the explorers journal fa l l 2 0 07 v ol . 85 no . 3 cover photo: the cover image was taken two days out from Pangnirtung as will steger and his team were climbing a frozen waterfall on the Weasel River. This is the southern entrance of the Auyuittuq National Park, a 90km river valley leading to Qikiqtarjuaq. © 2007 Will Steger Foundation, Abby Fenton the climate change issue features VbyePaul n tAndrew ur ing t o t he E n d s of t he E a r t h Mayewski, p. 22 IbytW.’ sBerrynoLyons, t Ep.a32s y B e ing D r y Rby eConstanza a l m Ceruti, of tp.he ic e - c l o a k e d mou n ta in g o d s 36 he a d ing nor t h w i t h W il l S t e ge r interview by Jeff Stolzer, p. 38 frozen lake, Taylor valley, Antarctica, Photo by kathy welch specials Pby oPauli nts U n k n o w n: I n t o t h e w i l d s o f P ata g o n i a Jeffrey, p. 13 Aby Brett M oPrettyman, u nta ip.n16 o f Th e i r O w n IbynMarilyn th eBridges, F o otste ps of Alexander p. 44 regulars p r e s i d e n t ’ s n o t e , p. 2 e d i t o r ’ s n o t e , p. 4 e x p l o r at i o n n e w s , p. 8 e x t r e m e c u i s i n e , p. 54 e x p e d i t i o n M e d i c i n e , p .56 e x P o s t F a c t o , p. 58 r e v i e w s , p. 60 w h at w e r e t h e y t h i n k i n g ? , p. 64 the explorers journal fa l l 2 0 07 president’s letter A pivotal point in our history During our successful 2007 Explorers Club Annual Dinner, which highlighted major advances in polar exploration, Paul Andrew Mayewski gave a captivating presentation on climate change in Greenland. In the weeks that followed, I could not help but think about the topic, knowing that so many members of our Club have been involved in climate change research. Among our members are some of the world’s most recognized experts in the fields of atmospheric science, oceanography, geochemistry, glaciology, underwater filmmaking, and polar exploration—fields of science crucial to our understanding of Earth’s ecosystems and the ongoing causes of global warming. Given the importance of the subject, I began to discuss the idea of honoring those explorers and scientists on the forefront of climate change research at this year’s Lowell Thomas Awards Dinner with as many members as I could. The response I received was overwhelmingly enthusiastic. This summer, our members carried Explorers Club Flag No 42 aboard the Russian MIR submersible that became the first manned underwater device to reach “The Real North Pole”—landing on the seabed some four kilometers below the ice at 90° N. As many of you are aware from the press, there is the political debate over this expedition, and because of the political controversy that surrounds this subject as well as our dinner topic, I think it is important to point out that according to our Club’s bylaws, we take no stand on politics. As your president, I take pride in celebrating the accomplishments of our fellow members. This new first is an achievement for us as well as the mission of the Club. Congratulations to Frederik Paulsen, Michael McDowell, and Anatoly Sagalevitch. Please accept my personal invitation to enjoy a fabulous and informative evening on Thursday, October 18th, at Cipriani Wall Street, and help us honor the work of fellow explorers Richard Feely, Ph.D., W. Berry Lyons, Ph.D., Paul A. Mayewski, Ph.D., Julie Palais, Ph.D., Adam Ravetch, Sarah Robertson, Susan Solomon, Ph.D., and Will Steger. Invitations are still available online at www.explorers.org. Seating is limited and reservations will be taken on a first-come first-served basis. Rob Jutson, dinner chair, his entire committee, and I look forward to seeing you there. Da niel A . Bennett Lowell Thomas Awards Dinner EXPLORINGCLIMATECHANGE THE PRESIDENT, DIRECTORS, OFFICERS, OF THE EXPLORERS CLUB & ROLEX WATCH USA, INC. SALUTE THE 2007 LOWELL THOMAS AWARD WINNERS. Richard A. Feely, Ph.D. W. Berry Lyons, Ph.D. FN’92 Paul A. Mayewski, Ph.D. FN’78 Julie M. Palais, Ph.D. FN’03 Sarah Robertson and Adam Ravetch FN’95 Susan Solomon, Ph.D. Will C. Steger FN’85 the explorers journal fa l l 2 0 07 editor’s note salutes the 2007 recipients of the explorers club Lowell Thomas Award Something Familiar, Something Peculiar… A ngel a M.H. Schuster Acting Editor-in-Chief c o n g r at u l at i o n s t o Richard Feely, Ph.D. W. Berry Lyons, Ph.D. Paul Mayewski, Ph.D. Julie Palais, Ph.D. Adam Ravetch & Sarah Robertson Susan Solomon, Ph.D. Will Steger Thank you for your efforts to keep our world in Balance image courtesy of © 2007 Will Steger Foundation So you have noticed a few changes, have you—the smaller trim, a higher page count, the perfect bind, and a host of new columns and features? Driven in large part by a growing concern for the environment, we have redesigned The E xplorers Journal with two goals in mind. Our first has been to visually capture the mystique that is the very essence of The Explorers Club and literally “put it on paper.” Our second has been to minimize our ecological footprint by using every square centimeter of paper on press. Guiding us in this effort has been Jesse Alexander, a New Yorker with a passion for exotic travel and a keen eye for all that is cool in the world. Over the course of the summer, Jesse and I found ourselves in the archives of The Explorers Club, poring over back issues of The E xplorers Journal since its launch as a pamphlet in 1921. Charting its evolution in size and use of type, we noted each innovation—the first use of images inside rather than only on the cover, the first use of color, and so on—and marveled at the edge of its editorial, particularly during the 1950s and 1960s. In recasting The E xplorers Journal, our cues have come from its past as well as its future. This issue we have brought together some of the best minds in climate research, who are elucidating the inner workings of our planet— separating fact from fiction and human induced change from Earth’s natural process. According to Explorers Club Fellow Paul Andrew Mayewski, who penned the lead story in our climate package, “more knowledge is needed, not to demonstrate the direction of change, but rather to reduce uncertainty in the degree and style of future change.” Having spent the better part of four decades on the forefront of climate research, Mayewski spearheaded the Greenland Ice Sheet Project, which pushed back our knowledge of Earth’s climate history by nearly a million years. We hope you enjoy our new format and look forward to your feedback! for their contributions to our under s ta nding of Global Cl im at e Cha nge the explorers journal fa l l 2 0 07 the explorers club Board Of Directors President Daniel A. Bennett Officers PATRONS & SPONSORS Honor ary Chairman Sir Edmund Hillary, KG, ONZ, KBE Honor ary President James M. Fowler Honor ary Directors Robert D. Ballard, Ph.D. George F. Bass, Ph.D Eugenie Clark, Ph.D. Sylvia A. Earle, Ph.D. Col. John H. Glenn Jr., USMC (Ret.) Gilbert M. Grosvenor Donald C. Johanson, Ph.D. Richard E. Leakey, D.Sc. Roland R. Puton Johan Reinhard, Ph.D. George B. Schaller, Ph.D. Don Walsh, Ph.D. CLASS OF 2 0 0 8 V i c e P r e s i d e n t, C h a p t e r s Pat r o n s O f E x p l o r at i o n Garrett R. Bowden Jonathan M. Conrad Kristin Larson, Esq. Margaret D. Lowman, Ph.D. Robert H. Whitby Robert H. Whitby Robert H. Rose Michael W. Thoresen CLASS OF 2 0 0 9 Daniel A. Bennett Kenneth M. Kamler, M.D. Lorie Karnath Theodore M. Siouris Alicia Stevens Anne L. Doubilet William Harte Kathryn Kiplinger Daniel A. Kobal, Ph.D. R. Scott Winters, Ph.D. ART DEPARTMENT Acting Editor-in-Chief Art Director Angela M.H. Schuster Jesse Alexander Managing Editor Deus ex Machina Jeff Stolzer Steve Burnett Contributing Editors Jeff Blumenfeld Jim Clash Clare Flemming, M.S. Michael J. Manyak, M.D., FACS Milbry C. Polk Carl G. Schuster Nick Smith V i c e P r e s i d e n t F o r O p e r at i o n s C o r p o r at e Pa r t n e r O f E x p l o r at i o n Rolex Watch U.S.A., Inc. Garrett R. Bowden Corporate Benefactors Of Exploration Vice President, Research & Education Lenovo Redwood Creek Wines Margaret D. Lowman, Ph.D. Treasurer Mark Kassner Corporate Supporter Of Exploration National Geographic Society Kevin O’Brien S e c r e ta r y Daniel A. Kobal, Ph.D. A s s i s ta n t S e c r e ta r y Anne Doubilet the explorers journal © (ISSN 0014-5025) is published quarterly by The Explorers Club, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021, telephone: 212-628-8383, fax: 212-2884449, website: www.explorers.org, e-mail: editor@explorers. org. The views and opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of The Explorers Club or The Explorers Journal. Subscriptions should be addressed to: Subscription Services, The E xplorers Journal, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021. Subscriptions one year, $29.95; two years, $54.95; three years, $74.95; single numbers, $8.00; foreign orders, add $8.00 per year. Members of The Explorers Club receive The E xplorers Journal as a perquisite of membership. Postmaster Send address changes to The E xplorers Journal, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021. SU B MISSIONS Manuscripts, books for review, and advertising inquiries should be sent to the Editor, The E xplorers Journal, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021. All manuscripts are subject to review. The E xplorers Journal is not responsible for unsolicited materials. Copy Chief Valerie Saint-Rossy All paper used to manufacture this magazine comes from well-managed sources. The printing of this magazine is FSC certified and uses vegetable-based inks. 50% RECYCLED PAPER Lynda Roy A s s i s ta n t T r e a s u r e r CLASS OF 2 0 10 masthead EDITORS V i c e P r e s i d e n t, M e m b e r s h i p MADE FROM 15% POST CONSUMER WASTE The Explorers Club, The Explorers Journal, The Explorers Club Travelers, World Center for Exploration, and The Explorers Club Flag and Seal are registered trademarks of The Explorers Club, Inc., in the United States and elsewhere. All rights reserved. © The Explorers Club, 2007. e xpl or ation ne ws edited by Jeff Blumenfeld and for the circumnavigation attempts currently underway by Lewis and Eruc. The panel of experts recognize Lewis as being first in line to complete a humanpowered circumnavigation when he completes his expedition October 6 in Greenwich, England. Lewis’s quest has been a long-sought grail of circumnavigation aspirants since Ferdinand Magellan’s expedition completed the first circumnavigation of the world in 1522. Panel Decides Rules for true circumnavigation Definitive rules for circumnavigations of the world completed under human power have been published by AdventureStats of Explorers Web, Inc., an independent panel of international historians, geographers, and explorers. Their conclusions will ratify existing guidelines held by the Guinness Book of World Records. The rulings will also clarify the recent dispute between teams from three nations—Britain, Canada, and Turkey—regarding the first circumnavigation of the planet by human power. Last April a major row erupted in the international press between Briton Jason Lewis (above), Canadian Colin Angus, and Turkish son and long-time U.S. resident Erden Eruc over the definition of a legitimate human-powered circumnavigation 8 (HPC). Angus, who claims to have completed an HPC in May 2006, traveled exclusively in the Northern Hemisphere, which, according to Lewis and Eruc, does not entitle him to claim a circumnavigation of the entire world. Guinness also refuted the claim by Angus as their criteria for human-powered circumnavigation feats require the traveler to cross both the equator and at least one pair of antipodal points (locations on the surface of the planet that are diametrically opposite to each other). In turn, Angus accused Guinness of setting the rules on what constitutes a humanpowered circumnavigation to suit a Briton—Lewis. The new rules come down heavily in favor of the existing guidelines set by Guinness, T he ru l e s set by THE EXPLORERS CLUB TRAVELERS A World of Adventures Travel with Explorers Club members and friends on luxurious adventures far off the beaten path in the company of distinguished & engaging leaders. FEATURED JOURNEY: Himalayas by Air March 21–April 7, 2008(18 days) Experience the Himalayas’ diverse ethnic groups, religious traditions, wildlife habitats, and biodiversity in a single, unforgettable 18-day journey, visiting India, Bhutan, Myanmar, and China, with an extension to Nepal. e x pl o r e r s w e b r e q u i r e t h e c i r c u m n av ig a t o r t o : • Start and finish at the same point, traveling in one general direction • Reach two antipodes • Cross the equator • Cross all longitudes • Cover a minimum of 40,000 km or 21,600 nautical miles (a great circle) British yachtsman Adrian Flanagan, who is sailing the first-ever single-handed “vertical” circumnavigation of the globe—considered the last great sailing prize in long-distance, single-handed sailing—says, “I agree with all points in the defining criteria, but would expand on one. In crossing the equator, it needs to be crossed twice in opposite directions. The one really important point, which the panel does make, is for the necessity of at least one pair of antipodal points on the track. Many sailors ignore this—all the Vendée Globe racers and the Volvo competitors SELECTED JOURNEYS The Farside of Antarctica December 1, 2007–January 7, 2008 (38 days) Please contact us at: 800-856-8951 9am - 6pm Mon-Fri, ET Toll line: 603-756-4004 Fax: 603-756-2922 Email: [email protected] Website: www.explorers.org Ultimate Serengeti Safari February 12–24, 2008 (13 days) Chile’s Patagonian Fjords & the Falkland Islands February 18–March 2, 2008 (14 days) From Cape Horn to the Cape of Good Hope February 28–March 22, 2008 (24 days) TheyLivedAd_FINAL.qxp:Layout 1 EXPLORATION NEWS 6/25/07 4:04 PM are thus probably not completing a ‘true’ circumnavigation.” A complete set of rules and regulations for human-powered circumnavigation are posted at http:// www.adventurestats.com/rules. shtml#around. For information on Jason Lewis’s expedition see: www.expedition360.com. Page 1 COMINGTO BOOKSTORESTHIS FALL is the latest collection from The Explorers Club book series, published by The Lyons Press. Gathered here are the firsthand accounts of more than forty current members of the Club, ranging from the remarkable to the captivating to the bizarre, which SOUTH POLE THEN AND NOW Looking into deep space Happy Birthday Sputnik Space Race turns 50 October 4 marks the fiftieth anniversary the Soviet launch of Sputnik I, and “the singular event that launched the space age and the US–USSR Space Race,” says NASA web historian Steve Garber. According to Garber, the world’s first artificial satellite was about the size of a basketball, weighed only 183 pounds, and took about 98 minutes to orbit the Earth on its elliptical path. “As a technical achievement, Sputnik caught the world’s attention and the American public off guard,” he says. “More important, the launch ushered in new political, military, technological, and scientific developments.” For more, write to [email protected]. 10 It has been 50 years since a team of 18 men under the leadership of scientist Paul Siple and naval officer Lt. John Tuck spent the first winter/austral summer in history at the South Pole as part of the 1956–57 International Geophysical Year. The “winterovers,” as they were known, witnessed sunset and sunrise at the South Pole, events that are separated in Antarctica by six months of darkness and almost unimaginable cold. During that time, temperatures dropped to -74.5° Celsius (-102.1° Fahrenheit) on September 18, 1957, the coldest temperature recorded on Earth at the time. These men laid the foundation for the scientific legacy that continues with the recent inauguration of the $19.2-million South Pole Telescope as part of the International Polar Year 2007–2008. The telescope—23 meters high, ten meters across, and weighing 280 tons—was test-built in Kilgore, TX, then taken apart, shipped by boat are sure to become a memorable part of exploration lore for genera- to New Zealand, and flown to the South Pole. Since last November, the SPT team under the guidance of project manager Steve Padin, Senior Scientist in Astronomy and Astrophysics at the University of Chicago, have worked to reassemble and deploy the telescope, which is now up and running. The cold, dry atmosphere above the South Pole will allow the SPT to more easily detect the CMB (cosmic microwave background) radiation, the afterglow of the big bang, with minimal interference from water vapor. For more on the South Pole Telescope: http://spt.uchicago.edu/spt. tions to come. Included in this exciting collection are stories such as “A Bad Day at the Office” by Robert Ballard, “Flying Giant of the Andes” by Jim Fowler, “The Running of the Boundaries” by Wade Davis, “Race to the Moon” by James Lovell, “Out on a Limb” by Margaret Lowman, and many more. This collection redefines what the original members called exploration, reflecting a modern adventurer— including several women—whose aim has shifted to protecting national treasures, preserving the planet, and making discoveries that will benefit the whole of humankind while expanding the world’s knowledge. AVAILABLE NOVEMBER 2007 ISBN: 978-1-59228-991-2 AVAILABLE WHERE BOOKS ARE SOLD Peary Centennial Expedition Planned The north beckons Dupre On February 17, 2009, polar The Lyons Press is an imprint of The Globe Pequot Press EXPLORATION NEWS explorer Lonnie Dupre, 46, and a team of Inuit companions and explorers will begin an epic dogsled journey through the High Arctic, traveling in the footsteps of Robert E. Peary, who with Matthew A. Henson and a team of Inuit, became the first men to reach the North Pole on April 6, 1909. Although the claim was disputed by skeptics, it was upheld in 1989 by the Navigation Foundation (www. navigationfoundation.org). According to Dupre, a resident of Grand Marais, MN, the five-month project will begin in January 2009 with a month and a half of training dogs, preparing equipment, and living with the polar Inuit of the Qaanaaq district of northwest Greenland. Then, on February 17, the day the sun comes back at the end of four months of polar night, a team of six explorers, three sleds, and 36 dogs will depart on the 2,400-kilometer journey. While the team is not venturing to the North Pole, they plan to document all of Peary’s historic huts, camps, depots, and cairns in Canada and Greenland. Dupre will also develop a “Not Cool” campaign to explain how climate change is affecting Inuit culture and how pollution is threatening wildlife. For more information contact: Lonnie Dupre at [email protected], or visit www.lonniedupre.com. How North is North? A once and future land In July, the Euro-American North Greenland Expedition 2007 flew to the northernmost coast of Greenland, then headed out on the sea ice to establish 12 whether there is a more northerly point of permanent land than Kaffeklubben Island, the currently established northern point. Oodaaq Island was discovered some 1360 meters north of Kaffeklubben in 1978, but it has since vanished into the ocean. Team member Jeff Shea of Point Richmond, CA, told us, “We stood on an ‘island’ north of Kaffeklubben. I put it in quotes because it appeared to be sitting on top of the sea ice, but we’re not sure if it was connected to land. This is representative of these impermanent features off the north coast of Greenland near Kaffeklubben. This feature was shown in a 2005 satellite image appearing in much the same shape as it is in now. “It looks like an island, but time will tell if it’s determined to be the northernmost,” Shea says. “For now, we dubbed it Stray Dog West.” peak fees for Everest’s relatively unpopular fall season. With the end of the decadeold Maoist insurgency last year, tourism has rebounded in Nepal (up 36 percent in the first seven months of 2007 compared to 2006) but it is still far below historical levels. Ang Tshering asks that climbers and guides e-mail their comments on reducing peak fees to office@nepal mountaineering.org and to the Ministry of Tourism at [email protected]. Nepal seeks peak fee cut Eighteen environmental scientists spent seven weeks traveling down the 2,375-kilometer Danube to “give the river a health checkup,” according to Philip Weller, executive secretary of the International Commission for the Protection of the Danube River, which organized the study. Known as the Joint Danube Survey 2, the trip began on August 14 in Regensburg, Germany, and ended in late September in in Romania and the Ukraine. Weller said the goal was to gather information to improve Danube-related policies of the countries along the river, home to more than 80 million people. For more on this project, see www.icpdr.org/jds. Everest more economical? Ang Tshering Sherpa, president of the Nepal Mountaineering Association, is campaigning to reduce peak fees in his country in order to attract more climbers. The Nepalese government has formed a Royalty Revision Committee, and Ang Tshering’s hope is that fees will be reduced across the board, according to the American Alpine Club News. In general, Nepal’s peak fees are higher than those of comparable mountains in Pakistan, India, and even China. According to Reuters, Nepal is already considering a 50 percent cut in its The Not So Blue Danube Pollution threatens a European wonder Points Unknown into the wilds of Patagonia text by Paul Jeffr ey Eager to protect the dramatic landscapes of western Patagonia, Cristian Donoso is leading an expedition by kayak to this region, one of the most inhospitable places on earth. Spending five months navigating open seas and fjords and pulling their kayaks across glaciers, Donoso and his team will face daunting physical and mental challenges as they gather information that will inform Chile and the world about this little-known area. With its labyrinth of rocky islands, serpentine channels and icy fjords, western Patagonia, in southern Chile, is one of the least-explored areas on Earth, with annual rainfall reaching up to eight meters and winds frequently rising to hurricane force. Nestled among glaciers that hug the slopes of steep Andean peaks and drenched by storms that blow out of the southern Pacific, the harsh region deters all but the hardiest explorers. That has not stopped Cristian Donoso, a young Chilean lawyer who over the past 14 years has ventured some 40 times into the region’s most inaccessible corners. Just like the indigenous photographs by Cr isti a n Donoso peoples who paddled here in fragile canoes for thousands of years before the arrival of Europeans, he often travels in a sea kayak, which allows him to manoeuvre around the narrowest fjords and discover their hidden beauty. “In order to strengthen the protection of this territory, we have got to know what’s there,” says Donoso, who reports that today most Chileans have little knowledge of it. He warns that such ignorance makes it easier for those seeking commercial gain to exploit the region’s natural resources—seafood, water, virgin forests—with little respect for its biodiversity. With his team of three men and one woman, the 31-year-old explorer has embarked on an ambitious five-month Transpatagonia Expedition that started this September. They will traverse 2,039 kilometers of the central part of western Patagonia on open sea, lakes, and rivers, as well as travelling overland for about 150 kilometers, dragging kayaks with provisions—weighing some 100 kilograms each—behind them as sledges. The group will ascend unclimbed peaks and visit the explorers journal uncharted territories. To enhance understanding of the region’s geological past, soil and rock samples will be collected and analyzed by scientists. The explorers will also collect geological evidence, including stalagmites in caves on Madre de Dios Island, showing how the climate has changed over time. Scholars of the region’s human history eagerly await the expedition’s reports on the remains of fishing and hunting camps that belonged to the Kaweskars, who lived in the region for more than 4,000 years. A famous incident, the 1741 sinking of the English frigate Wager on the north coast of the Guayaneco Archipelago, will come alive again when expedition divers search for the wreck’s exact location. They will then trace the route described in the journal of John Byron, who survived the shipwreck thanks to assistance from two indigenous groups, who spirited him and three other survivors through the treacherous waters in their canoes. Donoso, a 2006 Rolex Enterprise Awards Laureate, is planning to produce a documentary video for broadcast on Chilean television in 2008. To follow his expedition, September through January, see his website at: http://patagoniaincognita.blogspot.com. biography Paul Jeffrey is an Oregon-based writer and photographer who has covered international emergencies such as the genocide in Darfur, Sudan, and the tsunami in South Asia. 14 the explorers journal A Moun ta in of Their Own after leading dozens of clients up the world’s highest peak, two of Everest’s best climb for themselves text by Br ett Pr ett y m a n From his first glimpse of the tiny man with the effervescent smile, Geoff Tabin knew Apa Sherpa was different. It was 1988, and Tabin was serving as the doctor on an expedition on Mount Everest that had hired Apa as part of the climbing support team. “He was very shy, very cheerful, and unbelievably strong,” Tabin said. “He had this incredible balance about him. While other Sherpas carrying the same loads were plodding along he was skipping 16 and dancing up the mountain. And that smile…he just never quit smiling.” While Apa didn’t make it to the top of Chomolungma in 1988—Tabin did—the Sherpa man from Thame managed to string together an unbelievable list of summits in the ensuing years. Today, 19 years later, the 5-foot-4 and 120-pound Apa is still displaying what has become the trademark grin of the man who has skipped to the summit of Everest more than any other human, most recently on May 16, 2007. This past spring, the reserved yet still distinctly feisty 47-year-old broke his own world record with a seventeenth trip to the highest point on the planet—four of which were made without oxygen. Apa made his first 16 Everest summits while employed by clients to get them to 29,035 feet above sea level. This time there were no clients, just family, friends, and fellow Everest record setter Lhakpa Gelu Sherpa, who in 2003 set a speed record for the fastest summit from basecamp in just under 11 hours. Apa and Lhakpa surrounded themselves with other Sherpas, many of them extended family and friends, to round out the climbing members of the SuperSherpas Expedition. “All the other times I was there for a job to the explorers journal 18 at approximately 8:45 A.M. on May 16. The team climbed more than 7,700 vertical feet in less than 24 hours—and at the highest altitude in the world. “This trip was not as hard as others when we had to help others so much,” Lhakpa said. “Our Sherpa team was so strong and we didn’t have to turn around for anything. I am so very proud of how we worked as a team.” “If there is anything good that comes from our summit…our goal would be to create a more peaceful world,” Apa and Lhakpa radioed the SuperSherpas basecamp shortly after reaching the summit. “Our second goal would be to continue in Sir Edmund Hillary’s footsteps and contribute to education and improving health care in the Khumbu region, and for all Nepali people in the remote regions.” To raise awareness of the PHOTOGRAPHS COURTESY OF SUPERSHERPAS LLC get others to the top to try and support my family. This time Lhakpa and I did it not only for our families but for all the Nepali people,” Apa said from his current home in Salt Lake City, UT, where Lhakpa also lives. “I am very proud of our team, the history we made, and the awareness we have brought to the Sherpa people.” Free of the constraints and obligations to get clients to the top, the SuperSherpas basically raced from Camp 2 to the summit, passing other climbers hunkered down in tents trying to acclimatize to the elevation. The SuperSherpas team started its final push for the summit on May 14, spending the night at Camp 2 (21,300 feet), and then climbed to Camp 4—a gain of more than 4,200 feet—in nine hours. After a four-hour rest at Camp 4, they took off at 10 P.M. and summitted role of Sherpas and the need for a better education system in their home country, a documentary is being made about the expedition—filmed entirely by Sherpas, of course. Apa and Lhakpa never made it out of grade school in Nepal. They both became porters for Everest expeditions at an early age to support their families. The men eventually proved themselves worthy of becoming part of climbing teams and started leading people to the top. Even as the most accomplished climber on Everest, Apa still made less than 20 percent of the money Western guides pull in for taking clients to the top. Because they spend more time on the mountain helping prepare camps for the climbers, Sherpas are also exposed to the dangers of Everest more frequently than Western climbers. Apa and Lhakpa decided it was time to draw attention to the Sherpa people and the fact that they have been involved in some way on every expedition attempt since people started trying to conquer Everest in the 1920s. The men are also hoping that their success will help raise money for more and better education for all Nepali children, and create a better pay scale for Sherpas involved in expeditions. Because they live at high elevations their entire lives, Sherpas do not need to go through the lengthy process of acclimating their bodies to the grueling demands of extreme heights. Amazingly, research on the Sherpas’ ability to cope with high elevations has not been done. Researchers from the Orthopedic Specialty Hospital in Utah asked Apa and Lhakpa to undergo a barrage of tests before leaving Salt Lake City for Kathmandu, and again during the climb. Results from the medical and nutritional research are still being analyzed, but it is clear that there is something unique about the Sherpas that allows them to excel at elevation where others break down. Making it to the top is always a thrilling, but all climbers know an expedition is only a success if they make it back home. Apa and Lhakpa were almost back to basecamp, about halfway through the Khumbu Icefall, when they were asked to head back up the mountain to help retrieve the body of a climber who had been killed in an avalanche. Although they had never met the Korean man who perished, Apa and Lhakpa honored his family by helping to bring his body back down the mountain. This required going through the icefall at the time of highest risk, late in the day after warming from the intense sun. Many climbers, including Apa, believe the icefall is the most dangerous part of the Everest climb. The record-holders finally made it back to basecamp, albeit on a sad note, but they still found energy enough to celebrate with the basecamp team. They started by calling their families. Missing his wife and three children in Utah, Apa was in a hurry to get back to the United States, so the team wasted little time packing up camp. “We were the last to arrive and the first to leave,” Lhakpa said about the mere 22-days the team spent at basecamp, surely another record for Everest expeditions. “Everybody was jealous that we had managed to make the climb so quick.” Lhakpa was also excited to get home, but he had a present to pick up for his wife Fuli. The team headed to Kathmandu, where they were treated like royalty and swarmed by the media and wellwishers. When things finally settled down for the heroes, they headed for the U.S. Embassy in Kathmandu, hoping to get final permission to take Lhakpa’s three children—ages 10 to 16—to North America. It took some work, but permission was granted and the team plus three returned to Utah on May 30. “I feel like we have accomplished so many goals, but it is most important that the children are here now with their mother,” said Lhakpa. “Education is so important and now they can go to schools here and be with us.” Although they both hint that their time on Everest is over, Apa and Lhakpa both say it is too soon after their latest expedition to decide if they will return to attempt another climb. “One never knows. We will have to see what happens in the future. The mountain will always be there,” they said. information For more information on the SuperSherpas Expedition visit www.supersherpas.com. For a detailed day-by-day account of the expedition with pictures, video, and notes from Mount Everest basecamp visit: www.sherpas.sltrib.com. biography Brett Prettyman has been an outdoors writer and editor for The Salt Lake Tribune since 1990. the explorers journal exploring climate change charting a new course for Pl anet Earth by m a rga r et D. Low m a n The Dry Valleys in Antarctica, photo by David Marchant, Boston University “A race is now on between the techno-scientific forces that are destroying the living environment and those that can be harnessed to save it.” - E.O. Wilson 20 For more than a century, the collective talents of the Explorers Club have tested the limits of human stamina. Our members have rocketed into space, dived deep into our oceans, and ventured into cave systems and rainforest canopies. And, in the process of exploring our planet, they have been instrumental in pioneering new technologies to facilitate the discovery and recovery of information, whether a new species or previously unknown geophysical process. Perhaps more important, our colleagues have championed the need to conserve Earth’s wild places not only for explorers of the future but for humanity as a whole. In his new book, The Revenge of Gaia, British environmental writer James Lovelock, who has long viewed our planet as a complex superorganism, claims that Earth is about to catch a morbid fever that may last as long as 100,000 years. Climate change is not a localized phenomenon—restricted to developing countries or expanding urban areas. It is a global issue that affects the entire planet. Hurricanes are increasing in numbers and intensity as a consequence of the warmer oceans that trigger increased storm cycles. Warmer temperatures are melting polar ice at unprecedented rates, and also drying out remaining fragments of tropical rainforest, leading to increased fire frequency. Most scientists, myself included, agree that Earth is rapidly approaching a tipping point, beyond which the costs and technology for ecosystem repair may become prohibitive. For The Explorers Club, what began as an idea embraced by a select few of our members has become a mandate for our organization—to ensure a healthy future for global exploration. As the club’s vice president for research and education, I will be working with our president, Daniel A. Bennett, and our board of directors to guarantee that research and education become primary components of all expeditions supported by the organization. While the future may look bleak for the environment, we believe our profound desire to chart a new course for our planet offers exciting economic opportunities for new green technologies and initiatives. As explorers, our goal is not only to explore, but to educate and inspire. the explorers journal exploring climate change 1 No. Venturing Of t h e exploring our planet’s polar regions: to t h e E nds Earth chroniclers of the past and portents of the future by Paul A ndr ew M ay ewsk i It has been 50 years since the first International Geophysical Year (IGY) invited the best minds in science from around the globe to join forces in tackling issues such as understanding Earth’s oceans and atmosphere and the delicate relationship between them. Since then, many advances have been made in this area, among the most important, the understanding of the role of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide (CO2) in determining Earth’s climate. In more recent years, a realization that gases such as CO2 are on the rise has led to an interest in determining and documenting past levels of greenhouse gases. Gathering such information, however, entails journeying literally to the ends of the Earth. For there, locked in thousands of meters of ice, are records of our planet’s changing chemical and physical climate that stretch back nearly a million years. When I began my climate research nearly 40 years ago, few in the scientific community regarded Earth’s polar regions as important to the vast majority of civilization. At that time, Antarctica was viewed as not only a frozen continent but also a continent frozen in time. This view seemed to be amply supported by the ice-free valleys of the Victoria Land Coast in East Antarctica, where rocks had been exposed to millions of years of 22 wind erosion, creating timeless landscapes. The vast interior of the polar plateau also appeared to be changeless to the few limited expeditions that passed but once across the surface. Increased access to the most remote portions of Antarctica and the Arctic—afforded by aircraft and ship in recent years—complemented by our ability to mount lighter, faster, and more efficient expeditions and establish well-equipped field stations, has resulted in the acquisition of an abundance of information that is dramatically changing our understanding of the critical role polar regions play in Earth’s complex ecosystem. Remarkably, these regions have now emerged as “first responders” for monitoring current climate because they are so sensitive to warming; the vast ice-trapped environmental libraries they host chronicle hundreds of thousands of years of Earth’s climate history. The ice cores we extract from the polar regions contain highly robust records of past climate. These ancient records not only allow us to better understand the long-term cyclical changes in climate caused by natural phenomena such as the 26,000-year precession of the equinoxes, which is in part responsible for the ice ages; volcanic eruptions; and solar activity, but to separate these factors from variations in climate the explorers journal Discovery of abrupt climate change by the Greenland Ice Sheet Project Two (GISP2) in 1992 revolutionized the understanding of climate change. Prior to 1992 climate change was viewed as a slow process, taking thousands of years. Following 1992 changes in temperature and atmospheric circulation intensity were demonstrated to operate frequently and rapidly (change in less than 10 and in some cases less than two years). Data for this figure from: Mayewski et al., 1994, Science, 1997, Journal of Geophysics; Grootes et al., 1997, Journal of Geophysics. wrought by human activity. Moreover, the study of particularly deep ice cores such as those we have recovered from Greenland and Antarctica is yielding a number of paradigm-changing concepts about how the climate system operates. When I directed the Greenland Ice Sheet Project 2 (GISP2) in 1993, we recovered the first ice core to bedrock, extending to 3,056 meters, below the surface in Greenland. The resulting climate record was annually dated back to 110,000 years ago and instead of demonstrating, as 24 assumed to that date, that climate changes slowly over hundreds to thousands of years, showing that temperature, precipitation, and atmospheric circulation can change dramatically in the span of a decade. The finding was an absolute break with scientific consensus. The idea that in less than a decade—and in some cases within two years—the climate in a region could change so rapidly opened up the possibility for significant climate surprises. Close correlation between the abrupt climate events evident in ice core records and those found in cores taken from ocean floor sediments suggested that changes in ocean circulation accompany changes in the atmosphere. Such abrupt climate change events appear to be most dramatic in the North Atlantic, no doubt a consequence of the fortuitous shape of the North Atlantic basin with respect to sea ice formation, which allows the extent of sea ice to vary over a considerable area. Examination of the GISP2 ice cores reveal that since the departure of the major Northern Hemisphere ice sheets some 10,000 years ago, abrupt climate events are of significantly smaller magnitude—a mere 1º to 2ºC in temperature—than their Ice Age counterparts. Yet such seemingly small changes in climate can have a major impact on ecosystems and civilizations. The demise of the Akkadian culture in Mesopotamia 4,200 years ago and the decline of the Maya civilization ca. A.D. 900 can both be attributed in large part to shifts in atmospheric circulation, which led to drought. The Norse colonies in Greenland in A.D. 1400 found themselves more isolated with each passing year as a consequence of increased sea ice, which made it impossible for European ships to resupply the settlements. These findings send a clear and imperative message to modern society: we are not immune to even small changes in climate. When the Arctic Climate Impact Assessment (AICA)—which included not only our ice core data, but research from many other Arctic projects—was released in 2004, it demonstrated without a doubt that our planet was well into the initial stages of warming and, as expected, early evidence would come from the polar regions, notably temperaturesensitive Arctic sea ice and surrounding glaciers. Earth’s northern polar reaches consist of a vast ocean encircled by land—the inverse of the southern polar region. Arctic seas and lands are home to diverse populations of wildlife, vegetation, and people. In recent decades, the delicate Arctic climate balance has begun to change dramatically as a consequence of greenhouse gas warming. The extent and thickness of sea ice has diminished, permafrost is thawing, coastal erosion is accelerating, the abundance and distribution of plants and animals has been altered, and glaciers are retreating at accelerating rates. A soon-to-be-released study developed by several of us under the auspices of the Scientific Committee for Antarctic Research (SCAR), entitled the State of the Antarctic and the Southern Ocean Climate System, emphasizes the critical role that region plays in the global climate system. Climate over the Antarctic is profoundly influenced by its massive ice sheet, which in places is more than 4,000 meters thick. Antarctica holds some 80 percent of the world’s fresh water as ice (glaciers outside Antarctica comprise another ten percent) and along with its surrounding sea ice, the resulting whiteness plays a major role in Earth’s ability to reflect incoming solar radiation. The white reflective surface of the Antarctic ice sheet is doubled in size during the maximum yearly extent of sea ice and sea ice is highly sensitive to changes in ocean and surface air temperatures, making it a highly dynamic component of the global climate system. The extent of the sea ice and its duration determines the vigor of heat exchange between the ocean and overlying atmosphere. Surface and subsurface melting of Antarctic ice into the Southern Ocean leads to the production of the coldest, densest water on the planet. The strongest winds on Earth encircle the Antarctic and blow over the Southern Ocean. The combination of winds and dense bottom water production are primary drivers of the world’s largest ocean current system and therefore are of critical importance to the transport of heat and moisture throughout the planet. The Antarctic ice sheet is today one-and-a-half times the size of the United States and has a sea level equivalent, if completely melted, of 57 meters. By virtue of its size, reflectivity, and its surrounding ocean that acts as a heat sink, the warming impact of human source changes in greenhouse gases (rise in CO2, CH4, and N2O, and decrease in upper atmosphere O3 ) may be partially buffered, but for how long? Mounting evidence suggests that warming is beginning to impact ever-increasing portions of the Antarctic and Southern Ocean. Model projections suggest that over the twenty-first century the Antarctic interior will warm by approximately 3º to 4ºC, which exceeds temperatures of the last few million years for this region, and sea ice extent will decrease by some 30 percent. Estimates for sea level rise are on the order of six to seven meters over the next 2,000 years, but there is no reason to assume that the rate of change will be linear. Massive melting and sea level rise could occur at any time as a consequence of ice sheet destabilization (through heating of surface ice, basal ice, or ocean-ice contact points). Changes in climate (temperature, precipitation, ocean and atmospheric circulation, sea ice, atmospheric chemistry) over the Antarctic and the Southern Ocean will have a dramatic impact on the global climate system. Significant regional climate changes have already taken place in the Antarctic during the past 50 years. Atmospheric temperatures have increased markedly over the Antarctic Peninsula. Glaciers are retreating on the Antarctic Peninsula, in Patagonia (see page 36), on the sub-Antarctic islands, and in West Antarctica adjacent to the peninsula. The penetration of marine air masses has become more pronounced over portions of West Antarctica. Well above the surface, the Antarctic atmosphere has warmed during winter. The upper kilometer of the circumpolar Southern Ocean has warmed, Antarctic bottom water across a wide sector of east Antarctica has freshened, and the densest bottom water in the Weddell Sea has also warmed. In contrast to these regional climate changes, over most of Antarctica near-surface temperature and snowfall have not increased significantly during at least the past 50 years (therefore no offset thus far for rising sea level due to melting), and ice-core data suggest that the atmospheric circulation over the interior has thus far remained in a similar state for at least the past 200 years. Due to its unique meteorological and photochemical environment, the atmosphere over Antarctica has experienced the most significant depletion of stratospheric O3 on the planet, detected through monitoring that began with the IGY five decades ago. The depletion is in response to the stratospheric accumulation of man-made chemicals produced largely in the Northern Hemisphere. The ozone hole influences the climate of Antarctica (smaller ozone holes also impact the the explorers journal southern victoria land antartica Mt. Erebus, the only active volcano exposed on the Antarctic continent; the massive Ross Ice Shelf, which drains glaciers flowing out of the Transantarctic Mountains and portions of West Antarctica; and the city block-size icebergs spawned off the ice shelf can be seen from the coast of Southern Victoria Land, East Antarctica. Arctic), allowing solar radiation to penetrate to the surface, and along with the global rise in CO2, CH4, and N2O, provides immense potential for climate change over the Southern Hemisphere. The Southern Ocean is our most biologically productive ocean and a significant sink for both heat and CO2, making it critical to the evolution of climate past and present. Therefore it acts as a wild card for future climate change that is human-induced. 26 The Arctic Ocean is expected to be nearly ice free by the latter twenty-first century in response to greenhouse gas warming. In the process, habitats and lifestyles throughout the Arctic will continue to change dramatically. A climate surprise portented by our ice core research in Greenland may appear in the cooling of northern Europe, induced through warming, which increases Arctic ice melt. This in turn increases the influx of fresh water into the North Atlantic. The salinity decrease as a consequence of the freshening in the Arctic may be sufficient to reduce the density of North Atlantic surface water, leading to a reduction in deepwater production and, as a consequence, reduced heat transport to northern Europe. In addition, changes in precipitation and atmospheric circulation are evolving over the Northern Hemisphere as a result of warming over the Arctic and lower latitudes. Temperatures of the last few decades are the highest recorded in the instrumental era—the last 100 years—and through examination of temperature reconstructions utilizing ice core, tree ring, historical, and other data series, it is clear that Northern Hemisphere temperatures are the highest of at least the last millennium. This finding, repeated by several investigators and validated by numerous reviews of the data, is a consequence the explorers journal northern victoria land antartica During our first over-snow exploration of a vast region of Northern Victoria Land in 1974-75, our four-member University of Maine team spent more than 100 days traversing the mountains and crevasse fields of this remote region of Antarctica of human activities that have led to rapid recent rise in greenhouse gases. The effects of this rise will be part of the climate change system for many decades to come. There is, however, even more to the story of human impact on the chemistry of the atmosphere that is revealed through ice cores. Dramatic and unprecedented increases over the last few decades in acid rain, toxic elements, radioactivity 28 products, and the appearance of humanly engineered chemicals are all recorded. There is hope that the impact of clean air legislation can also be identified in the ice cores in the form of stabilization or a decrease in acid rain and some toxic metals such as lead. Ice cores provide the basis for assessing natural versus human controls on climate and chemistry of the atmosphere. Changes in physical and chemical climate have already taken their toll on the health of both humans and ecosystems through disease, drought, and storms. Drawing upon these two forms of evidence— monitoring of the present-day atmosphere and reconstruction of the past atmosphere—it has become clear that greenhouse gases such as CO2 have risen dramatically in recent years. With a rise clocked at nearly 30 percent in the last few decades, the increase is nearly 100 times faster than any rise that occurred over the past 650,000 years. The cause of this rise as well as rise in other greenhouse gases (such as CH4 and N2O ); the decrease in upper atmospheric O3; the rise in acid rain, toxic elements, and radioactive fallout; and many other significant alterations to the natural state of the chemistry of the atmosphere is undoubtedly—because of its timing, rate, and in some cases unique chemical signature—human the explorers journal MICRO B ES ON THE ROCKS activity. This alarming trend is a critical finding that is now reshaping politics and becoming a factor in both our health and our economy. Without intervention, it will increasingly determine our overall quality of life. However, it is important to remember that we have options. While there is no quick fix for our environmental dilemma, there clearly needs to be action. Immediate reduction in the emissions of greenhouse gases such as CO2 and CH4 will reduce the time it takes the planet to recover, the severity of future change, and the probability of climate surprises. Immediate and more stringent reductions in the emissions of toxic metals and acid rain, for example, will yield a cleaner and healthier environment in months to years depending upon the degree of restriction. While it is certainly true that legislation will lay a major foundation for a cleaner, healthier environment, it will also depend to a large degree on the actions of those in the private and public sectors. Our future could be one characterized by energy efficiency and a return to more natural states of the atmosphere. We have the ice cores to set our standards. The decision is ours and the opportunities for creativity in technology and lifestyle could drive us toward an amazing future. Germs frozen in glaciers for millions of years might revive as global warming melts the icecaps. Scientists investigated samples of the oldest known Acknowledgments ice on Earth, which lies frozen in the Dry Valleys of the Transantarctic Mountains. After melting five U.S. research in the Arctic and Antarctica is supported by the ice blocks 100,000 to 8 million years old, Rutgers Office of Polar Programs of the National Science Foundation. University marine microbiologist Kay D. Bidle Our research has been made possible through the combined and his colleagues found microbes in all the ice and efforts of national agencies such as the National Science grew them in the lab, the first time scientists have Foundation; logistics support provided by the U.S. Navy ever resurrected such ancient, frozen life. and U.S. Air National Guard; help from contractors such as While the young microbes grew very quickly, Raytheon Polar Services and VECO; the Scientific Committee doubling in number every couple of days, the for Antarctic Research (SCAR); and the efforts of the interna- older samples grew very slowly, doubling only tional scientific community. every 70 days. Genetic analysis revealed the older DNA had deteriorated significantly, likely due to cosmic rays destroying it over time. biography While more ancient germs might not last past especially long deep freezes, their DNA still A Fellow of The Explorers Club and director of the Climate could. The researchers —whose findings are de- Change Institute at the University of Maine, Paul Andrew scribed online in the Proceedings of the National Mayewski has led more than 45 expeditions to the Arctic, Academy of Sciences—suggest that as global Antarctic, Himalayas, and the Andes. Co-author of The warming melts the ice, prehistoric microbes or Ice Chronicles, Mayewski received the first SCAR Medal Dramatic human impact on the chemistry of the atmosphere over the past few decades compared to the last 5000 years as genes could flow into the seas, altering the evolu- for Excellence in Antarctic Research in 2006. In October, inferred from ice core records. Data for this figure from: Petit et al., 1999, Nature; Indermuhle et al., 1999, Nature; Etheridge tion of microbes in the oceans. Mayewski and colleagues will carry the Explorers Club Flag et al., 1996, Journal of Geophysical Research; Blunier et al., 1995, Nature; Etheridge et al., 1998, Journal of Geophysical Re- as they undertake an over-snow traverse to the South Pole to search; Chappallez et al., 1999, Nature; Leuenberger and Sigenthaler, 1994, Trends; Etheridhe et al., 1994, Trends; Kang et collect ice cores and pursue related glaciological research. al., 2002, Atmospheric Research; Mayewski et al., 1986, Science; 1990, Nature; Hong et al., 1994, 1996, Science; Schuster et al., —CHARLES Q. CHOI 30 2002, Environmental Science and Technology. exploring climate change Hassan Basagic prepares to sample sediment melting out of 2 No. Canada Glacier, Taylor Valley, Antarctica It’s Not Easy Being Dry the remote valleys of Antarctica I was a young faculty member in the earth sciences department at the University of New Hampshire when, in 1981, my good friend and colleague, Paul A Mayewski, asked me to accompany him on a trip to the Antarctic. And, as they say, “the rest is history.” After a snowmobile traverse of the Rennick Glacier in Northern Victoria Land, we returned to the primary U.S. scientific station at McMurdo. From there we took a short helicopter ride into the Dry Valleys to check on a number of rock glacier sites that Paul had been monitoring. I was struck by the stark beauty and the unusual scenery of the valleys. The western portion of Wright Valley reminded me of the desert of the American Southwest, save for the vast East Antarctic Ice Sheet dripping over the edge of the Transantarctic Mountains. The Dry Valleys have a number of ice-covered lakes as landscape features. As a marine scientist, I was intrigued by the Photo by Sarah Fortner by W. Ber ry Lyons A view of Canada Glacier and the perennially ice-covered fact that lakes could actually exist in such a harsh environment. Throughout the 1980s, I returned to Antarctica with Paul a number of times to investigate the chemistry of many of the small ice bodies in the Tranantarctics, but could not forget about those fantastically strange lakes in the Dry Valleys. In the early 1990s, Bob Wharton, a Fellow of The Explorers Club and currently provost at Idaho State University, asked me if I would join a diverse group of scientists—hydrologists, glaciologists, and geochemists such as myself, as well as stream, lake, and soil ecologists and ecological modelers—in drafting a grant proposal to the National Science Foundation (NSF) to establish a Long-Term Ecological Research (LTER) project in the McMurdo region. Knowing I would have an opportunity to investigate the lakes of the Dry Valleys, I jumped at the chance. The NSF had established the LTER program a decade earlier to facilitate the collection of observational data and monitoring of the manipulation of experiments over time within a number of ecological settings. The idea was to better understand how 34 ecosystems function and how they are affected by disturbances, such as climate change. In 1993, our grant was approved and the McMurdo Dry Valley (MCM) region of Antarctica (77º–78ºS) was designated an LTER site. Our activities have focused on the Taylor Valley where Robert Falcon Scott first observed its unusual environment. Taylor Valley is a mosaic of perennially ice-covered lakes, ephemeral streams, soils, outcroppings of bedrock and glaciers. MCM-LTER is classified as a polar desert ecosystem with a mean annual temperature of ~-20ºC and a precipitation rate of ~5 centimeters per year. The MCM-LTER is now one of the 26 sites in the LTER network and is considered a real end-member ecosystem. There are no vascular plants, the streams only flow four to ten weeks per year during the austral summer, and the lakes, although having liquid water, have three to five meters of permanent ice-cover that blocks a high proportion of the incoming radiation needed for phytosynthesis. Yet despite physical constraints, Taylor Valley has an active ecosystem dominated by singlecelled eukaryotes and prokaryotes; in fact, life Photo by Christopher Gardner Lake Fryxell, Taylor Valley, Antarctica. exists anywhere there is liquid water—from the soils to cryoconite holes in the glacier surfaces. Because changes in this polar desert ecosystem are so closely coupled to the generation of liquid water and the change of state of ice/ snow to water, ecosystem dynamics are driven by climate. Very small temperature changes by temperate climate standards are amplified in the hydrologic cycle of Taylor Valley. Like other desert ecosystems, the relationship of the abundance of water to life is paramount, but unlike warm deserts, variations of the degree days above freezing rather than rainfall become the critical factor in the well-being of the ecosystem as a whole. Since the relationship between climate variation, hydrology, and biology may be as tightly bonded in this ecosystem as any other on our planet, our fieldwork includes the monitoring of ice/snow gain/loss on the glaciers, the flow of water in the streams, and the water volume change in the three closed-basin lakes in Taylor Valley. These climatically driven hydrological changes are then related to changes in nutrient—carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus—transport, biological production, biomass gain or loss, and biodiversity in all components of the landscape, including streams, lakes, soils, and glaciers. Today, after nearly 15 years of MCM-LTER investigations of the ecology of Taylor Valley, five of the original eight principal investigators are still together. Our group places around 30 scientists in the field every year. These include the now old and grizzled principal investigators as well as technicians, postdoctoral fellows, and graduate and undergraduate students. Because Antarctic research is international by nature, we also maintain strong research collaborations with a number of colleagues from New Zealand and Britain. In addition, we have had team members from Germany, the Czech Republic, Austria, Russia, and Japan in the field with us. biography W. Berry Lyons is currently director of the Byrd Polar Research Center and a professor in the School of Earth Sciences at Ohio State University. the explorers journal exploring climate change 3 No. Realm of the Ice-Cloaked Moun ta in Gods high in the Andes hope is melting away by Consta nza Ceruti For centuries, if not millennia, people of the Andes have venerated their ice-capped mountains, which harbor within their glaciers the sacred waters upon which all life in the region is dependent. It is a tradition evident not only in the region’s rich archaeological record, but one that continues today in the many communities that thrive in the shadows of the awe-inspiring peaks. Over the past decade, our team from Catholic University of Salta has recovered bundles of offerings and sacrifices left on Andean summits, which attest a profound devotion to the mountain gods—the highest found to date atop Llullaillaco, a 6,700-meter-high volcanic peak in northern Argentina. There, 500 years ago, three Inca children were sacrificed and buried along with textiles and amulets on this lofty mountain. As messengers to the realms of the gods, they would intercede for the good health of the Inca emperor and for a plentiful supply of water to ensure fertility of the llama herds and abundant crops. Archaeologist and National Geographic Explorer-in-Residence Johan Reinhard and I could not believe our eyes when we first came across the face of the six-year-old girl after almost a month of archaeological fieldwork, enduring the cold and the extreme altitude of Llullaillaco’s summit. 36 In Quechua, the language of the Inca, Llullaillaco, means “that which lies about water, or which hides the water.” It is a fitting moniker as Llullaillaco is the only mountain in the area to have a permanent ice field on its high slopes, which one might liken to a small hanging glacier. Yet this volcano feeds no streams or rivers that might quench the thirst of the Atacama Desert at its feet. Instead its waters are contained in a hidden lagoon, 1,000 meters down from its summit. Our sense of wonder would only grow stronger in the months that followed when we studied the mummified remains of a 15year-old Inca maiden, and the seven-year-old boy back in our university laboratories; the CT scans showing all their organs, including the brains, in a near-perfect state of preservation. Seven years have passed since we discovered the Llullaillaco ice mummies, and their presence among the living has contributed substantially to our knowledge of ancient Andean cultural heritage and the need to preserve it. Looting has long been a major threat to the archaeological sites in South America, and the Inca mountaintop shrines are no exception. On a previous expedition to the 6,100-meter summit of nearby Mount Quehuar, we recovered a partly destroyed mummy bundle that had been dynamited by treasure-hunters. But extraordinary sites such as these face a far greater foe in the form of global warming, a silent destroyer of Andean heritage and an ancient tradition of mountain god worship that continues to this day. The retreating glaciers, brought on by everincreasing summertime temperatures, are taking their toll on the religious life of the Andes. This became evident during a recent pilgrimage I observed while in the Vilcanota Range of the Andes in southern Peru. The Taytacha Qoyllur Ritti (Festival of the Father of the Star of Snow) is one of the most important mountain pilgrimages in the Andean world. Every June, some 70,000 people gather at the glacier basin of Sinacara, the vast majority of pilgrims, merchants, and dancers coming from the Peruvian Sierra and the highlands of Bolivia. Some come from places as distant as northern Argentina and Chile, which, in the fifteenth century, were part of the greater Inca Empire. Sinacara lies at an elevation of some 5,100 meters at the foot of the snow-capped Qolque Punku (the Silver Gate), not far from Ausangate, a sacred mountain revered by the ancient Inca and still invoked during initiation ceremonies and divination rituals. Today, however, the festivity is nominally dedicated to the worship of an image of Christ depicted on a sacred rock near the glacier, where, according to legend, Jesus is said to have miraculously appeared to a young indigenous peasant in the eighteenth century. During the five-day festival, masked dancers don costumes representing the different ethnic groups of the Andes and dance day and night for hours. The qhapaq chunchos, adorned with feathered headdresses, incarnate the indomitable tribes of the Amazonian rainforest, on the lower slopes of the eastern Andes, while the qhapaq collas represent the wealthy Aymara herders of the Bolivian highlands. The physical endurance of the dancers is in itself an offering to the nearby mountain spirits or Apus, especially to Apu Ausangate. During the climax of the festival, young “bearmen” known as ukukus, climb the glaciers that flow down from Qolque Punku. Acting as mediators between the pilgrims and the mountain spirits, the ukukus climb at night—braving freezing temperatures, bridging crevasses, and confronting the ghosts of condemned souls—to retrieve ice revered for its healing properties. In years past, the ukukus would extract large chunks of ice—as big as they could carry on their backs—and return to their home communities, where it would be broken up and distributed among the villagers as blessings from the Apus. But sadly, things have begun to change and global warming is to blame. As the ukukus descended the glaciers of Qolque Punku, many now returned empty-handed. In an attempt to halt the retreat of the glaciers, mountain police now forbid the extraction of ice. Pilgrims are only permitted to collect melt-water in small bottles to take back as relics. One man I encountered brought a tiny effigy doll, representing a bear-man, on whose back he had placed a small handful of ice, hoping to be able to smuggle his precious cargo down the mountain, without catching the attention of the police. With a saddened heart, I could not help but admiring his strategy of resistance, and his fierce determination to honor the ancestral traditions, in spite of adversity. As in ages past, pilgrims, including young children, climbed the lower reaches of the glaciers in daylight to light small candles on the ice. Bare footed and kneeling on the snow, they contemplated the flame in hopes of finding answers to their greatest concerns. Surely they would have preferred to use larger candles, of the kind that the Lord of the Star of Snow is said to like best. But these too are forbidden in another desperate attempt to stop the glacial retreat. The Quechua fear that once the ice is gone, the Lord of the Star of Snow will no longer hear their prayers. In the heart of the Andes, the impact of global warming reaches beyond the imaginable. B IO g r a p h y A high-altitude archaeologist and the author of six books and numerous other publications, Constanza Ceruti is a scientific investigator for the National Council for the Scientific Research in Argentina and a professor of Inca archaeology at Catholic University of Salta. She has climbed more than 100 mountains above 5,000 meters. A recipient of the Gold Condor, the most important award given by the National Army of Argentina, Ceruti was named an Emerging Explorer of the National Geographic Society in 2005. In 2007 she received the Courage Award from the Wings Worldquest. the explorers journal JS: One of the goals of the expedition was to visit Inuit living in remote villages and learn about their experience with climate change. What did the Inuit share with you? exploring climate change WS: We traveled with three Inuit hunters who are all in their 50s or 60s, men who were born in igloos or huts. They were nomadic and had a traditional culture when they were young, so they have seen all the changes. We also interviewed more than 100 hunters, elders, and women in the villages to get their input. We were able to see the surroundings through their eyes so we got quite a bit of feedback on the expedition. It is remarkable how fast things are changing up there. The Inuit are basically marine people who rely on the sea ice to hunt walrus, seal, and fish. In some areas they do hunt caribou, but the sea ice is really their hunting platform and also their means of transportation. They told us how the reduction of sea ice by almost a third over the past year alone has affected their culture. The Inuit are noticing much later freeze-ups, anywhere from six weeks to two months, and then earlier break-ups. In the area that we traveled in, the sea ice would normally be around for about nine months out of the year, but it’s now reduced to six months. Losing the sea ice, especially the summer sea ice, is real bad news for any animals like the walrus and polar bear that live on the sea ice, or a human being that relies on it for hunting. 4 No. heading north with Will Steger JS: What signs of global warming did you personally witness on your recent expedition? F. Scott Fitzgerald once said, “There are no second acts in American lives,” but then the great American writer never met Will Steger. Over the period of a decade from 1986 to 1996, Steger completed the first confirmed, unresupplied dogsled journey to the North Pole; traversed Greenland; crossed Antarctica and the Arctic Ocean by dogsled; and was named the first Explorer-in-Residence by the National Geographic Society. Steger’s “second act” has focused on education. He founded the Global Center for Environmental Education at Hamline 38 University and the World School for Adventure Learning at the University of St. Thomas. He also founded the Will Steger Foundation, launching the Global Warming 101 initiative to raise broad public awareness about global warming as witnessed through his polar expeditions. Managing Editor Jeff Stolzer recently spoke to Steger about the Global Warming 101 Expedition (www.globalwarming101.com), a 1,900-kilometer dogsled traverse of Canada’s Baffin Island, which he completed in May of this year. head shot by Jim Paulson, dogteam photo by John Huston interview by Jeff Stolzer WS: The ice in Cumberland Sound—a large sound about 80 kilometers across and 190 kilometers long—had totally broken up at the end of January, which the Inuit hunters in that area said they had never seen before. We normally would have crossed that sound to get to the village of Pangnirtung but we had to go around. It wasn’t a major deal but it cost us an extra three days and then after we went around it, another storm came in and broke up the ice that we had just traveled on. It was also very obvious that the glaciers are in rapid retreat up there. Another thing we noticed was that in some areas thaws in the springtime and the summer and the snow is melting all the way down to the ground and then freezing solid in the winter, which is impacting the lemming population, which thrives under the snow, where its warm. Small rodents, lemmings are the basic food for the wolf, the fox, to some extent the wolverine, and almost entirely for the snowy owl. In areas where the lemming population is dropping, you have fox and wolf populations that are competing directly with the polar bear, because they’re now going after the ring seals. So when you have one section of the food chain caving in, it affects the entire system because the chain is so delicate. And the Inuit kept pointing that out to us, very clearly. When it affects one, it affects all. But it is actually a lot more serious than that, because we are starting to upset the heat balance on the globe. Eighty percent of the extra heat that is now being captured on the surface of the globe because of human-induced global warming is being added to the ocean. So the whole ocean is warming and the sea level rise is probably due to this thermal expansion of the warming ocean. This is being played out in the Arctic, where we are starting to lose sea ice. In the summer we used to have ice on the Arctic Ocean in that northern area that would reflect 99 percent of the energy of the sun back into the atmosphere. Now, with the thawing of the ice, you’re getting exposed water and ground, which is a darker surface. That absorbs up to 96 percent of the sun’s energy. It’s like the difference on a hot sunny day between wearing a white t-shirt and a black t-shirt. That’s what is happening up north now, and that’s why we’re seeing this rapid change that is three to five times faster than down here. JS: Did you find evidence of global warming everywhere on your expedition or was it a more localized phenomenon? WS: It differs from region to region. Global warming isn’t a blanket warming of the Earth—some areas are actually getting colder. We saw that on Baffin Island. In some areas, there were much stronger winds in the fall. And they never had thawing weather before. As a result the snow was really hard-packed or iced up. And that affected the caribou—there was virtually no game in that the explorers journal t h e Fj o r d Steger and his team nears the head of Clyde Inlet at the mouth Photo by Elizabeth Andre of the Clyde River on the fourth and last leg of the expedition. 40 the explorers journal to 50 below weather. So there was a remarkable difference. It was a relatively mild winter compared to what it would normally be there. Polar Bear tracks A polar bear has left his mark on a JS: Mountaineer Ed Viesturs and entrepreneur Richard Branson participated in this expedition. How did they respond to the rigors of traveling by dogsled and the frigid conditions? desolate track between Qikiqtarjuaq to Clyde River, a region heavily populated by the animals. JS: You had some encounters with polar bears on this expedition. Tell me about those. WS: Yes, we had quite a few. We had 50 dogs and they were always staked between the camp and downwind, so they were our early warning system for bears and we always had plenty of notice when 42 the bears came in. We had one bear that actually wandered into our camp at about two o’clock in the morning, but we were very much aware of it and we used a couple of explosive devices to scare it off. The problem with bears is if they come into camp unexpectedly and then you go out of your tent in the evening and suddenly you’re face to face with a bear, that’s when it’s dangerous. So having the dogs, we stayed relatively safe. JS: I understand that Richard Branson is working on a film about your expedition. JS: In 1986, you and seven companions dogsledded to the North Pole, roughly during the same months as your recent expedition. The 1986 expedition started and ended north of Baffin Island, but were you able to see major differences in terms of the ice, open leads, temperatures, etc? WS: Yes, you can compare the two expeditions because the route that we did in 1986 now has open water, very thin ice, so right now that route has totally changed. Baffin and the region that we were recently in are the coldest of the Canadian Arctic and there they would normally have three months of solid winter—40 to 50 degrees below zero, the ice doesn’t move, it’s very good for hunting. This year they had about a three-week period of that 40 Photo by Sarah McNair-Landry area. And in those areas it is very difficult to make igloos, because the ice is so hard-packed, particularly around the Probiscer and Callowan area. At Home Bay in eastern Baffin the snow is really quite deep, the wind hadn’t blow much. In that area, it seemed quite normal, the bear population was up. But we’re seeing the bear population starting to be affected by global warming on the fringes, like in southern Hudson Bay—that population has dropped by more than 20 percent. And then you have up at the Beaufort Sea north of Alaska on the Arctic Ocean, that population is dropping, and Spitzbergen and Svalbard—that area is also seeing the bear population go way down. So on the fringes, you’re getting a polar bear decline. But in the center, that population is still really viable. But if this warming trend continues, within 20 years that population is also going to drop. WS: They responded quite well. They joined us in the Spring, when we had fantastic weather. The temperature didn’t get much below zero and we had 24-hour light, so it was ideal to travel. They got a break that way. Ed Viesturs is a very tough guy, he can handle anything and he did very well. He’s a great guy to work with and is used to working in close groups. Richard has been on expeditions before in close quarters, he is an easy guy to please, he’s not grumping over the food rations, he’s always good-natured and a very upbeat guy. His son, Sam, was there, a great young man, 21 years old. I think he’s going to be a future leader in dealing with the challenge of global warming. So these three guys were really fun to travel with. Before they joined us we had been traveling as a group of eight, so it was nice to have some new blood and we had some great conversations. You know, Richard showed up at our expedition after traveling and conducting business for two months and despite a shoulder injury he really did quite well. On the first day he did 50 kilometers. It was also great to be around a person who is working on finding solutions to global warming. WS: Yes, we’re doing a film, and our main goal is to put a cultural face on global warming, in addition to the science. The field has changed a lot in the last six months—global warming is everywhere, people are talking about it. But I still think people are really confused about the science of it. If they can perceive it from a cultural and human perspective, it really touches them. If we look at global warming as an ethical and moral issue, a human rights issue, and show people who are really affected by it right now, I think it will drive people to action. We also wanted to get the Inuit voice out there. They are innocent victims in global warming and they don’t really have a say in what’s going on. JS: You had a major educational component to this expedition. Can you talk about what did in terms of using the internet and developing classroom lesson plans? WS: Yes, globalwarming101.com was our website and we had quite a bit of traffic on that. We did a couple things for K-12 education with lessons plans and we were connected to a number of schools around the United States and in Canada. We broke ground on this during the expedition. When I was up here 20 years ago, before the internet, we used primitive technology to bring the adventure live into the classroom. Now it’s live on the internet. So the expedition is the spark that drives people into your program and we used the expedition as an educational platform around which we weaved the content. Once people are drawn in, they’re curious and open about learning things about the Arctic and what’s changing there. JS: In terms of expeditions, what is up next for you? WS: My next major expedition will be March to May in 2008, up in Ellesmere Island. It’s a 2,250kilometer expedition and I’ll be traveling with five teammates, all ages 21 to 25. Everybody has a considerable amount of experience on the ice and with dog mushing, so we’re going to work with National Geographic and do our own program, to first of all be an eyewitness to global warming. We’re going to look at the ice shelves of northern Ellesmere and survey what’s left there—most of them have slipped into the ocean. Also, we’re going to be working with photographer Jim Balog, who just did the cover story for National Geographic, to put out some remote control, time-lapse cameras to photograph the glaciers there on an hourly basis for several years to record their retreat. So we have a great scientific package, but I’m also passing the torch to the next generation. It’s going to be their issue and I wanted to show them firsthand, as eyewitnesses, what’s left up there. They will be ambassadors to their own generation. I really have a lot of faith that this younger generation is going to take ownership of this and they will be a political force in the near future. I really want to do what I can to encourage that and help people empower themselves. the explorers journal In the Footsteps of Alexander an aerial adventure by M a r ily n Br idgeS As I fly across the vastness of Anatolia, something in the distance catches my eye, beckoning me to come closer. What at first appeared to be an incongruity in the landscape resolves into a pattern made by ancient hands. Passing beneath my wingtips, my quarry reveals itself to be the sublime remains of a once-great city, silenced by the passage of time. For a brief moment I lose all awareness of the present. Leaning out the open door of my single engine plane, I sometimes feel like Artemis the huntress in my pursuit of the past. With mounting excitement, I wonder how much of an ancient site might still be visible. Sometimes, I’m amazed to find much more than I expected. Given access to almost any point in three-dimensional space, I control both the airplane and the camera at will, selecting the best altitude and direction of view. Working solely in black and white, I paint with light, using sun and shadow to accentuate the sculptural forms of my subjects. I want to create a mood that allows us to experience these sites as if in a dream, without the distraction of transient colors. For this journey, I have followed the route taken by Alexander the Great when he began his conquest of the Persian Empire in 334 B.C.—tracing the Aegean and Mediterranean coasts of Turkey from Troy to Side, and then flying inland to Sagalassos and then on to Cappadocia. A crossroads between Asia and the West in Classical and Hellenistic times, Anatolia was a vibrant wellspring of architecture and philosophy. Later, as the Roman province of Asia, it boasted some of the wealthiest cities of the empire. Now part of modern Turkey, Anatolia contains more magnificent Greek and Roman sites than any other part of the world—its rich history and scenery a splendid subject for aerial exploration. I am struck with the immensity of the transformation of these ancient cities into magnificent ruins. Human as well as natural causes produced this metamorphosis. A succession of cultures occupied and altered most of the sites through many centuries. Cities were destroyed by earthquakes and wars, and rebuilt by their original inhabitants or their conquerors. Temples and theaters were quarried and their stones recycled, obliterating and accreting layer upon layer of history. At Simena, for example, a medieval fortress with crenellated walls encloses a Hellenistic theater and overlooks a Turkish village built among the ruins of an ancient Lycian city. The coastal city of Miletos was one of the greatest commercial ports in the world until the Maeander River silted up its harbor, choking off its access to the sea. For a few centuries, the city held off its fate by dredging channels through the silt, but the inexorable river could not be defeated. Today the ruins of Miletos lie half buried in a desolate plain, many kilometers from the sea. The Roman theater there has a Byzantine fortress strangely perched as Freya Stark would say, “like a barnacle on its back.” biography Renowned for her extraordinary black-and-white aerial photographs of ancient sites, Marilyn Bridges is the visual author of Markings: Aerial Views of Sacred Landscapes (Aperture 1986), Planet Peru: An Aerial Jour- HERAKLEIA UNDER LATMO ney Through a Timeless Land (Aperture 1991), Egypt: Antiquities from Above (Little Brown & Co. 1996), and This Land is Your Land (Aperture 1997). Her work has been featured in solo exhibitions by over 300 museums and galleries, including the American Museum of Natural History, the Smithsonian Institution, the Field Mu- On a promontory extending into Lake Bafa, the ancient cem- seum of Natural History, and the Royal Ontario Museum. Bridges received an MFA from the Rochester Insti- etery of Herakleia slumbers in silence. Hundreds of Carian tute of Technology. She was awarded a Guggenheim Fellowship, a Fulbright Scholarship, and the 2003 Wings tombs, some in pairs, a few in family groups, are cut deeply Trust Award, for “Courage and Artistic Excellence”. She is a licensed pilot and a Fellow of The Explorers Club. into the bare rock. The ruins of a Byzantine fortress guard For more information, see www.marilynbridges.com. the headland. 44 Aqueduct at Aspendos The Roman aqueduct carried water across a valley for nearly two kilometers to the acropolis of the city. To keep Aspendos in line, Alexander exacted hostages and tribute from the city in 334 B.C. 46 the explorers journal Islet near Kekova This tiny islet, near the island of Kekova, holds the remains of ancient walls and rock-cut rooms. 48 the explorers journal Temple of Apollo at Didyma The site of a famous oracle, the temple was never completed. The Persians destroyed the temple in 493 B.C. After conquering neighboring Miletos in 334 BC, Alexander had the temple reconsecrated. Four years later, when Alexander was in Egypt, the oracle at Didyma reported that he was the son of Zeus. 50 the explorers journal Miletos The great theater dates from immediately after the time of Alexander. A Byzantine fortress clings to it, “ like a barnacle on its back”, in the words of the English traveler Freya Stark. Miletos was the greatest commercial emporium in Asia Minor. When Alexander arrived, he found a Persian garrison in control, and Miletos thus became the first city to offer him resistance. Alexander vigorously besieged the city and blockaded the Persian fleet until Miletos surrendered. 52 the explorers journal Extreme Cuisine food for the epicurean adventurer Here are t wo of my camp favorites Zinfandel Capellini serves 4, Weight one dried serving: 6 ounce 1. Heat in a large skillet over medium heat: Living Well in the A California-based writer, Linda Frederick Yaffe is the author of Backpack Gourmet, High Trail Cookery, and the recently released Solar Cooking for Home and Camp. 54 • 1 onion, minced 3. Reduce heat, add and cook 5 minutes longer: • 8 ounces diced fresh brown crimini mushrooms • 4 cloves garlic, minced • 12 ounces capellini pasta, broken in thirds 5. Stir into the mushroom mixture and cook 5 minutes: To enjoy gourmet dining in the wilderness, here are the basics: • Buy or borrow a food dehydrator with a heater and fan. • Cook a soup, stew, or casserole as though you were making Biography • 2 teaspoons extra virgin olive oil 2. Add and cook until transparent: by Linda Fr eder ick Ya ffe Imagine feasting on hot gourmet meals at 4,000 meters…without cooking in camp. It’s simple: prepare one-pot meals at home, slide them into a dehydrator, dry until crumbly, then bag them for your next adventure. The ancient art of food dehydration is wonderfully basic. Heat and air circulation remove most of the water content from food. This lack of water keeps microorganisms from living and growing. Since complete meals can be dried yearround in any weather, it is easy to take advantage of each season’s bounty, using the finest ingredients available. And because home-dried meals can be stored up to two years, you can keep a ready supply on hand for extended expeditions or unexpected weekend escapes. In all my years of home drying gourmet backpacking meals, I have never lost food to spoilage. I have, however, encountered the wrath of my fellow travelers, who were destined to dine on store-bought freeze-dried that was both expensive and flavorless. with Linda Frederick Yaffe 4. Meanwhile, cook until barely tender then drain : Outback “...what does he care if he hasn’t got any money: he doesn’t need any money, all he needs is his rucksack with those little plastic bags of dried food and a good pair of shoes and off he goes and enjoys the privileges of a millionaire in surroundings like this.” —Jack Kerouac, The Dharma Bums, 1958 Outdoor Cooking tonight’s dinner, cutting the ingredients into small pieces for faster drying. • While it’s cooking, cover mesh dehydrator trays with oven-proof parchment paper or 100 percent polyethylene plastic wrap to keep liquid foods from leaking through. • Spread the cooked food in a thin layer on the covered trays and place in preheated dehydrator. • Dry the food until it’s crumbly—about 4 to 6 hours. Check while drying, occasionally turning the food and breaking up large pieces. If you detect any moisture, continue to dehydrate • Let the food cool completely. The next day double-bag in small plastic bags, label, and store in a cool, dark, dry place or refrigerate in a black plastic bag for best long-term quality. • In camp, pour the dried meal into a pot. Cover with water, boil, stir, and serve. These lightweight meals need no soaking or simmering. The following recipes go from pack to plate in three minutes. Excellent dehydrators are available by mail: E xc a l i b u r www.excaliburdehydrator.com 1-800-875-4254 N e s c o/A m e r ic a n H a rv est www.nesco.com 1-800-288-4545 • 15 ounces canned small white beans, rinsed and drained • 1/3 cup T.V.P. (textured vegetable protein) • 3 cups finely diced tomatoes plus juice • 1/2 cup chopped fresh basil leaves • 1/3 cup zinfandel wine • 1/4 cup salsa • 1/2 teaspoon salt • 1/8 teaspoon cayenne pepper 6. Remove skillet from heat and stir in: • 1/2 cup finely grated Parmesan cheese 7. Toss together the pasta and sauce, stirring to coat. 8. Spread on covered dehydrator trays and dry for 5 hours at 145 degrees. 9. To rehydrate, cover with water 1/4 - 1/2 inch above level of food in pot, boil, stir, and serve. Bouillabaisse Serves 4, Weight one dried serving: 4 ounces 1. Steep together in a measuring cup then set aside: • 1/4 cup warm water • 1/2 teaspoon saffron threads 2. Heat in a large skillet over medium heat: • 3 teaspoons extra virgin olive oil 3. Add and cook for 8 minutes: • 1 sweet yellow onion, diced 4. Stir in and cook 5 minutes longer: • 5 cloves garlic, minced • 4 fresh mushrooms, diced • 1 teaspoon minced fresh thyme or 1/2 teaspoon dried • 1/2 teaspoon salt • 1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper • 1/8 teaspoon celery seed 3. Place the onion and saffron mixtures in a soup pot. Stir in: • 3 cups fresh or canned diced tomatoes plus juice • 2 pounds boneless, skinless fish fillets cut into 1/2 inch cubes • 1 whole bay leaf • 2 cups chicken broth 4. Cover, bring to a boil, then reduce heat and simmer for 30 minutes. 5. Discard bay leaf. Stir in: • 1/4 cup dry white wine • 2 tablespoons minced fresh Italian parsley 6. Spread on covered dehydrator trays and dry for 6 hours at 145 degrees. 7. To rehydrate, cover with water 1 inch above level of food in pot, boil, stir, and serve with crusty bread or crackers. BACKPACK GOURMET Good Hot Grub You Can Make at Home, Dehydrate, & Pack for Quick, Easy, & Healthy Eating on the Trail $12.95, PB, 160 pages, 20 illustrations, 5 1/2 x 8 1/4, 978-0-8117-2634-4 Learn to prepare and dehydrate over 160 soups, stews, pastas, casseroles, breakfasts, and snacks for easy eating on the trail. SOLAR COOKING FOR HOME AND CAMP $12.95, PB, 128 pages, 23 illustrations, 5 1/2 x 8 1/4, 978-0-8117-3402-8 Full of recipes developed especially for solar cookers—entrees, side dishes, snacks, and baked goods—with instructions for making your own solar box or folding panel cooker. Available from your favorite bookstore or STACKPOLE the explorers journal BOOKS www.stackpolebooks.com • 1-800-732-3669 EXPEDITION MEDICINE your heatlh and safety in the field Rest Insured by Mich a el J. M a n ya k , M.D., FACS 56 There is nothing more exhilarating than the moment you realize that you really ARE going on that expedition, the one you have been dreaming about for years or have been unexpectedly asked to join. Your excitement, however, soon becomes tempered by logistics and by sobering thoughts of health and safety. It is a well-known adage at The Explorers Club that an adventure is an expedition that has gone wrong. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the area of travel medical insurance. Rest assured that the subtleties of your policy for your particular situation may not be apparent until you are in the midst of a crisis. Although we often take our health care for granted in an industrialized urban society, we lose that confidence on remote travel…and for a good reason. Travel health issues are far more common than suspected. As many as one half of people who travel to developing areas report problems. Many of these get resolved, but some eight percent of an estimated 50 million travelers become ill enough to seek medical care abroad or upon reaching home. So, how do we get medical help if something arises on the road? An important component of any trip should be arranging for travel medical insurance to include evacuation. Do not assume that tour operators or travel companies offer more than very basic services. Often these do not exceed minimal temporary medical care and emergency transportation to a regional medical facility, which may be inadequate for anything other than basic first aid. Without proper insurance, costs can be considerable with evacuation expenses alone frequently ranging over $100,000. • Medicare and most health maintenance organizations do not provide coverage for international travel. • Even comprehensive medical insurance policies do not cover evacuation. • Travel insurance has one or more components: 1) travel assistance for logistics—lost luggage, trip cancellation, etc., 2) medical coverage for treatment, subject to policy limits, and 3) evacuation. Not all may be included in a policy. • Check the exclusions in any policy you have. Many adventurous activities are excluded from policy coverage and alcohol or drug-related incidents often are not covered. • Medical evacuation occurs by the decision of the insurance company; it is not triggered by natural disasters or outbreak of hostilities. • The insurance company determines Her e are som e k ey the destination for the evacuee, p o i n t s t o c o n s i de r : regardless of patient and family • Surgical mortality is almost 20 per- desires. With few exceptions such as cent higher in Western Europe than Global Rescue out of Boston, MA, you in the U.S. This rises to nearly 30 per- do not have a vote. cent in Eastern Europe, to more than • 70 percent in Latin America, and oxcart (interpreted by the insurance higher still in the rest of the world. company as the most readily available • Private medical insurance cover- means of transfer) to the outpatient age on domestic policies generally clinic in the next village (designated has similar coverage for interna- regional medical facility), establish tional travel. Check your existing before departure what would happen policy before travel. for a serious medical event. To avoid being transported by the explorers journal Ex Post Facto ownership statement tales from The Explorers Club archives It’s All About Pecking Order by Cl a r e Flemming, M.S. “I decided in my teens that I would do what one woman could do to show that women had as much brains as men and could do things as well if she gave them her undivided attention.” ~~A. S. Peck Determination can be everything in exploration. Nowhere is this more evident than in the research collections of The Explorers Club. For there, among the records of numerous firsts in exploration, is a file, within which is a paper trail documenting a seminal exchange between famed Victorian mountaineer, Annie Smith Peck, and the powers that be at the Peary Arctic Club of New York , more than a century ago. Born in 1850, Peck was educated in classics at Rhode Island College and the University of Michigan, prior to landing a professorship at Smith College. Shortly thereafter, she found herself drawn to mountaineering. Venturing out on her own, she summited a number of peaks, including Mexico’s 5,700-meter Pico de Orizaba, 58 radically breaking with tradition by climbing in pants. She soon realized that she could make her living as a mountaineer and lecturer, and left her post to engage in climbing—and its associated fundraising—full time. In June, 1899 Peck penned a letter to Herbert Bridgman, secretary of the Peary Arctic Club, in hopes of joining one of Robert Peary’s early polar expeditions: I had the pleasure yesterday of meeting Mr. [Russell] Porter who told me of the expedition to Greenland this season and gave me your address. I thought that if possible I should like to take this trip if it is not too expensive. Of course I am used to roughing it and traveling quite independently, and I think I should not bother any body as some women might. Three gentlemen attempted the ascent of Orizaba [Mexico] with me, but only one of them reached the summit. Very truly yours, Annie S. Peck Despite the fact that Peary had previously included his wife Josephine on his expedition to Greenland, and certainly relied on numerous Inuit women for his numerous Arctic needs, Bridgman made it clear in his telegraphed response that Peck was not welcome: “Peary Arctic Club cannot accept women in hunting party.” And so—bother or no bother— Miss Peck was not to be a part of that or any of Peary’s expeditions. Instead she set her sights on the majestic Andes and would become, in 1908, the first person to summit the 6,768-meter Peruvian peak, Huascarán. The following year, she planted a suffragette pennant on top of 6,400-meter Coropuna, also in Peru. To this day Peck retains the honor of being the only woman to make a first ascent on a major world peak. Annie Peck died in 1935 at the age of 85 in Brooklyn, New York. 1. Publication Title: The Explorers Journal. 2. Publication Number: 00145025. 3. Filing Date: 10/1/07. 4. Issue Frequency: Quarterly. 5. Number of Issues Published Annually: 4. 6. Annual Subscription Price: $29.95. 8. Complete Mailing Address of Headquarters or General Business Office of Publisher: The Explorers Club, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021-4928. 9. Full Names and Complete Mailing Addresses of Publisher, Editor, and Managing Editor: Publisher: Daniel A. Bennett, President, The Explorers Club, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021-4928. Editor: Angela M.H. Schuster, The Explorers Club, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021-4928. Managing Editor: Jeff Stolzer, The Explorers Club, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021-4928. 10. Owner: The Explorers Club, 46 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021-4928. 11. Known Bondholders, Mortgagees, and Other Security Holders Owning or Holding 1 Percent or More of Total Amount of Bonds, Mortgages, or Other Securities: None. 12. Tax Status: The purpose, function, and nonprofit status of this organization and the exempt status for federal income tax purposes has not changed during preceding 12 months. 13. Publication Title: The Explorers Journal. 14. Issue Date for Circulation Data Below: Fall 2007. 15. Extent and Nature of Circulation: Average Number of Copies Each Issue During Preceding 12 Months: 4,000. Number of Copies of Single Issue Published Nearest to Filing Date: 3,200. a. Total Number of Copies 3,200. b. Paid Circulation: 2,819. (1) Mailed Outside-County Paid Subscriptions Stated on PS Form 3541: 2,572. (2) Mailed InCounty Paid Subscriptions Stated on PS Form 3541: 247. (3) Paid Distribution Outside the Mail, Including Sales Through Dealers and Carriers, Street Vendors, Counter Sales, and Other Paid Distribution Outside USPS®: 0. (4) Paid Distribution by Other Classes of Mail Through the USPS: 0. c. Total Paid Distribution: 2,819 d. Free or Nominal Rate Distribution: (1) Free or Nominal Rate Outside-County Copies included on PS Form 3541: 0. (2) Free or Nominal Rate In-County Copies Included on PS Form 3541: 0. (3) Free or Nominal Rate Copies Mailed at Other Classes Through the USPS: 104. (4) Free or Nominal Rate Distribution Outside the Mail: 277. e. Total Free or Nominal Rate Distribution: 381. f. Total Distribution: 3,200. g. Copies not Distributed: 277. h. Total: 3,200. i. Percent Paid: 88.09%. 16. This Statement of Ownership will be printed in the Fall 2007 edition of this publication. 17. I certify that all information furnished on this form is true and complete: Angela M.H. Schuster, Acting Editor-in-Chief. THE EXPLORERS CLUB LEGACY SOCIETY reviews edited by Milbry C. Polk a troublesome tooth yanked out by a fellow explorer without so much as a word. Rica—encounters with beasts of the deep such as sharks, calamities, military threats, madness, hurricanes, and despair. Along the way, Haslett learns many lessons the hard way and imparts them to us, like pearls on the necklace of a castaway. Footsteps on the Ice: The Antarctic Diaries of Stuart D. Paine, Second Byrd Expedition By M. L. Paine 384 pp • Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 2007 • ISBN-10: 0826217419, ISBN13: 978-0826217417 • $34.95 According to Paine family lore, 22-year-old Stuart Paine, chafing in the New York summer heat, decided to remove his coat while at the office. When his boss told him to put it back on or go to Antarctica, Paine opted for Antarctica. Shortly thereafter he signed on as a dog-sled driver for Admiral Byrd’s 1933 expedition to chart the southern part of the continent. Paine kept detailed notes of his experiences on the expedition, which his daughter, M.L. Paine has edited in Footsteps on the Ice. The result is charming. The reader is able to virtually take every step with Paine, from arduous 1,100-kilometer treks to having 60 Voyage of the Manteño: The Education of a Modern-Day E xpeditioner By John Haslett 336 pages • New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2006 • ISBN-10: 0312324324, ISBN-13: 978-0312324322 • $25.95 Inspired by his hero, Thor Heyerdahl, John Haslett decided in 1993 to make his own balsa raft and attempt to recreate the sailing feats of the ancient coastal Ecuadorians, by sailing from that coast all the way to Hawaii. Haslett ended up with two balsa raft expeditions, learned a tremendous amount about ancient sea craft design as well as human nature in what turned into a harrowing series of near disasters. Odysseus-like Haslett endured shipwreck— in Panama and in Costa Top Secret Tourism By Harry Helms 277 pp • Los Angeles: Feral House, 2007 • ISBN: 978-1932595239 • $14 To explore is to go out to discover and investigate places of which little is known. In Harry Helms’ new book, Top Secret Tourism, those places are U.S. military installations. Right up front he warns the intrepid that conducting such exploration is probably illegal and just might get you into lots of trouble. Some like Nevada’s Area 51 are shrouded in mystery and associated with unexplained “Curiosity and inspiration to discover nature’s secrets spring from the minds of those driven to explore. I joined The Legacy Society to help inspire future explorers. Join us!” — Dr. Martin Nweeia Robert J. Atwater Capt. Norman L. Baker Barbara Ballard Robert D. Ballard, Ph.D. Samuel B. Ballen Mark Gregory Bayuk Daniel A. Bennett John R. Bockstoce, D.Phil. Bjorn G. Bolstad Capt. Bruce M. Bongar, Ph.D. Garrett R. Bowden Harry Davis Brooks Lt. Col. Jewell Richard Browder* August “Augie” Brown John C.D. Bruno Lee R. Bynum* Virginia Castagnola Hunter Julianne M. Chase, Ph.D. Maj. Gen. Arthur W. Clark, USAF (Ret) Leslie E. Colby Jonathan M. Conrad Catherine Nixon Cooke Constance Difede Mr. & Mrs. James Donovan Col. William H. Dribben, USA (Ret) Sylvia A. Earle, Ph.D. Lee M. Elman Michael L. Finn Robert L. Fisher, Ph.D. John W. Flint Kay Foster James M. Fowler W. Roger Fry Alfred C. Glassell, Jr. George W. Gowen Randall A. Greene Jean Charles Michel Guite Capt. Robert “Rio” Hahn Allan C. Hamilton Scott W. Hamilton O. Winston “Bud” Hampton, Ph.D. Brian P. Hanson James H. Hardy, M.D. Judith Heath Robert A. Hemm Gary “Doc” Hermalyn, Ph.D. Lotsie Hermann Holton Charles B. Huestis Robert Edgar Hyman J.P. Morgan Charitable Trust Robert M. Jackson, M.D. Kenneth M. Kamler, M.D. Prince Joli Kansil Lorie M.L. Karnath Anthony G. Kehle, III Anne B. Keiser Kathryn Kiplinger Thomas R. Kuhns, M.D. Hannah B. Kurzweil Carl C. Landegger Michael S. Levin Florence Lewisohn Trust* J. Roland Lieber Michael Luzich James E. Lockwood, Jr.* Jose Loeb John H. Loret, Ph.D., D.Sc. Margaret D. Lowman, Ph.D. Robert H. Malott Leslie Mandel Robert E. McCarthy* George E. McCown Capt. Alfred S. McLaren, Ph.D., USN (Ret) Lorus T. Milne, Ph.D. Since 2000, Dr. Martin Nweeia has lead seven expeditions to the High Arctic to unravel the evolution and function of the narwhal’s fabled tusk. James M. Mitchelhill* Arnold H. Neis Walter P. Noonan Martin T. Nweeia, D.D.S. Dr. John W. Olsen Kathleen Parker Alese & Morton Pechter William E. Phillips Prof Mabel L. Purkerson, M.D. Roland R. Puton Dimitri Rebikoff* John T. Reilly, Ph.D. Adrian Richards, Ph.D. Bruce E. Rippeteau, Ph.D. Merle Greene Robertson, Ph.D. Otto E. Roethenmund James Beeland Rogers, Jr. Faanya & Robert Rose Rudy L. Ruggles, Jr. Gene M. Rurka Avery B. Russell David J. Saul, Ph.D. Willets H. Sawyer, III A. Harvey Schreter Mr. & Mrs. Donald Segur Theodore M. Siouris William J. L. Sladen, M.D., D.Phil. Susan Deborah Smilow Sally A. Spencer Pamela L. Stephany Ronnie & Allan Streichler Arthur O. Sulzberger Vernon F. Taylor, III Mitchell Terk, M.D. C. Frederick Thompson, II James “Buddy” Thompson Marc Verstraete Van de Weyer Robert C. Vaughn Ann Marks Volkwein Leonard A. Weakley, Jr. William G. Wellington, Ph.D. Robert H. Whitby Julius Wile* Holly Williams Francis A. Wodal* * Deceased A s l on g a s t h e r e i s Th e Ex pl or e r s Clu b, you r n a m e w i l l b e li s ted a s a m e m b e r of t h e L eg a c y S o c i et y. THE LEGACY SOCIETY COMMITTEE Theodore M. Siouris (Chairman), Robert J. Atwater, George W. Gowen, Scott W. Hamilton, Brian P. Hanson, Kathryn Kiplinger, William E. Phillips For information and to join us: The Explorers Club, 46 East 70th Street New York, NY 10021 212-628-8383 www.explorers.org RE VIEWS objects and sounds some attribute to UFOs, others to aircraft testing. Some like New York’s Plum Island, are toxic. Others are depots for unknown quantities of chemical and biological warfare weapons. Trying to be helpful, Helms includes maps but they are little more than an arrow pointing off into nowhere along a desolate highway. Too Close to the Sun. Born in 1887, Denys Finch Hatton was raised on a country estate, learned to hunt and to dance, was educated at Eton then Oxford, gliding through with an effortless style that was the hallmark of upper class English life. When family fortunes declined, Denys’ elder brother inherited the estate and its accumulating debt, while Denys was encouraged to make his fortune abroad. Denys chose Kenya, arriving there in 1911. After a series of false starts, Denys made himself into the most sought-after white hunter, taking rich clients, including princes, into the game parks. Wheeler’s book brings to life the brief flame of colonial Kenya, peopled by a dashing daredevil elite such as Finch Hatton. the Sun: The Audacious Life and Times of Denys Finch Hatton By Sara Wheeler 320 pages • New York: Random House, 2007 • ISBN-10: 1400060699, ISBN-13: 978-1400060696 • $27.95 The enigmatic Denys Finch Hatton looms large on the romantic landscape of bygone Africa. Immortalized in his time by two lovers, Karen Blixen (aka Isak Dinesen) in Out of Africa, and Beryl Markham in West with the Night, Finch Hatton remains alluring long after his untimely death—having crashed his plane in 1931. Now, his life has been chronicled by Sara Wheeler in 62 A Naturalist and Other Beasts: Tales From a Life in the Field By George B. Schaller 272 pages • San Francisco: Sierra Club Books, 2007 • ISBN-10: 1578051290, ISBN-13: 978-1578051298 • $24.95 In his new book, A Naturalist and Other Beasts, George Schaller, author, field biologist, and long-time affiliate of the Wildlife Conservation Society in New York, has given us a snapshot of his experiences studying an array of animals over the past 50 years. Schaller’s pioneering work observing pandas, mountain gorillas, tigers, lions, deer— all subjects of past books such as The Mountain Gorilla and The Last Panda—changed often erroneous public perceptions about the animals, led to the establishment of preserves and paved the way for hundreds of field researchers to follow in his wake. More recently, Schaller has been engaged in studies of the Tibetan Plateau, an area little understood environmentally and whose species are highly endangered. Schaller’s book is divided into geographical sections: Americas, Africa, South Asia, China, Mongolia, and the Tibetan Plateau, with chapters in each devoted to his research subjects, including blue herons, wildebeests, tigers, and pika respectively. Schaller comments during his return to the Virungas to see the mountain gorillas 40 years after his original research, “I do not like to return to places where my heart rests, fearful that things have changed.” While nothing can stop the tsunami surge of human population growth and the subsequent worldwide environmental destruction. it is thanks to individuals like Schaller that there are places and unique species left at all. THE EXPLORERS CLUB c h a p t e r c h a i r s 46 east 70th street, New York, NY 10021 I 212-628-8383 I www.explorers.org N at ion a l ch a p t er ch a irs Alask a Robert W. Taylor, M.D. Tel: 907-452-4900 Fax: 907-457-1701 [email protected] [email protected] At l a n ta W. Hayes Wilson, M.D. Tel: 404-351-2551 Fax: 404-351-9238 [email protected] Ce n t r a l F l or id a G. Michael Harris Tel: 727-584-2883 Fax: 727-585-6078 [email protected] Chi c a g o / G r e at L a k e s Mel Surdel Contact person: Cheryl Istvan Tel: 312-640-0741 Fax: 312-640-0731 [email protected] G eorg e Rog e r s Cl a r k Joseph E. Ricketts Tel/Fax: 937-885-2477 [email protected] G r e at e r P ie d m on t Nena Powell Rice Tel: 803-777-8170 Fax: 803-254-1338 [email protected] J u p i t e r F l or id a Rosemarie Twinam Tel: 772-219-1970 Fax: 772-283-3497 [email protected] Ne w E n g l a nd Gregory Deyermenjian Tel: 978-927-8827, ext. 128 Fax: 978-927-9182 [email protected] N or t h Pa cif i c A l a s k a Mead Treadwell Tel: 907-258-7764 Fax: 907-258-7768 [email protected] N or t he r n C a l if or ni a Lee Langan Tel: 415-931-3015 Fax: 415-398-7664 [email protected] Pa cif i c N or t h w e s t Edwin J. Sobey, Ph.D. Tel: 425-861-3472 Fax: 503-214-7849 [email protected] P hil a d e l p hi a in t er N at ion a l ch a p t er ch a irs A rg e n t in a Hugo Castello, Ph.D. Fax: 54 11 4 982 5243/4494 [email protected] A u s t r a l i a - Ne w Z e a l a nd Peter Hess Tel: 302-777-1715 [email protected] Ann McFarlane, Ph.D. Tel: 61-2-9328-4883 Fax: 61-2-9328-4888 [email protected] Rock y M o u n ta in Canada S a n D ieg o East Asia William F. Schoeberlein Tel: 303-526-0505 Fax: 303-526-5171 [email protected] William T. Everett Tel: 760-765-3377 Fax: 760-765-3113 [email protected] S o u t he r n C a l if or ni a David A. Dolan, FRGS Tel. 949-307-9182 [email protected] S o u t he r n F l or id a Stanley L. Spielman, M.D. Tel/Fax: 305-233-8054 [email protected] Southwest Brian Hanson (Chapter Liaison) Tel: 512-266-7851 [email protected] S o u t h w e s t F l or id a Col. Gerry W. Bass Tel: 239-594-5224 [email protected] S t. L o u i s Mabel Purkerson, M.D. Tel: 314-362-4234 [email protected] Texas Ted D. Lee Tel: 210-886-9500 Fax: 210-886-9883 [email protected] Wa s hin g t on DC Dr. Lee Talbot Tel: 703-734-8576 Fax: 703-734-8576 [email protected] Joseph G. Frey Tel: 416-239-8840 [email protected] www.explorersclub.ca Dr. Michael J. Moser [email protected] G r e at Br i ta in Barry L. Moss Tel: 44 020 8992 7178 [email protected] I ce l a nd Haraldur Örn Ólafsson Tel: +354 545 8551 Fax: +354 562 1289 [email protected] Ind i a Avinash Kohli [email protected] N or way Hans-Erik Hansen Home Tel: 47 22-458-205 Work Tel: 47 67-138-559 [email protected] P ol a nd Marek Kaminski Home Tel: 48-695664000 Work Tel: 48-58-5544522 Fax: 48-58-5523315 [email protected] [email protected] Ru s s i a Alexander Borodin Tel: 7-095-973-2415 [email protected] W e s t e r n Eu rop e Lorie Karnath Tel: 49-1723-95-2051 [email protected] WHAT WERE THEY THINKING ? great moments in exploration as told to Jim Clash landing on the Moon with buzz aldrin JC: What do you remember about your lunar landing on July 20, 1969? has landed,” it struck me as, “Gee, we’re in the middle of something, Neil, don’t do that!” Buzz Aldrin: Obviously, when we touched down, we were very relieved. Neil [Armstrong] and I acknowledged that with a wink, a nod, and a pat on the shoulder. The immediate surface was very powdery, as best we could see looking down from five meters. Off in the distance was a very clear horizon, maybe with a boulder. And, of course, the brightness of the sunlit surface was almost like looking out at sunlit snow. Your pupils close down, just as in orbit when the sun is on the spacecraft. The sky is black as can be, but there’s no way you can see stars. They’re there, of course, but you can’t make them out, because they’re too faint with all the ambient light in your eyes. Knowing that we were going to call ourselves Tranquility Base—but we had never rehearsed that because we didn’t want people to know—we hadn’t inserted that historic announcement into our procedures checklist. So when Neil said, “Tranquility Base, the Eagle Jim Clash: How did you feel when you stepped onto the lunar surface? 64 Buzz Aldrin: Can you give me some multiple choices I can pick from to describe my emotions? I don’t go through life verbalizing what I feel. After the fact, it’s really kind of difficult. I guess if you’re used to doing a lot of describing, those things come easily. That’s why, I guess, the greatest inadequacy I’ve experienced in my life is when someone asks, ‘What did it feel like?’ I have a very hard time trying to tell someone. I could probably manufacture all sorts of wondrous things. But in retrospect, I felt like we were proceeding with the checklist, such as carrying the camera down. There are lots of little things, more than meets the eye. More of Jim Clash’s columns and videos can be found online at www.forbes.com/adventurer.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz