August 2004 Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills Information Booklet READING Grade 9 Revised Te x a s E d u c a t i o n A g e n c y • Student Assessment Division Copyright © 2004, Texas Education Agency. All rights reserved. Reproduction of all or portions of this work is prohibited without express written permission from Texas Education Agency. INTRODUCTION The Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills (TAKS) is a completely reconceived testing program. It assesses more of the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) than the Texas Assessment of Academic Skills (TAAS) did and asks questions in more authentic ways. TAKS has been developed to better reflect good instructional practice and more accurately measure student learning. We hope that every teacher will see the connection between what we test on this new state assessment and what our students should know and be able to do to be academically successful. To provide you with a better understanding of TAKS and its connection to the TEKS and to classroom teaching, the Texas Education Agency (TEA) has developed this newly revised edition of the TAKS information booklet. The information booklets were originally published in January 2002, before the first TAKS field test. Now, after several years of field tests and live administrations, we are able to provide an even more comprehensive picture of the testing program. We have clarified some of the existing material and, in some cases, provided new sample items and/or more explanations of certain item types. However, it is important to remember that these clarifications do not signify any change in the TAKS testing program. The objectives and TEKS student expectations assessed on TAKS remain unchanged. We hope this revised version of the TAKS information booklet will serve as a user-friendly resource to help you understand that the best preparation for TAKS is a coherent, TEKS-based instructional program that provides the level of support necessary for all students to reach their academic potential. BACKGROUND INFORMATION The development of the TAKS program included extensive public scrutiny and input from Texas teachers, administrators, parents, members of the business community, professional education organizations, faculty and staff at Texas colleges and universities, and national content-area experts. The agency involved as many stakeholders as possible because we believed that the development of TAKS was a responsibility that had to be shared if this new assessment was to be an equitable and accurate measure of learning for all Texas public school students. The three-year test-development process, which began in summer 1999, included a series of carefully conceived activities. First, committees of Texas educators identified those TEKS student expectations for each grade and subject area assessed that should be tested on a statewide assessment. Then a committee of TEA Student Assessment and Curriculum staff incorporated these selected TEKS student expectations, along with draft objectives for each subject area, into eleventh grade exit level surveys. These surveys were sent to Texas educators at the middle school and secondary levels for their review. Based on input we received from more than 27,000 survey responses, we developed a second draft of the objectives and TEKS student expectations. In addition, we used this input during the development of draft objectives and student expectations for grades 3 through 10 to ensure that the TAKS program, like the TEKS curriculum, would be vertically aligned. This vertical alignment was a critical step in ensuring that the TAKS tests would become more rigorous as students moved from grade to grade. For example, the fifth grade tests would be more rigorous than the fourth grade tests, which would be more rigorous than the third grade tests. Texas educators felt that this increase in rigor from grade to grade was both appropriate and logical since each subject-area test was closely aligned to the TEKS curriculum at that grade level. In fall 2000 TEA distributed the second draft of the objectives and TEKS student expectations for eleventh grade exit level and the first draft of the objectives and student expectations for grades 3 Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 1 through 10 for review at the campus level. These documents were also posted on the Student Assessment Division’s website to encourage input from the public. Each draft document focused on two central issues: first, whether the objectives included in the draft were essential to measure on a statewide assessment; and, second, whether students would have received enough instruction on the TEKS student expectations included under each objective to be adequately prepared to demonstrate mastery of that objective in the spring of the school year. We received more than 57,000 campusconsensus survey responses. We used these responses, along with feedback from national experts, to finalize the TAKS objectives and student expectations. Because the state assessment was necessarily limited to a “snapshot” of student performance, broad-based input was important to ensure that TAKS assessed the parts of the TEKS curriculum most critical to students’ academic learning and progress. In the thorough test-development process that we use for the TAKS program, we rely on educator input to develop items that are appropriate and valid measures of the objectives and TEKS student expectations the items are designed to assess. This input includes an annual educator review and revision of all proposed test items before field-testing and a second annual educator review of data and items after field-testing. In addition, each year panels of recognized experts in the fields of English language arts (ELA), mathematics, science, and social studies meet in Austin to critically review the content of each of the high school level TAKS assessments to be administered that year. This critical review is referred to as a content validation review and is one of the final activities in a series of quality-control steps designed to ensure that each high school test is of the highest quality possible. A content validation review is considered necessary at the high school grades (9, 10, and 11) because of the advanced level of content being assessed. ORGANIZATION OF THE TAKS TESTS TAKS is divided into test objectives. It is important to remember that the objective statements are not found in the TEKS curriculum. Rather, the objectives are “umbrella statements” that serve as headings under which student expectations from the TEKS can be meaningfully grouped. Objectives are broad statements that “break up” knowledge and skills to be tested into meaningful subsets around which a test can be organized into reporting units. These reporting units help campuses, districts, parents, and the general public understand the performance of our students and schools. Test objectives are not intended to be “translations” or “rewordings” of the TEKS. Instead, the objectives are designed to be identical across grade levels rather than grade specific. Generally, the objectives are the same for third grade through eighth grade (an elementary/middle school system) and for ninth grade through eleventh grade (a high school system). In addition, certain TEKS student expectations may logically be grouped under more than one test objective; however, it is important for you to understand that this is not meaningless repetition—sometimes the organization of the objectives requires such groupings. For example, on the TAKS writing tests for fourth and seventh grades, some of the same student expectations addressing the conventions of standard English usage are listed under both Objective 2 and Objective 6. In this case, the expectations listed under Objective 2 are assessed through the overall strength of a student’s use of language conventions on the written composition portion of the test; these same expectations under Objective 6 are assessed through multiple-choice items attached to a series of revising and editing passages. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 2 ORGANIZATION OF THE INFORMATION BOOKLETS The purpose of the information booklets is to help Texas educators, students, parents, and other stakeholders understand more about the TAKS tests. These booklets are not intended to replace the teaching of the TEKS curriculum, provide the basis for the isolated teaching of skills in the form of narrow test preparation, or serve as the single information source about every aspect of the TAKS program. However, we believe that the booklets provide helpful explanations as well as show enough sample items, reading and writing selections, and prompts to give educators a good sense of the assessment. Each grade within a subject area is presented as a separate booklet. However, it is still important that teachers review the information booklets for the grades both above and below the grade they teach. For example, eighth grade mathematics teachers who review the seventh grade information booklet as well as the ninth grade information booklet are able to develop a broader perspective of the mathematics assessment than if they study only the eighth grade information booklet. The information booklets for each subject area contain some information unique to that subject. For example, the mathematics chart that students use on TAKS is included for each grade at which mathematics is assessed. However, all booklets include the following information, which we consider critical for every subject-area TAKS test: an overview of the subject within the context of TAKS a blueprint of the test—the number of items under each objective and the number of items on the test as a whole information that clarifies how to read the TEKS the reasons each objective and its TEKS student expectations are critical to student learning and success the objectives and TEKS student expectations that are included on TAKS additional information about each objective that helps educators understand how it is assessed on TAKS sample items that show some of the ways objectives are assessed Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 3 Introduction to TAKS Reading at Grade 9 The ability to read effectively is essential for all students. As students move from grade to grade, reading skills are critical for academic progress. Students who cannot read well will struggle to succeed not only in English language arts but in social studies, science, and mathematics as well. Good readers have more opportunities available to them throughout their lives—in education, employment, and personal enrichment—than those who have not learned this fundamental skill. At the high school level, students use their already established reading skills to explore literary and expository texts with a greater depth of understanding. Students analyze how literary elements and techniques contribute to a text’s meaning and how an author crafts a piece of writing to affect the way the reader reads and understands it. As students learn how to analyze various types of texts and learn to make connections between what they read and what they already know, their powers of comprehension and critical thinking expand. It is no accident that good readers become good thinkers. Writing, though not assessed at the ninth grade level, is also critical for academic success. Students who have learned to communicate well on paper have an advantage both in school and in the workplace. Because good writing requires good thinking, the act of writing actually helps students learn to clarify their thoughts and focus their ideas. In addition, students who write well are usually strong readers. Why? In very simple terms, a writer must be able to read what he or she has written and recognize whether the words mean what the writer wants them to mean. Therefore, every time a student is writing effectively, that student is also reading carefully and thoughtfully. In this way, writing and reading reinforce each other. In order for students to be successful readers and writers, reading and writing activities must occur at every grade level, not merely at the tested grades. The TEKS were organized to ensure that at each grade level students acquire the reading and writing skills they will need for success at the next grade. That is, these skills are addressed in a systematic, “building block” manner from grade to grade. Because of this careful alignment, students’ abilities are strengthened as they progress through elementary school, middle school, and high school. For example, ninth grade students who are exposed to a rich, process-based reading and writing program will be more successful not only in their high school classes but also on the TAKS ELA tests at grade 10 and exit level, since these tests are integrated reading and writing assessments. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 4 Reading Objectives The ninth grade reading TAKS objectives are listed below. Objective 1: The student will demonstrate a basic understanding of culturally diverse written texts. Objective 2: The student will demonstrate an understanding of the effects of literary elements and techniques in culturally diverse written texts. Objective 3: The student will demonstrate the ability to analyze and critically evaluate culturally diverse written texts and visual representations. Objectives 1, 2, and 3 will be assessed through multiple-choice items based on a set of three pieces, called a “triplet,” presented for the student to read. (See the section on page 6 titled “What Is a Triplet?” for details.) In addition, Objectives 2 and 3 will be assessed through three open-ended (short-answer) items. Each open-ended item is equivalent to three multiple-choice items. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 5 General Guidelines for TAKS Reading at Grade 9 What Is a Triplet? The grade 9 reading test is based on a thematically linked set of pieces for the student to read and analyze. The term triplet is used to describe this set of three pieces. The components of a triplet are as follows: a published literary selection a published expository (informational) selection a one-page viewing and representing piece Both the literary and expository (informational) selections will be published works or excerpts from published works. The selections must not appear in any of the state-adopted high school English textbooks. At Grade 9 the combined length of a triplet is approximately 2,500–3,000 words, and the paragraphs of the literary and expository selections are numbered for easy reference. The readability of the selections will be appropriate for ninth grade students, and the selections overall reflect cultural diversity. The term culturally diverse simply means “pertaining to a variety of backgrounds and perspectives.” We are committed to finding selections that represent, as much as possible, the wide range of backgrounds, perspectives, and experiences of Texas students. At the same time, each selection must be accessible to all students, regardless of ethnicity or background. Viewing and representing pieces are one-page pieces with minimal text. These visual representations focus on media literacy; they may include, but are not limited to, a created advertisement, a created or published cartoon, a page from a created website, a photograph, or a chart or other graphic piece. The components of each triplet are thematically linked; that is, there will be a strong connection across the three pieces in terms of a common theme or idea. In this way, students are not reading random selections that would require them to “shift gears” between each piece. The triplet concept not only provides a rich built-in context for the reader as he or she moves from piece to piece but also forms the basis for a focused and unified test. Multiple-Choice Items A multiple-choice item may be based on one of the selections or the viewing and representing piece; in addition, an item may address both the literary and expository selections. Items based on the literary and expository selections assess Objectives 1, 2, or 3; items based on the viewing and representing piece assess Objective 3 only. Items reflect authentic questioning; that is, they reflect the ways that teachers naturally and routinely ask questions during instruction. Item stems include specific paragraph and/or text references when appropriate. A paragraph and/or text reference is necessary if it would be too time-consuming for students to find the relevant section of text in order to answer the question. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 6 Open-Ended Items Open-ended items (also called short-answer items) require students to write a brief response. Open-ended items are based on the literary or expository selections only; no open-ended items address the viewing and representing piece. These items assess Objectives 2 and 3 only and may be based on either an individual selection or both selections. For open-ended items that address one selection, students have five lines to respond on the answer document. However, for items that ask students to make a connection between the literary and expository selections, students have eight lines to respond. All open-ended items require students to generate clear, reasonable ideas about various aspects of a text and to support these ideas with relevant evidence from the text. Text evidence may take the form of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Although students may use a paragraph citation to indicate where in the text they have taken their evidence, they may not use a citation by itself (for example, see paragraphs 6–8). The best text evidence clearly supports the validity of the student’s ideas or analysis. Students’ responses to open-ended items are scored based on content; writing conventions are not taken into consideration unless the frequency and/or severity of errors causes clarity problems. Possible scores for open-ended responses are 0 (insufficient), 1 (partially sufficient), 2 (sufficient), and 3 (exemplary). Each open-ended item—the literary item, the expository item, and the “crossover” item—is based on a separate reading rubric. These three rubrics appear on pages 35–46. Dictionary/Thesaurus Use The use of an English language dictionary and thesaurus is permitted throughout the test. While students are working, they must have access to an English language dictionary and thesaurus or an English language dictionary/thesaurus combination. The school may provide these, or students may bring copies from home. Any dictionary may be provided, but current dictionaries have features such as synonyms, idiomatic expressions (especially helpful to English language learners), geographical names, biographical names, etc. Districts may want to gradually update their dictionaries as budgets permit. The minimum schools need is one dictionary/thesaurus for every five students testing, but the state’s recommendation is one for every three students or, optimally, one for each student. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 7 Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 8 Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills (TAKS) Blueprint for Grade 9 Reading TAKS Objectives Number of Items Objective 1: Basic Understanding (Reading) 9 multiple-choice items Objective 2: Literary Elements and Techniques (Reading) 12 multiple-choice items 1 open-ended item* Objective 3: Analysis and Critical Evaluation (Reading) 12 multiple-choice items 2 open-ended items* Total number of items 33 multiple-choice items 3 open-ended reading items *One open-ended item assesses the literary selection (Objective 2), one assesses the expository selection (Objective 3), and one connects the two selections (Objective 3). Each open-ended item is equivalent to 3 multiple-choice items. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 9 A Key to Understanding the TEKS Included on TAKS Grade 9 Reading Example from Objective 1 A (6) Reading/word identification/vocabulary development. The student uses a variety of strategies to read unfamiliar words and to build vocabulary. The student is expected to B (B) rely on context to determine meanings of words and phrases such as figurative language, [idioms,] multiple-meaning words, and technical vocabulary. C KEY A. Knowledge and Skills Statement This broad statement describes what students should know and be able to do for ninth grade reading. The number preceding the statement is the number of the knowledge and skills statement as it appears in the TEKS for English I. B. Student Expectation This specific statement describes what students should be able to do to demonstrate proficiency in what is described in the knowledge and skills statement. Students are tested on skills outlined in the student expectation statement. C. [bracketed text] Although the entire student expectation has been provided for reference, text in brackets indicates that this portion of the student expectation is not tested on TAKS. NOTE: The full TEKS curriculum can be found at www.tea.state.tx.us/teks/. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 10 TEKS STUDENT EXPECTATIONS—IMPORTANT VOCABULARY For every subject area and grade level, two terms—such as and including—are used to help make the TEKS student expectations more concrete for teachers. However, these terms function in different ways. To help you understand the effect each of the terms has on specific student expectations, we are providing the following: a short definition of each term an example from a specific student expectation for this subject area a short explanation of how this term affects this student expectation Such as The term such as is used when the specific examples that follow it function only as representative illustrations that help define the expectation for teachers. These examples are just that—examples. Teachers may choose to use them when teaching the student expectation, but there is no requirement to use them. Other examples can be used in addition to those listed or as replacements for those listed. The English I TEKS (12) (D) states that the student is expected to analyze texts such as editorials, [documentaries,] and advertisements for bias and use of common persuasive techniques. Students learn to analyze persuasive techniques by examining a variety of texts; the terms following the such as are examples of types of texts that may be used for this kind of analysis. However, this list is not exhaustive or exclusive. Teachers may use these types of texts or others to teach students how authors create bias or use persuasive techniques to influence the reader. Including The term including is used when the specific examples that follow it must be taught. However, other examples may also be used in conjunction with those listed. The English I TEKS (12) (A) states that the student is expected to analyze characteristics of text, including its structure, word choices, and intended audience. The terms following including are examples of critical characteristics of text that a student needs to master. These characteristics must be taught; however, teachers are not limited to teaching only these characteristics. Remember Any example preceded by the term such as in a particular student expectation may or may not provide the basis for an item assessing that expectation. Because these examples do not necessarily have to be used to teach the student expectation, it is equally likely that other examples will be used in assessment items. The rule here is that an example will be used only if it is central to the knowledge, concept, or skill the item assesses. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 11 It is more likely that some of the examples preceded by the term including in a particular student expectation will provide the basis for items assessing that expectation, since these examples must be taught. However, it is important to remember that the examples that follow the term including do not represent all the examples possible, so other examples may also provide the basis for an assessment item. Again, the rule here is that an example will be used only if it is central to the knowledge, concept, or skill the item assesses. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 12 TAKS Grade 9 Reading—Objective 1 Before students can form their own ideas about a text, they must be able to understand its basic meaning. To develop an initial understanding of what they read, students must be able to do four things: (1) use context and other word-identification strategies to help them understand the meaning of the words they read, (2) recognize important supporting details, (3) understand what a selection or a portion of a selection is mostly about—in other words, understand the “gist” of that selection, and (4) produce an accurate summary of a selection. These skills are the building blocks that students need in order to develop a deeper understanding of what they read. Objective 1 The student will demonstrate a basic understanding of culturally diverse written texts. (6) (7) (8) Reading/word identification/vocabulary development. The student uses a variety of strategies to read unfamiliar words and to build vocabulary. The student is expected to (B) rely on context to determine meanings of words and phrases such as figurative language, [idioms,] multiple-meaning words, and technical vocabulary; (C) apply meanings of prefixes, roots, and suffixes in order to comprehend; (E) use reference material such as glossary, dictionary, thesaurus, [and available technology] to determine precise meanings and usage; and (F) identify the relation of word meanings in analogies, homonyms, synonyms/antonyms, and connotation/denotation. Reading/comprehension. The student comprehends selections using a variety of strategies. The student is expected to (F) identify main ideas and their supporting details; and (G) summarize texts. Reading/variety of texts. The student reads extensively and intensively for different purposes in varied sources, including world literature. The student is expected to (B) read in such varied sources as diaries, journals, textbooks, maps, newspapers, letters, speeches, memoranda, [electronic texts, and other media]. Objective 1—For Your Information For vocabulary items, students are always provided with enough context clues to allow them to identify the correct meaning of the word as it is used in the reading selection. However, students should also be able to use a variety of word-identification strategies, such as word structure (prefixes, roots, and suffixes), analogies (a comparison of two words or phrases that suggests a similarity between them), or connotation (the emotional impact of a word beyond its dictionary definition), in conjunction with context to help them understand the words they are reading. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 13 Items testing multiple-meaning words may require students to identify the correct answer from a sample dictionary entry. The entry includes the tested word, its part of speech, and multiple definitions of the word. Students must use the information given and context clues to choose the correct meaning of the word as it is used in the reading selection. Some items require students to recognize main idea(s) or gist in expository texts or in a limited portion of a literary text. These items clearly indicate to students that they are to focus on broad or central ideas. Summary items focus on the reading selection as a whole. A summary is a short paragraph that includes the main idea and the most important details of a text. Summary items can be attached to either literary or expository selections; however, for literary texts, students must be able to recognize a plot summary. For items assessing summarization, all answer choices are constructed authentically as short paragraphs. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 14 TAKS Grade 9 Reading—Objective 2 To appreciate the literature they read in high school, students must develop an understanding of the literary elements that are at the heart of all stories. This understanding must go beyond mere identification to encompass the ways in which the parts of a story, singly and in combination, contribute to its overall meaning. Students must also understand the ways in which an author uses literary techniques and language to craft a story. In open-ended items assessing Objective 2, students must write a short response analyzing how literary elements, literary techniques, or figurative language function in a story. Objective 2 The student will demonstrate an understanding of the effects of literary elements and techniques in culturally diverse written texts. (10) Reading/literary response. The student expresses and supports responses to various types of texts. The student is expected to (B) (11) use elements of text to defend his/her own responses and interpretations. Reading/literary concepts. The student analyzes literary elements for their contributions to meaning in literary texts. The student is expected to (A) recognize the theme (general observation about life or human nature) within a text; (B) analyze the relevance of setting and time frame to text’s meaning; (C) analyze characters and identify time and point of view; (D) identify basic conflicts; (E) analyze the development of plot in narrative text; (F) recognize and interpret important symbols; (G) recognize and interpret poetic elements like metaphor, simile, personification, and the effect of sound on meaning; and (H) understand literary forms and terms such as author, drama, biography, autobiography, myth, tall tale, dialogue, tragedy and comedy, [structure in poetry, epic, ballad,] protagonist, antagonist, paradox, analogy, dialect, and comic relief as appropriate to the selections being read. Objective 2—For Your Information Items dealing with theme require students to recognize that any theme identified must be justified by evidence from the text. Items dealing with setting do not simply measure whether a student can identify the time and/or the place of a selection. Instead, these items require students to analyze how the setting is central to and enhances the meaning of the text. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 15 In order to understand literature, students must learn to interpret literary techniques. Students must first be able to recognize literary techniques so that they then may analyze how the author uses them to shape a reader’s understanding of characters, events, and theme. Items that assess a student’s knowledge of literary techniques, such as foreshadowing, flashback, and symbolism, will be appropriate for ninth graders; that is, students will not be asked questions about literary techniques that are overly sophisticated or too far beyond their developing understanding of author’s craft. Literary techniques are assessed only when they are clearly present in the text. Items dealing with literary language move beyond simple identification of similes, metaphors, etc. Instead, these items require students to understand how an author uses non-literal language to create meaning and how that language functions in the text. Where appropriate, items may address historical or contemporary context and its contribution to meaning in a text. If the context is important to an understanding of the selection but is not explicit in the selection or so widely known that all students would be aware of that context, a short explanatory paragraph establishing the context is provided for the selection. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 16 TAKS Grade 9 Reading—Objective 3 To read well at the high school level, students must go beyond their initial understanding or impressions of a selection. Students must be able to develop their own interpretations, make thoughtful judgments about what they read, examine how a selection relates to their own lives, and find meaningful connections across parts of a single selection or between two selections. Students must also be aware of the way an author crafts a selection. An author’s purpose for writing, organizational decisions, point of view or attitude toward the subject, and unique use of language all affect the way a reader reads and understands a selection. In open-ended items assessing Objective 3, students must write a short response analyzing or evaluating some aspect of the expository selection or some aspect of text common to or based upon both selections. These are the skills students must learn in order to move beyond the literal meaning of a text, develop the deeper understanding necessary to think critically about what they read, connect what they know to new information, and become independent thinkers. Objective 3 The student will demonstrate the ability to analyze and critically evaluate culturally diverse written texts and visual representations. (7) (8) Reading/comprehension. The student comprehends selections using a variety of strategies. The student is expected to (E) analyze text structures such as compare and contrast, cause and effect, and chronological ordering; and (H) draw inferences such as conclusions, generalizations, and predictions and support them from text. Reading/variety of texts. The student reads extensively and intensively for different purposes in varied sources, including world literature. The student is expected to (D) (10) Reading/literary response. The student expresses and supports responses to various types of texts. The student is expected to (B) (12) interpret the possible influences of the historical context on a literary work. use elements of text to defend his/her own responses and interpretations. Reading/analysis/evaluation. The student reads critically to evaluate texts. The student is expected to (A) analyze characteristics of text, including its structure, word choices, and intended audience; (B) evaluate the credibility of information sources and determine the writer’s motives; (C) analyze text to evaluate the logical argument [and to determine the mode of reasoning used such as induction and deduction]; and (D) analyze texts such as editorials, [documentaries,] and advertisements for bias and use of common persuasive techniques. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 17 (19) (20) Viewing/representing/interpretation. The student understands and interprets visual representations. The student is expected to (B) analyze relationships, ideas, [and cultures] as represented in various media; and (C) distinguish the purposes of various media forms such as informative texts, entertaining texts, and advertisements. Viewing/representing/analysis. The student analyzes and critiques the significance of visual representations. The student is expected to (B) deconstruct media to get the main idea of the message’s content; and (C) evaluate and critique the persuasive techniques of media messages such as glittering generalities, logical fallacies, and symbols. Objective 3—For Your Information Objective 3 items may assess any portion of the triplet. (Note: The viewing and representing piece is assessed under Objective 3 only.) To move beyond a basic understanding of two related texts, students must be able to compare, connect, and contrast ideas, themes, and issues across texts. Items that address the viewing and representing piece may require students to examine the purpose of various media forms, evaluate the persuasive techniques of media messages, or deconstruct media to determine the central idea of a message and how effectively that message has been conveyed. Items that assess a student’s ability to recognize that authors organize information in specific ways focus on the organizational patterns authors choose in order to arrange and link ideas. It is important for students to know that authors organize ideas in various ways, depending upon how they want the reader to understand those ideas. Familiarity with common organizational patterns—for example, sequencing, description, comparison/contrast, cause/effect, and problem/solution—helps students learn how these patterns can affect the meaning of a text. If students are able to recognize this connection, they will develop their ability to comprehend, evaluate, and appreciate a wide variety of texts. For items of this type, students are expected to identify general patterns rather than use specific terminology. Items that assess the ability to read and think inferentially require students to move beyond their basic understanding of a text to demonstrate a deeper, more complete understanding of what they’ve read. These types of items can take many forms; for example, items may require students to draw a conclusion, make a reasonable prediction, understand the relationship between two parts of a text, understand how a text relates to their own lives, or understand the deeper meanings implied by a text. Where appropriate, items may require students to interpret the impact of historical context on a text or visual representation. If the context is important to a student’s understanding but is not explicit in the text or visual representation, a short explanatory paragraph establishing such a context is provided for the selection. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 18 Items that require students to support interpretations or conclusions with evidence from the text include paraphrased ideas or sentences taken verbatim from the text. However, an individual item never mixes these answer-choice options; that is, paraphrased ideas and verbatim quotes are not combined in the same item. Answer choices using words, phrases, or sentences taken verbatim from the text are italicized. To determine how style, tone, and mood contribute to the effect of a text, students must be able to recognize how an author uses these elements to make a text unique. Students must understand that the way an author uses words, phrases, and sentences to make a text distinctive from others represents his or her style. The author creates a particular tone when his or her attitude toward the content is reflected in the text, affecting the way the student reads and understands it. For example, a text that has an objective tone is very different from one that has a sentimental tone. Mood is somewhat different from tone: mood is the feeling or atmosphere the writer creates through the details or language he or she uses. Items of this type are developed only when these elements are clearly present in the text. Items that assess style, tone, and mood will not be too sophisticated for ninth graders or too far beyond their developing understanding of author’s craft. To answer questions about how an author’s motives or point of view affects the text, students will need to examine the author’s attitude toward his or her subject or topic. The author’s motivation for writing or the point of view he or she brings to the selection not only affects the tone of the piece but also the way the author shapes and develops his or her ideas. These items are developed for selections only when the writer’s attitude is obvious and clearly has an effect on the text. Items assessing author’s purpose require students to analyze how an author presents his or her ideas. To determine the purpose of a text—whether that purpose is informative, persuasive, expressive, or entertaining—students must recognize that the way authors organize their writing depends on which organizational pattern will best convey what they want the reader to understand. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 19 DIRECTIONS Read the two selections and the viewing and representing piece. Then answer the questions that follow. The Night Before Thanksgiving by Sarah Orne Jewett I. 1 There was a sad heart in the low-storied, dark little house that stood humbly by the roadside under some tall elms. Small as her house was, old Mrs. Robb found it too large for herself alone; she only needed the kitchen and a tiny bedroom that led out of it, and there still remained the best room and a bedroom, with the low garret overhead. 2 There had been a time, after she was left alone, when Mrs. Robb could help those who were poorer than herself. She was strong enough not only to do a woman’s work inside her house, but almost a man’s work outside in her piece of garden ground. At last sickness and age had come hand in hand, those two relentless enemies of the poor, and together they had wasted her strength and substance. She had always been looked up to by her neighbors as being independent, but now she was left, lame-footed and lamehanded, with a debt to carry and her bare land, and the house ill-provisioned to stand the siege of time. 3 For a while she managed to get on, but at last it began to be whispered about that there was no use for anyone so proud; it was easier for the whole town to care for her than for a few neighbors, and Mrs. Robb had better go to the poorhouse before winter, and be done with it. At this terrible suggestion her brave heart seemed to stand still. The people whom she cared for most happened to be poor, and she could no longer go into their households to make herself of use. The very elms overhead seemed to say, “Oh, no!” as they groaned in the late autumn winds, and there was something appealing even to the strange passer-by in the look of the little gray house, with Mrs. Robb’s pale, worried face at the window. My notes about what I am reading II. 4 Someone has said that anniversaries are days to make other people happy in, but sometimes when they come they seem to be full of shadows, and the power of giving joy to others, that inalienable right which ought to lighten the saddest heart, the most indifferent sympathy, sometimes even this seems to be withdrawn. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 20 5 So poor old Mary Ann Robb sat at her window on the afternoon before Thanksgiving and felt herself poor and sorrowful indeed. Across the frozen road she looked eastward over a great stretch of cold meadow land, brown and wind-swept and crossed by icy ditches. It seemed to her as if before this, in all the troubles that she had known and carried, there had always been some hope to hold: as if she had never looked poverty full in the face and seen its cold and pitiless look before. She looked anxiously down the road, with a horrible shrinking and dread at the thought of being asked, out of pity, to join in some Thanksgiving feast, but there was nobody coming with gifts in hand. Once she had been full of love for such days, whether at home or abroad, but something chilled her very heart now. 6 Her nearest neighbor had been foremost of those who wished her to go to the town farm, and he had said more than once that it was the only sensible thing. But John Mander was waiting impatiently to get her tiny farm into his own hands; he had advanced some money upon it in her extremity, and pretended that there was still a debt after he cleared her wood lot to pay himself back. He would plough over the graves in the field corner and fell the great elms, and waited now like a spider for his poor prey. He often reproached her for being too generous to worthless people in the past and coming to be a charge to others now. Oh, if she could only die in her own house and not suffer the pain of homelessness and dependence! 7 It was just at sunset, and as she looked out hopelessly across the gray fields, there was a sudden gleam of light far away on the low hills beyond; the clouds opened in the west and let the sunshine through. One lovely gleam shot swift as an arrow and brightened a far cold hillside where it fell, and at the same moment a sudden gleam of hope brightened the winter landscape of her heart. 8 “There was Johnny Harris,” said Mary Ann Robb softly. “He was a soldier’s son, left an orphan and distressed. Old John Mander scolded, but I couldn’t see the poor boy in want. I kept him that year after he got hurt, spite o’ what anybody said, an’ he helped me what little he could. He said I was the only mother he’d ever had. ‘I’m goin’ out West, Mother Robb,’ says he. ‘I sha’n’t come back till I get rich,’ an’ then he’d look at me an’ laugh, so pleasant and boyish. He wa’n’t one that liked to write. I don’t think he was doin’ very well when I heard—there, it’s most four years ago now. I always thought if he got sick or anything I would have a good home for him to come to. There’s poor Ezra Blake, the deaf one, too—he won’t have any place to welcome him.” My notes about what I am reading Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 21 9 The light faded out of doors, and again Mrs. Robb’s troubles stood before her. Yet it was not so dark as it had been in her sad heart. She still sat by the window, hoping now, in spite of herself, instead of fearing; and a curious feeling of nearness and expectancy made her feel not so much light-hearted as light-headed. 10 “I feel just as if somethin’ was goin’ to happen,” she said. “Poor Johnny Harris, perhaps he’s thinkin’ o’ me, if he’s alive.” 11 It was dark now out of doors, and there were tiny clicks against the window. It was beginning to snow, and the great elms creaked in the rising wind overhead. My notes about what I am reading III. 12 A dead limb of one of the old trees had fallen that autumn, and, poor firewood as it might be, it was Mrs. Robb’s own, and she had burnt it most thankfully. There was only a small armful left, but at least she could have the luxury of a fire. She had a feeling that it was her last night at home, and with strange recklessness began to fill the stove as she used to do in better days. 13 “It’ll get me good an’ warm,” she said, still talking to herself, as lonely people do, “an’ I’ll go to bed early. It’s comin’ on to storm.” 14 The snow clicked faster and faster against the window, and she sat alone thinking in the dark. 15 “There’s lots of folks I love,” she said once. “They’d be sorry I ain’t got nobody to come, an’ no supper the night afore Thanksgivin’. I’m dreadful glad they don’t know.” And she drew a little nearer to the fire, and laid her head back drowsily in the old rocking chair. 16 It seemed only a moment before there was a loud knocking, and somebody lifted the latch of the door. The fire shone bright through the front of the stove and made a little light in the room, but Mary Ann Robb waked up frightened and bewildered. 17 “Who’s there?” she called, as she found her crutch and went to the door. She was only conscious of her one great fear. “They’ve come to take me to the poorhouse!” she said, and burst into tears. 18 There was a tall man, not John Mander, who seemed to fill the narrow doorway. 19 “Come, let me in!” he said gayly. “It’s a cold night. You didn’t expect me, did you, Mother Robb?” 20 “Dear me, what is it?” she faltered, stepping back as he came in and dropping her crutch. “Be I dreamin’? I was aGrade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 22 dreamin’ about—Oh, there! What was I a-sayin’? ’Tain’t true! No! I’ve made some kind of mistake!” 21 Yes, and this was the man who kept the poorhouse, and she would go without complaint; they might have given her notice, but she must not fret. 22 “Sit down, sir,” she said, turning toward him with touching patience. “You’ll have to give me a little time. If I’d been notified I wouldn’t have kept you waiting a minute this stormy night.” 23 It was not the keeper of the poorhouse. The man by the door took one step forward and put his arm round her and kissed her. 24 “What are you talking about?” said John Harris. “You ain’t goin’ to make me feel like a stranger? I’ve come all the way from Dakota to spend Thanksgivin’. There’s all sorts o’ things out there in the wagon, an’ a man to help get ’em in. Why, don’t cry so, Mother Robb. I thought you’d have a great laugh, if I come and surprised you. Don’t you remember I always said I would come?” 25 It was John Harris, indeed. The poor soul could say nothing. She felt now as if her heart was going to break with joy. He left her in the rocking chair and came and went in his old boyish way, bringing in the store of gifts and provisions. It was better than any dream. He laughed and talked, and went out to send away the man to bring a wagonful of wood from John Mander’s, and came in himself laden with pieces of the nearest fence to keep the fire going in the mean time. They must cook the beefsteak for supper right away; they must find the pound of tea among all the other bundles; they must get good fires started in both the cold bedrooms. Why, Mother Robb didn’t seem to be ready for company from out West! The great, cheerful fellow hurried about the tiny house, and the little old woman limped after him, forgetting everything but hospitality. Had not she a house for John to come to? Were not her old chairs and tables in their places still? And he remembered everything, and kissed her as they stood before the fire, as if she were a girl. 26 He had found plenty of hard times, but luck had come at last. He had struck luck, and this was the end of a great year. 27 “No, I couldn’t seem to write letters; no use to complain o’ the worst, an’ I wanted to tell you the best when I came,” and he told it while she cooked the supper. “No, I wa’n’t goin’ to write no foolish letters,” John repeated. He was afraid he would cry himself when he found out how bad things had been; and they sat down to supper together, just My notes about what I am reading Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 23 as they used to do when he was a homeless orphan boy, whom nobody else wanted in winter weather while he was crippled and could not work. She could not be kinder now than she was then, but she looked so poor and old! He saw her taste her cup of tea and set it down again with a trembling hand and a look at him. “No, I wanted to come myself,” he blustered, wiping his eyes and trying to laugh. “And you’re going to have everything you need to make you comfortable long’s you live, Mother Robb!” 28 My notes about what I am reading She looked at him again and nodded, but she did not even try to speak. There was a good hot supper ready, and a happy guest had come; it was the night before Thanksgiving. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 24 The Kindness of Strangers by Susan Schindehette and J. Todd Foster Cristina Hunt. A perfect trade—and one of only a handful of so-called paired exchanges performed so far in which there is a double stranger-to-stranger donation. Two couples had never met—until each husband donated one of his kidneys to save the other man’s wife 1 2 At first the encounter was as awkward as a double blind date. One man blushed a tomato-red color; a woman shifted in her chair and rubbed her hands together. But their discomfort was understandable. When David and Cristina Hunt faced Jennifer and Will Stoelting across a conference table at the Inova Transplant Center in Fairfax, Va., in June, the stakes were life and death. Both women were suffering from kidney disease and knew that, unless they could find a transplant in the near future, they could die. But if the meeting went well, the four would gather again in a little more than a month, this time at Inova Fairfax Hospital. There doctors would remove one healthy kidney from each of the two husbands, then implant those kidneys into their ideally matched recipients. David Hunt’s would go to Jennifer Stoelting and Will Stoelting’s to Despite the initial jitters, that first meeting was a huge relief to Cristina, 31, and Jennifer, 27, both of whom had been on dialysis for years. “I just thought, ‘Yea, I’m getting a kidney,’” recalls Jennifer, though, as David put it, “They could have been Hitler and Eva Braun1 as long as they had a kidney to give us.” Indeed, just five weeks later, on July 18, in four simultaneous surgeries that spanned nearly eight hours, a 23-person medical team removed David’s kidney and implanted it in Jennifer just as Will’s was being given to Cristina. Even in the best circumstances “a living, unrelated kidney doesn’t match perfectly, but luckily for us, all four procedures went off without a hitch,” says Dr. Johann Jonsson, 48, director of kidney-transplant services at Inova, who operated on David. “These husbands gave these wives at least 10 additional years to live.” 3 Of the 13,372 kidneys transplanted last year, more than 8,000 came from cadavers. Unfortunately for the 52,498 Americans now on waiting lists, cadaver kidneys remain functional for only about nine years, while ones from living donors can last twice that. Of course, if no relative yields a match, finding a suitable—and willing—donor presents a formidable obstacle. Paired exchanges are a new and promising alternative because they offer 4 ■ see Kindness, page 2 1 Adolf Hitler’s girlfriend Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 25 ■ Kindness, cont. from page 1 4 cont. 5 6 donors an incentive. In the case of the Hunts and Stoeltings it was a straight exchange. But in some cases a parent may also bump his or her own child to the top of a waiting list by serving as an anonymous organ donor. “Until fairly recently it was kind of unheard of to donate to a stranger,” says Toni Webb, spokeswoman for the Washington Regional Transplant Consortium, one of the few organizations around the country that coordinate local paired transplants. “I think we’re going to see a lot more of these exchanges.” For Cristina Hunt, the development came none too soon. Born in New York City to a bookkeeper whose husband left the family when Cristina was a baby, she met David, now a 31-year-old career Marine captain, in 1990 while the two were on separate vacations in Tijuana. They married three months later. Within a year the couple’s first son, Christopher, was born. But in 1995, while pregnant with Jordan, now 6, Cristina was diagnosed with a form of nephritis, a chronic inflammation of the kidneys. In late 1998 she was put on dialysis, and in the years since she has spent nine hours every night hooked up to a machine to cleanse her blood. Over time Cristina, a homemaker, developed several severe infections, and this year she nearly died twice, once from septic shock and another time from massive blood loss. Her doctors said a transplant seemed her best option. In January the Hunts were told that husband David would be an acceptable match. But in March, the day before the transplant was due to take place, both were devastated to learn that recent transfusions had caused Cristina to Page 2 develop antibodies to David’s blood, and he was no longer a possible donor. Meanwhile in Manassas, Va., not far from the Hunts’ Stafford, Va., home, Jennifer and Will Stoelting were experiencing much the same anguish. As a girl growing up in Pennsylvania, Jennifer, whose family has a history of kidney disease, developed high blood pressure and a succession of serious bladder infections, which later caused her kidneys to fail. While a senior at Manassas Park High School in 1993, she met Will, now 27, who works for an insurance company. The two, who have no children, wed in 1996. Throughout their marriage Will stood by Jen during her trips every other day to a dialysis clinic. Four years ago Jen, a medical receptionist, put her name on the national waiting list maintained by the Richmond, Va.-based United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS). “But you never know if they’re going to call you,” says Will. “It could be 10 years.” 7 The fateful notice came much sooner. Both Jennifer and Cristina were undergoing treatment at Inova, and nurses Masomeh Dhaliwal and Pat DiSanto, the hospital’s transplant coordinators, realized that their respective blood types might mean a possible match. In May the Stoeltings received a phone message from DiSanto, who in measured tones announced that she might have found a match from a man whose wife also needed a transplant. “Jen freaked out,” recalls Will. “But I knew it wasn’t a sure thing.” Happily, tissue typing, CT scanning and further tests revealed that both 8 ■ see Kindness, page 3 Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 26 ■ Kindness, cont. from page 2 husbands were ideal donors, and the two couples met with doctors at a June briefing. “The doctors said, ‘Okay, the date is July 18.’ It was quick,” recalls Will. Cristina remembers that news as “nerveracking, like a prearranged marriage.” 9 10 Just 12 hours after the surgeries, all four patients were recovering beautifully. Jennifer’s mother, Dolores Adams, 50, visited David Hunt in his hospital room and thanked him for saving her daughter’s life. “I gave him a kiss and said, ‘You don’t know what this means to me,’” she recalls. “He said, ‘I’m glad to do it, ma’am, but I didn’t know it would hurt this bad.’” Despite their painful operations, both men were out of the hospital in three days and are now back at work. According to doctors, their remaining kidneys will simply grow larger to accommodate the Page 3 added workload. As for their wives, the first three months after transplant are most critical, but both are back at home and expected to recover fully. Cristina, now free of her dialysis catheter, can look forward to swimming with her sons for the first time when she is fully healed. And Jennifer? She reports that she is simply “doing great.” In the weeks following their surgeries the couples have remained in touch and predict that the remarkable bond between them will last throughout their lives. In fact, Will’s stepfather, Stuart Martin, 62, sees this as something more than a medical marvel. “These husbands gave their hearts to their wives when they were married,” says Martin. “And they gave their kidneys to continue that love.” People Weekly. All Rights Reserved. Time Inc. Photograph courtesy of © John Francis Ficara. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 27 11 13 weeks on the Top Ten for Teens book list CICADA MEDAL FOR YOUNG ADULT NONFICTION RANDOM ACTS Stories of Everyday Kindness Le Sp e enc er RANDOM ACTS Stories of Everyday Kindness by Lee Spencer “Meet the hospital volunteer who knits funny hats for children with cancer, the ‘roadside helper’ who delivers gas and fixes flat tires, the ten-year-old soup-kitchen chef, and others in this delightful collection of heartwarming tales.” —Rose Magellen, Weekly Book Review Photograph courtesy of © Lee White/CORBIS. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 28 Use “The Night Before Thanksgiving” (pp. 20–24) to answer questions 1–8. 1 Which words from paragraphs 9 and 10 help the reader understand the meaning of the word expectancy in paragraph 9? 3 Which of these best summarizes the plot of the story? A A a curious feeling of nearness B* as if somethin’ was goin’ to happen C not so much light-hearted as light-headed D perhaps he’s thinkin’ o’ me B* Mrs. Robb is old and weak and has little money. She can no longer support herself but doesn’t want to go to the poorhouse. Just as she thinks she will have no other choice, a young man she helped years earlier comes to her aid. Objective 1 2 C Mrs. Robb was once a strong and selfsufficient woman. She reached out to help others, including John Harris, an orphan. Over the years, though, she has become weak and ill, and she is unable to support herself. D Mrs. Robb is sad because she has no one with whom to spend Thanksgiving. As night falls, it begins to snow, and a cold wind blows. The old woman uses the last of her firewood to heat one small room of her house. What is paragraph 3 mostly about? A B People who live in Mrs. Robb’s town whisper about her letting her house become run down, but strangers think the house looks appealing. Mrs. Robb is strong and brave, and she refuses to listen to the people in town who want to send her to the poorhouse for the rest of her life. C* Mrs. Robb fears that she will be placed in the poorhouse, since she is no longer able to care for herself and there is no one to take responsibility for her. D Mrs. Robb can no longer support herself, and the townspeople want to put her in the poorhouse. Her neighbor John Mander pretends to help, but he is actually taking advantage of her. He wants to send her off so he can get her land. Some people think Mrs. Robb should go to the poorhouse because she can no longer take care of herself, and she is relieved by the thought of getting some help. Objective 1 4 The author has Mrs. Robb talk to herself in order to — Objective 1 A* reveal her thoughts to the reader B show how she is slipping mentally C illustrate how few friends she has D make a point about aging and poverty Objective 2 Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 29 5 One way the author creates tension in the story is by — A 7 describing the interior of Mrs. Robb’s house A B* having an unidentified person knock at the door C explaining Mrs. Robb’s relationship with John Harris D providing details about the items in John Harris’s wagon Why doesn’t Mrs. Robb want the people she loves to know about her lonely condition on the night before Thanksgiving? She is afraid they will be angry with her. B* She doesn’t want to worry them. C She senses they wouldn’t care much. D She prefers to spend the holiday by herself. Objective 3 Objective 2 This item requires students to understand how an author crafts a piece of writing to produce a particular effect. 8 The author develops the selection primarily by — A* recounting Mrs. Robb’s thoughts and actions on the night before Thanksgiving 6 The way the characters speak helps the reader understand something about — A* the time and place in which the story is set B a conflict between the characters C the plot of the story D a major theme in the story B comparing Mrs. Robb’s present situation with that of her neighbors C analyzing the reasons why Mrs. Robb is alone on the night before Thanksgiving D alternating between events in Mrs. Robb’s life and events in John Harris’s life Objective 3 Objective 2 This item requires students to understand what techniques the author uses to establish setting. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 30 Use “The Kindness of Strangers” (pp. 25–27) to answer questions 9–14. 9 Read the following dictionary entry. 11 hitch \ hich\ n 1. a sudden movement or pull 2. a device that connects two things 3. an unforeseen difficulty or obstacle 4. any of various knots used to secure a line temporarily Which definition best matches the meaning of the word hitch as it is used in paragraph 3 of the article? A Definition 1 B Definition 2 A Despite their painful operations, both men were out of the hospital in three days and are now back at work. B Throughout their marriage Will stood by Jen during her trips every other day to a dialysis clinic. C Both women were suffering from kidney disease and knew that, unless they could find a transplant in the near future, they could die. D* “These husbands gave their hearts to their wives when they were married,” says Martin. “And they gave their kidneys to continue that love.” C* Definition 3 D Which of the following quotations from the article best expresses a theme of the selection? Definition 4 Objective 1 Objective 2 10 According to the article, what happens after someone donates a kidney for transplant? A The donor’s other organs take over the functions of the removed kidney. B The donor experiences chronic pain that must be controlled by medication. C The donor must undergo occasional dialysis. D* The donor’s remaining kidney grows larger to do the added work. Objective 1 In items such as this, students need not search the text to locate the specific lines quoted in the answer choices. Instead, students need to recognize which piece of textual evidence answers the question. 12 In paragraph 1, the authors use a simile to — A describe how blind dates can be embarrassing B* emphasize the nervousness the four people felt C show how important organ donations are D explain why the two couples were meeting Objective 2 Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 31 13 In paragraph 4, the authors present statistics and other background information in order to — A persuade the reader to become a kidney donor B* emphasize that the couples’ experience was unusual C stress that transplants from cadavers are the most effective D point out why some people need kidney transplants 14 The article suggests that family members of those needing transplants — A* can help by offering to become donors themselves B often end up needing kidney transplants themselves C can never be matching donors for transplants D have difficulties when they stay on dialysis too long Objective 3 Objective 3 This item requires students to understand why an author includes certain pieces of information. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 32 Use “The Night Before Thanksgiving” and “The Kindness of Strangers” to answer questions 15 and 16. Crossover Items 15 In both selections, the theme is best expressed through the — 16 In both selections, the women — A A* actions of people B characters’ thoughts C dialogue D setting lack family support B* have problems they can’t solve alone C depend on their husbands for help D need strangers to help them out Objective 3 Objective 2 Use the visual representation on page 28 to answer questions 17 and 18. 17 The purpose of the photograph on the book jacket is most likely to — 18 Which of these elements of the book jacket supports the author’s credibility? A show a way that people can be kind to others A Random Acts: Stories of Everyday Kindness B convince readers to help little children B “. . . this delightful collection of heartwarming tales.” C Rose Magellen, Weekly Book Review C* appeal to the readers’ emotions D compare the sizes of adult and infant hands Objective 3 In viewing and representing items, students are asked to deconstruct media to determine the message being conveyed. D* Cicada Medal for Young Adult Nonfiction Objective 3 Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 33 OPEN-ENDED ITEMS 19 In “The Night Before Thanksgiving,” what is one conflict faced by Mrs. Robb? Support your answer with evidence from the selection. Objective 2 20 Do you think the husbands in “The Kindness of Strangers” are brave? Explain your answer and support it with evidence from the selection. Objective 3 Open-ended items such as this have no one correct answer. Students must, however, explain the answer they choose and support it with relevant, strongly connected textual evidence. 21 How is the idea that good deeds are rewarded important in both “The Night Before Thanksgiving” and “The Kindness of Strangers”? Support your answer with evidence from both selections. Objective 3 This item is an example of an open-ended crossover item. In responding to open-ended items that range across two selections, students must offer an idea or analysis based on both selections and provide relevant, strongly connected textual evidence from both selections. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 34 READING RUBRIC—LITERARY SELECTION OBJECTIVE 2 SCORE POINT 0 — INSUFFICIENT In insufficient responses, the student ❒ may offer an incorrect theme, character trait, conflict, or change ❒ may offer a theme, character, conflict, or change that is too general or vague to determine whether it is reasonable ❒ may incorrectly analyze a literary technique or figurative expression ❒ may offer an analysis that is too general or vague to determine whether it is reasonable ❒ may present only a plot summary ❒ may not address the question in any way or may answer a different question than the one asked ❒ may offer only incomplete or irrelevant textual evidence In addition, insufficient responses may lack clarity. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 35 READING RUBRIC—LITERARY SELECTION OBJECTIVE 2 SCORE POINT 1 — PARTIALLY SUFFICIENT In partially sufficient responses, the student ❒ may offer a reasonable theme, character trait, conflict, or change but provide only general, incomplete, or partially accurate/relevant textual evidence or provide no textual evidence at all ❒ may offer a reasonable analysis of a literary technique or figurative expression but provide only general, incomplete, or partially accurate/relevant textual evidence or provide no textual evidence at all ❒ may offer a reasonable idea or analysis and may provide textual evidence, but this evidence is only weakly connected to the idea or analysis ❒ may offer accurate/relevant textual evidence without providing an idea or analysis In addition, partially sufficient responses may be somewhat unclear or vague. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 36 READING RUBRIC—LITERARY SELECTION OBJECTIVE 2 SCORE POINT 2 — SUFFICIENT In sufficient responses, the student ❒ must offer a reasonable theme, character trait, conflict, or change and support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence ❒ must offer a reasonable analysis of a literary technique or figurative expression and support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence In addition, sufficient responses must be clear and specific. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 37 READING RUBRIC—LITERARY SELECTION OBJECTIVE 2 SCORE POINT 3 — EXEMPLARY In exemplary responses, the student ❒ must offer a particularly thoughtful or insightful theme, character trait, conflict, or change and strongly support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence ❒ must offer a particularly thoughtful or insightful analysis of a literary technique or figurative expression and strongly support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence In addition, exemplary responses must demonstrate the student’s depth of understanding and ability to effectively connect textual evidence to the idea or analysis. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 38 READING RUBRIC—EXPOSITORY SELECTION OBJECTIVE 3 SCORE POINT 0 — INSUFFICIENT In insufficient responses, the student ❒ may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, or make a prediction that is not based on the text ❒ may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, or make a prediction that does not address the question ❒ may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, or make a prediction that is not reasonable ❒ may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, or make a prediction that is too general or vague to determine whether it is reasonable ❒ may incorrectly analyze or evaluate a characteristic of the text ❒ may not address the question in any way or may answer a different question than the one asked ❒ may offer only incomplete or irrelevant textual evidence In addition, insufficient responses may lack clarity. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 39 READING RUBRIC—EXPOSITORY SELECTION OBJECTIVE 3 SCORE POINT 1 — PARTIALLY SUFFICIENT In partially sufficient responses, the student ❒ may draw a reasonable conclusion, offer a reasonable interpretation, or make a reasonable prediction that is supported only by general, incomplete, or partially accurate/relevant textual evidence or provide no textual evidence at all ❒ may offer a reasonable analysis or evaluation of a characteristic of the text that is supported only by general, incomplete, or partially accurate/relevant textual evidence or provide no textual evidence at all ❒ may offer a reasonable idea, analysis, or evaluation and may provide textual evidence, but this evidence is only weakly connected to the idea, analysis, or evaluation ❒ may offer accurate/relevant textual evidence without drawing a conclusion, offering an interpretation, making a prediction, or providing an analysis or evaluation In addition, partially sufficient responses may be somewhat unclear or vague. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 40 READING RUBRIC—EXPOSITORY SELECTION OBJECTIVE 3 SCORE POINT 2 — SUFFICIENT In sufficient responses, the student ❒ must draw a reasonable conclusion, offer a reasonable interpretation, or make a reasonable prediction and must support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence ❒ must offer a reasonable analysis or evaluation of a characteristic of the selection and must support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence In addition, sufficient responses must be clear and specific. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 41 READING RUBRIC—EXPOSITORY SELECTION OBJECTIVE 3 SCORE POINT 3 — EXEMPLARY In exemplary responses, the student ❒ must offer a particularly thoughtful or insightful conclusion, interpretation, or prediction and strongly support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence ❒ must offer a particularly thoughtful or insightful analysis or evaluation of a characteristic of the text and strongly support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence In addition, exemplary responses show strong evidence of the student’s depth of understanding and ability to effectively connect textual evidence to the idea, analysis, or evaluation. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 42 READING RUBRIC LITERARY/EXPOSITORY CROSSOVER OBJECTIVE 3 SCORE POINT 0 — INSUFFICIENT In insufficient responses, the student ❒ may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, or make a prediction that is not based on the selections ❒ may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, or make a prediction that does not address the question ❒ may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, or make a prediction that is not reasonable ❒ may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, or make a prediction that is too general or vague to determine whether it is reasonable ❒ may incorrectly analyze or evaluate a characteristic of text based on both selections ❒ may not address the question in any way or may answer a different question than the one asked ❒ may offer only incomplete or irrelevant textual evidence from one or both selections In addition, insufficient responses may lack clarity. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 43 READING RUBRIC LITERARY/EXPOSITORY CROSSOVER OBJECTIVE 3 SCORE POINT 1 — PARTIALLY SUFFICIENT In partially sufficient responses, the student ❒ may draw a reasonable conclusion, offer a reasonable interpretation, or make a reasonable prediction based on both selections but supported only by general, incomplete, or partially accurate/relevant textual evidence from one or both selections ❒ may draw a reasonable conclusion, offer a reasonable interpretation, or make a reasonable prediction based on both selections but may offer textual support from only one selection or may offer no textual support at all ❒ may offer a reasonable analysis or evaluation of a characteristic of text based on both selections that is supported only by general, incomplete, or partially accurate/relevant textual evidence from one or both selections ❒ may offer a reasonable analysis or evaluation of a characteristic of text based on both selections but may offer textual support from only one selection or may offer no textual support at all ❒ may offer a reasonable idea, analysis, or evaluation based on both selections and may provide textual evidence from both selections, but this evidence is only weakly connected to the idea, analysis, or evaluation ❒ may offer accurate/relevant textual evidence from both selections but may draw a conclusion, offer an interpretation, make a prediction, or provide an analysis or evaluation based on only one selection ❒ may offer accurate/relevant textual evidence from both selections without drawing a conclusion, offering an interpretation, making a prediction, or providing an analysis or evaluation In addition, partially sufficient responses may be somewhat unclear or vague or may indicate that the student has difficulty making connections across selections. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 44 READING RUBRIC LITERARY/EXPOSITORY CROSSOVER OBJECTIVE 3 SCORE POINT 2 — SUFFICIENT In sufficient responses, the student ❒ must draw a reasonable conclusion, offer a reasonable interpretation, or make a reasonable prediction based on both selections and must support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence from both selections ❒ must offer a reasonable analysis or evaluation of a characteristic of text based on both selections and must support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence from both selections In addition, sufficient responses indicate that the student is able to make clear and specific connections across selections. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 45 READING RUBRIC LITERARY/EXPOSITORY CROSSOVER OBJECTIVE 3 SCORE POINT 3 — EXEMPLARY In exemplary responses, the student ❒ must offer a particularly thoughtful or insightful conclusion, interpretation, or prediction based on both selections and strongly support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence from both selections ❒ must offer a particularly thoughtful or insightful analysis or evaluation of a characteristic of text based on both selections and strongly support it with accurate/relevant textual evidence from both selections In addition, exemplary responses indicate that the student is able to make meaningful connections across selections. These responses show strong evidence of the student’s depth of understanding and ability to effectively connect textual evidence to the idea, analysis, or evaluation. Evidence may consist of a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a specific synopsis. Grade 9 Reading TAKS Information Booklet 46
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz