Political versus Economic Institutions in the Growth
Process
Emmanuel Flachaire, Cecilia Garcı̀a-Peñalosa, Maty Konte
To cite this version:
Emmanuel Flachaire, Cecilia Garcı̀a-Peñalosa, Maty Konte. Political versus Economic Institutions in the Growth Process. 2011. <halshs-00586038>
HAL Id: halshs-00586038
https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00586038
Submitted on 14 Apr 2011
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.
1
GREQAM
Groupement de Recherche en Economie
Quantitative d'Aix-Marseille - UMR-CNRS 6579
Ecole des Hautes études en Sciences Sociales
Universités d'Aix-Marseille II et III
Political versus Economic
Institutions in the Growth Process
Emmanuel Flachaire
Cecilia García- Peñalosa
Maty Konte
April 2011
Document de Travail
n°2011-20
!
"
"
" "
' "
# " !
( *
"
#
!
# $
# "
" "(
%
!
)
#
% $
%
# "#
"
"
!
&
( +
! $
*/0 */% $ &
&
1 2 $
" )
3
$
"#
@
4
&
"
?
&
"
%
)
*$
(
5
=&
<
!
%
<
(!
@
"
#
!
=&
"
$
%
"
"
! #
"
" ,( *
"
" $
$ % $
%
(
% $
%
#
%
& $
% $
$
%
( .
' " %
&$
#
%
(
"
5 ;
(>
5 ;
?
5 ;
(!
!
!
% $
" "
#
"
)
"% $ &
% $
%
!
$
"
&
"
"
$
%
" %
!
"
456
3
45 7 89 4 /: (
=&
0
"
"
=&
1
"
0
&
$ )$
1
(%
"(!
&
"
<
=&
"
=& 0
1
()
?
(
*
"
"
% $ (
"" #
)
%
"
"&
% $
#
$
"&
"
( *
&$
!
%
( *
3
! $
" "
$
% $
% $
( +
"
&
#
&
#
&
$
"
%
!
3
$
&
!
"
!
"$
$
3
$
!
% $
)$
% $
!
"A
(
.
!
%
( B
&
:C& $
# "
%
"
"
"
D
% E
"(
&
!
&
"
"
%
A
$ )
#
"
"A
%
A
""
"
.
$ !
% $
0
%
"
% $ &
%
)
'
"
( 2
% $
$
% $
"
#
#
"
"
%
%
"
' "&
"
-C(
&
( B
!
( 2
B ,,:C& F
B
,C& <
/C
"
"
%
" G
&
& "A
%
%
%
"
> B
C
"9 )
"8
%
B
,C(
( B
C(
% $
%
"
"
#
"
%
"
( +
$
"
B ,,,C&
#
!
" %
$
A
$
A
&
#
3
)
( B
"
$
"
! %
! "A
" !
"A
"
6 &!
6 *$
%
% $
% $
&
(
@
&
"
6
$ ) !
"
!
"
" A
&
%
%
"
!
$ ) $
( .
#
!&
!
&
%
"
% $ ( 2
"
!
" #
$
%
!
0
!
%
#
%
( B
C&
( *
&
$ "
$
( B
/C&
"
"
!
!%
"
#
&
$ )
2
&
!
%
%
"
% % $
"
"A
#
%
( .
"
$
&
( .
#
%
"
.
"
&
"
" G
B
B ,,,C
" $
#
"
%
"
"
!
#
!
"
( .
%
"
"
>
E
" 9 )
#
"
&
!
B
"
!
( +
)
'
"
(
JC $
*
H
&
"I
!
"
@
&
$ %!
%
"4
"5
B
!
/
%
!
%
( B
:C&
( B
"
(
&$
"
"
!
!
"9
-C(
( 8
". #
%
B
0
0C& H
*
H
B
7C
3
$
% $
( B
A
$
$ "!
C&
% $
!
!"
6
%
C
"
( .
!
%
$
D
' "
' "
!
!
%
#
"
(
)
"
!
"
&
"
"
' "
A
!
"
$
% '
"
"
$
' "
&
!
B
" "% $
,C
"
$
@
'
% $
C(/
'
# $
!"
!
!
% $ 1
!
". #
"(
"#
A
%
" "#
%
!
#
#
"
( B
%
#
!
$
,7 C
"I
%
!
%
!
4
!
%% $
&
"
$
"
# $
$ ) !4
B ,,:C& F
)
"
"
" &
%
" &
#
%# )
"
$
!
%
"
' " %
! "A
! :
$
"
(
%
'
%
# " #
"
%
H
" "
"
%
&$
!
"
#
" % $
!
"#
"
% % $
#
#
#
" !
$
>
(
! "
% ( *
$
%
%
%
" ,-
*
%
"
(
B
%
". #
0C&
( B
/C&
B
7C
"A
% $
"A
!
%"
%
"
( +
"
"
&4
A
.
"5
#
%
&
%
!
% $
% $
%
& $
%
( *$
&
"
%
> B
( B
%
!
"
8
&
#
( <
( B
!
"% $ (
"# "A
%
$ $
&
"
"
$
" $
"A
A
"
"
% $
!
"
%
&
!
%
!
$!
(
H
(
!
!
% $
#
#
# $
A
%$
$
&
"
"
$
"
C
&
!
( 4
,C
A
"A
C
C
%
!
%
"
% $
"
B
% '
B ,,:C(: 6
! "A
%
"A
"
"
!
"' "
&$
"G
"
%
"
!
$
%
&$
(
.
%
!
@ "
!
$( 6
"
" "
%
"
&
"
( .
B
C&
% !
&!
"
( 6
"
B
)
%
% $
#
( B ,, C& $
!B
C
K ( :
δ
"
C
"
%
"
" "% $
!
3
!
δ
δ
C&
B
C( *
δ
!
B
%
B
)$
"H
" (
"
#
C&
!
$ %
8
:
H
#
!#
"#
δ
6
"
#
"
δ
:
!
#
% $
$
#
%
#
$
!% $
H
( 2
%
%
0$
%
"
!
%
% $ &
!
!
&!
( +
"
&
"
"
"
!$
A
!
"
#
# $
" % '
"
"
δ
δ
ε
( B
/
-C&
%
(
B C
$
K ( :
%
%
( .
"" "
C&
$ "
.
"
-/ "
B
&
"
$
"
" "#
" "
"&
8
!
#
C
"
( *#
! *$
"
( B
,C&
"
"A
&
#
( B
&
%
$ )& H
%
3
&#
#
"
4
!
#
%
!
!
)&
!
& $ $
" "
!
+<
%
( +
"
#
%
#
"
" (J
$
% ! $ "&
"A
# $
!
"
( .
"
" $ "A
"
"
#
!% $
"
"
!
!
" "
( .
%
!
,7 & ,, C(
"
"
( 2
" ' "
B4
!
"I
/C
( +
"
B ,,:C
" $# )
!
!$
!
%
!
%
"
$"
#
" !
"
E
#
)
#
$
" D"
"
%
"
( *$
!$
#
!
. #
!
" E
!
+ 5
!$
"
%$
&$
,C
"A
@ "#
"#
" ,7 & ( (
H '
"
" B+ 5 C& #
#
&
"
"(
#
$
(
( B
% !
D $
>
*$
!
!
"
(
(
"
5 )
"
:
% / J #
# %
!
B ,,:C( .
+<&
#
!
!
% $
(
,C( +
"
"
+
"
% $
( B
!
"
!
!
" ,-
*$
&
"
!
"!
%
"
&
!$
"
-0
$
(
+
"
"
"
%
!% $ 1
% %
#
"
$
. #
J
C&
"$
"
"
#
"
"
&#
*$
%
" % B
*
!
% $ &"
C(
2
#
!
$
B
B
A
"
!
F
:
B
0C
"
%
( B
/C(
%
# $
!
"" !
"
!
( 2
2
"B
$
2C !
+
%
"
( .
%
%
%
)
& !
#
B0(J,C
!
#
" #
&
!
( .
"
$
%
"
&$
( +
#
F
$
$
"
&
"
&
"
"
!
# $
% $
& "
% $
$
#
"
"
"
$
#
&#
#
$
#
$
/C( 6
"&
!
" ( ,
&
#
!
" &
"
( 7
%
$
# $
% $
$
#
(
3
"$
!
$
%
(
#
& . #
0"
( 2
"
!"
#
%
# $
# $
!
(
& $
&
!
$
"A
(
!
% (//
"
%
( .
(
(
! (
# $
#
!
"A
% $
!
"
"
&
"
"!
" B
$
!
"(
#
%
%
!
!
$
#
"
%
%
#
)
( +
!
#
"
&
$
"
&
. !
!
A
$
$
&
"
&$
(
+<( .
"A
"
"
!
"!
$
. #
$ %
&
%
%
"
B-(-,C( *
%
:
.
9
"
&
&
!
% $
$ " '
"
%
"
#
$& $ $
"
)
"
"
!
% %
&
( .
6 %
!"
&
"
&
!
"
"
!
"
"
%
" %
# $
"
"
%%
"
" &
8
@
&
!
!
!
"
!
!
1
!
%
" #
"
!:
"
(
)
"
!
#
"
$
%
%
%
#
!
"
&
"
%
%
!
%"
J
"#
!
"
#
"
"
( .
"A
"
#
( +
"
& #
$
%
.
'%
& <
&
8
$
!
$
C( .
@
#
!
&#
%
$
"
# $
& #
#
%
"
$
%
.
"
"L
"
"
# #$
#
" #
"A
&#
$
( +
"
#
#
"
#
&
!
%*"
"( .
$
9
&$
"
"$
"
&$
!% $
&
"
!
!
B*96C
<
"
"&
9
) &
"
!
" "
)
$
( 2 '
"+
%
!
% $
"
&
" %
!$
%
+<
"
$&
"
&6
&
!
"
63
"
(
#
"
$
8 @ &
"
3
"
&
#
!
3
""
.
"
!
%
%
&#
( .
$
&
&
%
&$
"
!
"A
% "
"
"
B
"
#
#
%
#
"
!
3
@
6
$
$
<
!
( +
$
$
$
"
#
"A
&
( .
# $
@
$
A
B
C
#
"5
"
B+<C
"
A
B5 C
$
%
"
!
(
'
.
'
B
C
"
% '
B
. #
/
*96
"
%
$
C&
B
C
&
.
"
# "
" %
B
!
#
&$
C
B
% $
B
"
C
!
!
$
-
"
I
% '
C
#
" B
"
% '
C(
#
" #
+<
H
( .
&
$
I
%
"
% $ ( +
I
( .
( . "
B
3
" "
$
#
% C&
"
:
:
#
B
%C
/
"
"
# !
+<
$
"
#
%
B6 %
B
&
$
$
N
"$
"
#
&
$
!
#
@
( .
%
B
(
#
:&
)
"
"
#
( :-&
(
C( *
"I
&
"
" %
JC( 4
B
!
C
I
# "
%
#
!
% '
! #
( 6
#
@
"
"
#
/0 #
!
!
$
&
"
"
!
%
A
!
(
%
"
! #
%%
( +
"$ )
+<
"I
&
!
"
"
#
"%
$
!
%
A
( .
#
!
&
$
#
"
$
!
#
!
%
& 3
6
%
) !
$
#
p
#
!
H
1
" %
%$ )
"
!
"$
!
"
"A
N
:M #
!
" "
% $
P
'
B
"
3
"O
&
"
"$
"(7 .
N
N
"
#
N
!
" %
"
%%
!
" %
"
!
*96
!$ )
@ C(
*
I
A
"
$!
6 %
$
&$
"
C& $
!
( 2
C& $
:M
C&
&
" %
!
" BF
" %
&
)
&$
N
& $
& "
&
% '
% $ (
$
B
(-
%
&
#
" %
$
%
#
!
( 6
&
"
(
$&
.
'
#
"
7
#
:
" *96
"
6
.
)
%
% !
%
( B
%
:C !
'
"
% F
& "$ )
A
!
!
$
(
7
(
" %
"
( 6
# ( +
( 2
" "
"
!
*96
I
"
I
F $
&
%
%
"
( +!
&
" B C
!
"
# "A
A
%
%
C
"
"
"
#
"
A
!
#
δ
"#
" %
I
"
$
"
$
"
(
#
"
!
"
#
:
!
B
"
B C
"
:M
& $
' " A
"B
' "
" B CC(
I
(
N
A
#
"
" &
A
" *96
" &
!
% '
# &
' "
"
%%
%%
( +
#
%
' " A
F
%
" $ !
. #
% '
C& $
"
$
% '
< .
#
%
i
"
&$
!
(
I
& $
p
"
"
" '
"
"
% '
#
& δ i& $
%
"
I
!
!
C( .
"
"&
"
B' " A
A
"&
(
& δ ,...,δ ( 2
"
"&
!
#
"
%
$
#
"
' "%
&
)
#
"I
! 3
"
#
#
B
C
&$
" *96
"( +<
#
/&
( 2
% '
#
B. #
$
& $
"
' " A
I
#
%
(
.
. #
:
" # 8
"
" <
"
!
"
N
!
$&$
!
.
#
B ,7-C( 2
$
+<
'
%
!
I
% '
!
(
" "
%
" % '
"
I
.
#
%
1
&$
%
"
"
"' "
% "1
%
"
' " A
)
"
&
!
!
% '
! $ " #
)# $
"
"
% $
( B
!
(
,
/C
!
#
"
(
*
#
(
"#
"
'
!
%
Q + !
%
!
"
"
" "
( +
$
!
& #
%
:C
"
"A
$
% #
"
%
(
"
)
A
'
' "
" "
%
%
&
"
3
!
&$
"
'
!
%
&
&"A
A
%
(
'
"
%
&
!
%
#
( .
1 y
1 y
y
"
"
# & x
"
"
#
"
( 6
!
$
#
"A
#
" &
β
I
ε ,
xβ
ε ,
% $
$
%
! $ %
ε
"β
"
# %
"#
B C
" ε
"
B
C 3
#
#
(
" B C !$
"
""
" σ &
x"
'
% $
' "
"
&
% %
$ %
"
#
"
"
! σ
& $
"
( 4
% %
$1
" ε
%
" %
#
N ,σ ,
$
y# $
&
N ,σ ,
#
$ %
" B C&
"
!
&
% %
&
% $
%
"
ε
"
"δ
$
!
"
$ "A
"
δ ,δ ,δ ,δ ,δ ,δ
# $
xβ
"
#
"%
"
#
%
%
% %
%
% $
( +
I
( .
$ % $
"
$
%
" "
"
" !
"A
"
$
%
( *
% $
" # $
"#
"
( .
$
#
(
%
%
( +
*
!
"
!
% "
% $
!( .
"
$
!
% $ ( .
%
"
!
"
%
( 8
/C
"
#
!% $
B
$
#
% $
% !
$
&$
$
( B
""
%
%
&
"
% $
)
"
"
!
#
!
$
%
"
#
'
# " ' "
#
&
I
"A
'
y
( F $
#
!
&
#
!%
" %
&
H
!
#
"
%
" x(
&
!
*
" & %
"
# $
#
" %
%
( +
%
!
' " #
" %
"
"
(
! ""
%
'
%
&
"
(
"
#
&
#
"
@
#
"
% "
%
#
"A
$
#
1
( .
!
$
" !
" "
&
#
#
" "
(
"
!
# #
#
%
(
%
%
"
# $
K
f y x, z,
K
$
%
#
# #
αk & β k
!
"
'
)
$
"
%
)
"
#
K& '
%
%
"
!
"
""
% #
&
,7,C(
,
"
"
'
"
!
#
B C
"
"#
#
%
( .
8
% )
'
!
&
" "
#
&"
B + &
8+
K
!
+ !
" 8+
6 %
,-7&
" ' "
n
% )
"
"!
( +
) ) + !
8+
$
"
# "I
"A
@ %
".
"
"
( B ,--C( .
" # 6 $ @ B ,-7C&
"F
K
% %
x( .
fk
"
"
!H
$
#
" fk y x β k , σ k
" !
xβ k & !
! #
B C(
!
"$
#
E yx
B0C
# #
"( +! $
3
K
!
!
"
"
z&
#
@ "#
" σk
$
& π k z, αk
%
#
$1
π k z, αk fk y x β k , σ k ,
k
!
k $
!
"
9
B/C
"n
"
#
B
C
"
(,
! #
"
"
B
C(
"
"A
$ "
%
A
%
'
$
"
%
!
&
(
#
%
&
$
!
!
%
%
$ "
!
!
% $
&
$
%
# #
( 2
"
"
!$
H
!
# #
x
#
$ $
!
(
"
% $
"
#
$
$
" "
"$
$
"
#
I
)
"
(&
% '
( .
&
"A
!
A
%
(
$ %!
"
"
#
%
!
$
"
#
&
"&
% $ &
&
#
" z( .
" !
#
!
%
%
$
*
$
%
%
#
#
#
!
#
%
"
"A
#
"
'
+
#
&
" %
%
"
"A
(
""
&
$
!
(
"A
# #
"
#
#
#
$
% $
(
'
2
#
%
-0
"
#
"
%
#
.
$
""
"
&
"
&
#
% &$ "
%
"
#
"R
$!
& $
#
"
!%
$
$
$
(
. #
J
"A
$
! 8+
'
"
"
&
6
&
"K
U
"
3
%
C #
" !
!
" X
#
'
" $
( B
%
)
" ( .
&$
*$
!
#
!
" "
!'
XST"
B +
( Z
" "
.
"
( .
! #
% $ $
!
"( +
" "
#
$
#
"
( 6
& ( ( K
$
&
" "
( 8
&
#
"
"A
!
!
&
"
$ 8+
#
"
*96
(
! ""
"
+
&
"
,C(
"
#
""
"# 8
( B
C(
" "
%
"
B. # /&
K
!
C&
8+
8+ & 3
:-(/&
%
(
!
%
" $
"
" "
$
" "
. #
8+
!
8+
&
&$
# #
&N
&
% $
"
%
( .
$
%
"
%
$
#
"
!
I
$
( .
"
"%
"
!
% $
!"
%
$
(
&$
#
%
%
#
%%
& $
%
(
.
!
!
#
" "% $
%
#
%
" B
( .
!
#
*
H
( .
N
.
$
! '
!
% $ ( F $
2
!
!
!
C !
"
)$
"
"
I
I
%
%
( B ,, C(
( +
"
!
. #
(
0
"
$
"
!
$
(
#
&
N
%
"
$
%
%
%
V
3
"
"
#
"
I
"$
B
$
$
! 3
$
"A
!
$
2 "
"
%
&#
$
"
%
%
I
%
" :C
%"
&
&$ $
!
/
"
%
F $
. #
I
$
"
"$
(
"
$
A
&
"
% %
" "
%% $
#
&
%
!#
"
"
"
"A
#
$
$
"
% $ ( .
#
'
$ %
# ( .
!%
"
"
$
( .
"
" %
/ (-(
"
"
)
"
#
J (
!
$ % $
% $
$
8+ & $
!
A
"
% '
-
%
# (
&
" 1
%
'
"
" " *96
"'
%
"
!
" $
%
#
( 2
J ( ( .
%%
( *
#
3
%
"
( .
"
"
$
#
$
"
"
#
#
"&
! #
( 2
#
&$
(
(&
2
"
"
# &
)
"
" "
#
"%
%
"
"
% $
"
#
(
&
!
7
"
$
+
!
& $ &
" "
$
2
" "
!
# "C(
. #
!
K
" (
"
$
$ 8+
( 2
% $
( *
!
&
8+
"
V#
$
"
"
%
% '
$
#
"$
!
&
. #
:
3
" &
#
#
" (
"
% '
!
$ %
"
/
"
, J(
"'
"
$
#
&
B8+ S 70/(0C( 4
(
!%
"
(
"
I
'
#
'
$
"
!
'
"
#
"
( Z
%
$
!
"!
%
" *96
,
#
%
$
% '
#
(
"
"
8+
%%
#
$
C
#
( 2
"
" "
%
C( .
"
!
"
&
%
%
" "
)
" "
" "
&
K
#
"
#
"
"$
!
! Z( 2
#
%
"
"
"
" %
B +
!
$
"
"
!
" "
%
$
"
8+
! ""
" "
"
"
$!
"
!'
&
A
! K& $
'
!
" B
"
$
"X
"
"
"
%
B0C !
"A
#
2
3
( . #
&$
(
"
'
%
!
"
I
2
%
"
#
"
"
' " A
"
#
'
(
&$
"
B
"A
"
&$
%
!
( .
"
"
%
"
"'
#
%
#
"
%
$
#
%
( +
%
!
"
B
#
C
$
"
# #
" "
! #
&
"C&
I
%$
.
"
"
!
#
& $
( B
(
K
"
& #
" "
( 2
$
&
'
(
.
%
$
%
"
"
#
"#
" %
"
% '
I
#
"
#
.
%
!
#
' "
.
*
(
:
.
( 9
M
!
I
"
C
%
% $
$
I
%%
(
/
.
"
"
" "
!
&
#
%
(
&
"
# &
A
% $
%
I
" :M& $
" & $
&$
"
% '
&
"A
$ %
"
%
( .
" "
% '
# (
" %
"
!
(
#
B
:
%
"
% %
& $
% '
&
% '
H
!
%
$ %
%
%
"
$
.
#
0
5
/
*
&
#
!
(
%
" &$
"
$
!
# #
( +
%
I
$
%%
"
#
%
!
!
B
% $
%
A
!
(
"
" C( +
!
!
$
B8+ S , J( !
$
%
!
%
&
"#
%
&
" ,70( &
% '
! % $
%
"
"
!
"
!
"
)
$ %
$
" &
!
" "
"A
%"
&
*
&$
"
+
" &$
" 8+ S 70/(0 !
"
(
%
" "
" *96
"
& 8+ S 07(-& ,-/(7&
0
B
"
&
&
, , &$
' "
% $
& XST U& $
#
'
,C $
"
"
'
"(
$ "
""
( 2
% '
$
! *$
'
&
%
$
!
#
%
H
3
(
# $
C ".
B
C(
$
' " % !
" #
% $
"
"9
&
)
:
B
,C $
%
"
"
A
%
& "
# $
"
*
H
"
(
9
&$
#
%
@
%
!
%
#
i#
# #
%
!
( .
"
'
# #
%
"
$
# #
(
. #
π ik ( 2
,
%
0
%
"
%
%
8
$
( + %
(
D %
(/ :M !
$"
B0( 07 %
(::7 !
H
!% $
%
E
%
!
%
!
"
&
%
$
#
$
%
"
" ""
H
"
!
%
( B
%
#
" !
%
!
$
#
! +<
""A
"(
J
"
!
3
(
#
:C(
! J(/70
#
" " "
"
+
&$
"&
%
EV
$
%
$ %
%
& %
&
&
%%
" D% $
( +
C(
"
"&
% "
C&
$
" /( /-&
"#
#
&$
" " "
$
C(
#
" D% $
"
"A
( 7-M !
% "
!
""
!
( .
!
&
&+
"
( F $
"
B7(, ,
B
"6 %
%
:(/:,
# #
#
#
!
%
$ ' "
&
% % $
!
HA
+
EB
" " "
( .
(&$
*
%
# #
'
"%
"
"
#
!
( +
%
#
&
" $
&
%
% %
"
. #
"
#
" %
%
'
# #
!
'
$
!#
": ( . #
#
(
"
". ) C
i
"$
%
"
B:C
π k zi , αk fk yi xi β k , σ k
!#
%
%
&
3
&
(:J ! #
'
π k zi , αk fk yi xi β k , σ k
"
!
( .
% 8
k
K
k
"
%
"
%
π ik
2
%
"&
$
!
(&$&
,
$ ""!
" "% $
" %
!
"
*
#
!
+
$
&
+<
!
"
"
$ %
( +
"
!
'
"
&$
!
$
$
"
"
"
"
"
&$
$
%
!
#
(
" " +<
!
(
"
&$
"
# &
"
"& $
$
!
$
( 2
%
"
%
$
(
$
&
.
$
$
"
%
"
"
. #
"
"
%
!
!
$
" "(
. #
"
% '
, $
" "
I
!
"
&
#
%
! "
#
"
(
&
"
%
%
&
!
%
&
(
(&$&
+
"
#
'
!
"
2
&
#
"
"
( +
%
"
!
B
(
1
%
J
*
!
"
BC
" &
#
#
"
#
!
)
0& $
$
"
.
"
.
'
%
!
"A
-
(
. #
,
$
%
&
"
!
%
&
)
$ % '
( *
%
$
$
#
(
# ( .
( B
( .
!
"
&#
(
!
#
#
I
% '
"#
!% $
#
#
"
%
%
&
#
""
"&
> $ "
& "
%
I
#
&N
"
!
" &
J
+<&
" #
&
(
0(
"
"
%
. #
"B
#
$ ' "
!
!
"
" "#
)
$
&
!
"B C !. #
&
( .
(
C
"
!!
$
"
%"A
"
&
%
!
$"
#
#
%
"
#
"
!
& "
"C&
$
/C $
%
&
%
$
$
!
$
$
$
"
"
"G
/C
&
$
)
B ,,:C( 6
"&
"
B
(
"
!
% $
"
!$
#
%
% "
"
%
&
% '
"
" "( .
#
"
#
$
"
% $
!
( +
#
"
0
!
H
$
%
$
%
"
%
$
% '
(&$&$
*
#
!-
!
V
6
B ,J C !
"
#
$
"A
%
(
$
"
H
&
""
$
B (077
I
"
( ,,C&
%
"
(
'
B
&
7
.
I
. #
!
,C( +
%%
&
%
#
" "(
$
$
)
"
H
!
"
""
!
$ )
(
$
%
% % $
( B
:C( .
$
"$
% $
"
!% $
9
!
%
"
"
"( +
&
I
%
#
6
"*
"
) %!
"
$
'
$
"
"
!
) "( 2
#
$
!
9
% "
!
%
#
!% %
&$
%
%
"
"
%
% '
%
$
( 6
$
&
""
&
( 6
9
$
%
(
% $
"
"
$
(
$ %
$
7
#
%
"
% '
0
" "
!
B C ! . #
I
% '
*
(
&
"%
" %
!
"
"
" %
%
!
-
(
. #
%
#
!
"
" "
"
H
" "
$
"
V
"
% $ C
I
*
% "
# $
B!
"
-
%
"
% '
#
"
"
$
$
!
%
"
$ "
( B
,C !
!
!
#
% $
3
7
"
"
"
$
"
"
"
% "
"
"
$
!
#
! "
(
&
!
! B ,-
,7:C
"
!
B ,7:
C
"
" (
. #
/
!
"
%
&!
'
$
"$
!
" C( 8
$
%
8
"
% #
&
"& . @
#
% '
"&#
"
" "
%
$
"(
&$
" "
"
&
I
"
"
# ( +
A
!
% '
#
% '
(
" "
"
"& $
>
"
% &$
I
&
!
B
"
I
"( 8
I
#
%
"
"
"!
%
!
%
(
.
!
.
"
#
$
" %
%
" #
!
%
"
"
"
&
"
!
& $
& $
!
%
)
( + !
:C&
%
%
%
( .
$
"
(/M
'
%
"
$
" ""
#
!
% % $
#
%
! 0( (
%#
%
&
"
#
A
"
!
"#
!
"A
!% $
#
@ " #
$
&#
$
"
( 2
$ !
%
"
&
(
I
%
% # $
"
$
"
%
%
( B
#
"
! $ % $
% $
#
%
$
"
)
% % (0M
.
"#
(
.
'
&
% $
! % $
"
%
% $
"( *
"
#
!
%
%
%
%
"
%
%
@ "#
I
!
%
% $ (
,
!
%
$"
"
%
%
( .
&
$
"
*
" %
$
% $ &
"
"
#
&
,
*
"
#
>
$
%
!
% '
"
!
% $
% $
"
(
%
$
%
%
"
&
$
% % $
"
#
$ )#
!
% $ &
"( H
%
%
( +!
&
"
%
% $
&
%
%
"
!
!
#
"
%
& $
$
$
!
#
"
Q +
!$
"
( +
$
% $
(
"
$ )
!
A
$
#
(
( 8
&
#
#
"
% $
!!
%"
$
"
$
.
#
"
" #
% $
%
!
" "
"
"
"
#
'
"
( .
! % $ (
( .
' " %
% $
!
" #
( +
! "
&
%
#
% $
#
% $
%
3
%
% $
%
!
% (
+ #
% & H(& 6( G
"
&
" G(
1
(5 #
%
% & H(& 6( G
&
" G(
6
&
B
" G(
% $ (+
" & +(
,
&
%
!
"
&
"
!
& 0J,W / (
B
$
B
"
(5 #
(
C( 5
"
(
C( "
B
%
( 07:W/- ( 4
" (
:C !
%
!!
"
#
1
%
"
(
-(
% & H(& 6( G
!
C( .
(
(5 #
) % !
&
B
" 6( H
F
#$
:C( +
!
"
! B " (C&
"(
(* ! "
(
8
& (
" G( <
"
N
!
)
3
B ,7-C(
!
!
$
(
%
&&
"
"
0W /J(
8
& 5(
" G( 2( 9
B
C( +
"
( '(
8 & G(& (
&
(
&
&
*
8
)& 2(
" 6( H
&
" G(
B
C( H
&
) Q
0W -(
C(
$
"
(
" 5( H
B
C( 6
(%
% "
" (
H
% $
+
,
,W- (
)&
"
!B
1
)&& :/ WJ0(
$
"
"
( (& 4(
"
&
%
"A
"
& 0 0W0 -(
(9
"&
%
" H( 8( 5 #
B$
"
B ,--C(
)
C(
"!
-
, & &
.
#
-
W07(
H
& H(
"
(
B
0C( +
&
" &
"% $ (
)/& 00W J (
H
!& 6(
" (
(G
B ,,:C(
%
"
#
(
/& 0J:W07/(
H
!& 6( 4(& (
" 6( H
(G
B
0C( .
Q
&
!
"
"
B
,C( +
#
"
:C(
%
%
%
%
(
1 F $
,C(
"
0&
:W 0 (
"
.
(
(
" $
>
)/& 0W0,(
" .( <( X
(
(+
"
!
B
%
&
$
(
& %
(
(9 )
& .(& *( 5
:C(
.
(
#
& .(
B
!
" 5( 9
"
"
" G( 5( .
! B " (C&
& 2(
& .(&
&
!
12
B
" %
"
0 & ,-W ,(
%
C
"
1
,
-C(
% % B+8
&
(
!
!
!
1
3 &
.
/,/W: /(
& *( B
6( H
! B " (C&
% $ 1
!
' " % $
&
( - W ,0(
( +
(
(
%
"
&
(& 5( 9
&
(9
@" 6
% $ Q
(
@
&
"
(6
(6
!
B
/C( H
!
B
-C( 2
"
E
"
"
" "
Q
#
3& --W,,(
!
& G( B
"
& - W0 0(
!
& (&
F
&
0C(
!
"
1
"
(
$
& 0,:W/ 0(
F
& 5(
"
( G
B ,,,C( 2
"
"
Q
F
&
0& 70W J(
(
"
(.
B ,7,C( 5 %
"
(
4 B C& ,-W0 -(
,
)& 6(
" (
!
B ,,:C( +
%
9
"
(
& 5(& ( 9
9
"
&
(6
! &
$
/4&
JW ::(
& 6( B ,J C( $
.
%
&
-
" H( 2
,
"'
(
( 4 $ X )1 H
$
#
# " (
!
/ & / -W/0-(
& ( B ,,:C(
&
4
B ,,7C( 9 $
.
B ,, C(
1
-W -(
" 5( <
% $ (
9
&
$
@" 6
) $& 4(& H( 5
!
"% $ (
( G(
& .(
" H(
B
" 5( 5
/& J7 W- (
C( 5
B
.(
( 4 $ X )1 2
.
C(
(
" % $ (
6! 2 ) %
( ,J-(
4
& H( B ,7 C( -
4
& H( B ,, C( 6
16
# "%
*$ &
&
" 9( H
1
(
$
(
# "% 1
" (
"
" & 2( 4 $ &
B
1"
3& 0,W J (
,C( H
JC( +
" .(
/C(
B
$
% $
(
""
1
$!
#
$( + 5( 8
B " (C&
+
3
!
0& J:W 7J(
!
& .( B
2
"
(
( 9(& G( < "
" & 5(
( 4 $ X )1 4
2
2
!
(
6
(
%
(
#
& .(
"
(. #
B
JC( H
""
1 .
"
"
(
4& 0 ,W0 /(
& .(
"
$
#
F
"
6 $ @&
6
(. #
B
7C( .
"Q +
(F
% $
A
!"
1 +
%
B "(C& 6
"
(
$
(
( B ,-7C(
%
)& G(& G( 2 % &
%
"
@ "
"
!
(X % B
C(
" !
" (
!$ )
(
,
4& /J W/J/(
-
"$ ) "
7
'
-
3/&
: 7W: ,(
6 %
& 4( B ,-7C(
'
.
!
(2
& G( 5( B
"
#
-
C(
) ) E
1%
@
!
"
& 0W J(
.
EQ
"
@
"
"
"% $ (
0)& , :W, 7(
<
&
( H(
"
% $
(
> B
%
C( H " % #
%
(
%
Q +"
&!
0
!
%
%(
#
<
#
'
*# (
% $
%B%" C
%B
K ( :C
%B
%B "
C
C
"
6H
H
-0 (-0
-0 7(/7
-0 (7,
(7
(,:
( :
0(07
J(/0
(:,
J(
( ,
( ,
-0 0( 0
-0 ( ,
(/,
(-/
( ,
(
0(,
(00
-0 :(:
0(:,
H
%
9 % !
9 % !
% % $
9 % !
9 % !
!
:
"
-0 :(7J
!
"
%
% $
-0 ( ,
/0 /(/
/- ( 0
-0 (/,
/ J
(-:
(7,
/( 0
( ,
(
((:
(
( /
0(70
(7/
-(0,
% $
H
% $
K"
! "
% "
1 " %
+<C
1
"
"
!
2
!
"
B
#
9 % !
9 % !
!
!
C
( %&
N
$
$$$(!
"(
&
,
9
( B ,,7C
( B
C
( B
C
( B ,,7C
%
%
:
9
% $
B
$$$(
"
%
%
2. J(0
8
"9
+<
"
%
0(
K
%
-(-,
(-(,7
/(J
2. J(0
2. J(0
2. J(0
:
2. J(
9 % !
H
9 % !
% $ K
% % $ K"
9 % !
9 % !
%
! "
!
% "
:
:
% !
"
!
2. J(
2. J(
"
"
%B%" C
%B
K ( :C
/ J -(7:
/ J (7,
(/,
( J
/(,(/-
(/7
(0
%B C
%B " C
/ J
/ J
(:0
(JJ
(J
(0/
0(,
(/7
(-J
(::
/ / :(J-
/(
2. J(
8
"9
( /
(-0
7(J:
:
%
!
"
!
C
$$$(
( %&
+<
/ 7 :(7
B
N
$
$$$(!
"(
&
,
"
-/ :(/J
0(:,
0
%
!
"
!
$$$(
( %&
+<
-/ :(7J
(,
0(J,
-(-,
0
%
!
"
!
N
$
$$$(!
"(
,
-/
( ,
. #
( ,
(
(-
#
1 H
!
""
/
"
9
( B ,,7C
&
'
% $
%B%" C
%B
C
%B " C
"
% $
%B%" C
%B
C
%B " C
"
% $
(
( /
(:
(0/
(
(//
( /
% $
(
( /
(0(
( 7
( ,
( -
%B%" C
%B
(
(:J
(-0
(-/
(:(J%B%" C
(
(:J
(/(/7
(/
%B
(
(J:
(-7
(J,
(:,
(-
(
(:/
(07
(/
(/-
. #
<
(
(J/
(:/
(:0
%B "
C
(
(:,
(:
(:
#
:(J# $
$
:(7
# $
$
01 H
%B "
1
"
. #
C
# $
6H
/(
0(:7
(,:
( 0
(,J
(J
"$
:
C
"
C
(
(:J
(::
"
(
(/,
(:
(
(/0
(
(
(0:
(
%
1 +
J
<
#
*96
+<
educ
.
%"
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
-0
(J
/0
(/-
/0
(0-
.
< (
" "
: B
&
p
"
%C
(
"
%
"(
"( YYY
% '
-
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
< (
( 0
:(7,
+<
%
$ )
M& YY % '
.
.
.
/0
(:7
.
.
.
.
< (
( :(-
%
.
.
.
( 0
(J0
(
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1
.
.
.
.
"
"6 %
% F
.
educ,dem,eco
.
.
.
. # /1
%&
F
'
M(
.
+<
eco
.
.
.
#
R
F
6 %
2 )
.
.
.
"
+<
.
.
"
+<
dem
.
.
.
.
< (
/0
( :
&
"
(
&
:M& Y
!
% '
<
#
"
*96
BC
.
"
A
B C
.
.
.
%"
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
R
A
(((
/ J
-/
(0< .
< .
A
F
. # :1
" 1
% !
"
&"
:M& YYY % '
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
(((
/ J
-/
( J
< .
< .
B CB C
" " %
"
M( .
"
A
B C
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
(((
/ J
-/
(0
< .
#
+<
.
.
.
.
"
"
A
B C
.
.
.
"
.
.
.
"
.
5
"
$
"
7
' " A
(
( Y % '
#
"
%
(((
00
-/
(0:
.
B CB C
+<
M& YY
"
&'
% '
) % (
Z
"
.
S
.
.
S
.
.
.
.
.
S
.
.
S
.
.
.
S
.
.
S
J1
1
!
" "
#
( .
"
.
.
.
&
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
U
.
XST U
.
.
.
.
.
.
!
&
.
.
.
.
.
"
U
.
.
.
.
&
XST
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
S
.
XST
&
U
.
.
/ (-
.
&
&
U
.
XST"
.
"
.
.
.
.
&
&
.
.
.
.
S
.
.
.
S
. #
.
.
S
"
XST" &
.
.
" "
"
!
%
%
.
.
.
" $
'
"(
.
.
.
.
8+
.
B +
" &X
#
#
"
C( Z
! ""
%
"
)
) % (
<
#
2 "
.
%"
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"
.
-(7
.
(
( -
:( 7
.
.
7(J-
.
.
0(-0
.
.
.
.
2
( :
(
.
.
( 7
(0,
.
.
( J
.
.
.
.
p
(
< .
( :
.
.
"
. #
#
-1
1
( YYY % '
.
!
M& YY % '
.
"
:M& Y % '
,
"
. #
M(
J& $
-0
L
"
S
S
S0
S
S
S0
S
S
S0
S
S
S0
S
S
S0
. #
71
!
" "
.
"
.
ZST"
.
.
.
&
&
"
&
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
70/(0
.
ZST"
.
&
"
&
&
U
.
.
&
&
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
U
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ZST
.
.
.
.
&
.
.
.
U
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ZST
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
U
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ZST U
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"
.
.
1
( 6
.
!
#
"
"
.
"
" "
!
$
'
"(
0
.
8+
.
B +
" &X
#
"
.
#
%
) C( Z
! ""
(
<
#
2 "
%
%
.
%"
.
.
.
.
( /
.
0:(::
.
(
.
.
.
.
.
.
"
.
.
.
.
:(J0
.
.
"
.
.
.
,(,
.
( 0
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"
(((
.
.
.
R
"
&/ J #
(:/
1
!
( YYY % '
(
( 7
< .
( ,
< .
(0
(
(J7
(((
"
,1
( -
.
2
. #
"
,(:,
.
p
.
.
.
(0,
"
M& YY % '
0
"
. #
:M& Y % '
7& $
M(
#
(,,
(,,
8 %
8 $
"
H
)
%
"
#
%
%
8 % "
8
8 @
(,,
(,,
(,,
(,,
(,7
(,,
(,,
(,,
(,,
F %
+
+
G
4
"
4 $L
"
4 $
%
6
6$ "
6$ @
"
"
%"
"6
(,,
(,,
(7,
(,J
(,,
(,,
#
5
(,,
H
&5
"
6
"
8
F "
+ "
+ "
+
+
"
G
G "
(,,
( 5 (
(,,
(,,
4
4%
%
4 $
%
"
%
9
6
6
6
6
6
.
.
.
.
.
(:J
%
(,,
9
@
!
)
"
" "
(7J
". # %
)
%
"
%
< @
L #
L # #$
. #
#
1
"
1
# #
'
#
"!
(7:
"
0
"
$
%
.
% $
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"
.
.
.
.
.
.
. #
"
1
!
#
C(
# %
<
.
&!
'
#
696
696
.
.
.
.
.
%B%" C
K ( :C
.
%B
C
.
%B "
.
.
.
.
.
.
1 +<
C(
&
p
"( YYY % '
%
# %
!
"(
0
(:-
&!
"
&"
$ )
M& YY % '
'
"
. #
(((
,
:
( 0
/ (,7
#
"
&
:M& Y % '
00
"
.
(((
#
. #
.
.
.
(
.
.
.
< .
.
.
.
F
2 )
.
.
.
"
B
.
.
"
. #
.
.
C
"
.
.
%B
#
!
'
M(
B
(
" "
F
% F
" "
<
#
BC
%
%
.
.
%B%" C
.
.
%B
K ( :C
.
%B
C
.
+
.
%B "
.
.
.
.
.
C
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
%
.
.
.
.
(((
2
+
(((
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
(((
.
.
(((
.
%B "
"
*
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
C
.
) "
.
H
.
.
.
.
.
R
#
.
.
!
%
.
.
.
9
. #
(((
.
.
"
.
.
.
.
.
(((
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"
.
.
.
.
.
B C
%
%
.
.
.
.
B C
%
%
01
M& YY
(/7
"
% '
B %:C
#
!
1
(0:
(:
!
:M& Y % '
#
! #
"
(0/
"
M( H
!
%
0/
0J
"
!
#
(:0
#
%"
(/
YYY % '
!
BC
!
" B C&
<
#
" ,%
+
%
.
K ( :C
.
%B
C
.
%B "
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
(((
R
.
.
.
1
,
#
#
!
( YYY % '
.
.
.
(J/
"
.
(0
!
'
(((
.
.
.
.
.
.
(((
.
.
.
.
.
"
$
"
.
.
(((
2
+
.
.
.
"
.
.
.
.
/1
.
.
.
. #
!
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
C
"
.
.
.
%B
" ,7:
%
%
.
.
%B%" C
,7:
(:
.
.
(/J
"
" #
#
#
& " -/
$
M& YY % '
:M& Y % '
0:
( .
J #
M(