AGRIFRANCE RURAL REPORT IN 2016 Oak barrel staves – a market success story PREFACE 01 Panorama RURAL LAND IN 2015 P.2 02 Focus Oak barrel staves – a market success story P.22 For more than 15 years now, Agrifrance and BNP Paribas Wealth Management have been producing an annual report providing an overview of the French rural land sector and the year’s key market trends. While the grain and timber sectors are still hampered by a difficult economic environment, the wine trade is in good shape following the excellent 2015 harvest. From an investment standpoint, rural land offers an appealing diversification opportunity that continues to attract buyers. The average prices we have observed are currently lower than those of our European neighbours, and the overall profitability of capital invested in rural land remains attractive. Our Focus article bridges the worlds of forestry and wine to explore a French success story whose quality and knowhow have made it a global leader. This is an in-depth look at barrel making, a high value added sector enjoying rapid international growth, which is dominated by France. We would also like to take this opportunity to thank our clients as well as the investment professionals who have placed their trust in us, and we hope that you will find this report interesting and informative. Happy reading! B. Léchenault, Head of Agrifrance. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 1 2 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 01 Panorama RURAL LAND IN 2015 Farmland p. 4 Vineyards p. 10 FORESTS p. 16 BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 3 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 Farmland 4 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 2015 harvest A good year for winter crops, but a struggle for revenue WHEAT I a record year. The global harvest (733 million tonnes) was excellent, and the various grain-producing countries are facing strong competition in a weak demand environment. In France, the planted area of almost 5.2 million hectares was the highest level since 1936. With a large harvest in the region of 40.5 million tonnes, prices struggled. Yields were also high in 2015, at a record national average of 79.4 q/ha, compared with a five-year average of 72.6 q/ha. Overall quality was good. In February 2016, prices fell to €137/tonne, from €186/tonne a year earlier (-26.3%). However, euro depreciation improved the competitiveness of French wheat over Russian wheat. Soft wheat prices (€/tonne) Source: La France Agricole 200 180 160 140 120 100 May 14 Sept 14 Jan 15 May 15 Sept 15 Jan 16 BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 5 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 CORN I small harvests in Europe. While the forecasts for US harvests were revised up, estimates in Europe were slashed, and harvests were smaller than expected. In France, production fell by 5 million tonnes to 13.1 million tonnes. This was attributable to drought and a significant contraction in the planted area (11%). The average yield slumped by 20 q/ha, to 85 q/ha. Prices have been falling since July 2015, stabilising at €146/tonne in February 2016, compared with €144/tonne in February 2015. Corn prices (€/tonne) Source: La France Agricole 200 180 160 140 120 100 May 14 Sept 14 Rapeseed I harvest slightly down; prices relatively stable. After reaching 1.6 million hectares in 2012, the planted area of rapeseed was some way below the ten-year average in 2015, shrinking by 20,000 hectares to 1.48 million hectares. The average yield was 36.4 q/ha, in the mid-high range for recent years. Global stocks remain high, while prices are falling following a large harvest, in line with the soybean trend. Since September 2014, prices have returned to higher levels. After rising to €400/ tonne at the start of the summer, prices fell back to €356/tonne in February 2016. These prices are almost identical to February 2015. Rapeseed prices (€/tonne) Source: La France Agricole 450 425 400 375 350 325 300 275 May 14 Sept 14 Jan 15 6 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 May 15 Sept 15 Jan 16 Jan 15 May 15 Sept 15 Jan 16 Common Agricultural Policy 1 out of 2 FRENCH CITIZENS AGREEs THAT FINANCIAL SUPPORT FOR FARMERS SHOULD INCREASE. 2015 weather conditions An almost record year Temperature °C OF FRENCH CITIZENS BELIEVE THAT THE EUROPEAN UNION AGRICULTURE AND RURAL AREAS ARE IMPORTANT FOR THE FUTURE. Min. 30 24.9 20 12.7 10 8 0 8 2.4 1.1 Jan Feb 4.3 Mar Precipitation mm 18.1 6.9 Apr 19.4 9.5 May Precipitation 12.8 39.1 51.6 57.9 39.4 26.8 15.2 15.1 Jun Jul Aug Normal 51.4 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr Sunlight hours May 82 28.9 14 Jun Jul Sunlight 222.3 200 100 62.2 101.1 20.1 16 14.8 10.4 8.2 8.2 Sep Oct Nov 87.6 Sep 5.9 Dec Annual precipitation 567.5 mm (normal: 695.6 mm) 41.3 Aug 12.4 Oct 51.9 21.8 Nov Dec 87.4 92.3 Nov Dec Normal 310.6 300 Average temperatures Max.: 17.4 °C (normal: 16.1 °C) Min.: 8.3 °C (normal: 7.5 °C) Avg.: 12.9 °C (normal: 11.8 °C) Normal 27.5 80 40 92% Max. 226.2 256.4 209.8 128 199.2 122.4 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Source: Météo France Although heat records are no longer unusual, the consistently warm weather in 2015 made it one of the hottest years in recent decades. 9 OUT OF 10 FRENCH CITIZENS ARE IN FAVOUR OF A CUT IN SUBSIDIES IF FARMERS DO NOT COMPLY WITH THE RULES ON ANIMAL WELFARE, THE ENVIRONMENT AND FOOD SAFETY. 88% OF FRENCH CITIZENS SAID THEY AGREE WITH THE “GREENING” ASPECTS OF THE CAP. Source: Eurobaromètre CEE In terms of temperature, precipitation and sunlight levels compared with the averages over the last three decades, 2015 looks to have been a record shattering year. With relatively high temperatures in spring and summer and an exceptionally mild end to the year, 2015 almost hit the highs of the 2011 heatwave. In April 2015, the temperature at the Tours weather station was measured at 28.3°C, compared with 29.2°C in April 2005. In July, one record fell, with 37.5°C being reached, although August’s temperatures were significantly below those of the 2003 heatwave. The most surprising months were November and December. In November, temperatures peaked at 22.3°C (an absolute record) and did not fall below 14.9°C, whereas the average lows for the month usually hover around 5.9°C. The annual level of precipitation was some 10% lower than normal, and June and July were very dry months. However, August and September saw a number of storms, and there were some noteworthy examples of sporadic heavy rainfall (e.g. 38 mm fell in four hours in Tours on 13 September). More than records, the persistence of these weather phenomena is particularly striking. Twenty or thirty years ago, the country was swept by westerly winds, whereas northerly and southerly winds are now preventing atmospheric disturbances. This consistency has provided excellent conditions for the harvest of grapes and other crops. Source: Météo France and la Nouvelle République BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 7 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 Agricultural land market Land prices continue to rise, even though profits from farming are falling. €353,000 Average farm price 8 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 According to a report by the Chambers of Agriculture, average farm costs are €353,000, but yield profit of less than 1%. Against a general backdrop of falling prices and farming income, land values continue to rise in line with the sector consolidation trend. Between 1955 and 2010, there has been a fourfold reduction in the overall number of farms. Farming statistics put the total number of farms at 300,000 in 2025, compared with 515,000 today. Given this trend, the need to finance land and farming capital is becoming vital, and those working in the sector are exploring new sources of financing: crowdfunding, land investment by external investors, etc. But for the first time, the pace of growth in farmland prices slowed in 2015. In France, the average price per hectare of farmland was €5,835 compared with €5,675 in 2014. Year-on-year, the average price rose by just 2.8% in 2015, versus 6.2% in 2014. This slowdown should be seen in the context of falling farm income and product prices. The best grain-growing areas dominate the top end, with prices at more than €15,000 – or even €20,000 – per hectare. Notable among these are the Nord Pas de Calais region, the Santerre, Champagne Crayeuse and Saint Quentinois areas, and certain areas in the south of France, such as La Crau, or the Durance Valley. Land prices in the cheapest areas are between €2,500 and €3,000 per hectare, for example, in Mayenne, in the Jura region or the Morvan. FREEHOLD FARMLAND FRANCE AVERAGE € 5,835 PER HECTARE (+2.8%) 2015/2014 (+5.3%) over 10 years €7,500 Freehold land €6,500 France average €5,500 Freehold grassland €4,500 €3,500 €2,500 Source: Valeurs vénales Price per hectare The average price for leased farmland went up by 6% year-on-year in 2015 to €4,795 per hectare, a much greater percentage increase than for freehold farmland. This increase was particularly marked for grain-growing areas, at 8.1% versus 2.8% for grassland. LEASED FARMLAND AVERAGE GROSS RENTAL YIELD ON LEASED LAND: +3.5% LEASEHOLD LAND €1,500 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Farmland prices in France 2006-2015 2015/2014 France leased average 2015 2014 €4,795 €4,525 +6.0% Arable land (avg.) 2015 €5,870 €5,430 2014 The price of arable land continues to outstrip pasture land. AVERAGE LAND €7,020 PRICE PER HECTARE (+5.8%) over 10 years +8.1% Grassland (avg.) 2015 2014 €3,720 €3,620 +2.8% POLYCULTURE/PASTURE LAND €4,650 PRICE PER HECTARE (+4.7%) over 10 years The hierarchy of prices between the different types of farming remains unchanged: the average price per hectare of arable land is €7,020 (+2.5%), versus €4,650 per hectare (+3.3%) for polyculture/pasture land, i.e. a difference of around 20% compared with the national average. In terms of profitability, the gross rental yield on leased land stands at an average of 3.5% per year, while the average rent is €166 per hectare. Depending on region and land type, the average gross rental yield varies between 3.9% for grassland and 3.2% for grain-growing land. These yields are a very positive sign, and in the current economic environment, we are seeing an increase in the number of non-farming investors. As such, investment in farmland remains particularly attractive as a means of diversifying or transferring assets. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 9 Source: Valeurs vénales Meanwhile, over the last ten years the supply of farmland has increased by 5.3% per year. Moreover, farmland remains much cheaper in France than in other European countries. 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 Vineyards 10 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 WINE 2015 was a very good year. With a harvest equating to 47.9 million hectolitres, France was edged into second place by Italy in 2015. Nonetheless, production rose by 2% on the previous year, and by 5% compared with the average for 2010-2014. Industry professionals are expecting a very high quality vintage for 2015 thanks to favourable temperatures, plenty of sunshine and excellent harvest conditions. 15 5 2 5 5 7 2 0 0 -5 -10 -7 1 4 -2 -5 -1 -6 2015/2014 -15 9 7 2015/2010-2014 average -14 -20 FRANCE Champagne Burgundy Alsace Loire Valley Bordeaux region Languedoc Source: Agreste 10 South-East Wine production in France and its main regions (in %) 47.9 Looking at exports, wines and spirits had a record year in 2015, with sales up 8.7% at €11.7 billion. With a positive trade balance of €10.4 billion, wines and spirits are France’s second most valuable export, after aeronautics (€22.2 billion), and are ahead of perfumes and cosmetics (€9.2 billion). million HECTOLITRES 2015 HARVEST IN FRANCE 15 Source: FEVS 10 5 0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TRADE BALANCE x2 BETWEEN 2004 AND 2015 2015 Trade balance 2004-2015 (€ billion) It is worth noting, that for the third consecutive year and due to small harvests, there was a 3.6% reduction in the volume of wine exported in 2015. Sales of French wines and spirits to the USA – the main purchasing country, accounting for 22.2% of exports – went up by 28% to €2.6 billion. In terms of export sales, the USA is followed by the UK (11.8%), Germany (7.3%), China (7.1%) and Singapore (6.8%). In this flourishing market, some industry professionals are arguing for an increase in vineyard areas in order to boost volumes and capture market share, especially of entry-level wines. Planting of 8,000 hectares of vines is planned, including for what used to be known as «table wine» (vin sans indication géographique or VSIG). 2 bottles out of 5 are not produced in the country where they are drunk. In recent years, the markets have become increasingly global. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 11 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 In the Centre-Val de Loire region Significant rainfall in September meant the harvest took place earlier than usual. Compared to the previous year, 2015 saw an abundant harvest. Nonetheless, the summer drought had a noticeable impact on crops in the Cher département. Sales of Sancerre and Pouilly-Fumé rose, driven by exports to the USA. For Cabernet d’Anjou and Crémant de Loire, sales held up well, although the Anjou and Saumur appellations make little impact on the export market. In the Bordeaux region Rain at the end of August benefited the vineyards. The harvest, which took place under good conditions, was completed at the end of October. Quantities only just matched those of 2014, as the rain came too late for the white wine grapes. In the rest of south-west France, the harvest was a week earlier than in previous years. Despite greater pressure on vine health at the end of the cycle in some départements, potential production should exceed the 2014 level. The recovery in the Chinese market boosted sales after two years of decline. This market is becoming more sophisticated and is now turning its attention towards mid-range wines. Between September 2014 and September 2015, exports to China rose to 432,000 hectolitres, an increase of 14% year-on-year. 12 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 In Languedoc-Roussillon The harvests took place under healthy vineyard conditions, thanks to a return to drier weather from mid-September onwards. Rain from mid-August enabled the veraison (change of color of the grape berries) period to continue after the summer heatwave. Production was expected to outstrip 2014 levels. In Corsica, the harvests took place in favourable weather conditions. The last heavy rainfall of October came after all the grapes had been harvested. Sales rose by 23% between 2012 and 2014, and profitability is improving. However, the rise in bulk prices has yet to fully offset the small harvests. in Champagne The vineyards appear very healthy, with no rot observed. The harvest took place early in 2015, with the grapes being picked in September. Production fell by 7% year-on-year in 2015, due to the summer drought, and was down by 5% compared with the average for 2010-2014. On the sales side, the global appetite for champagne shows no sign of receding, and France remains the world’s leading producer of sparkling wines, ahead of Italy and Spain. Global consumption (15.4 million hectolitres) has shot up by 30% in the last ten years. Champagne sales hit a record high in 2015, at €4.75 billion, representing more than 310 million bottles sold. Sales in France recovered in 2015, after a slowdown lasting several years, with 162 million bottles sold. As for exports, the USA became the second biggest foreign market (19 million bottles) after the UK. In Burgundy and the Beaujolais region The harvests, particularly of red wine grapes, were affected by the drought and heatwave during the summer, although it was possible to maintain the grapes in a perfectly healthy condition until the harvest. In Beaujolais, production plummeted. The only exception in this region was the Yonne département, the most westerly area, where production outstripped that of the previous year. The region’s production fell by 14% compared with 2014, and by 6% versus the average for 2010-2014. In the last three vintages, the region has lost 35% compared with a normal harvest. The drop in production has led to a sharp rise in prices. For example, pinot noir prices in supermarkets have gone up by 10% in a year. Fortunately, however, stocks increased by 13% between 2014 and 2015. They had reached a critical level with just eight months’ of stock left. Exports went up 5% over the first nine months of 2015, with sales totalling €549.4 million. Four markets illustrate this momentum well – Canada, Japan, Hong Kong and the USA – which thanks to a favourable euro/ dollar exchange rate, represented an increase of 15% on 2014, at €135.3 million. In Provence and Côtes-du-Rhône The harvests, which had begun early, were stepped up in the Mediterranean départements because of heavy rain. Some production was lost to an outbreak of black rot (a fungal disease) in the Vaucluse. Production was down by 1% on 2014, which had been an exceptional year for quantity, but remained 9% ahead of the fiveyear average. The Côtes-du-Rhône market is healthy, while the market for Provence wines is very healthy. At €139/hl, the price of red Côtes-du-Rhône has gone up by 29% compared with 2010. In Provence, the average price for rosé has jumped by 50% since 2010, and has settled around €210/hl. Provence rosés have become extremely popular with US buyers. The USA has become the biggest overseas market, accounting for the export of 22 million litres between January and September 2015 (+32% versus the same period in 2014). At this level, wine merchants are struggling to keep up with demand. Evin law relaxed after pressure from the wine trade Wine tourism has become a key element of the strategy for promoting France as a destination on international markets. Last year, French MPs approved an amendment to article 13 of the Evin law on alcohol advertising. The new text makes it possible to promote a wine-producing region and its cultural, gastronomic and countryside heritage, without this being considered as advertising that contravenes the law. The Prime Minister, the Minister of the Economy and the President have all supported the amendment to the Evin law in the hope that it will boost employment in wine tourism. An estimated 10-12 million people already visit French winemakers every year. This initiative is intended as a response to competition from the wine tourism sectors of Italy, Spain, South Africa and California. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 13 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 PRICE FOR 1 HECTARE OF VINEYARD LAND: FROM LESS THAN 15,000 € TO MORE THAN 15,000,000 € WINE-GROWING LAND Prices generally on the increase. In 2015, the average price of vineyard land in France was around €140,000/ha. Prices have generally recovered over the last 10 years, and are rising by 6% per year. It is worth noting, however, that prices differ hugely from one appellation to another. While the terroir, surface area, plantation type and general condition are key aspects in the valuation of vineyards, prices are also closely linked to the health of the wine market, especially in terms of exports. At the top end, there is limited supply for structural reasons, and prices are rising strongly. At the mid and low ends, the market has improved following a period of restructuring (grubbing-up schemes and reforms of planting rights). 14 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 In the Bordeaux region, wine-growing land costs €23,570/ha, compared with €39,310/ha ten years ago. In Saint Émilion, prices have risen by 11%, and range between €230,000/ha and €1,290,000/ha. Prices in Saint Estèphe vary from between €374,000/ha and €663,000/ha. The most prestigious appellations, meanwhile, fetch far higher prices: Margaux and Saint Julien are generally above the €1,000,000 mark, at between €1,100,000 and €1,382,000 per hectare. Pauillac holds the record for the highest average price, at between €2,100,000 and €2,679,000. Although the average for Pomerol is around €1,000,000, it holds the record for the highest price in the Bordeaux region, with €2,900,000/ha. Champagne still leads the market, although prices plateaued in 2014 and fell by 2% in 2015, to €1,200,000/ha. Over the last ten years, the price of vineyards has nonetheless increased by 4% per year. Source: Valeurs Vénales 2015 Loire valley Anjou: €18,000/ha Saumur Champigny: €64,500/ha Bordeaux region Bordeaux Rouge: €23,570/ha St Emilion: €1,290,000/ha St Estèphe: €663,000/ha Pauillac: €2,670,000/ha Margaux - Saint Julien: €1,382,000/ha Pomerol: €2,900,000/ha Champagne Champagne: €1,200,000/ha Burgundy Grands Crus: > €15,000,000/ha Premiers Crus: €1,500,000-2,500,000/ha Villages: €600,000-€1,000,000/ha Beaujolais Beaujolais: < €13,000/ha Beaujolais Crus: €50,000-€100,000/ha Côtes du Rhône Hermitage: €1,230,000/ha Côte-Rôtie: €1,176,000/ha Châteauneuf du Pape: €422,000/ha Gigondas: €175,000/ha Vacqueyras: €119,000/ha Côtes du Rhône Villages: €32,000/ha Côtes du Rhône: €28,000/ha Provence Côte de Provence: €60,000/ha Bandol/Cassis: €150,000/ha Maximum prices in 2015 for vineyard land (in €/ha) In Burgundy, prices remain very high at the top end. For a Côte de Beaune or Nuits village appellation, prices start at €600,000/ha and rise to around €1,000,000/ha. For premier cru names, prices range from between €1,500,000/ha to €2,500,000/ha. For a terroir with grand cru status, the price can top €15,000,000/ha, which is a world record. In the Beaujolais region, prices are still low at entry level, at less than €13,000/ha. On the other hand, Beaujolais cru prices are in the €50,000100,000 range per hectare, and rose by 1% in 2015. In a very tight market in the northern Côtes du Rhône, prices for Côte-Rôtie or Hermitage often exceed €1,000,000. In 2015, average prices rose by 5% for the Hermitage appellation, to €1,230,000/ha, while for Côte-Rôtie, prices edged up just 1% versus 2014, to €1,176,000/ha. In the southern Côtes du Rhône, prices for the Côte du Rhône AOP rose by 6% to €18,000-28,000/ha, while Côte du Rhône Village fetches €32,000/ha. Châteauneuf du Pape, which saw prices rise by 2%, is still the region’s most expensive appellation, at €422,000/ha. For Gigondas, prices went up by 6% to €175,000/ha. Vacqueyras prices increased by 7.5% to €119,000/ha. In the Loire Valley, demand is mainly local. External investors have not shown much interest in this region, although it offers a number of advantages. There is little variation in the market in the Loire Valley. Prices range between €18,000/ha for Anjou and €64,500/ha for Saumur-Champigny. In Provence, the vineyard market is very active, mostly in relation to rosé wines. Bandol and Cassis prices are steady at around €150,000/ha. Prices for Coteaux d’Aix have stabilised at €45,000/ha, while for Côte de Provence, the price is around €60,000/ha. In coastal areas, prices are falling, with the maximum standing at €115,000/ha. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 15 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 FORESTS 16 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 Timber market on a positive trend since 2008 The catch-up effect observed since 2008 has continued. Medium-term prices have risen. In 2015, price levels were generally favourable, and forestry operators brought significant volumes of timber to the market. The downturn recorded in softwoods in the first half of 2015 had no impact on the volume of timber offered for sale. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 17 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 Hardwoods I good results for oak and beech. The year began with some question marks regarding oak. The main concern was about secondary quality wood, which had previously been taken up by the Asian market. However, the sales results swept away any fears: almost all oak lots (94% of volumes) found a buyer. Moreover, at the top end of the market, oak lots fetched €301/m3. For lower quality wood (sleepers), prices were generally less spectacular, coming in below €100/m3. A pleasant surprise came from beech, which continued its recovery. Large diameter trees (5 m3) sold for €86/m3, a price not seen for a number of years. After the outbreak of ash dieback, a fungal disease, volumes are increasing again (22,000 m3 in 2015, up from 16,000 m3 in 2014). Results for the year were mixed: three-quarters of the wood found buyers, but the average price fell from €93/m3 in 2014 to €70/m3 in 2015. Demand for poplar wood fell compared with 2014. The volumes brought to the market fell from 44,000 m3 to 32,000 m3, but prices remained broadly flat at €32.99/m3. Oak 140 2015 2ND HALF 94% 92% 89% 2014 2ND HALF 2013 2ND HALF Oak 100 Beech 2014 2ND HALF Beech Poplar 20 2013 2ND HALF Poplar 2015 2ND HALF 2014 2ND HALF 2013 2ND HALF 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Hardwood prices (in €/m3) 2009 Source: CDC, Asffor Experts forestiers and Agrifrance 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 49% 47% 56% Ash 2015 2ND HALF 2014 2ND HALF 74% 67% 2013 2ND HALF 94% Breakdown of wood volumes sold at auction as a proportion of the total 18 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 Source: Experts forestiers de France 60 90% 84% 83% 2015 2ND HALF Ash Cop21 Forest operators are closely monitoring the debate on carbon pricing. CO2 capture largely depends on the natural mechanism of photosynthesis. Trees capture CO2 from the atmosphere when they are growing. Their carbon stock increases with the age of the tree. An estimated 20% of CO2 emissions is currently offset by forests, which are the main contributor to the mitigation of climate change. Softwoods I prices are falling The market has been broadly flat, despite the downturn in the construction sector. Prices for Douglas fir timber varies depending on the wholesaler. The price of wood of less than 1 m3 went up, while the larger Douglas fir categories did less well, mainly due to the lack of appropriate sawing equipment for this type of product. At the top end, prices approached €80-100/m3, although most sales were concentrated at around the €50/m3 mark. The price of 50 cm spruce timber went down by 9-10%, although prices for the smaller categories were maintained. There was little change in the volume of white pine sold, and prices remained stable at around €40-45/m3, depending on the category. The average price of maritime pine fell below €35 m3. Douglas fir 60 2015 2ND HALF Douglas fir 2014 2ND HALF 77% 78% 95% 2013 2ND HALF 50 Maritime pine 40 73% 94% 89% 2014 2ND HALF 2013 2ND HALF Spruce Maritime pine 87% 82% 96% 2015 2ND HALF 30 2014 2ND HALF 2013 2ND HALF 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Softwood prices (in €/m3) 2009 Source: CDC, Asffor Experts forestiers and Agrifrance 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Pine 2015 2ND HALF 2014 2ND HALF 2013 2ND HALF 71% 82% 92% Source: Experts forestiers de France 2015 2ND HALF Spruce pine Breakdown of wood volumes sold at auction as a proportion of the total BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 19 01 RURAL LAND IN 2015 Forest land In a low interest rate environment, and thanks to its diversification and safe haven properties, forest land is still in demand, although prices are high, or even overvalued in terms of technical value in some cases. 20 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 112,700 101,600 Overall, the amount of forest land sold has increased over the last five years, including in the segment of forests covering an area greater than 100 hectares. 113 ,100 106,500 Total More than 100 ha Source: SAFER The amount of forest land for sale is on the increase 108,100 33,400 28,300 2010 2011 31,200 2012 29,300 26,300 2013 2014 Forest land sold (in hectares) Prices vary according to segment We note an increasing trend for the highestquality and largest forests to attract a premium. Whereas the average price for forest land has settled at around €4,000/ha, prices in the 100 hectare-plus segment saw faster growth between 2013 and 2014. Since 1998, French forest land has increased in value by an average of 4-5% per year, while the CAC 40 – despite rising strongly in 2000-2008 – has gone up by only 3% per year over the same period. €12,000 Maximum price €10,000 Price for forests of more than 100ha €8,000 €6,000 Average price €4,000 Source: SAFER Prices vary considerably, from €650/ha to more than €11,500/ha, which reflects marked differences in the type of property sold. The price of forest land depends on wood quality, surface area, location and ease of access to plots. The most expensive forests are in the Paris Basin (€10,000/ha upwards), western France (€5,000/ha) and eastern France (€4,500/ha). The cheapest forests are in the south of France. €14,000 €2,000 0 2009 2011 2013 2014 Forest land prices (average price per hectare) 250 Avg. price/ forest land 200 Max. price/ forest land 150 CAC 40 100 50 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 2014 Average and maximum forest land price versus CAC 40 (base 100 - 1997) BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 21 Source: SAFER/INSEE The market for forests covering more than 100 hectares represented 120 transactions in 2014, with 29,300 hectares sold, equivalent to around 26% of total sales, and less than 1% of total forest land. 02 Focus OAK BARREL STAVES – A MARKET SUCCESS STORY 22 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 A s the beneficiaries of more than 2,000 years of tradition, barrel makers have always played a major role in trade and economic development. Wine, like many manufactured products, needs special packaging to be transported effectively. Mesopotamian goatskins, then earthenware jars and Gallo-Roman amphorae have made way for the barrel, which was invented by the Gauls. A less fragile vessel that could be rolled, making it easier to transport, the barrel has gradually become the standard container used by the wine trade. Since the mid-20th century, barrels have been used in the production of fine wines, and are now a tool of the trade, rather than just a container. The world’s top winemakers now use barrels to imbue their wines with the tannins necessary to produce the very best vintages. This year, we have decided to bridge the worlds of wine and forestry with an in-depth look at oak barrel staves – a market success story. Without significant quantities of the highest quality wood, there would be no such story. This is why we have decided to focus the first section on the forestry sector. As is the case for wine, French forests benefit from conditions that are highly favourable to the production of wood for staves, thanks to “oak crus” and “forest terroirs” that produce top-quality timber. In the second section, we look at the barrel making process. This ancient skill, developed over centuries, is now becoming a more technical, value-added activity, thanks to new technologies and innovation. Lastly, we complete our analysis with a detailed presentation of the French forestry sector, which ranks first worldwide. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 23 02 Oak barrel staves – a market success story 6 million hectareS France produces more oak than any other european country and ranks second worldwide, behind the United States. 24 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 French forestry is a world leader Picardy Forêt de Compiègne Parisian Basin Forêt de Fontainebleau Pays de la Loire Forêt des Jupilles Auvergne Forêt de Tronçais Alsace Lorraine Forests of the Vosges, Darnay and Haguenau Centre Forests of Blois, Loches and Chateauroux OAK FRENCH FORESTRY 16 million Source: Agrifrance hectares INCLUDING 10 million hectares OF HARDWOODS Main sources of stave oak in France Major production areas Of the 250 species of oak existing anywhere in the world today, just two account for most of the wood used for staves. These are pedunculate oak (quercus robur) and sessile oak (quercus petraea). These two species are very well represented in French forests, occupying 15-20% of forested land. French forestry is the uncontested leader in this very high-end segment of the market, producing more oak than any other European country, and ranking second worldwide, behind the USA. While the USA has vast quantities of oak, it is generally white oak (quercus alba), a low-tannin species, that tends to add less subtle flavours to the wine. As is the case with wine, the “forest terroir” used to produce wood for staves shows that some forested areas are particularly suitable for the production of high-quality wood, such as the most famous forest, the Forêt de Tronçais in the Allier department. STAVE WOOD <10% OF OAK HARVESTED IN FRANCE (around 250,000 m3 per year) 30% OF TOTAL OAK SALES BY VALUE BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 25 02 Oak barrel staves – a market success story Highly favourable soil and climate for the best “oak crus” Average temp Rainfall Sunlight in °C in mm/yr in hrs/yr Oak requirements Species Pedunculate oak 10 to 15 700 to 1,200 1,800 Station climate resources Average climate data Bourges (Berry) 10.9 705 1,770 Example: pedunculate oak. Comparison between the climatic requirements and average climate data for the Centre region 26 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 Sources : Guide des forêts de France de G. Plaisance & Météo France. The key characteristics of these forested areas are their soil and climate. The bioclimatic needs of oak trees depend on their water supply, and temperature, light and wind requirements. Soil is also important for the supply of nutrients. An analysis of technical production data shows that France is particularly suitable for growing oak trees. Located between the Equator and the North Pole, at a latitude of between 43° and 51° north, France has a temperate climate, and therefore does not suffer tropical heat or polar frosts. A long tradition of timber management and production It was Colbert who initially identified certain French regions for the production of high-quality oak timber in an ordinance of 1669. At that time, the French Navy needed long lengths of timber for naval construction, especially to make masts for ships. Highly prized by barrel makers in today’s market, the oak produced in these regions is mainly intended for sawing, rotary cutting, slicing and other “noble” uses of timber (see map page 25 showing the main sources of stave oak in France). Lumber 7m Carpentry 2.3 m Barrels, furniture and slicing Base index: March 07 140 120 100 80 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Oak with min. diameter of 50 measured 1.3 m from the ground 3.8 m Source: “Les terrains boisés, leur mise en valeur”, Institut pour le Développement Forestier Wood for grinding or burning With 80% of the supply, the French National Forests Office (ONF) is the largest producer of stave wood. To ensure the regular and homogenous quality of their products, barrel makers also buy wood from forests in neighbouring countries, such as Switzerland (Neuchâtel), Germany (Palatinat), Luxembourg (Ettelbruck), or certain forests in Hungary or Romania, albeit to a very limited extent. Since 2013, demand has been strong, and oak prices have climbed by 30%. The price of split oak can exceed €2,000/m3, while the roadside price is close to €550/m3 or more, depending on the quality and grain required. Average unit price for standing timber sold by the ONF Source: French National Forests Office BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 27 02 Oak barrel staves – a market success story Know-how developed over centuries is becoming increasingly technical The main stages of making a stave, and then a barrel 1 Log oak trunks with branches removed, with/without bark 2 Batten log cut into lengths of 100 to 110 cm 3 Quarters the batten is cut by splitting 4 Doublon each quarter is a doublon split into 2 raw staves 5 Dry staves after drying for 9 to 36 months, 2 raw staves become 2 dry staves Production of staves: from the log to the stave Only 20% of logs will become barrels. from 5 m3 of logs, 1 m3 of stave wood can be obtained which, after processing, will produce 10 or 11 225-litre barrels. It takes an average of 2,000 hammer blows to make 1 barrel. 28 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 Drying Felled wood has a humidity level of 60-80%, which must be reduced to 20% by drying for between nine months and three years, so that it is stable enough to work on. To ensure sufficient rotation and drying time, stave producers need to have substantial wood stocks, which explains why they have a very high working capital requirement. Kept in piles, the wood will lose water and volume until it becomes solid and resistant, while maintaining its flexibility. This drying process also enables the humidity to be reduced gradually, and eliminates the harshest and most astringent tannins more effectively, ensuring better quality. Exposure to rainwater and air also helps essential flavour precursors to develop before “toasting”. Why did oak become the wood of choice for barrel making? Its high resistance to rot and microbial attacks has contributed over time to making oak the wood of choice for wine barrels. Oak offers excellent: 1/ mechanical qualities, such as strength, solidity, thermal isolation 1 Preparation for assembly 20 to 32 staves are assembled together 2 and impermeableness, while enabling an efficient exchange between the content and oxygen (microporosity). 2/ chemical characteristics, bringing interesting flavours (e.g. vanilla, whisky-lactones, eugenol) and extractable phenolic compounds (e.g. tannins, lignins, phenolic acids). Assembly “mise en rose”, the staves are placed in a circle to form a “rose”. 3 HEATING key moment of the process with final curve of the staves and release of the aromatic qualities from the oak Nonetheless, barrels have some disadvantages. They have a limited life and if not completely airtight, evaporation can occur, requiring the barrel to be refilled to the top to minimise the «headspace» of air between the wine and the top of the barrel, known as ullage. 4 Finishing mounting the base, planing, signing, etc. Production of barrels First stage of the assembly A barrel is made up of around 20 to 32 staves (curved wood sections) held together by iron hoops. This first stage of the assembly is called the “mise en rose” in French (the craftsman places the staves in a circle with a truss ring surrounding them to form a “rose”). The barrel is then moistened and heated in a process known as “bousinage” or toasting. Toasting Final assembly This stage is a key moment in the process of giving wine its aromatic qualities, and comprises two steps: bending and heating. Depending on the region, fire, steam or boiling water may be used in the bending process (in which the barrel is shaped), and when the barrel is heated, the final curve of the staves is fixed, and aromatic molecules are released from the oak. Expert barrel makers tailor this stage to the specific requirements of each customer. The barrel maker then finishes the assembly of his barrel, sands and planes the outside surfaces, and takes off the assembly hoops and replaces them with the final hoops. The barrel will then be tested to check that it is watertight and has no defects, before being delivered to the customer. It is now ready to receive the wine, which will become enriched with tannins and undergo a very slow process of oxygenation. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 29 02 Oak barrel staves – a market success story FRANCE No. 1 PLAYER IN THE BARREL MARKET. OAK BARRELS ARE USED IN AROUND 2% OF GLOBAL WINE PRODUCTION. 30 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 A key French industry dedicated to fine wines With 75% of global production of barrels in 2014, France is the number one player in this market. France is the leading producer of wooden packaging in Europe and has a barrel industry with a history of excellence. Oak for barrels in figures Standing price €150-400/m3 Roadside price €350-550/m3 Barrel making in France Annual production: 550,000 barrels, i.e. 75% of global production Trade surplus: €327,000,000 Stave price €2,200-2,500/m3 66%: Proportion of production exported Barrel price €700 on average for French oak Around 60 barrel makers and 1,900 employees, with 1,500 at barrel makers and 400 at stave mills BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 31 Oak barrel staves – a market success story No. of companies Barrels 60 178 Pallets A trade surplus of €327.4 million in 2014 The balance of the wooden packaging sector is in surplus. In the barrel segment, 66% of production was exported in 2014. The outlook differs depending on the product category: the barrel segment has a positive trade balance, whereas the other segments import more than they export. With globally recognised know-how, barrel making is positioned in high-end products and benefits from an excellent international reputation. A significant portion of barrel sales are recorded outside France, with export sales accounting for 49.7% of total sales, compared with 6.3% for pallet manufacturers. Barrel making is also more profitable. Its EBITDA margin (EBITDA/sales) in 2013 was 13.4%, compared with 4.4% for the other segments. France exports most of its products to the European Union (39% of exports in 2014) and the United States (37.5% of exports in 2014). Sales (excl. tax) in €m Barrels 192.9 488.3 Pallets Sales per company in €000 4,823.5 Barrels Pallets 2,743.7 Export sales as a proportion of total sales Barrels Commodities as a proportion of total purchases (% of sales) Barrels 48.3% Pallets 32.5% EBITDA margin (EBITDA/sales) Barrels 13.4% Pallets 4.4% Key figures for barrel and wooden pallet manufacturers (XERFI) 32 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 49.7% Pallets 6.3% Source: XERFI/INSEE 2014 02 A positive economic environment and a favourable outlook In France, the overall packaging market grew by 2% in 2014. Barrel makers benefited from this market improvement. Their high-end positioning and strong value creation ability brings substantial bargaining power, enabling them to raise their prices by 4.3% in 2014, compared with 2% for the sector as a whole. The recent fall in value of the euro against the dollar has improved the position of French barrel makers in the USA. USD per 1 EUR Source: XE.com 1.50 1.40 1.30 1.20 1.10 1.00 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 33 02 Oak barrel staves – a market success story 34 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 66% French export-oriented production 34% French production marketed in France 7% Italy Source: XERFI/INSEE 22% USA 4% 15% 8% South Africa 3% Argentina Australia Other countries 4% 3% New Zealand Chile Breakdown of French production of barrels and exports by country A fragmented sector The sector is mostly made up of SMEs and micro enterprises. However, we are now seeing a wave of consolidation. Most barrel makers have become vertically integrated operators that own their own sawmills or stave mills. This ensures a secure supply, while optimising barrel quality. 400 Value in €m 327.4 Volume in 000 tonnes 200 30.8 0 -200 -13.1 -70 -23.5 -5.9 -19 Source: XERFI/INSEE 2014 France’s trade surplus in wooden packaging is solely due to barrel making. Outside this segment, all other packaging categories have a negative balance, with pallets showing the highest deficit. -181.7 BASIC PALLETS PALLET TRAYS PALLET BOXES BARRELS Trade balance by product segment BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 35 02 Oak barrel staves – a market success story INTERVIEW Jérôme FRANÇOIS, Chairman of the Management Board of TFF GROUP ”Research and innovation are key to the future development of our businesses.” You head up TFF Group, the world’s leading producer and distributor of oak barrels used for making and ageing wines and spirits. — What is the history of your company, which has its origins in Burgundy, near Beaune? Well, in 2010 we were proud to celebrate the 100th anniversary of our company, which is still family-owned. It was my great-great-grandfather, Joseph François, who set up a workshop to make and repair barrels. At that time, there were lots of small barrel makers who quite often worked only part of the year, and many wine merchants had their own barrel making facilities. As you can imagine, our businesses have undergone radical change since then. We now operate on every continent, and our teams work throughout the year, in both the northern and southern hemispheres, always close to the wine production locations. 36 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 — What have been the main changes in recent years? Concerning wine, the main change is that the barrel has gone from being just a container to become a winemaking tool. In the 1970s, our customers – mainly in the US – wanted to enhance their best vintages by placing them in barrels for a time so that they could take on new flavours, particularly tannins. In partnership with the world’s best winemakers, we have developed a comprehensive range of products and services to meet the new expectations of an increasingly quality-conscious clientele. External growth (the acquisition of companies in the sector) and the search for new opportunities have largely contributed to this development. The systematic pursuit of diversification, particularly geographically, prompted us to look for complementary characteristics and synergies, always within our core business area of wood products for wine and spirits. So our activity gradually evolved from the traditional market of wine, barrels, large containers and wine products or timber work towards whisky around ten years ago, and since then we have become the uncontested leaders among independent barrel makers in a market that is growing strongly. Today, our business is evolving towards bourbon in the USA, a market in which we have great ambitions. — How would you sum up your last financial year? — What are your future prospects? 2014-2015 looks to have been an exceptional year, in every aspect. We increased our revenue by 20.4%, to €204 million. Our operating income rose by €10 million to €45 million, an increase of 28.5%, and our operating margin remained above 20% of revenue. We operate in 80 countries, and 50% of our employees are based outside France. Our products are distributed by some 40 firms, under around 30 different and complementary brands: -Our activity in casks and barrels for use in fine wine production still represents more than 50% of our business. TFF Group has consolidated its position as global leader with a market share in excess of 30%. Although this market may be considered a mature one, our revenue in this segment went up by 11.7% over the period, and we are continuing to pursue our external growth strategy, particularly through acquisitions. The global market for wine saw a pick-up in 2015 after the slowdown observed over the last few years, which was mainly because of small harvests in Europe and the loss of vineyards worldwide. Our complementary activity in wood products for oenology accounts for 8% of consolidated revenue. - Our activity in barrels for whisky production and ageing also makes TFF Group the global leader among independent barrel makers. Over the last ten years or so, we have tapped into the strong growth in this market by establishing or acquiring four barrel makers in Scotland. This segment now represents more than 35% of the Group’s business. Lastly, I should stress that last year’s export sales benefited from favourable currency movements, after several unfavourable years, which made a significant contribution to our results. In line with our diversification strategy, over the last year we have put in place an ambitious plan to capture market share in a complementary sector – whisky and bourbon, where we can leverage our traditional expertise – which we are aiming to make a new source of growth for our Group. We are in the process of building a brand new barrel making facility of over 20,000 m² in Ohio, which will initially produce 130,000 barrels in 2016-2017. This will gradually increase to 400,000 barrels per year. Our target is for this activity to account for one-third of our consolidated revenue. This should enable us to continue to balance the relative weighting of our different businesses. In the wine and whisky markets, our aim is to consolidate our position, while maintaining very high levels of profitability. Finally, we are always looking to enhance the quality of our wood and optimise our production processes, and we continue to hold the strong conviction that research and innovation are key to the future development of our businesses. TFF Group – some figures for 2015: Consolidated revenue: €204 million (+20.4%) Operating income: up €10 million to €45 million (22.1% of revenue) 30%: Global market share 87%: Proportion of activity carried out internationally, in 80 countries 40 locations, including 17 production facilities in France, Hungary, Spain, Australia, Scotland and the USA 754 employees worldwide, including 379 in France. Agrifrance would like to thank TFF Group for their interview and the visit of TFF Group in Burgundy. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 37 02 Oak barrel staves – a market success story 38 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 Conclusion and outlook Through its export of high-end products, the French barrel making sector is leading the way for the forestry industry. At a time when exports of unprocessed logs is a controversial issue in France, and one of the solutions is to put in place customs or tariff barriers, stave mills are forming partnerships within the wine and spirits sectors and are still key players in the wine world. Thanks to expansion overseas, California and Ohio are now the promised land for French barrel makers. French barrel making is following the development of the global wine trade and is an integral part of the wine value chain. This would not have been possible without having ideal conditions for production and wood management, from the oak tree to the stave. The French “forest terroir” is exceptionally favourable to timber production. Moreover, thanks to long-established know-how, barrels generate a substantial trade surplus and high value added. As a result, the sector represents direct employment of almost 1,900 people in France. The production process is now evolving towards new techniques and the search for new markets. Nowadays, the relationship between oak and wine is widely recognised, enabling new products to be developed. Through innovation, R&D is redefining a sector that it would be wrong to consider a ”traditional” one. BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 39 Glossary Batten: felled tree cut into sections Bending: the process of obtaining the curved staves Cask: spherical container, generally made of wood, that can be used for wine, cider, eaude-vie or other liquids Frost crack: crack or split in trees, stone or the ground, caused by freezing Heating: process whereby an item is heated and then cooled gradually to increase its strength Log: a felled tree trunk, with branches removed, with/without bark Organoleptic: relating to the properties that an individual experiences via the senses Quarter: the piece obtained from a batten after splitting Robinia: tree or shrub of the Fabacae family, whose main species is the robinia pseudoacacia, commonly known as acacia and also called false acacia or black locust Shortening: the staves are all shortened to the same length before being used in barrel assembly Stave: oak or chestnut wood, cut into lengths and mainly used in barrel making. Once bent or curved, a number of these small planks are assembled within metal hoops to form the body of the barrel. The stave is made using the quarter piece Timber: logs for sawing, rotary cutting, slicing and other “noble” uses Toasting: the final heating process; its intensity will affect the wine being made by adding flavours and tannins through the oak staves Tree ring: on a barrel cut in cross-section, a ring indicating the amount of wood formed during a growing season Tun: large wooden cask used in wine production that generally holds 50 to 300 hectolitres Ullage: the loss of wine or alcohol through evaporation from the barrel (around 5%) 40 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 References and abbreviations ASFFOR: French Association whose corporate object is to promote joint forest investment in France French National Institute for the landscape and management program for natural areas Bureau de recherches géologiques et minières (BRGM): the French Geology and Mining Research Institute La France Agricole: a French agricultural magazine CDC: French public company wich centralises notaries deposits. The CDC also studies market trends of wood in France Chambers of Agriculture: regional organisations for agricultural and rural development Doc’Eco, Group Information Centre / BNP Paribas Group Fédération des Exportateurs de Vins & Spiritueux de France (FEVS): French union of wine and spirit exporters Eurobaromètre CEE Experts Forestiers de France (EFF): organisation that represents forestry experts in France Forêts de France: a French forest magazine FranceAgriMer: the French National Farm Office of Agriculture and Marine Resources and Products French Ministry of Agriculture (Agreste) “Guide des forêts de France” by G. Plaisance: French publication about forests INSEE: (Institut National de la Statistique et des Études Économiques, pronounced /inse/) is the French National Institute for Statistics and Economic Research Institut pour le Développement Forestier, “Les terrains boisés, leur mise en valeur”. The Institute for Forest Development is the La Revue des Vins de France: a French viticultural magazine about wine and wine tasting La Nouvelle République: a French newspaper La Vigne: a French viticultural magazine “Le bois et le vin” (“Wood and Wine”), by Roger-Paul Dubrion, France Agricole /Campagne & Compagnie Les Douanes Françaises: French customs office Météo France: the French national meteorological service National Forests Office or ONF, a public establishment of the National Government of France charged with the management of national forests SAFER: the French Land Use and Rural Settlement Corporation Valeurs Vénales: annual rating for rural land prices XE.com XERFI/INSEE report, 2013 BNP PARIBAS WEALTH MANAGEMENT I 41 AGRIFRANCE As part of BNP PARIBAS PROPERTY SNC - the BNP PARIBAS subsidiary dedicated to real estate activities - AGRIFRANCE is the department specialising in rural property: vineyards, prestigious country estates, farmland and forests. With over 40 years’ experience in this domain, AGRIFRANCE works hand-in-hand with its clients in their personal wealth management. Through a network of reputed professionals, AGRIFRANCE is also able to provide complementary services, such as property appraisals and estate management. Advisory services and transactions in agricultural real estate, vineyards, forests and leisure properties BNP PARIBAS PROPERTY SNC, 33, rue du Quatre Septembre, 75002 Paris, France Tel: +33 (0)1 42 98 43 51 Fax: +33 (0)1 42 98 43 53 A French general partnership company (SNC) with share capital amounting to €1,200,000. Registered in the Paris Trade and Companies Register under n° 784 194 144 RCS PARIS. Holder of professional licence T 718 issued by the Paris Prefecture of Police. Guarantee BNP Paribas, 16, Boulevard des Italiens, 75009 Paris, France. E.C. Identification: C.E FR25784194144. A BNP Paribas Group company. This paper is made from transformed potato waste 42 I AGRIFRANCE - RURAL REPORT IN 2016 This is a promotional document, provided solely for information purposes, and under no circumstances does it constitute an offer or proposal effected in a State (or jurisdiction) in which such an offer or proposal is not authorised, or an offer or proposal made to persons to whom such an offer, proposal or sale would be illegal. Photo credit: © Thinkstock © iStock © Agrifrance © TFF Group © Graphic Obsession Creation: Design Media
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz