WHITE-BROWED SPARROW-WEAVER PLOCEPASSER MAHALI

58
WH I T E -B ROWE D S PA R ROW- W E AV E R I N K WA Z U L U - N ATA L
Durban Natural Science Museum Novitates 37
WHITE-BROWED SPARROW-WEAVER
PLOCEPASSER MAHALI
(AVES: PLOCEIDAE)
IN KWAZULU-NATAL, SOUTH AFRICA
H. DIETER OSCHADLEUS
Animal Demography Unit, Department of Zoology, University of Cape Town, Rondebosch 7701, South Africa
email: [email protected]
O
schadleus, H.D. 2014. White-browed Sparrow-Weaver Plocepasser mahali (Aves: Ploceidae) in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Durban
Natural Science Museum Novitates 37: 58-61. Records of the White-browed Sparrow-Weaver Plocepasser mahali in KwaZulu-Natal have
increased in frequency over recent decades. A total of 24 records are documented from a variety of sources and these serve as a baseline
from which to monitor future records of this species in the region. Two early records dated from 1910 and 1958, and the remaining
records are from 1977 onwards. The only confirmed breeding records in KwaZulu-Natal are from Canigou Farm near Estcourt. The
White-browed Sparrow-Weaver in KwaZulu-Natal most likely originated from the west (Free State), although birds in Zululand may have
visited from the north (Mpumalanga). The apparently increasing frequency of the White-browed Sparrow-Weaver in KwaZulu-Natal
may be related to increasing bush encroachment. Factors limiting its range expansion in KwaZulu-Natal may include rainfall and diet.
Continuing to monitor this species at the edge of its range may provide clues to its ecological requirements.
KEYWORDS: KwaZulu-Natal, Plocepasser mahali, range records, White-browed Sparrow-Weaver.
INTRODUCTION
METHODS
White-browed Sparrow-Weavers Plocepasser mahali are cooperatively
breeding passerine birds of eastern and southern Africa. They live in
pairs or small groups year-round consisting of a dominant breeding
pair and subordinate, non-breeding males and females (Collias &
Collias 1978; Lewis 1982). Breeding is usually restricted to the
rainy season, particularly November to February, but breeding of
neighbouring groups is not necessarily synchronized (Earlé 1983). In
southern Africa, the White-browed Sparrow-Weaver occurs mainly
in dry woodland and savanna (Colahan 1997). Its main stronghold
is in north-central southern Africa, with isolated populations in the
Eastern Cape and eastern Free State (Colahan 1997).
Clancey (1964) mentioned one record of this species in
KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, but in recent decades the number of
records has increased. Biotic changes in distribution, and the rates at
which these are occurring, are important to document, especially in
the light of global climate change. This paper details all records of the
White-browed Sparrow-Weaver in KwaZulu-Natal up to December
2014, based on a variety of sources.
Digital biodiversity data sets held at the Animal Demography Unit,
collected largely by citizen scientists, were searched for records of
White-browed Sparrow-Weavers in KwaZulu-Natal. These projects
are the South African Bird Ringing Unit (SAFRING, 1948-to date),
Birds in Reserves Project (BIRP, 1992-to date), the Southern African
Bird Atlas Project (SABAP1, 1987-1991), the Southern African Bird
Atlas Project (SABAP2, July 2007-to date), and the Nest Record
Cards (NRC, 1952-to date). Published references were based on an
unpublished bibliography of the Ploceidae family. Some specimen data
are included from visits to museums and databases received from
museum curators. Unpublished sightings emailed to the author are
included. The ADU has a digital database of bird club outings, but
the original cards have not been traced – these records are thus not
included in the table of results but are mentioned in the Results.
The raw data covering White-browed Sparrow-Weaver records
in KwaZulu-Natal were extracted from bird-atlas projects. Other
records were included if there was a date (at least to the resolution
of a year) and a locality. Coordinates to the nearest minute were
assigned to localities obtained from the literature. Records appearing
Durban Natural Science Museum Novitates 37
59
WH I T E -B ROWE D S PA R ROW- W E AV E R I N K WA Z U L U - N ATA L
Table 1. Confirmed, geo-referenced records of the White-browed Sparrow-Weaver in KwaZulu-Natal, listed chronologically. * Vegetation types: 1 - Valley Thicket, 2 Natal Lowveld Bushveld, 3 - NE Mountain Grassland, 4 - Natal Central Bushveld, and 5 - Wet Cold Highveld Grassland.
Locality
Dates
Veg. type
Observer
Sources
Pongola River
13 Jul. 1910
2
F.O. Noomé
Ditsong Nat. Mus. Nat. Hist.-6413
Cathkin Park 2-10 Oct. 1958
3
D.R. Calder
Calder 1959
1977
4
Les Nutting
Nutting 1979, Cyrus & Robson 1980
Canigou farm, Estcourt
1978
4
Les Nutting
Nutting 1979, Cyrus & Robson 1980
Canigou farm, Estcourt
20 Oct. 1979
4
Les Nutting
Nutting 1979, Cyrus & Robson 1980
Canigou farm, Estcourt
11 Jan. & 1 Feb. 1980
4
Les Nutting
NRC 780.001
Mar. 1982
4
Ian Trench
Johnson 1982
2829DA [Spioenkop]
18 Jul. 1984
4
Unknown
SABAP1-049156
Spioenkop Dam
8 Sept. 1984
4
I. Trench
Cyrus 1985
2729DC [S of Memel]
Oct. 1984
[5 or 3]
Unknown
SABAP1-049190
2730DC [W of Vryheid]
Feb. 1988
[4 or 3]
Unknown
SABAP1-058636
Canigou farm, Estcourt
Spioenkop Dam
2730DC [W of Vryheid]
March 1988
[4 or 3]
Unknown
SABAP1-058637
30 Nov. 1996
1
W.L. Branford
BIRP-2600965
Spioenkop N.R. 16 Jun. 2000
4
C.N. Burne
BIRP-2602679
Spioenkop N.R. 30 Apr. 2001
4
Chris Mathews
BIRP-2506798
Cotswold farm
Aug. 2001
4
Tony Roberts
pers. comm.
Glencoe dump site
Aug. 2005
4
Peter Dearlove
pers. comm.
Hluhluwe GR
4 Nov. 2007
2
Andrew Kruger
Davis 2008a, Davis 2008b
Pongola NR
22 Nov. 2007
2
Tim Wood
BIRP-2509655
16 Dec. 2007
4E . Russell, S. du Preez & G. Leisegang
Weenen N.R. Spioenkop Dam NR
Ndumo GR, main camp
25-26 Oct. 2008
2
Pentad 2850_2955 [Weenen]
6 Jul. 2012
Pentad 2850_3000 [Weenen]
24 Sept. 2013
Pongola NR
29 Sept. 2013
in more than one source were cross-referenced. Habitat categories
were assigned to White-browed Sparrow-Weaver records, according
to the South African vegetation map (Low & Rebelo 1996).
RESULTS
There are 24 dated records of White-browed Sparrow-Weavers in
KwaZulu-Natal (Table 1, Fig. 1). No records were found for KwaZuluNatal in the SAFRING database.
The earliest dated record of a White-browed Sparrow-Weaver
in KwaZulu-Natal is from 13 July 1910. Specimen TM_6413 from the
Ditsong National Museum of Natural History (formerly Transvaal
Museum), Pretoria, South Africa, was collected by F.O. Noomé, a
Museum taxidermist, on the Pongola River. This record was not known
to Clancey (1964), presumably since the collection of the Ditsong
Museum had not then been digitized.
Calder (1959) reported a group of up to six birds seen at El
Mirador hotel, Cathkin Park (28°59’S; 29°28’E); several were seen daily
from 2-10 October 1958 (Calder 1958, 1959). Calder saw no nests
and attributed the presence of the birds as being related to belowaverage rainfall in the eastern Free State at that time.
The next record is from the farm of Mr G. Reynolds: Canigou
Farm (29°03’S; 29°59’E), 12 km ESE of Estcourt (Nutting 1979). A
pair built a nest in a gum tree in the cattle kraal near the farm house
(NRC, Nutting 1979). Up to six birds were present from 1977 to 1980
(Nutting 1979, Cyrus & Robson 1980). Mr Reynolds saw five or six
pers. comm.
Francois Furstenburg
Davis 2008c, Davis 2009a
4
Johan de Villiers
Davis 2012, SABAP2
4
Michael Cunningham
SABAP2
2
Unknown
Davis 2013
birds and on 20 October 1979 there were 13 nests with two or three
having one entrance (Nutting 1979), indicating breeding. There are
monthly bird club records from June to December 1979. Mr L. Nutting
submitted a Nest Record Card, noting an eggshell below the nests
on 11 January 1980 and the adults at the nest on 1 February. Cyrus
(1982) gives one confirmed record for the species in KwaZulu-Natal
for the period 1980-1982, presumably referring to the latter breeding
record.
In March 1982 there was a record from Spioenkop Dam by Ian
Trench (Johnson 1982). A bird club field card indicates that this
sighting was on 14 March. This was followed by an atlas card on 18
July 1984 for the grid covering the eastern part of the dam (the
entrance side), and presumably the record was from the dam area.
On 8 September 1984 Ian Trench again recorded this weaver at
Spioenkop Dam; this being the third published record for the species
in KwaZulu-Natal (Cyrus & McCosh 1985), and a bird club field card
was submitted. Further records from this locality were on 16 June
2000 and 30 April 2001 (BIRP records) and 16 December 2007 (Elena
Russell, Sandi du Preez and Gill Leisegang, as reported on the internet
listserver: SABirdNet). No nests have been reported from this locality.
In October 1984 the White-browed Sparrow-Weaver was recorded
from the quarter-degree-grid cell 2729DC on the border of the Free
State and KwaZulu-Natal (SABAP1); this atlas card was labelled as
KwaZulu-Natal. In February and March 1988 there were SABAP1 atlas
records of White-browed Sparrow-Weavers from 2730DC, west of
Vryheid. The exact localities and observers for these SABAP1 records
60
WH I T E -B ROWE D S PA R ROW- W E AV E R I N K WA Z U L U - N ATA L
Fig. 1. Confirmed, geo-referenced records of the White-browed SparrowWeaver for KwaZulu-Natal and the eastern Free State; white circles 1836-1970,
solid triangles 1970-1989, solid squares 1989-2009. Also shown are SABAP1
records (1987-1991, quarter-degree-grid cells, Harrison et al. 1997), with darker
shades of grey indicating higher reporting rates.
are not captured in the database. On 30 November 1996 there was a
BIRP record from Weenen Nature Reserve (28°56’S; 30°04’E), some
25 km from Canigou Farm.
More recent sightings are from Cotswold Farm (28°04’S; 30°19’E)
where three birds and roost nests were seen in August 2001 by Tony
Roberts. Birds and nests were seen at the Glencoe dump (28°10’S;
30°09’E) in August 2005 by Peter Dearlove; a week later only two
nests were seen at the site by Tony Roberts. David Hoddinott, Tony
Roberts and Garth Aiston did not find them here in March 2006. The
species was seen in Hluhluwe Game Reserve (~28°04’S; 32°04’E) on 4
November 2007 by Andrew Kruger and this record was accepted by
the KZN Regional Rarities Committee (Davis 2008a, 2008b). On 2526 October 2008 a pair was seen in the main camp of Ndumo Game
Reserve (26°53’S; 32°16’E) (Davis 2008c).
On 6 July 2012 Johan de Villiers recorded the species in a
SABAP2 pentad near Weenen (Davis 2012) and a year later Michael
Cunningham recorded it in an adjacent pentad on 24 September
2013. These records may have been in the Weenen Nature Reserve
and are not far from Canigou Farm. A few days later this species
was recorded in the Pongola Nature Reserve, reported initially on
SA Rare Bird Forum and subsequently published (Davis 2013). No
records from 2014 were found.
The habitat categories for White-browed Sparrow-Weaver
records from KwaZulu-Natal were mostly Natal Central Bushveld
(Table 1). At least 14 records came from this vegetation type;
two were in in Natal Lowveld Bushveld, and one in NE Mountain
Grassland. Habitat was not determined for the SABAP1 records, due
to the large grid size spanned by these records.
DISCUSSION
There are two early records from KwaZulu-Natal, in 1910 and 1958
(Table 1). From the 1970’s there are some records of this species in
KwaZulu-Natal every decade. The only confirmed breeding records in
KwaZulu-Natal are on Canigou Farm near Escourt. The birds appear
to have arrived on this farm in 1977 and remained until about 1980.
Nests were built at some other sites but no breeding records were
obtained.
Durban Natural Science Museum Novitates 37
The closest region to central KwaZulu-Natal where most of the
White-browed Sparrow-Weaver records come from is the Free State,
where the species is widespread (Skead 1966; Colahan 1997). This
suggests that the records in central KwaZulu-Natal relate to birds
originating from the west. Clancey (1964) noted the distribution as
the western Free State, east as far as between Winburg and Senekal.
The earliest records east of 28°45’E are from 1984, soon after
the Free State atlas project (1983-1986) began (Earlé & Grobler
1987). It is not clear if the White-browed Sparrow-Weavers in
Zululand originated from the west (Free State) or from the north
(Mpumalanga).
Although particular in its micro-habitat requirements (Vernon
1983; Ferguson 1985), the White-browed Sparrow-Weaver finds
suitable conditions in a variety of vegetation types, with high
reporting rates in particular from the dry woodland and savanna
areas, and the much-altered Sweet Grasslands of central southern
Africa. Nest trees are usually at the ecotone between two habitats:
one with reduced ground cover, where the birds forage, and the
other having good grass cover, providing nest material (Vernon 1983;
Ferguson 1985). Such ecotones have been extensively generated in
the Sweet Grasslands by crop farming and livestock grazing. In these
areas alien trees planted as windbreaks, or along roads, are commonly
used for nesting (Colahan 1997). KwaZulu-Natal probably offers
a variety of habitats near human dwellings that the White-browed
Sparrow-Weaver can utilize.
The apparently increasing records of the White-browed
Sparrow-Weaver in KwaZulu-Natal may be related to increasing
bush encroachment. Woody cover has increased in the Weenen area
(Hoffman & O’Connor 1999) and in the Hluhluwe area (Wigley et al.
2009, Wigley et al. 2010) over the last century, both areas in which the
White-browed Sparrow-Weaver has been recorded. Too much bush
encroachment, however, would be a limiting factor for this species
(Colahan 1997).
There have been slight range expansions of this species in other
parts of southern Africa. The White-browed Sparrow-Weaver has
increased in numbers and range in the Eastern Cape, spreading
southwards through the Cradock district since 1950 (Skead 1966,
1967; Collett 1982). The distribution map in Colahan (1997) also
shows records from the northern and eastern Transvaal beyond
the eastern edge of the range shown by Tarboton et al. (1987). It is
spreading towards and into the Kruger National Park (Arkell 1997;
Lawson 2010; SABAP 2) and bush encroachment is suspected to be a
contributing factor (Arkell 1997).
The White-browed Sparrow-Weaver has not become permanently
established in KwaZulu-Natal, in spite of the apparent suitable
habitat and increasing records of birds. Possible reasons may be
related to rainfall (Ferguson 1989). Another possibility is the lack of
Hodotermes harvester termites in KwaZulu-Natal (Ian A.W. Macdonald
pers. comm.). The importance of termites in the diet of the Whitebrowed Sparrow-Weaver varies, however. For instance, Ferguson
(1985) notes that beetles were the most important arthropod taken.
While the optimal ecological factors required by the White-browed
Sparrow-Weaver are not clearly understood, continuing to monitor
this species at the edge of its range (including KwaZulu-Natal) may
provide clues to its ecological requirements.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
SAFRING is sponsored by the South African National Biodiversity
Institute and the Namibian Ministry of Wildlife and Tourism. The
University of Cape Town provides accommodation and services.
Durban Natural Science Museum Novitates 37
WH I T E -B ROWE D S PA R ROW- W E AV E R I N K WA Z U L U - N ATA L
SAFRING data, Nest Record Cards and Cape Bird Club field cards
were computerized at the ADU with funds from SABIF via the NRF
and SANBI. The records from the Ditsong National Museum of
Natural History were supplied by Tamar Cassidy. Thanks to David
Hoddinott, Tony Roberts, Garth Aiston, Peter Dearlove, Gill Leisegang,
Steve Davis, Richard Dean and Carl Vernon for providing information.
Richard Dean, Les Underhill, David Johnson and Ian A.W. Macdonald
provided comments on earlier drafts.
REFERENCES
ARKELL, G. 1997. Whitebrowed Sparrow-weavers. Hornbill 47: 21.
CALDER, D.R. 1958. [No title]. Natal Bird Club News Sheet 58: 1-2.
CALDER, D.R. 1959. White-browed Sparrow-weaver Plocepasser mahali.
Ostrich 30: 163.
CLANCEY, P.A. 1964. The Birds of Natal and Zululand. Oliver & Boyd:
London
COLAHAN, B.D. 1997. Whitebrowed Sparrowweaver Plocepasser
mahali. In: HARRISON, J.A., ALLAN, D.G., UNDERHILL, L.G.,
HERREMANS, M., TREE, A.J., PARKER, V. & BROWN, C.J. (eds), The
atlas of southern African birds. Vol. 2: Passerines, pp. 532-533. BirdLife
South Africa: Johannesburg.
COLLIAS, N.E. & COLLIAS, E.C. 1978. Cooperative breeding behavior
in the White-browed Sparrow Weaver. Auk 95: 472-484.
COLLETT, J. 1982. Birds of the Cradock District. Southern Birds 9: 1-76.
CYRUS, D. & ROBSON, N.F. 1980. Bird atlas of Natal. University of
Natal Press: Pietermaritzburg.
CYRUS, D. 1982. Observations of rare and out-of-range birds in Natal
(1980-82). Albatross 269: 6-9.
CYRUS, D. & MCCOSH, B. 1985. Recent field notes. N.B.C. recorder &
rare birds panel. Albatross 281: 6-8.
DAVIS, S. 2008a. KwaZulu-Natal Honorary Recorder’s report. 7 May
2008. KZN Birds 23: 21-22.
DAVIS, S. 2008b. KwaZulu-Natal Honorary Recorder’s report. August
2008. KZN Birds 24: 21-24.
DAVIS, S. 2008c. KwaZulu-Natal Honorary Recorder’s report.
November 2008. KZN Birds 25: 20-23.
DAVIS, S. 2012. Honorary Recorder’s report. KZN Birds 37: 26-29.
DAVIS, S. 2013. Honorary Recorder’s report. KZN Birds 40: 28-31.
61
EARLÉ, R.A. 1983. Aspects of the breeding biology of the whitebrowed
sparrowweaver Plocepasser mahali (Aves: Ploceidae). Navorsinge van
die Nasionale Museum, Bloemfontein 4: 177-191.
EARLÉ, R. & GROBLER, N. 1987. First atlas of bird distribution in the
Orange Free State. National Museum: Bloemfontein.
FERGUSON, J.W.H. 1985. The influence of crop-farming on
Whitebrowed Sparrow-weavers Plocepasser mahali. Proceedings of a
Symposium on Birds and Man, Johannesburg 1983: 45-54.
FERGUSON, J.W.H. 1989. Preferred habitat of White-browed Sparrow
Weavers Plocepasser mahali. South African Journal of Zoology 24:
1-10.
HOFFMAN, M.T. & O’CONNOR, T.G. 1999. Vegetation change over
40 years in the Weenen/Muden area, KwaZulu-Natal: evidence
from photo-panoramas. African Journal of Range & Forage Science
16(2&3): 71-88.
JOHNSON, D. 1982. New distributional data. Albatross 269: 9-10.
LAWSON, P. 2010. Interesting local sightings. Hornbill 98: 26-27.
LEWIS, D.M. 1982. Cooperative breeding in a population of Whitebrowed Sparrow Weavers Plocepasser mahali. Ibis 124: 511-522.
LOW, A.B. & REBELO, A.G. (eds). 1996. Vegetation of South Africa,
Lesotho and Swaziland. Dept Environmental Affairs & Tourism:
Pretoria.
NUTTING, L. 1979. White-browed Sparrow Weavers in Natal. Albatross
257: 4.
SKEAD, C.J. 1966. White-browed Sparrow-weaver, Plocepasser mahali A.
Smith, in the eastern and north-eastern Cape. Ostrich 37: 128-129.
SKEAD, C.J. 1967. Ecology of birds in the Eastern Cape Province.
Ostrich Supplement 7: 1-103.
TARBOTON, W.R., KEMP, M.I. & KEMP, A.C. 1987. Birds of the Transvaal.
Transvaal Museum: Pretoria.
VERNON, C.J. 1983. Aspects of the habitat preference and social
behaviour of the White-browed Sparrow Weaver. Honeyguide 113:
11-14.
WIGLEY, B.J., BOND, W.J. & HOFFMAN, M.T. 2009. Bush
encroachment under three contrasting land-use practices in a
mesic South African savanna. African Journal of Ecology 47: 62-70.
WIGLEY, B.J., BOND, W.J. & HOFFMAN, M.T. 2010. Thicket expansion
in a South African savanna under divergent land use: local vs.
global drivers? Global Change Biology 16: 964–976.