<I G5 494 >?D 3?>C945B E>35BD19>DI 12?ED
?>5MC ?G> D1CD5 -9D8 2EI5BC D? 25 E>35BD19> 12?ED D859B
D1CD5C 1>4 D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= =1I 25 12<5 D? 3?BB5<1D5
D859B @1CD @EB381C5C G9D8 177B571D5 9>6?B=1D9?> D81D G?E<4
75>5B1D5 1449D9?>1< F1<E5 D? D85 3ECD?=5B
+<D9=1D5<I G5 =1I 25 9>D5B5CD54 9> D85 45C97> ?6 D85 B53
?==5>41D9?> =5381>9C= 9DC5<6 EBB5>D<I 1<< D85 B5C51B38
2I 3?=@ED5B C395>D9CDC 6?3EC5C ?> 59D85B GB9D9>7 D85 =?CD 56
K395>D ?B @B5493D9F5 B53?==5>45B CICD5= ?G5F5B CDB1D5
793 3?>35B>C 1B5 >?D 9>3<E454 9> D85 @B?35CC ?6 GB9D9>7 D85
@B?7B1= 6?B 1 B53?==5>45B CICD5= D 9C 3<51B D81D D85
B53?==5>45B CICD5= 9C 1 =5381>9C= 1>4 DBI9>7 D? 45C97>
D85 =?CD @B?KD12<5 =5381>9C= 6?B D85 C5<<5B G?E<4 25 1>
9>D5B5CD9>7 381<<5>75 6?B 6EDEB5 B5C51B38
867690:065 $!$ 14 6+(4( (:,56 691 5;//(64,& (37,.,%4,$ ,'(06,=('
9,6+ $0' &+$4$&6(4,<(' %;
24,&(5 .(55 6+$0 )7.. /$4-(6 5+$4( )14 5(..(4 $0 70%$.$0&(' $0' 5+7@(' ',564,%76,10 9,6+ $ *$2 $0'
-1
1
l
h
F
h
l
*' (,"")' &*!'*" $' 6D5B G5 C55 1 B5F5BC5 @1DD5B> *85 C5<<5B 38??C5C 1
<5CC D81> 6E<< =1B;5D C81B5 2531EC5 ?>35 1719> D85 9>49B53D
719> 6B?= 9>3B51C9>7 D85 =1B;5D C81B5 253?=5C C=1<<5B D81>
D85 49B53D <?CC ?B D85 ED9<9DI 49Q5B5>35 25DG55>
2EI9>7 6B?= C5<<5B 1>4 2EI9>7 6B?= 453B51C5C C81B@<I
1C D85 DI@5 75DC =?B5 L5H92<5 5>35 D85 @B935 9>3B51C5
4E5 D? <51F9>7 ?ED C?=5 2EI5BC ?6 ?>5 @B?4E3D 9C C? 8978
D81D 9D =?B5 D81> 3?=@5>C1D5C 6?B D85 <?CC 9>3EBB54 ?> D85
2EI5BC ?6 D85 ?D85B @B?4E3D C D85 >5HD @B?@?C9D9?> C8?GC
D85 B5F5BC1< ?6 D85C5 DG? 5Q53DC 1<C? 9=@<95C D81D D85 D?D1<
=1B;5D C81B5 1>4 D85 457B55 ?6 E>21<1>35 ;55@ 453B51C9>7
6?B 1<< 'B?@?C9D9?> CE==1B9J5 D85 3?=@1B1D9F5 CD1D93C 5Q53DC
?6 1> 9>3B51C5 9> D85 9>6?B=1D9F5>5CC ?6 867690:065 !#% "##
0 6+( 2(4)(&6 $;(5,$0 (37,.,%4,7/ ,) 6+( /($574(5 1) %7;(45 %7;,0* (,6+(4 241'7&6
)41/ (,6+(4 5(..(4 '1 016 &+$0*( 9,6+ ,) 6+( '(*4(( 1) 70%$.$0&( ,0&4($5(5 ,0 ,) 6+( '(*4(( 1) 70%$.$0&( '(&4($5(5 $0'
6+( '(*4(( 1) 5+7@,0* ,0&4($5(5 ,0 ,) 616$. /$4-(6 5+$4( $0' 6+( '(*4(( 1) 70%$.
$0&( '(&4($5(5 ,0 $5 6+( ',564,%76,10 1) %7;(45 %(&1/(5 2(4)(&6.;
5+7@('
-5 81F5 C8?G> D81D D85 5H9CD5>35 ?6 1 B53?==5>45B CIC
D5= 3B51D5C 1449D9?>1< CEB@<EC 1>4 9>DB?4E35C 9>6?B=1D9?>1<
5HD5B>1<9D95C 9>D? D85 @B939>7 @B?2<5= ?6 D85 C5<<5B 6 D85 ?ED
@ED ?6 D85 B53?==5>45B CICD5= G5B5 9>45@5>45>D ?6 C1<5C
D85> 5=@<?I9>7 1 B53?==5>45B CICD5= G?E<4 25 5AE9F1<5>D
D? ?Q5B9>7 1 8978 AE1<9DI @B?4E3D 9> 1 8?B9J?>D1<<I 49Q5B5>
D91D54 =1B;5D *89C @B?2<5= G?E<4 25 F5BI CD1>41B4 1>4
D85 C5<<5B G?E<4 C9=@<I 381B75 1 89785B @B935 6?B 1 89785B
AE1<9DI @B?4E3D &EB K>49>7C C8?G D81D G85> D85 B53?=
=5>45B CICD5= 4?5C <9DD<5 D? B54E35 D85 E>35BD19>DI D85>
D89C 9C 9>4554 D85 G1I D85 C5<<5B 81>4<5C D85 @B?2<5= 2I C57
=5>D9>7 D85 =1B;5D 9>D? 9>L5H92<5 2EI5BC G8? 17B55 D? @1I
9B; 5B75=1>> 13;>?G<5475C K>1>391< CE@@?BD D8B?E78
%) %) 1>4 ))
/0 +)49 & )5+ ',33,5 N?==?49DI
2E>4<9>7 1>4 D85 2EB45> ?6 =?>?@?<IO 7$46(4.;
1740$. 1) &101/,&5 /0 59)80 " 99,.)0,8 )5+ ! 6/30 N >D5B>5D (53?==5>41D9?> )ICD5=CO 1740$. 1)
$4-(6,0* (5($4&+ 50
/0 77,5 & )5965 )5+ ! )8:05
NE>4<9>7%5G 'B?4E3DC %5G $1B;5DC #?G
(9C;O .1$0 $0$*(/(06 (8,(9 /0 5:,85,: 647;:05. 5+;9:8= !,768:
N=1J?>3?= (53?==5>41D9?>C D5=D? D5=
?<<12?B1D9F5 9<D5B9>7O
+662'510.,0(&1/276(414*
'9
.,0'+6/
/0 03+ )5+ )::,8 N B9D931< ,95G
?> (53?==5>41D9?> )ICD5=CO "14-,0* $2(45 >'$26,8( 0)14/$6,10 ;56(/5 $0' 1'(..,0* ,0
&101/,&5 $0' $0$*(/(06 &,(0&(? %B /0 !,950*2 )5+ %)80)5 N(53?==5>45B
)ICD5=CO 1//70,&$6,105 1) 6+( /0 "*/4)3,59,, ! N1ECC91> 45=1>4 1>4
3?==?49DI 2E>4<9>7O 1740$. 1) 75,0(55 /0 <,8= !,950*2 )5+ ! (,*2/);9,8 N*85 $1B;5D 6?B F1<E1D9?>CO /(4,&$0 &101/,&
(8,(9 /0 <,8= )5+ ! (,*2/);9,8 N(53?==5>45B CICD5=C 6?B 5F1<E1D9>7 3?=@ED5B
=5CC175CO 1//70,&$6,105 1) 6+( /0 8,,9, " ,*2,84)5)5+ )+0, N=@9B931< >1<IC9C ?6 'B5493D9F5 <7?B9D8=C 6?B
?<<12?B1D9F5 9<D5B9>7O !(&+0,&$. (2146
!
$93B?C?6D (5C51B38
/0 8=5163-9965 )5+ "40:/ N*85
B51D AE1<9J5B ?>CE=5B 8?935 581F9?B 1D
>D5B>5D )8?@2?DCO .1$0 "14-,0* $2(4 /0 /,<)30,8 )5+ )=>305 N*85 Q53D
?6 -?B4 ?6 $?ED8 ?> )1<5C &><9>5 ??; (5F95GCO
#$.( "14-,0* $2(45 ) $"
51