Magazine Spring 2012 (T)horny issues STEVE & ANN TOON 3 The heat is on Events schedule 2012 –13 4 South Africa: The South African situation 6 Zimbabwe: A mixed bag: happy endings and heartache 7 Zimbabwe: Volunteer with Dambari Wildlife Trust PAUL BOSCH 9 Zambia: Wear and tear Kenya: A new lease of life MATT BROOKE TEAM RHINO 8 Zambia: A setback in North Luangwa 10 Namibia: Scene of the crime training 12 Namibia: A poaching case, a remarkable rhino and a major grant 13 Fundraising like crazy 14 London Marathon 2012 Where in the world? 15 News in brief 16 Tanzania: How did you solve a problem like Mkomazi? 18 Kenya: Dealing with an emergency 19 Kenya: Rhino soup 21 Save the Rhino’s shiny new website 23 Events in brief 24 Shoot to kill? 25 Pecha Kucha Wild! 26 India: Inspiring India 27 India: Community Spirit MIKE PETCHEY 28 Indonesia: Species in peril 29 Indonesia: Final stronghold 30 31 Thank you Try a rhino recipe! Contents 22 Douglas Adams The Party CLAIRE BILYARD RICHARD FLAMAND DEDI CANDRA STEVE & ANN TOON SAVE THE RHINO VINCENT GUILLEMIN 20 Supply and demand: the illegal rhino horn trade The heat is on I don’t mean that literally: As I write, London in February is not a warm place, but the arguments over rhino conservation approaches are certainly hotting up. In the last issue of The Horn, we wrote about the arguments for and against legalising the trade in rhino horn, and had some great responses from readers. So in this edition, we’re opening up more of the hot debates in the rhino world. There’s a whole can of worms just waiting to be opened: from whether it’s OK to poison rhino horns, in the expectation that anyone consuming it (illegally of course) would become unwell; to whether it is acceptable to shoot-to-kill poachers. And other wriggly matters in between. Cathy Dean | Director We haven’t come to a verdict on all of these by any means: for example, on legalising trade, we want to see what arises from the research that the In this edition of The Horn South African government has we’re opening up more commissioned of the hot debates on factors affecting the in the rhino world demand, as well as more detail on the proposed model for selling rhino horn. On others — such as the proposed moratorium on trophy hunting of rhinos — we are clear. (We agree with the conclusions of an excellent paper published by the Endangered Wildlife Trust*.) an economist, argues that the goal should be to ensure that wild populations of species are secure and growing, whatever it takes to achieve that. What costs are acceptable? Should we endorse the farming of rhinos for their horns, which can be harvested from the live animal? We’re really keen to hear your thoughts and opinions on the debates covered in this magazine. With the launch of our new website in March (six years after the previous site was developed), by the time you read this, you will be able to post comments on these articles, as well as checking through all the latest news and updates from the field. We’re pretty excited about the possibilities, so please add us to your favourites. Our twitter feed (@savetherhino) and Facebook page are also updated almost daily, and we really enjoy the exchanges with our followers and hearing what you’ve been up to. Let us know. I’m happy to admit that we don’t know all the answers: these are really, really difficult issues to get hold of. Michael ‘t Sas-‐Rolfes, *https://www.ewt.org.za/portals/0/ewt/documents/Rhino%20hunting%20moratorium.pdf Virgin London Marathon 2012 Rhino Mayday Rhino Climb Kilimanjaro Save the Rhino Annual Dinner ING New York City Marathon Gold Challenge Go Karting Eleventh Douglas Adams Memorial Lecture Virgin London Marathon 2013 Rhino Trek South Africa 2013 UK challenges Sunday 22 April 2012 Tuesday 1 May 2012 Thursday 27 September to Saturday 6 October 2012 Tuesday 16 October 2012 Sunday 4 November 2012 Ongoing until December 2012 January/February 2013 Dates to be confirmed Tuesday 12 March 2013 April 2013 Dates to be confirmed Various dates SRI Events Schedule For more information about any of these events, please visit www.savetherhino.org/events or email [email protected] or call +44 (0)20 7357 7474 3 South Africa The South African Situation South Africa is viewed as the primary custodian of Africa’s rhinos. With 18,796 white rhinos and 1,916 black rhinos as of last estimates at the end of 2010, this represents approximately 93% and 40% of the total white and black rhino populations respectively. In recent years poaching levels have soared, and the current crisis is creating debates worldwide about the best way to tackle illegal poaching. Jo Shaw | Programme Officer — Large mammal trade, TRAFFIC East Africa Office T IS RENAUD FULCON White rhinos in South Africa account for 93% of the global population NICOLAS HILL Figure 1 Number of rhinos lost to poaching in South Africa 2000 —2011 he unwavering commitment shown towards rhinoceros conservation and diligent investment in protection and monitoring meant that South Africa largely escaped the first terrifying wave of rhino poaching that occurred throughout the rest of Africa prior to the mid-‐1990s. The recovery of the white rhino population from somewhere between 20 and 50 individuals in KwaZulu-‐Natal in the early 1900s to the current global population of over 20,000 animals is one of the great conservation success stories and perhaps partly explains the deep emotional attachment and pride that many South Africans feel for their rhinos. number of hunters from Asia taking part in trophy hunts of white rhino, or ‘pseudo-‐ hunting’ as it has become known. As white rhinos in South Africa were placed on the Appendix II listing of CITES in 1994 with special exemption for sport hunting, export of hunting trophies remained a legal mechanism for the international movement of rhino horn. It has been noted that these hunters were generally unskilled and inexperienced and prepared to shoot even young female rhinos as long as they came away with a horn. One of the acknowledged reasons for South Africa’s past rhino conservation success has been the strong alliance between private and public sector players. Indeed, approximately 20 —25% of rhinos in South Africa are now privately owned, a larger number than currently persists in the majority of former rhino range states. A significant incentive for private ownership of rhinos has been the potential for income generation via trophy hunting. Sport hunting of white rhino started in 1968 at a time there were only 1,800 animals and has continued with an average of approximately 50 animals hunted per year ever since. Traditionally, white rhino trophy hunts have been sold primarily to international hunting clients from the United States and Europe for roughly £20,000 each. Secondly, there have been a spate of thefts and armed robberies of rhino horns from stockpiles on game reserves and museums throughout South Africa and this crime has also shown a dramatic rise in Europe and the US. Since 2007, at least 65 horns have been stolen in South Africa and around 50 internationally. 500 400 300 200 100 0 4 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Rhino poaching However, the most disturbing trend has been the horrific increase in poaching of rhinos in South Africa. Prior to 2006, illegal killing of rhinos was being maintained at consistently low levels. Since 2008, rhino poaching in South Africa has skyrocketed year on year, culminating in a total of 448 rhinos killed in 2011. (See Figure 1, left.) The face of rhino poaching has also changed, with trusted wildlife industry professionals adding to the ranks of the more traditional poaching demographic. Unfortunately, there is no indication that the rhino poaching crisis is coming under control, as rhino deaths continue apace despite the government responses to combat poaching, including the deployment of Army personnel along the border between Kruger National Park and Mozambique. Sources of rhino horn Response However, from the mid-‐2000s something changed relating to the demand for rhino horn from Asia, which has placed rhinos throughout Africa increasingly under attack. In South Africa, rhino horn has been sourced in at least three ways. One of the first indicators of this change was the increasing The South African Department of Environmental Affairs has made several legislative changes in response to the threats to rhinos. In July 2008, a National Moratorium was placed on rhino horn sales to try and prevent domestic sales of rhino horn from entering the illegal international market. Stricter regulations on the marking of rhino horn and on trophy hunting of white rhinos were introduced in 2009 to try and clamp down on leakage of rhino horn from South Africa and draft amendments to combat identified loopholes were produced in September 2011. South African citizens and private owners of rhinos are also developing a range of increasingly innovative approaches to make rhinos less attractive to poachers, including dehorning as well as newer ideas such as introducing dye or even poison into rhino horns. However, these methods have limited applicability and huge cost implications for utilization on the largest and most important populations for conservation. Furthermore, the sad death of a white rhino during the demonstration of the horn dyeing technique at the Rhino and Lion Park in Johannesburg in January 2012 highlights the risks inherent in any activities requiring immobilization. There is a huge groundswell of public concern and support to combat rhino poaching in South Africa. However, with over 150 organizations now actively involved in their own efforts to address this problem, there is concern over lack of integration and duplication of effort, when what is needed is a strategic response. What next? Some were against any form of sustainable utilization of wildlife, including sale of any rhinos by National Parks, and called for all rhino horn stockpiles to be destroyed or proposed the donation of rhino horn stockpiles in South Africa to Asia. Others, including the private sector but also state representatives such as EKZNW, wanted the government to push for the opening of international trade in rhino horn. The debate about whether legalizing international trade in rhino horn could be part of the solution to rhino poaching in South Africa is growing in intensity and becoming increasingly emotional and polarized between strong pro-‐ and anti-‐factions. Whether the South Africa government will decide that it can convince the international community at CITES and submit a proposal for legal trade for the next Conference of the Parties in Bangkok in March 2013 remains to be seen. However, such debates should not detract from what is the most immediate issue at hand — stemming the increasing tide of illegal killing of rhinos in the world. STEVE AND ANN TOON In January 2012, the Portfolio Committee on Water and Environmental Affairs called a Parliamentary Hearing in Cape Town to discuss rhino poaching. The meeting was attended by a range of government and provincial representatives as well as NGOs and concerned individuals. There were several common threads, including the need for better communication and collaboration between government departments and improved permitting and database systems for live rhinos and rhino horn stockpiles. Although there have been a number of recent breakthroughs, there is also a need for increased number of arrests, prosecutions and stiffer sentencing, preferably mandatory imprisonment for rhino crimes. Many of the participants expressed concerns about capacity shortages and constraints to achieve the above and combat the poaching threat. However, the issue of whether to legalise international trade in rhino horn took centre stage. 5 Zimbabwe A mixed bag: happy endings and heartache 2011 saw continuation of the sustained poaching onslaught on rhino populations in South Africa and Zimbabwe. Lowveld Rhino Trust (LRT) has continued to provide technical and management support for rhino populations in the south east Lowveld of Zimbabwe, where well over 80% of the country’s remaining rhino now reside. Chap Masterson | Rhino Veterinarian for Africa, Lowveld Rhino Trust/International Rhino Foundation A side from the usual annual rhino darting operations for management purposes, in which a total of some 70 animals were darted, primarily to positively mark rhino for individual identification and so facilitate population monitoring at the individual level, the ongoing poaching challenge necessitated several veterinary interventions, by either myself or Dr Chris Foggin of the Wildlife Veterinary Unit, to treat animals wounded to various degrees by bullets or wire snares or to capture calves orphaned by poaching events. All such interventions undertaken on Save Valley Conservancy, Bubye Valley Conservancy and Chipinge Safari Area were funded by LRT and were greatly facilitated by the new Of 25 bullet casings found LRT veterinary Toyota Landcruiser purchased with a grant from USFWS. at the scene, 7 were found The successful grant application for to have hit ‘Double’ and one hit ‘Trouble’ this vehicle was submitted by Save the Rhino International (SRI) whom LRT owes a debt of gratitude for their support not only for assistance in the acquisition of this vehicle but also for their valuable participation and support for LRT initiatives as well as for other rhino conservation efforts in the sub-‐region. As with all such attempts to save victims of poaching, the treatment outcomes were a mixed bag of happy endings and deep heartache. On the one hand, we had the case of the 6 A near miss — one of three head wounds for Double rather than euthanasia. He did very well for over a month before what must have been a hairline crack in his shoulder blade — caused by one of the bullets — gave way and I was left with no choice but to euthanize him; the heart-‐wrenching irony being that his ghastly facial wounds had all but healed by that time. ALL PICS LOWVELD RHINO TRUST Chap and vet assistant Mr Rhinos Kambanje with a de-‐horned bull black rhino bull ‘Maduma’, shot five times, traumatically dehorned and left for dead. Obviously one of the bullets, presumably the one that hit the angle of his jaw, knocked him unconscious enabling the poachers to cut off his horns — severely mutilating his face in the process — before making good their escape. The bull, however, was made of tougher stuff and upon regaining consciousness was found stumbling around with severe injuries and blood loss. His pluck and resilience as well as his ability to feed and drink tipped the decision towards attempting a treatment As sad as the loss of Maduma was, we can thankfully report that all other animals treated for various wounds had happier endings. The most encouraging of these was the case of the black rhino cow ‘Double’ and her bull calf ‘Trouble’ ambushed by poachers on their way to water on Save Valley Conservancy late one afternoon in October. Of 25 bullet casings found at the scene, fired from AK-‐47 assault rifles, seven were found to have hit the cow, some in very compromising positions, including three in the head, two in the left foreleg, one in the left knee and one high in her rump, with her calf having taken a Volunteer with Dambari Wildlife Trust Do you sometimes get fed-up with working in the city; being surrounded by people, buildings, traffic? My office window overlooks sun-drenched grassland, busy with birds and insects, and occasionally I glimpse two magnificent kudu bulls! bullet in his left front knee. Due to the relentless and dedicated tracking efforts of the LRT monitoring scouts in difficult terrain, enduring unbearably hot conditions, it was possible to treat the animals timeously and all their wounds responded well to the early medical intervention. On a personal level, having made the rather daunting move to return to my homeland, Zimbabwe, with a young family, and despite the trials and challenges that this entails, I can safely say, a year later, that I could not imagine being anywhere else other than right here, privileged to be a member of a dedicated team determined to secure the future of our beleaguered rhino populations. In this regard LRT is enormously grateful to all our supporters, donors and partner institutions enabling continuation of our work. While my work environment at Dambari is wonderful, there’s rarely time to appreciate it. Development, administration and fundraising for the 50-‐acre field station, and Dambari’s various research and conservation projects, falls onto the shoulders of just three staff. COLIN GILLES Last year we were fortunate to have four people volunteer at Dambari, which made us realise what a boon an extra pair of willing hands could be. An MSc graduate reviewed and collated a backlog of research data, and we received invaluable assistance from SRI’s Cath Lawson, Cathy Dean and Cathy’s husband Kenneth Donaldson. Not only did they help with many office tasks but they were also great for our planning and ideas sessions. Their advice and enthusiasm encouraged us to explore a paying volunteer scheme to earn critical funding to support our field station base, and we are looking forward to hosting our first guest in June. Primarily a research and conservation Trust, we can take two to four visitors at a time. Volunteer activities might include (dependent on timetables): The beautiful landscape at Dambari iFieldwork in the Matobo Hills World Heritage Site: assisting researchers with data collection and entry for biodiversity projects iDeveloping and distributing environmental educational materials for rural schools iHelping out with office/station-‐based tasks and sharing skills with staff COLIN GILLES Lowveld Rhino Trust also provided support and veterinary services, in conjunction with SAVE Australia, Dambari Wildlife Trust and the Wildlife Veterinary Unit, for rhino darting operations, to dehorn, ear notch and implant VHF transmitters, in intensive protection zones (IPZs) in Hwange and Matopos National Parks. In addition, as LRT veterinarian, I was privileged to be made available as additional wildlife veterinary capacity in support of Dr Chris Foggin, a long-‐time partner of LRT and legend in rhino conservation in Zimbabwe. Adele Edwards | Logistics Manager, Dambari Wildlife Trust ALL PICS DAMBARI WILDLIFE TRUST UNLESS STATED Two orphans were retrieved after their mothers were killed by poachers, one from Bubye Valley, the other from Save Valley Conservancy. The first of these, a 10-‐month-‐old bull calf ‘Be-‐Brave’, earned his name standing vigil by the carcass of his poached mother despite the attentions of a pride of lions intent on scavenging and perhaps indulging themselves in some fresh rhino calf — judging from claw marks found on the young rhino’s back when he was captured for bottle-‐ raising a few days later. Both calves were delivered into the capable and loving care of Katrina and Blondie Leatham and their rhino assistant Enos, of Bubye Valley Conservancy, who are all too familiar with raising orphaned rhino, but who do so with selfless dedication. Those who choose to spend a fortnight volunteering with Dambari Wildlife Trust can enjoy a unique opportunity to work in small groups ‘behind the scenes’ in a beautiful setting . . . and your contribution will impact practical conservation directly! For more information about the Trust visit www.dambari.com or to enquire about being a paying volunteer, email [email protected] Grants Our thanks to Kenneth Donaldson and Cath Lawson, who made donations totaling £1,850 towards the core costs of DWT. 7 Zambia A setback in North Luangwa The threats facing rhino are all too many where small populations exist. The incredibly sad loss of six rhinos in North Luangwa National Park in 2011, to causes other than poaching, has caused deep upset and concern, and also brought reflection upon the varied challenges facing rhino conservation in an ever-changing environment. Claire Lewis | Technical Advisor, North Luangwa Conservation Programme R hino poaching across the world has reached alarming scales not seen since the early 1980s. Zambia suffered in those dark days and the black rhino was declared nationally extinct in 1998. The country was once home to an estimated 12,000 rhinos and about a third of those resided in the Luangwa Valley. To have so comprehensively wiped out every last standing rhino was an astonishing feat of total decimation by poachers. In 2003, an ambitious programme was launched to re-‐establish black rhinos in Threats other than poaching North Luangwa National Park. Wildlife that face rhino are all too agencies across South Africa donated 25 individuals and, by 2010, all animals had many where small been released into a sanctuary network in populations exist the centre of an Intensive Protection Zone. Six calves had been born, all bar one to the first females that arrived in 2003. So it was with great joy that monitoring rhino officers discovered that three of the females that had been translocated in subsequent years had calved in mid-‐2011. Two of those females had arrived in 2006, indicating that it had taken them five long years to feel settled enough to reproduce — a prolonged period by any standards. However, our joy was short lived and, in a tragic period at the end of the dry season in October to November 2011, the first of what was to be six rhino deaths was discovered. It is with sad irony that the year in which South Africa lost 448 rhinos SRI Grants 8 Save the Rhino has made $2,000 available to NLCP for work to react to these deaths, in addition to $5,000 sent in December 2011 to be used for scout rations or towards vehicle costs. to poaching, Zambia lost 20% of its population and none of them was poached. And the saddest part of all? One of the 2006 females, Buntungwa, had produced her first calf in 2011, but when we found her carcass we could only assume that her 3-‐month old calf had died too. A panel of experts was called to North Luangwa to carry out a thorough investigation of underlying causes that led to so many deaths in such a short time, and to critically assess past, current and future issues relating to the conservation of the Park’s rhino population. Their findings are still pending as this issue of The Horn goes to press, but complex interactions between dry-‐season browse availability, intra-‐specific competition and adaptation to a new environment, all compounded by the sanctuary’s restricted area, were contributory factors. Frankfurt Zoological Society is committed to ensuring that lessons are learned, shared and carried forward in an effort to safeguard North Luangwa’s remaining rhino population in both the short and the long term. Zambia Kenya Wear and tear A new lease of life Zambia’s North Luangwa National Park spreads out over 4,636 km² from the Luangwa River in the east to the Muchinga escarpment in the west, one of the oldest sections of the Great Rift Valley on the continent. The North Luangwa Conservation Programme (NLCP) works over an area more than twice that size, facilitating law enforcement and protected area management in the surrounding areas, criss-crossed with a remote but relatively extensive network of about 1,000 km of roads, none of which are sealed but graded at best. The Laikipia Wildlife Forum’s Environmental Education Bus was in a sorry state. During the 6½ years between in January 2004 (its launch) and June 2010, it had travelled 169,000 km on unpaved and extremely rough roads, carrying 640 Kenyan school groups and 49 community groups, reaching a total of 24,531 people directly, and many more indirectly through open days. Cathy Dean | Director T he wear and tear was leading to more and more breakdowns, with 5 to 7 trips each year cancelled or significantly postponed (6 months or more) due to breakdowns, and 7 to 10 trips incurring significantly increased journey times (5 hours plus) and distances, due to diversions to avoid impassable roads as a result of rain. On average, the Bus became completely stuck in mud three times a year, resulting either in children and staff sleeping overnight in the Bus or the Bus being abandoned for the night and children continuing on foot. It was reaching the end of its useful life. Claire Lewis | Technical Advisor, North Luangwa Conservation Programme T ough vehicles are therefore needed for a functional law enforcement unit, in deploying and managing patrols, providing back up, distributing rations, reacting rapidly to reports of illegal activity, helping with sector administrative management, escorting arrested poachers to police stations, attending court sessions and recovering illegal firearms and trophies. The LWF asked for our help, and thanks to the generosity of our long-‐time funders, USFWS and Chester Zoo, we were able to come up with the bulk of the funds needed to buy a new vehicle. The LWF team had carried out a thorough assessment of the functional requirements, and had researched the options available: the new Bus would be able to cope with extremely rough roads and muddy conditions, carry its passengers in a quieter dust-‐and-‐moisture-‐free environment, have excellent visibility and be a teaching tool in itself, not just a means of transport. Vehicles are also used for other conservation and management activities undertaken by the Zambia Wildlife Authority (ZAWA) across the entire ecosystem, for example responding to wildlife conflict situations in surrounding communities. Other vehicles are assigned to particular units, such as the one used for the Rhino Monitoring Team. On average, each Land Cruiser completes approximately 30,000 km per year and can be expected to carry out field duties for 6 to 8 years. The rough driving conditions result in cumulative wear and tear above and beyond normal circumstances and replacement of older vehicles and regular maintenance and repair of others is essential. NLCP NLCP took delivery of its newest 4x4 Land Cruiser for the rhino monitoring officers in December 2011, funded through generous donations from Mohamed bin Zayed Species Conservation Fund, Martin Wills Fund, Simon Gibson Charitable Trust, Peter Lawrence and SRI. This vehicle will be used every day to move the ZAWA rhino officers around the Intensive Protection Zone so they can make best use of their time tracking rhinos on foot. The car is also used to reach sites to pick up radio telemetry signals, to distribute lucerne and bone meal to supplementary feed stations and to retrieve camera trap units for downloading back at base. Having this vital piece of ‘kit’ makes the job of the rhino officers that much easier and more efficient, meaning we can spend more of everything on keeping the rhinos safe. Thank you to all the donors. Tough vehicles are needed to navigate tough terrain With input from Chester Zoo, the artwork on the Bus — which had to be neutral in colour to comply with the requirements of conservancies in the Laikipia District — was designed around a new rhino logo to complement the LWF’s existing five symbols. A strapline in Swahili, ‘Conserve the environment for improved livelihoods’ helps brand the Bus as an LWF initiative. LWF In December 2011, Sammy Njorogo was promoted to Environment and Eco-‐Literary Programme Manager and Jackson Njaria recruited as EELP Assistant. And in January 2012, the new Bus was launched. It promises to be a full-‐on year. Thanks Our very grateful thanks to USFWS RTCF, which provided a grant of $34,660 for the new bus, and to Chester Zoo ($2,015 plus support in-kind). SRI gave $2,375 from our own core funds. The LWF and the Royal Netherlandish Embassy also helped cover the costs: a good collaborative effort. 9 Namibia CRIME THE SCENE OF THE t al “The way of integrating practic and theoretical work was good and made it enjoyable” Participant ares so remote that the ne Wêreldsend, a place lice tape away, was buzzing. Po shop is about 180km grass. ous-looking patch of cordoned off a suspici emitted ound. A metal detector Bones lay scattered ar er the s carefully hovered ov a gentle hum as it wa watched expectant Namibians area. And around 30 e Evans, Rod Potter and Wayn as the course leaders, . explained what to do Trainees learned how to take plaster casts of footprints found at the scene, which might later link a suspect to the crime Cathy Dean | Director A session on practical exhibits demonstrated items that might be found at a crime scene, ranging from weapons (axe, handgun, snare, bullet cartridges etc) to things that the poachers might have discarded (clothing, drinks cans) ans and Wayne Ev rse r, the cou Rod Potte e th in , instructors setting l fu ti u a e b send of Wêreld L BERND BREL A model of a black rhino is used to demonstrate anatomy, and to illustrate where to look for bullets KOBUS DE WET funding, but a series of igation into Tory party s No, this wasn’t an invest by Wildlife Investigator ining courses developed o wh Scene of the Crime tra ers nag ma e dlif wil Evans, especially for Rod Potter and Wayne particularly rhino and ious deaths of animals, pic sus have to deal with weeks, Rod and Wayne Over the course of three elephant, on their turf. ironment and Tourism, from the Ministry of Env taught groups of staff ice, Pol Unit of the Namibian the Protected Resource pment elo Dev ral Integrated Ru Save the Rhino Trust and to how , for k loo , what to and Nature Conservation sible to present the best pos how and ce den evi t collec case come to court. prosecution should the One of the practical sessions: th e participa nts study a pre tend crime scene befo re the start of the trainin g course a n d discuss wh at sort of th ings they might be looking for at the site ut up the good job – witho “I can only say keep and can see rhinos dying what you taught us I most cases” criminals winning in Participant 10 All those who might encounter a wildlife crime scene should carry an incident or pocket book, in which they can record details of the investigation. These notes will be invaluable when they come to present the case in court ctor etal dete m a g in s U sings r bullet ca fo k o lo to s ts require and bulle f the anning o careful sc a entire are “We need to expose the court to the importance of Wildlife crime and their impact so they prosecute effectively” Participant A second practical exercise saw participants divide into groups to examine two suspicious sites – a campsite and a vehicle – and record evidence. Each group then reported back on their methods and procedures, followed by critique and discussions Rod and Wayne showed trainees how to identify elephant ivory and how to distinguish real rhino horns from fake ones at The Basic courses were aimed anyone who might encounter a al carcass in the course of their norm , kers trac t’s Trus o Rhin work: Save the etc staff ks par l ona nati MET’s Having lea rned how to carry out crime scen e investiga tions on the Advanced Course, se ven of those who qualifi ed went on to take part in the Train -the-traine r course, so that they could teach further groups of p eople via tw o Basic courses for up to 30 pe ople each Bernd Brell (left), Director of Field Operations at Save the Rhino Trust Namibia; Rod Potter (right) presenting Bernd with his well-deserved Advanced course certificate One of the groups at work on planning how they would inspect a suspect vehicle WA YNE EVA NS Simson Uri-Kho b, (far right) Director of Capa city Building at Save the Rhin o Trust, puts into practic e his newly learned Train-th e-Trainer skills Thanks Each Advanced course participant received a detailed course handbook, which included all the references and material taught ALL PICS ROD POTTER UNLESS NOTED We would like to thank: USFWS and the Game Products Trust Fund, which awarded $24,585 and $20,655 respectively towards the cost of the Advanced, Train-the-trainer and Basic courses; IRDNC, for hosting the training courses at Wêreldsend; Bernd Brell of Save the Rhino Trust for organising the logistics; and of course Rod Potter and Wayne Evans, the trainers. 11 Namibia A poaching case, a remarkable rhino and a major grant A round up of recent news from Save the Rhino Trust (SRT), which recently responded to the first poaching incident in the Kunene in 17 years. Sue Wagner | Fundraising and Communications Manager, Save the Rhino Trust O n 25 October 2011, SRT’s trackers were patrolling with Community Game Guards when they came across the carcass of a rhino calf that had been caught in a snare and had both horns removed. It was estimated that the calf was about two years old and that it had died some four weeks previously. The probable cause of death was dehydration and starvation. There was evidence that the mother had remained near her calf in its dying days and repeatedly returned to the site long after its death. Fortunately, she did not fall victim to the poachers’ snares (four other snares were found in the area). The newly-‐formed North West Regional Security Committee responded to this incident, with SRT’s Director of Field Operations and pilot, Bernd Brell, flying to fetch the Protected Resource Unit’s (PRU) investigating officer. MET officials were soon on the The rhino had returned scene and great support of free food and accommodation for the investigating team ‘home’ by walking 250km was received from Wilderness Safaris, the to almost the exact tour operator in the region. DAVE HAMMAN PHOTOGRAPHY spot of her capture SRT The communication and co-‐ordination between all the stakeholders involved in rhino conservation was very encouraging, as teamwork is the name of the game when it comes to successful investigation after a poaching incident. Unfortunately, no arrests have yet been made. An exceptional patrol and a rare ‘homing’ event of a translocated rhino In September, SRT deployed two teams on a focused foot and donkey patrol in a very remote area of north-‐west Namibia. Due to the remote and rugged terrain, these patrols require extensive pre-‐planning and only take place a couple of times per year, with satellite image maps used to plan the route. National Geographic photographer Dave Hamman and wildlife artist Neil Taylor joined the patrol to provide images and artwork to support SRT’s work. It was an exceptional patrol resulting in 23 rhino sightings over eight days — the most ever for this eco-‐zone in a single patrol — including numerous rhino cows with relatively old, 12 healthy calves. The teams had one epic day of foot-‐slogging, notching up nearly 40 km as they packed out from their camp deep in the mountains. A most unusual discovery was made on this patrol. A rhino cow that was originally captured and airlifted into Orupembe Conservancy in the far north west was sighted. She had returned ‘home’ and had walked roughly 250 km (155 miles) to almost the exact spot where she was captured in July 2010. It is regarded as a very rare long-‐ distance ‘homing’ event for black rhino. SRT awarded IUCN’s Save Our Species Grant Just before Christmas, Save the Rhino Trust received a wonderful Christmas gift in the form of the very exciting news that our proposal to Save Our Species, developed in collaboration with SRI, had been successful. The grant has been provided to support monitoring work in response to the African rhino poaching crisis. Save Our Species is a joint initiative of the Global Environment Facility, the IUCN and the World Bank. A fundamental goal is to ensure the long-‐term survival and well being of threatened species and their critical habitats for biodiversity conservation Save the Rhino Trust, in collaboration with Namibia’s Ministry of Environment and Tourism (MET), has been monitoring black rhino for three decades with four teams of dedicated trackers. Monitoring data is used to inform decision-‐making on the management of this unique black rhino population — the last truly free-‐ranging black rhino population in the world. Save the Rhino Trust feels most honoured to have been selected as a recipient of this grant from SOS. Supporters Fundraising like crazy We’ve had an incredible number of people who have decided to give their time and energy to raising funds for us. We want to send them a huge thank you! Here are some of the crazy things our supporters have been up to. Phillpe Flamand in HK Jo Paulson | Events Manager Richard Vigne is the CEO of Ol Pejeta conservancy in Kenya. He has taken on the Gold Challenge, where he will cover 2,012 km before the start of the London Olympics on his cross-‐trainer and rowing machine. That equates to approximately 6.8km per day! Richard has raised a fantastic £5,429 so far and has topped the Gold Challenge individual fundraising league table. Richard Vigne and a rhino calf Brothers Richard and Philippe Flamand have been spreading the message about rhino poaching to the East — in style. Each completed in a marathon in a rhino costume — Richard in Dubai and Philippe in Hong Kong. Together they’ve raised over $18,000. Andree Schoombee, along with Marcel, Pierre, Angie and Barend will be travelling from London to Cape Town in Toyota Land Cruisers, visiting rhino programmes along the way. Their Going Down South mission will take 6 months. Arif Hussain has raised over £4,000 by asking his friends and family for a donation instead of presents for his 40th birthday. It sounds like he had one hell of a party! Nadia Alnaimi who has recently starred in Safari Vet School on ITV has set up ‘Team Rhino’ at Cambridge University to raise funds and awareness of rhino poaching. Save the Rhino friends Linton Park Wines are running the Comrades ultra marathon in June. Vlok, with two of the cellar workers Owen and Byron, will be running the 89 km race to raise money for rhinos. Don’t be drinking too much of that wine now — remember, you’re in training! Peter de Wit and Paul Bosch are taking part in the Gortex Transalpine run, an eight-‐ day footrace beginning in Germany and ending in Italy, travelling over the Alps. They will be running 320 km and covering an incredible 15,000 m difference in elevation. South African Travel and Tourism Association (SATOA) has picked Save the Rhino as its appointed charity this year. SATOA will support us at each of its events, holding raffles and raising awareness of our goals. g... Not forgettin allenge ore Iron Man ch g on the Singap kin ta ht rig W Graham anjaro for us th climbing Kilim not content wi o, wh anc! d Bl ol t sf on or Mark W nts to climb M cided he now wa de s ha , ar ye last rhino costume ris marathon in Pa e th n ru s o ha Frank Smits wh marathon Aviemore half s a place in the ha o wh y le Co Lorraine When in Rome… me marathon. Ro e th on g ng takin Stephanie Cheu apparently! n ho at ar 0 m run a tions to IRV202 asked for dona y dl kin ry ve asan ams Bhuvana Sriniv ing to Colin Ad ts for her wedd en es pr of d ea inst r donations to cided to ask fo de sly es lfl se s s ha birthday Shannah Adam ts for her 30th er than presen th ra os in rh lp he es, cake tion of car wash doing a combina is r r rhinos lle fo He ey e on bi Ab ence to raise m sil d re so on sp bakes and a us this year. have helped ho w e or m y ... and the man You really do make such a big difference Arif Hussain’s 40th birthday cake Above: Team Rhino Right: Graham, The Singapore Iron Man Below right: Vlok, Owen and Byron Bottom: Going Down South to Cape Town 13 Events Virgin London Marathon 2012 Preparations for the London Marathon on 22 April are running at full speed! Katherine Ellis | Michael Hearn Intern W ith 2012 being the year of the Olympics, it only seems appropriate that this year’s Virgin London Marathon is set to be Save the Rhino’s biggest team so far. We currently have 62 Gold Bond runners and 10 Own Place runners signed up, whose training and fundraising preparations are well underway. Fingers crossed that none of the team will be injured in the lead up to the Marathon. This year’s team has several international runners, with participants flying all the way from South Africa, Kenya, USA and even Peru! These runners are helping to raise Save the Rhino’s profile around the world, especially in countries such as South Africa, which saw almost 450 rhinos poached in 2011. ALL PICS MATT BROOKE Happy runners at the rhino rug Following the debut of the 10 brand new rhino costumes at last year’s London Marathon, demand for the suits has soared, with all the new costumes snapped up midway through 2011. The popularity of these costumes means that many of the old costumes are being given a new lease of life. They have been thoroughly assessed and repairs are underway to fix metal work, re-‐pad straps, glue plates together, and re-‐paint the costumes. We are hoping to have a large crash of 17 rhinos on the streets on Marathon day 2012. The London Marathon is Save the Rhino’s biggest fundraising event of the year and we are hugely grateful for all the hard work that our team members put in with fundraising and training in the months leading up to the Marathon. Thank you very much to everyone who is running for us this year and the best of luck! A well-‐deserved massage after completing a marathon challenge! Virgin London 3 Marathon 201 a place in If you missed out on n in 2013, 2012 and want to ru run it to or if you can’t wait e email as ple , all over again hino.org er eth av @s katherine 14 Where in the world? This year our cuddly rhinos have been out and about in the UK. They have been spotted relaxing on the beach and sightseeing in the capital. Where will the rest of 2012 take them? Katherine Ellis Michael Hearn Intern Show your support for Save the Rhino by purchasing a cute cuddly rhino as a gift for someone close to you or for yourself, take a shot in an exciting location, and send it in to [email protected] The best photos will be published in the next Horn magazine and on our blog www.savetherhino.org/latest_ news/blog The toughest choice is deciding which colour to buy — white or black? Along with our rhinos, we have plenty of other merchandise in stock. You can save the world and spread the word about Save the Rhino by purchasing an eco-‐friendly cotton shopper bag. Or you could show your love of rhinos by wearing a silver rhino pin badge on your jacket. And with summer approaching, surely it’s time to purchase a new logo t-‐shirt or cap — the same as those worn by rangers in the field! You can purchase any of the merchandise featured on this page by visiting our website www.savetherhino.org telephoning Katherine directly, or sending a cheque along with details of your order by post to the Save the Rhino office. News in brief From our partners ecotricity ‘Ecotricity is an energy company unlike any other. We supply homes and businesses across Britain with green energy, and then use our customers’ bills to create even more sources of renewable power — like windmills. ‘We are working together with Save the Rhino to help raise money and protect these critically endangered animals. It is not just climate change that threatens these animals, poaching is at an all time high and so by simply switching your energy supplier you can raise money to help protect these magnificent animals. Ecotricity will donate £40 for switching Electricity and £60 for switching to dual fuel.’ To sign up please call 08000 302 302 and quote ‘SRI’ or ‘Save the Rhino’ or visit www.ecotricity. co.uk/rhino Western black rhino declared extinct Since the last issue of The Horn, the IUCN Red List (which provides information on the conservation status of species globally) has declared the Western black rhino subspecies as extinct. Although this has been suspected by many, this is the first time that the extinction has been officially registered, as the Red List delays changing the status of a species for five years, in case any new information is received. You can read comment from Cathy Dean, SRI Director at www.savetherhino.org/latest_news/news and search ‘black rhino’ LOWVELD RHINO TRUST Operation Stop Poaching Now Our Stop Poaching Now appeal aims to raise awareness and funds for the African countries most affected by the rise in poaching of rhino horn: South Africa, Zimbabwe, Namibia and Kenya. You can also donate by text right now: text STOP99 followed by a space, then the amount you’d like to donate (£1, £3, £5 or £10) to 70070. Thanks to Just Text Giving by Vodafone, absolutely all of your donation will go to helping Save the Rhino. JEAN-‐CHRISTOPHE VIE Funds raised will support the teams on the ground, providing them with much needed support, equipment and training. Visit our website to read more: www.savetherhino.org/support_us/ campaigns_and_appeals ALAIN COMPOST Javan rhino declared extinct in Vietnam Javan rhinos were also declared extinct in Vietnam in October 2011. The subspecies Rhinoceros sondaicus annamiticus is now probably extinct too, although unlike the Western black rhino, its official status has not yet changed. This is incredibly sad news. The last remaining population of Javan rhinos survive in Ujung Kulon Java. SRI Staff changes Lucy Boddam-Whetham has left SRI after four years to join the Zoological Society of London (ZSL) as Assistant Programme Manager, South and Central Asia. We wish Lucy the very best of luck in her new post. Susie Offord has replaced Lucy as Deputy Director. Francesca Shapland has also left SRI, with Laura Adams, our fourth Michael Hearn Intern, replacing her as the new Office and Communications Manager. Congratulations Save the Rhino would like to offer heartfelt congratulations to two leaders of rhino conservation who have recently won awards. Martin Brooks received the Sir Peter Scott Award for Conservation Merit and Richard Emslie (above right) received the Harry Messel Award for Conservation Leadership, at the recent IUCN SSG meeting in Abu Dhabi. 15 Tanzania Many of the Tanzanian staff have worked at Mkomazi for over 20 years, and are mostly all sel f-taught. This is Fred Ayo, Worksho p Manager. Every piece of equip ment or vehicle is treated with TLC an d its life is extended as far as po ssible. E A HOW DID YOU SOLV OMAZI? PROBLEM LIKE MK es. rk is a sight for sore ey Mkomazi National Pa visit but onceptions before my I tried to have no prec rious nd’s eye from all the va had an idea in my mi rked wo ns and reports I had fundraising applicatio come: how far Mkomazi had on. What I knew was extinction me Reserve, with local from a degraded Ga nds ing rhinos, to how it sta of many species includ ife. rk, brimming with wildl today, as a National Pa an tional Park on the Keny It neighbours Tsavo Na cted ote of one of the largest pr border, forming part ecosystems in Africa. | Lucy Boddam-‐Whetham S NOTED Former Deputy Director h the Fitzjohns. Tony about spending time wit I was nervously excited worked closely with since I was young. I had is someone I have admired time with her face-‐ ng ndi looking forward to spe Lucy Fitzjohn, and was them both better. My te delight to get to know to-‐face. It was an absolu intenance background for the ride (and his ma partner Matt came along cies of fence work and laining the various intrica came in handy when exp was the Fitzjohns’ st mo at impressed us the t replacement to me!). Wh se philosophy is eviden ’s boy-‐scout, no-‐nonsen iled ll-‐o practical approach. Fitz we are ctuary and Mkomazi Rhino San all around. Kisima Camp rk. All of the Fitzjohn’s wo d har and tion ica machines, run on pure ded rked there for over s, many of whom have wo staff are local Tanzanian ses achieved at e to see the many succes 20 years. It was a privileg ’t imagine what Mkomazi Mkomazi, though I still can y first arrived. the en must have been like wh ctuary ze of the San shows the si ew his vi l (T . ia es er This a fence lin ibly straight ed d cr in ha I e t th ls d an ght whi n during a fli on the shot was take d the other n a y er en sc e th on’t on one eye y hand – I w utching in m cl s a w I g a sick-b or not!) was needed divulge if it be We are currently fundraising to e cran g liftin a hase purc able to truck that will enable additional population management at the Sanctuary, which is split into five sections. In order to maximise breeding success and genetic diversity of the population, the breeding pairs will be rotated and r some could even be moved to othe locations within the Park. 16 ALL PICS MATT BROOKE UNLES Another important member of the team is Lucy Fitzjohn, who works tirelessly on all of the admin and fundraising at Mkomazi. During my visit we spent a lot of time working on the fundraising needs of the rhino work and plans for the future. The best news whilst we were there was that the most recent additions, two of three rhinos that had been brought to Mkomazi from Dvur Kralove Zoo in 2009, had successfully mated and produced a male calf named Hilla. The calf was barely a month old when we were there and was well hidden in the undergrowth, but here is a photo of proud dad Jamie, standing watch over his new family. Another source of inspiration: this photo shows the view from the hilltop where the EEP classroom is positioned. The rhino skull in the foreground is a poignant reminder of how far Mkomazi has come. SRI continue The rest of the rhinos rtages sho ter wa d an , to thrive etimes require within Mkomazi som topped be the water pans to er kindly ws bo ter up via the wa . (Mkomazi Zoo er est Ch by funded after all.) ’, does mean ‘no water SRI One of the bi ggest fundin g needs at the moment is the replac ement of the Sanctuary fe nce. The pole s are coming to the end of their 12-15 ye ar lifespan. Many are ro tten like thes e ones and need replac ing. Thanks to funders including Mohamed bin Zayed Species Conservation Fund, Chester Zoo and The Bower Trust, last year, Mkomazi was able to replace approx. 10km of fence line (so far) with a mixture of wooden and metal poles. This is back-breaking work for the team, but it is vital that the integrity of the Sanctuary is not compromised. It’s not just about the rhinos at Mkomazi, there is also a successfu l breeding programme for the endangered African wild dog. I am sure the children find Elisaria’s smile and enthusiasm infectious and inspiring. Mkomazi also has its own Environmental Education Programme (EEP) called Rafiki wa Faru (meaning friend of the rhino); avid readers of The Horn might remembe r reading about it previously. The Operations Manager. Elisaria Nnko also acts as the Environmental Education Officer and is seen here explaining how the breeding programme works to the school group. SRI Tony Fitzjohn is not just a conservationist, but has also had to turn his hand to being a vehicle mechanic, pilot, diplomat, road and fence builder, teacher, community liaison advisor… the list goes on and on. 17 Kenya Dealing with an emergency ALL PICS SRI The Laikipia District straddles the equator and is an extremely important rhino habitat, home to around 45% of Kenya’s black rhinos and 72% of its Southern white rhinos. These rhinos are state-owned but held in private and community sanctuaries, which are members of the Association of Private Land Rhino Sanctuaries (APLRS). APLRS activities include translocations (to maintain rhino populations at productive densities), plus innovative programmes such as its Intelligence and Informers network, and an Emergency Fund, for use by all conservancies with rhinos in Kenya. The emergency fund is used to support a wide area comprising private and community rhino sanctuaries — a great, shared resource Katherine Ellis | Michael Hearn Intern Intelligence and Informers network Eight of the APLRS areas are located in insecure and banditry prone areas where poaching for rhino horn has skyrocketed since 2009. Poaching has been exacerbated by infiltration of ammunition from neighbouring Somalia, along with intensified global demand for rhino horn in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Each day, anti-‐poaching rangers risk their lives to protect the rhinos, with a real threat of encountering armed poachers. The APLRS Intelligence and Informers Scheme uses new ideas to counter the current poaching threat. It aims to enhance the security and monitoring of rhinos in Kenya’s private rhino sanctuaries through cash incentives, to increase the motivation and morale of security personnel. Sanctuaries who are members of APLRS agree to give a standard compensation to security personnel who apprehend poachers or recover firearms. Funds are also available to rangers who supply credible information leading to the arrest of poachers or the recovery of rhino horn. These rewards are offered in recognition of the considerable threat to the ranger’s personal safety, whilst also reinforcing information and intelligence-‐gathering mechanisms. It is hoped that by advertising the rewards available, further information will be generated, leading to the prosecution and conviction of rhino poachers. Emergency Fund As there are so few rhinos in the wild, each individual preserved has a valuable conservation impact. It is obvious that wild rhinos get hurt — male rhinos often fight, and they occasionally break through fences and wander out of conservancy areas. This is where the APLRS’s Emergency Fund fits in: a central fund enabling member conservancies to respond to poaching threats or emergencies. 18 The Emergency Fund can be used for a wide range of activities, from providing veterinary care for injured rhinos to translocating an aggressive bull or recapturing an animal that has broken through a fence. During an emergency, money is needed for many things, including truck/aircraft use, capture and vet staff, drugs, darts, veterinary care and special feed. The Emergency Fund can be used to cover 50% of the costs, while the other 50% is paid by the conservancy involved. On average, seven animals a year require emergency assistance; however this may increase as Laikipia’s rhino population grows. In the past year, funds have helped save the lives of several rhinos. For example, in November 2010 in the Lewa conservancy, action was taken to treat a young male black rhino calf after his mother was poached the previous month. In February 2011, funds were used by Ol Pejeta Conservancy (OPC), to treat and save the life of Dada, a black rhino, shot by poachers. Support was also given to OPC conservancy in March 2011, when adult males received treatment following fights. Save the Rhino welcomes initiatives such as the APLRS, which benefits all members and involves coordination between conservancies, private landowners and the government. The APLRS schemes will benefit the Laikipia rhino population and enhance Kenya’s capacity to achieve the targeted black rhino growth rate of 6% per year in established sanctuaries, and to achieve Kenya’s Vision 2030 of having 2,000 black rhinos in the wild. Grants Our very grateful thanks to Chester Zoo and Ian Anderson, for their grants of £7,500 and £3,000 respectively, towards the Intelligence and Informers network run by the APLRS. Chester Zoo and SRI had both previously made grants for the Emergency Fund. Rhino soup Flipping open my wife’s grandfather’s book, Hunter by Hunter, I came upon the following passage, in which J.A. Hunter discusses his meals with his camp cook. Myself: What soup do we have tonight, Malumbe? Malumbe: Rhino soup, bwana. Myself: What meat? Malumbe: Fillet of rhino, bwana. Myself: What for tomorrow? Malumbe: Rhino heart, bwana. Whatever part I ate, I still had visions of the charging animal that had died in defence of his heritage and this hardly aided digestion. Richard Bonham | Chairman, Maasailand Preservation Trust MPT and its rangers now protect the last remaining rhinos in the Chyulu Hills This conversation took place only 65 years ago and only 30 miles from where we are working with Kenya Wildlife Service on the Chyulu Hills Game scout and rhino programme, endeavouring to protect the few rhinos that J.A left behind. J.A, at that time, was responsible for clearing land for settlement, which involved shooting 1,000 rhino on what is now known as the great Makueni rhino hunt. ALL PICS SRI The Rhino Poaching Crisis — A Market Analysis, by Michael ‘t Sa s-‐Rolfes, is a must-‐read for anybody interested in rhino conversation. It demonstrates a staggering change in markets, from rhino being destroyed as vermin 60 years ago, to rhino horn having a market value of $6,000 a kilo only two decades ago, and finally to the current horn value of approx. $65,000 per kilo. The reasons for this huge hike are explained well in Michael’s paper. Grants t to the Ernes Our thanks ust Tr le b ta hari Kleinwort C 4,796 (£ o Zo r te es (£5,000); Ch life ns to the Wild for renovatio r fo 95 £7 d mp an Warriors Ca nd the a s; p a tr a mer infra-red ca st (£500). aritable Tru h C a m ch Dis For us on the ground, it spells out the huge challenge we are facing. We need to provide security for unfenced rhino in the Chyulu area, whose horn value equates to a few million dollars. Now, in a poor country, where people will risk a custodial sentence for stealing a mobile phone, the temptation to poach a rhino must be almost impossible to resist. The rhino crisis we are facing has two fronts. One is ours — in the field desperately trying to play for time. The greater battle, to deflate the market value, takes place thousands of miles away, and will dictate if we will win or lose and if rhino will survive. 19 report Supply and demand The illegal rhino horn trade Trade in rhino horn has a long history, with the earliest records of use in medicine in China going back millennia. Rhino horns were also prized for their translucent appearance when carved and used to make cups and bowls, which were believed to have the added advantage of being able to detect alkaloid poisons. More recent demand for rhino horn during an earlier wave of poaching in the 1960 – 70s was primarily for use in the construction of ceremonial dagger handles, known as jambiyas, in Yemen. Jo Shaw | Programme Officer — Large Mammal Trade, TRAFFIC East/Southern Africa Office T chewing fingernails’ can imply denigration of Asia’s ancient healing arts. Respect for tradition and the concept of face in front of one’s peers plays a major role in Eastern culture, and specifically influences current attitudes and practices of rhino horn usage. his market has largely dissipated in recent years, primarily due to economic decline and social unrest in that region. Rhino horn has also been in constant demand in Asia as a constituent in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) with ever-‐shifting peaks of trade between China, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan and territories. By the mid-‐1990s, all the important rhino horn consumer countries in Asia had banned the substance in their TCM industries. TCM uses herbs and animal products to create harmony and balance in VICKY HUNT Traditional Chinese Medicine RENAUD FULCONIS TRAFFIC’s report on The Rhino Horn Trade Dynamic between South Africa and Viet Nam is due to be launched in May 2012 and covers these issues in more detail. The report will be available for download from www.traffic.org 20 the body. Rhino horn is believed to be effective in reducing temperature and has commonly been used to treat high fevers and convulsions, to control haemorrhaging and to assist the liver in cleansing the blood of toxins resulting from the intake of alcohol or poison. TCM often prescribes rhino horn in combination with herbs and other traditional ingredients. It has not, as is widely and falsely propagated, been prescribed as an aphrodisiac. The medicinal properties of rhino horn, and other TCM ingredients, have an ingrained cultural significance in the East and for Westerners to simply dismiss such beliefs as ‘being like TRA FFIC Rhino horn has been in constant demand in Asia, where it is consumed as medicine Viet Nam Trade patterns detected by TRAFFIC indicate that the resurgent demand for rhino horn is driven primarily by users from Viet Nam. Increasing prosperity in the Vietnamese economy has led to increased levels of individual disposable income and, sadly, use of rhino horn appears to be a way to demonstrate one’s affluence and high social status. Both traditional and modern preparation of rhino horn medicines typically involves grinding the horn into a powdered form, which is then placed in hot water to produce a white, cloudy liquid. In Viet Nam, special porcelain bowls with a rough serrated bottom for the home preparation of rhino horn are now widely available. Rhino horn consumers Today, rhino horn consumers in Viet Nam are thought to fall into four main descriptive categories; habitual users are invariably wealthy, middle-‐aged, urban-‐dwelling elites who frequently use rhino horn as a detoxifying beverage and body-‐rejuvenating tonic. Belief in the detoxification properties of rhino horn, especially following excessive intake of alcohol, probably stands as the most common routine usage at this point in time. Associated with the above, rhino horns are purchased and offered as high-‐value, status-‐conferring gifts to important political officials and other socio-‐economic elites within the country. Individuals suffering from serious illnesses such as cancer are also turning to rhino horn to cure or improve their condition. Although never described in the traditional medical literature, recent popular belief in Viet Nam seemingly promotes rhino horn usage as treatment, and possibly a cure, for life-‐threatening disease. As early as June 2009, TRAFFIC researchers were told stories of important individuals — an unnamed Minister or another famous person — who inevitably had cancer but were ultimately cured following treatment with rhino horn. In reality, evidence strongly suggests that the promotion of miraculous curative powers for rhino horn represents a cynical marketing ploy to increase the profitability of the rhino horn trade. TRAFFIC has also identified another consumer group comprising affluent, young Vietnamese mothers who keep small quantities of rhino horn for home preparation of medicines to treat high fever, especially for their children. Save the Rhino’s shiny new website We are very excited to announce the launch of our new website! Over the past few months we have been working very hard to get ready for our launch. Hopefully you’ve caught up with this in your RhiNEWS and have had the chance to look around. If not, then I hope this inspires you to go and check out the new site! You can find us at www.savetherhino.org Laura Adams | Office and Communications Manager T he site features all of the sections that you know and love from the old site: you can read all about the programmes and projects that we fund, find out everything you need to know about your favourite rhino species, and keep up-‐to-‐date with the latest rhino news. There are some changes though. We hope that it will be easier for you to get involved. You can comment on the latest news stories and share them through social media. We’ll have posts tackling the ‘thorny issues’ of rhino conservation and will be posting updates on our blog. We also have a fantastic new look design, which we believe is more user-‐ friendly, and means that you should find what you are looking for more easily. Make the most of the search tools, there’s lots of good information on there! What’s more, we would like to hear your feedback. Whether it’s about any of the info that you have read, or any suggestions for content you would like to see, please go to our blog www.savetherhino/news/ blog. We’ve put a post up there already that you can comment on: just search for articles tagged The Horn. We’ll send a free eco-‐bag to the first 10 people to post a helpful comment! The future? This diversification in use of rhino horn and broadening of acceptance throughout affluent Vietnamese society represents a concerning trend. However, testimonials are beginning to surface in the Vietnamese media from individuals who have experienced allergic reactions due to poisoning as a result of using rhino horn medicines. One wonders if there are not also distressed relatives of those who have died from serious illness, despite spending large sums of money on rhino horn as a treatment. Such tales of disappointment may ultimately provide the key to changing opinion on the medical properties of rhino horn and lead to a reduction in its demand. Screenshots of our fab new website. What do you think? Let us know! Thanks The team at TicToc who have helped us to produce the fantastic new site. 21 Events Douglas Adams The Party Sunday 11 March saw a mass of towel-adorned Douglas Adams fans congregate for ‘the second most significant 60th jubilee of the year’ (Chortle): Douglas Adams The Party. Save the Rhino and Douglas’s family and friends got together to create a 60th birthday party worthy of the late, great Douglas Adams. Held at the Hammersmith Apollo for 3,500 people, the event captured the essence of an evening spent at one of Douglas’s famous house parties. Jo Paulson | Events Manager ALL PICS CLAIRE BILYARD ‘When a lean, affecting Gilmour sang Wish you Were Here or Gary Brooker from Procul Harum ended the show with A Whiter Shade of Pale, this really felt like a birthday party to remember’ The Times Save the Rhino Patron and good friend of Douglas’s, Clive Anderson, did a fantastic job of hosting the evening and interviewing Python star Terry Jones and Sanjeev Bhaskar, where it came out that Douglas had once almost killed most of the Monty Python stars by driving the wrong way down the motorway. Sanjeev also told us that his famous comedy series The Kumars at Number 42 was a nod to the significant Hitchhiker’s reference (42 being the answer to life, the Universe and everything). Clive hilariously referred to the time he famously offended the Bee Gees to the extent they walked off his talk show after the tribute act The Heebeegeebees (made up of Angus us of course had to be P.S. The highlight for -‐dancing rhinos! tap ht the troupe of eig ‘In pursuit of the spirit of Adams, the whole evening was a touching tribute to a man whose work is not only loved, but still being adapted anew for television and radio nearly 11 years after his untimely death’ Herald Scotland ‘For a brief time it felt like the much-missed wordsmith was indeed here. Particularly at the eyecatching end when the onstage screen showed him strolling naked into the ocean’ London Evening Standard 22 M any of Douglas’s friends from the worlds of music, comedy, entertainment and science came together to honour the author, most famous for The Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Galaxy. Stephen Fry was there in virtual form to introduce a film of himself and Mark Carwardine discussing Douglas’s passion for conservation. Deayton, Michael Fenton Stevens and Philip Pope) sang Meaningless Songs (In Very High Voices). Douglas is of course best known for his science fiction writing, in which he explored his curiosity about the Universe and demonstrated his ability to think about the world in completely new ways. Those of Uncaged Monkey fame, Robin Ince, Simon Singh and Helen Keen covered the science for the evening, proving that Tellytubbies are in fact evil and that cats will one day take over the world (as well as how we know the Universe is expanding). Jon Culshaw stood in for the sadly missing Brian Cox (who had to fly to Australia last minute – ‘to point at volcanoes’ according to Robin Ince), with an excellent impression (complete with pointing). He also demonstrated his versatility by treating us to impressions of Sir Patrick Moore and Tom Baker (for whom Douglas wrote Dr Who episodes). John Lloyd, creator of Blackadder and QI wrote The Meaning of Liff with Douglas in 1983. He treated us to a few of the top ‘Liffs’ that they created together – a redefinition of a place name with a meaning for which there is no current word. He also read some of the winning entries to the competition we ran in the lead up to the show. The winner PEAKIRK n: One who regularly points out that there are no lavatories on the USS Enterprise Interspersed throughout the night were various sketches written by Adams in the early years – for the 70s series The Burkiss Way and 1974 Cambridge Footlights, performed as if for a radio recording. Rory McGrath, Will Adams, Martin Smith and Susan Sheridan were amongst the performers demonstrating Douglas’s inventive use of language and wry sense of humour. The surprise reveal at the end of the night was the band, who last performed together in Douglas’s living room. Introduced by Richard Curtis, the line up included David Gilmour, Robbie McIntosh, Gary Brooker, Jodi Linscott, Paul ‘Wix’ Wickens, Margo Buchanan, Dave Bronze and Paul Bevis. Ending with a heart-‐warming thanks by Douglas’s family and a film of Douglas walking into the sea overlain by What a Wonderful World, there wasn’t a dry eye in the house, or a person left sitting in their seats. We’re proud and honoured to have created ‘one of the greatest events in the Galaxy’ (Stephen Fry), with the wonderful friends and family of Douglas Adams. Thank you to everyone who helped make this happen. The Party raised almost £70,000, and we will be making grants to two other charities with which Douglas was closely involved: The Environmental Investigation Agency and the Gorilla Organization. Events in brief World Rhino Day On Tuesday 22 September 2011, we took six rhino costumes to the Vietnamese Embassy in London for a peaceful protest. We ‘de-horned’ one of our rhino costumes and got out our placards to demonstrate against the killing of rhino horn to be used in Traditional Chinese Medicine. We chose the Vietnamese Embassy as there has been an increased demand from Vietnam since a rumour has 3 Peaks 3 Weeks taken hold about a politician being cured of cancer by using rhino horn. We even gathered up jars of human toenails to demonstrate that rhino horn is made up of the same stuff — keratin — and delivered a letter to the Vietnamese Ambassador to explain why we were there and to help raise awareness of the problems that countries like Vietnam are causing for rhino populations. In January 2012, eleven women from the UK, Europe, USA and Australia climbed the three highest peaks in Africa in three weeks to raise money for conservation, education and health in Africa. Between them, they raised over £100,000 for three charities: Laikipia Wildlife Forum, Support for International Change and School of St Jude’s. Save the Rhino has been involved with the 3 Peaks 3 Weeks challenge since it began in 2007. With the massive success of the challenge, founders Chloe and Laura have been able to set up the Peaks Foundation and include many more challenges in many more countries. We wish them the best of luck with this venture. Visit www.peaksfoundation.org for more information. When you want to be noticed, dress in a giant rhino costume. It works for our marathon runners, so we thought we would give it a try! SRI CHARLOTTE PEYRAT Rhino Trek VAGANAY Rhino Climb South Africa 2012 Kilimanjaro On 6 May 2012, a crash of intrepid rhino explorers will travel across two reserves in South Africa on the lookout for rhinos. Rhino MayDay This year’s Rhino Mayday will take place on Tuesday 1 May at the Grant Museum of Zoology, University College London. They will trek 100 km over 5 days, sleeping under the stars and taking turns to look out for unwanted intruders at night. They will end their trek at Hluhuwe-iMfolozi Park, where they will see where the money they have raised will be spent. We will have a variety of speakers, talking on topics as diverse as rhino horn trade, monitoring and poaching, education and population management. We will have a variety of talks and a panel discussion so that you can join in the debates. The event will be an information-sharing and awareness-raising event for anyone with an interest in wildlife conservation. MIKE PETCHEY We will have another trek in 2013, so look out for details on our website. The late, great Douglas Adams took part in a trek from Mombasa to the top of Kilimanjaro for Save the Rhino back in 1994, taking a turn to wear the famous rhino costume along the coastal stretch. He wrote about it in The Salmon of Doubt. Since then, we have continued this trip for rhino conservation and offer a very special trip to visit one of the rhino programmes we support: Mkomazi (where the legendary Tony Fitzjohn works). The next climb, which will summit at a full moon, takes place from 27 Sept to 6 Oct 2012. We will offer a similar climb in September 2013. rmation on all of our Contact [email protected] for info g/events events, or visit www.savetherhino.or 23 Shoot to kill? Last year, Save the Rhino received an email from a concerned supporter after a comment on a well-known rhino conservation blog apparently ‘celebrated’ the death of five poachers, shot by rangers in South Africa. What were Save the Rhino’s views on the shooting, they asked? Is it ever OK to defend a policy that can mean the loss of human life in order to protect wildlife? Laura Adams | Office and Communications Manager S ave the Rhino’s position, and the policy adopted by most of the programmes that we support, is to shoot-‐to-‐kill only as a last act and in self-‐defence. Anti-‐poaching rangers must first do all they can to avoid this. In the event of a contact (a ranger meeting a poacher), it would be much more beneficial if they were caught and arrested, giving the opportunity to recover valuable information about who has commissioned them to turn to poaching, information about the supply chain, and smuggling routes. If a poacher fires — they virtually all carry guns these days — and endangers the ranger’s safety, then rangers may fire back, with the chance that lives may be lost in this exchange. SRI Many anti-‐poaching and monitoring programme staff in the field are armed but not all. Those protecting National Parks a prison sentence are free or Game Reserves usually are, while those protecting rhinos and other wildlife in to return and poach conservancies (private or more rhino community-‐owned) are not. It’s a tough ask to face a poaching gang when all you possess is a torch, a phone and a GPS. Some rhino holders are applying for Police Reservist status, which would allow named individuals to bear arms; others have come to arrangements with local police forces or the government department to carry out joint patrols. Whoever is protecting the rhinos, is it morally acceptable to shoot to kill? TONY FITZJOHN Poachers who do not receive MAASAILAND PRESERVATION TRUST 24 Shoot-‐to-‐kill is one of the most controversial issues facing rhino conservation Very occasionally, shoot-‐to-‐kill is not only tolerated but encouraged, as a way of sending a very clear signal to poaching gangs, and rewarding the bravery of the rhinos’ protectors. In Kaziranga National Park, India, forest guards receive a cash bonus to their salary if they successfully wound and kill a poacher. This stance has affected funding; indeed this policy caused the BBC Wildlife Fund to pull out of planned funding for the programme a couple of years ago. Furthermore, in Kaziranga the forest guards will not be prosecuted for shooting a poacher, whether in self-‐defence or as a pro-‐active ambush or attack. The issue of indemnity for armed wildlife guards is an important one for many field programmes, whose staff risk being caught up in lengthy court cases and even prison, while acting in the line of duty. Protecting rhinos endangers lives. Mohammad Hasen Ali, a ranger at Rajiv Gandhi Orang National Park in Assam, India was fatally wounded when apprehending a poacher and declared dead on arrival at the nearest medical centre. His family received $2,000 in compensation. Conversely, a Zambian poacher has just been killed, one of a group of three armed poachers who resisted arrest and shot at rangers in Tshakabika, Sinamatella in Hwange National Park in Zimbabwe. There are casualties on both sides. In South Africa, 232 suspected poachers were arrested in 2011. But of these how many will actually end up being sentenced? Why don’t we hear of more poachers going to prison, and why is it so hard to convict a poacher? iThe disparity between sentencing in different countries is great. The law in many countries does not assign long prison sentences to wildlife crime. Events Many anti-‐poaching teams are armed and virtually all poachers carry guns On a dark night in the wilderness of London Zoo, some strange and unusual creatures gifted us with a brief glimpse of their beauty. Interacting quite happily with the spectators, this rare but wondrous species (Celebritus dinewithus) showed their natural aptitude for communication. STEVE ROBINS In Zambia, possession of rhino horn or a conviction of poaching can receive a sentence of 20 years, while in Kenya, the penalty for poaching is simply a fine (and a relatively low fine at that) iEven where tough laws do exist, for a criminal case, it Jo Paulson | Events Manager is difficult to prove beyond all reasonable doubt that a poacher is guilty. To do so would require DNA analysis linking the rhino carcass, the horn and the poacher. Too often, the expertise is not available for this type of sophisticated analysis. Even in South Africa, where this facility is available, many poachers are currently awaiting trial dates, and appeals have been sent out for more evidence from the public to complete these prosecutions. If a poacher is apprehended before an attack, there is very little to prove, except armed trespass On 16 November 2011, six celebrity speakers and MC Clive Anderson (right) joined us at our annual fundraising dinner. Each speaker had just 20 slides with 20 seconds per slide to talk about something ‘Wild’. Clive Anderson was responsible for taming: iFrank Gardner, the BBC’s Security There is general frustration about the prosecution of rhino poachers. It is important to build the political will to ensure that prison sentences are given. Time and time again, poachers are acquitted at trial. If this is the case, then legal measures to crack down on poaching are not working. Poachers who do not receive a prison sentence are free to return to national parks and poach more rhino. Correspondent, who told us stories from 20 wild places he’s been — from the wilderness of Djibouti to the wild living in Tokyo iRichard Bonham from the Chyulu Hills rhino programme, on the pressures on ecosystems and the challenges involved in wildlife management The highly organised nature of poaching syndicates means that the poacher ‘on the ground’ is doing the dirty work, but somewhere much higher up the chain is a criminal gang, very literally, calling the shots. This makes convicting poaching offences harder, and means that killing a poacher will achieve very little in terms of reducing the number of poaching incidents. Syndicates can easily find another person willing to take the risk and shoot a rhino. And that puts those who protect the rhinos in an unenviable position. iLouis Theroux, (right) on the USA’s love affair with exotic animals, to the extent that the US now has more tigers as pets than there are wild tigers in India iKen Livingstone, (right) who talked iHayden Turner, wildlife television RENAUD FULCONIS presenter, who took us to remote Cameroon where he met the Baka people who sharpen their teeth with a knife and hammer ALL PICS DOMINIC NICOLLS about his passion for wildlife, from applying to be a keeper at London Zoo to hitchhiking across Africa iRichard Terry, cameraman and filmmaker, on the array of injuries he has sustained after he stepped out from behind the camera The auction and raffle had some fantastic prizes, including a Kenyan safari, a restaurant review with Giles Coren, a brick of 500 $25 billion Zimbabwean dollar notes, a Namibian safari and a rhino darting experience in South Africa. The evening raised a massive £46,000 for rhino conservation. 25 India Inspiring India It was an invitation I couldn’t turn down: an email from my dear friend Susie Ellis, Executive Director of the International Rhino Foundation, asking whether I fancied travelling with her to Darjeeling and Kolkata, to help teach a pair of fundraising workshops, followed by a visit to Manas and Orang National Parks and Pobitora Wildlife Sanctuary, to check on the progress of Indian Rhino Vision 2020. Most of my expenses would be paid by a grant she had obtained from USFWS. It took me under a nanosecond to accept. Cathy Dean | Director T he word of the trip was ‘Yikes! Yikes!’ when a passenger on the plane shouted in Hindi that he was going to blow it up. (We could have done without the well-‐meaning translator sitting next to us.) ‘Yikes!’ when we saw the carpet in Delhi International Airport, a vision in orange. ‘Yikes!’ as we careered nearly 7,000 ft up an impossibly twisty road to the gorgeous hill station of Darjeeling. Each group reported back One good night’s sleep later and there we were, budget and others in front of a group of 20 people working for would critique it local conservation NGOs. Susie’s former Development Officer, Maggie Moore, had planned the whole workshop, with sessions covering prospect strategy and research, the basics of donor cultivation, ‘The Perfect A group in Kolkata Proposal’, writingfor work up a practice different donors, budgeting, donor stewardship and proposal reporting. We took it in turns to present, happily ad-‐libbing about good and bad examples we’d each come across. SRI on their draft proposal and After an initial shyness, by the time we’d got the trainees working in small groups on writing a practice proposal and budget, everyone was having a great time. We’d told them not to worry about whether the project was realistic, just to ensure that the proposal followed the right guidelines. I remember with particular fondness a discussion about how to budget for training elephants to catapult themselves across railway lines in a sling, thus avoiding elephant deaths and train derailments. Being creative is great fun. Each group reported back on their draft proposal and budget, and then the others would critique it. Their enthusiasm was utterly infectious: we were all practically cheering when one group came up with truly poetic descriptions of their project site that would have painted a vivid picture for any proposal review committee. On the last day, Kanchenjunga appeared through the mist, illustrating the words of their invented proposal! Each two-‐and-‐a-‐half day course ended with a formal evaluation, and I’m delighted to say that we had great feedback from all participants. Those in Darjeeling, in particular, were so impressed that we had come all the way from Virginia and London to pass on our knowledge. But far from it being one-‐way traffic of knowledge from Save the Rhino and the IRF to West Bengal-‐based NGOs, we also learned new things: about our own skills as trainers, the fundraising climate and grant givers in India, local environmental issues, and of course about the work being done by conservation organisations in the area. There was a plea for help to expand the Indian Rhino Vision 2020 project, which is currently based only in Assam, to cover West Bengal too, and I very much hope there will be some support for this. The thing that makes me happiest in my job is being able to team up with other like-‐minded people, to deliver great conservation activities. There’s no point competing; it’s so much more fun to collaborate. Thanks Susie Ellis of the IRF for the invitation to join her; Bibhab Talukdar and Saurabh Baruah of Aaranyak for arranging all the logistics; and Amit Sharma and Deba Dutta of WWF-India for hosting us in Assam. It was a brilliant trip — thank you. 26 Community spirit Indian Rhino Vision 2020 (IRV2020) has created a forum to involve the local community in conservation activities. Under the banner of IRV2020, WWF India, Manas National Park Authorities and other local organisations have collaborated to undertake many community initiatives, in conjunction with the release of rhino translocated to Manas from other parks in Assam. A dairy unit in Madrijhar village Deba Kumar Dutta | Senior Project Officer, WWF India Amit Sharma | Coordinator of the Rhino Conservation Programme, WWF India M anas National Park is a World Heritage Site situated in Bodoland Territorial Council (BTC), Assam, India. The pristine and fragile landscape of Manas is located on the northern belt of the river Brahmaputra. Local people fondly know Manas as Jwngni Manas Hagrama, Amar Manas, ‘our beloved Manas’, or Jwngni Game, ‘our game reserve’. Colloquially, Jwngni Game Manas has more affinity with the Bodo community, which dominates the villages around the border of the Park. The translocation of rhino has become a great way to facilitate to community involvement in conservation activities. During the period January 2010 to December 2011, interactive programmes were arranged in 23 schools, reaching out to more than 4,200 children from 35 villages, and reaching out to more than 5,000 adults from 48 different villages. Manas Ever Welfare Society (MEWS), based at Bansbari Range, has set up tourist cottages that have been in operation for more than two years, with extensive technical support from WWF. To initiate community-‐based tourism, a local group of about 20 youths were encouraged to train in the local art form, Bihu, which is popular with tourists. These youths have been performing over the last two years and are able to earn a handsome livelihood. A small dairy unit with two cows and two calves was set up in Madrijhar village. With support from the agriculture department and active engagement from members of MEWS, a pilot initiative of alternative cropping has been undertaken in the fringe areas of Manas under the Bansbari range. Through this initiative, 15 families from five villages were encouraged to cultivate ginger. They were provided with 50 kg free seeds per family. The first harvest was made during the early part of 2011 and the average productivity has been 110 kg per family. In 2011, over 50 families were provided with free seeds to compensate for crop damage by a rhino at Bhuyanpara Range. However, the 8km electric fence commissioned in 2009 does largely contain crop depredation, and the local community are happy and supportive. Community awareness has helped maintain the electric fence, with dozens of people volunteering their time to assist. Breakage inflicted by human actions has gone down by almost 50%, and theft of materials has been non-‐existent since community programmes began. There has been a visible decrease in the number of cattle entering the Park for grazing. We have seen a huge change in the attitude of the villagers. Villagers and school authorities extend invitations to us, wanting to know more about rhinos and Manas, and share information they have about rhinos and other wildlife. Sometimes villagers even make a call at midnight with news of rhino that have strayed, and help us to bring the rhino back inside the Park boundary. Villagers frequently visit our field camp located at Bansbari, Gyati village to learn more, and provide us with information on rhinos and other wild animals. We hope that these positive trends will continue, and that Manas will flourish further. Above: Community support for the electric fence Left: Working with schools in the Manas area ALL PICS WWF Thanks We duly acknowledge the Assam Forest Department, WWF, IRF, USFWS and BTC for their initiative and continued support. We also offer our thanks to the Chief Wildlife Warden of Assam, all the members of the Task Force for Translocation of Rhinos within Assam and its sub-groups. A special thanks to all the doctors from College of Veterinary Sciences, Khanapara, WTI, Aaranyak and Assam State Zoo. Thanks to the media, Police Department, Indian Army, SSB, District Administration, local NGOs and the community for their much-needed support. Left: Meeting held with Bamunkhal villagers Above: Student Bicycle rally round the fringe of Manas 27 Indonesia Species in peril Sumatran and Javan rhinos are easily the most threatened large mammals on Earth. A different set of threats places each species in peril. Susie Ellis PhD | Executive Director, International Rhino Foundation In 1995, earnest, concerted efforts began for organised protection of Indonesian and Malaysian rhinos. The IUCN Asian Rhino Specialist Group and the International Rhino Foundation (IRF) facilitated and coordinated this effort, which was funded by the Global Environment Facility through the UN Development Programme, with participation by WWF and other NGOs. The IRF has continued to support Rhino Protection Units in Sumatra’s Way Kambas and Bukit Barisan Selatan National Parks (and in Java’s Ujung Kulon National Park) and the Sumatran rhino breeding centre in Sumatra, managed through Yayasan Badak Indonesia. Save the Rhino, the Asian Rhino Project, and WWF are also key funders of this work. The government of Indonesia has already adopted the Indonesian Rhino Conservation Strategy and Action Plan, and established a Rhino Task Force, but more needs to be done to implement the strategy effectively. We are at a critical point in conserving Sumatran rhinos, which face imminent danger of extinction if urgent recovery measures are not initiated. A small captive Sumatran rhino population of ten animals is maintained by four institutions in Sumatra, Sabah (Malaysia), and the United States. The population of Sumatran rhinos is managed internationally by the Sumatran Propagation and Management Board. How do we engage communities living next to rhino areas to help conserve them? Sumatran rhino conservation is at a critical point, with the danger of extinction looming Last year, the governments of Sabah, Malaysia and Indonesia agreed in principal to share gametes (sperm) between programmes, including the US. The captive breeding programme is at a tipping point. There are only two males producing sperm —Andalas, who was born in the US and was moved to Indonesia in 2007, and his father, Ipuh, at the Cincinnati Zoo. Andalas’ sister, Suci, is one of the three 28 breeding-‐age females in the population; the other two are at the Sumatran Rhino Sanctuary in Way Kambas National Park. One, Ratu, is expecting a calf in June. In Sabah, Tam, a male who wandered out of the forest in 2008 does not appear to be producing sperm. Tanjung, a female living in isolation, was caught and moved to facilities in Tabin Wildlife Sanctuary to join Tam. Ostensibly, she has the potential to breed, but it is too soon to tell. One thing is for sure: true international cooperation will be needed to make the captive programme viable and sustainable, including collection of a few new individuals to genetically augment the population, in addition to exchange of gametes. As The Horn goes to press, Asian rhino conservationists will meet in Indonesia to further strategize about steps, including collaboration, which will be necessary to reverse the decline and secure the future of these small populations. We can expect a spirited debate. The beauty and horror of these discussions is that not everyone sees the problem or the solution the same way. Are the populations really decreasing? Is protection enough? How do we increase usable habitat? What is the role of translocations? How do we engage communities living next to rhino areas to help conserve them? Should more emphasis be placed on captive breeding? One of the ground rules for these discussions will be that people leave their personal, institutional and national agendas at the door to focus on the problem at hand. This is sometimes easier said than done, but it is our hope that these meetings will lead to agreement on the highest priority actions for these critically endangered species, including engaging the full support of the governments of Indonesia and Sabah, Malaysia, who bear ultimate responsibility for their survival. ALL PICS DEDI CANDRA T he Sumatran rhino, numbering no more than 200 individuals, is primarily threatened by human encroachment, which leads to a loss of usable habitat, and poaching, with a decrease in population size of over 50% during the last two decades. Approximately 175 animals live in three populations in Sumatra; and around 20—25 individuals live in fragmented pockets of habitat in Sabah, Malaysia. The species is extinct in Peninsular Malaysia. Final stronghold The Javan rhino, a shy, secretive species, has the dubious distinction of facing the highest probability of extinction of all large mammals on the planet. Occurring only as a single population of perhaps between 27 and 44 animals, its final stronghold is Indonesia’s Ujung Kulon National Park (UKNP) on the western tip of Java, where they face habitat encroachment, and the risk of catastrophic loss posed by natural disasters such as volcanic activity, tsunami and disease. Susie Ellis PhD | Executive Director, International Rhino Foundation A nti-‐poaching patrols in UKNP have had their seventeenth straight year without rhino poaching. These successes were offset by news that the last-‐ known Javan rhino inhabiting Vietnam was killed by poachers in 2010, causing biologists to declare the species extinct on the Asian mainland. Javan rhinos persist in UKNP because they are carefully monitored and guarded by IRF-‐ funded Rhino Protection Units, elite anti-‐poaching teams that patrol every day. Last month, the decomposed carcass of a Javan rhino was discovered. Its horn intact, the animal is believed to have been under 10 years of age. Three dead rhinos also were found in 2009 — two decaying carcasses and one older set of bones — probably not poached as the horns were intact. More likely, they died from natural causes or disease. In the past, there have been disease outbreaks among Javan rhinos caused by diseases spread by domestic livestock grazing in rhino habitat. This remains a major threat; even now, it is common for local people to graze their cattle within UKNP boundaries. IRF Recently discovered Javan rhino skeleton is analysed Recent video-‐camera-‐trap surveys conducted by UKNP staff have identified 37 individual rhinos, with only 4 — 5 reproductive females; previous studies conducted by WWF-‐Indonesia had confirmed at least 19 individuals. Faecal DNA studies are being carried out this year to back up these population estimates and to determine the sex ratio. The death of this fourth rhino in UKNP is devastating and, combined with the loss of the last animal in Vietnam, totals a loss of 11% of the population (if indeed there are 44 animals) in the past three years. If this rate of decline continues, and if reproduction does not significantly improve, the species could be lost by 2030 — in a mere 18 years’ time. The population may have reached carrying capacity in the current habitat and probably cannot grow any larger without intervention. Expanding the habitat available to Javan rhinos, through establishing the Javan Rhino Study and Conservation Area (JRSCA) on the eastern side of UKNP should allow the population to increase and continue reproducing, which in turn would help to expand the species’ population and contribute to preventing its extinction. Habitat modifications (for example, removal of invasive Arenga palm and replanting with rhino food plants) have already taken place in the JRSCA. Two rhinos regularly visit JRSCA’s recently replanted habitat. Uncompleted activities include: iconstructing small bridges and a patrol road, iproviding a water supply and saltlick, iconstructing five new guard posts, iconstructing an electric fence that should significantly reduce, if not stop, the entry of domestic cattle into the Park from surrounding villages. All of these are critical first steps to laying the foundation for the longer-‐term goal of translocating a subset of the UKNP population to a suitable second site (to be determined) elsewhere in Indonesia — which, given the rate of decline, needs to be done as soon as possible. As much as we need comprehensive scientific studies, as well as community engagement, to support conservation, to inform Javan rhino management, we need to decisively act before all the necessary information is in place. Yielding to pressure from a handful of local NGOs opposed to the project, the Indonesian government has put the JRSCA construction on temporary hold. The JRSCA has the support of the IUCN Asian Rhino Specialist Group, a number of international and Indonesian NGOs, including the IRF. We see the JRSCA as the last desperate chance to set the Javan rhino on the path to recovery. We know we won’t have this opportunity again. Thanks Our grateful thanks to Safaripark Beekse Bergen van Dieren rijk and to Blair Drummond Safari Park for their support for Javan rhino conservation efforts. 29 BAKE-‐OFF Try a rhino recipe! Recipes by James Vause. Check out James’s fundraising page for Gold Challenge: www.justgiving.com/jamesthegoldrhino Bakewell Tarts Enough for 24 little Bakewells Shortbread (for the outside of the tarts) 175g self-‐raising flour 175g margarine 100g sugar 100g semolina For the almondy middle bit 110g self-‐raising flour 110g ground almonds 60g almond flakes 170g sugar 1 tablespoon baking powder 120ml vegetable oil 180ml water 1 teaspoon almond extract 1 2 teaspoon vanilla extract You’ll also need lots of jam (about half a jar in total—seedless raspberry works well) and some ready-‐roll icing and glacé cherries if you want to make cherry bakewells like you get in the shops. Step 1 3UHKHDW\RXURYHQWR&5XEWKHVKRUWEUHDG ingredients together with your fingers. Chill and roll out the shortbread mix to about 5mm thick, then divide up with a round cutter, or cut round the top of a big mug. Use the rounds you have made to line your cake cases and put them in the oven to bake for 8 minutes. Step 2 While the cases are in the oven, make the almond -‐y middle by mixing together the dry ingredients (flour, ground almond s, almond flakes, sugar, baking powder) in one bowl and wet ingredients (oil, water, almond extract, vanilla extract) separa tely, and then mix together. Step 3 Get the cases out of the oven after about 8 minute s, before they start going golden brown. Add about a teaspo on of jam and then fill up with almond mix a little way under the top so WKH\GRQWRYHUIORZLQWKHRYHQ5HWXUQWRWKHRYHQRQ &DQG cook until golden brown, about 20—25 minutes. Step 4 Leave to cool, roll out icing, cut into rounds big enough to cover the top of the Bakewell. Add half a glacé cherry. Serve with a nice cup of tea. isin Cookies Easy Oat & Ra nding on the size pe 20 cookies, de Makes about e 115g margarin 85g sugar flour 115g self-‐raising ts 115g oa 115g raisins QDGXOWWRKHOS QWR&DVND YH UR RX W\ HD 3UHK t) you with this bi them ther, and make gredients toge in e est th gg of l su al ix we M like (but shape that you into whatever rhinos!) greased baking ies onto a well-‐ Place your cook em to spread room around th tray with a little as they cook. lden til they look go —20 minutes un 15 t ou ab r fo Bake y. brown and read firm up on the ies to cool and ok co e th e av Le eating. fore storing or baking tray be Why not send us your photos? You can email pictures of your baked goodies to [email protected] and we’ll post them on our blog www.savetherhino.org/latest_news/blog 30 ALL PICS JAMES VAUSE Thank You! Our heartfelt thanks to: rmest We would like to express our wa s, thanks to the following individual bodies for companies and grant-making k over their generous support for our wor achieve the last six months. We could not goodwill, all that we do, without the time, port of and financial and pro-bono sup you all. Companies e, Association for 2:09 Events, Aardman Animations, Appl na Ranch, BP Bora a, Afric to ism Tour of the Promotion repoint Cent Amoco Foundation, Bush and Beyond, , ricity Ecot use, Computer Services, The Colourho Google, , Gifts It Give , acar Give a, Everyclick, Expert Afric , Insiders ation Anim cast Head tion, erva Cons Great Plains er Company, Linton Africa, Joya Collection, Kalahari Pepp on Speaker Bureau, Lond Park Wines, Lion Television, The o Wuas, The Dony Ol sh, ionfi Miss s, Macmillan Publisher om, Alex vel.c letra onsib Resp , pany Com tre Radio Thea Safarilink, ork, Netw vi Rhind Design, Rhino Wine Gear, Roga ver kesil Smo le, Jung r Silve Saffery Champness, SATOA, y, oner Stati r Victo c, TicTo , very Travel, Steppes Disco Wilderness Safaris Namibia Charities, trusts and foundations s and other grant-‐making organisation Individuals s, Will Adams, Nadia Alnaimi and Team Polly Adams, Sue Adams, Shannah Adam e Aspinall, Tim Audin, David Back, Louis Rhino, Clive Anderson, Rachel Ashton, Banks, David Barker, Eve Beadnell, Mir Bahmanyar, Andrew Balfour, Adam aloni, Alex Bertram-‐Smith, Sanjeev Alyson Beaumont, Paul Beavis, Jan Becc , Stephen Blackman, Steph Blakemore Bhaskar, Claire Bilyard, Brian Bishop, Brand, Lisa e, Brac Sue es, Bowl l Haze am, Lucy Boddam-‐Whetham, Richard Bonh ke, Dave Bronze, Margo Buchanan, Gary Brooker, Matthew Brook, Matt Broo egie, Mark Carwardine, Chris Cassell, Suzi Bullough, Daniel Butler, Sophie Carn ng, Bridget Cohen, Lorraine Coley, Giles Margot Chamberlain, Stephanie Cheu Family, Culshaw, Richard Curtis, The Damon Coren, Mark Coreth, Jo Crocker, Jon , Veer De sa Liam Davies, Jo Daykin, Mary Christopher Davies, Kevin Jon Davies, w Farro el Dani i, Fath d Kirsten Douglas, Davi Angus Deayton, Kenneth Donaldson, ael Mich , Fells d Davi Fell, uary, Andy and students from the MTA, Byron Febr hen Fry, Frank Gardner, David Gilmour, Step ira, Ferre ie Foss ns, teve on-‐S Fent man, Nigel Goodman, Roy Grutters, Julie Gnaczynski, Doug and Celia Good r, er, A Haworth, Alex Hearn, Terry Helle Patricia Hall, Vlok Hanekom, John Harm a Emm and as Thom len, Hum l Berte Hingley, Bryan Hemmings, William Hill, Susan ic, Jelic aret Marg Irene late the , ieson Jam Hunt, Arif Hussain, Robin Ince, Diane s, ldine Joaquim, Simon Jones, Terry Jone Richard Jenkin, Nicholas Jelley, Gera n Gavi nas, Lave Tilly sa, el, Florian Kras Melissa Kane, Helen Keen, Grahame Klipp ay, Linds ew Andr h, Leac hen Step Lawson, Lay, Peter Law, Leonie Lawrence, Cath ta Lloyd, Sarah Lloyd, Karma Lochrie, Rena John ne, gsto Livin Ken ott, Linsc Jody Tom s, Magg Maggs, Theo Maggs, Tolly Loj, Matt Long, Anthea Mackenzie, Dirk the McCleery family, Rory McGrath, r, chne Mars r Olive y, Maggs, Darren Male tte Anne Menzies, Robert Menzies, Julie Robbie McIntosh, Jocelyn McNulty, Lee-‐ ella Arab e, Neal Mark an, Nath Paul in, Murr Mills, Leia Mills, Hamish Milne, Susan y Werner Oeder, Guy Ottewell and, Berr Neville-‐Rolfe, Emma-‐Louise Nicholls, a Laur hey, Petc Mike er, Nicola Paulson, Overvelde, Kevin Parker, Michael Park y Hilar , dlove Prou erine Kath el Proetel, Petetti, Colin Pink, Philip Pope, Manu all, Simon Raddall, Alison Rankin, , Ben Puxley and Michael Crane, Lynne Radd s, , J Saffron, Mark Sainsbury, Ben Scale M Rogers, Claire Russon, Richard Ryan n Owe s, Smit k Fran h, n Singh, Martin Smit Duncan Sharp, Susan Sheridan, Simo ey, Stark ph Jose n, vasa Srini ana Bhuv Smith, Debbie Sonenblick, Jeff Spinks, and air Stevens, Carole Symington, Dave Malcolm Stathers, Cam Steele, Alasd Thrift, wyn Bron ard Terry, Louis Theroux, Mona Taliaferro, Geraldine Taylor, Rich es, -‐Jon Todd n Lillia es, -‐Jon , David Todd James Thrift, Jane Thrift, Matthew Todd , dway Trea Jon y, Tove r Olive p, Thor Louisa William Todd-‐Jones, Matt Thomson, wyn, Wald lyn Caro e, Vign ard Rich k, Hayden Turner, Michelle van Schalkwy h, van der Merwe, Martin Waltham-‐Smit Richard Walker, Tom Walker, Tolene ht, Wrig am Grah ndt, Wiela Wickens, Kirstie Debbie White, Lizzie Whitebread, Wix David Worsfold, Mark Worsfold Ashden Trust, Amnéville Zoo, Aspinall Foundation, The e de la Barben, ogiqu Zool Parc Balmain Charitable Trust, en and Dierenrijk, Berg se Beek k ripar Safa , BBC Wildlife Fund for the Wild, Dambari Chester Zoo, Colchester Zoo’s Action tion Fund, erva Wildlife Trust, Disney Worldwide Cons European Zoo, in Dubl t, Trus The Dischma Charitable n Charitable Gibso n Simo ria, Aqua and Association of Zoos al Anim Park, Trust, Howletts and Port Lympne Wild Charitable Trust, JJ International Rhino Foundation, The sley Safari Park, Know t, Trus Ernest Kleinwort Charitable Linbury Trust, The t, Trus ard Leon Mark Zoo Krefeld, The , Fund Mohamed bin The Marjorie Coote Animal Charities Zoo, Save Our Opel , Zayed Species Conservation Fund Taiwan Forestry Zoo, gart Stutt g, Species, savingrhinos.or ands Conservation Wildl ice, Serv ife Wildl and Bureau, US Fish snade ZooStuttgart Trust, The Martin Wills Fund, ZSL Whip Wildlife Service, and Fish US au, Zoo, Taiwan Forestry Bure Zoo on Lond ZSL , Trust ion ervat Cons Wildlands And all those who wish to remain anonymous 31 31 Trustees Henry Chaplin Christina Franco Tim Holmes Tom Kenyon-‐Slaney (Chair) George Stephenson David Stirling Founder Patrons Douglas Adams Michael Werikhe CHESTER ZOO Staff Director: Cathy Dean Deputy Director: Lucy Boddam-‐Whetham/Susie Offord Events Manager: Jo Paulson Office and Communications Manager: Francesca Shapland/Laura Adams Finance and Admin Assistant: Yvonne Walker Michael Hearn Intern: Katherine Ellis NEIL MITCHARD Polly Adams Benedict Allen Clive Anderson Louise Aspinall Nick Baker Simon Barnes Mark Carwardine Chloe Chick Mark Coreth Dina de Angelo Robert Devereux Ben Hoskyns-‐Abrahall Angus Innes Fergal Keane Francesco Nardelli Martina Navratilova Julian Ozanne Viscount Petersham Mark Sainsbury Robin Saunders Alec Seccombe Tira Shubart James Sunley Nick Tims William Todd-‐Jones Jack Whitehall COVER IMAGE TOP: MATT BROOKE COVER IMAGE BOTTOM: RICHARD FLAMAND Patrons The Horn Design and layout: Alex Rhind Design | www.alexrhind.co.uk Original concept: Interstate | www.interstateteam.com Printing: The Colourhouse Limited | www.thecolourhouse.com Thanks to Alan Anderson and Colourhouse, for their loyal and efficient support over the years Founder Directors Johnny Roberts David Stirling Save the Rhino International Connecting conservation and communities 16 Winchester Walk, London SE1 9AQ T: +44 (0)20 7357 7474 F: +44 (0)20 7357 9666 E: [email protected] W: www.savetherhino.org Save the Rhino International, Inc c/o Chapel & York Limited, 1000 N. West Street, Suite 1200, Wilmington, DE 19801 http://savetherhino-‐inc.webs.com Save the Rhino International, Inc is a 501 (c) (3) non-‐profit organisation. Donations to it are tax-‐deductible to the extent allowed by law. EIN 31-‐1758236. Made from 60% recycled paper Registered Charity No. 1035072
© Copyright 2024 Paperzz