Centre for Appropriate Technology
!
A report prepared for Indigenous Essential Services (IES),
Northern Territory Department of Planning and Infrastructure
#
"
#
$ %
#
&
#
#
$ '
(
#
#
$
&
#
) $ $
*
#
#
&
*
+,
-
#
) $ $
)
&
*$
&
&
$
#
/
$ 1 # &
&
"
(
#
#
&
#
#
#
$
-
#
.
#
#
"
(
&
0
)01
2*
"
&
$
#
#
&
&
#
#
34,
#
$ 1
&
#
&
#
01
-
5
6
$ 7
#
#
#
$ /
#
&
&
#
#
$
0
&
#
#
8
& #
9
#
#
#
# &
&
$ :
)#
$
# &
1 # &
&
&
&
& #
1
&
&
(
#
$
-
#
$ "
#
&
#
70
$
&
$
'
&
&
01
01
$ "
#
#
#
&
#
& ,
&
#
#
&
01
<
&
&
*;
&
01
#
01
#
#
#
&
#
(
$
#
&
&
#
=
#
$ >
#
-
&
#
&
&
& ,
&
,
&
$
#
&
#
$
&
?
#
#
-
#
$>
(
&
$
,
(
$
&
&
&
&
,
&
)
@
#
&
01
&
$
01
&
# &
*$
$ >
&
(
&
#
#
#
#
&
$
01
&
#
#
&
1 # &
&
#
#
& #
#
& ,
#
$
&
&
&
&
#
#
#
'
&
&
#
#
&
'
$
&
#
&
&
&
&
#
#
$
#
>
01
&
#
$
)4
5
6
(
#
*
$
#
#
&
#
&
&
#
&
&
#
#
& $ '
#
#
&
&
-
-
01
$ "
&
$
(
&
#
&
#
#
$
#
7
7&
#
'
$
#
'
(
A
#
B
&
& :
@
0
&
)'A0*
9
"
$
(
1
A
0
&
$
(
#
&
:
$
1
#
@
&
#
%
%
)
%
?
#
&
&
'
7
&
#
?
&
($
(
?
"
>
0
* #
:
A&
"
#
(
#
6
&
&
$
!
$
,
$
@
&
$
(
:
&
!
"
#
!
!$
&
'
)
'
%
(
$
"
*
+
# '*#$
#$
&
,
# '*#$
#$
)
-
$ # #
.
$
0
#
&
' $
$ /
2 !!
1'
$
&
#$
!
$ #
$
&&
!
(
.
*
0
'
(
"
(
"
'
'
!
'
)
'
$
""
$
"+
"+
#
"-
%
)&
#
))
'
)+
'
"0
*
&
*
&+
'
+
&.
+
+"
+&
,
-
%
)
,
' (*
'
&)
#$
,
*
&"
)"
+
(
*'
"
&+
'
'
'
* !
$ # !!
&.
#
'
3
'
)&
))
,
,
!
),
),
!
,&
*
,)
#
!
,+
,-
),
!
,"
,,
3 '
!$
#
'
#
,0
3 '
,
)-
!
!
$ #
)).
(
)0
+"
!
* !
-
)-
'
3
,.
),
'
%
'1
'
!
1
+0
!
'
,
.
,&
!
0
!
##
,-
"
- =
:
#
&
"
,)
,+
-3=
#
$
!
"
"
$
) @
'A0$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
)76 A 3CCD*
<*$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
-E= @" @
7
,6
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &
-<= 0
&
#
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ &
'4
!4 5
>
3=
(
#
&
C
4$ $$$$ 3
>
=0 ( ,
#
$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
>
)
)
E= 0
#
&
#
(#
*$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
*
>
#
<= "
(
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
>
#
4= A-
>
.=
01
& $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ <
>
#
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ .
= "&
#
#
F
&
H
>
D=
>
C= 0
#
$ @
4GF
&
#
H
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ C
#
3 =0
>
*
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ D
",A )
>
)
# ,
*$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ E3
#
)
-
*$
&
$0
>
#
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ E
>
#
33= :
#
>
3 =
>
3E= "&
#
&
#
#
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ E4
#
&
#
$ 0
) 5
(6*
# ,
>
3<=
#
>
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ E<
&
&
#
#
& ,# (
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ E
#
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ED
34= "
( ,
#
#
&
&
&
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ <
>
3.= 1
#
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ <
>
3 =6
#
>
3D= 7
>
8
3C= 0
&
=
;
#
01
#
$$$$$$$ 4<
(
&
#
#
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ <<
&
&
>
9
#
&
$ $$$ 4
&
&
&
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4D
'4
3= 1
#
$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 3C
=
&
01
#
&
E=
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4
#
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
#
<=
$ $$$$$$$$$$ E
4= I
&
# ,
) 5
(6*
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ <3
.= %
=
#
#
43
$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4E
D= 0
#
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 4.
64 4
"7@%
"
7
(
)
*
)
/
:
8
/
*
9#
:&
01
A0
@
A
0
&
6
(6
(
)3
*
%
"
#
#
#
)@ @"
4*$ '
.; @
4; 0" @
"
8
9#
&
) @
;
4*$
?
)
*
)
#
*
$ "
#
&
) 1 : J :
<*
8
5
6
#
9
$
"
) " *#
7
0
&
'
)'A0* 7 &
,
'
A
4
#
#
2
$
-
)01
*
#
$
2#
-
01
$
#
$
# $
#
=
•
&
•
-
8
#
9;
•
&
#
-
>
"
"
1
7
8
)
6
$
-3$
#
0
$ 1
(
(
1 : J :
#
,
;
. ;
4*
(
)@1
<*$
#
. ;
'
(
#
&
&
4
$1 # &
5
6*
&
#
-
(
(
&
&
(
$ )@1
)$ $
(
. ;
1
&
. *
#
,
8
9
&
#
)
,
6
0
#
4*$
&
&
#
@
"
)6
;
3CCC*
)>
"
7
(
@
-
&
0'"
*$
%
)"7@%*
5
6
#
) 1 :
,
<*$ @
&
&
&
0
#
&
;
1
'
)>
0'"
;
$ 3CD *$ 1
1
#
#
&
44
'
4
#
#
? #
"7@%
-
) @
-
4=< ,4 ;
@
$
F
1
&
0
&
;1
3CCD*$ '
#
&
&
&
#
,
$ 0
=
•
#
•
) $ $
•
)
(
/*
*
) $ $
#
,
#
•
*
(#
&
•
#
/
#
) $ $
*
+,
,
-
) $ $
*
&
•
:
&
&
&
#
$
"
& &
&
-
#
$ 7
,
$ '
&
-
,
#
,
#
&
&
$ 0
?
? #
( )
&
*$ '
&
&
&
#
$ '
#
&
&
&
&
5
& $
"
&
,
#
&
$
$
#
&
@
#
"
$ '
$ 1 # &
&
&
#
"
#
$
)
8
80
4 9
9
&
#
#
*$
(#
# ,
&
&
4
& &
,
,
0
) $ $
)0
$
3; 6
3C4 *$ /
$
&
&
)0
$
3; 6
0
3C4 ; 1
:
#
#
+
#
978
78
(
&
#
& $
5
#
-
3C<4*$
8
$ 0
9
#
&
.
#
)1
:
3C<4; A #
*$ '
8#
3C<
01
9
)
A #
&
&
01
(
*$
&
&
#
&
& 8A<4 9 )@/
.*$
&
01
(
& #
$
#
&
=
8
*
)
)"
A
1 +
9)
3C.<*
3C.4*
)0
-
%
#
$
&
3CC *
)A #
1
3*$
-
)01
*
$
01
)
#
*
#
#
)
C ,C4K
E5
35
*
E K
##
*$ 1 # &
)0
$
01
)
$ '
&
&
)
#
&
$
*
,
#
3CCC*$
#
/
&
0
#
&
3CC /0A " 8"
)/0A "
+
<;
6
A #
9
#
;A #
*$ 1 # &
A #
)
*
4.K
&
.< /0 #
(
#
&
$
&
3 K
,
)
A #
&
*$
7
#
/0A "
#
#
#
A
,
A #
,
#
(
)
0
1
1
#
%
978
6
<;
#
A #
01
*$
#
(
)"
)
<*$
6
#
4*$ 01
0
#
&
)
& *
#
#
A #
8
;
#
9 )1
A #
)0
&
;
4
'
#
4;
A #
;
78
0
+
:
3C<4;
*
;6
0
3C4 *$
01
#
#
(
#
#
&
#
)
$ '
& #
A #
*$
#
#
&
(
)
A #
3CD
*$ 0 &
3C<3
01
01
&
7
01
(
&
JA #
3CC4
&
#
)
A #
*$
&
1
01
#
#&
-
(
)A #
3; 1
:
3C<4*$
1
&
%
#
;0
$
01
#
#
(
1 #
(
(
)"
#
A #
)
#
5
6
)
E
1
%
<*$ '
6
#
0
A #
#
;A
(
4;
#
;0
,
$
0
01
#
#&
3; A #
1
'
<*$
#
)
$4 5* )1
3C<4*$ '
8
:
9#
01
A #
-
*
01
L34
&
&
)
*$ :
&
A #
;A #
(
1
%
#
#
8
&
9)
*$
&
&
&
&
)A #
#
#
1
&
%
#
01
#
*$
&
,
#
"
&
#
(
$ >
#
&
01
01
&
$ "
(
-
$ #
@
74
4
"
#
4
01
"
'
*
)A
+
1
&
)0
01
)0
3
;A #
1
%
7 #
+
&
"
*$
5
6
3,
#
)
#
$
@
@
,
5
6
*$ 7
"
-E*
,<
$
&
$
.
$
8
4
5
8:
78 78
&
&
&
(
#
01
)@/
(
-
E K
#
#
#
)
0
.*$ 1 # &
#
+
(
.*$ '
&
#
&
)@1
. ;
. *$ 1 # &
(
(
#
#
(
)@1
4
5
6#
& 4
5
6#
. ;
(
. *$ "
&
01
-
#
01
&
#
#
0
#
4
4
$
$ #
'
&
)
$
#
01
$E
&
(
#
*
#
#
)!
!
( 3CCC;
A #
*$
#
#
;
# &
$ '
#
&
&
#
#
#
$ !
(
#
#
&
!
( 3CCC*$ '
#
#
(
#
"
)!
#
(
$
*'
-
0
1
E4
5
#
$
44,D..
5
4 (
$
#
CD
4*$
5
#
#
# $ 7
"
&
&
)!
,#
#
&
&
#
&
<$
#
#
3CC
0
<
#
#
#
,
#
$
)<.
)33
5
6*
)33
) 70* ) .
<* )
"
5
6*
-3
)
)34
*$ "
(
&
#
(
;#
5
6* )76 A 3CCD*
5
6*
#
#
!4 5
3
#
5
6*
)E$C
5
6*
#
&
5
6* ) @
,
#
&
)>
3*$
4
6 97
*5
#
5<0
E
-
#
8"
)"!0
3* #
4
0
@
M
:
+
0
0
1
#
(
9
0
&
#
(
$
&
$
"
01
' (*
#
4$
#
(
?
3
(
(#
#
A
1
0
#
#
$ " 01
&
#
,
&
"
,
&
&
-
$ '
)A0 *
#
5
6 01
6 #
5
6 01
@
?
#
#
&
01
01
&
$
&
#
#
&
?
01
#
&
$
#
&
&
#
&
5 9
0-
$
4
#
#
#
)01
#
&
*
#
$
#
)
01
& #
(
*$
:
#
#
#
#
&
$
#
#
#
)
*=
-
#
-
#
)
-
)
). 3 *
<*
*
). 3 *
&
; 46 )
D 6 )3 3*; 3 46 )3 3*; 3. 6 )3
-
'
-
*
)< C*
#
*; 4 6 )E <*;
,'
6
)
)
<*
#
&
&
$ "
&
#
&
$
& &
3
#
&
$
E*
;$ 5 8
5
*5
Monitoring House
Regime Ref No.
8
9
4
5 5
Power
source
electric
Calgon Dosing Trial
Building use
Make
Model
A
Indigenous
Household
Hardie Dux
50V1-36B
B
Non-Indigenous
household
Hardie Dux
HDE 80V
C
Non-Indigenous
household
Ha die Dux Forte
125F1-36
D
Indigenous
household
Ha die Dux Proflo
50V1-38C
E
Community
facility
Har ie Dux Proflo
160F-136
F
Community
facility
H rdie Dux Forte
50V1-36B
G
Indigenous
household
Solahart
unreadable
H
Indigenous
household
Solahart
31748
electric
electric
electric
electric
solar
Additional systems monitored
under ‘Control’ Trial
James Hardie
160F-136
J
Indigenous
Household
Solahart
Not recorded
K
Indigenous
Household
James Hardie
Not recorded
L
Indigenous
Household
James Hardie
Not recorded
M
Indigenous
Household
Rheem
101 Series
N
Indigenous
Household
Solahart
Not recorded
01
solar
3.6
50
3.6
80
3.6
125
3.6
55
3.6
164
3.6
50
2.4
200
2.4
200
3.6
160
3.6
200
3.6
25
3.6
25
3.6
50
3.6
200
electric
Non-Indigenous
temporary accom
#
element Capacity
kW rating
(L)
electric
I
>&
4
#
solar
electric
electric
electric
solar
#
$
#
#
-
&
$
#
#
& #
#
( $ >
#
#
$ "
#
&"
#
$
$
9
#
)>
& E$. (
*$
#
(
#
,
$
( ,
!4 5
"; 4
0
2 87
5
#
#
&
$< (
4
48
#
9
,
*5
5
$ !
#
)>
E
#*$
!4 5 &;
= 7>
=
>
8
44
9
-
4
< 848
4
48 64
84
#
#
&
&&
8
5
$
&
$
-
!4
8
8
-
$'
#
5
#
4 4
#
&
$
4
#
(
#
A0
#
$ "
#
#
&
#
&
#
#
$
' #
,
&
&
-
-
#
#
$ '
01
#
$
#
&
#
-
#
#
01
#
$
&
#
#
$ 0
#
&
&
>
&
#
&
F
#
&
$
#
4$
#
#
$
#
D5
3 5 4 3C5 <5 .
#
#
@
#
#
<5
335 .
&
35 45 $
35 45
#
45 .5 $
&
$
&)
5
0
#
&
$ @
#
#
&
#
&
#
#
$
#
$
3$
#
#
#
(
#
$
$
#
#
#
,
)>
<*$ "
#
&
#
#
#
$
E$ :
&
#
5
&
#
$
<$ A
4$ @
#
#
#
#
##
$
$
.$ /
#
) &
# &
.
&
#
#
#
$ 0
,
;
*$
#
#
,
#
$
&
&
#
&
(
!4 5
7 7
&+
);
4
4 4
8
5
'4 4 4
) 5
(6*$
<
78
78
8
01
&
#
#
$ @
&
&
#
01
4
9
$
#
#
)
*
&
#
E
<$ ' #
#
#
#
#
$
&
&
#
#
8
9
?
01
& #
(
#
9
( $ >
9
#
0
&
&
$
#
01
&
&
(
#
$
& &
#
9
,
#
#
#
$
%&
8
9
# ,
)0
$
-
3; 6
0
3C4 *
#
$ A-
8
9
#
#
$ 0
#
&
)
(
*
# $ '
-
#
#
-
&
$ 1 # &
#
#
#
$
#
#
&
8
)
*#
<,
#
9
$
#
#
-
$ 1 # &
$
&
#
&
(
& &
& & $ >
&
#
#
(
#
>
4$ ' #
#
$
#
#
&
(
#
@
($
5-
#
&
#
&
'
&
#
-
3 $4 *$
#
(
-
!4 5
+; :
9
7
8
54
7 4
6
$
8
5
"
4
48
#
& #
#
#
(
-
$ 7
(
#
A
#
#
$
<4
&
#
#
$
4K )
>
& $
#
$
#
)N $4( *
#
#
&
$
)
'
)
7 44
#
$
#
#
-
$
#
$
#
#
01
*
)
4
& #
#
#
#
&
(
)
*$
#
#
-
-
"; 5 5
54
0
E 5 .5 4
7
1
4
6
$ #
$
7 4
4 <8
$ #
D5
3 54
4
7 4
4 7 4
3C5 <5 .
#
8
<5
335 .
35 45
&
7
3.3
")
4 6*
!)
D 6*
7)
4 6*
A)
3.<6*
>)
4 6*
%)
6*
1)
6*
')
3. 6*
F)
6*
I)
46*
6)
46*
)
4 6*
)
6*
)!76 O !
45 .5
) *
CE
43
3
4
9
6
3D
3
.C
E4
4
<
.3
34
.
4<
.
3
C
<D
.D
E
CD
4
DC
<
.
3E
3
3
334
E
0
!76
0
!76
3.
3
3
7
7
!76
!76
7
7
7
7
4
4
!76
#
7O
0O
!76
*
#
$
-
#
$
3E
&
4 6
#
. ,C
$
#
( 3D
$
&
01
#
&
-
-
#
& ,#
4
)
&
$ >
.
(
07O3E *
#
#
#
$
#
#
#
#
#
#
01
#
$
&
$
160
NO Calgon, 5 weeks
Calgon, 2 years
140
mass (g)
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
electric,
50L
electric,
80L
electric,
55L
electric,
164L
electric,
50L
electric,
50L
solar,
200L
solar,
200L
solar,
200L
solar,
200L
Type of hot water system and capacity
!4 5
5
,;
7 4
$ #
4
7 4
8
<
44
7
01
&
$ '
# ,
& ,#
#
4
)>
<4
.
(
#
4
E*$ "
#
-
#
$
&;
7 4
9
5 5
7 4
4
48
:
$ #
#
,0
&+
$ 4
4 6
.3
34
$ 4
D 6
.
3
$
446
.D
E
$<4
3.<6
DC
4
4
4
= 9>
4 6
.
3E
E
4 6
)"
$ C
$ D
4
$
5
"
&
#
#
&
#
7
# ,
&
#
#
OE.*$ "&
#
$ "&
#
#
)
&
#
&
3 65
)0AO<
O3 *$ '
#
&
(
# #
#
#
'
$
#
#
#
-
&
#
#
&
$
#
#
&
$ 7
#
*$ 7
#
3
E<65
01
#
&
#
65
)0AO
O.*$
01
D 65
#
3 65
)0AO
#
#
3
#
#
#
O
O .* #
&
#
$ 1
)0AO
# ,
#
CE 65
0AO3
#
$ "
#
1
E<65
#
B
&
#
>
#
#
$
#
&
4
4
#
#
#
#
)0AOEC
&
3
65
)0AO.4
O<*
#
#
$
O.*
250
Average hot water use (L/day)
225
200
175
150
125
100
75
50
25
el
ec
tr
ic
,5
0L
el
ec
tr
ic
,8
0L
el
ec
tr
ic
,5
el
5L
ec
tr
ic
,1
64
el
L
ec
tr
ic
,5
el
0L
ec
tr
ic
,5
0L
so
*
la
r,
20
0L
so
*
la
r,
20
0L
*
so
la
r,
20
0L
so
la
r,
20
0L
0
!4 5 -; 6
*5
5
8
5
98 5 8
8
5 49<?5 " + @ ?5 " - % 8
A< 8
6 5 47
4 7
0
#
9
=4
9 4
8
#
7
9>
&
#
$ >
&
01
#
(
#
&
0
#
#
-
$
&
#
$ @
#
#
>
&
D$ % &
#
$ 1 # &
#
#
#
#
#
$ '
#
#
#
&
&
&
&
##
$
"
&
#
#
E< 65
#
&
#
4 65
< 65
)6
@
"
#
&
3E.6
$
CD(6 &
*$
# ,
3<
65
#
#
Average water use in electric hot
water systems (L/day)
50
40
30
20
10
0
Jun05-Dec05 Dec05-Apr06 Apr06-Nov06 Dec06-May07
May07June07*
Period
!4 5
7 4
.;
< 54
#
6
8
8
8
8
5
4 4
4
&
#
#
(
#
#
$
57
9
#
# ,
$
$
&
#
#
(
&
*)
#
A
) $ $
0
&
#
<*$ >
#
&
#
$
&
#
&
$
&
&
#
$
"
)
*#
#
$
4
#
#
&
A
#
&
)&
54
7 4
")B
&
"+B ,B"
" B +B"
B"
,
.B )B"
"
-
85 8
,
74
+
4
.B "B"
9
5
+
57
154 4
& B ,B"
);
$ 5
&
!
&
7
&
A
>
%
1
J
residential
M
residential
N
residential
))
6
)
9
(
#
*
4
#
#
(
#
(
&
$
&
$
'
5
(6
#
#
#
#
#
#
?
#
$
&
&
$
-
#
>
#
3 $ 7
>
C
01
$
@
&
#
&
&
#
#
?
##
4#
1
(
01
$
&
$
01
$ 7
.
# ,
)>
33*$ '
01
#
( 3D
&
#
$
60
6
40
4
2
20
0
0
60
6
40
4
2
20
0
0
14
100
80
8
60
6
40
4
2
20
0
0
7 44
4
8
5
120
12
Cumulative hot
water use (kL)
Household D
10
8
Household E
Ew
60
6
40
4
2
20
0
0
Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun05
05
05
06
06
06
06
07
07
8
29
100
80
Es
Date
54
100
80
Date
Ds
0;
Bs
Date
Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun05
05
05
06
06
06
06
07
07
Date
!4 5
8
Household B
Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun05
05
05
06
06
06
06 07
07
Dw
10
Bw
Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun05
05
05 06
06
06
06 07
07
120
12
10
Cumulative scale
accretion (g)
80
Ascale
14
Cumulative hot
water use (kL)
12
120
4 4 <8 5 8
2
=
4
>
Cumulative scale
accretion (g)
8
100
Cumulative hot
water use (kL)
10
Household A
Awater
14
Cumulative scale
accretion (g)
12
120
Cumulative scale
accretion (g)
Cumulative hot
water use (kL)
14
10
Fs
8
6
4
2
0
120
12
10
Mw
8
Ms
Household M
40
4
2
20
0
0
Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun05
05
05
06
06
06
06
07
07
Date
Date
7 44
4
8
C54
84 8
:4 5
5 5 4
5
6 5
8
8 5 8 5 8
4
80
60
6
Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun- Sep- Dec- Mar- Jun05
05
05
06
06
06
06
07
07
!4 5
;
85 8
!
9
5
100
Cumulative scale
accretion (g)
Household F
Fw
14
Cumulative hot
water use (kL)
12
170
150
130
110
90
70
50
30
10
-10
Cumulative scale
accretion (g)
Cumulative hot
water use (kL)
14
4 <8 5 8
!
8
=
9
4
4
>
7
8
8
8 7
5
!
"#
$#
0
#
#
%&
'
4 6
"
.
)
#
D 6
#
#
!
* #
1
#
4$E(6$
(
#
,
A
C
#
#
"
!
<(6$
<$D(6
334 $ 1 # &
4K
$
#
7
*#
)
-3E$4(6
>)
&
# &
4 6
3<,3C65
*
#
>)
*#
?
3
?
3
7$
>
&
#
#
&
7
# ,
#
#
&
#
#
$
1
A
#
3.<6
$ 1
>
#
$ 1
#
#
F
A
>
4
7
.$ '
4 6
#
>
A$
4 K
3
3
&
>
#
3<(6 )>*
<(6 )A*$
#
#
$
>
#
#
-
(
&
#
#
&
#
(
-
$
#
$
#
7
A )<$D(6*
&
)334 *$
##
#
#
&
A
# ,
$
,
!
1
%)
#
.(6
"#
#
$#
& *#
#
&
#
#
#
%&
6
# ,
-
-
&
7
)3 *
$ 1
#
$
-
#
3
CC(6
3E$4(6
> #
>9 3.
1#
#
(
#
$
&
'
6
,
#
&
#
-
3 ,3
#
)3
*$
3
1#
#
#
& #
(
$
7
#
&
#
&
#
#
>
#
33 ): O $4.*$
total scale mass deposited (g)
180
160
140
R2 = 0.5654
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
total water consumption (kL)
!4 5
;
4
84
7
8
8
)$ $
#
&
5 74
7 4
8 9
8
#
&
48
*
$
!
)+
5 5
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
4
"
%&
#
-
&
$ >
3
#
#
#
#
#
$
#
#
#
#
$ :
#
#
&
#
$ 0
#
#
-
#
$
180
A
B
D
E
F
G (solar)
H (solar)
M
160
cumulative scale deposition (g)
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
cumulative hot water use (kL)
!4 5
9
"; 5 5
4
4
6
8
7 44
4 "9
8
5
4
88
4
#
"
#
#
#
$ "
(
)3
6*
#
&
#
01
&
$
&
#
#
$
01
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
>
'
(
& ,#
#
)>
3E
#
#
# ,
(
01
*$
&
#
#
#
&
#
#
&
01
#
& #
#
#
$
01
&
01
)>
3<*$
&
#
#
3C 5
(6 )07O3D
#
3 5
(6 )07OE.
3 65
)07OC
O
O
01
*$
&
O.*$ @
*
#
01
3 65
;
)07O3D
$
&
#
&
$ 1 # &
&
+
#
#
#
01
$
O.*
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
60
H
140
Dosing
50
Control
hot w ater use, Dosing
120
hot w ater use, Control
H
40
H denotes
100
statistical
significance
80
H
30
H
60
20
Hot water use (kL)
scale accumulation rate per kilolitre of water
heated (g/kL)
160
40
10
20
el
ec
tri
c,
50
L
L
el
ec
tri
c
,1
64
el
ec
tri
c,
55
L
el
ec
tri
c,
80
L
el
ec
tri
c,
50
L
0
el
ec
tri
c,
50
L
0
Hot water system type and capacity
!4 5
&; 6
9
5 5
4
5 5 4
= B '>
8
48
4
62
9
6
4 4
7
8
498
8
5
29
8
4
7
4
4
8
rate of scale accumulation (g/kL) and hot water use (L/day)
!
"#
$#
#
#
100
%&
'
(
average scale
accumulation rate
90
average hot water use
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Calgon, 690 days, n=20
!4 5
); 6
5 < 48
48 5
7
No Calgon, 35 days, n=6
4
6
4
5 5
4
+
+
7 44
@
#
&
&
01
#
#
#
&
<4
< , .
5
6$
5
6
#
)
&
(6
#
*
#
$
A
"
#
&
#
01
*
#
-
*
#
-
&
3
&
4< $
# ,
)
)
4K
$.,3E$4(6 &
#
$
#
#
$
&
#
&
#
!
&
$
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
&
&
'
(
#
$
#
,
(
$ $
#
4
#
P 1 # &
$
$
%
A
#
#
$ "
&
#
#
$
#
#
34
#
!
#
#
$ 1 # &
)>
(#
)3 *$
-
(#
&
E*$
$
#
(
$
'
#
(
?
#
$
&
( ,
#
)>
#
34*$
#
#
#
-
)>
3.*$ '
#
#
#
##
#
"
@
*$ '
#
#
)6
-
$ 0
#
(
#
#
&
&
!
!4 5
9
8
+; 4
6
8
;
"#
2 87
4 5
<
$ 7
&
$#
48
#
9
44
&
7
#
%&
'
(
< 48 644
7 4 644
4
74
,
#
(
#
!4 5
?
,;$ 5 8
7
4
4
4
34
8
974 4 <7
8 4
$
9
49 5
8
4
9
5
8 8
4 <5
C5
9
7
#
4,4
# ,
)
$
. ,D ° *
!
"#
-
$#
#
#
&
C4K
°
3
%&
'
01
4,E K
)0
(
C ,
+
*
01
$ 0
#
#
#
#
-
&
#
&
&
&
#
. ,D °
#
E K
$
01
&
&
#
&
#
$
&
!
@
)0
+
*
01
#
$
4
#
#
#
#
#$
#
#
4 6
#
& $
&
$ "
&
4$E
3E$4(6
#
# ,
#
#
&
$
4K
$ '
#
#
#
+;D 9
$
5 5
4
6
#
29
4 4
48
1
"
) 5
(6*
E
) *
#
"&
1
# &
&
7
#
4$
)65
)6*
*
D
4
7
EE
C
C
CD
E$C
3 $
<
3
.
4
3.<
D
7 4
= B '>
9
!
.
)(6*
#
#
A
E
>
3E
334
3.
<$
3E$
C3
4
$.
3.
4
4
!
"#
$#
#
%&
#
%&
#
'
(
#
#
+$
#
)
*
#
3.<6
6
)
*$ !
&
E465
1$
&
3<65
3.<6
#
<$D65
6
%
#
#
;
#
$ '
#
&
&
&
6 #
$
#
&
(
$
#
#
;"
@
-E*
'
&
#
01
,
01
&
#
#
$
&
&
#
&
&
)<,3. 65
*
#
$
#
#
,
&
,
#,
01
$
#
-
#
)0
$
3 ,
3*
#
#
5
6
)1
:
&
#
3C<4*$ 6 #
#
&
01
#
) $ $
#
$ '
$
$
&
#
&
+
01
$
#
)0
*
$
!
"#
01
$#
#
#
%&
#
&
-
'
(
&
-
70
01
&
&
01
#
$
#
$ 6 #
&
-
$ >
#
&
#
&
#
$
+"
'4
49
5 5
4
(
-
#
#
#
&
*$
)
#
-
$ 1 # &
&
&
8
9
&
$ ' #
8#
#
9
#
1 # &
(
#
$
#
8
9
#
&
8
9
)>
3 *$
#
#
#
&
$ '
#
'
(
#
#
#
,
$
#
#
&
#
$
&
#
#
#
(
#
$
&
#
&
&
#
&
&
$
1 # &
&
#
!
"#
$#
#
#
#
#
8
%&
'
(
9
,
#
$
!4 5
-;'
7 4
8
+&
E
F
8 8
$ #
7 4
8 4 4
44 44
8
9
<8 5 8 8
4
6
7
&
&
01
&
$ 1 # &
&
#
&
01
#
&
$
)$ $
#
*
&
#
&
&
$
#
Q
01
$
#
&
-
01
-
70
#
01
&
01
&
&
#
01
#
$
!
'
#
"#
$#
&
#
#
%&
'
01
#
&
#
&
$
&
01
#
=
3$
$
#
(
(
#
#
)
*
E$
#
(
&
&
#
#
(
<$ #
;
01
(
$
#
$
A
A&
&
-
#
$
(
!
,
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
3 '
,
&
8
&
?
)01
*$
&
&
$
#
&
*
9
?
#
&
=
&
*
&
,
#
,"
$
4 44
#
#
1
&
$
#
-
#
)
&
1
'
#
$ 3CD ;
1
0
&
*
#
&
&
$
#
#
&
)
#
5
(
?
#
,&
4 9
&
$ >
$
45
(
(
*#
#
#
#
$ 7
& ,#
#
(
$
&
#
$
-
-
(
&
&
$ 1 # &
&
&
#
$
!
,)
"#
7
5 5
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
4
&
&
-
&
=
•
8# 9
)
#
#
*
•
#
#
#
•
) &
&
#
#
& *
#
(
$
(
#
(
#
$
$
,+
8
(
-
(
&
#
&
$
#
#
$
&
&
0
5
#
&
$
&
)
#
(
#
&
$
*
,
$
&
(
$
,,
#
4
4
$ #
>
#
#
01
$ 1 # &
&
#
&
#
$ 1 # &
01
#
#
$
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
(
#
#
5
#
(
&
$ ' #
&
#
#
#
,-
'
4
6
$
4
%&
01
&
#
$
(
#
=
3$ >
$
&
&
E$ 7
#
01
&
#
&
;
&
#
#
$
"
&
&
#
01
$ 1 # &
?
#
#
#
#
$
'
#
"
$
&
#
&
&
&
#
$
!
,.
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
5 74
'(
"
#
&
$ "
&
#
$
"
+
<
#
$ "
&
#
#
#
"
$
#
R4
*
#
,
"
&
#
)
)
RE4
)E
*
(
#
#
*)
-<*$ >
#
&
#
#
&
$
#
#
#
$ 01
#
&
&
#
01
$
' #
&
&
$
&
#
#
(
#
$
' #
#
?
$ "
&
,
&
.
#
(
$
"#
#
4
5
6)
*#
$ "
&
4
#
#
&
(
&
5
6#
#
-
&
-
$ '
$
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
)
&
&
#
-
.$
?
! 45
(
#
(
&
$ '
#
&
) $ $
#
$
#
(
,
?
5
&
&
*
&
&
<
J
&
,
$
6
4
6
4
#
&
&
, (
&
$
#
#
#
&
#
$ A
#
#
#
)
$
?
&
J
*
& ,
&
#
&
#
#
&
<
$
$ #
01
4
&
&
$
' #
#
&
#
#
&
#
#
#
&
&
(
& ,
#
#
$
#
8
$ '
9
&
!
,;(54 4
6
5 74
*
*
*
*
*
"#
5 74
"
"
"
"
@
4
94
&
1
"
3$3
1
3$
1
#
>
%&
'
8
(
4
&
&
#
5
6)
*$
(
#
$
F 85 8
7
#
#
E
! 45
4 7
#
&
3$E
#
<
&
&
4
& #
*
$#
&
&
(
#
$
?
#
,
#
,
#
,
#
&
&
4"
7
"
#
6
1
#
&
4
6
&
85 8
4
$
4 7
&
&
(
$3
&
&
&
&
#
$
$
#
#
#
$E
1
#
)#
$<
&
*
# &
&
?
#
&
&
&
&
4&
$ #
44
4 7
(#
577 9
7
01
#
4
8 5 8
5 49
$ 1
&
&
&
"
(
E$3
&
&
#
E$
01
#
01
E$E
#
&
&
$
#
&
&
&
*
)
$
!
,0
"#
6 5 4
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
4
*( "
?
&
)"
& ,
-<*$
01
#
$
&
&
& ,
$
(
$
& ,
#
#
-
E K )
RE.
R3
&
*
&
&
$
$ "&
#
#
R
-
$
1 # &
#
-
#
-
$
(
&
$
&
&
01
#
R
R44
4
$ 1 # &
#
&
&
#
&
#
&
&
-
01
&
#
?
#
#
$ '
#
#
01
&
01
'
&
8
&
$
$
01
9
!
-;
4
:7
" ' "6
A
3
$#
#
8
45
#
%&
'
(
4
! 45
#
6
4
4
6
4
0 0
1 #
6 )< S R4
R
-4
#
)< S RE
R
*
R
,
R
3
R
,
*
J
)< S R
R
<
R
D
R
<
R
<
R
D
R
<
R
<
R
D
R
<
*
-4
&
)< S R
*
-4
1
J
)< S R
*
-4
)R
-4
#
)R4
R
,
R
<
R
,
*
R
&
-4
4
R
4
R
4
*
0
)R4
R
-4
A&
33
-
$<(@
1
"#
R
,
R
,
R
R
,
R
,
R
4
*
7
R4 5
-4
0/!
"6
6"! /:
)S
*
R
44
R
D
R
3 E
R
4
3C
4
0 0
)
4
R
E3 4
<
R
3
R
3 D
R
3 3
R
4D 4
R
3
R
3
-<
S R 45 -4
*
&
)R3$
( -. ( 5 -4
*
)
D
5
-R
-# 5
-4
*
0/!
"6 6
0 0/
R
R
<
,
3
C
<
R
<
C3
":
' +2*
6
R
$
5 4
R
44
R
3 E
R
R
G
3
C
&+-<
0
R
G
3 3 <
"-)<
-)
R
G
G
- <
+.
G
+)<
0).
G
3C
4
C3
"-,<
,
++<
&"
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
%(
&
&
$
&
>
&
#
3D$
&
&
#
#
&
#
-
&
>
(
$
-
(
#
#
(,
#
#
-
,
(
&
$
$300,000
Capital
External labour
$250,000
Value ($)
Local labour
$200,000
$150,000
$100,000
$50,000
$Failure management
Preventive
maintenance
Calgon Treatment
Hard water management scenario
!4 5
.; 4 4 5 4
>
46
4
>
-
#
-
&
#
&
#
01
#
$
#
?
&
$
&
-
($
!
"#
$#
&
&
#
&
,
&
4K
-
(
(
#
$
)
#
$ 01
-
'
&
& &
&
%&
&
#
*
#
&
?
01
#
#
R.
-
RE
$
#
&
&
?
,
,
#
D
$ '
-
&
&
$
& #
&
$
>
&
$
&
&
#
(
&
$
&
&
(
(
)
*
#
&
#
(
&
#
#
$
#
&
(
&
-
01
$
$
&
01
&
$ 1 # &
(
#
$
"
&
#
&
&
#
01
#
!
"#
$#
&
#
#
$
%&
'
(
&
&
&
#
$
.; 5
9 8
4
4
! 45
1
44
#
•
4
8
8
6
7 7
4
6
8
4
$ #
•
•
#
•
:
•
:
#
#
#
•
(
)
:
*
#
•
(
•
'
#
•
:
•
6(
#
•
A0
#
#
&
6(
&
&
&
#
#
•
6
?
#
(
•
4 9
1
•
T#
#
T
•
•
/
)
•
• /
01
*
4
•
/
,
• /
#
&
#
•
• /
)
,
*
#
(
+
%&
#
#
$
&
&
#
&
&
(
#
01
&
!
"#
#
&
$#
#
#
&
-
'
(
#
&
"
%&
&
$
&
-
#
#
&
$
#
#
01
&
# ,
-
& $
#
&
&
&
-
R34
$
#
$400,000
$375,000
Failure management
$350,000
Preventive maintenance
$325,000
Calgon Treatment
$300,000
$275,000
Cost ($)
$250,000
$225,000
$200,000
$175,000
$150,000
$125,000
$100,000
$75,000
$50,000
$25,000
$1
2
3
Failure frequency of key household infrastructure (years)
!4 5
6 5
&
0;
44
649
6 9
94
98 5 8
4
8
9
45
<
&
&
&
H
4
6 9
&
#
& ,
7
7
&
$
&
5 5
C5
4
&
&
$
!
"#
*
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
,)-
'
&
-
01
#
#
3)
E
*
#
&
$ %&
(
01
01
, , &
#
#
01
&
$
01
#
#
$
Failure management
$400,000
Preventive maintenance
$375,000
Calgon Treatment
$350,000
$325,000
$300,000
$275,000
Cost ($)
$250,000
$225,000
$200,000
$175,000
$150,000
$125,000
$100,000
$75,000
$50,000
$25,000
$1/5 years
1/3 years
1/2 years
Replacem ent frequency for hot w ater system s under SHMP use
w hen com pared to annual failure rates
!4 5 " ;
54 8
8
9
>
$ #
9
4
4
7
&
#
#
5
C5
6 4
4
4
5
4 < 9
6 9 4
6<
01
&
#
&
&
#
#
&
01
01
$
#
>
#
#
#
#
&
&
&
&
01
& #
&
$
&
$ 7
01
01
>
&
!
"#
$#
#
#
#
#
%&
'
(
&
&
&
&
&
$
,
5
'
#
9
4
#
& 4
(
&
5
6
#
,
(
$
&
#
&
, (
&
(
$
#
#
&
(
' 01
$
&
&
#
&
&
01
&
&
&
#
#
$ 1 # &
#
01
(
#
,
#
#
#
$
&
(
$
01
$ 0
(
01
&
(
#
&
&
#
$ 1 # &
&
&
01
&
#
&
#
&
-
$ A&
01
&
&
$
#
&
#
$ "
#
&
&
(
&
(
#
&
&
&
&
($
!
&
"#
$#
$ /
&
&
%&
&
#
&
&
&
$ "
&
&
#
&
$
#
&
&
#
&
#
'
&
$ '
,
#
01
&
&
#
&
(
$
(
!
-
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
'
3$ Q
#
#
01
$ @
(
$
&
#
01
)
*
&
&
#
$
01
&
&
&
#
&
&
,
(
#
#
-
#
#
#
#
#
01
$ 1 # &
&
-
#
&
&
$ :
&
#
$ @
&
01
&
&
1
#&
#
$
E$ 01
&
&
&
#
) -
*
<$ "
$
01
#
,
# $ 0
#
#
01
#
#
$
4$ "
01
#
#
&
#
#
$
#
(
(
# $
01
#
.$ "
&
#
$
01
#
-
4,4
#
(
!
"#
$#
&
01
#
&
&
#
#
#
#
&
%&
'
(
#
?
#
$
$ "
&
01
&
#
#
&
#
&
$
D$
&
&
&
01
#
& #
&
#
-
& ,
&
#
&
#
#
#
C$ '
$
&
#
&
#
$ '
&
&
#
01
#
&
&
&
&
#
$
#
&
&
&
$
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
.
3$ % &
&
&
&
$ 6
&
&
#
$
'
&
&
#
#
&
#
$
E$ % &
&
&
)
#
:
"
'
*
#
1
,
$
(
&
&
&
&
#
&
&
# $
<$ % &
#
#
,
#
&
(
&
4$
#
$
"
&
#
$
.$
01
#
&
=
•
&
•
#
5
#
#
#
•
&
#
•
#
#
&
•
01
&
•
&
•
-
$
(
!
0
!
"#
!
$#
$
#
#
%&
'
(
$
&
&
•
7
•
@
$
=
#
) $
P*P
E$.(@
&
$<(@
P "
E$.(@
,#
$ 1 # &
&
&
&
$ 0
#
#
•
#
$
&
#
) $ $
#
(
#
#
#
#
. U*
(
(
$
(
,
#
&
#
&
$
#
#
#
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
!
ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics). 2001. Housing and Infrastructure in Aboriginal
and Torres Strait Islander Communities. In Australian Bureau of Statistics on
behalf of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission: Australian
Government, Canberra.
ACC (American Chemistry Council). 2004. The Use of Phosphates for Potable Water
Treatment: Phosphate Forum of the Americas.
Anghileri, L. J. 1964. Hydrolysis of sodium polymetaphosphate and sodium
pyrophosphate under the influence of temperature and pH. The International
Journal of Applied Radiation and Isotopes 15 (9):549-551.
BOM (Bureau of Meteorology). 2005. Monthly Rainfall Data Summary: Mt Allan
Station No 15565, 1969-2005.
Boulton, AJ , and MA Brock. 1999. Australian Freshwater Ecology: processes and
management. Glen Osmond, SA: Gleneagles Publishing.
Cantor, A. F., D. Denig-Chakroff, R. R. Vela, M. G. Oleinik, and D. L. Lynch. 2000.
Use of polyphosphate in corrosion control. Journal American Water Works
Association 92 (2):95-102.
DLPE (Department of Lands Planning and Environment). 1998. Water Chemistry
Laboratory Report, Yuelamu/Mt Allan Production Bore 21/01/98. Darwin:
Northern Territory Government.
Ebrahimi-mehr, M., T. Shahrabi, and M. G. Hosseini. 2004. Determination of suitable
corrosion inhibitor formulation for a potable water supply. Anti-Corrosion
Methods and Materials 51 (6):399-405.
Edwards, M., L. Hidmi, and D. Gladwell. 2002. Phosphate inhibition of soluble
copper corrosion by-product release. Corrosion Science 44 (5):1057-1071.
Edwards, M., and L. S. McNeill. 2002. Effect of phosphate inhibitors on lead release
from pipes. Journal American Water Works Association 94 (1):79-+.
Edwards, Marc, Loay Hidmi, and Dawn Gladwell. 2001. Phosphate inhibition of
soluble copper corrosion by-product release. Corrosion Science 44 (5):10571071.
FaCSIA (Families Community Services and Indigenous Affairs). 2007. National
Indigenous Housing Guide: Australian Government, Canberra.
Hatch, G.B. , and O. Rice. 1945. Corrosion control with threshold treatment.
Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 37 (8):752-59.
Hostetler, S, J Wischusen, and G Jacobson. 1998. Western Water Study (Wiluraratja
Kapi) - Groundwater Quality in the Papunya-Kintore region, Northern
Territory: Australian Geological Survey Organisation (AGSO).
Lehrman, L., and L. Shuldener. 1952. Action of Sodium Silicate as a Corrosion
Inhibitor in Water Piping. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 44 (8).
Lloyd, B., L. Wilson, and A. Adams. 2000. Hot Water Use and Water Heating
Systems in Remote Indigenous Communities. Alice Springs: Centre for
Appropriate Technology.
Marshall, G. 1999. A Review of Scale Prevention Devices for Use in Hot Water
Systems in Remote Indigenous Communities. Alice Springs: Centre for
Appropriate Technology.
McElroy, Sister M. K., J. F. Hazel, and W. M. McNabb. 1965. Reactions between
iron (III) ions and glassy polyphosphates. Journal of Inorganic and Nuclear
Chemistry 27 (4):859-866.
!
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
McNeill, L. S., and M. Edwards. 2000. Phosphate inhibitors and red water in stagnant
iron pipes. Journal of Environmental Engineering-Asce 126 (12):1096-1102.
———. 2002. Phosphate inhibitor use at US utilities. Journal American Water Works
Association 94 (7):57-63.
Mercer, K. L. , Y. Lin, and P.C. Singer. 2005. Enhancing calcium carbonate
precipitation by heterogeneous nucleation during chemical softening. Journal
American Water Works Association 97 (12):116.
Nganampa Health Council Inc. 1987. Report of Uwankara Palyanyku Kanyintjaku
(UPK Report) - An Environmental and Public Health Review within the
Anangu Pitjantjara Lands: A cooperative initiative by the Nganampa Health
Council Inc., South Australian Health Commission and Aboriginal Health
Organisation of SA.
NHMRC (National Health and Medical Research Council) & NRMMC (Natural
Resource Management Ministerial Council). 2004. Australian Drinking Water
Guidelines: Commonwealth Government of Australia.
PWC (PowerWater Corporation). 2005. Water Quality Report. Darwin: Power and
Water Corporation, Northern Territory.
SA Water. 2005. Sustainability Report. Adelaide: SA Water and South Australian
Government.
Sarin, P, V.L. Snoeyink, J. Bebee, W.M. Kriven, and J.A. Clement. 2001. Physicochemical characteristics of corrosion scales in old iron pipes. Water Research
35 (12).
Shafizadeh, Arash. . 2007. Telephone conversation. Water Treatment Chemist,
WA Water Corporation. Perth, 23 January.
Stover, Frederick S. 1997. Capillary electrophoresis of longer-chain polyphosphates.
Journal of Chromatography A 769 (2):349-351.
Territory Health Services. 2002. The Northern Territory Public Health Bush Book
2nd ed: Northern Territory Government.
USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency). 2004. Lead and Copper
Rule Reference Guide: Office for Water, United States Government.
Water Corporation Western Australia (WCWA). 2006. Drinking Water Quality
Annual Report 2005-2006. Perth: Water Corporation, Western Australia.
WHO (World Health Organisation). 2006a. Final Statement of WHO Meeting of
Experts on the Possible Protective Effect of Hard Water Against
Cardiovascular Disease, 27-28 April 2006. Washington DC, USA.
———. 2006b. Nutrients in Drinking Water. Geneva: World Health Organisation.
WU (Wageningen University). Food-Info.net 2006 [cited 28 January 2006]
Available from http://www.food-info.net/uk/e/e452.htm.
!
##
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
!
77
4
: ;
5 94
"#
$#
#
#
%&
'
(
44
8 47
I
J
*5
5
=
-
)
*
$
!
(
1
=
#
"
&
$
#
@
"
$
#
(
,#
$
$
3$ 7
#
-
#
$
$ 0
$
E$ 0
&
)
4*
#
#
)
* &
#
&
$
<$
(
#
$
4$ @
&
#
#
&
,#
$ '
#
$
.$ @
&
(
$
#
-
#
$ 7
&
,
$ @
$
(
#
&
)
$
)
*
!
D$
-
#
"#
$#
#
#
#
%&
#
$
#
#
?
,
#
#
$
#
#
#
&
#
(
.
$
C$
'
$
)
!
77
4
:";*5
5
5
6 7
=#% <"
"#
C5 49 8
$#
4
#
7 44
#
%&
'
= '# < 00.>
)>
)
(
!
*5
#
5(
%
5
"#
8
7
4
"
4 9=
$#
>
<
#
7 64
#
%&
'
(
9
)
Element
Abbreviation
Total Dissolved Solids
Silver - Filterable
Silver - Total
Aluminium - Filterable
Aluminium - Total
Arsenic - Filterable
Arsenic - Total
Boron - Filterable
Boron - Total
Barium - Filterable
Barium - Total
Beryllium - Filterable
Beryllium - Total
Bromine - Filterable
Bromine - Total
Cadmium - Filterable
Cadmium - Total
Chromium - Filterable
Chromium - Total
Copper - Filterable
Copper - Total
Iron - Filterable
Iron - Total
Iron - Total
Mercury - Filterable
Mercury - Total
Iodine - Filterable
Iodine - Total
Manganese - Filterable
Manganese - Total
Molybdenum - Filterable
Molybdenum - Total
Nickel - Filterable
Nickel - Total
Lead - Filterable
Lead - Total
Antimony - Filterable
Antimony - Total
Selenium - Filterable
Selenium - Total
Tin - Filterable
Tin - Total
Uranium - Filterable
Uranium - Total
Zinc - Filterable
Zinc - Total
TDS
500-1000
mg/L
Ag_F
100
µg/L
Ag_T
100
µg/L
Al_F
200
µg/L
Al_T
200
µg/L
As_F
7
µg/L
As_T
7
µg/L
B_F
4000
µg/L
B_T
4000
µg/L
Ba_F
700
µg/L
Ba_T
700
µg/L
Be_F
NGV
µg/L
Be_T
NGV
µg/L
Br_F
NGV
µg/L
Br_T
NGV
µg/L
Cd_F
2
µg/L
Cd_T
2
µg/L
Cr_F
50
µg/L
Cr_T
50
µg/L
Cu_F
2000
µg/L
Cu_T
2000
µg/L
Fe_F
300
µg/L
Fe_T
300
µg/L
Fe_T
0.3
mg/L
Hg_F
1
µg/L
Hg_T
1
µg/L
I_F
100
µg/L
I_T
100
µg/L
Mn_F
500
µg/L
Mn_T
500
µg/L
Mo_F
50
µg/L
Mo_T
50
µg/L
Ni_F
20
µg/L
Ni_T
20
µg/L
Pb_F
10
µg/L
Pb_T
10
µg/L
Sb_F
3
µg/L
Sb_T
3
µg/L
Se_F
10
µg/L
Se_T
10
µg/L
Sn_F
NGV
µg/L
Sn_T
NGV
µg/L
U_F
20
µg/L
U_T
20
µg/L
Zn_F
3000
µg/L
Zn_T
3000
µg/L
denotes drinking water guideline exceedence.
ADWG
Units
Yuelamu bore 2004
2600
<10
<10
<20
<20
3
3.5
760
800
<50
<50
<1
<1
2820
3830
<0.2
<0.2
<5
<5
10
10
20
40
-<0.1
<0.1
830
320
5
5
10
15
<2
<2
1
2
<0.2
<0.2
13
15
<10
<10
177
201
210
220
)
&
77
4
:&;%
4 4
577 4
%
4
5
7
8:
4
5
78 78
2'
9
8
44
)
4
&
4
6
$
3
7
A
! =
="
0
=
7
@
= 3D5 <5
:& #
+
.
! =
=%
"
=
7
=
6
$
1
5
#
#
&
$
@
#
#
#
#
"
#
#
$
#
(
$
C54
7
"
C54
7
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
0
#
3 4
>
•
•
7
1
"
A
Q
)#
$
3 *
( 4
( 3
)7:6" %A 1" 1 3
*
$<4
""
&
#
&
)6
#
*
5
7
4
0
$"
-
(
3 6
$
6
$
E
&"
#
7
7
-
4
$
3$
&
3
"
3
& #
#
&&
#
$
6&
3
(
5
6
$
44
0
4A
$4 3$
( #
3$4
$
<
5
6
6
$
(
$"
(
(
$
&&
>
44
(
0
0
&
>
) 6*
) 6*
3
(&
)
5
6*
<
<
$
E
<
$<
3$
<
<
$.
3$4
4
<
$D
$
!
$4
#
4
4
$@
6
3 4
:
6
$
4
4
6
#3 4
$>
6
6
E$E$ $
$
<
&&"
44
"
4
7
)
5
"
4
>
5
6*
)
>
/*
)
)
/*
5
6*
)
5
6*
$4
3$
3$4
$
)
5
#
#
$
6
$
4
77
7
4
:);
"
4 4
4
6 "
-
8
9
74
"
&