Worms in Alberta - Alberta Worm Invasion

AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
WormsinAlberta:
InvasiveSpeciesandEcosystemInteractions
TEACHERSGUIDE
Inthisseriesoflessonplans,Grade7studentswilllearnaboutinvasivespeciesand
ecosysteminteractionsbyinvestigatingearthwormsinAlbertaandcontributingtoa
citizenscienceresearchproject.TheselessonsalignwiththeAlbertaGrade7Science
ProgramofStudy,UnitA–InteractionsandEcosystems.
OverviewofLessonActivities
• IntroduceearthwormsasinvasivespeciesinAlberta
• Identifydifferentwaysofcollectinginformation(e.g.earthwormcollection,talking
toexperts,computerresearch,etc.)
• Collect,analyze,andevaluatedataaboutearthworms
• Researchtheimpact(bothpositiveandnegative)ofearthwormsonthe
environmentandtheimpactofhumansonearthworms
Duration
6Lessons(approximately8classperiodsof50minutes)
Lesson1:Introduction
Lesson2:EarthwormCollectionPreparation
Lesson3:EarthwormCollection
Lesson4:EarthwormDataAnalysis
Lesson5:EarthwormImpacts
Lesson6:ShouldEarthwormsbeBannedinAlberta?
http://www.photl.com/221692.html
Updated11-6-14
1
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
BackgroundInformation
EarthwormsarenotnativetoAlberta,ormostofCanada,afterbeingextirpated(local
extinction)bythemostrecenticeage10,000yearsago.Asaresult,Canada’sforestshave
largelyadaptedtoanenvironmentwithoutearthworms.Theshadedareasinfigure1
representwherenativeNorthAmericanspeciesarelocated.Thethicklineindicatesthe
Wisconsinanglacialmargin.
Figure1.DistributionofnativeNorthAmericanearthworms
(Hendrix,P.F.&Bohlen,P.J.(2002).ExoticearthworminvasionsinNorthAmerica:Ecologicaland
policyimplication.BioScience,52(9),801-811.)
Earthwormswerere-introducedtoCanadathroughhumanactivitiesasaresultof
colonizationandthespreadofagriculture.Theseearthwormscontinuetobeintroduced
intoCanada’sforestsbytheactivitiesofhumanssuchasdriving,inwhichearthworm
cocoonsarethoughttohitcharideinthemudattachedtovehicles,orthroughangling,
whenanglersdumpearthwormsaftertheyaredonefishing.RecentevidencebyDr.Erin
CameronattheUniversityofAlbertahasshownthatearthwormintroductionisanongoing
processratherthanasingleeventandsoearthwormspreadcontinuesintoremoteareasof
AlbertaandCanadathroughhumanaction.
Earthwormsarebrokenintothreebroadcategories.Litterdwellingearthwormshaveno
permanenthomesandonlyresideintheleaflitterlayerofforests.Theseearthwormsare
commonlysmallandhaveadeepredpigment.Soildwellingearthwormsarequitesmall
andarerarelyseenabovethesurfaceunlessduringaheavyrainfall.Theylackskin
pigmentationandasaresulttheycanappeargreyish,yellow,pinkorwhiteincolour.
Finally,deepburrowingwormsliveinpermanentburrowsinthesoil.Apileofleavesand
fecescalled‘middens’oftencoverstheburrows.Deepburrowingwormsaretypicallythe
largestoftheearthwormsandaredeeplypigmented,oftenwithapurplishcolour.
Updated11-6-14
2
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
EarthwormschangeCanada’sforestsbyreducingtheleaf-litterlayertypicallypresenton
theforestfloor.Soildwellinganddeepburrowingwormsmayactuallyeliminatethelayer
completely.ThedestructionoftheleaflitterlayercanresultinforestsbecomingCO2
emittersratherthancarbonstoragesites,thereductionofhabitatforbirdsandinsects,the
introductionofplantsdeepintoforeststhatwouldotherwisebefoundontheedgesof
forests,andtheleachingofnitrogenintowaterways.
Formorebackgroundinformation:
• Cameron,E.K.(2010).Gotbait?Howwe’vespawnedanundergroundinvasion.
ConservationMagazine,14,20-22.Retrievedfromhttp://magazine.abconservation.com/index.cfm/issue/springsummer-2010-volume-14/
• GreatLakesWormWatch:EarthwormEcologicalGroups
• OrganicGardening.com
• WormFacts
• ContainthoseCrawlers(MinnesotaDepartmentofNaturalResources)
Updated11-6-14
3
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Lesson1:Introduction
Purpose
• Identifywhatstudentsknowaboutearthworms
• IntroduceearthwormsasaninvasivespeciesinAlberta
• Considerthequestion:‘ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’
Overview
Inthislesson,studentswillfirstbeaskedwhattheyknowaboutearthworms.Oncethey
haveconsideredthis,studentswillbeintroducedtoDr.ErinCameron’sresearchproject
aboutearthworms,specificallyintroducingearthwormstothestudentsasaninvasive
speciesinAlberta.Studentswillthenbeaskedtoconsiderthequestion:‘Should
earthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’andidentifywhatthekindsofinformationtheyneedin
ordertoanswerthisquestion.
ProgramofStudiesOutcomes
OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge
1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify
relatedissuesandscientificquestions
§ describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem
4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglifesupportingenvironments
§ describeandinterpretexamplesofscientificinvestigationsthatservetoinform
environmentaldecisionmaking
AttitudeOutcomes
InterestinScience
§ Showinterestinscience-relatedquestionsandissues
Materials
• Picturesofearthwormsoractualearthworms
• KWLchart(individual)
• KWLchart(class–useposterpaperoruseanonlinetoolsuchasGoogleDocs)
• Accesstointernetandprojector
• Video-TalkingwiththeExpert:Dr.ErinCameronvideo
LessonActivities
1. Introduction(5min)
Beginbyshowingstudentsapictureofanearthworm(orifyouareable,bringinsome
earthwormsforstudentstolookat)andaskthemiftheyknowwhattheyare.If
studentsrespondwith‘worm’,askthemiftheyknowaboutanyspecifickindsofworms
(e.g.tapeworms,earthworms,roundworms,hookworms,inchworms,etc.)andwhat
kindofwormthismightbe.
Updated11-6-14
4
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
2. KWLChart–Earthworms(20min)
Onceyouorthestudentshaveidentifiedthisasanearthworm,havestudentsusethe
KWLchartstoindividuallywritedownasmanythingsastheycanaboutearthworms
undertheKcolumn(iftheyarenotsureaboutsomething,theycanplaceastarbeside
it).DothefirstonewiththestudentstodemonstratehowtheKWLchartworks(see
below).Havestudentssharetheiranswersasaclassandrecordtheirresponsesonthe
classKWLchart(ifpossible,setupasaGoogleDocforthealltheclasstosee).If
questionsaboutearthwormsariseduringthisdiscussiontheycanbeaddedtotheW
column.Additionally,studentswillbeguidedtoaddmoretotheWcolumninthenext
lesson.
Examples
ThefollowingchartindicatespossiblestudentresponsesfortheKcolumn.Question
promptsareprovidedforyoutohelpsolicitresponsesfromstudents.Thelastcolumn
includesadditionalresourcesandinformationidentifyingwhererelatedcontentis
addressedinthefollowinglessons.
PossibleStudent
QuestionPrompts
LessonLinksandAdditional
Responses
Resources
Livemostlyinorontopof
soil(canbefoundunder
rocksandtrees,nearwater)
Eatdirt,manure,smaller
things(bacteria,fungi),dead
animalorplantmaterial
Shapedlikeatube,have
segments,reddish-brownin
colour
Baitforfishing
Birdseatthem
Goodforsoil*
Wheredoearthworms
live?Haveyouseenthem
inplacesotherthanthe
ground?
Whatdoearthwormseat?
Inlesson3studentswilllearn
aboutthe3classificationsof
earthwormsandtheirhabitat.
InLesson5studentswillread
informationabouthow
earthwormsobtaintheir
nutrients.
Whatdoearthworms
InLesson3studentswilllearn
looklike?Dotheyalllook aboutthethreemaintypesof
thesame?
earthwormsandlearnthatthey
varyinsizeandcolor.Additional
informationregardingearthworm
classificationcanbefoundonthe
projectwebsite.
Whathumanactivityuses InLesson5studentswillexplore
earthworms?
theeffectsusingearthwormsfor
baitcanhaveontheenvironment.
Whatthingseat
Earthwormsarealsoeatenby
earthworms?
fish,moles,andturtlesamong
otherthings.Studentswillexplore
thisrelationshipinLesson5
Whydoyouwant
Earthwormshelptoaeratethe
earthwormsinyour
soilandcyclenutrients.However,
garden?
theycanbeharmfultosome
ecosystems.[Seelesson5]
Updated11-6-14
5
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Inthechartbelowwehavelistedpossiblestudentresponsesthatmaycontain
misconceptionsorscientificallyincorrectideas.IfstudentsstatetheseduringtheKWL,
promptthemtoclarifytheirideabyasking,“Howdoyouknowthis?”Duringthe
discussionyoumightalsoaskstudentshowconfidenttheyareintheircurrentideas
aboutearthwormsandletthemknowthattheywillhavetheopportunitytorevisitthe
KWLchartduringthefollowinglessonsandrevisetheirideasastheylearnnewthings
aboutearthworms.Youmightalsohavestudentsstarstatementswheretheclass
discussionraisesdisagreementoruncertainty.
Fortheteacher’sinformation,thechartbelowincludesadescriptionofthecorrect
scientificidea,lessonlinks,andadditionalresources.Sincethepointofthispartofthe
activityisforstudentstofreelysharetheirideasandpriorknowledgeitisbestto
addressthespecificmisconceptionsthatariseinthefollowinglessonswhere
appropriate.Formisconceptionsthatarenotdirectlyaddressedinthefollowinglessons
wehaveprovidedadditionalresourcesthatcanbeusedtoaddressthetopics.Itis
importanttobeawarethatsincethesearecommonmisconceptionsandthescienceis
notalwaysstraightforwardtoexplain,theInternetisalsofullofmisinformation
regardingthesetopics.Astheseideasareaddressedduringthefollowinglessons,have
studentswriteinthecorrectionintheLcolumnforthingstheyhavelearned.
PossibleStudent
Misconceptions
ScientificIdea
LessonLinksand
AdditionalResources
Cutinhalftheywillsurvive
Earthwormshaveaheadanda
tail.Ifyoucuttheminhalf,
sometimesoneendwill
surviveandregeneratesome
ofthemissingsegments.
Althoughsometypesofworms
canregeneratenewworms
fromboththeheadandthetail
end(dependinguponwhere
thecutoccurs),thisis
extremelyunlikelyinthe
earthwormspeciesthat
studentswillencounter.
Wormscanliveinwaterfora
fewdaysaslongasthewater
hasenoughdissolvedoxygen.
Thecurrenttheoryisthatthey
cometothesurfacebecauseit
iseasiertomoveoverland
withtheincreasedhumidity.
Thereareover3000speciesof
earthwormsaroundtheworld
Thefollowingsources
provideadditional
informationregarding
earthwormregenerationand
posethetheoretical
possibilitythatregeneration
couldresultintwoworms.
- EarthwormRegeneration
Cometothesurfacewhenit
rainssotheydon’tdrown*
Earthwormsarethesame
everywhere*
Updated11-6-14
Resources:
- ScientificAmerican
article
Resources:
• Earthwormdiversity
6
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
3. TalkingwiththeExpert:Dr.ErinCameron(20min)
Nowthatstudentsknowalittlebitmoreaboutearthworms,tellthemtheywillbe
watchingavideofeaturingsomeonewhostudiesearthworms,Dr.ErinCameron.Hand
outthe“TalkingwithanExpert”videoguide.Asstudentsarewatchingthevideohave
themwriteanswerstothequestionsontheguide.Considerstoppingthevideoasthe
differenttopicsarediscussed.Discusstheanswerswiththeclassinordertoclarify
conceptsandterminologypresentedinthevideo.
Afterviewingthevideoandcompletingthevideoguidehavestudentsfillinanything
newtheyhavelearnedaboutearthwormsundertheLintheirKWLchart.Sharesome
thoughtsasaclass.
Example
StudentsshouldhavethefollowingkeypointsaddedtotheLcolumn:
• EarthwormsinAlbertaareaninvasivespecies(i.e.nonativespeciesinAlberta)
• NativeearthwormswereeliminatedfrommostofCanadabyglaciersduringthelast
iceage.
4. Closure(5min)
Tellstudentsthatoverthenextfewdaystheywillbetryingtoanswerthefollowing
question:ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?Askstudentstospendthe
remainderofclasstalkingtoapartnerortwoaboutwhatkindsofevidencetheywould
needtocollectinordertoanswerthisquestion(thiswillgetthestudentsthinking
abouttomorrow’slesson).
AdditionalResources
NSTA-TheWonderofWorms(commonmisconceptions)
http://www.nsta.org/elementaryschool/connections/201302SmithWormMisconceptions
Table.pdf
Updated11-6-14
7
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Lesson2:EarthwormCollectionPreparation
Purpose
• Considerthequestion:‘ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’
• Identifydifferentwaystocollectinformationtoanswerthequestion
• Prepareforearthwormcollection
Overview
Studentswillbeaskedtoconsiderthequestion:‘ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’
Theywillthenidentifythekindsofinformationtheyneedinordertoanswerthisquestion.
Finally,studentswillpreparetoseeifthereareanyearthwormsintheirschoolyardasone
wayofcollectingdata(orothersiteasdeemedappropriatebytheteacher).
ProgramofStudiesOutcomes
OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge
1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify
relatedissuesandscientificquestions
§ describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem
§ identifyexamplesofhumanimpactsonecosystems,andinvestigateandanalyzethelink
betweentheseimpactsandthehumanwantsandneedsthatgiverisetothem
§ analyzepersonalandpublicdecisionsthatinvolveconsiderationofenvironmentalimpacts,
andidentifyneedsforscientificknowledgethatcaninformthosedecisions
SkillsOutcomes
InitiatingandPlanning
§ identifyscience-relatedissues
§ identifyquestionstoinvestigatearisingfrompracticalproblemsandissues
Materials
• Article–EarthwormsinAlberta(1or2copiespergroup–incolourifpossible)
• KWLchart(individual)
• KWLchart(class–setupasagoogledoc)
• Accesstointernetandprojector
• Videos
§ SitePreparation
§ FlipandStrip
§ HandSampling
§ MiddenCount
§ MustardExtraction
LessonActivities
1. Introduction(10min)
Assignstudentstogroupsof3or4(theywillworkontherestofthelessonsinthis
group)andaskeachstudenttoshareonethingtheylearnedaboutwormsinthe
previousdaysclasswiththeirgroup.Asaclassreadthearticle‘EarthwormsinAlberta’
Updated11-6-14
8
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
whichsummarizesthespreadofwormsinNorthAmericaandintroducesstudentsto
thethreetypesofearthwormstheymightseewhilecollectingearthworms.
2. ShouldEarthwormsbeBannedinAlberta?(15min)
Intheirgroups,havestudentsthinkaboutwhattheywouldneedtoknowinorderto
answerthequestion‘ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’OntheirKWLcharts,
undertheWcolumn,havestudentswritedownquestionstheywouldneedansweredin
ordertodecideifearthwormsshouldbebannedinAlberta.
Asaclass,havestudentssharetheirresponses.Inthechartbelowaresomesuggested
promptsthatcanbeusedtoguidestudentstosomeofthekeyideasthatshouldbe
included.Asyouaredoingthis,havetheclassconsiderhowtheymighttryandfindout
thatinformation(puttingthatinbracketsbesideeachquestion).Belowaresomekey
thingsthatthestudentsshouldhaveasyouwillbedoingtheseinsubsequentlessons.
W
Prompts
Whatdoyouwanttoknow?
Doearthwormscauseanydamage?(Internet Whymightsomeonewanttoban
search,talktoanexpert)
earthworms?[Helpstudents
reframetheiranswersinto
questions]
Whatarethebenefitsofearthworms?
Isthereanyreasonpeoplemight
(Internetsearch,talktoanexpert)
notwantearthwormstobe
banned?[Helpstudentsreframe
Whousesearthworms?(Internetsearchor
theiranswersintoquestions]
tryandcollectearthworms)
Whereareearthwormslocated?(internet
Areearthwormsanissue
search,tryandcollectearthworms)
everywhereinAlberta?[Help
studentsreframetheiranswersinto
questions]
Howdidearthwormsgettonewlocations?
Haveearthwormsalwaysbeen
(Internetsearchoranalysisofwhere
foundinAlberta?[Helpstudents
earthwormsarefound)
reframetheiranswersinto
questions]
3. EarthwormCollectionPreparation(10min)
AskstudentsiftheycanrememberwhatDr.Cameron’sresearchwasaboutandshare
someanswers.Next,tellthemtheyaregoingtobecollectingearthwormdatatohelp
themlearnmoreaboutearthwormsandcontributetothecitizenscienceproject
describedbyDr.Cameron.Citizenscienceisresearchthatisundertakenby
nonprofessionalscientistsorordinarycitizens.
Showstudentsthevideo–SitePreparation.Afterthevideoiscomplete,discussthe
questionsforconsiderationwiththeclass.Theseparticularquestionsfocuson
Updated11-6-14
9
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Foundation3:Skills,intheAlbertaScience7-8-9ProgramofStudies.Specifically,these
questionsbegintoaddressusingtoolsandapparatuseffectivelyandaccuratelyfor
collectingdata,andestimatingmeasurements.
SitePreparation-QuestionsforConsideration
1.
Whydoyouthinkitisimportanttosamplemorethanoneplot?
Togetanaveragenumberofwormsinthewholesamplearea.
Theplotsizeissmallandtheearthwormsmaynotbeequally
distributedinthelargerareathatwearesampling.
2. WhydoesDr.Cameronmeasuretheleaflitterinallfourcorners
oftheplot?
Again,togetanaveragefortheplot.Theleavesandother
materialmaybepiledupinonecornersoifweonlysampledin
onecornerourestimatemaybetoohighortoolowforthe
wholeplot.
4. EarthwormCollectionMethods(15+min)
Therearemultiplemethodsforearthwormcollection.Abriefsummaryofthefour
methodtypesaredescribedbelow(foradditionalinformation,clickhere).Themustard
extractionmethodisthemosteffectivemethodforcollectingalltypesofearthworms
andtheonethatwesuggestyouuse.However,theothermethodscanalsobeusedto
provideadditionaldata.Onceyouhavedecidedwhichmethod(s)youwillbeusingto
collectearthwormswiththeclass,showstudentsthecorrespondingvideo(s).Afterthe
video(s),discusswiththeclassthekeypointsandquestionsforconsideration.
MustardExtraction:collectingearthwormsthatcometothesurfaceafterpouring
mustardwaterintothesamplearea;themustardwateractsasanirritantso
earthwormsmovetothesurface.
KeyPoints
• mosteffectivewayofsamplingforearthworms
• mustardisanirritanttowormswhichiswhytheycrawltothesurface
• requiresmorepreparationaheadoftime
• bestforcollectingalltypesofearthworms
QuestionsforConsideration
1. Whywouldweonlycounttheearthwormsthatemergefromwithinour
sampleareaandnotoutsideofit?
Wemightusethesampleplottoextrapolatetoalargerarea.Theones
outsidethesampleareamaybesampledbysomeoneelse.
2. Whydoyouthinkitisimportanttowait5minuteseachtimewepour
themustardwater?
5minutesallowstheearthwormstimetocrawltothesurface.Ifwedo
notwaitenoughtimethenwemaynotbecollectingallofthe
earthwormsinthatarea.
Updated11-6-14
10
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
FlipandStrip:flippingrocks,leaves,andlogs,strippingoffbarkandjustgenerally
huntingaroundforearthworms.
KeyPoints
• simpleformofsampling
• needsomewayofidentifyingthesamplearea
• notasaccurateasothermethodsasthesampleareaislargerandthere
isagreaterpossibilityofnotcollectingalloftheearthworms
• bestforcollectinglitterdwellingandsoildwellingearthworms(you
mightsometimesfinddeepburrowingearthworms)
QuestionsforConsideration
1. Whataretheadvantagesofsamplingforearthwormsusingtheflipand
stripmethod?
Itisverysimpleandnospecialtoolsormaterialsarerequired.
2. Howisthesampleareaintheflipandstripmethoddifferentfromthe
sampleareainotherearthwormcollectionmethods(orinhowthesite
preparationvideodisplayed)?
Theothersampleareas(andtheoneshowninthesitepreparation
video)isspecifically25cmx25cm,whileinthismethodyouneedto
identifyalargerareawhichisnotasspecific.
HandSample:usingasmallspadeorshovelanddiggingthesoiloutofasamplearea
(approximately15cmdeep);thensearchingthroughtheremovedsoilforearthworms.
KeyPoints
• simpleformofsampling(althoughdiggingcanbedifficultdependingon
thesoil)
• needtogetdeepintothesoilforabettersample
• bestforcollectinglitterdwellingandsoildwellingearthworms(thedeep
burrowingearthwormscansensethevibrationsofthedigging)
QuestionsforConsideration
1. Whataretheadvantagesofhandsamplingforearthworms?
Itissimpleandonlyminimaltoolsarerequired.Thesampleplotarea
issmallandyouareabletosiftthroughallofthesoilinthatplot.
2. Whydoyouthinkitisimportanttodigatleast15cminthegroundto
obtainyoursample?
Inordertocollectasmuchoftheareawheretheearthwormsmaybe
present.
Updated11-6-14
11
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
MiddenCount:identifyingmiddens(pilesofearthwormfeces);eachmiddenholdsone
earthworm.
KeyPoints
• notdifficult,althoughyouneedtobeabletoidentifyamidden
• eachmiddenhasaburrowholeinthemiddle
• onlyoneearthwormlivesineachburrowhole
• bestforcollectingdeepburrowingearthworms(theyaretheonlykind
thatlivesintheburrows)
QuestionsforConsideration
1. Whataretheadvantagesofsamplingforearthwormsusingmiddens?
Itisverysimpleandnospecialtoolsormaterialsarerequired.
2. Whymightwenotgetanaccuratenumberofearthwormsinoursample
areaifweareonlycountingmiddens?
Weareassumingthateachmiddenhasanearthwormlivinginit,
whichcouldcauseustooverestimatethenumberofearthworms.
Thereisonlyonespeciesofearthwormthatcreatesmiddens,therefore
wemaybeunderestimatingthenumberofearthwormsintotal.
5. Closure
Remindstudentsthattheywillbeoutsideduringthenextclasstocollectearthworm
dataandtheyshoulddressappropriatelyfortheweather(e.g.ifitissupposedtorain
theyshouldbewearingwaterproofshoesandtheymaywanttobringachangeof
clothesincasetheygetwet).Ifstudentswillbeusingtheapp,askthemtodownloadthe
wormtrackerapp(whichcanbedownloadedforfreehere)totheirmobiledevice
(currentlyonlyavailableforiPadoriPhone).
Updated11-6-14
12
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Lesson3:EarthwormCollection
Purpose
• Identifydifferenttypes(adultsandjuveniles)andspeciesofearthworms
• Collectdatausingoneormoreearthwormcollectionmethods
Overview
Studentswillbeintroducedtodifferentspeciesofearthworms.Theywillthencollect
earthwormdatausingoneormoreearthwormcollectionmethods.
ProgramofStudiesOutcomes
OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge
3.Monitoralocalenvironment,andassesstheimpactsofenvironmentalfactorsongrowth,health
andreproductionoforganismsinthatenvironment
§ investigateavarietyofhabitats,anddescribeandinterpretdistributionpatternsofliving
thingsfoundinthosehabitats
4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglifesupportingenvironments
§ describeandinterpretexamplesofscientificinvestigationsthatservetoinform
environmentaldecisionmaking
§ analyzealocalenvironmentalissueorproblembasedonevidencefromavarietyofsources,
andidentifypossibleactionsandconsequences
SkillOutcomes
InitiatingandPlanning
§ selectappropriatemethodsandtoolsforcollectingdataandinformation
PerformingandRecording
§ usetoolsandapparatuseffectivelyandaccuratelyforcollectingdata
AnalyzingandInterpreting
§ classifyorganismsfoundinastudyplot
CommunicationandTeamwork
§ communicatequestions,ideas,intentions,plansandresults,usinglists,notesinpointform,
sentences,datatables,graphs,drawings,orallanguageandothermeans
AttitudeOutcomes
Collaboration
§ Workcollaborativelyincarryingoutinvestigationsandingeneratingandevaluatingideas
Safety
§ Showconcernforsafetyinplanning,carryingoutandreviewingactivities
Materials
• Powerpointpresentation–IdentifyingEarthworms
• AlbertaWormInvasion–WormTrackerApporEarthwormDataSheet(oneper
group)andcomputersthatstudentscanusetomanuallyenterthedataat
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca/app/
• UserguidefortheWormTrackerApp
• EarthwormCollectionKit(onepergroup)
§ Quadrat(forinstructionsonhowtocreatethis,clickhere)
Updated11-6-14
13
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
Magnifyingglasses
Ruler
3plasticcupsfilledhalfwaywithwaterandsealedwithalid
Mustardwater–one2Ljugpersamplesite(ifusingthemustardextraction
method)
Spadeorshovel(ifusingthehandsamplemethod)
Gloves(optional)
Tarpsorgarbagebagsforcollectionmaterials
MustardWaterPreparation(perjug)
Mix20gramsofgroundmustardpowderwith2Lofwaterinajug.Shake
well.Preparethemorningoforthenightbefore.Ifyoupreparethemixture
tooearlythemustardmayhardentothebottomofthejug.
LessonActivities
1. Introduction(10minutes)
Remindstudentsthatonewaytohelpusmakedecisions(forexample,withourfocus
question‘shouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’)istocollectsomedataorevidence.
Thedatathatstudentswillbecollectingisacountofhowmanyandwhatkindsof
earthwormsthereareinachosensite(thismaybeasitechosenonschoolgroundsor
youmaychoosetogooffschoolgroundswiththeappropriatepermission).Gothrough
withthestudentsthePowerPointpresentation–IdentifyingEarthworms.Theyshould
beabletoidentifyjuvenile,litterdwelling,soildwellinganddeepburrowing
earthworms.
2. EarthwormCollection(40+min)
Adjusttheinstructionsasnecessarydependingonthemethod(s)youchoosetouseand
thenumberofclassesyouhavetodedicatetothisactivity.Provideeachgroupwithan
EarthwormCollectionKit.Haveyourgroupscollectearthwormdatain3differentareas
(ideally,studentswouldbeabletocollectdatainmultiplehabitats–example,
schoolyard,woodedarea,andneararoadside).Studentswillusethecupstocollect
theirearthwormstemporarilywhiletheyaresamplingthesite.Oncetheyhave
completedtheirsampling.Havethemreturntheearthworms.
3. Closure(5min)
Oncetheactivityiscomplete,makesurethatstudentshavereturnedtheirearthworms,
dumpedthewaterintheplasticcups,andputallmaterialsbackinthekit.Ifthereis
extramustardwateritwillkeepforafewdaysbutwillthenneedtobeflusheddown
thesinkwithwater.
*Ifstudentsrecordedthedataonthepaperdatasheets,providethemtimetomanually
enterthedataoncomputersoncebackintheclassroom.
Updated11-6-14
14
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Lesson4:EarthwormDataAnalysis
Purpose
• Analyzedatacollectedfromearthwormcollection
Overview
Studentswillbegintoanalyzethedatatheyhavecollectedandcompareittootherdata
thathasbeencollectedacrossAlberta.Theywillthenhaveachancetodevelopideasabout
thedatathathasbeencollected.
ProgramofStudiesOutcomes
OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge
1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify
relatedissuesandscientificquestions
§ describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem
§ identifyexamplesofhumanimpactsonecosystems,andinvestigateandanalyzethelink
betweentheseimpactsandthehumanwantsandneedsthatgiverisetothem
§ analyzepersonalandpublicdecisionsthatinvolveconsiderationofenvironmentalimpacts,
andidentifyneedsforscientificknowledgethatcaninformthosedecisions
3.Monitoralocalenvironment,andassesstheimpactsofenvironmentalfactorsongrowth,health
andreproductionoforganismsinthatenvironment
§ investigateavarietyofhabitats,anddescribeandinterpretdistributionpatternsofliving
thingsfoundinthosehabitats
4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglifesupportingenvironments
§ identifyintendedandunintendedconsequencesofhumanactivitieswithinlocalandglobal
environments
§ analyzealocalenvironmentalissueorproblembasedonevidencefromavarietyofsources,
andidentifypossibleactionsandconsequences
SkillsOutcomes
InitiatingandPlanning
§ stateapredictionandahypothesisbasedonbackgroundinformationoranobserved
patternofevents
PerformingandRecording
§ estimatemeasurements
AnalyzingandInterpreting
§ compileanddisplaydata,byhandorcomputer,inavarietyofformats,includingdiagrams,
flowcharts,tables,bargraphsandlinegraphs
AttitudeOutcomes
ScientificInquiry
§ Seekandapplyevidencewhenevaluatingalternativeapproachestoinvestigations,
problemsandissues
Collaboration
§ Workcollaborativelyincarryingoutinvestigationsandingeneratingandevaluatingideas
Updated11-6-14
15
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Materials
• Computers,iPads,orsmartphoneswithGoogleEarthinstalledoneach
• AnalysisofEarthwormDataHandout
LessonActivities
1. Introduction(10+min)
IfstudentsusedapapercopyoftheEarthwormDataSheet,theywillneedtoinputthe
dataintotheweb-basedapplication.Inputtingtheirdatamaytaketime;thereforeyou
mayneedmorethanonedayforthislesson.Oncedatahasbeenuploadedeither
throughtheWormTrackerapportheweb-basedapplication,studentscandownload
themostrecentmapdatafileforGoogleEarth.
GoogleEarth
ThefollowingtutorialwillassistyouindownloadingGoogleEarth:SettingupGoogle
EarthforExploringYourData.
OnceyouhavedownloadedGoogleEarth,watchthefollowingtutorial:Viewingyour
DatainGoogleEarth.
BothvideosarealsoavailableonAlbertaWormInvasion:WormTrackerwebsite.
2. DataAnalysis(30+min)
DemonstrateforthestudentshowGoogleEarthworks(ifyouneedinstructionsonhow
todothis,seethelinksabove).Havestudentsdownloadthemapdatafromthe
followinglink(ifthisdoesnotworkyoucandownloadthe.kmlfilefromtheWorm
Trackerwebsitehere).OncethestudentshaveopenedthemapdatainGoogleEarth,
havethemworkwiththeirgrouptoanswerthequestionsontheworksheet–Analysis
ofEarthwormData.
3. Conclusion(10min)
Gothroughtheworksheetwiththestudents(alternatively,youmaychoosetousethis
worksheetasaformofassessment).
Updated11-6-14
16
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Lesson5:EarthwormImpacts
Purpose
• Researchtheimpactofearthwormsontheenvironmentandtheimpactofhumans
onearthworms
Overview
Studentswillresearchinformationabouttheimpactofearthwormsontheenvironmentor
theimpactofhumansonearthwormsandbecomean‘expert’inoneoftheseareas.They
willthenconductajigsawactivitytosharethisinformationwithothers.
ProgramofStudiesOutcomes
OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge
1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify
relatedissuesandscientificquestions
§ describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem
§ identifyexamplesofhumanimpactsonecosystems,andinvestigateandanalyzethelink
betweentheseimpactsandthehumanwantsandneedsthatgiverisetothem
§ analyzepersonalandpublicdecisionsthatinvolveconsiderationofenvironmentalimpacts,
andidentifyneedsforscientificknowledgethatcaninformthosedecisions
4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglife-supporting
environments
§ identifyintendedandunintendedconsequencesofhumanactivitieswithinlocalandglobal
environments
§ analyzealocalenvironmentalissueorproblembasedonevidencefromavarietyofsources,
andidentifypossibleactionsandconsequences
SkillsOutcomes
PerformingandRecording
§ researchinformationrelevanttoagivenproblemorissue
CommunicationandTeamwork
§ communicatequestions,ideas,intentions,plansandresults,usinglists,notesinpointform,
sentences,datatables,graphs,drawings,orallanguageandothermeans
AttitudeOutcomes
Collaboration
§ Workcollaborativelyincarryingoutinvestigationsandingeneratingandevaluatingideas
Materials
• KWLchart(individualandclass)
• ImpactsofEarthwormsHandout(canbemodifiedifnotallarticlesareused)
• Impactsarticles
§ ImpactsofEarthwormsinGardens
§ ImpactsofEarthwormsonOtherSpecies
§ ImpactsofEarthwormsonVegetation
§ ImpactsofEarthwormsonLeafLitter
§ ImpactsofEarthwormsontheNutrientCycle(optional)
§ ImpactsofEarthwormsandComposting
Updated11-6-14
17
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
§
§
ImpactsofHumansonEarthwormmigration
ImpactsofFishingonEarthwormmigration
LessonActivities
1. Introduction(5min)
Remindstudentsthatoneofthepurposesoftheearthwormcollectionactivitywasto
collectsomedatatohelpanswerthequestion,‘shouldearthwormsbebannedin
Alberta?’.UsingtheclassKWLchart,brieflyhighlightsomeofthekeypointsfromthe
dataanalysisandhavestudentsfillinthisinformationontheirKWLchartsunderL.
2. ImpactsJigsaw(35min)
OntheKWLchart,revisitwithstudentssomeoftheotherwaystocollectinformation,
specificallydoingsomecomputerresearch/talkingtoexperts.Giveeachstudentacopy
oftheImpactsofEarthwormsHandout.
a) Inordertolearnabouttheenvironmentalimpactsthatearthwormshaveandthe
impactsthathumanshaveonearthwormmigration,assigneach‘expert’groupone
oftheimpactarticles(youmayhavetoassignthesamearticletomorethanone
grouporgivemorethanonearticletoagroupdependingonhowmanygroupsyou
have).
b) Haveeachgroupreadtheirarticle(s)andsummarizethepositiveandnegative
impactsonthehandout.Computersshouldbeavailableforstudentsincasethey
wouldliketodosomemoreresearchregardingtheirassignedtopic.Studentswill
becomethe‘experts’fortheimpacttheyareassignedsoallstudentsinthegroup
willneedtobeabletobrieflysummarizetheimpactfortheirpeersinthenextpart
oftheactivity.(20min)
c) Regroupthestudentssothatthereisatleastone‘expert’fromeachimpactinthe
newgroups.Haveeach‘expert’provideabriefsummaryoftheimpact;explaining
anypositiveornegativeimpactsonotherspecies,populationsorecosystems.The
studentsshouldfillinthechartonthehandoutforeachimpactbaseduponthe
‘expert’presentation.(15min)
3. Conclusion(10min)
Oncetheyhavecompletedthejigsaw,havetheoriginal‘expert’groupscomeback
togetherandsummarizewhattheyhavelearnedabouteachoftheimpacts(some
groupsmayhavegatheredmoreorlessinformationsothisisachancetohearwhatwas
saidineachgroup).Askstudentstoconsideriftheythinkanythingshouldbedoneto
controlearthwormsinAlbertaforthenextlesson(e.g.shouldtheybebannedor
controlledinsomeotherway).
Updated11-6-14
18
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Lesson6:ShouldEarthwormsbeBannedinAlberta?
Purpose
• EvaluatewhetherearthwormsshouldbebannedinAlberta
• Presentfindingsfromresearchanddecision
Overview
Inthislesson,youwillreviewwithstudentswhattheyhavelearnedsofarabout
earthwormsanddiscusswhymakingdecisionsaboutwhetherearthwormsshouldbe
controlledinAlbertaisnotaonesidedissue.Studentswillthenevaluatetheinformation
theyhavegatheredandmakeadecisiononwhethertheythinkearthwormsshouldbe
controlledinAlberta.Theywillpresenttheirdecisionandevidencetotheclass.
ProgramofStudiesOutcomes
OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge
1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify
relatedissuesandscientificquestions
§ describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem
§ identifyexamplesofhumanimpactsonecosystems,andinvestigateandanalyzethelink
betweentheseimpactsandthehumanwantsandneedsthatgiverisetothem
§ analyzepersonalandpublicdecisionsthatinvolveconsiderationofenvironmentalimpacts,
andidentifyneedsforscientificknowledgethatcaninformthosedecisions
4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglifesupportingenvironments
§ identifyintendedandunintendedconsequencesofhumanactivitieswithinlocalandglobal
environments
§ describeandinterpretexamplesofscientificinvestigationsthatservetoinform
environmentaldecisionmaking
§ analyzealocalenvironmentalissueorproblembasedonevidencefromavarietyofsources,
andidentifypossibleactionsandconsequences
SkillsOutcomes
PerformingandRecording
§ researchinformationrelevanttoagivenproblemorissue
§ selectandintegrateinformationfromvariousprintandelectronicsourcesorfromseveral
partsofthesamesource
AnalyzingandInterpreting
§ identifystrengthsandweaknessesofdifferentmethodsofcollectinganddisplayingdata
CommunicationandTeamwork
§ communicatequestions,ideas,intentions,plansandresults,usinglists,notesinpointform,
sentences,datatables,graphs,drawings,orallanguageandothermeans
§ defendagivenpositiononanissue,basedontheirfindings
AttitudeOutcomes
InterestinScience
§ Showinterestinscience-relatedquestionsandissues,andpursuepersonalinterestsand
careerpossibilitieswithinscience-relatedfields
MutualRespect
§ Appreciatethatscientificunderstandingevolvesfromtheinteractionofideasinvolving
Updated11-6-14
19
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
peoplewithdifferentviewsandbackgrounds
ScientificInquiry
§ Seekandapplyevidencewhenevaluatingalternativeapproachestoinvestigations,
problemsandissues
Collaboration
§ Workcollaborativelyincarryingoutinvestigationsandingeneratingandevaluatingideas
Materials
• KWLcharts(individualandclass)
• Computers,mobiledevices
• Postermaterials
• AlbertaEarthwormInvasionProjectRubric
LessonActivities
1. Introduction(5min)
HavestudentstakeouttheirKWLcharts(andprojecttheclassKWLchart)andtheir
ImpactsofEarthwormsHandouts.Brieflydiscusswithstudentswhattheyhavelearned
inthepreviouslessonsabouttheimpactsofearthwormsonotherspecies,populations,
andecosystemsandtheimpactsthathumanshaveonthemigrationofearthworms.
Remindstudentsoftheoverarchingquestionfortheunit:Shouldearthwormsbe
bannedinAlberta?Tellthemthatinthislessontheywilltakeontheroleofadifferent
memberofthecommunity(e.g.fisherman,forester).Fromtheperspectiveofthat
memberofthecommunitytheywillbeaskedtocometoadecisionaboutwhetheror
notearthwormsshouldbecontrolledinAlbertaandifso,how?Controllingearthworms
couldincludeacompleteorpartialbanonthesaleofearthworms,effortstoeliminate
earthwormsalreadypresentinAlberta,and/oreducationalcampaignstochange
people’sbehavior.
2. ShouldEarthwormsbeBannedinAlberta?(2classes)
Forthisactivity,youshoulddecideonthedifferentrolesthatyouwillassignstudents.
Possiblerolesinclude:fisherman,forester,gardener,natureclubmember,
environmentalist.Thedifferentroleswillhavedifferentprimaryconcerns.Possible
areasofconcernforeachrolearelistedbelow.
§ Fisherman–willlikelybeconcernedwithanydecisionthatwouldaffecttheir
abilitytousewormsasbait.
§ Forester–willlikelybeconcernedwithhowthespreadofearthwormswill
impacttreespeciesinforests.
§ Gardener–willlikelybeconcernedwithanydecisionthatwouldlimit
earthwormsingardensorpurchasedforcomposebins.
§ Natureclubmember–willlikelybeconcernedwithhowthespreadof
earthwormswillimpactwildlifespecies.
§ Environmentalist–willlikelybeconcernedwithhowthespreadofearthworms
willimpactnativespeciesandchangestocarbonandnitrogencycling.
Updated11-6-14
20
AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker
http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca
Assignstudentstogroupsandassigneachgrouptotakeononeoftheroles.Intheir
groups,studentsshoulddecidewhatactionsshouldbetakenregardingearthwormsin
Albertafromtheperspectiveoftheroletheyareassigned.Theyshouldsupporttheir
decisionbasedonevidencefromthedatathathasbeencollectedonearthwormsand
whattheyhavelearnedthroughtheimpactsactivity.Studentsshoulddiscussthe
impactsoftheirdecisiononearthworms,humans,otherspecies,andtheenvironment.
Oncetheyhavemadetheirdecision,studentswilleithercreateaposterormakea
multimediapresentationtopresenttheirdecisionandtheevidencetosupporttheir
decision.Encouragestudentstosearchoutadditionalinformation(e.g.fromthe
Internet)ifneededtosupporttheirdecision.
3. Conclusion:TownHallMeeting(1class)
Havestudentspresenttheirposterormultimediapresentationtotheclass.Aseach
grouppresents,encourageotherstudentstoaskquestionsofthegroupsabouttheir
decisions.Forexample,aretheirimpactsofthedecisionthatthegrouphasn’t
considered?Afterallofthegroupshavepresented,haveeachstudentdecidewhat
approachtheythinkisbestandwriteareflectiondescribingtheirdecisionandtheir
reasonsforit.
4. Assessment
Therubriclistedinthematerialslistcanbeusedtoassessthegroupprojectsor
modified(byremovingthe“presentation”criteria)tobeusedasanindividual
assessmentforthefinalstudentreflections.
Updated11-6-14
21