NELLCO
NELLCO Legal Scholarship Repository
New York University Public Law and Legal Theory
Working Papers
New York University School of Law
5-1-2012
Separation of Powers or Division of Power?
Jeremy J. Waldron
NYU School of Law, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: http://lsr.nellco.org/nyu_plltwp
Part of the Constitutional Law Commons, Jurisprudence Commons, Legal History, Theory and
Process Commons, Legislation Commons, Politics Commons, and the Public Law and Legal Theory
Commons
Recommended Citation
Waldron, Jeremy J., "Separation of Powers or Division of Power?" (2012). New York University Public Law and Legal Theory Working
Papers. Paper 329.
http://lsr.nellco.org/nyu_plltwp/329
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the New York University School of Law at NELLCO Legal Scholarship Repository. It has been
accepted for inclusion in New York University Public Law and Legal Theory Working Papers by an authorized administrator of NELLCO Legal
Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected].
!"
#$%
#&
'(
)
(
*
+
&
#
+&
&
,
*&
+&
-&
.-
!/!01)2
3-4&
#
2&
#
-
.
678
&
')
&
9
-7
8
)
2
-
1
+
&
-
88
&
-8-
82
&&-
')
:;;
)
3
!678
<"0$<"!"%3
4
<')
!"
#!<=>?8@?! A $<"!!%
;
4$B;
)
7;
&%
)
&,
1
2
*
)
-
&
)
+
C
+
A'B)
!"
#!<=>?8@?68! A $<"!!%
=! ==
D3&4)';8@6;EC:EC@)C,>667?ECEB
7E(6?!=/$! 0%;
3
4
F
;/!"?EC@,,(E?GC
@(26)7?6$! 0F%
/)
!HH
03;4
&
'($ %;EC6)7E??I
,6.6C7E@;@7>@EE7>I<F/$;';<"" %
<F/2
&
J-
&$;8@6A!D13
K4%
:G
:
:;$
<!!D! <=<F
%C
-&
7)
1
$%
&)
2
E
-
+
)
2+
.
234
-
,
6
3436
4
8,;6IC?E,:;ECE>6:,IEB>6@(EB>6
;EC:EC!"/!!"!!D$@;! 0<%.!<"
,34
-
(
')&
L=/
3&
&-
4
C
-
&
-
-
(;
&
)
3
)43-4>
&
)3
4
-2
&-
!"')6),EC@6MC,6?>)@ECC,'E>C'I>6B6,6?@776?C=/
$@N<""0%<A !!
!<)23>4>67;B;:>6@8,:,6.6EB!/ A!/ =
$<""/%
!"
#$%
:
1
$
%
$
%
7<++
7!
$
#7<
;%
7=D:;
7A7
234
-
&-
3
4!
D
C8
!A7A
7<2
&
+)>L!+
3
&
4.
7
&-
++
(
(
34
7!<A
=D.
2
&!
2
$&%<A
?7
,@3
4B
3
O2
O&24
1
2
E
17@3
&
4
(
+J
!=8@6A<
!D7@ !!
!F
E
$%1
;$
&%3
4.7
B
-
&*
.2B
7<
7!
1
&
-&)
--$%
1
3
4
-$
%
#
*
E
7<
92'@
)';8
3-
@PQ
4@
-&82
@
!/;?6C,EC?68E@:EC!DA$! /A%13
4
!08@6DF0 #'E>C@E;G6(E?66EBNE86?C)6CAFF/$7
@! 00%RR!= D"
7<7A7!
7!7A(
&-
&
B3
4
7!
7!++
E-
++
-
8
-
7A
7<
.
8
E1
&
7#
.
&
! ,6' !(
D/N6E?N6
(>CNEC@(?686(D"FD!!$! 0 %
<"8 "
#) /8?NC@(?686(!=AD
$<"!!%
<!!=="
<A
!
!
+
-&+
++7<
A7<#2
7A
2&#
(7
7!#
&
-8&
3J
&
4
4>3
3
-43
43-4
42
.
7<7A--
&-1
&.
7!&
&'()
$
!)';8
->3PQ
<<8@6D!!
O2
4
&-
&-6
&
B
34
834
3
4+
2*
E8
))E
&
1
'.&)2
<A!=.
8
13
4
7!<A-
8
13
O
2
&
C
&
344
3
4
2.
))
$E
2#2
#
%
*+$"
E
'@2 *+
$C
&34
-8@21
@
&
@O
&2&
&
%
6@
@
<=S8@6;D
<DB#?J#(
<F.8
1
.)7
.
-
)@
@
1
@
&@)
,
J1
PQ
K
-
#
2
1
#
3@G
B
&
O
77
@
&&
E@@
&
2
4
</@E;G6(E?66A< A"$R =%
<0AF=$R!=A%
< >I6G>6;EC:[email protected]?I
.212
-B
@
PQ
K
&&
&
&
-CJ7@
&
@2
7!
,+
@
(
J
@
13
4(2
@
A";
A!@E;G6(E?66!DAFD$R!=F%
&E
26
&
@
1
&
1
&
#&
1
:
;-&!
<
+&
@
>
&+
3
&4
&
$
%&
#
A<AFF$R!=0%
AAN>CI:
A=@E;G6(E?66!DAFF$R!=/%
.
;&-
3,4C
-
-
-
&-
&
&-
.
,
-
,-
E&>
&>
34
34.
$%>&
$%&
>2
$%>2
>&
&
+
2
+
$%
-
$%
&B$%
-&
C
AD>E..6@68>C;!0;< >37
4
-
-&
-
$%
$%
(>
)$
&-
1
P.Q
-
17-
&
>
2
1
;K-B
-
#B
1K
AF)$8 13PQ7
#
)T--K
K
-
#
?
--
.?@
@;
;
;;@$%
;;J4
A/;80
A0>E..6@68>C;<F
-
.2
&
&
-./0//
)
+-
-
-
E)2
!0
34-+-
3
4
2
,6
)
>3
-4
?*;*
A ;'6?6)I.6C>)EB@(CN6C6?@!DA$>@>! /"%13
;U
1
4
$6.
(>
1.:?G6(E?G8MHH%
=")EC6S:6:>67?EB>6@(!D/$;
;.;
)>! 0 %.MF
=!/=.8<
B
-
6
-
)
1
I2
G
#
J
&1
-
(2
-#
1.)2#(!3
=<;)&(2
-
61)M(6.6?6;ECE)IC,
E;6I00<$N?;(! /0%
=A8@6A?E@)21
3
&
-
#
-
34
2
-
-
34
<0-
4$;=%
==)EC6S:6:="D/D.8<
).
))
&
-
83()
*43
&
)4)>
&)
13(
&
4(*
3.
&4&
#
*
)
@
3&
4&&.
E)
1
C-
&-
J
-
1
K
1
=D!D/.MF
=F)19@
D!=13
4
=/
K&
)2
&
)
J
$#
,#
%
)2
)
()
)
)2
1
)
&
3(
&
43
&4
3(
-
-
-&-
(-&-
4
&
#
&
=0!F!.MF
= ;8213
#
K>
4
D"B6,6?@L=/<=!
)2
$
)2&%
-)2
&-
-
>3
4-
&
A$F%+
(
-
2-
(,6
&-
-2
))
4!5
(
@#2
$)%
D!<A B
1
-
J
&
+
&
&
F/
$F%
>
&
18,
83,
KPQ
PQ.4E
82
.
&$
%
8
-
8
&
$
%(
C
.
8
D<,;6IHH!!<
,&
-
#
J
J-
(
(
J
J
$%
J
J
$
%
34
&
+
-
DA?,82
$!!"%13PCQ
&;
4
D=E
-
&
.2
(
&
6
J6
-
2-
#
#
.
1
-
-
$&
%,
3
&4
2
&2
J6&
+
+
J
-
&V
6+(+
+3
-&#
4+
&
.
2
-
-&
8
+
+
82
#--
882
#
&
8
&-
&
-
&
-
)
1
&
(
:;
C
2
$8%(
#
8
J
-J
.
$&
-%
&-
6
B&(
&
2
;
+
+
&$
DD;*
%.
&2-3
4+%
8&+
-&
3-4@.
,
P! =<Q;<"F<==13
-
-&
&4-
J&
&
#-
&
&
&
J
DFF
D/;.)
?(?$ $.=13>
&
&
#
K
&
-4
D0
),)0";@B@?68DD0!$! <%'G
,A/N6E?N6E(C'E:?C@EBC6?CEC@@(ADA
A0D$<""F%
@6MC,6?E@W>6CIC>6N:@N?;>76@NE8
D<!$! /=%13U-
4
D ,
P! =<Q;<"F<==
(-
*(-
#
-
+,
)
-
&
+
&
1
&
-&
(
&
&2
&B
'
@2&
.
&
-13I
F"+,=0 :<00$! 0 %
4
&
&
&
&&
#&
J
@B2
-
&
(
&*E
:
@2+
+
-
F!B:@@6?>6)E?@IEB@($! F=%13
X-JX
-
I-
+
3&4
3
4+
;
3
7
;
:
>?4.
$)
%
(
&-
(
$!%
-
(
.2
1
F<
)
2E
&
(
)
>
$
%
&
V
-
.
;
(
!'
78
3
47
)
.
-
*CB
+
+
2
+
+
+
FA7EC6?C,86?)6:@6>66M6;:86:C.E:C,!<"0
F=! $B2<!=)23
4BLD!
%
+
@
#
;
+
$
%2
78
3
42
EG.
$
%
2
J
N
$
%
FDD