N_\i\k_\
9L:BJKFGJ
The financial crisis exposed the paucity of board oversight
of risk, especially in financial services, as expressed in their
risk statements. Piper Terrett reports on the debate that is
forging better standards
_`^_$gif]`c\]X`cli\j`ei\Z\ekp\XijÆC\_dXe9ifk_\ij#8@>
Xe[#dfi\i\Z\ekcp#D=>cfYXcÆ[\dfejkiXk\k_\ZXkXjkifg_`ZZfjkj
f]\oZ\jj`m\fi`eXggifgi`Xk\i`jbXgg\k`k\j%K_\j`q\f]k_\j\Ôidj#
Xe[k_\jfZ`XcZfej\hl\eZ\jf]k_\`i]X`cli\#dX[\^fm\ieXeZ\Xe`jjl\
@e)''0#;Xm`[NXcb\inXj[`jgXkZ_\[Yp
]fijfZ`\kp%
k_\>fm\ied\ekkfi\m`\nZfigfiXk\^fm\ieXeZ\`ek_\LBYXeb`e^
j\Zkfi%@e_`jÔe[`e^j_\ZXcc\[]fiXdXafij_Xb\$lgf]k_\YfXi[iffd#
i\Zfdd\e[`e^k_Xkefe$\o\Zlk`m\[`i\Zkfij[\mfk\dfi\k`d\kf
Xjj\jj`e^i`jbXe[Xjbkfl^_\ihl\jk`fejXYflkZfdgXepjkiXk\^p%
N_`c\NXcb\iXcjfi\Zfdd\e[\[k_XkZfdgXe`\jXggf`ekYfXi[
i`jbZfdd`kk\\j#_\\dg_Xj`j\[k_Xkk_\YfXi[Xcfe\`jlck`dXk\cp
<og\ikjXi^l\k_Xk
i\jgfej`Yc\Xe[XZZflekXYc\]fii`jb%
i`jbXgg\k`k\nXjgfficple[\ijkff[Xe[`dgc\d\ek\[#Xe[k_Xkk_`j
Zfeki`Ylk\[kfk_\ÔeXeZ`XcZi`j`j%D`Z_X\cDX`e\cc`#:_Xik\i\[=:J@#
;`i\Zkfif]Zfdd\iZ`Xck_`eb$kXebQ&P\e#jXpjk_Xkk_\`e[ljkip
ÈZfek`elXccpkXZbjfei`jbÉ%?\Zfek`el\j1ÈMXcl\XkI`jb#i`jb
jkXk\d\ekj#9Xj\cn\`^_k`e^jXe[k_\`iXjjfZ`Xk\[Zi\[`kiXk`e^jXi\
XccX[[$fej%I`jbdljkY\`ek\^iXk\[n`k_XccÔeXeZ`Xcj%É
K_\`eX[\hlXZpf]k_\i`jbXggifXZ_\jf]ÔidjjlZ_XjC\_dXenXj
m`j`Yc\kfXcc`ek_\`ii`jbjkXk\d\ekj%;\\gX>fm`e[XiXaXe#=\ccfnXk
k_\@ek\ieXk`feXc:Xg`kXcDXib\kj8jjfZ`Xk`fe:\eki\#gXikf]?\ec\p
9lj`e\jjJZ_ffc#\ogcX`ejk_Xkk_\j\j_flc[Y\j\k[`i\ZkcpYpk_\YfXi[#
i\cXk\Zc\Xicpkfk_\ZfdgXepËjjkiXk\^pXe[\o`jkXjXnfib`egif^i\jj
`e\]]\Zk`m\Xji`jb$dXeX^\d\ekkffcj%DXepi\X[`[\ek`ZXccp[\jg`k\
mXjkcp[`]]\i\ekjkiXk\^`Z^fXcjXe[i`jbgifÔc\j%È=fiXeldY\if]
Ôidj#Éj_\jXpj#Èk_\i\`jXi\Xcjkil^^c\kfZi\Xk\XjkXk\d\ek
k_Xkk_\]ifekc`e\Ylj`e\jjZXekilcp\e^X^\n`k_Æfe\k_Xk
È@Ë[
XZklXccp`eÕl\eZ\j[Xp$kf$[Xpi`jb$kXb`e^%
Y\b\\ekfj\\^ff[i`jb$Xgg\k`k\jkXk\d\ekjk_XkXi\kilcp
k_\i\jlckf]jkife^[\YXk\jY\kn\\ek_\\o\Zlk`m\jXe[efe$
\o\Zlk`m\jfeYfXi[jÆjkXk\d\ekjk_Xki\Õ\Zkk_\ÔidjËjkiXk\^`Z
Z_f`Z\jXe[k_\Xcc`\[i`jb$kXb`e^i\hl`i\[#Éj_\jXpj%K_\
flkZfd\nflc[k_\eY\X[\kX`c\[gcXe#lj`e^Zc\Xik\id`efcf^p
k_Xk[\Ôe\jk_\i`jbXgg\k`k\Xe[jg\Z`ÔZi`jbjk_Xk\o`jk%K_`jn`cc
K_\`e[ljkip
gifm`[\k_\YfXi[ËjY`e[`e^i`jbdXe`]\jkf%
`jjk`ccXcfe^nXp]ifdXZ_`\m`e^k_`j#XggXi\ekcp%>fm`e[XiXaXeËj
i\j\XiZ_ZfeZcl[\jk_XkdXepi`jb$Xgg\k`k\jkXk\d\ekjXi\efkifYljk
\efl^_Xe[]fZljkff_\Xm`cpfei`jbjkfj_Xi\_fc[\ijXkk_\\og\ej\
f]fk_\ijkXb\_fc[\ij%
9fXi[c\X[\ij_`g
:_i`j?f[^\#?\X[f]k_\=I:ËjZfigfiXk\^fm\ieXeZ\le`k#jki\jj\j
k_XkYfXi[j#efk\o\Zlk`m\j#dljkkXb\i\jgfej`Y`c`kp]fij\kk`e^i`jb
Xgg\k`k\%È@]pfl_Xm\XYfkkfd$lgXggifXZ_#pflËi\efk^f`e^kfjgfk
Xcck_\i`jbj#É_\nXiej%ÈK_\i\ËjXe\\[]fiYfXi[jkf^\k`emfcm\[`e
_fi`qfejZXee`e^Xe[c`eb`e^k_\i`jbXgg\k`k\kfk_\jkiXk\^p%@kËjXcjf
@eXJ\gk\dY\i
`dgfikXekkfj\kk_\kfe\]ifdk_\kfg%É
)'((i\gfik#9fXi[jXe[I`jb#k_\=I:\dg_Xj`j\jY\kk\ii\glkXk`feXc
i`jbXe[k_\e\\[]fiZi`j`j$dXeX^\d\ekgcXej%È9\ZXlj\jfZ`Xc
d\[`Xd\Xejk_Xke\njZXejgi\X[jfhl`Zbcp#ÉjXpj?f[^\#ÈR\m\e`]
k_\gifYc\d_XjXd`efiÔeXeZ`Xc`dgXZkTk_\i\glkXk`feXci`jbZXe
jfd\k`d\jY\^i\Xk\ik_XeÔeXeZ`Xci`jb%:fdgXe`\j_Xm\Y\Zfd\
XnXi\f]k_\e\\[kf]fZljfeZi`j`jdXeX^\d\ekXe[kf_Xm\XeX^`c\
@]YfXi[jXi\kfj\kÔidjËi`jbXgg\k`k\j
XggifXZ_kf`k%É
Zfii\Zkcp#k_\pe\\[XZZliXk\`e]fidXk`fe%Fe\f]k_\_Xi[\jkk_`e^j
k_Xk`ji\^lcXicplg[Xk\[%=`eXeZ`Xcj\im`Z\j`ejk`klk`fejXi\i\hl`i\[
]fiZfdgXe`\j`j^\kk`e^`e]fidXk`feÕfnji`^_kY\kn\\ek_\YfXi[
Ypk_\=J8kfZfdgc\k\X]fidXci`jb$Xgg\k`k\jkXk\d\ek#flkc`e`e^k_\
Xe[k_\dXeX^\d\ek%K_`j[f\jefkd\XeYfdYXi[`e^YfXi[jn`k_
i`jbkpg\jk_\p]XZ\#Xe[kf_fc[k_\ZXg`kXce\Z\jjXipkfd`k`^Xk\k_fj\
gXg\infib%:ilZ`Xccp#_fn\m\i#`k[f\jefkd\Xe_fc[`e^YXZb]ifd
i`jbj%K_\LB:figfiXk\>fm\ieXeZ\:f[\f])'('#fm\ij\\eYpk_\
k_\YfXi[`e]fidXk`fek_Xk`jg\iZ\`m\[kfY\le`dgfikXek%?f[^\jXpj1
=`eXeZ`XcI\gfik`e^:fleZ`c=I: #jkXk\jk_XkYfXi[jXi\i\jgfej`Yc\
ÈN\_Xm\_\Xi[jkfi`\jf]n_\i\k_`e^jn\i\befnen`k_`eXZfdgXep
]fiÈ[\k\id`e`e^k_\eXkli\Xe[\ok\ekf]k_\i`jbjÉk_\pXi\n`cc`e^
Ylk`knXjefk]\ckk_Xk`knXj`dgfikXek\efl^_kfk\cck_\YfXi[XYflk
kfkXb\`eXZ_`\m`e^ÈjkiXk\^`ZfYa\Zk`m\jÉn_`c\dX`ekX`e`e^Èjfle[
Xe[#n_\ek_\`jjl\Yifb\R`ek_\e\njT#k_\YfXi[d\dY\ijbe\n
i`jbdXeX^\d\ekXe[`ek\ieXcZfekifcjpjk\djÉ%Le[\ik_\=J8Ëj
@e]fidXk`fee\\[jkfÕfn]ifdYfXi[kf
efk_`e^XYflk`k%É
c`jk`e^ilc\j#glYc`Zcpc`jk\[ZfdgXe`\jXi\i\hl`i\[kf[`jZcfj\_fn
\o\Zlk`m\#kffÆ\jg\Z`Xccpn_\edXepYfXi[d\dY\ijXi\^\e\iXc`jkj%
k_\p_Xm\Zfdgc`\[n`k_k_\:f[\Xe[#n_\i\k_\p_Xm\efk#\ogcX`e
?fnÔeXeZ`XcYlj`e\jj\jj\kk_\`ii`jbXgg\k`k\j`e
È>ff[i`jbdXeX^\d\ek`jefkfecpXYflk_Xm`e^k_\i`^_kXejn\i#
n_p%
^\e\iXc#Xe[_fnk_\pnfi[k_\i`jbjkXk\d\ekj`egXik`ZlcXi#_XjY\\e YlkXcjfXZc\XiXejn\i#ÉjXpjCfeFËJlcc`mXe#?\X[f]Gfik]fc`f
le[\iZcfj\jZilk`ep]fccfn`e^k_\Zi`j`jf])''/&'0%E\ni\j\XiZ_
DXib\kI`jbDXeX^\d\ekXkDfi^XeJkXec\p%È9fXi[jk_Xkm`\ni`jb
Yp>fm`e[XiXaXe]fik_\?\ec\p9lj`e\jjJZ_ffc]fle[k_XkdXep
]leZk`fejXjj`dgcpb\\g`e^k_\dflkf]kiflYc\Xi\efk[f`e^k_\`i
i`jbjkXk\d\ekjXi\jk`ccYXeXcXe[fm\i$^\e\iXc`j\[#Xe[k_\i\]fi\Xi\ afY]fij_Xi\_fc[\ij%É
È9fXi[jk_Xkm`\ni`jb]leZk`fejXjj`dgcp
b\\g`e^k_\dflkf]kiflYc\Xi\efk[f`e^
k_\`iafY]fij_Xi\_fc[\ijÉ
(- AXelXip)'() Z`j`%fi^
YfXi[iffdi`jb
JkXb\_fc[\imXcl\
>fm`e[XiXaXeli^\jYfXi[jkfgXpdfi\Xkk\ek`fekfi`jbjkffk_\i
jkXb\_fc[\ijY\j`[\jj_Xi\_fc[\ij%I`jb$Xgg\k`k\[`jZljj`fej_Xm\
kiX[`k`feXccp]fZlj\[fei`jbjX]]\Zk`e^\hl`kp_fc[\ijfik_fj\k_Xk
d`^_k`eÕl\eZ\ZXg`kXc[\gcfpd\ek%ÈJli\cpk_`jZXeefkY\\efl^_#É
j_\jXpj%ÈK_\i\Xi\j\m\iXci`jbjk_XkXi\efkd`k`^Xk\[YpZXg`kXc%
I`jb$Xgg\k`k\[`jZljj`fejdljki\Õ\Zki`jbjkffk_\ijkXb\_fc[\ij
`eZcl[`e^Yfe[_fc[\ij#\dgcfp\\j#Zljkfd\ijXe[k_\Zfddle`kp%
N\e\\[kf^fY\pfe[ZXg`kXc$]fZlj\[i`jb$Xgg\k`k\jkXk\d\ekj%N\Xcjf
e\\[kfY\dfi\_fe\jkXYflkk_\i`jbjn\Xi\kXb`e^k_XkX]]\ZkXYifX[\i
JkXb\_fc[\ij`eZcl[\n`[\ijfZ`\kp
^iflgf]jkXb\_fc[\ij%É
Xe[k_\\em`ifed\ek%È9fXi[je\\[kfkXb\XZZflekf]le[\icp`e^
jfZ`XcXe[\em`ifed\ekXcÆXjn\ccXj\Zfefd`ZÆmXcl\[i`m\ij#_fn
k_\pXi\`eZi\Xj`e^cpc`eb\[Xe[k_\`iZldlcXk`m\`dgXZk#ÉjXpjKfep
DXenXi`e^#:_`\]<o\Zlk`m\f]LBk_`eb$kXebKfdfiifnËj:fdgXep%
È@eZi\Xj`e^cp#ZfdgXe`\jn`ccY\kXcb`e^kf`em\jkfijn_fn`ccnXek
J\kk`e^Xe[dfe`kfi`e^
k_\dkfkXb\k_`j`ekfXZZflekkff%É
i`jbXgg\k`k\`jk_\YfXi[ËjafY%DXenXi`e^Xe[>fm`e[XiXaXeYfk_nXie
X^X`ejkflkjfliZ`e^i`jb$Xgg\k`k\jkXk\d\ekjkfZfigfiXk\\o\Zlk`m\j
fiZfejlckXekj%ÈJkiXk\^`Zi`jbdXeX^\d\eke\\[jkfY\Xj_Xi\[
Zfdg\k\eZpf]XccYfXi[d\dY\ijÆ`k`jXYflkd`e[j\kXjdlZ_XjXep
jg\Z`ÔZjb`ccfigif]\jj`feXc`jd#ÉjXpjDXenXi`e^%È@]XÊgif]\jj`feXcË
_\cgjkf[\m\cfgk_`j]fiXg\i`f[f]k`d\#k_\ek_Xk`jkfY\n\cZfd\[#
Ylkk_\ek_\i\`jk_\Z_XeZ\k_Xkk_Xkg\ijfe`jj\\eXji\jgfej`Yc\]fi
@]k_\
i`jb#Zfdgfle[`e^k_\fi^Xe`jXk`feËji`jbgifÔc\%É
ÔeXeZ`XcZi`j`jXe[k_\NXcb\iI\m`\n_Xm\kXl^_kYfXi[jXepk_`e^#`kËj
k_Xkk_\pÆefkk_\i`jbZfdd`kk\\Xe[efk\o\Zlk`m\jÆXi\lck`dXk\cp
XZZflekXYc\]fik_\i`jbjXZfdgXepkXb\j%
(.