Marc Baudry (*) & Béatrice Dumont (**)1
!
"
#
$%
!
!
!
&
&
$'
(
*
)
!
#
+
"
-
!
#
$,
!
$
!
!
#
(
"
!
)$
$
!
!
!
$'
$%
!
$
$
./
-
0 / 0 /1
'
(2) 3 !
4
-
0;<<< 4
$
% 4 ' 5 64 (22) 3 !
$
7 !5
$
4
% 4 ' 5 64 $
3 !
4
%&
89
:
&5
&
#
$%
!
$%
=
<<;
(
)
+
5
!
0
$
#
!
#
<<<
$
<<
!
!
"
>>8
#
<<0$
5 "
!
!
+
$ %
<<<
"
<<
#
? !
$
;@
&
+
11
3A+
$
>>8
>B "
&
;0B
0 B
>>
<<
0
@
>>
@B
&
!
0 $;
1B =
!
!
$
;@
#
$
#
;B$ =
3A
;
&
$
$
0 B
#
1B
$
(C@
#
$
;
<
;<B 0;B
$%
<<
!
;01
)
$
!
<
0$;
<<<
$&
!
D
!
15
5
!
$&
#
!
<<<
#
!
5
#
@<
$
!
$
0<
#
# 5
#
D
E
"
$
#
>>8
"
<<0
$
=
!
"
5
!
E
?
#
$%
"
!
# $
>>;
#
# $
%
!
!
&
!
&
(
)
!
!
#
$
F
G > 8H
*
#
+
,
$'
"
$
!
$,
!
#
G > 0H
$&
#
(
!
)$
(
)$ 9
,
"
$
$=
$
!
(
)$ %
-
!
$
!
(
#
"
!
!
)$
$
!
!
!
$'
$ %
!
$
$
#(
)
!
$&
#
$
!
"
!
!
$
F
G > 8H
G > 0H$ I
#
"
#
$
!
!! "#$#%&'$ ()(*#%
I
( ∈{
$
" !
{
}$
})
D
=
#
=
D
!
! $
=α ! + "
!
D
"
!
α
#
! "
$%
α !+
−
"
−
>
#
"
$
#
$,
#
α>
>
#
⇔
α<
"
−
#
! − !#
−
( )
#
! − !#
( )
! > !#
! < !#
α
!
−
-
− −
−
<α < +
! −!−
!+−!
−
?
( )
+
!
"
$
D
!
?
%
"
D
α$%
!
α
]<
α
"
]$ %
#
=<
<
−
−
α " !+−!
!
−
−
$
+
−
−
% =
α " !+−!
! −!−
− −
$
α "−
α "
! −!−
$
"
!
α$ "
% =
$
α
#=
"
(0)
"
$'
!
α
!
( =
'
≠
!+−!
#
+
#
+& α
)
! −!−
"
(1$ )
<<
(1$ )
' #= + ' ≠
' #= −
+
> < ∀# ≠
!+−!
! −!−
=
& ='
"
(0)
=−
#
D
(0)
=
( = )
D
"
< <
$%
"
!< = <
=
+
$
=<
=
(1$ )
(1$ )
'
=
≠
(
)
!
!
'
=
)
! !
E
#
$
≠
!
(
!
"
$
!
'+,-%&*.,' &()%%#*-.#(
%
"
!
"
!
!
#$ &
$
!"
D
#
" !
!
#
µ
µ
!
$ &
!
Ω
(
π =
(
∈Ω
−µ
!
∈{
( } )$
"
!
)%
(;)
%
D
!
D
#
D
$
?
?
?
$&
E
D
!
"
$
!
"
! $
!
$%
!
!
α
(1)$
"
!
!
#
α
1
!
"
$%
α
!
"
-
α
"
= αJ + αJ
) ≠ [α
"
(@$ )
] = αJ
) ≠ [αJ ] = <
(@$ )
"
)≠
$
!
αJ
αJ
(
(
)
αJ
)$ '
αJ
!
!
"
αJ
$:
αJ
#
$%
!
αJ
!
!
!
$
-./#$#*#-%.'&*.,'
I
!
"
?
-
(
1
6
$
"
$:
%
!
"
"
$$
(1$ )
"
$
{
}
K ∈Ω
) ≠ [π
(
( ! π +
=
≠
]
(8)
=
(1)
(8)
#∈Ω
(
#
-
+
#
)
#
=
−& α
+µ
−
"
(
!
= ∈Ω
=
≠
∈Ω
(
))≠ [ ]
+
∀ ∈Ω
( $ )
"
* = −α
+
* (
(
+µ , −
"
!
!
* )
) ≠ [*
(
=
≠
+
]
( $ )
!
)$ +
!
∈{
( })
(
( ∈{
Ω
(1$ )
∈Ω $
!
+
(
∈Ω
+
"
( })$
,
!
!
Ω $
!
= ∈Ω
"
* = −α
"
(+
−
) + µ (+
−
, )−
(
=
≠
(+
−
+
) ) [* ]
≠
(>)
(>)
α
*
αJ
) ≠ [*
]
"
( $ )
(@)
!
"
!
$&
-
J
) ≠ [* ] = −α
+
(>)
*
* $
+µ , −
(
=
≠
!
J
) ≠ [* ] = −α
+
) ≠ [*
]
( <)
"
+µ -
+
+
∀ =
-
(
+(
+( (
$
,
D
+ αJ . + µ /
= − +−
+
(
=
≠
(
$ )
(
(>)
−
. =−+
$ )
−
-
* = αJ
(
(
=
(
−
+
+
"
D !
(
-
(
$ )
(
$ )
(
$ )
$ )
−
/ =+ , −
(
=
≠
−
(
+ -
+
+
!
!
)
(
!
!
,
+
$ )
!
-
$ )( $ )( $ )
!
(
$
! "#$&*&
,
8!
$
(
&
)
08<
!
$=
5
#
(
#
&
)$
<< 5 <<;$
!
+
&01
#!2 .(*,+3&-.&01#(
Duration of the pay monthly talk plan (1 or 2 years
contracts)
eng
Inclusive minutes
tpcb
Price per minute in the talk plan
pmdf
Bonus voice call (week-end, after 8.00pm)
tpcc
Voice call price (outside the pay monthly talk plan)
pahf
Discount for voice calls outside the pay monthly talk plan rcahf
Number of free text messaging
smsg
Adjustable talk plan
fa
ftc
Talk plan everything included
Second-tariff unit bill
fals
Postponed minutes
A
Free presentation of the phone number
B
Free double call
C
Free consumption check
D
Discount on calls from abroad
E
Multimedia services and email
F
Free dedicated customer services
G
After-sales service
H
Red list
I
K
Free phone book
Calls from abroad
L
Insurance (theft & lost)
M
Ability to suspend the talk plan
N
O
Free detailed bill
P
Discount to call abroad
Free possibility to change talk plan
Q
New phone through fidelity points
R
&01# 2 .(* ,+ #-.
,$(
L< L<< 5
L< L<<
<;L<0L<< 5 8L<0L<<
;L<>L<< 5 ;L<L<<
< L L<< 5 0 L L<<
<;L<0L<<0 5 0L<0L<<0
1L<1L<<0 5 0<L<1L<<0
<L< L<<0 5 0 L< L<<0
< L<L<<0 5 0 L<L<<0
8L L<<0 5 0<L L<<0
< L L<<0 5 0 L L<<0
<;L< L<<1 5 < L<0L<<1
< L<0L<<1 5 0 L<0L<<1
1L<1L<<1 5 0<L<1L<<1
< L<;L<<; 5 0 L<;L<<;
#
!
!
" !
D
!
!
!
#
$
!
#
!
!$ %
!
!
!
#
0
"
! ! = ( 0− ρ + λ
$I
−ρ
)
− ρ
ρ
λ$
"
#
$
0
!
!
$
&01#
-#(41
*(,+*"#5-.'/.5&1/,%5,'#'*&'&1
)(.(
!
B
8$080
1
$0; ;
$0; ;
$1 <<
>$;0 ;0
08$ >8
$0@;1
>$<>8@
1@$>>18
$ 811
$0@0 ;
;;$0;8>
$110>0
;$;;0;8
@<$> ;
$ 180>
1$8>8@1
@;$8<>
$ @>
1$1>>0
8<$ < 1
$<@<<
1$<8@>8
81$ ;1
$<0@
0$> 1@
<$>@@@<
0$8 88
<$ @01 ;
0$0 < 8
8$ 8
$> 88
;$0< @
<$8;8>81
$> ;
<$@1 <>
$1@;81
><$@ >@
<$; @ 08
$< @0
> $8 ;>
<$11 ;0
$8 ;
>1$11
<$00@>;
$ >;>@
>;$808
<$ 0@< 1
<$>< < ;
>@$@1;
<$ 8@<8;
<$@88 0
>8$0
<$ ;0@8
<$;> <8
>8$> 00
<$ 0 118
<$;<>1
> $1
<$ <>
<$1 @@<>
> $ 1>0
<$<>;><0;
<$0@
>>$
<$< @108@
<$00 1;
>>$;;<@
<$<; 881
<$ < >8
>>$8;0@
<$<1 ;8
<$ @08@;
>>$> 80
<$< 1><;
<$< @;;
<<$
0
$
B
$ 0>
@
8
B
!
$
!
!
#
" $
&01#6 -#(41
*(,+*"#5-.'/.5&1/,%5,'#'*&'&1
)(.(
M
B
eng
<$<<<>;08>
<$< @;; ;
pmdf
<$<8 100
$< @1@
tpcc
<$<1<000>
$
pahf
5<$ > 8
5;$ @8;
rcahf
5<$ 0@ >;
5@$;>1>
smsg
<$<8 @8@>
$>>;1
fa
<$<>;
$@@>11
ftc
<$ << 88
$8
fals
<$
8;
;$> 88
A
<$
808
;$> 0
B
<$ 11>1
C
<$ >@
>8
;
0
@$ 1>@8
;$1;>
D
<$
;$> <
E
<$ <@
@$ 1 1
F
<$ < ;@;
;$@0> >
G
<$0 @ 8>
$ < <
H
<$ 1>@@
;$ 1> 1
I
<$ >0;1
$ 8 <;
K
<$0 > 1
$ 80
L
<$<
<;1
<$00>8 @
M
<$ @ 8
0$;0 >0
N
<$<8 1 0
$> 0
O
<$0 0@>>
$800<0
P
<$<>;0 1@
$@;;1
Q
<$0 8 @8
$ 0 0;
R
<$ <1;88
$> 0
"##/,',%#*-./%#*",$
!
!
)
" (
!
µ
$
D
)$
!
!
#
!
$
!
#
!
!
$:
αJ $ %
αJ
!
(
(@$ )
"
"
"
εJ
$I
αJ $ I
!
β + εJ
αJ
!
αJ
!
β
J
;
/
J
2
J
1
J
J
* = µ / + β . +1
( 0$ )
J
J
1 = + αJ
( 0$ )
J
+ εJ .
J
εJ
!
.
($ $
!
! !
)$ I
) [J ] = < ∀ ∀
) [αJ ] = < ∀
;
N
( 1$ )
∀
( 1$ )
$
)[
]= <
,
[J
J #] = σ
<
,
[αJ
αJ ] =
,
[J
J #] = σ
<
[J
[J
[αJ
αJ ] = < ∀ ∀
,
,
,
∀ ∀
( 1$ )
= #
=
=
σα
( 1$ )
=
( 1$ )
<
= #
=
( 1$ )
∀ ∀
( 1$ )
J # ] = < ∀ ∀# ∀ ∀
J #] = < ∀
( 1$ )
∀# ∀ ∀
( 1$ )
( 0)
( 1)
$
$
"
#
G >8<H$
( 1)
J
) [2
]= <
∀
∀ ∀
,
[2J
[2J
,
[2J
J
2
#
,
[2J
J
2
]= σ
,
&
( ;)
J
J
1 = 1J
1(
{
!
!
-
J
2
#
J
2
#
]= <
]=
( ;$ )
∀ ∀# ∀
]=
#
σ
#
σα +
+
∀
≠
( ;$ )
∀ ∀#
≠
( ;$ )
#
σα +
!
J
1
J
1(
}
≠ #
σ
( ;$ )
σ
( ;$ )
!
"
(
Ω
!
Ο
Λ
Ω =σ
( @$ )
Ο
Ο
Λ
"
E
!
( ∈{
$
})
Φ
Λ ='
Φ
η =σ σ
"
Ο
Γ
(
+η
( @$ )
Ο(
Φ( (
ηα = σ α σ $
"
Γ(
#
!
∈{
(}
∈{
( })
!
( @$ )
Γ ( ∈{
}
∈{
( })
Γ =
( @$ )
J
O
O
Φ
$ &
=
Φ
Ο
'
!
E
}
(
+ ηα
Φ(
( ∈{
" Λ
D
5 #
J
J
2
( 0)
3=−
(
=
Ω
I
σ )−
π+
σ
J
J
1 ′ Ω− 1 +
Ω
−
( 8)
( @$ )$@
!
!
η
"
/
" !
D
5 #
ρ
.
$ I
ηα
λ
"
5 #
-
%
ρ
!
(
−ρ
! = 0 +λ
)
−ρ − ρ
#
λ$ I
"
D
(0
#
#
)$ 3
!
( )
%
!
)
/ $
.
η
!
(1) (
ηα $ O !
!
.
" Ω$ I
"
( 8)
P = ( 5 ′ Ω− 5 )− 4 ′ Ω− *
Θ
(* − 5ΘP )Q Ω (* − 5ΘP )
(
$ )
(
$ )
−
σP =
=
@
Ω
−
Ω
σ
σ
−
Λ (
∈{
( })
Λ $
Θ
µ
!
β
!
5
( 0)$ I
.
3P
!
( $ )
5 #
(
$ )
η
3P
"
#
ηα
!
( 8)
$
%
&
/
ηα $
η
!
P
3P
3P $ I
!
#
!
$
%
P
3P
"
ρ
λ$&
ρ
λ
!
P
3P
!
P
3P $ I
!
!
!
"
$
#
!
$%
#
!
!
ηα = < $
!
(*.%&*.,' -#(41*(
;$
!
E
µ
!
!
$
!
ρ
λ
!
#
<$ 0
<$ 1 > ;$
"
(0
−ρ
!
+λ
)
−ρ − ρ
"
D
!$
!
ρ
λ
$
η
ηα
D
σ
!
<$< $
!
σα
#
σ
!
!
!
B
$
;-
ρ
<$<@@<<;
λ
<$<>@80
η
<$<<01 @8
ηα
<$< 00
β
$<;;;
σ
/
#
R;;@ $0$
!
-
5;1<@$0@
(η α = < )
!
#
8$1>
!
#
0 0$
8$ >
A
$
D
#
?
#
!
!
G
!
$
H
!
$
!
,'/14(.,'
%
#
! +
"
!
$
!
!
#
.
9
"
$
+
!
( >@>)
$6!
#
$%
$
#+#-#'/#(
F
( > 8)
6
# '
)
! $ SSSM .
( <<;) =T
D
T
$ L
:
F
.$ $ (.) ( <<;) =
'% 9 $
9
3 2
#
0
L! $
6U<;5=5@;
TT
W ! X<;5=5@;
0
7
4$ ( >@ ) ,
2$
$ Y .$
9$ $ ( >8<)
50 0$
&
0< !
!
<<;
-L
L
8
)
+
%
;
)
4
4
$ 1@>5 0$
'
! V
$
5
$ 9$
-
( > 0) 6
>;;
$1;851 $
)