@T|@*5!** L4T*i4i?|@h|)q
,_i?Ui uhL4 @ @?i* Lu L?|hit
aL? #g)
#iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut
N?iht|) Lu ||tMh}
||tMh}c D2Sf
,4@*G _g)9T||i_
ht @T@}iLh}L
#iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Ut
wLt@?@ 5|@|i N?iht|)
@|L? +L}ic w .fHf
,4@*G UT@T@9*ti_
6_i* ihi35iM@t|@?
#T|L 6 _i* ?‚@*tt ,UL?‚L4UL
N?iht_@_ _i *U@?|i
fSbf *U@?|ic 5T@?
,4@*G €_i*94ih*?u@i@it
a@?@h) 2ff
Devwudfw
Vlqfh Julolfkhv +4<9<,/ uhvhdufkhuv kdyh ehhq lqwuljxhg e| wkh lghd wkdw sk|vlfdo fdslwdo
dqg vnloohg oderu duh uhodwlyho| pruh frpsohphqwdu| wkdq sk|vlfdo fdslwdo dqg xqvnloohg oderu1
Lq wklv sdshu zh frqvlghu wkh furvv~frxqwu| hylghqfh iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| xvlqj
d wlph~vhulhv/ furvv~vhfwlrq sdqho ri :6 ghyhorshg dqg ohvv ghyhorshg frxqwulhv ryhu d 58 |hdu
shulrg1 Zh irfxv rq wkuhh hpslulfdo lvvxhv1 Iluvw/ zkdw lv wkh ehvw vshflfdwlrq ri wkh djjuhjdwh
surgxfwlrq whfkqrorj| wr dgguhvv wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv1 Vhfrqg/ krz
vkrxog zh phdvxuh vnloohg oderuB Ilqdoo|/ lv wkhuh dq| furvv~frxqwu| hylghqfh lq vxssruw ri wkh
fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlvB Rxu pdlq qglqj lv wkdw zh qg vrph vxssruw iru
wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv lq rxu pdfur sdqho gdwdvhw1
MHO Fodvvlfdwlrq Qxpehuv= R73/ R7:1
W `i @hi }h@|iu* |L @? @?L?)4Lt hiuihii uLh ih) tiu* t}}it|L?t `i @*tL |@?! 6h@?UitUL @ti**c wL*@
L**@_Lc #@_ #iaL?}c `**@4 Bhii?c #@?i* O@4ih4itc @h|ih O**c aLtiVU|Lh +‚Lt+** uLh |ih i*Tu*
UL44i?|t @?_ t}}it|L?t @?_ aL?}`@ wii uLh 4@!?} @@*@M*i |L t t _@|@ti| L? tULL*?} _h@|L? 6?@?U@*
tTTLh| uhL4 W?t|||L V@*i?U@?L _i W?it|}@UL?it ,UL?‚
L4U@t @?_ 5T@?t ?t|h) Lu 5Ui?Ui @?_ AiU?L*L})c
,2fffbHfc t }h@|iu**) @U!?L*i_}i_

W?|hL_U|L?
Ryhu 63 |hduv djr/ Julolfkhv +4<9<, surylghg hylghqfh iurp X1V1 pdqxidfwxulqj gdwd vxjjhvwlqj
wkdw fdslwdo dqg vnloohg oderu duh uhodwlyho| pruh frpsohphqwdu| dv lqsxwv wkdq duh fdslwdo dqg
xqvnloohg oderu1 Julolfkhv uhihuuhg wr wklv qglqj dv wkh _fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|% k|srwkhvlv1
Julolfkhv* k|srwkhvlv kdv uhfhlyhg uhqhzhg dwwhqwlrq odwho|/ dv wkh X1V1 dqg rwkhu ghyhorshg qdwlrqv
kdyh lqyhvwhg khdylo| lq _vnloo~eldvhg% lqirupdwlrq whfkqrorj| dqg wklv ghyhorsphqw dsshduv wr
kdyh frlqflghg zlwk d ulvh lq wkh zdjhv hduqhg e| vnloohg zrunhuv uhodwlyh wr wkh zdjhv ri xqvnloohg
zrunhuv1 Lqghhg/ eholhi lq wkh h{lvwhqfh ri fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| lv vr vwurqj wkdw vrph
uhvhdufkhuv kdyh vxjjhvwhg prgli|lqj wkh vwdqgdug qhrfodvvlfdo surgxfwlrq whfkqrorj| wr dffrxqw
iru wklv skhqrphqrq lq dgguhvvlqj txhvwlrqv ri hfrqrplf jurzwk/ wudgh dqg lqhtxdolw| +vhh/ h1j1
Vwrnh| +4<<9,/ dqg Nuxvhoo hw do1 +5333,,1
Jroglq dqg Ndw} +4<<;, kdyh uhfhqwo| uhplqghg xv wkdw sk|vlfdo fdslwdo dqg vnloohg oderu kdyh
qrw dozd|v ehhq ylhzhg dv uhodwlyh frpsohphqwv1 Iru h{dpsoh/ wkh| qrwh wkdw lq dq hduolhu hud/ wkh
wudqvirupdwlrq iurp vnloohg duwlvdq vkrsv wr idfwrulhv lqyroyhg wkh vxevwlwxwlrq ri sk|vlfdo fdslwdo
dqg2ru xqvnloohg oderu iru kljko| vnloohg oderu ~ suhflvho| wkh rssrvlwh ri zkdw lv k|srwkhvl}hg wr eh
kdsshqlqj wrgd|1 Jroglq dqg Ndw}*v qglqjv vxjjhvw wkdw fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| pd| rqo|
eh d wudqvlwru| skhqrphqd1 Dv frxqwulhv surjuhvv wkurxjk ydulrxv vwdjhv ri ghyhorsphqw/ vnloohg
oderu pd| fkdqjh iurp ehlqj uhodwlyho| pruh vxevwlwxwdeoh zlwk fdslwdo dqg xqvnloohg oderu wr ehlqj
kljko| frpsohphqwdu| wr wkhvh wzr lqsxwv1 Lw wkhuhiruh vhhpv lpsruwdqw wr frqvlghu wkh hylghqfh
iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| ryhu orqj shulrgv ri wlph dqg dfurvv frxqwulhv dw glhuhqw vwdjhv
ri ghyhorsphqw1 Wkh dlp ri wklv sdshu lv wr frqgxfw vxfk dq h{huflvh1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ zh h{dplqh
wkh hylghqfh iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| xvlqj d sdqho gdwdvhw ri :6 frxqwulhv ryhu wkh shulrg
4<98~4<<31
Qrw vxusulvlqjo|/ vlqfh Julolfkhv +4<9<,/ wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv kdv dw0
wudfwhg wkh dwwhqwlrq ri pdq| uhvhdufkhuv zkr kdyh pdlqo| xvhg furvv~vhfwlrqdo pdqxidfwxulqj
gdwd iru d vlqjoh +w|slfdoo|, ghyhorshg frxqwu| wr whvw wklv k|srwkhvlv1 Kdphuphvk +4<<6, dvvhvvhv
wkh qglqjv iurp prvw ri wkhvh vwxglhv dqg frqfoxghv wkdw wkhuh _pd| eh% fdslwdo~vnloo frpsoh0
phqwdulw|1 Krzhyhu/ kh fdxwlrqv wkdw _pdq| ri wkh vwxglhv wkdw glvdjjuhjdwh wkh zrun irufh e|
ghprjudsklf jurxs h{foxgh fdslwdo dv d surgxfwlyh lqsxw gxh wr wkh glfxow| ri jhqhudwlqj vdwlv0
idfwru| gdwd rq fdslwdo vwrfnv lq wkh furvv vhfwlrqv h{dplqhg% +Kdphuphvk +4<<6, s1 446,1 Iru
4
h{dpsoh/ lq wkh ruljlqdo Julolfkhv +4<9<, vwxg|/ wkh dvvxpswlrq ri shuihfwo| frpshwlwlyh pdunhwv
doorzv gdwd rq udwhv ri uhwxuq wr sur{| iru wkh pdujlqdo surgxfw ri fdslwdo dqg wkhuhe| fdswxuh
yduldwlrqv lq wkh vwrfn ri fdslwdo1 E| frqwudvw/ lq wklv sdshu/ zh pdnh xvh ri wkh Shqq Zruog Wdeohv~
Yhuvlrq 819 gdwdvhw rq lqyhvwphqw udwhv dfurvv frxqwulhv wr frqvwuxfw sk|vlfdo fdslwdo vwrfnv1 Zh
h{dplqh wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv gluhfwo|/ zlwkrxw uhvruwlqj wr dvvxpswlrqv ri
shuihfwo| frpshwlwlyh pdunhwv/ e| hvwlpdwlqj wkh sdudphwhuv ri ydulrxv glhuhqw vshflfdwlrqv ri dq
djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq1 Zkloh wkh frpshwlwlyh pdunhwv dvvxpswlrq pd| vhhp uhdvrqdeoh
iru ghyhorshg frxqwulhv/ lw pd| eh ohvv uhdvrqdeoh iru ghyhorslqj frxqwulhv zkhuh idfwruv pd| eh
ohvv preloh dqg pdunhwv ohvv frpsohwh1
Kdphuphvk +4<<6, dovr qrwhv wkh glfxowlhv wkdw hduolhu vwxglhv kdg lq xvlqj rffxsdwlrqdo gdwd
wr glhuhqwldwh ehwzhhq vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg zrunhuv1 Lq wklv sdshu/ zh iroorz wkh wudglwlrq lq wkh
pdfur~jurzwk olwhudwxuh dqg glhuhqwldwh oderu dffruglqj wr hgxfdwlrqdo dwwdlqphqw ohyhov xvlqj
wkh uhfhqw Eduur dqg Ohh +5334, gdwdvhw1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ zh frqvlghu yh dowhuqdwlyh sur{lhv iru
vnloohg oderu udqjlqj iurp zrunhuv srvvhvvlqj vrph sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq wr zrunhuv srvvhvvlqj vrph
srvw~vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq> iru hdfk sur{|/ wkh iudfwlrq ri wkh oderu irufh wkdw grhv qrw phhw wkh
hgxfdwlrqdo wkuhvkrog xvhg wr ghqh vnloohg oderu lv uhjdughg dv xqvnloohg oderu1 Zh dovr h{dplqh
zkdw kdsshqv zkhq zh dxjphqw rxu oderu gdwd zlwk gdwd rq uhwxuqv wr vfkrrolqj +hduqlqjv, lq dq
hruw wr dffrxqw iru glvsdulwlhv lq hflhqf| xqlwv dfurvv zrunhuv zlwklq wkh fodvv ri zrunhuv uhjdughg
dv vnloohg ru xqvnloohg1 Rxu dqdo|vlv ri vhyhudo glhuhqw fodvvlfdwlrqv dqg phdvxuhv ri vnloohg dqg
xqvnloohg oderu lv dqrwkhu qryho ihdwxuh ri wklv vwxg|> lq sulru vwxglhv lqyroylqj vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg
oderu/ d vlqjoh hgxfdwlrqdo wkuhvkrog kdv ehhq fkrvhq wr glylgh zrunhuv lqwr vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg
fodvvhv zlwkrxw pxfk frqvlghudwlrq ehlqj jlyhq wr wkh hpslulfdo uhohydqfh ri wkh wkuhvkrog fkrlfh1
Lqwhuqdwlrqdo h{dplqdwlrqv ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv kdyh ehhq frqgxfwhg
e| Idoorq dqg Od|dug +4<:8,/ Ehupdq hw do1 +4<<;, dqg Ioxj dqg Khufrzlw} +5333,1 Rxu dssurdfk
lv prvw forvho| uhodwhg wr wkh Idoorq dqg Od|dug +4<:8, vwxg|> wkh Ehupdq hw do1 dqg Ioxj dqg Khu0
frzlw} vwxglhv gr qrw hpsor| djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrqv wr whvw fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|
dfurvv frxqwulhv1 Idoorq dqg Od|dug xvhg gdwd slhfhg wrjhwkhu iru < ghyhorshg dqg 46 ohvv ghyho0
rshg frxqwulhv iru d vlqjoh |hdu/ 4<96/ wr hvwlpdwh uhgxfhg irup htxdwlrqv ghulyhg iurp wzr~ohyho
FHV surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrqv wkdw doorzhg iru wkhuh wr eh glhuhqfhv lq wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq
 Ai
4i|L_L*L}) ti_ ? |t T@Tih uL**Lt #g) @?_ @T@}iLh}L E2fff L ?it|}@|i @ }i?ih@* |Lu@U|Lh
,5 @}}hi}@|i tTiU€U@|L? ? U L|T| t }i?ih@|i_ t?} T)tU@* U@T|@* @?_ *@MLh Lh 4@? U@T|@* @_t|i_
*@MLh tih?} @t ?T|t
5
ehwzhhq fdslwdo dqg vnloohg oderu dqg wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq fdslwdo dqg xqvnloohg
oderu1 Dw wkh hfrqrp|~zlgh ohyho/ wkh| qg _plog% +wkrxjk vwdwlvwlfdoo| lqvljqlfdqw, hylghqfh
lq idyru ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv1 Lq wklv sdshu/ zh dovr pdnh xvh ri wkh
wzr~ohyho FHV surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq vshflfdwlrq wkdw Idoorq dqg Od|dug dgyrfdwh1 Krzhyhu/ vlqfh
zh xvh qrqolqhdu hvwlpdwlrq phwkrgv wkdw zhuh qrw ihdvleoh dw wkh wlph ri wkh Idoorq dqg Od|dug
vwxg|/ zh gr qrw qhhg wr iroorz Idoorq dqg Od|dug ixuwkhu lq dvvxplqj shuihfwo| frpshwlwlyh pdu0
nhwv vr wkdw idfwru sulfh gdwd +uhhfwlqj pdujlqdo surgxfwv xqghu shuihfw frpshwlwlrq, fdq eh xvhg
wr hvwlpdwh olqhdu uhgxfhg irup htxdwlrqv1 Ixuwkhupruh/ zh xvh gdwd iru pdq| pruh frxqwulhv/ :6/
dqg wkhuh lv dovr d wlph glphqvlrq wr rxu sdqho gdwdvhw wkdw zdv plvvlqj iurp Idoorq dqg Od|dug*v
vwxg|1 Vshflfdoo|/ iru hdfk ri wkh :6 frxqwulhv/ zh kdyh 9 dqqxdo revhuydwlrqv/ vsdfhg yh |hduv
dsduw= 4<98/4<:3/111/4<<3 +d wrwdo ri 76; revhuydwlrqv,1 Rxu dqdo|vlv wkxv doorzv iru d fohduhu dqg
pruh frqylqflqj dvvhvvphqw ri zkhwkhu wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv lv frpprq wr
pdq| frxqwulhv ryhu vrph ohqjwk ri wlph1
Rxu pdlq qglqj lv wkdw wkhuh lv lqghhg vrph hylghqfh lq vxssruw ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsoh0
phqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv1 Wklv k|srwkhvlv qgv juhdwhvw vxssruw zkhq vnloohg oderu lv ghqhg xvlqj d
orz wkuhvkrog/ h1j1 fodvvli|lqj vnloohg zrunhuv dv wkrvh zkr kdyh frpsohwhg d sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq1
Wklv wkuhvkrog iru vnloohg oderu lv frqvlghudeo| orzhu wkdq wkh wkuhvkrog wkdw rwkhu uhvhdufkhuv
kdyh xvhg wr ghqh vnloohg oderu/ h1j1 fodvvli|lqj vnloohg zrunhuv dv wkrvh zkr kdyh pruh wkdq d
vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq +h1j1 Nuxvhoo hw do1 +5333,,1 Vwloo/ zh hpskdvl}h wkdw rxu hylghqfh lq idyru
ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv lv zhdn1 Dgglwlrqdo fdxwlrq lq wkh lqwhusuhwdwlrq
ri rxu uhvxowv frphv iurp wkh Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv wkdw zh shuirup lq wkh sdshu1 Wkhvh h{0
shulphqwv vxjjhvw wkdw/ iru vpdoo vdpsoh vl}hv frpsdudeoh wr zkdw kdyh dydlodeoh lq rxu pdfur
sdqho gdwdvhw/ wkh qrqolqhdu whfkqltxhv wkdw xvh wr hvwlpdwh wkh wzr~ohyho FHV surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq
surgxfh uhodwlyho| lpsuhflvh hvwlpdwhv1 Wkhuhiruh/ rxu hylghqfh iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|
pd| qrw zduudqw prgli|lqj wkh vshflfdwlrqv ri wkh djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq whfkqrorj| wr wdnh df0
frxqw ri wklv k|srwkhvlv1 Dowhuqdwlyho| rxu uhvxowv pljkw uhdvrqdeo| vhuyh wr erovwhu dowhuqdwlyh
+dqg frpsohphqwdu|, h{sodqdwlrqv iru ulvlqj zdjh dqg lqfrph lqhtxdolw|/ iru h{dpsoh/ vnloo~eldvhg
whfkqrorjlfdo fkdqjh ru frxqwu|~vshflf jryhuqphqw srolflhv1
6
2
, @4??} Ai @ti uLh @T|@*5!** L4T*i4i?|@h|) t?}
}}hi}@|i hL_U|L? 6?U|L?t
Wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv vwdwhv wkdw sk|vlfdo fdslwdo lv pruh frpsohphqwdu|
wr vnloohg oderu wkdq wr xqvnloohg oderu1 Pruh irupdoo|/ vxssrvh djjuhjdwh rxwsxw/ \ / lv jlyhq e| d
wkuhh~idfwru surgxfwlrq whfkqrorj| \ @ I +N> V> Q,/ zkhuh N ghqrwhv wkh sk|vlfdo fdslwdo vwrfn/
V ghqrwhv wkh txdqwlw| ri vnloohg oderu dqg Q ghqrwhv wkh txdqwlw| ri xqvnloohg oderu1 Ghqrwh e|
c wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq lqsxwv l dqg m1 Wkhq fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| krogv
li gc A gc7 1
Lq rughu wr dvvhvv wkh h{whqw ri fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|/ zh pxvw zrun zlwk d ixqfwlrqdo
irup wkdw lv jhqhudo hqrxjk wr dffrpprgdwh glhuhqw hodvwlflwlhv ri vxevwlwxwlrq1 Iru h{dpsoh/ wkh
uhodwlyho| jhqhudo FHV irup iru I +N> V> Q,>

\ @ D ^dN 4 . eV 4 . fQ 4 ` 4 >
zkhuh d A 3> e A 3> f A 3 dqg 4> lpsolhv wkdw wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq dq| wzr
lqsxwv/ c iru l> m 5 iN> V> Qj/ lv frqvwdqw dqg htxdo wr 3 4 1 Wr doorz iru glhuhqw hodvwlflwlhv
ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq dq| wzr lqsxwv zh pdnh xvh ri Vdwr*v +4<9:, wzr~ohyho FHV surgxfwlrq
ixqfwlrq1 Wkh wzr prvw lqwhuhvwlqj yhuvlrqv ri wklv wzr~ohyho FHV irup iru sxusrvhv ri whvwlqj wkh
fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv duh
k
l*4
k
l*4
\ @ D d^eN w . +4 e,V w `4*w . +4 d,Q 4
\ @ D d^eN w . +4 e,Q w `4*w . +4 d,V 4
>
+4,
>
+5,
zkhuh D lv d srvlwlyh +idfwru qhxwudo, hflhqf| sdudphwhu/ d/ e duh glvwulexwlrq sdudphwhuv dqg
> 4 duh wkh lqwud~ dqg lqwhu~fodvv hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq sdudphwhuv/ uhvshfwlyho| +/ @ 4
lpso| shuihfw vxevwlwxwdelolw|/ / @ 3 lpso| wkh Free~Grxjodv vshflfdwlrq/ dqg / @ 4
lpso| shuihfw frpsohphqwdulw|,1 Hyhq wkrxjk wkh wzr vshflfdwlrqv duh vlplodu/ wkh| glhu lq rqh
lpsruwdqw zd|1 Lq +4,/ wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq N dqg Q/ dqg Q dqg V duh wkh
vdph/ zkloh lq htxdwlrq +5, wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq N dqg V/ dqg Q dqg V duh wkh
vdph1 Wkxv/ wkh fdslwdo vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv gc A gc7 lv uhdglo| whvwhg xvlqj hlwkhu
vshflfdwlrq1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ dv zh zloo ghprqvwudwh odwhu/ fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| krogv lq
vshflfdwlrq +4,^5` l A ^ ? `1
7
Wkrxjk ixuwkhu glvdjjuhjdwlrq lv srvvleoh/ h1j1 wkurxjk wkh xvh ri d wudqvorj vshflfdwlrq
+vhh/ h1j1 Ehujvwu‚rp dqg Sdqdv +4<<5, dqg Uxl}~Duudq} +5335,,/ zh irfxv rq wkh wzr~ohyho FHV
vshflfdwlrqv dv wkh| duh wkh rqhv wkdw kdyh ehhq xvhg lq wkh uhfhqw olwhudwxuh h{dplqlqj wkh
frqvhtxhqfhv ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv1 Iru h{dpsoh/ Idoorq dqg Od|dug
+4<:8, dqg Fdvhool dqg Frohpdq +5335d/e, erwk suhihu wr zrun zlwk vshflfdwlrq +4,1 Nuxvhoo hw do1
+5333, frqvlghu dq h{sdqghg yhuvlrq ri vshflfdwlrq +4,
k
\ @ DNrk d^eNew . +4 e,V w `4*w . +4 d,Q 4
l 3k
4
>
zkhuh Nr uhsuhvhqwv wkh vwrfn ri fdslwdo vwuxfwxuhv/ dqg Ne uhsuhvhqwv wkh vwrfn ri fdslwdo htxls0
phqw1 Zkloh zh zrxog olnh wr hvwlpdwh vxfk d vshflfdwlrq/ zh odfn wkh uhtxlvlwh gdwd rq fdslwdo
vwuxfwxuhv dqg fdslwdo htxlsphqw iru doo ri wkh frxqwulhv lq rxu vdpsoh12
Vwrnh| +4<<9,/ rq wkh rwkhu kdqg/ kdv sursrvhg d pruh uhvwulfwlyh yhuvlrq ri vshflfdwlrq +5,
\ @ D^eN w . +4 e,Q w `*w VE3 =
+6,
Khuh V @ V . tQ uhsuhvhqwv _phqwdo hruw%/ t ? 4 lv wkh uhodwlyh hflhqf| ri xqvnloohg oderu lq
 Htxdwlrq +6, lv
frqwulexwlqj wr phqwdo hruw/ dqg 4 lv wkh vkduh ri rxwsxw wkdw dffuxhv wr V1
fohduo| d uhvwulfwhg irup ri +5, dv lw uhtxluhv qglqj wkdw hvwlpdwhv ri duh qrw vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw
iurp }hur1 Frqglwlrqdo rq wklv qglqj fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| krogv li 3 ? 41
Jroglq dqg Ndw} +4<<;, vwduw r zlwk wkh wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq +4, exw ixuwkhu vshfldol}h
lw wr wkh fdvh zkhuh 4, $ 4 dqg 5, $ 31 Wklv lv hyhq pruh uhvwulfwlyh wkdq Vwrnh| +4<<9,/
vlqfh lw lpsolhv/ dv lq Vwrnh|/ wkdw qdo rxwsxw \ kdv wkh Free~Grxjodv irup exw lw ixuwkhu uhtxluhv
wkdw wkh N~V djjuhjdwh/ zklfk Jroglq dqg Ndw} uhihu wr dv N W / kdyh wkh Ohrqwlhi irup
k
l
\ @ D +plq ^eN> +4 e,V`, Q 3 =
2
khti** i| @* E2fff L?*) UL?t_ih |i N5 iUL?L4)c uLh U tU _@|@ @hi @@*@M*i Ai) ti @ |L*ii*
,5 u?U|L?c U@*Mh@|i_ tL |@| |ihi t U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|)c @?_ €?_ |@| @h@|L?t ? u@U|Lh ?T|t U@?
@UUL?| uLh 4Lt| Lu |i @h@|L? ? |i t!** Thi44 ? |i N5 +3hh@?3 E2ff2 uL**Lt T L? khti** i|
@* E2fff @?_ i @4?it |i igiU| Lu U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|) L? N5 t!** Thi44 Mi|ii? bSDbbb )
UL?|h@t| | khti** i| @*c +3hh@?3<t it|4@|L? t _L?i t?} @ |h@?t*L} ThL_U|L? u?U|L? |@| @**Lt ih
|L _ti?|@?}*i |i igiU|t Lu U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|) @?_ Lu t!**M@ti_ |iU?L*L}U@* U@?}i L? |i N5 t!**
Thi44 +3hh@?3 €?_t |@| U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|) U@? @UUL?| uLh @| 4Lt| ef TihUi?| Lu |i hti ? |i
t!** Thi44c | t!**M@ti_ |iU?L*L}U@* U@?}i @UUL?|?} uLh 4Lt| Lu |i @h@|L? ? |i t!** Thi44
6L**L?} 5|L!i)<t uLh4*@|L?c |i hit|hU|i_ ihtL? Lu |i |L*ii* ,5 tTiU€U@|L? E t
t ' dKg w n E 3 K7 w o*w 3 c
@?_ U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|) L*_t u w f
8
Lq wklv fdvh/ vlqfh gc7 @ 3 ? 4 dqg g W c @ 4/ wkh dxwkruv duh pdnlqj wkh hpslulfdoo| whvwdeoh
dvvxpswlrq wkdw gc7 ? g W c 1 Wkhlu dlp lv wr vkrz wkdw li whfkqrorj| fkdqjhv/ uhsuhvhqwhg e| d
fkdqjh lq D/ wkhq lw qhhg qrw eh wkh fdvh wkdw wkh uhodwlyh ghpdqg iru vnloohg oderu lqfuhdvhv1 Dv
D lqfuhdvhv/ ohvv lv qhhghg ri erwk wkh N W djjuhjdwh dqg Q wr surgxfh wkh vdph ohyho ri rxwsxw1
2
,*@t|U|) Lu 5Mt|||L? i@thit
Iru jhqhudo surgxfwlrq whfkqrorjlhv zlwk pruh wkdq wzr lqsxwv wkhuh lv qr vlqjoh ghqlwlrq iru wkh
hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq sdluv ri lqsxwv1 Shukdsv wkh prvw frpprqo| xvhg ghqlwlrq lv
wkh Doohq~X}dzd sduwldo hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq wkdw phdvxuhv wkh shufhqwdjh fkdqjh lq wkh udwlr
ri wzr lqsxwv lq uhvsrqvh wr d fkdqjh lq wkh udwlr ri wkh wzr lqsxw sulfhv/ kroglqj doo rwkhu sulfhv
+exw qrw doo rwkhu lqsxwv, dqg rxwsxw txdqwlw| frqvwdqw1 Wklv lv wkh phdvxuh xvhg/ h1j1 e| Julolfkhv
+4<9<,1 Dqrwkhu hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ghqlwlrq lv wkh Klfnv~Doohq gluhfw sduwldo hodvwlflw| ri
vxevwlwxwlrq wkdw phdvxuhv wkh shufhqwdjh fkdqjh lq wkh udwlr ri wzr lqsxwv lq uhvsrqvh wr d fkdqjh
lq wkh udwlr ri wkh wzr lqsxw sulfhv/ kroglqj doo rwkhu sulfhv/ lqsxwv dqg rxwsxw txdqwlw| frqvwdqw1e
Lq zkdw iroorzv/ zh vkrz wkdw lq wkh wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq +4,^5`/ wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsoh0
phqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv +gc A gc7 , krogv l A ^ ? ` uhjdugohvv ri zklfk hodvwlflw| phdvxuh
zh xvh/ wkh Doohq sduwldo hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ru wkh gluhfw sduwldo hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq1D
51414
Wkh Doohq Sduwldo Hodvwlflw| ri Vxevwlwxwlrq
Vxssrvh wkhuh duh q lqsxwv xvhg lq surgxfwlrq1 Ohw ^[ > ===> [6 ` irup d sduwlwlrq ri wkhvh lqsxwv
lqwr p q glvwlqfw vxevhwv ru lqsxw fodvvhv1 Iru h{dpsoh/ lq vshflfdwlrq +4, zh kdyh p @ 5 zlwk
[ frqvlvwlqj ri N dqg V zkloh [2 frqvlvwv ri Q dorqh1 Dv vkrzq lq Vdwr +4<9: ss1 535~537/
549~54:, wkh jhqhudo wzr~ohyho FHV surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq lpsolhv wkdw wkh Doohq sduwldo hodvwlflw| ri
e
Lhi uLh4@**)c @tt4i |@| L|T| t t ThL_Ui_ t?} ? ?T|tc % ' t% c c %? c @UULh_?} |L tL4i }i?ih@*
ThL_U|L? |iU?L*L}) t ' 8 E% S
wi||?} 8 Y8*Y% @?_ 8 Y 2 8*Y% Y% c |i **i? T@h|@* i*@t|U|) Lu
@ '
tMt|||L? t _i€?i_ M) j
Glm
q
% 8
n@4 n n
c ihi
%l %m ƒGƒ
5
f
9 8
G9
7 8?
8
8
8?
6
8?
8? :
:
8
8??
@?_ G t |i ULu@U|Lh Lu i*i4i?| 8 ? G Ai _hiU| T@h|@* i*@t|U|) Lu tMt|||L? Mi|ii? |i | @?_ |i |
_ ' 3 Y *?E%l *%m c ihi + @?_ @** % @hi i*_ UL?t|@?|
i*i4i?| ? t% t }i? M) j
&
Y *?E8l *8m D
`i |@?! @? @?L?)4Lt hiuihii uLh TL?|?} L| |i @*|ih?@|i _i€?|L?t Lu |i i*@t|U|) Lu tMt|||L? @?_
|ih TL|i?|@* igiU| L? U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|)
9
vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq wkh lwk dqg mwk lqsxwv lv jlyhq e|
+
@
@
>
r . l r +r ,>
li l 5 [o > m 5 [r > u 9@ v
li l> m 5 [r > l 9@ m

zkhuh lv wkh lqwhu~fodvv hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq/ r lv wkh lqwud~fodvv hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq
zlwklq fodvv v/ dqg r lv wkh uhodwlyh vkduh ri wkh idfwruv lq fodvv v lq wrwdo h{shqglwxuh1 Lq wkh fdvh
ri wkh wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq +4, zh kdyh
4
4
4
4
4
4
@
>
. r
4 4 4
@
@ c7
@
@
gc
@
gc7
zkhuh r lv wkh uhodwlyh vkduh ri N dqg V lq wrwdo h{shqglwxuh1S Lpsrvlqj wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsoh0
phqwdulw| frqglwlrq jlyhv
@
@
gc
A gc7
/
,
4
4
4
4
. r
4 4 4
4
4
4
? 3=
r 4 4 ?
4
4
Jlyhq wkdw r 5 +3> 4, lw iroorzv wkdw A 1. Iroorzlqj wkh vdph orjlf/ rqh fdq vkrz wkdw iru
vshflfdwlrq +5,/ gc A gc7 krogv l ? 1
51415
Wkh Gluhfw Sduwldo Hodvwlflw| ri Vxevwlwxwlrq
Iroorzlqj Vdwr +4<9: ss1 535~537/ 549~54:,/ iru wkh jhqhudo wzr~ohyho FHV surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq/
wkh gluhfw sduwldo hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq wkh lwk dqg mwk lqsxwv lv jlyhq e|
_
@
;
A
A
?
A
A
=

jo

lo
3 lo


lo n lr
>
n jr lr lr n j lo n lr
3
r >
li l 5 [o > m 5 [r > u 9@ v
+7,
li l> m 5 [r > l 9@ m
S
L|Ui
.
|@| |i **i? T@h|@* i*@t|U|) Lu tMt|||L? Mi|ii? g @?_ 7 t ?L| UL?t|@?|
6@**L? @?_ w@)@h_ Eb.D @*tL ti |L*ii* ,5 ThL_U|L?t u?U|L?t Ai) hi*@|i |i U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i
4i?|@h|) UL?_|L? uLh |i |L*ii* tTiU€U@|L? E Ei jgc : jgc7 i 4 : w |L OU!t T@h|@* i*@t|U|) Lu
UL4T*i4i?|@h|) UL?UiT| uLh }i?ih@* ThL_U|L? u?U|L? tTiU€U@|L?tc U t itti?|@**) |i _@* Lu |i **i? T@h
|@* i*@t|U|) Lu tMt|||L? Ai T@h|@* i*@t|U|) Lu UL4T*i4i?|@h|) 4i@thit |i TihUi?|@}i U@?}i ? |i h@|L Lu
|L ?T| ThUit ? hitTL?ti |L @ U@?}i ? |i h@|L Lu |i |L ?T| ^@?||it L*_?} @** L|ih ?T|t @?_ |i ThUi
88
Lu L|T| UL?t|@?| W| t }i? M)G S ' 8l 8lmm Nt?} |t i*@t|U|) 4i@thic U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|) hi^hit
S7cg : Scg 6@**L? @?_ w@)@h_ Eb.D tL |@| uLh |i |L*ii* ,5 tTiU€U@|L? Ec S7cg '  3 4 n lv E4 3 w
ihic @t @MLic l r t |i hi*@|i t@hi Lu g @?_ 7 ? |L|@* i Ti?_|hi @?_ Scg '  3 4 Oi?Uic U@T|@*t!**
UL4T*i4i?|@h|)c S7cg : Scg c hi^hit @}@? |@| 4 : w
:
zkhuh r dqg o duh wkh lqwud~fodvv hodvwlflwlhv ri vxevwlwxwlrqv ehwzhhq sdluv ri lqsxwv zlwklq
fodvvhv v dqg u/ uhvshfwlyho|/ zkloh lv wkh lqwhu~fodvv hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq/ r + o , lv wkh
uhodwlyh h{shqglwxuh vkduh ri wkh vwk +uwk, fodvv ri idfwruv dqg r +o , lv wkh uhodwlyh vkduh ri wkh
mwk +lwk, hohphqw ri wkh vwk +uwk, fodvv lq wrwdo h{shqglwxuh1
Dv qrwhg deryh/ wkh wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq +4, frqvlvwv ri rqo| wzr fodvvhv ~ rqh +uhsuh0
vhqwlqj wkh uvw ohyho, wkdw djjuhjdwhv wzr lqsxwv +N dqg V, xvlqj FHV/ dqg dqrwkhu wkdw hpsor|v
rqo| rqh lqsxw +Q, xvlqj Free~Grxjodv ~ qhvwhg lq dqrwkhu FHV +uhsuhvhqwlqj wkh vhfrqg ohyho,1
Iru vshflfdwlrq +4,/ zh kdyh r @ 3 w > @ 3 4 1 Vlqfh wkh vhfrqg fodvv lq rxu surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq
lv Free~Grxjodv lw iroorzv wkdw o @ 4 dqg lo @ lo 1 Dffruglqj wr htxdwlrq +7,/
_
@
gc7
_
gc
4
4
@ _
c7

@
lo
+4 ,

lr


.
lr
. +4 ,
lr

lo
.

=
lr
Lpsrvlqj wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| frqglwlrq jlyhvH
_
_
gc
A gc7
/
4
?
4
, +4 ,

+4 ,
4
4
.
o r
lo

lr

lr
.

lr
. +4 ,
A +4 ,
4
4
.
o r

lo
.

lr
, A =
Djdlq iroorzlqj wkh vdph orjlf/ rqh zrxog frqfoxgh wkdw iru vshflfdwlrq +5,/ gc A gc7 krogv
l ? 1
Lq vxppdu|/ uhjdugohvv ri wkh zd| lq zklfk wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq lv ghqhg/ fdslwdo~vnloo
frpsohphqwdulw| lq vshflfdwlrq +4, ^5` krogv l A ^ ? `1
,t|4@|L? hLUi_hit @?_ 5TiU€U@|L?t
Zkloh wkhuh lv vrph vxssruwlqj hylghqfh iru wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv xvlqj
dowhuqdwlyh gdwdvhwv dqg phwkrgrorjlhv dv qrwhg lq wkh lqwurgxfwlrq/ wkh k|srwkhvlv kdv qrw ehhq
H
?Ui @}@?c ?L|Ui |@| |i _hiU| T@h|@* i*@t|U|it Lu tMt|||L? Mi|ii? g @?_ @?_ Mi|ii? @?_ 7 @hi
?L| UL?t|@?|
;
whvwhg 4, xvlqj djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq vshflfdwlrqv gluhfwo| ru 5, xvlqj d furvv~vhfwlrq/
wlph~vhulhv sdqho gdwdvhw1b Wkh odwwhu srlqw lv sduwlfxoduo| uhohydqw lq jurzwk prghov wkdw xvh wkh
djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrqv prwlydwhg e| wkh vxssrvhg h{lvwhqfh ri fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdu0
lwlhv1 Lq dgglwlrq/ dv rxu olwhudwxuh uhylhz vxjjhvwhg/ wkhuh lv qr frqvhqvxv |hw rq wkh dssursuldwh
ixqfwlrqdo irup wr xvh wr fdswxuh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|1 Rxu hvwlpdwlrq h{huflvh/ wr zklfk
zh qrz wxuq/ vkhgv vrph oljkw rq wklv txhvwlrq dv zhoo1
Wkh wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrqv zh frqvlghu duh kljko| qrqolqhdu dqg wkhuhiruh/ qrqolqhdu hvwl0
pdwlrq phwkrgv +lq sduwlfxodu/ qrqolqhdu ohdvw vtxduhv +QOOV, dqg jhqhudol}hg phwkrg ri prphqwv
+JPP, hvwlpdwruv, zloo eh xvhg wr rewdlq hvwlpdwhv ri dqg 1 Wkhvh frpsxwdwlrqdoo| lqwhqvlyh
phwkrgv zhuh qrw ihdvleoh zkhq Idoorq dqg Od|dug +4<:8, uvw sursrvhg hvwlpdwlrq ri surgxf0
wlrq ixqfwlrq vshflfdwlrqv/ dqg frqvhtxhqwo|/ wkh| kdg wr uhvruw wr hvwlpdwlrq ri uhvwulfwlyh olqhdu
vshflfdwlrqv dv qrwhg lq wkh lqwurgxfwlrq1

Ai ALwii* ,5 5TiU€U@|L?t
Wkh wzr~ohyho FHV surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq htxdwlrqv wkdw zloo eh hpslulfdoo| whvwhg duh
k
l*4
k
l*4
\| @ Df d^eN|w . +4 e,V|w `4*w . +4 d,Q|4
\| @ Df d^eN|w . +4 e,Q|w `4*w . +4 d,V|4
hb|n0| >
+8,
hb|n0| >
+9,
zkhuh l ghqrwhv wkh frxqwu|/ w ghqrwhv wkh |hdu dqg % lv wkh huuru whup1 Zh dvvxph h{rjhqrxv/
Klfnv~qhxwudo whfkqrorjlfdo jurzwk1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ zh dvvxph D lv jurzlqj dw wkh udwh / zlwk
Df uhsuhvhqwlqj wkh lqlwldo +w @ 3, ydoxh ri D iru frxqwu| l1f Qrwlfh wkdw prgho vshflfdwlrq +8,
fruuhvsrqgv wr wkh uvw yhuvlrq ri wkh wzr~ohyho FHV irup/ htxdwlrq +4,/ dqg prgho vshflfdwlrq
+9, fruuhvsrqgv wr wkh vhfrqg yhuvlrq ri wkh wzr~ohyho FHV irup/ htxdwlrq +5,1 Zkloh lw lv srvvleoh
wr olqhdul}h htxdwlrqv +8~9,/ wkh uhvxowlqj htxdwlrqv duh frpsolfdwhg dqg lpsrvvleoh wr hvwlpdwh1
Wkh rqo| uhpdlqlqj yldeoh rswlrq lv qrqolqhdu hvwlpdwlrq dqg wkdw lv krz zh surfhhg1
b
6*} @?_ OihUL|3 E2fff L ?it|}@|i |i hi*@|i_ _i@ Lu @? i^T4i?|t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|) )TL|itt _L
ti ?|ih?@|L?@* T@?i* _@|@ uhL4 D UL?|hit OLiihc |i) _L ?L| it|4@|i ThL_U|L? u?U|L?t _hiU|*) @t i
_L ihi W?t|i@_c |i) ti @ *?i@h hi}hittL? 4L_i* Lu @}i @?_ ?i4T*L)4i?| h@|Lt Lu t!**i_ |L ?t!**i_ Lh!iht
Aih hit*|t t}}it| |@| ?it|4i?| ? i^T4i?| h@tit |i hi*@|i _i4@?_ uLh t!**i_ Lh!iht
f
A@| tc | ' f eb| W? @? ?|ihit|?} T@Tihc @ti** @?_ L*i4@? E2ff2@ ti @ |L*ii* ,5 tTiU€U@|L? ?
U |i) @**L |i iUi?U) T@h@4i|iht uLh |i |hii _gihi?| u@U|Lhtc ?t!**i_ *@MLhc t!**i_ *@MLh @?_ U@T|@* |L
_gih uhL4 L?i @?L|ih

Nt?} @ tiUL?_ Lh_ih A@)*Lh tihit i T@?tL? | t TLttM*i |L LM|@? @ *?i@h @TThL 4@|L? Lu |i |L*ii* ,5
tTiU€U@|L? N?*!i |i *?i@h3i_ ihtL? Lu 5|L!i)<t uLh4*@|L?c _tUtti_ Mi*L E? uLL|?L|i c |i *?i@h3i_
@TThL 4@|L? Lu |i |L*ii* ,5 tTiU€U@|L? E*?i@h3i_ @hL?_ 4c w ' f UL?|@?t @ *@h}i ?4Mih Lu *?i@h T@h|t
| 4*|T*i ULiUi?|t |@| U@??L| Mi _i?|€i_ t?} t|@?_@h_ *?i@h it|4@|L? |iU?^it
<
Lq xvlqj sdqho gdwd iru rxu hvwlpdwlrq h{huflvh/ zh pxvw frqiurqw wzr srwhqwldo hfrqrphwulf
sureohpv1 Iluvw/ wkhuh lv wkh sureohp ri xqprghohg/ frxqwu| vshflf {hg~hhfwv/ gxh iru h{dpsoh/
wr glhuhqfhv lq whfkqrorj|/ fxowxuh ru jhrjudsk| +vhh/ h1j1 Lvodp +4<<8,,1 Dvvxplqj wkhvh idfwruv
duh wlph lqyduldqw/ zh fdq uhvroyh wkh {hg hhfwv sureohp e| vxssrvlqj wkdw wkh huuru whup/
%| @ . | / zkhuh uhsuhvhqwv wkh frxqwu| vshflf {hg idfwruv lq frxqwu| l1 Xqghu wklv
dvvxpswlrq/ orj glhuhqflqj +8, dqg +9, |lhogv
#
orj
@.
\c|3
#
orj
\|
\|
\c|3
k
$
d^eN|w . +4 e,V|w `4*w . +4 d,Q|4
4
orj k
d^eN w
k
@.
w
d^eN|w . +4 e,Q|w `4*w . +4 d,V|4
4
orj k
d^eN w
4
3 . +4 e,Vc|3`4*w . +4 d,Qc|3
c|
$
l
w
+:,
l . | c|3 =
+;,
l
4
3 . +4 e,Qc|3 `4*w . +4 d,Vc|3
c|
l . | c|3 >
D vhfrqg sureohp frqfhuqv wkh srvvleoh hqgrjhqhlw| ri wkh lqsxw yduldeohv lq rxu uhjuhvvlrq vshfl0
fdwlrqv/ dv hpskdvl}hg e| Fdvhool hw do1 +4<<9,1 Zh uhvroyh wklv vhfrqg sureohp e| xvlqj d JPP/
lqvwuxphqwdo yduldeohv surfhgxuh wr hvwlpdwh wkh orj~glhuhqfhg prgho/ zkhuh zh xvh vxlwdeoh
odjjhg ydoxhv ri wkh lqsxw dqg rxwsxw yduldeohv dv lqvwuxphqwv1
2
,5?it|i_?LMM#L}*@t 5TiU€U@|L?
Dq dowhuqdwlyh wr wkh wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrqv lv wkh pruh uhvwulfwhg yhuvlrq ri wkhvh vshfl0
fdwlrqv sursrvhg e| Vwrnh| +4<<9, dv jlyhq e| htxdwlrq +6,1 Rxu hvwlpdwhg yhuvlrq ri Vwrnh|*v
surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq vshflfdwlrq lv ri wkh iroorzlqj irup=
\| @ Df ^eN|w . +4 e,Q|w `*w V|3 hb|n0| =
+<,
Lq +<,/ fdslwdo dqg xqvnloohg zrunhuv duh frpelqhg lqwr dq djjuhjdwh e| d FHV vshflfdwlrq1 Wkh
uhvxowlqj djjuhjdwh phdvxuh lv wkhq frpelqhg zlwk vnloohg oderu xvlqj d Free~Grxjodv whfkqrorj|1
Qrwlfh wkdw rxu vshflfdwlrq +<, lv uhdoo| d vshfldo fdvh ri +6, lq wkdw zh dvvxph wkdw t @ 3> wklv
dvvxpswlrq lpsolhv wkdw phqwdo hruw lq wkh surgxfwlrq surfhvv lv h{huwhg rqo| e| vnloohg zrunhuv12
Wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| zrxog krog lq wklv fdvh li wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq
fdslwdo dqg xqvnloohg zrunhuv lv juhdwhu wkdq xqlw|/ wkdw lv/ 3 ? 41 Vlploduo|/ wkh uhvwulfwhg
yhuvlrq ri vshflfdwlrq +4, wkdw zh zloo hvwlpdwh lv jlyhq e|
\| @ Df ^eN|w . +4 e,V|w `*w Q|3 hb|n0| >
2
+43,
Aihi i t|t ?L i4ThU@* i_i?Ui L? ^ E|i UL?|hM|L? Lu ?t!**i_ *@MLh |L 4i?|@* igLh| 5|L!i) EbbS t4T*)
@tt4it |@| ^ ' f2D ? Lh_ih |L !iiT |i t!** Thi44 |? @ hi@tL?@M*i h@?}i ? ih U@*Mh@|L? i ihUtit
43
zkhuh wkh vxflhqw frqglwlrq iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| lv uhyhuvhg/ ? 31 Zh zloo uhihu wr
vshflfdwlrqv +<~43, dv wkh _FHV~qhvwhg~lq~Free~Grxjodv% vshflfdwlrqv/ dqg zh zloo hvwlpdwh
wkhp xvlqj qrqolqhdu ohdvw vtxduhv1
Dv lq wkh fdvh ri wkh jhqhudo/ wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrqv/ zh dovr frqvlghu d orj~glhuhqfh
yhuvlrq ri wkh FHV~qhvwhg~lq~Free~Grxjodvv vshflfdwlrq wkdw jhwv ulg ri frxqwu|~vshflf {hg
hhfwv1 Orj~glhuhqflqj +43, dqg +<, +qrwh wkh fkdqjh lq rughu, zh rewdlq wkh iroorzlqj wzr
h{suhvvlrqv=
#
orj
\c|3
#
orj
$
\|
$
\|
\c|3
^eN|w . +4 e,V|w `
@ . orj
. +4 , orj
w
w
^eNc|
3 . +4 e,Vc|3 `
#
Q|
Qc|3
#
V|
^eN|4 . +4 e,Q|w `
. +4 , orj
@ . orj
w
w
Vc|3
^eNc|3 . +4 e,Qc|3 `
$
. | c|3 >
+44,
. | c|3 =
+45,
$
Zh zloo hvwlpdwh +44~45, xvlqj qrqolqhdu ohdvw vtxduhv dqg xvlqj d JPP/ lqvwuxphqwdo yduldeohv
surfhgxuh zkhuh odjjhg ydoxhv ri lqsxw dqg rxwsxw yduldeohv duh xvhg dv lqvwuxphqwv1
e
Ai #@|@
Rxu hvwlpdwlrq uhtxluhv gdwd iru uhdo JGS +\ ,/ wkh vwrfn ri sk|vlfdo fdslwdo +N,/ xqvnloohg oderu
+Q,/ dqg vnloohg oderu +V,1 Zh rewdlq gdwd iru \ iurp wkh Shqq Zruog Wdeohv y1 819 +SZW~
819,/ dqg frqvwuxfw gdwd iru N xvlqj lqyhvwphqw vkduhv gdwd iurp wkh SZW~819 dqg wkh shushwxdo
lqyhqwru| dssurdfk1 Gdwd iru erwk \ dqg N duh lq frqvwdqw X1V1 grooduv +4<;8 lqwhuqdwlrqdo sulfhv,1
Vlqfh wkh gdwd zh xvh wr frqvwuxfw wkh vnloohg oderu sur{lhv duh rqo| dydlodeoh hyhu| yh |hduv/ rxu
gdwdvhw frqvlvwv ri d qxpehu ri dqqxdo revhuydwlrqv +9, iru hdfk frxqwu|/ vsdfhg yh |hduv dsduw1
Zh frqvwuxfwhg yh dowhuqdwlyh sur{lhv iru vnloohg +xqvnloohg, oderu vlqfh lw zdv qrw fohdu wr xv krz
vnloohg oderu vkrxog eh ghqhg1 Rxu yh sur{lhv iru vnloohg oderu duh= 4, zrunhuv zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg

`i ?L|i |@| | t TLttM*i |L LM|@? @ *?i@h3i_ ihtL? Lu |i hit|hU|i_ ,5?it|i_?LMM #L}*@t tTiU€U@
|L? #_i |i *iu| @?_ h}| @?_ t_it Lu Ef M) | c @?_ |i *iu| @?_ h}| @?_ t_it Lu Eb M) 7| wL}*?i@h3?}
|i hit*|?} i^@|L?t @hL?_ w ' f }it hitTiU|i*)
&| 2
n 0| c
r|
&| 2
n 0| c
?|
*L} +| ' *L} f n b| n K *L} &| n E 3 K *L} r| n *2KE 3 Kw *L}
t c & ' g c r ' 7 @?_
ihi + ' *L} +| ' *L} f n b| n K *L} &| n E 3 K *L} ?| n *2KE 3 Kw *L}
ihi + ' t7 c & ' g
7 c ? ' 7 `i LM|@?i_ it|4@|it uhL4 |iti *?i@h tTiU€U@|L?t t?} w5 | |4i @?_ € i_
igiU|t @?_ ?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it M| uL?_ |@| |i) __ ?L| U@?}i |i 4@? UL?U*tL?t i LM|@?i_ uhL4 |i
4Lhi }i?ih@* ?L?*?i@h tTiU€U@|L?t `i |ihiuLhi ULti |L L4| |iti €?_?}t uhL4 |i T@Tih
44
vrph srvw~vhfrqgdu| +froohjh, hgxfdwlrq +odehohg V4,/ 5, zrunhuv zkr kdyh frpsohwhg vhfrqgdu|
hgxfdwlrq +V5,/ 6, zrunhuv zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vrph vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq +V6,/ 7, zrunhuv zkr kdyh
frpsohwhg sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq/ +V7,/ dqg 8, zrunhuv zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vrph sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq
+V8,1e Hdfk vnloohg oderu sur{| zdv frqvwuxfwhg e| pxowlso|lqj dfklhyhphqw udwhv iru d sduwlfxodu
fxw~r fulwhulrq +xvlqj gdwd iurp Eduur dqg Ohh +5334,, e| wkh vl}h ri wkh oderu irufh lq hdfk frxqwu|
dw hdfk gdwh lq rxu vdpsoh1 Wkh uhpdlqghu ri wkh oderu irufh +wkrvh qrw fodvvlhg dffruglqj wr wkh
ghqlwlrq ri vnloohg oderu +V4~V8,, zdv uhjdughg dv xqvnloohg oderu/ dqg zdv ghvljqdwhg e| Q4/
Q5/ Q6/ Q7 ru Q8/ fruuhvsrqglqj wr wkh ghqlwlrq ri vnloohg oderu1 Rxu edodqfhg sdqho gdwdvhw
frqvlvwv ri :6 frxqwulhv> iru hdfk frxqwu| wkhuh duh vl{ dqqxdo revhuydwlrqv ri doo lqsxw dqg rxwsxw
yduldeohv vsdfhg yh |hduv dsduw vwduwlqj lq 4<98 dqg hqglqj lq 4<<3 +76; revhuydwlrqv,1 Zh fkrrvh
wr zrun zlwk d odujh sdqho ri frxqwulhv/ udwkhu wkdq hvwlpdwlqj surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrqv iru lqglylgxdo
frxqwulhv dv zh kdyh rqo| vl{ revhuydwlrqv shu frxqwu| dqg wkh FHV vshflfdwlrqv lqyroyh dv pdq|
dv vl{ sdudphwhuv1
Vlqfh zrunhuv zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vrph froohjh hgxfdwlrq pd| frqwulexwh pruh hflhqf| xqlwv
wkdq zrunhuv zkr kdyh rqo| dwwdlqhg vrph vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq/ wkh sur{lhv zh xvhg iru vnloohg
+xqvnloohg, oderu frxog vxhu iurp djjuhjdwlrq sureohpv/ iru h{dpsoh/ zkhq vnloohg oderu lv ghqhg
dv wkrvh zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq +V6,1 Lq dq hruw wr dgguhvv wklv sureohp/ zh
iroorz Fdvhool dqg Frohpdq +5335d, dqg hpsor| dgglwlrqdo gdwd rq uhwxuqv wr vfkrrolqj wr zhljkw
lqglylgxdov zlwklq rxu wzr glylvlrqv ri wkh oderu irufh lqwr vnloohg ru xqvnloohg oderu1 Zh zloo uhihu wr
wklv gdwdvhw dv wkh _zhljkwhg% oderu gdwd wr glhuhqwldwh lw iurp wkh gdwd zkhuh uhwxuqv wr vfkrrolqj
gdwd duh qrw xvhg lq wkh frqvwuxfwlrq ri sur{lhv iru vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg oderu +wkh _xqzhljkwhg%
oderu gdwd,1 Zkloh dgmxvwlqj wkh vnloohg2xqvnloohg oderu sur{lhv wr dffrxqw iru uhwxuqv wr vfkrrolqj
pd| vhhp txlwh uhdvrqdeoh/ lw frphv dw wkh frvw ri gudvwlfdoo| uhgxflqj rxu vdpsoh vl}h iurp :6 wr
7< frxqwulhv +iurp 76; wr 5<7 revhuydwlrqv, gxh wr wkh odfn ri gdwd rq uhwxuqv wr vfkrrolqj iru 57
frxqwulhv1 Zh zloo uhwxuq wr wklv lvvxh odwhu lq wkh sdshu1 Ehfdxvh ri wklv gdwd frqvwudlqw/ zh uhsruw
uhvxowv iru erwk wkh odujhu/ xqzhljkwhg oderu gdwdvhw dqg wkh vpdoohu zhljkwhg oderu gdwdvhw1
Dsshqgl{ 4 surylghv ixuwkhu ghwdlov frqfhuqlqj wkh vrxufhv dqg frqvwuxfwlrq ri wkh gdwd xvhg
lq wklv sdshu dv zhoo dv d wdeoh uhsruwlqj wkh phdq ydoxhv ri \ / N/ V7 dqg Q7 iru hdfk frxqwu| lq
wkh vdpsoh1
e W?
@? i@h*ih _h@u| Lu |t T@Tih i UL?t_ihi_ @ _i€?|L? Lu t!**i_ *@MLh @t UL4Tht?} |Lti L @_ UL4T*i|i_
TLt|tiUL?_@h) EUL**i}i i_U@|L? OLiihc ? 4@?) *itt _ii*LTi_ UL?|hitc |i uh@U|L? Lu Lh!iht 4ii|?} |t
_i€?|L? @t U*Lti |L 3ihLc @?_ tL i _hLTTi_ |t _i€?|L? uhL4 Lh @?@*)tt
45
D
+it*|t
Rxu uhvxowv duh rujdql}hg dv iroorzv1 Zh uvw dgguhvv wkh txhvwlrq frqfhuqlqj zklfk vshflfdwlrq/
+4, ru +5,/ lv suhihuuhg1 Zh wkhq uhsruw hvwlpdwlrq uhvxowv iru wkh suhihuuhg vshflfdwlrq xvlqj
wkh ydulrxv hvwlpdwlrq whfkqltxhv> zlwkrxw dqg zlwk {hg hhfwv uhpryhg +zlwk IH, dqg xvlqj
lqvwuxphqwdo yduldeoh +LY, hvwlpdwruv1 Zh dovr frqvlghu wkh urexvwqhvv ri rxu vshflfdwlrq dqg
hvwlpdwlrq uhvxowv xvlqj dgglwlrqdo gdwd rq zdjh udwhv wr dxjphqw rxu phdvxuhv ri vnloohg oderu1
Ilqdoo|/ zh uhsruw wkh uhvxowv ri d Prqwh Fduor h{huflvh wkdw doorzv xv wr dvvhvv wkh uholdelolw| ri wkh
sdudphwhu hvwlpdwhv zh uhsruw lq wkh sdshu1 Zh surfhhg e| uvw uhsruwlqj rxu hvwlpdwlrq uhvxowv
rewdlqhg iurp xvlqj wkh xqzhljkwhg~oderu gdwd dqg wkhq frpphqwlqj rq wkh uhvshfwlyh uhvxowv
rewdlqhg iurp xvlqj wkh zhljkwhg~oderu gdwd +wkh odwwhu uhvxowv duh txdolwdwlyho| vlplodu wr wkrvh
rewdlqhg xvlqj wkh xqzhljkwhg gdwd dqg khqfh duh suhvhqwhg lq Dsshqgl{ 7,1
D
5TiU€U@|L? 5i@hU
Wkh wzr pdlq frpshwlqj vshflfdwlrqv iru whvwlqj wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv duh
jlyhq e| rxu htxdwlrqv +4, dqg +5,1 Zlwklq hdfk ri wkhvh wzr vshflfdwlrqv/ zh frqvlghuhg wkh wzr~
ohyho qrqolqhdu prgho dqg wkh FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG prgho zlwkrxw ru zlwk {hg hhfwv uhpryhg1 Iru
uhjuhvvlrq prghov edvhg rq vshflfdwlrq +5, zh iuhtxhqwo| rewdlqhg sdudphwhu hvwlpdwhv wkdw kdg
wkh zurqj vljqv/ kdg yhu| odujh vwdqgdug huuruv ru zhuh hpslulfdoo| lpsodxvleoh lq pdjqlwxgh/ h1j1
hvwlpdwhv iru lq h{fhvv ri rqh1D E| frqwudvw/ xvlqj vshflfdwlrq +4, rxu hvwlpdwhg sdudphwhuv
jhqhudoo| kdyh wkh uljkw vljqv dqg duh doprvw dozd|v hpslulfdoo| sodxvleoh lq pdjqlwxgh wkrxjk qrw
qhfhvvdulo| vwdwlvwlfdoo| vljqlfdqw1 Iru wklv uhdvrq zh suhihu vshflfdwlrq +4, wr vshflfdwlrq +5,>
wkh uhvw ri wkh sdshu uhsruwv dqg dqdo|}hv uhvxowv iurp hvwlpdwlrq prghov edvhg rq vshflfdwlrq +4,
dorqh1 D pruh h{whqvlyh mxvwlfdwlrq iru rxu fkrlfh ri vshflfdwlrq +4, ryhu +5, lv jlyhq lq Dsshqgl{
5/ zklfk uhsruwv vrph uhjuhvvlrq uhvxowv xvlqj vshflfdwlrq +5,1 Zlwklq rxu suhihuuhg vshflfdwlrq
+4,/ wkh txhvwlrq wkdw uhpdlqv lv wkh dssursuldwh hvwlpdwlrq prgho/ wkdw lv/ zkhwkhu wr xvh wkh
wzr~ohyho FHV ru wkh FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG1 Zh qrz wxuq rxu dwwhqwlrq wr dgguhvvlqj wklv txhvwlrq1
D 6@**L? @?_ w@)@h_ Eb.D TTi?_ @?_ khti** i| @* E2fff hiTLh| t4*@h _U*|it | it|4@|it uhL4
ihtL?t Lu tTiU€U@|L? E2
46
D2
LiUi?| ,t|4@|it
Wdeoh 4 suhvhqwv frhflhqw hvwlpdwhv rewdlqhg iurp qrqolqhdu uhjuhvvlrqv xvlqj wkh xqzhljkwhg~
oderu gdwd lq ydulrxv yhuvlrqv ri vshflfdwlrq +4,1 Doo ri wkh QOOV hvwlpdwlrq uhvxowv uhsruwhg
lq Wdeoh 4 +dqg vxevhtxhqw wdeohv, zhuh rewdlqhg xvlqj hfrqrplfdoo| sodxvleoh lqlwldo sdudphwhuv1
D julg vhdufk rq wkh lqlwldo sdudphwhu ydoxhv zdv dovr frqgxfwhg wr dvvhvv wkh urexvwqhvv ri wkh
uhvxowv1
Xqghu wkh froxpq lq Wdeoh 4 odehohg _QOOV/% zh uhsruw qrqolqhdu ohdvw vtxduhv +QOOV, sd0
udphwhu hvwlpdwhv iru vshflfdwlrq +8, +wkh wzr~ohyho prgho zlwk qr fruuhfwlrq iru {hg hhfwv, iru
hdfk ri wkh yh zd|v ri fodvvli|lqj vnloohg oderu1 Xqghu wkh froxpq _QOOV zlwk IH/% zh uhsruw
QOOV hvwlpdwhv iru wkh orj glhuhqfh vshflfdwlrq +:, +wkh wzr~ohyho prgho zlwk {hg hhfwv +IH,
uhpryhg, djdlq iru doo yh zd|v ri fodvvli|lqj vnloohg oderu1 Ilqdoo|/ xqghu wkh froxpq _JPP~LY
zlwk IH% zh uhsruw hvwlpdwhv iurp d JPP~LY surfhgxuh dssolhg wr wkh orj~glhuhqfh vshflfdwlrq
+:,1 Wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwru zdv fkrvhq wr ghdo zlwk d srvvleoh hqgrjhqhlw| sureohp dulvlqj iurp
wkh idfw wkdw wkh huuru whup lq wkh orj~glhuhqfh vshflfdwlrq +:, lv olnho| wr eh frqwhpsrudqhrxvo|
fruuhodwhg zlwk wkh lqsxw yduldeohv/ N| / V| dqg Q| 1 Pruh jhqhudoo|/ wkh shushwxdo lqyhqwru| ds0
surdfk xvhg wr frqvwuxfw fdslwdo vwrfn ydoxhv +vhh wkh dsshqgl{ iru ghwdlov, lpsolhv wkdw N| zloo
dozd|v ghshqg rq c|3 / zklfk lv rqh ri wkh wzr frpsrqhqwv ri wkh orj~glhuhqfh vshflfdwlrq
huuru whup dw gdwh w1 Qrwlfh wkdw c|3 lv dovr d frpsrqhqw ri wklv glvwxuedqfh dw wlph w 4> zklfk
lpsolhv wkdw wkh huuru whup lq wkh orj~glhuhqfh vshflfdwlrq glvsod|v uvw~rughu vhuldo fruuhodwlrq1
Wr dgguhvv wkhvh srvvleoh hqgrjhqhlw| sureohpv/ zh dovr xvh d JPP~LY hvwlpdwru wr hvwlpdwh wkh
uvw~glhuhqfh +{hg hhfwv uhpryhg, vshflfdwlrqv1 Iroorzlqj wkh iudphzrun rxwolqhg lq Duhoodqr
dqg Erqg +4<<4,/ rxu uvw~glhuhqfh JPP~LY hvwlpdwru xvhv dv lqvwuxphqwv lqsxw~rxwsxw ydul0
deohv odjjhg wzr shulrgv ru pruh/ dqg fruuhfwv iru wkh uvw~rughu dxwrfruuhodwhg glvwxuedqfhv1S
Wklv phwkrgrorj| zdv lqlwldoo| lpsruwhg lqwr wkh jurzwk olwhudwxuh e| Fdvhool hw do1 +4<<9, dqg kdv
vxevhtxhqwo| ehfrph dq lpsruwdqw ehqfkpdun hvwlpdwlrq phwkrg1.
S
W? T@h|U*@hc Lh B it|4@|L? Lu E. @?_ E Ehit*|t uhL4 |i *@||ih @hi Thiti?|i_ *@|ih ? A@M*i tit
*L} tc|32 c *L} tc|3 c *L} gc|32 c *L} gc|3 c *L} 7c|32 c *L} 7c|3 @?_ *L} c|32 c *L} c|3 @t ?t|h4i?|t L|Ui |@|
|i ?4Mih Lu LMtih@|L?t i @i @@*@M*i uLh Lh B hi}hittL?t t }hi@|*) hi_Ui_ M) |i ti Lu |hii *@}t Lu
@** @h@M*it 5i?t||) @?@*)tit ihi TihuLh4i_ t?} @*|ih?@|i ti|t Lu ?t|h4i?|tc i} |i t4@**ih ti| *L} gc|32 c
*L} gc|3 c *L} 7c|32 c *L} 7c|3 @?_ *L} c|32 *L} c|3 c @?_ ?L| ULhhiU|?} uLh €ht|Lh_ih @|LULhhi*@|L? `i _L
?L| hiTLh| |iti hit*|t @t |i) @hi t4*@h |L |Lti hiTLh|i_ ? A@M*it  @?_ .
*?_i** @?_ L?_ EbbHc 2fff t}}it| @? @*|ih?@|i @TThL@U |@| ?L*it B it|4@|L? Lu @ t)t|i4 Lu
ThL_U|L? u?U|L?t ? ML| *ii*t @?_ €ht| _gihi?Uit t?} *@}}i_ €ht| _gihi?Uit Lu @** @h@M*it _@|i_ | 3 2 @?_
i@h*ih @t ?t|h4i?|t ? |i *ii*t i^@|L? @?_ *@}}i_ *ii*t _@|i_ | 3 @?_ i@h*ih @t ?t|h4i?|t ? |i €ht|
47
Wdeoh 4= Wzr~Ohyho FHV Qrqolqhdu Hvwlpdwlrq
Vnloohg Oderu
Dwwdlqhg
Sdudphwhu
Froohjh
Frpsohwhg
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
Vhfrqgdu|
Dwwdlqhg
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
Vhfrqgdu|
Frpsohwhg
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
Sulpdu|
Dwwdlqhg
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
Sulpdu|
Qr1 Rev1
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
QOOV
318796;WWW
+3139;6<,
315378<
+3148<6<,
31674:<W
+314<539,
516945
314576<
3187677WWW
+313:559,
3176:4;WW
+3153338,
3143959
+3153855,
3153<54
3197:6<
318<;74WWW
+313;4<7,
31784<7WWW
+3149844,
314797:
+314<444,
3183939
317:9;8
31974:3WWW
+313<55;,
3184;7;WWW
+314;64<,
3145654
+3156685,
<1<533
3133496
31<3:88WWW
+314893:,
315;955WW
+3146::8,
3195467WWW
+3155989,
717656
3136:94
76;
QOOV zlwk IH
3156;94WWW
+313:89;,
3185549
+41349;3,
0315;688
+41374<,
3169;:9
318769;
316:;6<WWW
+313:57;,
3183;57
+315<;85,
03145<;8
+31637;6,
314<:5<
31989<5
3183697WWW
+313:79:,
0313:4<7
+3153<<6,
318:88<WWW
+3153:6<,
;1;3:8
3133543
3199443WWW
+313<<37,
03137835
+314:68<,
31:3945WWW
+314<9<9,
461969
3133355
31;3495WWW
+3147786,
31468<7
+3144;53,
319989:WWW
+314:6<8,
481<85
313333:
698
JPP~LY zlwk IH
31:;99;WWW
+315<83<,
317889:
+5179<8,
3166434
+51648<,


4158:8WWW
+31794;;,
3148759
+41:675,
414366
+418589,


31:988<
+31<8:3<,
3189:6:
+41<<47,
314<;55
+41<;;9,


31;6873
+31856<8,
3165944
+71::76,
3183<5<
+71:<56,


31;<:54
+41554<,
03136;65
+6137<;,
31<6886
+713899,


54<
L|itG 5|@?_@h_ ihhLhtc ? T@hi?|ititc ihi hiULihi_ t?} t|@?_@h_ @TThL 4@|L? 4i|L_t
`|i<t i|ihLt!i_@t|U|) ULhhiU|L? @t ti_ 888c 88c 8 5}?€U@?|*) _gihi?| uhL4 f @| |i I c
DIc @?_ fI *ii*tc hitTiU|i*)
48
Vwdqgdug QOOV hvwlpdwlrq ri vshflfdwlrq +8, zlwkrxw wkh uhprydo ri {hg hhfwv ru xvh ri
lqvwuxphqwv ~ vhh wkh _QOOV% froxpq ri Wdeoh 4 ~ |lhogv hvwlpdwhv iru dqg wkdw duh srvlwlyh
dqg/ zlwk rqh h{fhswlrq/ vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp }hur1 Uhfdoo wkdw iru wklv wzr~ohyho vshflfdwlrq/
fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| lv vdlg wr rewdlq li A 1 Wkh QOOV hvwlpdwhv vxjjhvw fdslwdo~vnloo
frpsohphqwdulw| iru rxu wzr h{wuhph ghqlwlrqv ri vnloohg oderu> wkh glhuhqfh lv irxqg wr
eh vljqlfdqwo| srvlwlyh zkhq vnloohg oderu lv ghqhg dv wkrvh zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vrph froohjh ru
wkrvh zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vrph sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq1 Xvlqj wkh plggoh wkuhh ghqlwlrqv iru vnloohg
oderu/ wkh glhuhqfh lv srvlwlyh/ dqg wkhuhiruh frqvlvwhqw zlwk fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|/
exw wklv glhuhqfh lv qrw vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp }hur1 Qrwlfh/ krzhyhu/ wkdw d olnholkrrg udwlr
whvw ri wkh uhvwulfwlrq wkdw @ lv uhmhfwhg +s ? =43, rqo| zkhq wkh ghqlwlrq ri vnloohg oderu lv vhw
dw rqh ri wkh wzr orzhvw wkuhvkrogv/ hlwkhu wkh dwwdlqhg sulpdu| ru frpsohwhg sulpdu| wkuhvkrog1
Zkhq zh xvh QOOV wr hvwlpdwh wkh qrqolqhdu/ wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq zlwk {hg hhfwv
uhpryhg/ vshflfdwlrq +:, ~ vhh wkh _QOOV zlwk IH% froxpq lq Wdeoh 4 ~ zh qg wkdw wkhuh lv
hylghqfh idyrulqj fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| zkhq vnloohg oderu lv ghqhg xvlqj wkh orzhvw wkuhh
wkuhvkrogv= wkrvh zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vrph sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq/ wkrvh zkr kdyh frpsohwhg sulpdu|
hgxfdwlrq dqg wkrvh zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vrph vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq1 Ghqlqj vnloohg oderu deryh
wkh _dwwdlqhg vhfrqgdu|% wkuhvkrog/ hylghqfh ri fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| ydqlvkhv> lw hyhq
dsshduv wkdw wkhuh lv hylghqfh ri fdslwdo~vnloo vxevwlwxwdelolw|/ dv wkh hvwlpdwhg glhuhqfh ehfrphv qhjdwlyh/ wkrxjk wklv glhuhqfh lv qrw irxqg wr eh vljqlfdqw1 Wkh hylghqfh iru fdslwdo~
vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| xvlqj d orz vnloo wkuhvkrog dsshduv wr ghulyh iurp wkh vljqlfdqwo| srvlwlyh
hvwlpdwhv ri > wkh hvwlpdwhv ri duh qhyhu irxqg wr eh vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp }hur1 Olnholkrrg
udwlr whvwv frqup wkdw wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv/ @ fdq eh uhmhfwhg +s ? =43, rqo| zkhq vnloohg oderu
lv ghqhg xvlqj rqh ri wkh wkuhh orzhvw wkuhvkrogv1
Dsso|lqj wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwru wr wkh uvw glhuhqfhg wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq +:, |lhogv
srvlwlyh hvwlpdwhv ri wkh glhuhqfh iru doo yh ghqlwlrqv ri vnloohg oderu ~ vhh wkh _JPP~LY
zlwk IH% froxpq lq Wdeoh 4/ vxjjhvwlqj fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|1 Krzhyhu/ wkh glhuhqfh
lv qhyhu irxqg wr eh vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp }hur1 Lqghhg/ zlwk mxvw wzr h{fhswlrqv/ wkh
_gihi?Ui i^@|L? Ai) €?_ |@| |t @*|ih?@|i Rt)t|i4t @TThL@U )i*_t *Lih t|@?_@h_ ihhLht @t UL4T@hi_
| |i B €ht|_gihi?Ui it|4@|Lh Lu hi**@?L @?_ L?_ Ebb i? @TT*i_ |L *?i@h 4L_i*t W| t ?U*i@h
i|ih |i Mi?i€|t Lu |i t)t|i4t it|4@|Lh L*_ i |i?_ |L |i ?L?*?i@h ThL_U|L? u?U|L? tTiU€U@|L? |@| i
it|4@|i 6h|ih4Lhic @TT*)?} |t @TThL@U L*_ UL4i @| |i ULt| Lu uh|ih hi_U?} |i ?4Mih Lu LMtih@|L?t
i @i @@*@M*i Mi*L |i 2b LMtih@|L?t i hiTLh| uLh |i BWV it|4@|Lh ? A@M*it  @?_ `i *i@i
tU @? i ihUti |L u|hi hiti@hU
49
hvwlpdwhg ydoxhv ri dqg duh/ e| wkhpvhoyhv/ qhyhu vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp }hur1 Zkloh wkh
JPP~LY frhflhqw hvwlpdwhv grq*w glhu wkdw pxfk iurp wkh fruuhvsrqglqj QOOV hvwlpdwhv/ wkh
vwdqgdug huuruv ri wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwhv duh 5 wr 58 wlphv kljkhu wkdq wkh fruuhvsrqglqj QOOV
hvwlpdwhv1
Wkh vwdwlvwlfdo lqvljqlfdqfh ri sdudphwhu hvwlpdwhv xvlqj uvw glhuhqfh JPP hvwlpdwruv lv
d zhoo~nqrzq gudzedfn ri wklv whfkqltxh> uhvhdufkhuv hvwlpdwlqj surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrqv zlwk plfur
gdwdvhwv kdyh hqfrxqwhuhg wkh vdph glfxow| ~ vhh wkh vxuyh| e| Julolfkhv dqg Pdluhvvh +4<<;,1 Dv
wkhvh wzr dxwkruv qrwh/ lw vhhpv wkdw hruwv wr frqwuro iru khwhurjhqhlw| dqg hqgrjhqhlw| ohdg rqo|
wr _h{dfhuedwlrqv ri rwkhu sureohpv dqg plvvshflfdwlrqv1% +s1 4<;,1 Rqh srwhqwldo uhphg|/ pruh
+dqg ehwwhu phdvxuhg, gdwd/ zloo rqo| frph zlwk wkh sdvvdjh ri wlph1 Vwloo/ wkh JPP dssurdfk
lv suhihuuhg wr QOOV hvwlpdwlrq ehfdxvh wkh JPP dssurdfk uhsuhvhqwv dq hruw wr dgguhvv wkh
hqgrjhqhlw| sureohp1 Zkloh zh pd| qrw fxuuhqwo| kdyh hqrxjk gdwd/ zh fdq frqgxfw d Prqwh
Fduor h{huflvh wr dvvhvv krz zhoo rxu JPP~LY hvwlpdwru iduhv +uhodwlyh wr QOOV, lq ghwhfwlqj
fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| lq vpdoo vdpsoh vl}hv1 Wklv h{huflvh lv shuiruphg lq vhfwlrq 91 Wr
iruhvkdgrz rxu qglqjv/ wkh Prqwh Fduor whvw ri wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwru |lhogv hvwlpdwhv vlplodu wr
wkrvh uhsruwhg lq Wdeoh 4 dorqj zlwk odujh vwdqgdug huuruv1 Khqfh rxu idloxuh wr ghwhfw fdslwdo~vnloo
frpsohphqwdulw| xvlqj wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwru pd| zhoo eh gxh wr wkh vpdoo vdpsoh surshuwlhv ri
wkh hvwlpdwru dqg qrw wr wkh devhqfh ri fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| lq wkh dydlodeoh djjuhjdwh
gdwd1
Frqvlghu qh{w/ wkh FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG vshflfdwlrqv +43~44,1 Uhfdoo wkdw wkhvh vshflfdwlrqv
duh mxvw uhvwulfwhg yhuvlrqv ri wkh pruh jhqhudo wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq +4,1H Lq sduwlfxodu/ wkh
uhvwulfwlrq lv wkdw lq wkh pruh jhqhudo vshflfdwlrq +4,/ lv htxdo wr }hur/ vr wkdw wkh hodvwlflw| ri
vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq fdslwdo dqg xqvnloohg oderu gc dqg +v|pphwulfdoo|, ehwzhhq xqvnloohg dqg
vnloohg oderu/ c7 duh htxdo wr xqlw|1 Zh fdq whvw wklv uhvwulfwlrq e| vlpso| h{dplqlqj zkhwkhu wkh
hvwlpdwhv ri uhsruwhg lq Wdeoh 4 iru wkh pruh jhqhudo/ wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq duh vljqlfdqwo|
glhuhqw iurp }hur1 Iru wkh QOOV dqg QOOV~IH hvwlpdwhv/ lv dozd|v srvlwlyh dqg vljqlfdqwo|
glhuhqw iurp }hur1 Wkh vdph krogv wuxh iru wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwhv ri zkhq vnloohg oderu lv
ghqhg dv wkrvh zkr kdyh dw ohdvw frpsohwhg d vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq1 Zh duh wkhuhiruh deoh wr
uhmhfw wkh FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG vshflfdwlrq lq wkhvh fdvhv lq idyru ri wkh pruh jhqhudo wzr~ohyho
H Bi?
Lh €?_?}t uLh |i |L*ii* ,5 tTiU€U@|L? E2 i }?Lhi |i ,5?it|i_?# tTiU€U@|L?t Eb
@?_ E2 |@| @hi hit|hU|i_ ihtL?t Lu tTiU€U@|L? E2
4:
FHV vshflfdwlrq dv wkh suhihuuhg vshflfdwlrq1b Vwloo/ iru frpsohwhqhvv/ zh uhsruw QOOV dqg
JPP~LY hvwlpdwhv ri vshflfdwlrqv +43~44, lq Dsshqgl{ 61
Zkloh rxu pdlq irfxv lv rq wkh suhvhqfh ru devhqfh ri fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|/ rxu hvwl0
pdwhv ri lq Wdeoh 4 duh dovr ri lqwhuhvw iru wkh hvwlpdwhv wkh| lpso| iru wkh Doohq hodvwlflw| ri
@
@ 4@+4 ,1
vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq dqg xqvnloohg oderu dqg vnloohg oderu +ru fdslwdo, ghqhg e| c7
@
Wkh lpsolhg hvwlpdwhv ri c7
xvlqj wkh hvwlpdwhv ri lq Wdeoh 4/ udqjh iurp 416 wr 4312f Zh
qrwh wkdw Nohqrz dqg Urguljxh}~Foduh +4<<:, xvh djjuhjdwh/ furvv~frxqwu| gdwd wr hvwlpdwh wkh
hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq zrunhuv zlwk d sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq ru ohvv dqg zrunhuv zlwk pruh
hgxfdwlrq1 Wkhlu hvwlpdwh iru wklv hodvwlflw| lv 98$ Wkxv rxu vhhplqjo| kljk hvwlpdwhv ri wkh
hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq ehwzhhq xqvnloohg dqg vnloohg oderu zkhq wkh vnloo wkuhvkrog lv orz +h1j1
frpsohwhg sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq, duh qrw zlwkrxw suhfhghqw1
D
#tUttL? Lu |i ,t|4@|L? +it*|t
Wr vxppdul}h/ rxu pdlq qglqj lv wkdw xvlqj d wlph~vhulhv/ furvv vhfwlrq sdqho ri :6 frxqwulhv/ wkhuh
dsshduv wr eh vrph hylghqfh lq vxssruw ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv1 Wkh QOOV
uhvxowv iurp Wdeoh 4 duh eurdgo| vxssruwlyh ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv/ wkrxjk
wkh hylghqfh lv riwhq qrw vwdwlvwlfdoo| vljqlfdqw1 Krzhyhu/ zkhq zh dgguhvv wkh hqgrjhqhlw| lvvxh
e| xvlqj d JPP~LY hvwlpdwru/ wkh hylghqfh iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| lv juhdwo| zhdnhqhg>
wkh vwdqgdug huuruv dvvrfldwhg zlwk wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwru gr qrw doorz xv wr pdnh dq| uhdo
lqihuhqfh dv wr zkhwkhu wkhuh lv fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| ru vxevwlwxwdelolw|12 Wklv qglqj
lv frqvlvwhqw zlwk wkh srvvlelolw| wkdw ryhu frxqwulhv dqg dfurvv wlph/ wkh h{whqw ri fdslwdo~vnloo
frpsohphqwdulw| +ru vxevwlwxwdelolw|, lv vxemhfw wr fkdqjh/ dv dujxhg e| Jroglq dqg Ndw} +4<<;,1
Lw pd| dovr eh dq duwlidfw ri rxu uhodwlyho| vpdoo vdpsoh/ dqg zh zloo dgguhvv wklv srvvlelolw| odwhu
lq wkh sdshu1
Zlwk uhjdug wr surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq vshflfdwlrqv/ zh dujxh djdlqvw wkh xvh ri wkh wzr~ohyho
vshflfdwlrq +5, lq idyru ri wkh wzr~ohyho vshflfdwlrq +4,1 Ixuwkhupruh/ zh duh deoh wr uhmhfw wkh
pruh uhvwulfwlyh FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG vshflfdwlrq/ lq idyru ri wkh pruh jhqhudo/ wzr~ohyho vshflfd0
b h
hiiU|L? Lu |i hit|hU|i_ ,5?it|i_?# tTiU€U@|L? t UL?tt|i?| | |i €?_?}t Lu khti** i| @*
E2fff L LM|@?i_ |i t@4i €?_?} t?} L?*) N5 _@|@
2f
W? L?i U@tic |i BWV it|4@|i Lu 4 i? t!**i_ *@MLh t _i€?i_ @t |Lti L @i UL4T*i|i_ tiUL?_@h)
i_U@|L?c |i i*@t|U|) Lu tMt|||L? 4i@thi t **_i€?i_ @t |i it|4@|i Lu 4 i Uii_t ?|)
2
`i ?L|i |@| Lh *@U! Lu t|hL?} i_i?Ui uLh U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|) t UL?tt|i?| | |i Lh! Lu @ti**
@?_ L*i4@? E2ff2@ L LM|@? @ t4*@h hit*| t?} @ 4Lhi ?_hiU| it|4@|L? 4i|L_
4;
wlrq +4,1
Ilqdoo|/ zh qrwh wkdw rxu frhflhqw hvwlpdwhv vkhg vrph oljkw rq wkh dssursuldwh ghqlwlrq ri
vnloohg oderu/ dw ohdvw iru sxusrvhv ri dvvhvvlqj wkh lvvxh ri fdslwdo~vnloohg oderu frpsohphqwdulw|1
Wkh QOOV dqg QOOV zlwk IH hvwlpdwhv lq Wdeoh 4 vxjjhvw wkdw d orz wkuhvkrog iru glylglqj
oderu lqwr xqvnloohg dqg vnloohg fodvvlfdwlrqv/ vxfk dv zkhwkhu zrunhuv kdyh frpsohwhg sulpdu|
hgxfdwlrq/ pd| eh pruh frqgxflyh wr d qglqj ri fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|1 Wklv lv d pxfk
orzhu wkuhvkrog wkdq kdv wudglwlrqdoo| ehhq frqvlghuhg lq wkh olwhudwxuh +h1j1 Nuxvhoo hw do1 +5333,
ghqh vnloohg zrunhuv dv wkrvh zkr kdyh frpsohwhg d srvw~vhfrqgdu| +froohjh, hgxfdwlrq ru ehwwhu,1
De
+LMt|?itt Lu |i +it*|t t?} _t|i_ 5!**i_ w@MLh #@|@
Zh kdyh h{dplqhg wkh urexvwqhvv ri rxu uhvxowv e| frqvlghulqj dq dowhuqdwlyh dqg srvvleo| pruh ds0
sursuldwh ghqlwlrq iru vnloohg2xqvnloohg oderu1 Dv glvfxvvhg hduolhu/ wklv _zhljkwhg% oderu gdwdvhw
dgmxvwv iru glvsdulwlhv lq hflhqf| xqlwv dfurvv zrunhuv zkr ehorqj wr glhuhqw hgxfdwlrqdo vxe0
jurxsv zlwklq wkh fodvv ri zrunhuv zh kdyh ghvljqdwhg dv vnloohg ru xqvnloohg oderu1 Dgmxvwlqj wkh
phdvxuhv ri vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg oderu iru wkh uhwxuqv hduqhg e| wkh ydulrxv hgxfdwlrqdo vxejurxsv
surylghv xv zlwk d pruh suhflvh phdvxuh ri wkh frqwulexwlrq ri vnloohg oderu wr rxwsxw1 Ixuwkhu
ghwdlov frqfhuqlqj wkh frqvwuxfwlrq ri wklv zhljkwhg oderu gdwd fdq eh irxqg lq Dsshqgl{ 41
Xqiruwxqdwho| gxh wr d odfn ri gdwd rq uhwxuqv wr vfkrrolqj iru doo :6 frxqwulhv/ wklv dgmxvwphqw
wr wkh oderu gdwd holplqdwhv dssur{lpdwho| rqh~wklug ri wkh frxqwulhv lq rxu vdpsoh> zh kdyh
7< frxqwulhv ohiw/ |lhoglqj mxvw 5<7 revhuydwlrqv +dv frpsduhg zlwk wkh 76; revhuydwlrqv dydlodeoh
lq wkh ixoo vdpsoh,1 Odujh vdpsoh vl}hv duh sduwlfxoduo| fuxfldo wr rxu zrun/ dv wkh uhvxowv iurp
hvwlpdwlqj +wkh fxuydwxuh ri, wkh kljko| qrqolqhdu qhvwhg FHV surgxfwlrq vshflfdwlrqv uhtxluhv
d vxflhqwo| odujh qxpehu ri revhuydwlrqv1 Lqghhg/ wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwlrq surfhgxuh iru wkh
qrqolqhdu prghov/ zklfk uhtxluhv wkh xvh ri lqvwuxphqwv/ uhgxfhv wkh vdpsoh vl}h hyhq ixuwkhu wr
mxvw 47: revhuydwlrqv> wkh uhvxowv iurp dsso|lqj wklv surfhgxuh wr wkh vpdoohu zhljkwhg~oderu gdwdvhw
zhuh xquholdeoh uhvxowlqj lq hfrqrplfdoo| lpsodxvleoh frhflhqw hvwlpdwhv dqg duh qrw uhsruwhg1 Wkh
uhvxowv iurp dsso|lqj QOOV wr wkh wzr~ohyho prgho dqg wkh orj~glhuhqfh yhuvlrq ri wklv prgho
xvlqj wkh zhljkwhg~oderu gdwd +iru zklfk 5<7 revhuydwlrqv zhuh dydlodeoh, duh suhvhqwhg lq Wdeohv
D7 lq Dsshqgl{ 71
Wkh uhvxowv lq Wdeoh D7/ wkh dqdorj ri Wdeoh 4/ uhyhdo wkdw xvlqj wkh zhljkwhg oderu gdwd/ wkh
QOOV dqg QOOV~IH hvwlpdwhv ri wkh glhuhqfh duh srvlwlyh iru prvw vnloohg oderu ghqlwlrqv/
4<
exw duh qhyhu vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp }hur1 Dv iru wkh FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG vshflfdwlrq/ wkh
uhvwulfwlrq wkdw @ 3 lv fohduo| uhmhfwhg edvhg rq wkh hvwlpdwhv uhsruwhg lq Wdeoh D71 Krzhyhu/
iru frpsohwhqhvv/ zh uhsruw wkh FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG hvwlpdwhv xvlqj wkh zhljkwhg oderu gdwd +wkh
dqdorj ri Wdeoh D6, lq wdeoh D8 ri Dsshqgl{ 71 Ghvslwh vrph glhuhqfhv/ wkh hvwlpdwlrq uhvxowv xvlqj
wkh zhljkwhg oderu gdwd duh txdolwdwlyho| vlplodu wr wkrvh zh rewdlqhg xvlqj wkh xqzhljkwhg~oderu
gdwdvhw1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ wzr ri rxu pdlq qglqjv/ zhdn hylghqfh iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|/
dqg wkh uhmhfwlrq ri wkh pruh uhvwulfwlyh FHV~lq~FG vshflfdwlrq lq idyru ri wkh jhqhudo wzr~ohyho
vshflfdwlrq frqwlqxh wr krog zkhq zh xvh wkh zhljkwhg oderu gdwd1
Zh kdyh dovr wulhg wr vsolw wkh gdwd wr h{dplqh wkh vhqvlwlylw| ri rxu uhvxowv wr glhuhqw vxe0
vdpsohv ri frxqwulhv exw wr gdwh/ rxu hvwlpdwhv iurp vxfk vdpsoh vsolwv kdyh ehhq hpslulfdoo|
lpsodxvleoh1 Zh wklqn wklv lv gxh wr kdylqj d olplwhg qxpehu ri revhuydwlrqv wkdw fdq qrw dgh0
txdwho| fdswxuh yduldwlrq lq wkh fxuydwxuh ri rxu djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrqv1
S
L?|i @h*L , Tih4i?|t
Rxu pdlq qglqjv uhvw rq wkh sdudphwhu hvwlpdwhv wkdw zh uhsruw lq Wdeoh 4 +dv zhoo dv Wdeohv D6~
D8,1 D qdwxudo txhvwlrq frqfhuqv wkh uholdelolw| ri wkh hvwlpdwhv zh kdyh rewdlqhg xvlqj qrqolqhdu
hvwlpdwlrq whfkqltxhv iru wkh wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq jlyhq rxu _vpdoo% vdpsohv dqg srwhqwldo
sureohpv zlwk {hg hhfwv dqg hqgrjhqhlw|1 Lqghhg/ Nxpdu dqg Jdslqvnl +4<:7, dqg Wkxuve|
+4<;3, uhsruw uhvxowv iurp Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv h{dplqlqj wkh vpdoo vdpsoh surshuwlhv ri
FHV sdudphwhu hvwlpdwhv rewdlqhg xvlqj qrqolqhdu dqg olqhdu hvwlpdwlrq surfhgxuhv dqg qg wkdw
doo ri wkh FHV sdudphwhu hvwlpdwhv zhuh uholdeoh zlwk wkh qrwdeoh h{fhswlrq ri wkh hodvwlflw| ri
vxevwlwxwlrq sdudphwhu hvwlpdwh$ Vlqfh wklv hvwlpdwh lv wkh sulpdu| frqfhuq ri rxu vwxg|/ zh ihow lw
qhfhvvdu| wr xqghuwdnh rxu rzq Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv/ zklfk zh ghvfuleh ehorz1 Zh qrwh wkdw
Nxpdu dqg Jdslqvnl dqg Wkxuve| h{dplqhg rqo| wkh vwdqgdug FHV vshflfdwlrq/ qrw wkh wzr~ohyho
vshflfdwlrq wkdw zh h{dplqh/ dqg wkh| irfxvhg rq olqhdu dqg qrqolqhdu hvwlpdwlrq whfkqltxhv wkdw
glhu iurp wkrvh xvhg lq wklv vwxg|1 Ixuwkhupruh/ wkh| xvhg idu ihzhu revhuydwlrqv wkdq zh kdyh
dydlodeoh lq rxu sdqho gdwdvhw +h1j1 Wkxuve| xvhg mxvw 53 revhuydwlrqv, dqg wkhlu wlph vhulhv gdwd
kdg qr furvv~vhfwlrq frpsrqhqw1 Vlqfh zh orrn dw furvv~frxqwu|/ wlph vhulhv gdwd/ rxu yduldeohv duh
olnho| wr vkrz +diwhu frqwuroolqj iru wkh wlph wuhqg, pxfk pruh yduldwlrq1 Iru doo ri wkhvh uhdvrqv/
53
d qhz vhw ri Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv vhhpv zduudqwhg122
Wkh irfxv ri rxu Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv lv rq wkh vpdoo~vdpsoh surshuwlhv dqg wkh srwhqwldo
sureohpv ri {hg~hhfwv dqg hqgrjhqhlw| ri wkh QOOV hvwlpdwruv ri wkh wzr~ohyho FHV sdudphwhuv/
dqg 1 Lq sulqflsoh/ zh frxog h{dplqh wkh surshuwlhv ri wkh hvwlpdwruv zh frqvlghu iru doo ri wkh
vshflfdwlrqv vxjjhvwhg lq wkh sdshu +xvlqj doo wkh sur{lhv iru vnloohg oderu dqg erwk wkh xqzhljkwhg
dqg zhljkwhg oderu gdwd,1 Dv rxu dlp lv wkh pruh olplwhg rqh ri surylglqj vrph dvvhvvphqw ri wkh
uholdelolw| ri wkh ydulrxv hvwlpdwruv zh hpsor|/ zh kdyh fkrvhq wr irfxv dwwhqwlrq rq wkh wzr~ohyho
FHV vshflfdwlrq +wkh prvw xquhvwulfwhg qhvwhg FHV vshflfdwlrq, dqg wr xvh rqo| wkh xqzhljkwhg
gdwd lq rxu Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv1 Dv d sur{| iru vnloohg oderu/ zh kdyh fkrvhq wr xvh zrunhuv
zkr kdyh frpsohwhg sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq +V7,1
Lq sduwlfxodu/ zh frqvlghu wkh vwrfkdvwlf frxqwhusduw ri vshflfdwlrq +4, jlyhq e|
orj \| @ orj Df . w .
dqg
#
orj
\|
\c|3
k
l
4
orj d^eN|w . +4 e,V7w| `4*w . +4 d,Q74| . %| >
k
$
@.
d^eN|w . +4 e,V7w| `4*w . +4 d,Q74|
4
orj k
d^eN w
+46,
l
. +4 e,V7wc|3 `4*w . +4 d,Q74c|3
c|3
l . %| %c|3 >
+47,
zkhuh %| lv d glvwxuedqfh whup1
D fulwlfdo txhvwlrq frqfhuqlqj rxu vlpxodwlrq h{huflvh lv krz wr jhqhudwh glvwxuedqfhv zlwk
exlow~lq hqgrjhqhlw| dqg {hg~hhfwv sureohpv12 Zlwkrxw dq| sulru nqrzohgjh ri wkh pdjqlwxgh
ri wkh hqgrjhqhlw| sureohp lqkhuhqw lq +46~47, qru wkh zd| e| zklfk lw dhfwv %| / zh frqvwuxfw d
glvwxuedqfh whup lq wkh iroorzlqj vlpsoh exw lqwxlwlyh zd|=
%| @ %| . +gc| . 7c| . c| , . +
gc . 7c . c , =
+48,
Lq htxdwlrq +48,/ %| lv d udqgrpo| jhqhudwhg l=l=g= frpsrqhqw wkdw lv ruwkrjrqdo wr wkh h{sodqdwru|
yduldeohv/ dqg wkh whupv lq wkh wudqvsrvhg yhfwru +gc| > 7c| > c| , @ | duh wkh glvwxuedqfhv iru
frxqwu| l dw gdwh w iurp wkh uhjuhvvlrq
[| @ ]c|32 . | >
+49,
22
AL Lh !?L*i_}ic |ihi t ?L ThLh Lh! i @4??} |i t4@** t@4T*i ThLTih|it Lu it|4@|it LM|@?i_ uhL4
?L?*?i@h Lh *?i@h it|4@|L? Lu |i |L*ii* ,5 tTiU€U@|L? |@| i UL?t_ih ? |t T@Tih At Lh L?|i
@h*L i Tih4i?|t @hi Lu ?_iTi?_i?| ?|ihit| Mi)L?_ Lh @TT*U@|L? i @4??} |i U@T|@*t!** UL4T*i4i?|@h|)
)TL|itt
2
Ai @|Lht @hi }h@|iu* |L @? @?L?)4Lt hiuihii<t t}}it|L? uLh }i?ih@|?} ihhLht | M*|? i?_L}i?i|)
54
zkhuh [| @ +N| > V| > Q| ,/ ]| @ +[| > \| ,/ dqg lv d 6 7 pdwul{ ri hvwlpdwhg sdudphwhuv1 E|
frqvwuxfwlrq/ wkh odvw htxdolw| vd|v wkdw wkh glvwxuedqfh yhfwru | lv ruwkrjrqdo wr ]c|32 / exw lv
fruuhodwhg zlwk [| 12e Jlyhq wkh uhodwlrqvkls ehwzhhq | dqg %| sursrvhg lq htxdwlrq +48,/ wklv
kdv wzr pdlq lpsolfdwlrqv= +l, wkh frpsrqhqw +gc| . 7c| . c| , lq htxdwlrq +48, lqwurgxfhv dq
hqgrjhqhlw| sureohp ehfdxvh lw phdqv wkdw fruu+[| > %| , 9@ 3> dqg +ll, fruu+]|32 > %| , @ 3/ wkdw lv/
wkh vhfrqg odjv ri wkh h{sodqdwru| dqg ghshqghqw yduldeohv uhsuhvhqw jrrg lqvwuxphqwv lq rughu
wr hvwlpdwh vshflfdwlrq +47,12D Rq wkh rwkhu kdqg/ wkh frxqwu|~vshflf dyhudjhv gc / 7c dqg
c lq h{suhvvlrq +48,/ zlwk ac @ +4@W ,
SA
|'
ac| / lqfrusrudwh {hg hhfwv1 Wkxv rxu glvwxuedqfh
whup/ %| > lv frpsulvhg ri erwk hqgrjhqhlw| dqg {hg hhfw frpsrqhqwv1 Reylrxvo|/ wkh odujhu
duh wkh sdudphwhuv dqg lq devroxwh ydoxh/ wkh odujhu lv wkh yduldqfh ri wkhvh frpsrqhqwv dqg/
frqvhtxhqwo|/ wkh uhodwlyh vl}h ri wkh hqgrjhqhlw| dqg {hg hhfw sureohpv exlow lqwr wkh glvwxuedqfh
whup1
Rqfh wkh glvwxuedqfh whupv duh ghqhg/ +46, dqg +47, duh xvhg wr jhqhudwh gdwd rq rxwsxw/
\ / hpsor|lqj rxu sdqho gdwd ri :6 frxqwulhv ryhu vl{ 8~|hdu~lqwhuydo shulrgv iru jlyhq ydoxhv ri
fdslwdo/ N/ xqzhljkwhg vnloohg oderu/ V7/ dqg xqvnloohg oderu/ Q71 Lq doo Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv/
wkh irxu sdudphwhuv ri wkh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrqv zhuh dozd|v vhw dv iroorzv= Df @ 4/ @ 3=35/
d @ 3=7/ e @ 3=8> wkhvh ydoxhv idoo zlwklq wkh udqjh ri frhflhqw hvwlpdwhv zh rewdlqhg iurp rxu
QOOV uhjuhvvlrqv1 Zh fkrvh wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq sdudphwhuv @ 3=6 dqg @ 3=4 wr doorz
iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| +l1h1 @ 3=5 A 3,1
Dqrwkhu lpsruwdqw frqvlghudwlrq lv wkh fkrlfh ri wkh yduldqfh iru wkh udqgrp glvwxuedqfhv1
Odujh ydoxhv iru 02| dqg 02|3 0c|3 zrxog |lhog rxwsxw vhulhv iurp vshflfdwlrqv +46~47, wkdw zhuh
doprvw sxuho| udqgrp1 E| frqwudvw/ yhu| vpdoo ydoxhv iru 02| dqg 02|3 0c|3 zrxog uhvxow lq rxwsxw
vhulhv wkdw zhuh qhduo| ghwhuplqlvwlf1 Wkh yduldqfhv iru htxdwlrqv +46~47, zhuh fkrvhq dffruglqj
wr wkh uxoh xvhg lq Nxpdu dqg Jdslqvnl +4<:7, dqg Wkxuve| +4<;3,= wkh yduldqfhv zhuh fkrvhq
wr |lhog fhuwdlq U2 ydoxhv iru wkh QOOV uhjuhvvlrqv1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ wkh uxoh xvhg wr rewdlq wkhvh
|i L?|i @h*L i Tih4i?|tc i LM|@?i_ SJooEf| c #| M dff.c ffoc ƒ SJooE~|32 c #| ƒ f32 Ai ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? |i i T*@?@|Lh) @h@M*itc ML| ? *ii*t @?_ €ht| _gihi?Uitc @?_ |i ?t|h4i?|t t
} W? T@h|U*@hc |i @ih@}i @*i @UhLtt |i _gihi?| @h@M*it UL?|@?i_ ? iU|Lht f| @?_ ~| i^@*t
2e
W?
2D
SJooEf| c ~|32 ' SJooEf|3 c ~|32 ' SJooEf| c ~|3 ' SJooEf|3 c ~|3 ' fSbc
@?_
SJooEf| 3 f|3 c ~|32 ' SJooEf| 3 f|3 c ~|3 ' fDS
55
yduldqfhv lv
02| @ ydu+orj \| ,+4 U02| ,>
02|3 0c|3 @ ydu^orj +\| @\|3 ,`+4 U20|3 0c|3 ,>
+4:,
+4;,
zkhuh U02| @ 3=<9> dqg U02|3 0c|3 @ 3=581 Wkhvh U2 ydoxhv zhuh rewdlqhg iurp QOOV uhjuhvvlrq dqg
glhuhqfhg QOOV hvwlpdwlrq/ uhvshfwlyho|1 Wkxv zh fkrvh 02| @ 3=449:9 dqg 02|3 0c|3 @ 3=3498<1
Iru hdfk ri wkh :6 frxqwulhv/ zh kdyh 9 dqqxdo revhuydwlrqv1 Krzhyhu/ jlyhq wkdw zh xvh
wkh vhfrqg odj ri wkh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq yduldeohv wr frqvwuxfw duwlfldo glvwxuedqfhv/ zh zhuh
uhvwulfwhg wr jhqhudwlqj iru hdfk wuldo ri wkh Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqw rqo| 5<5 ++9 5, :6,
revhuydwlrqv rq %| xvlqj d udqgrp qxpehu jhqhudwru1 D wrwdo ri 433 vhwv ri 5<5 %| ydoxhv zhuh
frqvwuxfwhg lq wklv idvklrq1 Xvlqj wkhvh 433 glvwxuedqfh vhwv zh exlow 433 fruuhvsrqglqj vhwv ri
duwlfldo rxwsxw gdwd +\ , xvlqj wkh dfwxdo gdwd rq fdslwdo/ vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg oderu/ dqg kroglqj
frqvwdqw rxu sdudphwhu fkrlfhv iru wkh wzr~ohyho FHV ixqfwlrq/ / / Df / / d/ e1 Iru wkh QOOV
hvwlpdwlrq hpsor|lqj wkhvh vlpxodwhg gdwd/ wkh wuxh sdudphwhu ydoxhv zhuh xvhg dv lqlwldo jxhvvhv
lq wkh krsh vxfk fkrlfhv zrxog plqlpl}h wkh qxpehu ri lwhudwlrqv uhtxluhg iru frqyhujhqfh12S
Zh shuiruphg irxu Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv1 Lq wkh uvw rqh/ zh dvvxph wkdw wkhuh lv qhlwkhu
{hg hhfw qru hqgrjhqhlw| sureohpv dqg vhw @ @ 3> wkdw lv/ wkh glvwxuedqfh whup lv frpsohwho|
ruwkrjrqdo/ zlwk yduldqfh htxdo wr 02| @ 3=449:9 dv glvfxvvhg deryh1 Wkh vhfrqg h{shulphqw
lqwurgxfhv {hg hhfwv +l1h1 @ 3> A 3,1 Lq wklv fdvh/ zh fkrrvh d ydoxh ri vr wkdw wkh
yduldqfh ri wkh glhuhqfhg huuruv lv 02|3 0c|3 @ 3=3498</ dv glvfxvvhg suhylrxvo|1 Wkh wklug dqg
irxuwk h{huflvhv xvh glvwxuedqfhv wkdw lqfrusrudwh erwk {hg hhfw dqg hqgrjhqhlw| sureohpv +l1h1
> A 3,1 Zh pdlqwdlq wkh ydoxh ri xvhg lq wkh vhfrqg h{shulphqw/ dqg wr dvvljq d qxpehu
wr zh xvh wkh idfw wkdw htxdwlrq +48, lpsolhv wkdw wkh yduldqfh ri wkh glhuhqfhg huuruv fdq eh
ghfrpsrvhg dv
02|3 0|3 @ ydu +
%| %|3 ,
+4<,
.2 ydu +^gc| gc|3 ` . ^7 ec| 7 ec|3 ` . ^ ec| ec|3 `, =
Lq wkh wklug h{shulphqw/ zh vxssrvh wkdw wkh uvw vxppdqg rq wkh uljkw kdqg vlgh ri h{suhvvlrq
2S
W? tL4i U@titc itTiU@**) | B it|4@|L?c |i @*}Lh|4 __ ?L| UL?ih}i i? |i it|4@|it Lu |i
T@h@4i|iht @ @?_ K tii4i_ |L Mi ih) U*Lti |L i|ih f Lh  W? |iti U@titc i @tt}?i_ @ @*i Lu i|ih ff Eu U*Lti
|L f Lh fbb Eu U*Lti |L  |L |i ULiUi?| |@| @t U@t?} |i ThLM*i4c @?_ it|4@|i_ |i hi4@??} T@h@4i|iht
56
+4<,/ ydu +
%| %|3 ,/ htxdov wkh vhfrqg uljkw kdqg vlgh whup1 Lq rwkhu zrugv/ wkh frqwulexwlrqv ri
wkh ruwkrjrqdo frpsrqhqw dqg wkh hqgrjhqrxv frpsrqhqw wr wkh yduldqfh ri wkh glhuhqfhg huuruv
duh dvvxphg wr eh htxdo1 Lq wkh irxuwk h{shulphqw/ zh dpsoli| wkh lpsruwdqfh ri wkh hqgrjhqhlw|
sureohp/ dqg dvvxph wkdw rqo| 58( ri wkh yduldqfh lq wkh glhuhqfh huuruv frphv iurp wkh ruwkrjr0
qdo frpsrqhqw/ l1h1 ydu +
%| %|3 , @ +4@7,02|3 0|3 / zkloh wkh hqgrjhqrxv frpsrqhqw frqwulexwhv
wkh uhpdlqlqj :8( ri wkh yduldqfh1 Lq hdfk h{shulphqw/ zh dsso| wkh wkuhh hvwlpdwlrq whfkqltxhv
xvhg suhylrxvo|= +l, QOOV rq ohyhov +5<5 revhuydwlrqv,> +ll, QOOV rq wkh uvw~glhuhqfhg vshfl0
fdwlrq/ zklfk fruuhfwv iru {hg hhfwv +54< revhuydwlrqv,> dqg +lll, JPP rq wkh uvw~glhuhqfhg
vshflfdwlrq hpsor|lqj ; lqvwuxphqwv/ wkh w5 dqg w6 gdwhg odjv ri \ / N/ V7/ dqg Q7 dv zdv rxu
sudfwlfh xvlqj wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwru +54< revhuydwlrqv,1 Wkh uhvxowv duh uhsruwhg lq Sdqhov D~F
ri Wdeoh 51 Hdfk sdqho uhihuv wr d glhuhqw hvwlpdwlrq whfkqltxh dqg uhsruwv wkh uhvxowv iurp ds0
so|lqj wkdw whfkqltxh wr wkh irxu glhuhqw huuru vfhqdulrv1 Wkxv zh fdq vhh krz wkh shuirupdqfh ri
wkh hvwlpdwru hyroyhv dv zh fkdqjh wkh huuru vwuxfwxuh1 Lq hdfk fdvh/ wkh wdeoh surylghv wkh vdpsoh
phdq/ vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq dqg eldv ri wkh hvwlpdwhv ri dqg 1 Wkh odvw froxpq ri Wdeoh 5 uhsruwv
wkh urrw phdq vtxduhg huuru +UPVH, wr idflolwdwh frpsdulvrqv dfurvv wkh glhuhqw hvwlpdwruv12.
Dv vkrzq lq Sdqho D/ zkhq huuruv duh ruwkrjrqdo wkh vdpsoh phdq QOOV hvwlpdwhv ri dqg duh uhodwlyho| forvh wr wkhlu wuxh ydoxhv +3=6 dqg 3=4 uhvshfwlyho|, dqg kdyh vpdoo eldvhv +5=8( dqg
6=7(/ uhvshfwlyho|,1 Krzhyhu/ wkh hvwlpdwhv duh lpsuhflvh1 Wklv lv hvshfldoo| wuxh iru hvwlpdwhv ri
wkh sdudphwhu zklfk kdg d vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq ri 3=595</ pruh wkdq wzlfh wkh phdq hvwlpdwh1
Zkhq wkh huuru lqfrusrudwhv {hg hhfwv/ wkh suhflvlrq ri wkh hvwlpdwhv ulvhv ehfdxvh wkh vwrfkdvwlf
sduw wkdw ydulhv iurp vdpsoh wr vdpsoh lv h{foxvlyho| gxh wr wkh ruwkrjrqdo frpsrqhqw wkdw kdv d
orzhu zhljkw zkhq rwkhu frpsrqhqwv duh lqfoxghg1 Lqghhg/ lq wkh vhfrqg urz ri Sdqho D zh vhh
wkdw wkh glvshuvlrq phdvxuhv ri wkh hvwlpdwhv ri dqg idoo wr 3=3475 dqg 3=358;/ uhvshfwlyho|1
Qrwlfh/ krzhyhu/ wkdw wkh {hg hhfw sureohp fdxvhv dq lpsruwdqw eldv wkdw dprxqwv wr 3=383<
+l1h1/ 4:(, iru dqg 3=:543 +deryh :33(, iru 1 Wkh elj ghwhulrudwlrq lq wkh hvwlpdwlrq ri zkhq
{hg hhfwv duh lqwurgxfhg lv fohdu li zh orrn dw wkh UPVH> lwv ydoxh pruh wkdq wulsohv1 Wkh
wklug dqg irxuwk urzv ri Sdqho D suhvhqw wkh uhvxowv zkhq wkh huuru whup lv frpsrvhg ri erwk
{hg hhfw dqg hqgrjhqhlw| frpsrqhqwv1 Wkh suhflvlrq lqfuhdvhv zlwk wkh frqwulexwlrq ri wkh
hqgrjhqhlw| frpsrqhqw iru wkh uhdvrqv jlyhq deryh1 Lq dgglwlrq/ wkh vlpxowdqhlw| sureohp lqgxfhv
dq xszdug eldv wkdw/ dorqj zlwk wkh suhflvlrq ri wkh hvwlpdwhv/ lqfuhdvhv zlwk wkh frqwulexwlrq
2. +5,
t _i€?i_ @t |i t^@hi_ hLL| Lu |i t4 Lu |i @h@?Ui @?_ |i t^@hi_ M@t
57
Wdeoh 5= Prqwh Fduor H{shulphqwv
Sdqho D= QOOV
Huuruv
Ruwkrjrqdo
Zlwk {hg hhfwv +IH,
Zlwk IH dqg hqgrjhqhlw|
+83( 83( frqwulexwlrq,
Zlwk IH dqg hqgrjhqhlw|
+58( :8( frqwulexwlrq,
Sdudphwhu
Phdq
3163:9
313<99
3157<4
31;543
315966
31;686
315988
31;765
Vw1 Ghy1
313<;8
31595<
313475
31358;
31343;
313585
3133:4
31349<
Eldv
3133:9
0313367
031383<
31:543
031369:
31:686
0313678
31:765
UPVH
313<<3
31595<
31385<
31:548
3136;:
31:68:
313679
31:767
Eldv
314484
313493
31334;
031338:
3144<5
31739<
314846
317:3<
UPVH
3178<8
317:95
314343
3156;8
3146<9
3175:7
3148;7
317;38
Eldv
3195:<
31773<
316:9:
31579;
313558
31384:
031336;
0314<:<
UPVH
41469<
41336<
31;:89
31:466
315485
31:<65
315395
31::<;
Sdqho E= QOOV zlwk IH
Huuruv
Ruwkrjrqdo
Zlwk {hg hhfwv +IH,
Zlwk IH dqg hqgrjhqhlw|
+83( 83( frqwulexwlrq,
Zlwk IH dqg hqgrjhqhlw|
+58( :8( frqwulexwlrq,
Sdudphwhu
Phdq
317484
314493
31634;
313<76
3174<5
31839<
317846
318:3<
Vw1 Ghy1
31777<
317:8<
314344
3156;8
313:5;
31463:
3137:9
313<8:
Sdqho F= JPP~LY zlwk IH +; lqvwuxphqwv,
Huuruv
Ruwkrjrqdo
Zlwk {hg hhfwv +IH,
Zlwk IH dqg hqgrjhqhlw|
+83( 83( frqwulexwlrq,
Zlwk IH dqg hqgrjhqhlw|
+58( :8( frqwulexwlrq,
Sdudphwhu
Phdq
31<5:<
31873<
319:9:
31679;
316558
31484:
315<95
0313<:<
Vw1 Ghy1
31<7:;
31<353
31:<38
3199<6
31546<
31:<47
315394
31:876
L|itG W? |i L?|i @h*L i Tih4i?|t i ti |i |L*ii* ,5 tTiU€U@|L?  | UL4T*i|i_
Th4@h)< E5e @t |i |hitL*_ uLh t!**i_ *@MLh @?_ 4 ' fc w ' f
58
ri wkh hqgrjhqhlw| frpsrqhqw1 Dv d frqvhtxhqfh/ wkh phdq QOOV hvwlpdwh ri jhwv forvhu wr
lwv srsxodwlrq ydoxh/ zkhuhdv wkh phdq QOOV hvwlpdwh iru ulvhv ixuwkhu deryh lwv wuxh ydoxh1
Frqvhtxhqwo|/ rqh zrxog eh ohg wr frqfoxgh djdlqvw wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv/
dv ? / dqg wkh hvwlpdwhv dsshdu wr eh txlwh suhflvh1 Ryhudoo/ Sdqho D vxjjhvwv wkdw lq vpdoo
vdpsohv QOOV hvwlpdwlrq gholyhuv frqvlvwhqw hvwlpdwhv rqo| zkhq huuruv duh frpsohwho| ruwkrjrqdo1
Pruhryhu/ lq doo fdvhv/ wkh glvshuvlrq lv uhodwlyho| kljk/ wkxv pdnlqj wkh hvwlpdwhv idluo| lpsuhflvh
hvshfldoo| iru wkh sdudphwhu 12H
Sdqho E suhvhqwv wkh uhvxowv ri shuiruplqj QOOV hvwlpdwlrq rq wkh uvw~glhuhqfh vshflfdwlrq1
Wkh xvh ri wklv vshflfdwlrq uhvxowv lq wzr fkdqjhv zlwk uhvshfw wr wkh suhylrxv hvwlpdwlrq phwkrg1
Iluvw/ e| glhuhqflqj wkh gdwd zh orvh dqrwkhu :6 revhuydwlrqv/ zklfk ixuwkhu zhdnhqv wkh hvwlpdwlrq
suhflvlrq1 Vhfrqg/ wkh uvw~glhuhqfh prgho lqgxfhv vhuldo fruuhodwlrq dprqj frqvhfxwlyh huuruv
ehfdxvh wkh glvwxuedqfhv qrz iroorz d PD+4, surfhvv/ %|3 %c|3 1 Wkhvh wzr dgghg ihdwxuhv duh
suredeo| uhvsrqvleoh iru wkh zruvh rxwfrph zh revhuyh zkhq huuruv duh ruwkrjrqdo1 Lq sduwlfxodu/
frpsdulqj wkh uvw urz ri Sdqho E wr wkh uvw urz ri Sdqho D/ zh revhuyh pxfk pruh lpsuhflvh
dqg eldvhg hvwlpdwhv lq wkh iruphu sdqho/ vkrzlqj d UPVH wkdw lv 7=9 dqg 4=; odujhu iru dqg
/ uhvshfwlyho|1 Krzhyhu/ zkhq zh hvwlpdwh xvlqj duwlfldo vdpsohv wkdw lqfrusrudwh {hg hhfwv/
wkh ehqhw iurp xvlqj wkh uvw~glhuhqfh hvwlpdwru ehfrphv hylghqw1 Wkh vhfrqg urz ri Sdqho E
vkrzv wkdw fruuhfwlqj iru {hg hhfw sureohpv surylghv phdq QOOV hvwlpdwhv wkdw duh txlwh forvh wr
wkhlu srsxodwlrq ydoxhv zlwk d eldv ri 3=9( dqg 8=:(/ uhvshfwlyho|1 Vlplodu wr wkh QOOV hvwlpdwhv
lq Sdqho D/ suhflvlrq lv orz/ zlwk d uhodwlyho| odujh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq iru hvwlpdwhv ri 1 Wkh
lqwurgxfwlrq ri hqgrjhqhlw| sureohpv jhqhudwhv dq xszdug eldv lq wkh hvwlpdwhv dqg/ dv lq Sdqho
D/ lv dovr dvvrfldwhg zlwk d vpdoo lpsuryhphqw lq suhflvlrq1 Erwk wkh eldv dqg wkh lpsuryhphqw lq
suhflvlrq lqfuhdvh dv wkh hqgrjhqhlw| frpsrqhqw ehfrphv juhdwhu/ fdxvlqj wkh ryhudoo shuirupdqfh
ri wkh uvw~glhuhqfh hvwlpdwru wr zruvhq1 Iru h{dpsoh/ zkhq wkh hqgrjhqhlw| frpsrqhqw dffrxqwv
iru :8( ri wkh glhuhqfhg~huuru yduldqfh/ wkh UPVHv iru dqg duh pruh wkdq 83( deryh wkh
ydoxhv rewdlqhg zkhq wkh huuru whup lv frpsrvhg ri rqo| {hg hhfw dqg ruwkrjrqdo frpsrqhqwv1
Wkh frqfoxvlrq iurp Sdqho E lv wkdw/ lq vpdoo vdpsohv/ QOOV hvwlpdwlrq ri wkh uvw~glhuhqfh
prgho gholyhuv frqvlvwhqw hvwlpdwhv rqo| zkhq huuruv lqfrusrudwh erwk {hg hhfw dqg ruwkrjrqdo
2H `i
@*tL TihuLh4i_ @ L?|i @h*L i Tih4i?| uLh ww5 it|4@|L? t?} eH LMtih@|L?tc @t i @_ ? |i
ThiLt tiU|L? Ai t|@?_@h_ _i@|L?t Lu |i it|4@|it ihi *Lih E@t i TiU|i_c M| t|** tMt|@?|@* 6Lh
i @4T*ic ? |i Lh|L}L?@* U@tic |i t|@?_@h_ _i@|L?t i^@* ffSHH uLh 4 @?_ fHbf uLh w
59
frpsrqhqwv1 Lq doo fdvhv/ hvwlpdwlrq lv idluo| lpsuhflvh/ hvshfldoo| iru wkh sdudphwhu 12b
Hvwlpdwhv iurp dsso|lqj JPP wr wkh uvw~glhuhqfh prgho duh suhvhqwhg lq Sdqho F1 Wkh
uvw vwulnlqj uhvxow lv wkdw glvshuvlrq ulvhv hqruprxvo|1 Iru h{dpsoh/ lq wkh fdvh ri ruwkrjrqdo
huuruv/ wkh hvwlpdwhv iru dqg kdyh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrqv ri 3=<7:; dqg 3=<353/ uhvshfwlyho|/ dqg
d vxevwdqwldo eldv ri 3=95:< +533(, iru dqg 3=773< +deryh 733(, iru 1 Erwk wkh glvshuvlrq
dqg wkh eldv ghfolqh dv zhljkw lv jlyhq wr {hg hhfw dqg hqgrjhqhlw| frpsrqhqwv1 Dv lq Sdqhov
D dqg E/ wkh glvshuvlrq ghfuhdvhv zlwk wkh ghfolqh lq wkh yduldqfh ri wkh ruwkrjrqdo sduw1 Wkh
eldv/ lq wxuq/ ghfolqhv dv zhoo/ dv JPP dsshduv wr eh zrunlqj wr fruuhfw +dw ohdvw sduwldoo|, wkh
vlpxowdqhlw| sureohp1 Wkh lpsuryhphqw lv hylghqw dv zh jr grzq wkh urzv ri Sdqho F1 Wkh eldv
ri wkh phdq sdudphwhu hvwlpdwh ri ghfolqhv wr 3=336; +4=59(, zkhq hqgrjhqhlw| h{sodlqv :8(
ri wkh glhuhqfhg~huuru yduldqfh/ zkhuhdv iru hvwlpdwhv ri wkh eldv rewdlqv lwv plqlpxp ydoxh
ri 3=384: +84=:(, zkhq vlpxowdqhlw| h{sodlqv 83( ri wkh glhuhqfhg~huuru yduldqfh1 Qrwlfh wkdw
wkhvh ydoxhv duh wkh plqlpxp eldvhv irxqg dfurvv doo wkuhh hvwlpdwlrq whfkqltxhv zkhq hqgrjhqhlw|
lv suhvhqw1 Krzhyhu/ wdnlqj lqwr dffrxqw wkh odujh glvshuvlrq gholyhuhg e| JPP/ lwv shuirupdqfh
pxvw vwloo eh uhjdughg dv wkh zruvw ri wkuhh hvwlpdwruv1 Wklv fdvh fdq eh pdgh e| frpsdulqj wkh
ydoxhv ri wkh UPVH dfurvv wkh wkuhh sdqhov= h{fhsw lq wkh {hg~hhfw~huuru fdvh iru wkh sdudphwhu
/ JPP hvwlpdwlrq |lhogv wkh kljkhvw UPVH ydoxhv ryhu doo h{shulphqwv1f
Vxppdul}lqj wklv vhfwlrq/ rxu Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqwv vxjjhvw wkdw QOOV hvwlpdwlrq ri wkh
wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq +zlwk dqg zlwkrxw fruuhfwlqj iru {hg hhfwv, surylghv idluo| frqvlvwhqw
hvwlpdwhv ri wkh hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq sdudphwhuv/ dqg / zkhq lw vkrxog1 JPP hvwlpdwlrq/
rq wkh rwkhu kdqg/ rewdlqv kljko| frqvlvwhqw hvwlpdwhv rqo| iru zkhq lw vkrxog1 Krzhyhu/ doo
whfkqltxhv surylgh lpsuhflvh hvwlpdwhv1 Wkh sureohp vhhpv wr eh hvshfldoo| vhulrxv iru hvwlpdwhv
ri wkh sdudphwhu / zklfk duh vxevwdqwldoo| xszdug eldvhg lq wkh suhvhqfh ri erwk {hg hhfwv
dqg hqgrjhqhlw| sureohpv1 Lqghhg/ li {hg hhfwv dqg hqgrjhqhlw| sureohpv lq wkh gdwd zhuh ri
wkh vdph irup dqg lqflghqfh dv wkrvh irxqg lq rxu Prqwh Fduor vwxg|/ wkh eldvhg hvwlpdwhv ri pljkw ohdg xv wr huurqhrxvo| uhmhfw wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv ri qr fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|1 Zh
frqfoxgh wkdw vpdoo~vdpsoh hvwlpdwhv xvlqj QOOV~ohyho/ QOOV~IH/ dqg JPP~LY ri wkh hodvwlflw|
2b L?|i @h*L i Tih4i?| uLh ww5 it|4@|L? L? €ht|_gihi?Ui_ _@|@ t?} SD LMtih@|L?t E|i ?4Mih
|@| i @_ ? |i ThiLt tiU|L? _i*ihi_ t|@?_@h_ _i@|L?t i^@* |L ff.f uLh 4 @?_ fDe uLh w ? |i Mit|
tUi?@hL Eic | ihhLht UL4TLti_ Lu t| € i_igiU| @?_ Lh|L}L?@*|) UL4TL?i?|t
f Ai TLLh TihuLh4@?Ui Lu |i B it|4@|Lh ? |i t4@** t@4T*i t3i Lu Lh i Tih4i?|t t UL?tt|i?| |
€?_?}t uhL4 tiih@* L|ih hiUi?| t|_it |@| tii! |L _i?|u) |i T@h@4i|iht Lu ThL_U|L? u?U|L?t t?} t4@**
4UhL*ii* T@?i* _@|@ ti|tc @t thi)i_ ? Bh*Uit @?_ @hitti EbbH
5:
ri vxevwlwxwlrq sdudphwhuv lq wkh wzr~ohyho FHV vshflfdwlrq vkrxog eh wdnhq zlwk fdxwlrq jlyhq
wkdw wkhlu uholdelolw| dsshduv wr eh uhodwlyho| orz1
.
L?U*tL?t
Wkh dlp ri wklv sdshu lv wr h{dplqh wkh furvv~frxqwu| hylghqfh iru fdslwdo~vnloohg oderu frpsohphq0
wdulw| xvlqj djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq ixqfwlrq vshflfdwlrqv dqg d wlph~vhulhv/ furvv~vhfwlrq sdqho ri
frxqwulhv1 Lq sduwlfxodu/ zh dgguhvv wkuhh hpslulfdo txhvwlrqv1 Iluvw/ zkdw lv wkh ehvw vshflfdwlrq
ri wkh djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq whfkqrorj| iru sxusrvhv ri h{dplqlqj wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw|
k|srwkhvlvB Vhfrqg/ krz gr zh ghqh vnloohg oderu1 Ilqdoo|/ lv wkhuh dq| furvv~frxqwu| hylghqfh lq
vxssruw ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlvB Zlwk uhjdug wr wkh uvw lvvxh zh dujxh
wkdw vshflfdwlrq +4, lv suhihuuhg wr vshflfdwlrq +5,1 Ixuwkhupruh/ zlwklq vshflfdwlrq +4, zh qg
wkdw zh fdq uhmhfw wkh uhvwulfwhg/ FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG vshflfdwlrq lq idyru ri wkh pruh jhqhudo
wzr~ohyho FHV irup1 Vhfrqg/ xqolnh rwkhu hpslulfdo vwxglhv/ zh frqvlghu yh glhuhqw phwkrgv ri
fodvvli|lqj vnloohg oderu dv wkh dssursuldwh wkuhvkrog iru glylglqj zrunhuv lqwr vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg
fodvvhv lq d furvv~frxqwu| vwxg| lv qrw dw doo fohdu1 Ilqdoo|/ dqg shukdsv prvw lpsruwdqwo|/ zh qg
vrph hylghqfh lq vxssruw ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv1 Wkh fdvh iru fdslwdo~vnloo
frpsohphqwdulw| fdq eh pdgh xvlqj rxu QOOV hvwlpdwhv ri wkh uvw glhuhqfhg prgho/ zklfk wdnhv
dffrxqw ri frxqwu| vshflf {hg hhfwv1 Xvlqj wkrvh hvwlpdwhv/ dv uhsruwhg lq Wdeoh 4/ hylghqfh
iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| rewdlqv zkhq wkh wkuhvkrog iru ghqlqj d vnloohg zrunhu lv yhu|
orz/ h1j1 zrunhuv zkr kdyh dwwdlqhg vrph sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq/ ru zkr kdyh frpsohwhg sulpdu| ru
dwwdlqhg vrph vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq1 Wkhvh wkuhvkrogv duh doo orzhu wkdq wkh frpsohwhg vhfrqgdu|/
ru srvw~vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq wkuhvkrog iru vnloohg oderu wkdw lv pruh w|slfdoo| hqfrxqwhuhg lq wkh
olwhudwxuh1
Vwloo/ zh xujh fdxwlrq lq wdnlqj wkhvh QOOV hvwlpdwhv iru wkh glhuhqfhg prgho wrr vhulrxvo|1
Iluvw/ zh irxqg wkdw zkhq wkh gdwd zlwklq wkh vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg fodvvlfdwlrqv iru oderu duh
dgmxvwhg iru uhwxuqv wr vfkrrolqj/ wkh QOOV~IH hvwlpdwhv vxssruwlqj fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdu0
lw| fhdvh wr eh vwdwlvwlfdoo| vljqlfdqw/ dv vkrzq lq Wdeoh D71 Vhfrqg/ rxu QOOV uvw~glhuhqfh
hvwlpdwru iduhv srruo| lq rxu Prqwh Fduor vwxg| zkhq erwk {hg hhfw dqg hqgrjhqhlw| sureohpv
duh suhvhqw1 Ilqdoo|/ dqg prvw lpsruwdqwo|/ rxu suhihuuhg hvwlpdwlrq whfkqltxh/ wkh JPP~LY uvw
glhuhqfh hvwlpdwru zklfk dgguhvvhv wkh hqgrjhqhlw| sureohp/ |lhogv eldvhg hvwlpdwhv/ hvshfldoo|
5;
iru zklfk pljkw huurqhrxvo| ohdg wr xv wr uhmhfw wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv ri qr fdslwdo~vnloo frpsoh0
phqwdulw|1 Dqrwkhu sureohp zlwk wkh JPP~LY hvwlpdwru lv wkh odujh vwdqgdug huuruv dvvrfldwhg
zlwk wkh hvwlpdwhv1
Zh frqfoxgh wkdw wkhuh lv vrph hylghqfh lq vxssruw ri wkh fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|0
srwkhvlv dw wkh djjuhjdwh surgxfwlrq ohyho/ krzhyhu wkh hylghqfh lv qrw yhu| vwurqj1 Vhwwlqj dvlgh
wkh gdwd dqg hvwlpdwlrq sureohpv/ dq lqwuljxlqj dowhuqdwlyh h{sodqdwlrq iru rxu zhdn hylghqfh lv
wkdw wkh h{whqw ri fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| +ru vxevwlwxwdelolw|, ydulhv zlwk d frxqwu|*v vwdjh ri
ghyhorsphqw dqg lv wkhuhiruh vxemhfw wr fkdqjh ryhu wlph/ dv Jroglq dqg Ndw} +4<<;, kdyh frqylqf0
lqjo| dujxhg1 Li wklv k|srwkhvlv lv wuxh/ wkhq/ frqvlvwhqw zlwk rxu qglqjv/ hylghqfh lq vxssruw ri wkh
fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| k|srwkhvlv vkrxog eh hvshfldoo| glfxow wr rewdlq xvlqj d wlph~vhulhv/
furvv~vhfwlrq sdqho ri frxqwulhv1 Ilqdoo|/ rxu qglqjv kdyh lpsolfdwlrqv iru wkh ghedwh frqfhuqlqj
wkh vrxufh ri ulvlqj zdjh dqg lqfrph lqhtxdolw| dfurvv frxqwulhv1 Vrph dxwkruv/ h1j1 Nuxvhoo hw
do1 +5333, kdyh srlqwhg wr fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| dv wkh olnho| vrxufh ri wklv skhqrphqrq1
Rxu odfn ri vwurqj hylghqfh iru fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| vxjjhvwv wkdw uhvhdufkhuv pljkw zdqw
wr frqvlghu dowhuqdwlyh/ frpsohphqwdu| h{sodqdwlrqv iru ulvlqj lqhtxdolw|/ iru h{dpsoh/ vnloo~eldvhg
whfkqlfdo fkdqjh1
5<
TTi?_ G #@|@
Wkh gdwd xvhg lq wklv sdshu +xqzhljkwhg dqg zhljkwhg, duh dydlodeoh iurp wkh dxwkruv xsrq uhtxhvw1
Lqfrph +\, ^Vrxufh= SZW~819`
Furvv~frxqwu| uhdo JGS shu zrunhu dqg uhdo JGS shu fdslwd duh lq frqvwdqw grooduv +4<;8 lqwhu0
qdwlrqdo sulfhv, xvlqj wkh Fkdlq lqgh{ dv ghvfulehg e| Vxpphuv dqg Khvwrq +4<<4,1 Wkhvh gdwd
duh iurp wkh Shqq Zruog Wdeohv +SZW,/ Yhuvlrq 819 dqg duh dydlodeoh rq~olqh dw=
kwws=22gdwdfhqwuh1fkdvv1xwrurqwr1fd2szw2lqgh{1kwpo1
Sk|vlfdo fdslwdo vwrfnv +N, ^Vrxufh= SZW~819`
Sk|vlfdo fdslwdo lv frqvwuxfwhg xvlqj wkh shushwxdo lqyhqwru| dssurdfk zlwk lqyhvwphqw vkduhv
gdwd rewdlqhg iurp SZW~8191 Lq sduwlfxodu/ wkh sk|vlfdo fdslwdo vwrfn lv fdofxodwhg e| vxpplqj
lqyhvwphqw iurp lwv hduolhvw dydlodeoh |hdu +4<93 ru hduolhu, wr 4<<3 zlwk wkh dqqxdo ghsuhfldwlrq
udwh {hg dw 9 shufhqw1 Wkh lqlwldo sk|vlfdo fdslwdo vwrfn lv ghwhuplqhg e| wkh lqlwldo lqyhvwphqw
udwh/ glylghg e| wkh ghsuhfldwlrq udwh soxv wkh jurzwk udwh ri lqyhvwphqw gxulqj wkh vxevhtxhqw whq
|hduv1 Vhh Gx| dqg Sdsdjhrujlrx +5333, iru ixuwkhu ghwdlov frqfhuqlqj wklv surfhgxuh1
Vnloohg dqg Xqvnloohg Oderu +V/ Q, ^Vrxufh= Eduur dqg Ohh +5334,/ dqg Ohh +5334,`
Zh frqvwuxfw yh dowhuqdwlyh sur{lhv iru vnloohg dqg xqvnloohg oderu dv wkh ghqlwlrq ri vnloohg2xqvnloohg
oderu lv duelwudu|1 Wkhvh sur{lhv duh frqvwuxfwhg xvlqj dfklhyhphqw udwh gdwd iurp Eduur dqg Ohh
+5334, dqg pxowlso|lqj wkhvh udwhv e| wkh vl}hg ri wkh wrwdo oderu irufh1 Rxu yh sur{lhv iru vnloohg
dqg xqvnloohg oderu duh dv iroorzv=
Xqzhljkwhg gdwd
41 V4 lv htxdo wr wkh qxpehu ri zrunhuv wkdw kdyh dwwdlqhg dw ohdvw vrph srvw~vhfrqgdu| hgx0
fdwlrq dqg Q4 lv htxdo wr wkh uhvw ri wkh zrunhuv lq wkh oderu irufh1
51 V5 lv htxdo wr wkh qxpehu ri zrunhuv wkdw kdyh frpsohwhg vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq/ dqg Q5 lv
htxdo wr wkh uhvw ri wkh zrunhuv lq wkh oderu irufh1
61 V6 lv htxdo wr wkh qxpehu ri zrunhuv wkdw kdyh dwwdlqhg dw ohdvw vrph vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq/
dqg Q6 lv htxdo wr wkh uhvw ri wkh zrunhuv lq wkh oderu irufh1
71 V7 lv htxdo wr wkh qxpehu ri zrunhuv wkdw kdyh frpsohwhg sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq/ dqg Q7 lv htxdo
wr wkh uhvw ri wkh zrunhuv lq wkh oderu irufh1
81 V8 lv htxdo wr wkh qxpehu ri zrunhuv wkdw kdyh dwwdlqhg dw ohdvw vrph sulpdu| hgxfdwlrq/
dqg Q8 lv htxdo wr wkh uhvw ri wkh zrunhuv lq wkh oderu irufh1
63
Zhljkwhg gdwd
Zlwklq d jlyhq vnloo fodvv vd|/ Vl ru Ql/ l @ 4/5/6/7 ru 8/ zh zhljk lqglylgxdov e| d ixqfwlrq ri
wkh ohqjwk lq |hduv ri wkhlu vfkrrolqj ohyho wlphv wkh uhwxuq wr vfkrrolqj1 Lq dgglwlrq/ wkh djjuhjdwh
ydoxh lv frqvwuxfwhg vr wkdw lw lv phdvxuhg lq whupv ri wkh hflhqf| xqlwv ri wkh orzhvw hgxfdwlrqdo
vxefdwhjru| lqfoxghg lq wkh vnloo fodvv1 Ohqjwkv ri hgxfdwlrqdo dwwdlqphqwv vxejurxsv e| frxqwu|
duh iurp Ohh +5334,1 Uhwxuqv wr vfkrrolqj e| qdwlrq duh wdnhq iurp Elov dqg Nohqrz +5333,/ dqg
zhuh rewdlqhg iroorzlqj wkh Plqfhuldq dssurdfk zklfk dvvxphv wkdw orj~zdjhv duh olqhdu lq |hduv
ri vfkrrolqj1
Dq h{dpsoh= Ohw oc eh wkh ohqjwk lq |hduv ri hgxfdwlrqdo ohyho m lq frxqwu| l/ Oc wkh qxpehu
ri zrunhuv zlwk wklv vfkrrolqj ohyho/ dqg ! lv wkh Plqfhuldq uhwxuq lq frxqwu| l1 Iru qdwlrq l/ V5
dqg Q5 duh frpsxwhg dv iroorzv=
V5+l, @ OcSr . h{s +! ocrRr , OcrRr . h{s +! ocSRr , OcSRr >
Q5+l, @ OcR . h{s +! oc@R , Oc@R . h{s +! ocSR , OcSR . h{s ^! +ocSR . ocrr ,` Ocrr >
zkhuh xs/ ds/ fs/ vv/ fv/ vsv dqg fsv ghqrwh xqhgxfdwhg srsxodwlrq/ dwwdlqhg sulpdu|/ frp0
sohwhg sulpdu|/ vrph vhfrqgdu|/ frpsohwhg vhfrqgdu|/ vrph srvw~vhfrqgdu| dqg frpsohwhg srvw~
vhfrqgdu| hgxfdwlrq/ uhvshfwlyho|1
Wkh Eduur dqg Ohh +5334, gdwdvhw lv dydlodeoh rq~olqh dw= kwws=22zzz51flg1kduydug1hgx2flggdwd1
Oderu Irufh ^Vrxufh= SZW~819`
Wkh furvv~frxqwu| gdwdvhw rq wkh oderu irufh lv fdofxodwhg iurp wkh SZW~819 vhulhv rq JGS shu
fdslwd dqg JGS shu zrunhu1 Lw uhsuhvhqwv wkh srsxodwlrq ehwzhhq wkh djhv ri 48 dqg 98 +wdnhq wr
uhsuhvhqw wkh oderu irufh,1
64
Wdeoh D4= Phdq Ydoxhv ri Xqzhljkwhg~Gdwd iurp wkh :6 Frxqwu| Vdpsoh
Frxqwu|
Frgh
Dojhuld
Dujhqwlqd
Dxvwudold
Dxvwuld
Edqjodghvk
Eud}lo
Ehojlxp
Erolyld
Fdqdgd
Fkloh
Frorpeld
Frvwd Ulfd
F|suxv
Ghqpdun
Hfxdgru
Ho Vdoydgru
Ilqodqg
Iudqfh
Jhupdq|
Jkdqd
Juhhfh
Jxdwhpdod
Kdlwl
Krqgxudv
Lfhodqg
Lqgld
Lqgrqhvld
Ludq
Ludt
Luhodqg
Lvudho
Lwdo|
Mdpdlfd
Mdsdq
Mrugdq
Nhq|d
G]D
DUJ
DXV
DXW
EJG
EUD
EHO
ERO
FDQ
FKO
FRO
FUL
F\S
GHQ
HFX
VOY
ILQ
IUD
GHX
JKD
JUF
JWP
KWL
KQG
LFH
LQG
LGQ
LUQ
LUT
LUO
LVU
LWD
MDP
MSQ
MRU
NHQ
JGS
+ploo1 XV',
7795314
48363<16
4:64:;13
:486<19
<;3;91;
73975417
<;7;<15
<5741:
63;;341<
6<64818
9;83<13
:3<71;
656613
88<541;
533;413
:;::19
7;;<:15
8:9<4<1<
9::8;716
<;461<
7<94318
476991;
7:6<19
7:6916
557814
96475416
4;3<9919
4869:716
958:919
5436418
5:79513
846:931:
83;914
43;87961<
93<71;
45;<917
Fdslwdo
+ploo1 XV',
<:<8;1;
5;838<13
85534:1<
4;;;9516
7548713
:668<714
58<87;1<
4:39417
:8;9;;1<
;84:31;
43;<6615
947919
;95814
4934951:
74<9718
684:17
4:549;19
495843<14
47776;613
:69;15
44;73<19
474;81;
5;3516
9:;915
954<1:
;5;;371<
58<58613
559<6919
:<83:17
8733;14
9676<16
47869:315
473;71;
64<<7;416
::<913
5599516
Vnloohg Ode1
+V7, +wkrxv1,
<8713
8<4416
898718
5;5818
74:;1:
<;;<1:
637419
9:616
<6;918
4;7;1<
5;7418
5<713
4;;14
54:71<
443;14
6451;
49:815
48<<;1:
566:91<
454:16
58;;18
69617
6771<
58:1;
:<13
93:6:1:
4::<51:
5<3715
9<71:
<5416
<9:1:
476<<18
7381;
87:3413
55513
478517
Xqvnloohg Ode1
+Q7, +wkrxv1,
635518
747716
:8:19
87614
535341;
63<5519
;4;17
43631:
46461:
4;4;19
839:14
76619
<718
74514
458:13
43:319
99<15
:63716
765514
647:15
43471<
48:417
537716
;3419
5<1:
4<<3941<
68<;:19
;3;818
59371:
63;19
6<71:
:7:41:
7;<16
48::516
66:16
888:14
L|itG Ai tLhUit uLh |iti _@|@ @hi `ADS @?_ @hhL @?_ wii E2ff L?|h) tTiU€U 4i@? @*it Thiti?|i_
@MLi @i Mii? hL?_i_ |L |i €ht| _iU4@* T*@Ui
65
Wdeoh D4= Phdq Ydoxhv ri Xqzhljkwhg~Gdwd iurp wkh :6 Frxqwu| Vdpsoh/ frqwlqxhg1
Frxqwu|
Frgh
Nruhd/ Uhs1
Pdodzl
Pdod|vld
Pdol
Pdxulwlxv
Ph{lfr
Pr}dpeltxh
P|dqpdu +Exupd,
Qhwkhuodqgv
Qhz ]hdodqg
Qruzd|
Sdnlvwdq
Sdqdpd
Sdudjxd|
Shux
Sklolsslqhv
Sruwxjdo
Vhqhjdo
Vlhuud Ohrqh
Vlqjdsruh
Vsdlq
Vul Odqnd
Vxgdq
Vzhghq
Vzlw}huodqg
Wdq}dqld
Wkdlodqg
Wxqlvld
Wxunh|
Xjdqgd
Xqlwhg Nlqjgrp
Xqlwhg Vwdwhv
Xuxjxd|
Yhqh}xhod
]dluh
]dpeld
]lpedezh
NRU
PZL
P\V
POL
PXV
PH[
PR]
PPU
QOG
Q]O
QRU
SDN
SDQ
SU\
SHU
SKL
SUW
VHQ
VOH
VJS
HVS
OND
VGQ
VZH
FKH
W]D
WKD
WXQ
WXU
XJD
JUE
XVD
XU\
YHQ
]DU
]PE
]ZH
JGS
+ploo1 XV',
45694<1;
5<:313
79:3<17
648913
699313
6588661;
44:;319
499:<1;
47878614
64;9:17
7796717
<3:4;13
87;913
8;771<
7657417
:774618
7749:1;
946:1:
67:41;
47<:616
58:35;14
5635413
4798;16
<<<3;18
;:;5418
;4941;
<;59:1<
4737816
4566;;18
9<8<19
896<991:
663:8571<
4578913
<8<<416
4673;1<
84<<15
;37618
Fdslwdo
+ploo1 XV',
4:645515
5;;;17
;;8;:16
4;<51:
6<<<15
7<<84;18
5::;13
4763<1:
6;784:1:
8:88:18
47:3;:13
:<97315
43<4<1;
:47916
;89<419
4483:91:
<773817
75:313
648165;14
697571;
96:5:819
45:9:1:
5343:15
59495:13
5:8;4914
;8<<1;
46:99617
4:3361;
56;93716
54:41;
446568314
;76;4:<14
5684616
538:731:
9<541;
54:;<18
4;<<:18
Vnloohg Ode1
+V7, +wkrxv1,
433<814
66:16
56;71:
;<14
5431<
;:3918
79719
656313
74<914
44531;
479:19
859913
68:16
74319
56::16
434<917
4;961;
6:614
46417
7;<14
;68913
5:<713
8<<19
5<491<
57651;
439;14
:77:13
7881<
;69519
:<418
4<6:41;
<967618
93917
4:3719
4:6;15
7671<
:6716
Xqvnloohg Ode1
+Q7, +wkrxv1,
6;6714
56841<
59871<
556:14
5::19
445:714
8<6;18
4457:1<
443517
48318
6::16
4;63;16
5;515
8<416
59::15
9:841<
549518
545:18
443;16
79:1:
779816
55<618
874515
43;819
97818
:9:318
47;7517
46:51:
4396<17
7<481;
:6381:
96861:
85;17
5;3914
;;::13
477817
548:17
L|itG Ai tLhUit uLh |iti _@|@ @hi `ADS @?_ @hhL @?_ wii E2ff L?|h) tTiU€U 4i@? @*it Thiti?|i_
@MLi @i Mii? hL?_i_ |L |i €ht| _iU4@* T*@Ui
66
TTi?_ 2G ,t|4@|L? +it*|t t?} 5TiU€U@|L? E2
Lq wklv dsshqgl{ zh uhsruw hvwlpdwhv iru wkh QOOV/ QOOV zlwk IH dqg JPP~LY hvwlpdwruv dssolhg
wr vshflfdwlrq +5,1 Wkhvh hvwlpdwhv/ dv vkrzq lq Wdeoh D5/ frqwudvw vkduso| zlwk wkh frpsdudeoh
hvwlpdwhv iru vshflfdwlrq +4, dv uhsruwhg lq Wdeoh 4 lq wkh wh{w1 Lq sduwlfxodu zh qrwh wkdw zlwk
rqo| d ihz h{fhswlrqv/ wkh hvwlpdwhv ri h{fhhg xqlw|/ vr wkdw wkh Doohq hodvwlflw| ri vxevwlwxwlrq
@
ehwzhhq xqvnloohg dqg vnloohg oderu +ru fdslwdo,/ c7
@ 4@+4 ,/ lv loo~ghqhg1 Zh qrwh dovr
wkdw wkhuh lv odujh yduldwlrq lq wkh sdudphwhu hvwlpdwhv dfurvv wkh glhuhqw hvwlpdwlrq phwkrgv dqg
dfurvv wkh glhuhqw ghqlwlrqv iru vnloohg oderu1 Ilqdoo|/ zh revhuyh wkdw lq vrph fdvhv wkh vwdqgdug
huuruv duh h{wuhpho| odujh1 Ehfdxvh wkh hvwlpdwhv uhsruwhg lq Wdeoh 4 iru vshflfdwlrq +4, duh qrw
jhqhudoo| surqh wr wkhvh vdph sureohpv/ zh suhihu wkh hvwlpdwlrq uhvxowv edvhg rq vshflfdwlrq +4,1
Zh uhdfkhg wkh vdph frqfoxvlrq iru wkh uhvwulfwhg/ FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG prgho1
Wdeoh D5= Hvwlpdwhv ri dqg xvlqj Vshflfdwlrq 5
Vnloohg Oderu
Dwwdlqhg
Froohjh
Sdudphwhu
QOOV
8=5347
Ee.2Df.
3=7;455WWW
7=:535
EfS2.e
Ee.2Df.
ESS22
3=587<9WWW
Eff.eSf
5=<5::
3=7<469WWW
9=;;:;
4=4634WW
3=47<9:
3=6:;6<WWW
Vhfrqgdu|
EfeSb
3=5;;77WWW
Eff.e.b
Efeee2b
Ebe2DfHH
Ef22eDS
3=934;5WWW
Eff.De2
Ebb
4=74;8WWW
ESDDf
Vhfrqgdu|
EffDbS.
ES.f
3=68346
5=84:7
Ebe2DfHH
JPP~LY zlwk IH
5=;9:8
5=4;<6
Frpsohwhg
Dwwdlqhg
:=6:<5
QOOV zlwk IH
5=7776
Eff.2eH
E2eSS
ESDee.
4=3944WWW
EfDDSD
4=;999
ESSfS
5=958:
ED2H
3=83;57W
3=:4;;8
Ef2bHD2
Efe
3=78548W
345<;8
4=<39;
Frpsohwhg
4=5736WWW
4=99:7
Sulpdu|
3=8:5<3WWW
4=7758WWW
3=5<3<5
4=67<;
3=99:77W
4=:668
3=64:8:
3=46467
3=7;:79WW
5=<66<
4=933<
3=858<3WWW
3=7;773W
4=:656
3=36;76
5=77<8
76;
698
Dwwdlqhg
Sulpdu|
Rev1
Ef2eSH
EfSf2
EffS
Eff.2
EfHS
EffeH
Ef2e.
EfbebS
EfHS2H
Efb2.
EffH
EfbHD
EfbHD
Ef2DHS
ESfef
EeDf2
Ee.H
Ee.b
EHb2
Ef2.e2
E2fDe
54<
L|itG 5|@?_@h_ ihhLhtc ? T@hi?|ititc ihi hiULihi_ t?} t|@?_@h_ @TThL 4@|L? 4i|L_t
`|i<t i|ihLt!i_@t|U|) ULhhiU|L? @t ti_ 888c 88c 8 5}?€U@?|*) _gihi?| uhL4 f @| |i
I c DIc @?_ fI *ii*tc hitTiU|i*)
67
TTi?_ G ,t|4@|it uhL4 |i ,5it|i_?# 5TiU€U@|L?
Wdeoh D6 uhsruwv wkh hvwlpdwhv zh rewdlqhg iru yhuvlrqv ri wkh qrqolqhdu FHV~qhvwhg~lq~FG vshf0
lfdwlrq +43~44,1 Uhfdoo wkdw iru wkhvh vshflfdwlrqv/ fdslwdo~vnloo frpsohphqwdulw| rewdlqv li wkh
hvwlpdwhg ydoxh ri ? 3> hvwlpdwhv ri 3 ? 4 lpso| fdslwdo~vnloohg oderu vxevwlwxwdelolw| dqg
fdslwdo~xqvnloohg oderu frpsohphqwdulw|1 Dv Wdeoh D6 uhyhdov/ iru wkh qrqolqhdu FHV~qhvwhg~lq~
FG vshflfdwlrq/ zh gr revhuyh hvwlpdwhv ri wkdw duh srvlwlyh dqg vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp
}hur/ lpso|lqj fdslwdo~vnloohg oderu vxevwlwxwdelolw|1 Krzhyhu/ zh qrwh wkdw wkh srvlwlyh dqg kljko|
vljqlfdqw QOOV hvwlpdwhv iru duh pdlqo| revhuyhg lq vshflfdwlrqv wkdw gr qrw dffrxqw iru {hg
hhfwv ru pdnh xvh ri lqvwuxphqwv> lq wkh {hg hhfwv +uvw glhuhqfh, vshflfdwlrq zlwkrxw ru zlwk
lqvwuxphqwv +QOOV zlwk IH, dqg +JPP~LY zlwk IH,/ wkh hvwlpdwhv ri duh +zlwk rqh h{fhswlrq,
srvlwlyh dqg +djdlq zlwk rqh h{fhswlrq, qrw vljqlfdqwo| glhuhqw iurp }hur1
Wdeoh D6= FHV~Qhvwhg~lq~FG Qrqolqhdu Hvwlpdwlrq
Vnloohg Oderu
Dwwdlqhg
Sdudphwhu
Froohjh
Frpsohwhg
Vhfrqgdu|
Dwwdlqhg
Vhfrqgdu|
Frpsohwhg
Sulpdu|
Dwwdlqhg
Sulpdu|
Qr1 Rev1
QOOV
318699;WWW
+314;;<:,
3197849WWW
+31344:<,
3164;66W
+3149;::,
31:36:5WWW
+3134537,
3169;99WWW
+31469;<,
31::954WWW
+31345<7,
31;4<4<WWW
+314;5;7,
31;67<3WWW
+313478;,
31<7:85WWW
+314:777,
31;<<64WWW
+3134463,
76;
QOOV zlwk IH
3195746
+3183;:4,
3176638WWW
+3136848,
3166<<3
+31:48::,
3196;33
+31<39<8,
31:8375
+319;589,
3178986WWW
+31438;4,
31579:9WW
+3145<53,
31;5479WWW
+3135:68,
31<7:46WWW
+3134::<,
3164<<4WWW
+3143:68,
698
JPP~LY zlwk IH
313;;98
+718;6;,
3148888
+31558:8,
313;34;
+51;867,
3167896
+31543;7,
313566<
+418435,
3148776
+317;799,
031378<<
+316579:,
3136786
+31577;:,
3146:75
+;1;5:8,
316498:
+3158;<9,
54<
L|itG 5|@?_@h_ ihhLhtc ? T@hi?|ititc ihi hiULihi_ t?} t|@?_@h_ @TThL 4@|L? 4i|L_t
`|i<t i|ihLt!i_@t|U|) ULhhiU|L? @t ti_ 888c 88c 8 5}?€U@?|*) _gihi?| uhL4 f @| |i
I c DIc @?_ fI *ii*tc hitTiU|i*)
68
TTi?_ eG ,t|4@|L? +it*|t t?} |i `i}|i_w@MLh #@|@
Khuh zh uhsruw hvwlpdwhv iru wkh vshflfdwlrqv uhsruwhg lq Wdeohv 4 dqg D6 xvlqj wkh zhljkwhg
oderu gdwd dv ghvfulehg lq vhfwlrq 8171
Wdeoh D7= Wzr~Ohyho FHV Qrqolqhdu Hvwlpdwlrq +zhljkwhg~oderu gdwd,
Vnloohg Oderu
Dwwdlqhg
Sdudphwhu
QOOV
3=7:<;:WWW
QOOV zlwk IH
3=69<<<WWW
Froohjh
3=7:838
3=88954
3=337;4
3=<5954
Frpsohwhg
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
3133355
31<;:<9
3=599;<WWW
3134<57
3196;87
3=78648WWW
Vhfrqgdu|
EffH2
Ef.f
EfD.f
Efff2
4=46:66WWW
EfSb
EffbS2
EeS.
EeSeS
EffbSH2
3=;7:48WW
EfeDHb
3=;:378WWW
Dwwdlqhg
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
451436
3133836
3=69465WWW
Vhfrqgdu|
3=68956WW
3=3383<
3=398<3
Frpsohwhg
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
313364:
31<8843
3=753<9WWW
Sulpdu|
3=69337WW
3134<57
31;;<9:
3=987<5WWW
Ef.HH
3=393<5
EfS.He
3=57;;;
Dwwdlqhg
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
61793;
31395;7
3=585:4WW
Sulpdu|
3=859:8WWW
417749
3155<<3
3=<4;58WWW
3=5:736
3=7::45
OU Whvw @ s A "2 +gi @ 4,
71793<
313679;
5<7
51<4;6
313;:8;
578
Qr1 Rev1
EfeS
EffbfH
EfH2He
Ef222b
EfHf
Ef2e.2
Ef2
Efe222
Ef2..f
3=6<733
Efe2b
3144566
31:6:83
3=7<98<WWW
EffbSe
3=8957<WW
Ef2e22
Ef2e.eD
Ef22ef
3=73937WW
Ef2fSHb
Ef2bH
3=77446WWW
Efefe
Efee.
L|itG 5|@?_@h_ ihhLhtc ? T@hi?|ititc ihi hiULihi_ t?} t|@?_@h_
@TThL 4@|L? 4i|L_t `|i<t i|ihLt!i_@t|U|) ULhhiU|L? @t ti_
888c 88c 8 5}?€U@?|*) _gihi?| uhL4 f @| |i I c DIc @?_ fI *ii*tc
hitTiU|i*)
69
Wdeoh D8= FHV~Qhvwhg~lq~FG Qrqolqhdu Hvwlpdwlrq +zhljkwhg~oderu gdwd,
Vnloohg Oderu
Dwwdlqhg
Sdudphwhu
QOOV
3=783:8
Froohjh
3=:55<<WWW
Frpsohwhg
4=4344;WWW
Vhfrqgdu|
3=:;36<WWW
3=<795:WWW
EffDf
Eff.b
Dwwdlqhg
4=44474WWW
Vhfrqgdu|
3=;56:4WWW
3=:44<6WWW
Frpsohwhg
3=;<;::WWW
Sulpdu|
3=;:579WWW
3=7<9<9WWW
Dwwdlqhg
3=:4:6;WWW
3=84886WWW
Sulpdu|
EffSfSS
Efff2eS
Ef2HSf
EffSHf
Ef2HD.
Ef2SD
EffDf
Ef2D2S
EffS.
Ef2HS.
3=<::75WWW
Qr1 Rev1
5<7
QOOV zlwk IH
3=8;;98
ESb
3=76:79WWW
EffH2D
EfDeDD
3=8<;;5WWW
3=86536WW
Ef22Hf
EffS
Ef.eff
3=;4999WWW
Eff2.eb
Ef2eb
3=<<<;8WWW
578
L|itG 5|@?_@h_ ihhLhtc ? T@hi?|ititc ihi hiULihi_ t?} t|@?
_@h_ @TThL 4@|L? 4i|L_t `|i<t i|ihLt!i_@t|U|) ULhhiU|L?
@t ti_ 888c 88c 8 5}?€U@?|*) _gihi?| uhL4 f @| |i I c DIc
@?_ fI *ii*tc hitTiU|i*)
6:
+iuihi?Uit
Duhoodqr/ Pdqxho/ dqg Vwhskhq Erqg/ _Vrph Whvwv ri Vshflfdwlrq iru Sdqho Gdwd= Prqwh Fduor
Hylghqfh dqg dq Dssolfdwlrq wr Hpsor|phqw Htxdwlrqv/% Uhylhz ri Hfrqrplf Vwxglhv 8;
+Dsulo 4<<4,/ 5::~5<:1
Eduur/ Urehuw M1/ dqg Mrqj0Zkd Ohh/ _Lqwhuqdwlrqdo Gdwd rq Hgxfdwlrqdo Dwwdlqphqw= Xsgdwhv
dqg Lpsolfdwlrqv/% R{irug Hfrqrplf Sdshuv 86 +Mxo| 5334,/ 874~8961
Ehujvwu‚
rp/ Yloo|/ dqg Hsdplqrqgdv H1 Sdqdv/ _Krz Urexvw lv wkh Fdslwdo~Vnloo Frpsohphqwdulw|
K|srwkhvlvB/% Uhylhz ri Hfrqrplfv dqg Vwdwlvwlfv :7 +Dxjxvw 4<<5,/ 873~8791
Ehupdq/ Hol/ Mrkq Erxqg/ dqg Vwhskhq Pdfklq/ _Lpsolfdwlrqv ri Vnloo~Eldvhg Whfkqrorjlfdo
Fkdqjh= Lqwhuqdwlrqdo Hylghqfh/% Txduwhuo| Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv 446 +Qryhpehu 4<<;,/
4578~45:<1
Elov/ Pdun/ dqg Shwhu M1 Nohqrz/ _Grhv Vfkrrolqj Fdxvh JurzwkB/% Dphulfdq Hfrqrplf Uhylhz
<3 +Ghfhpehu 5333,/ 4493~44;61
Eoxqghoo/ Ulfkdug/ dqg Vwhskhq Erqg/ _Lqlwldo Frqglwlrqv dqg Prphqw Uhvwulfwlrqv lq G|qdplf
Sdqho Gdwd Prghov/% Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrphwulfv ;: +Qryhpehu 4<<;,/ 448~4761
Eoxqghoo/ Ulfkdug/ dqg Vwhskhq Erqg/ _JPP Hvwlpdwlrq zlwk Shuvlvwhqw Sdqho Gdwd= Dq Dssol0
fdwlrq wr Surgxfwlrq Ixqfwlrqv/% Hfrqrphwulf Uhylhzv 4<=6 +5333,/ 654~6731
Fdvhool/ Iudqfhvfr/ dqg Zloexu Mrkq Frohpdq LL/ _Wkh Zruog Whfkqrorj| Iurqwlhu/% Zrunlqj
Sdshu/ Kduydug Xqlyhuvlw| +Pd| 5335d,1
Fdvhool/ Iudqfhvfr/ dqg Zloexu Mrkq Frohpdq LL/ _Wkh X1V1 Whfkqrorj| Iurqwlhu/% Dphulfdq
Hfrqrplf Uhylhz <5 +Pd| 5335e,/ 47;~4851
Fdvhool/ Iudqfhvfr/ Jhudugr Hvtxlyho/ dqg Ihuqdqgr Ohiruw/ _Uhrshqlqj wkh Frqyhujhqfh Ghedwh=
D Qhz Orrn dw Furvv~Frxqwu| Jurzwk Hpslulfv/% Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf Jurzwk 4 +Vhswhpehu
4<<9,/ 696~6;<1
Gx|/ Mrkq/ dqg Fkulv Sdsdjhrujlrx/ _D Furvv~Frxqwu| Hpslulfdo Lqyhvwljdwlrq ri wkh Djjuhjdwh
Surgxfwlrq Ixqfwlrq Vshflfdwlrq/% Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf Jurzwk 8 +Pdufk 5333,/ ;:~4531
Idoorq/ S1U1/ dqg Ulfkdug Od|dug/ _Fdslwdo~Vnloo Frpsohphqwdulw|/ Lqfrph Glvwulexwlrq/ dqg
Rxwsxw Dffrxqwlqj/% Mrxuqdo ri Srolwlfdo Hfrqrp| ;6 +Dsulo 4<:8,/ 5:<~6351
Ioxj/ Nduqlw/ dqg ]yl Khufrzlw}/ _Htxlsphqw Lqyhvwphqw dqg wkh Uhodwlyh Ghpdqg iru Vnloohg
Oderu/% Uhylhz ri Hfrqrplf G|qdplfv 6 +Mxo| 5333,/ 794~7;81
Jroglq/ Fodxgld/ dqg Odzuhqfh I1 Ndw}/ _Wkh Ruljlqv ri Whfkqrorj|~Vnloo Frpsohphqwdulw|/%
Txduwhuo| Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv 446 +Dxjxvw 4<<;,/ 9<6~:651
Julolfkhv/ ]yl/ _Fdslwdo~Vnloo Frpsohphqwdulw|/% Uhylhz ri Hfrqrplfv dqg Vwdwlvwlfv 84 +Qryhp0
ehu 4<9<,/ 798~79;1
Julolfkhv/ ]yl/ dqg Mdftxhv Pdluhvvh/ _Surgxfwlrq Ixqfwlrqv= Wkh Vhdufk iru Lghqwlfdwlrq/% lq
Vwhlqdu Vwurp/ +Hg1, Hfrqrphwulfv dqg Hfrqrplf Wkhru| lq wkh 53wk Fhqwxu|/ Wkh Udj0
qdu Iulvfk Fhqwhqqldo V|psrvlxp/ Hfrqrphwulf Vrflhw| Prqrjudsk Qr1 64/ +Fdpeulgjh=
Fdpeulgjh Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv 4<<;,/ 49<~5361
Kdphuphvk/ Gdqlho V1/ Oderu Ghpdqg/ 5qg Hg1/ +Sulqfhwrq= Sulqfhwrq Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv/ 4<<6,1
6;
Lvodp/ Qd}uxo/ _Jurzwk Hpslulfv= D Sdqho Gdwd Dssurdfk/% Txduwhuo| Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv 443
+Qryhpehu 4<<8,/ 445:~44:31
Nohqrz/ Shwhu M1/ dqg Dqguhv Urguljxh}~Foduh/ _Wkh Qhrfodvvlfdo Uhylydo lq Jurzwk Hfrqrplfv=
Kdv Lw Jrqh Wrr IduB/% lq Ehq V1 Ehuqdqnh dqg Mxolr M1 Urwhpehuj/ +Hgv1,/ QEHU Pdfurh0
frqrplfv Dqqxdo 4<<:/ +Fdpeulgjh/ PD= PLW Suhvv/ 4<<:,/ :6~4361
Nuxvhoo/ Shu/ Ohh H1 Rkdqldq/ Mrvh~Ylfwru Ulrv~Uxoo/ dqg Jlrydqql O1 Ylrodqwh/ _Fdslwdo~Vnloo
Frpsohphqwdulw| dqg Lqhtxdolw|= D Pdfurhfrqrplf Dqdo|vlv/% Hfrqrphwulfd 9; +Vhswhpehu
5333,/ 435<~43861
Nxpdu/ W1 Nulvkqd/ dqg Mdphv K1 Jdslqvnl/ _Qrqolqhdu Hvwlpdwlrq ri wkh FHV Surgxfwlrq Sd0
udphwhuv= D Prqwh Fduor Vwxg|/% Uhylhz ri Hfrqrplfv dqg Vwdwlvwlfv 89 +Qryhpehu 4<:7,/
896~89:1
Ohh/ Mrqj~Zkd/ _Ohqjwk ri Hgxfdwlrqdo Dwwdlqphqw= D Furvv~Frxqwu| Gdwd Vhw/% Xqsxeolvkhg/
Nruhd Xqlyhuvlw| +5334,1
Uxl}~Duudq}/ Pduwd/ _Zdjh Lqhtxdolw| lq wkh X1V1= Fdslwdo~Vnloo Frpsohphqwdulw| Yv1 Vnloo~
Eldvhg Whfkqrorjlfdo Fkdqjh/% Zrunlqj Sdshu/ Kduydug Xqlyhuvlw| +Qryhpehu 5335,1
Vwrnh|/ Qdqf| O1/ _Iuhh Wudgh/ Idfwru Uhwxuqv/ dqg Idfwru Dffxpxodwlrq/% Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplf
Jurzwk 4 +Ghfhpehu 4<<9,/ 754~77:1
Vdwr/ N1/ _D Wzr~Ohyho Frqvwdqw~Hodvwlflw|~ri~Vxevwlwxwlrq Surgxfwlrq Ixqfwlrq/% Uhylhz ri
Hfrqrplf Vwxglhv 67 +Dsulo 4<9:,/ 534~54;1
Vxpphuv/ Urehuw/ dqg Dodq Khvwrq/ _Wkh Shqq Zruog Wdeoh +Pdun 8,= Dq H{sdqghg Vhw ri
Lqwhuqdwlrqdo Frpsdulvrqv/ 4<83~4<;;/% Txduwhuo| Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv 439 +Pd| 4<<4,/
65:~69;1
Wkxuve|/ Mhuu|/ _Dowhuqdwlyh FHV Hvwlpdwlrq Whfkqltxhv/% Uhylhz ri Hfrqrplfv dqg Vwdwlvwlfv
95 +Pd| 4<;3,/ 5<8~5<<1
6<