Chapter Five Rational Functions A rational number is a number that is the quotient of two integers. A rational function is the quotient of two polynomials. Since creating a rational function involves division, for the first time you must be careful about the domain you are using. Unlike addition, subtraction, and multiplication, division of two numbers is not always possible. Dividing by the number zero is an illegal operation and cannot be done. Your calculator will declare a mathematical error if you attempt such a division. When you analyze a rational function, your first step must be to find out if there are any input values that would make the value of the polynomial in the denominator zero. You must reject such values from the domain to prevent the function from attempting to perform an illegal operation. Examples of rational numbers: , , ,6 ,0 Irrational numbers: , , , Rational functions: , , If you could divide by 0, then 1 0 = z would imply that z which is impossible. such quotient. 0 = 1, There is no To remind yourself not to use these values in the function, you usually show them on the graph with dotted lines parallel to the y-axis passing through the excluded numbers on the x-axis. Your graph cannot cross such a dotted line since the intersection would indicate a value obtained by your function using that x-value, which is impossible. Since you may use any other x-value but these, you can use inputs as close to the eliminated ones as you want. A line or curve which can be approached as closely as you wish, although perhaps not actually reached, is called an asymptote. The dotted lines indicating the values you have eliminated from your domain are therefore called (vertical) asymptotes. These asymptote lines have the effect of breaking up your domain into separate pieces and you analyze the function over each piece to produce separate parts of the graph. You use the same reasoning you have for previous graphs to complete the rational function graphs. The graphs obtained for rational functions by these methods are quite accurate. Your basic method for producing the graph of a function has been to find a starting point (often the intercept), then move through the domain from your starting value as far as possible in each direction to analyze the endbehavior, and sketch the graph considering other important properties of the function (like the number and location of turning-points). Vertical asymptotes break up the graph into several pieces. 82 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS For non-polynomial functions you should always check the domain first before applying this method. You must be sure not to use values that are not allowed or that you do not wish to use as inputs. Since all polynomial functions (including linear and quadratic) have domains consisting of all real numbers, checking the domain is not a crucial step in obtaining the graphs for these functions, although you may limit your domain to reasonable values for some applied problems. However, with the rational functions, it is necessary for you to remove any impossible input values from the domain before you start. You can then go on with the steps you usually take. Steps to obtain the graph of a rational function: First remove from the domain any x-values which produce a value of zero in the denominator. You can indicate these missing values with vertical asymptote lines (often represented with dotted lines). Next, for each piece of the graph, select a value to obtain a starting point and plot this point. Move through the domain in both directions from your starting value as far as you can. This may be toward the ends of the domain at the extremely large positive and negative x-values, or toward the values you have removed, indicated by the vertical asymptotes. Analyze the behavior of the function at the ends of each piece of domain and sketch the curve representing this behavior. Note that the graph may be split up into several pieces. For an example in applying these steps, look at f1 (x) = 1 . x The first thing you must do is eliminate from the domain any x-values that produce a denominator value of zero. This time, the only such x-value is x = 0. The graph cannot cross the y-axis anywhere, and this function has no intercept. The y-axis, x = 0, serves as a vertical asymptote. This asymptote divides the domain into two separate pieces, those x-values that are negative (to the left of x = 0) and those that are positive (to the right of x = 0). Now analyze the function separately in each piece of the domain. Looking at the right-hand side first, you may choose an input value to use to obtain a starting point. For example, you might select x = 2. Then f1(2) = . You may plot this point. CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS Now move through the domain from x = 2 to your left. You cannot go as far as x = 0, since this value is not in the domain. However, you can use x-values very close to x = 0, as long as they are all above it. As you do this be aware of what is happening to the values obtained by the function. The smaller (closer to x = 0) you make the input values, the larger the values of f1(x) are. Dividing the number 1 by smaller and smaller positive values produces larger and larger quotients. Your graph should show this by curving upward as you move from your ( ) to the left (but not beyond the y-axis). starting point 2, 1 2 Next, move from x = 2 to the right toward the larger positive x-values. As the input values become higher positive numbers, the values of f1(x) become smaller (closer to zero), since dividing the number 1 by large positive numbers produces small positive quotients. When you move further to the right, your input value becomes larger and your quotient becomes closer to zero. Your graph approaches the x-axis (y = 0) from above and moves closer and closer to it. Eventually the curve appears to merge with the x-axis although the two never quite meet. The x-axis acts as a horizontal asymptote to your curve since the graph gets as close to the axis as you want if you move far enough to the right. Note what happens as your x-values move from x = 2 toward x = 0: f1(2) = f1(1) = f1( ) = =2 f1(.1) = = 10 f1(.01) = = 100 f1(.001) = = 1000 As you use increasingly large positive x-values, the values of f1(x) get close to 0: f1(2) = f1(5) = f1(10) = f1(100) = f1(1000) = That takes care of the graph for the domain to the right of x = 0. Now work on the domain to the left of x = 0. Again, you may select a value to use to get a starting point in this part of the domain. You might choose x = –2. Then your starting point on this side of the y-axis is ( −2, f1 (−2) ) = ( −2, − 12 ) . Moving through domain values to the right of x = –2 (up to but not including x = 0) produces f1(x) values that become more negative since you are now dividing your numerator, 1, by negative numbers that are becoming smaller (that is, in absolute value). This causes the graph to drop steeply toward extremely negative values as you move further to the right (but not past the y-axis). 83 Note the values of f1(x): f1(–2) = f1(–1) = f1(–.1) = f1(–.01) = f1(–.001) = = –10 = –100 = –1000 84 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS Finally, move through the domain from x = –2 toward increasingly negative x-values (to the left). You obtain the values of f 1(x) by dividing your numerator, 1, by negative numbers that are becoming larger in size (further from x = 0). The quotients you obtain are all negative, but are getting closer to 0. The graph of the function for this part of the domain is approaching the x-axis as you move further to the left, but on this side you come from below the axis since all the values of the function are negative. The y-axis, x = 0, is a horizontal asymptote on this side too. This completes the graph of the function f1(x) = . You can also use the methods you previously learned to determine the graphs of functions obtained from this one by stretching, translating and reflecting. For example, the graph of is stretched vertically compared to the graph of . The values are three times as large in both positive and negative directions. The figure on the right shows the graphs of and . The graph of that of is the reflection of across the x-axis. The values of are the same as those of but with opposite signs. The graph of is given on the left. The values of f1(x) now are: f1(–2) = f1(–5) = f1(–10) = f1(–100) = f1(–1000) = CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS The graph of is the translation of the graph of to the right by 4 units. The values obtained by are the same as those obtained by but for 85 Sketch the graphs of: a. , b. , c. –2 a. x-values that are 4 units higher. The graph of is given at the right. b. The graph of + 2 is the translation of the graph of two units upward. Notice that means the horizontal asymptote also moves up 2 units from the x-axis to y = 2. The graph is given on the left. c. For a more complex example, let f2(x) = . One way to approach this is to rewrite the expression for the function = = =3+ In this form you can see that you can obtain the graph from the graph of by translating up 3 units, to the right 2 units, and a large vertical stretch by a factor of 14. The horizontal asymptote is y = 3. (The graph is given on page 88.) If you do not want to carry out all the algebraic steps to rewrite the expression in recognizable form, you can obtain the graph from the original expression by the usual procedure. First, you must exclude x = 2 from the domain because the denominator, x – 2, would be zero for x = 2 and this is not permissible. You show this exclusion from the domain with a dotted line through x = 2 (the vertical asymptote). The graph is in two pieces. You can rewrite the expression in the numerator by looking for a multiple of (x – 2), the denominator, so you can divide. Since the coefficient of the x-term in the numerator is already 3, what you need to have is 3(x – 2) or 3x – 6. What you do have is 3x + 8, which is 14 higher than what you want. Adding 14 to 3x – 6 is just another way of writing 3x + 8. You then can divide 3x – 6 by x – 2 for a quotient of 3, and have a remainder of 14. This method often works. 86 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS The intercept is at (0, –4) since f2(0) = = = –4. This gives you a point for the left part of the graph. Now, analyze the end-behavior. On the left-hand side, extremely negative x-values produce large negative numbers in both numerator and denominator, so the quotient is a positive number. However, you can say something much more precise than that. Remember that the x-value you are using is very large in size. The term 3x + 8 tells you to multiply this very negative number by 3, producing a more negative value, then to add 8. However, adding 8 to an extremely negative number does not have much effect, and the larger in size the x-value is, the less significant the addition of 8. The dominant term in the numerator is 3x. Similarly, in the denominator, the size of the x-value is what is important. Subtracting 2 from a number that is already very negative has very little effect. The value of the term x dominates that of x – 2. Specifically, You can see that as the input values become more negative, the 8 added in the numerator and the 2 subtracted in the denominator become less and less significant. When x = –10, the –22 obtained in the numerator is quite different from –30, but when x = –100, the –292 is pretty close to the –300 you had before adding 8. For x = –1000, there is very little difference between the calculated –2992 and the approximated –3000. The same is true for the denominator, which has a value very close to x when x is far to the left. When the x-values are very large in size, the only terms that are significant are those that have the highest degree, both in numerator and denominator. In this example, the highest power of the variable is the first power both in the numerator and in the denominator. Therefore, for x-values that are very far to the left, = 3. CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS The graph of this function on the extreme left is a curve that is very close to y = 3. From the preceding calculations, you can also see that the values of the function are all below 3, and get closer to 3 when you use more negative values for inputs. The line y = 3 is a horizontal asymptote for the graph. Remember that you found this by looking at the values of the function for extremely negative x-values. Don't forget that the function values are determined by the input values. Also note that the asymptote is not part of the graph, but is a guide line to help make the graph more accurate. The only parts of the asymptote line that are helpful are the far ends that show what value the function is approaching when the x-values are large in size. At the other end of this piece of the graph you have numbers close to, but less than x = 2. When you use these numbers in the function, the numerator has a value near 3(2) + 8 = 14. The denominator has a value near but slightly below 0. Remember the denominator could never be equal to 0. Therefore, when you use values just under 2 for x, your quotient is a negative number that is large in size (since you are dividing by a number that is almost 0). Specifically, The left-hand part of the graph shows a curve that is very close (although slightly below) f(x) = 3 for x-values on the extreme left, passes through the intercept (0, –4), and then heads rapidly downward when you get near the dotted line indicating the excluded value x = 2. On the right side, you can get a starting point by using any value greater than 2 for x. Find and plot such a point. Next you see that x-values slightly above x = 2 produce numerators near 14 divided by denominators that are slightly above 0. This gives you quotients that are very large in size, and positive. 87 88 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS The graph shows a curve to the right of x = 2 that is very high near x = 2, then drops and eventually passes through your starting point. Finally, use the x-values on the extreme right of your domain, the very large positive numbers. These numbers give very large positive numbers in both numerator and denominator. Again, closer examination shows that since you are using very large values for x, the 8 added in the numerator and the 2 subtracted in the denominator do not play significant parts in the calculations. As you use larger and larger values for x, the positive quotients get closer to 3, and since the numerator is always more than 3 times the denominator, these quotients are always larger than the limiting value 3. On this side, the line y = 3 is again a (horizontal) asymptote and the graph approaches this line (from above) as you move your x-values to the right. Sketch the graphs of: a. b. a. b. Complete graph of f2(x). CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS A different sort of example is given by f3(x) = . There are now two x-values, x = –2 and x = 5, that make one of the factors in the denominator equal to 0. You must remove both these numbers from the domain to avoid having the denominator take on a value of 0. The graph is in three pieces, one for the domain from the extreme left up to x = –2, another between x = –2 and x = 5, and the third from above x = 5 to the extreme right. The intercept, , gives you a starting point for the middle piece. Then when you move through the domain from x = 0 toward x = –2, the values of f3(x) are very large in size because the denominator is close to 0. The numerator, –4, is a negative number. When you use x-values very close to, but above, x = –2, the factor (x + 2) is close to 0, but positive, while the factor (x – 5) is negative. The denominator, the product of a positive and a negative number, is negative, and the function values, calculated with a negative numerator and denominator are positive. Therefore, the graph shows large positive values when the x-values used are slightly above x = –2. As you move through your domain toward x = 5, using x-values slightly smaller than x = 5, the function values again become very large in size since the denominator is near 0. Since the x-values are slightly less than x = 5, the factor (x + 2) is a positive number, while the factor (x – 5) is negative. Since your numerator is negative and your denominator is negative (the product of a positive and a negative number), the function values produced from these x-values are again positive. Sketching this information produces the middle part of the graph. Moving to the left-hand piece of the domain, you may select an x-value to give a starting point. Any x-value less than x = –2 can be selected. For example, using x = –4 produces the point . As you move from x = –4 toward x = –2, the factor (x + 2) becomes close to 0, making the denominator small and the value of the function large in size. Since the x-values you are using now are less than x = –2, (x + 2) is a negative number, as is (x – 5). Their product is positive, so your function value is the quotient of the numerator, –4, divided by a positive denominator. This quotient is a negative number that is becoming large in size as you move toward x = –2. 89 90 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS As you move toward the other end of this part of the domain, you start using x-values that are very far from 0, and negative. You determine the values of the function by dividing –4 by the product of two negative numbers that are very large in size, (x + 2) and (x – 5). The values you obtain are negative and very close to 0 since the denominator is far larger than the numerator. The graph of the function on the extreme left-hand side of the domain is very close to, but below the x-axis. The x-axis, y = 0, is an asymptote to the graph of f3(x) for these x-values. Next you obtain the graph for the right-hand piece. You might again select an x-value to use to obtain a starting point. For example, you might use x = 7. This gives you the point . If you move to the left, toward x = 5, your denominator becomes small since (x – 5) is near 0, and the function values are large in size. The numerator is negative, and since x is greater than 5 in this part of the domain, both (x + 2) and (x – 5) are positive. The function values are negative, since you obtain them by dividing a negative numerator by a positive denominator. The graph for x-values slightly above x = 5 shows a function taking on very low negative values near x = 5, rising to pass through . Finally, check what happens for large positive x-values. Both (x – 2) and (x + 5) are very large positive numbers, so your function values are the results of dividing –4 by large positive numbers. These values are close to 0, and negative. The graph shows a curve approaching the x-axis asymptotically, from below the axis. This completes the graph. Some general principles: When you divide a number by a denominator that is small in absolute value, that is, near zero, your quotient is very large in size, although this quotient could be either positive or negative. When you divide a number by one much larger than it, the quotient is small in absolute value. If the power of the denominator is greater than that of the numerator, the quotient will be near zero when you use large values for your variable. To determine the value of a quotient when your x-values are very large (in either positive or negative directions), you consider only the highestpower terms in both numerator and denominator. CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS Other examples of rational functions: f4(x) = Again there are two x-values that would make the denominator 0, both x = –1 and x = 1. You must remove these two numbers from the domain. The graph is in three pieces, from the extreme left to x = -1, between x = –1 and x = 1, and from x = 1 to the extreme right. You may select an x-value less than –1 to find a starting point for the left-hand piece. Graph this point. Extremely negative x-values give quotients of positive numbers divided by positive numbers, so the function values on the left are positive. Also, since for these inputs it is the highest degree terms that are significant, you can ignore the effect of subtracting 1 in the denominator. =2 You can see that the function values are close to y = 2 on the extreme left. Notice that your starting point has a function value higher than 2. This is because the numerator is always more than twice as large as the denominator. This shows you that your graph is above y = 2 while close to this value for x-values far to the left. As your x-values get closer to x = –1 (from below), the quotient (still positive) gets larger and larger since the numerator is near 2, while the denominator becomes small (near 0). The graph for this section of the domain shows a curve above y = 2, very close to y = 2 on the extreme left, passing through your starting point, and becoming very large in the positive direction when your xvalues get near x = –1. On the other side of x = –1, the denominator is still near 0, but now is negative in sign. The numerator is still close to 2. Your quotient is again very large in size, as always when you divide by numbers near 0, but it is now negative. The intercept is (0, 0), which gives you a point in the section between x = –1 and x = 1. 91 92 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS Using values approaching x = 1 from below, you are again dividing a number near 2 by a negative number close to 0. Such quotients are again negative numbers of large size. The graph in this middle section shows a curve that is very negative near x = –1 that rises to pass through the intercept at the origin, and again becoming extremely negative when you get near x = 1. In the third section, input values just above x = 1 produce quotients that are numbers near 2 divided by very small positive numbers. These quotients are large positive numbers. If you select an x-value greater than 1 to use for a starting point, you can plot this now. Notice that the function value here is larger than 2. When you use very large positive x-values you can again ignore the small effect that the subtraction of 1 has in the denominator, and you can again see that your function values get near 2 when you select large enough x-values. The graph of this third section begins with very high positive values when you are just above x = 1, then passes through your point and approaches y = 2 when your x-values get far enough to the right. You might also note that this is the graph of an even function, so the graph must be symmetric about the y-axis. f5(x) = . The only x-value that makes the denominator of this function equal to 0 is the value x = 2. Exclude this value from your domain. You can mark this exclusion with a vertical asymptote. You can obtain the intercept as usual, the point . When you move from x = 0 to your left, toward more negative x-values, you see that the denominator has larger sized numbers than the numerator. In fact, = . Therefore, the end-behavior on the extreme left is asymptotic to the x-axis. Since the x-values are negative in this part of the domain, you can see that the curve is close to the xaxis but below the axis for extremely negative x-values. CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS When you use x-values very close to, but less than x = 2, the denominator is near 0, but negative. The numerator, 3x2 – 3x – 36, is also negative, near –30. The function values are therefore positive and becoming larger as you take your x-values closer to x = 2. The graph is near, but under, the x-axis for very negative x-values, ( passes through the intercept 0, 4 1 2 ) , then rises rapidly as the x-values approach x = 2. If the x-values you select are slightly above x = 2, then your numerator is still near –30 and your denominator is close to 0, but positive, since cubing an x-value larger than 2 produces a number larger than 8. The result is negative, and large in size. When you use large values for x, the higher power in the denominator causes the function values to be near 0, but since the function is behaving like , these values are positive. The graph of the function to the right of x = 2 shows extremely negative values for x-values just above x = 2, then rises to cross the x-axis to attain positive values, but the curve then heads toward the x-axis from the positive side as the x-values increase. f6(x) = Since the denominator factors into 5(x2 – 2x – 3) = 5(x + 1)(x – 3), you see that you must exclude x = –1 and x = 3 from the domain to prevent getting a denominator of 0. For x-values near x = –1, the function must get very large in size since the denominator is near 0 for such x-values. If you use x-values less than x = –1, both (x + 1) and (x – 3) are negative so the denominator is positive for these x-values. Since the numerator isalways positive, the function has very large positive values for x-values that are slightly below x = –1. For very large x-values, = . The function is asymptotic to a parabola that opens upward and is fairly wide. The graph on the left shows a curve that looks like a parabola opening upward, then as you move across toward x = –1, the curve turns rapidly upward. 93 94 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS For x-values slightly above x = –1, x + 1 is positive and x – 3 is negative, so the denominator is negative and near 0. The function ( values are large negative numbers. The intercept is 0, − 6 15 ) . When you use x-values slightly below x = 3, x + 1 is positive and x – 3 is negative. The denominator for these x-values is negative and near 0, so again the graph shows extremely negative values for x-values just below x = 3. The graph between x = –1 and x = 3 rises from the extremely negative values it has near x = –1, passes through the intercept, and returns to very negative values when you approach x = 3. For x-values greater than x = 3, the denominator is still near 0, but both (x + 1) and (x – 3) are positive, so the function has large positive values. As the x-values get larger, the function again approaches its asymptotic curve, y = . The graph shows high positive values when the x-values are close to x = 3, decreases for a while, then heads toward the parabola y = . When a function has a graph that is asymptotic to another curve, it is important that you select your viewing window with care in order to have a complete graph visible in your screen. If you view your graph from too far away, the asymptotic curve will dominate the graph of the function and you may lose the details of the graph that illustrate what is happening at some of the x-values. In the graph for f 6(x) you have just completed, the end behavior of the parabola dominates the graph at the ends. If you choose an x-interval for your graph that is too large, you will see the graph of this parabola overwhelming the turns the graph makes between x = –1 and x = 3. The figure in the right-hand column shows what happens to the graph when you use the x-interval [–100, 100]. Now that you understand how the graphs of rational functions behave, and which features are the necessary to examine (particularly restrictions to the domain and end-behavior), you can use your graphics calculator to produce complete graphs of these functions. If you were graphing f 4(x), for example, you would have to be sure that the left side boundary was lower than x = –1, the right side above x = 1, the top higher than y = 2, and the bottom should at least be low enough to show the curve crossing below the axis. If your window was not at least this large, you might miss the graph in one or more of the sections, and fail to obtain a complete graph. X interval: [–100, 100] CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS Applications The kinds of applied models that rational functions may describe usually have domains that are naturally limited to certain sets of values. For example, S(t) = might model the starting salary for a certain executive position (in thousands of dollars), where t is the number of years that have passed since 1950. If you start to graph this function, you will quickly realize that you must remove –75 from the domain. It is not a possible value for t because it would produce a value of 0 in the denominator. The model apparently should only be considered for t-values above –75 (that is, after 1875). The intercept gives the starting salary this position would have had in 1950 (0 years from 1950!), which is 7 ($7000). As t increases (as time went by), the influence of the constants 1050 in the numerator and 150 in the denominator diminish in importance in calculation of the salary. By 1990 (t = 40), the starting salary had become , or $25,400. In the distant future, this salary will be determined by , which represents the ultimate starting salary of $60,000. Now the graph over this part of the domain shows a curve that is extremely negative for t-values slightly above t = –75 (because for values near here you are dividing a negative numerator by a small positive denominator). A t-value of –75 makes sense, since it means a time 75 years before 1950, or 1875, but the graph does not. Even in 1875, salaries were not negative! The model may make sense for some values below 0, but probably not too far below. You would only use this model for the part of the domain in which the results make sense, maybe from t = –5 and higher. When you are working with applied models, make sure you use the function (and graph) only with values of the domain that give you realistic answers. The mathematical model does not know which set of values this should be and produces results (meaningful or not) throughout the entire domain of the function. You must apply common sense to your results, which even experienced workers sometimes forget to do. 95 96 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS Exercises 1. Sketch the complete graph of: a. f(x) = b. f(x) = c. f(x) = d. f(x) = e. f(x) = 2. Sketch the complete graph of: a. f(x) = b. f(x) = c. f(x) = –6 + d. f(x) = 5 – 3. Write a possible equation for the function whose graph is given by: a. b. c. CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS 97 4. Sketch the complete graph of: a. f(x) = b. f(x) = c. f(x) = d. f(x) = e. f(x) = 5. Sketch the complete graph (including all end behavior) of: a. f(x) = b. f(x) = c. f(x) = 6. One model for the world's record in the long jump (in feet) is given by the function L(x) = , where x represents the number of years that have passed since 1900. Sketch a complete graph of this model. What information does the intercept give you? The world's record in 1990 was 29.2 feet. What does the model predict the record would be? According to this model, what is the ultimate world record? 7. The number of daily sales that a saleswoman can make is given by the function S(t) = , where t represents the number of weeks of sales experience she has. Sketch a complete graph for this function. How many daily sales could she make when she first started the job? What will be the greatest number of daily sales she can hope to achieve? 8. Find the maximum value of the function f (x) = 3 4 −2 + 8x − x x 2 . 98 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS Answers 1. a. b. d. 2. a. c. e. b. d. c. CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS 3. Note that in each answer c represents some positive number. a. 4. b. a. c. b. Wide-range view of 4b. c. 5. a. d. Close-up view of 4b. e. b. Wide-range view of 5b. c. Close-up view of 5b. 99 100 CHAPTER 5: RATIONAL FUNCTIONS 6. The intercept notes that the world record in the long jump in 1900 was 24 feet. The model predicts a record of 29.83 feet, or 29 feet 10 inches, in 1990. The ultimate world record, according to the model, is given by the asymptote, 30 feet. 7. With no experience, daily sales are 3 units, according to the model. The number of sales, with great experience, will approach, but not surpass, 20 units per day. 8. The maximum point appears to be at (4.03, 15.87).
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz