Boosting Trees for Anti-Spam Email Filtering

"!$# %&#'!$(*)+(
, %.-
/0/213
54
687:93;=<:>5?@7A>B>C<:>D7FE
GIHKJMN L E5O7AP >DQJR<:S
TMU"GVXWY<AE<A7Z>\[^]?<:_`B<a>
Gcbdef<:gI7Z>C`Bh<a_3`
if_R;K9<:>\Ej;=`D7Z`kVmlnH=;Kà<AP [o_R;p[:78q3<r?@7Z`D7AHKJR_s7.tiV?u
vnln>\q3;xwf;K>Cln_I7b7ZH=y7Fq3lz^{}|
~7A>D[o<aHKln_7r$nFn|ARm?@7A`D7ZH=ln_R;p7
3FFM^F:F3R$IjR
b<agR`B<:hI<:>@nF3z
IjC D¡n¢D
£¥¤¦¨§Z©«ªm¬o®¨¯n°A±ª¨²j¦$^³óµf¶A±o®¨±o¦¨©¸·²m²¹:¶F²®º©¸µf²¤:¦¨ª»³=®c¦º§A²¶A®º¼A½¸²µ¾D³R±¿:À
¦ºµf±o¦¨©¸´±o½«½¸ÁmÂF½¸¦¨²j®¨©¸¤AÃ¿A¤:¬±¤:¦¨²Ä5²½¸²´¦º®¨¤Z©«´µf±©¸½Aµ5²ª¨ªº±Ão²ª±o®¨²x¶n²®¥³=o®¨µ5²Ä
o¤r¦¥¬8¶Z¿A¼A½¸©¸´´®º¶Fo®¨±AÅÆRÇ@È±o¤AÄ+É}©¸¤AÃaÊ:¶Z±µ8ËÊ:²·²j®¨±½c·D±o®¨©¸±¤:¦ºª$^³M¦¨§A²
Ì ÄA±Í:ª¨¦m±½¸Ão®¨©¸¦¨§ZµÎ¬c©¸¦º§0´j¤:ÂFÄZ²¤A´²Ï:®¨±o¦¨²Är¶A®º²ÄA©¸´¦º©«o¤Aª@Ð¸ÈjÑBÒ§A±D·o²$¼n²²¤
±o¶A¶A½¸©¸²Ä°¬c§A©¸´§fÄZ©ÔÓ²®©¸¤¦¨§A²m´µ5¶A½¸²¹:©«¦¥Áx^³¦¨§A²m¼A±ªº²M½¸²±®º¤A²®ºªc´¤Aªº©¸ÄA²®¨²jÄË
Õc¬Öµ5±©¸¤×´¤A´j½«¿Zª¨©¸¤Aª´j±¤¼F²ÄA®º±D¬c¤Ø³=®öµÙ¿A®²¹:¶n²®¨©¸µf²j¤a¦ºªÅ8±:ÚÕc§A²
¼n:ª¨¦º©¸¤AÃDÏ:¼A±ªº²Äµ5²¦¨§A:ÄAª´½¸²±o®¨½¸Áo¿A¦¨¶n²®¥³K®¨µÛ¦¨§A²¦º§A²®½¸²±o®¨¤A©¸¤AÃ×±½¸Ã^À
®º©«¦º§AµfªR®º²ª¨¿A½¸¦ºªc¶A¿A¼A½¸©¸ª¨§A²jÄ¤¦¨§Z²M¦¥¬²·D±½¸¿A±o¦¨©¸¤ó®¨¶n®¨±Z°A±´§A©¸²·:©¸¤AÃ·o²®¨Á
§A©¸Ão§½«²j·²½¸ªI^³¦¨§A²xÜIÝIµ5²±ªº¿A®¨²^ÞA¼FÚR£¥¤A´®º²±ªº©¸¤AÃ@¦º§A²M´jµf¶Z½«²j¹a©¸¦¥Á^³ß¦º§A²M¼Z±ª¨²
½¸²±o®¨¤A²®ºªc±½¸½¸D¬cªI¦ö¼A¦¨±o©¸¤¼F²¦º¦¨²®à§A©¸Ão§:Ïa¶A®º²´©¸ª¨©¸o¤Aá@´j½«±oª¨ªº©ÔÂn²®¨ªj°F¬c§A©¸´§f©¸ª±
·o²®¨Á5©«µ5¶Fo®¨¦º±¤:¦I©¸ª¨ªº¿A²¬c§A²¤µ5©«ªº´½¸±ªºª¨©âÂF´±o¦¨©¸¤óª¨¦ºªM±®º²ó¤Aª¨©¸ÄA²®º²ÄË
! "#%$&('*)+ ,".-*#$0/*1*2#%3/456*"/*" 7% 8! "#%$&('*)96';:<;'"#>=+#> #>7?
".$0/@'* 7 AB#>,,?)#>,%CD-*#B"#%$FE,.;GH2 I9 ,JH2,K/L7>/@MB/@'* 8N$0#?4O#%$$0#>=P"/
,QEOR6'SP IP/@$9E.6'*,K/ 27> "#>=T7>/*B#%$07>U IC9VW/X:=Y8*,%Z".-*#9$0/@1* #%
-,J7>-* #>[#>=\]1*2)]U7>",K('*7>#916*USP#% #%$0,".S#=['"?)#B/4".-*#B)@$0#%"
/@6*U$0 "08/H4".-*#A#> #>7>".$0/*'*27^ @7>/*B6'*27%H" /@'7_-''*#>*4O/@$U'*= ,7%$0UBU'"K#>U8
`/@/*=U'*)Q#% A7>7>/*6'",:W2"?-N6';:';"#>=N=[;#%$0" ,#%B#%';",%CDW-*#aMR0/@$b4c7>"/*$0,
".-"B7>/@';".$0U16*"#9"/]".-*#Q$0/ d4e#%$K" /@'f/4g6'*,K/ 27> "#>=h,.;i#%M j$0#+".-*#M4e/d
2/:U'*)k"0:b/lmYnJ16*USo#% A ,U'*#>p#%'*, [#]"/Q,K#%'*=ZA'*=TqnB*,#%6*=/@';8rB,$&#
('*#>p#%'*,K2[;#Q"/9/@1*"?U'tsvuYwC9x'P"?-*#L7>/@';".$;$08ZU'*=2[* =6U,9Y8Q:,"K#L+U$0)#
B/@6';"y/H4"UB#b".$'*,04O#%$$0U'*)6':';"#>=B#>,,?)#>,"/j"?-*#>($7>/*6*"#%$0,z'*=B,/@$0"&
('*)M".-$0/@6*)@-M".-*/,K#gB#>,K,.)#>,b/@'*7>#^".$'*,&4e#%$$&#>=Z@"K/".-*#{/U'"b".-"b".-*#>8+Y8L1#
2US#> 8]"/L1#>7>/*B#/[#%$0:^-*#>(a#>=Q18+,.9C
|6*"/@"K27^}c~hB#>".-*/*=,$&#:b#>2,.6* "#>=M4e/@$==$0#>,,K('*)B".-* ,b$0/@1* #%9Z*,U'*7>#
,.B#>,,?)#>,7%'k1{#= ,"U'*)@6* ,.-*#>=f4c$0/@".-*#kE #>) "UH"#>IQ#%H2Aa#>,,.)#>,
1#>7%6*,#B/4z".-*#>U$^$0" 7%6*U$<4e/@$K9Z*[/@7%;16*(;$08Z;'*=Q:b/@$0=9""#%$K'*,%Z:j-* 7>-97%'
1#4O/@6'*=]('".-*#-*#%=#%$b/*$1/*=89/4z".-*#B#>,,.H)#>,%C
D-*#B,.! "#%$&('*)k$0/*1*2#%7%'P1#,K#>#%'k,9$0"K27%6*U$U'*,".'*7>#+/4A".-*#
D#>p*""#>);/@$0 %" /@'P$0/@1* #%ODn>Z{(':j-* 7_-P/*'*28P"0:b/L7>U,K,#>,$0#/;,,U1* #l
c '*=k O OYCz/:b#>[#%$>Z;,U'*7>#/@'*# ,".-*#^/@/,K2"K#/4y".-*#^/".-*#%$>Z* "j ,/
7%'Q1{#J,K#>#%'NH,".-*#$0/@1* #%/4A =#%'"d4O8@U'*)P,U'*) #B7>U,,%Z r Cj}'9".-* ,:Y8Z
".-*#9#>[XU6"K2/*'t/H4g6*"/@M" 79,.! "#%$&('*)f,8*,"#%B,B7%'1#9=/@'*#P18T6*,U'*)
7>/@B/@'+B#%,?6$0#>,b/45}c~O$0#>7> , /@'Z$0#>7% OZ#>"7Cn>C|'*/".-*#%$bU{/@$0".;'"b ,,.6*# ,
".-*#g$&#>(H" [#jU{/@$0".;'*7>#j1#>"0:b#>#%'"?-*#j"0:b/"08r{#>,A/4y/;,,U1* #B ,7>U,,d!7%" /@'*,Yl
-* #9'P6*"/@H"#>=9! "#%$".-"B ,,#>,+,? A#%$07>#%';".);#/4A,.M%8P1#
7>7>#%*".1* #"/Qa/,"6*,#%$0,%Z4e#>:b#%$^#>/@* #9$0#B (SH#>28o"/H7>7>#%*"Ja!2"K#%$".-"U';
7>/@$$0#>7>" 8 =#%';"d!#>,g,.M {#%$07>#%';".)#^/4y #>) "U"K# ,A,.;9Z*#>,.#>7>U 8
4".-* ,U* #>,B".-*#L6*"/*" 7= ,7%;$0=U'*)N/H4A".-*#B ,7>U,,d4O#>=\ #>) "U"K#LB#>,0
,.)#>,%CzD-* ,j$&/@1* #%,.6*))#>,K",b".-*#7>/@'*, =#%$"K2/*'+/45B ,7>U,,K!7%H" /@'97>/,K",4e/@$
".-*# #%$'*U'*)Q'*=9#>[XH(6H" /@']/4y,.!2"K#%$,8*,"#%a,%C
}c'o$0#>7>#%'"8;#%$0,%Z+[,"B/*6'"^/4"K#>7_-'* 6*#>,J-Y[#1#>#%'f* #>=\"/9DZ
7_-* #>[*U'*)U$0#>,, [#{#%$4O/@$'*7>#>,U'+,/@B#7%H,#>,%Cz*/@B#^/4".-*#"/*;¡r#%$4O/@$J
('*)B#>"?-*/@=,b$0#j¢'*,#%B1*2#>,b/4£#>7> , /@'9D$0#>#>,js¤m%¥¦wZ@6{/@$0"b§z#>7>"/@$©¨H7_-*U'*#>,
sªYwZ«/@/;,"U'*)QsUm%¬¦w5;'*=Q}c'*,".;'*7>#?¡r1,#>=P#%$'*U'*)PsUm%®YwC
¯! "#%$0U'*)B-,A ,/1#>#%'a".$0#%"#>=B,A^$0" 7%6*U$z7%H,#b/4DCb/@-*#%'9sd°>w
6*,#>=NBB#>".-*/*=Q1,#>=9/*'9Db±}O£±f:b#>2)*-"U'*)L;'*=9".-*#$6* # #%$'*U'*)9 )/@$0 ".-
~}c²²A¢A~³"/^7>(H,,d4e8'*=! "#%$©#% OCA-B*#>"AOCbsUm%q¦w6*,#>=".-*#V^ [#«Y8#>,
$0/@7>-9"K/B! "#%$,?#% OC£$K6*7_S#%$<#>"jOCs¬¦w57>/*$0#>=Q6{/@$0"§z#>7>"/@$
¨H7_-*U'*#>,JO*§^¨kn>Z@1{/@/;,"U'*)B/45buCd¬^".$0#>#>,%Z~}²A²A¢~´'*=9~b/*7>7_-* /Z7>/*'*7>(6*=U'*)
q
".-"*§^¨ ,J'*=\1{/@/;,"U'*)N$&#".-*#"/*;¡r#%$4O/@$a('*)Qa#>".-*/@=,B'*=f,.6*))#>,"K('*)
".-"*§j¨ v,j;$0#, )@-;" 8k1#>""#%$WU']=2,K"U'*)@6* ,.-*U'*)N"?-*#"0:b/"08r{#>,j/4a2,K7>(H,,d
!7%" /@'C|'*=$0/@6*"K,/@/*6*2/;,J'*=P7>/ #%)@6*#>,B7>/@;$0#>=\-a ,Vj [#+«Y8#>,
)@U'*,"^".-*#Db ¨k«bf¨N#%a/@$08;1,#>=9 #%$'*#%$Bsq¦wZ'*=Q7>/@B1*U'*#>=P".-*#>,#":b/;
$0/@7>-*#>,U'f9,".H7_S/47>U,,K!#%$&,:j-* 7_-(M$0/[#>=\"?-*#L#%$4O/@$M'*7>#QsUm%°¦wC+}c'
".-*#>U$:b/@$SZz".-*#>,K#Q6*"/@$0,M(';".$0/*=6*7>#Q7>/;,"0c,#%'*, " [#]#>[XU6"K2/*'tB#%,?6$0#>,L'*=
":b/Q61* 7Q="?9,#>",YZ".-*#L² mPsUmKw'*=k".-*#9U'*)@sqYw0Z:j-* 7>-\B )@-;"1#?
7>/@B#,".;'*=$0=Q1#%'*7>-$KS+7>/@$/*$4e/@$<".-*#$0/@1* #%9C
}c'o".-* ,J;#%$>Zz:b#,?-*/X: "?-"".-*#M|j=«/*/,"B )/@$0 ".-: ".-P7>/*';!=#%'*7>#?¡
$"#>=t$0#>= 7>" /@'*,+ ,LP[#%$&8\:b#> b,.6* "#>= )/*$0 ".-4O/@$B==$0#>,,U'*)f".-*#9,.
!2"K#%$0U'*)J$0/@1* #%9C #-Y[#/@1*".U'*#>=B[#%$08B7>7%6$"#7>U,,d!#%$0,/@'"0:b/7>/@${/@$Z
'B#> 8J² mb'*=U'*)@9Z*'*=B:b#-Y[#A/*1*,#%$0[#>=".-"".-*# )/*$0 ".- ,z[#%$08
$0/@16*,""//[#%$!"K"U'*)C|g'*/"?-*#%$A=['"?)#/4y6*,U'*)B|^=«/@/,K"A ,b".-"'*/B$0 /@$
4e#%"?6$0#^! "#%$0U'*)L ,'*#>#>=#>=P,U'*7># "j ,1* #"/B# L7> #%';" 8N;')#U$0)#^4O#%".6$&#
,#>",J/H4y"#%'*,^/4y".-*/@6*,?'*=,.n>C
}c'".-*#,K#>7>/@'*=N$&"/4A".-*#B#%$W:b#,.-*/: -*/: U'*7%$0#%,K('*)9"?-*##>p$0#>,, [#?
'*#>,,b/4".-*#1,#W2#%;$'*#%$0,A7%;'L1{#j#>p* / "#>=4O/@$©/@1*".U'*U'*)B".-*#E.-* )@-;¡r$&#>7>2,K2/*'*I
!2"K#%$0,L"?-"L$0#Q'*#>#>=#>=³4e/*$$0#%j6*,K#%$* 7%" /@'*,%C #P-Y[#9#>[XU6"K#>=t".-*#
$0#>,.6* ",/4A,.6*7>-! "#%$0,6*,U'*)9".-*#BB#%,.6$0#>,Û'"?$0/@=6*7>#>=o('fsUm_wZ:^-*27>-]".S#U'"/
7>7>/@6';"".-*#B ,7>U,,K!7%H" /@']7>/,",%Z'*=Q-Y[#,?61*,".';"U 89(M$0/[#>=9".-*#$0#?
,.6* ",ga#%'" /@'*#>=]U'9".-"b:b/@$SC
D-*#L;#%$ ,J/*$0)@'* >#>=T,4O/ /X:W,%lJ*#>7>"K2/*'\q2,B=#>[/;"#>=\"K/9#>pr*UU'f".-*#
|j=«/*/,"^ #%$'*U'*)Q )/@$0 ".-;'*=Q".-*#[X$0U';",6*,#>=PU'Q"?-*#7>/@;$" [##>p
#%$0UB#%';",%C}c'h,K#>7>" /@'´°f".-*#P,#>""K('*)T ,P$0#>,#%';"#>=h(' =#>". OZU'*7>(6*=U'*)h".-*#
7>/@$/*$L;'*=Q".-*##>pr{#%$0UB#%'"?5a#>".-*/@=/;2/;)8Q6*,#>=C*#>7>" /@']u9$0#%/@$&",".-*##>p
#%$0UB#%';",7%$K$0 #>=9/@6*"'*=9".-*#$0#>,.6* ",W/@1*".U'*#>=Cz±zU' 8Z,K#>7>" /@'9¬7>/@'*7>U6*=#>,
'*=Q,#>7>"K2/*' B/@6*" U'*#>,,/@B# U'*#>,W4e/@$4 6$0"?-*#%$$0#>,#%$&7_-C
jW0
}c'T"?-*2,M,#>7>" /@'T"?-*#9)#%'*#%$ >#>=t|^=«/@/;,"L )/@$&2"?- : ".-f7>/@';!=#%'*7>#?$H"#>=
$0#>= 7>" /@'*,sUm>uYwy ,=#>,7%$&(1{#>=Z$0#>,".$&27>"K('*)+"/B".-*#7%,#/4A1*U'$08+7>(H,,d!7%" /@'C
D-*#L6$K/,#+/41/*/,"U'*)P ,J"K/+!'*= ]-*2)*-*28f7>7%6$"#M7>(H,,d!7%" /@'T$6* #
18f7>/@B1*U'*('*)T';8 A
/@$:b#%Sf-8/"?-*#>,#>,.n>Z#%7>-f/4j:j-* 7>-tY8
1#k/@'* 8´B/*=#%$"#> 8´7>7%6$H"#C} "9 ,N,,?6B#>=h".-*#k#>p*2,K"#%'*7>#k/4f,#%$"K#
$0/@7>#>=6$&#L7% #>=f".-*#
©4e/@$H7> r6*U$0U'*)P".-*#B:b#%SP-8/"?-*#>,#>,%CD-*#
1/*/,"U'*) )/@$&2"?-h!'*=,AW,#>"/4:b#%Sj-;8/".-*#>,K#>,A187% U'*)".-*#:b#%S^ #%$'*#%$
$0#%#%"K#>=28+U'9,#%$0 #>,/4 ´$0/*6'*=,%CAD-*#>,#^:b#%S-;8r{/".-*#>,#>,$&#j".-*#%'+ U'*#%$0 8
7>/@B1*('*#>=]U'"/9,U'*) #$6* #7% #>=P".-*#

; @ C
"!$#%
'&$(*),+.-"(*)./10*("/
32
'465 87 :9 6;8<>= 5 ?<
°
D-*#|^=«/*/," #%$'*U'*)9 )/@$0 ".-
A l "!$#r&%('*),+-'n,.-'/ 021 nn
3 45 ! m 76
8 X1 5 n:9 m-; 6
3 4=< ! m 2
>(?9A@CBDE FBDHG4IJBKzG &) 8 c? n
W-*/@/,K#=L ? MON
3 P5 ! m Q6 ? n&#>prVUWL ? +-'X> ? &%K'Onn
8 ?SR X1 5 nT9 8 5
Y?
Z Y ? ,z7>-*/,#%'B,/^".-" 8 ?SR 1 : 1{#<^= ,"?$0U16*" /@'
\[]
^J_ ".-*#7>/@B1*U'*#>=k-8/;".-*#>, ,%l z` &% n! b a L ? > ? % n
? 0J1
#>
" 7!$#r % 1 )c+ 1 dn )-e-e\ef)X % / )c+ / ,n .b1#A"?-*#A,#>"/4 6 ".$H('*U'*)^#>pr;* #>,%Z:j-*#%$0#
#%7_-a('*,K".'*7>#g%K'1#> /@'*),W"/U'*,".;'*7>#j,.H7>#h'*=O+\' M #]Umi),jBm
. ,"?-*#7>U,,
/@$U1{#>A,,/*7>U"#>=P"
/ %K'0CD-*#B)/@/H4A".-*#B2#%;$'*U'*)Q$0/@7>#>=6$&# ,"/$&/@=6*7>#
M4 6'*7>" /@'o/4b".-*#B4O/@$k
`t4
l hml N Z*,.6*7>-P".-H"%Z4e/*$'8]#>pr;* O
# % Z".-*#, )@'
/n
4 `z& %n ,^(';"#%$$&#>"#>=Q,b".-*#$0#>= 7>"#>=]7>(H,,JV Um^/@o
$ jBm%n>Z'*=9"?-*#)@'* ".6*=#
p `z& %n p ,U';"#%$$0#>"K#>= ,BQB#%H,.6$0#+/47>/@';!=#%'*7>#9U'k".-*#9$0#>= 7>" /@'Ck6*7>-\
4 6'*7>" /@'7%'+1#J6*,K#>=9#>2"?-*#%$4e/*$A7>U,K,d4e8*U'*)L/@$W$'S;('*)+'*#>: 6'*,K#>#%'9#>p* #>,%C
D-*#j*,K#%6*=/¡@7>/*=#/4|j=«/*/,"2,$0#>,K#%'"#>=+U'|^ )/@$0 ".- mCz} "U';".U'*,
k[#>7>"K/@$/H4:#> )@-;",Q,9o=2,K".$0U16*" /@' 8 /X[;#%$B#>pr;* #>,%C D-*#P)/@H/4".-*#
j )/@$&2"?- ,"/!'*= P:b#%Sf-8/;".-*#>, ,L:W2"?-TB/@=#%$K"#> 8T /X:
#%$$0/@$©: ".-$0#>,.{#>7>"b"/".-*#>,#^:b#>2)*-",YCy}c'* "U 8Z".-*#j= ,"?$0U16*" /@' 8 1 ,6'*d4e/*$9Z
16*"z".-*#1/*/,"U'*)JH2);/@$0 ".- #>p/@'*#%';"U 8L6="K#>,z".-*#:b#> )@-"K,y/@'#%7>-B$0/@6'*=
"/4e/@$&7>#".-*#:b#%SB #%$'*#%$W"/B7>/@'*7>#%';".$"#^/@'+".-*##>p* #>,^:j-* 7_-9;$0#-$0=#>,"
"/L$0#>= 7>"18+".-*#$0#>7>#>=U'*)Q-;8r{/".-*#>,#>,%C
¨P/@$0#A$0#>7> ,#> 8Z* #>" 8 ? 1{#b".-*#A= ,".$&(16*"K2/*'"z$0/@6'*= < Z'*P
= > ? n
l hql N ".-*#
:#%;SL$6* #7> 6*U$0#>=N7>7>/*$0=U'*)9"/ 8 ? C}']".-* ,j,#>"K"U'*)Z:b#%S+-8/"?-*#>,#>r
, > ? & %n
,/S#$0#%d¡@[U6*#>=Q7>/@';!=#%'*7>#?¡r$K"#>=Q$0#>= 7>" /@'*,OCv#CUZ*".-*#, )@'M/n
4 > ? & %n ,
".-*#J$0#>= 7>"#>=P7>U,,YZ'*= p >K?. %n p ,jU';"#%$$0#>"K#>=H,jB#%,?6$0#/4z7>/@';!=#%'*7>#U'
".-*#L$0#>= 7>" /@'n>CM| $B#>"K#%
$ L ? ,".-*#%'7_-*/,K#%'N;'*=k".-*#= ,".$&(16*"K2/*' 8 ? ,
6="#>=CzD-*#7_-*/;27>#/s4 L ? : 21#=#>"#%$BU'*#>=1;8j".-*#"08r{#z/4:b#%Sb #%$'*#%$,K#>#
'*#>p@"^,#>7>" /@'n>Cb}c']".-*#"08* 7%y7%H,#".-
" L2?A ,/,K2"K2[;#Z".-*#B6="K('*)+4c6'*7>" /@'
=#>7%$0#%,#>,k/@$U'*7%$0#%,#>,?nB".-*#9:b#> )@-"K, 8 ? 5 n4O/@$B:j-* 7>t
- > ? SH#>,L])/@/*= /@$
1=nA$0#>= 7>" /@'Z'*=".-* ,A[$0U" /@'M ,$0/*/@$0"K2/*'"/"?-*#7>/@';!=#%'*7># p > ? & %('en p C
& (*),+>-"(*)"/ 0*("/
u
D -*#B!'b-8/"?-*#>, ,%ZH`Z7>/*6*"#>, ",B$0#>= 7>" /@'*,6*,U'*)k+:#> )@-;"#>=k[;/"#B/4
".-*#:b#%SL-;8/".-*#>,K#>,%C
}c'+sUm¦u%w "z ,A$0/[#%'".-"".-*#b".$H('*U'*)#%$$0/@$ /4".-*#b|^=«/@/,K"A )/@$0 ".- OCv#C
".-*#b4c$7>" /@'/4".$U'*U'*)#>p* #>, 5 4e/@$ :j-* 7>-B".-*#, )@'a/4 `z& %(' n= #%$&,z4c$0/@C
+\'en
2,"Aa/,
" ? 021 Y ? Z;:j-*#%$0# Y ? ,".-*#j'*/@$M 2%H" /@'B4c7>"/*$7>/@6*"#>=/*'$0/@6'*=
< CAD-* ,j6{#%a$j1{/@6'*=9 ,j6*,#>=9U'9)*6*2=U'*)+".-*#^=#>, )@'9/4z1/".-M".-*#$KB#>"#%o$ L2?
'*=P".-*#
A )/@$0 ".-Z:j-* 7_-kH""#%*",^"/M!'*=\M:#%;SQ-;8r{/".-*#>, ,
> ? ".-"^BU'*(a2>#>, Y ? C
& (*),+>-"(*)"/ 0*("/
!
c} 'hsUm>uYw".-$0#>#9=#%$0#%';"B[X$0U';",B/4j|^=«/*/,"$0#+=#?!'*#>=Zb7>/@$$0#>,?/@'*=U'*)k"/
".-$0#>#B=#%$&#%'"B#>".-*/*=,^4e/*$7>-*/@/;,U'*)9".-*#L ? [U6*#>,J'*=P7% 7%6*U"U'*)Q"?-*#J$0#?
=27>"K2/*'*,/45"?-*#:b#%S+-8/"?-*#>,#>,%Cb}c'9"?-*2,^:b/@$SM:b#7>/@'*7>#%'"?$"#/@'|j=;«A/*/,"
ze # "%$ H Y ,U'*7>#9 "B2,M".-*#9/@'*#+".-"-,7>-*2#>[;#>=T".-*#1{#>,"
$0#>,.6* ",^('".-*#D #>p@"jW"#>)/@$&2%H" /@'+=/@U'PsUmY¬>w0C
|^7>7>/@$0=U'*)P"/9".-* ,B,#>""U'*)Z :#%;SN-;8/".-*#>,K#>,a;$0#B,U* #Q$6* #>,J:W2"?-k$0#%d¡
[XU6*#>=\$0#>= 7>" /@'*,YC6*7_-],U* #L$K6*2#>,"K#>,"j"?-*#J[U6*#B/4L1{/@/;2#%;'k$0#>= 7%"#
'*=MS#$0#>= 7>" /@'91H,#>=/@'M".-"z[U6*#CD-*#^$0#>= 7%"#>,6*,#>=9$0#?4e#%$©"/".-*#
$0#>,#%'*7>#/H4 a7>#%$0".U'M:/*$0=LU'+".-*#"K#>p@"%Z;#Cv)CEK".-*#j:b/@$&= ;#%$0,bU'+".-*#
B#>,,.);#>IC±/@$M 28Z1,#>=9/*'Q) [#%'Q$&#>=27%H"
# &Z{/@6$bU'"K#%$0#>," #>,/@'+:b#%S
-8/"?-*#>,#>r
, >:j-* 7_-]S#$&#>=27>"K2/*'*,/4y".-*#4e/@$K9l
?< #
% ; # 6; 4 5"9
5"9 =
>&%nT!
('*),+
)
1
d4-&Q-*/;2=,Û'
/".-*#%$0:W2,K#
%
:j-*#%$0#"?-*#
'*= 1<;$0#$0#%y'*6B1#%$0,YC
),+
)
±/*$+) [#%'\$&#>=27%H"#.&Z ".-*#[XH(6*#>,
'*= 1$&#J7%H27%6*U"K#>= ,4e/;2 /:,%C
),+
)
#>0
" /11#+".-*#,.61*,#>"B/4#>p* #>,4e/*$^:j-* 7_-o".-*#9$0#>= 7%"#0&\-*/ =,'*=k #>"
/
1{#".-*#,.61*,#>"/4z#>pr;* #>,^4e/@$<:j-* 7_-]".-*#B$0#>= 7%"1
# &Q=/*#>,'*/"g-*/;2=C^#>"
+
s 32w ZH4e/@$W'8+$0#>= 7%"4
# 2©Zr1{#m^5
4 2P-*/ =,j;'*7
= 6B/".-*#%$0:W2,K#
C 8 [#%'+".-*#7%6$K$0#%'"
=2,K".$0U16*" /@' 8 ?Z*".-*#^4O/ /X:W('*)+$0#%'*6B1#%$0,$&#j7% 7%6*U"#>=4e/*
$ 9 M #:6K)Y
m .@Z'*=
4e/@<
$ ; M # jBim )-Um .@l
=?>
@
! b / 8 ? 5 n>s %(' M
' 021
/
+\'J! Kw ]e
;
>BA
D -" ,%Z =C@ > ,J"?-*#L:b#> )@-;"%Zz: ".-f$0#>,.{#>7>""/Q"?-*#L= ,".$&(16*"K2/*' 8 ? Zz/4".-*#
".$U'*U'*)B#>prM*2#>,W('+$0"K2"K2/*'D/ :j-* 7_-9;$0#/47>U,,E;C|j, " ,b,.-*/:j'BU'PsUm¦u%w
>
¬
Y?
,ga('*UB >#>=P4O/@$b$&" 7%6*(;$j$0#>= 7%"K#J1;8L7>-*/@/;,U'*)l
R1 e
q
1
L ? ! mCAD-*#>,#,#>""U'*),W(M*289"?-"%l
) >
'*=N1;8L,K#>""U'*)
m
!
=C>
U'
=
0m%n
>
Y ? !´q b
R1 1e
1
=?>
Oqn
=?>
D-@6*,YZ".-*#$0#>= 7%"# &97>-*/,#%'9 ,"?-"b4O/@$b:j-* 7>-9".-*#[U6*#/4 Y ? ,^,. #>,"%C
§z#%$08f,. /*$>#%$&/k[XU6*#>,M4e/*$"?-*#Q$B#>"K#%$0, =C@ > 7%6*,#
$&#>=27>"K2/*'*,
) >
"/ 1{#kU$0)#P/@$MU';!'* "#\U'h)*'*2"?6*=#C}' $K7>" 7>#Z^,.6*7_-U$0);#
$&#>=27>"K2/*'*,
Y8Q7%6*,#+'@6B#%$&27%H$0/@1* #%B,"/9".-*#LH2);/@$0 ".-9Z'*=o,#>#%"/9U'*7%$0#%H,#".-*#
"#%'*=#%'*7>89"/B/[#%$!"%C|^,,.6*))#>,K"#>=9U'ksUm%¬¦wZ*".-*#^4O/ /:U'*)L,.a/@/"?-*#>=9[XU6*#>,W4e/@$
-Y[#1#>#%'7>/@'*, =#%$0#>=l
+
>
) >
!
) >
) [@U'*) ".-*#[U6*#9m-;
6
q
m
j e
R1
1 j =C>
U'
CzD-* ,j,?B/@/;".-*U'*)L #>7>",b".-*#[XH(6*#B/4
j
R R j
j 1
Y?! b
>
O°n
=C>
=?>
=
>
=
>
+
Y
j e
R j =?>
=
>
=
>
,b4O/ 2/:,Yl
u@n
O} "z ,(M/@$0"?'"z"K/,#>#".-"".-*#,K/^4 $z$&#>,#%'"K#>=J:b#%S$6* #>,b7%'B1#=U$0#>7>" 8
,#>#%'9,b=#>7> , /@'9".$&#>#>,:W2"?-9,K('*);2#U'"#%$K''*/@=#L:^-*27>-+"#>,"K,"?-*#j[U6*#/45
1/*/ #%'P$0#>= 7%"#%n^'*=Q"0:b/B2#%X4'*/@=#>,".-H") [#"?-*#$0#%dc[XU6*#>=\$&#>=27>"K2/*'*,
4e/@$W".-*#":b/L{/,,U1* #/@6*"K7>/@B#>,^/4A".-*#"K#>,"%CjDW-*#>,##>p*".$0#%B#> 8],U* #=#>7> , /@'
".$0#>#>,j$&#,/@B#>"UB#>,W7% 2#>= > *j CA}'9".6$K'Z".-*#1/*/ #%']$0#>= 7%"#>,
7%'´1#o,#>#%'´,P1*(';$084e#%"?6$0#>,\:b#P: 2B6*,#k".-*#o:/*$0= _ fU'*,"#%H=´/4
O+4c$0/@i'*/:/@'n>C]D-@6*,YZz".-*#9U$0#%=8k=#>,7%$&(1{#>=t7%$0 "#%$&2/*'o4e/@$g!'*=U'*)
".-*#L1#>,K"J:b#%S]$6* #Zz/@$".-*#L1#>,K"4O#%".6$0#Z 7%'\1{#L,K#>#%'k,J]'".6$Hz,.* 2"K"U'*)
7%$0 "#%$0 /@'Q;'*=N6*,#>=+4O/@${#%$4e/*$BU'*)L=#>7> , /@';¡*".$0#>#U'*=6*7>" /@'fsUm¦u%w0C
±/;2 /:U'*)9".-*#2=#%,.6*))#>,K"#>=QU'fsUm>uYwz:#B-Y[#B#>p@"#%'*=#>=P".-*#
)/@$0 ".-"/LU'*=6*7>#9$1* ".$;$0 28o=#>#%P=#>7> , /@'k"?$0#>#>,%CBD-*#,.* ""U'*)P7%$0 "#%$0 /@'
6*,#>=97>/@'*, ,",W('+7>-*/*/,U'*)B".-*#^4e#%H".6$0#^".-"a('*UB >#>,#> 6" /@'kOq;n>Z:j-* #".-*#
$0#>= 7>" /@'*,"y"?-*# #%Y[#>,z/4".-*#1/*/,"#>=B".$&#>#>,A$0#A);2[;#%'18#> r6H" /@'90m%n>CV/"K#
".-"".-*#);#%'*#%$|^=«/@/;,"$0/@7>#>=6$&#J$0#%H('*,6'*7>-'*)#>=C
}c'".-* ,#%$>Z :b#J:W2 =#%'*/"#L,
^".-*#B|j=;«A/*/,"H2);/@$0 ".-U';
7>(6*=U'*)]".-*#B#>p@"#%'*=#>=
C
ge/@$
AU'P,/@B#!)@6$0#>,.n
: 2,".'*=]4O/@$+ #%$'*#>=k7>U,K,d!#%$:W2"?-P:b#%S9$6* #>,B/4=#%*".- C|^,J+,?#>7>U
7%,#Z
#6 5:W2 z1#=#%'*/"#>=NH,
>C
# 6; 4
; 4 5"9 %
% #
&$(*)>+>-"(*)./10*("/
! /?( ("#$#%'&
$&$(*),+>-"(*)"/10 ("/ ( /?( ("#$#%'&*),+- .."/)102+
3 /:( ("#4#%'&5) 6874&*9:<;=%
z ?
?
%
D-*##%*U$0 7%b#>p#%$0UB#%';",U'o".-* ,:b/@$S]-Y[#1#>#%'f#%$4O/@$B#>=o/@']":b/Q61;
2 7f7>/@${/@$f4O/@$+".-*#f'"Kc,?#% ! "#%$&('*)´$0/*1*2#%lt".-*#f² mk'*=´".-*#
U'*)@9C 1 DW-*#Q² mL7>/*$6*,7>/@';".U'*,L{#%$0,/@'^B#>,,.);#>,a;'*=T,. B#>,0
,.)#>,%CzD-*#U'*)@37>/@$6*,A7>/*'".H('*,B#>,K,.)#>,#>p@".$K7>"#>=B4c$0/@ ".-*#g('*)*6*2,K"
2 ,"A;'*=J,? a#>,,.)#>,YCyD1* #<°{CUmA,?-*/X:W,".-*#b, >#>,z/4".-*#":b/7>/*$/@$KCyx'".-*#
/@'*#j-'*=Z;".-*#j#%$&7>#%'".H)#/4,. #% ,b/@'".-*#jU'*)@; ,K#>#%B,A"/1{#jB/@$&#
$0#% ," 7B".-'9"?-*##%$07>#%';".)#/@'+".-*#B² mCx'".-*#/".-*#%$^-'*=Z"?-*#"/@* 7>,^/4
2#>);2"K(M"#B#>,,.H)#>,jU']".-*#B² mJ$&#B/@$0#=2[;#%$0,#B".-'(']".-*#BU'*)@9ZU'
:j-* 7_-] yB#>,,.H)#>,j$0#$&#>(H"#>=Q"/B U'*)@6* ," 7>,%C
D-*#P"0:b/\7>/@$K/@$T;$0#k$0#>,#%';"#>=´$0" " /@'*#>=Ú';"/ m 6P4O/ =,%ZÛ'h/@$0=#%$+"/
#%$4O/@$"?-*##>pr{#%$0UB#%'"K,6*,U'*)Nm 6XO4e/ =97%$0/;,,0c[XH2 ="K2/*'C
D-*#^4O#%".6$0#,K#>"/H45".-*#7>/*$/@$K ,^".-*#7>/@a/@'* 86*,#>=]U'9".-*#"#>p*"b7%"#>)/H
$0 %" /@'] 2"K#%$".6$0#1)Hc/4 c:b/@$&=,jB/*=#>y: ".-P1*U'$084e#%H".6$0#>,%C}'Q"?-*2,a/@=#>OZ
#%7_-M:b/@$0=U'+".-*#W[/@7%;16*(;$08B4O/@$B,bJ1*U'$&8B4e#%H".6$0#Z@;'*=BB#>,,?)# ,$0#%$0#?
,#%'"K#>=-Y[*('*)B".-*#<4e#%"?6$0#>,A7>/@$K$0#>,./*'*=('*)M"/".-*#^/@7>7%6$$&('*)B:b/@$0=,,#>"A"K/".$6*#C
D-*#^4e#%H".6$0#>,A/H4y".-*#² m7>/*$6*,j$0#^) [#%'M#%'*7%$08*"#>=ZU'+/@$0=#%$"/$0/"K#>7>"A".-*#
$0 [X7>8/H4"?-*#j#%$0,K/@'a#>,,.)#>,YCy±/@6$z[;#%$0, /@'*,A/H4"?-*#7>/@${/@$$0#^%[ U1* #Z
=3 #%$0U'*)f/@'f".-*#Q6*,#9/H4g"0:b/N$0#>,K/@6$07>#>,%lQ,"/@;c:b/@$0=f ,"L'*=tP #%M" >#%$>C
D-*#L#%';1*2U'*) H=2,?1* ('{)\/H4<"?-*#>,#L"0:b/Q$0#>,/*6$07>#>,B('o".-*#+)#%'*#%$"K2/*'\$0#>,?6*2"K,JU'
".-*#^4e/;2 /:U'*)M4e/@6$<[#%$0, /@'*,%l
«|~¢lVW/L$0#>,K/@6$07>#>,j6*,#>=CbD-*#^4O#%".6$0#>,^$0#".-*# /:b#%$c7%,#>=]:/*$0=,%C
Dx²Wl*"/@;c:b/@$&=92 ,"6*,#>='*/M2#%M" >#%$>C
¢©¨P¨ l#%M" >#%$^6*,#>= '*/+,"/@;c:b/@$0=9$0#%B/[OC
¢©¨P¨
DWx²l«/".-+ #%M" >#%$j;'*=9,"/@;c:b/@$0=+ ,"g6*,K#>=C
D1* #J°CUm^,.-*/:,W".-*#^4e#%H".6$0#,.7>#=UB#%'*,K2/*'Q/H45".-*#^4O/@6$b[;#%$0, /@'*,%C
! "
#%$'&s^(&K- J*$
) [+&-,
^J\[.,0/ D-*#9B#%,?6$0#>,J6*,#>=o('o".-* ,#%$4O/@$^#>[XH(6H"U'*)
".-*#L,?!2"K#%$0U'*)k,8*,"#%i;$0#U'"?$0/@=6*7>#>=U'k".-* ,B,#>7>" /@'Ck#>" '*=21 1#
".-*#g'*6B1#%$b/H4,?'*=L #>) "UH"#B#>,,.H)#>,AU'+".-*#^7>/@$6*,%Z$0#>,?#>7>" [#> 83 #>"
4653798 :<;3= >?=A@CBD=E@F FA@8 GH@8?86IKJ FALEFEMNIKFAOPIK8 GQ@=SR :<7T8 GU=EINIK=E;VMNWTX FZY[Y\@8?]C]
^P_\_S`(aCb\bSc\c\c.d6e\e?_-dUfPgAhPiAj\k9eE_li\m'don\klb\peEiAqTrsqPf\k
E
?
¥
² m
mZ36®;®
u@ªm
m%ª
u@°Cd¥
q Zvuu@®
q;°Z°m%q
q Zq¥¬
q;°ZUm%°¥
¨P#>,,.H)#>,
#>);2"K(M"#
«|~¢, >#
¢©¨P¨ ,K2>#
Dx²³, >#
¢©¨P¨ DWx²T, >#
,
,
U'*),.
qZª®;°
u@ªm
qZvumYq
m C
¬Zd¥q°
V|
V|
V|
* Dy1* #+mlz£UB#%'*, /@'*,^/4z".-*##>[XU6"K2/*'97>/@${/@$C
R =#%'*/"#".-*#+'@6B1#%$/4,?iB#>,K,.)#>,".-H"$0#B7>/@$$0#>7>"K28P7>U,,K!#>=T1;8
,8@,K"#%9Z@;'*= ".-*#j'*6B1#%$/4,? B#>,K,.)#>,AB ,7>U,K,d!#>=Q,A #>) "U"K#CA}c'
".-*#b,.B#b:Y8Z% #>" R '*=
1{#b".-*#j'*6J1{#%$/4 #>) "U"#^B#>,,.);#>,z7>(H,,d!#>=
189B,8*,"#% H,,. ;'*=Q #>) "U"#Z$0#>,.#>7>"K2[;#>28CDW-*#>,#4O/@6$b[U6*#>,4O/@$ 7>/@'"K('*);#%'*7>8J"?1* #:j-* 7_-a,.6$&2>#>,z"?-*#j1#%-Y[*2/*6$/4^,8*,"#%CyD-*#:W2=#> 8;
6*,#>=NB#%H,.6$0#>,j$0#>7> , /@'TOn¦Zr$&#>7% <O$Kn;'*= 9$0#=#?!'*#>=k,4O/ 2/:,Yl
1
&
1
R
! R 2
j 1R
R
! R t
j ! H
=j¯j m%n &
&
B#%,.6$&#j ,A"?-*#g-$KB/@'* 7ga#%'1#>"0:b#>#%'$0#>7> , /@'9;'*=$0#>7%H2OZ'*=
: ".- ! m) [#>,z#> 6@:b#> )".-"/^".-*#b7>/@B1*U'*#>=LB#%,?6$0#>,%C|^== " /@' 8Z,/@a#
#>pr{#%$0UB#%'"K,LU'T"?-*#Q#%$B:W2 jH2,K/k7>/@'*, =#%$M".-*#Q7>7%6$7>8TB#%,?6$0#\
!
RR n>C
|T:Y8"/= ,"U'*)@6* ,.-M".-*#A"0:b/"08#>,z/4B ,7>U,K,d!7%" /@'B ,z".-*#6*,#/46*" 2"08
B#%,.6$0#>,+s®Yw6*,#>=fU'k"?-*#D~W¢A #>[U6" /@'*,9sUmmKwC9}'k".-* ,)#%'*#%$bB#%,.6$0#Z
/, " /@'*,bU'B".-*#W7>/@'"K('*);#%'*7>8".1* #j$&#j,,/*7>U"#>= /,K,z[XU6*#>,%Z i R Z Z R Z
Zy:^-*27>-fU'*= 7%"#Q-*/: =#>,U$;1*2#Q;$0#".-*#+/@6*"7>/@a#>,%Zz7>7>/@$0=U'*)P"/N ]6*,#%$
=#?!'*#>=9,7>#%'$0 /CzD-*#/[#%$K #%$4O/@$;'*7>#j/4,8*,"#% U'M"#%$B,/4"?-*#j6*" 2"08
2,g R i R jt j21 R R j 1 C
|'*=$0/@6*",/*/@6* /,#>"AOCs¤mw$0/@{/,#$0" 7%6*U$©,7>#%'$0 /,('a:j-* 7_-a2,K7>(H,0
,d4e8*U'*)NM2#>);2"K(M"#LB#>,K,.)#B,j,? ,Q
"UB#>,B/@$&#7>/,"K289"?-']".-*#B,8rJ
B#>".$0 7B ,7>U,,d!7%"K2/*'C}'"K#%$B,/46*" 2"08Z;".-*#>,#b,7>#%'$0 /,z7%;'1#W".$'*,U"K#>=
(';"/ i R ! Z ! UmZ R !mUT
'*= ! CNDW-*#>8\ ,/PU'".$&/@=6*7>#
".-*#A¦2,<@O; 44 % #& 4 =Q |j7>7%nB#%,.6$0#Z*:j-* 7>- , *c7>/,K"A,#%'*, " [#7>7%6$H7>8
B#%,.6$0#l
"! ! $$P# 1 #[1 jjt R
D-*#
) )
6
=
6
) )
ª
-*#%'k#>[U6"U'*)]! "#%$0U'*)k,8*,"#%B,YZy"?-*2,B#%H,.6$0#,.6 #%$0,4 $&/@".-*#+,.a#
$0/@1* #%B,9,L,K".'*=$0=tH7>7%6$7>8hsUm%ª¦wC£#>,.* "#Q".-* ,M4 H7>"%ZA:b#9: 6*,#Q "M4e/@$
7>/@$0 ,/*'96$/,K#>,%C
!:
2 C
?!
}c'h/@$&=#%$+"/\7>/*$0#P/@6$+1/*/,"U'*)hB#>".-*/*=,Q)@U'*,"9/"?-*#%$"#>7>-'* r6*#>,YZ:b#
('*7>U6*=#^".-*#$0#>,.6* ",/4".-*#4O/ 2/:U'*) )/*$0 ".-B,z/@'".-*#b":b/#>[U6" /@'7>/@${/@$l
[i<,- Jo\[D[.,0/ *".'*=$&= Db£}O£D #%$'*U'*)´ )/@$0 ".-9Z6*,U'*)t".-*#
~¨ = ,".'*7>#?1,K#>=t4c6'*7>" /@'³4O/@$4O#%".6$0#9,#> #>7>" /@'C #N-Y[#9#>[U6;
"K#>=\ "/@'f"?-*#Q² mL7>/*$6*,%C\*#>#fsUm ¦wb4e/*$7>/** #>"#9=#>". ,;1/@6*"B".-*#
6
$&" 7%6*(;$U* #%B#%';"." /@'C
&sU$4[&
4[',D/
# U'*7>(6*=#+".-*#B1#>,"$0#%{/@$0"#>=P$0#>,.6* ",/@1*"?U'*#>=1;89".-*#
' [#^1%8;#>,$0/*7_-/@'a".-*#j² mj</@$6*,js¤mw'*=/@'a".-*#jU'*)@ sq¦wC
/
U'ksdq>w0C
#U'*7>U6*=#B".-*#J1{#>,"$0#>,.6* ",/@'".-*#U'*)@
7>/*$6*,j$0#%{/@$0"#>=
\&J&4 /
D -*2,^$0/@7>-+7>/@B1*U'*#>,jV^ [#«b%8;#>,<;'*= VjV¯U'Q,".7>S
W
/4^7>(H,,d!#%$0,%Cf*#>[#%$7>/@';!)@6$"K2/*'*,L$0#+#>[XU6"K#>=T/@'k"?-*#U'*)@;
7>/@$K6*,U'ksUm%°¦w {:#$&#%/@$0"b".-*#B1#>,"^$0#>,.6* ",^/45"?-"#%$>C
! 0
D-* ,,#>7>" /@'P$0#>,#%';",)#%'*#%$K5$&/@7>#>=6$0#4O/@$b#%*U$0 7% 8k".6'*U'*)Q+$a#?
"#%$^/4"?-*#J,K8@,"K#%9Z7>7>/@$0=U'*)9"/Q+);2[;#%'P/@*"UB %" /@'7%$0 "#%$0 /@'CBD-*#".6'*U'*)
$0/@7>#>=6$&#J ,^=#>, )@'*#>=]4e/*$1#>U'*)9$0"/4z".-*#+m 6YO4O/ =Q7%$0/,K,0c[X =" /@'P$0/*7>#>,,%C
8 [#%'Bj;$B#>"#%$ &"/1#".6'*#>=Z@;' $
r H '*=J'
eO Z{".-*#$0/*7>#>=6$0# ,^".-*#^4e/;2 /:U'*)l
% 5"9
4 # # 5"9
85
6% #
5"9
mCb±/@$#%7_-".$0UU'9".-*#+m Y6 O4O/ =97%$0/,,&c[X =" /@']$0/@7>#>,K,%l
W,#ª/H4y".-*#®"?$U'*U'*),.61*,#>",<4e/@$© #%$'*U'*)7>U,,K!#%$¦C
#,#> #>7>"
".-*#Bª4O/ =,g$;'*=/@B 8CDW-*#J$0#%H('*U'*)+4O/ =Q ,6*,#>=N,B[ 2=H" /@'
,.61*,K#>"%C
±/@$A$'*)#/H4[U6*#>,b/4".-*#j$;B#>"#%$ & Z"#>,"".-*#^7>(H,,d!#%$/@'B".-*#
[ 2=H" /@'],.61*,#>"%C
% 5"9
qCb±/@$b#%7>-+"#>,"#>=9[U6*#B/4 & @Z 7>/*6*"#"?-*# $
/@6*"?6*",/45H2".-*#".$&(H2,YC
®
6% # J6*,K('*)+".-*#

5.9 4 # # 5"9
5
°Cb|^7>7>/@$0=U'*)+"/".-*#
OO Z,K#>2#>7>""?-*#1#>,"^[XU6*#4O/@$&Q,
".-*#[U6*#B"/1#J6*,K#>=QU'9".-*#^!'H,8*,"#%9C
© b 'D!
?
!
D-*#6$/,K#/4/*6$b!$0,K"#>pr{#%$0UB#%'" ,"/9,.-*/: "?-*#J);#%'*#%$A#%$4e/@$K'*7>#B/4
|j=«/*/,"U'+".-*#,?O! "#%$0U'*)+=/@U'Cb*2p+|^=«/@/,K"7>U,,d!#%$0,-Y[#g1{#>#%'
2#%;$'*#>=ZA,K#>""U'*)k".-*#+=#%*".-f/4j"?-*#9:#%;SN$K6*2#>,a4 $0/* 6]"/k¬ :b#L=#%'*/;"#L#%H7_7>(H,,d!#%$,
Zz:^-*#%$0# ,".'*=,4e/@$".-*#+=#%*".-o/4j".-*#+:b#%SP$6* #>,
,L;$0" 7%6*U$^7%,#Z:b#B=#%'*/"#B".-*#
6 A7>(H,,d!#%$B,
>CJ¢7>[#%$0, /@'B/H4
A-,b1#>#%'M #%$'*#>=M4e/@$6B"/BqZ¬ 6 6W:b#%SB$6* #>,b/@'B".-*#j² m
'*=\mZ 6 6 6:b#%S+$6* #>,^/@'+".-*#U'*)@C
±z )@6$0#9m,?-*/X:W,j".-*# 1B#%,?6$0#/4b#%7_-]7>U,,K!#%$ #%$'*#>=Z,JM4c6'*7>" /@'
/45"?-*#J'*6J1{#%$/H4©$0/*6'*=,g6*,#>=CDW-*#>,#J* /", ,/+7>/@';".U'+".-*#J{#%$4O/@$'*7>#/4
".-*#1,#> U'*#L )/@$0 ".-a,%Cj} "7%'Q1{#,#>#%']".-"
^7> #%$0 8Q/@6*"?#%$4O/@$B,
".-*#k/".-*#%$9H2);/@$0 ".-B,%CD-*#k#>p#%$&(a#%'"P ,/t,.-*/:,9"?-"%Zj;1/[#kf7>#%$0".U'
'@6B1#%$M/4$0/@6'*=,%Zb B[#%$&, /@'*,H7_-* #>[#]7>/@'*, ,"#%';")/*/@=h$0#>,.6* ",%Z
'*=".-"z"?-*#%$0# ,'*//X[;#%$!""U'*)U'B"?-*#j$0/*7>#>,,%Cz|W4e"K#%$bm%¬ 6$0/@6'*=,/41{/@/;,"U'*)Z
[#%$0, /@'*,+$0#%7>-T' 1 [U6*#N1{/[#Q®¥ /@'f".-*#9"0:b/P7>/@${/@$CT}O"M7%'T1#
'*/" 7>#>=\"?-"".-*#+=#>#%#%$".-*#:b#%S]$6* #>,%Z".-*#,.H2 #%$".-*#L'*6B1#%$/4$0/@6'*=,
'*#>#>=#>=T"/k7_-* #>[#+)/*/@=T#%$4e/@$K'*7>#CPD-* , ,a'*/;"J,?6$$0 ,U'*)Zz,U'*7>#9=#>#%{#%$
:#%;SN$K6*2#>,-'*= #QB6*7>-kB/@$0#M(';4O/@$M" /@'C+|j== " /@'H2 8Z".-*#M!)@6$0#,.-*/:,
%[;/@1#".-*#A,"?1* 2 %"K2/*'ZU'*7%$0#%,U'*)".-*#b'@6B1{#%$/4{$&/@6'*=,5$&#>,.6* ",z/@'* 8U',K2 )@-;"
[X$0U"K2/*'*,j/4z".-*# :1jB#%,.6$&#C
|T7>/@'*7%$0#>"K#[U6*#b4O/@$".-*# T$B#>"K#%$/4"?-*#
#%$K'*('*)B )/@$0 ".-
J6*,K"A1#) [#%'Z;U'B/@$0=#%$©"/j/*1*".U'$0#%7>U,K,d!#%$0,'*=M"/1#j;1*2#W"/S#b7>/@J
$0 ,/@'*,1{#>":b#>#%'".-*#= #%$0#%';"[#%$0, /@'*,^/4
j'*=k1,#> U'*#LB#>"?-*/@=,%C
D/]/@6$BS@'*/: #>=)#Z "B2,B,"K2 6'*7> #%$B:j-H" ,B".-*#1{#>,"B:%84e/*$7>-*/@/,K('*) C
x'".-*#² mZ;:#^-%[;##>,"U"K#>=L".-*#
;$B#>"#%$©: ".-M".-*#".6'*U'*)L$0/*7>#>=6$0#
$0#>,#%';"#>=QU'],#>7>" /@']°CvuZ);2[*U'*) ´[XH(6*#>,^4c$0/@m"/+qZ¬ 6 6U'],"#%*,^/4Aq¬'*=
,#> #>7>"U'*)".-*#[U6*#:j-* 7_-+p*UB >#>,".-*# :1<a#%,.6$0#Cz*U'*7>#".-*#j{#%$4e/*$'*7>#
2,b[#%$&8,".1* #'*=+".-*#".6'*U'*)L$0/*7>#>=6$0#^U'[/;2[;#>,U'"#%'*,K#g$0/*7>#>,,U'*)Z{:#^-%[;#
!p@#>=fm3Z 6 6 6B$0/*6'*=,b4e/*$b".-*#7>U,,d!#%$0,^/@'+".-*#BU'*)@7>/@$6*,%C
D1* #>,Jq9'*=\°9$&#>,#%'"".-*#$0#>,.6* ",/4< 7>(H,,d!#%$0,/*'P".-*#B"0:/+7>/@${/@$C
±/@$W#%7>-97>U,,d!#%$>Z:b#U'*7>U6*=#L"?-*#J'*6J1{#%$/H4$0/@6'*=,6*,#>=Z$&#>7% eZ$&#>7>2,K2/*'Z
1 ;'*=\".-*#+p*(B6 1 H7_-* #>[#>=T A/[#%$^".-*#9$0/@6'*=, #%$'*#>=C9|^7>7>/@$0=U'*)
"/L"?-*#a$&#>,.6* ",%Zy1{/@/;,"U'*)97>U,,d!#%$0,7>2#%;$0 8N/*6*".#%$4O/@$".-*#B/".-*#%$H2);/@$0 ".-B,%C
Vj [#«bY8#>,%Z V^V´'*=+".-*#j*"?7_SM7_-* #>[#$0#>7> , /@'9$H"#>,A, )@-;" 8 /:#%$".-;'
:/ ( ("#4#%'&5),+/?( ("#$#%'&
+
/:( ("#4#%'&5) -
2
2
74&*9:<;=%
( /?( ("#$#%'&
/?( ("#$# %&
'
8 /?( ("#$#%'&
/:( ("#4#%'&
2
m
6
$2
P
^,
100
95
90
F1
85
80
Stumps
TreeBoost[1]
TreeBoost[2]
TreeBoost[3]
TreeBoost[4]
TreeBoost[5]
Naive Bayes
Decision Trees
75
70
65
60
55
1
5
25
100
500 1000 2500
Number of rounds
T&4 &4 :^V,
100
95
90
F1
85
80
Stumps
TreeBoost[1]
TreeBoost[2]
TreeBoost[3]
TreeBoost[4]
TreeBoost[5]
Naive Bayes
k-NN
Stacking
75
70
65
60
55
1
±z2)*6$0#Lml
$0/@6'*=,
5
1
25
100
Number of rounds
B#%H,.6$0#/4
500 1000
74&59:<;=%^'*= /:( ("#4#%'&5),+-Z{4e/@$<('*7%$&#%,U'*)'*6B1#%$W/4
mm
[
".-*/,#/*1*".U'*#>=1;81/*/,"U'*)B7>U,,d!#%$0, -*/:#>[;#%$>Z".-*#^/@1*".U'*#>=9$0#>7% $H"#>,$&#
J6*7>-+ /:#%$¦C
D
VC«bY8#>,
£CDy$0#>#>,
$0#>7%H2
ª°Cd®ª
ª®Cdªm
® C u@¥
® Cdªª
® C ¥
® Cdªª
¬q¬
¬q¬
¥q¬
¥¬
u@¬ 6
¬¬ 6
$&#>7>2,K2/*'
®;¬CUmm
ª;ªC¥m
®;¥Cvu@ª
®;¥C® 6
®;ªC°m
®;¥C® 6
>
>
> >
/ ®>Cdªª
74&*9:<;=%
/?( ("#$#%'&*) m/?( ("#$#%'&*)2q6/?( ("#$#%'&*2) °6- /?( ("#$#%'&*) u/?( ("#$#%'&*2) ¬6-
/ ®;ªC¬q
:1 1 /
ª®{CUm%®
ª®{Cq¬
® {C®¥
®¥{C°®
®¥{Cvu@ª
®¥{C°®
®;¥C°®
®;¥C 6
®;¥C¬®
®;¥Cªm
®;ª3C 6m
®;ªCUm%q
>
/ ®¥{C ®
D1* #Jqlz²#%$4O/@$;'*7>#/4©H2 7>(H,,d!#%$0,^/@'+".-*#J² m7>/@$6*,
|^7>7%6$7>8k$0#>,.6* ",B-%[;#a1{#>#%'k7>/*$0#>=\6*,K('*)P".-*#9m 6XO4e/ =k7%$&/,,0c[ 2=H"#>=
U$0#>= < "#>,K"%CA«/@/;,"U'*)B7>(H,,d!#%$0,#%$4O/@$ , )@'*d!7%';" 8Q1#>""K#%$b".-'M£#>7> , /@'
Dy$0#>#>,YC x'+".-*#7>/@';".$$&8Zr'*/M, )@'*d!7%'"^=#%$0#%'*7>#>,j7%;'91#/*1*,#%$0[#>=Q1{#>":b#>#%'
".-*#b=3 #%$0#%';"z[#%$0,K2/*'*,z/4
.C¨P/@$0#U'"#%$&#>,"U'*) 8Z*2"z7%;'J1{#'*/" 7>#>=".-"
7>7%6$7>89'*=9$0#>7> , /@'Q$H"#>,b, 2)*-" 89U'*7%$0#%,K#: ".-+".-*##>p$0#>,, [#%'*#>,,W/4y".-*#
:#%;SL$6* #>,%Z'*=]".-"".-* ,^U$0/[#%B#%';"=/*#>,g'*/"^ #>7>"".-*#J$&#>7% 5$H"#CAD-* ,
4 7>"W: 2z1##>pr* / "#>=]U'9".-*#4e/ /:U'*)#>p#%$0UB#%';",%C
/:( ("#4#%'&
- 0
! !:! !
/:( ("#4#%'&
D-* ,L,#>7>"K2/*'T ,L=#>[;/"#>=t"K/k#>[XU6"K#
B('-* )@-;$0#>7> , /@'¯,7>#%'$0 /,%Z
:j-*#%$0#/@'* 89[;#%$08 /:/@$'@6* Unj$&/@/@$&" /@'+/4 O O r a2,K7>(H,,d!
7%" /@'*, , 2/:b#>=C
/ / [ [
- J
5
^J[$4[.,0/
# ,".;$0"A18B#>[U6"U'*)B:j-*#>".-*#%$z"?-*#7>/@';!=#%'*7>#^/4y$0#>= 7>" /@'ZOCv#CUZ;".-*#j)H
'*2"?6*=#/4z".-*#$0#>= 7>" /@'Z ,jB)/*/@=9U'*= 7%"/*$/4".-*# r6H2 "08+/45"?-*#$0#>= 7>" /@'
/@$'*/"%C±/@$W".-* ,J6${/,#Z$0#0R0#>7>" /@'P7%6$0[;#>,$0#B7>/@6*"#>=]4O/@$^#%7>-]7>(H,,d!#%$>C
D-*#$&/@7>#>=6$0#+"/]7>/@6*"#L]$0#0R0#>7>" /@'k7%6$&[#L ,B".-*#B4O/ /:U'*)lB±/@$U'*7%$0#%,0
('*)T$0/@{/@$0" /@'*, &t1#>"0:b#>#%' 6k'*=´m 6 6ZA$0#0R0#>7>"".-*# & /4g"?-*#92#>,K,L7>/@';!=#%';"
$0#>= 7>" /@'*,%Z1/;".-9/,K2"K2[;#J/*$'*#>)@" [#Z'*=Q7>/@M6*"#".-*#H7>7%6$7>89/4z".-*#$0#?
U'*U'*) 0m 6 6PU &n $&#>=27>"K2/*'*,%C´D-*#9=#>,U$0#>=´1#%-Y[* /@6$ ,+".-"7>7%6$H7>8
[XU6*#>,,.B/*/".-* 8+U'*7%$0#%,#B, /@'*)L, &9U'*7%$0#%,#>,%C
lMNWT>?8 ;38Y[= WT=S: =E;3W :<7T8 =S:<7T86@%>IKFS]C]<MT86@] WT= :C8?]C:C]7TFALZ8 OD8 86W @FAW!3O#"T:BP@8?]$"9R FAOPIKJ
O=\=S]C:<MNWTX R 8?:<7T=\YP] FA@8!FEIK]C=%]<MKXAWPM9>?FEWP:<IHJ OD8?:C:C8@%
m%q
VC«bY8#>,
VjV
*".7>SU'*)
D
74&59:<;=%
/?( ("#$# %&*) m/?( ("#$# %&*)2q6/?( ("#$# %&*2) °6/?( ("#$# %&*) u/?( ("#$# %&*2) ¬6-
$&#>7% ªqCvu 6
ªªC 6
®mC¥ 6
m;Z36
m;3Z 6
m;3Z 6
m;3Z 6
m;3Z 6
m;3Z 6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
/ 6
®¥C° 6
® C ;¥
® Cvu*¥
® Cq
® Cq
> >
> ,
> ,
$0#>7> , /@'
®®C36 6
®¥Cvu6
® C¬ 6
®ªC°°
®ªC¬°
®ªC¬q
®ªC®°
>
/ / :1 1 /
ª;®C®u
®;qC¥®
®;°C®°
/ ®;¥C®m
®;¥C¬®
®;¥C ª
®;¥C ª
®;¥C ª
®ªC°°
®ªCUm%q
®ªCUmm
®ª3C 6m
®¥Cª®
®¥C® 6
Dy1* #B°lz²#%$4e/*$'*7>#/4A 7>U,,K!#%$&,j/@'+"?-*#JU'*)@7>/@$6*,
±z )@6$0#q9* /",".-*#+$0#0R#>7>"K2/*'P7%6$0[#>,7>/@M6*"#>=]4e/@$^"?-*#J,K2pP #%$'*#>=o7>(H,,d
!#%$0,%CzD-$0#>#7%6$&[#>,$&#);2[;#%'BU'B#%7>-* /"%l".-*#7>7%6$7>8B7%6$0[;#Z@'*/"#>=,d|j UZ
".-*#7%6$0[#7>/@'*,K2=#%$&('*)+/@'* 89B ,7>U,,d!7%" /@'*,^/4 rHG 2O a O%Z'*/"#>=Q,
2+"/L ¤Zj'*=h".-*#P7%6$0[#P7>/@'*,K2=#%$&('*)".-*#kB ,7>U,,d!7%"K2/*'*,N/H4L2O a O
, 2"/L UCADW-*#(H""#%$b$0#".-*#6'*= ,U$0#>=P"08#/4z#%$$0/@$&,/H4y".-*#>,#
c Z'*/"#>=Q
,7>#%'$0 /,%CD-*#4O/ /X:W('*)+7>/@'*7>U6*, /@'*,7%'91{#=$Y:j'l
D-*#7>/@';!=#%'*7>#/4+$0#>= 7>" /@'P ,M)/*/@=]('*= 7%"K/@$/4A ",^ 6 2"08CD-*#
-* )@-*#%$".-*#P7>/@';!=#%'*7>#\/H4J".-*#k$0#>= 7>" /@'*,P7>/@'*, =#%$0#>=Z".-*#k-*2)*-*#%$9".-*#
7>7%6$K7>8H7_-* #>[#>=C
D-*#=#%*".-/H4r:b#%S^$6* #>,y)*$0#%" 8^(M$0/[#>,y"?-*#z r6 "08/4".-*#A$0#>= 7>" /@'*,YC
x'o".-*#9² m7>/@$6*,YZy:^-*#%$0#%,
'*#>#>=,B"/N$0#0R0#>7>"B".-*#L¥° /4".-*#
#>,,7>/*';!=#%'"#>p* #>,+"/k7>-*2#>[;#Q\m 6 6 /4g7>7%6$K7>8Z
2¬
/@'* 8L'*#>#>=,q° 9C|´,K(a2U$b16*"b #>,,b, )@'*d!7%';"<1{#%-Y[@ /@6$/*7>7%6$0,b/@'B".-*#
U'*)@;9C\}'f/".-*#%$:b/@$&=,%Zz=#>#%#%$
! "#%$0,7>/@'*7>#%';".$H"#".-*#
B ,7>U,K,d!#>=N#>p* #>,^7> /,#%$W"/B".-*#=#>7> , /@']".-$0#>,?-*/ =C
74&*9:<;=%
/?( ("#$# %&
/?( ("#$#%'&*) 6-
$0#>= 7>" /@'*,j,K#>#%"/L1{#1#>""#%$<".-'+ #>) "U"#B$0#>= 7>" /@'*,%Z,U'*7>#
".-*##%$$0/@$&,y$0/*=6*7>#>=a1;8^".-*#B/;,"7>/@';!=#%';"A$0#>= 7>" /@'*,A$0#z/H4".-*#A"08# "/ UCY| {/,,U1* ##>p*U'" /@'B ,z".-H"y".-*#b7>U,,K!#%$&,$0#b1*U,#>="/$0#>= 7>"
".-*#+B/,"4 $0#> 6*#%';"7>U,,%Z©".-" ,B2#>);2"K(M"#CP/:b#>[#%$>Z ".-*#L$0#>,.6* ",$&#
'*/"W, )@'*d!7%'"^#%'*/@6*)@-M4O/@$b,K"."U'*)".-* , =#%C
|G{/"#%';"Uz!'H#%M z! "#%$0U'*)\* 7%" /@'³7>/@6* =t-Y[#".-*#M4e/;2 /:U'*)
,.{#>7>d!7%" /@'lB¨P#>,,.);#>,:j-*/,#7>/*';!=#%'*7>#L/4".-*#+$0#>= 7>" /@'k ,)@$0#%"#%$
".-;'J^"?-$0#>,.-*/ = ;$0#6*"/@H" 7% 28B7>U,,K!#>=Z*OCv#CUZ;,. B#>,K,.)#>,A$&#
m%°
21* /*7_SH#>='*=Q #>) "UH"#JB#>,K,.)#>,j;$0#=#> 2[;#%$0#>=P"/".-*#6*,#%$¦Cz¨P#>,,.)#>,
:j-*/;,#N$0#>= 7>" /@'7>/@';!=#%'*7>#o2,9 /:b#%$B".-' h
$0#9,"/*$0#>=tU'hk,?#>7>U
4O/ =k4O/@$=61* /@6*,LB#>,K,.)#>,%CPD-*#96*,#%$B-,B"/P[#%$0d4O8kd4g".-*#>,K#$&#L #>) "0
U"K#QB#>,,.);#>,%CtD-* ,,.{#>7>d!7%" /@'h ,,.6* ".;1*2#]4O/@$-Y[*('*)f6*"/@H" 7
! "#%$0,^: ".-]= #%$0#%'"^=#>)@$0#>#>,^/4A,"?$0 7>".'*#>,,OCv#CUZ=3 #%$0#%';"^[XU6*#>,^4O/@$b".-*#
9$KB#>"#%$n¦C +[XU6*#>,7>/@6* =P1#B".6'*#>=N6*,K('*)+".-*#$0/*7>#>=6$0#B/4z,#>7>" /@'
°C uC
/ /
=(,d
s[ ,- -U$4[#%$'&s^(&K- J!/
}c'M".-* ,,K#>7>" /@'Z /?( ("#$# %&7>U,,d!#%$0,$0#^#>[XH(6H"#>=6*,K('*)B".-*#*c7>/,"bB#%,.6$0#>,
(';".$0/*=6*7>#>=f('o,#>7>" /@'f°C+D-$0#>#,7>#%';$0 /,B/4,".$0 7>".'*#>,,B$0#L$&#>,#%'"K#>=kU'tsUmKwl
nbV/7>/;,"b7>/@'*, =#%$0#>=Z7>/@$$0#>,.{/@'*=U'*)L"K/ ! mD 1n*#%a;6*"/@"K27,K7>#%'$0 /Z
4e/@$bBB/*=#%$"#> 8LH7>7%6$"#W! "#%$>Z) [*U'*) !¯®' '*=97%nbb/@* #>"#> 896*"/@H" 7
,7>#%'$0 /Z©4e/*$P[#%$08f-*2)*-t7>7%6$H"#+! "#%$>Zb,, )@'*U'*)
!®®®Cf|^,L'*/"#>=TU'
,#>7>" /@'Q°{Z@:b#: 7>/@'*, =#%$"?-*#>,#,7>#%';$0 /,j,j;$0" 7%6*U$j6*"K2 "08Q".$&27>#>,YC
}c'¯sUm ¦wjP,U* #kB/*=!7%H" /@'T/4".-*#9|^=«/@/;,"L )/@$&2"?-4e/*$-'*= U'*)
)#%'*#%$j6*"K2 "08 H".$0 7>#>,L ,9$0#>,#%';"#>=ChD-*#Q =#%o2,+"/kU'* "U >#\"?-*#Q:b#> )@-"
=2,K".$0U16*" /@'¯/4#>pr;* #>,N7>7>/@$&=('*)T"K/\".-*#P) [#%'h6*" "08 M".$0 pZj'*=h".-*#%'
$6']".-*#B2#%;$'*U'*)Q )/@$0 ".-,6*,.6OC #-Y[#J{#%$4O/@$B#>=P#>p#%$0UB#%';",: ".".-* ,J,K#>""U'*)Zz16*"B".-*#L$0#>,.6* ",$&#L'*/"7>/*'[*U'*7>('*)l/@'* 8k".-*#+U'* "U$0/@6'*=,B/4
1/*/,"U'*)J;$0#j #>7>"#>=L1;8B".-*#U'* "U %" /@'91,#>=+/@'B6*" "8 Y4O"#%$z'@6B1#%$©/4
$0/@6'*=,%Z".-*#J{#%$4O/@$'*7>#,#>#%B,"K/1{# US#B4'*/96*" "8P-=N1{#>#%'97>/@'*,K2=#%$&#>=C
*('*7>#o/@6$$0/*7>#>=6$0#]4e/*$".6'*U'*)f".-*#k'@6B1{#%$/4J$&/@6'*=,L7%;'t'*/"=#>"K#%$BU'*#
:j-*#%'9".-*#U'*2"K(Hz,".)##%'*=,YZ:b#-Y[#J$&#0R#>7>"#>=]".-* ,g;$0/@7>-C #".-*U'S+".-"
'9$0/@*U"K#B/@=d!7%"K2/*'9/4y"?-*#|j=«/*/," )/@$&2"?-,.-*/@6* =NH2,K/7>/@'*, =#%$
".-*#:b#>2)*-"j6{="U'*)+4c6'*7>" /@'C
|'*/".-*#%$B$0/@H7_-P7>/*'*, ,",U'f=R&6*,K"U'*)k".-*#+=#>7>2,K2/*'T".-$0#>,?-*/ = *Ck}c'T
=#?4 6* ",K7>#%'$0 /Z7>/@$K$0#>,./*'*=('*)M"/ ! m;Zr;'#>p* # ,7>U,,d!#>=P,b,. d4
2"K,$0#>= 7>" /@'P ,j)*$0#%"#%$W".-' 6 U']".-* ,7%,#Z P! 6C^}c'*7%$0#%H,U'*)9".-*#[U6*#/4
J$&#>,.6* ",jU'9-* )@-*#%$W$0#>7> , /@'97>U,,K!#%$¦C#>:W2,$0#>,#%';"#>=ks®Xw B$0/*7>#>=6$0#4e/@$
7% 7%6*(H"U'*)N"?-*#J/**"U=#>7>2,K2/*'P".-$0#>,.-*/;2=4e/@$^+,8*,"#%9Z) [#%'P'P$1* ".$K$08
6*" 2 "089".$0 pCAD-*#$0/*7>#>=6$0# ,[X =Q/*'*28M:j-*#%'+".-*#^,8@,K"#% /@6*".6*",$0/@1X
1*2 " #>,%Z,/B".-*#$0#>= 7>" /@'9$0);('*,$0#>,?6*2"K('*)a4 $0/* ".-*#1/*/,"U'*)B7>U,,d!7%"K2/*'*,
,.-*/@6* =N1{##>=9U';"/$0/@11* " #>,%Cb| B#>"?-*/@=+4O/@$#>,"U"K('*)$0/*11* 2 " #>,
) [#%']".-*#B/@6*".6*"/4A|^=«/@/;,"j ,,.6*))#>,"K#>=QU'Ts¥¦wZ6*,U'*)NM /) ," 7B4c6'*7>" /@'C
}c'* "U#>p#%$0UB#%';",+: ".-T".-* ,M4 6'*7>"K2/*' -Y[#Q'*/;":b/@$S#>=t$0/*#%$0 8Zj1{#>7%6*,#
$0#>U" [#> 89 /X:´$0#>= 7>" /@'*,^$0#^,#%'"b"/B#>p*".$0#%B#$0/@1;1*2 "089[XU6*#>,%C©| {/,,U1* #
,/U6*" /@'o:/*6*2=k1{#L"/9,K7% #=/:j']".-*#L$0#>= 7>" /@'*,1#?4O/@$0#+* 8@U'*)P".-*#$0/@1;
1* 2 "08P#>,"U"K# -*/:b#>[#%$>Z "7%'Q1{#J/*1*,#%$0[#>=P".-"^$0#>= 7>" /@'k$&)U'*,)@$0/:
*
3
'
D
m>u
:^V,
/:( ("#4#%'&5)m-
74&59 : ;6%
/:( ("#4#%'&5) q6-
100
100
100
99.5
99.5
99.5
99
99
99
98.5
98.5
98.5
98
98
97.5
97
0
10
20
/:( ("#4#%'&5)2° 30
40
50
60
98
97.5
All
L to S
S to L
97
70
80
97.5
All
L to S
S to L
0
10
20
/:( ("#4#%'&5)du30
40
50
60
70
80
0
100
100
100
99.5
99.5
99.5
99
99
99
98.5
98.5
98.5
98
98
98
97.5
97.5
97.5
All
L to S
S to L
97
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
All
L to S
S to L
97
35
40
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
100
100
99.8
99.6
99.6
99.6
99.4
99.4
99.4
99.2
99.2
/:( ("#4#%'&5)2° 15
20
25
30
35
40
0
2
/:( ("#4#%'&5)du4
6
8
10
100
100
99.8
99.8
99.6
99.6
99.6
99.4
99.4
99.4
99.2
All
L to S
S to L
0
2
4
6
8
10
0
2
4
6
8
/:( ("#4#%'&
15
20
25
2
30
30
/:( ("#4#%'&5) ¬64
6
99.2
All
L to S
S to L
99
25
35
40
35
40
All
L to S
S to L
0
100
99
10
99
99.8
99.2
20
99.2
All
L to S
S to L
99
15
/:( ("#4#%'&5) q6-
99.8
10
5
/:( ("#4#%'&5)m-
All
L to S
S to L
/:( ("#4#%'&5) ¬6-
All
L to S
S to L
0
100
5
10
97
99.8
0
5
T&4 &4 :^V,
74&59 : ;6%
99
All
L to S
S to L
97
10
All
L to S
S to L
99
10
8
0
2
4
6
8
10
±z2)*6$0#Lql~b#0R0#>7>" /@'o7%6$0[#>,^4O/@$ 7>(H,,d!#%$0,%C %fp*2,Ylg{#%$07>#%';".)#
/45$0#0R0#>7>"#>=Q$0#>= 7>" /@'*, 4+p* ,%lA7>7%6$K7>8CAVW/"#^".-"Hp@ ,j$;'*)#>,$0#^=3#%$0#%';"
('".-*#* /",%C
P
m%¬
: ".-\1{/".-P"?-*#L'@6B1{#%$'*=f".-*#=#%*".-/4".-*#L6*,#>=f:b#%SQ$6* #>,%C9*U'*7>#Q';8
$B#>"K#%$0,;$0#QU';[/ [#>=hU't"?-*2,9,K7% ('*)Zj:b#P-%[;#N$0#0R0#>7>"#>=h".-*#N$&/@11* 2"08
#>,"U" /@'/45$0#>= 7>" /@'*,YC
|^2"K#%$'" [#> 8Z:b#aMS#B/@6$^7>U,,d!7%"K2/*'P,7>-*#%B#,#%'*, " [#+"/+".-*# ]4 H7?
"/@$1;8Q".6'*U'*)Q"?-*# 9;$B#>"#%$^"K/L".-*#M[XU6*#:j-* 7>-\Mp@UB >#>,".-*#B:#> )@-;"#>=
7>7%6$7>8\a#%,.6$0#CPx'*7>#QB/@$0#Z".-*#+7>/@'*7%$0#>"K#9[XU6*#+4O/@$ ] ,B/@1*".U'*#>=t6*,U'*)
".-*#B".6'*U'*)Q$0/@7>#>=6$&#J/H4A,#>7>" /@'P°CvuZ{(']:j-* 7>-P,#>[#%$K[XH(6*#>,4e/*$".-*#B$J
#>"#%$j;$0#B"#>,"#>=C^Dy1* #>,uQ'*=P¬,?6$0 >#B".-*#$0#>,.6* ",/*1*".U'*#>=P/@'9".-*#B"0:b/
7>/@$6*,%Z);2[*U'*) +4 7>"K/@$[XU6*#>,^/4©®+'*=Q®®;®CA~b#>,.6* ",$0#>,#%';"#>=]('osUm?w4O/@$".-*#
² m7>/@$6*,%Z'*=ksqYw5;'*=9('osUm%°¦w4O/@$".-*#J('*)* 7>/*$6*,j$0#H2,K/L$0#%/*$0"#>=C
|^)@U'Z
7>2#%;$0 8J/*6*".#%$4O/@$a,z".-*#1,#> U'*#gB#>"?-*/@=,%Czx'B"?-*#<² m
7>/@$6*,%Z*: ".- !¯®Z*[#%$08-* )@-;$0#>7> , /@'Q$K"#>,;$0#gH7_-* #>[#>=ZU';".U'*U'*)7>/@';
, =#%$1* 8-* )@-+$0#>7% $"K#>,%Cy} ",K#>#%B,A".-H"A".-*#=#%*"?-/4
z, )@-;" 8LU
$0/[#>,A".-*##%$4e/@$K'*7>#Z ".-*/@6*)@-+'*/,K2)*'*!7%;'"= #%$0#%'*7>#>,7%;'L1{#g7>-* #>[#>=C
±/@$
!F®®®Z$0#>7> , /@'¯$"#>,/H4Lm 6 6 e:j-* 7_- ,9".-*#QU* 7> "P)/@U'".-* ,
,7>#%'$0 /@n$0#7>-*2#>[;#>=Z#>p*7>#%*"4O/@$
>ZU'"?U'*('*)]4cU$^ #>[#> ,J/H4<$0#>7% OC
/:b#>[#%$>Z$0#>7%H2$H"#>,A$0#,K2 )@-;" 896'*,".1* #^: ".-$0#>,.{#>7>"b"/".-*#^=#%*".-/H4
h[X;$08@U'*)³4 $0/* uCvu@¬
"/t¥ C° 6 C x'´"?-*#('*)* 7>/@$6*,%Z^: ".!´®{Z
z7>U,,d!#%$0,7>-* #>[#j[;#%$08-*2)*-;$0#>7> , /@'9$"#>,b'*=L$0#>7%H2$"#>,
$0/@6'*=Q®¬ :^-*27>-+7> #%$0 89/@6*".{#%$4O/@$ ".-*#^/".-*#%$bB#>".-*/*=,%Cz±/@$ !´®;®®[#%$08
-*2)*-;$0#>7> , /@'\$K"#>,$0#7>-*2#>[;#>=Z16*"".-*#$0#>7% A$"#>,$0#B6'*,".1* #CB}c']".-* ,
7>/@$6*,%Z;".-*#= #%$0#%'*7>#>,U'#%$4e/@$K'*7>#^: ".-$0#>,.{#>7>"A"/".-*#=#%*".-a/4".-*#:b#%S
$6* #>,g$&# ,/L6'*,".;1*2#Z'*=Q'*/"W7>/@'[*U'*7>U'*)9#%'*/@6*)@-M4O/@$b,".H"U'*)7>/@'*7>U6*, /@'*,%C
x6$M(M$0#>,, /@' ,L"?-"L-* )@-[XU6*#>,9U'T"?-*# T4c7>"/@$,#>#%F"/fU'".$&/@=6*7>#
('*,K".1* 2"08TU'o".-*#L#>[U6" /@'Z:j-* 7_-f1#>7>/*B#>,/[#%$0,#%'*,K2"K2[;#L"/]/@6*" #%$0,%C]±/@$
#>prM*2#ZW/@'".-*#N² m;Zb:j-* 7_-7>/@';".U'*,km3Z 6;®®]#>prM*2#>,YZ A> *O

=/@#>,j'*/;":b/@$KS$0/@{#%$0 89:j-*#%'+) [@U'*) 9[U6*#>,/4A®®®Z;,U'*7>#".-*#B ,7>U,K,d!7%Y
" /@'/4/*'*28/@'*#A #>) "UH"#B#>,,.);#A #%=,"/j,K7>/@$0#A:b/@$&,#z".-'4;'8#%H2-=
1#>#%'! "#%$0#>=t".-* ,^:/*6*2=P) [# =
! ®(® e®q n¦Cz¨P/@$0#>/[#%$>Z;4O/@$m 6 6 $0#>7>d
) )
, /@'P[XH(6*#>,YZ".-*#$0#>7% z[$0U" /@']4c$0/@
6 "/km 6 6 /@'* 8P #>7>",j"?-*#LB#%,.6$&#
(' 63C 6ªB6'* ",%C
$ /:( ("#4#%'&
"#$#%'&
$ /:( ("#4#%'&
B
-
/:( (
, !
/:( ("#4#%'&
74&59:<;=%
>< 6; 4 4 % # 4 =
c} 'M/@$0=#%$z"K/) [#j7> #%$0#%$b* 7>".6$0#^/4".-*#j1#%-Y[* /@6$b/47>(H,,d!#%$0,:j-*#%'+B/[*('*)
".-*#=#>7> , /@'P"?-$0#>,.-*/ =Z:#U'*7>(6*=#M(']±z )@6$0#B°"?-*#J$0#>7> , /@';$0#>7%H27%6$0[#>,^/4
#%7_-]7>U,,K!#%$¦CJD-*#>,K#J7%6$&[#>,g;$0#16*2 ") [@U'*) +M: =#L$'*)#/4A[XH(6*#>,YZy'*=
7>/@6*"U'*)o4e/@$#%7>-f[XH(6*#P".-*#Q$&#>7% j'*=t$0#>7> , /@'h$"K#>,%CT}c'T"?-*#>,#97%6$0[#>,%Z
-*2)*-;$0#>7> , /@'t$H"#>,/4gm 6 6 9Z®® 9Z®ª '*=f®¬ -Y[#L1{#>#%'k,#> #>7>"#>=f,/Q,
"/P/@1*".U'f".-*#9$0#>7% j$H"#H"".-*#>,#Q{/U'"K,%C\D1* # ],.6$&2>#>,M".-*#>,#9,.J
*
m
Vj«
74&59:<;=%
D«^sUm?w
D«^sqYw
D«^s°Yw
D«^svuw
D«^s¬Yw
®Cq
m 6Cq
quCUm
u@¬Cq
m%®CUm
°¥Cvu
6
~b#>7% ¥ª{C¥¥
ª®{C 6
®°{C¬¬
®°{C¥
®m;Cvu@ª
>
²A$&#>7C
® C ¬
®®3C 6ª
®ªC¥m
®ªC® 6
®®C°q
| 7>7
^
® {C°ª
®ª{C¬ª
®ª{C¬®
®ª{C¥
®ª{Cª¥
®®CUm%q
®ª{C®q
> >
®°{C®¥
*
>
>
/ ~b#>7% u C®
m Cd°
u Cd®
® Cd¥
m%q Cvu
m%q°CUm
m%¥ª3C 6
>
/ / >
² $&#>7C
A
®ªCª 6
®®C¬m
/ ¥HuCvu@°
¥ C° 6
¥Hu3C 6m
HuCvu@¬
C¬°
,
,
| 7>7
^
®®C u@¥
®®C
>
/ / / ®®Cd®¥
®®Cd®¥
D1* #ulb/,"0¡*,#%'*, " [##>[XH(6H" /@'P$0#>,.6* ",/@'+"?-*#J² m7>/@$K6*,%C
*2#>,YC |^ ".-*#P[X$0U';",Q$&#NU'*= ,"U'*)@6* ,.-;1*2#h"+2#>[;#>/4a®¬
/4J$&#>7>2,K2/*'C
/:b#>[#%$>Z:j-*#%'oB/[@U'*)Q"K/Q-*2)*-*#%$[XH(6*#>,B/4$0#>7> , /@'h ®¬ n^9, )@'*d!7%';"
=3 #%$0#%'*7>#o,#>#%B,+"/\/*7>7%6$91#>"0:b#>#%'
Q'*=".-*#k$0#>,"+/4[X$&(;'",96*,U'*)
=#>#%#%$M:#%;Sk$6* #>,%CTD-* ,B4c7>"$0/[#>,B".-"BU'*7%$0#%,U'*)f".-*#9#>pr$&#>,, [#%'*#>,,+/4
".-*#:b#%S+$6* #>,7%'9U$&/X[;#".-*#B#%$4O/@$;'*7>#:j-*#%']$0#> r6*U$0U'*)9[#%$&8-* )@-P$0#?
7>2,K2/*'P! "#%$0,YC ^';4O/@$0".6'"K#>28Zz'*/]7>2#%;$7>/@'*7>U6*, /@'*,7%;'k1#+=$Y:j'k1{/@6*"".-*#
B/,"$0/@$&(H"#B=#%*".-CJ²z;$0#%'"?-*#>" 7% 28Z "7%'P1#L'*/"K#>=N"?-"j/*'Q"?-*#a² m
u A7>-*2#>[;#>,j".-*#1{#>,"$0#>7% y$"K#>,%C
74&*9:<;=%
/?( ("#$# %&*) C 3D E
?
!
'
!
D-*#kU,"]#>pr{#%$0UB#%'"]/4".-* ,N{#%$9#>p* /@$0#>,Q"?-*#\#%$4O/@$M'*7>#k/41/*/,"U'*)
7>(H,,d!#%$0,bU'L ".-*#jY[X U1* #^4O#%".6$0#,?7>#[#%$0,K2/*'*,A/4".-*#j² mW7>/@$6*, ;".-*#>,#
=3 #%$^U']".-*#"08#B/4z4O#%".6$0#>,6*,#>=]"/$&#%$0#>,#%';"j".-*#B#>,K,.)#>,%CW±/@$<#%7_-][#%$
, /@'/4".-*#P7>/@$6*,%Z';B#> 8 «|g~W¢Z¢©¨N¨TZbDx² '*=h¢z¨P¨ DWx²yZ
2° 7>U,,d!#%$-H,1#>#%'+ #%$K'*#>=Z@:W2"?-L6B"K/Jq¬ 6 6$0/@6'*=,b/41{/@/;,"U'*)C
*('*7>#+".-*#BU'"K#%'" /@'o/4A".-* ,#>pr{#%$0UB#%'"B ,"/9,.-*/: d4jB/@$0#B7>/@M*2#>p]4O#%".6$0#>,
7%'t{/"#%';"U 28h#%$4O/@$1#>"K"#%$>Z'*/k".6'*U'*)t$0/*7>#>=6$0#P"/k);#>"Lk7>/*'*7%$0#>"#ND
[XU6*#B ,g$0#> 6*U$0#>=C±z )@6$&#u+,.-*/:,".-*# 1jB#%H,.6$0#:W2"?-Q$0#>,.{#>7>"j"K/".-*#J'*6
1#%$^/4A:b#%S9$6* #>,6*,#>=C} "7%'Q1{#J/*1*,#%$0[#>=P".-" 7>(H,,d!#%$0,J{#%$4O/@$[#%$08
,UB (;$j #?4O"!)@6$0#%n>Z ".-*/*6*)@-, 2)*-"zU$0/[#%a#%'",/4zm{/U'"z7%'B1{#/@1*".U'*#>=
: ".-P #%"K2>#>=4e#%"?6$0#>,LO$0 )@-;"^!)@6$0#%n>CBD-*#>,#+$0#>,.6* ",)@$&#>#J:W2"?-P".-*#B/@'*#>,
$0#%/@$&"#>=Q189|'*=$0/@6*"K,/@/*6*2/;,#>"jOCzU'fsUmKwC
P
/?( ("#$# %&*) 6-
h ? D-*#B#>pr{#%$0UB#%'"K,$0#>,#%';"#>=P('".-* ,#%$^,.-*/: ".-"^".-*#|^=«/*/,"^2#%;$'*U'*)
)/@$0 ".- ,N;$0/@*U"#]4O/@$+".-*#P,.#%H2^! "#%$&('*)h$0/@1* #%9C}O"97> #%$0 8
m%¥
Vj«
VjV
*".7>S
74&59:<;=%
D«^sUm?w
D«^sqYw
D«^s°Yw
D«^svuw
D«^s¬Yw
¥C36
q C36
°mCq
°qC¬
q 3C 6
®CUm
>
>
~b#>7% ¥¥{C¬¥
ªm;C® 6
ªuCª 6
® {Cvu@¥
®uCª 6
®¬{Cqq
®¬{Cªu
®¬{Cªu
>
/
² $&#>7C
A
®®Cvu@¬
®ªCª 6
®ªCª 6
®®CUm%¬
| 7>7
^
®®{Cvu@°
®®{Cvu 6
®®{Cvu
®®{C¥
®ªC®q
®®CUm>u
®®CUm>u
®®CUm>u
®®{C ®
®®{C¥¬
®®{C¥¬
®®{C¥
/ ~b#>7% ²A$&#>7C
>
ª qC6
qm%¥CUm
q 6®C¬
°u@qC
°°¥Cq
u@¬mCUm
>
¬;qCªm
¬ 6C®u
¥;¥C¬¬
¥HuCqq
®®C m
¥;®Cª°
(/ ® ®
ª¥C®Hu
®mCq
® 6C Hu
®°CUmY°
®°C¬;¬
74&59:<;=%
q{C°¥
/:( ("#4#%'&5) m- 3 / /:( ("#4#%'&5)2q6- ªm;Cvu@®
/:( ("#4#%'&52) °6- ¥¥{C¬u
/:( ("#4#%'&5) u- ª {Cqu
/:( ("#4#%'&52) ¬6- ¥¥{C¥¬
6
6
, >
>
/ / 6
&4
m 6 6
uuC¥ 6
¥¥{C¥¬
¥ {C° 6
;® ª
®uC¤m%¥
® Cdªª
®¥C 6ª
® Cdªª
® ®
®¥C¬ 6
®¬Cvu*q
®uC 6
® Cq;¬
® C ;¥
74&59:<;=%
/:( ("#4#%'&5) m/:( ("#4#%'&5)2q6- >
/:( ("#4#%'&52) °6- / >
/:( ("#4#%'&5) u- ª°{C®® /
/:( ("#4#%'&52) ¬6- ª¬{C¬> > D 1* # {l~b#>7% $H"#/4z! "#%$&#>=k,.
y
/4©-* )@-;$&#>7>2,K2/*'k$"#
®¥Cdq®
;® ª
®ªCd°ª
®ªCd¬¬
®ªCd¬¬
®ªCd¥¬
®ªCd¬u
/
®®Cd®¬
/ / / / ®®C¥°
Dy;1*2#B¬lAb/;,"0¡@,#%'*,K2"K2[;##>[XU6" /@']$0#>,.6* ",^/@'+".-*#U'*)@;
m
|^7>7
$0#>,.6* ",j'*/"^$0/[@ =#>=
/ ®®Cd®¬
7>/@$6*,%C
® ¬
®ªC¥¬
®ªC¥¬
®ªC¬u
®ªC¬u
/ ®ªC¥¬
® ¬
®ªC®
>
/ ®®C¬ª
®®C°¥
®®CUm
®ªC®
*
>
B#>,,.H)#>,j:W2"?-N$&#>,.#>7>""/!p*#>=k/U';",
m%ª
=:^V,
/:( ("#4#%'&5)m-
74&59 : ;6%
/:( ("#4#%'&5) q6-
100
100
100
95
95
95
90
90
90
85
85
85
80
80
80
75
75
75
70
60
65
70
/:( ("#4#%'&5)2° 75
80
85
90
/:( ("#4#%'&5)du-
70
95
100
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
100
100
100
100
95
95
95
90
90
90
85
85
85
80
80
80
75
75
75
70
70
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
100
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
100
100
95
95
90
90
90
85
85
85
80
80
80
75
75
75
/:( ("#4#%'&5)2° 70
80
70
90
100
40
50
60
/:( ("#4#%'&5)du70
80
90
100
100
95
95
95
90
90
90
85
85
85
80
80
80
75
75
75
70
70
50
60
70
80
80
85
90
95
100
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
95
100
70
100
100
40
75
/:( ("#4#%'&5) q6-
100
60
70
/:( ("#4#%'&5)m-
95
50
65
&4 =4 :^,
100
40
60
70
60
74&59 : ;6%
70
/:( ("#4#%'&5) ¬6-
70
95
90
100
40
50
60
40
50
60
/:( ("#4#%'&5) ¬670
80
90
100
70
80
90
100
70
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
±z2)*6$0#Q°lL²$0#>7> , /@';~b#>7% ^7%6$0[#>,L;'*= $0#>7%H2W[XU6*#>,M4e/@$".-*#+!p*#>=t$0#>7> , /@'
$"#>,jH"gm 6 6 9Z®® Zr®;ª '*=Q®¬ 9C%Qp* ,%lA$0#>7% 4+Lp* ,%lb$0#>7> , /@'C
C
m%®
100
100
95
99
90
98
F1
F1
85
80
97
75
BARE
LEMM
STOP
LEMM STOP
70
65
1
5
25
100
Number of rounds
BARE
LEMM
STOP
LEMM STOP
96
95
500 1000 2500
0
500
/?( ("#$#%'&*) 6-
1000
1500
Number of rounds
2000
2500
±z2)*6$0#jul5¢$$0/@$b$H"#/4
2° y7>U,,K!#%$&, #%$'*#>=9: ".-M=#%$&#%'"b4O#%".6$&#
,#>",/@'P"?-*#L² mCD-*#L$&2)*-"0-;'*=k, =#L* /" ,B9>/*/@ /4"?-*# #?4e"0-;'*=\, =#
*2/;"%C
/@6*".#%$4e/@$KB,y£#>7> , /@'+D$0#>#>,%ZV^ [#«Y8#>,A;'*= V^Vta#>".-*/@=,z/*'"?-*#"0:b/^#>[XY
(6H"#>=\1#%'*7>-$KSQ7>/*$/@$Kl^".-*#² mB7>/@$6*,'*=k"?-*#a('*)*7>/@$6*,%CB}c'
".-*#>,#b=".b,K#>",%Z".-*#bB#>".-*/*= ,A$0#>, ,".;'""/^/X[;#%$!""U'*)j'*= 1 $H"#>,y1{/X[;#®¥
$0#7_-* #>[#>=C²A$0/*7>#>=6$0#>,4e/*$A6*"/*" 7% 8".6'*U'*)".-*#^7>U,,d!#%$;$B#>"#%$&,%Z
,.6*7_-],b".-*#J'*6B1#%$b/H4©1{/@/,K"U'*)$0/*6'*=,%Z$0#$&/X[* =#>=C
}c'M,7>#%'$&2/;,A:j-*#%$0#-* )@-;$0#>7> , /@'+7>U,,K!#%$&,j$0#j$&#> r6*U$0#>=Z*|^=«/@/,K"A7>U,0
,d!#%$0,-Y[#1#>#%'P$0/[#>=Q"K/L:b/@$S9$&/@#%$0 8C¢©pr{#%$0UB#%';",-Y[##>p* / "#>=k".-*#
#>pr$0#>,K, [#%'*#>,,/4".-*#^:b#%SB$6* #>,b:j-*#%'U'*7%$0#%H,U'*)".-*#>U$b=#%*".-Cz}O"b7%'+1#^7>/@';
7>(6*=#>=o".-"=#>#%{#%$^:#%;S9$6* #>,j"#%'*=P"/+1#B/@$0#,?6*2"?1* #J:^-*#%'Q /*/@S;('*)+4O/@$
[#%$08N-* )@-o$0#>7> , /@'P7>U,,d!#%$>C}']".-* ,, ".6"K2/*'Z".-*#7_-* #>[#>=f$0#>,.6* ",/*'9".-*#
":b/B7>/@$6$K$0#^4cU$0 89,." ,04c7>"/*$08C
Db:b/Q|^=«/*/,"7>U,K,d!#%$0,7%1* " #>,-Y[#91#>#%'f,?-*/X:^'P"/N1{#Q6*,#?4c6*U'
!'z#% ! "#%$0U'*)N;*2 7%"K2/*'*,%lnD-*#B7>/@';!=#%'*7>#M/4".-*#$0#>= 7>" /@'*,,.6*)
)#>,",+! "#%$a:j-* 7_-f/@'* 8k7>U,K,d!#>,".-*#9B/@$0#+7>/@';!=#%';"aa#>,,.)#>,YZz=#> 2[;#%$0U'*)
".-*#j$0#%H('*U'*)B#>,,?)#>,A"K/".-*#b!'6*,#%$>Cz1nAD-*#W7>(H,,d!7%" /@'+".-$&#>,.-*/ =7%'
1#"?6'*#>=Q"/B/@1*".H(']B[#%$089-* )@-Q$&#>7>2,K2/*'97>U,,d!#%$>C
B g W
|j,b^4c6*".6$0#j$0#>,K#%$07>-B ('*#Z{:#W:/*6*2=M2US#"K/,".6*=8B".-*#$0#>,#%';"#>="#>7>-'* r6*#>,U'
Ja/@$0#^= +7%6*2"W7>/@$6*,%C #j".-*U'SM".-"b1/".-M".-*#² m'*=9".-*#U'*)@ $&#
"/@/#%,8Z'*=+".-"".-*#g² m^ , ,/B"/*/,.H2OC£6*#j"K/".-*#>,#W4c"7>,%Z;=#?4 6* "Y
$B#>"#%$&,5$0/*=6*7>#[#%$&8)/@/*=J$&#>,.6* ",%Z@;'*=J"?-*#A".6'*U'*)J$&/@7>#>=6$0#>,A$&#>,.6* "z/@'* 8JU'
, 2)*-"bU$0/[#%B#%';",%C¨P/@$0#>/[#%$¦Z,/@B##>p#%$&(a#%'",^'*/"$0#%{/@$0"#>=+-*#%$0#ae:j-* 7_,".6*=8P".-*#,# #>7>"/H4".-*#L'*6B1#%$/4j$0/@6'*=,%Z ".-*#L6*,#/H4W$&27>-*#%$^4O#%".6$&#,.7>#>,%Z
q
6
#>"7CnB-Y[#j,?-*/X:^'6*,b".-"A"?-*#j7>/@';!=#%'*7>#/47>U,,d!#%$0,=#%{#%'*=,j/*'B,#>[#%$HY
$B#>"#%$&,%C W,U'*)QU$&)#%$7>/*$6*,%Z".-*#,# #>7>"K2[;#%'*#>,,/4A".-*#B".6'*U'*)Q$0/*7>#>=6$0#>,
:/*6*2=T1#Qa/@$0##>p* 27> "9'*=ZA-*/@{#?4 6* 8ZB/@$&#, )@'*d!7%';"7>/@'*7>U6*, /@'*,91/@6*"
".-*#/@*"U$B#>"K#%$b,#>""U'*),W/4y|^=«/@/,K"7>/@6* =N1{#=$Y:j'C
}c'/@$0=#%$b"K//[#%$07>/@B#^".-*#>,# (a2"?" /@'*,%Z:b#$0#7%6$$0#%';" 89:b/@$S;U'*)/@'+".-*#
=#>[#> /@B#%';"/45B'*#>:´7>/@$K6*,:^-*27>-+: 7>/@';".U'9B#>,,?)#>,bU'+":b/(;'*)@6)#>,%Z
¢A'*) ,.-h'*= ;'*2,?-Zb: ".-tk$&#% 2,K" 7$&/@/@$&" /@'T/4,.FB#>,,.);#>,%Ctx6$
(';"#%';" /@'T ,"K/\S#9Y[X U1* #kB/,"B/4^".-*#9U';4e/@$K" /@'fU'T"?-*#Q-*#%=#%$'*=
".-*#g1{/@=8M/4".-*#ga#>,,.)#>,YZ:j-* 7>-: /X:h"/#>pr{#%$0UB#%';": ".-M/".-*#%$4O#%".6$&#
,.7>#>,"?-']".-*#"08r* 7%
1)9/4:b/@$&=, a/@=#>OC±/@$^#>p* #Z:#B".-*U'S]".-"
(';4O/@$M" /@'91{/@6*"b".-*#7>/@{/@'*#%'"K,/H4y".-*#,#%'*=#%$b#%M H==$0#>,,%Z"?-*#g'*6B1#%$
'*=L,K#> r6*#%'*7>#>,b/4,/@a#,.#>7>U7>-$7>"K#%$0,%Z,?6*7_-H,A,.7>#>,b/@$ UZ@;'*
= {c)@$B,
/4y,/@a#j:b/@$0=,b7%'91{#$0#> #>[X';"b4O/@$ =#%'"d4O8@U'*)+,.B#>,,?)#>,%C¨P/@$0#>/[#%$>Z;:b#
:<;'"b"/LSH#>#%+".-*#="K#'*=9"UB#/4AB#>,,.H)#>,U'9".-*#-*#%H=#%$>Z:j-* 7>-9: 5H2 /:
"/,UB6*U"#J! "#%$0U'*)9,8*,"#%7%$&/,,"UB#C
|'*/".-*#%$ (';"#%$0#>,K"U'*)j U'*#b4O/@$4c6*".6$0#$&#>,#%$07>- ,".-*#{/@$0".1* "08/4';"dc,.
!2"K#%$0,%Z"?-"A ,%Z;"/,".6*=8-*/:t^! "#%$©2#%;$'*#>=LU'$0" 7%6*U$©=".^,#>"b#%$4O/@$B,
('k= #%$0#%';"=".,#>"%C #9".-*U'ST".-H"J"?-*2,+ ,[#%$08TU/*$0".';" ,,.6*#4e/@$
)#%'*#%$V^²f,8*,"#%B,b:j-* 7>-9$0#U';"#%'*=#>=Q"/B1#^!'$0#%H* 7%" /@'*,%Cb*U'*7>#
".-*#b4O#%".6$0#>,b$0/[@ =#>=+('+"?-*#j² m7>/@$K6*,$0#W#%'*7>/@=#>=Q'*=M".-*#b4O#%".6$0#>,('M".-*#
U'*)@$0#j'*/;"%Z".-*#W,".6*=8B/4".-*#j{/@$0".1* "08L ,'*/;"/;,,U1* #1#>"0:b#>#%'B".-*#>,#
":b/+7>/@${/@$Cx6$'*#>: 4c6*".6$0#B7>/@$6*,: 2b /X: "/9,".6*=8P".-*#{/@$0".1* "08k/4
!2"K#%$0,gH)@U'*,"".-*#('*)* 7>/*$6*,j'*=P7%$0/,,b"UB#C
~b#>)@;$0=U'*)L"/M".-*# #%$'*U'*)Q$0/*7>#>,,%Z:b#:b/@6* =Q US#B"/,"?6*=8L".-*#U'".$&/@=6*7?
" /@'k/H4".-*#9B ,7>U,,d!7%"K2/*'f7>/,",U'*, =#9".-*#+|j=;«A/*/," #%$'*U'*)k )/@$0 ".-9C
}c'* "Uz#>p#%$0UB#%';",^: ".-9".-*#BB#>".-*/*=Q$0/@{/,#>=QU'osUm Yw5-Y[#'*/;":b/@$S#>=Q$0/H
#%$0 8Z@H2"?-*/@6*)@-:b#<1{#> 2#>[;#".-" #%$'*U'*)=U$0#>7>" 8B7>U,,d!#%$0,b7>7>/@$0=U'*)"/^,/@a#
6*" 2 "08Q,K#>""U'*),: z#%$4O/@$ 1{#>""#%$b"?-'+".6'*U'*)a7>(H,,d!#%$/*'*7># #%$'*#>=C
}c'+== " /@'Z*:b#j:b/@6* =+ (SH#j"/#>pr{#%$0UB#%';": ".-B".-*#W4O/ 2/:U'*)B"0:b/2#%;$'*U'*)
)/@$0 ".-B,YlNmYnB|j "#%$K'"U'*)k£#>7> , /@'hDy$&#>#>,Qs ¦wZ4O/@$1{#>('*)Tk1{/@/,K"U'*)1,#>=
"#>7_-'* 6*#P".-")#%'*#%$K 2>#>,9"?-*#Q'*/" /@'T/H4g U'*#%$ 8t7>/*J1*U'*#>=h=#>7> , /@'".$0#>#>,%Z
'*=qny6{/@$0"z§z#>7>"/*$¨H7_-*U'*#>,%ZY4O/@$1#>U'*)".-*#b/"?-*#%$"/*;#%$4O/@$BU'*)B#>"?-*/@=
(']D#>p*"jH"#>)/@$0 %"K2/*'9$0/@1* #%B,%C
*
*
B
A
b D-* ,L$0#>,#%$&7_-f-,J1{#>#%'t$&"U 28o4c6'*=#>=t18k"?-*#¢ iO}cD.m%®®®Y.mYq°®qn^'*=
18"?-*#'* ,.-kOD}q 6 6 6X 6°°¬Y<
6°Y 6qZD}q 6 6 6X.m%¥°¬Y<6qY 6qn'*=9".H(;'
0m%®®¥X 8~ 6 6 6¬m%n 8/[#%$'B#%';",%
C Y[@ #%$^$$0#%$K,-*/ =,gB)*$';"j18+".-*#£#?
qm
$0".B#%';"^/4 ^'* [#%$0, " #>,%Z~b#>,#%$&7_-P'*=k}c';4O/@$M" /@'Q*/*7> #>"08Q/4A".-*#B".H(;'
8/[#%$'B#%';"%C
*©b sUm?wJ}KC|g'*=$0/*6*",/@{/@6* /,%ZC^/@6*",U,%ZBCy-;'*=$0U'*/,%Zy;'*=\C8$0/@{/@6* /,%C
|'#>pr{#%$0UB#%'"?7>/@$&2,K/@'/4' [#1Y8#>,U'B'*=+S#>8@:b/@$&=*1,#>=J;'"d
,.; ! "#%$0U'*): ".-h#%$0,/*'j#?M B#>,,.);#>,%C }
' ?. @ P @
O > ? b

$% z . Y O $ Z)#>,m 6Y¡m ;¥Z@q 6 6 6C
# ; 5 9 9 % 9 ?9 9 69 # 9 5 "5 9 "5 9
#
# 5*4 ; ?9 5' ?<
5"9= # 9 4 5"9
"# 4 < 9 ;
*
#
sqYwJ}KCy|'*=$0/@6*"K,/@/*6*2/;,%Z8Cz²z /@6$H,%Zz§BC!;$S% #>",K2,YZ58MC5;S@S; ,%ZACz;8
$0/*/@6* /,%Z;'*= ²C*"?"/*/@6* /,%C´#%$'*U'*)T"/o!2"K#%$+,.F#? OlP|
7>/@M$0 ,/@'h/H4at'H2[;#\1Y8#>,U'´'*= TB#%B/*$081H,#>= $0/*7_-C }c'
$ * #&( 'X " % # %
?a ) . .+ *,
> Y ? 0/ >* %$21
- . _ ?
H 4
3 5/ 6 78797+: Zq 6 6 6{C
5 #! < 5 5"9 4 < ?9 .# 9 :9 9 ; % =9 5 # 5"9 44 ?<
9 ; # 4 4 5' 9 5" 6;
45
% = # 5 ?9 9 5"96 # 9 4 5.9 # ?9 4
#
7
s°Yw C Cb/*-*#%'CN#%;$'*U'*)$K6*2#>,M".-"7>U,K,d4e8k#?M eCP}c'; # 5 4.?6;H:9* 5 ?@< =<9>8>9?6@AB # ?@9 % = ^ 5 @% ?
9 9= 5 ?# 5.C9 4.4 . ZmY®®> C
svuwJzC$'*/*$'*=\«^Cz¨k7>7>-*UCQCDE 5 J% 9 4 5"9 5'L
?*< 4PZ
um*Oªn>l¥Hu¡rª°*Zm%®®;ªC
s¬YwJCA£$K6*7_S#%$¦Z£C 6Z'*=h§JCVCv§A'*USC6{/@$0"9[#>7>"K/@$LM7_-*U'*#>,4e/@$
,.; 7%"#>)/*$0 %" /@'CF -5-- & HG JI & IgY
% Zm 6O¬n¦lUm 6u@ªX¡
m 6;¬uZmY®®®C
# 9 5"9
? 5 #!
%#
s YwLKBC±$0#%6'*=k'*=kzC¨k,/@'C^D-*# "#%$'"K('*)9=#>7> , /@'".$0#>#B #%$'*U'*)N )/H
$0 ".-C}M
' .? * g *N
<9? O O P
> . M
$ * * $zZm%®;®®C
"# 9 :9
# 5 4 ; :9 5' ?<
?< 9 # 9 5.9
5.9= # 9 4 5"9
4 < ?9
s¥YwLC;±$0 #>=;'ZrDC@^," #Z'*=9~CDbU1*,.-*U$'*OC|j== " [# /) ,"K27$&#>)@$0#>,, /@'l
^,"?" ," 7%[* #>:t/41/*/,"U'*)P
C ZqªOqn¦l°°¥Y¡*u 6¥*Z%q 6 6 6C
9 9
5'
4
sªYwJDC/@H7_-*UB,%CD#>p*"A7%"K#>)/@$0 %" /@': ".-,.6{/@$0"z[#>7>"K/@$z7>-*U'*#>,%lz#%$';
U'*): ".-]';8L$0#> #>[X;'"W4e#%H".6$0#>,%CA}'9CM
V #>Q =#> #>7'*=QC~b/@6*[#>U$0/;eZ#>=d
"/*$0,%R
Z ?? @
- $1S>9T * < 7 - # > . U
$ *@Z'*6B1#%$+m%°®ªU'T#>7>".6$0#9V/;"#>,U'Tb/@M6*"#%$*7> #%'*7>#Z)#>,
m%°;¥Y¡m>u@q{Z-*#%'* "Z£¢Zm%®;®ªC@$&('*);#%$§z#%$0U)ZW#> =#>(1{#%$0)Z£¢WC
"# 9 :9
# 5*4 6; ?9 5 ?< % # 5 9 5.9= # 9 4 5"9
qq
4 < ?9
s®Yw£C;£C@#>: ,%C¢z[U6"U'*)L'*=+/@*"UB >U'*);6*"/@'*/@B/*6*,A"#>p*"A7>U,,K!7%H" /@'
,8*,"#%a,%C}c.
' ?. @ L @ <9T R2 _ ?%Z
m%®;®¬C
# 5*4 ; ?9 5 ?<
?<
"# >5' 64 <
6
;
"
5
9
4
7 5"9 #
?9 9 9 %
4 < ?9
5"96 # 9 4
"# 9 ?9
#5 4<
sUm Y6 wJzC¨ $& r6*#>CO " " ?
& Y @ " $ @=

&
.

²
*
=CD-*#>, ,%Z^£#%C2#%'*)*6")#>,]*2,K"#%B#>,
K

}';4e/@$K " 7>,%C ^'*2[;#%$0, "."²/ " #>7%'* 7%M=#".U6';8@Zm%®®;®C
sUmm?wJC~b/@1{#%$0",/*'9'*=9£C*|JC^6*2OCADW-*#".$0#>7?®! "#%$0U'*)L"?$7>S!'$0#%/*$0"%Cz}c'
& * > 1 )&( ' Y O $ _ ? 3 & - 1S> : Zq 6 6mC
<
?<
5"96 # 9 4
#
sUm%qYw¨TCz-BOZC£6 ,%Zb£CzW#>7_S#%$K'Z'*=h¢CAW/@$0[* "Ct|1Y8#>,U'
$&/@7>-9"/M! "#%$0U'*)R6'S+#? OCJ}' $ @
&( 'X O
1 _ ? @L
@6A "

Z
;
)
>
#
j
,
¬
Y
¬
¡
;
q
Z
%
m
;
®
®ªC
%
# # 5 ?<
5 #! < 5
5 # 5"9
"# 9 ?9 5 #
sUm%°Yw48MCyS*S ,%Zb}C|'*=$0/@6*",K/@/@6* /,YZ58MCy²z /@6$,YZz§JC$KS% #>", ,%ZbCz;8
$0/*/@6* /,%Z;'*=²C*".H"/@/*6*2/;,%C*".7>SU'*)97>U,,d!#%$0,4e/*$j';"dc,.!d
"#%$&('*)+/4A#?H2OC}c' ?? @
@4
?H ) _ ?
- ^
P% I R $ * @@
. . @ 3 - I6$ 797 < : Z)#>,uu¡r¬ 6Z
q 6 6 6C
?< 5 ; ?9
%#
# 9 5*4 6; ?9 55 4 '5 ??9 < ?< "5 96 # 9 4 5.9
%
#
#4
4 < ?9 .# 9 :9
>
sUm%¬YwJ~C*¢C*7>-*U$0#'*==KBC@*U'*)#%$>CHr
BJJBKGl|´1/*/,"U'*)1,K#>=L,8*,"#%
4O/@$"#>p*"7%"#>)/*$0 %" /@'C 4 <?9A$ "# 9 ?@9 *Z@°®OqD °n¦lUm%°¬Y¡m* ªZq {C
sUm*Y wJ~CY¢C%*7>-*U$0#Z KBC%*U'*)#%$>Z'*=|JC%*U'*)@-HeC«/*/,"U'*)j'*=B~b/*7>7_-* /* #>=
"/M"#>p@"<!2"K#%$0U'*)C}c' # 5 .4 ?6H; :*9 5'B
?@< < 9 9 % P 9 O # 9 5"9 5"9 1
> # 9 .4 5"9 "# 4 < 9 ; % 5 9 :M9 9= 5 .# 5"9 % # O * >9TZmY®®ªC
sUm>uwJ~Cz¢WCA*7_-;*($&#Q'*=#KJCz*U'*)#%$>C}c$0/[#>=T«/@/;,"U'*)k|^2);/@$0 ".-B, W,U'*)
b/*';!=#%'*7>#?$"#>=P²A$0#>= 7>" /@'*,%C $ *@Z°¥ °n>lq®;¥Y¡r°° {Z@m%®;®®C
6
$
6
6
$
sUm%¥YwJCW¨ C #> ,,%ZBC|*"#Z±C C£;B#%$6Z£C^¢C /@-'*,/@'Z±CCx^ #>,%Z
DC 8/*#>"Z@;'*=DC*j;C¨kp@UB >U'*)"#>p*"0BU'*U'*)L{#%$4e/*$'*7>#C --5 O%d2* O B Zm¦uu@n>l °Y¡ ®*Zm%®;®®C
9
9 =
sUm%ªYwLKBC KA'*)C|g'M#>[XH(6H" /@'/H4,".H" ," 7%;$0/@7>-*#>,z"/"K#>p@"z7%"K#>)/@$0 %" /@'C
0
. Y O $ Zm%®®®{C
5 % # 9 5' 69 5 #
5"9
#
sUm%®YwLKBC KA'*)'*= JCU6Cz| $0#?c#>pr;BU'" /@'+/4y"K#>p@"b7%"#>);/@$0 %" /@'9B#>"?-*/@=,%C
}'# .? *
2 _ ? b
$XY 1

z . Y O $ Z)#>,u*qY¡@u@®Zm%®®®{C
#9 5 ?94 ;69 : 9 5 '5 "5 9
#
5"96 # 9 4 5"9
#
q°
"# 4 < 9 ;
5

Download Report

Boosting Trees for Anti-Spam Email Filtering

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz