Downloadable Reproducible eBooks Thank you for downloading this eBook from www.socialstudies.com To browse more eBook titles, visit http://www.socialstudies.com/ebooks.html To learn more about eBooks, visit our help page at http://www.socialstudies.com/ebookshelp.html For questions, please e-mail [email protected] Free E-mail Newsletter–Sign up Today! To learn about new eBook and print titles, professional development resources, and catalogs in the mail, sign up for our monthly e-mail newsletter at http://socialstudies.com/newsletter/ DOCUMENT-BASED ACTIVITIES THE GREAT DEPRESSION AND NEW DEAL Using Primary Sources and the Internet Social Studies School Service www.socialstudies.com Document-Based Activities on the Great Depression and New Deal Using Primary Sources and the Internet Kerry Gordonson, Writer Bill Williams, Writer Dr. Aaron Willis, Project Coordinator Katie Brown, Editorial Assistant Social Studies School Service 10200 Jefferson Blvd., P.O. Box 802 Culver City, CA 90232 http://socialstudies.com [email protected] (800) 421-4246 All the Web addresses in this book can be found on our Web site: http://www.socialstudies.com/uslinks.html Updated 2005 © 2001 Social Studies School Service 10200 Jefferson Blvd., P.O. Box 802 Culver City, CA 90232 United States of America (310) 839-2436 (800) 421-4246 Fax: (800) 944-5432 Fax: (310) 839-2249 http://socialstudies.com [email protected] Cover art courtesy of the National Archives and Records Administration http://www.nara.gov/exhall/newdeal/76.gif Permission is granted to reproduce individual worksheets for classroom use only. Printed in the United States of America. ISBN 1-56004-119-6 Product Code: ZP183 iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Teacher Introduction ................................................................................................v Overview: Impact of the Great Depression ..............................................................vii LESSONS 1. Roosevelt’s Fireside Chat Teacher Page ...................................................................................................... 1 Student Worksheet ............................................................................................... 3 2. The New Deal and the Arts Teacher Page ...................................................................................................... 5 Student Worksheet ............................................................................................... 7 3. “An Emergency is On”: African Americans and the NRA Teacher Page ...................................................................................................... 9 Student Worksheet ............................................................................................... 11 4. “Sunny Cal”: The Okies Head West Teacher Page ...................................................................................................... 13 Student Worksheet ............................................................................................... 15 5. The Court-Packing Controversy Teacher Page ...................................................................................................... 17 Student Worksheet ............................................................................................... 19 Culminating Activities ............................................................................................ 23 Appendix Answer Key ......................................................................................................... 27 Rubrics ................................................................................................................ 31 Selected Documents ............................................................................................ 37 Related Web Sites ................................................................................................ 41 Suggested Curriculum Materials ........................................................................ 43 iv v DOCUMENT-BASED ACTIVITIES ON THE GREAT DEPRESSION AND THE NEW DEAL TEACHER INTRODUCTION Description: In this unit students recognize the effects of the Great Depression on America and Americans of various social, economic, and cultural walks of life. They investigate the actions of the president to deal with the situation and how individuals and groups were affected by policies. They use primary sources to develop a general concept of the New Deal and its implications for America. A “fireside chat,” a song, a painting, political cartoons, and an article from a journal provide a variety of sources for the students to analyze. Unit objectives: Knowledge: students will • understand the steps taken by President Roosevelt to combat the economic crisis • evaluate how and why changing economic conditions affected Americans • recognize the human toll of the Depression, in particular the Dust Bowl refugees Skills: • analyze, evaluate, and interpret primary source documents • communicate effectively the results of their analysis in discussion and written argument • use relevant and adequate evidence to draw conclusions Prior Knowledge Required: Students have studied the 1920s and the economic and social conditions that preceded the Great Depression. They should know the causes of the Depression and be familiar with the major components of the New Deal. Lesson Format: Each lesson consists of two parts: a teacher page containing an introduction, objectives, URL(s) used in the lesson, teaching strategies, wrap-up questions, and an extension activity; and a reproducible student page with a brief introduction which sets the context for the lesson, URL(s) used, and questions to be answered about the source. vi Assessment: Based on the time available, you may want to select which answers you want to assess in each activity. Most questions require short answers. Others will require a response of anywhere from a paragraph to a full page (or longer if preferred). Suggested rubrics are included in the Appendix. Additional Sources: The Appendix contains answer keys, evaluation rubrics, primary source documents, an annotated list of Web sites on the Great Depression and the New Deal, and supplementary materials available from www.socialstudies.com. vii OVERVIEW: IMPACT OF THE DEPRESSION “I pledge you, I pledge myself to a new deal for the American people” -Franklin D. Roosevelt, acceptance speech, Democratic National Convention, Chicago, 1932 The 1920s had been characterized by exceptional economic growth, the development of a consumer society, an expansion of the middle class, and rapid social change. However, danger signs began to emerge near the end of the decade. Too much of the economic expansion had been based on “buying on margin” in the stock market and buying on credit in the marketplace. As a result, people were creating enormous personal debt. When stock prices began to fall, brokers began calling in “margin” debts, and people responded by selling their stocks at a rapid pace. On Tuesday October 29, 1929, the stock market experienced what has come to be called “The Great Crash.” Losses exceeded $30 billion. Many people were ruined financially. This signaled the beginning of the Great Depression. Not all of the impact of the Depression was the result of business and consumer practices—weather was also a factor. The Midwest was hit by dust storms in the early 30s, then drought combined with the wind to turn these once fertile plains into what became known as the “Dust Bowl.” Farmers watched helplessly as their crops withered away, then found themselves unable to pay off their debts since they had nothing to sell. Many lost their land to foreclosure and effectively became refugees in their own country. Among the hardest hit were the farmers from Oklahoma, many of whom traveled west to California in search of work, but often found more hardship. John Steinbeck immortalized the plight of the “Okies” in his classic novel The Grapes of Wrath. When Franklin Roosevelt assumed the presidency in 1933, the United States and the rest of the western world was in a deep economic depression. He immediately began to implement the “three R’s” that would characterize the collection of programs and measures that came to be known as the New Deal: relief, recovery, and reform. In his first hundred days in office, Roosevelt pushed program after program through Congress. He closed the banks, had Congress pass the Emergency Banking Act, and established the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) and the Federal Emergency Relief viii Administration (FERA). To familiarize Americans with his plans, he initiated a series of “fireside chats” that were broadcast over the radio. These chats became one of the hallmarks of his presidency, and helped add to his already substantial nationwide popularity. In 1933 Congress passed the National Industrial Recovery Act. This legislation established the National Recovery Administration (NRA) and had the broad goal of bringing about economic stability through business planning, such as fair practice codes for wages, working conditions, production, and pricing. The result was mixed, as some people felt that the reforms were not being administered fairly and were favoring certain groups over others. Ensuing New Deal legislation moved from specifically trying to fix problems in the economy to creating jobs for the large numbers of unemployed. In 1935 the Works Progress Administration (WPA) was established and charged with constructing hospitals, schools, and playgrounds. In addition, the WPA provided significant funding for the arts, helping musicians, painters, writers, actors, and historians to produce an outpouring of creative projects. However, not everyone was in favor of the New Deal programs. Some believed the government had not done enough to aid the suffering; others felt it had gone too far and imposed regulation in places where it did not belong. One of the greatest sources of opposition was the Supreme Court, who frustrated FDR to no end by questioning the constitutionality of and/or delaying the implementation of key pieces of legislation. To get around the “nine old men” who he felt were keeping the country mired in the throes of the Depression, Roosevelt proposed a constitutional amendment that would add up to six new judges to the Supreme Court and up to 44 judges to lower federal tribunals. He claimed that the Court was overworked and that the new justices would help the existing ones clear the backlog of cases, but many people were skeptical. The controversy over this “court-packing” plan (as it came to be known) was one of the largest that FDR had to face. ix Ironically, America came out of the Depression primarily as the result of having to face a larger threat: the looming specter of World War II. Preparing for war required increased production, which provided a boost to the economy that lasted through the war and laid the basis for the boom of the 1950s. The New Deal’s impact nonetheless was huge and still continues to affect America today: key government programs such as Social Security, the FDIC, the Federal Housing Administration, and others originated in the 1930s. Whether or not the New Deal was a “success” remains a matter for debate. No definitive evidence exists proving that the New Deal pulled the country out of the Depression; however, it did break new ground in terms of social legislation and centralized control of the economy, and it changed the way in which people conceptualized what the role of federal government should be—all legacies which persist to this day. x 1 Roosevelt’s Fireside Chat Teacher Page Overview: The source is a transcript of FDR’s fireside chat of May 7, 1933. In it he discusses both measures that have been taken already as well as those soon to be implemented as part of the New Deal, including the bank holiday, the CCC, the TVA, the Farm Relief Bill, and the Railroad Bill. He also spends a great deal of time providing a rationale for these measures, taking great pains to assure the public that neither the Executive Branch nor the government as a whole is overstepping its bounds. Objectives: Students will: • understand Roosevelt’s plans to combat the main problems of the Depression • interpret the meaning of statements used in the speech • assess the goals, benefits, and broad implications of Roosevelt’s policies Web Sites Used in this Lesson: The document exists on the New Deal Network Web site at http://newdeal.feri.org/chat/chat02.htm Strategies: Pose the following questions to the class: “How does the President or other top level officials communicate with the public today? How effective do you think today’s methods are?” Distribute handout to students. Have students answer questions 1 and 2 only, then discuss the answers to these questions and make comparisons to today. Students complete the remaining questions. Wrap-Up: After students have completed the worksheet, discuss interpretations of the quotation in questions 3 and 7. Come to a consensus about the meanings. Ask students, “What do you think Roosevelt’s most important immediate goal was? What was his most important long-term goal?” Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 2 Extension Activity: Obtain a transcript of a present-day presidential radio address and have them identify the central theme of the message, interpret meanings of key phrases, and assess the policy implications and/or political goals Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 3 Roosevelt’s Fireside Chat Student Worksheet Introduction: FDR’s first ten days in office had been marked by a flurry of emergency measures designed to curb the downward spiral of the U.S. banking system and to put the nation as a whole back on a firmer economic footing. One of those measures was the bank holiday, which closed all the banks for five days so that the government could examine their financial health. By March 15th, many banks had been certified as sound enough to be reopened and the stock market had risen significantly above its mid-February low. FDR had been president for only two months when he gave this radio address to the nation. All Web links for this lesson can be found at: http://www.socialstudies.com/uslinks.html Directions: Roosevelt’s Fireside Chats Go to http://newdeal.feri.org/chat/chat02.htm. Answer the following questions about the primary source: 1. What do you think FDR hoped to accomplish by holding these fireside chats? Why do you think he called them “fireside chats” instead of radio addresses or speeches? 2. Who would have been likely to listen to the fireside chats? How might have they benefited by listening to them? 3. Roosevelt said, “The country was dying by inches.” How does he justify this opinion? 4. In part 5 of the chat, why do you think Roosevelt spent so much time talking about Congress before focusing on his economic recovery plan? Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 4 5. Part 7 discusses the Civilian Conservation Corps. Here Roosevelt states, “we are killing two birds with one stone” because the CCC will be both “enhancing the value of our natural resources” and “giving opportunity of employment to one quarter of a million of the unemployed.” Do you think these two goals were equal in importance? Why or why not? 6. In part 8 he refers to “incident benefits” of the TVA reaching the entire nation. Was Roosevelt just trying to convince everyone that a local project was in the national interest? Were there specific benefits that the TVA would provide for the country as a whole? 7. In part 18, Roosevelt states, “We cannot ballyhoo ourselves back to prosperity.” What does he mean by this? 8. In part 29, FDR says, “…the domestic situation is inevitably and deeply tied in with the conditions in all the other nations of the world.” Why do you think he thought it was important to make this point? 9. Part 22 suggests a broader concern than economic recovery. “We are working toward a definite goal, which is to prevent the return of conditions which came very close to destroying what we call modern civilization.” What “conditions” do you think he is referring to here? Based on your knowledge of the era, do you think most Americans would have agreed with the president that this was the goal of the New Deal? Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 5 The New Deal and the Arts Teacher Page Overview: This primary source for this lesson is a painting from an online exhibit at the National Archives. Created for an exhibition at the 1936 Kansas State Fair, it tells the story of the National Youth Authority (NYA). The foreground of the painting shows several types of NYA activities; the left side shows manual occupations, while the right depicts tasks that were more intellectual in nature. The background’s shadowy figures represent problems and temptations faced by young people during the Depression: crime, poverty, gambling, and homelessness. Overall, this source can show students one sort of art that was being created under the auspices of the New Deal, and get them to think about the effect the NYA had on the youth of America. Objectives: Students will: • view a painting and make inferences from it • speculate on an artist’s intentions • place the painting in the context of the New Deal • evaluate how effectively the artist communicated his message Web Sites Used in this Lesson: Send students directly to http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/new_deal_for_the_arts/images/work_pays_america/ima ges/national_youth_admininistration.jpg, which shows only the painting and does not include background information or interpretations of the painting. More information can be found in the “Work Pays America” section of the NARA online exhibit at http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/new_deal_for_the_arts/work_pays_america.html. The URL for the entire exhibition, “A New Deal for the Arts,” is http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/new_deal_for_the_arts/index.html. Strategies: Introduce the lesson with a brief discussion on what we can learn about a time period from looking at art created in that period. Distribute handout to students and review the introduction so that all students understand the role of the NYA. Student answers for questions 1–5 can be 2–3 sentences. Responses to question 6 can range in length from a single paragraph to a maximum of one page, depending on time available. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 6 Wrap-Up: After students have answered questions, pose the following questions to the class: • Do you think that government support of the arts during the 1930s significantly alleviated the misery of the Great Depression? • To what extent should government support the arts today? Extension Activity: Individually or in pairs, have students select a New Deal program or measure and create their own painting or poster celebrating or criticizing it. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 7 The New Deal and the Arts Student Worksheet Introduction: During the depths of the Great Depression of the 1930s and into the early years of World War II, the federal government supported the arts in unprecedented ways. For 11 years, between 1933 and 1943, federal tax dollars employed artists, musicians, actors, writers, photographers, and dancers. Never before or since has our government so extensively sponsored the arts. The National Youth Administration (NYA) provided jobs for young adults, especially college students, many of whom found themselves without work, direction, or hope. In 1936, Alden Krider, an NYA artist, painted the story of the NYA for an exhibit at the Kansas State Fair. All Web links for this lesson can be found at: http://www.socialstudies.com/uslinks.html Directions: Painting depicting the activities of the National Youth Administration Go to http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/new_deal_for_the_arts/images/work_pays_america/ima ges/national_youth_admininistration.jpg Answer the following questions about the painting: 1. Describe the different types of activities depicted in the foreground of the painting. 2. What is notable about the use of color in the painting? 3. What do you think the figures in the background represent? 4. The quotation in the center of the painting is from FDR’s words establishing the NYA in 1935. Why do you think the artist included it in the painting? Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 8 5. What is the difference between the activities shown in the left compared to those shown in the right? Why might the artist have done this? 6. In your own words, describe what you think the message of this painting is and how effectively the artist communicated the message. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 9 “An Emergency Is On”: African Americans and the NRA Teacher Page Overview: This is an article written by T. Arnold Hill and published in Opportunity, Journal of Negro Life in September, 1933. It will provide students with a point of view that is critical of the effect the policies of the NRA were having on black workers. Objectives: Students will: • understand how the NRA affected workers • note the differences in how blacks and whites experienced the New Deal • engage in a detailed analysis and critique of the author’s arguments. Web Sites Used in this Lesson: The document exists on the New Deal Network Web site at http://newdeal.feri.org/opp/opp33280.htm. This site also has several other articles from Opportunity that cover many different subjects. Strategies: One option for implementing the lesson would be to give students the worksheet and assign questions 1–5 only. Discuss the answers to establish the context of the article. Next, assign the remaining questions in order to assess and critique the author’s point of view. Questions 6–12 are meant to be answered in a paragraph or more. Omit some of the questions if time is an issue. Wrap-Up: After students have completed the worksheet, have them exchange letters to Roosevelt and peer-assess them for the quality of the argument. Do students agree with Hill’s assertion that “forthright leadership” would be the key to meeting this “emergency”? Ask students if they think there is wage inequality based on race in America today. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 10 Extension Activity: Although this piece portrays the NRA as ineffective in remedying wage inequalities based on race, New Deal policies generally led to the improvement of blacks in American society. Have students find examples of how this occurred and evaluate which of FDR’s measures they think was most important in helping blacks on the road to equality. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 11 “An Emergency Is On”: African Americans and the NRA Student Worksheet Introduction: The National Recovery Administration (NRA) was one of the centerpieces of the New Deal. Its main task was to work with industries to establish codes outlining fair labor and business practices. The main goal here was to curb production: Owners would benefit from higher prices and the huge surplus of excess goods would start to dwindle, hopefully setting the country back on the path to economic stability. Under the provisions of the act establishing the NRA, workers were promised collective bargaining, and minimum wages and maximum work hours were to be set. However, the NRA affected white workers and black workers in very different ways, as this selection will reveal. All Web links for this lesson can be found at: http://www.socialstudies.com/uslinks.html Directions: “An Emergency is On” Go to http://newdeal.feri.org/opp/opp33280.htm and answer the following questions: 1. What type of source is it? ___ written ___ image ___audio/video ___chart/graph Specifically describe the type of source. (i.e. letter, photo) _______________________________ 2. Dates _________ If no date, can you tell the time period from the content? ___________________ 3. Who created the source? __________________________________________ 4. Why might the source have been created? 5. a. Who in the past would have come in contact with this source? b. How might they have been affected by the source? Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 12 6. What is the “emergency” referred to in the title? 7. For what reasons might employers have been inclined to fire black workers rather than pay them the same wages as white workers? 8. In your own words, restate Hill’s argument why a dual wage scale would be economically unsound. 9. Why does Hill insist that black workers should demand equal pay and risk getting fired rather than accept lower wages than white workers? 10. In part 7, what is the “hypocrisy” to which Hill refers, and why does he believe that it “disqualifies the government as a democracy fit to pass sentence upon other nations”? 11. Upon whom does Hill place the blame for “the failure of Negroes to rouse themselves on behalf of their own salvation”? What does Hill see as the solution to this “emergency”? 12. Assume the role of President Roosevelt and write two or three paragraphs responding to Hill’s arguments. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 13 “Sunny Cal”: The Okies Head West Teacher Page Overview: This primary source from the Library of Congress is a 1940 folk song composed by Jack Bryant at a Farm Security Administration (FSA) camp in California’s Central Valley. Students will first listen to an audio clip of the song (Bryant performs unaccompanied, singing and playing acoustic guitar), then analyze the lyrics. This lesson should give students an idea of what it was like to be a migrant worker in California, and should also provide them with valuable practice in analyzing a non-written primary source. Objectives: Students will: • listen to a song from the Depression era about life for Okies in California • place the song in its historical and social context • make inferences about what audience the author of the song was trying to reach • evaluate how effectively the artist conveyed his message Web Sites Used in this Lesson: These primary sources are buried deep within the Library of Congress’s labyrinthine Web site. There are no permanent URLs for them; instead, you will need to go to http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/afctshtml/tshome.html, which is the home page for an American Memory exhibit titled “Voices from the Dust Bowl: The Charles L. Todd and Robert Sonkin Migrant Worker Collection.” From here, click on “Search by Keywords” and type “Sunny Cal” into the box called “Search Descriptive Information.” Two links for “Sunny Cal” should appear; the first link goes to the bibliographic record for the song, while the second goes to a page with a link to an audio file of Bryant performing the song. Also, from the first link students can follow other links to read a transcription of the song and to view an image of the actual typewritten lyrics from 1940. Strategies: Teacher introduces lesson with a brief discussion on what the Okies encountered upon reaching California. Teacher distributes handout to students; make a decision as to whether the song will be played to the whole class or students will go to the Web site individually. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 14 Wrap-Up: After students have completed the worksheet, have a discussion focused on these issues: • How reliably do songs reflect the mood of a time period? • Do songs reflect or create attitudes? Have students give examples of contemporary songs that they think reflect the mood of the country. Have students compare attitudes toward migrant workers in the 1930s with attitudes toward illegal immigrants today. Extension Activity: Individually or in pairs, students read the part from The Grapes of Wrath where the Joads, en route to California, meet up with an old acquaintance who has been living in California, but has decided to return to the Midwest. Compare his complaints with those voiced in “Sunny Cal.” Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 15 “Sunny Cal”: The Okies Head West Student Worksheet Introduction: The economic difficulties of the Depression were exacerbated by geographic conditions for thousands of Midwest farm families. During much of the 1930s drought and dust storms wreaked havoc on Oklahoma, Kansas, Texas, and other Plains states. It is estimated that over 400,000 people left Oklahoma and went to California to find work. However, California did not prove to be the solution to all of their problems, as this source will indicate. All Web links for this lesson can be found at: http://www.socialstudies.com/uslinks.html Directions: “Sunny Cal” Go to http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/afctshtml/tshome.html, which is the home page for an American Memory exhibit titled “Voices from the Dust Bowl: The Charles L. Todd and Robert Sonkin Migrant Worker Collection.” From here, click on “Search by Keywords” and type “Sunny Cal” into the box called “Search Descriptive Information.” Two links for “Sunny Cal” should appear; click on the second. On the next page, click on the blue button that says “Listen to this recording.” After this selection has finished, go back to the search page and click on the first “Sunny Cal” link, then use the information on that page to help you answer the following questions: 1. What type of source is it? ___written ___ image ___audio/video __chart/graph Specifically describe the type of source. (i.e. letter, photo) _______________________________ 2. Dates_________ If no date, can you tell the time period from the content? ___________________ 3. Who created the source? _________________________________ 4. In one sentence summarize the story told by this source. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 16 5. Write a sentence describing the mood or emotion expressed in the source. 6. What might have motivated the author to write this source? 7. a. Who do you think was the intended audience for this source? b. How do you think the author hoped to affect or influence his audience? c. Write a sentence or two explaining whether or not you think the author effectively conveyed his message. 8. In your own words, write a three- to four-sentence statement in which you express why this source is historically important. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 17 The Court-Packing Controversy Teacher Page Overview: This lesson uses two political cartoons from the FDR Cartoon Archive. Both are direct commentaries on Roosevelt’s plan to add six additional justices to the Supreme Court. The two cartoons offer an example of opposing viewpoints (it should be fairly clear which one is pro-Roosevelt and which one is anti-Roosevelt). In the activity, students use the same criteria to make inferences about and evaluate each cartoon, then conclude by comparing the two to decide which is more effective. Objectives: Students will: • understand the symbolism and meanings of two political cartoons from the 1930s • place the cartoons within the appropriate historical context • identify the point of view of each cartoon • evaluate how effectively each cartoonist communicated his message Web Sites Used in this Lesson: Both cartoons come from the FDR Cartoon Archive at http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/. The URL for the one titled “Hear Ye! Hear Ye! Hear Ye!” is http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37020608.gif. The URL for the one titled “But Captain!” is http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37012302.gif. Strategies: Introduce political cartoons by using a current example. Engage the class in a discussion of the meaning of your chosen cartoon. Generally discuss the purpose of political cartoons. Distribute handout to students and review the introduction to establish the general context. All questions could be answered in 1-3 sentences except for the final question, for which students should write at least one paragraph in which they defend their choice. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 18 Wrap-Up: After students have completed the exercise, read the following statement to the class: “Even though the court packing measure failed to pass, it was still a success for FDR.” Ask students what this statement means, and if they agree or disagree with the statement. Next, have a discussion focused on how to recognize a point of view. Pose the following questions: 1. “Do you think that political cartoons are an effective means of expressing a point of view?” 2. “What was the historical significance of the court packing controversy especially as it was revealed through political cartoons of the time?” Extension Activity: Have students go to http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/index.html at the FDR Cartoon Archive and examine other cartoons about the court-packing controversy. Have them select four cartoons that they think offer the most incisive commentary on the controversy: one from January-March, one from April-June, one from July-September, and one from October-December. Students should defend their choices either individually in writing or as part of a group oral presentation. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 19 The Court-Packing Controversy Student Worksheet Introduction: The Supreme Court had invalidated several of the early New Deal initiatives such as NIRA. Frustrated by these circumstances, Roosevelt was anxious to extend his reform to the court itself. FDR’s proposed legislation would have allowed him to appoint up to six new justices. He was accused of trying to “pack” the court with justices who would be favorable to the New Deal. The following primary sources indicate differing perspectives on Roosevelt’s plan. All Web links for this lesson can be found at: http://www.socialstudies.com/uslinks.html Directions: “Hear Ye! Hear Ye! Hear Ye!” and “But Captain!” Go to http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37020608.gif http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37012302.gif Answer the following questions about the primary sources 1. What type of source is this? ___written ___ image ___audio/video __chart/graph Specifically describe the type of source. (i.e. letter, photo) _______________________________ 2. Dates_________ If no date, can you tell the time period from the content? 3. Why might the source have been created? 4. a. Who in the past would have come in contact with this source? b. How might they have been affected by the source? Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 20 Look at the source titled “Hear Ye! Hear Ye! Hear Ye!”: 1. List the characters or objects shown and identify who or what they represent. 2. Describe the action taking place. 3. Explain how the words in the source clarify the symbols. Which words appear to be the most significant? Why do you think so? 4. What is the significance of the title? Look at the source titled “But Captain!”: 1. List the characters or objects shown and identify who or what they represent. 2. Describe the action taking place. 3. Explain how the words in the source clarify the symbols. Which words appear to be the most significant? Why do you think so? 4. What is the significance of the title? Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 21 Compare the two sources: 1. Which people and/or groups would have agreed with the view presented in “Hear Ye! Hear Ye! Hear Ye!”? Why? 2. Which people and/or groups would have agreed with the view presented in “But Captain!”? Why? 3. Which of the two sources do you think makes its argument most effectively? Why? Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 22 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 23 Culminating Activities 1. Divide the class in half and engage in a formal debate about the following statement: “The New Deal was not targeted to help all Americans, but rather a few key groups.” To assess this, you can use the debate rubric in Appendix. 2. Assign a formal essay using the following lead-in thesis statement: “ The most important way in which FDR’s administration sought to remedy the Depression was …” A rubric for evaluating a formal essay is available in the Appendix. 3. Have students search the additional sites and locate a single primary source that they think best exemplifies one of the following: • • • • • • • • the impact of the Depression on agriculture the impact of the Depression on industry How African Americans were affected by the Depression the most controversial part of the New Deal life in cities during the Depression FDR’s “finest hour” during the Depression the greatest threat the Depression posed to Americans the changing face of labor during the Depression If time permits, students should make a five-minute oral presentation defending their chosen source. If the student chooses a written document, they should summarize the content for the class before defending their selection; if the student chooses an image, have them show it to the whole class; if they choose an audio or video clip, have them play it for the class. A rubric for evaluating an oral presentation is available in Appendix. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 24 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 25 APPENDIX Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 26 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 27 Answer Key Lesson 1: Roosevelt’s Fireside Chat 1. To keep the public calm and informed about what he and his administration were doing. By exuding an easy and confident manner he hoped to make the American people feel better about the situation. To create an inviting atmosphere, a sense of the president informing every citizen personally as to what he was doing. 2. The main audience would have been middle- and lower-class Americans who were being affected by the depression. (There is the obvious given of people having access to a radio.) Roosevelt was called “The People’s President” and these chats helped to reassure the public that he was following through with his pledge for a “new deal.” People could have been encouraged knowing that he was following through with his plans. 3. “…because trade and commerce had declined to dangerously low levels; prices for basic commodities were such as to destroy the value of the assets of national institutions such as banks, savings banks, insurance companies, and others. These institutions, because of their great needs, were foreclosing mortgages, calling loans, refusing credit. Thus there was actually in process of destruction the property of millions of people who had borrowed money on that property in terms of dollars which had had an entirely different value from the level of March, 1933.” 4. Roosevelt was re-assuring critics that what he was doing was constitutional and was with the support of Congress (“Congress still retained its constitutional authority and no one has the slightest desire to change the balance of these powers”). 5. Answers will vary. Students could argue that employment was the greater issue at that time. 6. Answers will vary. For the greater benefit it may be argued that by increasing cheap hydroelectric output and controlling floods, farmers in the area were more productive and as a result more food would be available. 7. Just talking and bragging about what can be or has been done will not solve the problem. Concrete action must be taken. 8. Possible responses could include: the U.S. as an exporting nation needed markets for its goods; necessary imports were more expensive. 9. Subject to student interpretation. Reference could be made to the collapse of institutions, especially financial ones, violence used against protest groups such as the Bonus Army, and a general sense of “giving up” on traditional beliefs. Lesson 2: The New Deal and the Arts 1. Typing, sewing, scientific research, surveying, building/constructing, and weaving 2. Brighter colors in the foreground with more light (red, yellow, green, flesh tones). 3. Shadowy figures appear to depict human frailties or defects such as gambling, idleness, drinking, stealing. What happens to people who are not using their potential? 4. To reinforce the theme of the painting 5. Left represents more skilled manual labor while the right depicts more white-collar intellectual skills. Both are of equal importance to society. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 28 6. Student responses may vary. Lesson 3: An Emergency is On 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Written; Journal Of Negro Life, a magazine September 1933 T. Arnold Hill was the author and the National Urban League was the publisher. As a voice for African Americans at the time. Students may have other ideas. A. Subscribers or purchasers of the publication. It was started by the National Urban League in 1910 as a publication to enable African Americans to secure self-reliance and civil rights, thus the majority of readers would be African Americans. B. Readers may have been motivated to take action based on the recommendations of the publication. 6. The emergency—African Americans were losing their jobs because white employers would not pay them wages equal to white workers. 7. Answers will vary. Discrimination is an obvious possibility. 8. Student answers will vary based on their comprehension and ability to rephrase. 9. “There should be no wage distinction based upon race in the NRA codes. To the extent that people are unemployed, to that same extent will those who work have to take care of them. This fits Negroes as well as whites. If all Negroes are discharged in the South, so that whites may work, then the employed whites will have to support the idle Negroes. It is unfair, of course, that the race should be forced into mendicancy, but it is better that Negro workers insist upon wages equal to those paid whites, even if it means their ultimate discharge, than to accept smaller wages and thereby perpetuate the class distinctions that now exist. Neither position is a satisfactory one for the Negro, but it is fair to assume that if the burden of support for the maintenance of Negroes were thrown upon the State, conditions would tend to right themselves much more quickly than if Negroes submitted to a smaller wage.” 10. How can the government rush to aid foreign countries while enslaving 12,000,000 of its own people? 11. He blames the “Negro” leadership for its reliance on ignorance and custom instead of agreeing on a new unified course of action. 12. Assess each answer individually. Lesson 4: Sunny Cal 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Audio, song 1940/08/17 Jack Bryant Migrant workers experience moving to California. Answers will vary, but could include frustration or disappointment. Possible response—the author’s own experience and a wish to warn others. A. Other migrant workers, government authorities B. Answers will vary. C. Subjective response 8. Answers will vary. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 29 Lesson 5: The Court Packing Controversy 1. 2. 3. 4. Image, cartoon Not on the actual cartoon, but 1937 appears in the URL. As a commentary on FDR’s plan to make changes to the court. a. People who read this newspaper. b. Answers will vary. Some may have found it humorous while others may have been annoyed. “Hear Ye” 1. FDR (as policeman), a justice in the cart, vehicles labeled with pieces of legislation. 2. FDR as policeman is handing a citation or piece of paper to the old justice in the cart and is telling him he has held things up long enough. 3. Answers will vary. 4. It is a phrase used to bring a court to order. “But Captain! 1. 2. 3. 4. FDR, “the people,” a ship and life preservers. FDR is about to get rid of the life preservers. Answers will vary. Answers will vary, but suggest a warning to the captain to reconsider. Comparison 1. Most likely people who supported FDR’s plan to reform the court. Students could speculate on specific groups that would support FDR. 2. Most likely those who oppose FDR’s plan. Again, students could speculate on opposition groups. 3. Answers will vary. Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 30 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 31 Argumentative Paragraph/Essay Rubric Structure-Introduction - states thesis/main idea - introduces main points Weighting Level 1 (50-59) - simple opening statement - limited identification of main points SCORE Level 2 (60-69) - thesis stated but unclear - main points unclear Level 3 (70-79) - thesis is stated but somewhat unclear - main points introduced with moderate clarity Level 4 (80-100) - thesis is precisely stated - main points clearly introduced Structure-Conclusion – summarizes thesis/main idea – summarizes main points Weighting Level 1 (50-59) - abrupt ending; limited summarizing of main points SCORE Level 2 (60-69) - thesis summarized but unclear - main point summarized but unclear Level 3 (70-79) - thesis summarized but somewhat unclear - main points summarized but unclear Level 4 (80-100) - thesis clearly summarized - main points clearly summarized Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 32 Supporting Reasons or Arguments - arguments are related to the main idea logically Weighting Level 1 (50-59) - arguments are unrelated SCORE Level 2 (60-69) - arguments are unclear and not logically related to the main idea Level 3 (70-79) - arguments are usually clear and logically related to the main idea Level 4 (80-100) - arguments are quite clear and logically related to the main idea Level 1 (50-59) Evidence and Examples - relevant supporting evidence - limited support of points, evidence mostly - sufficient quantity of facts irrelevant used - limited or unrelated facts used Weighting SCORE Level 2 (60-69) - some points have been supported, some evidence not relevant - insufficient or missing some facts Level 3 (70-79) - most points have been supported with relevant evidence - sufficient use of facts Level 4 (80-100) - each point has been supported with relevant evidence - substantial facts used Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 33 Mechanics of Writing - correct grammar and spelling used - use of correct citation method Weighting Level 1 (50-59) - grammar and spelling used with limited accuracy and effectiveness - citation method not followed or absent SCORE Level 2 (60-69) - grammar and spelling used with some accuracy and effectiveness - citation method used but with significant errors Level 3 (70-79) - grammar and spelling used with considerable accuracy and effectiveness - minor errors in citation method Level 4 (80-100) - correct grammar and spelling used with accuracy and effectiveness almost all of the time - precise use of citation method Additional Criteria Weighting Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 34 Debate Rubric Clear articulation of position Level 1 - position is not clearly stated SCORE Level 2 - position is recognized, but only clarified through prompting Level 3 - a clear position is stated Level 4 - a clear position is stated and fully articulated Provides support for position Level 1 - limited support for initial position SCORE Level 2 - support for initial position is present but lacks clarity of presentation Level 3 - support for initial position is clearly presented and reasoned based on evidence Level 4 - supporting arguments for position are both reasoned and persuasively presented Considers other positions Level 1 - limited sensitivity to other positions SCORE Level 2 - other positions acknowledged but not considered Level 3 - other positions acknowledged and considered Level 4 - other positions considered and effectively incorporated or countered Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 35 Effectively critiques positions Level 1 - limited sensitivity to other positions SCORE Level 2 - other positions acknowledged but not considered Level 3 - other positions acknowledged and considered Level 4 - other positions considered and effectively incorporated or countered Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 36 Oral Presentation Rubric Your Name: ______________________ Topic:_____________________________ Criteria Possible Self-Assessment Points Provided depth in coverage of topic. Presentation was well planned and coherent. Presenters were models of thoughtfulness. Personal experience integrated where relevant and appropriate. Explanations and reasons given for conclusions. Teacher Assessment 10 10 10 Communication aids were clear and useful. 10 Bibliographic information for others was complete. 10 Total Possible Points 50 Rate each category according to the following scale: • • • • • • 9–10 = excellent 7–8 = very good 5–6 = good 3–4 = satisfactory 1–2 = poor 0 = unsatisfactory Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 37 The New Deal and the Arts http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/new_deal_for_the_arts/images/work_pays_america/ima ges/national_youth_admininistration.jpg Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 38 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 39 “Sunny Cal”: The Okies Head West Song Lyrics Jack Bryant Firebaugh, 1940 You've all heard the story Of old Sunny Cal The place where it never rains They say it don't know how. They say, "Come on, you Okies, Work is easy found Bring along your cotton pack You can pick the whole year round. Get your money ever' night Spread your blanket on the ground It' s always bright and warm You can sleep right on the ground." But listen to me Okies I came out here one day Spent all my money getting here Now I can't get away. http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/afctshtml/tshome.html Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 40 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 41 Recommended Web Sites on the Great Depression and the New Deal New Deal Network Over 20,000 items comprise this online database of photographs, political cartoons, and texts (speeches, letters, and other historic documents) from the New Deal period. Based at the Institute for Learning Technologies at Columbia University, the New Deal Network also offers several features that explore New Deal topics with accompanying lesson plans. The illustrated features discuss letters written to Eleanor Roosevelt for aid during the Great Depression, American slave narratives from the Federal Writers Project, Resident Youth Centers of the National Youth Administration, the Civilian Conservation Corps, and the Tennessee Valley Authority. http://newdeal.feri.org/ New Deal and the Arts: National Archive Exhibit This online exhibit sponsored by the National Archives and Records Administration examines the various federally funded programs of the New Deal that employed vast numbers of artists, writers, photographers, and musicians. Categories of featured art include “Rediscovering America”, “Celebrating the People”, “Work Pays America”, “Activist Art”, “Work Pays America” and “Useful Arts”. http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/new_deal_for_the_arts/index.html Voices from the Dust Bowl: The Charles L. Todd and Robert Sonkin Migrant Worker Collection, 1940-1941 The Library of Congress hosts this online presentation of a multiformat ethnographic field collection documenting the everyday life of residents of Farm Security Administration (FSA) migrant work camps in central California in 1940 and 1941. The collection consists of audio recordings, photographs, manuscript materials, publications, and ephemera generated during two separate documentation trips supported by the Archive of American Folk Song (now the Archive of Folk Culture, American Folklife Center). http://lcweb2.loc.gov/ammem/afctshtml/tshome.html Franklin D. Roosevelt Presidential Museum and Library This online counterpart to the Franklin D. Roosevelt Library in Hyde Park, New York is devoted to fulfilling Franklin Roosevelt's dream of making the records of the past available “for the use of men and women in the future.” Over 10,000 digitized documents from the President's Secretary File are available as both text and in their original version for research purposes. Photographs, audio recordings, motion pictures, and political cartoons are also available online. http://www.fdrlibrary.marist.edu/index.html Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 42 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 43 Resources on the Great Depression and the New Deal available from Social Studies School Service To order, go to http://www.socialstudies.com/mproduct.html and enter the code and quantity of the desired titles or call toll-free 800-421-4246. AMERICA LOST AND FOUND: The Depression Decade. Focusing on the profound psychological impact of the Great Depression, this award-winning PBS compilation of rare newsreel footage chronicles events in the political and social history of the 1930s; meanwhile, the narrator interprets the meanings behind the events. The main focus is on the way the Depression darkened the American Dream, and on the way the media of the time—radio with its songs and heroes, movies with their happy endings, newsreels drumming up hope for the New Deal, even cartoons (showing Popeye, like the nation, knocked flat on his back, but leaping back to his feet after a swallow of spinach)—reinvented a positive self-concept for Americans. Grades 7 and up. Black-and-white. 58 minutes. Direct Cinema Education. DCE100V VHS videocassette $95.00 JACKDAW® KITS. These primary source kits contain reproductions of historic documents, maps, engravings, diaries, paintings, newspapers, letters, and other documents. In addition, the kits include colorful broadsheets supplying a basic chronological overview of the material, modern interpretations, and evaluations. Comprehensive teacher’s guides provide reproducible activities that encourage students to discover the historical significance of primary source materials. Grades 7–12. Golden Owl. DJ201 THE DEPRESSION $50.00 DJ200 THE NEW DEAL $50.00 THE DEPRESSION HITS HOME: Photo Collection. Urban and rural photographs of the Great Depression appear on these 12 posters: worried throngs pack Wall Street in front of the New York Stock Exchange; dust clouds loom over the main street of a small Kansas town; men curled in fetal positions sleep on Skid Row pavement in San Francisco; a migrant worker’s baby plays with a “toy” shotgun shell while daddy repairs the jalopy that will carry them to the next Texas field. Such striking black-and-white photographs (shot by Dorothea Lange, Ben Shahn, Russell Lee, and others) are clearly reproduced and captioned on heavy card stock. A 10-page guide with reproducible pages contains background information, discussion questions, ideas for research and writing, and a bibliography. Grades 6– 12. 17" x 22". Jackdaw Publications. ©1997. DJ268 12 posters, guide $40.00 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 44 THE GREAT DEPRESSION: 1929–1939. This series of 30 photographs and political cartoons offers a pictorial commentary of the despair which gripped the United States during the 1930s. Photo aids depict unemployment and bread lines, FDR, a “Hooverville,” bank closures, New Deal programs, and men desperate for any kind of work. The captioned photographs are printed on 11"h x 14"w heavy glossy stock. Documentary Photo Aids. DPA73 30 photo aids, guide $51.50 THE GREAT DEPRESSION. Narrated by Mario Cuomo. In this evocative look at Depression-era America, hoboes recall what it was like to ride the rails, John Kenneth Galbraith weighs in on New Deal policies, and Pretty Boy Floyd’s nephew observes dryly, “A lot of people in Oklahoma would say ‘hooray.’ They clapped their hands when somebody robbed a bank. My uncle made them clap their hands too often.” Newsreel footage, classic Dorothea Lange photographs, and contemporary interviews with eyewitnesses, authors, and historians such as James Michener and Howard Zinn profile the stock market crash, FDR, Upton Sinclair, Dust Bowl migration, marathon dancing, the march of WWI vets on Washington, Huey Long, and more. Color and black-and-white. Total time: 200 minutes. History Channel. ©1998. FE321V BOXED SET: 4 VHS videocassettes $59.95 THE DEPRESSION AND NEW DEAL: A History in Documents. By Robert S. McElvaine. Newspaper articles, letters, poetry, political cartoons, songs, fiction, photographs and other primary source documents give vital insight into the Depression and New Deal. An introductory essay, commentary, and sidebars supplement the primary source material and persistent illustrations. Materials include songs by Woody Guthrie, articles from periodicals (from Fortune magazine to the Communist New Masses), murals and posters sponsored by the WPA, an excerpt from The Grapes of Wrath, and selections from Eleanor Roosevelt’s “My Day” column. Grades 7–12. Index. Timeline. Suggested readings. Illustrated. 7" x 10". Oxford University Press. 191 p. ©2000. OUP480 Hardback $36.95 Paperback 1-4 copies $19.95 each 5 copies and over $17.95 each THE GRAPES OF WRATH. Directed by John Ford. A chronicle of the injustice and inhumanity encountered by the Joad family in their journey from the Dust Bowl of the Depression to the “promised land” of California, where they become migrant farm workers. Based on the novel by John Steinbeck, this classic production stars Henry Fonda. Closed captioned. Black-and-white. 1sv129 minutes. 20th CenturyFox. SV141V VHS videocassette $14.98 SV141DV DVD $14.98 PEN4239 Paperback 1-4 copies $15.00 each 5 copies and over $13.50 each Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com 45 Permission granted to reproduce for classroom use only. © 2001 Social Studies School Service. (800) 421-4246 socialstudies.com
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz