AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca WormsinAlberta: InvasiveSpeciesandEcosystemInteractions TEACHERSGUIDE Inthisseriesoflessonplans,Grade7studentswilllearnaboutinvasivespeciesand ecosysteminteractionsbyinvestigatingearthwormsinAlbertaandcontributingtoa citizenscienceresearchproject.TheselessonsalignwiththeAlbertaGrade7Science ProgramofStudy,UnitA–InteractionsandEcosystems. OverviewofLessonActivities • IntroduceearthwormsasinvasivespeciesinAlberta • Identifydifferentwaysofcollectinginformation(e.g.earthwormcollection,talking toexperts,computerresearch,etc.) • Collect,analyze,andevaluatedataaboutearthworms • Researchtheimpact(bothpositiveandnegative)ofearthwormsonthe environmentandtheimpactofhumansonearthworms Duration 6Lessons(approximately8classperiodsof50minutes) Lesson1:Introduction Lesson2:EarthwormCollectionPreparation Lesson3:EarthwormCollection Lesson4:EarthwormDataAnalysis Lesson5:EarthwormImpacts Lesson6:ShouldEarthwormsbeBannedinAlberta? http://www.photl.com/221692.html Updated11-6-14 1 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca BackgroundInformation EarthwormsarenotnativetoAlberta,ormostofCanada,afterbeingextirpated(local extinction)bythemostrecenticeage10,000yearsago.Asaresult,Canada’sforestshave largelyadaptedtoanenvironmentwithoutearthworms.Theshadedareasinfigure1 representwherenativeNorthAmericanspeciesarelocated.Thethicklineindicatesthe Wisconsinanglacialmargin. Figure1.DistributionofnativeNorthAmericanearthworms (Hendrix,P.F.&Bohlen,P.J.(2002).ExoticearthworminvasionsinNorthAmerica:Ecologicaland policyimplication.BioScience,52(9),801-811.) Earthwormswerere-introducedtoCanadathroughhumanactivitiesasaresultof colonizationandthespreadofagriculture.Theseearthwormscontinuetobeintroduced intoCanada’sforestsbytheactivitiesofhumanssuchasdriving,inwhichearthworm cocoonsarethoughttohitcharideinthemudattachedtovehicles,orthroughangling, whenanglersdumpearthwormsaftertheyaredonefishing.RecentevidencebyDr.Erin CameronattheUniversityofAlbertahasshownthatearthwormintroductionisanongoing processratherthanasingleeventandsoearthwormspreadcontinuesintoremoteareasof AlbertaandCanadathroughhumanaction. Earthwormsarebrokenintothreebroadcategories.Litterdwellingearthwormshaveno permanenthomesandonlyresideintheleaflitterlayerofforests.Theseearthwormsare commonlysmallandhaveadeepredpigment.Soildwellingearthwormsarequitesmall andarerarelyseenabovethesurfaceunlessduringaheavyrainfall.Theylackskin pigmentationandasaresulttheycanappeargreyish,yellow,pinkorwhiteincolour. Finally,deepburrowingwormsliveinpermanentburrowsinthesoil.Apileofleavesand fecescalled‘middens’oftencoverstheburrows.Deepburrowingwormsaretypicallythe largestoftheearthwormsandaredeeplypigmented,oftenwithapurplishcolour. Updated11-6-14 2 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca EarthwormschangeCanada’sforestsbyreducingtheleaf-litterlayertypicallypresenton theforestfloor.Soildwellinganddeepburrowingwormsmayactuallyeliminatethelayer completely.ThedestructionoftheleaflitterlayercanresultinforestsbecomingCO2 emittersratherthancarbonstoragesites,thereductionofhabitatforbirdsandinsects,the introductionofplantsdeepintoforeststhatwouldotherwisebefoundontheedgesof forests,andtheleachingofnitrogenintowaterways. Formorebackgroundinformation: • Cameron,E.K.(2010).Gotbait?Howwe’vespawnedanundergroundinvasion. ConservationMagazine,14,20-22.Retrievedfromhttp://magazine.abconservation.com/index.cfm/issue/springsummer-2010-volume-14/ • GreatLakesWormWatch:EarthwormEcologicalGroups • OrganicGardening.com • WormFacts • ContainthoseCrawlers(MinnesotaDepartmentofNaturalResources) Updated11-6-14 3 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Lesson1:Introduction Purpose • Identifywhatstudentsknowaboutearthworms • IntroduceearthwormsasaninvasivespeciesinAlberta • Considerthequestion:‘ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’ Overview Inthislesson,studentswillfirstbeaskedwhattheyknowaboutearthworms.Oncethey haveconsideredthis,studentswillbeintroducedtoDr.ErinCameron’sresearchproject aboutearthworms,specificallyintroducingearthwormstothestudentsasaninvasive speciesinAlberta.Studentswillthenbeaskedtoconsiderthequestion:‘Should earthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’andidentifywhatthekindsofinformationtheyneedin ordertoanswerthisquestion. ProgramofStudiesOutcomes OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge 1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify relatedissuesandscientificquestions § describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem 4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglifesupportingenvironments § describeandinterpretexamplesofscientificinvestigationsthatservetoinform environmentaldecisionmaking AttitudeOutcomes InterestinScience § Showinterestinscience-relatedquestionsandissues Materials • Picturesofearthwormsoractualearthworms • KWLchart(individual) • KWLchart(class–useposterpaperoruseanonlinetoolsuchasGoogleDocs) • Accesstointernetandprojector • Video-TalkingwiththeExpert:Dr.ErinCameronvideo LessonActivities 1. Introduction(5min) Beginbyshowingstudentsapictureofanearthworm(orifyouareable,bringinsome earthwormsforstudentstolookat)andaskthemiftheyknowwhattheyare.If studentsrespondwith‘worm’,askthemiftheyknowaboutanyspecifickindsofworms (e.g.tapeworms,earthworms,roundworms,hookworms,inchworms,etc.)andwhat kindofwormthismightbe. Updated11-6-14 4 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca 2. KWLChart–Earthworms(20min) Onceyouorthestudentshaveidentifiedthisasanearthworm,havestudentsusethe KWLchartstoindividuallywritedownasmanythingsastheycanaboutearthworms undertheKcolumn(iftheyarenotsureaboutsomething,theycanplaceastarbeside it).DothefirstonewiththestudentstodemonstratehowtheKWLchartworks(see below).Havestudentssharetheiranswersasaclassandrecordtheirresponsesonthe classKWLchart(ifpossible,setupasaGoogleDocforthealltheclasstosee).If questionsaboutearthwormsariseduringthisdiscussiontheycanbeaddedtotheW column.Additionally,studentswillbeguidedtoaddmoretotheWcolumninthenext lesson. Examples ThefollowingchartindicatespossiblestudentresponsesfortheKcolumn.Question promptsareprovidedforyoutohelpsolicitresponsesfromstudents.Thelastcolumn includesadditionalresourcesandinformationidentifyingwhererelatedcontentis addressedinthefollowinglessons. PossibleStudent QuestionPrompts LessonLinksandAdditional Responses Resources Livemostlyinorontopof soil(canbefoundunder rocksandtrees,nearwater) Eatdirt,manure,smaller things(bacteria,fungi),dead animalorplantmaterial Shapedlikeatube,have segments,reddish-brownin colour Baitforfishing Birdseatthem Goodforsoil* Wheredoearthworms live?Haveyouseenthem inplacesotherthanthe ground? Whatdoearthwormseat? Inlesson3studentswilllearn aboutthe3classificationsof earthwormsandtheirhabitat. InLesson5studentswillread informationabouthow earthwormsobtaintheir nutrients. Whatdoearthworms InLesson3studentswilllearn looklike?Dotheyalllook aboutthethreemaintypesof thesame? earthwormsandlearnthatthey varyinsizeandcolor.Additional informationregardingearthworm classificationcanbefoundonthe projectwebsite. Whathumanactivityuses InLesson5studentswillexplore earthworms? theeffectsusingearthwormsfor baitcanhaveontheenvironment. Whatthingseat Earthwormsarealsoeatenby earthworms? fish,moles,andturtlesamong otherthings.Studentswillexplore thisrelationshipinLesson5 Whydoyouwant Earthwormshelptoaeratethe earthwormsinyour soilandcyclenutrients.However, garden? theycanbeharmfultosome ecosystems.[Seelesson5] Updated11-6-14 5 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Inthechartbelowwehavelistedpossiblestudentresponsesthatmaycontain misconceptionsorscientificallyincorrectideas.IfstudentsstatetheseduringtheKWL, promptthemtoclarifytheirideabyasking,“Howdoyouknowthis?”Duringthe discussionyoumightalsoaskstudentshowconfidenttheyareintheircurrentideas aboutearthwormsandletthemknowthattheywillhavetheopportunitytorevisitthe KWLchartduringthefollowinglessonsandrevisetheirideasastheylearnnewthings aboutearthworms.Youmightalsohavestudentsstarstatementswheretheclass discussionraisesdisagreementoruncertainty. Fortheteacher’sinformation,thechartbelowincludesadescriptionofthecorrect scientificidea,lessonlinks,andadditionalresources.Sincethepointofthispartofthe activityisforstudentstofreelysharetheirideasandpriorknowledgeitisbestto addressthespecificmisconceptionsthatariseinthefollowinglessonswhere appropriate.Formisconceptionsthatarenotdirectlyaddressedinthefollowinglessons wehaveprovidedadditionalresourcesthatcanbeusedtoaddressthetopics.Itis importanttobeawarethatsincethesearecommonmisconceptionsandthescienceis notalwaysstraightforwardtoexplain,theInternetisalsofullofmisinformation regardingthesetopics.Astheseideasareaddressedduringthefollowinglessons,have studentswriteinthecorrectionintheLcolumnforthingstheyhavelearned. PossibleStudent Misconceptions ScientificIdea LessonLinksand AdditionalResources Cutinhalftheywillsurvive Earthwormshaveaheadanda tail.Ifyoucuttheminhalf, sometimesoneendwill surviveandregeneratesome ofthemissingsegments. Althoughsometypesofworms canregeneratenewworms fromboththeheadandthetail end(dependinguponwhere thecutoccurs),thisis extremelyunlikelyinthe earthwormspeciesthat studentswillencounter. Wormscanliveinwaterfora fewdaysaslongasthewater hasenoughdissolvedoxygen. Thecurrenttheoryisthatthey cometothesurfacebecauseit iseasiertomoveoverland withtheincreasedhumidity. Thereareover3000speciesof earthwormsaroundtheworld Thefollowingsources provideadditional informationregarding earthwormregenerationand posethetheoretical possibilitythatregeneration couldresultintwoworms. - EarthwormRegeneration Cometothesurfacewhenit rainssotheydon’tdrown* Earthwormsarethesame everywhere* Updated11-6-14 Resources: - ScientificAmerican article Resources: • Earthwormdiversity 6 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca 3. TalkingwiththeExpert:Dr.ErinCameron(20min) Nowthatstudentsknowalittlebitmoreaboutearthworms,tellthemtheywillbe watchingavideofeaturingsomeonewhostudiesearthworms,Dr.ErinCameron.Hand outthe“TalkingwithanExpert”videoguide.Asstudentsarewatchingthevideohave themwriteanswerstothequestionsontheguide.Considerstoppingthevideoasthe differenttopicsarediscussed.Discusstheanswerswiththeclassinordertoclarify conceptsandterminologypresentedinthevideo. Afterviewingthevideoandcompletingthevideoguidehavestudentsfillinanything newtheyhavelearnedaboutearthwormsundertheLintheirKWLchart.Sharesome thoughtsasaclass. Example StudentsshouldhavethefollowingkeypointsaddedtotheLcolumn: • EarthwormsinAlbertaareaninvasivespecies(i.e.nonativespeciesinAlberta) • NativeearthwormswereeliminatedfrommostofCanadabyglaciersduringthelast iceage. 4. Closure(5min) Tellstudentsthatoverthenextfewdaystheywillbetryingtoanswerthefollowing question:ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?Askstudentstospendthe remainderofclasstalkingtoapartnerortwoaboutwhatkindsofevidencetheywould needtocollectinordertoanswerthisquestion(thiswillgetthestudentsthinking abouttomorrow’slesson). AdditionalResources NSTA-TheWonderofWorms(commonmisconceptions) http://www.nsta.org/elementaryschool/connections/201302SmithWormMisconceptions Table.pdf Updated11-6-14 7 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Lesson2:EarthwormCollectionPreparation Purpose • Considerthequestion:‘ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’ • Identifydifferentwaystocollectinformationtoanswerthequestion • Prepareforearthwormcollection Overview Studentswillbeaskedtoconsiderthequestion:‘ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’ Theywillthenidentifythekindsofinformationtheyneedinordertoanswerthisquestion. Finally,studentswillpreparetoseeifthereareanyearthwormsintheirschoolyardasone wayofcollectingdata(orothersiteasdeemedappropriatebytheteacher). ProgramofStudiesOutcomes OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge 1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify relatedissuesandscientificquestions § describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem § identifyexamplesofhumanimpactsonecosystems,andinvestigateandanalyzethelink betweentheseimpactsandthehumanwantsandneedsthatgiverisetothem § analyzepersonalandpublicdecisionsthatinvolveconsiderationofenvironmentalimpacts, andidentifyneedsforscientificknowledgethatcaninformthosedecisions SkillsOutcomes InitiatingandPlanning § identifyscience-relatedissues § identifyquestionstoinvestigatearisingfrompracticalproblemsandissues Materials • Article–EarthwormsinAlberta(1or2copiespergroup–incolourifpossible) • KWLchart(individual) • KWLchart(class–setupasagoogledoc) • Accesstointernetandprojector • Videos § SitePreparation § FlipandStrip § HandSampling § MiddenCount § MustardExtraction LessonActivities 1. Introduction(10min) Assignstudentstogroupsof3or4(theywillworkontherestofthelessonsinthis group)andaskeachstudenttoshareonethingtheylearnedaboutwormsinthe previousdaysclasswiththeirgroup.Asaclassreadthearticle‘EarthwormsinAlberta’ Updated11-6-14 8 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca whichsummarizesthespreadofwormsinNorthAmericaandintroducesstudentsto thethreetypesofearthwormstheymightseewhilecollectingearthworms. 2. ShouldEarthwormsbeBannedinAlberta?(15min) Intheirgroups,havestudentsthinkaboutwhattheywouldneedtoknowinorderto answerthequestion‘ShouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’OntheirKWLcharts, undertheWcolumn,havestudentswritedownquestionstheywouldneedansweredin ordertodecideifearthwormsshouldbebannedinAlberta. Asaclass,havestudentssharetheirresponses.Inthechartbelowaresomesuggested promptsthatcanbeusedtoguidestudentstosomeofthekeyideasthatshouldbe included.Asyouaredoingthis,havetheclassconsiderhowtheymighttryandfindout thatinformation(puttingthatinbracketsbesideeachquestion).Belowaresomekey thingsthatthestudentsshouldhaveasyouwillbedoingtheseinsubsequentlessons. W Prompts Whatdoyouwanttoknow? Doearthwormscauseanydamage?(Internet Whymightsomeonewanttoban search,talktoanexpert) earthworms?[Helpstudents reframetheiranswersinto questions] Whatarethebenefitsofearthworms? Isthereanyreasonpeoplemight (Internetsearch,talktoanexpert) notwantearthwormstobe banned?[Helpstudentsreframe Whousesearthworms?(Internetsearchor theiranswersintoquestions] tryandcollectearthworms) Whereareearthwormslocated?(internet Areearthwormsanissue search,tryandcollectearthworms) everywhereinAlberta?[Help studentsreframetheiranswersinto questions] Howdidearthwormsgettonewlocations? Haveearthwormsalwaysbeen (Internetsearchoranalysisofwhere foundinAlberta?[Helpstudents earthwormsarefound) reframetheiranswersinto questions] 3. EarthwormCollectionPreparation(10min) AskstudentsiftheycanrememberwhatDr.Cameron’sresearchwasaboutandshare someanswers.Next,tellthemtheyaregoingtobecollectingearthwormdatatohelp themlearnmoreaboutearthwormsandcontributetothecitizenscienceproject describedbyDr.Cameron.Citizenscienceisresearchthatisundertakenby nonprofessionalscientistsorordinarycitizens. Showstudentsthevideo–SitePreparation.Afterthevideoiscomplete,discussthe questionsforconsiderationwiththeclass.Theseparticularquestionsfocuson Updated11-6-14 9 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Foundation3:Skills,intheAlbertaScience7-8-9ProgramofStudies.Specifically,these questionsbegintoaddressusingtoolsandapparatuseffectivelyandaccuratelyfor collectingdata,andestimatingmeasurements. SitePreparation-QuestionsforConsideration 1. Whydoyouthinkitisimportanttosamplemorethanoneplot? Togetanaveragenumberofwormsinthewholesamplearea. Theplotsizeissmallandtheearthwormsmaynotbeequally distributedinthelargerareathatwearesampling. 2. WhydoesDr.Cameronmeasuretheleaflitterinallfourcorners oftheplot? Again,togetanaveragefortheplot.Theleavesandother materialmaybepiledupinonecornersoifweonlysampledin onecornerourestimatemaybetoohighortoolowforthe wholeplot. 4. EarthwormCollectionMethods(15+min) Therearemultiplemethodsforearthwormcollection.Abriefsummaryofthefour methodtypesaredescribedbelow(foradditionalinformation,clickhere).Themustard extractionmethodisthemosteffectivemethodforcollectingalltypesofearthworms andtheonethatwesuggestyouuse.However,theothermethodscanalsobeusedto provideadditionaldata.Onceyouhavedecidedwhichmethod(s)youwillbeusingto collectearthwormswiththeclass,showstudentsthecorrespondingvideo(s).Afterthe video(s),discusswiththeclassthekeypointsandquestionsforconsideration. MustardExtraction:collectingearthwormsthatcometothesurfaceafterpouring mustardwaterintothesamplearea;themustardwateractsasanirritantso earthwormsmovetothesurface. KeyPoints • mosteffectivewayofsamplingforearthworms • mustardisanirritanttowormswhichiswhytheycrawltothesurface • requiresmorepreparationaheadoftime • bestforcollectingalltypesofearthworms QuestionsforConsideration 1. Whywouldweonlycounttheearthwormsthatemergefromwithinour sampleareaandnotoutsideofit? Wemightusethesampleplottoextrapolatetoalargerarea.Theones outsidethesampleareamaybesampledbysomeoneelse. 2. Whydoyouthinkitisimportanttowait5minuteseachtimewepour themustardwater? 5minutesallowstheearthwormstimetocrawltothesurface.Ifwedo notwaitenoughtimethenwemaynotbecollectingallofthe earthwormsinthatarea. Updated11-6-14 10 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca FlipandStrip:flippingrocks,leaves,andlogs,strippingoffbarkandjustgenerally huntingaroundforearthworms. KeyPoints • simpleformofsampling • needsomewayofidentifyingthesamplearea • notasaccurateasothermethodsasthesampleareaislargerandthere isagreaterpossibilityofnotcollectingalloftheearthworms • bestforcollectinglitterdwellingandsoildwellingearthworms(you mightsometimesfinddeepburrowingearthworms) QuestionsforConsideration 1. Whataretheadvantagesofsamplingforearthwormsusingtheflipand stripmethod? Itisverysimpleandnospecialtoolsormaterialsarerequired. 2. Howisthesampleareaintheflipandstripmethoddifferentfromthe sampleareainotherearthwormcollectionmethods(orinhowthesite preparationvideodisplayed)? Theothersampleareas(andtheoneshowninthesitepreparation video)isspecifically25cmx25cm,whileinthismethodyouneedto identifyalargerareawhichisnotasspecific. HandSample:usingasmallspadeorshovelanddiggingthesoiloutofasamplearea (approximately15cmdeep);thensearchingthroughtheremovedsoilforearthworms. KeyPoints • simpleformofsampling(althoughdiggingcanbedifficultdependingon thesoil) • needtogetdeepintothesoilforabettersample • bestforcollectinglitterdwellingandsoildwellingearthworms(thedeep burrowingearthwormscansensethevibrationsofthedigging) QuestionsforConsideration 1. Whataretheadvantagesofhandsamplingforearthworms? Itissimpleandonlyminimaltoolsarerequired.Thesampleplotarea issmallandyouareabletosiftthroughallofthesoilinthatplot. 2. Whydoyouthinkitisimportanttodigatleast15cminthegroundto obtainyoursample? Inordertocollectasmuchoftheareawheretheearthwormsmaybe present. Updated11-6-14 11 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca MiddenCount:identifyingmiddens(pilesofearthwormfeces);eachmiddenholdsone earthworm. KeyPoints • notdifficult,althoughyouneedtobeabletoidentifyamidden • eachmiddenhasaburrowholeinthemiddle • onlyoneearthwormlivesineachburrowhole • bestforcollectingdeepburrowingearthworms(theyaretheonlykind thatlivesintheburrows) QuestionsforConsideration 1. Whataretheadvantagesofsamplingforearthwormsusingmiddens? Itisverysimpleandnospecialtoolsormaterialsarerequired. 2. Whymightwenotgetanaccuratenumberofearthwormsinoursample areaifweareonlycountingmiddens? Weareassumingthateachmiddenhasanearthwormlivinginit, whichcouldcauseustooverestimatethenumberofearthworms. Thereisonlyonespeciesofearthwormthatcreatesmiddens,therefore wemaybeunderestimatingthenumberofearthwormsintotal. 5. Closure Remindstudentsthattheywillbeoutsideduringthenextclasstocollectearthworm dataandtheyshoulddressappropriatelyfortheweather(e.g.ifitissupposedtorain theyshouldbewearingwaterproofshoesandtheymaywanttobringachangeof clothesincasetheygetwet).Ifstudentswillbeusingtheapp,askthemtodownloadthe wormtrackerapp(whichcanbedownloadedforfreehere)totheirmobiledevice (currentlyonlyavailableforiPadoriPhone). Updated11-6-14 12 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Lesson3:EarthwormCollection Purpose • Identifydifferenttypes(adultsandjuveniles)andspeciesofearthworms • Collectdatausingoneormoreearthwormcollectionmethods Overview Studentswillbeintroducedtodifferentspeciesofearthworms.Theywillthencollect earthwormdatausingoneormoreearthwormcollectionmethods. ProgramofStudiesOutcomes OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge 3.Monitoralocalenvironment,andassesstheimpactsofenvironmentalfactorsongrowth,health andreproductionoforganismsinthatenvironment § investigateavarietyofhabitats,anddescribeandinterpretdistributionpatternsofliving thingsfoundinthosehabitats 4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglifesupportingenvironments § describeandinterpretexamplesofscientificinvestigationsthatservetoinform environmentaldecisionmaking § analyzealocalenvironmentalissueorproblembasedonevidencefromavarietyofsources, andidentifypossibleactionsandconsequences SkillOutcomes InitiatingandPlanning § selectappropriatemethodsandtoolsforcollectingdataandinformation PerformingandRecording § usetoolsandapparatuseffectivelyandaccuratelyforcollectingdata AnalyzingandInterpreting § classifyorganismsfoundinastudyplot CommunicationandTeamwork § communicatequestions,ideas,intentions,plansandresults,usinglists,notesinpointform, sentences,datatables,graphs,drawings,orallanguageandothermeans AttitudeOutcomes Collaboration § Workcollaborativelyincarryingoutinvestigationsandingeneratingandevaluatingideas Safety § Showconcernforsafetyinplanning,carryingoutandreviewingactivities Materials • Powerpointpresentation–IdentifyingEarthworms • AlbertaWormInvasion–WormTrackerApporEarthwormDataSheet(oneper group)andcomputersthatstudentscanusetomanuallyenterthedataat http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca/app/ • UserguidefortheWormTrackerApp • EarthwormCollectionKit(onepergroup) § Quadrat(forinstructionsonhowtocreatethis,clickhere) Updated11-6-14 13 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca § § § § § § § Magnifyingglasses Ruler 3plasticcupsfilledhalfwaywithwaterandsealedwithalid Mustardwater–one2Ljugpersamplesite(ifusingthemustardextraction method) Spadeorshovel(ifusingthehandsamplemethod) Gloves(optional) Tarpsorgarbagebagsforcollectionmaterials MustardWaterPreparation(perjug) Mix20gramsofgroundmustardpowderwith2Lofwaterinajug.Shake well.Preparethemorningoforthenightbefore.Ifyoupreparethemixture tooearlythemustardmayhardentothebottomofthejug. LessonActivities 1. Introduction(10minutes) Remindstudentsthatonewaytohelpusmakedecisions(forexample,withourfocus question‘shouldearthwormsbebannedinAlberta?’)istocollectsomedataorevidence. Thedatathatstudentswillbecollectingisacountofhowmanyandwhatkindsof earthwormsthereareinachosensite(thismaybeasitechosenonschoolgroundsor youmaychoosetogooffschoolgroundswiththeappropriatepermission).Gothrough withthestudentsthePowerPointpresentation–IdentifyingEarthworms.Theyshould beabletoidentifyjuvenile,litterdwelling,soildwellinganddeepburrowing earthworms. 2. EarthwormCollection(40+min) Adjusttheinstructionsasnecessarydependingonthemethod(s)youchoosetouseand thenumberofclassesyouhavetodedicatetothisactivity.Provideeachgroupwithan EarthwormCollectionKit.Haveyourgroupscollectearthwormdatain3differentareas (ideally,studentswouldbeabletocollectdatainmultiplehabitats–example, schoolyard,woodedarea,andneararoadside).Studentswillusethecupstocollect theirearthwormstemporarilywhiletheyaresamplingthesite.Oncetheyhave completedtheirsampling.Havethemreturntheearthworms. 3. Closure(5min) Oncetheactivityiscomplete,makesurethatstudentshavereturnedtheirearthworms, dumpedthewaterintheplasticcups,andputallmaterialsbackinthekit.Ifthereis extramustardwateritwillkeepforafewdaysbutwillthenneedtobeflusheddown thesinkwithwater. *Ifstudentsrecordedthedataonthepaperdatasheets,providethemtimetomanually enterthedataoncomputersoncebackintheclassroom. Updated11-6-14 14 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Lesson4:EarthwormDataAnalysis Purpose • Analyzedatacollectedfromearthwormcollection Overview Studentswillbegintoanalyzethedatatheyhavecollectedandcompareittootherdata thathasbeencollectedacrossAlberta.Theywillthenhaveachancetodevelopideasabout thedatathathasbeencollected. ProgramofStudiesOutcomes OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge 1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify relatedissuesandscientificquestions § describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem § identifyexamplesofhumanimpactsonecosystems,andinvestigateandanalyzethelink betweentheseimpactsandthehumanwantsandneedsthatgiverisetothem § analyzepersonalandpublicdecisionsthatinvolveconsiderationofenvironmentalimpacts, andidentifyneedsforscientificknowledgethatcaninformthosedecisions 3.Monitoralocalenvironment,andassesstheimpactsofenvironmentalfactorsongrowth,health andreproductionoforganismsinthatenvironment § investigateavarietyofhabitats,anddescribeandinterpretdistributionpatternsofliving thingsfoundinthosehabitats 4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglifesupportingenvironments § identifyintendedandunintendedconsequencesofhumanactivitieswithinlocalandglobal environments § analyzealocalenvironmentalissueorproblembasedonevidencefromavarietyofsources, andidentifypossibleactionsandconsequences SkillsOutcomes InitiatingandPlanning § stateapredictionandahypothesisbasedonbackgroundinformationoranobserved patternofevents PerformingandRecording § estimatemeasurements AnalyzingandInterpreting § compileanddisplaydata,byhandorcomputer,inavarietyofformats,includingdiagrams, flowcharts,tables,bargraphsandlinegraphs AttitudeOutcomes ScientificInquiry § Seekandapplyevidencewhenevaluatingalternativeapproachestoinvestigations, problemsandissues Collaboration § Workcollaborativelyincarryingoutinvestigationsandingeneratingandevaluatingideas Updated11-6-14 15 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Materials • Computers,iPads,orsmartphoneswithGoogleEarthinstalledoneach • AnalysisofEarthwormDataHandout LessonActivities 1. Introduction(10+min) IfstudentsusedapapercopyoftheEarthwormDataSheet,theywillneedtoinputthe dataintotheweb-basedapplication.Inputtingtheirdatamaytaketime;thereforeyou mayneedmorethanonedayforthislesson.Oncedatahasbeenuploadedeither throughtheWormTrackerapportheweb-basedapplication,studentscandownload themostrecentmapdatafileforGoogleEarth. GoogleEarth ThefollowingtutorialwillassistyouindownloadingGoogleEarth:SettingupGoogle EarthforExploringYourData. OnceyouhavedownloadedGoogleEarth,watchthefollowingtutorial:Viewingyour DatainGoogleEarth. BothvideosarealsoavailableonAlbertaWormInvasion:WormTrackerwebsite. 2. DataAnalysis(30+min) DemonstrateforthestudentshowGoogleEarthworks(ifyouneedinstructionsonhow todothis,seethelinksabove).Havestudentsdownloadthemapdatafromthe followinglink(ifthisdoesnotworkyoucandownloadthe.kmlfilefromtheWorm Trackerwebsitehere).OncethestudentshaveopenedthemapdatainGoogleEarth, havethemworkwiththeirgrouptoanswerthequestionsontheworksheet–Analysis ofEarthwormData. 3. Conclusion(10min) Gothroughtheworksheetwiththestudents(alternatively,youmaychoosetousethis worksheetasaformofassessment). Updated11-6-14 16 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Lesson5:EarthwormImpacts Purpose • Researchtheimpactofearthwormsontheenvironmentandtheimpactofhumans onearthworms Overview Studentswillresearchinformationabouttheimpactofearthwormsontheenvironmentor theimpactofhumansonearthwormsandbecomean‘expert’inoneoftheseareas.They willthenconductajigsawactivitytosharethisinformationwithothers. ProgramofStudiesOutcomes OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge 1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify relatedissuesandscientificquestions § describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem § identifyexamplesofhumanimpactsonecosystems,andinvestigateandanalyzethelink betweentheseimpactsandthehumanwantsandneedsthatgiverisetothem § analyzepersonalandpublicdecisionsthatinvolveconsiderationofenvironmentalimpacts, andidentifyneedsforscientificknowledgethatcaninformthosedecisions 4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglife-supporting environments § identifyintendedandunintendedconsequencesofhumanactivitieswithinlocalandglobal environments § analyzealocalenvironmentalissueorproblembasedonevidencefromavarietyofsources, andidentifypossibleactionsandconsequences SkillsOutcomes PerformingandRecording § researchinformationrelevanttoagivenproblemorissue CommunicationandTeamwork § communicatequestions,ideas,intentions,plansandresults,usinglists,notesinpointform, sentences,datatables,graphs,drawings,orallanguageandothermeans AttitudeOutcomes Collaboration § Workcollaborativelyincarryingoutinvestigationsandingeneratingandevaluatingideas Materials • KWLchart(individualandclass) • ImpactsofEarthwormsHandout(canbemodifiedifnotallarticlesareused) • Impactsarticles § ImpactsofEarthwormsinGardens § ImpactsofEarthwormsonOtherSpecies § ImpactsofEarthwormsonVegetation § ImpactsofEarthwormsonLeafLitter § ImpactsofEarthwormsontheNutrientCycle(optional) § ImpactsofEarthwormsandComposting Updated11-6-14 17 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca § § ImpactsofHumansonEarthwormmigration ImpactsofFishingonEarthwormmigration LessonActivities 1. Introduction(5min) Remindstudentsthatoneofthepurposesoftheearthwormcollectionactivitywasto collectsomedatatohelpanswerthequestion,‘shouldearthwormsbebannedin Alberta?’.UsingtheclassKWLchart,brieflyhighlightsomeofthekeypointsfromthe dataanalysisandhavestudentsfillinthisinformationontheirKWLchartsunderL. 2. ImpactsJigsaw(35min) OntheKWLchart,revisitwithstudentssomeoftheotherwaystocollectinformation, specificallydoingsomecomputerresearch/talkingtoexperts.Giveeachstudentacopy oftheImpactsofEarthwormsHandout. a) Inordertolearnabouttheenvironmentalimpactsthatearthwormshaveandthe impactsthathumanshaveonearthwormmigration,assigneach‘expert’groupone oftheimpactarticles(youmayhavetoassignthesamearticletomorethanone grouporgivemorethanonearticletoagroupdependingonhowmanygroupsyou have). b) Haveeachgroupreadtheirarticle(s)andsummarizethepositiveandnegative impactsonthehandout.Computersshouldbeavailableforstudentsincasethey wouldliketodosomemoreresearchregardingtheirassignedtopic.Studentswill becomethe‘experts’fortheimpacttheyareassignedsoallstudentsinthegroup willneedtobeabletobrieflysummarizetheimpactfortheirpeersinthenextpart oftheactivity.(20min) c) Regroupthestudentssothatthereisatleastone‘expert’fromeachimpactinthe newgroups.Haveeach‘expert’provideabriefsummaryoftheimpact;explaining anypositiveornegativeimpactsonotherspecies,populationsorecosystems.The studentsshouldfillinthechartonthehandoutforeachimpactbaseduponthe ‘expert’presentation.(15min) 3. Conclusion(10min) Oncetheyhavecompletedthejigsaw,havetheoriginal‘expert’groupscomeback togetherandsummarizewhattheyhavelearnedabouteachoftheimpacts(some groupsmayhavegatheredmoreorlessinformationsothisisachancetohearwhatwas saidineachgroup).Askstudentstoconsideriftheythinkanythingshouldbedoneto controlearthwormsinAlbertaforthenextlesson(e.g.shouldtheybebannedor controlledinsomeotherway). Updated11-6-14 18 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Lesson6:ShouldEarthwormsbeBannedinAlberta? Purpose • EvaluatewhetherearthwormsshouldbebannedinAlberta • Presentfindingsfromresearchanddecision Overview Inthislesson,youwillreviewwithstudentswhattheyhavelearnedsofarabout earthwormsanddiscusswhymakingdecisionsaboutwhetherearthwormsshouldbe controlledinAlbertaisnotaonesidedissue.Studentswillthenevaluatetheinformation theyhavegatheredandmakeadecisiononwhethertheythinkearthwormsshouldbe controlledinAlberta.Theywillpresenttheirdecisionandevidencetotheclass. ProgramofStudiesOutcomes OutcomesforScience,TechnologyandSociety(STS)andKnowledge 1.Investigateanddescriberelationshipsbetweenhumansandtheirenvironments,andidentify relatedissuesandscientificquestions § describeexamplesofinteractionandinterdependencywithinanecosystem § identifyexamplesofhumanimpactsonecosystems,andinvestigateandanalyzethelink betweentheseimpactsandthehumanwantsandneedsthatgiverisetothem § analyzepersonalandpublicdecisionsthatinvolveconsiderationofenvironmentalimpacts, andidentifyneedsforscientificknowledgethatcaninformthosedecisions 4.Describetherelationshipsamongknowledge,decisionsandactionsinmaintaininglifesupportingenvironments § identifyintendedandunintendedconsequencesofhumanactivitieswithinlocalandglobal environments § describeandinterpretexamplesofscientificinvestigationsthatservetoinform environmentaldecisionmaking § analyzealocalenvironmentalissueorproblembasedonevidencefromavarietyofsources, andidentifypossibleactionsandconsequences SkillsOutcomes PerformingandRecording § researchinformationrelevanttoagivenproblemorissue § selectandintegrateinformationfromvariousprintandelectronicsourcesorfromseveral partsofthesamesource AnalyzingandInterpreting § identifystrengthsandweaknessesofdifferentmethodsofcollectinganddisplayingdata CommunicationandTeamwork § communicatequestions,ideas,intentions,plansandresults,usinglists,notesinpointform, sentences,datatables,graphs,drawings,orallanguageandothermeans § defendagivenpositiononanissue,basedontheirfindings AttitudeOutcomes InterestinScience § Showinterestinscience-relatedquestionsandissues,andpursuepersonalinterestsand careerpossibilitieswithinscience-relatedfields MutualRespect § Appreciatethatscientificunderstandingevolvesfromtheinteractionofideasinvolving Updated11-6-14 19 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca peoplewithdifferentviewsandbackgrounds ScientificInquiry § Seekandapplyevidencewhenevaluatingalternativeapproachestoinvestigations, problemsandissues Collaboration § Workcollaborativelyincarryingoutinvestigationsandingeneratingandevaluatingideas Materials • KWLcharts(individualandclass) • Computers,mobiledevices • Postermaterials • AlbertaEarthwormInvasionProjectRubric LessonActivities 1. Introduction(5min) HavestudentstakeouttheirKWLcharts(andprojecttheclassKWLchart)andtheir ImpactsofEarthwormsHandouts.Brieflydiscusswithstudentswhattheyhavelearned inthepreviouslessonsabouttheimpactsofearthwormsonotherspecies,populations, andecosystemsandtheimpactsthathumanshaveonthemigrationofearthworms. Remindstudentsoftheoverarchingquestionfortheunit:Shouldearthwormsbe bannedinAlberta?Tellthemthatinthislessontheywilltakeontheroleofadifferent memberofthecommunity(e.g.fisherman,forester).Fromtheperspectiveofthat memberofthecommunitytheywillbeaskedtocometoadecisionaboutwhetheror notearthwormsshouldbecontrolledinAlbertaandifso,how?Controllingearthworms couldincludeacompleteorpartialbanonthesaleofearthworms,effortstoeliminate earthwormsalreadypresentinAlberta,and/oreducationalcampaignstochange people’sbehavior. 2. ShouldEarthwormsbeBannedinAlberta?(2classes) Forthisactivity,youshoulddecideonthedifferentrolesthatyouwillassignstudents. Possiblerolesinclude:fisherman,forester,gardener,natureclubmember, environmentalist.Thedifferentroleswillhavedifferentprimaryconcerns.Possible areasofconcernforeachrolearelistedbelow. § Fisherman–willlikelybeconcernedwithanydecisionthatwouldaffecttheir abilitytousewormsasbait. § Forester–willlikelybeconcernedwithhowthespreadofearthwormswill impacttreespeciesinforests. § Gardener–willlikelybeconcernedwithanydecisionthatwouldlimit earthwormsingardensorpurchasedforcomposebins. § Natureclubmember–willlikelybeconcernedwithhowthespreadof earthwormswillimpactwildlifespecies. § Environmentalist–willlikelybeconcernedwithhowthespreadofearthworms willimpactnativespeciesandchangestocarbonandnitrogencycling. Updated11-6-14 20 AlbertaWormInvasion:WormTracker http://worms.educ.ualberta.ca Assignstudentstogroupsandassigneachgrouptotakeononeoftheroles.Intheir groups,studentsshoulddecidewhatactionsshouldbetakenregardingearthwormsin Albertafromtheperspectiveoftheroletheyareassigned.Theyshouldsupporttheir decisionbasedonevidencefromthedatathathasbeencollectedonearthwormsand whattheyhavelearnedthroughtheimpactsactivity.Studentsshoulddiscussthe impactsoftheirdecisiononearthworms,humans,otherspecies,andtheenvironment. Oncetheyhavemadetheirdecision,studentswilleithercreateaposterormakea multimediapresentationtopresenttheirdecisionandtheevidencetosupporttheir decision.Encouragestudentstosearchoutadditionalinformation(e.g.fromthe Internet)ifneededtosupporttheirdecision. 3. Conclusion:TownHallMeeting(1class) Havestudentspresenttheirposterormultimediapresentationtotheclass.Aseach grouppresents,encourageotherstudentstoaskquestionsofthegroupsabouttheir decisions.Forexample,aretheirimpactsofthedecisionthatthegrouphasn’t considered?Afterallofthegroupshavepresented,haveeachstudentdecidewhat approachtheythinkisbestandwriteareflectiondescribingtheirdecisionandtheir reasonsforit. 4. Assessment Therubriclistedinthematerialslistcanbeusedtoassessthegroupprojectsor modified(byremovingthe“presentation”criteria)tobeusedasanindividual assessmentforthefinalstudentreflections. Updated11-6-14 21
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz