Wind power in Canada

Wind power is one of the fastest growing forms of
energy in the world.
I
t currently supplies about 1.1 per cent of Canada‟s electricity demand, with 99 wind farms representing approximately
3,249MW of generating capacity. Wind power also helps to create new jobs for Canadians, encourages innovations and helps to
offset emissions from fossil fuels. Supplying just over one percent of Canada‟s electricity, wind energy powers over one million
homes, and has great potential for growth. Countries like Denmark get over 20 per cent of their electricity from wind, and if
Canada were to do the same, it would translate into enough energy to power 17 million homes. The Canadian Wind Energy
Association has outlined a future strategy for wind energy that would reach a capacity of 55,000 MW by 2025, meeting the goal
of 20 per cent of the country‟s energy needs. With oil prices skyrocketing to record highs, it seems clear that Canadians are going
to have to look at alternative energy resources and while this phenomenon is creating great concern around the world, it is also an
ideal time for wind energy producers to turn this period of instability into an opportunity.
The growth of wind power all over the world is another indicator that this source of energy is becoming more popular,
and in 2009, around the world, more than 37,000 MW of new wind farms were built. Data unveiled by the Global Wind Energy
Council showed that Canada‟s 950 megawatts of new wind turbines that were hooked up in 2009 to the electrical grid placed it
ninth overall among wind power producing nations. China was the busiest at adding new capacity, with a massive 13,000 MW
built, more than doubling its existing base of wind power production. The United States came second with 9,900 MW of new
capacity, and Spain was third with 2,460 MW. According to Steve Sawyer, the Brussels based wind-council‟s security-general,
“the continued rapid growth of wind power, despite the financial crisis and economic downturn, is testament to the inherent
attractiveness of the technology, which is clean, reliable and quick to install”.
We‟ve seen something like this happen before. High oil prices in the seventies also inspired innovations in the energy
sector and developers and engineers started developing solar powered cells, auto dealers imported more fuel-efficient cars while
manufacturers eliminated many gas guzzlers from their product lines. Most importantly, governments started legislating fuel
efficiency standards, and this created an opportunity for more efficient methods of technology. Wind energy does appear to be
here to stay. Ontario, Canada‟s industrial heartland and most populated province, is starting to make inroads with renewable
energy producers. This bodes well for other provinces that are starting to incorporate legislation that allow for more green
energies like wind power.
Although most early development for wind power in Canada was located primarily in Ontario, Quebec and Alberta,
since the late 1990‟s every province has pursued
Courtesy of Canadian Wind Energy Association
wind power at some point to supplement their
provincial energy grids. With the first commercial
wind farm built in Alberta in 1993, the most recent
province to add wind power to its energy grid was
B.C. in 2009 with the completion of the Bear
Mountain Wind Park. Owned by Bear Mountain
Wind LP, the farm began operations in November
2009. BC‟s first operating wind farm has a
generating capacity of 102 megawatts. Almost all
the provinces currently have some wind power
projects underway and Manitoba is planning to build
the largest wind farm in Canada, to be located in the
southern part of the province.
In Ontario, the amount of electricity
generated by wind has increased from 15 megawatts
in 2003 to 1,100 megawatts in 2009, enough
electricity to supply the needs of 300,000 homes.
The province is at the forefront of wind energy in
Erie Shores Wind Farm, Port Burwell, Ontario
Canada, with more than 2,600 MW of wind
generation capacity expected to be in service by the end of 2011. Despite this, the Ontario government decided in early February
2011 to pause off shore wind energy developments. The McGuinty government announced that it would stop all offshore wind
projects until further scientific research is conducted into its environmental impact. The unexpected decision drew praise from
opponents of wind turbines, but disappointment from environmentalists and businesses that support the renewable power,
including The Canadian Wind Energy Association (CanWEA). “Ontario is proving itself a leader in driving a new clean energy
future that delivers emission free power and new jobs for our skilled trade workers,” said CanWEA president Robert Hornung.
“This is an unfortunate decision that surrenders the province‟s leadership role in exploring the potential for offshore wind energy
in the Great lakes and creates significant uncertainty for investors.” Many companies and
groups are responding to the decision with a mixture of shock and disappointment, especially
since the government had steadfastly supported its Green Energy Act since its introduction,
and there is now increased risk that other changes might be made down the line. Robert
Hornung added that “as a responsible industry that promotes sustainable development
practices, we look forward to working with the government to understand their proposed
timelines and scope of research into the application of offshore wind energy in the Great Lakes
and we ultimately believe there is great potential for offshore wind energy to provide clean
energy and new jobs in Ontario. We are encouraged, however, to see the government‟s
continued commitment to its Long-Term Energy Plan, which includes significant growth in
wind energy production in Ontario.”
With wind power spreading all over the country, public opinion seems to be mostly
in support of the alternative energy source. According to a survey conducted by Angus Reid
Bear Mountain Wind Park in
British Columbia
Strategies in October 2007, 89 percent of respondents said that using renewable energy sources like wind or solar power was
positive for Canada, because these sources were better for the environment. Only four per cent considered using renewable
sources as negative since they can be unreliable and expensive. According to a Saint Consulting survey conducted in April 2007,
wind power was the alternative energy source most likely to gain public support for future development in Canada, with only 16
per cent opposed to this type of energy. By contrast, 3 out of 4 Canadians opposed nuclear power developments. Despite this
general support for the concept of wind power in the public at large, local opposition often exists, with some concerns from
residents including a perceived eyesore”, noise levels, or reduced property values. There are also some environmental concerns
that have come up in the discussion on wind power, including the disturbance of bird‟s migratory patterns. According to David
Suzuki, “just as with every kind of new technology, wind turbines must be applied with care. Thorough environmental
assessments must take into account bird flight paths, and zoning processes must take into consideration issues that might be
raised by host communities. Just as solar panels graduated from powering small items such as digital watches and calculators to
being incorporated into large-scale, energy-efficient projects, I am confident that wind turbines will also reach a critical mass. As
I cross the country and talk to people, I hear about more and more wind turbines dotting the landscapes.”
In 2008, the Canadian Wind Energy Association (CanWEA) outlined a future strategy for wind energy that would
reach a capacity of 55,000 MW by 2025, fulfilling 20 per cent of the country‟s energy needs. The plan, Wind Vision 2025, could
create over 50,000 jobs and represent around CDN $165 million annual revenue. If achieved, CanWEA‟s target would make the
country a major player in the wind power sector and would create around CDN $79 billion of investment. It would also save an
estimated 17-megatons of greenhouse gas emissions annually. According to CanWEA, Canada can get 20 per cent of its
electricity - 55,000 MW - from wind by 2025, by putting up 22,000 wind turbines spread over about 450 locations across Canada.
All told, the wind farms needed would occupy a land area of about 5,500 square kilometers, or about the size of Prince Edward
Island. Can-WEA believes this will take a very concentrated effort, but it compares the effort to developing Canada‟s electricity
„oil sands‟. According to CanWEA, “at $132 billion, costs will be similar, but Canada‟s wind power pioneers will enjoy some
advantages which their counterparts in Fort McMurray would have envied. For starters, wind technology is already well
advanced and understood and price-wise, wind power is becoming more and more cost-competitive. The business and
environmental cases for wind power are very solid, so there is no reason to believe that WindVision 2025 is unattainable.”
Wind power is becoming more popular and supplies approximately 1.1 per cent of Canada’s electricity demand.
A typical wind turbine is made up of about 8,000 separate parts – from electronics to heavy metal components. The
wind energy supply chain is extremely broad and diverse and holds enormous opportunities for Canadian manufacturers. Canada
is already producing wind turbine towers, blades, and nacelle covers and we have the skills, the plants and equipment to produce
an even broader range of components. Today, approximately half of the value of a wind turbine has the potential to be readily
produced on a large scale in Canada. Given the pressure on our traditional manufacturing base, this represents a significant
opportunity for diversification and renewal. Recent studies estimate that public and private investors around the world will pump
between $800 billion and $1 trillion into wind power from 2008 to 2020. Can- WEA believes that with a $132 billion price tag, if
governments send a clear signal that WindVision 2025 is a national priority for Canada, the private sector will respond, and at
least 60 percent of the total, some $79 billion, can flow to the bottom line of Canadian equipment manufacturers, construction
and engineering firms and other suppliers in all regions of the country. The benefits would also be great in terms of employment
opportunities for Canadians. Installing the 55,000 MW called for in CanWEA‟s WindVision 2025 would mean at least 52,000
new, “green collar jobs” for Canada in 2025. Approximately half of these would be high quality manufacturing jobs and a third
would relate to operation and servicing. According to CanWEA, if industry and government work together to establish a versatile
wind turbine and component manufacturing capacity in Canada, the employment outlook would be even brighter. Additionally,
these estimates are only for the Canadian market and with world wide investment in wind power expected to top $1.8 trillion by
2025, export markets could mean tens of thousands of additional jobs for Canadian workers. By 2020, the Worldwatch Institute
predicts there will be two million jobs worldwide in the wind power industry.
According to CanWEA, “now is the time to ramp up our investment in wind energy manufacturing.” Recent rapid
growth in global wind energy demand has led to significant bottlenecks in the supply of many key components for wind turbines.
This is even causing many wind energy project developers to delay projects for up to two years because of difficulty in securing
turbines. As a result, turbine manufacturers are adding new capacity and with the right incentives, manufacturers will add this
capacity in Canada. As in any global industry, investment will gravitate to countries that offer the highest returns. Traditional
factors such as cost of capital, the supply of skills, raw materials and components and access to markets will all come into play as
companies decide where to locate their facilities. However, governments that offer subsidies, tax rebates and other incentives to
lower production costs serve as a magnet for investment. This is certainly the case in wind energy equipment manufacturing
where governments around the world have recognized that hundreds of billions of dollars in equipment sales and as many as two
million high quality jobs are up for grabs over the next two decades.
Whether we like it or not, our ability to grow the Canadian wind equipment manufacturing sector will depend to a
considerable extent on how attractive Canada‟s investment climate is relative to other countries - and many other countries are
using incentives to influence this decision. Canada‟s main competition is the United States, where manufacturers invested more
than $1 billion in 2007 and the first part of 2008 to build or expand 41 wind turbine manufacturing facilities, creating 9,000 high
quality jobs. Part of the reason Canadian electricity suppliers are having trouble keeping up with demand is that new projects
must go through permits and approvals processes related to municipal zoning, environmental assessment, and integration with the
electricity system. While such processes are important, Can-WEA explains that the current system doesn‟t work very well and is
often confusing or unclear, and there is also a lack of dedicated government resources. Currently, there are simply not enough
people working on approvals and permits, at all levels, to handle the interest in new wind energy development across Canada.
It‟s a good time to be in the wind turbine business or to supply components to the major producers. Manufacturers are
now rapidly making investments in new plants in an effort to get supply to catch up with demand. Over the next 12 years, it is
projected that over $1 trillion will be invested in new wind energy projects as an additional 400,000 + MW is added to global
wind energy capacity. At this time, Canada is barely visible in the world market in terms of wind
turbine manufacturing, particularly for large turbines and components. In terms of installed wind
energy capacity, Canada sits in 11th place globally and most of the components for the wind farms
built here have come from suppliers in the United States or Europe. However, over the long run, there
is no reason to believe that the relationship we see in many other countries like Denmark and Spain,
between local installing capacity and growth in the local manufacturing base will not hold true for
Canada. The pattern is already starting to emerge with the opening of three component-manufacturing
plants since 2006 in Quebec‟s Gaspé region, in the wake of Hydro Quebec‟s tender for 1000MW of
wind power which called for 60 per cent local content. These plants, which build turbine towers,
blades and nacelle covers, now employ several hundred people and are starting to export to other
regions of the province, to Ontario and the United States. Canada also has tower-manufacturing
facilities in Ontario and Saskatchewan.
According to CanWEA, currently Canadian wind projects depend almost exclusively on
European and US suppliers for turbines and key components, however we have an opportunity to
change this, as the pace of wind farm construction picks up. Canada has the skills and industrial
capacity to serve this rapidly growing market, but Canadian companies are going to have to get more
The 23 wind farms under
contract with Hydro-Quebec
aggressive to seize these opportunities. Using experience in other countries as a guide, multinational
Distribution.
turbine manufacturers will procure many parts from local suppliers when price and quality are
competitive. To attract investment, Canadian firms must also be open to licensing, joint ventures and
sub-contracting arrangements.
For the past five years, Westburne has been involved in important wind farm projects totalizing over 1 000 MW of
renewable energy. Westburne‟s experienced team has distinguished itself and is now recognized as the benchmark in the Quebec
wind industry for the supply of electrical material and equipment. This division of Westburne is headed up by Matthieu Crevier,
Business Development Manager, Strategic Account and Engineering. ■