!"#"$%&!'$()*'+,)&-&!'$()*'+,)&./0&1"#"$%
2',)'%%"&34"5'5"
6/$.,0,$*,&20/*,,("$%)
71/0,$*,8&7,409'0:-;9$,&<=><
!"#$%&'()*+(,-%.$#"(-/ (0.1#$23&4($'(564(7-"'5859:;
<<<'="#$%&'$+>(?(@AAB(:65;C9DD;
!.-E++F2$G3(=%1"23*+F(2$(HE>-1+.(59:;
?/(:8&30*@"5,*590,8&'$(&6"5:
I2#$E#."-(!#1#
J+=#.>&+$>(-/ (K.E*2>+E>%.+4(0$27+.32>L(-/ (M"-.+$E+(N@>#"LO
JLDQFDUORSDED#XQLÀLW
@$(>*23(=#=+.(3-&+(.+"#>2-$3*2=3(1+><++$(1-FL4(#.E*2>+E>%.+4(#$F(>*+(E2>L(#.+(#$#"LP+F'()*+(1-FL(23(*23>-.2E#""L(#(.+/+C
.+$E+(/-.(>*+(&+#3%.+&+$>3(-/ (#.E*2>+E>%.#"(#$F(%.1#$(3=#E+4(/.-&(Q2>.%72#$(&#$(>-(R+(S-.1%32+.T3(&-F%"-.'()*+(#%C
>*-.(>*2$U3(>*#>(#""(="%.#"(#$F(F2//+.+$>(1-F2+34(*%&#$(#$F($-$C*%&#$4(3*-%"F(1+(>*+(.+/+.+$E+(/-.(="#$$2$G4(.+G#.F"+33(
-/ (G+$F+.4(.#E+4(=.-=-.>2-$34(#12"2>2+34(#$F("2/+3>L"+(E*#.#E>+.3'
!"#$"%&'()*$(+ $,)-"%'#-'.)#$,/0$-%'*$%&$-1(&#1*$1%/2#0$'($'"#$"%&'()*$(+ $'"#$3(0*4$!"#$%0#,$'",'$'"#$".5,/$
3(0*$%&$'"#$)#+#)#/-#$+()$'"#$()6,/%7,'%(/$(+ $&8,-#9$+)(5$8%11,)$'($"(.&#9$3.%10%/6$'($-%'*9$6,)0#/$'($'#))%'()*9$
",&$5#,&.)#0$".5,/$"%&'()*$%/$0%++#)#/'$:,*&$(;#)$'%5#$,/0$&8,-#$<&(5#'%5#&$'"#$,/%5,1$3(0*$%&$,1&($,$
'#)5$(+ $-(58,)%&(/9$+()$'"#$'.)'1#=&",8#0$+()')#&&$(+ $>,&&(-();,)(9$+()$#?,581#9$()$+()$'"#$@(;#)/5#/'$
(+ $>.0,/A&$)#-#/'$-%'*$81,/&$:%'"$'"#$/#%6"3(.)"((0&$%/$'"#$&",8#$(+ $,$)"%/(-#)(&B4
!"#$#?,581#&$-(.10$3#$#/01#&&9$+)(5$'"#$0),:%/6&$(+ $C),/-#&-($0%$@%()6%($D,)'%/%$'($'"#$,/'")(8(5()8"%-$
E88#)$F(1',$"(.&#&9$'"#$G(6(/$;%11,6#$5,8$%/$D,1%$<,&$)#-(/&').-'#0$3*$H6('#55#1%$+()$$D,)-#1$@)%,.1#B$
'($'"#$&'.0%#&$(+ $H&2,)$>-"1#55#)9$.8$'($'"#$'"(.&,/0&$(+ $()6,/%-$,/0$3(0%1*$5#',8"()&$'",'$",;#$8(8.1,=
'#0$'"#$"%&'()*$(+ $,)-"%'#-'.)#$,/0$81,//%/64$I;#/$%/$5(0#)/$.)3,/%&59$)#+#)#/-#&$'($'"#$3(0*9$,/0$5#0%-,1$
,/0$"#,1'"$,/,1(6%#&$%/$6#/#),19$,)#$+)#J.#/'4$K,)'),5$,/0$>"(3)((2$-1,%5$'",'$'"#$LMNOP&$;%&%(/$(+ $.)3,/$
K)%',%/$:,&$)#+),-'#0$'")(.6"$'"#$+()5$,/0$-(/'#/'$(+ $5#0%-,1$%5,6#)*$,/0$)"#'()%-Q$<K,)'),5$R$>"(3)(=
(29$SPPM9$84$MMNB4$!"#$"(1%&'%-$;%&%(/$(+ $,/,'(5*$,/0$8"*&%(1(6*$8)(;%0#0$,$)#+#)#/-#$5(0#1$+()$'"#$%0#,&$
(+ $-(58)#"#/&%;#$81,//%/64$!"#$81,/$(+ $T1*5(.'"$%/$MNOU9$+()$#?,581#9$0#&%6/#0$3*$T,')%-2$V3#)-)(53%#9$
%&$3.%1'$,)(./0$,$3(0%1*$%0#,$(+ $'"#$-%'*4$!"#$3(53%/6$",0$:(./0#0$'"#$.)3,/$()6,/%&5$,/0$"#,1%/6$'"#$-%'*$
-#/')#$:(.10$,11(:9$,--()0%/6$V3#)-)(53%#9$'"#$-)#,'%(/$(+ $,$L;%)%1#$W#6%(/,1$-,8%',1Q$<-%'#0$%/$K,)'),5$R$
6KREURRNS7KHFHQWHULVOLNHQHGWRWKHKHDUWWKHWUDIÀFÁRZVWKURXJKDUWHULHVDQGWKHPDS
(+ $T1*5(.'"$L)#;#,1&$'"#$-%'*$-#/')#$,&$%+ $1*%/6$8)(&'),'#$(/$,$&.)6#(/A&$',31#9$&')#'-"#0$+)(5$1%53$'($1%53Q$
<%3%0#5B4$>(5#'%5#&9$,/0$%/$)#-#/'$'%5#&$5()#$,/0$5()#$+)#J.#/'1*9$'"#$()6,/%-$5#',8"()$%&$.&#0$%/$'"#$
QHJDWLYH(OLHO6DDULQHQIRUH[DPSOHLQ7KH&LW\GLGDFWLFDOO\XVHGWZRLPDJHVWKHÀUVWLVWKDWRI DKHDOWK\
'%&&.#9$5#,/%/6$,/$()6,/%7#0$,/0$+./-'%(/%/6$-%'*X$'"#$&#-(/0$%&$),'"#)$,$0%&#,&#0$'%&&.#9$),;,6#0$3*$'.5(.)$
-#11&Y$
L0#-1%/#$,/0$0#,'"$#/'#)$Z[\$/($5,''#)$:"#'"#)$%'$",88#/&$%/$'"#$5%-)(&-(8%-$'%&&.#&$(+ $-#11=&').-'.)#$:"#)#$-,/-#)$
-,.&#&$0%&%/'#6),'%(/9$()$%/$'"#$"#,)'&$(+ $'"#$1,)6#$-%'%#&$(+ $'(0,*$:"#)#$-(58,-'/#&&$,/0$-(/+.&%(/$-,.&#$&1.5&$'($
&8)#,0Q$<>,,)%/#/9$MNOU9$84$M]B4
K('"$5,1#$,/0$+#5,1#$3(0%#&$,)#$)#1,'#0$'($&8,-#$<,1'"(.6"$5.-"$5()#$(+'#/$'"#$+()5#)BY$'"#$3.%10%/6$5,=
'#)%,1&9$,)-"%'#-'.),1$5(/.5#/'&9$-%'*$,/0$5#')(8(1%&$,)#$(+'#/$1%/2#0$'($'"#$5,1#$3(0*9$:"%1#$'"#$"(5#9$6,)=
0#/9$1,/0&-,8#$,/0$,6)%-.1'.),1$1,/0$,)#$5()#$+)#J.#/'1*$-(//#-'#0$'($'"#$+#5,1#$3(0*$<V22#)5,/9$SPP^B4
!"#)#$%&9$"(:#;#)9$,1&($,$"#)5,8")(0%'#$3(0*$%/$'"#$"%&'()*$(+ $,)-"%'#-'.)#9$,/0$%'$%&$,/$%/'#)#&'%/6$,/0$
8,),0%65,'%-$-,&#Y$,'$'"#$MNSN$W.&&%&-"#$V.&&'#11./6$%/$_.)%-"9$,&$'"#$'%'1#$&,*&9$,/$#?"%3%'%(/$(+ $W.&&%,/$
,)-"%'#-'.)#9$'"#)#$:,&$,$8(&'#)$3*$I1$`%&&%'72*$)#8)#&#/'%/6$'"#$+,-#&$(+ $,$6%)1$,/0$,$3(*$5#)6#0$'(6#'"#)$
:%'"$'")##$#*#&$%/&'#,0$(+ $+(.)$<'"#$-#/'),1$#*#$3#1(/6%/6$'($3('"$&%0#&B9$,&$,/$%-(/$(+ $,$/#:$"#)5,8")(0%'#$
".5,/%'*$'",'$:(.10$(;#)-(5#$,11$+()5&$(+ $#?81(%','%(/$,/0$-)#,'#$8#)+#-'$#J.,1%'*4$V/$%0#,$(+ $#J.,1%'*$
3,&#0$(/$#1%5%/,'%/6$0%++#)#/-#&$'",'$'(0,*$-(/'),0%-'&$,$;%&%(/$(+ $'"#$-%'*$+(./0#09$(/$'"#$-(/'),)*9$(/$'"#$
8)(5('%(/$(+ $0%;#)&%'*$,/0$(88()'./%'%#&$(+ $)#,1%7,'%(/$'",'$/##0$'($3#$(++#)#0$'($'"#$5.1'%81%-%'*$(+ $3('"$
".5,/$,/0$/(/=".5,/$.)3,/$3(0%#&$<T,3,9$SPMPX$T#))(/#9$SPMPX$T,3,$R$T#))(/#9$SPMMB4
a/$-(/'#58(),)*$,)'9$'"#$)#1,'%(/&"%8$3#':##/$3(0*9$"(5#$,/0$-%'*$",&$81,*#0$,$5,b()$)(1#9$8,)'%-.1,)1*$%/$
'"#$:()2&$(+ $:(5#/Y$+()$#?,581#9$%/$'"#$+#55#=5,%&(/$(+ $`(.%&#$K(.)6#(%&$()$'"#$:,12%/6$"(.&#&$(+ $
`,.)%#$>%55(/&4$V/0$'"#/$%/$c1,.0#$c,"./$:"($0#8%-'#0$"#)$3(0*$%/$'"#$%/'#)%()$(+ $,$"(.&#$()$#;#/$%/&%0#$
,$8%#-#$(+ $+.)/%'.)#9$()$c%/0*$>"#)5,/$:"($8"('(6),8"&$"#)&#1+ $'($0#&-)%3#$'"#$0%++#)#/'$5#')(8(1%',/$
1,/0&-,8#&9$()$I0:,)0$d(88#)$:"($8()'),*#0$:(5#/A&$3(0%#&$%/$"(.&#&$()$"('#1$)((5&9$'($#?81,%/$'"#$
,'5(&8"#)#$,/0$+.)/%&"%/6&$&'*1#&9$()$F,1%#$I?8()'$:"($.&#&$"#)$3(0*$,&$,$2%/0$(+ $:,12%/6$5(0.1()$'($
5#,&.)#$.)3,/$&8,-#&9$()$@,3)%#1#$K,&%1%-($:"(9$%/$'"#$&#)%#&$-,11#0$c(/',-'$MNeO9$-(58,)#&$'"#$0%++#)#/'$
'#?'.)#&$,/0$5,'#)%,1&$(+ $-",%)&$'")(.6"$'"#$'),-2&$1#+'$(/$,$:(5,/A&$3.''(-2&4
!"#$ )#+#)#/-#$ '($ '"#$ ".5,/$ 3(0*$ ,&$ ,/$ %/&8%),'%(/$ +()$ ,)-"%'#-'.)#$ %&$ &'%11$ ,1%;#$ '(0,*9$ ,&$ %/$ '"#$ -,&#$ (+ $
c,1,'),;,A&$!.)/%/6$!()&($f$'"#$/,5#$(+ $'"#$d>K$&2*&-),8#)$%/$D,15g$=$:"%-"$%&$,$'),/&1,'%(/$(+ $,/$,)-"%=
'#-'.),1$&-.18'.)#$3*$'"#$&,5#$c,1,'),;,9$'"#$!:%&'%/6$!()&(Y$%/$'"%&$-,&#$'"#$5(;#5#/'$(+ $'"#$".5,/$3(0*$
<5,1#$(/-#$,6,%/B$%/&8%)#&$'"#$0*/,5%-$'()&%(/$(+ $'"#$3.%10%/64$V/0$:"%1#$c1,.0#=h%-(1,&$`#0(.?$-(/-#,1#0$
2 | 59
Planum. The Journal of Urbanism | Conference Proceedings
!"#$!%%&'"()*)()+')"&+",$)"#%!+"-* "!"./&%0&+1"2,$)"3456"7!&8-+"0/"#%!&8&(9"'!%%)0":&;)<!=9">)!+"?-/@)%"!+0"
?-(<!+"A-8,)("8$-B"&,")C#%&'&,%D9"/+!8$!<)0%D9"&+",$)"E1.!(",-B)("&+"F!(')%-+!"!+0",$)"GB&88"H)",-B)("&+"
I-+0-+J"I!8,%D9",$)()"!()",B-".--;8"&+"#!(,&'/%!("K"0))<"&<#-(,!+,",-"<)+,&-+"&+",$)"()%!,&-+8$&#".),B))+"
ERG\DQGDUFKLWHFWXUH7KHÀUVWLV7KH'DQFLQJ&ROXPQE\-RVHSK5\NZHUWLQZKLFKWKHLQÀQLWHYDULDWLRQV
-* "!('$&,)',/(!%"'!+-+8"!()"!+!%DL)0"&+"()%!,&-+",-",$)".-0&)8"-* "<)+"!+0"<!%)"!+0"*)<!%)"1-08"2,$)"K-+&'"
'-%/<+8=9"!+0")@)+"<!8;89"$-(+89")D)89"8;&+"!+0".-+)89"1&(%8"!+0".-D89"!+0"<),!#$-(&'"!+&<!%89"&+"!"%-+1"
M-/(+)D",$(-/1$",$)"')+,/(&)8"!+0"'/%,/(!%",(!0&,&-+8"2HDNB)(,9"366O=J
P$)"8)'-+0".--;"&8"A%)8$"!+0"G,-+)".D"H&'$!(0"G)++),,9"B$&'$"()'-+8,(/',8"!"$&8,-(&'!%"1)+)!%-1D"-* ",$)"
UHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHERG\RUUDWKHUÁHVKDQGFLWLHV,QSDUWLFXODU6HQQHWWGLUHFWO\UHODWHVQXGLW\RI DUQ
'$&,)',/()"B&,$"+!;)0+)88"-* ",$)".-0D9")8#)'&!%%D"&+",$)"R());"'&@&%&L!,&-+J"K+"!"'$!#,)(")+,&,%)0"?!;)0+)889"
G)++),,"()'!%%8",$)"'%-8)"%&+;".),B))+",$)"2<!%)=".-0D9"0)<-'(!'D"!+0",$)"'&,D"&+",$)"E,$)+8"-* "S)(&'%)8T"
´7R WKH DQFLHQW $WKHQLDQ GLVSOD\LQJ RQHVHOI DIÀUPHG RQH·V GLJQLW\ DV D FLWL]HQ $WKHQLDQ GHPRFUDF\ SODFHG JUHDW
)<#$!8&8"-+"&,8"'&,&L)+8")C#-8&+1",$)&(",$-/1$,8",-"-,$)(89"M/8,"!8"<)+")C#-8)0",$)&(".-0&)8J"P$)8)"</,/!%"!',8"-* "0&Q
8'%-8/()"B)()"<)!+,",-"0(!B",$)";+-,".),B))+"'&,&L)+8")@)(",&1$,)(J"U)"<&1$,"'!%%",$)";+-,",-0!D"V<!%)".-+0&+1WX",$)"
E,$)+&!+8",--;",$&8".-+0"%&,)(!%%DJ"K+"!+'&)+,"R());9",$)"@)(D"B-(08"/8)0",-")C#()88")(-,&'"%-@)"-* "!+-,$)("<!+"'-/%0"
.)"/8)0",-")C#()88"-+)Y8"!,,!'$<)+,",-",$)"'&,DJ"E"#-%&,&'&!+"B!+,)0",-"!##)!("%&;)"!"%-@)("-("!"B!((&-(JW"
2G)++),,9"366Z9"#J"[[=J
P$)")C#-8/()"-* ",$)"+!;)0".-0D"2#()0-<&+!+,%D"<!%)="V#/,8"&,8"8,!<#"-+",$)"8,-+)8"-* "E,$)+8W9"!+0",$)"
'&,D"#(-/0%D"0&8#%!D8",$)"'-(()8#-+0&+1"+/0&,D"-* "!('$&,)',/()T"VS)(&;%)8"')%).(!,)0"!+"E,$)+8"&+"B$&'$"$!(Q
PRQ\VHHPHGWRUHLJQEHWZHHQÁHVKDQGVWRQHµ6HQQHWWS,ZLOOQRZFRQVLGHUÀYHQDNHGERGLHV
,$!,"!()"&<#-(,!+,"*-("!('$&,)',/()"!+0",$)"'&,DJ"K,"&8"%&,,%)"<-()",$!+"!"#(),)C,9"!%<-8,"M/8,"!"%-1&'!%",$()!0"&+"
-(0)(",-"'!((D",$(-/1$",$)"()!8-+&+19"0)@)%-#&+1"-+"8-<)"-* "<D"#()@&-/8"B-(;"2S!.!9"\]3]=J
7KHÀUVWWZRLPDJHVDUHYHU\IDPRXVWKH9LWUXYLDQ0DQE\/HRQDUGRGD9LQFL\RXFDQVHHLWRQWKHRQH
)/(-"'-&+="!+0",$)"7-0/%-(".D"I)"^-(./8&)("2KY0"8/11)8,"1-&+1",-"%--;"!,"-+)"-* ",$)"<!+D"#()%&<&+!(D"0(!Q
B&+189"&+"B$&'$"&,"!##)!(8"#()'&8)%D"!8"!"8)C)0"<!%)".-0D=J"K* "!('$&,)',/()"!+0",$)"'&,D"!()"<!+Q<!0)9"+-,"!8"
!"$/<!+"#(-0/',"&+"1)+)(!%9"./,"!8"!(,)*!',8"0)8&1+)0"*-%%-B&+1",$)"<)!8/()<)+,8"-* ",$)"<!%)".-0D9",$)8)"
!()",$)",B-"#&',/()8",$!,"&,"&8"+-(<!%9"#)($!#8")@)+".!+!%9",-"%--;"!,J"I)-+!(0-Y8"0(!B&+19")+0%)88%D"!+!%D8)0"
!+0"()#(-0/')09"0)8)(@)8"8-<)"*/(,$)("'-+8&0)(!,&-+J"I)-+!(0-"$!8",(!+8%!,)0"&+,-"!+"&<!1)",$)"_&,(/@&!+"
0)8'(&#,&-+"-* ",$)"&0)!%"#(-#-(,&-+8"-* ",$)"$/<!+".-0D9",!;)+"!8"!"<)!8/()"-* "!('$&,)',/()"2!+0"!%%",$&+18=J"
7!%@&+!" F-(1$)(&+&" !+!%D8)0" $&8" <-0)" -* " ,(!+8#-8&,&-+" !+0" ,$)" '-+'%/8&-+" &8" 8&<#%)T" I)-+!(0-" 0&0" +-,"
()8#)',",$)"<)!8/()8"'-+,!&+)0"&+",$)"P()!,D"-* "_&,(/@&/8J"K+"#!(,&'/%!("_&,(/@&/8"B(-,)",$!,",$)"(!,&-"-* "
,$)"$)!0"2<)!8/()0"*(-<",$)".!8)"-* ",$)"+)';",-",$)"$!&(%&+)=",-",$)"$)&1$,"-* ",$)"<!+"8$-/%0".)"!"N/!(,)(9"
!+0"&+"I)-+!(0-Y8"0(!B&+19",$&8"(!,&-"&8"&+8,)!0"-+)T8&CJ"P$)"()!8-+"*-(",$&8".),(!D!%"&8"/+0)(8,!+0!.%)"&* "D-/"
%--;"!,",$)"0&1&,!%")%!.-(!,&-+"()#(-0/')0"&+"F-(1$)(&+&Y8"!(,&'%)T"&* "I)-+!(0-"$!0"()8#)',)0",$)"#(-#-(,&-+8"
1&@)+".D"_&,(/@&/89",$)"&0)!%"<!+"B-/%0"$!@)".))+")C,()<)%D"<!'(-')#$!%&'9"!%<-8,"!"*()!;"2F-(1$)(&+&9"
\]]69"##J"4]Q43=J"I)-+!(0-"B!8"&+8#&()09",$)()*-()9".D"$&8";+-B%)01)"-* "()!%"<!+9"!&0)0".D",$)"!.&%&,D"-* ",$)"
0)8&1+",-";))#",$)",$-/1$,"!+'$-()0",-"()!%&,DJ"`-/"'!+"8!D9"#!(!0-C&'!%%D9",$!,"I)-+!(0-Y8"_&,(/@&!+"#&',/()"
,)%%8"/8",$!,"&0)!%"<!+"a"#)(*)',"!+0")C!',%D"#(-#-(,&-+)0"a"0-)8"+-,"()!%%D")C&8,J"7!D.)"D-/"'!+"8!D",$!,"
,$)"&<#-(,!+')"-* ",$)"_&,(/@&!+"7!+".D"I)-+!(0-"0!"_&+'&"$!8".))+"-@)()<#$!8&L)09"B$&%)",$)",$-/8!+08"
-* "0(!B&+18"!+0"8;),'$)8".D"I)-+!(0-"8$-B)0"$&8"&+,)()8,"&+",$)"()!%".-0&)8"-* "B-<)+"!+0"<)+9"*/%%"-* "
0)*)',8"!+0"0)*-(<&,&)89"8&';9"V/1%DW9",(/%D"()!%J"P$)"%&,)(!,/()"-+",$)"7-0/%-(".D"I)"^-(./8&)("&8")+0%)88"
,--9"!+0"+-,"</'$"<-()"'!+".)"!00)0J"K,"&8"')(,!&+%D"!"<!%)".-0D"2)@)+",$-/1$",$)()"&8"!"*)<!%)"@)(8&-+9"8))"
b!(#)(9"\]33=9"!+0"I)"^-(./8&)("$&<8)%* "&8")C#%&'&,"&+",$&8"()1!(0J"G-"$)"B(-,)"&+"!"%),,)("-* "363[T"
´7KHQDNHGPDQIRUPHLVWKHPDQZKRKDVVXUPRXQWHGKLPVHOI «DFRPSOH[RI ÀUPDQGUHFWDQJXODUSODQHV7KHQDQ
;)0"<!+"*-("<)"&8"!('$&,)',/()J"U$)+"K"+-"%-+1)("<!;)"!('$&,)',/()9"K"8))")@)(D,$&+1"!8"B-<)+W"2'&,J"&+"b--#)("\]]\=J
Planum. The Journal of Urbanism | Conference Proceedings
3 | 59
!"#$%#&'"#('%%$)*+#"'#,+&-#"./"#".+#0',1*'2#3/%#'&+#'4 #".+#+*+5+&"%#'4 #/#(/2/,$65/"$78#*+"#1%#%/-#95/%71*$&+:#
;$%$'&#'4 #/27.$"+7"12+8#$&#3.$7.#(2'('2"$'&%#/&,#.15/&#&++,%#/((+/2#/)%"2/7"8#1&$4'25#/&,#%"/&,/2,$<+,=#>#
7'&7+("#"./"#72+/"+,#/#7/&'&8#2+(2',17+,#$&#/27.$"+7"12+#5/&1/*%=#?/&7+#@'%+-8#$&#".$%#2+6/2,8#/&/*-<+,#".+#
/27.$"+7"12/*#62/(.$7#%"/&,/2,%#./&,)''A%#$&#".+#B=C=8#7'5$&6#"'#".+#7'&7*1%$'&#"./"#".+#)',-#'4 #2+4+2+&7+#
$&#/&".2'('5+"2$7#,$/62/5%8#(2+,'5$&/&"*-#5/*+#/&,#3.$"+8#$%#7./2/7"+2$<+,#$&#"+25%#'4 #6+&,+2#/&,#2/7+#
D@'%+-#EFFGH=#!&#4/7"8#".$&6%#/2+#/#)$"#5'2+#&1/&7+,#$&#".$%#7/%+#"''=#!&#".+#2+7+&"*-#)++&#2+(1)*$%.+,#5/"+I
2$/*%#42'5#".+#7'&4+2+&7+#J.+#K$;$&+#L2'('2"$'&8#'26/&$<+,#)-#".+#9J2$+&&/*+#,$#0$*/&':#$&#GMNG#DO$5'*$#
P#!2/7+8#EFFQH8#".+#%(++7.#)-#?+#O'2)1%$+2#7'&7+2&%#(2+7$%+*-#".+#0',1*'2#/&,#$"#$%#;+2-#$&"+2+%"$&6=#!&#.$%#
ORQJSDSHUWKH0RGXORUEHFRPHVDÁH[LEOHIULHQGO\GRPHVWLFWRRO,QWKHVSHHFKDQGGUDZLQJVWKHUHDUH
7+2"/$&*-#".+#%"/&,/2,#%$<+%8#".+#R$)'&/77$#%+2$+%8#".+#%-%"+5#'4 #O.$&+%+#)'S+%#"./"#/**'3#1%#"'#5+/%12+#/&,#
,+%$6&#".+#3'2*,#%'#+S/7"*-8#$&#/#5/".+5/"$7/*#/&,#$&+S'2/)*+#3/-8#)1"#".+%+#/%(+7"%#/2+#(2+%+&"+,#3$".#%'5+#
1&,+2%"/"+5+&"=#9!#3$**#%(+/A#/%#/#72/4"%5/&:8#%'#)+6$&%#".+#%(++7.#'4 #O'2)1T#".+#0',1*'2#$%#/#%$5(*+#"''*8#
XVHIXODQGLPSHUIHFWOLNHDUDGLRZKLFK´KDVLWVIDGLQJLWVQRLVHLWVQRWVRZHOOGHÀQHGZDYHVµ
!#3'1*,8#".+2+4'2+8#*$A+#"'#"/A+#".$%#%$5(*+8#72/4"%5/&#?+#O'2)1%$+2#%+2$'1%*-8#/&,#2+5+5)+2#/&'".+2#&/A+,#
5/&#($7"12+#)-#?+#O'2)1%$+28#&'"#'4 #".+#0',1*'28#.'3+;+28#)1"#.$%#'3&#&/A+,#)',-=#U'1#7/&#%++#$"#'&#(/6+#
GQM#'4 #".+#)''A#J.+#C+S#/&,#>27.$"+7"12+8#$&#".+#+%%/-#)-#V+/"2$<#O'*'5$&/#DO'*'5$&/8#GMMWH=#O'*'5$&/#
$%#/&#$5('2"/&"#.$%"'2$/&#'4 #/27.$"+7"12+#/"#L2$&7+"'&#B&$;+2%$"-#3.'#./%#/&#'2$6$&/*8#1&7'&;+&"$'&/*#/&,#
7'5(+"+&"#/((2'/7.=
V+4'2+#2+"12&$&6#"'#?+#O'2)1%$+2X%#&/A+,#)',-8#!#3'1*,#*$A+#"'#Y1'"+#/&'".+2#(/(+2#)-#O'*'5$&/8#)+7/1%+#
$"%#%1)Z+7"#$%#*$&A+,#"'#%'5+#$%%1+%#/,,2+%%+,#)+*'3=#!"#$%#".+#+%%/-#O'**/)'2/"$'&%T#J.+#L2$;/"+#?$4+#'4 #0'I
,+2&#>27.$"+7"12+8#$&#3.$7.#O'*'5$&/#2+7'&%"217"%#".+#2'*+#"./"#%'5+#3'5+&#D(/2"&+2%8#7'I3'2A+2%8#3$;+%8#
*';+2%H#./;+#./,#$&#".+#3'2A#'4 #".+#62+/"+%"#/27.$"+7"%#'4 #".+#5',+2&#5';+5+&"T#?$**-#[+$7.#/&,#0$+%#;/&#
,+2#['.+8#?+#O'2)1%$+2#/&,#O./2*'""+#L+22$/&,8#>&&+#J-&6#/&,#?'1$%#\/.&8#O./2*+%#[+&&$+#0/7A$&"'%.#
/&,#0/26/2+"#07K'&/*,8#[/-#/&,#O./2*+%#]/5+%8#>*$%'&#/&,#L+"+2#C5$".%'&8#K+&$%+#C7'""#V2'3&#/&,#
[')+2"#^+&"12$#/&,#5/&-#'".+2#(/$2%#/"#3'2A#/&,#'4"+&#$&#*$4+#"''8#"'#3.$7.#!#3'1*,#/,,8#$&#".+#3'2*,#'4 #
(*/&&$&68#>&&/#0'2"'&8#_'2/.#`+,,+%8#a/Y1+*$&+#J-23.$""8#],$".#]*5+2#b'',#/&,#O/".+2$&+#V/1+2#$&#".+#
HQYLURQPHQWGRPLQDWHGE\WKHÀJXUHVRI 3DWULFN*HGGHVDQG/HZLV0XPIRUG
J.+%+#/2+#'4"+&#%"'2$+%#'4 #7*/&,+%"$&+#3'2A8#&+6*+7"+,#%A$**%8#%'5+"$5+%#%"'2$+%#'4 #%1)Z16/"$'&#/&,#(%-7.'I
*'6$7/*#;$'*+&7+8#)1"#O'*'5$&/#.$6.*$6."%#/&'".+2#$5('2"/&"#/%(+7"#'4 #".+%+#7'**/)'2/"$'&%T#%.+#+5(./%$<+%#
".+#$&"+2/7"$;+#&/"12+#'4 #".+#3'2A#'4 #,+%$6&#/&,#/27.$"+7"12+#1&,+2%"'',#/%#7'55'&#3'2A=#!&#/,,$"$'&8#
7'55'&#3'2A$&6#7/&#)+#+%(+7$/**-#(2',17"$;+#3.+&#5+&#/&,#3'5+&#/2+#(1"#"'6+".+28#(2+7$%+*-#)+7/1%+#'4 #
".+$2#,$;+2%$"-T#5+&#/&,#3'5+&#$&"+&,+,#/*5'%"#*$A+#,$44+2+&"#%(+7$+%8#7'5(/&$'&#%(+7$+%#D$&#".+#3'2,%#'4 #
K'&&/#@/2/3/-8#EFFcH#3.'%+#,$44+2+&7+%8#$&#7'**/)'2/"$'&8#7/&#6$;+#(2'4+%%$'&/*#(+24'25/&7+%#/#(/2"$71*/2#
SK\VLFDODQGPHQWDODJLOLW\VRDVWRRYHUFRPHWKHREVWDFOHVRI DGLIÀFXOWMREDQGJDLQDFRPSOHWHQHVVWKDW
/*'&+8#3'1*,#)+#1&/""/$&/)*+=
?+"X%#6'#)/7A#"'#?+#O'2)1%$+2=#J.+#($7"12+#/((+/2%#$&#/&#+%%/-#)-#O'*'5$&/#,+;'"+,#"'#".+#.'*$,/-#.'5+#
,+%$6&+,# )-# ]$*++&# `2/-8# )1$*"# $&# GMEWIEM# '&# ".+# 2'7A%# '4 # ['Y1+)21&+IO/(I0/2"$&8# )+"3++&# _$7+# /&,#
0+&"'&=#J.+#.'1%+#$%#/#5$%1&,+2%"'',#5/%"+2($+7+#'4 #2/"$'&/*$%"#/27.$"+7"12+8#/&,#)+4'2+#!#"/*A#/)'1"#"./"#
($7"12+#'4 #?+#O'2)1%$+2X%#&/A+,#)',-8#!#Z1%"#3/&"#"'#4'71%#5-#/""+&"$'&#'&#".$%#;$**/8#$&"+62/"$&6#".+#7'&I
%$,+2/"$'&%#'4 #O'*'5$&/#3$".#".+#/&/*-%$%#'4 #O/2'*$&+#O'&%"/&"#/&,#a/%5$&+#[/1*"=#O'&%"/&"#"/*A%#/)'1"#/#
9&'&I.+2'$7#5',+2&$%5:8#/#A$&,#'4 #"+5(+2+,#2/"$'&/*$%5=#J.+#.'1%+#$%#$&#4/7"#)1$*"#42'5#".+#$&%$,+8#%"/2"$&6#
42'5#".+#7'&72+"+#&++,%#'4 #*$4+8#/&,#".+#)',-T#
9`2/-#2+&,+2+,#".+#%1)Z+7"#/&#/7"$;+#/6+&"#$&#.+2#+&;$2'&5+&"8#4'27+41**-#%./($&6#".+#%(/7+#"'#2+7+$;+#.+28#5'2+#/#
(/2"$7$(/&"#"./&#/#5+2+#'771(/&"=#d===e#C.+#+&6/6+,#/**#'4 #".+#%+&%+%#"'#+&"2/&7+#".+#'771(/&"X%#7'&%7$'1%&+%%#'4 #)',$*-#
$55+2%$'&#$&#/#%+Y1+&7+#'4 #+S(+2$+&7+%:#
DO'&%"/&"8#EFFf8#((=#MfIGEWH=
4 | 59
Planum. The Journal of Urbanism | Conference Proceedings
!"#$#%&$'(()"*#$+,-&*$./$0)1)2,*'3$0)*4#'*#$'*5$6'"1#$7)("4&4$)*$#%&$%,4#)8/$)7 $4/2.)1,($'*5$2'#&8,'1$
-,)1&*(&3$9%,(%$:&$0)8."4,&8$;8'(#,(&5$'+',*4#$<8'/$'*5$%,4$%)2&=$>#$,4$'$4,&+&$#%'#$#))?$;1'(&$,*$4&-&8'1$4#'@
+&43$'4$#%)"+%$:&$0)8."4,&8$9)"15$%'-&$1,?&5$#)$&8'4&$#%&$)8,+,*'1,#/$)7 $#%&$'8(%,#&(#"8&A$#%&$()*4#8"(#,)*$)7 $
'*)#%&8$%)"4&$)*$#%&$4"88)"*5,*+$1'*53$#%&$()*4#8"(#,)*$)7 $#%&$0'.'*)*$'*5$&4;&(,'11/$#%&$5&(,4,)*$)7 $#%&$
)9*&8$B'*5$()@5&4,+*&8C$D&'*$!'5)-,(,3$78,&*5$'*5$;'8#*&8$)7 $<8'/3$#)$'11)9$:&$0)8."4,&8$#)$;',*#$2"8'14$
)*$&,+%#E*,*&$)7 $#%&$-,11'F4$9'114=$G,1&&*$<8'/3$9%)$9'4$'+',*4#$#%&$,*#&8-&*#,)*3$7&1#$#%&$'(#$)7 $:&$0)8."4,&8$
#)$.&$'$4/2.)1,($8';&$H$'$?,*5$)7 $,*-'4,)*$'*5$)((";'#,)*$)7 $#%&$%)"4&$H$'*5$'$2'#&8,'1$8';&$#))3$.&('"4&$
:&$0)8."4,&8F4$;,(#"8&4$()*#8'4#&5$4%'8;1/$9,#%$%&8$'8(%,#&(#"8'1$-,4,)*$#%'#$)*1/$#%&$9%,#&$9'114$()"15$4%)9=
0)1)2,*'$8&()*4#8"(#4$)#%&8$,2;)8#'*#$'4;&(#4$)7 $#%&$4#)8/3$9%,(%$>$2"4#$;)4#;)*&$.&('"4&$2/$;"8;)4&$
%&8&,*$,4$2)8&$1,2,#&5=$I%&$;%)#)$4%)94$:&$0)8."4,&8$9%,1&$;',*#,*+$#%&$9'114$)7 $<8'/F4$%)"4&A$,#$,4$#%&$
ERG\RI DPDQRI ÀIW\QDNHGZLWKWKHVLJQVRI OLIHOLYHGVRPHKHDYLQHVVWKLFNJODVVHV+HGRHVQRWKDYH
#%&$()2;1&J,)*$)7 $#%&$;'8'5,+2'#,($2)5"1)83$'*5$%,4$8,+%#$1&+$8&-&'14$'$1)*+$'*5$#&88,.1&$4('83$8&4"1#,*+$78)2$
#%&$,2;'(#$9,#%$'$.)'#$'#$4&'=$I%&$8&1'#,)*4%,;$)7 $:&$0)8."4,&8$9,#%$#%)4&$;1'(&4$B%)"4&3$#&88'(&43$8)(?43$4&'C$
9)"15$8&2',*$-&8/$4#8)*+=$K&$9)"15$)7#&*$8&#"8*$#)$#%)4&$;1'(&4$'*5$5,&$,*$#%&$9'#&84$#%&8&3$,*$LMNO3$78)2$
'$%&'8#$'##'(?$#%'#$4"8;8,4&5$%,2$5"8,*+$%,4$%'.,#"'1$49,2=
P&J#$#)$#%&$%)"4&3$'4$'$7"8#%&8$4&,Q"8&$)7 $#%&$#&88,#)8/3$:&$0)8."4,&8$.",1#$#%&$0'.'*)*3$'$4,2;1&$4%&53$42'11$
,*$4,Q&$BR=NN$./$R=NN$2&#&84C3$."#$'4$'(("8'#&$'*5$()2;1&#&$'4$#%&$2)4#$4#"5,&5$)7 $'8(%,#&(#"8&=$:&$0)8."4,&8$
.",1#$'$%)2&@*&4#$'8)"*5$%,4$;&84)*3$/&4$+&)2&#8,($'*5$8'#,)*'13$."#$9,#%$#%&$4'2&$,5&'$)7 $()*5&*4,*+$'11$
#%'#$,4$*&(&44'8/$#)$1,7&$'8)"*5$#%&$.)5/=$I%&$<8'/$-,11'$'*5$:&$0)8."4,&8F4$0'.'*)*$'8&$.)#%$'$?,*5$)7 $
.)5/@%)2&3$'#$#%&$4'2&$#,2&$5)2&4#,($'*5$8'#,)*'13$4&*4,#,-&$'*5$'(("8'#&=
S&#$#)$2&$#%'#$;%)#)$)7 $:&$0)8."4,&83$*'?&5$9%,1&$;',*#,*+$#%&$9'1143$4&&24$,2;)8#'*#A$#%,4$,2'+&$)7 $#%&$
0)8."F4$1,-&5@,*$.)5/3$*)#$#%&$T)5"1)83$,4$#%&$.)5/$#)$9%,(%$8&7&8&*(&$4%)"15$.&$2'5&$7)8$'*$,5&'$)7 $;1'*@
*,*+$#%'#$,4$4&*4,#,-&$#)$5,77&8&*(&43$#)$#%&$5,77&8&*#$4#)8,&4$)7 $2&*$'*5$9)2&*3$.)/4$'*5$+,8143$/)"*+$'*5$
)15=
I%&$4&()*5$*'?&5$.)5/$,4$#%'#$)7 $U8,&58,(%$V#)9'44&83$?*)9*$./$#%&$;4&"5)*/2$)7 $K"*5&8#9'44&83$'8#,4#$
'*5$.,)@'8(%,#&(#=$>*$#%,4$('4&$,#$,4$*)#$'$58'9,*+3$."#$;8&(,4&1/$%,4$"*(1)#%&5$.)5/$;%)#)+8';%&5$5"8,*+$#9)$
;&87)82'*(&4$#%'#$9&8&$%&15$,*$T"*,(%$'*5$W,&**'$,*$LMNXELMNY=$Z*$#%&4&$#9)$)(('4,)*4$K"*5&8#9'44&8$
;8)*)"*(&5$#%&$7'2)"4$[*'?&5$4;&&(%F$'+',*4#$8'#,)*'1,42$,*$'8(%,#&(#"8&3$'+',*4#$#%&$5&*"5'#,)*$)7 $'8(%,@
#&(#"8&$);&8'#&5$./$#%&$7"*(#,)*'1,4#$('*)*4=$I%&$'1#&8*'#,-&$;8);)4&5$./$K"*5&8#9'44&8$,4$&J;8&44&5$,*$#%&$
WKHRU\RI ÀYHVNLQVIURPWKHERG\WRWKHFRVPRVZHFDQVD\7KHÀUVWVNLQLVQDWXUDOO\WKHHSLGHUPLVWKDW
VXUURXQGVRXUERG\WKHÀUVWKRXVHZHOLYHLQWKHFORWKHVDUHWKHVHFRQGVNLQFRQVLGHUHGDVH[WHQVLRQVRI #%&$.)5/$B'*5$K"*5&8#9'44&8$'14)$5&4,+*&5$(1)#%&4$'*5$4%)&4$4",#'.1&$7)8$#%&$%&'1#%$)7 $#%&$.)5/C\$#%&$#%,85$
VNLQLVWKHKRXVHDQGLQWKH0XQLFKDQG9LHQQDVSHHFKHV´WKHÀUVWVNLQZDVODLGEDUHWREHWWHUSURFODLPWKH
8,+%#$#)$#%&$#%,85]3$#%&$8,+%#$#)$'$%)2&$*)$1)*+&8$4#8,;;&5$)7 $'11$)8*'2&*#3$'$1,-,*+$%)"4&3$5,8&(#1/$#8'*47)8@
2&5$./$#%&$,*%'.,#'*#4\$#%&$7)"8#%$4?,*$,4$('11&5$,5&*#,#/$'*5$,4$#%&$;1'(&$,*$9%,(%$7'2,1,&4$'*5$%)2&4$'8&$
FRQWDLQHGWKHQHLJKERUKRRGWKHFLW\ZKLOHWKHÀIWKVNLQLVWKHHDUWKWKHHQYLURQPHQWDQGQDWXUHWKH
&()1)+,('1$78'2&$,*$9%,(%$9&$1,-&=
>F2$*)#$'$#8"&$1)-&8$)7 $K"*5&8#9'44&8F4$;8)^&(#43$'*5$4)2&#,2&4$>$8&2',*$;&8;1&J&5$./$4)2&$)7 $%,4$'8(%,@
#&(#"8&4$9%,(%$4&&2$#))$;8)+8'22'#,('11/$()1)87"1$'*5$(%,15,4%$B'*53$2)8&)-&83$#%&$'8(%,#&(#"8&$9,#%)"#$
"**&(&44'8/$)8*'2&*#4$)7 $:))43$7)8$&J'2;1&3$.&1)*+4$#)$2/$;&84)*'1$;'*#%&)*C3$."#$#)5'/$%,4$2&44'+&$
('114$ 7)8$ 8&*&9&5$ ()*4,5&8'#,)*=$ >*$ #%)4&$ )15$ ;&87)82'*(&4$ '*5$ 2'*,7&4#)4$ #%&8&$ &2&8+&$ 4)2&$ 8&1&-'*#$
'*5$4#,11$("88&*#$#%&2&4A$#%&$2'*,7&4#)4$)*$#%&$_6,+%#$#)$`,*5)9]$'*5$)*$_I%&$I8&&$I&*'*#]$,*5,('#&$#%&$
SRVVLELOLW\IRUSHRSOHWRWUDQVIRUPWKHLURZQKRPHDQGÀOOLWZLWKJUHHQHU\DQGWUHHVWKHKRXVHRI +XQ@
5&8#9'44&8$.&,*+$()*(&,-&5$'4$'$*'#"8'1$'*5$-&+&#'1$2'(%,*&\$#%&$2'*,7&4#)4$)*$#%&$K"2"4$I),1&#$'*5$)*$
I%&$V'(8&5$V%,#$;)4&$#%&$;8).1&2$)7 $9'4#&$8&(/(1,*+$'*5$;8);)4&$'$2)8&$+&*&8'1$,5&'$)7 $)"8$8&1'#,)*4%,;$
ZLWKWKHHQYLURQPHQWWKHÀIWKVNLQ´6KLWLVRXUVRXO>@7KHIUDJUDQFHRI KXPXVLVKRO\DQGFORVHUWR
<)5$#%'*$#%'#$)7 $78'*?,*(&*4&=$a===b$I%&$42&11$)7 $%"2"4$,4$#%&$42&11$)7 $<)53$#%&$8&4"88&(#,)*$)7 $42&113$#%&$
Planum. The Journal of Urbanism | Conference Proceedings
5 | 59
!"#$$%&' %(""&)*+$(*,-%.')&"%/0#%1+2)#3%10(*4%2(*5%(6%7#!*+6,%899:4%;5%<9=5%>+6,%2&6*#";&)+),%#?;#)(#62#!%
&' %@)##6%AB($3(6@%+63%A(&C;$+66(6@%0+D#%+%'&)#)B66#)%(6%EB63#)*F+!!#)5%G*%(!%(";&)*+6*%*&%6&*#%*0#%B!#%
&' %*0#%A&3,%+!%+%"#+6!%&' %3(!!#"(6+*(6@%(3#+!%+63%;)&H#2*!4%')&"%*0#%"#6*(&6#3%I6+J#3%!;##20#!-%*&%*0#%
#6D()&6"#6*+$%A&3,%+)*%.'&)%#?+";$#4%*)##!%;$+6*#3%(6%*0#%F(63&F!%+63%!*)##*!%&' %>($+6%(6%:KL<=4%+63%*0#%
3#"&6!*)+*(&6%&' %0&F%#+!,%(*%(!%*&%B!#%+63%*)+6!;&)*%*0#%0B"B!%*&($#*%.,&B%2+6%!##%EB63#)*F+!!#)%!(**(6@%
3&F64%A+)#'&&*4%+$"&!*%(6%+2*(&64%&6%*0#%!;#2(+$%*&($#*%!#+*%!*)B2*B)#%.7#!*+6,4%899:4%;5%LK=5
/0#%*0()3%("+@#%(!%')&"%+%A&&J%A,%M+D(3%N)&B204%/0#%O)*%&' %O$$&*"#6*!4%;+@#%8:%.N)&B204%899L=5%G*%(!%+%
F&)J%&' %PB!*(6#%QB)$+634%+%R#F%S&)JCA+!#3%;0&*&@)+;0#)%F0&%0+!%(6D#!*(@+*#3%*0#%)#$+*(&6!0(;!%A#*F##6%
A&3(#!%+63%$+63!2+;#!5%G6%!&"#%!*B3(#!%.)#;)&3B2#3%(6%*0#%A&&J%T' %U&"+6%V&)6=%QB)$+63%0+!%2)#+*#3%("+C
@#!%&' %F&"#6W!%6+J#3%A&3(#!%.+63%#D#6%*0&!#%&' %20($3)#6%+63%'+"($(#!=%(6%"+6,%;+)*!%&' %*0#%X6(*#3%1*+*#!4%
#!;#2(+$$,%(6%6+*(&6+$%;+)J!4%A#+20#!4%2+";!4%(*(6#)+6*%!#**$#"#6*!%+63%+$*#)6+*(D#%2&""B6(*(#!5
/0#%;0&*&%(6%N)&B20W!%A&&J%;&)*)+,!%+%@)&B;%&' %F&"#6%F0&%@)&F%+%D#@#*+A$#%@+)3#6Y%6+J#3%A&3(#!4%6&)C
"+$4%ZB(#*4%&)3(6+),5%/0(!%(!%6&*%+6,*0(6@%#?2#;*(&6+$%+63%(63##3%*0#)#%+)#%"+6,%@)&B;!%*0+*%2&"A(6#%+@)(C
2B$*B)#%+63%6B3(!"4%@+)3#6(6@%+63%*0#%6+*B)+$6#!!%&' %(63(D(3B+$%+63%!&2(+$%A#0+D(&B)%[%R+J#3%\+)3#6(6@%(!%
+$!&%+%"&D#"#6*4%F(*0%&'*#6%D#),%2&""#)2(+$%(";$(2+*(&6!%.G%]%V%^&$$+)34%899L=5%M+D(3%N)&B20%+63%N&$(6%
U+)3%0+D#%2&63B2*#3%"+6,%!B)D#,!%&6%;#&;$#W!%!#$'C&)@+6(_+*(&6%*&%AB($3%+%!0#$*#)4%+%0&"#4%&)%*&%2B$*(D+*#%+%
;(#2#%&' %$+634%'&)%#?+";$#%(6%*0#%!"+$$%2$+!!(2%A&&J%N&**#)!%+63%1ZB+**#)!Y%/0#%E(33#6%E(!*&),%&' %E&B!(6@%
.N)&B20%]%U+)34%:KKL=4%(6%F0(20%*0#,%*),%*&%3#"&6!*)+*#%*0+*%(6%0B"+6%0(!*&),4%*0&!#%F0&%3&%6&*%0+D#%+%
0&"#%*),%*&%&A*+(6%(*%A,%+6,%"#+6!4%&'*#6%)#+$(_(6@%(*%F(*0%*0#()%&F6%0+63!5%G*%(!%)(@0*4%$+F'B$%*&%*+J#%*0#%;(#2#%
&' %*0#%F&)$3%F0(20%;#&;$#%6##3%*&%$(D#5
G6*#);$+,%A#*F##6%A&3,4%+@)(2B$*B)#%+63%$+63!2+;#%(!%&' %;+)*(2B$+)%(6*#)#!*%0#)#5%`)&"%*0#!#%)#;&)*!4%#?;#C
)("#6*!%+63%(66&D+*(&6!%2&"#%(6*&%A#(6@%(6%*0#%2(*(#!%+63%(6%*0#%2&B6*),!(3#4%')&"%2&""B6(*,%@+)3#6(6@%
*&%#3B2+*(&6+$%'+)"!4%')&"%O$_0#("#)%@+)3#6!%*&%*0#%*0#)+;#B*(2%B!#%&' %6+*B)#%+63%$+63!2+;#4%')&"%!20&&$%
@+)3#6(6@%;)+2*(2#!%*&%!#$'C"+6+@#3%B)A+6%)#'&)#!*+*(&65%/0(!%(!%6&*%!&"#*0(6@%6#F%(6%*0#%0(!*&),%&' %;$+6C
6(6@Y%G%$(J#%*&%&22+!(&6+$$,%$&&J%+*%*0#%;(2*B)#!%*0+*%!0&F%*0#%@)&B;%&' %F&"#6%+63%20($3)#6%)#&)@+6(_(6@%
F(*0%*0#()%&F6%0+63!%7+"!+,%\+)3#6%+63%P&06!*&6%/#))+2#%(6%*0#%6#(@0A&B)0&&3%&' %a3(6AB)@0%)#6&D+*#3%
B63#)%*0#%!B;#)D(!(&6%&' %^+*)(2J%\#33#!4%&)%*0#%("+@#!%&' %*0#%!"+$$%2&""B6(*,%*0+*%+B*&6&"&B!$,%"+6+C
@#!%*0#%(6*#)(&)%!;+2#!%&' %*0#%A$&2J!%&6%1B66,!(3#%\+)3#6!4%F0#)#%b#F(!%>B"'&)3%&62#%$(D#34%3#!(@6#3%A,%
1*#(6%+63%U)(@0*4%(6%*0#%&B*!J()*!%&' %%R#F%S&)J5%/0(!%)#6#F#3%)#$+*(&6!0(;%A#*F##6%A&3,%+63%$+63%.6+*B)#4%
+@)(2B$*B)#%+63%$+63!2+;#=%0+!%20+6@#3%(6%)#2#6*%,#+)!%&6%*0#%A+!(!%&' %@#63#)%3(''#)#62#!5%U&"#6%0+D#%
;$+,#3%+6%(";&)*+6*%)&$#%(6%*0#%0(!*&),%&' %+@)(2B$*B)#%.+63%*0#,%!*($$%0+D#%+6%(";&)*+6*%)&$#%(6%$#!!%3#D#$&;#3%
2&B6*)(#!=4%AB*%(6%*0#%(63B!*)(+$(_#3%+@)(2B$*B)+$%!,!*#"!%&' %U#!*#)6%2&B6*)(#!%*0#%#";$&,"#6*%&' %F&"#6%
0+!%3#2$(6#3%!0+);$,%(6%*0#%$+!*%3#2+3#!%+63%B)A+6%0&)*(2B$*B)#%F+!%+%;)#3&"(6+6*$,%"+$#%+2*(D(*,%*&&5%/&3+,%
F#%+)#%!##(6@%+%)#D#)!+$%&' %*0(!%*)#634%F(*0%+%@)&F*0%(6%'#"+$#%0&)*(2B$*B)#4%;+)*$,%3B#%*&%*0#%#2&6&"(2%2)(!(!4%
AB*%+$!&%3B#%*&%*0#%)&$#%*0+*%F&"#6%;$+,%(6%!&2(+$%)#$+*(&6!0(;!4%+!%+%$(6J%A#*F##6%;)&3B2*(&6%+63%)#;)&3B2C
*(&64%+63%A#*F##6%;)&3B2*(&6%+63%2&6!B";*(&65
/0#%+F+)#6#!!%&' %*0#%)#$+*(&6!0(;%A#*F##6%A&3,%+63%+@)(2B$*B)#4%+63%6B*)(*(&6%+63%0#+$*04%+!%F#$$%+!%+*C
*#6*(&6%*&%ZB+$(*,%"#+6%*0+*%F&"#6%+)#%*0#%;)&*+@&6(!*!%&' %*0#%#?;#)(#62#!%&' %+$*#)6+*(D#%+@)(2B$*B)#%+63%
2)(*(2+$%2&6!B";*(&64%')&"%&)@+6(2%'+)"(6@%@)&B;!%*&%H&(6*%;B)20+!(6@4%')&"%!&2(+$%'+)"!%*&%*0#%;)&"&*(&6%
&' %#3B2+*(&6+$%+63%;!,20&$&@(2+$%*0#)+;#B*(2%@+)3#6(6@%+2*(D(*(#!5%1B!+6%VB2J(6@0+"4%F(*0%)#'#)#62#%*&%*0#%
b&63&6%+)#+4%*+$J!%+A&B*%+%)#@#6.3=#)+*(&6%(6%*0#%!#$'C;)&3B2*(&6%&' %'&&34%+!%+%;)&2#!!%&' %)#@#6#)+*(&6%&' %
;)&?("(*,%+@)(2B$*B)#%+63%20+6@#%(6%'+)"(6@%;)+2*(2#!%3)(D#6%A,%F&"#6Y%$#!!%B!#%&' %'#)*($(_#)!4%2+)#'B$%20&(2#%
&' %2)&;!%+63%!##3!4%ZB#!*(&6(6@%&' %*0#%*)+3(*(&6+$%'&&3%2B$*B)#4%+63%6&*%$#+!*%+$!&%+%"&)#%!#6!(*(D#%#,#%*&%
DHVWKHWLFVLQWKHDUUDQJHPHQWDQGPDQDJHPHQWRI FXOWLYDWHGÀHOGV%XFNLQJKDP
6 | 59
Planum. The Journal of Urbanism | Conference Proceedings
!"#"$"%&"'
!""#$%&'(!)(*+,,-.(!"##$%$&$'()*%+),*-./&$%$'()$%)0$'(1!23#4)56$&2-276$.*&)839*%$-#)*-)*):$-'23()2; )02%-.$2/-%"--<)
/0%&'(12034#56(+7(*+.6(++78+9-)
:;$<=#$4'4(>)(*+,,7.((?/DOLQHDFKHGLVWLQJXHODÀJXUDGHOOLFRUSLHORUSDUWLFXOH@A(';2#(50B(345#<';(3#BBCD;%;(E42$08
E4&';(34(F#;'&$3;6(4'(G#$455&(H;$$4'4(!)6(#3)6(F#;'&$3;)(FC0;%;(E42$0E4&';(I$&(&$2#(#(5J4#'K&)(L#'#K4&6(
>&$54B4;)
:0J"4'<=&%(1)(*+,,9.(=2#"%)>?"@.2%-'3/.')'6")5&2'4)A6")?"B"%>+@"3*'$2%)2; )839*%)!22+)C32D$%B6(!$#&6(MN(*+.6(ONO8
ON7)
P4%;B4(!)P)6(Q$&J#(R)6(#35)6(*+,,N.(E*)+$F$%*)732723G$2%")(H$4#''&B#(O79O)(>4B&';6(SB#J2&)
:#&2$4K(P;B;%4'&(*O77-.(:&22B#(F4'#A(S)(O,+7)(Q'(!<$#52(T)6(P;'(U&V(G)6(W#45%&'(F)X)6(#35)(H=#(1#Y(;I (
!$J=42#J20$#)(Z#U([;$"6(!\$&%5)
P;B;%4'&(:)(*O777.)02&&*923*'$2%-4)A6")53$F*'")E$;")2; ),2+"3%)H3.6$'".'/3")(H=#(];0$'&B(;I (2=#(1;J4#2V(;I (!$J=48
2#J20$&B(/452;$4&'56(9^(*M.6(_-+8_NO)
P;'52&'2(P)(*+,,N.(I$&""%)C3*()(F;'3;'6(G=&43;')
P$;0J=(T)(*+,,M.(A6")H3')2; )H&&2'#"%'-4)0/&'/3")*%+)0/&'$F*'$2%)(Z;224'<=&%6(R4E#(F#&E#5)
P$;0J=(T)6(W&$3(P)(*O77N.(02''"3-)*%+)JK/*''"3-4)A6"):$++"%):$-'23()2; ):2/-$%B)(Z;224'<=&%6(R4E#(F#&E#5)
T;335(`)6(H&E#$';$(a)6(#35)6(*+,,9.(L2+()*%+)L/$&+$%B4)I--*(-)$%)'6")06*%B$%B)?"&*'$2%)2; )L2+()*%+)H3.6$'".'/3")(
P&%\$43<#6(>QH(G$#55)
/&$&U&V(T)])(*+,,^.(=6"%)J7".$"-),""'<(>4''#&b;B45)(D'4E#$542V(;I (>4''#5;2&(G$#55)
/&$b#$(G)(*+,OO.(E")0239/-$"3)M)=2#"%N)A6")!"#$%$-')O2("/3P(!E&4B&\B#(;'(=22bAccUUU)B&b$;5b#224E&)#0c9-^c
/;;b#$(:)(*+,,+.(839*%)J7*."Q),2+"3%$'(Q)*%+),*-./&$%$-')R"-$3"<(Q':4'<&%&'(!)6(1&'3#$5(F)6(d;$&J=(a)6(#35)(
S%\;34#3(D2;b4&5A(`#'3#$6(1;J4&B(P=&'<#6(&'3(2=#(>;3#$'(>#2$;b;B45)(F;'3;'cZ#U([;$"6(a;02B#3<#)
/;5#V(F)(*+,,O.(/433#'(F4'#5A(`#'3#$6(a&J#6(&'3(2=#(:;3V(4'(`$&b=4J(12&'3&$35)(];0$'&B(;I (!$J=42#J20$&B(
S30J&24;'6(99(*+.6(O,O8OO+)
G&\&(`)(*+,O,.(0237$)/39*%$<)R$;;"3"%G"Q)$%'"3*G$2%$6(b;B424J=#)(>4B&';6(R$&'J;!'<#B4)
G&\&(`)6(G#$$;'#(*+,OO.)(=23+-Q)L2+$"-Q)A6$%B-<)5&*%%$%B)A6"23()M)?"-"*3.66(O+(*+7.6(M,N8M,7)
G#$$;'#(G)(*+,O,.('LYHU&LW\&RQRVFHQ]DSLDQLÀFD]LRQHFLWWjGHOOHGLIIHUHQ]H)(>4B&';6(R$&'J;!'<#B4)
G;BB&$3(Q(e(:(*+,,N.(A6")S*T"+)C*3+"%"3-4)H99"():2/-")C*3+"%-)(F;'3;'6(G&b&3&"45)
a&0B2(])(*+,OO.)I$&""%)C3*()*%+)'6")R"-$B%)2; )J*776$.),2+"3%$'(4)J'*($%B)$%<(F;'3;'6(!5=<&2#)
a#52&'V(G)(*+,,O.(:/%+"3'D*--"34)A6")5*$%'"31U$%B)D$'6)'6")!$F")JT$%-)(XfB'6(H&5J=#')
aVgU#$2(])(*O77-.(A6")R*%.$%B)02&/#%4)V%)V3+"3)$%)H3.6$'".'/3"<(P&%\$43<#6(>QH(G$#55)
J**3$%"%)I<)>WXYZ@)A6")0$'(4)['-)C32D'6Q)['-)R".*(Q)['-)!/'/3"<(Z#U([;$"6(a#4'=;B3)
1#''#22(a)(*O77-.)(RB#5=(&'3(12;'#A(H=#(:;3V(&'3(2=#(P42V(4'(W#52#$'(P4E4B4K&24;')(Z#U([;$"6(Z;$2;'(e(
P;%b&'V)
Planum. The Journal of Urbanism | Conference Proceedings
7 | 59